Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Corresponding author:
Adam Ruszaj
Cracow University of Technology
Institute of Production Engineering
al. Jana Pawla II 37, 31-864 Cracow, Poland
phone: (+48) 12 374-32-02
e-mail: ruszaj@mech.pk.edu.pl
34
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 7/1/16 4:05 PM
Management and Production Engineering Review
Taking into account the fact that these new mate- In order to increase economic and ecological air-
rials usually characterized high strength and wear re- craft engines general efficiency it will be necessary to
sistance application for shaping traditional processes increase the functionality of the drive and temper-
as cutting or grinding will be limited. Additional lim- ature efficiency. Temperature efficiency can be in-
itations in precise or micro-details manufacturing are creased by higher combustion temperature. But in
connected with size effect [5]. Therefore unconven- this case it is necessary to use more temperature
tional and hybrid processes becoming more widely resistant light materials (gradient materials, single
used in this areas of industry [6]. crystal, metal or ceramic matrix composites) and
Basic unconventional processes are: electrochem- better conception of cooling (new geometry of cool-
ical Machining (ECM), electrodischarge machining ing wholes, double bladed turbines) and apply cov-
(EDM) and beam methods as: laser beam machin- ers which are thermal barriers i.e. Oxidation Protec-
ing (LBM), electron beam machining (EBM) or ion tion Layer and Thermal Barrier Coatings. Because
beam machining (IBM) Main hybrid processes which of limited distance between ventilator and earth also
could be applied in this area are: cutting process- engine core dimension should be decreased. It will
es supported by laser beam or ultrasonic vibrations, be possible to solve this problem by replacement ex-
electrochemical or electrodischarge grinding, electro- isting turbine set consist of turbine blades mounted
chemical – electrodischarge machining. In the paper on the ring in special locks by monolithic turbine
the technological possibilities of electrochemical ma- set (ring and blades) made of one piece of materi-
chining for macro and micro details manufacturing al (blisks) (Fig. 2). There are carried out works on
were discussed. improvement of aerodynamic properties of turbine
blades (special surface smoothing, elliptical trailing
Challenges of aircraft engines edge of the blade) and hull cover (special foil – with
structure as skin of shark).
manufacturing
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 7/1/16 4:05 PM
Management and Production Engineering Review
machining (EDM). In all specified processes togeth- Conclusions resulted from above presented con-
er with metal removal increase tool wear also in- siderations are right as long as it is possible to keep
creases while accuracy of machined workpiece de- optimal electrolyte flow with velocity high enough to
creased; machined surface geometrical structure be- remove electrochemical reactions products and heat
come worse and surface layer properties significantly so as hydrogen volumetric concentration was lower
changed – usually because of significant temperature than 60–80% and electrolyte temperature was not
increase. In properly design and carried out electro- higher then 60–80◦C in each point of machined sur-
chemical machining process there is not mechanical face. Electrolyte flow should be also stable and with-
contact between electrode-tool and workpiece (as it out area of circulation or cavitations. The conditions
is in cutting processes) and there are no electrical of optimal electrolyte flow limits the maximal met-
discharges (as in electrodischarge machining) which al removal rate and accuracy. Hydrodynamic condi-
are the reason of local melting or evaporating of tions can be improved and accuracy and metal re-
electrodes material. Electrochemical machining can moval rate increased by introduction electrode tool
be understood as flow of electric charge. In outer oscillations and carrying out ECM process in pres-
electric circuit charge is transported by electrons. In sure chamber what make it possible to chocked elec-
space between electrodes there is electrolyte (water trolyte flow at its outlet from interelectrode space.
