(USD/tonne) Cash margin index (L) Crude oil price (R) (USD/bbl)
500 160
7yrs peak-to-peak 10yrs peak-to-peak 10yrs peak-to-peak? 140
400
120
Kiyong Park 300 100
82-2-3276-6177 80
200
kypark@truefriend.com 60
100 40
Nakyung Lee 20
82-2-3276-6241 0
0
nklee@truefriend.com 9yrs bottom-to-bottom 9yrs bottom-to-bottom
-100 -20
1985 1988 1991 1994 1997 2000 2003 2006 2009 2012 2015
V. Risk analysis.......................................................................................................................................................................................... 21
Chemicals
I. Investment summary
Recovery of the We recommend Overweight for the chemical sector with the following investment
business cycle; Global points. 1) The sector’s poor performance should soon be over. The petrochemical
demand growing faster sector seems to be passing a trough. Given the 10-year business cycle, the
than capacity; China’s rebound may continue three or four more years. 2) The supply-demand conditions
large demand for should be tight again in 2012. The 2008 financial crisis has delayed investment,
imported products including new and added capacity, in the Middle East (ME) region. As a result, only
1.8mn tonnes of ethylene capacity were added in 2011. While capacity will
increase by only 4.7mn tonnes in 2012, demand growth should be 5.6mn and offer
tight supply conditions. 3) Changes to supply and demand will be led by the usual
player, China. The country’s 2012F ethylene demand should be 17.3mn tonnes, up
8.1% YoY compared to Asia’s 5.5%. At present, China’s production capacity is
similar to its demand level. Any negative impact from additional capacity should be
limited as most additions will be completed in 2H12. With ~70% self-sufficiency in
petrochemicals, China will continue to depend on imports from neighboring
countries. Thus, the Korean petrochemical sector would benefit given Korea’s and
China’s significant mutual dependence in petrochemical trade.
Eased tightening policy We maintain our forecast for Asian demand growth led by China. Since 2011,
to improve the China had maintained a tight monetary policy to address high inflation and an
petrochemical sector overheated economy. However, Beijing has adopted a domestic economy stimulus
related to cars, home policy for 2012 that is expected to spur more demand in the petrochemical industry.
appliances, furniture China has several options including a lower reserves requirement, thanks to the
and home interiors consumer price index (CPI) that has eased since Jul 2011. Indeed, the reserve
rate was lowered already in Jan and Mar 2012. Since China’s economy is sensitive
to policies, the petrochemical sector should improve along with the eased
tightening push. We forecast stronger demand for synthetic resins whose
weighting is the biggest among petrochemicals. More specifically, demand should
be high for polyethylene (PE) and polypropylene (PP) as they are popular in both
the industrial and non-industrial sectors. Downstream, bigger demand in 2012
should be most apparent in the automotive industry. Home appliances should see
steady growth in domestic demand and more exports despite the present
weakened momentum. We are also positive about demand for furniture and home
interiors given the rising completions reported by the affordable housing project.
80 20
200 600
60 10
100 40 0 500
20 -10
0 400
0 -20
9yrs bottom-to-bottom 9yrs bottom-to-bottom
-100 -20 -30 300
1985 1988 1991 1994 1997 2000 2003 2006 2009 2012 2015 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
Source: Chemsystems, Bloomberg, Korea Investment & Securities Source: CEIC, Datastream, Korea Investment & Securities
2
Chemicals
To be no. 1 ethylene We have a positive view of Homan’s long-term growth outlook. Petrochemical
producer in Asia companies’ growth strategies can be largely grouped in two. They pursue
economies of scale and market dominance by expanding sales via continued
capacity addition and M&A. Or they could improve profits via quality differentiation.
Honam is already one of the Asian leaders in terms of production capacity. The
company’s NCC should be the largest in Korea once the addition at the Yeosu
plant is completed in 1H12 as planned. Honam also became Asia’s no. 2 ethylene
producer by acquiring Indonesia-based Titan Chemicals. With the added capacity
at Yeosu, Honam’s domestic production would be 2.0 mn tonnes p.a. and Titan
Chemicals makes 720,000 tonnes p.a. Moreover, the company announced in Mar
a plan to build a plant (ethylene capacity of 1mn tonnes p.a.) in Indonesia by 2016.
Honam should then be the no. 1 Asian petrochemical company as it will beat
Taiwan-based Formosa Petrochemical whose ethylene capacity (2.94mn tonnes
p.a.) is the largest in the continent. Honam is also widening its scope for mid/long-
term growth. Its new businesses include carbon composites, PET films and
batteries for large-scale stationary electrical energy storage. The company has
also finished building an engineering plastics plant in Alabama, US.
3
Chemicals
4
Chemicals
The prices for petrochemicals tend to move in line with naphtha. As naphtha is
made from crude oil, the oil price can be a gauge to estimate petrochemical prices.
Thus, we estimate the price for each petrochemical by using the long run elasticity
of oil prices in regard to naphtha and naphtha in regard to petrochemicals. But
having a more significant impact on the product prices are the supply and demand
conditions in the upstream and downstream industries.
1Q11 2Q11 3Q11 4Q11 1Q12 2Q12F 3Q12F 4Q12F 1Q13F 2Q13F 3Q13F 4Q13F
Crude oil and naphtha prices
Dubai crude 100.69 110.36 106.94 106.03 117.80 117.90 115.65 117.96 114.73 112.43 110.21 111.31
Naphtha 898.1 967.2 929.8 856.4 1,000.4 1,026.7 1,013.4 1,037.4 1,005.9 987.1 968.9 977.9
Basic petrochemical prices
Ethylene 1,265.4 1,265.8 1,107.7 1,040.8 1,174.2 1,216.9 1,201.1 1,229.6 1,192.2 1,169.9 1,148.3 1,159.0
Propylene 1,405.8 1,516.7 1,484.8 1,266.7 1,327.7 1,375.9 1,358.1 1,390.3 1,348.0 1,322.8 1,298.4 1,310.5
Butadiene 2,311.9 3,412.7 3,785.0 2,082.1 3,265.1 3,187.7 3,146.4 3,221.0 3,123.0 3,064.7 3,008.2 3,036.2
BTX (avg.) 1,066.9 1,158.5 1,181.0 1,094.0 1,216.6 1,260.8 1,244.4 1,273.9 1,235.2 1,212.1 1,189.8 1,200.8
Spread
Ethylene - naphtha 367.3 298.6 177.9 184.5 173.8 190.2 187.7 192.1 186.3 182.8 179.5 181.1
Synthetic resin avg. - naphtha 636.3 588.8 587.2 505.9 466.5 493.5 487.1 498.6 483.5 474.4 465.7 470.0
BTX - naphtha 168.8 191.3 251.1 237.6 216.2 234.1 231.0 236.5 229.3 225.0 220.9 222.9
Source: Cischem, Datastream, Petronet, Korea Investment & Securities
1,400
3,400
110 950
1,300
3,000
1,200
105 900
2,600
1,100
Dubai crude (L)
100 850
2,200
Naphtha (R) 1,000
Source: Cischem, Datastream, Petronet, Korea Investment & Securities Source: Cischem, Datastream, Petronet, Korea Investment & Securities
1,400
295 600
1,200
800
195 500
600
400
145 450
200
95 0 400
1Q11 3Q11 1Q12 3Q12F 1Q13F 3Q13F 1Q11 3Q11 1Q12 3Q12F 1Q13F 3Q13F
Source: Cischem, Datastream, Petronet, Korea Investment & Securities Source: Cischem, Datastream, Petronet, Korea Investment & Securities
5
Chemicals
Business conditions to We believe the current slump in petrochemical business conditions will not last
recover after passing long. Given the industry’s business cycle lasting about 10 years, the recovery
the trough phase that started after 2009 should continue for three or four years. Major drivers
for the industry’s recovery include policy actions to stimulate depressed demand
and corporate strategy to improve profitability. After the 1990s, Asia’s economic
growth pushed up demand for petrochemicals and China played the pivotal role.
China’s policy to stimulate domestic demand has led the industry’s recovery
despite weaker global demand since 2009. China is still the world’s fastest-growing
big economy. Moreover, other emerging Asian economies such as India should
also enjoy steady growth. In that sense, Korea’s petrochemical firms are well-
positioned to benefit from the rise. Their location advantage (closest to China and
belonging to Asian markets) and the ongoing strategic shift to high value-added
products backed on advanced technology should improve profitability.
