Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
16
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
17
CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
18
WEBER-STEPHEN PRODUCTS CASE No. 5:19-cv-00179
19 LLC,
COMPLAINT
20 Plaintiff,
21 v. DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
22
NEXGRILL INDUSTRIES, INC.,
23
Defendant.
24
25
26
27
28
COMPLAINT
1
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 2 of 54 Page ID #:2
COMPLAINT
2
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 3 of 54 Page ID #:3
1 California and this judicial district through several retail stores and/or on their
2 websites, including Home Depot, Walmart, Sears, Amazon, and Kmart, thus
3 specifically committing acts of infringement in this judicial district which give rise to
4 this lawsuit.
5 7. Nexgrill has purposefully availed itself of the privilege of conducting
6 business with residents of this judicial district, has a regular and established place of
7 business in this judicial district, and has established sufficient minimum contacts with
8 the State of California such that it should reasonably and fairly anticipate being
9 brought into court in California. Accordingly, the exercise of jurisdiction over
10 Nexgrill comports with the traditional notions of fair play and substantial justice.
11 8. All of Weber’s claims further described herein arise out of the same
12 nucleus of operative facts.
13 9. Venue is proper in this judicial district under 28 U.S.C. §§ 1391(b)-(d)
14 and 1400(b). See, e.g., TC Heartland LLC v. Kraft Foods Grp. Brands LLC, 137 S.
15 Ct. 1514 (2017). Indeed, Nexgrill argued in the “Illinois Action” (as that term is
16 defined in ¶ 26 below) that venue is proper in this judicial district.
17 THE PARTIES
18 10. Weber is a Delaware limited liability company with its principal place of
19 business in Palatine, Illinois.
20 11. Nexgrill is a California corporation with its principal executive office in
21 Chino, California. Nexgrill manufactures, distributes, and sells outdoor grills and
22 accessories under the Nexgrill® and Megamaster brand names, including the products
23 accused of infringement in this action.
24 12. Weber and Nexgrill directly compete with each other for the sale of
25 outdoor grills and accessories in the United States.
26 FACTUAL ALLEGATIONS COMMON TO ALL CAUSES OF ACTION
27 A. Weber’s Kettle Grill
28 13. Weber is a leading worldwide designer, developer, and manufacturer of
COMPLAINT
3
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 4 of 54 Page ID #:4
1 outdoor grills and accessories sold under the Weber® brand name. Weber’s founder,
2 George Stephen, began making and selling grills under the Weber® name in the
3 1950s. Since that time, Weber has developed and introduced numerous revolutionary
4 and iconic products, such as its 3-legged kettle grill design. Today, the Weber® brand
5 has become one of America’s most recognized and trusted brands in outdoor grills.
6 14. Weber’s distinctive 3-legged kettle grill design began with the 1956
7 Custom Bar-B-Q Kettle series of grills, then continued with the 1958 The Westerner
8 series of grills, the 1969 The Custom series of grills, the 1992 Master-Touch® series
9 of grills, the 2000 One-Touch® Gold series of grills, and finally the Original KettleTM
10 series of grills.
11 15. Weber owns and has standing to sue for infringement of United States
12 Patent and Trademark Office (“USPTO”) Trademark Reg. Nos. 1,478,530 (three-
13 dimensional pictorial representation of kettle portion for “barbeque grills”), 1,479,505
14 (two-dimensional silhouette for “barbeque grills”), and 1,481,521 (three-dimensional
15 pictorial representation of 3-legged kettle grill design for “barbeque grills”)
16 (collectively the “Weber Kettle Marks”).
17 16. Weber also owns several trademark registrations bearing the 3-legged
18 kettle grill design in a variety of classes of goods and services, including: USPTO
19 Trademark Reg. Nos. 1,466,756 (“restaurant services”); 1,481,520 (“griddles and
20 metal grids used as grills and metal grills for holding ears of corn and potatoes,
21 being accessories for barbeque grills”); 2,540,281 (“clothing, namely hats, t-shirts,
22 sweatshirts, polo shirts and chef shirts”); 2,540,282 (“barbecue sauce, steak sauce,
23 flavored cooking spices and flavored cooking rubs”); 3,834,455 (“paper napkins;
24 printed menus; printed survey cards; printed promotional materials relating to
25 restaurant and catering services and cooking”); 2,575,932 (“restaurant services”);
26 4,378,010 (“non-stick water-based cooking spray”); 4,415,012 (“Preparations for
27 cleaning, polishing and protecting exterior and interior surfaces of barbecue grills”)
28 (collectively, the “Other Weber Marks”).
COMPLAINT
4
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 5 of 54 Page ID #:5
1 17. The Weber Kettle Marks are in full force and effect and have become
2 incontestable pursuant to 15 U.S.C. § 1065. Nexgrill is infringing upon the Weber
3 Kettle Marks. At this time, Weber is not asserting that Nexgrill infringes the Other
4 Weber Marks.
5 18. Nexgrill does not have any license or rights to use the Weber Kettle
6 Marks, the Other Weber Marks, or any 3-legged grill design that is confusingly
7 similar thereto.
8 19. Together, the Weber Kettle Marks and the Other Weber Marks
9 underscore the fact that any product or advertisement bearing the famous and
10 distinctive Weber 3-legged kettle grill design is immediately associated by purchasers,
11 potential purchasers, and the public as being a product of, and affiliated with, Weber.
12 B. Weber’s Q® Grill
13 20. As a result of its innovative research and development efforts, Weber
14 also holds many important patents and other intellectual property rights in the field of
15 outdoor grilling, including rights relating to the Weber Q® product line of portable
16 gas grills.
