Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 7

Int. J. Plant Sci. 157(5):554-560. 1996.

? 1996 by The University of Chicago. All rights reserved.


1058-5893/96/5705-0004$02.00

REGENERATION
OFTOMATO ESCULENTUM
(LYCOPERSICON MILL.):SOMATIC AND
EMBRYOGENESIS
SHOOTORGANOGENESIS
FROMHYPOCOTYL
EXPLANTS
INDUCED WITH6-BENZYLADENINE
PHILIP 0. NEWMAN, SANKARAN KRISHNARAJ, AND PRAVEEN K. SAXENA'
Department of Horticultural Science, University of Guelph, Guelph, Ontario NIG 2W1, Canada

In vitro regeneration of plants was achieved in four cultivars of tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.). The explants
were 10-mm hypocotyl sections, excised from 2-wk-old seedlings grown on Murashige and Skoog (MS) medium
supplemented with or without 6-benzyladenine (BA). The hypocotyl explants were subcultured on MS medium without
growth regulators or on MS media supplemented with 5, 10, 20, or 40 ,uM BA. Regeneration through somatic em-
bryogenesis and shoot organogenesis occurred in explants of all treatments, even on hypocotyls from seedlings grown
on basal medium and subcultured to medium without growth regulators. Explants from seedlings grown on BA-
supplemented medium produced the highest frequency of regenerants when subcultured to media containing BA. In
contrast, BA had an inhibitory effect on explants obtained from seedlings grown on media lacking BA. Light micro-
scopic observations confirmed that regeneration occurred via both somatic embryogenesis and shoot organogenesis
from the subepidermal cortical tissue. Developing somatic embryos were encased in a distinct protoderm, had a sus-
pensor-like structure, and were loosely attached to the hypocotyl tissue. Somatic embryos and shoots developed into
complete plants on a medium lacking growth regulators.

Introduction mato and (ii) to obtain conclusive histological evi-


dence indicating that both forms of regeneration
Tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) is an im- (namely, shoot organogenesis and somatic embryogen-
portant food crop, for which successful applications of esis) occurred simultaneously on hypocotyl explants.
in vitro regeneration and genetic transformation have
already been implemented for genetic improvement Material
andmethods
(Lindsey 1992). Shoot organogenesis has been SEEDLINGCULTURE
achieved in tomato for explants from many different
tissues: apical meristems, cotyledons, stems, petioles, Seeds of four tomato cultivars-Manitoba, MH 6203 VF,
leaves, anthers, and inflorescences (Young et al. 1987; Orange Queen, and Sweet Million-were obtained from
Branca et al. 1990; Compton and Veilleux 1991). Stokes Seeds Ltd., St. Catharines, Canada. The seeds were
placed in a tea bag holder to prevent floating and surface-
However, there have been very few reports of somatic
sterilized for 15 min by placing them in a beaker and agi-
embryogenesis in tomato, indicating that classical pro- tating with a stir bar in 200 mL of half-strength commercial
tocols for achieving embryogenesis have not been suc- bleach (2.5% sodium hypochlorite, v/v), with two drops of
cessful (Young et al. 1987; Lamproye et al. 1990; Kob- "Tween 20" as a surfactant. The seeds were then rinsed
litz 1991). Lamproye et al. (1990, p. 129) reported the three times with sterile distilled water and cultured at the
formation and precocious germination of "bipolar rate of 10 seeds per petri dish (25 mm X 100 mm) contain-
structures comparable to somatic embryos" on hypo- ing 25 mL of appropriate media. Seventy seeds of each cul-
cotyl explants cultured on various concentrations of 6- tivar were grown on each treatment.
benzyladenine (BA) in combination with a synthetic Seeds were cultured on three different media treatments:
auxin analog, [benzo(b)selenienyl-3]acetic acid. This MS (Murashige and Skoog 1962) basal medium (MS 0) and
MS medium supplemented with either 50 pLMor 80 FM
IAA analog was synthesized by a complex chemical
BA). All three treatments were supplemented with B-5 vi-
reaction that replaced the nitrogen atom in the IAA tamins (Gamborg et al. 1968) and 3% sucrose and were so-
indole moiety with a selenium atom (Hofinger et al. lidified with 0.3% Gelrite (w/v). The pH was adjusted to 5.8
1980). Young et al. (1987) also observed formation of before autoclaving at 121?C for 20 min.
shoot primordia and somatic embryos on excised zy- The petri dishes were sealed with Parafilm (American Na-
gotic embryos cultured on media containing BA and tional Can, Greenwich, Conn.). The cultures were incubated
yeast extract. However, they relied solely upon scan- in a growth room, maintained at 240 ? 1?C, and a 16-h
ning electron microscopy to identify regenerating photoperiod (20-30 pLmolesm-2 s-') was provided by cool-
structures, and stated that the distinction between white fluorescent lamps (Phillips Canada, Scarborough,
shoots and somatic embryos was not clear. In neither Ont.). Hypocotyl explants were taken from the seedlings 14
d after initial culture.
of these reports was the frequency of regeneration
mentioned. HYPOCOTYLCULTURE
The specific objectives of the present investigation
Hypocotyl sections (ca. 10 mm long) were excised from
were (i) to develop an effective protocol for high-fre- the region immediately above the crown of the seedlings.
quency regeneration in four different cultivars of to- Because the hypocotyl explants were taken only from the
region nearest the crown, only one explant was taken from
'Author for correspondence and reprints. Fax 519-767-0755; E- each seedling. For the seedlings grown on MS 0, two cuts
mail psaxena@Pevbhort.uoguelph.ca. had to be made: one excision at the crown region to remove
Manuscript received August 1995; revised manuscript received April the roots and the other 10 mm higher on the hypocotyl. For
1996. seedlings grown on either MS + 50 FiM BA or MS + 80

