Prophet in Hindu Scriptures

An analysis (Part 1, 2 & 3)

Agniveer
 Prophet in Hindu Scriptures
An analysis (Part 1)
A relatively new
propaganda seems
to be on rage these
days – that Prophet
Muhammad (pbuh) has
been prophesised in Hindu
Scriptures. This seems to
be a great hit in major
Islamic websites over last
few years. It is also very
useful in increasing the
effectiveness of conversion
programs driven by vision
of making India a Muslim
among country within next
5 years (as resolved by
Maulana Abdullah Tariq
recently on Peace TV).
And why shouldn’t it
be effective. First, it is
proved that the Kalki
Avatar mentioned in
Bhavishya Puran is
none other than Prophet
Muhammad. Second, it is
Mission Agniveer - Vision Vedas. 1
also demonstrated that
Vedas, the final authority
in Hinduism, themselves
sang praise of Prophet
Muhammad.
Now the entry barriers
for a Hindu in embracing
Islam are suddenly
evaporated!
All that a devout Hindu
is doing now is accepting
the directions of his own
religion with further
sincerity.
Thus, when a close
friend of mine, who is an
expert in Islam, visited
a prominent temple in
the heart of Lucknow,
he was greeted by the
head priest. He could see
marks on forehead of the
priest. When discussions
continued on matter
of religion, the priest
explained to him how
Prophet is the final goal
for every Hindu and how
Islam alone can save
humanity.
has the space to check
relevance of his references.
The same style is evident
in his writing as well,
which form the basis of his
memorized speeches.

Now my friend realized And now, the confused

that the mark on the head Muslim youth has found a
was out of 5 times of daily new passion that confirms
prayer in submission to their seat in Paradise.
the legend who has been They would simply copy-
prophesised in Hindu paste from his articles
Scriptures! And this is the and spread the good
new direction of Islamic word around on internet
conversion techniques that forums, blogs and social
he has been witnessing. networking sites. The
print outs are circulated
In this series, we shall
in colleges and schools.
critically analyze the
This is often very effective
claims of this propaganda
against certain less-well-
and bring truth to the fore.
versed Hindus who fall
The founder of this under the ploy.
hypothesis is none other
I hope this article will
than the stage-performer
at least serve as a ready
Dr Zakir Naik who can
reference for answering
recite page number,
this propaganda through
chapter number and verse
a similar copy-paste if
number for any book
nothing more. However if
on earth. His style is so
this induces an attitude
hypnotic and entertaining
of questioning among the
that the audience no more
readers to seek the truth,

