Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
BY
C. JOHN WILLIAMS
(08BSHYD0323)
This report “ Comparative nalysis of Unit Linked Insurance Plans (ULIPs) – An IDBI FORTIS
Perspective” done during my Summer Internship Program (SIP) is submitted as a partial
fulfillment of the requirement of MBA program of ICFAI Business School (IBS), Hyderabad.
C.JOHN WILLIAMS
I would then like to thank my faculty guide, Prof. S Subramanian, for all his valuable inputs and
constant support towards me throughout my project and providing me an opportunity to learn
outside the class room. It was a truly wonderful learning experience.
I would like to thank the training heads Mr.Anand, Ms Sudha and Sales executive Ms Priya for
helping me with the training and other activities and constantly motivating me to give my best.
I would like to dedicate this project to my parents. Without their help and constant support this
project would not have been possible.
I would like to thank all my friends who did their SIP from IDBI FORTIS for their valuable
suggestions and support.
Last but not the least I would like to thank all the respondents who offered their opinions and
suggestions and sometimes critical views throughout the survey which made me constantly
update myself come out with a successful project.
The project aims to make a detailed study of Unit Linked Insurance Plans (ULIPs) in the Indian
context, a comparative analysis of ULIPs of some well known selec ted companies and in the
process identify the strengths and weaknesses of IDBI FORTIS.
The different selected companies apart from IDBI FORTIS on which the project is entirely
focused are namely:
a ICICI PRUDENTIAL
.b BAJAJ ALLIANZ
.c TATA AIG LIFE
.d LIFE INSURANCE CORPORATION OF INDIA
.e HDFC STANDARD LIFE
.
The comparative study is primarily based in terms of the various benefits offered viz. Death
Benefits, Health benefits, Maturity Benefits, financial benefits & other benefits. The various
parameters taken into consideration were flexibility, transparency, liquidity and the number of
funds options available.
The project consists of a detailed analysis of the c omparison of various ULIPs of IDBI FORTIS
with that of the selected major players in the market. The results of the project have been an
outcome of a detailed analysis of c ollected secondary data and well supported by analysis of
primary data collected through a survey in the Hyderabad city. The project required me to
design a questionnaire and conduct a primary survey. The survey was mainly conducted to
study the consumer perception, opinion and awareness of various insuranc e products. The
number of respondents targeted was 133.The sample of respondents included was carefully
selected targeting respondents from all age groups. Also the preferences of the respondents
towards these selected insurance companies have been noted and the reasons analyzed. The
data gathered from the primary survey was coded in a statistical tool called as Statistical
Package for Social Science (SPSS) for analysis and to find various factors that affect an investor
dec isions while choosing an investment option in this vast market.
Finally we interpreted the results of the project by combining both the primary and the
secondary data analyses then identified the areas where the company is really strong and the
areas where it needs to have a second look.
We have also found out the amount to which each of the selected companies was affected due
to the market slow down in the last one year
The project also involved a complete study of the positioning strategies adopted by IBDI FORTIS
in general. This includes a detailed study of the various advertising strategies as well.
Finally after a detailed study we have found out the merits and demerits of the IDBI FORTIS and
based on those we have given some recommendations to the company in areas where the
company to has to really work on.
The Project helped me enhance my knowledge on various technicalities of the Indian insurance
industry and gave me a broader prospective of various investment opportunities available in
the market. Marketing concepts learnt in the classroom were implemented in a real life
environment.
Figure 1: The trend of the Indian insurance industry ($Bn) 2000-2011 .................................17
Table 1 : The list of life insurance companies in
India ............................................................18
Figure 2 : The market share of the Indian Life Insurance industry ........................................19
Figure 3 : Premium break -up under 24
ULIPs ..............................................................................
Table 2 : Types of funds under 26
ULIPs ......................................................................................
Figure 4 : Advantages of Unit Linked Insurance
Plans ............................................................31
Table 3 : NAVs of HDFC Standard 43
Life ....................................................................................
Figure 5 : NAVs of HDFC Standard 43
Life .....................................................................................
Table 4 : NAVs of Bajaj Allianz ............................................................................................ 44
....
Figure 6 : NAVs of Bajaj 44
Allianz ..................................................................................................
Table 5 : NAVs of ICICI Prudential ....................................................................................... 44
....
Figure 7 : NAVs ofICICI 44
Prudential .........................................................................................
Table 6 : NAVs of 45
LIC ...............................................................................................................
Figure 8 : NAVs of 45
LIC ...............................................................................................................
Table 7 : NAVs of IDBI FORTIS............................................................................................. 45
....
Figure 9 : NAVs of IDBI 45
FORTIS .................................................................................................
Table 8 : NAVs of Tata- 46
AIG .....................................................................................................
Figure 10 : NAVs of Tata-AIG............................................................................................... 46
.....
Table 9 : Percentage c hange in NAVs of various companies due to recession ...................... 46
Figure 11 : Percentage change in NAVs of various companies due to recession ..................... 46
Figure 12 : Break-up of respondents between different age groups ....................................... 4 7
Figure 13 : Break-up of respondents by their 48
occupations ........................................................
Figure 14 : Break-up of respondents based on their preferences for various savings
instruments ........................................................................................................................ 48
......
Figure 15 : Break-up of respondents based on factors influencing their decision ................ 49
.
Figure 16 : Break-up of respondents based on preferences for various forms of investment ... 49
Figure 17 : Break-down of respondents based on their frequencies of investment ............5
0
Figure 18 : Break-down of respondents who own/do not own an insurance policy ................ 0
5
Even though LIC is still the market leader with more than over 60% of the market share, the
private players are giving it a tough time. Since the last decade the market share of LIC had
fallen down by about more than 20%.
The new private players have started offering a variety of unlimited schemes right from
insurance plans for a 30 day old baby to that of a 70 year old senior citizen. Also the private
companies have started creating the importance and need of insurance in today’s life They
have started positioning their brands and are marketing their products in such a way the
people have started feeling the need of security in their lives.
Taking into account the huge population and growing per capita income besides several other
driving factors, a huge opportunity is in store for the insurance companies in India. According to
the latest research findings, nearly 80% of Indian population are without life insurance cover
while health insurance and non-life insurance continues to be below international standards.
And this part of the population is also subjected to weak social security and pension systems
with hardly any old age income security. As per our findings, insurance in India is primarily used
as a means to improve personal finances and for income tax planning; Indians have a tendency
to invest in properties and gold followed by bank deposits. They selectively invest in shares also
but the percentage is very small (4-5%). This in itself is an indicator that growth potential for
the insurance sector is immense. It's a business growing at the rate of 15-20% per annum and
presently is of the order of around more than $55 billion.
India is a vast market for life insurance that is directly proportional to the growth in premiums
and an increase in life density. With the entry of private sector players backed by foreign
expertise, Indian insurance market has bec ome more vibrant.
Since the last decade the life insurance industry in India has been growing very fast and many
new companies have entered this business insurance. The Indian life insurance industry has
recorded a robust growth of more than 16 per cent for the nine-month period which ended on
December 31, 2008.It is expected to grow at an amazing rate of 20 per cent this year Also in
the present scenario the most sought after insurance plans are the Unit Linked insurance Plans
(ULIPs)
.
A ULIP is a life insurance policy which provides a combination of risk cover and investment.
