Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Al-Haythami said : « From the way of ‘Umar and by Al-Bazar from the way
of ‘Anbasah Al-Khawwas, and I do not know these two » (« Majma’ uz-
Zawa’id » v 10 p 63). So this Hadith is weak as these two narrators are
unknown.
« The Abdal are among the people of Sham (Syria and surrounding
areas): By them they are saved and by them they receive their
sustenance »
Hafiz ibn Hajar said concerning ‘Amr ibn Waqid: « Matruk » (abandoned)
(« Taqrib » 5132)
« Difference will occur after the death of a caliph and a man from
the people of Madinah will flee to Makkah. Some people from
Makkah will come towards him, take him against his will and
give him Bay’ah between the corner (of the Ka’bah) and the
Maqam of Ibrahim. A Military expedition will be send against
him, but it will be swallowed by the earth in the desert between
Makkah and Madinah, and when people will see this, the Abdal
of Syria and the best people of ‘Iraq will come towards him and
give him Bay’ah. » (« Musnad Ahmad » v 6 p 316, « Sunnan Abu
Dawud » Kitab Al-Mahdi n°4286)
The chain of narrators contains Salih Abu Khalil from one of his
companions, from Umm Salamah. So the companion of Salih Abu Khalil is
unknown.
Also the Shaykh objected to the Matn of the Ahadith as there is a clear
Idhtirab (contradictions that cannot be removed)
Indeed, some Ahadith mention 30, other 40, and some other numbers, and
Sufis could not explain this clear contradiction. Some Sufis tried to say that
the number of Abdal is 40 and 30 are upon the heart of Ibrahim, but this
reconciliation is false as one can see that Hadith of Ibn Mas’ud says 40 men
like Ibrahim and Hadith of ‘Ubadah says 30 men like Ibrahim. Also another
Hadith of Ubadah says the Abdal are 30, meaning their total number is 30.
This Idhtirab about the Ahadith of Abdal has been mentioned by Hafiz as-
Sakhawi who said, "It has a number of different routes from Anas (RA) from
the Prophet (SAW), WITH CONTRADICTORY WORDING, all of which
are da'eef." ['Maqaasid al-Hasanah' (pp 26-28 no.8)]
So one whose heart is free of Ta’asub can clearly see contradictions in these
Ahadith, as for people who follow their desire, then 30 and 40 is the same.
When one is under influence of opium of Sufism, then everything is
possible.
Note: the information about narrators have been taken from the article of
Abu Rumaysah that is also on this web page and from « Taqdis ul
Ashkhas » of Shaykh Muhammad Al-Lowh, also the quote of As-Sakhawi is
taken from Abu Rumaysah.
Shaykhul Islam Ibn Taymiyah wrote in his Fatwa on the Abdal, published
in his « Jami ul Masail » v 2 p 67, (Tahqiq Shaykh Uzayr Shams):
And this is true and proved by the Book and the Sunnah. There is
no mean to reach the satisfaction of Allah and His favour except
by Iman (faith) in the Prophets and by obeying them. »
So one can see in the Hadith mentioned by Shaykhul Islam that Muslims are
helped by the invocations of their weak ones, and the meaning of receiving
help and sustenance by them as been explained by the Prophet (saw) to
mean « by their invocations ».
So if these Ahadith are authentic -which they are not- they do not prove the
creed of the Sufis who claim Abdal are ruling the world and have received
powers by Allah, they have their assemblies in which they decide the
matters of the world, who to make rulers, what to give to everyone. While
the Sufis even claim Awliya have the power of « Kun fa Yakun » meaning
they say about something « Be » and it is so.
An-Nabbahani wrote in his « Jami’ Karamat » v 2 p 158 that the Sufi ‘Ali ibn
Muhammad Ad-Dinawri received the word « Kun » but Ad-Dinawri said :
1
As quoted in « Awliya Allah bayna Mafhum As-Soufi wal Manhaj As-Sunni As-Salafi » of
Shaykh AbdurRahman Ad-Dimashqi p 77
2
As quoted in “Taqdis ul Ashkas » v 1 p 135
“It has been revealed in some divine books: O my slave I am Allah,
when I desire something, I say “Kun” and it is, obey me my slave
and I would give you “Kun fa Yakunu” (be and it will be).”
So where do these Ahadith about Abdal say that Awliya have power of Kun
fa Yakun?
Moreover, the Sufis have some weak and fabricated Ahadith on the Abdal,
but they also mention Qutb, Ghawth, Awtad, Nuqaba, Nujaba and they do
not have any justification for it. They have made up a hierarchy of saints
and assemblies of saints, while no Ahadith say such, so their creed is based
on fairy tales and satanic Kashf of their leaders.
The Sufis differ about the Abdal and the hierarchy of saints.
Ibn ‘Arabi says that the assembly of saints is composed of one Qutb, 2
Imams, 4 Awtad and 7 Abdal, but the 4 Awtad in this assembly are only
substitutes to the 4 real Awtad who are the Prophets Ilyas, Idris, ‘Isa and
Khidr, who are all alive according to him (In fact, only ‘Isa is alive). The real
four Awtad do not change and they have four substitutes on the earth, and
3
« Mukhtasar Fatawa Misriyah » p 589, as quoted by Ad-Dimasqi in the same book.
4
“Khatmul Awliya” p 346, according to “Sanctity and Mysticsim in Medieval Egypt” by
J.A. Mc Gregor p 13.
these substitutes’ hearts correspond to the hearts of these four Prophets, and
these substitutes change after the death of one of them.5
Ibn ‘Arabi mentions 7 Abdal while Hakim At_tirmidhi mentions 40 and the
weak Ahadith mention 30 or 40, how can Sufis explain this, and at the same
time say « Al-Futuhat » and « Al-Fusus » are divinely inspired to Ibn
‘Arabi ?
