Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
doi:10.5681/jcs.2014.016
http:// journals.tbzmed.ac.ir/ JCS
of support for patients and families during Traditionally, Iranian studies on ECT were
illness and stress.5 Supportive care includes a mostly focused on the effectiveness and the
set of general and special medical side effects of the treatment.17
interventions carried out by a nurse to protect Although Cognitive disorders and physical
and comfort the patient and not just to treat complications following ECT always have
his illness.6 been considered, Psychological adverse
Recent studies indicate that the supportive effects are usually ignored.18 Especially, to
care by nurses for cancer patients may the best of our knowledge, there is no study
improve their mood 7 and in patients on on the effect of supportive care on self esteem
dialysis is effective in reducing anxiety and in patient receiving ECT.
depression.8 Considering the wide application of ECT19,
One of the most important therapeutic our aim in this study is to assess the effect of
procedures in the management of patients supportive care by nurses on the self esteem
with severe mental disorders is of patients undergoing ECT treatment. If the
Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT)9 which effectiveness of the intervention was proved,
provides therapeutic effects by inducing we emphasize on the importance of
seizures.10 providing proper nursing support to reduce
About 100 thousand people in the United psychological side effects associated with
States and more than 1 million people ECT.
worldwide receive ECT annually.11 Due to
the high prevalence of psychiatric disorders Materials and methods
and its associated negative consequences and This is a randomized clinical trial. Ethical
also high efficacy of ECT, this treatment has approval was granted by Study approval was
been considered as a useful and effective received from institutional review board of
method of treatment.12 Tabriz University of Medical Sciences
Despite wide usage of ECT, this method has (2786/4/5) and Baharan psychiatric hospital
being faced with social, political, legal and of Zahedan University of Medical Sciences
public rejection for years.13 According to the (2013).
past studies, most of the ECT patients Participants were selected from all in patients
announced the other patients as their main receiving ECT at the time of the study that
source of information for this procedure14 were: above 18 years, able to read and write,
which causes misconception, legend stories, and had no physical disease leading to
misunderstanding, stigma and low self- cognitive disorder or bipolar disorder with
esteem.15 high self esteem. We excluded Patients in
False representation of ECT in the media and acute psychosis phase, those who have
lack of useful training to properly represent received ECT less than 4 sessions and lack of
the reality cause negative psychosocial effects interest in continuing to participate in the
such as low self-esteem.11 research.
There is a direct association between low self- To determine the sample size, a pilot study
esteem, depression, hopelessness and feelings was conducted on 24 patients receiving ECT
of worthlessness. Low self-esteem intensifies who met the inclusion criteria. At 0.05
vulnerability to the stressors.16 This can lead statistical significance level and with a power
to difficulty in communicating and of 0.9, and also regarding Mean difference
unwillingness to participate in the treatment and standard deviation before and after the
plans.3 intervention for study group 5.16 (2.77) and
Thus paying attention and providing an control group -2.66 (2.65), 30 patients was
effort to enhance self-esteem is very crucial. estimated for each group. However,
150 | Journal of Caring Sciences, Jun 2014; 3 (2), 149-156 Copyright © 2014 by Tabriz University of Medical Sciences
Effect of supportive care on self esteem associated with ECT
Copyright © 2014 by Tabriz University of Medical Sciences Journal of Caring Sciences, Jun 2014; 3 (2), 149-156 | 151
Ebrahimi et al.
intervention using paired t-test, also to intervention group increased from 13.68 (3.81)
compare self esteem changes in two groups to 18.22 (2.36) and in the control group it
before and after intervention an independent decreased from 13.14(3.40) to 11.54 (3.60). Also
t test was used. mean difference of self esteem score showed a
The effect of demographic variables was significant statistical difference between before
controlled using the Analysis of Covariance and after intervention.
(ANCOVA). Gender, marriage, job and The possible cause of decrease in the average
educational level in two groups were self-esteem score after ECT could be receiving
compared by chi-square test and their age information from invalid resources and lack of
was compared by an independent t-test. P appropriate physical and emotional support.
values less than 0.05 were considered as Therefore, results of this study revealed that
significant. the information, emotional and physical
supportive care has a positive effect on
Results increasing self-esteem in patients receiving
ECT.