(USD/tonne) Cash margin index (L) Crude oil price (R) (USD/bbl)
500 160
300 100
80
200
60
100 40
20
0
0
9yrs bottom-to-bottom 9yrs bottom-to-bottom
-100 -20
1985 1988 1991 1994 1997 2000 2003 2006 2009 2012 2015
Note: Cash margin is the average cash margin of monomers and polymers of ethylene and propylene
Source: Chemsystems, Bloomberg, Korea Investment & Securities
(%)
25 NCC OPM Downstream OPM
20
15
10
-15
1990 1995 2000 2005 2010
Note: Four NCC firms (LG Chem, Honam Petrochemical, Korea Petrochemical, Yeochun NCC) and four downstream companies
(Hanwha Chemical, Kumho Petrochemical, KP Chemical, Taekwang Industrial)
Source: DART, Dataguide, Korea Investment & Securities
6
Chemicals
Petrochemical
ᆞ 1975 ᆞ 1985 ᆞ 1993 ᆞ 2001 ᆞ 2009
downcycle trough
ᆞ Serious oversupply
ᆞ Sharp rise in raw on new facility buildup/
ᆞ Sharp rise in raw
material costs capacity additions and ᆞ Oversupply ᆞ Sharp drop in product
material prices
Industrial impact ᆞ Serious oversupply resumed operation ᆞ Stagnant demand on prices due to rapidly
ᆞ Stagnant demand for
on new facility buildup ᆞ Expansion of business Asia’s economic crisis depressed demand
widely used petrochemicals
and capacity additions scope and weaker
division of labor
ᆞ Diversification beyond ᆞ Diversification beyond
ᆞ Vertical integration or ᆞ Companies in petroleum (environment
petrochemicals ᆞ Securing resources
diversification among advanced nations friendly)
ᆞ Focus on special and markets
Restructuring up/downstream penetrating emerging ᆞ Companies in
products ᆞ Diversification into
direction companies in case of economies emerging economies
ᆞ Companies in advanced high oil prices and low ᆞ Expansion of high value-added
going global and
economies penetrating other growth businesses
business scope expanding high value-
advanced economies added businesses
ᆞ M&As
ᆞ Reinforcing existing ᆞ M&As
ᆞ Business closure ᆞ Focus on internal
Restructuring efforts businesses ᆞ Overseas entry ᆞ M&As
ᆞ Overseas entry management resources
ᆞ M&As through JV
ᆞ Overseas entry
Source: LG Economic Research Institute (content recycled by Korea Petrochemical Industry Association), Korea Investment & Securities
7
Chemicals
Supply growth slower Petrochemical firms are expected to ramp up their utilization rates as the growth of
than demand growth; new capacity will be weaker than the rise of demand in 2012. The biggest variable
Petrochemical firms to that changes the petrochemical cycle is of course supply/demand conditions. All
focus on capacity demand for petrochemicals have linear growth. In contrast, capacity (production
addition in 2H12, plant facilities) tends to go up in phases as demand growth is difficult to predict while
maintenance in 1H12 facility expansion is time consuming. The discrepancy between them typically
leads to an imbalance between supply and demand. Due to the 2008 global
financial crisis, countries in the ME delayed making investment and the pace of
new capacity additions slowed. Accordingly, the capacity for ethylene increased a
mere 1.8mn tonnes in 2011. As supply should grow only 4.7mn tonnes in 2012F
while demand goes up as much as 5.6mn, the supply/demand balance for
ethylene will likely remain tight throughout the year. As a result, petrochemical
firms will ramp up their utilization. Historically, companies in Asia and the ME have
done routine plant maintenance mostly in 1H when demand is relatively weaker, so
this should help maintain a tight supply/demand balance.
250 90
200 88
150 86
100 84
50 82
0 80
2004 2006 2008 2010 2012F 2014F 2016F
8
5,000
0
4
-5,000
2
-10,000 0
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012F 2013F Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
Source: CMAI, Chemsystems, KPIA, Korea Investment & Securities Source: Bloomberg, KPIA, Korea Investment & Securities
8
Chemicals
Ethylene production
Scheduled startup Country Company Remarks
capacity
1Q12 Iran Ilam PC 458
1Q12 China Sichuan PC 800 Completed production line at end-2011
1Q12 India Gail 450 Construction
2Q12 Iran Kavian PC 1,000 Engineering
2Q12 China Fushun PC 800 Complete production line
2Q12 Korea Honam Petrochem. 250 Yeosu plant (750→1,000)
4Q12 Singapore ExxonMobil 1,000 Construction
2012 4,758
1Q13 China Yulin Energy and Chemical 570 Engineering
1Q13 China Wison Nanjing Chemical 295 Construction
1Q13 India ONGC Petro 1,100 Construction
1Q13 Iran Kavian Petrochemical 1,200 Engineering
2Q13 China Daqing Petrochemical 600 Engineering
3Q13 India Brahmaputra Cracker and Polymers 220 Engineering
3Q13 China Shanghai Petrochemical 450
2013 4,435
1Q14 Iran Gachsaran Petrochemical 1,000 Construction
2Q14 China Shanxi Coking 300 Construction
2Q14 UAE Abu Dhabi Polymers 1,500 Construction
4Q14 Iran Ilam Petrochemical 500 Construction
2014 3,300
Source: Industry data, Korea Investment & Securities
9
Chemicals
In 2012, ethylene We expect to see better supply-demand conditions for petrochemicals in 2012.
demand to rise 4.3% Global ethylene demand should total 135mn tonnes, up 4.3% YoY and outpacing
YoY globally compared 3.1% capacity growth. Changes to the supply-demand scenario will be led by
to 8.1% in China China that exerts an enormous influence on the demand side. Chinese demand for
petrochemicals should be 17.3mn tonnes, up 8.1% YoY and exceeding 5.5%
greater demand across Asia. Although China will boost petrochemicals capacity in
line with demand, any supply-side shock should be limited as most of the capacity
additions are scheduled in 2H12.
120 3
86
110
2
100
85
1
90
80 84 0
2009 2010 2011 2012F Demand increase Capacity increase
Source: KPIA, Korea Investment & Securities Source: KPIA, Korea Investment & Securities
China’s monetary China also provides an important demand base for propylene and its derivatives as
easing should lead to well as ethylene. Chinese demand for polyolefin represented 18% of global
bigger demand in 2012 demand in 2004 and the portion expanded to 23% in 2011, attributed mainly to its
strong economic growth. In 2011, global demand growth was a bit slow due to the
debt crises in Europe and the US. Chinese demand growth was also less than its
GDP growth but we expect the robust demand seen in 2009 to return in 2012. As
the Chinese government reverses monetary tightening implemented since 2H11,
the policy effects should lead to a big rise in polyolefin demand as was the case in
2009.
Polyolefin consumption breakdown by region (2011) China: GDP growth vs. polyolefin demand growth
1,500 12
IMF forecast
1,000 10
500 8
China
0 6
23% Europe
22%
-500 4
China government target
Middle
-1,000 2
East/Africa
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012F
11%
Source: Chemsystems, Korea Investment & Securities Source: Chemsystems, Korea Investment & Securities
10
Chemicals
China’s petrochemical Rising demand for petrochemicals in China is driving the growth of the global
industrial policies have petrochemical industry. Moreover, China’s government policies are guiding its
a huge influence on petrochemical industry’s growth. To meet the soaring demand for petrochemicals,
global demand China has turned toward securing production capacity and technological ability,
while lifting its self-sufficiency. Since the global financial crisis, the country has
been busy nurturing homegrown companies and focusing on domestic growth.
However, China will continue to depend on imports from neighboring countries as it
has ~70% self-sufficiency. And the Korean petrochemical industry is in a state of
significant mutual dependence with its Chinese counterpart.
1,000
-1,000
-2,000
-3,000
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
0 30
1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010
Eighth and ninth five-year plans 10th five-year plan 11th five-year plan
(1991-2000) (2001-2005) (2006-2010)
Despite economic growth and greater Self-sufficiency lifted
Synthetic demand for petrochemicals, financial on massive capacity Self-sufficiency lifted on
resin self- and technological limitations dragged additions attributed to massive capacity additions by
sufficiency down self-sufficiency; Relied on JVs with overseas oil domestic firms
imports majors
- Acquired technology
- Vertical integration,
- Attempted to attract overseas capital and skills through JVs
expansion, advancement
Government and technology with overseas oil
- Product diversification
policy - Focused on expanding capacity at majors
-Selectively attracted foreign-
small production facilities - Restructured small
funded firms
production facilities
Capacity - 6.3mn tonnes (2006-2010)
6.7mn tonnes (2000-
addition 2.9mn tonnes (1995-2000) - 2.2mn tonnes (2011-2012,
2005)
(ethylene) est.)
Source: Korea Institute for Industrial Economics & Trade, CMAI, KPIA, Korea Investment & Securities
11
Chemicals
Growing Chinese import The Chinese and Korean petrochemical industries are very dependent on each
demand provides other. Korea is the biggest exporter of petrochemicals to China, while China is the
opportunity for Korean biggest importer of petrochemicals from Korea. China’s polyolefin demand growth
exports to grow represents 48% of the increase in Asia and its self-sufficiency for synthetic resin
remains at a little more than 70%. As China is an enormous consumer market as
well as an export market, the Korean petrochemical industry that exports 50% of
its domestic production volume has no choice but to depend on China. Among
Korea’s synthetic resin export destinations, China accounted for an average 42%
in 2011. With Korea’s overall export volume rising in tandem with the portion of
exports to China, we can say China-bound exports undoubtedly have a significant
effect on the Korean petrochemical industry’s earnings.
