Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
148
International Journal of Aerospace and Mechanical Engineering 2:3 2008
residues. It can be effectively utilized for decentralized power characterized as per the procedure recommended in [11]. The
generation and thermal applications. Gasification of blend of HOME with diesel in the proportion 20% to 80% was
lignocelluloses biomass allows transforming its physical and prepared on volume basis termed as B20 is also used as liquid
chemical properties into a new fuel much more suitable to fuel in the present study. Characterization of liquid fuels,
obtain mechanical energy in a process described a time ago Diesel, hingan oil methyl ester (HOME) and B20 is carried
[9]. out following ASTM standard test methods. The
Partial combustion of biomass in the gasifier generates characteristics such as density, viscosity, gross calorific value
producer gas that can be used for heating purposes and as are determined for diesel, HOME and B20.
supplementary or sole fuel in internal combustion engines. Wood is the commonly used traditional fuel wherever heat
The utilization of producer gas in the diesel engine in dual generation is required. Wood is the well-known suitable
fuel operation is an established technology for conservation of biomass fuel because of its higher calorific value and low ash
FD. Producer gas could be used in CI engine, without any content. Small pieces of wood with approximate size of 5 cm
modification in the engine. However, it cannot replace the FD in length and 3-4 cm in diameter are suitable to be used as
completely. FD replacements up to 70–90% have been gasifier feedstock. After removing the outer skin and pulp
achieved in the dual fuel mode. Because of its poor ignition from the fruit, the nut covering the kernel is termed as shell of
characteristics some minimum amount of FD is required to hingan fruit (SHF) is absolute woody material. The SHF is
start the ignition [10]. On the other hand, increase in load on examined for development of producer gas in the down draft
the engine, brake thermal efficiency of the dual fuelled engine gasifier.
starts decreasing drastically. Dual fuelled engine at higher The proximate analysis of SHF is carried out to determine
loads emits more smoke. This is an indication of incomplete the characteristics such as moisture content, volatile matter,
combustion of fuel. All the emissions such as CO, HC, NOx ash content, fixed carbon using Infra Red- Moisture Meter and
and CO2 from the dual fuel mode of operation are higher than Muffle furnace. The calorific value of SHF is determined
that when diesel alone is used under all load conditions. using bomb calorimeter. SHF is used as a feedstock for
A typical composition of producer gas generated by gasifier in present study to generate producer gas. Diesel,
biomass gasification on volumetric basis is given in Table I HOME and B20 (liquid fuels) are used as fuels in single
[10]. cylinder, CI engine to generate base line data. The CI engine
TABLE I used for the study was Kirloskar, single cylinder, four-stroke
CONSTITUENTS OF PRODUCER GAS diesel engine. The engine is then run in dual fuel mode using
Gas Volume liquid fuel and producer gas. The CI engine in liquid fuel and
Carbon monoxide 18-22% dual fuel mode is analyzed for its performance and emission
Hydrogen 15-19% analysis.
Methane 1-5%
Hydrocarbons 0.2-0.4%
Nitrogen 45-55%
III. EXPERIMENTAL SETUP AND MEASURING DEVICES USED
Water vapor 4% A single cylinder, constant speed (1500 rpm), water cooled,
direct injection with rated output of 3.7 kW, CI engine was
In present study an attempt is made to utilize the biomass used for the study. A down draft gasifier is selected in the
residue remaining after seed separation of hingan fruit as study for generation of producer gas as the downdraft
feedstock for biomass gasification. The producer gas along configuration reduces the amount of high molecular weight
with diesel and esters of hingan oil are tried as a fuel in CI hydrocarbons and particles as compared to the updraft
engine to analyze the engine performance. The diesel or configuration [12].The schematic diagram of gasifier-engine
biodiesel replacement with the use of producer gas is also assembly and experimental setup is shown in Fig.1. The
analyzed. experimental setup includes a diesel engine, biomass gasifier,
gas filter, gas cooler, loading device. A downdraft gasifier is
II. MATERIALS AND METHOD used for generation of producer gas. Small pieces of SHF, 20
- 30 mm in diameter and length were used as feedstock for
A. Hingan Fruit gasification. The SHF is fed from the top of the gasifier at a
