Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Hosted by
Indian Association of Investment Professionals (IAIP)
Submitted by
JUNO
Juno – Student Research
Sector – Textile, Readymade Apparel
BSE: 532827 | NSE: PAGEIND| ISIN: INE761H01022
PAGE INDUSTRIES LIMITED
Date: 02/11/2016 Current Price: INR 16143.8 (BSE) Recommendation: BUY (22.75%)
Ticker: PAG IN (Bloomberg) USD 1.00: INR 66.7 Target Price: INR 19817.17
Page Industries Limited
This report is published for
educational purposes only by Highlights
students competing in the CFA
Research Challenge We issue a buy recommendation on Page Industries ltd with a one year
target price of INR 19817.17, indicating a 22.75% upside potential on
Share Price Returns
closing price of INR 16143.8 (BSE) on November 02, 2016. The key
rationale behind BUY recommendation are:
Growth Drivers
Page Industries owns licenses for Jockey and Speedo. Both the brands
are affordable but is positioned premium. The branded innerwear
industry in India has shown a compounding growth rate 9%. Increasing
Page Industries Sensex discretionary income and will further drive this industry with similar
Source: Moneycontrol growth rates.
Strong Brand Equity
Market Portfolio
Page Industries has successfully leveraged the brand image of Jockey
Last 16107
Change -247.75 -1.51%
International. It has a strong brand image with a brand equity score of
Bid 16107 17 4.6 among its competitors as per Neilsen survey. It caters to varied
Ask 16278.1 15 population segment with its diverse product line.
Opn/Cls 16015 16354.7 Excellent Financial Profile
Hi/Low 16390 16015
Page Industries has almost no debt on its balance sheet. The
52Hi 17399 10/24/2016
company’s ROE remains at 50% for last 5 years, which is the highest
52Low 9752.35 3/1/2016
among their peers. Total reserves and surplus balance of over INR 500
YTD 2737.3 20.47%
1yRet 2535.5 18.53% crore is adequate to meet the future capital expenditure requirements.
Beta 0.825 SENSEX Page has reduced its cash conversion cycle from 2015 to 2016 which is
AVAT 13.30k -55.23% a positive sign for the company’s long term growth.
MktCap 179.65B Valuations
ADV 214.15M
Valuation based on DCF approach shows the intrinsic value of stock to
Auct Px 16015.05
be INR 16411.46 per share. Page Industries focusses on increasing
Auct Vol 50
Source: Bloomberg profitability, distribution network and brand image. Company is
expected to show higher sales revenue with new product lines
FY-14 FY-15 FY-16 introduced.
Revenue 1,194.17 1,551.63 1,789.67
Risk Factors
Profit 153.78 196.02 232.66
The primary risk factors faced by Page Industries include currency risk
Reserves 277.85 375.61 494.07
0.49 0.35 0.15
that can have impact on royalty payments and raw material cost; input
D/E Ratio
ROE 53.21% 50.68% 46.04%
factor risk (labour and raw material risk). Page Industry now
Source: Team Calculations participates in a very competitive environment among international
brands like Hanes, FCUK, Tommy Hilfiger, US Polo Assn, and Benetton
in India.
Business Description
Figure 1: India Textile and Apparel
Industry Page Industries Ltd. is the exclusive licensee of Jockey International
250 Inc. (USA) and Speedo International Ltd. for manufacturing,
200
distribution and marketing in India, Nepal, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka and
CAG UAE.
150 PIL has increased the recognition of innerwear as branded apparel in
100
Exports India through brand Jockey. In India, innerwear segment is highly
Domestic unorganised and PIL has been successful in getting a foothold in the
50 organised segment. Speedo is also gaining popularity in India.
0 Swimming has been recognised as an important life skill and increasing
importance of factors such as fitness, hobby, healthy living and weight
management are giving further push to it.
Source: BI, Bloomberg The company began operations in 1995. As of June 2016, it has 13
state-of-the art manufacturing units spread over 1.78 Million sq. ft.
across India with 19,000 strong workforces.
Figure 2: Revenue Breakdown Business Segmentation
Others
2% People in the age group of 15-34 years are the largest consumers of
PIL. Jockey’s products consist of innerwear, socks and leisure wear.
Brand Jockey positions itself in Super premium/lifestyle, aspirational
Liesurew and medium premium brand segment. They have launched various
ear Mens
30% Innerwea categories like Pop colour, USA originals and leisure wear to attract the
r style conscious young people.
Womens 50%
Innerwea
Speedo products consists of swimwear, equipment, water shorts,
r apparel and footwear.