China’s synthetic resin imports vs. Korea’s synthetic Korea’s synthetic resin exports growth and
resin exports dependency on China
(USD mn) (USD mn) (%) Korea's synthetic resin export growth (L) (%)
China's synthetic resin imports (L)
5,000 1,300 80 55
Korea's synthetic resin export dependency on China (R)
Korea's synthetic resin exports (R)
4,500 1,200
60
50
1,100
4,000
40
1,000
3,500
45
900 20
3,000
800 0
40
2,500
700
-20
2,000
600
35
1,500 -40
500
Note: The synthetic resin data is the total of five types – polyethylene , polypropylene, Note: The synthetic resin data is the total of five types – polyethylene , polypropylene,
polyvinyl chloride, polystyrene and acrylonitrile butadiene styrene polyvinyl chloride, polystyrene and acrylonitrile butadiene styrene
Source: CEIC, KITA, Korea Investment & Securities Source: CEIC, KITA, Korea Investment & Securities
China’s industrial production growth and Korean Coupled growth of China’s M2 and synthetic resins and
chemical players’ share prices synthetic rubber imports
(% YoY) (2005.1.31=100) (% YoY) (% YoY)
China synthetic resin imports (L)
25 1200 200 35
China industrial production increase (L) China synthetic rubber imports (L)
Korean chemical company stock price index (R) China M2 growth (R)
1000 150 30
20
800 100 25
15
600 50 20
10
400 0 15
5
200 -50 10
0 0 -100 5
Jan-05 Jan-06 Jan-07 Jan-08 Jan-09 Jan-10 Jan-11 Jan-12 07 08 09 10 11 12
Note: The Korean petrochemical players’ share prices are the combined market cap Source: CEIC, Korea Investment & Securities
of LG Chem, Honam Petrochemical, Hanhwa Chem and Kumho Petrochemical
Source: Datastream, Korea Investment & Securities
China sources a To China, Korea is an important source of petrochemicals. China imports 30% of
significant portion of domestic demand for synthetic resin and 24% of the imports come from Korea, the
petrochemicals from biggest for any country. China’s most-imported petrochemicals from Korea include
Korea 1) high-density polyethylene (HDPE), PP and acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS)
for synthetic resin, 2) butadiene rubber (BR) for synthetic rubber and 3)
paraxylene (PX) and terephthalic acid (TPA) for synthetic fiber. To Korea, China is
the biggest importer of synthetic resin, synthetic rubber and synthetic fiber.
12
Chemicals
China’s synthetic resin imports by country (2011) Korea’s synthetic resin exports by country (2011)
Korea
24%
Others China
50% 42%
Others
59%
Taiwan
17%
Vietnam
India
4%
4%
Source: KITA, Korea Investment & Securities Source: KITA, Korea Investment & Securities
China’s synthetic rubber imports by country (2011) Korea’s synthetic rubber exports by country (2011)
China
26%
Others Korea
30% 38%
Others
44%
Indonesia
12%
US
10%
Taiwan Japan
11% US
11% India
6%
12%
Source: KITA, Korea Investment & Securities Source: KITA, Korea Investment & Securities
China’s synthetic fiber imports by country (2011) Korea’s synthetic fiber exports by country (2011)
Korea Others
23% 11%
Taiwan
10%
Others
52%
Saudi Arabia
15%
China
79%
Japan
10%
Source: KITA, Korea Investment & Securities Source: KITA, Korea Investment & Securities
13
Chemicals
China eases monetary Anticipation that demand will pick up in Asia, led by China, remains valid. China
tightening and vows to maintained monetary tightening since 2011 to tame its overheated economy and
stimulate domestic inflation. But the Chinese government has vowed to stimulate domestic demand in
demand 2012 and onward, which should lead to greater demand for the petrochemical
industry as well. China is expected to introduce various policy measures including
the central bank cutting its reserve requirement rate (RRR) as its CPI has
stabilized after peaking in Jul 2011. China already cut the RRR in Jan and Mar.
Given the time gap between implementation of monetary policy and its effects on
the real economy, we forecast demand growth backed by the Chinese policy
changes will be seen gradually.
Report delivered at the National People’s Congress (NPC): 2009 vs. 2012
2009 2012
Goal
Stimulate domestic demand via aggressive fiscal
Improve people’s lives and restructure industry
expansion and monetary easing
Details
- GDP growth 8%, CPI rise 4%, unemployment 4.6% - GDP growth 7.5%, CPI rise 4%, unemployment 4.6%
- M2 growth 17%, new loans RMB5trn - M2 growth 14% (no comment on new loans)
- Fiscal expenditure RMB7.62trn (budget deficit - Increase in fiscal expenditure and neutral monetary
RMB950bn) policy with easing bias
- Economic stimulus packages worth RMB4trn - Introduction of domestic consumption stimulus
- Investment of W716.1bn in rural area support measures
- More employment (create 9mn jobs with RMB42bn - Greater supply and better distribution to stabilize
budget) prices
- RMB500bn tax cuts - Shift to new growth pattern, industry restructuring,
energy saving and environmental protection
- More spending on science, technology and education
(education spending growth to match 4% of GDP)
- Improve people’s lives, create 9mn jobs, better social
security and supply 7mn units of public housing
Source: China NPC, Korea Investment & Securities
Slower CPI inflation rate hints at the release of Time gap exists for the effects of monetary policy to
additional monetary easing materialize in the real economy
(PY=100) (%) (% YoY)
115 CPI (L) 23 35 China industrial production growth
PPI (L)
21 China M2 growth
Required reserve ratio (R) 30
110 19
25
17
105
15 20
13 15
100
11
10
9
95
5
7
90 5 0
Jan-07 Jan-08 Jan-09 Jan-10 Jan-11 Jan-12 Jan-07 Jan-08 Jan-09 Jan-10 Jan-11 Jan-12
Source: National Bureau of Statistics of China, Korea Investment & Securities Source: National Bureau of Statistics of China, Korea Investment & Securities
Anticipated additional According to the KIS Emerging Market team, there could be an increase in China’s
monetary easing in benchmark rate as early as in 2Q12. The yield on one-year bills issued by the
2Q12 at the earliest People’s Bank of China (PBC) typically leads the central bank’s benchmark rate.
As the yield turned downward in Nov 2011, the benchmark rate would follow suit in
the near future. The policy event likely to occur first would be the central bank
cutting its RRR for banks. The KIS Emerging Market team expects at least two
cuts in 2Q12. The foreign exchange equalization fund increased only RMB25.1bn
14
Chemicals
in Feb, much less than the RMB140.9bn rise a month earlier. Given the outlook for
an accelerating economic slowdown in China and a weaker RMB, chances are the
foreign currency inflow to the fund will continue to slow, which may in turn trigger
monetary easing. The purchasing managers index (PMI), an important sentiment
reading, and the leading economic index rose for a second straight month. With
additional monetary easing, the indexes should continue to rise. Consumers’
growing inclination to spend, as shown in some survey results, also leads us to
expect much from China’s policy to stimulate domestic demand.
One-year bill yield leads key rate, picked up since Nov China’s actual savings rate entered positive territory
2011 after 25 months as CPI growth turned downward
(%) (%)
5.0 6
1yr deposit rate
Adj. deposit rate
4.5
China 1yr bill yield
4
4.0
3.5
2
3.0
2.5 0
2.0
-2
1.5
1.0
-4
0.5
0.0 -6
04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 07 08 09 10 11 12
Source: CEIC, Korea Investment & Securities Source: National Bureau of Statistics of China, Korea Investment & Securities
OECD leading economic index: China still on a downturn and nearing bottom
(av g.=50) (1996=100)
65 110
60
105
55
50 100
45 95
40
China Federation of Logistics & Purchasing - China composite leading indicator (L) 90
35 National Bureau of Statistics China - China composite leading indicator (R)
OECD - China composite leading indicator (R)
30 85
06 07 08 09 10 11 12
Source: National Bureau of Statistics of China, China Federation of Logistics and Purchasing, OECD
China’s consumer confidence index rallied for three Record weighting of respondents who plan to buy a car
straight months within the next three months
(pt) Consumer confidence index (L) (%) (%) (%)
110 50 24 China urban depositor survey: % plan to buy house in the next 3 16
% of consumption preference (R) months (L)
22
China urban depositor survey: % plan to buy car in the next 3
20 months (R)
45 14
105 18
16
40 12
14
100 12
35 10
10
95 30 6 8
Jan-10 Jul-10 Jan-11 Jul-11 Jan-12 Mar-05 Mar-06 Mar-07 Mar-08 Mar-09 Mar-10 Mar-11 Mar-12
Source: National Bureau of Statistics of China, PBC, Korea Investment & Securities Source: PBC, Korea Investment & Securities
15
Chemicals
China easing its Obviously, the change in Chinese demand for petrochemicals has a significant
monetary tightening effect on the industry’s business conditions, particularly in Asia. If the Chinese
should drive demand economy recovers, the demand for petrochemicals would grow and drive up prices
for petrochemicals in the process. As such, better economic conditions in China work to widen the
price spread between products and raw materials. Furthermore, China’s easing of
monetary tightening should be a boon for the industry’s business conditions. In
particular, there should be greater demand for synthetic resins, mainly PE and PP,
consumed in large quantities for industrial and non-industrial uses. By downstream
industry, demand should be healthy particularly from 1) the automotive sector
whose 2012 growth will likely be the most apparent among others, 2) the home
appliance sector backed by steadily growing domestic demand (despite weak
momentum) and 3) the furniture and home interior sectors due to more housing
construction completions.
