Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
(For Notice, 1
‘: _ -1-—
-J, r.
@\—| L_4 ii’ i
_llI.!flllIl ( ill
.'... ...“!!!==_ EN qE1L_i__*-i-.‘.%==_i-5=.ii1*E "
_ _ _ ._
Q I| |||||m@-!!!!!!!Q!!§!!!!!!§;e
IIllIIlIHK~l ‘ ' A E = = -
F1173? I
'
E.'E§.a.~§.n.§
E | il
lIlI___l
W5_.
Ilfl“I
__,—1
:::¢:'1 . F‘llillllllfllllifllil\1lWl|ll|l4||[l1l:i!ENlliII%ll!$]l“"
<<>>E |
IZIIII ' ‘ ‘ " ‘
n-i'>'c7%~6*.5*¢:'i~I@l'
E i—:—
100F000
_ W
.
I
__. .....
.,, M
R
we mini Wu
_.@mm_-.I.¢|..l|l.|_l.._,_
H
.
W
_m fig‘ W .1
M “ME.” 7.
.v w
M .
. , X >
%m.O~(IfE.,.II
9 ‘
M “ . ,. . _ I
v < u
..-’.’e-§’.!=e‘S-.FIE
*2?
_. .,._._. _. _._.
$2.... m __..._.i_
=?j_?i| .
-'-.~.:.h.-.1-'
_.,.
E ... -..
_ ‘
. .
c .-
5
Mum
mm.
. j 7 .
_m
GLASGOW.
.._§.......F
_sa
i
E :5
X
<4
>>>
SHIPBUILDERS,
...._|fi»
. .2...
=1...” ..§§.
"SERVIA.”
.
»\_
A
XMSHIP
AND
ENGINEERS
DMSON,
:Page221.)
, .
gH_ ..
ENGINEERING, MARCH 17, 1882.
(For Notice
= 1; _;Qqy3§ ,»"/am
M "li‘ A N
cg“!‘ARI. -; '
\. \
| WI
|;
_
- M 1'
» 5
* +9‘! ="
‘ 51?
I ..1-;;-.11»: Kai,
!
~‘ '| " \ ' ii
i'v|_I_[»*i
I In "1 .
L‘ 5
‘ F.
|
I
I
I
' '
*4 ‘
-_
' 1 1 ' 1 ,1 .
. .._
1*!
Ii %\k\!€%%=!i-\\- .§
_/l
m.. - I Iii‘
L. ARRANGEMENT OF ENGINES AND BOILERS.
OMSON, ENGINEERS AND SHIPBUILDERS, GLASGOW.‘
e Page 945.)
|Ti
E R Ii }'.Hl|l l l
" iii‘;-Z:,_—jj
—
.\' _ \ :'
_-' '-_
2-"Lu
"
,~-___....-;Qfi i
is
7 ¢ -\Yj12iI*gV//'1
_.___.___ 1/ —v
»- I
MARCHI7, 1882.] ENGINEERING. 245
reflection, said that the brake failed to act; but he did not
say this (as will be seen) immediately after the accident;
1| THE CUNARD STEAMSHIP “SERVIA.” and, although there is not the slightest evidence either
F"@-~"
IIIB
CONSTRUCTED BY MESSRS. J. AND G. THOMSON, ENGINEERS AND SHIPBUILDERS, GLASGOW positive or negative to support his statement, Colonel Yol
land concludes that this man spoke the truth. At the same
time there is evidence, both positive and negative, that the
brake acted as perfectly (when it was applied) going into
Blackburn as it had done at the previous stations on this
'onrney; and it would have prevented the collision if it
ad been applied in time.
Several passengers by this train gave evidence before the
coroner in Colonel Yolland’s presence, and swore to feeling
the brake act distinctl on the different carriages in variou
parts of the train. T e following testimony alone is con
elusive:
William Evans: “ On reaching the West Cabin I felt
the deep grinding bite of the brake on our carriage. \Ve
came into the Blackburn Station at as rapid, or more rapid
speed, I should say, than at any period of our journey
between Manchester and Blackburn. Immediately after
the collision, and after we had attended to the injured, I
spoke to the driver of the train. I naked him, ‘ Why in the
world did you bring that train into this station at such a
rate P’ He replied that he could not see the train standing
in the station, nor could any other man, until he was coming
into the station;” and, “ the driver did not say to me that
the Westinghouse brake would not act."