Hingan tree, botanical name Balanites Aegyptiaca(L.) Del; regular interval. The partial combustion of biomass in the
family Zygophyllaceac is a multipurpose tree. The tree yields gasifier generates producer gas (PG), which enters the gas
100 kg of fruit annually. The fruit typically consists of outer cooler. The dust particle in the gas is removed by passing
skin, pulp, shell and kernel in the tune of 13%, 27%, 45% and through the gas filter. The valves are provided in the passage
of gas to control the PG flow rate. Manometers are used to
15% respectively. The fat content of the kernels is high, levels
measure the air flow rate. The performance and emission tests
of 44-50% vegetable oil [11]. The oil obtained from the kernel
are carried out in liquid mode and dual fuel mode at different
of hingan is used for ester preparation by transesterification. load conditions. The dual fuel mode of operation is carried out
B. Characteristics of Fuels by supplying the PG-air mixture to the combustion chamber of
Ester of hingan oil i.e. hingan oil methyl ester (HOME) was the engine through inlet manifold. The liquid fuel flow rate
prepared by base catalyzed transesterification process and was measured on volumetric basis. AVL 444 digas analyser
was used for the measurement of emissions concentration. A
149
International Journal of Aerospace and Mechanical Engineering 2:3 2008
gas flow rate meter was used to measure the flow rate of PG. B. The Proximate Analysis of Shell of Hingan Fruit (SHF)
PG supply rate was controlled through a producer gas control The proximate analysis of SHF used as a feedstock for
valve (PG-valve). There was no control on aspirated air. To gasifier in this study is given in Table III. The ash content in
know the maximum intake of PG by engine, PG-valve is used feedstock is very low i.e. 0.497% on dry basic, which
slowly opened till the engine started faltering. Later PG-valve indicate the good suitability of feedstock as a gasifier fuel. It
is turned back slightly and the intake of PG at that point was is observed that the shell which is a woody material has 86%
taken as the maximum replacement in the engine for each volatile matter and 5.5% moisture content. The woody SHF
operating condition. Experiments were carried out on the has good calorific value of 18 MJ/kg.
engine at five different loading conditions (0 %, 25%, 50 %,
75% and 98 %) using diesel, HOME, B20 blend, diesel + PG, TABLE III
HOME + PG and B20 + PG respectively as a fuel to the PROXIMATE ANALYSIS OF SHF
engine. The composition of producer gas was determined S.N. Characteristic Parameter Corresponding Value
using ‘Chimeto Gas-Chromatograph’ and the calorific value 1. Volatile matter (% db) 86.00
of producer gas was calculated from the gas composition. 2. Ash content (% db) 0.497
3. Moisture content (% db) 5.500
4. Fixed carbon (% db) 8.003
5. Calorific value (MJ/kg) 18.004
150
International Journal of Aerospace and Mechanical Engineering 2:3 2008
LFCR (kg/hr)-
reduces the mass flow rate of PG and air required for
combustion, resulting into lowering in oxygen level required 0.60
for combustion.
0.40
32.00 0.20
Diesel
HOME
28.00 B20
0.00
Diesel+PG
24.00 0.00 25.00 50.00 75.00 98.00
Brake Thermal Efficiency(%).
HOME+PG
B20+PG Load(%)
20.00
16.00 Fig. 3 Variation of LFCR with applied load in liquid fuel and dual
fuel mode
12.00
50.00 B20+PG
2. Liquid Fuel Replacement(LFR) and Liquid Fuel
Consumption Rate (LFCR) 40.00
Both the term LFR and LFCR are interrelated terms. The 30.00
10.00
(LFCR) liquid (LFCR) dual
% Liquid fuel repalaceme nt(LFR) u 100 0.00
(LFCR) dual 25.00 50.00 75.00 98.00
Load(%)
liquid: (Diesel, HOME and B20), dual: (Diesel + PG, HOME + PG and B20 + PG)
Fig. 4 Variation of SEC with applied load in liquid fuel and dual fuel
Fig. 3, explains the LFCR with liquid fuel and dual fuel
mode
mode. The liquid fuel consumption is more with HOME in
comparison with diesel and B20. The considerable drop of E. Emission Characteristics in Dual Fuel Mode
LFCR is observed when the engine is operated in dual fuel Emission characteristics of engine are important as far as
mode. From Table 4.26, it can be easily seen that mean liquid environmental aspect is concerned. Also emission from the
fuel replacement of 46%, 50%, 55.5%, 60.36% and 26.24% is engine reflects the quality of combustion taking place inside
observed for 0, 25, 50, 75 and 98% loading respectively. the engine. The different emission parameters measured
Maximum LFR of in the tune of 59-61% is observed for all during liquid and dual fuel mode operation and discussed
the dual fuel mode combinations. below.