(% Y oY )
60 China sy nthetic resin demand growth (L) 108
20 102
10 100
0
98
-10
96
-20
-30 94
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
Chg. in Chinese demand for petrochemicals vs. synthetic resin spread in Asia
(% Y oY ) (USD/tonne)
60 China sy nthetic resin demand growth (L) 900
30 700
20
600
10
0 500
-10
400
-20
-30 300
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
16
Chemicals
Base effect for YoY auto Chinese demand growth should be the most pronounced in the automotive
sales growth and industry. Auto sales in China were relatively weak in 2011 but should grow
greater application of substantially in 2012. Beside steel, plastic is the most widely used raw material in
petrochemicals to auto production. The use of plastic should further expand with the growing
lighten vehicles application of reinforced or engineered plastic as automakers are accelerating
vehicle lightening to improve fuel efficiency. With the increase in auto sales, the
demand for tires is growing as well. Moreover, replacement demand is rising as
the number of cars on the road is rising. As such, the demand for synthetic rubber
used to make tires would grow as well.
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012F
Source: CEIC, China Association of Automobile Manufacturers, Korea Investment & Securities
Petrochemicals have Greater demand for automobiles fuels demand for petrochemicals. While there are
wide applications from various materials used in automobiles, PP is the most widely used synthetic resin.
synthetic resin, fiber As light-weight plastic has seen increasing application to lighten vehicles and
and rubber to other improve fuel efficiency, the use of plastic parts instead of metal should further
products expand. Moreover, growing auto sales will drive up demand for tires, leading to
greater synthetic rubber demand in the process. As such, there will likely be an
increase in demand for butadiene, the main raw material of synthetic rubber.
Source: KPIA, Korea Investment & Securities Source: KPIA, Korea Investment & Securities Source: Nexant, Korea Investment & Securities
17
Chemicals
Focus of stimulus Meanwhile, Beijing is shifting the focus of its stimulus policy to perk up domestic
policy shifted to demand from automobiles and home appliances to furniture and home interior
furniture and home goods. The Chinese government will likely expand its furniture trade-in program so
interior goods far implemented in some regions as a pilot project. Under the government’s
affordable housing scheme, the number of housing starts reached 10mn in 2011,
with an additional 7mn planned and targeting 5mn housing completions in 2012.
Interior-related industries should grow as the demand for interior products rises in
proportion to housing completions and move-ins. More demand is expected for
products such as polyvinyl chloride (PVC; wallpaper, flooring and window frames)
and polyurethane (PU; sofa and bed cushions), synthetic leathers (finishing
materials for furniture) and synthetic fabrics.
Policy momentum for Before the policy focus was shifted, the home appliance sector was the prime
home appliances has beneficiary of China’s massive stimulus package to perk up domestic demand.
weakened but demand Most home appliances use plastic for inner and outer materials and they also
should pick up on require various synthetic resins including PP, polystyrene (PS), polycarbonate
economic recovery (PC), PU, PVC and ABS. The Chinese electronics industry with a heavy exposure
to exports has tried to overcome dampened buying from advanced economies
post the 2008 financial crisis by stimulating domestic demand. With the
implementation of a subsidy program for rural areas and customers who trade in
old products for new, the demand for TVs, refrigerators and other consumer
electronics soared. Going forward, the Chinese government may also expand
subsidies for environmentally friendly goods or products sold to households
moving into homes built by the affordable housing initiative. With the global
economic recovery looming large, exports demand should pick up, albeit at a
modest pace.
10 20
0
0
-20
-10
-40
Strong impact from Fading impact from policy
-20 -60 policy
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Jan-08 Aug-08 Mar-09 Oct-09 May-10 Dec-10 Jul-11
Source: CEIC, Korea Investment & Securities Source: ChinaIOL, Korea Investment & Securities
18
Chemicals
Large facility needed to Korean chemical players have secured economies of scale and improved
respond to stronger efficiency via M&A and cooperation. For example, LG Chem merged with LG
petrochemical demand Daesan Petrochemical and LG Petrochemical; SK Innovation acquired SK
Petrochemical in line with its vertical integration strategy; Honam Petrochemical
merged with Lotte Daesan Petrochemical and plans to re-try a merger with KP
Chemical. Strategic affiliation was also pursued among companies and industries.
In the petrochemical industry, competitiveness is determined by high efficiency on
a large scale. Small-scale plants were built when petrochemical product demand
was low in the past. Now, aged plants are losing their efficiency and their units are
too small to respond to a new trend of cost reduction via mass production. Korean
chemical players boast competitive raw material costs as the relatively young
companies have built large-scale unit plants. They also enjoy a geographical
advantage in the growing Asian market, especially neighboring China with the
world’s greatest petrochemical appetite. Thus, their top lines will likely expand in
tandem with market growth. Moreover, their margins should be favorable without
securing cheap raw materials thanks to tight supply-demand conditions.
Production Average
Ranking Company Production site
capacity capacity/site
1 Saudi Basic Industries 15 13,392 893
2 Dow Chemical 21 13,045 621
3 ExxonMobil Chemical 19 12,515 659
4 Royal Dutch Shell 13 9,358 720
5 Sinopec 13 7,575 583
6 Total 11 5,933 539
7 Chevron Philips Chemical 8 5,607 701
8 Lyondell Basell 8 5,200 650
9 National Petrochemical 7 4,734 676
10 Ineos 6 4,656 776
Korean players Honam Petrochemical 2 2,000 1,000
LG Chem 2 1,930 965
Yeonchun NCC 1 1,910 1,910
Samsung Total Petrochemicals 1 1,000 1,000
Korea Petrochemical Ind. 1 470 470
Note: 1. Lyondell Basell includes subsidiary Equistar Chemicals
2. Honam Petrochemical’s capacity includes annual capacity of 250,000 tonnes to be added in Apr 20112
Source: Oil & Gas Journal, Korea Investment & Securities
Sumitomo
Formosa
Chemical
Petrochemical
Petrochemical
Chemical
SABIC
BASF
LG Chem
Chemical
Hanwha
Plastics
Mitsui
Formosa
Honam
19
Chemicals
Maintaining sound The prices and margins for petrochemicals are very susceptible to changing
financials is essential to external variables and thus are difficult to foresee. Existing producers face
secure fresh growth competition from emerging-market firms armed with economies of scale. To tackle
drivers the challenges and ensure sustainable growth and profit sources, petrochemical
companies are filling them with “unmatched” businesses that allow them to stand
apart from rivals, such as high-end, upgraded petrochemicals and new products
such as electronic materials and optical materials. Petrochemical companies have
sought fresh growth drivers in diverse fields across pharmaceuticals, electronics
and new materials. In particular, Japanese firms have developed various electronic
materials in line with the country’s thriving IT industry and still command an
unrivaled position in many chemical segments. To fund continued investment in
new businesses, it is essential for a company to have strong earnings power and
maintain a grip on sound financials. Korean companies rely on a limited amount of
borrowings to fund their operating and investment activities, which we believe
demonstrates their fundamental strengths can grow further.
(%)
140
120 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
100
80
60
40
20
0
-20
-40
Dow Chemical
Sumitomo
Formosa
Chemical
Petrochemical
Petrochemical
Chemical
BASF
SABIC
LG Chem
Chemical
Hanwha
Plastics
Mitsui
Formosa
Honam
20
Chemicals
V. Risk analysis
Despite the cost edge, Feedstock in the petrochemical industry can be roughly divided into naphtha and
ethane crackers cannot ethane. Naphtha is a refined light distillate from crude oil. Thus, the naphtha
replace naphtha production cost includes the cost incurred from the operation of refineries.
crackers’ diverse However, ethane can be procured at much lower prices as it is a by-product of
petrochemicals petroleum refining. With lower shale gas production costs led by the US,
supplied to downstream petrochemical facilities using ethane as feedstock are improving their cost
industries competitiveness. Despite the cost edge, ethane crackers are not a perfect
substitute for naphtha crackers that have wide-ranging production of ethylene,
propylene, C4 (feedstock for butadiene) and pyrolysis gas (feedstock for benzene,
toluene and xylene or BTX). In comparison, ethane crackers tilt toward ethylene
production (77.5%). As such, ethane crackers alone cannot supply many
petrochemicals to downstream industries. Furthermore, ethane crackers should
soon face a supply issue as petroleum production is necessary for additional
ethane production in the ME where ethane cracker capacity additions are already
active. Given the needed time to secure ethane and complete capex, it will be
quite a while before seeing actual capacity growth. Indeed, ethane crackers’
capacity weighting grew a mere 3%p over the past four to five years.
