Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
h i g h l i g h t s g r a p h i c a l a b s t r a c t
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Cementitious composites are the most used man-made materials in the world with a global annual pro-
Received 9 July 2018 duction quantum of 25 billion tonnes worldwide, contributing approximately 5% to the global green-
Received in revised form 1 November 2018 house gas emissions. In the initiative to reduce the carbon footprint of cementitious composite
Accepted 23 November 2018
production, are growing interests in the large volume reuse of industrial by products such as ground
granulated blast-furnace slag (GGBS), pulverized fuel ash (PFA) and granite quarry dust (GQD) in cemen-
titious composites production. Such an approach offers a two-fold solution towards addressing the waste
Keywords:
management problem related to those industry by-products. At the same time however; reduction of car-
Large volume recycling
Mechanical properties
bon footprints of cementitious composite materials exists. However, in order to enable scalable applica-
Durability performance tions of such a recycling approach, a comprehensive body of knowledge on the mechanical strength and
High strength cementitious composites durability performance of the cementitious composite products containing a large volume of the mate-
rials needs to be established. Hence, it is the primary aim of the study to report a comprehensive assess-
ment on the mechanical strength and durability properties of high strength cementitious composites.
These materials are produced with a large volume of the aforementioned materials as the primary binder
and aggregate phase. Throughout the investigation, high strength cementitious composites mixes were
produced with a large volume of PFA and GGBS binder. Then phase coupled with ordinary Portland
cement (OPC). GQD was used as the fine aggregate phase in substitution of natural river sand at various
level of substitution ranging between 0 and 100% by volume. The cementitious composites were charac-
terized in terms of its fresh cementitious composites. Its flowability and hardened cementitious compos-
ites properties mainly bulk density, compressive strength, flexural strength, and Ultrasonic Pulse Velocity
were also assessed. In addition, the durability properties such as water absorptivity and porosity were
also covered in this experimental program. Pore continuity was assessed in terms of air permeability
and capillary absorption of the hardened specimens according to the testing age. This paper has also
⇑ Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: cheacheeban@usm.my (C.B. Cheah), jaysern07@student.usm.my (J.S. Lim), mahyudin@usm.my (M.B. Ramli).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2018.11.194
0950-0618/Ó 2018 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
292 C.B. Cheah et al. / Construction and Building Materials 197 (2019) 291–306
covered the dimensional stability assessment in terms of drying shrinkage. Besides, a comprehensive
microstructural assessment was also performed to examine the microstructure morphology. From the
results, we found full incorporation of GQD as NRS without significant impairment to the mechanical,
durability and length change performance. Thus, the production of sustainable high strength cementi-
tious composites with large volume recycling of GQD is feasible which in turn reduces the depletion
on the natural river sand resources.
Ó 2018 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
[32] have studied the feasibility of high volumes GQD in the pro- of mechanical strength performance. Researchers also reported
duction of lightweight foamed concrete. The authors reported that that the replacement levels more than 75% shows a reduction in
incorporation of GQD in the production of lightweight foamed con- mechanical strength performance. This is largely due to the
crete showed positive results in terms of mechanical strength per- increase in water demands which in turn reduce mechanical
formance. Besides, incorporation of GQD has also reduced the strength performance. Superior performance on the usage of GQD
environmental impact in terms of lower energy consumption and as a NRS replacement material was believed to be due to its angu-
a lesser amount of greenhouse gases emissions. Thomas and Hari- lar shape and rough texture. Such physical natures have improved
lal [33] have used the GQD in the production of artificial coarse the compactness and resistivity towards the crack propagation in
aggregates by using cold bonding techniques. GQD has been cold cementitious composite matrices [38,43,45]. Presence of fines from
bonded with different ratios of OPC and PFA to form an artificial GQD have improved the cementitious composite matrix filling up
coarse aggregate with a specific gravity range within 1.9 to 2.5. the voids in the cementitious mixture [39,41]. However, beyond
The result shows that the mechanical performance of the artificial the optimal replacement levels, the mechanical performance of
coarse aggregate is highly dependent on the cement content. Sha- the cementitious composite is reduced [45–48].
kir et al. [34] have investigated the use of GQD in brick production. Singh et al. [39] have reported the permeability and water
Incorporation of GQD has found an increase with the Ultrasonic absorption performance of cementitious composites with GQD
Pulse Velocity (UPV) results. The authors also concluded that incor- replacement levels up to 50% with 10% incremental. The results
poration of GQD in brick production is feasible and fit to the have shown that 30% of GQD replacement levels have exhibited
requirement of the relevant thresholds. Thus, it can be used as an the lowest permeability and water absorption. However, 50% of
alternative to conventional bricks in the building sector. Appukutty GQD replacement levels have shown increments in both perme-
[26] has used GQD to replace sand in cement mortar for brick ability and water absorption. Another study reported the incorpo-
masonry with different ratios of 1:8, 1:6, 1:5 and 1:4 to compare ration of GQD up to 55% which exhibited improvement in
with bricks with basic compressive strengths above 3.5 MPa and impermeability performance. The mix with 70% of GQD replace-
7.5 MPa. The researcher found that GQD can be used to replace ment levels exhibited poorer impermeability performance [41].