17 21. Weber is the owner of the following “Patents-in-Suit”:
18 (1) United States Utility Patent No. 6,945,774, entitled “Gas Burner With
19 Flame Stabilization Structure,” which issued on September 20, 2005
20 (“the ‘774 Patent,” attached as Exhibit A);
21 (2) United States Utility Patent No. 7,073,429, entitled “Cooking Grate
22 With Grease Control Structures,” which issued on July 11, 2006 (“the
23 ‘429 Patent,” attached as Exhibit B);
24 (3) United States Utility Patent No. 7,373,875, entitled “Cooking Grate,”
25 which issued on May 20, 2008 (“the ‘875 Patent,” attached as Exhibit
26 C);
27 (4) United States Utility Patent No. 7,810,484, entitled “Heat Distributing
28 Cooking Grate With Grease Control Structure For A Barbeque Grill,”
COMPLAINT
5
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 6 of 54 Page ID #:6
COMPLAINT
6
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 7 of 54 Page ID #:7
1 25. Nexgrill does not have any license or rights to the Patents-in-Suit, the
2 ‘743 Mark, or any other intellectual property rights of Weber.
3 C. Nexgrill’s Willful Infringement Of Weber’s Asserted Intellectual Property
4 Rights
5 26. Weber previously notified Nexgrill of its infringement which gives rise to
6 this lawsuit. For example, on August 13, 2018, Weber filed a lawsuit against Nexgrill
7 in the Northern District of Illinois, which was assigned Case No. 18-cv-5519 (the
8 “Illinois Action”), accusing Nexgrill of infringing Weber’s intellectual property rights
9 in its Q® grill product line. To avoid protracted briefing and argument on jurisdiction
10 and venue, and to focus the issues on the merits of this dispute, Weber voluntarily
11 dismissed without prejudice the Illinois Action on December 4, 2018 pursuant to
12 Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 41(a)(1)(A)(i) in light of Nexgrill’s motion to transfer
13 the Illinois Action to this district for improper venue.
14 27. Further, on December 3, 2018, Weber notified Nexgrill that its
15 Megamaster 3-legged kettle grill product infringed Weber’s intellectual property
16 rights in its 3-legged kettle grill product line.
17 28. Notwithstanding Nexgrill’s awareness of Weber’s asserted intellectual
18 property rights and Weber’s specific claims of infringement of its asserted intellectual
19 property rights by Nexgrill’s Infringing Gas Products and Infringing Kettle Products,
20 Nexgrill’s infringement has persisted, without competent advice of counsel.
21 Nexgrill’s infringement has been intentional, deliberate, and objectively and
22 subjectively reckless.
23 29. Accordingly, Nexgrill’s ongoing infringement of Weber’s asserted
24 intellectual property rights has been willful.
25 COUNT I
26 INFRINGEMENT OF U.S. UTILITY PATENT NO. 6,945,774
27 30. Weber repeats and incorporates by reference the allegations contained in
28 the preceding paragraphs as if set forth fully herein.
COMPLAINT
7
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 8 of 54 Page ID #:8
1 31. Nexgrill has infringed and continues to infringe the ‘774 Patent through,
2 among other activities, the manufacture, use, sale, importation, and/or offer for sale of
3 the Infringing Gas Products throughout the United States, including within this
4 judicial district and by aiding, assisting, and encouraging the infringement of the ‘774
5 Patent by others.
6 32. By way of example, as shown below, the Infringing Gas Products include
7 every limitation of claim 1 of the ‘774 Patent – i.e., a gas burner assembly with a
8 burner tube having a plurality of linearly-aligned outlets ports (A) defining a flame
9 region; a slot (B) that provides a standing pilot flame; wherein the slot (B) is
10 proximate to an outlet port (C) and the slot extends beyond the flame region.
11 A C
12
13
B
14
15
16
17
18
19 33. Nexgrill has infringed and continues to infringe at least claims 1, 5, and 6
20 of the ‘774 Patent within the meaning of 35 U.S.C. § 271(a) through the foregoing
21 activities including, without limitation, making, using, importing, offering for sale,
22 and selling the Infringing Gas Products in the United States. The Infringing Gas
23 Products contain each and every element of at least claims 1, 5, and 6 of the ‘774
24 Patent both literally and under the doctrine of equivalents in contravention of 35
25 U.S.C. § 271.
26 34. Nexgrill has also indirectly infringed and continues to indirectly infringe
27 at least claims 1, 5, 6, 10, 11, and 15 of the ‘774 Patent under 35 U.S.C. § 271(b) by
28 knowingly and actively inducing infringement of those claims. Nexgrill has
COMPLAINT
8
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 9 of 54 Page ID #:9
1 knowingly and actively induced infringement of at least claims 1, 5, 6, 10, 11, and 15,
2 for example, through the foregoing activities including, without limitation, importing,
3 offering to sell, and selling the Infringing Gas Products in the United States, and by
4 instructing, aiding, assisting, and encouraging the offer for sale, sale, and use of the
5 Infringing Gas Products in a manner that infringes at least claims 1, 5, 6, 10, 11, and
6 15 of the ‘774 Patent. The direct infringers that are being induced by Nexgrill
7 include, without limitation, Nexgrill’s customers or end-users that use the Infringing
8 Gas Products, and/or connect the Infringing Gas Products to a fuel source, in the
9 United States.
10 35. Nexgrill has also indirectly infringed and continues to indirectly infringe
11 at least claims 1, 5, 6, 10, 11, and 15 of the ‘774 Patent under 35 U.S.C. § 271(c)
12 through the foregoing activities including, among other things, importing, offering for
13 sale, and selling the Infringing Gas Products in the United States and by instructing,
14 aiding, assisting, authorizing, advertising, marketing, promoting, providing for, and/or
15 encouraging the offer for sale, sale, and use of the Infringing Gas Products, which
16 constitute a material part of the patented inventions of claims 1, 5, 6, 10, 11, and 15
17 of the ‘774 Patent, which Nexgrill knows are especially made or adapted for use in an
18 infringement of at least claims 1, 5, 6, 10, 11, and 15 of the ‘774 Patent, and which are
19 not a staple article of commerce suitable for substantial non-infringing use. The direct
20 infringers for Nexgrill’s contributory infringement under 35 U.S.C. § 271(c) include,
21 without limitation, Nexgrill’s customers or end-users that use the Infringing Gas
22 Products or connect the Infringing Gas Products to a fuel source in the United States.
23 36. Nexgrill’s infringement, contributory infringement, and/or knowing and
24 intentional inducement to infringe has injured Weber and Weber is entitled to recover
25 damages adequate to compensate it for such infringement, but in no event less than a
26 reasonable royalty, as permitted under 35 U.S.C. § 284.
