Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 5

c

G.R. No. 154598 August 16, 2004


c
IN THE MATTER OF APPLICATION FOR THE ISSUANCE OF A WRIT OF
HABEAS CORPUS
RICHARD BRIAN THORNTON for and in behalf of the minor child SEQUEIRA
JENNIFER DELLE FRANCISCO THORNTON,c c c

c
ADELFA FRANCISCO THORNTON,c  
c
c
D E C I S I O Nc
CORONA, v.:c
 c  c c c c c  c c c c  c  c c c  c c c c
 c c  c c c   c  c  c c c

c !c "
c #c
 $ %c c cc & c'  cc c% cc'(cc) 'c c'(c
c & '
c c   c c *c
+,--./-c cc010-c c cc & c'  cc c% c
 *c2c  cc  cc) 'cc c &)'c$cc c 3c c&2c c
c cc 'cc & '
c
!cc$'c c  cc. cc$ cc% c4c554cc
 c  'c -%'c  ' c c 6 c " c c 1
c c c c
  c%c& ccc&&c%c $c c$ c7ccc.' 'c

c
,cc c c  c%c  c c& c cc c  
c c
 c c c c c  c )&c  c c 8% c  c '8c c c % '&c  c  c
 $cc%cc c c 
c0c 'c c c ccc c'c
  c  c  c c c  c c  c %c c % c c  c 'c c  c
  
c c
!c  $  c   c &c c   &c &c c ' c c
'c
c/c'$&c#cc  cc c$c $c c c % c
7c  c %c c  &
c  c  c  c  c  c c  c &%%c
7cc!(c1(c
cc9$c: c!'
c c
!c cc cc & c'  cc c  % c.$ccc1(cc
&c   c  c  $  c  $&c &' c c  c %c  c  c '  c  c c
: 
c !c  c cc : c c  'c  c  & cc   c  c
 c % 
c,c c  cc c $c c c c&%c'cc
cc
9$c: c  cc'';c c  c cc%c  %c 
c
!c %c  c  c ' c  c c %c  c c   < c 'c c & c
%c' c$c c ' c ' c cc"c-')c1c1c c c
'
c!c c c c cc & c'  c  c$cc cc
c  c ' c' c cccc & c'  c'&cc cc'
c
,c c c c  c &c ccc  cc c% c cc  c c
c ) 'c c  c ' 
c 0c  c  c 'c c 4;=5c > c .$c  c 'cc
55#2c%c$c' c' c%c) 'cc  cc & c'  c
c $  c   c c #5c >c 'c -  %c  c  'c c  c c c
  2c c: c!$& c5c> c 'c%?c'cc542*c
6 c '
c 5c >2c :!c 5c >542c  c 0$ c  c c >c c c

c
c

  2c  c) 'cc cccc & c'  c  cccc cc c


 c ) '
c  c '$c c ) 'c  c @  c c '
c c c
#5c>552cc'c  %c c) 'cc  c
c  c) 'c c c
' c  cc'
ccccc c cc
c
0c55#cc4;=5c  c(c c.$c c'c c'
c0c   *c
j   
        Ac c .$c  c c c ' c
%c) 'cc c c ' c c%c'  *c
ccc
&
c!c c%   c'  cc'  c & c'  cccc
 c
c
cc7 c c  cc4;=5c$  c c:!c5c cc#5c c c
 c) 'cc  ccc ccc & c'  cc'  cc$c'  c
 c'' Bc c $ c c c cc  c&' c c cc c$%cc
 c c8' 8c cc' c c.$cc c c c'c ' c'c
 c  c 
c 0c c 'c  c  c  c .$c c  c    c  c $c
'$ 'c c c) 'cc c$c cc' c&c''cAc c
' cc c c'cc c $ c c'c %ccc4;=5
c
!c% c c c  cc $ c) 'ccc cc & c
'  c %c '  c c $ c c   c 'c  c  c  c 'c c c
cc & c'  cc $cc c&c) c$%ccc c%cc ' c c
%c c c  %c  c c  cc ) '
c c $c &c c &c
 c ) 'c  c ' c &c 
c 0c  c & 'c c c c '%c ' c
) 'cc  ccc'c' ccccc c $  c&c  'cc
' 
c
+  cc4;=5c cc% cc cc cc c c cc  ccAc
cc'cc c$cAcc $
c c'$ccccc) 'c c
 c c' c $cc c% 
c+ c c cc ' c 'cc c
c c$ c ccc&c % c$c c' c&cc$c c% 
c
c c  c &c  c  c  c   c  c c c   c  c ) 'c c
 c  c c & c '  c c '  c %c '  c c $ c c  c % c c  c
 c c c 4;=5c %%c $c ' c ' c %c ) 'c c ' c