sand completely in masonry construction with higher strength Allam et al. [49] found that partial incorporation of 10% and
and cheaper cost. 17.5% GQD replacement levels helps to improve the water absorp-
Bishnoi and Bala [35] have studied the workability property of tion resistivity. The researchers claimed that the presence of GQD
GQD as NRS replacement material up to 35% at the same w/b ratio. tends to improve the grading of the fine aggregate phase while
The authors reported that incorporation of GQD tends to improve reducing the volume and numbers of capillary pores in the con-
the workability property of the concrete. Improvement of worka- crete matrix. Besides, improvement of durability properties of
bility property is related to the coarse grading of the GQD as GQD cementitious composite by improvement of the pore struc-
reported by Safiuddin and Raman [36]. However, Vijayalakshimi ture in the paste-aggregate interfacial zone (ITZ) has been reported
et al. [37] reported that incorporation of GQD tends to reduce the by Menadi et al. [50]. Kou and Poon [28] have investigated the dry-
workability performance. Some researchers have claimed that the ing shrinkage performance of concrete made with GQD as a NRS
presence of GQD tends to reduce the workability properties of replacement material from 0 to 100% with 25% increments. The
the fresh cementitious composites due to its excessive fines con- results have shown that the presence of GQD tends to reduce the
tent and high water absorption properties as compared to NRS drying shrinkage of the concrete. This is largely because GQD is rel-
[37–40]. Besides, the physical nature of the GQD (angular and atively coarser than NRS. Aggregates which are coarse in nature
rough in texture) has increases the internal friction between the tend to reduce the total specific surface areas, consequently,
particles, in turn, reduces the workability performance of the reduce water demand on that particular mix. Imamoto and Arai
cementitious composites [41]. [51] found that lower free water in the pore space helps to reduce
Raman et al. [42] have studied the mechanical strength perfor- the degree of drying shrinkage of the cementitious composites.
mance of cementitious composites with 20% and 40% GQD as NRS With the presence of lower free water in the cementitious matrix,
replacement material. The result shows that the incorporation of a lesser loss of free water to the surrounding exists resulting in bet-
GQD exhibited relative reduction in strength. Reduction of ter dimensional stability. However, Bonavetti and Iraser [52]
mechanical strength performance was believed to be due to the reported that presence of GQD tends to increase the length change
poor compaction due to reduction in workability. Improper com- of the cementitious composites. They have investigated the drying
paction increases the porosity in the microstructure of the cemen- shrinkage properties of the concrete with 0 to 25% of GQD replace-
titious composites [37]. Bishnoi and Bala [35] have investigated the ment levels. As the GQD replacement level increases, the length
mechanical performance of the GQD as NRS replacement material change also increases.
from 20% to 35% with an increment of 5%. The results have shown In the initiative to reduce the carbon footprint of cementitious
that partial incorporation of the GQD tends to improve the composites production, there is a growing interest in the large vol-
mechanical properties of the cementitious composites. Singh ume reuse of industrial by products such as ground granulated
et al. [39] have conducted a series of result with GQD replacement blast-furnace slag (GGBS) and pulverized fuel ash (PFA). These have
level up to 50% with 10% increments. 30% of GQD replacement been produced locally to partially replace the cement content up to
levels exhibited the optimum mechanical performance while a 50% with the ratio 4 to 1. In order to produce a more sustainable
reduction in strength was observed at a 50% of GQD replacement high strength cementitious composite, there is also growing atten-
level. Few researchers have conducted a series of results with 0– tion to finding alternative materials to be used as NRS in structural
100% GQD as a NRS replacement level. Joel [43] reported that a par- mortar. Gibson [30] claimed that GQD is the waste produced from
tial GQD replacement level up to 20% shows positive results in natural granite. It is suitable to be used in substitution to sand in
terms of mechanical strength performance. Suman and Srivastava the production of structural mortar. It was also believed that incor-
[44] reported that incorporation of GQD up to 50% exhibited a poration of the GQD in the production of cementitious composites
superior mechanical strength performance compared to the con- was theoretically stronger and more durable than the NRS. The pri-
ventional concrete. Replacement levels up to 60% did not signifi- mary aim of the study is to report a comprehensive assessment on
cantly show a reduction in mechanical strength performance. A the mechanical strength, durability properties, dimensional stabil-
similar finding reported by Kou and Poon [28] also found that ity and the microstructure morphology of high strength cementi-
GQD replacement levels up to 50% exhibited improvement in terms tious composites. The material is produced with a large volume
294 C.B. Cheah et al. / Construction and Building Materials 197 (2019) 291–306
of the aforementioned materials as the primary binder and aggre- fraction of fines content as compared to the natural river sand. The fineness modu-
lus of the GQD was determined as 2.76 while the specific gravity of the material is
gate phase. At the same time, the physical properties and mineral-
2.75 (Table 1).
ogy of both GQD and NRS will be also reported. Throughout the
investigation, high strength cementitious composites mixes were
2.1.5. Natural river sand (NRS)
produced with a large volume of PFA and GGBS binder phase cou-
Quartzitic natural river sand in an uncrushed form with a specific gravity of 2.63
pled with ordinary Portland cement (OPC) with the fix ratio as and 2.57 fineness modulus was used in this experimental program. From Fig. 3, the
aforementioned. GQD was used as the fine aggregate phase in sub- physical appearance of the natural river sand was relatively less angular and
stitution of NRS at various levels of the substitution ranging rounded in shape as compared to the GQD. NRS used in the study to washed and
between 0 and 100% with the increment of 20% by volume. remove any organic impurities. The samples were then sieved through 5 mm sieve
while retaining on the 75 mm test sieve and dried to the saturated surface dry con-
ditions. The XRD result obtained is showed in Fig. 4. The physical properties of the
2. Materials and methods GQD and NRS have been presented in detail as shown in Table 1.
2.1. Materials
2.1.6. Superplasticizer and mixing water
2.1.1. Ordinary Portland Cement (OPC) Two types of Polycarboxylate Ether (PCE) superplasticizers were used in this
BS EN 197-1 type I Ordinary Portland Cement (OPC) with specific gravity 3.15 experimental programme in order to maintain the mortar mix with low water/bin-
was used in this experimental programme. Both the physical and chemical proper- der content while fulfilling the targeted level of workability. Both superplasticizers
ties of cement used were in compliance with the specifications in BS EN 197-1 [14]. were in the aqueous form with the commercial code of WP 30 and Master Glenium
8788 supplied by Macro Dimension Concrete (MDC) Pte. Ltd. and BASF Malaysia.