2 agniveer.com
and at least reject the
obvious falsehoods that
come in this journey, I
would consider my efforts
to be fruitful.
This series is based on the
original article written
by Dr Zakir Naik and
published on Islamic
Research Foundation
website. You can review
the same here: http://
www.irf.net/index.
php?option=com_content
&view=article&id=201&It
emid=131
Before we get into a more
detailed analysis, let us
argue a few more points:
1. Muslims have been
in India for around
1000 years now. And for
majority of the time, they
were ruling this country.
Why is it that Muslims
could not discover this
obvious fact in so many
years? In fact, study
of Vedas and Purans
were more popular in
Mission Agniveer - Vision Vedas. 3
those times than it is
today! Why is it that no
commentary on Vedas
written by anyone since
Vedas were first authored
(they are considered
the oldest books) could
ever discover such an
important fact which is
to decide the fate of the
world?After all, as per Dr
Naik and Quran, the only
way to book a ticket to
Paradise is by believing
in Prophet Muhammad
to be the last Prophet
and his message being
the only authoritative
message of God! Thus no
message of Vedas can be
more important than this
message, if it is indeed a
true fiction!
2. If indeed Vedas could
prophesise coming of
Prophet Muhammad, why
not consider Vedas to be
work of another Prophet?
Is it not a miracle that
the oldest book on earth
could predict arrival of the
last Prophet! So, why not
accept Vedas as book of
God?The usual answer to
this perplexing question is
that Vedas may have been
the first book, but Quran is
last and hence only Quran
has to be followed. Now
my counter-question is
that is God perfect or not?
If yes, which is what Quran
wants us to believe, then
why could not God give his
first book as final edition?
If God knows everything,
what made him change his
own theories? This means
that God is imperfect.
Here, when trapped, the
proponents weakly argue
that God’s knowledge is
same but the application
changes from time to time.
If that be so, should not
a new Quran come now
when the world order has
completely changed from
barbaric middle ages when
Quran had to accept evils
like slavery, polygamy and
gender discrimination?
4 agniveer.com
Further, Vedas talk of
rebirth. They talk of
monogamy. They talk
of Law of Karma and
refuse belief in Heaven
or Hell. They believe that
nature, God and soul
are beginning-less and
endless. Creation and
Destruction happen in
continuous cycles. These
are completely opposite to
Quranic view of polygamy,
one birth, permanent
Heaven or Hell and this
being the first and last
creation of God that
happened in few days a
few thousand years ago. I
can agree to some extent
to future plans being
modified by God as part of
some grand strategy, but
how can even God change
the history of universe
that had already happened
even before Vedas came in
Quran, his revised edition
of message? Is God so
forgetful of what he has
already done? If that be
so, what is the guarantee
that he will not realize
some more mistakes and
send another edition of his
message?
Secondly, if indeed
Vedas could predict about
Prophet Muhammad, and
Dr Zakir Naik sincerely
believes so, should he
not consider Vedas also
as a book by Prophets?
If not last, at least the
first one? This is where
Dr Naik’s corrupt tricks
get exposed. He fears
that any admission of any
other books apart from
those followed by believers
(Jews, Christians and
Muslims) being given by
God may put him in Hell
forever, as per instructions
in Quran. So in another
article of his, he flatly
refuses to admit that
Vedas are indeed books of
revelation. He conveniently
forgets that he himself has
proved that Vedas gave
the biggest prophecy of
all times – the advent of
Mission Agniveer - Vision Vedas. 5
Prophet Muhammad and
claims that
“ There is no text
in the Qur’an or Sahih
Hadith mentioning the
name of the revelation
that was sent to India.
Since the names of the
Vedas or other Hindu
scriptures are no where
to be found in Qur’an and
Sahih Hadith, one cannot
say for sure that they were
the revelations of God.
They may be the revelation
of God or may not be the
revelation of God.”
You can check it out
on his FAQ on Hinduism in
his IRF site (www.irf.net)
3. We should also
scrutinize what
qualifications Dr Zakir
Naik possesses to interpret
Vedas? Is he a Sanskrit
scholar or a Vedic Pandit?
Or has he referred to
works of any scholar? No!
He simply lists names of
some commentrators on
Vedas in his articles whom
he has referred to. Most
of these are either western
indologists who are
considered authentic in
first place, or some others
whom only Dr Naik knows.
Further he does not
provide exact translation
by any of the scholars
and only writes out the
commentary that suits his
predrawn conclusion. Even
6 agniveer.com
the western indologists did
not hint on even remotest
reference to Muhammad!
Thus all Dr Naik has done
is following the old art
of marketing, “That a lie
shouted thousand times
becomes a truth!”
In next parts of the
series, we will analyze the
prophecy of Muhammad
in Bhavishya Puran and
Vedas respectively.
 Prophet in Hindu Scriptures
Bhavishya Puran (Part 2)
Dr Naik provides a very
detailed analysis of verses
of Bhavishya Puran
along with references.
The only mistake he made
was that he presented
a completely opposite
picture of Prophet
Muhammad compared
to what Bhavishya Puran
actually writes. (Refer
http://www.irf.net/index.
php?option=com_content
&view=article&id=201&It
emid=131)
http://bhavishyapuran.
blogspot.com/ provides
an excellent analysis of
the relevant portions of
Bhavishya Puran with
scans of original texts and
dictionary meanings of the
key words.
In summary, the actual
meaning of the verses is as
follows:
Mission Agniveer - Vision Vedas. 7
“Shri Suta Goswami
said that a demon called
Tripurasur who was earlier
burnt to ashes by Shiva
has taken birth again
in form of Mahamada
(Muhammad) and his
deeds are like that of an
evil ghost. The ghost was
rebuked by Kalidas as “O
rascal, you have created
an illusion to bewilder the
king, I will kill you, you
are the lowest…”
Further, the ghost called
Mahamada comes in
dream of King Bhoja and
says,
“O king, your religion is of
course known as the best
religion among all. Still
I am going to establish
a terrible and demoniac
religion by the order of
the Lord . The symptoms
of my followers will be
that they first of all will Bhavishya Puran:
cut their genitals, have no
1. Bhavishya Puran
shikha, but having beard,
is not considered an
be wicked, make noise
authoritative religious
loudly and eat everything.
scripture. It is amply clear
They should eat animals
that the book continued
without performing
to be written till late
any rituals. This is my
19th century. Because
opinion. They will perform
it also contains stories
purificatory act with the
of Jesus Christ, Akbar,
musala or a pestle as you
Sawai Jai Singh, Alha
purify your things with
Udal, Tulsidas, Surdas,
kusha. Therefore, they will
Guru Nanak, Shahjahan,
be known as musalman,
Aurangzeb, Shivaji and
the corrupters of religion.
even Queen Victoria and
Thus the demoniac religion
her Parliament. Bulk of
will be founded by me.”
the material seems to be
It is amply clear that written during foreign rule.
contrary to Dr Naik’s Thus, Bhavishya Puran
claims, Mahamada does not even come in
(Muhammad) is being category of evidence, when
condemned here as a it comes to Hindu religion.
demon and not as a
2. Still if Dr Zakir
spiritual person. Far
Naik has infallible faith
from being a Kalki
in Bhavishya Puran, he
Avatar, Muhammad is
should also admit that
being foretold as a devil
Muhammad was a devil
harbinger of nuisance!
and reincarnation of
Having analyzed the Tripurasur.
verses, let us analyze a
3. Also, if Dr Naik
few more points regarding

8 agniveer.com
has so much trust on Muhammad
Bhavishya Puran and
According to Bhavishya
considers the book so
purana
prophetic, why does he
not admit other advices Mahamada (Incarnation
of the book – the fastings of Tripurasura the
on specific days and demon) = Dharmadushika
their benefits, worship of (Polluter of righteousness)
different idols, avoidance
Religion founded
of meat, celibacy, shraadh,
by Mahamada =
prohibition of marriage
Paisachyadharama
among close relatives,
(demoniac religion)
agnihotra, holy places,
cow protection etc. And Original Sanskrit Version:
accordingly, he should Bhavishya Puran: Prati
refuse to believe in those Sarg: Part III:3,3 5-27
verses of Quran which are
against the precepts of Translation source:
Bhavishya Puran. (http://www.indiadivine.
In the next part of the org/articles/188/1/
series, we shall critically Bhavishya-Purana-The-
examine the claim of Prediction-of-Islam/
Prophet Muhammad in Page1.html)
Vedas. [From the third part of
More on Bhavishya Puran: the Pratisarga Parva.]
Extracted from http:// Shri Suta Gosvami said:
bhavishyapuran.blogspot. In the dynasty of king
com/ Shalivahana, there were
Bhavishya Purana : The ten kings who went to
Prediction of Islam And the heavenly planets
after ruling for over 500

Mission Agniveer - Vision Vedas. 9

years. Then gradually After he offered some
the morality declined prayers and pleased him.
on the earth. At that
Suta Goswami said: After
time Bhojaraja was the
hearing the king’s prayers,
tenth of the kings on
Lord Shiva said: O king
the earth. When he saw
Bhojaraja, you should
that the moral law of
go to the place called
conduct was declining he
Mahakakshvara, that land
went to conquer all the
is called Vahika and now is
directions of his country
being contaminated by the
with ten-thousand soldiers
mlecchas. In that terrible
commanded by Kalidasa.
country there no longer
He crossed the river
exists dharma. There was
Sindhu and conquered over
a mystic demon named
the gandharas, mlecchas,
Tripura(Tripurasura),
shakas, kasmiris, naravas
whom I have already
and sathas. He punished
burnt to ashes, he has
them and collected a large
come again by the order of
ammount of wealth. Then
Bali. He has no origin but
the king went along with
he achieved a benediction
Mahamada (Muhammad),
from me. His name is
the preceptor of mleccha-
Mahamada(Muhammad)
dharma, and his followers
and his deeds are like
to the great god, Lord
that of a ghost. Therefore,
Shiva, situated in the
O king, you should not
desert. He bathed Lord
go to this land of the
Shiva with Ganges water
evil ghost. By my mercy
and worshipped him in
your intelligence will
his mind with pancagavya
be purified. Hearing
(milk, ghee, yoghurt, cow
this the king came
dung, and cow urine) and
back to his country and
sandalwood paste, etc.

