Project Management Team

KLCC PROJEKS SDN BHD (248537-P) WORK PACKAGE : Ganchong Water PACKAGE NO : N/a
K L C C
ECER Project Department Treatment Works

DOCUMENT TYPE : Geotechnical DATE RECEIVED : September 2012

Design Report – Ground
Treatment (Rev. 2)
CROSS REFERENCE : Design / Document Review DATE RECEIVED : 29 NOV. 2012
form (dated 30 Sept 2012)
DESIGN/ DOCUMENT REVIEW
DRAWING COMMENTS BY KLCC STATUS CONSULTANT’S RESPONSE
Geotechnical Design Table of Contents.
Report (Rev. 2) - Consultant to improve structure. Please see attached comments. - Table of contents revised as commented including page numbering.
Ground Treatment
- Section 2.0. Consultant to confirm the adequacy and correctness of - Statement of correctness and adequacy of SI are included in page 2,
the soil investigations. Please see attached for further comments. item 2.0

- Section 5.2. See Attached for Comments. - Drg no. ECER/INF/TG.AGAS-WS/RCSB/C&S/CN/485/01 or page G(ii)-1.
- Type of treatment and cost comparison as per Appendix B, page B(ii)-3.
- R&R advantages at page 16, item 9.0 d&e.

- Section 6.2 & 6.3. Consultant to explain why surcharge is needed - Surcharge is required to accelerate consolidation of soft clay.
even when PVD is provided. - Rest period is revised to 13 months (wider PVD spacing: 1.7m) based on
- See Attached for other Comments. the calculation and soil parameter.
- Drawing of ground treatment as appended in page Appendix G(ii)-1.
- Time of settlement calculations as per page Appendix A(i)b-1.
- Settlement calculation as per page Appendix A(i)c-1 & A(i)c-2.
- Conclusions about settlement are explained in report item 6.1 (page 6-
7).

- Section 7.1. See Attached for Comments. - Revised summary of instrumentation are tabulated in Table3, page 19.

- Section 8.0 & 9.0. See Attached for Comments. - Method of measurement detailed as per explanation on item 8.0
(pg.15).
- Summary of findings are concluded in item 9.0 (a) (page 16).
- A) DESIGN CALCULATIONS

- See Attached for Comments. - Table of contents and page no. included (page ii).
- Settlement calculation have revised to various height & thickness based
on zoning area.

/conversion/tmp/scratch/400332019.doc

Page 1 of 2
DRAWING/DOCUMENT COMMENTS BY KLCC STATUS CONSULTANT’S RESPONSE
- iv) Slope Stability Analysis - Table of contents and page no. included :
(i) Table of content - page ii
(ii) Appendix A(iv) : Slope stability analysis
- See Attached for Comments.

- C) SPECIFICATIONS : - Revised Instrumentation summary is tabulated in table 3 (page 19).

- See Comments as Attached.

- D) & E) - Borehole profile is used in the settlement and stability analysis and
- See Comments as Attached. also to generalize the soil profile.
- Lab results are used to described soil profile and plots as shown in
the interpretative report.
GENERAL STATUS: A-REVIEWED AND ACCEPTED Note: 1. CONSULTANTS TO LIST ACTION TAKEN ON THE COMMENTS IN THE SPACE PROVIDED.

A B C B-REVIEWED AND ACCEPTED WITH COMMENTS 2. THIS FORM IS TO BE ATTACHED WITH REVISED DRAWINGS TO BE SUBMITTED FOR REVIEW.
C-NOT ACCEPTED, TO REVISE AND RESUBMIT 3. THESE COMMENTS ARE NOT EXHAUSTIVE, CONSULTANTS TO COMPLY WITH ALL STATUTORY AND ECERDC REQUIREMENT.

PREPARED BY: CHECKED BY: REVIEWED BY: REVIEWED/RECEIVED BY:

SIGNATURE: …………………………..……… …………………………………… ………….……………………………….. …………………………………….

NAME: Terrence David Cheam Tow Hai Mohamed Shuhaidi bin Omar How Tar Tin
Senior Engineer Design Manager Project Manager

DATE:

/conversion/tmp/scratch/400332019.doc

Page 2 of 2