Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
1. Have the same stance (solution) with their opening. But you can
always bring additional mechanism to the solution to perfect the
solution.
2. Add new justification or effectivity to the solution.
3. Add contextualization or picturization of the condition, that brings
more urgency to the problem.
4. Bring new rebuttals to opponent teams
WHAT THE CLOSING TEAM SHOULD NOT DO
NOTE :
• Just because it is a value judgment debate doesn’t mean it doesn’t need to
have mechanism.
• Just because it is a proposal debate doesn’t mean it doesn’t need a philosophy/
principle argument
DEFINITION
○ Giving definition does not mean you have to translate each word of the motion
based on the dictionary. Defining a motion means you give a clear explanation
what the debate is about.
○ Definition can be given in few ways :
○ Translating key words into a more understandable words; e.g. TH Celebrates the rise of
Feminist Cult ; TH Regrets the decline of highly-integrated family
○ Providing picturization of the problem or the phenomenon and what you will do
(solution/stance); e.g. THW Intervene in Syria
○ Clarify room of debate or limitation ; specify where or when this debate takes
place, but this doesn’t mean you have to be very specific. You have to be as
general as possible.
A definition is unfair and can be
challenged if :