Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
No ,5
Apd11YROss-73
Fifty patients with rheumatic mitral stenosis were studied with with the rate of stenmis progression. Of 22 patients with an
serial twmdimeisitital and Doppler echocardiography to deter . echocardiographic score <0 and a peak mitral gradient
mice the normal history of changes in mural valve area and its c10 mm Hg, only I patient (5%) had a more progressive course,
retalton to iransndtra gradients and mil-al valve morphology . compared with 50% of those with a toted eclrocardiographic score
Over the 39-month observatlan period (range 7 m 74 months) the A and a gradient alO mm Hg.
decline in valve area was 0.09 x 0.21 cmdfyear. In addition, there The rate of mitral valve narrowing in individual patients with
were aignilcaat inereasss in total echoeardiagraphie scare (p = rheumatic mural stenosis is variable. Patients whose valve disease
0 .0001), severity of mitral anulas calcification (p to 0,05) and progresses rapidly are those with a greater mitral valve eehnrar-
severity of ultra) regurgitation (p = 0 .11007). Patients with an diographie scorn and hither poak and moan lraasniltralgradlautn .
eeborardiographic score wit had a more progressive course . These findings emphasize the importance at nanlnvaslve evalun.
In addition, patients with a more progressive course (decline in tion of valvular morphology and hemadynamics and have hop1F
valve area ?0 .1 cmrhear) had a significantly greater initial mean cation for the frequency of follow-up mad prognosis in patients
gradient (p = 0 .01), peak gradient (p =.007)
0 and total emoar. with mural stenosis .
diagraphic score 4p = O .000d). Initial valve area did not correlate (J Am Cuff Cannot 2992;19:968-73)
The ratural history of rheumatic mitral stenosis has been the identified. Such information is of clinical importance for
subject of several extensive studies (I-3). These studies determining both the optimal frequency of follow-up in such
have documented a generally slow, but often variable clini- patients and the urgency of surgery or percutaneous balloon
cal course, with some patients showing little or no clinical valvuloplasty.
progression nor lung periods and others manifesting a more The ability to image the valve and subvalvular apparatus
rapid course . In contrast to these clinical studies, little with two-dimensional echocardiography allows for the non-
information is known regarding the temporal changes in invasive evaluation of mechanical or structural factors, or
mitral valve gradient or valve area . Such information would both, that might influence the rate of orifice narrowing. This
he important because symptomatic deterioration may not ability, along with Doppler echocardiography, which permits
reflect progression in valvuiar stenosis but may be the result repeated noninvasive estimation of hemodynamic factors
of a coincident event such as the development of atnlal including mitral valve area (4) and transmittal pressure
fibrillation, myocardial failure, pulmonary hypertension or gradient (5), has made possible a more extensive evaluation
increasing valvular regurgitation, In addition, the hemody- of the natural history of mitral stenosis .
namic, morphologic and mechanical factors that influence or The purposes of this study were to determine the nateral
predict the rate of stenosis progression have not been history of changes in mitral valve area and transmittal
gradient in patients with rheumatic mitral sfenessis and to
evaluate structural, mechanical and hemodynamic factors
From the Charles A . Dana Research Institute and she Harvard-Thomdlke
laboratory of she Beth Israel Hospital, Department of Medicine, Cardiovas . that might be related to the rate of stenosis progression,
cular Division, Hem srael Hospital and Harvard Medical School, Boston .
Massadmsetes. Dr. Gordon is supported by a W. A . end M . G . Saw Medical
Research Fellowship from the University of Western Australia . Penh, West. Methods
trot Aosiralia. Australian Dr. Manning is supported in pan by Physician .
Solent Award P.GCntvs from the National Institute of Aging, Belheea, Study patients. Adult echocardiographic records (u =
Maramd . 6,650), representing all studies performed at our institution
Manuscript received July 22 . 1991 : revised manuscripl received October
4,1991, -pre osleber 18. 1991. between July 1, 1983 and December 31, 1985, were re-
Address for rrednh
; : Warren l . Manning. MD. Cardiovascular Division . viewed. From these, 140 consecutive patients with a rtseu.
