Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 44

News analysis Health Business

GMO law fight Designer babies Coke unveils more Uganda’s pili pili
not over yet not likely soon sugar-free soda exports risk ban

Issue No. 551 Dec. 14 - 20 2018 Ushs 5,000,Kshs 200, RwF 1,500, SDP 8

Kutesa, Museveni
America bribe case
How the fight against corruption was lost

www.independent.co.ug
YOU BUY THE
TRUTH
WE PAY THE
PRICE

Independent Publications Limited, Plot 82/84, Kanjokya Street, P. O. Box 3304, Kampala, Uganda Tel: +256-312-637-391/ 2/ 3/ 4 Fax: +256-312-637-396
E-mail: editorial@independent.co.ug, advertising@independent.co.ug, circulation@independent.co.ug Website: www.independent.co.ug
Dec. 14 - 20 2018
INBOX

Issue No. 551 Dec. 14 - 20 2018

News analysis Business Health Arts Motoring

Cover story
Kutesa, Museveni America bribe case
How the fight against corruption was lost

4 The Week
30 Comments
FDC drops Wadri,
Alaso in NEC reshuffle The feminization of African
politics: Evidence shows that
women’s political leadership
9 The Last Word
strengthens governance capacity
Uganda’s painful truths: Why and cooperation with allies
the always-blame-government-
for-every-problem mantra is
32 Health
popular but destructive
Designer babies:
Why what everyone is
14 Analysis freaking out about is not
likely to happen
Edith Nakalema: What can
Museveni’s new anti-corruption tsar
do where others have failed?
35 Arts & Culture
27 Business
Kamya wows with wood:
Coke unveils sugar-free soda How a child’s curiosity
created international celebrity

STRATEGY & EDITORIAL DIRECTOR: Andrew M. Mwenda WRITERS:Ronald Musoke, Flavia Nassaka, Ian Katusiime,
MANAGING EDITOR: Joseph Were Agnes Nantaba, Julius Businge.
INVESTIGATIONS EDITOR: Haggai Matsiko DESIGN/LAYOUT: Sarah Ngororano
BUSINESS EDITOR: Isaac Khisa CARTOONIST: Harriet Jamwa
PHOTOGRAPHER: Jimmy Siya

PUBLISHER: Independent Publications Limited, Plot 82/84, Kanjokya Street, P. O. Box 3304, Kampala, Uganda
Tel: +256-312-637-391/ 2/ 3/ 4 | Fax: +256-312-637-396 E-mail: editor@independent.co.ug | advertising@independent.co.ug
circulation@independent.co.ug | Website: www.independent.co.ug

2 Dec. 14 - 20 2018
Offline

Miss Uganda Quiin


Abenakyo was on
Dec.08 named Miss
World Africa at the
Miss World finals on
the tropical Chinese
island of Hainan.
Abenakyo,22, was the
only African in the final
five as a Mexican model “What I can tell you is that
and volunteer, Vanessa a number of big people in
Ponce de Leon, 26 was
crowned Miss World. government own labour export
Abanakyo also emerged companies.”Speaker Rebecca Kadaga
second overall runner
up to Miss World.

Yichun, China:
Participant
takes part in
a chilli-eating
competition at a
hot spring

“Importing Cuban doctors has


been put on hold because we
thought salary enhancement
would improve efficiency. But
what we are hearing is not the
case.” Ruth Aceng, Minister for Health

“It is not enough to say you are


going to have a concert or gathering
in Mityana without indicating the
venue and plan for people you expect
to attend. You have to have agreed
with owners of the venue for your
meeting.” Emilian Kayima on Bobi Wine
claims that Police blocked his concerts
Hefei, China: Urban officers deliver a fresh addition to a pile of bicycles from a bike-sharing service

Gov’t officials who


72 1000 460m
Residents in Mityana Condoms Uganda needs
received allowances for annually according to
two years from UNHCR who face eviction
health experts

Dec. 14 - 20 2018 3
week
Uganda’s Quinn Abenakyo crowned Miss World Africa Police defends
Miss Uganda Quiin Abenakyo has action on blocked
been crowned Miss World Africa at
the 2018 Miss World finale in China. Bobi Wine concerts
Quinn is the first Miss Uganda to
make it to the top 5 finalists. The Miss As part of his festive season
world title went to Mexico’s Vanessa programme, Kyaddondo MP
Ponce de Leon with Thailand’s and singer Robert Kyagulanyi
Nicolene Limsnukan as first runner aka Bobiwine had planned to
up. Abenakyo was second runner hold music concerts in Mityana
up with Belarus’ Maria Vasilevich in and Gulu among other places.
fourth place while Jamaica’s Kadija But soon news made rounds
Robinson came fifth. that the concerts have been
Abenakyo who presented her cancelled something that
beauty with a purpose project on attracted even the attention of
teenage pregnancies in Uganda sway members of parliament.
supporters with her own story of With piling pressure
being born prematurely and how on the police as sections
she considers her survival a miracle. started questioning why
Abenakyo, 22, holds a Bachelors the musician’s concerts
degree in Business Computing. are being cancelled,
Police on Dec.06 said they
FDC drops Wadri, Musisi's suprise visit to Lukwago hadn’t been cancelled but
only asked that the right
Alaso in NEC reshuffle Council
On Dec.05, Kampala City
Authority (KCCA)
that one of her biggest challenge
while at the helm of the author-
procedures are followed.
Police spokesperson, Emilian
Executive Director Jennifer ity has been the irreconcilable Kayima, said Police had held
The Opposition Forum Musisi paid a rare courtesy visit differences between the politi- a meeting with the singer
for Democratic Change to Lord Mayor Erias Lukwago’s cal strategists and the technical and told him that he did not
(FDC) on Dec.07 shuffled its office at City Hall in Kampala. team. provide enough supporting
National Executive Commit- Musisi who has tendered in her However, when Lukwago documents including
tee dropping former Serere resignation from office effec- heard about her resignation agreements with owners of
woman MP Alice Alaso as its tive Dec.15 has since 2011 been earlier he sang on camera in places where he intended to
deputy president for Eastern in endless fights with the lord jubilation her departure but on hold his concerts.
region and Arua Municipal- mayor over city affairs. Wednesday the two were seen “He didn’t provide us with a
ity legislator Kasiano Wadri In her resignation letter to in photos smiling and exchang- plan of how he will handle the
as the party Deputy mobil- the president, Musisi had noted ing pleasantries. revelers. It is not enough to say
iser for Northern Uganda. you are going to have a concert
The two who are known or gathering in Mityana
to belong to ex-party Presi- without indicating the venue
dent Gen. Mugisha Muntu and plan for people you expect
faction have lost their posi- to attend ” Kayima said.
tions to former Busia Munic- This however is not the first
ipality legislator Taaka time that police is attempted to
Kevinah Wanaha as the new cancel the legislator’s concerts.
deputy President Eastern The previous attempt was with
and Obongi county MP Kaps his Kyarenga concert where
Fungaroo as deputy mobil- they kept tossing him but he
iser for Northern. finally held the show at his
One Love beach in Busabala.

eye Care Centre


Opticians
VillaGe Mall luGoGo Mall Garden City Mall
Bugolobi (On the 1st Floor) (Next to Game) (Next to Stanbic Bank)
+256 (0)41-4505 566 +256 (0) 41-4220 780 Ground floor
+256 (0)393 888 833 +256 (0) 392 264 422 +256 (0) 41-4237 700
Also open on Sundays 10:00am -2:00pm
+256 (0)392 265 500
downtown ViCtoria Mall enteBBe
KaMpala BranCh
(Plot 3 Johnstone Street)
+256 (0)717 227 066 / +256 (0)392 203 023
Also open on Sundays 11:00am-4:00pm
Free
Eye examination
+256 (0)41- 4257 759 / +256 (0)393 264 400

Call: 0701/0712/0752/0772-786 400 E-mail: sales@eyecareug.com Website: www.eyecareug.com

4 Dec. 14 - 20 2018
Week
Parliament questions new e-pass port Apaa land talks
After government However, after his held in Gulu
announced recently that presentation several members
they are phasing out the of parliament queried the A meeting chaired by Prime
current passport in favor of timing, deadlines and the Minister Dr. Ruhakana Rugun-
the East African Community price of Shs250, 000 and da was held in Gulu on Dec.07
(EAC) e-passport, parliament Shs500, 000 – for diplomats whereby he met elders from
received it with mixed that the new document is Acholi and Adjumani to dis-
feelings. When Internal to go for. Speaker Rebecca cuss the Apaa land question.
Affairs Minister, Obiga Kania Kadaga asked why The third formal negotiation
presented a statement on it, a government had chosen meeting of its kind attended by
slew of questions followed. be phased in a period of two an EAC passport yet it’s not eight elders was proposed by
Obiga who told legislators years. He said the move is not sovereign state and whether the President Museveni in August
that government had already just an EAC affair as about 150 law won’t need to be amended to discuss how settlers can
signed a contract with a foreign other countries have migrated to accommodate the changes. be relocated, land owners be
firm to supply it with the new from the paper type passports Others wondered what would compensated and where those
booklets said Presidents of the to a more superior e-passport happen to citizens who have that are to stay will be operat-
EAC had in 2016 agreed that that is fitted with microchips to just incurred an expense of a ing from.
issuing of the new passports store personal data, and can’t be passport and now need to pay Rugunda told the meeting
starts in 2017 and the old ones easily manipulated. for an electronic one. that government had reached
final stages of consultations
as they have heard the views
FDC opts out of IPOD meeting of the two groups which will
help them in another discus-
A week before the an Inter – For him, the event was helpful that even in 2016, FDC threat- sion they were to have with
Party Organisation for Dailogue to every party especially those ened to quit IPOD over gov- the president aimed at draw-
(IPOD) summit scheduled for that are represented in parlia- ernment’s failure to pursue ing a conclusion.
Dec.12 could be held, the main ment since its meant to harmo- electoral reforms. The previous two meetings
opposition Forum for Demo- nise their differences. were held on the September
cratic Change (FDC) party “It should be noted that 06th and 20th but both the
announced that they would not before JEEMA’s brief exit from Acholi and Adjumani elders
participate in the event. the IPOD, we had decried the failed to agree on Museveni’s
While speaking to journal- lack of meeting of the Summit proposals. Now, while the
ists on Dec.07, former FDC as the NRM Chairman Mr. Acholi team endorsed the pro-
presidential candidate Dr. Yoweri Museveni was never posal to allow for genuine land
Kizza Besigye said they had available for IPOD issues. It’s owners to stay on the land,
no basis of going into dialogue that position we found on the the Adjumani group called for
with a government that is not table when we were readmit- relocating all the settlers.
genuinely in power and has ted to the platform this year While meeting Apaa locals
frustrated all opposing parties and our efforts were geared in August, Museveni had
from conducting their activities at seeing all IPOD internal called for a speedy resolution
without interference. processes are actualized”, to end this fight between the
In a statement released on Kateregga said in a statement two communities over bound-
Dec.06, Secretary General of saying it would be inappropri- aries saying all Ugandans have
JEEMA party, Mohammed ate for other parties to opt out a right to stay where they want
Katerega said all parties harmo- now when the NRM and Presi- as long as they are there legal-
niously agreed to the holding of dent Museveni have agreed to ly. He said some people had
the event and dismissed allega- take part. settled on this land while well
tions that FDC and the Demo- It should be knowing that it’s a gazzetted
cratic Party were opting out. remembered land reserve.

eye Care Centre


Opticians
aCaCia Mall KiseMenti KaMpala (u)
Tel: +256 (0)41-4581 458 / +256 (0)392 267 700
Also open on Sundays 11:00 am -6:00 Pm
Free
Eye examination

For: Sun Glasses


Free Eye examination Eye Pressure Examination
Large selection of frames Frame Repairs
Contact lenses & Solutions All optical Accessories

Call: 071/0712/0752/0772-786 400 E-mail: sales@eyecareug.com Kampala-Uganda

Dec. 14 - 20 2018 5
Week
ACME’s Harriet Anena wins a Minister in Congo to strategize on ending Ebola
Wole Soyinka prize for Literature Health Minister Jane Ruth
Aceng was on Dec.05 in the
neighboring Democratic Republic
of Congo (DRC) to deliberate
with officials there on how to
end Ebola hemorrhagic fever that
has so far claimed more than 200.
The Minister said Uganda has
had 5 outbreaks mostly along its
western regions close to the DRC
but all of them were controlled at
Source with very limited spread
beyond the localities of original
incidence. She however said
Uganda is currently a high risk
country due to its proximity to meeting was vital to ensure that
Congo that has for most of the the two countries agree on high
year struggled to control the level coordination mechanisms
disease. and common platform to
“Uganda has not confirmed a address common challenges in
case but the scale of the ongoing containing the outbreak. She
outbreak in the Democratic said the issues agreed on include
Republic of Congo presents mapping common crossing points
a formidable risk of spread and ensure that there is joint
Harriet Anena a programmes officer at the African Center beyond the current epicenter monitoring and screening.
for Media Excellence (ACME) jointly won the award with due to challenges related to case The outbreak is now the second
Nigeria’s Prof Tanure Ojaide who authored Songs of containment and large numbers highest, after the 2014 outbreak in
Myself. Anena’s winning book, A Nation in Labour was of people who cross the border West Africa.
launched in 2015. She was handed her prize at an awards daily”, she said that’s why the
gala held in Lagos Nigeria on Dec.09.

Ultimark (U) Ltd Urgent


Stamps &
Authorized Dealer: Trodat Stamps & Trotec Laser Machines

trodat
Seals within

Introducing in Uganda
30 min

Stamps & seals


Made in Europe
Simple Steady Clean

Plot No.17,Shop No.NS 13/2 Madhvani Bldg, Nkrumah Road, Opp.Post Bank Kampala-Uganda | Tel:0754-262707,0757-777400 | Email:sales@ultimark.co

6 Dec. 14 - 20 2018
Humour Did you know?
Why men lie up and
women lie down
Both men and women lie, but
they lie about different (and
predictable) things.
Whether in personal ads or in
face-to-face conversations, men
tend to lie about their earnings
and their height. In contrast,
women tend to lie about their age
and their weight. And both men
and women often lie about the
number of sexual partners they
have had in their lives.
On all of these dimensions,
men typically lie upwards and
women typically lie downwards.
President Yoweri Museveni has assured Ugandans that he can still fight and defeat corruption. Men pretend that they make more
money than they actually do,
they pretend that they are taller
than they actually are, and they
pretend that they have had more
sexual partners than they actually
have. In contrast, women pretend
that they are younger than they
actually are, they pretend that
they are lighter than they actually
are, and they pretend that they
have had fewer sexual partners
than they actually have.
Of all these dimensions, height
is the only one that stays more or
less the same throughout adult
life. All the other dimensions
only increase with time. Age by
definition increases uniformly and
equally with time. Most people’s
earnings increase with age and
The outgoing KCCA boss Jennifer Musisi paid Lord Mayor Erias Lukwago experience. Because metabolism
a courtesy visit in his office 10 days before her departure from office. slows down with age, most people
become heavier as they get older.
And the lifetime number of sexual
partners cannot decrease and
usually increases with time.
In other words, women lie and
pretend to be what they used to
be before in the past, whereas men
lie and pretend to be what they
will be in the future (or what they
hope to become in an alternate
universe or in their fantasy).
But no matter how much they
wish, women cannot reverse
the course of time; they have
to get older, heavier, and have
more sexual partners as time
progresses. In contrast, men can
at least hope and dream of making
more money and having more
The Government is to introduce regulations on ownership and sexual partners (if not getting
management of church resources to ensure transparency. taller) in the future.