ULIPs have gained high acceptance due to attractive features they offer like flexibility,
transparency, liquidity and a vast variety of fund option. Unit linked plans are suitable for all
customer profiles; however as a general belief the risk averse investors tend to choose
traditional plans and an informed customer prefers a ULIP.ULIPs offer the kind of flexibility
that no insurance product can. ULIPs essentially combine the benefits of an insurance policy
and a market-linked investment. Investors c an select a ULIP with an equity-debt combination
that is in line with their risk profile. A risk-taking investor would typically select one with a high
equity component, while a risk-averse investor would opt for a debt-heavy one. Simply
put, ULIPs are structured in such a way that the protection element and the savings element
are distinguishable, and hence managed acc ording to your specific needs. In this way,
the ULIP plan offers unprecedented flexibility and transparency.
So with many players around for a company to really be successful it has to really be very
efficient on all fronts. It has to constantly adapt to the changing consumer preferences with a
lot of new innovations and implementing new technology try to different from the lot.
Especially if it is a new player in the market the company has to really work very hard to get
into the completion and stay afloat.
The project is being done as a part of summer internship program of ICFAI Business School-
Hyderabad. The completion of the project is a partial fulfillment requirement for being awarded
the Masters in Business Administration (MBA) degree from the university.
This study aims to make a comparative study of the Unit Linked Insuranc e Plans (ULIPs) of IDBI
FORTIS Life Insurance Company with that of some major selected players in the Indian
insurance market and study the consumer perception towards various insurance products. The
comparative analysis is based on the empirical data collected from the Hyderabad city. The
study also aims to discuss in detail the various positioning strategies adopted by IDBI FORTIS in
general.
a To compare the Unit Linked Insurance Plans (ULIPs) of IDBI FORTIS with that of some
. other selected companies.
b To identify the strengths and weaknesses of IDBI FORTIS and suggest areas where it
. could focus more and improve upon.
c To study the consumer perception towards various insurance products.
.d To study in detail the positioning strategies of brand IDBI FORTIS in general.
.
a The study is confined only to a small segment of the entire population due to
. monetary and time constraints and hence the results are applicable only to the city of
Hyderabad.
b The scope of the project is limited to conceptual and marketing aspects of Life
. Insurance Companies and doesn’t include Claim Settlement and the underwriting
part of the operations which are equally important aspect of learning.
c It is not always possible to evaluate companies under similar parameters since many
. companies deal with various businesses thus clubbing all the companies on the same
parameters is not always possible.
Step: 1
Developing a right research design and timeline for the project.
Step: 2
Collecting Secondary data of the insurance Industry
Step: 3
Designing of the Questionnaire
Step: 4
Analysis of secondary data
Step: 5
Pilot Study
Step: 6
Collection of primary data-Questionnaires and internet surveys
Step: 7
Analysis of primary data
Step: 8
Study of positioning strategies of IDBI FORTIS
Step: 9
Interpretation of the results
Step: 10
Preparation of the final report
In the data collection method, we have collected both primary and secondary data to meet our
objec
tives
Primary Data
The primary data was collected by a survey based on the questionnaire. It was formulated on
the basis of information carefully gathered by me about the various mindsets of the people.
This questionnaire was mainly formulated to target the common man to see his perception and
awareness of various investment options available. The number of respondents targeted was
around 150 and the survey was confined to Hyderabad city.
Secondary Data
The secondary data was collected directly from the companies and their websites and internet
surveys. Also a lot of similar research studies and journals have been referred to.
LITERATURE STUDY
Till today a lot of research has been done on the Indian insurance industry especially the life
insurance sector. The material for this study was collected from various internet sites, journals
and books by various authors. Similar research has been carried out by Sathak Mohanty who
worked on the risk profile of ULIPs and analyzed insurance as an investment option. He says
that Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC) is still the undisputed leader in the Indian context.
According to Anita Gupta-director, marketing and communication, ING Vysa Life insurance
ULIPs are suitable for all types of customers, right from the lower class to the premium c lass.
Also according to the Financial express (Dated 12th April, 2009) ULIPs are flexible to the core.
During the course of the project some official studies on the products of Tata-AIG and HDFC
standard Life have been referred to. Also the books on Marketing Management by Philip Kotler
and that of Marketing Research by Naresh Malhotra were referred to gain a deeper insight on
positioning strategies and marketing research techniques. A lot of groundwork has also been
done by studying the vast range insurance products before taking up this research.
Insurance may be described as a social device to reduce or eliminate risk of loss to life and
property. Under the plan of insurance, a large number of people associate themselves by
sharing risks attached to individuals. The risks which can be insured against include fire, the
perils of sea, death and accidents and burglary. Any risk contingent upon these, may be insured
against at a premium commensurate with the risk involved. Thus collective bearing of risk is
insurance.
CHARACTERISTICS OF INSURANCE
1 Sharing of risks
.2 Cooperative device
.3 Evaluation of risk
.4 Payment on happening of a spec ial event
.5 The amount of payment depends on the nature of losses incurred.
.
HISTORY OF INDIA N
INSURANCE
Insurance has a long history in India. Life Insurance in its current form was introduced in 1818
when Oriental Life Insurance Company began its operations in India. General Insurance was
however a comparatively late entrant in 1850 when Triton Insurance company set up its base in
Kolkata.
a Pre Nationalization
.b Nationalization and
.c Post Nationalization
.
Life Insurance was the first to be nationalized in 1956. Consolidating the operations of various
insurance companies formed Life Insurance Corporation of India. General Insurance followed
suit and was nationalized in 1973. General Insurance Corporation of India was set up as the
controlling body with New India, United India, National and Oriental as its subsidiaries. The
process of opening up the insurance sector was initiated against the background of Economic
Reform process, which commenced from 1991. For this purpose Malhotra Committee was
formed during this year who submitted their report in 1994 and Insurance Regulatory
Development Act (IRDA) was passed in 1999. Resultantly Indian Insurance was opened for
private companies and Private Insurance Company effectively started operations from 2001.
(Source: www.irdaindia.org)
The insurance sector was opened up for private participation a decade back. For years now, the
private players are active in the liberalized environment. The insurance market has witnessed
dynamic changes, which include presence of a fairly large number of insurers both life, and
non-life segment. Most of the private insurance companies have formed joint venture
partnering well-recognized foreign players across the globe.
The Indian life insurance market generated total revenues of $41.36 billion in 2007, thus
Representing a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 11.84% for the period spanning 2000-
2007. Life insurance market had a growth of $22.46 billion within a period of 7 years with a
growth rate of 118.24%. Estimated life premiums rose to INR 1,470,800 million ($36.77 billion)
in 2006 from INR 1,301,540 million ($32.54billion) in 2005. We envisage that life premiums in
2011 will be $65.96 billion, a growth larger than they were in 2007. The performance of the
market is forecast to accelerate, with an anticipated CAGR of 9.78% for the four-year period
2007-2011 expected to drive the market to a value of $65.96 billion by the end of 2011. There
would be a growth of $24.6 billion i.e. 59.48% in the next 4 years.
Non-life premiums in India were $6.53 billion in 2007. Gross written premium (GWP) in the
Indian non-life insurance market reached a value of $5.75 billion in 2006, this representing an
annual growth of 13.55% for the period spanning 2006-2007. Estimated non-life premiums rose
from INR230 billion ($5.75 billion) in 2006 to INR261 billion ($6.53 billion) in 2007.