10 20
0 0 46
North America Western Europe Middle East Asia Pacific Global 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012F 2013F 2014F
Source: Industry data, Korea Investment & Securities Source: Industry data, Korea Investment & Securities
Cash cost curve for ethylene production Basic petrochemicals: Naphtha vs. ethane crackers
(USD/tonne) (%) Ethylene Propylene C4 Pyrolysis gas Others
1,200 100
90
1,000 Northeast Asia
Western Europe avg. 80
avg.
800 70
Ethylene cash cost
Southeast Asia 60
600 avg.
US avg. 50
Source: CMAI (content recycled by Dow Chemical), Korea Investment & Securities Source: KPIA, Korea Investment & Securities
21
Chemicals
1. FX sensitivity
Chemical firms maintain Korean chemical firms buy and sell products and raw materials in USD terms
an amount of net FX according to global pricing, even when doing business in Korea. This allows firms
debt to offset risks to to hedge against FX risks on OP and EBT, as long as FX rates that are recognized
OP and EBT in sales and costs do not show drastic movements over the short-term. However,
as most chemical firms have more USD-denominated debt than assets, if all other
conditions are equal, USD appreciation typically harms their NP. The effects that
net exposure (USD-denominated debt minus USD-denominated assets) based on
FX rate movements have on the NP for each company are shown below.
Rising oil prices As the petrochemical industry uses naphtha obtained from crude oil distillation as a
typically favor margins raw material, the changes in crude oil and naphtha prices determine costs.
However, oil prices typically rise due to an increase in demand for crude, which is
driven by greater demand for refined petroleum and petrochemicals. Thus, higher
oil prices do not create a unilateral burden on costs and it is not possible to fully
pass oil price rises on to product prices. Typically, rising oil prices have a favorable
effect on the petrochemical industry’s margins. It is partly because product prices
move up in tandem with oil price hikes. However, the more direct reason is when
oil prices are rising, the crude price recognized in costs for petrochemical
production was lower one or two months earlier. In contrast, when oil prices are
falling, higher oil prices from the previous one or two months are reflected in the
costs, which erodes profits. But overall, a moderate movement in oil prices is more
favorable than a sharp rise or fall.
22
Company
LG Chem (051910)............................................................................................................................................................................... 29
Stock price (Apr 17, KRW) 322,500 Yr to Sales OP EBT NP EPS % chg EBITDA P/E EV/EBITDA P/B ROE
Market cap (USD mn) 9,031 Dec (W bn) (W bn) (W bn) (W bn) (KRW) (YoY) (W bn) (x) (x) (x) (%)
Shares outstanding (mn) 32 2010A 10,635 1,178 1,190 791 24,817 (0.9) 1,485 10.8 6.4 1.9 19.2
52W High/Low (KRW) 458,000/229,500 2011A 15,700 1,491 1,526 978 30,701 23.7 1,870 9.7 5.5 1.7 19.6
6M avg. daily turnover (USD mn) 70.7 2012F 16,799 1,361 1,416 929 29,166 (5.0) 1,822 11.1 5.9 1.6 15.7
Free float (%) 42.7 2013F 17,639 1,658 1,731 1,136 35,670 22.3 2,157 9.0 4.9 1.4 16.5
Foreign ownership (%) 22.5 2014F 18,521 1,963 2,063 1,354 42,506 19.2 2,532 7.6 4.0 1.2 16.7
Performance
Attractive with operating value of basic chemicals alone: We resume our
1M 6M 12M
analysis of Honam Petrochemical with BUY and SotP-derived TP of W420,000
Absolute (%) 0.3 4.0 (15.6)
based on the values of business divisions and investment assets. For the divisions’
Rel. to Kospi (%p) 2.7 (2.4) (8.3)
value, we used 2012F EBITDA (consolidated) and the average EV/EBITDA of the
KIS Universe manufacturing sector. Book values were used for the valuation of
12MF PE trend partners and joint ventures that are not subject to consolidated accounting. Honam
14.0 (X) 12MF PER (LHS) (W' 000) 500 and its subordinates Titan Chemicals and KP Chemical, makers of basic chemicals,
price (RHS) 450
12.0
400 are clearly undervalued based on their operating values alone. As the chemical
industry has bottomed, demand will grow stronger for synthetic resins (e.g.,
10.0 350
8.0 300
6.0
250
200
polyethylene or PE/polypropylene or PP) and upstream products (e.g., butadiene).
4.0 150 We also believe naphtha cracking centers (NCC) that have been burdened by high
100
2.0
50 naphtha prices can now be more profitable as oil prices eased after soaring on ME
0.0
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
0
political instability.
TP calculation (W bn, x)
Kiyong Park
EBITDA(2012F) Multiple Fair value Note
82-2-3276-6177
Division value 1,821.6 7.4 13,479.7 Avg. multiple of KIS Universe manufacturing sector
kypark@truefriend.com
Investment assets 1,085.1 End-2011 book value
Lotte Engineering &
Na Kyung Lee Construction
733.4
82-2-3276-6241 Seetech 148.0
nklee@truefriend.com Daesan MMA 140.1
Others 63.6
Net borrowings (329.6) 2012F net borrowings
Non-controlling
1,581.7
interest stake
Divisions’ value + investment assets value - net
Enterprise value 13,312.7
borrowings -non-controlling interest shares
Outstanding shares (‘000) 31,860 Common shares issued
TP (W) 420,000
Source: Korea Investment & Securities
100,000 0.8x
100,000 100,000
50,000 3.0x
0 0 0
Jan-07 Jan-08 Jan-09 Jan-10 Jan-11 Jan-12 Jan-07 Jan-08 Jan-09 Jan-10 Jan-11 Jan-12 Jan-07 Jan-08 Jan-09 Jan-10 Jan-11 Jan-12
Source: Korea Investment & Securities Source: Korea Investment & Securities Source: Korea Investment & Securities
24
Chemicals
NCC that sticks to basics: As of 2011, Honam’s sales quite evenly comprise
synthetic resins, textiles and rubber (PE/PP 36%, ethylene glycol or EG/ethylene
oxide or EO 17% and butadiene/styrene monomer 19%). Given their sensitivity to
business conditions, the profit weighting of PE/PP, for which the market was quite
poor in 2011, should expand along with the completion of 1H12 capacity addition
backed by the recovery of the Chinese and global economies. The market and
profits should improve beginning in 2H12. We peg the 2012F consolidated OP at
W1.4trn, down 9% YoY. It is difficult to expect any significant OP improvement
in1H12, which in turn should pull down the overall annual earnings. However, the
slow market since end-2011 and a consequential drop in spread have been mostly
priced in the 4Q11 and 1Q12 earnings. Thus, we forecast earnings to pick up after
bottoming in 1Q12.
Honam’s 2011 sales by product Honam’s consolidated annual sales and OP outlook
(W bn) Titan Chemical sales (L) (W bn)
PP EO/EG
20,000 KP Chemical sales (L) 2,500
18% 17%
18,000 Honam Petrochemical sales (L)
Consolidated OP (R)
16,000 2,000
14,000
12,000 1,500
BD/SM 10,000
PE
19%
18% 8,000 1,000
6,000
4,000 500
Others 2,000
10% NC/BTX
0 0
18%
2010 2011 2012F 2013F 2014F
Source: Company data, Korea Investment & Securities Source: Company data, Korea Investment & Securities
Less MEG profit, more butadiene profit: The monoethylene glycol (MEG)
spread has been falling since Jan 2012. China has imported MEG from outside the
region based on a strong 1Q12 demand forecast and is now left with piled up
inventory. Large-scale capacity additions are planned in the region for TPA, which
is KP Chemical’s main product. Thus, a dull market is inevitable for polyester
products for a while. Meanwhile, butadiene supply-demand conditions are tight
with a series of regular maintenance shutdowns at NCCs in the region. Since
butadiene prices will likely remain at the current level, it should significantly
contribute to Honam’s OP.