27 37. Weber has complied with 35 U.S.C. § 287 to the extent required by law.
28 38. Nexgrill’s infringement, contributory infringement, and/or inducement to
COMPLAINT
9
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 10 of 54 Page ID #:10
1 infringe the ‘774 Patent has been willful, deliberate, and objectively reckless.
2 39. Nexgrill’s infringement of the ‘774 Patent has caused irreparable harm to
3 Weber, which has no adequate remedy at law, and will continue to injure Weber
4 unless and until this Court enters an injunction prohibiting further infringement and,
5 specifically, enjoining further importation, manufacture, use, offer for sale, and/or sale
6 of the Infringing Gas Products and any other products within the scope of the ‘774
7 Patent, and enjoining Nexgrill from further contributing to and/or inducing
8 infringement of the ‘774 Patent.
9 COUNT II
10 INFRINGEMENT OF U.S. UTILITY PATENT NO. 7,073,429
11 40. Weber repeats and incorporates by reference the allegations contained in
12 the preceding paragraphs as if set forth fully herein.
13 41. Nexgrill has infringed and continues to infringe the ‘429 Patent through,
14 among other activities, the manufacture, use, sale, importation, and/or offer for sale of
15 the Infringing Gas Products throughout the United States, including within this
16 judicial district and by aiding, assisting, and encouraging the infringement of the ‘429
17 Patent by others.
18 42. Nexgrill has infringed and continues to infringe at least claims 1, 2, 5-15,
19 18, 20-25, 27, and 30-33 of the ‘429 Patent within the meaning of 35 U.S.C. § 271(a)
20 through the foregoing activities including, without limitation, making, using,
21 importing, offering for sale, and selling the Infringing Gas Products in the United
22 States. The Infringing Gas Products contain each and every element of at least claims
23 1, 2, 5-15, 18, 20-25, 27, and 30-33 of the ‘429 Patent both literally and under the
24 doctrine of equivalents in contravention of 35 U.S.C. § 271.
25 43. By way of example, as shown below, the Infringing Gas Products include
26 every limitation of claim 13 of the ‘429 Patent – i.e., a grill having a cooking chamber
27 (A) with a gas burner tube (B) having a flame region positioned under a removable
28 cooking grate (C). The removable cooking grate (C) has a plurality of openings (D)
COMPLAINT
10
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 11 of 54 Page ID #:11
1 and a plurality of elongated members (E) that define a cooking surface. The
2 removable cooking grate (C) also has an upper grease control assembly (F) and a
3 lower grease control assembly (G) that direct grease away from the gas burner tube
4 (B).
5
6 C
7 A
8
B
9
10
11
F G
12 E
E
13 D
D
14 D
E
15
16
44. Nexgrill has also indirectly infringed and continues to indirectly infringe
17
at least claims 1, 2, 5-15, 18, 20-25, 27, and 30-33 of the ‘429 Patent under 35 U.S.C.
18
§ 271(b) by knowingly and actively inducing infringement of those claims. Nexgrill
19
has knowingly and actively induced infringement of at least claims 1, 2, 5-15, 18, 20-
20
25, 27, and 30-33, for example, through the foregoing activities including, without
21
limitation, importing, offering to sell, and selling the Infringing Gas Products in the
22
United States, and by instructing, aiding, assisting, and encouraging the offer for sale,
23
sale, and use of the Infringing Gas Products in a manner that infringes at least claims
24
1, 2, 5-15, 18, 20-25, 27, and 30-33 of the ‘429 Patent. The direct infringers that are
25
being induced by Nexgrill include, without limitation, Nexgrill’s customers or end-
26
users that use the Infringing Gas Products in the United States.
27
45. Nexgrill has also indirectly infringed and continues to indirectly infringe
28
at least claims 1, 2, 5-15, 18, 20-25, 27, and 30-33 of the ‘429 Patent under 35 U.S.C.
COMPLAINT
11
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 12 of 54 Page ID #:12
1 § 271(c) through the foregoing activities including, among other things, importing,
2 offering for sale, and selling the Infringing Gas Products in the United States and by
3 instructing, aiding, assisting, authorizing, advertising, marketing, promoting,
4 providing for, and/or encouraging the offer for sale, sale, and use of the Infringing Gas
5 Products, which constitute a material part of the patented inventions of claims 1, 2, 5-
6 15, 18, 20-25, 27, and 30-33 of the ‘429 Patent, which Nexgrill knows are especially
7 made or adapted for use in an infringement of at least claims 1, 2, 5-15, 18, 20-25, 27,
8 and 30-33 of the ‘429 Patent, and which are not a staple article of commerce suitable
9 for substantial non-infringing use. The direct infringers for Nexgrill’s contributory
10 infringement under 35 U.S.C. § 271(c) include, without limitation, Nexgrill’s
11 customers or end-users that use the Infringing Gas Products in the United States.
12 46. Nexgrill’s infringement, contributory infringement, and/or knowing and
13 intentional inducement to infringe has injured Weber and Weber is entitled to recover
14 damages adequate to compensate it for such infringement, but in no event less than a
15 reasonable royalty, as permitted under 35 U.S.C. § 284.
16 47. Weber has complied with 35 U.S.C. § 287 to the extent required by law.
17 48. Nexgrill’s infringement, contributory infringement, and/or inducement to
18 infringe the ‘429 Patent has been willful, deliberate, and objectively reckless.
19 49. Nexgrill’s infringement of the ‘429 Patent has caused irreparable harm to
20 Weber, which has no adequate remedy at law, and will continue to injure Weber
21 unless and until this Court enters an injunction prohibiting further infringement and,
22 specifically, enjoining further importation, manufacture, use, offer for sale, and/or sale
23 of the Infringing Gas Products and any other products within the scope of the ‘429
24 Patent, and enjoining Nexgrill from further contributing to and/or inducing
25 infringement of the ‘429 Patent.