We anticipate that non-life premiums will grow by a CAGR of 9.40% between 2007-2011. We
are looking for non-life premiums to rise by $405 million over the five years to the end of 2011
with a growth rate of 62.02%. (Source: http://www.scribd.com/doc/4996143/OVERVIEW-OF-
INSURANCE-SECTOR-INDIA,http://www.indiaprwire.com/pdf/pressrelease/200805079347.pdf)
With a huge population base and large untapped market, insurance industry is a big
opportunity area in India for national as well as foreign investors. India is the fifth largest life
insurance market in the emerging insurance economies globally and is growing at 32-34%
annually. This impressive growth in the market has been driven by liberalization, with new
players significantly enhancing product awareness and promoting consumer education and
information. The strong growth potential of the country has also made international players to
look at the Indian insurance market.
Moreover, saturation of insurance markets in many developed economies has made the Indian
market more attractive for international insurance players, according to "Booming Insurance
Market in India (2008-2011)”
Total non-life insurance premium is expected to inc rease at a CAGR of 25% for the
period spanning from 2008-09 to 2010-11.
With the entry of several low-cost airlines, along with fleet expansion by existing ones
and increasing corporate aircraft ownership, the Indian aviation insurance market is all
set to boom in a big way in coming years.
Home insurance segment is set to achieve a 100% growth as financial institutions have
made home insurance obligatory for housing loan approvals.
Health insurance is poised to become the second largest business for non-life insurers
after motor insurance in next three years.
A booming life insuranc e market has propelled the Indian life insurance agents into the
‘top 10 country list’ in terms of membership to the Million Dollar Round Table (MDRT)
— an exclusive club for the highest performing life insurance agents.
(Source: http://www.marketsmonitor.com/Report/IM588_related.htm)
Minimum capital requirement for direct life and Non-life Insurance company is INR1000 million
and that for reinsurance company is INR2000 million. A maximum 26% foreign equity stake is
allowed in direct insurance and reinsurance companies. In the 2004-05 budget, the Government
proposed for increasing the foreign equity stake to 49%.
(Source: www.irdaindia.org)
s is evident from its very name it deals with insurance of human life “Life insurance
corporation of India”- a public sector undertaking has the monopoly in this sector since its
nationalization.
In our wordily life, whenever there is uncertainty, there is an involvement of risk. The instinct
for security against such risk is one of the basic motivating forces determining human attitudes.
As a squeal to this quest for Security, the concept of insurance must have been born. The urge
to provide insurance or protection against the loss of life & property must have prompted
people to make some sort of sacrifice willingly in order to achieve security through
“COLLECTIVE CO-OPER TION” in this sense story of ins urance is probably as old as the story of
mankind.
All life insurance companies in India have to comply with the strict regulations laid out by
Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDA). Therefore there is no risk in
going in for private insuranc e players. In terms of being rated for financial strength like
international players, only ICICI Prudential is rated by Fitch India at National Insurer Financial
Strength Rating of AAA (Ind) with stable outlook indicating the highest claims paying ability
rating.
90.00
80.00
70.00
60.00
50.00
Life
40.00
Non-life
30.00
20.00
10.00
0.00
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC), the state owned behemoth, remains by far the largest
player in the market. Among the private sector players, ICICI Prudential Life Insurance(JV
between ICICI Bank and Prudential PLC)is the largest followed by Bajaj Allianz Life Insurance
Company Limited (JV between Bajaj Group and Allianz).
(Source: http://www.scribd.com/doc/136703/Indian-Insurance-Changing-Trends-and-a-Fresh-
Perspective
)
Right now there are a total twenty two life insurance companies operating in India, of which
one (Life Insurance Corporation) is a Public Sector Undertaking and the remaining twenty are
all private sector enterprises. (Source: www.irdaindia.org)
Figure 2: The market share of the Indian Life Insurance industry (figures are approximate)
(Source: As per a report published in 2008 by Ms Pinky Walia-Financial
Advisor)
ABOUT IDBI
FORTIS
IDBI Fortis Life Insurance Co Ltd is a joint venture
between three leading financial conglomerates – India’s premier development and commercial
bank IDBI Bank one of India’s leading private sector banks Federal Bank and Europe’s banking
and insurance giant, Fortis, each of which enjoys a significant status in their respective business
segments. In this venture, IDBI Bank owns 48% equity while Federal Bank and Fortis own 26%
equity each.
IDBI Fortis launched its first set of products across India in March 2008, after receiving the
requisite approvals from the Insurance Regulatory Development Authority (IRDA). The company
offers its services through a vast nationwide network across the branches of IDBI Bank and
Federal Bank in addition to a sizeable network of advisors and partners.
At IDBI Fortis, people endeavor to deliver products that provide value and convenienc e to the
customer. Through a continuous process of innovation in product and service delivery the
company intends to deliver world-class wealth management, protection and retirement
solutions to Indian customers
IDBI Ltd. continues to be since its inception India’s premier industrial development bank
Created in 1956 to support India’s industrial bac kbone IDBI has since evolved into a
powerhouse of industrial and retail finance Today it is amongst India’s foremost commercial
banks, with a wide range of innovative products and services, serving retail and corporate
customers in all corners of the country from over 490 branches and more than 600 ATMs. The
Bank offers its customers an extensive range of diversified services including project financing,
term lending, working capital facilities, lease finance, venture capital, loan syndication,
corporate advisory services and legal and technical advisory services to its corporate clients as
well as mortgages and personal loans to its retail clients. As part of its development activities,
IDBI has been instrumental in sponsoring the development of key institutions involved in India’s
financial sector – such as the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI), National Stock
Exchange of India Limited (NSE) and National Securities Depository Ltd.
Federal Bank is one of India’s leading private sector banks with a national network and
dominant presence in the state of Kerala. It has a strong network of over 550 branches and 450
ATMs spread across India. The bank provides over four million retail c ustomers with a wide
variety of financial products. Federal Bank is one of the first large Indian banks to have an
entirely automated and interconnected branch network. They operate on the core banking
platform and are RTGS/ NEFT enabled through which the Bank offers state-of-the-art
technology enabled products and services.
Fortis, a European financial services provider engaged in banking and insurance with a
presence in over 50 countries, offers its personal, business and institutional customers a
comprehensive package of products and services through its own channels, in collaboration
with intermediaries and through other distribution partners. With a market capitalization of
over EUR 40 billion Fortis ranks among the 20 largest financial institutions in Europe Fortis’
sound solvency position and dedicated, professional workforce of over 80,000, enables it to
combine global strength with local flexibility to provide its clients with optimum support and
service
.
VISIO
N
To be the leading provider of wealth management, protection and retirement solutions that
meets the needs of our customers and adds value to their lives.
MISSIO
N
To continually strive to enhance customer experience through innovative product offerings,
dedicated relationship management and superior service delivery while striving to interact with
our customers in the most convenient and cost effective manner.
To be transparent in the way we deal with our customers and to act with integrity.
To invest in and build quality human capital in order to achieve the mission.
VALUE
S
Transparency:Crystal Clear communication to our partners and stakeholders
Value to Customers:A product and service offering in which customers perceive value
Rock Solid and Delivery on Promise: This translates into being financially strong,
operationally robust and having clarity in claims.
Customer-friendly:Advice and support in working with customers and partners.
Profit to Stakeholders: Balance the interests of customers, partners, employees,
shareholder sand the community at large
IDBI Fortis offers a variety of products targeting every customer right from a 3 month child to a
70 year senior citizen. All the products have been classified majorly under four plans namely
Wealthsurance
Homesurance
Bondsurance
Retiresurance
WEALTHSURANC
E
The Wealthsurance Foundation Plan enables the customer to save and build wealth to meet
your financial goals. However, unlike other investment alternatives, it also enables him to
achieve his wealth goals even in the event of unexpected death, accidents, disablement or
serious illness. The Wealthsurance Foundation Plan can ensure that his plans for wealth
creation are achieved by protecting that plan with insurance benefits.