If this description was from Allah, would there be any difference in it?
So for the Shadhilis, like ibn ‘Arabi, there are 7 Abdal, and this opposes
these weak Ahadith of 30 or 40, and Shadhilis attribute knowledge of Ghayb
to theirs leaders.
5
“Al-Futuhat Al-Makkiyah” v 3 p 9 Dar Al-Fikr, according to “Seal of saints” of
Chodkiewicz p 94, as mentioned in “Sanctity and Mysticsim in Medieval Egypt”
6
“Sanctity and Mysticsim in Medieval Egypt” p 23
“You would hear him speak of nothing but the Supreme
Intelligence, the Most Excellent Names and its four branches, the
names, the letters, the saints’ varied spheres of influence, the
spiritual stations of those with inward certainty, the angels with
near access to the Throne, the sciences of the mysteries, the
spiritual resources released through phrases of divine
remembrance, the day on which human beings’ destinies were
determined, the science of the (divine) will, the divine “grasp” in
which the cosmos exists and the men with an understanding
thereof, the sciences of the Solitaries (‘ulum al-afrad) and what
will take place on the Day of Resurrection by way of God’s
dealings with His servants: His forbearance, His grace, and His
vengeance. In fact, I once heard him say, “I tell you truly, if it
weren’t for people’s limited understanding, I would speak to
them of the future manifestation of God’s mercy.”
”On the Diwan of the godly men (salihun) - God be pleased with
them one and all!
I heard the Shaykh say - God be pleased with him: 'The Diwan is in
the cave of Hira which is where the Prophet (saw) undertook pious
devotions - God's blessings and peace be upon him: 'The support
(al-ghawth) sits outside the cave. Mecca is behind his right
shoulder and Medina is in front of his left knee. On his right are
four pivots (aqtab) who are Malikites, adherents of the school of
jurisprudence of the imam Malik b. Anas - God be pleased with
him! Three pivots are on his left each one an adherent of the (other)
three schools of jurisprudence. Then in front of them is the Wakil
who's called the Qadi of the Diwan. At this time he too is a
Malikite from the Banu Khalid who live in the region of Basra. His
name is Sayyidi Muhammad b. 'Abd al-Karim al-Basrawi. The
Support speaks to the Wakil, and the latter is called the Wakil
(deputy) because he speaks on behalf of everyone who's in the
Diwan'
Comment: So for Ad-Dabbagh the Qutb are 7, while other say the Abrar are
7 and ibn Arabi and others say the Abdal are 7, and Ad-Dabbagh also says
that the Awliya know Ghayb, so we let the Sufis explain who is the liar in
them and why do they respect all these contradicting books?
He replied- God be pleased with him and with our lords the
religious scholars: ‘How could the matter of the five things be
unknown to him-God’s blessing and peace be upon him-since
none of the people with the power of free disposal (tasarruf)
among his noble community would be able to exercise that
power without knowledge of these five?”
So for the Sufis, Ad-Dabbagh has the knowledge of Ghayb, so why do they
differ with him about the number of Qutbs?
Comment: Why do other Sufis books do not mention these 300 Akhyar?
Also no Ahadith mentions that these saints work by mutual consent. What
is the proof of such a claim? Is this not legislating what Allah did not reveal,
or do these Sufis have other Books revealed to them?
“On the other hand, Junayd and Abu al-`Abbas Sayyari and Abu
Bakr Wasiti and Muhammad b. 'Ali of Tirmidh, the author of the
doctrine, hold that miracles are manifested in the state of sobriety
and composure (sahw fi tamkin) not in the state of
intoxication. They argue that the saints of God are the governors of
His kingdom and the overseers of the universe, which God has
committed absolutely to their charge: therefore their judgments
must be the soundest of all, and their hearts must be the most
tenderly disposed of all towards the creatures of God. They are
mature (rasidagan); and whereas agitation and intoxication are
marks of inexperience, with maturity agitation is transmuted
into composure. Then, and only then, is one a saint in
reality, and only then are miracles genuine. It is well known
among Sufis that every night the Awtad must go round the
whole universe, and if there should be any place on which
their eyes have not fallen, next day some imperfection will
appear in that place; and they must then inform the Qutb, in
order that he may fix his attention on the weak spot, and that by
his blessing the imperfection may be removed…
Comment: One can see the function attributed to the Awtad and the Qutb,
all these powers attributed to them, while no Prophets had such powers.
How can four Awtad check every night the whole world?
All these fairy tales are not justified by any Hadith, but Sufis base on
conjectures and stories.
Abdul Hakim Murad’s belief in the Abdal
Abdul Hakim Murad wrote about the Abdal in his notes to his translation of
Ghazali’s Ihya book 12 and 13 under English name “Al-Ghazali on
disciplining the soul and on breaking the two desires” p 89:
Comment: One can ask Abdul Hakim Murad which Hadith says that the
Abdal direct the world’s spiritual activity and there are 7 Abrar, 3 Nuqaba
and 1 Qutb, and they are in continual communication?
So one can see that Abul Hakim Murad instead of rejecting this fabricated
religion, believes in it. Can there be a greater danger to Islam than these
books that ascribe to Islam what is not part of it? Can there be more
dangerous people than these Sufis and their legislation of a religion which
Allah did not reveal?
If such assemblies of saints existed, why would the Salaf not mention them
in their Tafasir and books of Hadith? Did they forget to tell us how the
Qutb, Ghawth, Abrar, Awtad and other work?
May Allah send Salah and Salam on the Prophet (saw), his family and
companions.