WP 30 is classified as Type F admixture with high range water reducing property
2.1.2. Pulverized fuel ash (PFA)
while Master Glenium 8788 is classified as Type G admixture with high range water
Pulverized fuel ash (PFA) used in the study was collected from the precipitator
reduction and retarding property as prescribed in ASTM C 494 [59]. Tap water sup-
unit of a local coal-fuelled power plant. Results obtained from the Blaine fineness
plied from a local potable water network complied to the requirement prescribed in
analysis indicated that PFA used in the study had a specific surface area of
the BS 3148 [60] was used.
3244 cm2/g. The specific gravity of the PFA was determined to be 2.8. Similarly,
the details on the physical and chemical properties of the PFA has been character-
ized and deliberated extensively in the authors’ prior work [53]. 2.2. Methods
Table 1
Physical properties of the GQD and NRS. 2.2.4. Bulk density of hardened cementitious composites
The bulk density of the hardened mortar was examined through the water dis-
Property Standard references Natural river Granite Quarry
placement method according to the standard prescribed in BS EN 12390-7 [66]
sand (NRS) Dust (GQD)
which is suitable for the test sample in all shapes. 3 prisms with the dimension
Specific gravity BS 812-2 [58] 2.63 2.75 of 40 mm 40 mm 160 mm were fabricated for every mix design and each test-
Water absorption (%) BS 812-2 [58] 1.61 2.22 ing age. The bulk density of the hardened cementitious composites was tested at
Fineness modulus BS 812-103.1 [57] 2.57 2.76 24 h, 7, 28 and 90 days during the curing age. The average bulk density obtained
was rounded to the nearest whole number and reported.
time of the gas flow over a constant flow distance within a 3 mm diameter flow
meter was obtained. The K value represented the intrinsic air permeability on that
particular sample and calculated by using the formula proposed by Cheah and
Ramli [72]. The intrinsic air permeability of the mortar was taken as the average
three tested representative samples and expressed to the nearest 0.1 m2.
Table 2
Mixture proportions (kg/m3) of different mortar mixes.
Mix Designation OPC (kg/m3) GGBS (kg/m3) PFA (kg/m3) NRS (kg/m3) GQD (kg/m3) SP Dosage (%) Water (kg/m3) w/b
CM 545 0 0 1602 0 1.20 202 0.37
GQD0 274 218 55 1644 0 1.20 180 0.33
GQD20 274 218 55 1328 334 1.20 174 0.32
GQD40 274 218 55 996 669 1.20 174 0.32
GQD60 274 218 55 664 1003 1.20 174 0.32
GQD80 274 218 55 332 1338 1.20 174 0.32
GQD100 274 218 55 0 1685 1.20 169 0.31
The mortar specimen was then placed into the shrinkage instrument and the read- workability of the mortar mixture due to the high specific surface
ing is taken until the value remained constant. The average result from two test
area of the GQD. The higher specific surface area tends to increase
prisms was obtained and used to represent the length change (%).
the water demand in the cementitious composites [37]. There are
51.16% of NRS and 50.32% of the GQD have which have passed
2.2.12. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) analysis
Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) analysis was conducted in order to study through the 1.18 mm test sieve. Based on the results, it was indi-
the microstructure morphology of the mortar mix. Selected samples were cut into cated that the NRS used possessed a higher fines fraction that is
the cross-sectional dimension of 10 mm 10 mm with 10 mm depth and coated by smaller than 1.18 mm. At the same time, there were 48.84% of
a layer of gold. The image was taken by using a FEI Quanta FEG 650 scanning elec- NRS and 49.68% of the GQD retained on the 1.18 mm test sieve.
tron microscope.
These results have indicated that the GQD possessed a higher frac-
tion of coarser particles and lesser finer particles than NRS. This
3. Results and discussion was believed to have reduced the specific surface area of the fine
aggregates in cementitious composites. As the specific surface area
3.1. Workability of the mortar is reduced, the water demand required to achieve the desired
workability tended to be reduced.
Based on Fig. 6, the water required to achieve a 150 ± 5 mm
diameter flow decrease in the presence of the GGBS and PFA. This
would be evident of the presence of SCMs improved workability of 3.2. Bulk density
the mortar mixture. The inclusion of SCMs in the mortar tends to
reduce the water demand up to 11%. The observation is in close Table 3 shows the bulk density of the mortar mix with different
agreement to the claim that the particles size of GGBS and PFA GQD sand replacement levels. Overall, the bulk density of the mortar
are generally smaller than PC which has filled up the gaps and was reported in the range of 2303 kg/m3 to 2388 kg/m3under nor-
pores in the cementitious matrix which in turn enhanced the mal weight mortar category. The bulk density of the mortar mix
workability of the cementitious mixture [76]. As the GQD contents was increasing from 1 to 90 days. The increase in bulk density was
increased in the ternary blended mortar, the water demand of the due to the continuous hydrations within the specimens which have
mortar mixture to achieve the desired workability tends to promoted a denser microstructure of the specimens on prolonged
decrease. This phenomenon was attributed to the grading of the curing durations [77]. The bulk density of ternary blended cementi-
GQD and natural river sand [36]. Based on the particle size distri- tious composites at the early age (1 day and 7 days) which consisted
bution shown in Table 2, the GQD possessed a higher fraction of of 40% of GGBS and 10% of the PFA was relatively lower than the con-
the coarser particles than the NRS. Nevertheless, the fineness mod- trol mix which was the full OPC blend mortar. The replacement of
ulus of the GQD was reported as 2.76 which are higher than the cement content has reduced the volume of the formation of hydrates
fineness modulus of 2.57 for the NRS. The higher the value of the in the matrix of the cementitious composite which was used to fill
fineness modulus indicates a coarser overall grading of the GQD up the pores in the matrix of the cementitious composite. This
as compared to NRS. Besides, the particle size distribution graph resulted in a reduction of the density of the mortar at the early age
showed that the GQD sample possesses a higher fraction of coarse [78]. However, further curing up to 28 days and above showed that
particles that have passed through the 1.18, 2.36 and 5 mm testing the bulk density of the ternary blended mortar possessed relatively
sieves. The fine particles in the GQD were believed to reduce the higher result than the control mix. This was believed to be due to the
presence of a pozzolanic reaction which promotes a denser cemen-
titious matrix at the later age of the test mortars. The presence of the
PFA and GGBS have reduced the water demand which has, in turn,
produced a denser microstructure matrix results in relatively higher
bulk density [79]. Table 3 shows that as the GQD replacement level
increases, the bulk density of the ternary blended mortar increases.