HOMESURANC
E
The Homesurance Protection Plan is a reducing term plan, which provides insurance cover
equal to the outstanding balance of your home loan. In the unfortunate event of death of the
home loan borrower, the insurance cover enables repayment of the home loan liability.
BONDSURANC
E
Bondsurance is a single premium plan which allows you to make a one-time investment and get
a guaranteed amount on maturity. You can choose a maturity period of 5 or 10 years for your
investment. At the end of the chosen period, you will receive a guaranteed maturity amount.
Besides the guaranteed maturity amount, Bondsurance also provides a life insurance cover. In
case of death before the maturity date, a Death Benefit which is also guaranteed will be paid.
Thus you can get life insurance cover, while earning an assured return on your investment.
RETIRESURANC
E
Retiresurance is a pension plan without life cover that allows a longer policy term so that the
customer’s investments can get the benefit of compounding The customer has to choose any
vesting age between 40-75 yrs. The vesting age chosen can also be postponed or preponed
within the above range by informing the company 30 days in advance. It is especially for people
who wish to lead a happy and prosperous life even after their retirement.
(Source:www.idbifortis.com)
Unit linked insurance plan (ULIP) is a life insurance solution that provides the client with the
benefits of protection and flexibility in investment. It is a solution which provides for life
insurance where the policy value at any time varies according to the value of the underlying
assets at the time. The investment is denoted as unit and is represented by the value that it has
attained c alled as Net Asset Value (NAV).
ULIPs are a category of goal-based financial solutions that combine the safety of insurance
protection with wealth creation opportunities. In ULIPs, a part of the investment goes towards
providing a life cover. The residual portion of the ULIP is invested in a fund which in turn invests
in stocks or bonds; the value of investments alters with the performance of the underlying fund
opted by the customer.
Simply put, ULIPs are structured in such that the protection element and the savings element
are distinguishable, and hence managed acc ording to your specific needs. In this way,
the ULIP plan offers unprecedented flexibility and transparency.
ULIPs came into play in 1960s and became very popular in Western Europe and America. The
reason that is attributed to the wide spread popularity of ULIP is because of the transparency
and the flexibility which it offers to the clients.
As time progressed the plans were also successfully mapped along with life insurance needs to
retirement planning In today’s times ULIP provides solution for all the needs of a client like
insurance planning financial needs financial planning for c hildren’s future and retireme nt
planning.( Source:http://www.scribd.com/doc/7216240/Understand-ULIP-Insurance)
STRUCTURE OF ULIPs
ULIPs offered by different insurers have varying charge structures. Broadly the different types
of fees and charges are given below. However the insurers have the right to revise or cancel the
fees and charges over a period of time
( Source: http://www.scribd.com/doc/7044410/ULIPs)
PREMIUM
LESS CHARGES
Fund
ULIPs
Management
Mortality
Structure Charges
Charges
Administration
Charges
Premium
Allocation
Charges
Invested
Amount
Most insurers offer a wide range of funds to suit one’s investment objectives risk profile and
time horizons. Different funds have different risk profiles. The potential for returns also varies
from fund to fund. The following are some of the common types of funds available along with
an indication of their risk characteristics .
(Source: www.irdaindia.org)
ULIP distinguishes itself through the multiple benefits that it provides to the consumer. The plan
is a one stop solution for everything the customers want. Unit Linked Insurance Plans (ULIPs)
are different from traditional plans purely because, they are much more transparent, various
charges are shared with the customer before the sale of the product, so as to enable the
customer to make an informed decision. ( Source:www.scribd.com /doc/7044410/ULIPs)
Customers have the flexibility to choose their life cover. Also the customers have the choice of
multiple fund options based on their risk appetite, thereby enabling an investor to make the
desired returns from the investment.
a Life protection
.
b Investment and Savings
.
Market linked fund based on risk profile
Switch option
Premium redirection
Automatic Transfer Plan(ATP)
c Tax Planning
.
d Flexibility of cover continuance
.
e Transparency
.
f Extra protection with riders
.
Death due to accident
Disability
Critical illness
g Liquidity
.
Partial withdrawals during the term
At maturity
h Variable investment options
.
i Premium holiday
.
j Allow Top-ups
.
Tax Rider
Benefits ADVANTAGES OF s
ULIPS
Guarantee Transparenc
d
Capital y
Returns
Flexibilit Invest as
y per
your risk
Premiu appetite
m
Holiday
The degree of buying of ULIPs insurance varies from person to person. It depends upon many
factors. The factors can be classified into personal, social, economic, psychological and
company related variables. Age and experience of policyholder are personal factors, while the
co- education is a social factor. Economic factors include occupation, income and wealth, and
the psychological factors consist of perception, satisfaction about the services rendered by
insurance companies, the impact of advertisement and personal selling made by insurance
companies on policyholders. The company related variables are the promotional efforts to sell
the policies to prospective buyers. These include advertisement and personal selling too.
The Wealthsurance Foundation Plan can ensure that his plans for wealth creation are achieved
by protecting that plan with insurance benefits. Wealthsurance is one of its kind in India. The
company offer 11 investment options and 8 protection benefits under the plan apart from tax
benefits (Source: www.idbifortis.com)
Under Wealthsurance there are a lot of different funds available which are explained below:
WEALTHSURANCE
Min entry age 30
dys
Max entry age 65
yrs
Min premium
10000
Max maturity age 75
yrs
Riders ADBR,ADB,WOPR,MAJOR DISEASES BENIFIT,HOSPITAL
CASH
BENEFIT,T ERMINAL ILLNESS BENEFIT
Min premium payment term 3
yrs
Types of funds EQUITY,NIFTY,Capital Guarantee, Asset
Allocator,
GRF,MONTHLY INT A/C,INCOME,LIQUID
As discussed earlier we would be comparing the Unit Linked Insurance Plans (ULIPs) of the
companies selected initially with those of IDBI FORTIS and then make a detailed analysis. This
analysis would be well supported by the primary data analysis and then the final results would
be interpreted .So here first we would be listing out various ULIPs of the selected companies
and their details. After that we make a detailed comparison with that of the plans under
Wealthsurance of IDBI FORTIS and explain it.
So following are the details of ULIPs of various companies and the comparative analyses.
ADBR-Accidental Death Benefit Rider, CIBR-Critical Illness Benefit Rider, NM-Not Mentioned
(Source: www.tata-aig-life.com)
a MARKET PLUS
.b PROFIT PLUS (RP & SP)
.c FORTUNE PLUS
.
MARKET PLUS PROFIT PLUS(RP&SP)
Min entry age 18 yrs Min entry age 0 yrs
Max entry age 70 yrs Max entry age 65 yrs
Max Maturity age 75 yrs Max Maturity age 70,75 yrs
Min premium 5000 RP Min premium 1000 RP
10000 SP 20000 SP
No of funds 4 No of funds 4
Riders ADBR Riders ADBR,CIBR
Min premium payment term 5 yrs Min premium payment term 3 yrs
FORTUNE PLUS
Min entry age 12 yrs
Max entry age 60 yrs
Max Maturity age 65 yrs
Min premium 20000
No of funds 4
Riders ADBR
Min premium payment term 5 yrs
(Source: www.licindia.com)
a ENDOWMENT PLUS II
.b ENHANCED LIFE PROTECTION II
.c UNIT LINKED PENSION RP
.d UNIT LINKED PENSION SP
.
