Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
2018 20)06
http://criticallegalthinking.com/2018/09/21/organised-state-abandonment-the-meaning-of-grenfell/ Sayfa 1 / 16
Organised State Abandonment: The Meaning of Grenfell 24.09.2018 20)06
— Claudia Davis, former partner of Steven Power, who died in the fire,
Commemoration Hearings, Grenfell Public Inquiry, May 25th, 2018
❝ Our clients firmly believe that it is absolutely vital that the terms of
reference are amended so that race, religion and social class are
considered, because whilst there will be – and I accept rightly – focus
on the construction and refurbishment of the tower which led to the
fire, that will not be the full story. That will not explain why it was that
these particular people – these particular people – were the ones that
died and will not explain what led them to their death.
On June 14th, 2017 a fire started in a flat on the 4th floor of Grenfell
Tower. It spread to the exterior of the flat, and within 12 minutes, had leapt
up 19 stories, fuelled by combustible cladding and a catastrophic failure of
many other fire safety provisions. The testimony of survivors of the fire,
the bereaved and their families with which the Public Inquiry began was
harrowing. The details of lives lived and lost in an entirely preventable
tragedy, the sense of the horror of knowing how individuals and entire
families succumbed to their deaths, was courageously spoken about by
survivors and the bereaved. The purpose of the commemoration hearings
was to clearly set out what is at stake in the Public Inquiry – simply put, to
hold power to account for this senseless and maddening loss of life.
http://criticallegalthinking.com/2018/09/21/organised-state-abandonment-the-meaning-of-grenfell/ Sayfa 2 / 16
Organised State Abandonment: The Meaning of Grenfell 24.09.2018 20)06
In the aftermath of June 2017, the word “Grenfell” has come to represent
much more than a high-rise tower on the Lancaster West Estate in the
Latimer Road area of West London. It has come to signify the worst
aspects of a neo-liberal mode of governance that took hold in Britain from
the 1980s onwards, in which the provision of social goods and services was
disaggregated amongst several different private providers; in which the
border between state authority and private provider, and their
corresponding legal duties have become blurred and difficult to discern.
Grenfell has come to represent the utter failure of the state to provide a
basic minimum of support for victims in the aftermath of a horrendous
tragedy that traumatised an entire community. Grenfell has become an
exemplary instance of the callous disregard for the value of human life, the
calculated indifference towards working class and racialised people that
characterise the actions of the politicians, policy-makers, and corporate
lobbyists who have pursued a de-regulation and privatisation agenda at
any cost.
http://criticallegalthinking.com/2018/09/21/organised-state-abandonment-the-meaning-of-grenfell/ Sayfa 3 / 16
Organised State Abandonment: The Meaning of Grenfell 24.09.2018 20)06
The suite of building and fire safety regulations that are relevant to
http://criticallegalthinking.com/2018/09/21/organised-state-abandonment-the-meaning-of-grenfell/ Sayfa 4 / 16
Organised State Abandonment: The Meaning of Grenfell 24.09.2018 20)06
The whole is only as strong as its many parts, and the fire safety regime
must therefore be cognisant of all the layers of safety, how they interrelate,
and must take steps to maintain them. Dr. Lane sets out in forensic detail
how each of these layers failed. That a loss of life on this scale happened
was not simply because the cladding was combustible — although it is an
astounding and egregious fact that a high-rise tower could be clad in
http://criticallegalthinking.com/2018/09/21/organised-state-abandonment-the-meaning-of-grenfell/ Sayfa 5 / 16
Organised State Abandonment: The Meaning of Grenfell 24.09.2018 20)06
material as combustible as petrol itself — but the failure of both active and
passive fire safety protection measures across the board. The multi-layered
approach to fire safety becomes a major liability when the management
and provision of social housing is fragmented, spread out between a web of
private, public and quasi-public organisations. The dicing up and
fragmentation of the provision and procurement of the different and
interlinked factors of fire safety has had disastrous consequences; a
materialised analogy to the tranching seen in the world of subprime
mortgages. As Dr. Lane notes, the refurbishment of Grenfell Tower that
took place between 2012–16, which is what rendered the Tower
structurally unsafe, involved no fewer than 6 parties as the major players,
but stretches to twenty when we include the suppliers of the materials
used. However, the large number of corporate and public actors involved
in the refurbishment does not reflect a stronger composite of legal
accountability and ethical behaviour, on the contrary, it has resulted in a
fracturing and dissipation of responsibility, a “merry-go-round of buck-
passing” that leaves those affected by their actions without remedy.