26 COUNT III
27 INFRINGEMENT OF U.S. UTILITY PATENT NO. 7,373,875
28 50. Weber repeats and incorporates by reference the allegations contained in
COMPLAINT
12
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 13 of 54 Page ID #:13
16 E
D
17 B D
B E
18 E
H C
C
19 H
20
53. Nexgrill has infringed and continues to infringe at least claims 1-6, 8, 10,
21
11, and 13-15 of the ‘875 Patent within the meaning of 35 U.S.C. § 271(a) through the
22
foregoing activities including, without limitation, making, using, importing, offering
23
for sale, and selling the Infringing Gas Products in the United States. The Infringing
24
Gas Products contain each and every element of at least claims 1-6, 8, 10, 11, and 13-
25
15 of the ‘875 Patent both literally and under the doctrine of equivalents in
26
contravention of 35 U.S.C. § 271.
27
54. Nexgrill has also indirectly infringed and continues to indirectly infringe
28
COMPLAINT
13
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 14 of 54 Page ID #:14
1 at least claims 1-6, 8, 10, 11, and 13-15 of the ‘875 Patent under 35 U.S.C. § 271(b)
2 by knowingly and actively inducing infringement of those claims. Nexgrill has
3 knowingly and actively induced infringement of at least claims 1-6, 8, 10, 11, and 13-
4 15, for example, through the foregoing activities including, without limitation,
5 importing, offering to sell, and selling the Infringing Gas Products in the United
6 States, and by instructing, aiding, assisting, and encouraging the offer for sale, sale,
7 and use of the Infringing Gas Products in a manner that infringes at least claims 1-6,
8 8, 10, 11, and 13-15 of the ‘875 Patent. The direct infringers that are being induced
9 by Nexgrill include, without limitation, Nexgrill’s customers or end-users that use the
10 Infringing Gas Products in the United States.
11 55. Nexgrill has also indirectly infringed and continues to indirectly infringe
12 at least claims 1-6, 8, 10, 11, and 13-15 of the ‘875 Patent under 35 U.S.C. § 271(c)
13 through the foregoing activities including, among other things, importing, offering for
14 sale, and selling the Infringing Gas Products in the United States and by instructing,
15 aiding, assisting, authorizing, advertising, marketing, promoting, providing for, and/or
16 encouraging the offer for sale, sale, and use of the Infringing Gas Products, which
17 constitute a material part of the patented inventions of claims 1-6, 8, 10, 11, and 13-
18 15 of the ‘875 Patent, which Nexgrill knows are especially made or adapted for use in
19 an infringement of at least claims 1-6, 8, 10, 11, and 13-15 of the ‘875 Patent, and
20 which are not a staple article of commerce suitable for substantial non-infringing use.
21 The direct infringers for Nexgrill’s contributory infringement under 35 U.S.C. §
22 271(c) include, without limitation, Nexgrill’s customers or end-users that use the
23 Infringing Gas Products in the United States.
24 56. Nexgrill’s infringement, contributory infringement, and/or knowing and
25 intentional inducement to infringe has injured Weber and Weber is entitled to recover
26 damages adequate to compensate it for such infringement, but in no event less than a
27 reasonable royalty, as permitted under 35 U.S.C. § 284.
28 57. Weber has complied with 35 U.S.C. § 287 to the extent required by law.
COMPLAINT
14
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 15 of 54 Page ID #:15
COMPLAINT
15
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 16 of 54 Page ID #:16
1 measurements indicate that the grease control structure (I) has a slope of
2 approximately 0.7 degrees; the apex (J) of the grease control structure (I) is located
3 below the cooking surface of the cooking grate (D) and between the cooking members
4 (G); and grease control ridges (K) form a closed loop around the perimeter of the
5 energy receptor portion (E).
6 D K
7 E
J
H F K
8 G H G
9 I H
B B G
10 H
C A G
11
12
63. Nexgrill has infringed and continues to infringe at least claims 1-7, 9-13,
13
15, and 17-24 of the ‘484 Patent within the meaning of 35 U.S.C. § 271(a) through the
14
foregoing activities including, without limitation, making, using, importing, offering
15
for sale, and selling the Infringing Gas Products in the United States. The Infringing
16
Gas Products contain each and every element of at least claims 1-7, 9-13, 15, and 17-
17
24 of the ‘484 Patent both literally and under the doctrine of equivalents in
18
contravention of 35 U.S.C. § 271.
19
64. Nexgrill has also indirectly infringed and continues to indirectly infringe
20
at least claims 1-7, 9-13, 15, and 17-24 of the ‘484 Patent under 35 U.S.C. § 271(b) by
21
knowingly and actively inducing infringement of those claims. Nexgrill has
22
knowingly and actively induced infringement of at least claims 1-7, 9-13, 15, and 17-
23
24, for example, through the foregoing activities including, without limitation,
24
importing, offering to sell, and selling the Infringing Gas Products in the United
25
States, and by instructing, aiding, assisting, and encouraging the offer for sale, sale,
26
and use of the Infringing Gas Products in a manner that infringes at least claims 1-7,
27
9-13, 15, and 17-24 of the ‘484 Patent. The direct infringers that are being induced by
28
Nexgrill include, without limitation, Nexgrill’s customers or end-users that use the
COMPLAINT
16
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 17 of 54 Page ID #:17
COMPLAINT
17
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 18 of 54 Page ID #:18
1 COUNT V
2 INFRINGEMENT OF U.S. UTILITY PATENT NO. 7,762,249
3 70. Weber repeats and incorporates by reference the allegations contained in
4 the preceding paragraphs as if set forth fully herein.