c
0c  c'$$c c'c c  cc c'ccc ccc  c
c 1 c  c +c c ,& c   c c c c   c c 1 c >
1
c "
c
;@@@c'c1cc;2c  c  c c c$
c'ccc cc
  c cc c c & c'  c $c&c c c c $cccc
  c c  c c c  c $$& c  c c c % c  c c c &c '&c
 cc c!  
c c
c c c%
c c
c c c   c  c (c '%?'c c  c ' c 'c  c  c  %c c c
4;=5c c( c c) 'cc c cc & c'  c%c c'  cc
$
c
c c c   c   c  c c 4;=5c $  c   c c #5c  c :!c 5c
'c &c %%c $c ' c ' c ) 'c c & c '  c '  c  c
$( c  ccc&c c c'c ' c'c c cc & c' 
c c c
'c c c c8' 8c c'c&c'  cc c
c

c
c

+c  %c  c  c < c  %c &' c c c  c c c 7 c c
%c    c (c c  c %c ' c c &%c '  c c  c
'  
c 0   c  c c c (c  c  & c c $ c  c c (%c c
 c &c   c 'c  c 'c (c   c $c $c ' c   c  c c
'&c c c  c  'c c ) '
c  c c c $c  c &%c
  c$cc 'cc c ' c $ cc&c c' c c c ccc
& c'  c' cc&cc c%c$ 
c  c'(cc' c' cc c
&c ccc c$( c c c   c c.$c c'cc55#
c c
&  c&c c'c *c
6 c c.$c c'cc55#c c c 'cc cc cc8 'c c
%  c  c $c  c c c '  
8c c 'c c  c .$c c  c
% c  c   %c  c $)c   c % %c '  < c c '  c  c
   c&c c%  c %c c & cc c
c c% cc
&  c%%c.$c c' c c%c ) 'cc ' c'  c c
c  c  c '%%%c c %c 'c '( c  c %c  c  c
'?cccc ccc c' c c c  c cc cc%c
 c c 'cc c'  c cc c' c$ c '
c
c $ c '  c  c  c c  c & c   c c  c ' 
c +c c
 c  c c 4;=5c  c c  c  c c c   c  c  c  $c c c
 c ) 'c c & c '  c '  c %c  c '  c c $
c %c c
7c c'c *c c
c c  c c c   c c ' c ) 'c c  c c c & c
'  c %c c $c '  c   c  & c c 'c  c  c c
c cccc c  c c c% c ( cc
c. c cc
c c'  c  c $
c' c cc ccc & c'  c ' % c
cc cc   cc c'  < c 'c c$c@&%3c  c
c  c  c  c 'c c ) 'c c  c c  c c % c c &c
  c&c c% *c c'  < cc cc&%cc&c ) '
c
 c cc c c$c c  cc'  c c c8' 8c c ' %c
 cc c) '
c c''c' c&c c'c cc   
         =c  c  c c $ c ( c c c (@ c '' c c
 ccc cc c%c' ccc c c+($< c$  c'c
 c+($< c$  c$$ c  c' c) 'cc ' c' 
c
+c%c c c&  cc c'c c *c
+ c  c  cc' cc'c c$c c' cc&
cc   c
< c &$ c  c c  c 8' 8c c  c .$c  c 'c c 55#c
$cc'c$'c' cc c) 'cc c' cc & c
'  c'  c%c$
c0c c $c$c c c$  cc c. 'c
' cc 'c c) 'cc ccc  c c.$ccc c
' c c &c  c ''
c c .$c c 'c  c  c c & c '  c
'&cc c  cc ) '
c/c c c  c c'  c c
 cc ) 'c c c'$cc cc'c&c $ c c
'c  c c c   c 'c  c  c $c c '&c  % c  c
!   c c   cc'
ccccc c  c ccc  *c
c +c c ,& c   c $c &c % c &c  c  $c c c c
$$&c ccc c  ccc$cc&c         

c
c

                
   ! 
   
     
           c c$c&c$ c&c&c c
'c c c $$&c  c c &c c c c . c 0 'c c c ) %c
 cc %c c ' cc c$
"   
  
 "   ! #
    !  