400 2,000
1,000
300
1,000
200
500
0
100
0 0 -1,000
Jan-08 Jan-09 Jan-10 Jan-11 Jan-12 Jan-08 Jan-09 Jan-10 Jan-11 Jan-12
Source: Datastream, Korea Investment & Securities Source: Datastream, Korea Investment & Securities
25
Chemicals
26
Chemicals
27
Chemicals
Current liabilities 2,323 2,728 2,774 2,688 2,681 Financial expenses 130 114 114 106 98
Accounts & other payables 1,555 2,177 2,167 2,205 2,223 Interest expenses 53 79 79 70 63
ST debt & bonds 133 178 148 128 118
Other non-operating profit (0) 0 0 0 0
Current portion of LT debt 390 125 125 125 125
Gains (Losses) in associates,
Non-current liabilities 1,402 1,860 1,667 1,583 1,400 6 55 63 67 76
subsidiaries and JV
Debentures 979 1,384 1,184 1,084 884 Earnings before tax 1,190 1,526 1,416 1,731 2,063
LT debt & financial liabilities 133 172 157 157 157
Income taxes 290 394 340 416 495
Total liabilities 3,725 4,589 4,441 4,271 4,081
Controlling interest 4,519 5,463 6,353 7,452 8,768 Net profit 900 1,133 1,076 1,316 1,568
Capital stock 159 159 159 159 159 Net profit of controlling interest 791 978 929 1,136 1,354
Capital surplus 17 15 15 15 15
Other comprehensive profit (4) 20 20 20 20
Capital adjustments 0 0 0 0 0
Total comprehensive profit 896 1,153 1,096 1,336 1,588
Retained earnings 4,274 5,188 6,062 7,142 8,441
Total comprehensive profit of
Minority interest 548 695 845 1,027 1,243 789 1,001 947 1,154 1,372
controlling interest
Shareholders' equity 5,067 6,158 7,198 8,478 10,011 EBITDA 1,485 1,870 1,822 2,157 2,532
28
Chemicals
LG Chem (051910)
BUY (Reinstate), TP: W440,000
Stock price (Apr 17, KRW) 356,000 Yr to Sales OP EBT NP EPS % chg EBITDA P/E EV/EBITDA P/B ROE
Market cap (USD mn) 20,739 Dec (W bn) (W bn) (W bn) (W bn) (KRW) (YoY) (W bn) (x) (x) (x) (%)
Shares outstanding (mn) 66 2010A 19,471 2,821 2,818 2,158 29,345 47.9 3,493 13.3 8.0 3.7 31.9
52W High/Low (KRW) 567,000/285,000 2011A 22,676 2,835 2,797 2,138 29,069 (0.9) 3,592 10.9 6.4 2.5 24.8
6M avg. daily turnover (USD mn) 125.0 2012F 24,639 2,735 2,688 2,055 27,947 (3.9) 3,605 12.7 7.2 2.3 19.7
Free float (%) 65.9 2013F 27,157 3,395 3,344 2,556 34,769 24.4 4,395 10.2 5.9 1.9 20.5
Foreign ownership (%) 36.6 2014F 30,011 4,112 4,064 3,107 42,261 21.5 5,262 8.4 4.9 1.6 20.7
Performance I&E materials’ growth potential merits high valuation: We reinstate coverage of
1M 6M 12M LG Chem with BUY and a TP of W440,000, the sum of enterprise value (EV) and
Absolute (%) (4.6) 2.3 (29.9) investment asset value. For the petrochemical division, we apply 2012F
Rel. to Kospi (%p) (2.1) (4.1) (22.7) EV/EBITDA of 7.4x, the average of the KIS Universe manufacturing sector. For the
information and electronic (I&E) materials unit, we apply 2012F EV/EBITDA of
12MF PER trend
12.0x that is on par with the average of global battery makers (Samsung SDI,
(X) (W' 000)
Johnson Controls, GS Yuasa and BYD). We view the multiple as justified as there
16.0 12MF PER (LHS) 600
price (RHS)
14.0
500
12.0 should be a growing profit contribution from batteries at the I&E division. The
400
10.0
optical materials such as polarizer and photo resist have steadily generated lofty
8.0 300
6.0
200
profits. Now is the turn for mid and large-size batteries for hybrid electric vehicles
4.0
100
(HEV), which are expected to break even and show full-fledged growth of OP
2.0
0.0 0
beginning in 2012. The I&E materials’ EBITDA should grow 29% YoY in 2012F.
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
TP calculation (W bn, x)
200,000 5.0x
200,000 200,000 1.7x
7.0x
100,000 100,000 3.0x 100,000
3.0x 0.7x
0 0 0
Jan-07 Jan-08 Jan-09 Jan-10 Jan-11 Jan-12 Jan-07 Jan-08 Jan-09 Jan-10 Jan-11 Jan-12 Jan-07 Jan-08 Jan-09 Jan-10 Jan-11 Jan-12
Source: Korea Investment & Securities Source: Korea Investment & Securities Source: Korea Investment & Securities
29
Chemicals
3,500
20,000
Source: Company data, Korea Investment & Securities Source: Company data, Korea Investment & Securities
New businesses on the right track: LG Chem’s new businesses such as mid
and large-size batteries and glass substrates are poised to deliver visible results.
The mid and large-size battery operation turned to profit in 3Q11. In the HEV
market, GM has seen the sales of its plug-in hybrid Chevrolet Volt surge after a
sluggish start. In preparation for the HEV market’s growth, LG Chem plans to add
HEV battery capacity to supply 100,000 vehicles every year. For glass substrates,
LG Chem will start volume production beginning in Jun as scheduled, aiming to
stabilize the production yield at the 40% level in 2012. We believe the glass
substrates will generate a stable, high-margin revenue stream because LG Chem
has a captive customer, LG Electronics. LG Chem will improve its glass substrate
OPM to match rivals by achieving economies of scale through constant capacity
additions into 2015 and securing advanced production technology.
30
Chemicals
Monthly sales of Chevrolet Volt and US HEV sales OPM of glass substrate makers
3,000 40,000
50
LG Chem
2,500
30,000 target OPM
2,000 40
1,500 20,000
30
1,000
10,000
500
20
0 0 Samsung Corning Precision Asahi Glass - LCD
Dec-10 Mar-11 Jun-11 Sep-11 Dec-11 Mar-12 Materials - LCD
Source: HybridCars.com, Korea Investment & Securities HybridCars.com Source: Company data, Korea Investment & Securities
Stable operation and strong growth potential: LG Chem has diversified its
capex in core businesses that ensure stable profitability and in new businesses set
to become growth drivers. In 2012, LG Chem plans to inject 42% of its capex in
adding capacity to the production facilities of petrochemicals such as acrylates,
superabsorbent polymer (SAP), caustic soda, ethylene dichloride (EDC) and
synthetic rubber to build economies of scale and a dominant market position. LG
Chem will also make a preemptive move in promising I&E materials such as glass
substrates and 3D film-type patterned retarders (FPR), and in mid and large-size
batteries. By investing ~W1.01trn or 58% of the full-year capex in 2012 in I&E
materials and new businesses, LG Chem should be able to secure long-term
growth and to lessen its vulnerability to the petrochemical cycles.