This is largely due to the presence of denser material use in the
cementitious composites [80]. The specific gravity of the GQD used
in this experimental program was reported as 2.75 while 2.63 for
NRS as shown in Table 1. The researchers have reported that the den-
sity of the mortar varies with the denser materials used which pro-
duced a denser matrix of the mix [81]. As the GQD replacement level
increases, the density of the cementitious composites increases as
the volume of denser GQD increases. Furthermore, the fines from
the GQD have are believed to have filled up the pores inside the
matrix which have produced a denser and a more compact cemen-
Fig. 6. Workability of mortar mix. titious matrix. This results in a higher density of the mortar [82].
298 C.B. Cheah et al. / Construction and Building Materials 197 (2019) 291–306
Table 3
Bulk density of the mortar mix.
Mix design Hybridization ratio (%) GQD replacement Bulk density (kg/m3) - standard deviation
level (%)
OPC GGBS PFA NRS GQD 1 day 7 days 28 days 90 days
CM 100 0 0 100 0 2303 ± 4.92 2318 ± 2.62 2323 ± 0.72 2324 ± 0.16
GQD0 50 40 10 100 0 2301 ± 4.32 2303 ± 3.74 2327 ± 1.73 2330 ± 4.43
GQD20 50 40 10 80 20 2342 ± 4.50 2342 ± 3.46 2343 ± 2.31 2343 ± 4.03
GQD40 50 40 10 40 60 2347 ± 0.23 2347 ± 3.68 2349 ± 4.08 2361 ± 1.25
GQD60 50 40 10 60 40 2356 ± 2.00 2356 ± 5.31 2363 ± 5.23 2366 ± 3.09
GQD80 50 40 10 20 80 2362 ± 4.16 2362 ± 0.47 2368 ± 3.54 2371 ± 4.92
GQD100 50 40 10 0 100 2370 ± 5.23 2370 ± 3.68 2382 ± 2.49 2388 ± 4.91
1.0% lower flexural strength at 28 days and 90 days of curing. As of the C-A-S-H framework from GGBS-PFA hybrid [77]. At 90 days,
such, it can be concluded that full utilization of the GQD does the ternary blended mortar with various GQD replacement levels
not show a remarkable decrement in mechanical strength perfor- showed better UPV performance as compared to the control mix.
mance which can be fully utilized in cementitious composite pro- These results were attributed to the combined enhancement
duction with SCMs. The decrement in mechanical strength effects of both SCMs and the GQD. The presence of SCMs such as
performance in GQD100 was established due to the presence of GGBS and PFA improved the microstructure of the cementitious
an excessive content of fines which are the fractions that pass composites. This was done through the continuous pozzolanic
through the 75 mm test sieve [56] from the GQD. Excessive fines reaction at a later age. The presence of the GQD had also densified
have induced a higher specific surface area which required more the overall aggregate phase. Theoretically, a lower w/b ratio and a
binder to bind the aggregate phase [41,82]. Insufficient paste con- denser material used in the production of cementitious composites
tent due to the high total surface area of the aggregate phase tends tends to improve the UPV performance due to a more compact and
to produce a poor interlocking between the aggregate and binder denser microstructure [80]. The w/b ratio was reported to reduce
with an adverse effect on mechanical strength [37]. In addition, as the GQD replacement level increases in Fig. 6. However, results
Singh et al. [39] has claimed that the GQD tends to incur resistivity obtained showed that a reduction of w/b by GQD does not further
to the flow due to its natural physical properties as discussed improve the UPV performance as there is further reduction in w/b
before. Although lesser water demand was required in GQD100, ratio. This can be observed in the GQD80 and GQD100 mix which
however, due to its higher water absorption properties, the free possessed relatively lower UPV results at the later age (90 days).
water in the cementitious matrix was absorbed by the GQD. This Although incorporation of the GQD has further reduced the water
resulted in a poor degree of compaction. Such a phenomenon has demand, the reduction in water does not show continuous
led to a higher void and poorer microstructure matrix resulting improvement of UPV results along with increasing the GQD
in lower compressive and flexural strength performance. replacement levels. This was largely due to the higher fraction of
fine content which has increased the total specific surface area of
the aggregate phase. As such, the paste volume demand was
3.4. Ultrasonic pulse velocity of propagation expected to be higher. As the binder content was kept constant,
the reduction in water consumption was believed to consequently
Ultrasonic pulse velocity of propagation is a type of non- reduce the paste volume in GQD80 and GQD100 resulting in a rel-
destructive assessment to indicate the density of compactness of atively poor interlocking microstructure. Therefore, a porous
the cementitious composites. This gives an indication of the veloc- matrix was formed. Overall, the presence of the GQD showed a rel-
ity of a pulse using ultrasonic longitudinal waves transmitted atively higher UPV result as compared to the control mix and
across the length of the cementitious composites. The ultrasonic GQD0. Singh et al. [40] claimed that the presence of GQD tends
pulse velocity of propagation of a mortar mix with different GQD to densify the matrix of the cementitious composites. Meanwhile,
replacement levels is shown in Fig. 9. Based on Fig. 9, the results an increase in the adhesion of concrete specimens with positively
showed a similar trend in compressive and flexural strength per- higher UPV results was obtained. Nevertheless, fully utilization of
formance as previously discussed. Ternary blended mortar showed the GQD exhibited similar UPV values. GQD0, however, exhibited
relatively lower UPV values as compared to the control mix at the better performance in the UPV values than the control mix at
early ages (1 day and 7 days). This was largely due to the hydration 90 days of curing age. Such a phenomenon can be explained. Full
in cement as the early age produced a more compact microstruc- utilization of the GQD with a ternary blended binder possesses a
ture as compared to the ternary blended mortar. Based on the similar performance as ternary blended mortar with full NRS as
7 day results, the use of the high volume of GQD tends to produce aggregate with an improved cementitious composite microstruc-
a denser overall aggregate phase which has had results in the ture at a prolonged curing age.
