Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
31]
Original Article
Mini Abstract: The misdiagnosis rate of nasopharyngeal carcinoma (NPC) patients with headaches was 43.4%. Improved awareness For correspondence:
of the various nonspecific symptoms of NPC is a pivotal step in decreasing the misdiagnosis rate. Dr. Li Xiang,
Department of
Oncology,
KEY WORDS: Headaches, misdiagnose, nasopharyngeal carcinoma Affiliated Hospital
of Luzhou Medical
College,
25 Taiping Road,
INTRODUCTION headache accompanied by other symptoms like Luzhou-646 000,
neck mass, nasal congestion, blood secretion, Sichuan, China.
E-mail: xl790927@
Nasopharyngeal carcinoma (NPC) is particularly diplopia, tinnitus, ear problems, etc. The
sina.com
common in southern China.[1] Due to the internal following medical examinations were performed
location of NPC and varied clinical symptoms, most to determine the precise pretreatment stage:
patients are in a locally advanced stage before General physical examination, hematological
diagnosis.[2] Headaches are the main symptom indices, nasopharyngeal fiberscope, chest X‑ray
because of the skull‑base invasion, intracranial or computed tomography (CT), ultrasound of
metastases, or skull‑base osteoradionecrosis. abdomen, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)
Lack of knowledge about NPC and the nonspecific nasopharynx and cervical part, whole‑body bone
Zhou-Xue Wu and
symptoms makes initial and accurate diagnosis scan or position emission tomography (PET). Li Xiang are the co-first
difficult in cases with intracranial or skull Staging was conducted according to the seventh authors
lesions. We present a series of patients with edition of the American Joint Committee on
NPC complaining of headaches and in which a Cancer (AJCC).[3] Access this article online
nonspecialist played a critical role in the diagnosis Website: www.cancerjournal.net
and management. Exclusion criteria were as follows: Lack of DOI: 10.4103/0973-1482.157334
pathological diagnosis, unclear medical history, PMID: ***
PATIENTS AND METHODS previous confirmed malignant tumors, and/or Quick Response Code:
Journal of Cancer Research and Therapeutics - January-March 2016 - Volume 12 - Issue 1 209
[Downloaded free from http://www.cancerjournal.net on Tuesday, November 20, 2018, IP: 125.161.138.31]
and the time of appearance, initial diagnosis time and result, 6 months. A cranial CT was done in our outpatient facilities.
diagnosing hospital type, diagnosis department, and accuracy He was diagnosed with hematencephalon and hospitalized
and time of diagnosis. All data were summarized for final analysis. by the neurosurgery department. The cranial computed
tomography angiography (CTA) revealed a left temporal lobe
RESULTS brain hemorrhage. Subsequent brain enhanced MRI analysis
revealed a regular margin ovoid mass in the left temporal lobe
Patient characteristics with several hemorrhages [Figure 1]. The neurosurgeons made
Two‑hundred and nineteen participants (155 males and a preliminary diagnosis of glioma or tumor apoplexy.
64 females) entered our prospective trial. The median
age was 46 years (range: 23–71 years). The incidence in Under general anesthesia, craniotomy surgery and resectioning
patients less than 30 years old was only 6.8% (15/219). The of the mass in the left temporal lobe were performed on the
30–59‑year‑old patients accounted for 59.4% (130/219). We patient. The postoperative pathology (pathological number:
observed a significant number (33.8%, 74/219) of NPC cases 2014‑00140) revealed a left temporal lobe malignant tumor
in patients of 60 years and older. The majority of patients and a metastatic squamous cell carcinoma. These findings
were in locally advanced stages. According to the 7th AJCC were corroborated by strong positive immunohistochemisty
staging guidelines, individuals were classified as follows: staining for P63 and pancytokeratin (PCK), and negative
1.4% stage II (three cases), 46.6% stage III (102 cases), 36.1% staining for vimentin and S‑100 proteins [Figure 2].