10 agniveer.com
Mahamada(Muhammad)
came with them to
the bank of the river
Sindhu. He was expert
in expanding illusion, so
he said to the king very
pleasingly: O great king,
your god has become my
servant. Just see, as he
eats my remnants, so I will
show you. The king became
surprised when he saw this
just before them. Then in
anger Kalidasa rebuked
Mahamada(Muhammad)
“O rascal, you have
created an illusion to
bewilder the king, I will
kill you, you are the
lowest…”
That city is known as their
site of pilgrimage, a place
which was Madina or free
from intoxication. Having
a form of a ghost (Bhuta),
the expert illusionist
Mahamada(Muhammad)
appeared at night in front
of king Bhojaraja and
said: O king, your religion
is of course known as
Mission Agniveer - Vision Vedas. 11
the best religion among
all. Still I am going to
establish a terrible and
demoniac religion by the
order of the Lord . The
symptoms of my followers
will be that they first of
all will cut their genitals,
have no shikha, but having
beard, be wicked, make
noise loudly and eat
everything. They should
eat animals without
performing any rituals.
This is my opinion. They
will perform purificatory
act with the musala or
a pestle as you purify
your things with kusha.
Therefore, they will be
known as musalman, the
corrupters of religion.
Thus the demoniac religion
will be founded by me.
After having heard all
this the king came back
to his palace and that
ghost(Muhammad) went
back to his place.
The intelligent king,
Bhojaraj established the
language of Sanskrit managed by a king or
in three varnas – the demigods.
brahmanas, kshatriyas
Note This: Lord Shiva
and vaisyas – and for the
said: O king Bhojaraja,
shudras he established
you should go to the place
prakrita-bhasha, the
called Mahakakshvara,
ordinary language spoken
that land is called
by common men. After
Vahika and now is being
ruling his kingdom for
contaminated by the
50 years, he went to
mlecchas. In that terrible
the heavenly planet. The
country there no longer
moral laws established
exists dharma. There was
by him were honored
a mystic demon named
even by the demigods.
Tripura(Tripurasur), whom
The arya-varta, the pious
I have already burnt to
land is situated between
ashes, he has come again
Vindhyacala and Himacala
by the order of Bali.
or the mountains known
He has no origin but he
as Vindhya and Himalaya.
achieved a benediction
The Aryans reside there,
from me. His name is
but varna-sankaras reside
Mahamada(Muhammad)
on the lower part of
and his deeds are like that
Vindhya. The musalman
of a ghost.
people were kept on the
other side of the river According to Bhavishya
Sindhu. Purana Muhammad was
the rebirth of Tripurasura
On the island of Barbara,
the Demon. Tripurasura
Tusha and many others
was killed by Shiva in
also the followers of
his(Tripurasura’s) past
Isamsiha were also
life. Tripurasura’s Past
situated as they were
life (Mythology[not from

12 agniveer.com
bhavishya purana])
source(http://www.
ashtavinayaktemples.com/
temple.
Tripurasur was the son
of Sage Gritsamad. One
day the sage sneezed and
from this was created a
young boy who the Sage
brought up as his own
son. The sage taught the
boy the Ganana Twam,
Ganesh Mantra. Equipped
with this mantra the
boy meditated intensely
on Lord Ganesh who
ultimately blessed him. He
was given three pura-s of
gold silver and iron. Since
he was the owner of these
three pura-s he was given
the name Tripur. Ganesh
also bestowed on Tripur
to be the most powerful,
who none but Lord Shiva
himself could destroy
and after being destroyed
by Lord Shiva he would
attain mukti-salvation.
This boon made Tripur
Mission Agniveer - Vision Vedas. 13
proud and he brought
havoc in the entire world.
He conquered the Nether
world and then proceeded
to takeover Heaven. He
defeated Indra the king
of heaven. His aggression
made Lord Brahma hide
in a lotus and Lord Vishnu
in the Shirsagar. He
soon also took over Lord
Shiva’s Kailash Parvat
and thus became the King
of all the three worlds. The
gods wondered on how
to vanquish Tripurasur.
Lord Narada told them
that, since he had been
granted a boon by Lord
Ganesh himself it would be
very difficult to vanquish
him. He advised them to
meditate on Lord Ganesh.
Pleased Lord Ganesh
decided to help the Gods.
Disguised as brahmin he
visited Tripurasur and
told him that he was a
very enlightened Brahmin
and could make for him
three flying planes. Riding
these he woud be able to
go anywhere he wished
within minutes. The planes
could only be destroyed
by Shiva.In return Lord
Ganesh asked him to
get him the statue of
Chintamani which was
at the Kailash Mountain.
Lord Shiva refused to give
the statue to Tripurasur’s
messenger. The angry
Tripurasur himself went
to get the statue. A fierce
battle started between
him and Lord Shiva. He
destroyed everything that
belonged to the Lord
Shiva who too retired to
the Girikandar.
Lord Shiva too realized
that he was unable
to destroy Tripurasur
because he had not paid
his respects to Lord
Ganesh. He recited the
Shadaakshar Mantra to
invoke Ganesh. On doing so
from his mouth emerged
Gajanan to grant Shiva
a boon. Shiva continued
14 agniveer.com
his invocation of Ganesh
who ultimately directed
him on how Tripurasur
could be killed. Lord Shiva
was asked to recite the
Sahastranam and then
direct an arrow at the
three pura-s of Tripurasur.
Lord Shiva followed these
instructions and finally
vanquished Tripurasur.
The place where Lord
Shiva invoked Lord
Ganesh he also created a
temple for him. The town
surrounding this temple
was called Manipur. The
village Ranjangaon is
considered to be the place
where Lord Shiva himself
sought the blessings of
Ganesh and ultimately
destroyed Tripurasur.
This prayer (chalisa)
praises the Lord Shiva
(Related to Tripurasura
killing)
Tripurasur sang yuddha
machayi,
sabahin kripa kari leen
bachayi.
By fighting and killing the
Demon Tripurasur,
a mlechha.
3 A sinner, A wicked
person, A savage or
barbarian race etc…