18%
Company Strategy
PIL incorporates Jockey’s philosophy of providing individual freedom
Source: Company Annual Report 2015-16
and promoting uniqueness. Brand portrays itself as spontaneous,
Table 1: City wise presence of EBOs playful and effortless and not confined and routine driven. PIL has
access to ideas, innovations and trends from Jockey International, USA
Major Cities Number of EBOs
and other Jockey licensees throughout the world. It has a strong in-
New Delhi 7
house product development department and is continuously evolving
Hyderabad 28 itself to gain manufacturing expertise and state-of the art technology.
Bengaluru 26 Women innerwear market is worth Rs.12150 crore which contributes
Mumbai 17 to 60% of the total innerwear market in India. PIL is targeting the
Chennai 22 increasing number of working and brand conscious women who desire
Kolkata 9 better fit and quality alongside a wider range of colours, styles, and
Source: Company Website
accessories.
Distributor Network Expansion
Table 2: Product Category Growth Rate Brand Jockey is present in 1400+ towns and cities and is sold through
Expected Growth 277 plus Exclusive Brand Outlets (EBO), 895 Large Format Stores (LFS),
Product Line (Next 10 years) Multi Brand Outlets (MBO), Traditional hosiery stores and Multi-
Men Category 9% purpose stores which is spread pan India.
Women Category 15% Speedo is sold through 1099 outlets in 106 cities which comprises of 18
T Shirt 13% distributors, 9 exclusive brand stores, 140 large format stores and
Kids Category 10.50% other retail stores.
Digitization
Source: Investors Reports
Jockey has launched its own B2C e-commerce portal and has also tied
up with other online retailers to expand its reach.
Opportunities
Increase in organised retail and disposable income are giving a
favourable push to PIL’s products. Consumers are becoming fashion
conscious, aspirational and brand savvy. Increase in women corporate
workforce and urban women population are further helping PIL in
Figure 3: Sales Revenue (in million INR)
establishing itself.
20000 Threats
Many famous foreign brands are entering Indian markets due to the
15000
potential here. Apparel industry is highly labour intensive and needs
10000
experienced and trained manpower. Availability of raw material at a
reasonable rate is also a main concern for PIL.
5000
Management and Governance
0
2012-13 2013-14 2014-15 2015-16
Source: Annual Reports
PIL is committed to practice of good corporate governance which
emphasis on integrity and accountability. It incorporates high level of
business ethics and effective supervision to enrich the stakeholder’s
value through business excellence. PIL timely and regularly discloses
critical aspects such as financial statements on a timely basis, insider
holdings, audit and nomination & remuneration committee,
Figure 4: Shareholding Pattern compensation policy, and shareholding rights.
Board of Directors
Foreign List of members of Board of Directors is given in Appendix A. The
10% Promoters Independent Directors are briefed at regular intervals about their legal
Public and regulatory roles. A familiarisation program is organised whenever
51% shareholding an Independent director is appointed.
39%
Institutions Insider Holding
Public
shareholding Two Non-Executive Director – Promoters and a Managing Director –
Non-Institutions Promoter are holding about 16.33% of shares each which might lead to
biased decisions on their part. None of the other directors are holding
Source: Company Annual Report
significant number of shares in the company.
Committees
Audit, nomination and remuneration committees have been
established to guide and manage the firm’s operation. Both the
committees are chaired by a combination of Independent and non-
Figure 5: EPS and DPS executive directors (Appendix B). Audit Committee oversees
250 company’s financial reporting process, approval for appointment of
209
176
CFO, obtain legal and professional advice. Nomination and
200
138 remuneration committee looks after performance evaluation,
150
101 appointment and removal of Board of Directors.
85
100
60 72 Shareholder Rights
50
50 PIL has the policy of one share one vote and the facility of e-voting (if
0 the shareholder is unable to attend AGM). This mechanism ensures
2012-13 2013-14 2014-15 2015-16 that the rights as well as the calls of the general public don’t go
uncalled for.
EPS per share Dividend per share
Social Responsibility
Source: Company Annual Report PIL has identified and partnered with Grassroots Research and
Advocacy Movement (GRAAM) to identify and spend the CSR
effectively and wisely towards good cause in a sustainable fashion.
Company is committed to health and safety of its employee and
customers and protecting the environment. They strive to reduce,
reuse and recycle waste. PIL actively donates to ‘Have a Heart
Foundation’. It aims to eradicate hunger, poverty and malnutrition and
provide education to the deprived section of the society. It promotes
gender equality and developing rural areas.
Management
ROE Decomposition
PAGE has been enjoying a good ROE as compared to that of the
industry over the years and has outperformed its peers when it comes
to ROE. The reason is primarily because of lower asset to equity ratio
due to lower dependency on debt, more efficient use of assets leading
to higher asset turnover and lower interest payments.