554
This content downloaded from 141.218.001.105 on August 15, 2016 00:37:19 AM
All use subject to University of Chicago Press Terms and Conditions (http://www.journals.uchicago.edu/t-and-c).
NEWMAN ET AL.-EMBRYOGENESIS AND ORGANOGENESIS IN TOMATO 555

p,M BA, only one excision was made. These seedlings failed er trichomes (fig. iB, arrows) and (2) structures of the
to develop roots after germination, so the base of the seed- second type were shootlike, with one or two leaves
ling was left intact and the hypocotyl was excised 1.0 cm which were more like true leaves than cotyledonary
above the base. leaves in their morphology, and had numerous tri-
Media preparation for hypocotyl culture was similar to
chomes (fig. IC, arrow). The structures resembling
seedling culture, with the exception that concentrations of 0,
5, 10, 20, and 40 ,uM BA were used. Four explants were stages of somatic embryos developed a proper root and
cultured per petri dish containing 25 mL of the medium. shoot system, and complete plantlets were obtained
Three petri dishes (12 explants) per treatment were used for (fig. ID).
each cultivar. The dishes were sealed with Parafilm and in- Hypocotyl explants taken from MS 0 seedlings had
cubated under the same conditions as described for seedling structures developing only from the two cut ends of
cultures. The numbers of regenerated structures were count- the hypocotyl explant. No callusing was observed on
ed under a dissection microscope 4 wk after the incubation any explants taken from MS 0 seedlings, regardless of
of the explants. the subculture medium. Regeneration from hypocotyls
STATISTICALANALYSIS of BA-grown seedlings occurred mostly from the
swollen crown region, and to a lesser extent at the cut
The experiment was designed in a split-plot design with surface, and along the length of the explant. Shootlike
seven replications for seedling cultures (main plot treatment) and embryo-like structures were observed at the crown
and three replications for hypocotyl cultures (subplot treat- region and in the middle portion of the explants, but
ment). The data were analyzed using the general linear mod-
el PROC-GLM for PC SAS (SAS Institute 1995) and the
only the shootlike structures were observed at the cut
means were compared by least significant differences (LSD) surface. A small amount of compact, yellow-green,
at 1% level of probability. nodular callus was also observed at the swollen crown
region when the explants were subcultured on BA.
LIGHT MICROSCOPIC
STUDIES Higher concentrations of BA in the subculture medium
The explants were harvested at various intervals over the resulted in a marginal increase in callusing.
4-wk incubation period, so that sections could be obtained EVIDENCE OF SHOOT ORGANOGENESIS
of the structures at different stages of development. Explants
were taken both from the control group (seedlings grown on Histological evidence of regeneration via shoot or-
MS 0 and subcultured on MS 0) and from the BA treatments. ganogenesis was found both on explants from the con-
The methods for sample preparation and histology have been trol group (explants from seedlings grown on MS 0
described (Malik and Saxena 1992). Cross sections of 10- and subcultured on MS 0) and on explants from BA-
,m thickness were cut, using a Spencer 820 microtome. The grown seedlings. Based on cross sections of the hy-
sections were stained with safranin 0 and counterstained
with alcian green and examined under a light microscope.
pocotyl explants, the shoots appeared to originate from
the cortex of the hypocotyl, and were characterized by
