You are on page 1of 4

UNIVERSITI SAINS MALAYSIA

PUSAT PENGAJIAN ILMU PENDIDIKAN

PLG 723 / PLG 728 – ICT Dalam Pengajaran (ICT in Instruction)

Semester 1, 2018/2019

Rubrik / Matriks Penilaian


(Evaluation rubrics / matrix)

ARTICLE REVIEW

Cemerlang (Excellent) (A) Baik (Good) (A-) Sederhana (Average) (B+) Memuaskan (Satisfactory)
Komponen (Component) (B)

INTRODUCTION Introduction is highly relevant Introduction is relevant in Introduction is somewhat Introduction is not quite
in describing the article (title, describing the article (title, relevant in describing the relevant in describing the
author, year, journal and author, year, journal and article (title, author, year, article (title, author, year,
main topic/background). main topic/background). journal and main journal and main
topic/background). topic/background).

DESCRIPTION OF THE Description states very clearly Description states clearly and Description states somewhat Description does not clearly
RESEARCH and orderly the details (RQs, orderly the details (RQs, clearly and orderly the details state the details (RQs,
methodology, findings). methodology, findings). (RQs, methodology, findings). methodology, findings).

COMMENTS/CRITIQUE Comments/critique are very Comments/critique are Comments/critique are Comments/critique are not
comprehensive, relevant, and comprehensive, relevant, and somewhat comprehensive, quite comprehensive,
structured (RQs, structured (RQs, relevant, and structured (RQs, relevant, and/or structured
methodology, findings); and methodology, findings); and methodology, findings); and (RQs, methodology, findings);
supported with relevant supported with relevant supported with relevant and/or supported with
references. references. references. relevant references.

CONCLUSION Conclusion is very well Conclusion is well Conclusion is somewhat Conclusion is poorly
summarized (agreement of summarized (agreement of summarized (agreement of summarized (agreement of
findings, justification, and/or findings, justification, and/or findings, justification, and/or findings, justification, and/or
suggestion). suggestion). suggestion). suggestion).

RESEARCH PROJECT

Komponen (Component) Cemerlang (Excellent) (A) Baik (Good) (A-) Sederhana (Average) (B+) Memuaskan (Satisfactory)
(B)

INTRODUCTION Introduction states very Introduction states clearly the Introduction states the Introduction lacks some
clearly the problem problem statement, ROs, and problem statement, ROs, and crucial information (eg,
statement, ROs, and RQs. RQs. RQs. problem statement, ROs, and
RQs).

LITERATURE REVIEW Literature review is current, Literature review is current, Literature review is Literature review is
very appropriate and highly appropriate and relevant. appropriate and relevant. somewhat appropriate and
relevant. Establishes an Establishes a sound Establishes a basic relevant. Fails to establish
advanced and proficient theoretical theoretical framework an
theoretical framework for the framework for for the research appropriate theoretical
research the research project. project. framework
project. for the research project.
Komponen (Component) Cemerlang (Excellent) (A) Baik (Good) (A-) Sederhana (Average) (B+) Memuaskan (Satisfactory)
(B)

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY Research methodology Research methodology Research methodology Research methodology
chosen is highly appropriate chosen is appropriate chosen is somewhat chosen is not quite
(addresses RQs). (addresses RQs). appropriate (addresses RQs). appropriate (addresses RQs).

DATA ANALYSIS Data analysis (for Data analysis (for quantitative Data analysis (for quantitative Data analysis (for quantitative
quantitative research) is research) is presented in an research) is presented in a research) is not quite
presented in a highly accurate accurate and detailed somewhat accurate and presented in an accurate and
and detailed manner; (for manner; (for qualitative detailed manner; (for detailed manner; (for
qualitative research) is research) is presented in a qualitative research) is qualitative research) is not
presented in a highly detailed detailed and insightful presented in a somewhat quite presented in a detailed
and insightful manner. manner. detailed and insightful and insightful manner.
manner.

DISCUSSION Discussion is very thorough, Discussion is thorough, Discussion is somewhat Discussion is not quite
accurate, and clearly based accurate, and clearly based thorough, accurate, and thorough, accurate, and
on the findings. on the findings. based on the findings. loosely based on the findings.

REFERENCES References are correctly cited References are correctly cited References are correctly cited References do not conform to
according to APA style, well- according to APA style, well- according to APA style, APA style, and/or not well-
organized and perfect (with organized and with some somewhat organized and organized.
no missing references). missing references. with some missing
references.

0129807058