5 71. Nexgrill has infringed and continues to infringe the ‘249 Patent through,
6 among other activities, the manufacture, use, sale, importation, and/or offer for sale of
7 the Infringing Gas Products throughout the United States, including within this
8 judicial district and by aiding, assisting, and encouraging the infringement of the ‘249
9 Patent by others.
10 72. By way of example, as shown below, the Infringing Gas Products include
11 every limitation of claim 1 of the ‘249 Patent – i.e., a grill assembly with a firebox
12 having two opposing side walls (A) and a generally arch-shapped bottom (B) situated
13 between the side walls (A); a frame assembly having two frame members (C) located
14 adjacent to the firebox side walls (A); a mounting assembly comprising mounting
15 members (D) that consist of vertical tabs (E) with top ends (F) directly attached to the
16 arch-shaped bottom (B) of the firebox, and bottom ends (G) directly connected to their
17 respective frame members (C) to create a distance between the firebox and the frame
18 assembly to avoid heat damage to the frame assembly; and wherein the mounting
19 assembly creates a fixed spatial relationship between the frame members (C) without
20 the use of cross members (H).
21 B
A B H F
22
A
23
H
24
E
25 C
D D C G C
26
27
28
COMPLAINT
18
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 19 of 54 Page ID #:19
1
2
9
73. Nexgrill has infringed and continues to infringe at least claims 1-3, 6, 7,
10
11, and 20 of the ‘249 Patent within the meaning of 35 U.S.C. § 271(a) through the
11
foregoing activities including, without limitation, making, using, importing, offering
12
for sale, and selling the Infringing Gas Products in the United States. The Infringing
13
Gas Products contain each and every element of at least claims 1-3, 6, 7, 11, and 20 of
14
the ‘249 Patent both literally and under the doctrine of equivalents in contravention of
15
35 U.S.C. § 271.
16
74. Nexgrill has also indirectly infringed and continues to indirectly infringe
17
at least claims 1-3, 6, 7, 11, and 20 of the ‘249 Patent under 35 U.S.C. § 271(b) by
18
knowingly and actively inducing infringement of those claims. Nexgrill has
19
knowingly and actively induced infringement of at least claims 1-3, 6, 7, 11, and 20,
20
for example, through the foregoing activities including, without limitation, importing,
21
offering to sell, and selling the Infringing Gas Products in the United States, and by
22
instructing, aiding, assisting, and encouraging the offer for sale, sale, and use of the
23
Infringing Gas Products in a manner that infringes at least claims 1-3, 6, 7, 11, and 20
24
of the ‘249 Patent. The direct infringers that are being induced by Nexgrill include,
25
without limitation, Nexgrill’s customers or end-users that use the Infringing Gas
26
Products in the United States.
27
75. Nexgrill has also indirectly infringed and continues to indirectly infringe
28
at least claims 1-3, 6, 7, 11, and 20 of the ‘249 Patent under 35 U.S.C. § 271(c)
COMPLAINT
19
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 20 of 54 Page ID #:20
1 through the foregoing activities including, among other things, importing, offering for
2 sale, and selling the Infringing Gas Products in the United States and by instructing,
3 aiding, assisting, authorizing, advertising, marketing, promoting, providing for, and/or
4 encouraging the offer for sale, sale, and use of the Infringing Gas Products, which
5 constitute a material part of the patented inventions of claims 1-3, 6, 7, 11, and 20 of
6 the ‘249 Patent, which Nexgrill knows are especially made or adapted for use in an
7 infringement of at least claims 1-3, 6, 7, 11, and 20 of the ‘249 Patent, and which are
8 not a staple article of commerce suitable for substantial non-infringing use. The direct
9 infringers for Nexgrill’s contributory infringement under 35 U.S.C. § 271(c) include,
10 without limitation, Nexgrill’s customers or end-users that use the Infringing Gas
11 Products in the United States.
12 76. Nexgrill’s infringement, contributory infringement, and/or knowing and
13 intentional inducement to infringe has injured Weber and Weber is entitled to recover
14 damages adequate to compensate it for such infringement, but in no event less than a
15 reasonable royalty, as permitted under 35 U.S.C. § 284.
16 77. Weber has complied with 35 U.S.C. § 287 to the extent required by law.
17 78. Nexgrill’s infringement, contributory infringement, and/or inducement to
18 infringe the ‘249 Patent has been willful, deliberate, and objectively reckless.
19 79. Nexgrill’s infringement of the ‘249 Patent has caused irreparable harm to
20 Weber, which has no adequate remedy at law, and will continue to injure Weber
21 unless and until this Court enters an injunction prohibiting further infringement and,
22 specifically, enjoining further importation, manufacture, use, offer for sale, and/or sale
23 of the Infringing Gas Products and any other products within the scope of the ‘249
24 Patent, and enjoining Nexgrill from further contributing to and/or inducing
25 infringement of the ‘249 Patent.
26 COUNT VI
27 INFRINGEMENT OF U.S. DESIGN PATENT NO. D503,582
28 80. Weber repeats and incorporates by reference the allegations contained in
COMPLAINT
20
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 21 of 54 Page ID #:21
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
84. The Infringing Gas Products have appropriated the ornamental design for
19
an outdoor barbeque grill assembly as shown and described in the ‘582 Patent. The
20
‘582 Patent claims a non-functional ornamental design.
21
85. In the eye of the ordinary observer, giving such attention as a purchaser
22
usually gives, the non-functional ornamental design for an outdoor barbeque grill
23
assembly claimed in the ‘582 Patent and the Infringing Gas Products are substantially
24
the same; the resemblance is such as to deceive an ordinary observer, inducing
25
him/her to purchase one supposing it to be the other.
26
86. Nexgrill has infringed and continues to infringe the ornamental design for
27
an outdoor barbeque grill assembly claimed in the ‘582 Patent within the meaning of
28
35 U.S.C. § 271(a) through activities including, without limitation, importing, offering
COMPLAINT
21
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 22 of 54 Page ID #:22
1 for sale, and selling the Infringing Gas Products in the United States.
2 87. Nexgrill has also indirectly infringed and continues to indirectly infringe
3 the ornamental design for an outdoor barbeque grill assembly claimed in the ‘582
4 Patent under 35 U.S.C. § 271(b) by knowingly and actively inducing infringement
5 through the foregoing activities including, without limitation, importing, offering to
6 sell, and selling the Infringing Gas Products in the United States, and by instructing,
7 aiding, assisting, and encouraging the offer for sale, sale, and use of the Infringing
8 Gas Products in a manner that infringes the ‘582 Patent. The direct infringers that are
9 being induced by Nexgrill include, without limitation, its retail customers, resellers,
10 and end-users that offer for sale, sell, or use the Infringing Gas Products in the United
11 States.
12 88. Nexgrill’s infringement and/or knowing and intentional inducement to
13 infringe has injured Weber and Weber is entitled to recover damages adequate to
14 compensate it for such infringement, but in no event less than a reasonable royalty, as
15 permitted under 35 U.S.C. § 284, as well as all remedies for design patent
16 infringement permitted under 35 U.S.C. § 289.