And no party is guiltier of this than the government itself. As the authors of
the report The Paper Trail note in relation to parliamentary debates on
whether sprinklers should be fitted in new high-rise towers and retrofitted
in existing ones, the government did not relent in asserting that this was
the responsibility of building owners. While Eric Pickles, then Secretary for
the Department for communities and Local Government did write to
building owners on the recommendation of the Coroner for the Lakanal
House fire, this remained within the discretion of building owners and was
never mandated as necessary by the government, despite clear evidence
that sprinklers would significantly decrease the potential loss of life in
high-rise fires. As research by Inside Housing notes, “just 18 of 2925
council-owned high-rise blocks in England had sprinklers fitted inside
flats” as of 2015.
http://criticallegalthinking.com/2018/09/21/organised-state-abandonment-the-meaning-of-grenfell/ Sayfa 6 / 16
Organised State Abandonment: The Meaning of Grenfell 24.09.2018 20)06
In the rush to deregulate, to cut costs for business, the statutory provisions
for fire safety became poorly defined and their interpretation uncertain.
Dr. Lane notes that “[t]he suites of National and European reaction to fire
tests is complex and confusing, as I have illustrated in my Appendix F. No
guidance is provided on which regime takes precedence when differing
classifications are obtained for the same material or product. This has
become a critical problem.” (Dr. Lane, expert report, para 2.29.3) She goes
on to note that an absence of clear definitions (of terms such as “external
surface” and “filler” as they apply to rainscreen cladding), coupled with no
clear direction on which regime (European or British) takes precedence
where there is conflict, has led to a situation in which a failure or lapse of
safety standards was practically inevitable. As for those Brexiteers so intent
on taking back control, she notes that “a material can fail to meet all
applicable European performance requirements… but nonetheless be
compliant with the National Class 0… defined by testing to British
Standards.” (Dr. Lane, expert report, para 2.9.11) A failure to adhere to
European standards of fire safety even before the UK leaves the EU does
http://criticallegalthinking.com/2018/09/21/organised-state-abandonment-the-meaning-of-grenfell/ Sayfa 7 / 16
Organised State Abandonment: The Meaning of Grenfell 24.09.2018 20)06
Dr. Lane also finds no evidence to assure her that the stair doors were
compliant, again chipping away at the multi-layered fire safety framework.
The smoke ventilation system, the width of the staircase — the only escape
route for residents — did not meet the statutory guidance. The fire lift
failed. The list of failures goes on and on. One could conclude that the
Council, the KCTMO, and all of the private contractors involved in the
different parts of the refurbishment simply did not have sufficient regard
for the lives of the people living in Grenfell Tower. But this is only the case
because they are operating in a context created by state and private actors
— one characterised by the organised abandonment of state
responsibilities to citizens and residents to provide basic levels of safety
http://criticallegalthinking.com/2018/09/21/organised-state-abandonment-the-meaning-of-grenfell/ Sayfa 8 / 16
Organised State Abandonment: The Meaning of Grenfell 24.09.2018 20)06
and security.