enhancement of the UPV results. The GQD within 60%, 80%, and
100% replacement levels showed a better performance as com- 3.5. Water absorption
pared to the mix with 0%, 20% and 40% GQD replacement levels.
The presence of the GQD tends to compensate the negative impact Fig. 10 showed the water absorption of the mortar mix with dif-
by GGBS and PFA at the early ages (1 day and 7 days). At the age of ferent GQD replacement levels. Overall, the mix with GGBS and
28 days, the UPV results with the presence of SCMs showed better PFA possessed relatively high water absorption as compared to
performance than the control mix. The high content of GGBS and the control mix at the testing age of 1 day and 7 days. GGBS and
PFA hybrids was claimed to enhance the medium term mechanical were claimed to enhance the mechanical and durability perfor-
performance due to the rigorous continuous time-based formation mance at the later age according to previous literature. However,
the presence of GGBS and PFA as SCMs has shown a negative
impact towards the early age (1 day and 7 days) performance in
terms of water absorption results. Amer et al. [87] reported that
this phenomenon was due to the hydration of cement produced
the hydrates framework which acts as a basic skeleton of percolat-
ing solids to the microstructure in the early curing age. The substi-
tution up to 50% of OPC with the combination of GGBS and PFA
have reduced the total cement content contributing to a higher
water absorption at early ages of 1 day and 7 days. It was also
observed that the incorporation of the GQD tends to compensate
the cement dilution effect at the early ages as found in the mechan-
ical performance section. Densification in the cementitious matrix
by the GQD slightly improved in its water absorption properties of
the ternary blended mortar [41]. Densification in the cementitious
matrix is supported by the bulk density result as aforementioned
in Table 3. As reported previously, fully utilization of the GQD in
Fig. 9. Ultrasonic pulse velocity of propagation of the mortar mix. ternary mortar did not further improve the water absorption
300 C.B. Cheah et al. / Construction and Building Materials 197 (2019) 291–306
properties at an early age (1 day and 7 days). The excessive fines as mentioned previously. From the results shown in Table 3, the
from the GQD tended to increase the total specific surface area presence of the GQD tends to increase the bulk density on that par-
which resulted in a higher paste demand. The deficiency in paste ticular mix design also at an early age (1 day and 7 days). A denser
volume has resulted in poor interlocking between aggregate and material which is the GQD used in the production of cementitious
paste. At 28 days onwards, the ternary blended mortar started to composites tends to produce a denser microstructure resulting in
exhibit significant resistivity towards the water absorption. The an improvement on the resistivity of air permeability. GQD20,
ternary blended mortar with the GQD replacement levels of 0%, GQD40, and GQD60 have shown relatively lower k-values than
20%, 40%, and 60% were reported to exhibit better resistivity GQD0 on the first day of its curing age. Partially GQD replacement
towards the water absorption as compared to the control mix. Fur- up to 60% has reduced the k-value range from 7.4% to 24.9% as
thermore, the presence of the GQD has reduced the number of compared to GQD0 on the first day of testing. Presence of the
voids and capillaries within the cementitious matrix [40]. The phe- GQD up to 60% tends to improve permeability resistivity at an early
nomenon was also believed to be attributed to the improvement of age. Overall, the k-value decreases as the GQD increases up to 80%
pore structure in the paste-aggregate ITZ [50]. Allam et al. [49] from 28 days onwards. Partial replacement of the GQD tends to
reported that the presence of the GQD tends to enhance the mix- improve the microstructure of the cementitious composites pre-
ture grading. Such enhancement has resulted in producing a more sent a more adequate grading, subsequently, reduce volume and
compacted mixture which permits water to enter the specimen. connectivity of the capillary pores. From Fig. 11, the k-values of
The result also showed that large volume of the GQD replacement GQD80 and GQD100 were observed relatively higher than the
levels up to 80% and 100% permitted relatively higher water GQD0 mix at all ages. Singh et al. [39] reported that beyond opti-
absorption as compared to the mix coded GQD0. However, it was mal replacement levels, there was a remarkable reduction in per-
also observed that there was not much significant difference meability resistivity performance. The fines from the GQD have
between the control mix with GQD80 and GQD100. increased the total specific surface area, which in turn, increased
the paste demand with a consequential effect as discussed in prior
3.6. Intrinsic air permeability sections. However, with GQD80 it was found that there is an
improvement in air permeability resistivity when compared with
The results of the intrinsic air permeability of the mortar mix the control mix. From the bulk density result recorded in Table 3,
with different GQD replacement levels have been shown in GQD80 possessed a relatively higher density. Such phenomenon
Fig. 11. Intrinsic air permeability is a method to investigate the explained a denser microstructure possessed a more refined
ease of liquids, gases and dissolved deleterious substances such microstructure; thus reducing the intrinsic air permeability value
as chloride or sulfate ions or carbon dioxide ability to penetrate at 28 days onwards. Such a phenomenon does not apply to the sit-
through the mortar/concrete mix [71]. Similar to the mechanical uation in the mix coded GQD100. GQD100 possessed relatively
strength and water absorption performance, ternary blended mor- higher intrinsic air permeability value than the control mix at all
tar exhibited a relatively higher k-value at the 1 day testing age ages. The differential recorded data was reported at 143.3%,
which is similar to the findings from Owaid et al. [78]. The authors 55.7%, 9.6% and 2.0% at the specific testing age. The differential
claimed that the presence of continuous pores was largely due to was found decreased at the prolonged curing age. At the prolonged
low GGBS reactivity and the slow pozzolanic reaction of the PFA curing age, the impairment in full utilization of the GQD tended to
at the early age (1 day and 7 days). From Fig. 9, the k-value of decrease.