17 89. Weber has complied with 35 U.S.C. § 287 to the extent required by law.
18 90. Weber’s infringement and/or inducement to infringe the ‘582 Patent has
19 been willful, deliberate, and objectively reckless.
20 91. Nexgrill’s infringement of the ‘582 Patent has caused irreparable harm to
21 Weber, which has no adequate remedy at law, and will continue to injure Weber
22 unless and until this Court enters an injunction prohibiting further infringement and,
23 specifically, enjoining further importation, manufacture, use, offer for sale, and/or sale
24 of the Infringing Gas Products and any other products within the scope of the design
25 claimed in the ‘582 Patent, and enjoining Nexgrill from further inducing infringement
26 of the design claimed in the ‘582 Patent.
27
28
COMPLAINT
22
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 23 of 54 Page ID #:23
1 COUNT VII
2 INFRINGEMENT OF U.S. DESIGN PATENT NO. D503,586
3 92. Weber repeats and incorporates by reference the allegations contained in
4 the preceding paragraphs as if set forth fully herein.
5 93. The ‘586 Patent claims an “ornamental design for a frame assembly for a
6 barbeque grill.”
7 94. The Infringing Gas Products are barbeque grills with frame assemblies
8 that infringe the ‘586 Patent.
9 95. Figure 1 of the ‘586 Patent is shown on the left below, and Nexgrill’s
10 Infringing Gas Products are shown on the right below.
11
Figure 1 of ‘586 Patent Nexgrill’s Fortress 2-Burner
12 Table Top Grill (Model No. 820-
0062)
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
96. The Infringing Gas Products have appropriated the ornamental design for
21
a frame assembly for a barbeque grill as shown and described in the ‘586 Patent. The
22
‘586 Patent claims a non-functional ornamental design.
23
97. In the eye of the ordinary observer, giving such attention as a purchaser
24
usually gives, the non-functional ornamental design for a frame assembly for a
25
barbeque grill claimed in the ‘586 Patent and the Infringing Gas Products are
26
substantially the same; the resemblance is such as to deceive an ordinary observer,
27
inducing him/her to purchase one supposing it to be the other.
28
98. Nexgrill has infringed and continues to infringe the ornamental design for
COMPLAINT
23
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 24 of 54 Page ID #:24
1 a frame assembly for a barbeque grill claimed in the ‘586 Patent within the meaning
2 of 35 U.S.C. § 271(a) through activities including, without limitation, importing,
3 offering for sale, and selling the Infringing Gas Products in the United States.
4 99. Nexgrill has also indirectly infringed and continues to indirectly infringe
5 the ornamental design for a frame assembly for a barbeque grill claimed in the ‘586
6 Patent under 35 U.S.C. § 271(b) by knowingly and actively inducing infringement
7 through the foregoing activities including, without limitation, importing, offering to
8 sell, and selling the Infringing Gas Products in the United States, and by instructing,
9 aiding, assisting, and encouraging the offer for sale, sale, and use of the Infringing
10 Gas Products in a manner that infringes the ‘586 Patent. The direct infringers that are
11 being induced by Nexgrill include, without limitation, its retail customers, resellers,
12 and end-users that offer for sale, sell, or use the Infringing Gas Products in the United
13 States.
14 100. Nexgrill’s infringement and/or knowing and intentional inducement to
15 infringe has injured Weber and Weber is entitled to recover damages adequate to
16 compensate it for such infringement, but in no event less than a reasonable royalty, as
17 permitted under 35 U.S.C. § 284, as well as all remedies for design patent
18 infringement permitted under 35 U.S.C. § 289.
19 101. Weber has complied with 35 U.S.C. § 287 to the extent required by law.
20 102. Weber’s infringement and/or inducement to infringe the ‘586 Patent has
21 been willful, deliberate, and objectively reckless.
22 103. Nexgrill’s infringement of the ‘586 Patent has caused irreparable harm to
23 Weber, which has no adequate remedy at law, and will continue to injure Weber
24 unless and until this Court enters an injunction prohibiting further infringement and,
25 specifically, enjoining further importation, manufacture, use, offer for sale, and/or sale
26 of the Infringing Gas Products and any other products within the scope of the design
27 claimed in the ‘586 Patent, and enjoining Nexgrill from further inducing infringement
28 of the design claimed in the ‘586 Patent.
COMPLAINT
24
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 25 of 54 Page ID #:25
1 COUNT VIII
2 INFRINGEMENT OF U.S. DESIGN PATENT NO. D503,587
3 104. Weber repeats and incorporates by reference the allegations contained in
4 the preceding paragraphs as if set forth fully herein.
5 105. The ‘587 Patent claims an “ornamental design for a hood surface for a
6 barbeque grill.”
7 106. The Infringing Gas Products are barbeque grills with hood surfaces that
8 infringe the ‘587 Patent.
9 107. Figure 1 of the ‘587 Patent is shown on the left below, and Nexgrill’s
10 Infringing Gas Products are shown on the right below.
11
Figure 1 of ‘587 Patent Nexgrill’s Fortress 2-Burner
12 Table Top Grill (Model No. 820-
0062)
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
108. The Infringing Gas Products have appropriated the ornamental design for
21
a hood surface for a barbeque grill as shown and described in the ‘587 Patent. The
22
‘587 Patent claims a non-functional ornamental design.
23
109. In the eye of the ordinary observer, giving such attention as a purchaser
24
usually gives, the non-functional ornamental design for a hood surface for a barbeque
25
grill claimed in the ‘587 Patent and the Infringing Gas Products are substantially the
26
same; the resemblance is such as to deceive an ordinary observer, inducing him/her to
27
purchase one supposing it to be the other.