solution of salts, acids or hydroxides) and between By chocking the electrolyte flow it is possible to sta-
electrode tool (cathode) and anode (workpiece) elec- bilize electrolyte flow in machining area, decrease
tric charge is transported by ions which are in elec- significantly volumetric hydrogen concentration and
trolyte. Especially, through the border of anode and increase water boiling temperature. As it was men-
electrolyte electrical charge is transported by ions of tioned above electrolyte flow can by also significant-
dissolved anode material (for instance: Fe+n , Cr+n , ly improved and accuracy increased by introduction
Ni+n , Ti+n ), which diffused inside interelectrode gap electrode tool oscillations and pulse interelectrode
and take part in further electrochemical reactions. voltage (pulse ECM). It gives possibility to obtain
Products of these reactions (usually hydroxides of Fe, (Fig. 3):
Cr, Ni, Ti and other anode components) are removed • during pause time: large interelectrode gap, inten-
outside of interelectrode gap by electrolyte forced sive electrolyte flow, intensive heat and electro-
flow through space between anode and cathode. Ac- chemical reaction products removal from machin-
cording to Faraday’s law the mass of dissolved anode ing space,
material is proportional to the charge transported • during pulse time: small interelectrode gap thick-
through the interelectrode gap. Through border be- ness, high current density and metal removal rate
tween electrolyte and cathode charge is transported however intensive heat and hydrogen emission oc-
mainly by hydrogen ions (H+ ). These ions are deion- curs.
ized and on cathode surface at first H2 particles and
then bubbles of hydrogen are created which are also Voltage pulses are generated when electrode tool
removed from interelectrode gap by electrolyte flow. is nearest to workpiece (Fig. 3). Pulse frequency and
From above presented ECM process description re- duty cycle should be chosen so as to remove from
sults that there are not any factors which could cause interelectrode gap during pause time, together with
electrode tool wear. Current flow is accompanied by electrolyte, heat and electrochemical reactions prod-
heat emission which should be continuously removed ucts rise during voltage pulse. However in this case
from interelectrode gap in order to avoid electrolyte of electrochemical machining mean metal removal
boiling. rate significantly decreases. Therefore, in order to ob-
tain as high as possible mean material removal rate
In order to reach in sinking operation high metal machining process should be carried out in stages.
removal rate, satisfactory accuracy and surface qual- In the first stage the constant voltage and constant
ity it is necessary to have as high as possible cur- electrode tool feed rate are applied and process pa-
rent density and as small as possible interelectrode rameters are optimized on criterion maximal metal
gap thickness. Together with current density increase removal rate. If after the first stage results are not
the number of atoms removed from machined surface satisfactory the second stage is introduced. In the
unit also increase and this is a reason of metal re- second stage usually pulse ECM process with elec-
moval and surface quality increase. From technolog- trode tool oscillations, is applied and process para-
ical experiments results that tolerance of workpiece meters are optimized on criterion of assumed accura-
dimensions is ∼0.1–0.2 of interelectrode gap thick- cy. In case when after second stage the surface qual-
ness. So, accuracy increases when interelectrode gap ity is not satisfactory the third stage (polishing) is
thickness decreases [9]. introduced. In comparison to the second stage on-
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 7/1/16 4:05 PM
Management and Production Engineering Review
ly criterion is changed: process parameters are op- control system, power supply unit, electrolyte supply
timized on criterion of optimal surface quality. Be- unit and electrode – tool unit.
cause of the fact that during the first stage the main Mechanical part consist of following elements:
part of machining allowance is removed on criteri- machine body, working table (usually with displace-
on maximal metal removal rate the mean machining ment in X and Y axis), assembly of Z unit (in-
process efficiency (for all stages) is usually satisfac- cluding also spindle or tool vibration unit) and ad-
tory. ditional tooling required for machining process (i.e.
tool and workpiece clamping). Design of mechanical
part are connected with machine-tool construction
constraints (i.e. dimensions of working area, drives
accuracy or positioning accuracy) and technological
constraints, which are defined by potential area of
machine-tool application.
Control system is responsible for control of in-
terelectrode gap thickness regulation (also including
reaction on the critical states in machining area) and
implementation of movements between electrode tool
and workpiece (according to programmed patch).
Fig. 3. Scheme of precise electrochemical machining with Power supply is based on specially designed pow-
application of pressure chamber and electrode tool oscil-
er energy source and the key factor is to provide
lations [10].
appropriate voltage signal in order to obtain high
localization of anodic dissolution. Moreover, if pos-
From above presented considerations results that sible power energy source is equipped with modules
ECM process is difficult for applying in industry. for prediction of critical states in the gap (protection
Other ECM process limitations are: against short-circuit).