Bent Note Hasplml, 330 Braakkne Avenue, Boston . Massaclmseus 02215. matically deformed mural valve and measutrat trarmaritoal
C19112by tie Anseican College of Cardiology 0r715.1097nsess.m
gradient were selected for further study . Of these, 90 pa- Characteristics of 50 Study patients at Entry and at
Table 1 .
studies were performed with use of on HP 77030A or Len 51051 d -11i. (cal 5 .0 a 09 5.2 x 1 .1 0.03
1.0- I
0 .g'
~ 0b'
u^ GA-
M
02-
01
00
U
-02
DA o
0 10 20 30 40 6o
0-3 47 0-12
(n-It) In-31) (n.al Ranked Patient Order
Total Echo Score Figure 2. Individual (patient rank order) rates of moral valve
narrowing for all 3D study patients . Patients were stratified in the
Figure 1 . Comparison of total echocardiographic (Echo) score and ptnoression (triangles, n ' 16)or the nonprogression (circles, a =34)
rate of initial valve narrowing in 50 patients . 'p < 0,05 versus group the basis of valve narrowing a0 .1 cm'lyear or
echocardiogmphic scores 0 to 3 and 4 to 7 ; n r mtmber of patients <0 .1 em'tycar, respectively.
in each group.
0.0007) and left a'rial dimension (p = 0.03). There were no ties associated with more rapid progression, study patients
significant differences in mean Iransmitrat gradient, peak were stratified into two groups defined by the rate of valve
transmittal gradient or heart rate at rest, area decrease for each patient being greater (progression) or
Change in mitral valve area. The mean rate of decline in less (nonprogression) than 01 cm 2lyear, The progression
mitral valve area was 0.09 ± 0.21 cm'lyear (p = 0 .0015). group comprised 16 patients (32% of the study group), and
Analysis of variables that might be associated with the rate the nonprogressive group included 34 patients . The mean
of stenosis demonstrated a significant difference in the rate rate of valve area decrease in the progression group was 0 .3
0.2 cm 2lyear ; in the nonprogression group, valve area did
of progression between patients with a total entry echocar-
diographic score <8 (0,0 *_ 0 .1 em 2 lyear) and patients with a not change (0 ± 0.l cm2)year) .
score >_8 (0 .3 ± 0 .3 c0 year) (p < 0 .05) (Fig . I). There was The chamcterisries at study entry were compared be-
no significant difference in the rate of valve area decrease tween the progressive and nonprogressive groups (table 2).
between men and women, patients with sinus rhythm (n = The progression group had a greater mean transmittal gra-
32) and atria[ fibrillation (n = 18), patients with increased
(>4 cm) and normal left atria) dimension or among patients
Wit, 2. Entry Characteristics of Caoups With Progression
with mild (valve area >2 cm'), moderate (valve area .4 1 to
and Nonprogression
2 cm') or moderately severe (valve area . <1 .4 cm') mitral
stettosis at study entry . Proerssion Nonprogression
(n = 16) (n = 34) p Value
The interobserver variabilities were minimal with a cor-
relation coefficient of r = 0 .96 and SEE = .19 mm Hg for Hale ofvalvenanowtm(cm"N) 0.7±0.2 010.1
comparison of peak gradient (range of peak gradients : 4 to Oar lyn 58 ! 18 94 17 NS
%Women Et 79 NS
29 mm Hg); r = 0.96 and SEE = 0.7 mm Hg for mean
Hein rate (ficaw'mim 72 ± 10 65 *- 14 Y5
gradient (range of mean gradients 1 .8 to 9 mm Hg), and r =
Wall salve area (am e) 1 .7 1-0.6 .8
16T0 NS
0.93 and SEE = 0 .2 cm' for mitral valve area (range of valve Mean Itatumival gndknt 6.7 ! 4 .0 4.1 ± 2 .7 0.01
areas 0.6 to 3.1 cm2), Intraobserver variabilities were also term till
small with a correlation coefficient of r = 0-98 and SEE _ Peak transtdiral geadient 13.7 a 7 .7 R.7 ± 4 .7 0,007
.4 mm Hg for peak gradient (range 4 to 28 .7 mm Hg), r =
1 lair Hg)
0.95 and SEE = 0 .7 mm Hg for mean gradient (range 1 .5 to Total Echo scare (9-I61 7 .8 2 2 .9 5.0 ± 2 .3 0 .4998
Milm I valve mabillw (0-4) 1 .9 m 0.8 1.4 n 0.7 0 .02
15 .2 mm Hg) and r = 296 and SEE = 0 .2 cm'- for valve area Suh'oivdecehkkening(0-4) 1 .2 a: 1 .1 0.8 s 1 .0 N5
(range 0 .8 to 3 .1 cm'). Mibm1 valve thickening (0-4) 2 .6 0 0A 2.0 ! 0 .8 003
Progressive and nvaprogressse groups . Examination of Mural valve cakificetian (6-4) 20 a 1 .2 0.8 *- 0.9 0.0004
the individual data (Fig . 2) demonstrated two subgroups of MItmI anuius ealeincalion (0-3) 04 a 0.9 .1 ! 0.9
0 NS
patients, are with relatively rapid progression of declire in Mam1 regurgitation (0-4) 1,4 ^- : 1.4 0 1 .3 NS
valve area and a second with little or no change in valve area Left trAil dimension Jr .) 4,7 D.8 5.1 a 0.9 NS
over the follow-up period . To better define the characteris- Values are mean values a SD . Abbreviations as in Table I.