Dec. 14 - 20 2018 7
Ocuilan, Mexico: Pilgrims visit the Virgin of Guadalupe statue
The Last Word Opinion

Uganda’s painful truths


By Andrew M. Mwenda
Why the always-blame-government-for-every-
problem mantra is popular but destructive

M
any Ugandans are angry feeling dans will organise politically to reign in his journey from poverty to prosperity. Yet
the country is not going in the Chinese investors. However, I am inclined he keeps telling his followers that their own
right direction. This is especially to believe this inhumanity is necessary for journey from misery to fortune is somehow
so among those who feel they our development – the short term cost to blocked by the government, not their lack of
can do better, which is understandable. our long-term prosperity. marketable skills.
However, they always attribute their frus- In the heated and often bitter debates This sense of victimhood is dysfunctional.
trations to factors that are politically conve- over Uganda’s development, we forget A dependent voting constituency is valu-
nient and emotionally satisfying to them. I that progress comes as much from public able for politicians to exploit for their own
have learnt over the years that the pursuit policy as it does from shared mentalities. ends. This is especially so when a politician
of accurate knowledge and the pursuit of Our country is suffering from the legacy of has a captive constituency indoctrinated
ideological or emotional satisfaction are indoctrination in the nanny state ideology. with the belief that they are surrounded by
inherently conflicting goals. Many people From home to school to traditional and enemies who are keeping them down. This
want information that gives them emotional social media, people are taught that their is because the politicians who do this posi-
satisfaction, like pundits who attribute misery is because of government not doing tion themselves as the defenders of the poor
every failure to the government; especially things for them. No one tells young people in exchange for their votes.
the person of President Yoweri Museveni. that personal advancement comes from When someone wants to help you, they
There is no doubt that many routine having the right social attitudes and mar- tell you what you need to hear; what you
functions of government in Uganda are ketable skills, not from government baby- must hear. And that is what I do in this
characterised by corruption, incompetence, sitting people. column. But when someone wants to help
absenteeism, laziness, apathy and indiffer- At Makerere and other universities, himself, often at your expense, they tell you
ence. However, morally important issues lecturers pump students with socially dys- what you want to hear. Those politicians
like these are not necessarily decisive causal functional ideologies about government who want to use poor Ugandans as ladders
factors of Uganda’s poverty and misery but being responsible for people’s wellbeing. to power will massage the egos of popular
merely characteristics of it. This is not to say Meanwhile they impart students with classes. This is the reason demagogues are
such moral issues are not important. Rather skills not demanded by the market. When loved. Yet while these arguments make the
it is to underline the fact that confusing I need a plumber, a carpenter, a gardener, poor feel a sense of gratification (someone
one with the other and imagining they can a mason, an electrician or a mechanic I can is helping me fight the enemy keeping me
be combined into one politically attractive hardly find a Ugandan who speaks English; down) they do not help them deal with the
package is not an approach that leads to meaning these vital jobs have been left to real challenge of their personal progress
understanding. “jua kali” who speak only Luganda, the i.e. investment in developing the requisite
For example, most of the discussion about proxy for low education achievement. skills.
“development” in Uganda focuses on the Uganda’s education system and our coun- For many Ugandans, political activities
state. While I think the state is important try’s intellectual climate are not conducive such as demonstrations, rallies, marches,
to economic development, I also believe its to progress. Academics, journalists, intellec- protests and posting insults on social media
actions are limited to the capacity inherent tuals, civil society and social media activists offer instant gratification and solidarity with
in people that make up that state – their pump our people with a sickening sense like-minded people. Many urban Ugandans
skills, values, norms, work ethics and social of entitlement. Ugandans think they are use such events to present their grievances
attitudes i.e. human capital. The standard entitled to a well-paying job simply because as a righteous crusade against presumed
of living of a nation depends more on they have a university degree. When this enemies (Museveni and his corrupt confed-
its output per person than on the money expectation is not met, it gives them an even erates in power) ostensibly responsible for
received as income for producing that more insidious sense of grievance that gov- the bad situation. They do this because it is
output. Otherwise the government could ernment is responsible. This explains why easy to do even though not productive.
make everyone rich by just printing money. they rally around demagogues in the naive The solution to the plight of many unem-
The challenge of low income earners is not and blind hope that they can deliver them ployed or underemployed Ugandans
because government has not created well- salvation. would be to invest in personal development
paying jobs for them but because they have Ugandan elites tow this politically correct by putting all their energies in acquiring the
low levels of productivity. line because it makes them look and feel requisite education, skills and self-discipline
A Chinese textile worker produces output “cool” as pro “the down-trodden”. This vital for success. But this path to success can
six times higher than her counterpart in non-judgmental leniency towards indi- be a lonely process of unromantic drudgery
Kenya, nine times higher than a Ugandan. viduals and groups that are always sitting with no immediate gratification as soli-
That explains the differences in incomes of idle and blaming everyone else for their darity with others voicing opposition to pre-
workers in these three countries. Sadly this misery is the problem. Take the example sumed enemies. Moreover this alternative
has little to do with government policy. In of Kyadondo East Member of Parliament to political protest can produce a painful
the face of low labour productivity, Chinese Robert Kyagulanyi aka Bobi Wine: he grew sense of one’s own inadequacies. That is the
investors in Uganda seek to increase the up in the ghetto but became prosperous by challenge for Uganda’s youths.
output of Ugandans by making them work exploiting his talents. The current system
long hours. This is inhumane and Ugan- that he is so keen to criticise did not block amwenda@independent.co.ug

Dec. 14 - 20 2018 9
cover story

Kutesa, Museveni
America bribe case
How the fight against corruption was lost
By Independent Reporters and from the convicted man. Simon Lokodo who are avowed fighters of

W
The timing of the Chinese man’s convic- corruption. But none mentioned the Kutesa
hen on Dec.05, an American tion appeared well set as Uganda, like the bribe saga.
court convicted Patrick Ho rest of the world, was marking the Anti- Finally Museveni spoke. He had earlier
Chi Ping on charges of bribing Corruption Week that started on Dec.03 to promised to unveil a new strategy to battle
foreign leaders in Chad and climax in major celebrations of the Interna- corruption in public office. Museveni also
Uganda in a bid to corruptly secure unfair tional Anti-Corruption Day on Dec.10 at the did not mention the Kutesa bribe saga on
business advantages for his multi-billion- Kololo Ceremonial Grounds in Kampala. the podium. It was an anti-climax even
dollar Chinese energy company, news As the day approached, interest heightened. when he announced what would ordinarily
media in Uganda picked interest. How What would Museveni say at Kololo about be a tough new measure; the confiscation of
would the government of President Yoweri the Kutesa Chinese bribe saga? property of corrupt officials, and the forma-
Museveni react this time? Before Museveni spoke at the Kololo tion of a major anti-corruption in President’s
Kutesa served as president of the UN event, a slew of government officials spoke Office under his trusted aide, Lt. Col. Edith
General Assembly from 2014 to 2015 and in angry, determined tones and vowed to Nakalema. Kutesa’s case puts Museveni
was specifically named as the recipient of a stamp out corruption and deal firmly with in a tight spot because he and Kutesa are
US$500,000 (Approx. Shs1.8 billion) bribe, the corrupt. Speakers included the Inspector related by marriage.
while President Yoweri Museveni was said General of Government, Justice Irene Muly- Still, while commissioning the offices
to have received an equal sum plus gifts agonja, and Minister of Ethics and Integrity of Nakalema’s unit, Museveni was prod-

Patrick Ho Chi Ping


Sam Kutesa

10 Dec. 14 - 20 2018
cover story
ded by journalist to comment on the alleged
bribes he and Kutesa allegedly received from
the convicted Chinese man. Museveni did not
Past corruption cases
comment about himself. But he said the Kutesa
case was being investigated internally, through
the Attorney General William Byaruhanga. The
against Sam Kutesa
President appeared to be mulling two impor-  2017: The leaked so-called Paradise pany to bag a tender to supply ballot
tant considerations; first whether there was any Papers reveal that Kutesa in 2012 papers. The others were his nephew,
wrong-doing, especially if Kutesa received the hired Appleby, a company renowned Sam Rwakoojo, who is the Secretary
money for himself or a charity, and secondly; for creating offshore account for the to the Electoral Commission and
what actions to take. Museveni told journalists rich and powerful, to form a company Enos Tumusiime, a high-flying city
that “obviously it was a crime for Kutesa to for him in the tax haven of Seychelles lawyer. IGG investigations revealed
take money from a foreign company. in an attempt to hide his money and that Lithotec’s competitor—Skipco
“What were they paying you for?” he said. dodge taxes. Property Limited– had been wrongly
But in case of action to be taken, he said vague-  2014: He is accused of corruption in disqualified from the tender and the
ly that Kutesa “is answerable”. a battle over his candidature for UN contract was cancelled. Nevertheless,
General Assembly presidency. More Lithotec got the contract to supply
Comparing earlier Kute\sa cases than 9,000 people signed an online ballots for the presidential elections.
It is a far cry from 2011 when Kutesa was petition urging the U.S. to block him.  2001 November: Lithotec gets another
once again in trouble over a bribe. At the time, Despite the campaign, Kutesa was contract to supply ballots for the local
Kutesa and then Government Chief Whip elected. government elections. The govern-
John Nasasira and Minister of State for Labour  2012: Kutesa, through his son-in-law, ment “loses” US$ 1 million in deal.
Mwesigwa Rukutana faced accusations of Albert Muganga, was cited in a fight  2000: Kutesa mentioned in the deal to
corruption over procurements for the 2007 to secure a deal for the construction of procure a technology, called an Intel-
Commonwealth Heads of State and Govern- the Standard Gauge Railway for the ligent Network Monitoring/verifica-
ment Meeting (CHOGM) in Kampala. But even Chinese company called CCECC. tion System (INMS), estimated to cost
before the matter proceeded, the trio “stepped  2012: Kutesa is mentioned in the deals the Ugandan taxpayer about Shs100
aside” to enable investigations to proceed. surrounding the construction of Karu- billion.
But this time, Museveni, Mulyagonja, Loko- ma and Isimba power dams.  1999: Parliament censures Kutesa.
do and others are not the only public officials  2009: Kutesa is mentioned in elec-  1998: A parliamentary committee
charged with fighting corruption who have this tions related deal worth $15 million to investigating the privatisation of
time reacted lukewarmly to the bribery allega- update the voters register by the Elec- Uganda Airlines Corporation con-
tions against a top government official. toral Commission. A US firm which cludes that it had been “manipulated
Earlier on Dec. 04, the head of the global had been pre-qualified for the deal and taken advantage of by Kutesa
anti-corruption body, Transparency Interna- attributed suspension of the award and “a few politically powerful
tional Uganda, Delia Ferreira Rubio, awarded to competing interests of presidential people who sacrifice the people’s
President Museveni also received an award in insiders. Kutesa was connected to a interests.”
recognition for his efforts of curbing corrup- competing firm from Bangladesh.  1997: During privatization of 80% of
tion through setting an anti-corruption office,  2005: Kutesa is named in a deal Sheraton Hotel, Kutesa, then minister
setting up legal frameworks to fight corruption described by Bright Rwamirama, for Investment and Planning is named
and constantly denouncing corruption. She did who at the time was the privatisation by a parliamentary committee for
not mention the Kutesa saga. committee chairman, as “outright soliciting a bribe of between $2-6 mil-
When the Chinese bribery allegations first robbery”. The deal involved the priva- lion together with Mayanja Nkanji,
broke as the case took off in the U.S in Decem- tisation of Uganda Diary Cooperation who was Justice Minister, Mathew
ber 2017, MPs across the aisle petitioned the Ltd (UDCL). While the entity was val- Rukikaire, who was the minister
Speaker of Parliament Rebecca Kadaga to get ued at $9 million with an annual turn- of state for privatization and Salim
Kutesa to offer an official explanation on the over of $12 million, President Musev- Saleh. The IGG found that three min-
floor of the House. Ntungamo Municipality eni blocked a process by the privati- isters had influenced the award.
MP Gerald Karuhanga described Kutesa’s sation unit to have the entity’s 70 %  1995: Kutesa, as board chairman,
alleged act as “a shame to the country” and sold to the best bidder, and instead used an accounting firm close to him
Lwemiyaga County MP Theodore Ssekikubo decided to offer it to a Malaysian to undervalue the ENHAS shares,
said Kutesa is “a shark who no one is touch- company called Malee Sampran PCL which he later sold to himself and
ing”. MPs Medard Ssegona (Busiro East) and for three years at a nominal fee of $ 1. Salim Saleh cheaply. Saleh acquired
Ssemujju Nganda (Kira Municipality) piled on It emerged that Malee was to incor- 45% shares for $3.75 million and sold
the pressure without tangible results as Deputy porate a company named Pan African them at $9.45 million. Kutesa was the
Attorney General Mwesigwa Rukutana cau- Foods Ltd (PAFL), which would take minister of state for Investment and
tioned that parliament should not be moved over DCL. It later emerged that Malee Planning.
basing on media reports. This time the MPs was a smokescreen for PAFL, which  1993: Kutesa’s first publicly known
are more muted. Does the court ruling in New despite being unregistered was con- corruption deal. In 1993, when
York change anything now? nected to Kutesa. ground handling at Entebbe Interna-
It is a far cry from March 1999, when Kutesa  2001: President Museveni re-appoint- tional Airport was privatised, a com-
who was then the Minister of State for Finance, ed him after elections because he pany called Effortes, a subsidiary of
was censured for alleged misuse of office and allegedly financed that election with Caleb International owned by Presi-
influence peddling over his purchase of Enteb- $500,000. dent Museveni’s brother, Caleb Akan-
be Handling Services, the ground-handling  2001: Kutesa is named among dwanaho aka Salim Saleh and Global
company at Entebbe International Airport, members of President Museveni’s Airlink owned by Kutesa unfairly
which was supervised by his ministry. campaign task force that was front- took 40% according to a parliament
This time, it is only the Executive Director ing Lithotec, a South African com- investigation.

Dec. 14 - 20 2018 11
cover story
of the Anti-Corruption Coalition Uganda Ashe and the Kutesas. Yan was arrested by wished to launch”.
(ACCU), Cissy Kagaba, who is speaking FBI agents in October 2015 and is accused of “In reality,” the FBI notes elsewhere, “this
out against Kutesa. But she is increasingly bribing John Ashe. Yan allegedly appoint- payment was a bribe to obtain business
sounding like a stuck record since she has ment of Ashe as a GSF adviser to enable advantages for the Energy Company in its
been making corruption allegations against her to pay him a monthly bribe of $20,000, efforts to secure contracts and ventures in
Kutesa long before he was named President supplemented by larger kickbacks. Uganda’s financial and energy sectors.”
of the UN General Assembly and went on It is not clear what, if any thing, was in it The document further reveals that Ho
the commit the alleged crimes between 2014 for the Kutesas. But tapping their phones also provided the Ugandan Foreign Minis-
and 2015. and intercepting their emails gave away the ter, as well as the President of Uganda, with
Kutesas dealings with their alleged Chinese promises of future benefits, including pro-
How Kutesa was netted briber, Patrick Ho of China Energy Fund posing to partner with both officials’ fami-
As part of the case against the Chinese Committee (CEFC). lies in potentially lucrative joint ventures.
man HO, the American government The CEFC Chairman is Ye Jianming, the In the case of the alleged Museveni bribe,
accused him of bribing Kutesa and Musev- powerful Chairman and Executive Direc- according to the FBI, Kutesa asked the
eni which are categorised under corrupt tor of CEFC China Energy Company Ltd, Chinese for the money as a contribution to
practices and international money launder- which is the parent company of CEFC and the election campaign of the President. It
ing in the U.S. The case involved two diplo- one of the 250 richest companies in the remains unclear if indeed he gave Museveni
mats; a Senegalese and a Chinese who faced world. the money as a campaign donation from the
eight charges of violating the U.S. Foreign Ye Jianming founded the CEFC and nur- Chinese.
Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA). tured it into a think tank with consultative In their book, `The politics of Elite Cor-
Kutesa was not charged or called to status with the UN. That is how Kutesa met ruption in Africa; Uganda in Comparative
testify because the FCPA and American Ho. The CEFC patronises former heads of African Perspective’, Prof. Roger Tangri of
money laundering law snares only U.S. states and hundreds of political leaders as Stanford University, USA, and Andrew
based persons making payments to foreign its advisers and researchers. Kutesa, while Mwenda of The Independent magazine,
government officials to assist in obtaining he was President of the UN General Assem- describe how Museveni solicits foreign
or retaining business. Kutesa is not a repre- bly, appointed Ye Jianming as “Special Hon- money contributions during elections. They
sentative of a U.S-based company accused orary Advisor to the UN” in what is being name past contributors as former Nigerian
of violating FCPA and he did not make the seen as making a pass to himself as he used president Olusegun Obasanjo, the late
payment. the same occasion to solicit the US$500,000 Libyan leader Muammar Gadhafi, former
That means that as long as Kutesa is not bribe. Kenyan president Daniel Arap Moi, and for-
pursued by any anticorruption entity in Kutesa accepts soliciting and getting the mer Tanzanian president Benjamin Mkapa.
Uganda, he is most likely to remain free at money. But he denies that the money was a They also point out that, under Uganda
home. But his freedom from prosecution in bribe and insisted it was a donation towards law, it is not illegal to seek such foreign
America may not be guaranteed, according his foundation. But, according to the FBI, contributions. However, the Political Parties
to sources. the NGO is fictitious. Kutesa allegedly used and Organisations Act limits the contribu-
It should be recalled that the FBI picked a fake organisation, forged letter heads, fake tion to maximum US$200,000 per year. So if
interest in Kutesa after his wife was emails, addresses, and dates and dragged in Museveni, through Kutesa, got US$500,000
appointed as “a major member of the the President’s name, and abused his office from the Chinese, it would be illegal.
Board” of an NGO called the Global Sus- at the UN and Uganda Foreign Affairs for Previously, the Ministry of Foreign
tainability Foundation (GSF) of Sheri Yan; personal gain. Affairs issued a statement defending Kute-
another Chinese national, who was known The FBI agent who investigated the case sa. It noted that the interaction and engage-
for arranging meetings between diplomats writes that: “Based on my review of email, ment Kutesa had with Ho was in fulfillment
and millionaire business executives and I know, in substance and in part, that in or of his official functions as president of the
socialites. The appointment was significant about February 2016, the Ugandan Foreign U.N. General Assembly.
to the FBI because Edith Kutesa was listed Minister (aided by his wife) solicited from “It is therefore erroneous to insinuate or
with the former 68th president of the UN defendant Chi Ping Patrick Ho aka “Patrick infer that Hon. Sam Kutesa, from references
General Assembly, John Ashe as GSF’s C.P. Ho”, a bribe which he characterised as made to him and CEFC…is linked to the
only two advisers. The FBI had Yan on their a “donation/contribution” for a “founda- bribery allegations,” a statement said. And
watch list and, therefore took interest in tion” that the Ugandan Foreign Minister that might be the end of the story.