Results a group of meristematic cells (fig. 2A, arrow). These
cells further developed to form a well-defined vascu-
SEEDLING GROWTH
lature (fig. 2B, arrow). Since the explant was taken
In all of the cultivars tested, germination was greater from well below the cotyledonary node, it was unlike-
than 90%, regardless of medium composition. Seeds ly that this shoot could have originated from an axil-
cultured on either 50 or 80 p,M BA germinated, but lary bud. Consecutive sections of the regenerated
the roots failed to elongate; instead a swollen area re- structures clearly demonstrated that these structures
sulted at the base of the hypocotyl, i.e., crown region were unipolar and therefore did not fulfill the require-
(fig. 1A, arrow). Seedlings grown on MS 0 had normal ment for bipolarity of a somatic embryo.
root systems (fig. IA, right). After 2 wk the shoot Further evidence of shoot organogenesis was ob-
length was only 1-2 cm for BA-grown seedlings but served by the presence of a vascular connection from
5-6 cm for MS 0-grown seedlings (fig. IA). In addi- the unipolar structure to the vascular cylinder of the
tion, only the cotyledonary leaves were visible on the hypocotyl (fig. 2C) and the presence of xylem vessels
BA-grown seedlings, while two or three true leaves originating from the stele of the hypocotyl explant (fig.
were visible on seedlings grown on MS 0 treatment 2C, arrow). Longitudinal section through a shoot pri-
after 2 wk. Callusing or regeneration were not ob- mordium arising from cortical tissue of the hypocotyl
served on the seedlings prior to the excision of hy- showed the two leaf primordia and the shoot apex, as
pocotyl explants in any treatment. well as the vascular connections to the leaf primordia
(fig. 2D). There was, however, no evidence of a root
REGENERATION FROM HYPOCOTYL EXPLANTS
primordium or of a layer of cells resembling an em-
Regeneration was observed on explants taken from bryonic protoderm, and thus these structures did not
BA-grown seedlings as well as on MS 0-grown seed- resemble a somatic embryo.
lings for all of the subculture media. The regenerated
EVIDENCE OF SOMATIC EMBRYOGENESIS
structures became visible 2-3 wk after subculture, and
appeared to be of two distinct types when viewed un- Histological evidence of somatic embryogenesis
der a dissection microscope: (1) structures of the first was found on explants from MS 0- and BA-grown
type were either globular or heart-shaped and had few- seedlings. Somatic embryos at the early globular stage

This content downloaded from 141.218.001.105 on August 15, 2016 00:37:19 AM


All use subject to University of Chicago Press Terms and Conditions (http://www.journals.uchicago.edu/t-and-c).
556 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PLANT SCIENCES

WElll

Fig. 1 Regeneration of plants from tomato hypocotyl cultures. A, Comparison of shoot length and root development of a seedling grown
on 50 ,uM BA (left) and a seedling of the same age grown on MS 0 (right). Note extensive root development and shoots on MS 0-grown
seedlings, while seedlings grown on 50 puMBA show reduced shoot length and no root (arrow) development (x 0.5). B, Globular-stage
somatic embryos (arrows) developing on a hypocotyl explant as observed under a dissecting microscope (x 25). C, Shoots regenerating on
the decapitated shoot end of a hypocotyl taken from a seedling grown on 50 ,uM BA. Note the numerous trichomes on the shoots (arrows)
(X 4). D, A plantlet that developed from a somatic embryo excised at the cotyledonary stage (x 0.3).