ENDOWMENT PLUS II ENHANCED LIFE
PROTECTION II
Min entry age 18 Min entry age 18
Max entry age 65 Max entry age 45
Max Maturity age 75 Max Maturity age 75
Min premium 12000 Min premium 12000
No of funds 7 No of funds 7
Riders ADBR,CIBR Riders NO
Min premium payment term TERM Min premium payment term TERM
(www.hdfcstandardlife.com)
IDBI FORTIS is a new company with over just over one year of operations and so we have very
less information about its past performance. Therefore not many negatives can be found with
the company in regard to the Unit Linked Insurance Plans. Some general demerits with regard
to the distribution network and marketing strategies have been mentioned after the analysis of
the primary data.
As a part of this comparative analysis we have also compared the performance of ULIPs of a
selected fund since the last one year (as the data of IDBI FORTIS is limited only to the last one
year). The comparison has been carried out in the next page.
Here in order to compare the performances of the ULIPs of the selected five companies with
that of IDBI FORTIS we have selected a particular type of fund called equity growth funds. The
reason for selecting equity growth fund is that we would be very c learly able to understand the
effect of market slowdown on these companies. Here we have considered the Net asset Values
(NAV) of the equity growth funds from April 1 s 2008 to April 30 th 2009.We have then compared
t
the compared the maximum and minimum NAVs during the period and found out the
percentage change for the NAVs observed for the equity funds of the respective selected
companies selected companies.
We have calculated the average NAV for every month (from April 1 st 2008 to April 30 th 2009) for
all the companies and then plotted them on graphs. We have then found out the extent to
which each company was affected due to the market slowdown. We have also taken into
consideration the latest NAVs of these companies to see the pattern of growth of these funds
post recession. The percentage change (negative) in the Net Asset value for all the companies
has been calculated below and we observe that LIC was the least affected among the selected
companies with only a percentage change of only -23.38% which is quite low compared to
-43.84% of that of Bajaj Allianz.
IDBI Fortis has shown a percentage change of -38.95%.But since IDBI Fortis is a new company
which was started just a year back we c an say that it has managed quite well and right now it
is showing a quite good and positive growth as we can see from its present NAV.
Month NAV
Apr-08 8.4099
May-08 7.7124 HDFC STANDARD LIFE
Jun-08 7.5374 9
Jul-08 8.1797 8
7
Aug-08 7.9632 6
Sep-08 5.9740 5
4
Oct-08 5.7968 3
Nov-08 5.6706 2
1
Dec-08 5.5100 0
Jan-09 5.4479
Feb-09 5.1516
Mar-09 6.1597
MONTH
Apr-09 6.4646
Month NAV
Apr-08 56.3500
May-08 56.6050 ICICI PRUDENTIAL
Jun-08 48.9250 60
Jul-08 48.8700 50
Aug-08 51.4450 40
Sep-08 49.1450 30
Oct-08 39.4450
20
Nov-08 35.6850
10
Dec-08 36.4000
0
Jan-09 34.8450
Feb-09 34.2650
Mar-09 33.4050
Apr-09 39.9150 MONTH
Month NAV
Apr-08 10.5838
May-08 10.4991 IDBI FORTIS
Jun-08 9.1765 12
Jul-08 9.3448 10
Aug-08 9.8183 8
Sep-08 9.0915 6
Oct-08 7.0785 4
Nov-08 6.9028 2
Dec-08 6.9151 0
Jan-09 6.6861
Feb-09 6.5328
Mar-09 6.4605
MONTH
Apr-09 7.7746
Sep-08 11.7975 8
6
Oct-08 10.1290
4
Nov-08 9.8400 2
Dec-08 9.9140 0
Jan-09 9.8000
Feb-09 9.6675
Mar-09 9.4175
MONTH
Apr-09 10.7340
PERCENTAGE (% ) CHANGE
LIC -23.38%
IDBI -38.95%
FORTIS
ICICI -40.98%
PRUDENTIAL
HDFC STANDARD -38.74%
LIFE
BAJAJ ALLIANZ -43.84%
Table 9 & Figure 11: Percentage changes in NAVs of various companies due to recession
We have done a detailed survey in Hyderabad c ity to understand and study the consumer’s
responses. The primary data was collected through questionnaires. This questionnaire was
mainly formulated to target the c ommon man to see his perception and awareness of various
investment options available. The sample size of the survey was 133.Out of these 89 were male
and 45 were female. The sample of respondents was carefully selected covering people in all
age groups and with different backgrounds and occupations. The analysis of these
questionnaires gives us an insight about the mindset of people regarding various investments.
We have also used factor analysis in SPSS to extract the prominent factors influencing the
investments decisions of the c ustomers .Customer preferences as to where they would like to
invest have been studied . Also we come to know about the preferences given by customers
towards various top life insurance companies and their reasons for it. Here we see that most of
the customers invest regularly from quite some time but since the last few months their
investments have come down due to recession and market slowdown. Following is the analysis
of the primary data collected through questionnaires. (Please refer to annexure I)
The sample included respondents from all the age groups out of which people in the age group
18-40 constituted around 70%.
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
18-30 31-40 41-50 >50
AGE
GROUP
The sample of respondents was heterogeneous with people of various occupations right from
government service to ones who were self employed. Out of these people who were working in
private companies constituted round 65%.
60%
40%
20%
0%
OCCUPATION
lso the customers’ preferences for different forms of savings have been c arefully studied The
main savings instruments generally preferred by customers are bank deposits, fixed deposits,
investments and post office schemes. Out of these Investments has been preferred by around
43% respondents and fixed deposits by around 27%.
PREFERENCE OF SAVINGS
6% 12%
Bank Deposits
12%
Fixed Deposits
Investments
27%
Post Office Schemes
Others
43%
Figure 14: Break-up of respondents based on their preferences for various savings instruments
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Family's Friend's Broker's Own Any
Opinion Advice Advice Decision Others
DECISION MAKING
The various forms of investments generally preferred by customers have been identified as
mutual funds, stocks and shares, insurance products and government bonds. Out of these
around 35% preferred stocks and shares and around 20% preferred insurance products.
FORMS OF INVESTMENT
35
%
29
%
20
%
13
%
5
%
Figure 16: Break-up of respondents based on preferences for various forms of investment
Talking about the frequency of investment around 45 respondents preferred investing once a
year and another 25% preferred investing 2-3 times a year. It was also noticed that greater
majority of respondents owned an insurance policy. Only 11% of the respondents did not own
an insurance policy.
FREQUENCY OF INVESTMNET
1% Once a year
14%
2-3 Times a year
15% 45%
More than 3 Times a year
Not Interested
OWN AN INSURANCE
POLICY
89%
11%
Yes No
Figure 18: Break-down of respondents who own/do not own an insurance policy
28%
23%
6% 4%
LIC
1% 1% ICICI Prudential
2% 2% 3% IDBI Fortis
3% 5%
Bajaj Allianz
7%
HDFC Standard
Life
13% 63% SBI Life
Max New York
Birla Sunlife
Kotak Mahindra
Others
Figure 20: Break-down of respondents who own insurance policies in various life insurance companies
Around 63% respondents felt that there was an amount of moderate to high risk involved with
ULIPs. Around 63% of the respondents owned an insurance policy in LIC which clearly shows
that LIC still continues to be the market leader in as it has been since the last 50 years or so in
spite of the presence various powerful private players which are still finding hard to capture a
major market share. Around 13%b respondents chose ICICI Prudential.