12 Dec. 14 - 20 2018
news analysis

Edith Nakalema said whereas many corrupt people are


being exposed, the number of corruption
cases being recorded also keeps going up,
an indicator that something is not being
What can Museveni’s new anti-corruption done right.
In some of the major corruption cases this
tsar do where others have failed? year, one Apollo Ssenketto was jailed for
10 years by the Anti- Corruption Court for
stealing up to shs24.7billion meant for the
By Flavia Nassaka of the world to mark the United Nations set Mukono – Katosi road project. He formed

P
annual Anti-corruption Day usually com- a fictitious company that was dubiously
resident Yoweri Museveni has memorated on December 09, Museveni said awarded the contract.
unveiled Lt. Col. Edith Naka- Nakalema was part of additional fuel he The commission of Inquiry into land
lema to the public as the newest was adding to the fight against corruption. matters led by Justice Catherine Bamuge-
anti-corruption tsar in State House. In any case, he said the existing agencies; mereire also exposed rackets of business-
Nakalema, a trusted Museveni aide, was from the Inspectorate of Government, the men, religious leaders, ministers, and other
named to the task soon after she returned to Auditor General, Parliament, and the Judi- prominent people involved in land and
Uganda in September after a one-year stint ciary have all become infested by corrupt property theft. The Minister of Lands Betty
at the Shrivenham Defence Academy in people he called ‘weevils’. Amongi and Minister of State for Lands
London, UK on a senior command and staff Museveni said his government has faced Ronald Kibuule have been implicated in
course. Before her departure she had been a seven challenges related to corruption and possible wrongdoing but no action has been
Personal Assistant to Museveni and the go- defeated three, namely army killing people, taken.
to person in State House. poaching in the national parks, and army Also, the Financial Intelligence Authority
Museveni commissioned offices for extortion at road blocks where they were launched an investigation into former Bank
Nakalema’s unit at the President’s Office killing people. He said officials who extort of Uganda Executive Director for Commer-
buildings in Kampala and told journalists money from people, illegal operations in cial Banks Supervision Justine Bagyenda
the he appointed Nakalema because she is wetlands, and embezzlement and bribery, over alleged illegitimate accumulation of
fearless, upright, and likely not to conceal and nepotism remain. wealth. This was shortly after the Inspector-
corruption. Before the Dec.10 announcement, Musev- ate of Government (IG) had quizzed her
Her posting follows another one in June, eni had on Dec.05 excited the country, when over acquisition of assets in different areas
when Museveni appointed one James he promised to make major pronounce- of Kampala and accumulation of money on
Tweheyo; a former secretary general of the ments on tackling corruption. Museveni different fixed deposit bank accounts.
Uganda National Teachers Union, Capt. was receiving an award for fighting corrup- The on-going hearings by the parliamen-
Martha Asiimwe, and one Sister Mary tion from a global accountability and anti- tary Committee on Commissions, Statutory
Grace Akiror to head an anti-corruption corruption NGO, Transparency Internation- Authorities and State Enterprises (COSASE)
unit in State House. But in October Musev- al that was marking 25 years of operation into how Bank of Uganda sold and allowed
eni abruptly removed Tweheyo and in Uganda. Several speakers highlighted takeover of several commercial banks, has
appointed him RDC. With Nakalema’s rising corruption levels despite numerous exposed more corruption.
appointment, the fate of the other two on institutions and laws in place to fight it.
the Tweheyo team remains unclear. Former leader of opposition in Parlia- More action needed
While explaining Nakalema’s appoint- ment Wafula Oguttu who was also awarded Wafula was joined by anti-corruption
ment on Dec.10, as Uganda joined the rest at the event for his anti-corruption efforts activist Cissy Kagaba to demand more

Dec. 14 - 20 2018 13
news analysis
action against the corrupt. Kagaba wanted if we did not have a high degree of altruism. Mike Mukula who had been found guilty
illicitly gained wealth to be recovered from This attitude of altruism must come back,” of embezzling GAVI funds to be freed was
the corrupt and government officials impli- he said and blamed the public for failing to wrong.
cated in scandals to leave office. report criminals. He said there is no crimi- “He also said he knows the corrupt offi-
According to the latest 2017 Corruption nal his government cannot handle. cials who solicit money from investors. Six
Perception Index (CPI), Uganda ranks 151 months later, no names have been exposed
out of the 180 countries ranked by Trans- Museveni the problem yet. All they say is that there is political will
parency International. It was at the same An official in the IG who preferred but this will should be about people seeing
rank in 2016 out of 176 countries, meaning anonymity told The Independent that the corruption levels going down,”Kagaba said.
only 25 countries were perceived to be more President has on many occasions blocked Kagaba says Museveni rides on political
corrupt. A year before in 2015, it had ranked investigations into corruption. According patronage and “mafias” will thrive since
139 out of the same number of countries to the official, that makes Museveni part of they run to the President for protection. She
ranked. In terms of CPI, the higher the cor- the reason anticorruption institutions and says Museveni’s hands are tied and he can-
ruption, the higher the ranking. laws fail. not afford annoying them.
While Uganda rated to the highs of 151 “He has told us to back off some cases “We would expect ministers implicated
in 2017, Rwanda performed best at 48 fol- mid-way investigations, some when we are in these commissions and investigations to
lowed by Tanzania at 103. Kenya came about to finish. He himself protects some step aside. That’s what happens in countries
143rd of the 180 countries ranked. Burundi people. How do you expect us to move? like Denmark, Finland and Switzerland
and South Sudan were worse than Uganda Fighting corruption is not speaking and whose CPIs are good,” Kagaba said.
at 157 and 179 respectively. threatening; it’s action,” the official said. “When they are investigated by the IGG,
The CPI does not measure actual inci- The official predicted that the 2018 rank- the president comes in to block. Their (IG)
dents of corruption but the extent to which ings will show Uganda has worsened. He hands are tied too,” she said and pointed at
citizens think corruption takes place. Ugan- said even when the amended Leadership countries in the region that are beating cor-
da’s worsening perception figures could be Code Act comes into force in March, the ruption.
Kagaba says Museveni comes up with
Uganda’s CPI viz-a-viz East Africa region in the last five years new laws and amendments not to curb cor-
ruption but to make it hard for the big wigs
to be implicated. She said the amendment
Country 2017/ 180 2016/ 176 2015/ 168 2014/ 175 2013/ 177 of the Leadership Code Act last year weak-
countries countries countries countries countries
ranked ranked ranked ranked ranked ened it when they exempted spousal prop-
erties from being considered when auditing
Uganda 151 151 139 142 140 the assets of public officials.
She said the government would be recov-
Rwanda 48 50 43 55 49 ering big monies if legally established insti-
Tanzania 106 116 117 119 111 tutions like the IG, the Office of the Auditor
General, PPDA and the Anti-Corruption
Kenya 143 145 139 145 136 Court were allowed to conduct their man-
Burundi 157 159 150 159 157 dates independently and allocated enough
resources instead of setting up units with
South Sudan 179 175 163 171 173 unclear departments that duplicate respon-
sibilities and waste taxpayers’ money.

due to increased reports in the media influ- tribunals needed for it to bite have not been Beyond the big monies
encing perception. But the World Bank, formed. The IGG has been criticized for pursuing
in its 11th edition of the Uganda Economic According to the 2017 amendment, in small cases instead of going for the big wigs.
Update released in May, noted that because addition to key civil servants and Members But an official at the IG told The Independent
of endemic delays in implementation, cost of Parliament declaring their wealth in that it is a deliberate strategy because they
overruns and corruption, project costs in terms of buildings, companies, land and might never bring the big wigs to book.
Uganda tend to escalate or double. others, they will this time have to declare Instead, the IGG believes, it is important to
In the State of the Nation Address in their cash at hand from Shs5million and make people understand the true cost of
June, President Museveni said Uganda was above. But many are expected not to com- corruption so that they can report culprits
struggling economically partly because cor- ply. And the IGG is toothless without tribu- right from the grassroots. That strategy
rupt officials make it difficult for investors nals, according to a 2010 ruling by court in was behind this year’s anti-corruption day
to establish businesses. He said he knew the which former MP Ken Lukyamuzi defeated theme of `Winning the fight against corrup-
culprits and that he would expose and kick the IGG. Court ruled that the IGG had tion; a sustainable path to Uganda’s trans-
them out of office. thrown him out of parliament wrongly over formation”.
“What happened to the IGG? Why don’t failure to declare his wealth in 2005 because The official said that it is a mistake to
the victims of corruption report those inci- the IGG is not the tribunal. limit assessment of the cost of corruption on
dents to the office of the IGG? That was the “We will ask them to declare the money big monies and big names. Take the case of
purpose of that office; to protect the public but some will want to hide. How are we the recent tragedy on Lake Victoria where
from corrupt officials; to protect investors expected to verify that with utmost accu- over 30 lives were lost because someone
against corrupt officials. The IGG should racy? As you know Uganda is a cash econ- was allowing an unlicensed boat on the
reflect on this. Are her staff credible? Why omy. Big monies exchange hands without water or when a nurse gives a child half a
does the public not trust that institution? We signing any document or going to the bank. dose of vaccine so she can use one for two
need answers,” Museveni said. We don’t use credit cards,” the official said. children and sell the other. What are the
He said it is wrong for people to expect Kagaba of ACCU told The Independent on health outcomes and the life-long impact
money for every little task. Nov. 06 that Museveni’s pledge to pay legal that may have?
“We could not have liberated this country fees for then jailed Junior Health Minister

14 Dec. 14 - 20 2018
news analysis

Museveni’s plan for


BoU after COSASE
President will shake up central bank, insiders say
By Haggai Matsiko

W
hen the committee Justine Bagyenda, the former Executive (COSASE), recently put a similar question
investigating the central Director Banking Supervision (EDS). to Bagyenda as the committee grilled
bank over closed banks But the quizzing process will rope in the her over the sale of Global Trust Bank to
starts querying the process BoU Governor Tumusiime Mutebile, DFCU in 2014. Bagyenda fumbled and was
surrounding the sale of Crane Bank, one his deputy; Louis Kasekende, and pinned by Mutebile who was backed by
particular question will arise again: How others. Abdul Katuntu, the chairman of BoU Secretary Susan Kanyemibwa.
did you zero on dfcu Bank as the buyer? parliament’s committee on Commissions, Insiders say this is a ploy to expose BoU
The question will be directed at Statutory Authorities and State Enterprises officials for corruption, incompetence, and
ineptness or all three and more. And that it
has President Museveni’s nod.
The president’s plan is to let COSASE
strip bare BoU officials to a point where
they are beyond redemption in the eyes
of the public. The President is also doing
his bit. By hinting at where he prefers the
COSASE investigators to look.
During a recent Cabinet meeting,
sources tell The Independent, President
Museveni told his ministers that he tried
to advise BoU officials on how to deal with
the closure of Crane Bank and COSASE
but they ignored his advice claiming that
BoU is an independent body.
Museveni had come under pressure
by some ministers to end the public
undressing of COSASE in public. The
President was reportedly explaining that
he would not now attempt to block the
on-going investigation by COSASE even
amidst fears that the committee’s exercise
could severely erode BoU’s integrity and
hurt the economy.
But the President Museveni went a
step further during celebrations to mark
the 25th anniversary of Transparency
International Uganda (TIU) at Imperial
Royale Hotel in the capital Kampala on
Dec.04 when he listed BoU amongst the
most corrupt institutions.
“We have given enough time for
civil servants to expose themselves,”
Museveni said, “had we moved against
them, we would have been politically
isolated, people would have thought we
are persecuting them but I can tell you
today, the whole population is fed up with
these corrupt people. Civil servants can
no longer blackmail us politically that if
you touch me, people in my area will vote
against the NRM, no.”
The two actions are a break from the
President Museveni.  FILE PHOTO past when the President has sought to

Dec. 14 - 20 2018 15
news analysis

BoU Governor Tumusiime Mutebile at a Crane Bank branch before it was closed in 2016.

Abdu Katuntu.  FILE PHOTO Emmanuel Mutebile.  FILE PHOTO Justine Bagyenda.  FILE PHOTO

shield BoU from the kind of scrutiny and records on the transfer of assets, and Former Crane Bank proprietor, Sudhir
exposure that the institution currently records on sale of assets, among others, are Ruparelia and Secretary to the Treasury
faces. missing. Keith Muhakanizi are also named
In March this year, for instance, Because of this, many are looking for all amongst the top 29 biggest shareholders.
President Museveni warned officials at possible explanations. Some like President Muhakanizi sits on the board of BoU.
BoU and the Inspectorate of Government Yoweri Museveni have already pointed Until recently, the most controversial
(IGG) that he was tired of seeing BoU to corruption. And in the case of GTB transaction between BoU and dfcu has
matters in the press. and Crane Bank, some are pointing to the been over Crane Bank.
At the time, IGG Irene Mulyagonja was relationship between BoU and dfcu, which Tycoon Sudhir’s lawyers have described
pushing to start investigating BoU over bought these banks under controversial the deal between DFCU and BoU as a
a controversial February staff reshuffle. circumstances. “sweetheart” deal. They claim that BoU
President Museveni blocked her effort and When Katuntu asked Bagyenda how she blocked all other potential buyers and
instead appointed a committee consisting zeroed in on dfcu as the buyer for GTB, made sure dfcu bought it a paltry Shs 200
of some members of COSASE, some BoU the former EDS said that they looked at billion. Sudhir valued the bank at Shs. 1.3
board members and representatives from the potential of other banks. But given that trillion. dfcu then made a profit of Shs 127
the IGG’s office. President Museveni she admitted that there was no bidding billion in just a year of acquiring the bank.
directed the team to work quietly and process for the transaction, this response But in the latest case, COSASE has heard
make recommendations to him. did not fly. that BoU sold assets of Global Trust Bank
It speaks volumes that several months in even more controversial circumstances.
later, he now wants BoU officials to get BoU, dfcu bank links It emerged that Bagyenda disclosed the
even more exposed even if that might Other critics have pointed out that the financial situation of GTB to DFCU before
involve hurting the central bank and the fact that BoU staff are shareholders in the bank was closed.
entire economy. dfcu and that this could be the reason the Apparently, BoU entered a confidential
Indeed as COSASE’s investigation into bank got these deals. The Independent has purchase agreement to sell GTB to Dfcu
BoU’s closure and sale of seven defunct seen a copy of dfcu 2017 financial results. two weeks before Global Trust bank was
banks nears its end, this appears at the Among others, the document lists two BoU eventually closed on July 25, 2014.
heart of its current strategy. It has become retirement benefit schemes amongst the It also emerged that BoU does not
clear that while BoU can justify why it top shareholders of DFCU bank. These are; have the required documents for such
closed the seven banks, the manner in Bank of Uganda Staff Retirement Benefit transactions; including minutes of the
which it sold these banks is the biggest Scheme-SIMS and Bank of Uganda Staff negotiation of the sale, bidding documents
thorn in their flesh. Retirement Benefit Scheme-AIG. For or evaluation reports of the assets of GTB.
While appearing before the committee, some, this raises a question of conflict of Bagyenda told the committee that BoU did
BoU officials have severally failed to interest. not follow any procurement process.
explain how they arrived at who they The other Ugandan shareholders Apart from this, it also emerged that
sold to and cannot provide minutes for include; National Social Security Fund, Bagyenda single-handedly signed and
negotiations of the sales they made. In the Parliamentary Pension Scheme, Uganda witnessed the agreement.
case of some of the banks, the committee Revenue Authority Staff Retirement Benefit Bagyenda first told the committee that
has heard that the companies BoU dealt Scheme, Centenary Bank Staff Defined she had consulted with the respective
with have since disappeared in thin air, Contributory Scheme, Makerere University authorities before signing the agreement
and that critical documents regarding Retirement Benefit Scheme, and Crane but both central Bank Governor
the sale of some of the banks’ assets like Bank. Tumusiime Mutebile and BoU Board