You forgave everybody and Paisachya (meaning)

saved the Gods. (from Sanskrit dictionary)
Paisachya
Mlechha (meaning)
Demonical, Infernal
(from Sanskrit dictionary)
Tripurasura
mleccha Asura (meaning)
(from Sanskrit dictionary)
1 A barbarian,a non
Aryan ( One not speaking Asura
the Sanskrit Language or 1 An evil spirit,demon
not conform in to Hindu
2 A general name for the
or Aryan institutions),a
enemies of Gods,
foreigner in general
In the next part of the
2 An Outcast, a very low
series, we shall critically
man, Bodhayana thus
examine the claim of
defines the word:
Prophet Muhammad in
gomAmsakhAdako yastu Vedas.
viruddhaM bahubhAshhate
| sarvAchAravihInashcha
mlechchha ityabhidhiiyate

He who eats cow’s meat,

and speaks a lot against
shastras and he, who is
also devoid of all forms of
spiritual practice, is called

Mission Agniveer - Vision Vedas. 15

 Prophet in Hindu Scriptures
Vedas (Part 3)
Let us now critically
examine the claim of
Muhammad in Vedas.
You can read the
original article at http://
www.irf.net/index.
php?option=com_content
&view=article&id=201&It
emid=131
Let me declare at outset
that Vedas contain no
history or geography
whatsoever and contain
description of fundamental
principles governing life
and universe in a variety of
manner. There are indeed
names of several historical
persons in Vedas. But
that does not mean that
Vedas prophesise those
people. It only means
that those words were
popular and people chose
to adopt these names. If
we find mention of word
16 agniveer.com
“Krishna” in Mahabharat
or Vedas, it does not mean,
they prophesise about Lal
Krishna Advani! By that
logic, Bible prophesises
about all people born with
name George and Islamic
texts about people named
Muhammad, Ali etc!
I shall not dwell into the
concept of Vedas being
beyond prophecies, history
and geography in this
analysis. On contrary, we
shall prove that even if we
assume Vedas to contain
prophecies, that can no
way be associated with
Prophet Muhammad,
unless IRF believes that
Prophet Muhammad was
a mass murderer and
protector of cows, as we
shall see later. And if
indeed they believe so, let
them issue a world-wide
fatwa to start donating
cows, stop eating beef and
admitting that Prophet
Muhammad killed the
entire population of
Mecca! Just as they would
be issuing a fatwa that
Prophet Muhammad was
a ghost/demon incarnate
in name of Tripurasur (as
per Bhavishya Puran).
Going further, they should
also then accept the
theory of rebirth!
I shall quote the text
published at IRF website
as “IRF:” and the analysis
of the same as “Analysis:”
The actual meanings of
the mantras will be quotes
as “Actual:”
1. Prophet Muhammad
(pbuh) Prophesised in
Atharvaveda
IRF:
In the 20th book of
Atharvaveda Hymn 127
Some Suktas (chapters)
are known as Kuntap
Mission Agniveer - Vision Vedas. 17
Sukta. Kuntap means the
consumer of misery and
troubles. Thus meaning
the message of peace and
safety and if translated in
Arabic means Islam.
Analysis:
1. By this logic, all books
of spiritualism and self-
help and their content
would mean Islam!
Because Peace and
removal of misery are
the primary goals of any
spiritual text on self-help
book.
2. Considering that
Vedas came way before
Muhammad founded
Islam, this only means
that whatever peaceful
or good was brought by
Muhammad in Islam
was actually already a
part of Vedic traditions.
And that the word Islam
was already existing
way before Muhammad
adapted it to name his
cult.
It is welcoming that 96:
Muslims are now
“The first house (of
acknowledging that they
worship) appointed for
owe their peacefulness
men was that at Bakkah
to Vedas. I hope they
(Makkah) full of blessings
would take this journey of
and of guidance and for
seeking truth even further
all kinds of beings”. Thus
and completely embrace
Kuntap stands for Makkah
the Vedas to reach their
or Bakkah.
original roots.
Analysis:
IRF:
1. Which dictionary states
Kuntap also means hidden
that Kuntaap means
glands in the abdomen.
hidden glands in the
These mantras are called
abdomen?
so probably because their
true meaning was hidden 2. Further, even if it means
and was to be revealed in so, as researched by Dr
future. Its hidden meaning Naik, how does it link with
is also connected with the navel? In abdomen, all
navel or the middle point other organs are hidden
of this earth. Makkah is inside – liver, stomach,
called the Ummul Qur’a intestine etc. It is only the
the mother of the towns navel which is not hidden!
or the naval of the earth.
3. The third line of IRF
In many revealed books
quote obviously refers to
it was the first house of
Islamic belief of earth
Divine worship where God
being flat, and Muhammad
Almighty gave spiritual
being born in centre of
nourishment to the world.
the earth! But as per
The Qur’an says in Surah
Vedas and modern science,
Ali-Imran chapter 3, verse