1 2 3 4
5
BAJAJ ALLIANZ
ICICI PRUDENTIAL
IDBI
FORTIS
LI
C
TATA-AIG
w WEALTHSURANCE
No idea 29%
Figure 22: Break-down of respondents with different perceptions about the term “WE LTHSUR
NCE”
26%
3%
Figure 23: Break-down respondents with various responses about the future of IDBI Fortis
Many people responded that they have no idea about IDBI Fortis or its various products under
the umbrella “wealthsurance” That is true as it is a new company it has a long way to go as
responded by around 26% of the respondents.
This could be due to the fact that IDBI FORTIS has a limited presence and it has just started its
operations just more than a year ago.
We also have found out the age played an important role in deciding the investing patterns of
the respondents .It was found out that people who were generally in between 18-30 had a
higher tendency to invest quite frequently in a year. The following table and the figure below
show us the results.
0
18-30(young) 30-50(middle) >50(old)
AGE
In order to find the relationship between the age of the respondents and their investment
patterns, a chi-square test for independence of attributes was used and results of the test is
shown in the following table :
It is noted from the above table that the calculated Chi-square value is less than the table value
and the result is significant at 5% level Hence the null hypothesis “the age of the respondents
and frequency of investment” holds good From the above analysis it is concluded that there is
a c lose relationship between the age of the respondents and their investment patterns
We have also used factor analysis in SPSS (Statistical Pac kage in Social Sc iences) extract most
prominent factors that considered by a consumer before making an investment decision. We
had initially considered 28 factors which can influence a consumer’s investment decision and
we have asked the customers to rate them according to their importance in the questionnaire
(Refer to annexure I).
Also we c an see from below that the KMO coefficient is 0.702. The coefficient always lies
between 0 and 1 and the requirement is that it should not be less than 0.50. So here we can say
this is a good test.
DF
378
Sig .
000
So following are the nine extracted prominent factors that influence the consumer while
making an investment decision:
1. Rate of return
2 .Death benefits and lock in period
3. Present market scenario and tax benefits
4. Past performance of the company
5. Flexible investment options and the risk involved
6. Amount payable and the after investment service
7. Opinion of media, friends and acquaintances
8. Level of knowledge about investment
9 .Commercials associated with investments
Table 13: The prominent factors influencing the consumer’s investment decision
MERITS
1 When compared to the other selected insurance companies IDBI Fortis gives a min fixed
. Interest rate for monthly interest account and a min fixed NAV (Net Asset Value) for
funds under Unit Linked Insurance Plans (ULIPs) at the time of maturity. So here in terms
of market slowdown and recession the fund value will not come down below a specified
limit which is not the case with the other companies.
2 The Fund allocation charges and fund management charges are very low when
. compared to most of the other companies in the market.
3 The growth of the company has been tremendous in terms of the premiums collected
. and the variety of funds introduced. All this has been done in a very short span of time
which indicates that there is a great future for IDBI Fortis.
4 IDBI Fortis offers funds almost to everyone right from a 3 month child to a 70 year old
. elderly person. The variety of funds offered is very vast.
5 The tie-up of the well known IDBI bank with Fortis International and Federal bank both
. of which are well established and good rated gives the company a greater sc ope for
good growth in the future.
6 All the plans offered by the company espec ially under ULIPs are really flexible as there
. are no charges charged for switching and a customer can make use of the switc hing
facility any number of times he wants to free of charge. Also the premiums payable can
be decided by the customers themselves ac cording to their feasibility and capacity.
DEMERITS
1 IDBI Fortis has a limited presence right now so most of the people know nothing about
. the company.
2 With already around more than 20 private companies in the market it is really a
. mammoth task for IDBI Fortis to establish itself and move forward successfully as it is
always difficult for any new company to capture the market very early.
Not all brand differences are meaningful or worthwhile. Not every difference makes a good
differentiator. Each difference has the potential to create company costs as well as customer
benefits. Therefore, the company must carefully select the ways in which it will distinguish itself
from competitors. A difference is worth establishing insofar as it satisfies the following criteria:
(source: http://www.determan.net/Michele/mposition.htm)
POSITIONING STRATEGIES
At present IDBI Fortis has its presence in 29 cities ac ross India and it has 31 branches overall.
Mumbai has got three branches. Following is the list of all the cities where the company is
operating right now:
AHMEDABAD MANGALORE
BENGALURU MUMBAI
CALICUT NAGPUR
CHANDIGARH
NASHIK
CHENNAI NEW DELHI
COIMBATORE NOIDA
DEHRADUN PUNE
GOA RAJKOT
GURGAON SURAT
HYDERABAD THIRUVUNATHAPURAM
INDORE UDAIPUR
JAIPUR VARNASI
KOCHI VIJAYAWADA
LUCKNOW VISAKHAPATNAM
LUDHIANA
IDBI Fortis has positioned itself quite nicely by offering all the produc ts under one single
umbrella “WE LTHSUR NCE” The Wealthsurance Foundation Plan enables the customer to
save and build wealth to meet his financial goals. However, unlike other investment
alternatives, it also enables him to achieve his wealth goals even in the event of unexpected
death, accidents, disablement or serious illness. Here under WEALTHSURANCE the company
offers all various varieties of plans right from plans for a 3 month baby to plans for elderly
people. Also in all its advertisement campaigns the company has been using the term
“WE LTHSUR NCE” extensively. The company has positioned itself in such way the customers
started feeling that Wealthsurance is the solution for all problems.
The name “Wealthsurance” is being marketed very effectively that too with the tag line
“investment chalta jaye chahe kuchh ho jaye” which means that the we alth creation
continues no matter whatever happens. This concept is being well supported by a new
commercial released by the company being aired on all major channels.
The company has also been promoting itself well especially since the past few months.
It created ripples across India when it became the first insurance company ever to
sponsor a major c ricket tournament singlehandedly when it sponsored the
Wealthsurance cup between India and Srilanka in Jan-Feb 2009.It made a right decision
to do so because India is a cricket crazy country and there is nothing better than
reaching to the people through cricket.
Also the logo and pictures IDBI Fortis has been using in its advertisement campaigns
through commercials and printed media have been really good. For example let us talk
about the most common picture used i.e. that of a peeled orange with its peel by its
side. The orange wouldn’t grow if the peel hadn’t protected it fruits from all sorts of
dangers like birds worms etc. The same is with all fruits, nuts and grains or for the
matter a human embryo. With this the company wants to say the best growth happens
under a protective cover that just as nature has provided a protective shield for every
fruit which projects the actual fruit and helps it grow IDBI Fortis acts as a protective
shield for the investments the customers make and helps the best growth to happen. So
with new innovative advertising strategies the company has been able to position itself
as a new company with innovative products. All the punch lines used by the company
easily attract the customers. Some of the advertising pictures used by the company are
illustrated below with their taglines:
Protection Guaranteed
IDBI Fortis positions itself as one of the top insurance companies in India. It aspires to be
in the top four in the next five years and in the top 3 in the next seven years from now.
Although the company has other products like Bondsurance, Homesurance and
Retiresurance right now it is just focusing on Wealthsurance as it feels that the
company needs to first capitalize on one particular product initially and latter on can
diversify
.