16 Dec. 14 - 20 2018
news analysis
Secretary, Susan Kanyemibwa, denied Bagyenda to act single-handedly in selling He warned that if the matter was
having been aware of the decision. GTB. However, for critics, this does not not handled well, there would be
“I doubt that that’s the case,” Mutebile explain how she could sell a bank without consequences.
told the committee, “I want to know from Mutebile or the board’s knowledge and Up until this point, however, BoU still
Board Affairs if this matter was discussed approval. appeared on firm ground, according to
in the board meeting because that would Three years later, President Museveni insiders. But as is the case with GTB and
be where that authority could have been found himself in almost a similar situation other banks, the central bank appeared to
obtained.” this time over Crane Bank. falter when it came to selling Crane Bank.
Kanyemibwa responded that from In a meeting attended by tycoon BoU officials blocked several investors,
the minutes of the board for the period Sudhir Ruparelia and officials from Bank some of who met President Museveni in a
January 2014 to December 2014 before her, of Uganda (BoU), President Museveni bid to buy assets of Crane Bank.
the matter of the agreement being referred listened attentively as the central bank As all these scandals continue to emerge,
to was never discussed. accused Sudhir of fraud at Crane Bank. the questions many observers following
BoU revoked GTB’s licence in July Sudhir had also detailed how BoU’s the central bank saga is: how will President
2014 because of under-capitalisation and mistakes were to blame for the closure of Museveni deal with the bank’s leadership
corporate governance weaknesses. Crane Bank. crisis? Insiders say President Yoweri
The case of GTB is interesting because it Sudhir hoped the president would Museveni has toyed with the idea of firing
almost cost Bagyenda her job. When BoU restrain the central bank officials from the senior leadership, considered names
decided to close the bank, former Nigerian proceeding to sue him. On the other of potential successors, and even used
President General Yakubu Gowon, who hand, the central bank officials hoped the his handlers to guide the officials to step
had interests in the bank, visited Uganda. president would get Sudhir to submit down and make his work easier. As these
While here, he visited the President at to their demands or give them a nod to reports have continued to circulate and
State House Nakasero and told him that proceed with the suit. fuel speculation, President Museveni has
he had been capitalising the bank but the The central bank had launched a suit avoided publicly commenting about the
Central Bank had decided to close it. against Sudhir who it also accused of central bank saga.
President Museveni drove his car from But his recent comments about BoU
State House and came to Yakubu’s Hotel and his decision to let parliament’s
suite at Serena Hotel. While there, he committee continue grilling central bank
called Mutebile and Bagyenda to come to officials over the seven banks amidst
the Hotel. growing concerns this exercise is eroding
While at the meeting, President BoU integrity, might have lifted a lid on
Museveni told the officials what the his plan for BoU officials.
owner of the bank had told him. Mutebile Insiders say Museveni is now ready
tried to explain but the president was so to pounce on BoU officials since they
angry, he could not let him explain. have been exposed publicly. According
Mutebile kept quiet. When Bagyenda to this version, this is a trick in the
also tried to explain, Museveni cut President’s book that he has explained
her off and called her the enemy of using an analogy of a disease that makes
development. He said he was going to a person’s mouth stink.
fire them for what they had done. In the president’s local language—
Unhappy with how they had been Sudhir Ruparelia Louis Kasekende Runyankore—the disease is called
treated by the president, Mutebile and ‘omuhembe’. The president has in
Bagyenda, decided to resign before the the past reportedly told those close to
president could fire them. him that when a person close to you is
Insiders say that Bagyenda had already breaching a March 20 agreement that suffering from this problem—omuhembe–,
typed out and signed her resignation offered the tycoon immunity from you do not chase them right away.
letter. However, before she could resign, prosecution as long as he paid BoU some $ Instead, you first let the mouth stink for
the president was presented with new 60 million to cover for the losses allegedly everybody else such that by the time you
evidence from among others a Ugandan registered under Crane Bank. act, everybody is wondering what took
investor who was working closely with the In countering, Sudhir said he had you so long.
GTB owner. met his end of the bargain as per that The President has used this approach
The Nigerian co-owned NiC, GTB agreement by paying BoU some $8 million to fire former Prime Minister Amama
and an insurance company in Rwanda. and giving them some 32 properties. But, Mbabazi, who he did not fire until there
It turned out that he was in the habit he said, rather than also meet their end, was a near revolt against him over his
of moving money around the three BoU was now threatening to sue him. management of the ruling party secretariat.
companies whenever the regulators of “ But isn’t your role to ensure a healthy President Museveni also used it with
these sectors raised concerns. financial sector and that businesses grow?” for Police Chief Kale Kayihura. He started
Officials at the Central Bank were armed Museveni asked the BoU camp at some publicly talking about how Kayihura had
with data showing that he had only been point, “So if that is your role, why don’t allowed criminals to infiltrate the police.
compliant six times out of eighteen. When you find a way to resolve this?” Indeed, by the time he fired Kayihura,
this data was presented to the president, In response, BoU officials reiterated the the police chief’s image had been badly
he was convinced. The meeting took fraud allegations against Sudhir like how tarnished by failures or the crisis in police.
place at the State Lodge in Fort Portal. he had allegedly extracted $ 80 million President Museveni also applied the
For a number of times, Bagyenda would from the bank. same on Lt.Gen. Henry Tumukunde. He
go to the president’s seat, kneel and the As the two sided argued, President kept Tumukunde on the job until days
president would say; “now you are my Museveni got frustrated and said that before he fired him; he was being avoided
friend”. in Runyankole they say that when two by among others the Presidents handlers
Insiders say this could have emboldened parties fail to agree, they are left to fight. for being too controversial.

Dec. 14 - 20 2018 17
news analysis

GMO law
fight not over
Civil society excited but frustrated
scientists pin hope on Museveni
By Ronald Musoke

U
gandan civil society is
celebrating a new law
that seeks to regulate the
development and application
of biotechnology. But it is cautious
celebration – until President Yoweri
Museveni signs it into law.
The objective of the new regulatory
framework is to ensure safe
development and application of
biotechnology. It will regulate research,
development and general release of
the controversial Genetically Modified
Organisms (GMOs).
Parliament passed the law on
Nov. 28 and on Dec.03, civil society
organisations, farmers’ organisations,
faith-based, women and trade policy
organisations, consumer groups and
environmentalists issued a joint
communiqué praising Parliament “for
addressing their long standing concerns
in the Bill.”
The Bill, which started out six years
ago as the National Biotechnology and
Bio-safety Bill, 2012 and was passed
on October 04, 2017, as the Bio-safety
Bill, 2017, had just jumped over another
hurdle; imposed by President Yoweri
Museveni who declined to assent to
it until the legislators included a slew
of additional safeguards and a name
change. The passed form is now called
the Genetic Engineering Regulatory Bill,
2018.
Actually, the civil society consortium
was celebrating the inclusion in the new
law of several aspects that its framers
had initially rejected but which are
now included; some on Museveni’s
insistence.
The civil society consortium says the
previous bill threatened people’s right
to food, right to a clean environment,
sustainable development, sustainable
diets and biodiversity of crop, animal,
fisheries and insects and the growing
economic market potential of organic
products in the global market.
In a letter to the Speaker of
A Ugandan farmer harvests a bunch of bananas on his farm. The new genetic engineering law seeks
Parliament, Rebecca Kadaga, on to protect local farmers like him from the proliferation of GMO technology.   COURTESY PHOTO
18 Dec. 14 - 20 2018
news analysis
December 21, 2017, Museveni insisted farming practices has also been
on a change in the Bill’s title, patent included in the law. It essentially
rights on indigenous farming products, notes that a person who cultivates any
and sanctions for scientists who mix GMO shall prevent contamination
GMOs with indigenous crops and or co-mingling of GMO crop with
animals. indigenous crops.
Agnes Kirabo, the executive director Also, any person who keeps or
of Food Rights Alliance, a Kampala- owns genetically modified livestock
based non-profit, told The Independent shall prevent cross breeding between
on Dec. 07 that the current version of genetically modified and non-
the law is a much better one than the genetically modified livestock.
one which President Museveni rejected Finally, a provision that provides
in December, last year. for an independent board known as
“We know that biotechnology the “National Genetic Engineering
is a risky science and all along we Council” which will be housed at
have been negotiating with our the discretion of the president has
science friends telling them that this also been welcomed since it ensures
technology is hazardous and they have that promoters of GMOs are not the
been responding saying we just have a same people who will regulate the
phobia for science.” development of genetic engineering in
“We needed safeguards and the country.
a redress mechanism such that Lawrence Akugizibwe, the vice
Ugandans are aware that whoever is chairperson of the Committee on
doing these things is going to be held Agriculture, Animal Husbandry
accountable in case anything goes and Fisheries in Parliament told The
wrong.” Independent on Dec. 06 that the new
Charles Ogang, the immediate law is meant to protect the country
former president of the Uganda from irresponsible introduction, use,
National Farmers Federation (UNFF) and production of GMO products.
told The Independent that the passing Lee Denis Oguze, the MP for
of the bill in the new form is good Maracha County in northwestern
news because Ugandan farmers need Uganda sat on the Science and
a law that protects them from getting Technology Committee that drafted the
exposed to GMO products. law which the president rejected last
Some of the critical clauses in the December.
law include the liability and redress Oguze who is now the Shadow
mechanism clauses which stipulate Minister of Science, Innovation and
that the advancement of modern Communication Technology wrote
biotechnology requires a precautionary a minority report opposing it. On
approach in addressing safety issues. Dec.05, he told The Independent that he
Within it is the strict liability provision is happy because President Museveni
which places legal liability on whoever possibly considered his minority
introduces a GMO product for any report in rejecting it.
damage caused as a result of the Oguze says he was mainly
product or process of developing it. concerned that in Africa, farmers
The new law also covers “benefit have for thousands of years depended
sharing” which seeks to protects the on inherited seed yet biotechnology
rights of the communities because, is capable of wiping out all the
the civil society say, Africa is facing indigenous seeds.
an onslaught of GMO developers “Biotechnology is a selfish
who take indigenous seed and patent technology in the sense that it goes
them without recognizing the rights of against the social norms of Africans
farmers. who believe in sharing,” he said.
Civil society is also happy with the
clause that calls for a comprehensive Sad Ugandan scientists
labelling and liability traceability But just like the law passed in
system. This clause demands the October, last year, left civil society
promoter of GMO products to label bitter; this one has also unsettled many
them sufficiently; including their scientists who over the last 20 years
relevant traits and characteristics to have been engaging in crop and animal
enable traceability. improvement research and have
All genetically engineered material always felt handicapped by a lack of an
will also have to be labelled with enabling law to test their innovations.
the phrase: “Contains genetically For years, they have been conducting
engineered material,” to help confined field trials on bananas, maize,
consumers exercise their right to cotton, potatoes and rice at Namulonge
choose products free from GMOs. and Kawanda research institutes with
A provision on co-existence of the hope that an enabling law would

Dec. 14 - 20 2018 19
news analysis
help Uganda join the four African can step up food production besides as provided for by the Cartagena
countries—Egypt, South Africa, the conventional and indigenous Protocol.”
Burkina Faso and Sudan—where the methods if we are to cope with the food
growing of genetically engineered demands in the country.” Cautious optimism
crops is legal. Arthur Makara, the Commissioner Meanwhile, Kirabo says much as
But, according to Clet Wandui in charge of Science Advancement and they have succeeded in having the
Masiga, a conservation biologist and Outreach at the Ministry of Science, safeguard clauses in the law, until the
geneticist, the law in its current form Technology and Innovation told president assents to the law, nothing is
might constrain Ugandan scientists. The Independent on Dec. 07 that he is guaranteed.
Masiga, a GMO developer, promoter unhappy with the strict liability clause. “We know that a lot of politics
and advocate, has been deeply Like many other scientists The happens in between Parliament up to
involved in cobbling the GMO law and Independent has spoken to, he says the point when the law is gazetted,”
he wanted one that clearly liberates this clause might end up acting as a she says, “We have experience where
scientists. deterrent to innovation in the country things are agreed on the floor of
He says he has reviewed GMO because, “a researcher is already Parliament and by the time the actual
laws and associated regulations in 45 declared guilty even before any Act is gazetted, some of the clauses
countries and, therefore, he says he investigation is done.” have been thrown out of the window.”
has good knowledge of what a good Makara hopes President Museveni “At the moment, we believe it is a
biotechnology law is and what a bad will again seek legal advice on these very good step forward because this
law could be. clauses that are likely to curtail law has a strict liability and redress
“We, at the moment, are trying to innovation in Uganda. mechanism.”
have a legal understanding of what Kirabo insists that if she had
this entire law means,” he told The an option, she would convince
Independent. Ugandans not to open the
But according to him, a good law is biotechnology door.
one which regulates the industry; “it “We don’t have institutions;
does not seek to promote and it does we don’t have systems or ethics
not constrain it.” in the country,” she says, “We
He adds: “In countries that have insist that this technology is
strict liability clauses, you will never risky and it puts our farming
find GMO work taking place, not even system and economy at risk.”
research”. Kirabo also thinks Uganda is
He told The Independent that the law missing out on the opportunity
which the president rejected was a of cutting out a niche as an
much better version because it neither organic food-exporting country
promoted nor stopped the science; all in the world.
that was needed was to try to clarify a She says around the globe,
few issues that the president raised in President Museveni Agnes Kirabo countries have consolidated
his letter. their niches and considering
“What happened is that some that Ugandan organic food has
people misunderstood the letter and Phillip Chemonges, the national been selling at a premium in Europe,
instead saw it as an opportunity to add coordinator of the Open Forum on North America and Japan, this should
incriminating clauses.” Agricultural Biotechnology in Africa have been an opportunity for the
Dr. Michael Ssekaayi Mbogga, a (OFAB) told The Independent that if government.
lecturer at the College of Agricultural President Museveni goes ahead to sign “The rich economies have
and Environmental Sciences at this Bill in its present form, it will be demonstrated that they are capable of
Makerere University told The “unfortunate.” buying our food at a premium; this is
Independent that it is also wrong to “Uganda wants a law that regulates something we needed to consolidate,”
reduce biotechnology to agriculture the science but unfortunately we have she says.
practices. “It is more than that,” he some people whose intent is to ban this Kirabo also quickly dismisses the
said, “We could use biotechnology to science,” he says, “The entire Bill apart idea that biotechnology is meant to
treat, for instance, diseases like Sickle from some clauses which are key have save the country from the ever rising
cell anaemia.” been hijacked by people who strongly incidents of hunger. She says Uganda
Dr. Ssekaayi says it is high time think the country should not have these does not have a problem of food
the country reclaimed its position in biotechnology innovations.” insecurity; instead, it has a challenge of
biotechnology research which it held But Dr. Giregon Olupot, a lecturer managing the food system.
20 years ago but seems to have lost in the College of Agricultural and “It would be interesting to find
thanks to the damaging debate that Environmental Sciences at Makerere out why most of the bumper maize
has polarized scientists, politicians, University told The Independent harvest the country registered has been
civil society and the public over the six that he is neither for nor against allowed to rot yet just months ago,
years. biotechnology. He only wants Uganda the government was asking for help
Ogang also told The Independent that to tow the precautionary line. to stem a food crisis,” Kirabo told The
Ugandans should look at biotechnology “Our only problem is that by the Independent, “If we get hungry in the
with favour because the country’s time we rose up, the kind of law in next couple of months, are we going to
food production techniques are not place was not meant to regulate but to claim that it is because we don’t have
keeping pace with the rapidly growing facilitate the proliferation of GMOs,” GM technology?”
population. he told The Independent, “I am for
“We need to look at how best we a law that regulates biotechnology

20 Dec. 14 - 20 2018
obituary

Business and motor rally ace


Charles Muhangi dies at 61
By Ian Katusiime trading under the name Hori-
zon Coaches. He had grown
Two things stood out the number of buses to over
in the life of Charles 20 by the early 1990s. Horizon
Muhangi; doing business Coaches were plying the Kam-
and motor racing. He pala- Kabale route and ventur-
developed a love for fast ing as far as Kigali, Rwanda
and Bujumbura in Burundi.
cars as his business was So he was an established busi-
growing. Muhangi under- nessman by the time he joined
stood the dynamic world motorsport in the mid-1990s
of business since he had and the Horizon Coaches brand
ventured into trade as a would always be emblazoned
on his racing Subaru.
young man in the turbu-
lent 1970s. Twenty years Business rivalry
later, he was dabbling in At the time of death,
motorsport when it was at Muhangi was embroiled in
the peak of its popularity ownership wrangles over busi-
in Uganda. ness properties in the city. He
was battling two prominent

T
businessmen Drake Lubega
hat was the era of the and Mansur Matovu over
motoring big names like ownership of prime property;
Karim Hirji, Chipper Qualicel Bus Terminal, Qualicel
Adams, Charlie Lubega, building, and Nabukera Plaza,
Emma Katto, and Moses in the city centre. The court
Lumala. Muhangi soon showed had given him reprieve a few
that he was not afraid to make months ago when it ruled in his
bold moves even in an already an opportunity to be part of the turbo charged cars in regional favour.
dare devil sport. He famously action. championship rallies. Then matters escalated
cruised to many podium fin- “At the time only Karim’s Muhangi was mulling a when a number of buildings
ishes in his favourite Subaru (Hirji) car was available,” comeback as is wont with many were closed over tensions in
Impreza 555 that he branded says Yusuf Yiga, a motorsport sports figures, by the time he November as Muhangi moved
‘Ekitaguriro’. But his first major driver whose father Wycliffe was found dead at his home in in to enforce his claim. There
break was when he won his Bukenya was a contemporary Buziga, a residential suburb in was heavy police deployment
first major title; the National of Muhangi in the sport. “And Kampala. and business was paralysed.
Rally Championship in 1998. Muhangi liked Subarus.” Business appears to have President Museveni was also
He went on to win the Africa When news broke on Dec.06 been in his blood. He was born involved in mediating the con-
Rally Championship (ARC) in that Muhangi was dead, Hirji into a business family Septem- flict.
1999 - a record he still holds as recalled those days in his ber 20, 1957 in Bushenyi. His “Those men should just sur-
the only Ugandan driver who eulogy. father was a trader who owned render as quickly as possible
has won it. He was also the first “He was my good friend. We trucks and earned from trans- because if they don’t quit, their
black African to claim the title. met as rally drivers,” Hirji said, port dealings. Unfortunately destination is Luzira prison. I
Still, some were taken back “I even sold him a car.” Muhangi’s father was killed in have suffered with them going
when he made a splash on a Hirji added that to those who the clashes of 1972 when forces through court for 13 years.
rally car; a Subaru, he bought watched motorsport in its hey- of then President Idi Amin, I defeated them in the High
from fellow businessman and days, Muhangi exhibited a rare repulsed a group of Ugandan Court, the Court of Appeal and
rally star Karim Hirji in 2000. A poise behind the wheels and exiles who had attacked from also in the Supreme Court,”
national championship event described how the Ekitaguriro Tanzania with the intention of Muhangi was quoted by Daily
was drawing close and his charmed motor rally enthusi- capturing Mbarara. Monitor last month. But the
Ekitaguriro had broken down. asts whenever and wherever it Muhangi then at St Mary’s tension was not yet over by
The spare parts he had ordered made rounds. College Rushoroza followed in the time Muhangi breathed his
were delaying to come into Muhangi, however, quit his father’s footsteps and joined last. According to Muhangi’s
the country and some people regular racing in 2003 when business. From the 1970s when mother, Angella Rwankore, the
thought he would lie low. But a resolution by FIA; a global he joined business, he concen- former rally ace left behind a
Muhangi was not one to allow organisation that promotes trated on the transport sector wife and seven children.
such mishaps make him miss safety in motorsport, banned and by 1984 he had two buses

Dec. 14 - 20 2018 21
feature

Parenting styles across cultures shape the behavior and personality of children.

