Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
The texts do not tell what this “unknown direction” could be. Our hypothesis
available at www.commonprophets.com is that Krishna was the same person
as Moses. Moses had led the Hebrews to Yisrael out of a place named
“Mitsrayim” to Yisrael. We show that “Mitsrayim” could be the Biblical name
for the Indus Valley. Thus Krishna leaving in an unknown direction could be the
same as Moses leading the Exodus from the Indus Valley. In this post we show
that the Biblical descriptions of the Exodus match more with Moses having led
the Exodus from Indus Valley. We examine the evidences provided by James K.
Hoffmeier.ii Hoffmeier admits that “despite over a century of archaeological
excavations in Egypt, proof of the dramatic Exodus has not been found.”
However, he adduces various secondary evidences to conclude that the
“Biblical description of entry into Egypt, the enslavement and the Exodus are
all plausible.”
I provide another possibility. The Exodus happened from the Indus Valley
where corroborating archaeological evidence is available. This suggestion is
part of a larger hypothesis that Adam, Noah, Abraham and Moses all lived in
the Indus Valley and Moses led the Exodus from here to Yisrael. Details of this
hypothesis are available on my website.iii In this article we restrict ourselves to
a comparative assessment of the beginnings of the Exodus from the Indus
Valley.
Mud bricks made in Egypt “rarely added straw temper,” and baked bricks were
used only sparingly.viii In comparison, baked bricks were the main construction
material in the Indus Valley, including at the site of Chanhu Daro, which we
suggest was the Biblical Mitsrayim.ix The conflict over collection of straw is,
therefore, more likely to have happened in the Indus Valley. The baked bricks
made here required large amounts of straw.
The Hindu narrative tells that the sages pronounced a curse that a particular
iron pestle would lead to the destruction of the Yadava clan. The Yadavas
ground the pestle to powder and dispersed the powder into the sea.xl They left
Dwarka soon thereafter and camped at Prabhasa. Here they drank liquor and a
terrible quarrel arose among them. Then:
Son killed father, brother killed brother, nephew killed uncle, grandson killed grandfather, friend killed
friend… When their arrows were exhausted and weapons were broken, they started pulling out reeds from the
seacoast. This grass grew out of the powder of the pestle. xli
We see that in both stories a metal object was ground to powder and became
the cause of the Hebrews/Yadavas killing each other.
Conclusion:
The secondary evidences of a short period of oppression and conflict over
collection of straw support the identification of Biblical Mitsrayim with Chanhu
Daro in the Indus Valley. The secondary evidence of parallel names is evenly
poised between Egypt and the Indus Valley.
The primary evidences of a stagnant river and the time and life events of a
person parallel to Moses also support the identification of Biblical Mitsrayim in
the Indus Valley. The primary evidence of time of habitation is evenly poised
between Egypt and the Indus Valley.
For more information please visit here (http://www.commonprophets.com/)
like my FB Page One God One Religion (https://www.facebook.com/One-God-
One-Religion-506460813155133/?modal=admin_todo_tour )
Please Subscribe My Channel (One God One Religion
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCN4sb3toJxNGPjmSubnwz_Q?view_as=s
ubscriber )
(एक ईश्वर
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCzJ4pdc_q_ybj_Yb99rkUGg?view_as=su
bscriber )
Buy my book here (https://www.amazon.in/gp/offer-
listing/B078J61BST/ref=tmm_other_meta_binding_new_olp_sr?ie=UTF8&con
dition=new&qid=&sr= )
i
Mahabharata, Mausala Parva 6:17, 24-25.
ii
Hoffmeier, James K., “Out of Egypt,” in Ancient Israel in Egypt and the Exodus, Biblical Archaeological Society,
2012.
iii
www.commonprophets.com.
iv
Mani, Vettam, Puranic Encyclopedia, Motilal Banarasidas, Delhi, 1979, Page 768.
v
This is considered by some to be an incorrect rendering. See, John, “Etymology of the Scripture Words Yahudi
[Jew] and Goy [Gentile],” www.Eliyah.Com/Forum2/Forum1/Html/000250.Html, Sep 7, 1998, Retrieved
October 21, 2018.
vi
Mani, Puranic…, Page 768.
vii
Half pound of straw is to be added to one cubic foot mud to make mud bricks. (Biblical Archaeology Society
Staff, How to Make a Mudbrick, http://www.biblicalarchaeology.org/daily/ancient-cultures/daily-life-and-
practice/how-to-make-a-mudbrick/, May 1, 2014, Retrieved March 6, 2017.) The weight of one cubic foot mud
is 34 kilograms. Half pound straw weighs 227 grams. The straw added works out to 0.6% by weight.
viii
Baked bricks were used only as paving slabs (Capaldi, Xavier, Ancient Egyptian Mud Brick Construction:
Materials, Technology, and Implications for Modern Man, 01 April 2011,
https://dataplasmid.wordpress.com/.../ancient-egyptian-mud-brick-construction-materi..., Retrieved July 27,
2016).
ix
“Most of the large cities of the IVC, i.e. Harappa, Mohenjodaro, Kot Diji, Ganeriwala, Rakhigarhi, and Lothal
were built from both mud and baked brick… (However,) most villages and towns in the IVC were built from
stones and mud bricks. The few exceptions are Jalilpur, Kalibangan, and Chanhudaro, where also baked bricks
were used… Chanhudaro stands out in this list, as there is no preceding mud-brick only phase for this site”
(Khan, Aurangzeb and Carsten Lemmen, Bricks and urbanism in the Indus Valley rise and decline, Helmholtz-
Zentrum Geesthacht, Germany, February 27, 2013, Page 4, arxiv.org/pdf/1303.1426, Retrieved July 29, 2015).