The guard, whose van was the third vehicle from the
engine, also made an important statement. He said in his
evidence, " I opened the valve of the Westinghouse brake
in the van after we had passed the West Cabin, and I did
not hear any rush of air." Now the brake is allowed to
have been all right at Over Darwen, the previous stop,
and 5t or 6 minutes before reaching Blackburn; and the
driver says there was 80 lb. of air in the gauge passing the
point where he applied the brake, less than one minute from
the time of collision. If, therefore, the guard found no air
on entering the station, it was clearly because the driver
had already let it out of the brake pipe, that is, had applied
the brake, although he bad done so too late to be of material
'/AIl"'§:%K!;QffiVA1i§Vm;§|§\\ V use.
i It is a fact, moreover, that the brake acted on the engine
and four uninjured carriages even after the collision, and
‘~@@%§@§/ . __
Y that nothing was found amiss with the brake couplings,
valves, &c., on the injured carriages, or in the state of the
train generally, to account for the accident in any way
by neat standards. An important feature in tho arrnnge- I AUTOMATIC CONTINUOUS RAILVVAY from any failure of an part of the brake.
We maintain that, aving regard alone to the fact that
ment is the accessibility of the air-pump, for by simply
pushing on one side one of the floor-plates, uncoupling and BRAKE. the signals were not at danger. it is quite superfluous to
turning over the bell-crank, the cover and side bars can UNDER the title of “Automatic Compressed Air turn to the brake as a. cause of the collision. The driver
be lifted straight up and the bucket withdrawn; another Brakes v. Automatic Vacuum Brakes and non states that on the few occasions when he had run to Black
point, also of some convenience, is that every part Automatic Brakes,” the Westinghouse Brake Com burn before, the station had always been clear ; that he
had never taken that particular train into the station pre
requiring lubrication can be reached from the engine pany have issued a reply to Colonel Yolland’s recent viously; that he had himself worked the brake only two
room floor. report on the Blackburn collision, which it will be or three times before, without any proper instruction ; that
remembered was accompanied by a special corrective his usual place for stopping was the further or east end of
minute by the President of the Board of Trade, and the platform (at a point about 165 yards past the point of
THE “SERVIA." collision) ; and that he expected by the state of the signals
W1-: publish this week another two-page engraving Ion which we have already commented (see P98 e to be able to do so on this occasion. And Colonel Yolland
relating to the Cunard steamship “ Servia," these illus 62, anle). The following passages from the West allows in his report, that the driver was quite justified in
trations, together with the view on the present page, inghouse Brake Company’s reply will be read with his endeavour to get to this place, so far as the signals are
showing‘ the arrangement of the engines and boes~ interest : concerned.
We postpone our description until the publication of The q'1°5ti°11 °f A\1l°"mtl° C°mP1‘°59°‘l All‘ Brakes ” Under these circumstances, then, there is nothing to
further engravings. Automatic Vacuum Brakes and non-Automatic Brakes justify the assumption, that the brake in any way failed.
has again been prominently brought forward. In the follow Had onl the last home signal been at danger, had the
ing pages it is proposed to review the subject generally, but express then run 240 yards past it, and had it then struck
more particularly in its relation to two important circum as it did another train at 25to 30 miles per hour, there
NOTES FROM CLEVELAND AND THE stances which occurred during the past year, viz. : might have been grounds for Colonel Yolland's conclusions,
NORTHERN COUNTIES. 1. The conference of railway engineers, held at Euston but us it is there is no excuse whatever for them.