those with higher echocardiographic scores for mitral valve fliggs et al . (19), by comparing a routine early postoperative
mobility, thickening, calcification and total morphology cardiac catheterization with subsequent data, documented
were more likely to exhibit a more progressive course than true restenosis in 5 of 45 patients who returned with recur-
were patients with low gradients and low echocardiographic rent symptoms over a meali follow-up period of 6.5 years . In
scores . A total echocardiographic score <8 mm Hg or a peak another study, Heger et a! . (201 followed up 18 patients who
Iransmitral gradient <i0 mm Hg, ur boo,, represent levels had en early postoperative catheterization after successful
that identify patients with a very low incidence of progres- commissurotomy with either echocardiography or repeat
sive stenosis . Conversely, patients with a score a8 are much cardiac catheterization at a mean of 12 .2 years. Significant
more likely to exhibit progression and they represent a group restenosis was found in five patients (28%). As in our study,
in whom closer follow-up should be considered, neither age nor gender nor initial valve area was predictive of
Pathogenesis of progression. Although there is still debate later restenosis.
about whether the progressive changes observed in mitral Factors influencing restenosis following pereutaneom hal-
stenosis might result from a continuous lowgrade subclinical loan mitral vnlvuloplwty . These factors have been the sub-
rheumatic process, most authorities now view the progres- ject ofmore intense scrutiny. Uncles et al . (21) reportedthe
sive anatomic changes in the mitral valve to be the response outcome of 100 patients followed up an average of 13 mouths
of valvular tissue to the stress of chronic turbulent flow after percutaneous balloon valvuloplasty . Mural valve mor-
through a deformed valve (15) . Variations in the degree of phology was assessed by the same echocardiographically
initial valvular deformity may be a result of differences in the based scoring method utilized in our study . Patients with a
severity of the initial infection, streptococcal virulence or low total echocardiographic score (tell) had only a 4%
the number of attacks of rheumatic fever. The greater the incidence of restenosis documented, whereas those with a
morphologic deformity, the greater the turbulence, leading score >8 had a 7040 incidence . The individual components of
to greater tirrue stresses, which result in further thickening, this score were not examined for their relation to later
calcification and cotnmissural fusion . This is also consistent restenosis. Although patients with a higher score were less
with the concept of hemodynnmie forces acting to influence likely to have a good immediate hemadynamic result, mul-
the rate of stenosis, with greater gradients causing greater tiple stepwise regression analysis identified the echocardio-
tissue stresses and thus a greater proliferative and calcific graphic score as the single most importune factor predictive
reaction. Such a hypothesis is in keeping with our data of restenosis, whereas the mitral valve area immediately
demonstrating that valves exhibiting greater morphologic after valvuloplasty was not predictive of restenosis by either
deformity, and thus a higher echocardiographic score, she- univariate or stepwise multiple regression analysis . These
a greater tendency to more rapid stenosis . results are consistent with those of the present study and
Comparison with postvalvotwtiy studies. If mitral valve suggest that the same pathogenic mechanisms may be oper-
morphology and gradient influence the rate at which stenosis ating. Patients who achieve a good long-term result after
progresses in the absence of an intervention, then the same balloon mitral valvuloplasty may do so as a result of already
factors may influence the incidence and timing of restenosis belonging to a slow progression subgroup determined, al
after surgical valvotomy or percutaneous balloon valvulo- least in part, by their valve morphology . Such observations
plmty. The reported incidence of restenosis after open or held significant implications for the selection of patients
closed surgical valvotomy has varied considerably among most likely to benefit from mitral valvuloplasry and the
diderent studies, with estimates varying between 2% and timing or valvuloplasty and follow-up study .