31
Chemicals
(W bn)
3,000
Source: Company data, Korea Investment & Securities Source: Company data, Korea Investment & Securities
32
Chemicals
Current liabilities 4,277 4,724 5,063 5,283 5,453 Financial expenses 183 218 226 229 229
Accounts & other payables 2,161 2,499 2,716 2,993 3,308 Interest expenses 61 67 76 78 78
ST debt & bonds 1,260 1,452 1,522 1,472 1,412
Other non-operating profit (13) (31) (34) (37) (41)
Current portion of LT debt 361 386 406 396 411
Gains (Losses) in associates,
Non-current liabilities 552 854 968 997 1,147 55 15 19 21 23
subsidiaries and JV
Debentures 150 299 349 399 499 Earnings before tax 2,818 2,797 2,688 3,344 4,064
LT debt & financial liabilities 333 390 440 400 430
Income taxes 619 627 602 750 911
Total liabilities 4,830 5,578 6,031 6,280 6,600
Controlling interest 7,703 9,553 11,331 13,611 16,441 Net profit 2,200 2,170 2,085 2,594 3,153
Capital stock 370 370 370 370 370 Net profit of controlling interest 2,158 2,138 2,055 2,556 3,107
Capital surplus 1,158 1,158 1,158 1,158 1,158
Other comprehensive profit (3) 18 18 18 18
Capital adjustments (16) (16) (16) (16) (16)
Total comprehensive profit 2,197 2,188 2,103 2,612 3,171
Retained earnings 6,254 8,053 9,813 12,075 14,887
Total comprehensive profit of
Minority interest 140 154 185 223 270 2,155 2,148 2,072 2,574 3,124
controlling interest
Shareholders' equity 7,844 9,708 11,516 13,834 16,710 EBITDA 3,493 3,592 3,605 4,395 5,262
33
Chemicals
Stock price (Apr 17, KRW) 129,500 Yr to Sales OP EBT NP EPS % chg EBITDA P/E EV/EBITDA P/B ROE
Market cap (USD mn) 3,468 Dec (W bn) (W bn) (W bn) (W bn) (KRW) (YoY) (W bn) (x) (x) (x) (%)
Shares outstanding (mn) 30 2010A 4,957 571 483 316 15,814 0.0 720 5.7 6.6 3.0 49.1
52W High/Low (KRW) 253,000/129,500 2011A 6,457 842 758 506 24,723 56.3 997 6.8 7.1 3.8 44.5
6M avg. daily turnover (USD mn) 41.5 2012F 6,957 737 670 447 16,302 (34.1) 904 7.9 6.6 2.4 27.8
Free float (%) 42.3 2013F 7,496 885 821 548 19,984 22.6 1,064 6.5 5.5 1.9 27.6
Foreign ownership (%) 12.0 2014F 8,078 937 880 586 21,401 7.1 1,130 6.1 5.1 1.6 24.2
Performance
Heavy exposure to automotive presents both chances and challenges: We
1M 6M 12M
reinstate coverage of Kumho Petrochemical (Kumho) with BUY and TP of
Absolute (%) (15.9) (41.1) (32.2) W160,000. The price is based on the sum of operating value and investment asset
Rel. to Kospi (%p) (13.5) (47.6) (24.9) values (SotP). For the operating value, we applied a 10% discount to the KIS
Universe manufacturing average EV/EBITDA given the concentrated focus on
12MF PE trend synthetic rubber and phenol derivatives compared to upstream companies such as
14.0 (X) 12MF PER (LHS)
price (RHS)
(W' 000) 300
NCCs. The reliance on the automotive and tire industries and the high price
volatility of butadiene (synthetic rubber feedstock) are risks. We believe
12.0 250
10.0
8.0
200
supply/demand conditions for butadiene will improve given the typical heightened
demand prior to NCCs’ regular maintenance in 1H. With greater car sales in China,
150
6.0
100
4.0
synthetic rubber inventories there should rapidly wind down. Conditions for
50
synthetic resin (i.e., acrylonitrile-butadiene-styrene) and phenol derivatives should
2.0
0.0 0
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
also improve.
Source: Korea Investment & Securities Source: Korea Investment & Securities Source: Korea Investment & Securities
34
Chemicals
('000 tonnes/yr)
Synthetic resin
1,400
19% SBR BR NBR SB latex SBS HSR SSBR
1,200
1,000
Phenol 600
derivatives
19% 400
Source: Company data, Korea Investment & Securities Source: Company data, Korea Investment & Securities
2,000 200
600
1,500 150
400 237 237
1,000 100
200
500 50
0 0 0
Jan-09 Jul-09 Jan-10 Jul-10 Jan-11 Jul-11 Jan-12 as of 2012 2015
Source: KITA, Korea Investment & Securities Source: Company data, Korea Investment & Securities
35
Chemicals
Focus on capacity additions for synthetic rubber and at subsidiaries: The key
strategy for Kumho’s tighter market grip is capacity additions at existing
businesses rather than entry to new areas. Kumho should post better earnings in
2H12 on capacity additions for synthetic rubber (combined 170,000 tonnes for
SBR and SSBR) and phenol derivatives (150,000 tonnes for bisphenol A, BPA).
Kumho’s SBR capex project, slated for completion in Sep, expanded from the
initially planned 80,000 tonnes to 110,000 tonnes without a significant cost
increase. The capacity addition of 60,000 tonnes for SSBR should also be
completed in Nov. Kumho’s combined capacity for SBR and BR should amount to
955,000 tonnes per year at end-2012, ranking at the top above Sinopec and
Lanxess. Subsidiary capex projects should also continue into 2013. Kumho P&B is
scheduled to add capacity for BPA by 150,000 tonnes at end-2012, phenol
300,000 tonnes and acetone 185,000 tonnes by end-2013. Kumho Polychem
plans to add capacity for EPDM by 60,000 tonnes to meet growing demand for
cars. Kumho Mitsui Chemicals should also contribute to Kumho’s growth by adding
50,000 tonnes for methylene diphenyl diisocyante (MDI), feedstock for
polyurethane used in cars and home appliances.
36
Chemicals
Current liabilities 2,240 2,713 2,652 2,579 2,435 Financial expenses 195 218 213 214 210
Accounts & other payables 560 721 777 837 902 Interest expenses 144 140 135 136 132
ST debt & bonds 716 813 763 713 613
Other non-operating profit 0 0 0 0 0
Current portion of LT debt 821 1,123 1,053 973 873
Gains (Losses) in associates,
Non-current liabilities 988 444 650 746 840 39 73 80 84 84
subsidiaries and JV
Debentures 452 100 230 240 227 Earnings before tax 483 758 670 821 880
LT debt & financial liabilities 502 267 337 417 517
Income taxes 137 215 190 232 249
Total liabilities 3,228 3,157 3,302 3,325 3,275
Controlling interest 826 1,448 1,771 2,194 2,657 Net profit 346 544 481 589 631
Capital stock 142 167 167 167 167 Net profit of controlling interest 316 506 447 548 586
Capital surplus 79 265 265 265 265
Other comprehensive profit 25 (73) (73) (73) (73)
Capital adjustments (40) (40) (40) (40) (40)
Total comprehensive profit 371 470 407 516 557
Retained earnings 572 1,047 1,438 1,930 2,460
Total comprehensive profit of
Minority interest 68 109 138 174 213 340 434 379 480 518
controlling interest
Shareholders' equity 893 1,557 1,909 2,368 2,870 EBITDA 720 997 904 1,064 1,130
37
Chemicals
Stock price (Apr 17, KRW) 25,250 Yr to Sales OP EBT NP EPS % chg EBITDA P/E EV/EBITDA P/B ROE
Market cap (USD mn) 3,110 Dec (W bn) (W bn) (W bn) (W bn) (KRW) (YoY) (W bn) (x) (x) (x) (%)
Shares outstanding (mn) 140 2010A 6,341 655 705 446 3,155 29.9 882 9.8 9.6 1.1 13.4
52W High/Low (KRW) 54,300/22,000 2011A 7,943 326 281 254 1,793 (43.2) 621 13.7 12.2 0.8 6.2
6M avg. daily turnover (USD mn) 55.7 2012F 8,071 404 434 482 3,410 90.2 751 7.4 10.6 0.8 11.0
Free float (%) 56.9 2013F 8,592 601 623 692 4,892 43.5 994 5.2 8.4 0.7 14.1
Foreign ownership (%) 15.9 2014F 9,099 773 794 881 6,231 27.4 1,217 4.1 6.7 0.6 15.6
Performance
High hopes for recovering PVC demand and robust earnings at YNCC: We
1M 6M 12M
recommend BUY on Hanwha Chemical and TP of W30,000. Our SotP-based TP is
Absolute (%) (7.5) (10.5) (49.5)
a combination of operating value and investment asset value. The parent company
Rel. to Kospi (%p) (5.1) (16.9) (42.2)
earnings will likely improve as the soft demand for polyvinyl chloride (PVC) should
recover. We believe the demand for PVC used as an interior building material will
12MF PER trend pick up on rising demand in China attributed to greater completions and move-ins
14.0 (X) 12MF PER (LHS) (KRW) 60,000 of the affordable housing scheme, the government’s furniture subsidy program and
price (RHS)
12.0 50,000 subsidy payouts for interior products. Instead of book value, we used the operating
value to calculate the fair value of Yeochun Naphtha Cracking Center (YNCC),
10.0
40,000
8.0
6.0
30,000
which should benefit from the petrochemical industry’s recovery. With the demand
4.0
20,000
for pure chemicals remaining solid, the sharp rise in oil prices has eased, which
2.0 10,000
should help improve margins at the NCC operator. The uncertain profit outlook at
0.0
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
0
Hanwha SolarOne and some of the other subsidiaries is a risk factor.