MIDDLESBROUGH, Wednesday. Station, on April 2, 1881. _ _ How thef collision occurred is perfectly clear. The
The (I'Im~elaml Iron Zllarl-et.—Yesterday there was a 2. Colonel Yolland's report on the Blackburn collision, driver, having just descended a steep incline 35 miles long,
large attendance on ‘Chan e, but very little business was which occurred on August 8, 1881. was running at a. reckless speed up to the station, intend
done. Messrs. Connal an Co., the warrant storekeepers Although the first-mentioned preceded the second by ing to proceed to the further end of the platform as usual,
here, had a stock of 169,566 tons, which is a decrease of several months, yet so much greater importance is attached andto make a smart stop similar to what he had been
1610 tons on the week. Previous to the market opening by some people to the latter, as emanating from the chief doing at previous stations, when suddenly he found another
a meeting of ironmasters was held, and they agreed that inspector of the Board of Trade, that it will be well to take train had got there first. He applied the brake, whistlcd,
they ought not to sell No. 3 Cleveland pig iron for less than it first into consideration. and reversed his engine, but for the want of about eighty
43s. 6d. per ton, the position and prospects of the trade A perusal of this document cannot fail to suggest several yards further distance, within which he could easily, by
warranting them, they thought, in stundin out for that ideas forcibly to the mind. means of the brake at his command, have brought his train
figure. Shipments of pig iron from Mid lesbrough are 1. The strong animus displayed throughout by Colonel to a. stand, came into collision with the unprotected train
very heavy, no fewer that 44,209 tons having been exported Yolland against the VVestinghouse brake, as shown, chiefly, already there.
during eleven days this month. No. 3 in second hands by his ignoring all facts and probabilities which told in its This view, however, did not commend itself to Colonel
was offered at 43s. per ton. Consumers are beginning to favour, at the same time that there was no evidence what Yolland. He preferred to accept the statement of the
buy ahead, being satisfied that they cannot gain anything ever, except that of the engine-driver and fireman, against it; driver that, on trying to apply the brake (at a point about
by waiting longer There are still inquiries from America, by his readiness to accept all the engine-driver said as true, half a mile from where ho intended to stop) some mysterious
but little or no actual business has yet sprung up. in the face of facts which rendered his evidence valueless ; ii-re(gulai-ity, the nature of which cannot be discovered,
The Finished Iron Trade.—Continued activity charac by a strained endeavour to make everything fit his own sud enly occurred to the brake. For the purpose of
lierises the manufactured iron trade throughout the North theories; and by a too apparent desire to convey the idea justifying his theories, Colonel Yolland made s. series of
of En land, and prices are nominally the same as they have that the collision resulted in some way from the automatic experiments with a similar train to the Manchester express,
been during the last fortni ht, viz., 71. 5s. per ton less nature of the brake. the brake always being applied at the spot indicated by the
2} per cent. for ship plates, ut while most manufacturers 2. Eve one must be struck by the introduction of so driver. In one ex eriment, when the brake coupling was
quote this figure plates can be bought in certain quarters much irre evant matter concerning automatic brakes gene purposel separa between the first and second carriages
for 5s. per ton less. rally, and about the so-called failures of the Westinghouse (as had n suggested might have been the case at the
brake, by a plying itself at improper times ; whereas he time of the accident, without any evidence to justify the
Shipbuildera and Engineers.—On the Tyne, Wear, and alleges the Bliackbum collision to have been caused, on the supposition) the train stopped ten yards short of the point
Tees both shipbuilders and engineers are in full swing. At contrary, by the failure of the brake to act when required ; of collision, from an initial speed of fifty miles an hour, as
Newcastle and Gateshead the men employed in the engi a class of failure which is well known to be peculiar to and as against forty mentioned b the driver as the speed on
neering establishments have given notice for an advance of inseparable from non-automatic brakes, on account of their the day of the collision. At ast, by cutting ofl’ the brake
10 per cent. in their wages. defective principle. from the train, and allowing it to act upon the engine
The Coal and Col-s Trades.—The fuel trade is steady. Colonel Yolland has, moreover, so contrived to mix up wheels only, the point of collision was in one experiment
The pitmen in Northumberland and Durham are agitating the Blackburn collision with this other irrelevant matter, passed. Colonel Yolland concluded, therefore, that the
for an advance in wages. and so used the alle ed failure of the brake as a foundation collision was caused by the brake refusing to act, except
upon which to buil his arguments, that it will be neces upon the engine wheels ; notwithstanding the positive
The Salt Deposils at Mi<ldlesbrough.—Messrs. Bell sary first to explain how the collision really came about; evidence that the couplings between the engine and train
Brothers, Limited, of Middlesbrough, are carrying on their and more particularly is this required on account of the were found properly connected after the accident. The last
boring operations for salt at Port Clarence successfully, use to which the report has been put by the opponents of mentioned experiment was not made under circumstances
and in the course of a few weeks they expect to be boiling automatic brakes. stated by the driver to have existed, but it seems to have
down salt. Mr. Isaac Lowthian Bell, the head of the firm, A train from Liverpool while standing in Blackburn been necessary to confirm Colonel Yolland in the fixed
who has long been known as a great authority on pig iron Station, was run into byfan express train from Manchester, conviction with which he began, conducted, and concluded
making, is equally well known as a chemist, from his at a speed of from 25to 30 miles per hour, killing eight the inquiry, viz., that the brake had failed. None of the
lengthy connexion with the \Vashington Chemical Works. and injuring sixty-four people. The signals which ought to experiments made, however, were of any sort of value, for
The people of Teesside are looking forward to a big have protected the Liverpool train were off at the time, and the same results might have been obtained by running
chemical trade being shortly established on the banks of this to most people would be suflicient to account for the close up to the station, and then applying the brake over
their river. accident. The driver, however, after having had time for the whole train.