60% (16) . Several of these studies have documented in- Limitations . Several potential biases are inherent in the
creased valvular calcification as a risk factor for late deteri- present study . Retrospective studies of untreated natural
oration (17,18). Initial success of the valvatomy and the history tend to select patients with less severe disease, as the
subsequent course do not correlate closely, suggesting that more severely affected patients are more likely to have had
factors other than the absolute valve area determine the rate an intervention before follow-up study . Many of our patients
at which symptoms return (17). In an extensive review and did have mild mitral stenosis, but the number of patients
follow-up of 339 patients after open or closed commissur- with a small valve area at entry in both the progression and
otomy, Hickey et al . (18) documented a need for mitral valve nonprogression groups suggests a reasonably equal distribu-
replacement at 10 years in 22% of patients and a need for tion of patients with moderately severe stenosis in both
valve replacement at 20 years in 53% . Risk factors for groups. Patients with a more progressive clinical course
subsequent valve replacement were the severity of stenosis might be expected to have more frequent echocardiographic .
before commissurotomy, the degree of mitral leaflet coleifl- follow-up studies and thug. be overrepresented . This does not
cation and immobility and the degree of mitral regurgitation appear to be the situation far oo' -idy because the majority
after commissurotomy- of patients were in the nonprogression group . We also
Few studies, however, have been able to determine assumed a linear progression between entry and final echo-
whether true restenosis or an inadequate primary result has cardiographic studies . Tins seems reasonable given the
been the cause of late symptomatic deterioration as surgical similar progression rates in patients with mild and more
results arc rarely assessed hemodyuamically . However. severe mitral stenosis .
Some patients showed an apparent increase in valve area 1'i-la' pressue halrtree by Doppler ultrasound . Circulation 1979:d0,
over the follow-up period . The magnitude of this apparent 1986-164
5. Katie ). Siromen S . ne:eemeaaan a€ pressure 10,1:111 io Clint
increase, however. was small in all but one patient and strnosis wnh Dapper echocardiogaphy . Br Heart ) 1979a41.529-)5
within the range of variation in the IBeasuTement technique 6 . Wlkins Gi. Weyn®r AE, Aha~l VM. Bloek PC, Palacios IFF percu-
as determined from our inrraohserver error analysis . The u balloon dictation M the mkrd vWva an analysis of echowr5o-
smphic vaiables related oio outcome and mednrsm of dialmiao . Br
milral valve echocardiographic score 111etnod used in this Heart 1 1988:fk299-300.
study is a subjective grading and is semiquantitative in 7 . Satin DJ . Deklana A, KIWI J, Weyman A . Reconunendations regarding
nature (22) . However, it has been successfully applied to quantification in M-mode echocardiography : results of a survey of echo-
cardiog.phic measarmntres .Circulation t970:58:1075-83.
studies of outcome after percutaneous balloon vaivulo-
8. Come PC . Riley Mr . fiver Dl, Morgue JP, Satan RD, McKay RG .
plasty. The method has also been validated against postmor-
Noninvaivo aanameor of nulial swnosis before and after pereutanrom .
tem specimens of rheumatic milral valves (23) . balloon milfal vaNUleplasly . Am J Cordial 198&,61 :817-25.
Clinical ii ig4icatious . In addition to furthering our under- 9. Halle L. Angdsen a. Doppler IJlteaaand er Cardiokgy : Physical Prim
cipler and Clidcal Applkaions . 2nd eel. Phiaddphg Lea and Febiger .
standing of the natural history of rheumatic mural slenosis, 1985 :115-22 .
the results of this study are of importance in the clinical 10. Abbasi AS. Allen MW. DnCrislafaro D . Gngar I. Iktalkm and evima.
management of such patients and in understanding the Q. fit. degree of mural reps100tan by range-teem poised Doepfm
echaeardiogapiy. clrcnntlon 1990 ;61a43-7,
mechanism of resienosis after surgical or balloon valvulu-
11. Dabin AA- March Hey. Cute K. Seler A . Lon hood. t hemodyn
plasly. The rate of progression of milral stenosis in individ- and clinical study armitral sneasis . Circulation 1971;44:181-0.