I’m because I’m from here


How where you’re born influences the person you become
By Samuel Putnam & Masha A. Gartstein values influences the choices parents Southern Europe.

A
make – and how this, in turn, influences Recently, we were able to trace some of
s early as the fifth century, the who their kids become. these differences to early childhood.
Greek historian Thucydides The enduring influence of cultural Parenting – perhaps not surprisingly –
contrasted the self-control values played a role.
and stoicism of Spartans with Although genetics certainly matter, the To conduct the research for our book,
the more indulgent and free-thinking way you behave is not hardwired. we worked with colleagues from 14
citizens of Athens. Over the past two decades, researchers different countries. Our goal was to
Today, unique behaviors and have shown how culture can shape your explore the way broad societal values
characteristics seem ingrained in certain personality. influenced how parents raise their
cultures. In 2005, psychologist Robert McCrae children. We then studied how these
Italians wildly gesticulate when and his colleagues were able to different parenting styles shaped the
they talk. Dutch children are notably document pronounced differences in behavior and personality of kids.
easygoing and less fussy. Russians rarely the personalities of people living in We did this primarily by administering
smile in public. different parts of the world. For example, questionnaires to parents around the
As developmental psychologists, we adults from European cultures tended world, asking them to describe their
are fascinated by these differences, how to be more outgoing and open to new daily routines, hopes for their kids and
they take shape and how they get passed experiences than those from Asian methods of discipline. We then asked
along from one generation to the next. cultures. Within Europe, they found them to detail the behaviors of their
Our new book, `Toddlers, Parents and that people from Northern Europe were children.
Culture’, explores the way a society’s more conscientious than their peers in We also relied on the work of Dutch

22 Dec. 14 - 20 2018
feature
Free to pursue happiness?
A second set of values we studied was
indulgence versus restraint.
Some cultures, such as the U.S.,
Mexico and Chile, tend to permit and
promote self-gratification. Others –
like South Korea, Belgium and Russia
– encourage restraint in the face of
temptation.
These values seem to be connected to
a specific set of parenting goals.
In particular, parents in indulgent
societies tend to emphasise the
importance of developing self-esteem
and independence. For example, they
expect children to entertain themselves
and fall asleep on their own. When
one of their kids misbehaves, they’ll
often suggest ways he or she can make
amends and try to repair the damage.
The message kids may get from this
kind of treatment is that they’re the
ones in control of their happiness, and
that they should be able to fix their own
mistakes. At the same time, when kids
are expected to pursue gratification,
they may be more likely to impulsively
seek immediate rewards – whether it’s
eating candy before dinner or grabbing a
toy off a shelf at a store – before getting
permission.
Meanwhile, in societies that prioritise
restraint, parents were more likely to
shout or swear when disciplining their
children.
This might make them more obedient.
But it might also cause children to be
less optimistic and less likely to enjoy
social psychologist Geert Hofstede, South Korea and Chile, high value is themselves.
who, in the 1970s, asked IBM employees placed on the well-being of the larger
around the world about factors that led group – typically their family, but also Is individualism the future?
to work satisfaction. their workplace or country. Parents seem to be motivated to best
We were able to compare his findings We found that the way parents prepare their kids for the world they’re
to ours, and we were surprised to see discipline their children is strongly likely to inhabit, and what works in one
that his results correlated with our own. influenced by these social values, and culture might not necessarily work well
The cultural values that were revealed likely serves to perpetuate these values in another.
through work preferences in the 1970s from one generation to the next. But as our world becomes more
could be seen in parenting practices and For example, compared to parents interconnected, this diversity of
child temperament 40 years later. in individualist cultures, collectivist parenting approaches may dwindle. In
This is important: It shows cultural parents are much more likely, when fact, most countries have become more
values are relatively enduring, and seem reprimanding their kids, to direct them individualistic over the last 50 years – a
to have an effect on how kids develop to “think about” their misbehavior, and shift that’s most pronounced in countries
over time. how it might negatively impact those that have experienced the most economic
around them. development.
To think about yourself, or to think This seems to promote group harmony Nonetheless, there’s still a huge
of others? and prepare a child to thrive in a difference in parenting styles and
collectivist society. At the same time, childhood development across cultures –
Perhaps the most well-known of these if you’re constantly being told to think a testament to the enduring influence of
broad cultural values are individualism about how your actions impact others, societal values.
and collectivism. you might also be more likely to feel
In some societies, such as the U.S. and anxiety, guilt and shame.
Netherlands, people are largely driven Indeed, we’ve found that kids in Samuel Putnam is Professor of Psychology,
by pursuits that benefit themselves. collectivist cultures tend to express Bowdoin College and Masha A. Gartstein is
They’re expected to seek personal higher levels of sadness, fear and Professor of Psychology, Washington State
recognition and boost their own social or discomfort than children growing up in University
financial status. individualist societies. Source: theconversation
In more collectivist societies, such as

Dec. 14 - 20 2018 23
Coca Cola production line at CCBA Uganda   Courtesy/ Photo.

Coke unveils sugar-free soda


By Isaac Khisa the 12th year in a row, according to Bever- from the previous year, but sales surpassed

C
age Digest as demand was hit by consumers expectations.
oca-Cola Beverage Africa has choosing healthier options and a slew of The company said its volume grew 2%,
expanded its sugar-free drink in sugar taxes aimed at stemming lifestyle- driven in part by double-digit growth for
the Ugandan market as it seeks related diseases. Coca-Cola Zero Sugar. Its water and sports
to tap into the increasing health- The per capita consumption of soda drinks grew 4 %.
consciousness consumers. drinks, including energy drinks, fell to
The company says it has unveiled Stoney about 154 litres servings during the year, the Status of Uganda’s soda consumption
Zero Sugar, Fanta Zero Sugar, Coca Cola lowest level since 1985 when the Beverage Kaheru said though soda consumption is
Zero Sugar and Sprite Zero Sugar as well Digest began tracking consumption trends. no luxury to the local population due to the
as a wide range of Spar-lettas with reduced This situation triggered the US-headquar- growing middle class it has caused changes
sugar quantities on the market. tered beverage company to embrace pro- in consumer behaviour.
“The major driver (for product diversi- duction of low-sugar soda varieties across He said more consumers are now more
fication) is the changing consumer habits, the globe starting with Coca Cola Zero informed and more health conscious and as
tastes and preferences...(and) the increased Sugar in the U.K. in 2016 and later the rest such are now opting for less sugary drinks.
consciousness of health – and that is why of the world. “So far, these (sugar free) drinks have
we present more healthy options for the Last year, the company unveiled the soda been very well-received by our soda con-
more health-conscious consumer to choose brand as “Coca-Cola No Sugar” but had sumers – because they know what they
from when they need refreshment,” Simon trouble gaining initial acceptance. Despite want and express their happiness if we give
Kahereu, the Corporate Affairs Director at that, the company went ahead with a them what they want,” he said.
CCBA Uganda told The Independent in an rebrand from Coke Zero to Coca Cola No “We will see even more activity towards
email. Sugar. consumption during the months ahead as
Coca cola has since this year increased However, in New Zealand, reports indi- we roll out more innovations – not just in
momentum on product diversification cate that there are no plans to phase out the the soda category but with water, juice and
including milk production known as Climb original Coca-Cola Zero formula, and that nutritional drinks as well.”
Up, Fuze Tea and a cocktail of juices. it will co-exist on the market alongside the
This development is in response to the reformulation, which is marketed under the Coca Cola’s new product portfolio
12-years of declining company sales of full name Coca-Cola No Sugar.
calorie soda worldwide as the population These new developments have seen Coca Fuze Tea in two variants –
become more health conscious and switches Cola record a slight growth in revenue. The Apple & Lemongrass flavoured
to drinking water instead. company, for instance, recorded second- Sprite Zero Sugar
Also, a number of countries including quarter earnings and revenue that beat Stoney Zero Sugar
U.K., U.S. and South Africa have imposed analysts’ expectations in July this year, bol- Spar-Letta range –
taxes on the beverage to reduce consump- stered by its efforts to bring its diet drinks Climb Up milk
tion on sugar and raise revenue that can be on the market.
Schweppes Dark Malt
used to prevent and control diabetes, obe- Coca Cola recorded a net income of
sity and other non-communicable diseases. $2.32 billion up from earnings of $1.37 bil- Minute Maid ‘Pulpy’ Orange
For instance, sales of soda drinks lion, during the same quarter a year ago. Fanta Zero Sugar
dropped 1.2 % in the U.S. in 2016, falling for However, its revenue fell 8% to $8.9 billion Schweppes +C

24 Dec. 14 - 20 2018
business

Uganda’s horticulture
By Patricia Akankwatsa

U
ganda’s horticulture sector re-
mains one of the top earners for

exports risk ban


the East African nation but the
recent European Union (EU)
warning over quality related issues could
hurt the sector if it is not addressed.
Paul Mwambu, the Commissioner for
Crop Inspection and Certification at the Stakeholders blame absence of
Ministry of Agriculture, Animal Industry
and Fisheries, told The Independent in an
interview that most of the country’s hor-
regulation for low quality products
ticulture products are falling short of the
EU recommended standards and thus risk “We have weak authorities. They know cultural College said the government needs to
being denied access to the 27-nation market. the problem but they not tackling it,” he create awareness especially about danger of
He said EU’s concerns revolve around said. poor quality as well as carry out research on
presence of pests, poor storage, packag- He said the EU wrote to the Ugandan high quality agricultural products.
ing and high levels of unwanted pesticide government giving it a number of options
residues. but the government has not put any of the Some of the EU requirements for
Uganda’s horticulture exports mainly options in place. horticulture export
to the EU have been growing over the
past years, with the flower export vol-  Fruits and vegetables exported to the
umes increasing from 6,047 million tonnes EU must comply with the European
worth US$52.99million in the financial legislation on plant health. The EU has
year 2012/13 to 7,191 million tonnes worth laid down phytosanitary requirements
US$61.88million. to prevent the introduction and spread
Similarly, the volume of vegetable and of harmful organisms (pests) to plants
fruit exports have increased from 16.5mil- and plant products in Europe. These
lion tonnes worth US$16million to 135.2 requirements are managed by the
million tonnes worth US$45million during competent food safety authorities in the
the same period under review. importing and exporting countries.
This is the second time that the EU is  The European legislation sets general
issuing a warning over horticultural exports and specific marketing standards for
in three years. In 2015, several EU member the minimum quality and minimum
countries raised a red flag on Ugandan maturity of all fresh fruits and vegeta-
products due to poor standards and exces- bles. A market standard determines the
sive chemicals. characteristics of “Extra class”, “Class
This prompted the Minister for Trade, I” and “Class II” products, the different
Industry and Cooperatives, Amelia Kyam- size codes and the allowed tolerances in
badde, to ban a section of horticultural quality size. The sizes vary between dif-
products including hot pepper for a month ferent European markets but the quality
to address the issue. is generally, “Extra class” or Class I.
This was followed up with the setting up  Packaging marketed within Europe
a technical team to train Ugandan farmers What needs to be done? must comply with the general require-
on quality compliance and pest control. Going forward, Biziirah says the govern- ments which aim at protecting the envi-
ment should give exporters loans to enable ronment, as well as with the specific
Exporters speak out them afford costs of laboratory testing. provisions designed to prevent any
Benon Biziirah, the quality manager of But Henry Kimera, the team leader at the risk to the health of the consumers. The
FFP Uganda Ltd, which exports mainly Consumer Education Trust, wants parlia- packaging must protect the product
hot pepper to the EU told The Independent ment to pass new laws that among others from contamination, leakage, and dehy-
that government’s failure to enact stringent will ensure production of high quality dration.
regulations on who and how to export is agricultural products through registration  To avoid health and environmental
to blame for the persistence of poor quality of all agro-chemical producing companies, risks, the EU has set maximum
products and exports. food safety and consumer protection. residue levels for pesticides. Products
“You hear that an individual is exporting He said exporting low quality horticul- containing more pesticides than
a fresh fruit and vegetable but you can’t ture products has been worsened as traders allowed will be withdrawn from the
even locate their address,” he said. “The shun buying their products from organised European market.
industry is basically too open, many export- farmers in favour of middle men.  The EU has set limits for several
ers are not registered.” “These Bills have been there for a long contaminants. Contaminants are
He said the high costs for testing residue time but are not being passed in parlia- substances that have not been added to
levels in the crops has also contributed to ment,” he said. food intentionally but may be present
the mess. “We normally tell producers and farmers as a result of various stages of its
James Kanyije, the CEO of KK Foods, to come and report about counterfeit prod- production, packaging, transportation
an exporter of fresh fruits and vegetables, ucts but how can you report to a system and and holding. For most fresh fruits
re-echoed Biziirah’s view saying the gov- institution that is weak?” he wondered. and vegetables, the limit for lead
ernment is yet to come up with strong Anna Anyango of Bukalasa, the head of contamination is 01.10mg/kg.
regulation. Department Human Nutrition at Bukalasa Agri-

Dec. 14 - 20 2018 25
business

By Julius Businge
There is an opportunity for private
sector players to invest in Uganda’s
power sector as government
moves to connect more people to
the national grid.

Z
iria Tibalwa Waako, the Chief
Executive Officer at the Electricity
Regulatory Authority told The
Independent on the sidelines of a
two-day symposium organised by ERA
at Imperial Resort Beach Hotel on Dec.5-
7, that the government is considering
the possibility of investing up to US$4bn
(Shs14.8tn) in the electricity transmission Muloni (on the right) talking to Kiwanuka during the symposium.   INDEPENDENT/JULIUS BUSINGE
network and up to US$1.7bn (Shs6.3tn)

US$5.7bn power
in the distribution network for the period
2018-2027.
She said part of this money will be
invested in the form of public-private

sector opportunity
partnerships as demand for electricity
increases.
At the moment, the electricity network
serves 1.2million customers, up from
merely 756,577 customers, three years
ago. yet Vision 2040 demands that everyone South sub-station, Luzira sub-station,
Tibalwa also revealed that there is must have access to modern energy.” Iganga and Mukono are ongoing.
an opportunity in the sector for those She said engagements of such nature Also several transmission lines have
interested in investing in solar home were important for sharing knowledge and been earmarked to support efforts of
systems as well as mini-grids. The move expertise to achieve sustainable, modern, evacuation of power. These include
is to boost electricity generation that reliable and affordable electricity for the Tororo-Opuyo-Lira 132Kv, Mbarara-
currently stands at about 950MW. population. Nkenda 132Kv, Bujagali-Tororo – Lessos
ERA’s Communication Manager, Muloni told participants that power 220Kv, Karuma-Kawanda 400Kv,
Julius Wandera, said it is time for the connectivity and reliability is important GuluAgago 132kv, Lira-Gulu-Nebbi
local population to reap from the new for meeting sustainable development 132kv, Masaka-Mbarara 400Kv among
initiative through supply of electricity goals regarding health, water, education, others.
poles and related materials in the network food, poverty reduction as well as
expansion. industrialization for the country’s The future
Themed “Accelerating Access to development agenda. Tibalwa said more electricity plants
affordable and Reliable Electricity She said the government is on course are expected to be commissioned with
Supply”, the symposium was part of the to implement the President Yoweri 242MW and 640MW by end of 2018 and
ERA’s regular consultation process and Museveni’s directive of offering US$5 cents 2019 respectively.
information sharing on pertinent issues as tariff to boost industrial growth. She said large hydro power plants
in the electricity supply industry with key Already in July this year, government generates 68% of the country’s electricity
stakeholders. reduced the tariff for the extra-large generation, with thermal power and
The symposium attracted around 10 industrial consumers by 15% with the off- co-generation contribution 11% each
Members of Parliament from the Natural peak tariff reducing to US cents 5/kWh. respectively. Small hydropower and
Resources Committee, executives from With more power coming onboard, solar plants account for 8% and 2%,
power distributor, Umeme, Uganda Muloni said that the overall tariff is respectively.
Electricity Transmission Company expected to reduce through free power She added that 18 more projects are
Limited and Uganda Manufacturers connection policy by government, waiving currently under feasibility study and that
Association. import duty on electric equipment, foreign 2800MW are to be commissioned by 2024.
currency hedging and fast-tracking of rural Going forward, she said by 2040,
Enter minister Muloni electrification through electrification of the electricity generation is expected to
Irene Muloni, the minister for Energy 491 Sub-counties. be 41,738MW, electricity per capita
and Mineral Development,said it is time She also said that upgrading and consumption 3,668kWh and national grid
for the players in the energy sector to seize extending of high voltage interconnections access over 80%.
opportunities available. within the East African region for power In the short term (National
“We have to keep our eyes on the ball trade purposes will come in handy. In Development Plan II 2019/2020), power
because demand for electricity is growing,” addition, 25 industrial parks have been generation is expected to be 2,500MW,
she said. earmarked for development to increase on national electricity access 30% and
“Access to electricity is at 23% meaning the power demand. electricity per capita of 578kWh up from
that 78% of the population has no access For instance, electrification of Namanve the current 215kWh.