28
110. Nexgrill has infringed and continues to infringe the ornamental design for
COMPLAINT
25
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 26 of 54 Page ID #:26
1 a hood surface for a barbeque grill claimed in the ‘587 Patent within the meaning of
2 35 U.S.C. § 271(a) through activities including, without limitation, importing, offering
3 for sale, and selling the Infringing Gas Products in the United States.
4 111. Nexgrill has also indirectly infringed and continues to indirectly infringe
5 the ornamental design for a hood surface for a barbeque grill claimed in the ‘587
6 Patent under 35 U.S.C. § 271(b) by knowingly and actively inducing infringement
7 through the foregoing activities including, without limitation, importing, offering to
8 sell, and selling the Infringing Gas Products in the United States, and by instructing,
9 aiding, assisting, and encouraging the offer for sale, sale, and use of the Infringing
10 Gas Products in a manner that infringes the ‘587 Patent. The direct infringers that are
11 being induced by Nexgrill include, without limitation, its retail customers, resellers,
12 and end-users that offer for sale, sell, or use the Infringing Gas Products in the United
13 States.
14 112. Nexgrill’s infringement and/or knowing and intentional inducement to
15 infringe has injured Weber and Weber is entitled to recover damages adequate to
16 compensate it for such infringement, but in no event less than a reasonable royalty, as
17 permitted under 35 U.S.C. § 284, as well as all remedies for design patent
18 infringement permitted under 35 U.S.C. § 289.
19 113. Weber has complied with 35 U.S.C. § 287 to the extent required by law.
20 114. Weber’s infringement and/or inducement to infringe the ‘587 Patent has
21 been willful, deliberate, and objectively reckless.
22 115. Nexgrill’s infringement of the ‘587 Patent has caused irreparable harm to
23 Weber, which has no adequate remedy at law, and will continue to injure Weber
24 unless and until this Court enters an injunction prohibiting further infringement and,
25 specifically, enjoining further importation, manufacture, use, offer for sale, and/or sale
26 of the Infringing Gas Products and any other products within the scope of the design
27 claimed in the ‘587 Patent, and enjoining Nexgrill from further inducing infringement
28 of the design claimed in the ‘587 Patent.
COMPLAINT
26
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 27 of 54 Page ID #:27
1 COUNT IX
2 INFRINGEMENT OF U.S. DESIGN PATENT NO. D510,680
3 116. Weber repeats and incorporates by reference the allegations contained in
4 the preceding paragraphs as if set forth fully herein.
5 117. The ‘680 Patent claims an “ornamental design for a frame assembly for a
6 barbeque grill.”
7 118. The Infringing Gas Products are barbeque grills with frame assemblies
8 that infringe the ‘680 Patent.
9 119. Figure 1 of the ‘680 Patent is shown on the left below, and Nexgrill’s
10 Infringing Gas Products are shown on the right below.
11
Figure 1 of ‘680 Patent Nexgrill’s Fortress 2-Burner
12 Table Top Grill (Model No. 820-
0062)
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
120. The Infringing Gas Products have appropriated the ornamental design for
21
a frame assembly for a barbeque grill as shown and described in the ‘680 Patent. The
22
‘680 Patent claims a non-functional ornamental design.
23
121. In the eye of the ordinary observer, giving such attention as a purchaser
24
usually gives, the non-functional ornamental design for a frame assembly for a
25
barbeque grill claimed in the ‘680 Patent and the Infringing Gas Products are
26
substantially the same; the resemblance is such as to deceive an ordinary observer,
27
inducing him/her to purchase one supposing it to be the other.
28
122. Nexgrill has infringed and continues to infringe the ornamental design for
COMPLAINT
27
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 28 of 54 Page ID #:28
1 a frame assembly for a barbeque grill claimed in the ‘680 Patent within the meaning
2 of 35 U.S.C. § 271(a) through activities including, without limitation, importing,
3 offering for sale, and selling the Infringing Gas Products in the United States.
4 123. Nexgrill has also indirectly infringed and continues to indirectly infringe
5 the ornamental design for a frame assembly for a barbeque grill claimed in the ‘680
6 Patent under 35 U.S.C. § 271(b) by knowingly and actively inducing infringement
7 through the foregoing activities including, without limitation, importing, offering to
8 sell, and selling the Infringing Gas Products in the United States, and by instructing,
9 aiding, assisting, and encouraging the offer for sale, sale, and use of the Infringing
10 Gas Products in a manner that infringes the ‘680 Patent. The direct infringers that are
11 being induced by Nexgrill include, without limitation, its retail customers, resellers,
12 and end-users that offer for sale, sell, or use the Infringing Gas Products in the United
13 States.
14 124. Nexgrill’s infringement and/or knowing and intentional inducement to
15 infringe has injured Weber and Weber is entitled to recover damages adequate to
16 compensate it for such infringement, but in no event less than a reasonable royalty, as
17 permitted under 35 U.S.C. § 284, as well as all remedies for design patent
18 infringement permitted under 35 U.S.C. § 289.
19 125. Weber has complied with 35 U.S.C. § 287 to the extent required by law.
20 126. Weber’s infringement and/or inducement to infringe the ‘680 Patent has
21 been willful, deliberate, and objectively reckless.
22 127. Nexgrill’s infringement of the ‘680 Patent has caused irreparable harm to
23 Weber, which has no adequate remedy at law, and will continue to injure Weber
24 unless and until this Court enters an injunction prohibiting further infringement and,
25 specifically, enjoining further importation, manufacture, use, offer for sale, and/or sale
26 of the Infringing Gas Products and any other products within the scope of the design
27 claimed in the ‘680 Patent, and enjoining Nexgrill from further inducing infringement
28 of the design claimed in the ‘680 Patent.
COMPLAINT
28
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 29 of 54 Page ID #:29
1 COUNT X
2 FEDERAL TRADEMARK INFRINGEMENT OF U.S. TRADEMARK REG.
3 NO. 3,987,743
4 128. Weber repeats and incorporates by reference the allegations contained in
5 the preceding paragraphs as if set forth fully herein.