x
Falk, David A, What We Know about the Egyptian Places Mentioned in Exodus, https://thetorah.com/what-
we-know-about-the-egyptian-places-mentioned-in-exodus/ Retrieved October 23, 2018.
xi
Islamic Awareness, On the Use of Miṣr in the Qur'ān, 22nd June 2012, www.islamic-
awareness.org/Quran/Contrad/External/misr.html, Retrieved October 23, 2018. Indeed, the Akkadian Empire
located on the banks of the Tigris and Euphrates Rivers in Ancient Iraq used the name “Misrii” for its border
areas beginning around 1950 BCE (M. Civil, I. J. Gelb, A. L. Oppenheim, E. Reiner (Eds.), The Assyrian Dictionary
Of The Oriental Institute Of The University Of Chicago, 1977, Volume 10, Part 2, p. 113). The Amarna Tablets
indicate that the communications between the Akkadians and Egyptians referred to Egypt as Misrii beginning
1363 BCE.
xii
Monier-Williams, Monier, Sanskrit-English Dictionary, Southern Publications, Madras, 1987, Page 363.
xiii
Skand Purana Gita Press, Gorakhpur, Samvat 2064, 382:1123. This reference relates to Hindu Rama, who we
suggest was the same person as Biblical Abraham.
xiv
The first plague was of the water of the river becoming “blood” (Exodus 7:20).The Hebrew word “dam” is
derived from the word “damam” which means to be “dumb…, to stop; to perish; to cease, to be cut down, to
rest, to be silent, to be still…” (Strong’s 01818, 01826).
xv
The Exodus took place at 1445 BCE (The Open Bible, Page 1, 52).
xvi
The word “dam” is derived from the word “damam” which means to be “dumb…, to stop; to perish; to
cease, to be cut down, to rest, to be silent, to be still…” (Strong’s 01818, 01826).
xvii
The Yamuna flowed west between 2500 and 1750 BCE, east between 1750 and 1100 BCE, westward during
1100 to 500 BCE, and eastward between 500 and 100 BCE (Chakrabarti, Dilip K and Sukhdev Saini, The Problem
of Saraswati River and Notes on Archaeological Geography of Haryana and Indian Panjab, Aryan Books
International, New Delhi, 2009, Page 27).
xviii
E J H Mackay “found evidence for a considerable amount of craft activity at the site during the Harappan
period (2500–1900 BC).” He “also investigated the Post-urban Harappan levels at the site (1900–1500 BC) and,
in particular, his exposure of the remains of the Jhukar habitations…” (Possehl, Gregory L., “W. Norman Brown
– Americans Excavating in British India” Expedition Magazine 50.2 (July 2008), Penn Museum, July 2008,
http://www.penn.museum/sites/expedition/?p=8807, Retrieved November 27, 2015).
xix
Miller, Heldi J, A New Interpretation of the Stratigraphy at Chanhu-daro and the Jhukar Phase, in South Asian
Archaeology, edited by C Jarrige and V Lefevre, Page 253-256, ADPF, Paris, 2001.
xx
The Open Bible, Page 1, 52.
xxi
Bible, Exodus 7:7.
xxii
Roy, S B, “Scientific (Astro-Dynastic) Chronology of Ancient India,” in C Margabandhu et. al., Editors, Indian
Archaeological Heritage, Agamkala Prakashan, Delhi, 1991, Page 702-703. Other scholars place the war of
Mahabharata in which Krishna had participated variously between 5500 BCE and 900 BCE (Vartak, P V, The
Scientific Dating of the Mahabharat War, Ved Vidnyana Mandal, Pune,
http://www.hindunet.org/hindu_history/ancient/mahabharat/mahab_vartak.html, Retrieved September 7,
2013; IGNCA, Dating The Kurukshetra War, http://ignca.nic.in/nl002503.htm, Retrieved September 7, 2013).
The range of 1445 BCE to 1124 BCE for the birth of Krishna suggested by Roy is within this larger range and we
accept this.
xxiii
Bible, Exodus 1:8, 13.
xxiv
Durham, John I, Word Biblical Commentary, Volume 3, Exodus, Nelson Reference & Electronic, 1987, Page 7;
Sarna, JPS, Exodus, Page 5.
xxv
Qanungo, Kalika Ranjan, History of the Jats, Edited and annotated by Vir Singh, Delhi, Originals, 2003,
http://www.jatland.com/home/History_of_the_Jats:Dr_Kanungo/The_legend_about_the_Yadu_Tribe,
Retrieved April 7, 2016, Page 196.
xxvi
Bhagwata Purana, Srimad Bhagwat Sudha Sagar, Gita Press, Gorakhpur, Samvat 2060, 10:1:69.
xxvii
Bhagwata Purana 10:1:17, 10:2:2, 10:5:19.
xxviii
Bible, Exodus 1:16.
xxix
Bhagwata Purana 10:6.2.
xxx
Bible, Exodus 2:3.
xxxi
Bible, Exodus 2:9.
xxxii
Bhagwata Purana, 10:3:47-50.
xxxiii
Bhagwata Purana 10:3:48-51.
xxxiv
Bhagwata Purana 10:41.
xxxv
Bhagwata Purana 10:44:38.
xxxvi
Bhagwata Purana 10:45:12, 31.
xxxvii
Bible, Exodus 31:18, 32:4, 32:19.
xxxviii
Bible, Exodus 32:20.
xxxix
Bible, Exodus 32:27.
xl
Bhagwata Purana 11:1:13-21.
xli
Bhagwata Purana 11:30:13, 19-21.