Over a period of decades, the government and the local council had
embraced a mode of governing that prioritised the efficient running of
businesses whose sole task, in turn, was profit maximisation. This mode of
governing and the site for profit-making was the provision of social goods
and entitlements. This could only unfold if, underlying this mode of
governance and organisation, there was a pre-existing and profound
disregard for the lives of those living in social housing. And of course, this
profound lack of care for the value of human life could only manifest in the
way that it did, because it intersected with a complex of racism, class
hierarchy, xenophobia, and able-ism each with their own specific histories
that are difficult to map yet crucial to understand. Understanding the
meaning of Grenfell requires an intersectional analysis of the socio-
http://criticallegalthinking.com/2018/09/21/organised-state-abandonment-the-meaning-of-grenfell/ Sayfa 9 / 16
Organised State Abandonment: The Meaning of Grenfell 24.09.2018 20)06
In the 1990s, management guru Peter Drucker used the term “organised
abandonment” in his book Post-Capitalist Society to describe what
organisations in the new “knowledge economy” needed to do in order to
effectively manage and plan for change. Given the emergence of an
economy based on the production, marketisation and application of
knowledge (rather than land or factory labour) which by its very nature,
would be continually evolving, organisations would have to learn to change
quickly and adapt to new circumstances. The concept of organised
abandonment denotes the purposeful jettisoning of any mode of
management, any aspect of organisational structure or way of doing things
that will no longer serve the interests of the organisation. “[The
organization] must be organized for systematic abandonment of the
established, the customary, the familiar, the comfortable, whether
products, services and processes, human and social relationships, skills or
organizations themselves.”
http://criticallegalthinking.com/2018/09/21/organised-state-abandonment-the-meaning-of-grenfell/ Sayfa 10 / 16
Organised State Abandonment: The Meaning of Grenfell 24.09.2018 20)06
In The Limits to Capital, Marxist geographer David Harvey used the term
“organised abandonment” to explain how, in the context of the built
environment, the hegemonic function of interest-bearing money capital
requires special institutional arrangements to deal with the “production,
use, transformation and abandonment of particular elements within the
built environment…”. The global credit system and the dominance of
fictitious capital determine the parameters within which “landowners,
developers, builders, the state” and residents can operate within and use
specific places. Tellingly, he uses red-lining as an example of organized
abandonment — a scenario in which financial institutions, in combination
with state and regional urban development and regeneration policies have
to engage in “organized abandonment” to accommodate public and private
investment in real estate. Relying on and reinforcing racial regimes of
ownership, red-lining becomes the mechanism through which people of
colour are excluded from homeownership in particular areas; racial
segregation is reinforced in the drive to accumulate profit through real
estate speculation and development. The managed decline of housing
estates in parts of London constitute a form of organised state
abandonment — the state relinquishing their duty to provide safe, secure
tenure for people on low incomes, in order to achieve the objective of
stimulating economic growth through real estate development. (See Anna
Minton, p. 10)
http://criticallegalthinking.com/2018/09/21/organised-state-abandonment-the-meaning-of-grenfell/ Sayfa 11 / 16
Organised State Abandonment: The Meaning of Grenfell 24.09.2018 20)06
This concept helps us do the work of understanding how the state and
capitalist interests devise means to subordinate and render particular
groups of people vulnerable to precarity, injury and premature death
across multiple scales, connecting decisions taken at the level of the local
estate to global financial interests in the real estate market; from decisions
taken by the Home Office regarding the deportation of individuals to a
http://criticallegalthinking.com/2018/09/21/organised-state-abandonment-the-meaning-of-grenfell/ Sayfa 12 / 16
Organised State Abandonment: The Meaning of Grenfell 24.09.2018 20)06
nationalist ideology that has always defined the true British subject as
white, male and propertied, revived by May’s hostile environment policy
and given new life by the Brexiteers. Avery F. Gordon uses the formulation
“organised socio-economic abandonment” to denote precisely this
combination of forces that operate to confine and capture the lives of the
worker, the enemy, the criminal, the migrant, the resident alien.