the ternary blended mortar with different GQD replacement levels
from 0% to 100% were reported 153% to 253% higher than the con- 3.7. Total porosity
trol mix at the first day of testing. However, the k-value of the tern-
ary blended mortar showed a remarkable reduction from 1 day to Fig. 12 showed the results of the total porosity of the mortar
7 days testing. Owaid et al. [78] also believed such results obtained mix with different sand replacement levels with the GQD. The
were due to the presence of PFA. The PFA retarded the hardening results of the total porosity are in line with the results of intrinsic
process of the cementitious composites resulting in a more porous permeability as shown in Fig. 9. The porosity from a control mix to
microstructure produced on the first day. At 7 days, the k-value for GQD100 reported 12.02%, 14.05%, 13.55%, 13.51%, 13.31%, 14.67%
the ternary blended mortar with the GQD exposed different and 15.06% at day one of testing, while, 8.85%, 9.79%, 9.62%,
replacement levels varying from 0% to 100% reported nearly to 9.53%, 8.99%, 9.84% and 10.15% was reported as the porosity at
the k-value of the control mix. From the results explained in 7 days of testing. The results have shown that the ternary blended
Fig. 11, the presence of the GQD tends to compensate the reduction mortar exhibited a higher porosity as compared to the control mix
of the performance due to SCMs in the early age (1 day and 7 days) at an early age (1 day and 7 days). The high porosity of the mortar
C.B. Cheah et al. / Construction and Building Materials 197 (2019) 291–306 301
containing GGBS and PFA at an early age (1 day and 7 days) was resistivity of the cementitious composites towards the aggressive
attributed to the dilution effect of cement as discussed earlier. ions such as sulfate and chloride penetration. This is believed to
The porosity of the ternary blended mortar was reduced signifi- give a negative impact towards the long-term durability perfor-
cantly from 1 day to 7 days as compared to the control mix. On mance of the cementitious composites. The samples used were
prolonged curing duration up to 90 days, the porosity of the cured up to 28 days by using moist curing methods. Thus, the per-
cementitious composites tends to decrease. This phenomenon formance of the specimens was able to give an indication of the
was attributed to the refinement of microstructure by the binders. service life of the mortar mix. The results showed that the rate of
Furthermore, from the results we have observed GQD20, GQD40 absorption was high during the first 8 h at a larger linear gradient
and GQD60 exhibited lower porosity than GQD0. The reduction in all mixes. This phenomenon was attributed to the water
of the porosity was reported in 1.7%, 2.7% and 8.2% for GQD20, absorbed to fill up the larger pores in the cementitious matrix.
GQD40, and GQD60 at 7 days curing. The phenomenon was largely 100% of the GQD replacement level showed the highest amount
due to the presence of the GQD improving the bonding perfor- of water absorbed in the first 8 h while 60% of the GQD replace-
mance on the paste-aggregate interface. Reduction in quantity on ment level showed the least water absorbed. The observation is
the continuity of capillary pores in the cementitious matrix was indicative of the ternary blended mortar with 100% GQD replace-
also resulting in a less porous microstructure. However, it was ment level possessing the highest degree of continuous capillary
observed that a high GQD replacement level exhibited higher pores in the cementitious matrix. Thus, it is expected that the resis-
porosity than GQD0 at all ages. GQD80 exhibited 4.4%, 0.5%, 1.6% tance to the ingress of aggressive ions such as sulfate and chloride
and 1.2% higher than GQD0, while GQD100 exhibited 7.2%, 3.7%, is relatively lower due to the high rate of absorptivity [80]. The Ca
5.4% and 3.7% higher than GQD0 at all testing ages. This was largely value of the ternary blended mortar with 40% of the GQD replace-
due to the presence of excessive fines from the GQD producing an ment level was relatively higher as compared to the ternary
increase in paste demand. A deficiency of paste volume led to poor blended mortar with 0% of the GQD replacement level within the
interlocking microstructure results though higher porosity was first 8 h. However, on the second day onwards, the Ca value of
observed. In addition, there was no observed significant reduction the ternary blended mortar with 40% of the GQD replacement level
in porosity of the control mix from 28 days to 90 days of testing. was observed to be lower than the ternary blended mortar with 0%
Meanwhile, the ternary blended mortar with different GQD of the GQD replacement level. This is primarily due to the larger
replacement levels still possessed some reduction in porosity. pores in the ternary blended mortar with 40% of the GQD replace-
The presence of the GQD possessed a lower porosity up to 60% of ment level. This was relatively more than GQD0. From the second
GQD replacement levels. Beyond 60% GQD content by total fine day onwards, the overall Ca results exhibited lower cumulative
aggregate, higher porosity was observed. Higher porosity observed weight gain as compared to the first 8 h. This was because the
in the mixes GQD80 and GQD100, was believed to reflect the large-sized capillary pores were completely filled up by the first
reduction of mechanical strength performance [80] as discussed 8 h. Overall, the use of GGBS and PFA as SCMs tends to reduce
earlier. As compared to the control mix, GQD100 possessed a rela- the degree of capillary pores in the cementitious matrix. The for-
tively higher total porosity (%). Generally, a lower w/b tends to pro- mation of the hydrates from GGBS and PFA has densified the
duce a denser and a more refine microstructure [80]. However, a cementitious matrix which results in a lower Ca value. Generally,
reduction in the w/b ratio would lead to insufficient proper com- the use of the GQD at various levels of sand replacement levels
paction which also leads to a more porous microstructure [77]. up to 80% enables the reduction in the degree of capillary pores.