18 agniveer.com
earth is almost spherical The story of Mecca being
and hence all points on it navel of earth seems
can be considered middle to indicate that there
point. was a grand statute of
reclining Vishnu there with
4. Had Mecca (Makkah)
Brahma coming to from
been on Equator, perhaps
his navel, as indicated by
some credibility could
certain researches. This
have been attached to IRF
is a popular Hindu image
claims. But as per modern
and may have led to story
science, in a non-flat
of Mecca being navel of
world, Mecca lies at 21-29
earth, in dark ages.)
N. It is not even on Tropic
of Cancer! But no way, can Kuntaap
be implied to mean
(The importance given
Mecca!
to Mecca in Islam is
because of historical 5. The logic of IRF is
reasons dating prior to fabulous:
advent of Islam. The
Kuntaapa = abdominal
worship of Mecca was so
glands = navel = center
popular that Muhammad
= center of the earth =
could not have spread
Mecca
Islam by opposing it. So
a religion that claims to hence, Kuntaapa = Mecca
worship only the shapeless,
Let’s use IRF logic on
omnipresent Allah would
Islam itself and see where
still seek to face Mecca
it leads us:
and visit it at least once to
get passport to Paradise. Poison = Death = Rest =
As per some historical Peace = Islam
researches, there was a
Hindu temple in Mecca. hence, Poison = Islam

Mission Agniveer - Vision Vedas. 19

So from IRF evidence
itself, there is cold, hard
proof that Islam is
Poison!
IRF:
Several people have
translated these Kuntap
Suktas like M. Bloomfield,
Prof. Ralph Griffith,
Pandit Rajaram, Pandit
Khem Karan, etc.
Analysis:
1. Of the translators
mentioned by IRF, two are
western indologists who
had their own Christian
agenda. They can no way
be considered relevant for
understanding of Vedas.
2. But interestingly, even
they talk of nothing
even remotely related to
Muhammad or Mecca
in the alleged verses.
The only common point
perhaps is the word camel.
It seems that IRF team
frantically searched for
various mantras referring
20 agniveer.com
to camel in Vedas, and
chose to interpret them,
as per their own agenda,
as would soon be evident.
Readers can review the
Griffith translation of
these mantras at http://
www.sacred-texts.com/
hin/av/av20127.htm and
decide themselves. They
can review translations
of other scholars
mentioned by IRF and
check truth themselves.
We shall provide excerpts
from translation by
Pandit Khem Karan as
illustration. You can
check them at http://
www.aryasamajjamnagar.
org/atharvaveda_v2/
atharvaveda.htm
3. In their pursuit of
searching mantras with
reference to camel, IRF
made another blunder. The
Kuntaap Sukta appear at
end of Atharvaveda and
are not considered to be
part of Veda Samhita,
but merely an addendum
(Khil Bhaag or Appendix)
by many scholars. This is
the only portion in entire
Vedas that have such
a difference in opinion
among scholars. Had IRF
chosen any other Sukta/
Hymn in more than 20000
mantras of Vedas, they
would have been much
safer. Thus Kuntaap which
IRF proved to mean
“safe” is not that safe
to defend their claim of
Muhammad in Vedas!
IRF:
The main points mentioned
in the Kuntap Suktas i.e.
in Atharvaveda book 20
Hymn 127 verses 1-13
are:
Mantra 1
He is Narashansah or the
praised one (Muhammad).
He is Kaurama: the prince
of peace or the emigrant,
who is safe, even amongst
a host of 60,090 enemies.
Mantra 2
Mission Agniveer - Vision Vedas. 21
He is a camel-riding Rishi,
whose chariot touches the
heaven.
Mantra 3
He is Mamah Rishi who is
given a hundred gold coins,
ten chaplets (necklaces),
three hundred good steeds
and ten thousand cows.
Mantra 4
Vachyesv rebh. ‘Oh! ye
who glorifies’.
Analysis:
Mantra 1
Actual Meaning
(Pandit Khem Karan):
Narashanshah or the
praised one shall be
praised. O Kauram – one
who dwells happily on
earth, we shall receive
60090 kinds of gifts from
those brave ones who have
destroyed violent ones.
Mantra 2, 3
Actual Meaning (Pandit
Khem Karan): His chariot
has twenty fast-moving
camels and she-camels.
He donated 100 gold
coins, 10 garlands, 300
horses and 10000 cows to
deserving people.
Mantra 4
Actual Meaning (Pandit
Khem Karan): Keep
preaching in the manner
a bird chirps on a tree
laden with fruits till death
comes.
So far, nothing seems odd
about the meanings given
by IRF or other scholars.
The only differences is
that certain terms have
subtly been introduced
to set the context for
proving Muhammad in
these mantras. In modern
parlance, this technique is
called covert persuasion.
Note that so far nothing
hints at Muhammad
except that there is a
mention of camel!
22 agniveer.com
Now let us enjoy the IRF
research magic!
IRF:
The Sanskrit word
Narashansah means ‘the
praised one’, which is the
literal translation of the
Arabic word Muhammad
(pbuh).
Analysis:
1. The Arabic term b-ismi-
llāhi r-raḥmāni r-raḥīm
which is uttered before
every verse of Quran
is literal translation of
“Dayanand ki Jai”. Does
it mean that Quran sings
glory of Dayanand? Now
Dayanand has been the
strongest critic of Quran
ever. So does it mean
that Quran admits that
Dayanand is right?
2. Again this is nothing
but Poison = Death = Rest
= Peace = Islam, hence
Islam = Poison ( we shall
keep revisiting this logic
wherever IRF uses the
same logic as well)
IRF:
The Sanskrit word
Kaurama means ‘one who
spreads and promotes
peace’. The holy Prophet
was the ‘Prince of Peace’
and he preached equality
of human kind and
universal brotherhood.
Kaurama also means an
emigrant. The Prophet
migrated from Makkah
to Madinah and was thus
also an Emigrant.
Analysis:
1. Kaurama means ‘one
who dwells peacefully
on earth’. Now history is
evident of how peaceful
has Prophet’s life been,
how many peaceful battles
he waged, how peacefully
he conquered Mecca and
how peaceful is Islamic
concept of brotherhood
for non-believers in Quran/
Prophet.
2. The way Prophet
Mission Agniveer - Vision Vedas. 23
migrated from Makkah
to Madinah, has been
replicated by millions
throughout the history.
One can hardly name a
historically famous person
who becomes famous
without moving around!
Krishna migrated from
Vrindawan to Mathura
and then to Dwarka.
Also Krishna has several
meanings which mean
‘promoter of peace’ and
‘praised one’. So this verse
equally applies to him as
well!
3. Again the logic is same:
Poison = Death = Rest =
Peace = Islam
IRF:
He will be protected from
60,090 enemies, which
was the population of
Makkah.
Analysis:
From which census
did IRF find out this
population figure? Or is
yet another revelation?
IRF:
The Prophet would ride
a camel. This clearly
indicates that it cannot be
an Indian Rishi, since it is
forbidden for a Brahman
to ride a camel according
to the Sacred Books of
the East, volume 25,
Laws of Manu pg. 472.
According to Manu Smirti
chapter 11 verse 202, “A
Brahman is prohibited
from riding a camel or an
ass and to bathe naked. He
should purify himself by
suppressing his breath”.
Analysis:
1. The mantra says
allegorically that the
chariot of the king will
have twenty male and
female camels. Even if
we take it literally, did
Muhammad ever travel
on such a camel-chariot?
And is Prophet the only
camel-rider on earth ever
in history?
24 agniveer.com
2. The mantra talks about
a king who is a Kshatriya
and not a Brahman. So
the relevant excerpt from
Manu is not applicable in
first place.
3. Vedas nowhere prohibit
camel-ride for anyone.
4. Manu Smriti has been
written much after Vedas.
So evidence of Manu
Smriti is not applicable
in first place. Also the
particular shloka from
Manu Smriti is considered
a later day interpolation
by many scholars. In fact
half of the Manu Smriti
is considered interpolated
because it is against
the Vedas, which Manu
himself declares to be
most supreme.
5. But even if we agree
to this shloka of Manu
Smriti, it is not applicable
or relevant in context
of given mantras of
Atharvaveda. Further
the shloka simply states
that if a Brahman has
to ride on a camel, he
can purify himself by
doing Pranayam. It does
not say that Brahman
is banned from riding
camel. And the mantra
or the entire Sukta has
no reference to Brahman
whatsoever. It talks about
battle and war, which is
prerogative of Kshatriya
and not Brahman, as per
traditional Manu system.
IRF:
This mantra gave the
Rishi’s name as Mamah.
No rishi in India or
another Prophet had this
name Mamah which is
derived from Mah which
means to esteem highly,
or to revere, to exalt, etc.
Some Sanskrit books
give the Prophet’s name
as ‘Mohammad’, but
this word according to
Sanskrit grammar can
also be used in the bad
sense. It is incorrect to
apply grammar to an
Mission Agniveer - Vision Vedas. 25
Arabic word. Actually
shas the same meaning
and somewhat similar
pronunciation as the word
Muhammad (pbuh).
Analysis:
1. The word “Mamahe”
is used in the 3rd
mantra of 127th sukta
of Atharvaveda and not
“Mamah”. There is a
world of difference as we
will see in next point. The
derivation as given by IRF
is their own independent
research not corroborated
by any text on grammar.
2. The word ‘Mamahe’ has
been used as a verb here,
meaning “We give” and
NOT a noun.
3. Further the word has
been used in plural and
not singular. So it can not
denote a singular person
by wildest stretch of
imagination.
4. If the word ‘Mamahe’
has to mean a noun
‘Muhammad’ in this 100 in number initially.
mantra, the mantra Some biographers do hint
becomes meaningless. at 40 followers, but 100
Because ‘Mamahe’ is the seems to be another new
ONLY verb in the entire revelation. Refer http://
mantra. And no sentence www.religionfacts.com/
can have any meaning islam/history/prophet.htm
without presence of even a
Thus this is the Prophetic
single verb!
imagination taken too far!
IRF:
IRF:
He is given 100 gold
The 10 chaplets or
coins, which refers to the
necklaces were the 10 best
believers and the earlier
companions of the Holy
companions of the Prophet
Prophet (pbuh) known as
during his turbulent
Ashra-Mubbashshira (10
Makkan life. Later on
bestowed with good news).
due to persecution they
These were foretold in this
migrated from Makkah
world of their salvation
to Abysinia. Later when
in the hereafter i.e. they
Prophet migrated to
were given the good news
Madinah all of them
of entering paradise by
joined him in Madinah.
the Prophet’s own lips and
Analysis: after naming each one he
said “in Paradise”. They
1. Suddenly, gold coins
were Abu Bakr, Umar,
have turned into believers
Uthman, Ali, Talha, Zubair,
with Prophet in his Mecca
Abdur Rahman Ibn Auf,
times!
Saad bin Abi Waqqas,
2. No text of Islam states Saad bin Zaid and Abu
that his followers were Ubaidah (May Allah be