stage IVA (79 cases), 7.7% stage IVB (17 cases), and 8.2% stage
IVC (18 cases). Education levels in patients were as follows: The second MRI of the nasopharynx showed thickening of the
31.1% had a primary school degree (68 subjects), 57.5% had a soft tissue in the nasopharyngeal hanging wall and bilateral
middle school degree (126 patients), and 11.4% had a college wall with disappearing infundibuliform recesses. The mass had
degree (25 patients). also invaded the parapharyngeal spaces, skull base, and left
cavernous sinus. Soft tissue nodules surrounded the bilateral
Misdiagnosis rate carotid sheath, which were likely to be metastatic lymph nodes
One‑hundred and twenty‑four patients were confirmed or caused by NPC [Figure 1]. Endoscopy revealed a rough mass with
suspected of having NPC during the initial visit. The definitive clear boundaries in the left pharyngeal recess. The histological
diagnosis rate was 56.6% (124/219), making the misdiagnosis findings and radiological examination resulted in NPC
rate 43.4% (95/219). These cases were misdiagnosed as diagnosis, and radiochemotherapy was initiated. The patient
sinusitis, nervous headache, intracranial tumors, otitis media, received one cycle of cisplatin and taxotere chemotherapy as
or tuberculosis. The diverse and nonspecific symptoms resulted a preradiotherapy treatment to reduce the primary disease.
in late diagnosis of NPC.
Based on the data we gathered, the misdiagnosis rate was
The influence of symptoms on misdiagnosis 86.4% (19/22) in the patients that initially presented only with
Headaches alone headaches. The neurologists were misled by the nonspecific
There were 22 patients who only suffered from a headache. symptoms of nasopharyngeal cancer.
Twenty‑one patients were assigned to Departments
of Neurology, and only one patient was assigned to a Headaches accompanied by palpable lymph nodes in neck
neurosurgery department. In the neurology departments, Fifty‑six patients complained of headache and neck mass.
12 of the 21 patients had a brain CT that failed to detect Among them, 30 patients first visited general surgeon and
nasopharyngeal lesions due to insufficient lower edge settings, five of those patients were directly referred to the oncology
or indistinct delineation of the skull base. Those 12 patients department as they were suspected to have NPC. The remaining
were treated for a nervous or vascular headache. All of these 25 patients received a cytological examination of the cervical
patients were given over‑the‑counter medication for pain lymph nodes. The results demonstrated metastatic squamous
relief. However, because the pain did not respond well to cell carcinoma in 22 patients, whereas three patients were
the prescribed medication, brain MRI was arranged, and initially diagnosed with lymphadenitis and were prescribed
following this a diagnosis of NPC was given. The remaining anti‑inflammatory therapy. This treatment failed, further
six patients with hypertension who did not receive a brain CT aggravating the headaches and stability of the lymph nodes.
were diagnosed with unstable blood pressure and subjected The patients returned to the oncology department 2 weeks
to antihypertensive therapy. Fortunately, three of the patients later, where a definitive diagnosis of NPC was confirmed
did receive an initial brain CT that included parts of the by endoscopic biopsy of the primary tumor. The remaining
nasopharynx, and therefore did reveal nasopharyngeal tumors 26 patients went directly to oncology and were diagnosed
with upward invasion into the skull base. Consequently, those with NPC. Therefore, 31 patients received a primary diagnosis
three cases received an initial diagnosis of NPC. of nasopharyngeal cancer.
The remaining 60‑year‑old male patient had daily headaches The misdiagnosis rate of patients presenting with a headache
involving the left temporal and parietal lobe areas for and a cervical lymph node mass was 44.6% (25/56). It is likely
210 Journal of Cancer Research and Therapeutics - January-March 2016 - Volume 12 - Issue 1
[Downloaded free from http://www.cancerjournal.net on Tuesday, November 20, 2018, IP: 125.161.138.31]
a c e
b d f
Figure 1: A 60-year-old man suffered from headaches for 6 months. Cranial computed tomography (CT) demonstrated hematencephalon
(a and b). Brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) revealed a homogeneously enhanced mass in the left temporal lobe accompanied with a
few hemorrhages (c and d). The second MRI demonstrated a homogeneously enhanced mass in the nasopharyngeal hanging wall and bilateral
wall, with disappearing infundibuliform recesses. The mass had also invaded the parapharyngeal spaces. The lymph nodes surrounded bilateral
carotid sheath (e and f)
Journal of Cancer Research and Therapeutics - January-March 2016 - Volume 12 - Issue 1 211
[Downloaded free from http://www.cancerjournal.net on Tuesday, November 20, 2018, IP: 125.161.138.31]
In patients with a rhinobyon, however, the accurate diagnosis Table 1: Influence of initial concomitant symptoms on
rate is only 48.7% (19/39 patients). Twenty patients were misdiagnosis of NPC patients with headaches at the first visit
misdiagnosed with chronic sinusitis or an upper respiratory Concomitant Misdiagnosed Visited Misdiagnosis
tract infection, because the clinical manifestations did not manifestations cases (n) cases (n) rate (%)
Only headache 19 22 86.4
help the doctors distinguish NPC from other common diseases. With neck mass 25 56 44.6
Unfortunately, neither patients nor doctors considered an With ear problems 17 44 38.6
NPC diagnosis until the cervical lymph nodes were enlarged, With rhinobyon 20 39 51.3
or until other new symptoms appeared, which were a sign of With epistaxis 5 46 10.9
With neurological 9 12 75.0
advanced stage NPC. or other symptoms
212 Journal of Cancer Research and Therapeutics - January-March 2016 - Volume 12 - Issue 1
[Downloaded free from http://www.cancerjournal.net on Tuesday, November 20, 2018, IP: 125.161.138.31]
negative findings. Headaches are often the first and most medical education for nonspecialists should be strengthened.