With the increase in producer gas flow rates, the LFR
increases. It can be seen that the maximum LFR has gone up 1. Carbon monoxide (CO) emission
to 60.91% in diesel + PG mode. The decrease in LFR is The variation of CO emission of the engine with various
observed high load conditions. At high load operations, liquid fuel and dual fuel mode is depicted in Fig. 5.
insufficient gas flow decreases the LFR. In order to reduce With increase in load, an increase in CO emission is
detonation, the intake of producer gas is reduced resulting in a observed. Much higher values of CO emission are recorded in
low liquid fuel replacement at high load. dual fuel mode as compared to liquid fuel mode. The higher
concentration of CO emission in the dual fuel mode gives an
151
International Journal of Aerospace and Mechanical Engineering 2:3 2008
HC (ppm).
40.00
HOME
0.40
B20
30.00
0.35 Diesel+PG
HOME+PG
0.30 B20+PG 20.00
0.25
CO (%)
10.00
0.20
0.00
0.15 0.00 25.00 50.00 75.00 98.00
Load (%)
0.10
0.05
Fig. 8 Variation of HC emission with applied load in liquid fuel and
dual fuel mode
0.00
0.00 25.00 50.00 75.00 98.00
Load (%) In liquid fuel mode operation CO2 emission is lower as
Fig. 5 Variation of CO emission with applied load in liquid fuel and compared to that of the dual fuel mode but insignificant
dual fuel mode difference in , HC and NOx emission is observed in both
2. Carbon Dioxide(CO2), Hydrocarbon(HC) and Nitrogen liquid and duel fuel mode. Since the producer is a mixture of
Oxides(NOx) emissions CO, HC, methane and CO2, the combustion of producer gas
Fig. 6, Fig. 7 and Fig. 8 illustrates the relationship between increases CO2 emission.
the % loading of the engine and the concentration of CO2, HC The NOx emission depends upon combustion chamber
and NOx present in the exhaust gas respectively. As expected, temperature which in turn depends on the applied load.
with increase in load there is always an increase in CO2, HC Insignificant difference in NOx emission is recorded while
and NOx emission. operating the engine in liquid fuel mode and dual fuel mode. It
8.00
was observed that the NOx emission increases with increase in
Diesel
HOME load for all the fuels tried on the engine. This is due to the
7.00
B20
Diesel+PG
lesser amount of oxygen available for combustion and hence
6.00
HOME+PG NOx formation. Also organic nitrogen from the air causes NOx
B20+PG
5.00 formation. Producer gas do not have organic nitrogen, it has
CO2 (%)
4.00
only atmospheric nitrogen, which inorganic nitrogen [13].
3.00
3. Smoke Density
2.00
Fig. 9 illustrates the variation of smoke density with respect
1.00 to load.
40.00
0.00 Diesel
0.00 25.00 50.00 75.00 98.00 HOME
35.00 B20
Load (%)
Diesel+PG
30.00 HOME+PG
Fig. 6 Variation of CO2 emission with applied load in liquid fuel and B20+PG
dual fuel mode 25.00
SD (%)
20.00
700.00
Diesel 15.00
630.00
HOME
560.00 B20 10.00
Diesel+PG
490.00 HOME+PG 5.00
B20+PG
420.00
NOx (ppm).
0.00
350.00 0.00 25.00 50.00 75.00 98.00
Load (%)
280.00
210.00 Fig. 9 Variation of smoke emission with applied load in liquid fuel
140.00
and dual fuel mode
With the increase in load there is an increase in the smoke
70.00
density. In liquid fuel mode operation the smoke density
0.00
0.00 25.00 50.00 75.00 98.00 attained a maximum value of 25% with diesel fuel where as it
Load (%) is 36% in dual fuel mode for Diesel+PG at full load. In dual
Fig. 7Variation of NOx emission with applied load in liquid fuel and fuel mode of operation, the smoke density is observed to be
dual fuel mode higher than that of the diesel mode for all combination of PG.
152
International Journal of Aerospace and Mechanical Engineering 2:3 2008
This is due to the decreased amount of fresh air in dual fuel [7] Deshmukh S J, Bhuyar L B. “Transesterified Hingan (Balanites) oil as a
fuel for compression ignition engines.” Biomass and Bioenergy. Article
mode.
in press, 2008 http://www.elsevier.com/locate/biombioe.