were characterized by a well-defined uniform proto- QUANTITATIVE OBSERVATIONS


derm, consisting of rectangular cells (fig. 3A), and a
suspensor-like structure at its base (fig. 3B). Darkly The average numbers of structures formed per ex-
stained meristematic cells (fig. 3A) and a strand of plant in each of the treatments and cultivars are shown
meristematic cells between the poles were present in in figure 4. Based on the observations during the early
the late globular-stage somatic embryos. Heart-shaped development of the shoots and somatic embryos, over
and late cotyledonary-stage somatic embryos were 80% of the structures formed were somatic embryos
loosely attached to the epidermal cells of the hypocotyl from seedlings grown on media containing BA. As
mother tissue and were frequently detached during described earlier, visual observations of the cultures
sectioning (fig. 3C-E). revealed that the shoots developed only from the cut
This content downloaded from 141.218.001.105 on August 15, 2016 00:37:19 AM
All use subject to University of Chicago Press Terms and Conditions (http://www.journals.uchicago.edu/t-and-c).
NEWMAN ET AL.-EMBRYOGENESIS AND ORGANOGENESIS IN TOMATO 557

Fig.2 Histological evidence of shoot organogenesis in hypocotyl cultures of tomato. A, B, Cross section of a hypocotyl explant showing
the vasculature of the hypocotyl as well as the meristematic zone and the vascular bundle of the regenerating shoot that originated by
organogenesis from the cortex of the hypocotyl (affows) (x 40). C, A developing shoot primordium, with vascular attachments to the vascular
bundle of the hypocotyl explant (x 40). Note the xylem tracheids (arrow) in the developing shoot. D, A shoot primordium developing on a
hypocotyl explant (x 40). Note the development of shoot apex and vascular strands extending into the leaf primordia.

end of these explants, whereas somatic embryos orig- structures than explants grown on either 50 or 80 ,uM
inated from the swollen crown region and along the BA.
length of the hypocotyl explant. Also, the cut ends
produced only two or three shoots (fig. 1C), whereas Discussion
more than 10 somatic embryos developed in a ring The protocol developed for high-frequency regen-
around the swollen crown region of the hypocotyl ex- eration of tomato cultivars was straightforward, as the
plants grown on BA (fig. iB). hypocotyl explants were easily obtained and the in-
The average numbers of regenerating structures duction media consisted of simple hormone-free me-
formed in each treatment varied from five to 20 per dium, or the one supplemented with BA, a readily
explant, except for the cultivar Sweet Million, in available synthetic cytokinin. The three most impor-
which the number of structures varied from one to five tant results of this study were (1) the simultaneous
per explant (fig. 4). The highest numbers of regener- formation of shoots and somatic embryos, (2) the for-
ants were observed on explants taken from seedlings mation of shoots and somatic embryos in the control
grown either on 50 or 80 ,uM BA and subcultured on group, which were not treated with exogenous growth
either 20 or 40 p,M BA. However, the structures regulators at any stage of the experiment, and (3) the
formed in these treatments were smaller and developed development of a reliable and simple procedure for
more slowly compared to those formed on subculture obtaining somatic embryos in tomato and the appli-
media containing lower concentrations of BA. Among cability of the culture conditions to each of the four
the seedling treatments, there were no significant dif- cultivars tested.
ferences between 50 and 80 ,uM BA treatments in any The frequency of regeneration observed in the pres-
cultivar. In all cultivars, explants taken from seedlings ent study was as high as 20 structures per explant, with
grown on MS 0 had significantly fewer regenerated ca. 80% of them being somatic embryos. Also, the
This content downloaded from 141.218.001.105 on August 15, 2016 00:37:19 AM
All use subject to University of Chicago Press Terms and Conditions (http://www.journals.uchicago.edu/t-and-c).
558 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PLANT SCIENCES

Fig.3 Histological evidence of somatic embryogenesis in hypocotyl explants of tomato. A, A late globular-stage somatic embryo, with
two dark-staining meristematic poles and a well-defined protoderm separating it from the surrounding tissue (X 100). B, A globular stage,
separated from the surrounding tissue by a layer of rectangular cells (protoderm) and with a short suspensor-like structure at one end (arrows)
(x 100). C, A cross section through nodular structures formed on hypocotyl explants that were taken from seedlings grown on either 50 or
80 ,uM BA and subcultured on 20 p.M BA (x 30). D, E, A cotyledonary stage (X 40) and heart-shaped (x 40) somatic embryos that have
separated from the hypocotyl explant during sectioning, respectively.