prominent symptom in ascending‑type NPC. To facilitate early This would help ensure that nonspecialists conduct a
diagnosis, it is important to recognize headache patterns of comprehensive differential diagnosis for patients with
ascending‑type NPC.[7] headaches, nasal obstruction, and hearing loss. It is important
to teach clinical doctors not to simply think of headaches as
Secondly, if the first doctor is inexperienced with NPC, it is a sign of intracranial tumors, and that imaging scans should
more likely that a wrong diagnosis will be made based on include sufficient ranges to exclude NPC.
these atypical symptoms. The structures near nasopharynx
are complex and can have a lot of lymphatic drainage as well. Submucosal carcinoma cannot be confirmed by a conventional
Nasopharyngeal cancer can encroach upwards towards the multiple biopsy. To improve the positive diagnosis rate, physicians
skull base and intracranial tissue and extend down to the oral should punch the surface tissue and make a deep biopsy through
cavity. It has a tendency to infiltrate peripheral organs, such the wound. One patient was definitively diagnosed on the
as the middle ear, parapharyngeal space, and infratemporal seventh biopsy by our center, providing an example that the
fossa. Consequently, patients may suffer from symptoms that clinically suspect cases cannot easily be eliminated.
are not exclusive to NPC. Sometimes, neck mass may be the
first clinical manifestation of NPC. Occasionally, blockage of NPC incidence rises steadily with age, peaking at 40–59 years
the Eustachian tube can produce a middle ear transudate. and then significantly declining. Headaches are the initial
Proptosis is a result of the tumor’s direct extension into the symptom that elicits medical attention in almost 20% of cases.
orbit from the posterior nasal fossa via ethmoid air cells or Approximately 60–70% of patients suffer from such painful
from the cavernous sinus through to the superior orbital symptoms in the definitive diagnosis.[9] The age distribution of
fissure. In addition, headaches or pain in the temporal or these subgroups from our hospital, however, had a small peak
occipital regions occur when the tumor extends to the base beyond 60 years, which possibly contributed to the difficulty
of the skull. in discriminating NPC from other senile diseases. In our study,
we found a similar sex‑specific incidence of NPC, with 70.8%
Doctors can contribute to a delayed NPC diagnosis when they male and 29.2% female cases yielding a 2.42:1 ratio. The cancer
ignore and misjudge the nonspecific early stage symptoms registry provides timely and dynamic information for making
that mimic other diseases. Patients with headaches alone were national, regional, and local cancer control policies. As the
misdiagnosed with nervous or vascular headaches and only a National Central Cancer Registry (NCCR) continues to expand,
minority of doctors considered intracranial tumors because of primary and secondary prevention of NPC is expected to
the incomplete image. The misdiagnosis rate of these patients improve.[10] Nonetheless, a general principle must stand out: If
was 86.4%. One patient even had an unnecessary craniotomy. a headache patient cannot be diagnosed with simply a primary
The misdiagnosis rates of neurosurgery departments were headache, particularly without other typical NPC features,
highest at 100% (1/1). This phenomenon indicates that further examination to exclude NPC is requisite. Also, fiberoptic
nonspecialists do not have a complete understanding of NPC, nasopharyngoscopy and image scanning of the nasopharynx
which is especially obvious during clinical work. are equally important. In addition, brain MRI would be more
beneficial for this purpose than CT. As far as we know, there
Nasopharyngeal endoscopy is the initial procedure of have not been pertinent studies of this topic. Our article is the
choice for the detection of NPC, with a definitive diagnosis first to analyze the characteristics of these unique patients who
of NPC confirmed by endoscopic biopsy of the primary presented with headaches as their primary, or only, symptom.