Chi-square test showed that both groups are Self-esteem and its importance in patients
similar in socio demographic characteristics with different psychiatric disorders have been
such as gender, marital status, job and studied from different perspectives. For
educational level. The independent samples example Guillon and colleagues studied the
t-test results showed no significant difference relationship of self-esteem and mental
in age distribution between the intervention disorders in adolescents. They found that
41.00 (10.90) and control 41.08 (11.22) groups mental disorders in adolescents is associated
(t=-0.03, P>0.05). Table 1 shows some socio- with low self-esteem and appropriate
demographic characteristics of the subjects. therapeutic interventions can enhance
According to the results, Paired t-test showed adolescents' self-esteem. 1
a significant difference between the mean Vracotas and colleagues also examined the
self-esteem score in both groups before and role of self-esteem in the first episode of
after intervention. On the other hand, an psychosis and showed a positive impact of
independent t-test showed that the mean self- high self-esteem on the psychotic sym-
esteem score of both groups has no ptoms.21 Their result is consistent with the
significant difference before intervention but present study in the sense that they also
after the intervention was significantly considered the importance of self-esteem in
different (Table2). patients with psychiatric disorders and
Analysis of research findings (Levin test) providing interventions to improve it.
regarding the study hypothesis showed that Seo and colleagues studied the effect of
variances of the dependent variable in both nursing interventions, such as social skill
groups are equal that is a necessary training, on self-esteem and social skills of
prerequisite for using ANCOVA test. Results chronic schizophrenic patients. They showed
of ANCOVA analysis showed that the self that Social skills training is effective in
esteem changes after the intervention is enhancing patients' self-esteem22 which is
significant and it means that supportive care consistent with informational support given in
provided by nurses can improve self esteem present study.
score (Table3). Madani et al., assessed the relationship
between self esteem and extent of coping
Discussion strategies and self-care programs in Multiple
Comparison of mean self esteem in both Sclerosis patients. Results revealed that self
groups showed a significant difference before care education can enhance self esteem.23 This
and after intervention. The means score in the study is in conjunction with the patients who
152 | Journal of Caring Sciences, Jun 2014; 3 (2), 149-156 Copyright © 2014 by Tabriz University of Medical Sciences
Effect of supportive care on self esteem associated with ECT
Table2. Comparison of mean self esteem score in intervention and control group
Before After 95% CI for Paired
Groups intervention intervention changes t- test
Mean(SD) Mean(SD)
Intervention 13.68 (3.81) 18.22 (2.36) - 5.53, -3.54 t=9.28, df=34, P=0.001
Control 13.14 (3.46) 11.54 (3.60) 0.89, 2.30 t=4.59, df=34, P=0.001
95% CI for difference -1.19, 2.28 5.23, 8.14
Independent t- test t=0.62, df=68, P=0.53 t=9.16, df=68, P=0.001
Table 3. Results of covariance test on self esteem score on intervention and control
group
Source of Sum of Degree of Mean F P -value Effect Power of
changes squares freedom square size Study
Pre test 295.90 1 295.90 63.00 0.001 0.50 1.00
Age 0.16 1 0.16 0.03 0.85 0.001 0.05
Gender 0.21 1 0.21 0.04 0.83 0.001 0.05
Marriage 0.001 1 0.001 0.001 0.99 0.001 0.05
Education 1.91 1 1.91 0.40 0.52 0.001 0.09
Job 0.03 1 0.03 0.001 0.93 0.001 0.07
Group 686.13 1 686.13 146.08 0.001 0.70 1.00
Error 291.20 62 4.69
Total 16926.00 70
Copyright © 2014 by Tabriz University of Medical Sciences Journal of Caring Sciences, Jun 2014; 3 (2), 149-156 | 153
Ebrahimi et al.
suffer from other stressful conditions and is information provided by trained nurses
consistent with present study from patient could increase self esteem.
education perspective. In this study, the importance of supportive
This study examined the effect of supportive care provided by nurses has been considered.
care and education on increasing self-esteem Our results show a positive effect of this
in patients receiving ECT and has common support on the psychological complications
results with several studies that evaluated the associated with the ECT which is consistent
effect of care and education on increasing self with the results provided by Eghtedar et al.,
esteem in different patients. For example who assessed the effect of informational,
Sanaei and colleagues studied the effects of a physical and emotional support on quality of
family-centered empowerment on self- life of 100 women with breast cancer. The
efficacy and self esteem in patients under- results of this study indicate that promoting
going coronary artery bypass surgery where supportive care improves quality of life in
their results indicated an increased self breast cancer patients.27
esteem.24 Rahimi et al., also studied the effect Similar to the emotional aspect of current
of continuous care model on self-esteem in study for self esteem, leung et al., in their
hemodialysis patients and they found study showed that emotional support is more
positive effect on the levels of self-esteem.25 important than instrumental support
Previous studies of patients receiving ECT regarding psychological status in 507 elderly
were more concerned with physical Chinese who suffered anxiety and
complications associated with the depression.28
procedure. 17 However, our goal was to
investigate the effect of care and education on Conclusion
patients’ self esteem following ECT.