Although GQD100 required a relatively lower w/b ratio to achieve This was believed due to the presence of rough and angular shapes
the initial flow diameter, however, the water absorption properties of the GQD physical appearance. Improvement of the performance
of the GQD was reported at 2.22% which is much more than the through better paste-aggregate bond reduced the continuity of
NRS with 1.61% water absorption. Higher water absorption proper- capillary pores [81]. This improvement was believed to have
ties have further absorbed the free water in the fresh cementitious reduced the porosity and air content in the cementitious compos-
composites resulting in less favorable compaction degree during ites. The ternary blended mortar with up to 100% of the GQD as
the placement of fresh mortar into the steel mold. sand replacement possessed a similar capillary absorptivity prop-
erty as the control mix.
3.8. Capillary absorption assessment
The capillary absorption of the mortar mix with different GQD 3.9. Drying shrinkage behavior
replacement level results was shown in Fig. 13. Basically, the cap-
illary absorption is given an overall insight towards the pore grad- Theoretically, drying shrinkage on the cementitious composites
ing of the cementitious composites. It is important to indicate the was due to the evaporation of internal free water from concrete or
302 C.B. Cheah et al. / Construction and Building Materials 197 (2019) 291–306
Fig. 17. SEM image of ternary blended mortar with 100% GQD replacement levels at
28 days curing age at 150 times magnification.
Fig. 19. SEM image of ternary blended mortar with 60% GQD replacement level at Fig. 21. SEM image of ternary blended mortar with 0% GQD replacement level at
28 days curing age at 3000 times magnification. 90 days curing age at 150 times magnification.
304 C.B. Cheah et al. / Construction and Building Materials 197 (2019) 291–306
Fig. 22. SEM image of ternary blended mortar with 60% GQD replacement level at Fig. 24. SEM image of ternary blended mortar with 0% GQD replacement levels at
90 days curing age at 150 times magnification. 90 days curing age at 3000 times magnification.
Fig. 23. SEM image of ternary blended mortar with 100% GQD replacement level at Fig. 25. SEM image of ternary blended mortar with 60% GQD replacement levels at
90 days curing age at 150 times magnification. 90 days curing age at 3000 times magnification.
[41] S. Singh, R. Nagar, V. Agrawal, A. Rana, A. Tiwari, Sustainable utilization of [66] British Standards Institution BSI, BS EN 12390-7 Testing hardened concrete -
granite cutting waste in high strength concrete, J. Clean. Prod. (2016) 1–13. Part 7: Density of hardened concrete, 2009.
[42] S.N.M. Raman, F.M. Zain, H.B. Mahmud, K.S. Tan, Influence of quarry dust and [67] American Society of Testing Materials, ASTM Standard Test Method for
fly ash on the concrete compressive strength development, AEESEAP Int. Conf. Compressive Strength of Hydraulic-Cement Mortars (Using Portions of Prims
Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, No. 1, 2005, pp. 7–8. Broken in Flexure), 2008.
[43] M. Joel, Use of crushed granite fine as replacement to river sand in concrete [68] American Society of Testing Materials, ASTM Stadard Test Method for Flexural
production, Leonardo Electron. J. Practices Technol. 9 (17) (2010) 85–96. Strength of Hydraulic-Cement Mortars, 2008.
[44] B.K. Suman, V. Srivastava, Utilization of stone dust as fine aggregate [69] British Standards Institution BSI, BS EN 12504-4 Testing concrete — Part 4:
replacement in concrete, J. Multidiscip. Eng. Sci. Technol. 2 (4) (2015) 3159– Determination of ultrasonic pulse velocity, 2004.
3240. [70] British Standards Institution BSI, BS 1881-122 Testing concrete — Part 122:
[45] M. Bederina, Z. Makhloufi, A. Bounoua, T. Bouziani, M. Quéneudec, Effect of Method for determination of water absorption, 1983.
partial and total replacement of siliceous river sand with limestone crushed [71] J.G. Cabrera, C.J. Lynsdale, A new gas permeameter for measuring the
sand on the durability of mortars exposed to chemical solutions, Constr. Build. permeability of mortar and concrete, Mag. Concr. Res. 40 (144) (1988) 177–
Mater. 47 (2013) 146–158. 182.
[46] A. Carlos, I. Masumi, M. Hiroaki, M. Maki, O. Takahisa, The effects of limestone [72] C.B. Cheah, M. Ramli, Composites : Part B The fluid transport properties of
aggregate on concrete properties, Constr. Build. Mater. 24 (12) (2010) 2363– HCWA – DSF hybrid supplementary binder mortar, Compos. B 56 (2014) 681–
2368. 690.
[47] R. Kishore, N.H.M. Raju, Flexural behavior of high strength stone dust concrete, [73] RILEM, CPC 11.3. Absorption of water by immersion under vacuum, 1984.
Challenges, Opportunities and Solutions in Structural Engineering and [74] Y. Benachour, C.A. Davy, F. Skoczylas, H. Houari, Effect of a high calcite filler
Construction, No. 2006, 2010, pp. 491–500. addition upon microstructural, mechanical, shrinkage and transport properties
[48] S. Singh, R. Nagar, V. Agrawal, Performance of granite cutting waste concrete of a mortar, Cem. Concr. Res. 38 (6) (2008) 727–736.
under adverse exposure conditions, J. Cleaner Prod. 127 (2016) 172–182. [75] American Society of Testing Materials, ASTM Standard Test Method for Length
[49] M.E. Allam, E.S. Bakhoum, G.L. Garas, H. Ezz, Durability of green concrete Change of Hardened Hydraulic-Cement Mortar and Concrete, 2010.
containing granite waste powder, Int. J. Eng. Technol. 8 (5) (2016) 2383–2391. [76] X. Zhou, J.R. Slater, S.E. Wavell, O. Oladiran, Effects of PFA and GGBS on early-
[50] B. Menadi, S. Kenai, J. Khatib, A. Aït-Mokhtar, Strength and durability of ages engineering properties of portland cement systems, J. Adv. Concr.
concrete incorporating crushed limestone sand, Constr. Build. Mater. 23 (2) Technol. Mater. Struct. Environ. 10 (10) (2012) 74–85.