IDBI Fortis aims to position itself as an insurance company for all classes. As the
premiums payable and the plans are flexible according to the customers choices every
person right from a worker to a high class businessman can purchase a policy. The
minimum premium payable per month is Rs.1000 which is very affordable by anyone.
We have found out that age plays a major role in deciding the investment patterns of
people as generally the younger class of people tend to take more risk and invest in
various instruments more frequently in a year( 2.10 times a year) when compared with
the older class of people(1.46 times a year).
Life insurance Corporation (LIC) of India is the company to be least affected during this
market slowdown as NAV of its equity growth funds came down just by 23% during this
major recession.
Life Insurance Corporation (LIC) of India is still the undisputed market leader as 63% of
the respondents surveyed owned a policy in it and it has also got a tremendous rating
of 4.2 out of 5 in the survey conducted.
A good positive growth is being shown by IDBI FORTIS and even though it is still over
one year old and has a long way to go it has already started working hard and is trying
to make competition much tougher.
All the products of IDBI FORTIS under Wealthsurance are really very good and have an
edge over most of the products of other major life insurance companies as the plans
offered by the company are really very flexible.
IDBI FORTIS has to improve its distribution network as its reach to a common man is
very limited .Also the number of agents working for the company is very less right now
when compared to the other companies
The company should constantly come out with innovative products as the competition is
very tough with around 22 companies fighting hard for the market share. Some new
innovative ideas have been suggested below.
An insurance plan for the unborn babies. The premium payment term
could be for 6 months and it could start once the fetus is 3 months old
inside the mother’s womb There could be various benefits under this
plan for the customers like in case of a premature or a complicated birth
the company would bear the expenses till the baby is healthy again
through the insurance policy. Also there could be death benefits in case
of the death of the baby inside the womb or at the time of delivery. This
plan could really be suc cessful as in India there are lot of premature child
deaths and if the company comes out with a plan like this very tactfully
with some implied conditions it would be the first Indian company to
offer insurance to unborn babies.
The company could also come out with a plan for both the husband and
wife where automatically the wife gets insured along with her husband
when her husband purchases the policy. This could also be the other way
round. This could be called the combo family plan. In simple words it
means buy one policy and get another free. No other company has done
something like this till now.
As the company is a new company it has to really work hard to get itself promoted. The
company could start sponsoring major events and conduct talk shows and seminars to
get noticed. It could also take the help of NGOs. There are many people in India who
still do not know about the concept of insurance.The company could take this as an
opportunity by trying to create awareness.
The company should come out with some really outstanding and out of the world
advertisements like the ones Vodafone has released recently which people find it hard
to forget soon.
The company should first promote the brand IDBI FORTIS and create a positive
impression in the minds of the people In today’s world it is really tough for the
customer to choose from among a vast list of insuranc e companies as almost all of
them offer the same plans .So the company has to be a bit different from others in
order to stand apart.
My SIP at IDBI FORTIS Life Insurance Company has been an extremely enriching one. My SIP
was divided into two main parts. One was the project work and the other was the promotion of
the company. Since the company is a new company we the students doing our SIP were given
the major job of promoting the company through sales. So apart from the project work I had to
generate sales for the company. Initially we found it very difficult to sell policies as the
company was a new company and no one was willing to buy moreover as we were basically
located at Hyderabad for our SIP it was even more diffic ult for us as we knew no-one out there.
We faced a lot of hurdles but at the end we took it as a challenge and moved forward. The first
twenty days were really terrifying as I could not sell even a single policy and it was really very
de-motivating but latter on I moved ahead with the experience gained in the first few days
tackling different customers in different ways. Finally when I sold my first policy in the second
week of March I gained confidence and after that I did not look back At the end of my SIP I
generated a sales of over 1.5 lakhs for the company and ended up being one among the
students with the highest sales generated. Though I did not have the opportunity of sitting in
the office and have much corporate exposure I don’t regret it as I got full hands -on on-the field
experience. I got to interact with a lot of customers and in the process learnt of their different
mindsets and the way to deal with each of them differently. Once I was also thrown out of the
house by an angry house-wife when I tried to sell insurance early in the morning to her. It was a
harrowing experience but after that incident I learnt that marketing is all about dealing with
right people at the right time. To summarize my experience in one line I would say that my
experience At IDBI FORTIS was a really great learning experience with a lot of new things learnt
and as I also wish to specialize in marketing this experience is really a big bonus for me.
I gained a broader perspective about various investment opportunities and the risk
involved in them.
I came to know about the various technicalities about the Indian insurance industry.
Interactions with customers during surveys and sales helped me enhance my marketing
skills
.
My on- hands on- the- field sales experience was an enriching one teaching me the
different facets a marketing personnel should posses and the way to deal differently in
different situations.
I learnt in a more detailed way about the nature of work existing in the insurance
industry, the kind of deadlines they have to meet, the kind of pressure and levels of
stress which they work under and the kind of recognitions given to them after they meet
or exc eed their targets.
Following are the achievements done during the summer internship from 23th February 2008
to 23th May 2008:
a Survey done with interest of IDBI FORTIS has been conducted successfully and
. results are discussed above.
b Sales done by me during the time have done great business to the company.
.
c I was one of the Sales toppers with a generated sales of more than 1.5 lakh.
.
d The experienc e gained during the internship has sharpened my marketing and
. negotiable skills and given me a great on the field experience.
(This questionnaire is only of the sake of some research work being done on insurance
companies. Confidentiality would be maintained.)
Name : _________________________________________________________________
Age Group:
Qualification:
12
Occupation:
Do you agree that Insurance products are susceptible to very low risk when compared to the
other options for investment?
Yes No Don’t
know
What do you understand by the term “Wealthsurance”?
A financial security and risk coverage for your family All the above
I have no idea
1. ___________________________________
2. ___________________________________
3. ___________________________________
Yes
No
If yes in which company? ______________________
According to you what is the amount of risk involved in (ULIPs) Unit Linked Investment Plans?
Company Rating
IDBI FORTIS
ICICI Prudential
Life Insurance Corporation of India
Bajaj Allianz
Max NewYork Life Insurance
Tata AIG Life
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
With the different variety of schemes and unbelievable plans offered by IDBI FORTIS Do you
think IDBI FORTIS is one of the best?
Yes
No
Why?_______________________________________________
Please rate between 1-5 for all the following factors depending on thier effectiveness in
influencing you to make an investment decision.