    !
   
    !         #

   >-$   c   2c
0c%c c c$$ < c8' 8c ) 'c  cc' c cc c
%c' cc $% c  ccc c $c  c' c  c cc c$c
 %c  c %%c 'c c  c ' c % c c 'c ) 'c c  c 5;c
 c 5#;c   c  c $ $ c &c  c c  
c 0c  c   c  c
@ &  cc c c c'%c c c c ccc ccc c
*c
80  c'8c c  c c '' c  c $c &%
c c c c  c c
  c$< c c c& c $
c0c c cc ( c8 ccc
 cc( 3c c c% c
8c
ccc
0c  c  c c  c %%c 'c c  c 'c ) 'c % c c  c
 c  c $ $ c &c  c   c c  c "c c  c  c c c
' cc c cc @$(%c&c  c %c& 'cc c$  cc
 c $cc c c$ $%c% c$
c
9%%c cc cc$c$&%c cc&c' &cc&%c  cc$c c
c  
c $$ c  c  c % c 'c  c c $ c  c c ''c
' c c  c %%c c c c  c  c c  c $c  c c
$% c  c c &  c ) 'c c ' '
#c 0c  c ' c c &c c c
 cc c c8' 8cc cc%c) 'c c%c c 'c
8c 'c c%  c c $c ccc'  84c c c c c c
6 c " c c c  c %  c c  c 
c  c $ c $ c c c
%c' ' c c c c c% %c ' cc' %c c   ccc
4;=5
c
1c  c c ccc c' 'c c$  c  ccc *c
c c  c $ c &c & c '$ &c  c c 'c  %c  c $ c
'c&c c'cc$  c c$c&c 
c cc c   cc
 c $$c        
          
!c 

c c
c $ c &c c   c  c &% c c '' c  c  c  c  c c $c c
$c  $c c )  '
c c  $c  c  c  c % c  c &c
 $ c c c (c  c  %c  c c  c &)'c  c c c ' c
''%c 
c ,'c c & c $ c &c   c % c c $  c  c
 cc c  c&c cc cc $?c c%c'ccc cc
 c &)'
85c c
c   c c c 4;=5c c c $ c c c (c  c ) 'c c  c
c c   c  c  $c c c  c  c c & c '  c %c c  c
'  c c $
c . c c 'c &c  c  c  c   c c c 4;=5c c #5c
 c :!c 5c c & c '$ &c 'c c 4;=5c  c c  &c  c c c
  c  c  c  $c c $c  %c  cc & c '  c c '  c %c
 c '  c c $
c  c  c   c c c 4;=5c $ c &c  c c $c  c
c#5c c:!c5cCc c$c' c c''c) 'c c ccc

c
c

  c  c  c  $c c c  c c & c '  c  c  c '  c c
$ c cc 
c
0c c ' c  c 'c  c  c  c &c  c  c  c   c c 
1
c
"
c;@;@@c*ccc  cc1 c c+cc,& c  ccc
c  cc1
c'ccc cc   c *c
'c 
c               $@c c  c c c c c c
    c%c'  cc$ c c&c c c c.$c
c c
c c&c'&c c c) 'c%cc ' c c.$cc&%
c
ccc
c c%   
    j    !     !   
      
! 
!                 

c c c $c &c $ c &c c c .$c c c c c %c
'c c c%c c c c   cc c c$c$c&c c
c %c c ' cc c$
c>-$   c/ 2c
.$c c%%c c cc &c c ccc  c c $cc c
''c ) 'c  c $c ' c c & c '  c '  c  c  c '  c c
$ c c
c c
/cc
c7%c c %c'cc ' cc c'  ccc c'c c
cc &c$ccc$ c ' c ccc  c' c cc% c
c  $ %c c 
c c  c&c c'c *c c
c c %c'cc cc8 ' c c c'  ccc c'8c  c
c   c c  $&c c  &c & 'c 'c ' c c  (c  c c
$c c $c c 'c  c  c c c  c 'c 'c c '%c c
c c  c 'c  c c  c ( c '&c  c  c  c
!  
c c
WHEREFOREc  c c  c &c GRANTED
c c c c & c '  c c
@

@!@"
c #c  c &c REINSTATEDc  c REMANDEDc c  c c c
  c c 
c
SO ORDERED
c