In this study we indicated the positive effect
Najafi et al., studied the effect of an
of supportive care provided by nurses on self
educational DVD on reducing complications
esteem of patients receiving ECT. Regarding
after ECT. Educational video before
high prevalence of psychological disorders
treatment leads to less headaches, memory
and their negative consequences and also
deficits and nausea.26 Their approach is
high efficacy of ECT, this procedure is highly
similar to the physical and informational
recommended as a useful treatment.
support provided in our study which could
ECT is a very important treatment for
decrease the physical side effects of ECT. The
psychiatric disorders. However, due to many
present study further examined the impact of
reasons, the patients receiving ECT
this support on the self-esteem.
experience many psychological side effects
Akhondi et al., studied the effect of education
such as low self-esteem. Some of the reasons
on consciousness and cognitive status in
causing these effects are lack of public
patients treated with ECT and confirmed that
acceptance, getting information from invalid
pre procedure education is effective on
sources and negative attitudes toward this
cognitive status of patients. Patients who get
treatment. Low self-esteem in patients with
required training prior to ECT about related
psychiatric disorders is associated with many
and advantages of using this method,
negative consequences and enhances their
materials and procedures, and temporary
vulnerability to stressors.
side effects of the treatment, had better
Nurses, due to the nature of their job, are in a
cognitive status.19 Education provided is
close relationship with their patients and can
consistent with informational support of
provide proper and standard support to
current study. In present study, emotional
decrease the adverse side effects of ECT.
and physical support in addition to
154 | Journal of Caring Sciences, Jun 2014; 3 (2), 149-156 Copyright © 2014 by Tabriz University of Medical Sciences
Effect of supportive care on self esteem associated with ECT
These nonmedical interventions are mostly modified labeling theory. Schizophr Res. 2012
easy to deliver and generally they are in the May;137(1-3):185-9.
3. Markowitz FE. Modeling processes in recovery
score of nursing duties. According to the
from mental illness: relationship between
results of this study it is recommended that symptoms, life satisfaction, and self-concept. J
nurses should spend more time with patients Health Soc Behav 2001; 42(1):64-79.
to meet their informational, physical and 4. Wood JH, Chambers M, White SJ. Nurses'
emotional needs. Nursing managers can knowledge of and attitude to electroconvulsive
therapy. J ECT. 2007; 23(4):251-4.
prepare their staff through training courses in
5. Chalco K, Wu D, Mestanza L, Muñoz M, Llaro K,
order to provide care and support for Guerra D, et al. Nurses as providers of emotional
particularly patients receiving ECT. support to patients with MDRTB. Int Nurs Rev
One of the limitations of this study was the 2006; 53(4):253-60.
possible interactions between nurses in the 6. Jonas WB. Dictionary of complementary and
intervention and control group through alternative medicine. Journal of Alternative &
Complementary Medicine 2005; 11(4):739-40.
conversation. This limitation was partially 7. Galway K, Black A, Cantwell M, Cardwell CR,
controlled by training specific nurses in the Mills M, Donnelly M. Psychosocial interventions to
morning or the night shifts, encouraging their improve quality of life and emotional wellbeing for
participation through incentives and by recently diagnosed cancer patients. Cochrane
collaborating with the management system. Database Syst Rev. 2012;11.
8. Öyekçin DG, Gülpek D, Sahin EM, Mete L.
However, in order to minimize the Depression, anxiety, body image, sexual
possibility of exchanging information functioning, and dyadic adjustment associated with
between the intervention and control group dialysis type in chronic renal failure. Int J
further actions should be taken. Psychiatry Med 2012; 43(3):227-41.
9. Payne NA, Prudic J. Electroconvulsive therapy Part
I: a perspective on the evolution and current
Acknowledgments practice of ECT. J Psychiatr Pract 2009; 15(5):
369–90.
This study is granted by Tabriz University of
10. Sekino M, Ueno S. FEM-based determination of
Medical Sciences. Researchers would like to optimum current distribution in transcranial
thank the research deputy of Tabriz magnetic stimulation as an alternative to
University of Medical Sciences, staff in electroconvulsive therapy. Magnetics, IEEE
Baharan hospital (Zahedan) and all patients Transactions on. 2004; 40(4):2167-9.
participating in this study. 11. Payne NA, Prudic J. Electroconvulsive therapy part
II: a biopsychosocial perspective. J Psychiatr Pract
2009; 15(5): 369–90.