ENGINEERING, APRIL 7, 1882.
(For D030-riplw
//%
7»/v* Q » . V ‘
.\ \ \ \ . 4
\<\ \\~
\\\ s ‘ \ 1
\ \
\ \
V , 2; ; ‘ \ \
\
wk;-\\vs»\\\\-.\~A\u \ -\~u\» \ ‘
‘ ... . . 1/ 4
1"‘ ‘
'
: ,, V,4 ‘ \ A
< \
m\ ‘ \ , .1 1-‘M;/ 1,
" ‘‘ ‘
§ ,, \~ ;\ ¢ ,4 \
~\ .. . W 5 .1 ;
'- r-’ /Z \ ‘ <
z ‘ ’, :' 4%
V
"¢--,,f
' in L A ‘ _.-_
1|
a\ , / ' \ ml
g u
I \\
3~ Z‘ §
\ ,4? §
=§
$§
$
S\~ §
, \Q
\ :.-.\..» ', \\ Q\
\\\- ////4;
Mr//Q A<_ _\\\\\\\\\~.V//2 \\, \ 5 , /1 /
~<\\~_~ kw4 _\\$-1:;
\
§
\\\\\\\ ~ \\\“\
. ~Q \_ ‘
1" ‘
. 1
\
,
1': .‘ \
\
';/1///////////////////¢
nu ~=‘
I
§§\\\\\\\\‘
‘/2?!/ll”//(1/////Z. /”f'_€'.’/f(€!."//.4,’//I»
I//,///////1///////; \\
\§\\\\\\\\\\ ‘
/
§ § a
~ é S
‘ E E
5 § \
\ § i
5 :
‘S 3a \
‘ \
E s
‘S 3§ 5
3 § \
1.. ‘
\§\\\\h\\ \\\\\\\\\§§\\\\\\§“\\\\\\\\§& \ \\&§\\\\\ R
CUNARD STEAMSHIP “SERVIA."
IOMSON, ENGINEERS AND SHIPBUILDERS, GLASGOW.
‘, we Page 349.)
I
m.
/ IQ)»
v
‘W//Z5
/////IIIIIII/IIIIIIIA “J”//////////../,. A /,
,
' ,1”,-' -
$~
Inalimanulqa
‘ .
\\\\\\\\\\\\_\\\\\\~k\“§|: @.¢ _ 0 999 0.0 6.0 Q 0.“ ..
. B.
..\§\\\\\\\\E\\\\\\\\§“i
\\\.§\\\\\\\ \\\§\.
£7111:/.5///1
I o
v\\\v\\\\\\,.\H.
Q\\l\\§E\\l~
Qgn 2
0 "" , £552} .
. Q
", W»
., ;“~\\»»“m€K- __. ~3\~~ -~ ~'
li§Y\K\§\\\\“\\\\\\\\\\\\&\\\\\\
.. . 7*I11
APRIL 7, 1882.1 ENGINEERING. 349
Fri:
‘Suermi
svnmu
I
'-lfl l l l