26 agniveer.com
well-pleased with all of
them).
Analysis:
1. What made IRF
think that necklace
can mean companions?
Merely the fact that 10
companions of Prophet
are very famous in Islamic
folklores? Almost all
Prophets of Islam roamed
in desert and hence were
camel riders.
2. So why can’t this mean
Ten Commandments of
Moses, by same logic!
IRF:
The Sanskrit word Go is
derived from Gaw which
means ‘to go to war’. A
cow is also called Go
and is a symbol of war
as well as peace. The
10,000 cows refer to
the 10,000 companions
who accompanied the
Prophet (pbuh) when he
entered Makkah during
Fateh Makkah which
Mission Agniveer - Vision Vedas. 27
was a unique victory in
the history of mankind
in which there was no
blood shed. The 10,000
companions were pious
and compassionate like
cows and were at the same
time strong and fierce and
are described in the Holy
Quran in Surah Fatah:
“Muhammad is the
Messenger of Allah;
and those who are with
him are strong against
unbelievers, (but)
compassionate amongst
each other.”
[Al-Qur’an 48:29]
Analysis:
1. This is yet another
research of Dr Naik that
‘Go’ means ‘to go to war’.
‘Go’ indeed means a lot of
things in various mantras
depending on the context –
Cow, Earth, Moving Body
etc. But in the current
context, where the subject
is of donation, the obvious
meaning is ‘Cow’.
Donation of Cow has
been a longstanding Vedic
tradition still practiced
and respected. All Vedic
legends were preservers
and protectors of cow. All
noble Vedic kings were
known to donate cows.
Cow forms the backbone
of Vedic civilization and
Hinduism.
This is where IRF comes
in tight spot. Because
contrary to donating
cows, Muhammad and
his followers till today
are known to be the
biggest tribe of cow-
killers. They take pride in
killing cows in Id. Thus,
this reference to donating
10000 cows is sufficient
enough to prove the most
sceptic mind that these
mantras have anything
even remotely to do with
Prophet Muhammad or
any of his predecessors or
successors.
2. It is even more hilarious
to see the comparison of
28 agniveer.com
10000 companions of
Muhammad with cow. If
they mean cow, then cow
cannot mean ‘to go at war’
in this mantra. Because
the same word cannot
mean two completely
different things in same
context.
3. If indeed Muslims
consider cows to be
compassionate and pious,
as described in IRF
article, what makes them
kill these cows in name
of Allah? What makes
Muhammad a cow-killer if
that be so?
4. In fact in this mantra,
to make sense in lines
of IRF propaganda,
Go has to mean three
things – to go at war (a
verb), symbol of peace
and symbol of war, all at
the same time! It has to
be a verb and a noun at
the same time! Because
‘Mamahe’ the only verb
in the mantra has been
deliberately interpreted
as a noun in this mantra r-raḥīm is another way of
by IRF experts. Thus this saying “Dayanand ki Jai!”
would have to be the only
Battle of the Allies
sentence of its kind in
described in the Vedas.
history of language where
a word is a verb and two IRF:
nouns at same time, and
It is mentioned in
another word which is
Atharvaveda Book XX
supposed to be a verb is
Hymn 21 verse 6, “Lord
now a noun.
of the truthful! These
Sounds confusing, right? liberators drink these
But then confusion alone feats of bravery and the
can breed such blinded inspiring songs gladdened
theories! thee in the field of battle.
When thou renders
IRF:
vanquished without
This mantra calls the fight the ten thousand
Prophet as Rebh which opponents of the praying
means one who praises, one, the adoring one.”
which when translated into
This Prophecy of the
Arabic is Ahmed, which is
Veda describes the well-
another name for the Holy
known battle of Ahzab
Prophet (pbuh).
or the battle of the Allies
Analysis: during the time of Prophet
Muhammed. The Prophet
Again the same logic of
was victorious without an
1. Poison = Death = Rest actual conflict which is
= Peace = Islam mentioned in the Qur’an in
Surah Ahzab:
=> Poison = Islam
“When the believers saw
2. b-ismi-llāhi r-raḥmāni