[8] Sridhar G, Paul PJ, Mukunda HS. “Biomass derived producer gas as a
V. CONCLUSION reciprocating engine fuel -an experimental analysis.” Biomass and
Bioenergy. 21, pp 61-67, 2001.
Some important findings on the engine performance and [9] Ramadhas AS, Jayaraj S, Muraleedharan C. “Power generation using
emission aspects of CI engine in dual fuel mode of operation coir-pith and wood derived producer gas in diesel engines.” Fuel
while using SHF in the gasifier are highlighted in the present Processing Technology. 87, pp 849-53. 2006.
work. This study proved that the diesel engine is capable of [10] Mohod AG, Gadge SR, Mandasure VN. “Liberation of carbon monoxide
through gasifier I.C. engine system.” I.E. (I) Journal I.D. 84, pp27–29,
successful running in dual fuel mode of operation with SHF as 2003.
biomass in the gasifier. The important findings are listed [11] Abdel R, Saadany E, Wasif M. “Chemical and physical studies on
below. Balanite aegyptiaca oil.” Grasas Y Aceites. 37(2), pp 81-85, 1986.
[12] ] P. McKendry. “Energy production from biomass (part 2): conversion
technologies.” Bioresource Technology. 83, pp 47–54, 2002.
x Diesel engine shows similar performance and [13] R.N. Singh, S.P. Singh, B.S. Pathak. “Investigations on operation of CI
emission characteristics with all the three liquid fuels engine using producer gas and rice bran oil in mixed fuel mode.”
used in the study. Renewable Energy. 32, pp1565-1580, 2007.
x The SHF is woody biomass having good calorific
value and low ash content that makes it suitable Samir J. Deshmukh was born on January 13, 1973, at
feedstock for biomass gasification or can be used as Buldana, Maharashtra, India. He did his primary and
firewood in rural households. secondary education from Daryapur(M.S.) in India. He
received his Bachelor degree in Mechanical Engineering and
x This study proved that the diesel engine is capable of
Masters degree in Thermal Engineering from Amravati
successful running in dual fuel mode of operation University, Amravati, M.S. India in 1994 and 2002
with the SHF as biomass in the gasifier. respectively. He is interested in alternate fuels and rural
x The SHF as biomass materials is suitable with little renewable energy.
Presently he is working as Assistant Professor in Mechanical Engineering
or no modification in the gasifier. Department, PRM Institute of Technology & Research, Badnera, Amravati.
x The waste/low-cost biomass feedstock is used for He is working on bidiesel and alternate fuels and its utility in rural area as an
producer gas generation. Hence, the power energy source. He is in the teaching and research field from last 12 years.
generation cost while using SHF as biomass is much Samir is a member of ISTE and IE (I).
cheaper than the conventional power generation cost.
x In dual fuel mode operation the engine performance
decreases, with increased emissions at all load
conditions.
x Carbon monoxide emission in dual fuel mode of
operation is higher than that of liquid fuel operation.
x Other exhaust emission characteristics such as HC,
NOx and CO2 are found to be closer irrespective of
the fuel used and irrespective of mode of operation.
x In the dual fuel mode of operation, while using SHF,
higher liquid fuel savings is achieved at part load
conditions.
x Maximum liquid fuel replacement in the tune of 60%
is achieved in all duel fuel mode operations, with no
engine modification.
REFERENCES
[1] Kesse D G. “Global warming-facts, assessment, countermeasures.” J Pet
Sci Eng. 26, pp 157-68, 2000.
[2] Murphy JD, McCarthy K. “The optimal production of biogas for use as a
transport fuel in Ireland. Renew Energy.” 30, pp 2111-27, 2005.
[3] Agarwal AK. “Biofuels (alcohols and biodiesel) applications as fuels for
internal combustion engines.” Progress in Energy and Combustion
Science. 33, pp 233-71, 2007.
[4] Pramanik K. “Properties and use of Jatropha curcas oil and diesel fuel
blends in compression ignition engine.” Renewable Energy. 28, pp 239-
48, 2003.
[5] Sharma Y C, Sing B. “Development of biodiesel from karanja, a tree
found in rural India.” J. Fuel. vol 87, pp1740-42. 2008.
[6] Otera J., “Transesterification” Journal Chem Rev. 93(4), pp1449-70,
1993.
153