The absolute absence of concern (in the first instance) for the lives of
marginalised people has a particular resonance, historically speaking, in
the British domestic and colonial contexts. For instance, peruse any
legislation relating to the enclosure or appropriation of land, and you will
be hard-pressed to find references to those whose land was being enclosed
or stolen. Whether this was about commons lands being enclosed or
indigenous lands being appropriated by colonial authorities, those being
dispossessed never appear in the text, as if they did not exist at all. This is
not to say that the British colonial state did not legislate to govern these
populations, but that there is a clear erasure or absenting of particular
groups of people in the text of legislation pertaining to matters of property
and ownership.
http://criticallegalthinking.com/2018/09/21/organised-state-abandonment-the-meaning-of-grenfell/ Sayfa 13 / 16
Organised State Abandonment: The Meaning of Grenfell 24.09.2018 20)06
This brings me to the second significant insight we can derive from the
concept of organised abandonment, and this is the way in which a range of
state and capitalist forces can operate without public accountability. For
the mode of organised state abandonment in today’s world relies heavily
on deregulation and privatisation. Doing away with regulations and modes
of inspection that no longer suit the imperatives of state authorities that
have eschewed the aspiration to provide safe, secure social housing for
those in need of it, and instead, have adopted a mode of managing social
housing that relies heavily on private providers has produced a public-
private nexus of social provisioning that has muddied the waters of legal
accountability. But this admittedly complex legal situation is mired in
something even worse: a political ethos of neoliberalism premised on the
abandonment of responsibility as central to the governing ideals of
organisational action. Whatever sector we look at, the culture of buck
passing in which nobody seems to have responsibility for anything has
become as ubiquitous as the air we breathe. It is telling that Richard Millet
QC for the Public Inquiry, warned against this precise tendency already
making itself apparent in the proceedings, and in spite of his warning, this
is precisely what the Council and corporate actors went on to do in their
opening statements.
http://criticallegalthinking.com/2018/09/21/organised-state-abandonment-the-meaning-of-grenfell/ Sayfa 14 / 16
Organised State Abandonment: The Meaning of Grenfell 24.09.2018 20)06
I want to suggest that Claudia Davis, along with all other bereaved families
and survivors of the fire should have the right to argue with and confront
— and then demand compensation — from each and every actor involved
in the refurbishment and maintenance of Grenfell Tower. The legal
complexity of our privatised state functions, coupled with the culture of
impunity produced by the moral, ethical and political failure to take
responsibility could be turned on its head by making it clear from the
outset that anyone and everyone involved in the provision of state services
and goods is responsible for any and all failings that result in harm, injury
or death. As a corrective to our current culture of indifference we need
overlapping spheres of responsibility whereby the distinction between
state and corporate actor matters as little as it does when it comes to
providing social goods and to those profiting from privatisation. What
would this look like? Quite simply, RBKC, the KTMO, Rydon, and all the
http://criticallegalthinking.com/2018/09/21/organised-state-abandonment-the-meaning-of-grenfell/ Sayfa 15 / 16
Organised State Abandonment: The Meaning of Grenfell 24.09.2018 20)06
There is a kind of primitivism that lies at the heart of the New Labour and
Tory profiteering that caused these deaths — a sacrificial logic that puts the
lives of social housing tenants at risk of death by fire while keeping the
consciences of neoliberalism’s key architects unscathed and pure. Surely,
the human right to shelter and equality law have a place in the legal
proceedings unfolding in the Public Inquiry, as does the ongoing criminal
law investigation. However, whether the legal inquiry proceeds in the
sphere of public, private or criminal law this situation requires a sea
change in the legal structures of accountability to catch up with what we all
know to be true — that responsibility for this state of affairs must be spread
as liberally as opportunities for profit that have seeped into all facets of
what remains of our embattled social welfare state.
http://criticallegalthinking.com/2018/09/21/organised-state-abandonment-the-meaning-of-grenfell/ Sayfa 16 / 16