TP calculation (W bn, x)
Kiyong Park EBITDA (2012F) Multiple Fair value Remark
82-2-3276-6177 Operating value (A) 931.4 6,460.7
kypark@truefriend.com KIS Universe manufacturing sector average multiple
Parent 643.7 7.4 4,763.2
applied
Na Kyung Lee Others 287.7 5.9 1,697.5 KIS Universe average multiple applied
82-2-3276-6241 Investment asset value (B) 2,258.4
nklee@truefriend.com KIS Universe manufacturing sector average multiple
YNCC 474.2 7.4 1,484.3
applied; Recognized 50% ownership
Others 774.1 Applied book value as of end-2011
Net debt (C) 3,988.6 2012F net debt based on Hanwha Chemical consolidated
Minority interest (D) 584.2
Market cap of preferred
9.8 Apr 13 closing prices
shares (E)
Enterprise Value 4,136.5 A+B-C-D-E
Free-float shares (‘000) 140,284 Common shares outstanding
TP (KRW) 30,000
Source: Korea Investment & Securities
Source: Korea Investment & Securities Source: Korea Investment & Securities Source: Korea Investment & Securities
38
Chemicals
(USD/tonne) (USD/tonne)
2,500 800
PVC PVC-ethylene spread (R)
27% PVC (L) 700
2,000 Ethylene (L)
600
PE
46% 500
1,500
400
1,000
300
200
500
CA 100
Others 25%
2% 0 0
Jan-08 Jan-09 Jan-10 Jan-11 Jan-12
Source: Company data, Korea Investment & Securities Source: DataStream, Korea Investment & Securities
Specialized/differentiated PE product sales Secure low-priced base materials via JV with Sipchem
100 10
0 0
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011P 2015F
Source: Company data, Korea Investment & Securities Source: Company data, Korea Investment & Securities
39
Chemicals
40
Chemicals
Current liabilities 3,355 4,109 4,198 4,479 4,656 Financial expenses 140 192 211 228 244
Accounts & other payables 1,305 1,552 1,577 1,679 1,778 Interest expenses 140 192 211 228 244
ST debt & bonds 1,604 2,262 2,312 2,512 2,612
Other non-operating profit (32) 33 33 35 37
Current portion of LT debt 0 0 0 0 0
Gains (Losses) in associates,
Non-current liabilities 2,920 2,947 3,107 3,498 3,589 209 96 189 196 208
subsidiaries and JV
Debentures 1,203 1,004 1,104 1,304 1,304 Earnings before tax 705 281 434 623 794
LT debt & financial liabilities 1,114 1,311 1,361 1,511 1,561
Income taxes 217 114 117 168 214
Total liabilities 6,275 7,056 7,305 7,977 8,245
Controlling interest 3,993 4,173 4,598 5,233 6,056 Net profit 487 167 317 455 579
Capital stock 707 707 707 707 707 Net profit of controlling interest 446 254 482 692 881
Capital surplus 483 489 489 489 489
Other comprehensive profit (92) 4 4 4 4
Capital adjustments (4) (3) (3) (3) (3)
Total comprehensive profit 395 171 321 459 583
Retained earnings 2,646 2,794 3,213 3,841 4,659
Total comprehensive profit of
Minority interest 709 624 457 218 (86) 357 236 489 698 887
controlling interest
Shareholders' equity 4,702 4,798 5,055 5,451 5,970 EBITDA 882 621 751 994 1,217
41
Chemicals
Glossary
42
Chemicals
70,000 600,000
60,000
500,000
50,000
400,000
40,000
300,000
30,000
200,000
20,000
100,000
10,000
0 0
Apr-10 Aug-10 Dec-10 Apr-11 Aug-11 Dec-11 Apr-10 Aug-10 Dec-10 Apr-11 Aug-11 Dec-11
300,000 700,000
250,000 600,000
500,000
200,000
400,000
150,000
300,000
100,000
200,000
50,000 100,000
0 0
Apr-10 Aug-10 Dec-10 Apr-11 Aug-11 Dec-11 Apr-10 Aug-10 Dec-10 Apr-11 Aug-11 Dec-11
43
■ Guide to Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd. stock ratings based on absolute 12-month forward share price performance
BUY: Expected to give a return of +15% or more
Hold: Expected to give a return between -15% and +15%
Underweight: Expected to give a return of -15% or less
■ Guide to Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd. sector ratings for the next 12 months
Overweight: Recommend increasing the sector’s weighting in the portfolio compared to its respective weighting in the Kospi (Kosdaq) based on market
capitalization.
Neutral: Recommend maintaining the sector’s weighting in the portfolio in line with its respective weighting in the Kospi (Kosdaq) based on market capitalization.
Underweight: Recommend reducing the sector’s weighting in the portfolio compared to its respective weighting in the Kospi (Kosdaq) based on market
capitalization.
■ Analyst Certification
I/We, as the research analyst/analysts who prepared this report, do hereby certify that the views expressed in this research report accurately reflect my/our personal
views about the subject securities and issuers discussed in this report. I/We do hereby also certify that no part of my/our compensation was, is, or will be directly or
indirectly related to the specific recommendations or views contained in this research report.
■ Important Disclosures
As of the end of the month immediately preceding the date of publication of the research report or the public appearance (or the end of the second most recent
month if the publication date is less than 10 calendar days after the end of the most recent month), Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd., or its affiliates does
not own 1% or more of any class of common equity securities of the companies mentioned in this report.
There is no actual, material conflict of interest of the research analyst or Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd., or its affiliates known at the time of publication of
the research report or at the time of the public appearance.
Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd., or its affiliates has not managed or co-managed a public offering of securities for the companies mentioned in this report
in the past 12 months;
Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd., or its affiliates has not received compensation for investment banking services from the companies mentioned in this
report in the past 12 months; Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd., or its affiliates does not expect to receive or intends to seek compensation for investment
banking services from the companies mentioned in this report in the next 3 months.
Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd., or its affiliates was not making a market in securities of the companies mentioned in this report at the time that the research
report was published.
Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd. does not own over 1% of Hanwha Chemical,Honam Petrochemical,Kumho Petro Chemical,LG Chem shares as of April 18,
2012.
Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd. has not provided this report to various third parties.
Neither the analysts covering these companies nor their associates own any shares of as of April 18, 2012.
Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd. has issued ELW with underlying stocks of Hanwha Chemical,Honam Petrochemical,Kumho Petro Chemical,LG Chem and
is the liquidity provider.
This report was written by Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd. to help its clients invest in securities. This material is copyrighted and may not be copied, redistributed,
forwarded or altered in any way without the consent of Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd. This report has been prepared by Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd.
and is provided for information purposes only. Under no circumstances is it to be used or considered as an offer to sell, or a solicitation of any offer to buy. We make no
representation as to its accuracy or completeness and it should not be relied upon as such. The company accepts no liability whatsoever for any direct or consequential
loss arising from any use of this report or its contents. The final investment decision is based on the client’s judgment, and this report cannot be used as evidence in any
legal dispute related to investment decisions.
HEAD OFFICE
CHUN SOO LIM, Executive Vice President, Head of Global Institutional Group (cslim@truefriend.com +822 3276 5800)
PAUL CHUNG, Sales Trading (pchung@truefriend.com +822 3276 5843)
27-1 Yoido-dong, Youngdeungpo-ku, Seoul 150-745, Korea
Toll free: US 1 866 258 2552 HK 800 964 464 SG 800 8211 320
Fax: 822 3276 5681~3
Telex: K2296
NEW YORK
DONG KIM, Managing Director (dkim@kisamerica.com +1 212 314 0681)
ELAINE LIM, Head of Sales (Elaine@kisamerica.com +1 212 314 0686)
JU KIM, Sales (jukim@kisamerica.com +1 212 314 0683)
Korea Investment & Securities America, Inc.
1350 Avenue of the Americas, Suite 1110
New York, NY 10019
Fax: 1 201 592 1409
HONG KONG
DANIEL KIM, Managing Director, Head of HK Sales (daniel.kim@kisasia.com +852 2530 8950)
SANGME LEE, Merchandising Director (sangme.lee@kisasia.com +852 2530 8910)
DAN SONG, Sales (dan.song@kisasia.com, +822-3276-5621)
JUN HWAN KIM, Sales (jun.kim@kisasia.com, +852-2530-8912)
Korea Investment & Securities Asia, Ltd.
Suite 2201-2, Jardine House
1 Connaught Place, Central, Hong Kong
Fax: 852-2530-1516
SINGAPORE
SUNG NAMGOONG, Managing Director, Head of Singapore Sales (snamgoong@truefriend.com +65 6501 5601)
ALEX JUN, Sales (alex.jun@truefriend.com +65 6501 5602)
Korea Investment & Securities Singapore Pte Ltd
1 Raffles Place, #43-04, One Raffles Place
Singapore 048616
Fax: 65 6501 5617
LONDON
JJ MOON, Managing Director (jamesmoon@kiseurope.com +44 207 065 2765)
MINGOO KANG, Sales (mingookang@kiseurope.com, +44 207 065 2760)
Korea Investment & Securities Europe, Ltd.
2nd Floor, 35-39 Moorgate
London EC2R 6AR
Fax: 44-207-236-4811
Telex: 8812237
This report has been prepared by Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd. and is provided for information purposes only. Under no circumstances is it to be used or
considered as an offer to sell, or a solicitation of any offer to buy. While all reasonable care has been taken to ensure that the information contained herein is not untrue
or misleading at the time of publication, we make no representation as to its accuracy or completeness and it should not be relied upon as such. This report is provided
solely for the information of professional investors who are expected to make their own investment decisions without undue reliance on this report and the company
accepts no liability whatsoever for any direct or consequential loss arising from any use of this report or its contents. This report is not intended for the use of private
investors.
2012. All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced or distributed in any manner without permission of Korea Investment & Securities Co.,Ltd.