26 Dec. 14 - 20 2018
Executive Style

NSSF to focus on stalled projects


What do you make of this growing the economy. We are

I
new development? part of the private sector and
t is gratifying to see that believe we are doing a very
six out of the nine direc- good job.
tors from the 10th Board
have been reappointed Now that the liberalisation
to serve on the 11-Board. To bill was withdrawn from Par-
me this is a confidence vote liament and there are plans
and indeed a testimony that to amend the NSSF Act to in-
the minister found our per- corporate the earlier proposed
formance satisfactory. sector reforms…what does
this mean to you?
What is your general as- True the bill was withdrawn
sessment of the three years because we argued to govern-
that you have served as ment that NSSF was doing a
BOD chair for the slightly good job and it is a national
over Shs10trillion Fund? institution. When we get prof-
We delivered on its and surplus it is distributed
most of our promises. internally. If you bring the
The Fund grew by 79% ‘guys’ from out they will get
from Shs5.5trillion in the the money here and take it
financial year 2014/15 to out. At cabinet level govern-
Shs9.98trillion in the finan- ment decided that NSSF stays.
cial year 2017/18.In terms of I think they are making a
staff recruitment and reten- separate law to ensure there is
tion, the Fund witnessed Patrick Byabakama Kaberenge, a seasoned banker a special and similar arrange-
stability under our tenure. and retired auditor has been re-appointed as the 11th ment to the one of NSSF
We recruited competent Chairman Board of Directors for the National Social regarding the about half a mil-
and experienced top man- Security Fund. His new contract, alongside other lion public sector employees.
agement who have deliv- nine members runs for the next three years. The According to URBRA and the
ered impressive results over laws we are operating under,
the years. Our emphasis on Independent’s Julius Businge spoke to him upon we can only invest in the East
merit-based recruitment getting a new term in Kampala on Dec.04. African region and our wish
has permeated the Fund, as is to allow us invest further
evidenced by consistently like in South Africa, America
good performance through- the highest interest rate of 15% that will be better. However, and UK. However, the govern-
out the Fund. As a Board, we declared for the last financial if they find difficulty to pay ment’s idea is keep the money
have supported and rewarded year was paid to members dur- us back, then, we will see near because we are short of
good performance and pro- ing the stewardship of the 10th what follows. We don’t want capital.
moted harmony at all levels Board. It is therefore no sur- them pressured and getting
in the Fund. Staff satisfaction prise that customer satisfaction them liquidated. Actually, it is What are the projections for
index has also improved from ratings currently stand at 85%. Uganda Clays that is going to the next three years?
84.3% in FY2015/16 to 90% in benefit from our stalled proj- We will continue to focus on
the FY2017/18. On real estate What is your urgent next ects because they are the ones growing our balance sheet size
development, a number of move? going to supply us with some to Shs15trillion. This projected
stalled real estate projects were We are going to do more of the raw materials. growth requires that the man-
unlocked. The Fund recovered outreach; getting closer to the datory cap is extended from
440 acres of Nsimbe land, com- members and be in position to Would you say the image of the current threshold of five
pleted the construction of an respond faster to the member’s the Fund as improved and it is employees to one employee,
Ultra Office Complex in Jinja, needs. We are going to finish time to forget the past? so that even self-employed
commenced development of these stalled projects especially The image is much bet- people are required to remit
Lubowa project and Pension the houses. ter. Everybody wants to deal social security contributions.
Towers, and is on course to with NSSF at the moment. We will go for the right tech-
complete another office com- How far are the plans that The Board is collaborating nology for pension administra-
plex in Mbarara and 40 apart- you had regarding converting well with the management tion, unlocking the value of
ments in Mbuya.We have also debt to equity in the case of and the Ministry of Finance is real estate projects of Pension
consistently paid a good return Uganda Clays? doing a fantastic job as a top Towers, completion of the first
on member’s savings during So far, nothing has changed. supervisor. We also have good phase of Lubowa, Nsimbe and
our three-year tenure. This has Uganda Clays was running political support. We have Temangalo developments. We
been consistently above two badly in the past but it has invested Shs7trillion in govern- will continuously improve
percentage points above the recorded improvement. If ment paper and most of it is staff capabilities, remuneration
10-year average rate of infla- they can pay us back without being used to do development and reward schemes.
tion. I am happy to note that changing our debt into equity projects which are critical in

Dec. 14 - 20 2018 27
Business
aviation csr

Airtel in an annual 12-Day


Christmas Initiative

O
n Dec.05, Airtel Uganda staff
members visited Bless A Child
Foundation in Makerere as part of
their ongoing annual Christmas
Initiative – 12 Days of Christmas.
Named after a popular Christmas song
that breaks down a series of grand gifts
given on each of the twelve days of Christ-
mas, the 12 Days of Christmas Initiative aims
at reaching out to less fortunate members
of society as well as to individuals and
organizations that have made a remarkable
Deputy President William Ruto (3rd R) welcomes the inaugural Kenya Airways direct flight difference in the lives of their community
from New York to Nairobi at the Jomo Kenyatta International Airport.   Courtesy Photo. members.
The Initiative that started on Dec.01with
Kenya Airways reduces US flights a visit to Nakaseke-based ACCESS Uganda

K
continued with the telco’s staff visiting
enya’s national carrier, Kenya Air- this route remains significant to us because Raphael Children’s Charity and Center for
ways, has reduced the number of of the role it plays in opening more eco- the Visually Impaired Children of Uganda,
flights on the newly launched New nomic and tourism growth opportunities and Noah’s Ark Home of kids with Dis-
York route from the current seven for Kenya and East Africa,” said KQ chief abilities.
to five a week. executive, Sebastian Mikosz. Others sect to benefit from the Initiative
The airline said the new decision that “The decision to adjust our schedule is to includes; Kapalaga Heart Foundation in
becomes effective January 15 will see the cater for seasonality in line with global prac- Bunga, Tusome Africa - Game our Schools in
airlines fly to US on Tuesday, Thursday, tices that allows airlines to reduce or add Iganga, Ursula School of the Disabled in Jin-
Friday, Saturday and Sunday. frequencies based on low or high seasons.” ja, Angel’s Center in Wakiso and a 7-year old
“As the only airline that offers a non-stop Kenya Airways started its direct non-stop girl named Emmanuella who needs financial
flight between East Africa and the USA, flights to the United States on Oct. 28. assistance to go for a heart surgery in India.

economy banking

Private sector healthy CBA, NIC in merger talks

T O
he health of Uganda’s Private n Dec.06, Commercial Bank of largest bank by assets base is at Kshh594
Sector continues to improve on Africa Limited and NIC Group billion followed by Equity Bank at Ksh424
the back of a rise in output in PLC announced that they are billion.
several sectors of the economy. in talks for a potential merger, a CBA is majority-owned by the
The latest Stanbic Purchasing Man- situation that would create the third largest Kenyatta family while the Nairobi
agers’ Index for the month of Novem- bank in Kenya. Securities Exchange- listed NIC Group
ber shows that the private sector stood Based on the third quarter financial is partly owned by the billionaire
at 55.7 above the 50.0 reading signalling results of the two companies, CBA asset businessman James Ndegwa’s family.
improvement in business conditions. base is Ksh 227 billion while NIC asset base If successful, the planned merger of
Though this latest figure declined is Ksh187 billion according to media reports. NIC Bank and CBA Bank would create
from 56.6 in October, it still points to a A combination of the two would put the one of the largest financial services
healthy Private Sector being above the total assets at Ksh414 billion. groups in the region.
two-and-a-half year survey average of Kenya Commercial Bank which is the
53.1. Four of the five broad sectors cov-
ered by the survey saw output rise, the ict
exception being construction.
Jibran Qureishi, the Regional Econo- Jumia partners with Buganda Kingdom

O
mist E.A at Stanbic Bank said a com-
bination of stable exchange rate and nline shop Jumia and Buganda was announced at a press event in Bulange,
improving agricultural productivity Kingdom’s official investment Mengo attended by Charles Peter Mayiga,
contributed to the performance. arm, Majestic Brands Limited the Katikkiro of Buganda, Majestic Brands
Companies increased their staffing has partnered to sell all Kingdom CEO Ronald Kawaddwa, and Jumia CEO
levels in response to the increasing merchandise to customers. The products Ron Kawamara. “The Buganda cultural and
orders for goods and services. include portraits of His Majesty - the King brand products are highly appreciated by
The PMI is a composite index, calcu- and those of Nnabegereka, marriage cer- millions of consumers globally. Today we
lated as a weighted average of five indi- tificates, totems and memorabilia. Officials are pleased to offer a new distribution chan-
vidual sub-components: New Orders, said on December 04 that the items can be nel for our customers to own the symbols
Output, Employment, Suppliers’ Deliv- purchased online via the Jumia app.  All and memorabilia that make up the norms
ery Times, and Stocks of Purchases. sales revenue will go to support the king- and culture of this great kingdom”, Jumia
dom development projects. The partnership CEO, Ron Kawamara said.

28 Dec. 14 - 20 2018
Business

NBL expands capacity


By Isaac Khisa of 140 million litres per annum.

N
This development comes
ile Breweries Limited, in as many months since the
a subsidiary of the new NBL’s Country Direc-
Belgium based AB tor, Thomas Kamphuis, said in
InBev, has boosted April this year that AB InBev
its production capacity to meet was investing US$22million
the growing beer demand. through its subsidiary NBL in
Onapito Ekomoloit, the upgrading its two plants – in
Director Legal and Corporate Jinja and Mbarara – as the
Affairs at NBL confirmed to world’s biggest beer-maker
The Independent that the beer steps up investment on the
company has added 250,000 African continent to meet
hectoliters (25million litres) booming beer demand.
to its production, boosting its Meanwhile, Ekomoloit
capacity to 205million litres has asked whoever claims to
of beer per annum at its Jinja possess any of their adulter-
Airtel Uganda in partnership with FUFA reward Uganda’s players from various Plant, eastern Uganda. ated products to report to the
teams at Speke Resort, Munyonyo, on Dec.08. More than 10 winners walked This is the second time that relevant authorities including
away with awards, cash prizes, and cars.   Courtesy photo. the company is expanding Police and Uganda National
the plant to meet the growing Bureau of Standards.
beer consumption since its He said the company, has
establishment more than six lately, been receiving unsub-
decades ago. stantiated claims that their
In 2009, the plant underwent products contain impurities.
a US$29million expansion, “To us, anything going into
effectively doubling the brewer the human body must meet
capacity to 180million litres. the highest quality,” he said,
This new expansion means adding, “It is one thing testing
that NBL has a production our products in the laboratory
capacity of 270 million litres and another thing seeing our
of beer per annum with the product in the glass.”
inclusion of the 65-million litre He said the company
production plant in Mbarara, adheres to the highest stan-
western Uganda. However, its dards in its beer production to
rival, Uganda Breweries Lim- ensure that consumer’s health
Eng Monica Azuba Ntege, Minister of Works and Transport flags off the ited, has a production capacity isn’t compromised.
2nd Edition of Tweddeko Road Safety Caravan organized by Vivo Energy
Uganda in partnership with National Road Safety Council, Uganda Police,
NTV Uganda and Uganda Red Cross Society.   Courtesy Photo.

Weekly share price movement (Dec.03, 2018)


Security Dec. 03 Nov. 19 Movement
BATU 30,000 30000 00
BOBU 139 139 00
CENT 980 1,015 3.4
QCL 249 255 2.3
DFCU 845 845 00
EABL 6,862 6,017 14
EBL 1,434 1,422 0.8
JHL 13,507 15,225 11.3
KA 347 349 0.5
KCB 1,434 1,413 1.5
NIC 15 15 00
NMG 2,487 2,519 1.3
NVL 337 340 0.9
Nile Brewries Limited Employee shows Assistant Inspector of Police,
SBU 31 32 3.1
Andrew Sorowen, UNBS, URA and Ministry of Health executive during
UCHM 24 23 52
the plant tour on Dec .05. The plant has a production capacity of 205
million litres per annum.  Courtesy photo. UCL 20 20 20
UMEME 321 340 5.5
ALSI -- -- --

Dec. 14 - 20 2018 29
Picking the trait and writing the genetic
code is a scenario that has been forecast
since the birth of the first test tube baby.

Designer babies
W
By A Cecile JW Janssens

hen Adam Nash was


still an embryo, living
in a dish in the lab,
scientists tested his Why what everyone is freaking out
DNA to make sure it
was free of Fanconi about is not likely to happen
anemia, the rare inherited blood disease
from which his sister Molly suffered. They
also checked his DNA for a marker that illnesses, all of these could in the future Designer babies are next
would reveal whether he shared the same be available to parents deciding to have a
tissue type. Molly needed a donor match designer baby.” The inevitable rise of designer babies
for stem cell therapy, and her parents The designer babies have thus been was proclaimed in 1978 after the birth of
were determined to find one. Adam was called the “future-we-should-not-want” Louise Brown, the first IVF baby, as the
conceived so the stem cells in his umbilical for each new reproductive technology or next step toward “a brave world where
cord could be the lifesaving treatment for intervention. But the babies never came parents can select their child’s gender and
his sister. and are nowhere close. I am not surprised. traits.” The same situation occurred in
Adam Nash is considered to be the first I study the prediction of complex 1994 when a 59-year-old British woman
designer baby, born in 2000 using in vitro diseases and human traits that result from stretched the limits of nature by giving
fertilizaton with pre-implantation genetic interactions between multiple genes and birth to twins using donated eggs that
diagnosis, a technique used to choose lifestyle factors. This research shows that were implanted in her womb at a fertility
desired characteristics. The media covered geneticists cannot read the genetic code clinic in Italy.
the story with empathy for the parents’ and know who will be above average in The response was the same in 1999,
motives but not without reminding the intelligence and athleticism. Such traits and when a fertility clinic in Fairfax, Virginia,
reader that “eye color, athletic ability, diseases that result from multiple genes offered sex selection of embryos to screen
beauty, intelligence, height, stopping a and lifestyle factors cannot be predicted against diseases that only happen in boys.
propensity towards obesity, guaranteeing using just DNA, and cannot be designed. In 2013, when 23andMe was granted a
freedom from certain mental and physical Not now. And very unlikely ever. patent for a tool that predicts the likelihood