Ethical issues 12. World Health Organization. World Mental Health
Survey Consortium 2004. Available from:
None to be declared. http://www.who.int/mental_health/evidence/Atlas_t
raining_final.pdf
Conflict of interest 13. Semkovska M, McLoughlin DM. Objective
cognitive performance associated with
The authors declare no conflict of interest in electroconvulsive therapy for depression: a
this study. systematic review and meta-analysis. Biological
psychiatry 2010; 68 (6): 568-77.
References 14. Iodice AJ, Dunn AG, Rosenquist P, Hughes DL,
McCall WV. Stability over time of patients’
1. Guillon MS, Crocq MA, Bailey PE. The attitudes toward ECT. Psychiatry research 2003;
relationship between self-esteem and psychiatric 117 (1): 89-91.
disorders in adolescents. European Psychiatry 2003; 15. Staring ABP, Gaag M, Berge M, Duivenvoorden
18(2):59-62. HJ, Mulder CL. Stigma moderates the associations
2. Davis L, Kurzban S, Brekke J. Self-esteem as a of insight with depressed mood, low self-esteem,
mediator of the relationship between role and low quality of life in patients with
functioning and symptoms for individuals with schizophrenia spectrum disorders 2009 ,
severe mental illness: a prospective analysis of Schizophrenia Research. 2009 ; (115): 363–69.
Copyright © 2014 by Tabriz University of Medical Sciences Journal of Caring Sciences, Jun 2014; 3 (2), 149-156 | 155
Ebrahimi et al.
16. Tarrier N, Khan S, Cater J, Picken A. The social skills and self-esteem of inpatients with
subjective consequences of suffering a first episode chronic schizophrenia. Arch psychiatr nurs 2007;
psychosis: trauma and suicide behaviour. Soc 21(6): 317-26.
Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 2007; 42(1): 29-35. 23. Madani H, Navipoor H, Roozbayani P. Relations
17. Malekian A, Amini Z, Maracy MR, Barekatain M. between self-esteem and applying coping
Knowledge of attitude toward experience and mechanism and self-care program in multiple
satisfaction with electroconvulsive therapy in a sclerosis (MS) patients. journal of ilam university
sample of Iranian patients. J ECT 2009; 25(2):106- of medical sciences 2008; 15(4):31-41.
12. 24. Sanaie N, Nejati S, Zolfaghari M, Alhani F,
18. Johnstone L. Adverse psychological effects of ECT. KazemNejad A. The effect of family-centered
Journal of Mental Health 1999; 8(1):69-85. empowerment in self efficacy and self esteem in
19. Akhondi M, Akbarpour F, Hojati H, Shakori patients undergoing coronary bypass graft surgery.
HR , Sharifnia H , Nazari R. Education effect on Journal of Gorgan Bouyeh Faculty of Nursing &
consciousness and cognitive status of Midwifery 2013; 11(3): 44-53. (Persian)
electroconvulsive therapy patients in phsyche unit 25. Rahimi A, Ahmadi F, Gholyaf M. Effects of
of Imam Reza hospital of Amol and Yahyanezhad applying continuous care model on self esteem in
hospital of Babol. Journal of Urmia Nursing and hemodialysis patients. Journal of Zanjan University
Midwifery Faculty 2011; 9(2): 61-5.(Persian) of Medical sciences 2005; 13 (53):16-21.(Persian)
20. Rajabi GH R, Bohlol N. Assess the reliability and 26. Najafi M, Tavakoli S, Ganji F, Rostami A. Effect of
validity of the Rosenberg self-esteem scale an first video education on reduction of post ECT
year students of Shahid Chamran university. complications. Iranian Journal of Medical
University of Isfahan Journals System New Education 2011; 10(5):1216-27.
Educational Approaches 2007; 3(2): 33-48. 27. Eghtedar Samere, Moghadasian S, Ebrahimi H,
21. Vracotas N, Iyer SN, Joober R, Malla A. The role Hassanzadazar M, Jassemi M, Esmaeili Z R.
of self-esteem for outcome in first-episode Evaluation of Nursing Supportive Care in Breast
psychosis. International Journal of Social Cancer. Iranian Journal of Breast Disease 2009; 2
Psychiatry 2012; 58(1): 41-6. (3 and 4):55-60.
22. Seo JM, Ahn S, Byun EK, Kim CK. Social skills 28. Leung KK, Chen CY, Lue BH, Hsu ST. Social
training as nursing intervention to improve the support and family functioning on psychological
symptoms in elderly Chinese. Archives of
Gerontology and Geriatrics 2007; 44(2): 203-13.
156 | Journal of Caring Sciences, Jun 2014; 3 (2), 149-156 Copyright © 2014 by Tabriz University of Medical Sciences