(1*2*3*4*5) 1 2 3 4 5 6(2*5)
Figure 14: Cash Conversion Cycle (in days) Net Profit Pretax
EBIT Sales Assets Compound
Year ROE /Pretax Profit
/Sales /Assets /Equity leverage
Profit /EBIT
100
80 Financial Ratios
FY-12 FY-13 FY-14 FY-15 FY-16 PIL’s Cash conversion cycle is quite low as compared to its peers which
Source: Team Calculations indicates the company’s long term growth as less cash is tied up in the
inventory and trade receivables. Company enjoys a good credit terms
with the lenders and other creditors. Though in 2016 the trend has
reversed a bit but it can be controlled if better inventory management
Figure 15: Financial Leverage (D/E) techniques are employed by the company such as JIT, ABC Analysis and
0.6 Six sigma to maintain inventory level close to EOQ level. From the
0.5 liquidity ratios, it is observed that current ratio is high but quick ratio is
0.4
low which means that inventory of PIL is high and they should try to
0.3
0.2 minimize it.
0.1 Ratios 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012
Profitability Ratios
0
PBIT Margin (%) 20.15 20.08 20.53 19.82 20.59
FY-12 FY-13 FY-14 FY-15 FY-16
Net Profit Margin (%) 13.04 12.7 12.94 12.84 13.16
Source: Team Calculations Return on Net Worth / Equity (%) 46.04 50.68 53.21 52.7 54.27
Return on Assets (%) 24.62 23.8 22.96 23.85 24.21
Total Debt / Equity (X) 0.15 0.35 0.49 0.41 0.39
Liquidity Ratios
Current Ratio (X) 2.2 1.79 1.58 1.65 1.54
Table 3: Cost of Equity Quick Ratio (X) 0.46 0.37 0.33 0.4 0.39
Activity Ratios
Inventory Turnover Ratio (X) 3.31 3.48 3.28 3.73 3.96
Beta 0.81579
Asset Turnover Ratio (%) 1.89 1.8738 1.7735 1.8565 1.8394
Return on Market 9.51% Cash conversion cycle 95 98 96 89 90
Valuation Ratios
Risk Free Rate 6.90%
Basic EPS (Rs.) 208.59 175.75 137.87 100.89 80.68
Cost Of Equity 9.03% Earnings Retention Ratio (%) 59.25 59.04 56.49 50.45 54.14
2025
2026
1.6% and dividend growth was 7.9% giving a market return of 9.5%.
The Implied Risk Premium of market in India is 2.6%
Source: Team Calculation Growth of Sales Revenue has been calculated by looking at the
historical growth rate of sales, the rate of growth of industry size, the
growth of men’s women’s and sportswear, the population growth of
Figure 17: Sensitivity Analysis India, the competition etc.
So, we expect the growth to happen at similar lines as historically, but
due to the larger base effect the rate will slow down.
Costs have been estimated to mostly continue to be a percentage of
sales (historically derived).
The major cost for the company was observed to be the raw materials
costs. The royalty system for the company was fixed at 4.9%
The net block of assets grew at a similar pace to that of sales
(historically observed) which have been taken into consideration. The
capacity utilization would improve due to which the additions to the
asset base will reduce a little going on.
Other Important Assumptions
• There would be no further debt repaid or taken, the requirements
will be sourced/financed internally.
Source: Team Calculation
• The Cost of Equity is assumed to remain constant over the 10 year
estimation period
Figure 18: Sensitivity Analysis • There would be no further expansion into other geographies.
• The royalty terms will not change
Price sensitivity to CF • The exclusivity of the company will hold
prediction Sensitivity Analysis
30000.00 The Discounted cash flow valuation model requires several key
25000.00 assumptions on critical inputs like cost of equity, terminal growth rate,
20000.00 sales growth, the cash flow predication accuracy etc . The target stock
15000.00
price can be quite sensitive to these inputs and vary significantly as the
10000.00
assumptions about these inputs change. To assess the impact of these
5000.00
0.00
key inputs on the intrinsic stock price, sensitivity analysis has been
115% 110% 105% 100% 95% 90% done by changing two of these factors in combination and arriving at
the target price
Source: Team Calculation The target stock price is found to be quite sensitive to the terminal
growth rate and the cost of capital, with the target stock price varying
quite significantly as these inputs change.