ual patients is quite variable . Health care resourceswould be 12 . Leuterogger F. Reefer FA, Fromer M, Fdlath F. Burckhavtl D. P0o-
best utilized by individualizing patient follow-up based on Fession of raid rearal stenoss and incidnee of resleaasis aft" open
comtnis molonry: a and, saes rsho®diognpiy. Am Heal J 194'940.
the likelihood of progression of stenosis- Our data suggest
562-6.
that patients with a low echocardiographic score and a law 13 Nichol PM, Githen BW, Kiseb IA. Two .dimeudonaleclocadioWepl is
transmitral gradient have a low rate of valve area narrowing .se .- or astral stenosis Cee1 .Oon 99TJ:55.-TV-g.
and may need less frequent echocardiugraphic follow-up- 14. Feogetrbanm H. Ed-indbpaphy.41b ed, Pta'hdellfhia : Leak Fehiger.
AM 231.
Most important, this study stresses the relation between I5 . Smetana IF. Natural history of ehmnie valvder disease . In : Frank) W5,
valvular morphology as assessed by echocardiography and 31091 AN (rile ;: Czv9ovancdar Clinics. VelnOar Ileva piseasc: Cue.
the clinical course ofpatients with mitral stenosis . The value prehensive Bvaluanan and Maaagemenr. Philadelp"ol PA Davis, 1986:
128,
of morphologic assessment in predicting the outcome after
16. Alum R . K1mliM8ah M, Gapa MP, PWmovah S . Mitrd eeslenosis:
surgical valvotomy or balloon valvuloplasty has already iocidena and epidemrology . lm Hon 11978*MLB.
been demonstrated. Our study extends the utility of this 17. Bekher JR. Reslreosis of He Initial v.Wva ae aimuni of fifty secagd
index to that of the natural history of progression of valve opereoatls Lvmet 1960 ;I:I81-4.
II. Hickey MSS, Bhcelaae EH . K'rhIf JW, Dean I5 . OW- prnbabil.
Cterteale .
ilir and life Mnory after augX,1 mitral comlli95t1rolunsy: inpficmimu
forhdlom ao.mixwmbmy. I Am Cog Cu" 1991 ;M-29-42-
1% Higle LM, Cihacy DL. O'Brien KP. Epste t SE, Nmrow AG . Mired
We art Fateful fo, Ike leehniool as,puoece of Manlyn S . Rile. . RDCS and
-t-i . ire aaeanceoa cause of armature syatp vrea OAbwiag "WA
Lisa V, Cad, RDCB. Inone isrumenty. An 1 Carded 1970;26:34-7 .
20. Hells, Jr. Warm LS. Weynaa AE . DBkn IC. Feign eom}L Lang-I-
chances in radial valve area after soccesUbt Initial conalisseratuall .
Circeblian 197949'463.8.
References 21. Paboon 1F, Block PC.., ilk CT, Weymat AE . Fogavr-up of 71 mvon
anderhoing eercanawus mkal balloon valvdoan . anlysis of loam
I . Rowe IC, habit RF, Spague His, White PD, Tin emcee of mitral detenniniag resleaass . Circuatioa 1989795719.
stn-is wihoct surgery: ten. and .,my-year penpectiees. .Are Intern 22 Abased VM . Wdkim Gr. D -Sto JP, et W. Prediction of slow=:Qd
Med 1960 :57 :74:-9. oatcame in 130Iwdnols an knitai a pertalanenls Wool, mhed Want .
2. Otneen Kit. The nmnal histon'of 271 patients with .,61 .11 stenosis under -Y . Cimcilion 19)0:82:418-56.
Medical treatment. Br Heart 1196224:349-57 . 23 . O'Sbea1P. Abascal VM. Somhem JF, Wdkim GT, PWaios IF, Weymen
1. Grant RT. After histories rot ten years of 1000 men eufering trots heart AE. Valuation of two-0inrcosiond echorardiog .phic score of morpho-
disease: a study in prognosis. Heart 1933:16 :275-483. logical characteristics of mitral stenosis in hmnm aol psy heads (abut) .
4. Halle L, Angetsen B . Tromsdal A . Noninvasive assessment of alnoven- Circulation 19118 ;7Msopp1111:11-122.