30 Dec. 14 - 20 2018
health
of traits in babies based on DNA of these mutations removes the entire or have red hair, but also increases their risk
two parents, the question of patenting main cause of disease – women who don’t of skin cancer. Or variations in the OCA2
designer babies was raised. In 2016, when have BRCA mutations can still develop and HERC2 “eye color” genes that are also
the U.K. permitted a woman to donate breast cancer through other causes, like all associated with the risk of various cancers,
her healthy mitochondria to a couple women. Parkinson’s and Alzheimer’s disease. To
using IVF to conceive a child, raising Variations are changes in the genetic be sure, these are statistical associations,
the number of parents to three, fears of code that are more common than reported in the scientific literature, some
unnatural children rose again. Last month, mutations and associated with common may be confirmed; others may not. But the
when Genomic Prediction, a New Jersey traits and diseases. DNA variants increase message is clear: Editing DNA variations
company, announced its DNA screening the likelihood that you may have a trait or for “desirable” traits may have adverse
panel for embryos would also assess the develop a disease but do not determine or consequences, including many that
risk for complex diseases such as Type 2 cause it. Association means that in several scientists don’t know about yet.
diabetes and heart disease that are caused large study populations, a DNA variant We can see this in the analysis of He
by multiple genes, fears of engineering was more frequent among people with the Jiankui’s gene-edited babies. By trying to
babies with high IQ or athletic prowess trait than those without, often only slightly make the babies resistant to HIV, he might
emerged. more frequent. have greatly increased susceptibility to
The same issues arose on Nov. 26 These variants don’t determine a trait, infections by West Nile virus or influenza.
when He Jiankui reported at the Second but increase its likelihood by interacting To be sure, even though complex
International Summit on Human Genome with other DNA variants and nongenetic traits such as intelligence, athletics and
Editing in Hong Kong that he had influences such as upbringing, lifestyle musicality cannot be selected or designed,
successfully edited the DNA of twin baby and environment. To design such traits there will be opportunists who will try to
girls born the previous month. in embryos would require multiple offer these traits, even if totally premature
The designer baby doom scenarios have DNA changes in multiple genes and and unsupported by science. Like Stephen
not evolved with the technology. It’s been orchestrating or controlling relevant Hsu, the co-founder of Genomic Prediction
the same story for decades. It’s the same environment and lifestyle influences too. who said about his offer to test embryos
“desirable” traits and the same assumption Let’s compare it to driving a car. DNA for polygenic risk, the risk of a disease
that parents want to select these traits if mutations are like the flat tires and the based on multiple genes, “I think people
technology allowed. But no one seems to failing brakes: technical problems that are going to demand that. If we don’t do
be questioning whether these traits are make driving problematic, no matter it, some other company will.” And also He
solely a product of our genes such that where you drive. DNA variations are said: “There will be someone, somewhere,
they can be selected or edited in embryos. like the color and the type of car, or who is doing this. If it’s not me, it’s
Wondering about designer babies was other features of the car that may affect someone else.” People need to be protected
understandable in the early days, but the driving experience and even might against this irresponsible and unethical use
repetition of these supposed fears now create problems over time. For example, of DNA testing and editing.
suggests lack of understanding of how a convertible is a delight when driving on Science brought incredible progress
DNA, and the genes they encode, work. Hollywood’s Sunset Boulevard on a breezy in reproductive technology, but didn’t
summer evening, but cruel when crossing bring designer babies one step closer. The
Designing favorable traits in babies is a high mountain pass in midwinter. creation of designer babies is not limited by
not simple Whether features of the car are an asset or technology, but by biology: The origins of
a liability depends on the context and that common traits and diseases are too complex
Although there are exceptions, DNA context might change — they are never and intertwined to modify the DNA
generally differs between people in two ideal all the time. without introducing unwanted effects.
ways: There are DNA mutations and DNA
variations. Another hurdle A Cecile JW Janssens is Research Professor of
Mutations cause rare diseases like Most DNA mutations do nothing Epidemiology, Emory University
Huntington’s disease and cystic fibrosis, else other than cause the disease, but Source:theconversation
which are caused by a single gene. DNA variations may play a role in many
Mutations in the BRCA genes substantially diseases and traits. Take variations in the
increase the risk of breast and ovarian MC1R “red hair” gene, which not only
cancer. Selecting embryos that do not have increases the chance that your child will

*terms and conditions apply

AfricellUG @AfricellUG

Dec. 14 - 20 2018 31
COMMENT
By Alexandra Borchardt
Assault on news media
These five mundane dangers confronting the profession
could be more dangerous than the physical attacks

T
he brutal torture and murder of Fourth, even as pay and prestige independent media, citizens cannot
the US-based Saudi journalist diminish, newsroom pressures are make informed decisions. In fact, when
Jamal Khashoggi has focused intensifying. When a “cub” reporter professional journalism is absent,
attention on Saudi Crown Prince joins a media organisation today, the people can easily become lost in a
Mohammed bin Salman, who is widely ability to write great copy is no longer maze of often-unreliable information,
believed to have ordered the killing. sufficient; young journalists must also or even fall prey to self-proclaimed,
It also highlights the hazards of the possess audio and video skills, data interest-driven experts and propaganda.
news business. When the final numbers journalism capabilities, and social- Journalism is democracy’s compass; we
are tallied, 2018 could be the most media savvy. These skills might lead must find a way to recalibrate it.
dangerous year on record for journalists to better news products, but nobody First and foremost, journalists need
worldwide. is good at everything. To demand that protection. That means ensuring not
But while physical attacks on they are and place endless demands on only their safety, but also their ability
journalists have become frighteningly them might encourage reporters to leave to access information and report their
bold – and Khashoggi’s killing may be the profession. findings without fear of reprisal. At a
the most audacious yet – most dangers Finally, the relentless rhetorical attacks minimum, attacks on journalists like
confronting the profession are much on members of the mainstream media Khashoggi must be fully investigated,
more mundane. Five stand out. by leaders like U.S. President Donald and their perpetrators must be held
First, the number of job opportunities Trump – whose “fake news” narrative to account and condemned by the
is dwindling, and positions are targets the credibility of the profession international community.
characterised by low pay, perpetual job itself – is having an effect. Although And yet, support for the media must
insecurity, and limited opportunities confidence in the news media has been go beyond punishing those with the
for advancement. In the United States, rising in recent surveys, the constant audacity to kill a reporter. For example,
for example, newsroom employment vilification of journalists’ integrity more programs are needed to help
has dropped nearly one-quarter in less and intelligence threatens to erode the nurture young talent. Governments
than ten years, while enrollment in top profession. could offer subsidies, give tax breaks,
journalism schools has tapered off more Together, these five challenges and sponsor initiatives that offer
recently. are taking a heavy toll on the news training in journalism and new media.
Second, “Big Tech” is outcompeting business, and this poses a risk to Future journalists need role models,
news organisations in the race to democracy itself. Without free and but they also need the technical skills to
attract limited talent. Journalism needs become role models themselves.
people skilled in technology to lead Perhaps most important, media
investigative reporting projects and to advocates everywhere must work to
manage the industry’s digital transition.
But at the moment, most computer
Governments increase the public’s media literacy.
News consumers must understand
engineers see a brighter future with
platform companies like Facebook and
could offer how journalism works, how journalists
do their jobs, and why professional
Google, which can offer higher pay,
more job security, and better work-life
subsidies, give media outlets are essential components
of a well-functioning democracy.
balance than even the biggest media
outlets.
tax breaks, Until the public values the output that
professional journalists produce, a
Third, journalism is a lot less
glamorous than it once was. Years ago,
and sponsor shortage of talent will be the next big
challenge for journalism. It could turn
weather-beaten foreign correspondents
on television or the front pages of major
initiatives that out to be its biggest yet.

newspapers lured young reporters to


the craft. And, although most of us who
offer training Alexandra Borchardt is Director of
Leadership Programs at the Reuters
took the bait never ventured farther
than city hall, we were nonetheless
in journalism Institute for the Study of Journalism.

driven by the noble mission of holding


the powerful to account. But in today’s
and new media Copyright: Project Syndicate, 2018.
www.project-syndicate.org
distributed social-media environment,
foreign correspondents are rare, and
media “influencers” are more likely to
be pop stars than policy wonks.

32 Dec. 14 - 20 2018
COMMENT
By Fatima Al Ansar and Shona Bezanson
The feminisation of African politics
Evidence shows that women’s political leadership
strengthens governance capacity and cooperation

L
ast month, Ethiopian Prime constraining, give us insights that are assumptions. With more female role
Minister Abiy Ahmed appointed essential for inclusive policymaking. models, young women and girls
a new cabinet; ten of the 20 A growing body of evidence shows will be able to imagine new career
positions went to women. One that women’s political leadership possibilities; parents will chart new
week later, the country’s parliament strengthens governance capacity, paths of success for their daughters;
unanimously elected Sahle-Work improves cooperation with allies and teachers will teach girls differently; and
Zewde to become Ethiopia’s first across parties, and advances issues like social and cultural barriers will fall.
female president, and a week after that, parental leave and childcare, access Some critics argue that gender quotas
lawmakers appointed Meaza Ashenafi to pensions, and the elimination of in government are condescending and
to serve as the first female Supreme gender-based violence. unnecessary. But in many parts of
Court president. While it is unreasonable – and indeed the world, they are essential. In some
Ethiopia is not alone. Rwandan undesirable – to expect that women societies, for example, women cannot
President Paul Kagame installed a new will agree on all issues or be equally easily vote, meaning that even when
gender-balanced cabinet last month. gender-sensitive in their politics, it is female candidates are on the ballot,
Rwanda already had the world’s fair to assume that a female leader’s it can be difficult for them to garner
highest percentage of women in a ideas will be informed by her unique electoral support.
national parliament; now, the country experiences. As leaders everywhere Ethiopia and Rwanda have recognised
will have even more female leaders. strive to build more equitable societies, this challenge and have moved to
While Ethiopia and Rwanda are they must not underestimate the address it. Moreover, by appointing
at the forefront of Africa’s push for importance of giving political voice to gender-balanced cabinets, leaders are
gender parity in politics, other African gendered expertise. intentionally addressing a common
countries are not far behind. Six of In much of the world, and in many experience for women in politics:
the world’s 20 top countries in terms African countries, a woman’s place being vastly outnumbered by male
of the share of legislative seats held is widely believed to be in the home; counterparts. These two governments
by women are in Sub-Saharan Africa, public space is regarded as a male now have the opportunity to bring
and in two African countries toward domain. When governments in Africa women’s perspective to bear on the
the bottom of the global list – Nigeria boldly and intentionally crowd women challenges their countries face.
and Mali – politicians are currently into decision-making bodies, and The creation of gender-equal cabinets
discussing ways to increase female entrust them with power, they are reinforces the message that progress is
representation. directly challenging these outdated about more than building individual
This shift is as inspiring as it is capacity. Rather, it also requires
historic. By appointing so many transforming the structures and
young, energetic female leaders – like institutions that govern society. For
Paula Ingabire, Rwanda’s minister
of information and communications
While Ethiopia young African women, the last few
weeks of political change represents
technology and innovation, Kamissa
Camara, Mali’s foreign affairs minister,
and Rwanda a milestone in the continuing push

are at the
for gender equality, marking the
or Bogolo Kenewendo, Botswana’s beginning of a new era of progress for

forefront of
trade minister – African countries are the continent.
demonstrating that young women can

Africa’s push for


aspire to, and achieve, impactful goals. Fatima Al Ansar, an alumna of the African
These changes are essential not only Leadership Academy, is Head of Mission

gender parity
for the sake of fairness, but also for at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and
Africa’s long-term prosperity. On a International Cooperation in Mali, founder

in politics,
continent where the average age of of Tilwalte Girls Peace Network, a 2017
presidents is 62, Africa needs more Oxford Consortium on Human Rights

other African
young women in power to reflect Fellow, and a Mastercard Foundation
the talent and desires of its youthful Scholar. Shona Bezanson is Associate
population. To sustain Africa’s
socioeconomic progress, young women countries are Director of the Mastercard Foundation
Scholars Program.
must be in leadership positions.
Women experience the world not far behind Copyright: Project Syndicate, 2018.
differently than men. We grow
up navigating cultural norms and
expectations that, while certainly

Dec. 14 - 20 2018 33
COMMENT
By Attilio Pacifici
European Union and Human Rights
70 years after the Universal Declaration, the European
Union has chosen seven priority areas to support

S
eventy years ago, when global non-discrimination and equality for the period 2016-2020: 1) Freedom of
leaders came together to agree all citizens, with specific provisions to Assembly, Freedom of Association,
on the Universal Declaration of ensure the human rights of women, Freedom of Expression and Press
Human Rights, the world was people with disabilities and children. Freedom; 2) Accountability and Anti-
just beginning its slow and painful However, as in many other countries, corruption; 3) Children’s Rights; 4)
recovery from a devastating World ensuring that laws and policies that Women’s Rights and Gender Equality;
War. Tens of millions of people had guarantee the enjoyment of human 5) Transitional Justice; 6) Human
died, millions of them systematically rights are fully implemented and Rights Defenders and Abolition
killed because of their ethnicity, respected is a continuous effort. For of Death Penalty; and 7) Anti-
religion, political beliefs or sexual this, national and local authorities, discrimination.
orientation. including government, parliament and Support to these areas is provided
The beginning of the first article of courts, carry the main responsibility. through cooperation with the
the Declaration, “All human beings In the European experience, civil Government of Uganda; especially in
are born free and equal in dignity and society actors – non-governmental support to the Justice, Law and Order
rights”, sounds indisputable today. organisations, religious and cultural Sector (JLOS), and through cooperation
Yet, at the time of the signature of the institutions, individual human with civil society organisations (CSOs).
convention in 1948, African countries rights defenders – and a free media The EU supports reforms of the
were yet to be liberated, and a vast play a pivotal role in building JLOS sector, aimed at strengthening
number of Europeans would still be citizens’ awareness of their rights equitable access to justice and
denied fundamental freedoms for and persistently reminding duty increasing accountability, by providing
decades to come. bearers of their responsibilities. assistance to the government worth
Europe’s own painful history of Development partners can support 66 million euros or Shs280 billion
human rights violations, war and both governmental and non- over three years. The European Union
non-democratic regimes causes the governmental actors to help them play and its Member States also provide
European Union and its Member States their respective roles in ensuring that financial support to CSOs in Uganda to
to value the Universal Declaration of all people are fully able to enjoy their protect and promote human rights, on
Human Rights (UDHR) even more human rights. the basis of initiatives from Ugandan
today. Even though the world has The European Union and its Member organisations. The areas of support
changed significantly in the past 70 States have chosen seven priority are as broad in scope as human rights
years, the UDHR remains morally, areas for action in support of human themselves: EU-funded projects
politically and legally just as relevant – rights and democracy in Uganda for promote transitional justice in areas
or even more so – as it was in 1948. that have suffered from violent conflict,
The UDHR has prompted dozens of ensure children’s rights, facilitate
international human rights treaties accountability of public officials to their
and declarations, regional conventions, constituencies, etc.
and national human rights legislation.
It also inspired European states to
Today, this It is our joint responsibility to ensure
that what was agreed on 70 years
agree on the European Convention on international ago still becomes alive today. The

treaty protects
Human Rights in 1950. European Union and its Member States
Today, this international treaty are committed to continue working
protects human rights and political
freedoms of 830 million European human rights together with the Government of
Uganda and all Ugandans to ensure
citizens in 47 countries. The European
Convention established the European
and political that all women and men, girls and boys
can fully enjoy all the rights they are
Court of Human Rights, which may
hand down legally binding judgements
freedoms of 830 entitled to.

in response to claims taken to the million European Attilio Pacifici is the Ambassador of the

citizens in 47
Court by any person or state party. European Union to Uganda. He wrote this
Over decades, its decisions have forced article on the occasion to mark Human
many European countries to change
their legislation to better ensure the countries Rights Day 2018.

human rights of their citizens, and


obliged the payment of sometimes
sizeable compensation to those found
to have had their rights violated.
In Uganda, the constitution stipulates

34 Dec. 14 - 20 2018
ART | BOOKS | SOCIETY | TRAVEL | CULTURE

Kamya wows
with wood But Kamya’s pieces take a
more contemporary approach
How a child’s to sculpture construction.
They are inspired by
curiosity created contemporary themes.
Stylistically, they are sleek and
international celebrity understated in approach to
wood, and employ modernistic
concepts like working with
found -objects (aluminum or
copper plates.