tumor.[8] The majority of misdiagnosed patients did not
undergo nasopharyngeal endoscopy, which led to adverse To summarize, this subgroup of NPC patients who presented
outcomes. However, submucosal nasopharyngeal cancer with only headaches, or headaches accompanied by other
may not be discovered by endoscopy. Three patients had atypical presentations, suffered from a high misdiagnosis
nasopharyngeal endoscopy, but were still misdiagnosed rate. This was related to the nonspecific symptoms of NPC,
because they had the submucosal type. low capabilities of the basic hospitals, and patients visiting
inappropriate departments that could not provide targeted
Thirdly, the level of a hospital is an important factor in examination and treatment. Educating hospital staff, a
misdiagnosis. The initial diagnosis rate of NPC in provincial decisive first step for diagnosing early stage NPC, can improve
hospitals is 70.5%, but dropped to 51.4% in municipal awareness of various nonspecific symptoms and signs of NPC,
hospitals. The rural hospitals had the lowest diagnosis rates especially among high‑risk populations.
of only 25%. This data indicates that the current distribution
of medical resources is extremely unbalanced and that there is REFERENCES
a wide gap between the provincial and basic hospitals.
1. Huang TR, Zhang SW, Chen WQ, Deng W, Zhang CY, Zhou XJ, et al.
Therefore, we propose that the following measures should Trends in nasopharyngeal carcinoma mortality in China, 1973‑2005.
be taken to avoid misdiagnosis. Principally, continuing Asian Pac J Cancer Prev 2012;13:2495‑502.
Journal of Cancer Research and Therapeutics - January-March 2016 - Volume 12 - Issue 1 213
[Downloaded free from http://www.cancerjournal.net on Tuesday, November 20, 2018, IP: 125.161.138.31]
2. Lu H, Peng L, Yuan X, Hao Y, Lu Z, Chen J, et al. Concurrent carcinoma and its clinical implications. ScientificWorldJournal
chemoradiotherapy in locally advanced nasopharyngeal carcinoma: 2012;2012:143829.
A treatment paradigm also applicable to patients in Southeast Asia. 8. Chan AT, Felip E, ESMO Guidelines Working Group. Nasopharyngeal
Cancer Treat Rev 2009;35:345‑53. cancer: ESMO clinical recommendations for diagnosis, treatment and
3. Edge SB, Byrd DR, Compton CC, Fritz AG, Greene FL, Trotti A. Nasal follow‑up. Ann Oncol 2009;20:123‑5.
Cavity and Paranasal Sinuses. In: Edge SB editor. AJCC Cancer Staging 9. Yin WB, Yu ZH, Xu GZ, Hu YM, Wang LH, Wang LH, et al.
Manual, 7th ed. Philadephia: Lippincott-Raven; 2009. p. 93-102. Nasopharyngeal cancer. In: Yin WB, editor. Radiation Oncology, 4th ed.
4. Ng WT, Choi CW, Lee MC, Law LY, Yau TK, Lee AW. Outcomes of Bei Jing: Peking Union Medical College Press; 2008. p. 443‑4.
nasopharyngeal carcinoma screening for high risk family members 10. Xu ZJ, Zheng RS, Zhang SW, Zou XN, Chen WQ. Nasopharyngeal
in Hong Kong. Fam Cancer 2010;9:221‑8. carcinoma incidence and mortality in China in 2009. Chin J Cancer
5. Mao YP, Li WF, Chen L, Sun Y, Liu LZ, Tang LL, et al. A clinical 2013;32:453‑60.
verification of the Chinese 2008 staging system for nasopharyngeal
carcinoma. Ai Zheng 2009;28:1022‑8. Cite this article as: Wu ZX, Xiang L, Rong JF, He HL, Li D.
6. Jiang F, Hu FJ, Li B, Qin WF, Feng XL, Bao WA, et al. Factors Nasopharyngeal carcinoma with headaches as the main symptom:
for misdiagnosis of nasopharyngeal carcinoma and relevant A potential diagnostic pitfall. J Can Res Ther 2016;12:209-14.
countermeasures. Chin J Clin Oncol 2012;39:2026‑35.
Source of Support: Nil, Conflict of Interest: None declared.
7. Lee YL, Ho CY. Headache as the sole symptom of nasopharyngeal
214 Journal of Cancer Research and Therapeutics - January-March 2016 - Volume 12 - Issue 1