Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Owned Convictions
Constructivist (may
stop at a stage)
Universal an “ideal”
Carol Gilligan: A Different Voice
Studied and worked with Lawrence
Kohlberg at Harvard
Developmental Assumption: People move
through predictable stages of development
with either relative success (health) or
relative failure (pathology)
Carol Gilligan: A Different Voice
Gilligan’s central assumption: the way
people talk about their lives reveals their
worldview (language shapes/reveals our
philosophy)
Problem: Women’s reports were being
ignored or considered inferior when
inconsistent with researcher’s
developmental assumptions
Carol Gilligan: A Different Voice
Most models based upon studies of men
only.
Models tended to validate male
experience while invalidating female
experience
Key: not good or better, but focus on
difference as complementary
Gilligan: Gender Contrasts
Men Women
Separation Attachment
Competing rights Conflicting
Responsibilities
Fixed/Abstract Ideas Contextual/Narrative
Ideas
Focus rules Focus on
Relationships
Justice
Care
Greeting
The Lord be with you
And also with you
Lift up your hearts
We lift them to the Lord
Let us give thanks to the Lord our God
It is right to give God thanks and praise
Erickson: Key Concepts
Unlike Freud, sexuality
not our basic drive but
“growth”
Epigenesis: “Growing
outward or upward”
Idea of a miniature tree
in every acorn
Interaction w/society
influences growth
Getting There from Here
Each “age” is a stage of
growth (includes all other
ages)
Ability to negotiate
“crises” influences our
preparedness to “go on”
to the next stage
Each crises has polar
(positive-negative) traits
to negotiate
Key Consideration: “Spiral
Staircase”
Stages more like a
spiral staircase
Each crises a
“landing”
Level of negotiation
makes a big
difference
Key Consideration: “Spiral
Staircase”
Every “age” or
“stage” influences
quality of life
“Trust” then involved
at every level
James Fowler’s Stages of Faith
“Make sense” of Faith
(still theological)
Six Stages (or seven)
(Undifferentiated)
Intuitive Projective
Mythic Literal
Synthetic- Conventional
Individuative-Reflective
Conjunctive or
Paradoxical
Universal
Faith Development more
Holistic
Influence of Erikson as well as Piaget
“Making Sense” of our Faith (Cognitive)
Relationships: Human & Heavenly
(Affective/Relational)
Putting Feet to Faith and Living in
Community (Behavioral)
Conversion “recapitulates” every stage
(similar to Erikson)
Fowler’s Sources for Faith
Master Stories
(narratives that give
meaning)
Images of Power
(authority)
Central Values (key
concepts that guide
us)
Always in
Conversation
Theology and Reciprocation
Faith Stages invite Theological
Perspective
Balswick’s key concern?
Theological Model?
Strengths or limits?
Practicing/Liturgical Self?