Mission Agniveer - Vision Vedas. 29

the confederate forces they
said, “This is what Allah
and His Messenger had
promised us and Allah
and His Messenger told
us what was true.” And
it only added to their
faith and their zeal in
obedience.”
[Al-Qur’an 33:22]
The Sanskrit word karo
in the Mantra means the
‘praying one’ which when
translated into Arabic
means ‘Ahmed’, the
second name of Prophet
Muhammed (pbuh).
The 10,000 opponents
mentioned in the Mantra
were the enemies of the
Prophet and the Muslims
were only 3000 in number.
The last words of the
Mantra aprati ni bashayah
means the defeat was
given to the enemies
without an actual fight.
Analysis:
Actual Meaning (Pandit
30 agniveer.com
Khem Karan): “O
Protector of Truthful!
You have been pleased
by those brave ones who
produce bliss, by acts of
bravery and noble passion
in wars against the
enemies. Through smart
action oriented zeal, ten
thousand enemies have
been defeated without
resistance.”
1. If indeed it means
Battle of Ahzab, why is
the number of soldiers in
Prophet’s army not given?
2. The phrase Dash Sahsra
or its variants are used in
several places in Vedas to
signify a large number or
limitlessness.
3. There is no word as
‘Karo’ in the mantra. The
closest sounding word in
the mantra is “Karave’
which DOES NOT mean
praying one’. It means
‘for the action-oriented’.
NO name of Muhammad
means ‘action-oriented’.
So any connection
with Muhammad is
categorically ruled out.
4. The mantra refers to
spiritual battle where the
mind destroys innumerable
varieties of negative
thoughts through practice
and meditation of positive
things in life. And hence
the victory is bloodless.
The sukta can also be
interpreted to explain
strategies of war. But no
way does it, or any mantra
in Vedas refers to any kind
of history.
IRF team is advised to
consult the Vedic experts
to understand the hidden
treasures and deep
essence of Vedic mantras
and come back to their
original roots, rejecting
the falsehood.
IRF:
The enemies’ defeat in the
conquest of Makkah is
mentioned in Atharvaveda
book 20 Hymn 21 verse
Mission Agniveer - Vision Vedas. 31
no 9:
“You have O Indra,
overthrown 20 kings
and 60,099 men with an
outstripping Chariot wheel
who came to fight the
praised one or far famed
(Muhammad) orphan.”
The population of Makkah
at the time of Prophet’s
advent was nearly 60,000.
There were several clans
in Makkah each having
its own chief. Totally there
were about 20 chiefs to
rule the population of
Makkah. An Abandhu
meaning a helpless man
who was far-famed and
‘praised one’. Muhammad
(pbuh) overcame his
enemies with the help of
God.
Analysis:
1. There is no census data
to validate that Mecca had
a population of 60,000 in
Muhammad’s era except
IRF research based on
their own revealed sources.
2. Literal translation of
this mantra means that
60000 plus enemies
and their 20 kings were
crushed under the chariots.
By this logic, there should
be 60,000 soldiers in
the battlefield. If that be
so, it means that entire
population of Mecca
fought against Muhammad
and were killed by him. If
that be so, if this mantra
be a true Prophecy,
Muhammad cannot be
a symbol of peace. On
contrary, it proves that
Muhammad carried out
a mass genocide of entire
Mecca population because
they refused to accept him
as their dictator! Then,
Islam remains a religion
of peace only in Arabic
dictionary, and not in
reality!
3. In reality, this Balttle of
Mecca was as small tribal
battle where 900-1000
soldiers and 300 soldiers
of Islam have supposed
32 agniveer.com
to have fought for a few
hours, as per Islamic
experts. And not more
than 10 leaders are known
to have participated
from Meccan side. Thus
neither the number 20,
nor 60000 in mantra has
any reference to this tiny
battle.
4. This sukta actually
details spiritual battle
in the mind as is evident
from other mantras in the
sukta. The same strategies
can be extended to
external war as well. But it
has no inkling of relation
with any tribal war.
And if still, it is assumed
to have so, it only means
Muhammad was a mass-
killer. IRF experts can
decide what they want to
accept.
III. Muhammad (pbuh)
prophesised in the Rigveda
IRF:
A similar prophecy is also
found in Rigveda Book I, which only denigrate
Hymn 53 verse 9: him. Their research of
Muhammad in Bhavishya
The Sanskrit word used is
Puran has already proved
Sushrama, which means
him a demon and a ghost
praiseworthy or well
Tripurasur!
praised which in Arabic
means Muhammad (pbuh). IV. Muhummad (pbuh)
is also prophesised in the
Analysis:
Samveda
1. Literally translated,
IRF:
the meaning is similar to
previous verse, implying Prophet Muhammad
Muhammad carried a (pbuh) is also prophesised
mass-genocide of 60000 in the Samveda Book II
plus people to rule Mecca Hymn 6 verse 8:

2. Sushravasa means a “Ahmed acquired from

good listener or a reliable
friend in this mantra,
nothing to do with
Muhammad.
3. Even if its means well
praised, it only means
that Muhammad was
well-praised by his men
for carrying carnage of
60000 people of Mecca!
It is in best interest of
IRF to not harp on such
attempts to discover
Muhammad in Vedas
his Lord the knowledge
of eternal law. I received
light from him just as from
the sun.” The Prophecy
confirms:
The name of the Prophet
as Ahmed since Ahmed
is an Arabic name. Many
translators misunderstood
it to be Ahm at hi and
translated the mantra as
“I alone have acquired
the real wisdom of my
father”.

Mission Agniveer - Vision Vedas. 33

Prophet was given eternal becomes ‘d’. For example,
law, i.e. the Shariah. ‘Sat’ + ‘Aachaar’ =
“SaDaachaar”. ‘Hi’ means
The Rishi was enlightened
only.
by the Shariah of Prophet
Muhammad. The Qur’an 3. If indeed Vedas
says in Surah Saba predicted word ‘Ahmad’
chapter 34 verse 28 which is Arabic word, does
it mean Arabic is older
“We have not sent
than Vedic Sanskrit?
thee but as a universal
(Messenger) to men, 4. If Vedas could predict
giving them glad tidings upto ‘Ahmad’ and
and warning them (against number of his armymen
sin), but most men and companion, what
understand not.” prevented Vedas from
predicting his actual name
Analysis:
“Muhammad”? Why did
This is laughing Jehad at Allah create so much
its best. The aim to kill of confusion? Had he
infidels by making them simply put the biography
laugh like anything. of Muhammad in a few
mantras clearly spelling
1. I tried my best to
his name, crores of people
locate this mantra in the
would have been convinced
Samaveda but could not.
of Prophet’s coming and
Maybe if they can provide
would have prevented
the exact mantra, that
themselves from going to
would help.
Hell! Allah must be crazy
2. ‘Aham At Hi’ is as per IRF research, then!
authentic Sanskrit way
General Analysis
of expression. And in
joining of words, ‘t’ 1. If indeed Vedas have

34 agniveer.com
prophecy on Muhammad,
why are they not in one
place. In an ocean of
20000 mantras, there
are only 7 mantras
about Prophet, the most
important topic of the
Vedas who would change
the entire structure of
Vedic concept topsy-
turvy! These too are
distributed randomly and
none clearly spelled the
name of Muhammad. They
only mean Muhammad
in same way as Islam
means Poison. Was it that
Allah was still confused
about the name of his last
Prophet?
2. If indeed Vedas predict
that Muhammad would
kill so many people and
make 10 his companion,
it means that Allah had
already decided that
these people would be
killed by Muhammad and
dispatched to Hell. He had
pre-decided the fate of
these people millenniums
Mission Agniveer - Vision Vedas. 35
before he gave them birth
on earth! Does it not
make Allah unjust and
biased?
3. If indeed Vedas could
predict Muhammad and
his life, why is IRF and
Muslim world shy about
embracing Vedas as Books
of God? Why he has to
write in FAQ on Hinduism
that Vedas may or MAY
NOT be book of God?
4. And if Vedas can predict
Muhammad, and they talk
of concepts which clearly
contradict Quran, which
one should be believed?
After all Quran was
written 20 years after
Muhammad’s death, there
was no oral tradition of
memorizing and protecting
Quran in Muhammad’s
times and his favorite
followers were fighting
of each others’ lives after
Muhammad died! So how
can we trust Quran to be
authentic?
But Vedas have an oral
tradition since its inception
and inbuilt mechanism to
prevent any interpolation
of even a syllable. So
they are definitely the
most protected books of
the world. So should not
IRF, Dr Zakir Naik and
his followers return to
their roots which are so
accurate, unchanged and
so strong in predicting
future?
Further, they predict
Muhammad as nothing
but mass-murderer, by
IRF’s own research in
Vedas! Their research in
Bhavishya Puran proved
him to be a ghost or
demon called Tripurasur
who is supposed to bring
lot of nuisance in the
world! (Kindly refer to
previous part of this
series)
They say that lie has no
feet! Hence it gets you
trapped!
36 agniveer.com
I appeal to all my lost
friends – IRF, Dr Zakir
Naik, his friends and his
followers - to explore
the real praiseworthy, the
real Narashansah in the
Vedas, the Ishwar and
reject false prophecies
about false prophets. Such
falsehood can only trap
you in your own mistaken
notions in same way as
this falsehood has trapped
you logically without any
room for escape.
I appeal to them to stop
believing in and spreading
myths and return back to
their original path – the
path of Truth and Reason!
Only then can peace be on
him (pbuh)!