(2009) 625–633. [77] C.B. Cheah, K.Y. Chung, M. Ramli, G.K. Lim, The engineering properties and
[51] K. Imamoto, M. Arai, Specific surface area of aggregate and its relation to microstructure development of cement mortar containing high volume of
concrete drying shrinkage, Mater. Struct./Materiaux et Construct. 41 (2) (2008) inter-grinded GGBS and PFA cured at ambient temperature, Constr. Build.
323–333. Mater. 122 (2016) 683–693.
[52] V.L. Bonavetti, E.F. Irassar, The effect of stone dust content in sand, Cemen 35 [78] H.M. Owaid, R.B. Hamid, M.R.T. Taha, A Review of sustainable supplementary
(I) (1995) 699–704. cementitious materials as an alternative to all-Portland cement mortar and
[53] C.C. Ban, P.W. Ken, M. Ramli, The hybridizations of coal fly ash and wood ash concrete, Aust. J. Basic Appl. Sci. 6 (9) (2012) 287–303.
for the fabrication of low alkalinity geopolymer load bearing block cured at [79] Md. Safiuddin, M.F.M. Zain, Supplementary cementing materials for high
ambient temperature, Constr. Build. Mater. 88 (2015) 41–55. performance concrete, BRAC Univ. J. III (2) (2006) 47–57.
[54] British Standards Institution BSI, BS EN 196-2 Methods of testing cement - Part [80] A.M. Neville, Properties of Concrete, 2011.
2: Chemical analysis of cement, 2005. [81] S. Singh, R. Nagar, V. Agrawal, A review on Properties of Sustainable Concrete
[55] Malaysia Standard Department MSD, MS EN 15167-1 Ground Granulated Blast using granite dust as replacement for river sand, J. Cleaner Prod. 126 (2016)
Furnace Slag for use in Concrete, Mortar and Grout - Part 1: Definitions, 74–87.
Specifications and Conformity Criteria (First Revision), 2010. [82] R. Burhan, A. Alshahwany, Effect of partial replacement of sand with limestone
[56] British Standards Institution BSI, ‘‘British Standard BS 882 : 1992 Specification filler on some properties of normal concrete, Al-Rafadain Eng. J. (2010) 37–48.
for Aggregates from natural sources for concrete,” 2001. [83] A.M. Rashad, An investigation of high-volume fly ash concrete blended with
[57] British Standards Institution BSI, BS 812-103.1 Testing aggregates — Part 103: slag subjected to elevated temperatures, J. Cleaner Prod. 93 (2015) 47–55.
Methods for determination of particle size distribution — Section 103.1 Sieve [84] M.A.M. Johari, J.J. Brooks, S. Kabir, P. Rivard, Influence of supplementary
tests, 2000. cementitious materials on engineering properties of high strength concrete,
[58] British Standards Institution BSI, BS 812-2 Testing aggregates — Part 2: Constr. Build. Mater. 25 (5) (2011) 2639–2648.
Methods of determination of density, 2000. [85] C.K. Kankam, B.K. Meisuh, G. Sossou, T.K. Buabin, Stress-strain characteristics
[59] American Society of Testing Materials, ASTM Standard Specification for of concrete containing quarry rock dust as partial replacement of sand, Case
Chemical Admixtures for Concrete, 2013. Stud. Constr. Mater. 7 (June) (2017) 66–72.
[60] British Standards Institution BSI, BS 3148 British Standard Methods of test for [86] W. Piasta, B. Zarzycki, The effect of cement paste volume and w/c ratio on
Water for making concrete, 1980. shrinkage strain, water absorption and compressive strength of high
[61] British Standards Institution BSI, BS EN 196-1 Methods of testing cement - Part performance concrete, Constr. Build. Mater. 140 (2017) 395–402.
1: Determination of strength, 2005. [87] M. Amer, N. Farzadnia, A. Abdullah, A. Ali, R. Demirboga, Development of high
[62] American Concrete Institute ACI, Standard Practice for Selecting Proportions strength alkali activated binder using palm oil fuel ash and GGBS at ambient
for Normal, Heavyweight, and Mass Concrete (ACI 211.1-91) (Reapproved temperature, Constr. Build. Mater. 93 (2015) 289–300.
2009), 2009. [88] E.Ö. Erhan Güneyisi, Mehmet Gesoglu, Strength, and drying shrinkage
[63] American Society of Testing Materials, ASTM Standard Specification for Flow properties of self-compacting concretes incorporating multi-system blended
Table for Use in Tests of Hydraulic Cement, 2010. mineral admixtures, Constr. Build. Mater. 24 (2010) 1878–1887.
[64] American Society of Testing Materials, ASTM C 305 Standard Practice for [89] Dale P. Bentz, Pierre-Claude Aitcin, The Hidden Meaning of Water- Cement
Mechanical Mixing of Hydraulic Cement Pastes and Mortars of Plastic Ratio Distance between cement particles is fundamental, Concr. Int. (May)
Consistency, 2009. (2008) 51–54.
[65] American Society of Testing Materials, ASTM Standard Test Method for
Compressive Strength of Hydraulic Cement Mortars (Using 2-in. or [50-mm]
Cube Specimens), 1999.