somatic embryos tended to be loosely attached to the ogenic cells as well as on the conversion of these cells
mother tissue, and could be easily excised for further into somatic embryos, since the continued presence of
development into plantlets. Another noteworthy aspect BA in the seed germination and explant culture me-
of the present study was the role of preconditioning of dium was necessary for optimum regeneration. Inhi-
source seedlings in the presence of BA. In the absence bition of regeneration by BA in explant cultures de-
of preconditioning, for hypocotyls taken from seed- rived from seedlings grown in MS 0 is likely to be a
lings grown on MS 0, the best subculture medium was result of supraoptimal levels of BA in the subculture
MS 0, and increasing concentrations of BA in the sub- medium.
culture media resulted in a nonsignificant decrease in The precise reason for the observed effect of pre-
the number of regenerants formed. For explants taken conditioning with BA is not clear, but a modified me-
from seedlings grown on either 50 or 80 ,uM BA, the tabolism or biosynthesis of endogenous cytokinins in
opposite was true: poorest regeneration was on MS 0, response to BA may be responsible, at least in part.
and increasing concentrations induced more structures, It is evident from many studies that cytokinins are
with the optimum BA concentrations being either 20 synthesized in root tips, and they differ quantitatively
or 40 ,uM. The explants from the seedlings grown on and qualitatively in various parts of the plant (Letham
50 or 80 ,uM BA not only produced higher frequencies 1986). Inhibition of root development in the BA-pre-
of regeneration but the mode of regeneration also tend- conditioned seedlings is indicative of an altered cy-
ed to shift toward somatic embryogenesis. These tokinin metabolism and transport. Much-limited hy-
trends were common to all cultivars. Thus, BA had a pocotyl elongation in preconditioned seedlings as
stimulatory effect both on the induction of embry- well as the development of somatic embryos and
This content downloaded from 141.218.001.105 on August 15, 2016 00:37:19 AM
All use subject to University of Chicago Press Terms and Conditions (http://www.journals.uchicago.edu/t-and-c).
NEWMAN ET AL. -EMBRYOGENESIS AND ORGANOGENESIS IN TOMATO 559