1- If the factor has no eff ect on your preference for the investment option
2- If the factor has only a slight affect on your preference for investment option
4- If the factor will strongly affect your preference for the investment option
5- If the factor will be decisive in your preference for the investment option
Particulars Rating
Rate of return( The amount which you get in return)
Extra returns for extra investments
Returns constant in all conditions (No opportunity for multiple returns)
Can give huge returns but high risk ( no guarantee of even min returns)
Factor Analysis
Communalities
Initial Extraction
ROR 1.000 .768
ER 1.000 .530
RC 1.000 .735
HRHR 1.000 .554
TB 1.000 .715
LIP 1.000 .661
DB 1.000 .781
CI 1.000 .673
T 1.000 .665
APA 1.000 .750
AP 1.000 .789
AC 1.000 .744
LK 1.000 .707
GK 1.000 .701
LKS 1.000 .620
AIS 1.000 .727
RP 1.000 .689
TS 1.000 .755
RA 1.000 .689
PP 1.000 .623
MS 1.000 .612
OPNF 1.000 .561
OPNM 1.000 .707
COM 1.000 .704
PE 1.000 .738
PF 1.000 .747
IO 1.000 .669
OF 1.000 .616
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28
Component
Number
Component
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
ROR .058 -.043 .127 -.162 .123 -.100 .729 -.264 .307
ER .052 .365 .002 -.014 -.182 -.261 .416 .094 -.332
RC -.324 -.577 .077 .267 -.079 .217 .086 -.374 -.137
HRHR .261 -.303 .193 .297 .291 .423 -.046 .041 .037
TB .455 -.674 .088 .158 .105 .076 -.066 -.005 -.026
LIP .618 -.086 .077 -.085 -.003 -.496 -.066 .083 .019
DB .622 -.480 .161 .051 -.138 -.316 -.053 -.094 -.071
CI .682 .044 -.404 .180 .048 -.004 .057 -.048 -.046
T -.573 -.084 -.176 .234 -.382 -.046 .122 -.178 .221
APA -.726 -.249 .010 .098 .143 .281 .170 .153 -.013
AP -.429 .166 .567 -.314 .068 -.005 -.086 .081 -.371
AC .297 .388 .432 -.027 .543 -.125 -.085 .021 .000
LK .439 -.243 -.072 -.087 -.588 .233 .050 -.076 .183
GK .675 -.187 -.330 -.066 .121 .242 .080 .122 -.040
LKS .349 -.087 -.453 -.465 -.120 -.013 .092 -.197 -.083
AIS .082 .216 .618 -.146 -.413 -.032 -.033 .038 .309
RP .272 .435 -.262 -.169 -.179 .437 -.323 .021 .025
TS .337 .489 .338 .462 -.049 -.150 -.037 -.096 .197
RA -.162 .092 -.647 -.012 .467 -.060 .070 -.089 -.031
PP -.186 -.277 .117 -.540 .366 -.010 .192 -.126 .139
MS .273 -.190 .431 -.323 .127 .274 .137 .216 .235
OPNF .131 .447 .174 .328 .022 .114 .161 -.359 -.194
OPNM -.200 .194 -.288 .369 .276 -.079 -.018 .293 .491
COM .353 .192 -.166 -.029 -.155 .103 .414 .544 -.114
PE -.384 -.403 -.180 .251 -.135 -.494 .022 .263 -.044
PF -.354 .677 -.200 -.152 -.242 .184 .072 .052 .009
IO .400 .562 .035 .284 .161 .098 .179 -.201 -.055
OF .067 -.268 .305 .407 -.097 .265 .287 .268 -.217
a 9 components extracted.
Component
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
ROR .047 .036 .132 -.056 -.008 .053 .119 .852 .025
ER -.116 -.001 .263 -.061 -.220 -.020 .600 .082 -.165
RC -.122 .001 -.080 -.523 .462 -.105 -.348 .124 -.281
HRHR .118 .088 .074 .207 .658 -.019 -.212 -.014 .073
TB .235 .561 -.166 .037 .527 -.026 -.179 .016 -.077
LIP .143 .710 .042 .244 -.193 .109 .157 -.004 .039
DB .213 .812 -.013 -.005 .143 .153 -.016 .011 -.177
CI .583 .347 .288 .118 .035 -.268 .165 -.089 .091
T -.113 -.273 -.063 -.723 -.096 .061 -.107 .071 .147
APA -.388 -.483 -.344 -.278 .345 -.166 -.063 .126 .070
AP -.650 -.265 -.104 .245 -.055 .216 .037 -.043 -.415
AC -.283 .144 .378 .692 -.032 .033 -.046 .081 .103
LK .651 .158 -.072 -.218 .097 .413 .032 -.002 -.155
GK .649 .255 -.039 .293 .242 -.212 .150 -.003 -.013
LKS .563 .127 -.164 .048 -.310 -.211 .069 .144 -.304
AIS -.096 -.008 .111 .085 -.126 .823 .005 .071 -.012
RP .527 -.358 .140 .275 -.179 .087 -.036 -.381 -.042
TS -.062 .167 .707 .108 -.036 .331 .030 -.100 .300
RA .089 -.161 -.037 .018 -.198 -.750 -.043 .094 .202
PP -.137 -.045 -.393 .236 -.056 -.098 -.214 .555 -.160
MS .105 .037 -.225 .453 .305 .392 -.003 .312 -.029
OPNF -.047 -.123 .721 .005 .052 -.008 .035 .015 -.140
OPNM -.060 -.165 .021 -.039 -.024 -.185 -.015 -.022 .799
COM .311 -.042 -.017 .164 .115 .042 .743 -.005 .111
PE -.351 .284 -.378 -.523 -.018 -.167 .162 -.107 .227
PF .022 -.692 .159 -.053 -.412 .063 .232 -.108 .031
IO .160 -.048 .741 .247 -.002 -.068 .144 .034 .072
OF -.103 .053 .065 -.131 .685 .149 .294 -.031 -.050
Component 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
1 .607 .567 .293 .418 .104 .110 .152 -.034 -.045
2 -.055 -.456 .592 .296 -.486 .082 .252 -.150 .148
3 -.535 .120 .175 .272 .281 .666 -.099 .145 -.202
4 -.146 .142 .527 -.417 .474 -.116 .002 -.297 .425
5 -.291 .031 .044 .592 .183 -.593 -.242 .257 .229
6 .406 -.647 .011 .159 .568 .077 -.172 -.074 -.164
7 .038 -.099 .146 -.200 .184 -.076 .569 .750 -.034
8 -.112 -.046 -.471 .270 .204 .128 .603 -.313 .413
9 .240 -.058 -.102 -.030 -.133 .380 -.357 .367 .709
www.idbifortis.com
www.hdfcstandardlife.com
www.licindia.com
www.bajajallianz.com
www.iciciprulife.com
www.tata-aig-life.com
www.irdaindia.org
http://www.scribd.com/doc/11005006/Insurance-Industry-Growth-Chart-Under-Drive-of-
Demand-and-Value-Recommended20090121
http://www.scribd.com/doc/4996143/OVERVIEW-OF-INSURANCE-SECTOR-INDIA
http://www.scribd.com/doc/7044410/ULIPs
http://www.indiaprwire.com/pdf/pressrelease/200805079347.pdf
http://www.scribd.com/doc/136703/Indian-Insurance-Changing-Trends-and-a-Fresh-
Perspectiv
e
http://www.scribd.com/doc/7216240/Understand-ULIP-Insurance
http://www.financialexpress.com/search/news/ulips+flexible+to+the+co
re/
http://unpan1.un.org/intradoc/groups/public/documents/apcity/unpan002873.pdf
http://wealth.moneycontrol.com/yourstartupkit/ulip/why-invest-in-ulips-/9051/0
http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/Personal-Finance/Insurance/Life-insurance-industry-
targeting-20-pc-growth-in-FY-09/rssarticleshow/4095144.cms
http://www.marketsmonitor.com/Report/IM588_related.htm
http://www.marketsmonitor.com/Report/IM126.htm
http://www.marketsmonitor.com/Report/IM126.htm
http://www.determan.net/Michele/mposition.htm
http://www.quickmba.com/marketing/ries-trout/positioning
http://tutor2u.net/business/marketing/brands_ positioning.asp
www.ducttapemarketing.com/strategies_for_positioning.htm
http://www.quickmba.com/marketing/research/
http://www.ats.ucla.edu/stat/Spss/output/factor1.htm
http://www.moneycontrol.com/planning_desk/fininvoption.php