• relatively high cost of machine tools which must The main functions of electrolyte unit is to supply
be built from corrosion resistant materials, of electrolyte to machining area, filtration of conta-
• negative influence of electrochemical reaction mination (product of dissolution) and measurement
products on industrial production and natural en- and stabilization of main physical properties of elec-
vironment (if harmful ECM process products are trolyte (conductivity, pH and temperature). Because
emitted outside the factory). For instance ions of environmental issues the obligatory standard is
Cr+6 in concentration of 0.05 mg/dm3 are strong- also to equip electrolyte unit with devices for utiliza-
ly harmful (carcinogenic). Of course electrochem- tion of electrochemical dissolution products.
ical machine-tools are equipped with units for re-
For micromanufactruring application one of the
duction and neutralization of electrochemical re-
main condition of high degree of machining elements
action products but it is a reason for additional
miniaturisation is application of electrode tool with
price of ECM machine tools increase. Because of
appropriate accuracy and stiffness and solve problem
above mentioned reasons industrial applications
of electrode clamping. Application of electrochemical
of ECM process are limited for cases, where on-
sinking is limited by possibilities of manufacturing of
ly ECM process can give satisfactory surface lay-
electrode which is projection of the machined shape
er quality (turbine blades of aircraft engines) or
In case of machining with application of universal
metal removal rate and accuracy in case of mezo
electrode tool possibilities of machined part minia-
and microdetails manufacturing. In this last case
turisation depends on proper selection of machining
the very good results are obtain (reached) for se-
condition and electrode-tool dimensions. The small-
quential electrochemical/electrodischarge [11] or
er the diameter of the electrode, the higher the res-
laser/electrochemical machining [21].
olution and accuracy of shaping, however problems
with proper clamping and tool stiffness occurs. Most-
ly, the stepped electrode tool with simple cylindrical
Characteristic of the electrochemical shape is prepared (machined) on the same machine-
machine-tools tool and is followed by machining without change of
tool-clamping. Such solution gives possibility to car-
Analysis of the typical machine-tools design for ry out machining with electrodes diameter less than
electrochemical machining gives possibility to distin- 0.1 mm, however it needs to integrate tooling for elec-
guish following functional elements: mechanical part, trode preparation on the working table and include
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 7/1/16 4:05 PM
Management and Production Engineering Review
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 7/1/16 4:05 PM
Management and Production Engineering Review
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 7/1/16 4:05 PM
Management and Production Engineering Review
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 7/1/16 4:05 PM
Management and Production Engineering Review
[8] Rolls Royce – The Jet Engine, 2005, SBN: [14] PECM Industrial, LLC, www.indec-ecm.com.
0902121235.
[15] EMAG Holding GmbH, www.emag.com/.
[9] Davydov A.D., Volgin V.M., Lyubimov V.V., Elec-
trochemical machining of metals: fundamentals of [16] PEMTec, www.pemtec.de.
electrochemical shaping, Russian Journal of Electro-
chemistry, 40, 12, 1230–1265, 2004. [17] Rajurkar K.P. et al., Micro and nano machining by
electro-physical and chemical processes, Annals of
[10] Wijers J., Upgrading to PEM, µMikroniek – Pro- the CIRP, 55, 2, 643–666, 2006.
fessional Journal on Precision Engineering, 54, 3,
48–53, 2014. [18] Sen M., Shan H.S., A review of electrochemical
macro- to micro-hole drilling processes, Internation-
[11] Skoczypiec S., Ruszaj A., A sequential electroche-
al Journal of Machine Tools & Manufacture, 45,
mical-electrodischarge process for micropart manu-
137–152, 2005.
facturing, Precision Engineering, 38, 680–690, 2014.
[12] Skoczypiec S., Application of laser and electrochem- [19] Fan Z.-W., Hourng L.-W., Electrochemical micro-
ical interaction in sequential and hybrid microma- drilling of deep holes by rotational cathode tools, Int.
chining processes, Bulletin of the Polish Academy J. Adv. Manuf. Technol., 52, 555–563, 2011.
of Sciences Technical Sciences, 63, 1, 305–313, 2015.
[20] Klocke F., Zeis M., Klink A., Veselovac D., Exper-
[13] Skoczypiec S., Grabowski M., Ruszaj A., Research imental research on the electrochemical machining
on unconventional methods of cylindrical micro- of modern titanium and nickel-based alloys for aero
parts shaping, Key Engineering Materials Key En- engine components, Procedia CIRP, 6, 368–372,
gineering Materials, 504–506, 1225–1230, 2012. 2013.
Unauthenticated
Download Date | 7/1/16 4:05 PM