C
By Dominic Muwanguzi genus subtropical and But Kamya likes to explore
tropical tree that grows new forms and dimensions
harles in Asia, Africa, and in his art. So, although his
Kamya is a Madagascar. figurines typically feature
self-taught His art is playful and double and plain curved
Uganda cheerful as he carefully surfaces, he uses spaces to
artist who preserves intricate create interesting variations.
has found a details as he juxtaposes The abstract sculptures
spot among the masters. nature and art. His are thematically narratives
He recently emerged sculptures meander of contemporary society
overall winner in a global like the root stumps issues; like the position of
sculpture competition; they are curved from the African woman in society
the Holzbildhauer in their natural form. as a mother, worker and a
Symposium Brienz But the artist adeptly symbol of beauty. He will also
in Switzerland, after exaggerates shapes within tackle themes of everyday
beating over one hundred his figurines to create a struggle and the futility of
sculptors from around the sense of wild- growth. He life that confound him as an
world. One of his works is is continuously exploring individual. It is a curiosity
a statuette, `Going Home’, concepts and integrates that began when Kamya was
which has been collected studio ingenuity and a child.
by Kenyan First Lady, craftiness. At one point he did not
Margaret Kenyatta. The lineal artwork have money to pay school
The 230cmx80cm carries variant textures fees and was on the brink of
sculpture conveys a rural and patterns that are dropping out. But he chanced
African woman going evocative of the organic on the curious idea to collect
home after work in the character of the medium root stumps that had always
garden. She is a towering used. To preserve that fascinated him from the
figurine in abstract style, natural quality is central family garden and sell them
combining elements of to the artist’s work and as sculptures. He quickly
double and plain curved instinctively reverberates discovered that although they
surfaces and the regular with the African were functional and preserved
sphere motif. In Kamya’s traditional approach to the natural forms of the roots,
work, these symbolise the wood curving where they had an aesthetic that
concept of the origin of wood carvers approached appealed to the public. Later he
human life- the embryo- the subject of sculpture was to discover that the craft
and the globe, planet with intent to preserve of root carving is an ancient
earth on which mankind the vegetation. In fact one and is visible in many
inhabit. It is a subtle most of the hardwood cultures across the world. That
comment on human life, sculptures from ancient is what provides his essential
identity, and spirituality. times are an archive of inspiration and ingenuity.
Kamya works the trees that are now
specifically with albizia extinct.
hardwood (Mugavu); a

Dec. 14 - 20 2018 35
Gambling nuns embezzled $500,000 from impoverished school to fund casino trips
Two nuns who worked as teachers will school funds.’ Both nuns were former that they had a pattern of going on trips,
not be charged over claims they embezzled school employees – Kreuper was the we do know they had a pattern of going
$500,000 from an impoverished school principal and Change was a teacher – to casinos, and the reality is, they used
to fund casino trips. Last week, St. James with the pair telling parents the school the account as their personal account.”
Catholic School in Torrance, California was operating on a shoestring budget. Auditors discovered a ‘long forgotten’
announced Sister Margaret Kreuper and But an attorney for the school claimed the church bank account that only Kreuper
Sister Lana Chang ‘were involved in the sisters had blown some of the huge sum and Chang knew about.
personal use of a substantial amount of on gambling trips, saying: ‘We do know

Police spends Can you lick your forehead like this man? Man accidentally
$600 to catch$2 declares himself a
While most people can
yogurt bottle thief barely reach their nose with their terrorist, kicked out
Sharing a fridge with room- tongue, one man can actually
lick his own forehead. Yagya A 70-year-old man from
mates in college usually means Scotland ruined his holiday
accepting that, from time to Bahadur Katuwal, 35, works on
a local school bus and his amaz- and got himself banned from
time, some of your treats will the United States forever after
mysteriously disappear. But for ing ability has made him a celeb-
rity in his country after his friend accidentally declaring himself
one Taiwanese woman sharing a terrorist on an online visa
a house with five other women posted a video of him on social
media. Yagya claims he has the form. John Stevenson and his
studying at the Chinese Culture wife, Marion, were supposed
University in Taipei, a missing $2 world’s longest tongue – but
he tries not to show it off often to vacation in New York this
yogurt bottle was a serious crime
because “it scares the children”. month, but they ended up los-
that had to be solved at any
The bus driver from Nepal, ing both their flight tickets and
cost. She brought in the police,
said he is the only person in the their advance for accommoda-
demanded that they carry out an
world that can lick their fore- tion in The Big Apple, after
official investigation, and bring
the criminal to justice. The police head. “I think I look great like John got permanently banned
conducted DNA tests worth this. I can cover my nose with from entering the United States
hundreds of dollars to find out my lips, lick my forehead and for declaring himself a terrorist
who drank the $2 yogurt bottle. make the sound of bullet bike. on an online visa form. Despite
The police have been accused “If I got to act in a horror movie, several attempts to convince US
of wasting taxpayers’ money on I wouldn’t need makeup like officials that he had just made a
solving stupid cases. other actors to scare people.” mistake, he remains banned.

Homeless man finds Odd job: Shop owners hiring thieves!


millions, gives it away The owner of a clothing did it, so she can prevent come off as strange, the
store in the UK is taking an it from happening again. woman explained that
Kevin Booth is poor and homeless and unconventional approach The witty entrepreneur, she is simply taking a
frequents a Food Bank in Washington, to preventing theft. She who prefers to remain different approach to theft
where he picks up donated items to help is paying £50 to any thief anonymous, says any thief prevention after years of
him survive on a day-to-day basis. He could who comes to her shop, who steals three items suffering significant loses
never have anticipated what he would steals something, and can keep one of them. during the holiday season.
come across one morning when he found a returns to tell her how they Realising that her job may
suspicious paper bag on the building’s front
step with US$17,000 (Approx.Shs64 million)
in it. Booth had a difficult decision to make
but handed it over to the food bank employ-
ees who called the police, prompting an
investigation of the money, where it came
from and who exactly handed it in. When
nobody claimed it, the food bank took it.
The police honoured Booth for his inspiring
display of generosity. “Not every citizen
would be as honest as you in this situation,”
Police Chief Brad Moericke. He said Booth
told him he knew that the money would
benefit more people than just himself.

36 Dec. 14 - 20 2018
2019 Honda CR-V
Check out its new standard safety technology
By Agencies lane-keep assistance – was reserved for the start, dual-zone climate control air-

H
range-topping CR-V VTi-LX AWD priced conditioning, a touchscreen with Apple
ONDA has dramatically increased from $44,290+ORC. CarPlay/Android Auto and satellite
the level of standard safety Now, however, Honda has added all of navigation, and even an electric tailgate
technology for the 2019 Honda the above extras as standard on the CR-V that is extremely rare for this price
CR-V VTi-S all-wheel drive VTi-S AWD. point.
model (AWD), which will be available in The CR-V VTi-S still gets Honda’s With a huge 556-litre boot volume,
dealerships from January 1, 2019. LaneWatch version of a blind-spot monitor, and full-sized spare wheel underfloor,
Previously the suite of tech dubbed which uses a passenger-side mirror- the 1.5-litre turbocharged four-cylinder,
HondaSensing – incorporating forward mounted camera to project traffic beside the automatic-equipped model now rates
collision warning autonomous emergency vehicle onto the centre screen. as one of the best and best-value buys
braking (AEB), adaptive cruise control, It also still includes 18-inch alloy wheels, in the segment.
and lane-departure warning with active keyless auto-entry with push-button

The Largest 7 seater 4x4 In Uganda


Only available at spear Motors Limited

Mercedes Benz GLS Driving you into the Future

0783 614 601 / 0753 614 601 sales@spearmotors.co.ug www.spearmotors.co.ug

Dec. 14 - 20 2018 37
Charles Rwomushana
was named after guitarist
By Agnes E Nantaba the ambition to become guild president of 1996.

C
the oldest university in Uganda; Makerere President Museveni appointed him
harles Rwomushana has often University. DRC for Pader district after which he was
times been named a controversial “It’s at this school that I became deployed back to State House.
political analyst for his contentious politically active,” he says. “I was handling political issues that
remarks and analysis of political He later joined Mbarara High School would culminate into overthrowing of
issues in the country. He is a former Guild because the school always engaged in the constitution,” he says, “I also handled
President of Makerere University, RDC of student fights with Ntare School and he monitoring government systems.”
Pader district and Head of Economics and wanted to take part in the next school war. Rwomushana is one of the many
Research at Internal Security Organisation Unfortunately it did not happen while he children of Winnie Safira Tumubwine
(ISO). It’s because of his remarks for and was there. Two years later, Rwomushana and Joseph Rwakinwa (RIP) of Rukungiri
against the current government; one that joined Makerere University and a month district. He was named Charles after a one
he once served that has led many to refer into the system realised that many students Charles Sonko, a guitarist who played a
to him as controversial. But Rwomushana had difficulty getting transport and welcoming song after his birth in the bush.
maintains his impartiality. writing materials even when they were on
“I don’t support or oppose anybody but government sponsorship. He convinced the
I relate with state power and its dynamics,” government to provide Shs10 million as a
says Rwomushana, also adding, “Therefore pilot project to help students. For this cause,
this notion of supporting this and that is for the students named him “chairman of the
part-time thinkers.” needy students” something that grew his
Perhaps his relationship with power popularity at the university. A year later,
dates to as young as only six years. he was elected guild president. His political
Rwomushana recalls mobilising about 100 ambitions kept growing and Rwomushana
very young boys about his age and training campaigned to represent Rujumbura
them in military formation. At the age of constituency in Rukungiri in the 1994
six, he says, he was the leader of the young Constituent Assembly race.
boys group, “very organised and never “I campaigned using door to door and
threatened by external forces”. was the first youth and very poor to win
At the time, his home was near a landing a free and fair general election,” he says.
site in Rukungiri district and by the time But his winning streak did not last. He was
Tanzanian forces extended to the area, they defeated when he tried to join parliament in
found the young boys ready in military
formation. The group would then join the
force to patrol the area; guiding the soldiers
on the direction of wild animals in the area.
“We would go with them, hunt and
shoot and as the leader, I would be given
some parts of the animals in appreciation,”
he recalls.
He recalls when one of the children was
shot as the soldiers battled hippos that had
come to rescue their mate. That was before
Rwomushana even started Primary one.
He later joined Bugangari Primary School.
He recalls that although he should have
been Anglican, he was baptized Catholic
in a hurried process because there was
a cholera outbreak and a fear of dying
without the First Holy Sacrament. Many
people died. As other priests fled the area,
one of them braved the deadly outbreak to
stay behind and baptize as many people
as possible such that at the time of death,
they would pass on as believers in Jesus
Christ. Rwomushana and his mother
survived and he resumed school. He later
joined Bugangari Secondary School where,
hesays, as early as senior two, he developed

38 Dec. 14 - 20 2018
Q&A

Charles Rwomushana’s Liteside


Any three things that we something that will cause turned out to be through force, persuasion,

I
don’t know about you? many to perish. challenges because the and education or spiritual
don’t know about the voters entrusted me with means. I am made by God
volumes of heat that What does being the power and expected to make and perpetuate
would melt me. I can powerful mean to you? me to battle for them. life.
be anywhere and some Being powerful is
stage if there is a problem, defined by outcomes. It’s Which talent would you What do you most value
I will generate some force about imposing a behavior most like to have? in your friends?
to destroy or push you on others to make them The talent to fight either I crave for a comrade
away. I am water and my believe in your line and through machines or because I have no capacity
word is fire. There is no live it. physically. to know someone at the
capacity to stop the fire level of a friend.
because God has baptised On what occasion do you What do you consider
me with fire and water. lie? your greatest Who are your favorite
I hate to tell lies achievement? writers?
What is your idea of and therefore cannot During my first year I don’t have any yet
perfect happiness? consciously construct a lie. at Makerere University, because many writers
Any moment with God It also consumes a lot of I gave myself a exaggerate just one idea
energy. responsibility to look after into hundreds of pages. I
What is your greatest thousands of students don’t want to read for fun
fear? Which living person do some of whom had their but to acquire knowledge
Betraying a value for you most despise? families displaced by the so I haven’t come across
materialism. I despise anyone who war. For some reason, I my favourite writer.
kills innocent people. How fought Amama Mbabazi
What is the trait you most do you promise someone with a passion but we Which historical figure
deplore in others? to renounce violence, were able to reconcile and do you most identify
Idiots and impervious; become part of you and I still feel at ease. with?
I struggle with idiots who receive amnesty but end There is no other
have and those without up killing them? I despise Where would you most individual who can come
power. such people. like to live? near Christ; he had a lot of
I never determined power, was able to restrain
Which living person do What is the quality you coming here and will it and was violent where
you most admire? most like in a woman? therefore remain here necessary. He was also
I only admire Jesus Individual’s characters as an individual. I am a very knowledgeable and
Christ and no other are determined by shareholder in Uganda had a very good doctrine
compares to him. conditions. and don’t know what of movement of resources
would be good outside it. through love.
What is your greatest What is the quality you
extravagance? most like in a man? What is your most What is your greatest
Other than donating, There is no permanent treasured possession? regret?
even if I had a trillion, character or trait to I don’t put my mind on I have not made
it would evaporate in describe an individual. material things. I treasure conscious mistakes. There
a second to get into the People change depending spiritual power. have only been accidents
dynamics of power. on circumstances. imposed on me by
What do you regard as the situations so I don’t have
What is the greatest thing What or who is the lowest depth of misery? regrets.
you have ever done? greatest love of your life? I have no problem with
I consciously I don’t have capacity any human being going How would you like to
contributed in bringing and time to love too much. through any level of die?
someone on earth who pain if it’s a sacrifice. If I don’t think about
wouldn’t be there without When and where were someone’s death is meant death because I am
that decision. you happiest? to save others after the beyond it.
Every time I have a failure of other forces, the
What do you consider the conversation with God pain is worth it. What is your motto?
most overrated virtue? is a happy moment for ‘There is victory in
Worshiping material; me. Others that would What is your favorite death’ and ‘I can’t be
most of the young be victories, like being occupation? impeded by souls that eat
people worship material elected guild president, Impacting behavior food’

Dec. 14 - 20 2018 39
Global comment
By Cobus van Staden
The G20’s Africa problem
Rather than include Africa in discussions about trade,
the G20 addresses narrower development issues

T
his has not been an easy year and it must constantly walk the fine will increasingly affect the global
for the G20. The 2018 summit line of speaking for the continent’s economy. By 2050, Nigeria will have
of the leaders of the world’s interests without imposing its voice on the world’s third-largest population,
largest economies was held in its neighbours. True, representatives and by 2100, one-third of all people will
Buenos Aires, a city still reeling from from the AU and the New Partnership be African. Clearly, any plan that the
a currency collapse. More broadly, the for Africa’s Development do attend G20 G20 makes for the future will have to
summit took place amid a fracturing summits. But the countries occupying put Africa at the forefront. Diminishing
of the multilateral order. Everything each institution’s rotating leadership the region to a set of development
from NATO to the consensus on climate do not always have the capacity to challenges will no longer do.
change appears to be coming apart at advocate forcefully on the continent’s To its credit, the G20 has started
the seams. behalf. paying more attention to Africa in recent
Still, the G20 has long positioned itself Moreover, this problem is years. Under the Chinese presidency in
as a global problem solver, having been compounded by the limited scope 2016, the body made industrialisation
conceived after the 1997 Asian financial of the G20’s interactions with Africa. in Africa a high priority. And this was
crisis and then emerging as the primary Rather than including Africa in followed by the Compact with Africa
global forum for addressing the crash wider discussions about global trade under the German presidency in 2017.
of 2008. A decade later, a global crisis is architecture, climate change, and the For its part, Argentina has not launched
on the agenda once again, only this time future of work, the G20 has largely an Africa initiative of its own; but it
it has assumed the form of a mounting limited its engagement with the has devoted attention to improving
trade war between the United States and continent to addressing narrower cooperation with the continent via
China. development issues. people-to-people diplomacy.
Unlike in 2008, however, the world’s To be sure, Africa’s large infrastructure The Compact with Africa is designed
capacity for multilateral decision- gap, slow regional integration, and to facilitate economic reforms across
making is deteriorating. The European high levels of unemployment all stem the continent, and to attract investment
Union remains preoccupied with its from underdevelopment. No one is from pools of private-sector funds in
own internal disputes, and the United saying that development should be the global North. But though it has been
States, under President Donald Trump, ignored; but nor should it be the only well received among African leaders,
has abandoned multilateralism and focus. When international engagement the compact nonetheless perpetuates the
weakened the institutions needed to with Africa is confined to the silo of trend of restricting African engagement
solve complex challenges such as the development, the continent is effectively to development issues.
threat of technological unemployment reduced to a set of problems for external Looking ahead, Africa must be
from automation. And the effects of the actors to solve. This tendency prevents afforded a greater role in setting the
Trump administration’s protectionism Africa from participating as a legitimate G20’s agenda. The continent will be
are already being felt. The World Trade and coequal member of the global disproportionally affected by climate
Organisation recently reported that in community. If one lacks a seat at the change and transnational migration.
response to U.S. tariffs, G20 countries table, then one is probably on the menu. Yet it will not be able to meet those
have imposed around 40 new import As matters stand, most of the G20’s challenges if its development is being
restrictions, affecting $481 billion in engagement with Africa happens hindered by an unequal global trade
global trade – a sixfold increase from through its Development Working system.
the year before. Group, which focuses on the basic These issues were on the agenda in
But while the world’s economic building blocks of development, Buenos Aires, but discussion of them
giants have been withdrawing from like poverty eradication. This means was largely deprived of an African
multilateralism, Africa has been quietly that Africa has no say in a host of perspective. This must change. It is time
moving in the opposite direction. Earlier other issues relating to development, for creative solutions to make the G20
this year, the continent’s countries including infrastructure, the shape of more representative and more effective
agreed on a new African Continental the digital economy, and the global in its engagement with the world. Our
Free Trade Agreement, and committed banking system. As a result, key collective future depends on it.
to pursuing deeper cross-border problems such as Africa’s structural
economic and infrastructure integration exclusion from global markets – which Cobus van Staden is a senior foreign policy
within the framework of the African is due in large part to G20 member researcher at the South African Institute of
Union, as outlined in the AU’s Agenda states’ own domestic agricultural International Affairs.
2063. subsidies – go unexamined.
But, despite its embrace of This isn’t just unfair to Africa; it Copyright: Project Syndicate, 2018.
multilateralism, Africa has struggled also poses risks for the G20. Africa www.project-syndicate.org
to get the G20’s attention. South Africa represents the world’s demographic
is the only African country in the G20, future, and its development trajectory

40 Dec. 14 - 20 2018
LIVE AT 9
We tell the story beyond the story.

#NBSLiveAt9

Вам также может понравиться