25 25
Manitoba MH6203 VF
a

20 2

I ab~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~o

b
~~~io bcc~~~~~
b
cd
Z cd d m

0 0
MSO 0 10 20 40 MS0 0 10 20 40
BAPconcontraon(W) BAPconcntrabon(W)

14 Sweet Million 14 OrangeQueen

.~12 i0 bc 20 40 .~12 0 0 20 4
lo 1 bc

110 M1S mb
ab

bc
o6 a ~~~~~~~~~~~ b
cbc
bc
ab b bc bc

b
bcN b bcN2

bbC bc
bc- bcb 0 10 20 40
20 40MSO
BAPoconcentralon
(uM) BAPoconcentralon
(uM)

Seedling grownon

Ms 0 ~ 5OpM BA 8OpMBA
Fig.4 The average number of regenerants per cultured explant for four of the tomato cultivars tested. Seedlings were grown for 2 wk, on
either MS 0, MS + 50 FM BA, or MS + 80 FM BA. Hypocotyl explants were taken from the 2-wk-old seedlings and subcultured on either
MS 0 or MS + 5, 10, 20, or 40 FLMBA. Regenerants were counted under a dissection microscope 4 wk after subculture. Bars with the same
letter are not significantly different (P = .01).

shoots at different sites on the cultured hypocotyl ex- bryo development was accompanied by significant
plants point to the possibility of auxin involvement changes in endogenous auxin and other growth reg-
causing localized differences in auxin/cytokinin ra- ulators (Murthy et al. 1995; R. Gill et al., unpublished
tios. It can be speculated that a high cytokinin/auxin data).
ratio resulting from discontinuation of auxin transport Since the induction of both shoot organogenesis
at the time of explanting the hypocotyl tissue, coupled and somatic embryogenesis occurs simultaneously,
with exposure to high BA during subculture, may albeit at different sites, this experimental system
have stimulated a limited degree of organogenesis in could be useful for studies on factors that favor so-
a largely embryogenic population of cells. We have matic embryogenesis over organogenesis, and vice
previously shown that seedlings of many species de- versa. Furthermore, the protocol could be useful for
veloped somatic embryos when grown continuously investigating the role of endogenous hormones in re-
on media enriched with cytokinins or phenylureas generation because of the independence of morpho-
with strong cytokinin activity, and the somatic em- genesis from exogenous growth regulators. For ex-

This content downloaded from 141.218.001.105 on August 15, 2016 00:37:19 AM


All use subject to University of Chicago Press Terms and Conditions (http://www.journals.uchicago.edu/t-and-c).
560 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PLANT SCIENCES

ample, the inclusion of the inhibitors of auxin, Acknowledgments


cytokinin or ethylene action, biosynthesis or transport We express our appreciation to Dr. J. Gerrath and
in the explant or seedling media may facilitate the Mr. B. N. S. Murthy for help in histology and exam-
determination of the effects of these hormones on dif- ining slides and to Ms. Tannis Slimmon for technical
ferentiation. In addition, its application to the study assistance with histology and photography. This re-
of the developmental biology of morphogenesis and search was funded in part by a research grant from the
the simplicity and efficacy of the regeneration pro- Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of
cedure are expected to facilitate gene transfer exper- Canada (NSERC) to Praveen K. Saxena and an
iments in tomato. NSERC summer scholarship to Philip 0. Newman.

Literature
cited
Branca C, G Bucci, P Domiano, A Ricci, A Torelli, M Bassi 1990 Lindsey K 1992 Genetic manipulation of crop plants. J Biotechnol
Auxin structure and activity on tomato morphogenesis in vitro and 26:1-28.
pea stem elongation. Plant Cell Tissue Organ Cult 24:105-114. Malik KA, PK Saxena 1992 Regeneration in Phaseolus vulgaris
Compton ME, RE Veilleux 1991 Shoot, root and flower morpho- L.: high frequency induction of direct shoot formation in intact
genesis on tomato inflorescence explants. Plant Cell Tissue Organ seedlings by N6-benzylaminopurine and thidiazuron. Planta 186:
Cult 24:223-23 1. 384-388.
Gamborg OL, RA Miller, K Ojima 1968 Nutrient requirements of Murashige T, F Skoog 1962 A revised medium for rapid growth
suspension cultures of soybean cells. Exp Cell Res 50:151-158. and bioassays with tobacco tissue cultures. Physiol Plant 15:473-
Hofinger M, T Thorpe, M Bouchet, T Gaspar 1980 Auxin-like ac- 497.
tivity of [benzo(b)selenienyl-3] acetic acid. Acta Physiol Plant Murthy BNS, SJ Murch, PK Saxena 1995 Thidiazuron-induced so-
2:275-280.
matic embryogenesis in intact seedlings of peanut (Arachis hy-
Koblitz H 1991 Cell, tissue and organ culture of Lycopersicon.
pogea L.): endogenous growth regulator levels and significance
Pages 231-245 in G Kalloo, ed. Genetic improvement of tomato.
Springer-Verlag, Berlin. of cotyledons. Physiol Plant 94:268-276.
Lamproye A, M Hofinger, J Berthon, T Gaspar 1990 [Ben- SAS Institute 1995 SAS/STAT user's guide, statistics version 6.
zo(b)selenienyl-3] acetic acid: a potent synthetic auxin in somatic Cary, N.C.
embryogenesis. CR Acad Sci Paris, Ser III, 311:127-132. Young R, V Kaul, EG Williams 1987 Clonal propagation in vitro
Letham DS 1986 Cytokinins. Pages 205-263 in DS Letham, PB from immature embryos and flower buds of Lycopersicon peru-
Goodwin, TJW Higgins, eds. Phytohormones and related com- vianum and L. esculentum. Plant Sci 52:237-242.
pounds. Elsevier, North Holland.

This content downloaded from 141.218.001.105 on August 15, 2016 00:37:19 AM


All use subject to University of Chicago Press Terms and Conditions (http://www.journals.uchicago.edu/t-and-c).

Вам также может понравиться