Relative Valuation
Table 4: Relative Valuation Page trades at a significant premium on P/E multiples to other listed
innerwear players like Rupa and Maxwell. This P/E multiple is justified
due to the following factors:
Comparison Page Lovable Maxwell Rupa • Distributor model followed by Page instead of wholesale channel,
5 yr Revenue CAGR 35.70% 18.20% 6.10% 16.80% which gives higher control to Page and constrained WC
5 yr PAT CAGR 37.20% 43.50% -5.50% 35.40%
5 Yr Avg Roe 55.00% 22.00% 4.90% 23.10% requirements
5 yr Avg Roce 35.30% 20.90% 10.90% 21.80%
P/E 76.10 22.30 21.40 43.87
• Due to the lesser mix of contractual laborer with Page, higher
PE/G(5yr hist) 2.2 0.7 NA 0.8
efficiencies are maintained
• The competition in men’s innerwear segment is far less when
Source: Team Calculation compared to vests. Page’s revenue contribution from men’s
innerwear is 70-75% of lowers, but this number is significantly
lower for its peers like Rupa (40%)
Figure 19: INR vs USD • Brand recall for Jockey Is really high and is perceived as an
aspirational product due to which higher margins (price) and
volume is seen for Page when compared to peers
Investment Risks
Currency risk
For FY 2015-16, outflow on account of import of raw materials,
Source: Trading Economics machinery, spares etc. amounted to Rs. 1,702 Million. Company’s
exposure to foreign currency is increased in last four years.
Expenditure incurred in foreign currency is increased by 57% from FY
2014-15 to FY 2015-16. The recent weakening in the price of rupee is
Figure 20: Expenditure incurred in foreign thus a matter of high concern for Industry in general and Page
currency (In Millions)
industries in particular.
1000
Raw Material and Input Factor Risk
800 Page Industries imports a significant portion of raw material from
600 China and some other countries. For some of these imported raw
Raw
400 Materials materials, the company is hugely dependent on few suppliers. Any
200 Royalty disruption at suppliers end to meet the supply could adversely affect
0 their manufacturing capabilities. In recent years dependency on
imported raw materials is increased, while in FY 2014-15, 8% of total
raw material was imported; for FY 2015-16 it has been increased 15%
Source: Company Report of total.
The industry is growing at a fast pace, in a highly labour intensive
sector and demand for experienced and trained manpower is
outstripping supply. Whilst outsourcing of the manufacturing process
is a possible option for small-scale mid-premium businesses,
outsourcing innovative and premium product manufacturing is
unproductive given the extent of training, regular monitoring and
versatility of skills required for such products.
Highly Competitive Segment
Many major international apparel brands have commenced operations
in India realizing that Indian market is likely to emerge as one of the
largest market in the world in the next few decades. The innerwear
industry has witnessed, over the past 2-3 years, the expansion of new
Figure 20: Indigenous vs Imported raw international brands like Hanes, FCUK, Tommy Hilfiger, US Polo Assn.,
material and Benetton in India. These international peers can successfully offer
the same following characteristics viz: (a) comfortable and durable
7000 products; (b) affordable prices for some brands like Hanes and USPA;
6000
and (c) aspirational brand recall.
5000
4000 Dependence on Economy
3000 Indigenous The global macroeconomic landscape is currently chartering a rough
2000 and uncertain terrain characterized by weak growth of world output.
Imported
1000 The situation has been exacerbated by; (i) declining prices of a number
0
of commodities, with reduction in crude oil prices being the most
visible of them, ii) turbulent financial markets (more so equity
markets), and (iii) volatile exchange rates.
The industry growth is directly correlated with the growth of economy.
Source: Company Report
The spur in economic activity has been slow in the recent years and for
the industry growth to happen, the GDP of the country should revive.
So, any slowdown of economy in future will pose risk to the industry.
Disclosures:
Ownership and material conflicts of interest:
The author(s), or a member of their household, of this report does not hold a financial interest in the
securities of this company.
The author(s), or a member of their household, of this report does not know of the existence of any
conflicts of interest that might bias the content or publication of this report.
Receipt of compensation:
Compensation of the author(s) of this report is not based on investment banking revenue.
Position as a officer or director:
The author(s), or a member of their household, does not serve as an officer, director or advisory board
member of the subject company.
Market making:
The author(s) does not act as a market maker in the subject company’s securities.
Disclaimer:
The information set forth herein has been obtained or derived from sources generally vailable to the public
and believed by the author(s) to be reliable, but the author(s) does not make any representation or
warranty, express or implied, as to its accuracy or completeness. The information is not intended to be
used as the basis of any investment decisions by any person or entity. This information does not constitute
investment advice, nor is it an offer or a solicitation of an offer to buy or sell any security. This report
should not be considered to be a recommendation by any individual affiliated with Indian Association of
Investment Professionals (IAIP), CFA Institute or the CFA Institute Research Challenge with regard to this
company’s stock.