6 129. This Court has jurisdiction over the subject matter of this claim for
7 trademark infringement under the Trademark Laws of the United States as codified in
8 15 U.S.C. § 1051 et seq.
9 130. The activities of Nexgrill complained of herein constitute willful and
10 intentional infringement of the ‘743 Mark. Nexgrill’s unauthorized use of the ‘743
11 Mark on its Infringing Gas Products began years after Weber’s registration and
12 continued use of the ‘743 Mark.
13 131. Any product or advertisement bearing the famous and distinctive grill
14 design covered by the ‘743 Mark is immediately associated by purchasers, potential
15 purchasers, and the public as being sourced, sponsored, or affiliated with Weber.
16 132. Long after Weber’s adoption and use of the ‘743 Mark on its Q® grill
17 product line, and long after Weber’s federal registration of the ‘743 Mark, Nexgrill
18 commenced manufacturing, distributing, advertising, selling, and offering for sale in
19 interstate commerce (including in this judicial district) the Infringing Gas Products
20 depicted below that are confusingly similar to the ‘743 Mark.
Nexgrill’s Fortress 2-Burner Table Weber Trademark Reg. No.
21 Top Grill (Model No. 820-0062) 3,987,743
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
COMPLAINT
29
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 30 of 54 Page ID #:30
COMPLAINT
30
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 31 of 54 Page ID #:31
COMPLAINT
31
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 32 of 54 Page ID #:32
1 148. Long after Weber’s adoption and use of the Weber Kettle Marks,
2 Nexgrill commenced manufacturing, distributing, advertising, selling, and offering for
3 sale in interstate commerce (including in this judicial district) the Infringing Kettle
4 Products depicted below that are confusingly similar to the Weber Kettle Marks.
5
Nexgrill’s Megamaster Kettle Grill Weber Trademark Reg. Nos.
6 (Model No. 810-0026) 1,481,521 and 1,479,505
7
10
11
12
13
14
149. Nexgrill’s unauthorized and unlicensed use of the Weber Kettle Marks in
15
connection with the sale, offering for sale, distribution, and advertising of the
16
Infringing Kettle Products in interstate commerce, without the consent of Weber, has
17
caused and is likely to cause confusion, mistake, or deception among the consuming
18
public, creates the false impression that Nexgrill’s Infringing Kettle Products are
19
authorized, sponsored, or approved by Weber, and impairs the distinctiveness of the
20
Weber Kettle Marks.
21
150. Based on Weber’s decades of continuous and exclusive use, extensive
22
advertising, sales, and the massive popularity of the 3-legged kettle grill design, the
23
Weber Kettle Marks have acquired secondary meaning. Any product and
24
advertisement bearing such trademarks is immediately associated by purchasers,
25
potential purchasers, and the public as being a product of, and affiliated with, Weber.
26
151. Weber has been directly injured by Nexgrill’s infringing activities.
27
152. Nexgrill has copied and imitated the Weber Kettle Marks in connection
28
with selling, distributing, and advertising Nexgrill’s Infringing Kettle Products.
COMPLAINT
32
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 33 of 54 Page ID #:33
COMPLAINT
33
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 34 of 54 Page ID #:34
1 160. Nexgrill is fully aware of the popularity of Weber’s Q® grill product line
2 and the clear association of the Q® grill design with that line of products.
3 161. Nexgrill’s Infringing Gas Products were designed to have the same
4 distinctive overall appearance and look as the Weber Q® grill products and are
5 confusingly similar in total image, appearance, and overall aesthetic look. As a result,
6 the public is, and is likely to be, confused.
7 162. Based on Weber’s continuous and exclusive use, extensive advertising,
8 sales, and the massive popularity of the Weber Q® grill product line, the Weber Q®
9 grill design has acquired secondary meaning. Indeed, since the introduction of the
10 Weber Q® grill design, Weber has spent millions of dollars advertising and promoting
11 its famous Q® grill products online and in magazines, newspapers, on billboards, bus
12 stops, buildings, television, and the like. (See, e.g., Ex. J (depicting various
13 advertising mediums of the Weber Q® grill products).) By 2010, Weber had sold
14 millions of its Q® grills, with wholesale revenues in excess of $250,000,000.00.
15 Since that time and to date, Weber continues to successfully sell, market, and
16 advertise its Q® grill product line. The commercial success of Weber’s Q® grills has
17 also generated substantial unsolicited media coverage. (See, e.g., Ex. K.)
18 163. The Weber Q® grill design obtained secondary meaning well prior to
19 Nexgrill’s introduction of the Infringing Gas Products. Nexgrill intentionally copied
20 and offers in interstate commerce grill products that create the same overall visual
21 effect and appearance as Weber’s famous Q® grill product line.
22 164. Nexgrill has used in commerce, and continues to use in commerce, the
23 Weber Q® grill design to unfairly benefit from Weber’s success by selling the
24 Infringing Gas Products bearing the same design in this jurisdiction and throughout
25 the United States.
26 165. Images of the Weber Q® grill design and Nexgrill’s Infringing Gas
27 Products are shown on the page immediately below.
28
COMPLAINT
34
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 35 of 54 Page ID #:35
1
Weber Q® Grill Nexgrill’s Fortress 2-Burner
2 Table Top Grill (Model No. 820-
0062)
3
10 166. Nexgrill could have selected an alternative aesthetic design and achieved
11 the same functionality as its current Infringing Gas Products, as discussed in
12 paragraphs 174-175 below.
13 167. The Weber Q® grill products have a distinctive, non-functional design
14 that the relevant consuming public associates with Weber.
15 168. Nexgrill has used Weber’s Q® grill design on its Infringing Gas Products
16 with the express intent to pass off Nexgrill’s Infringing Gas Products as those of
17 Weber and to cause confusion and mislead the purchasing public into believing that
18 Nexgrill’s Infringing Gas Products are authorized, sponsored, affiliated with, or
19 associated with Weber, and to trade upon Weber’s reputation for high-quality grill
20 products and to improperly appropriate Weber’s valuable goodwill and trade dress
21 rights.
22 169. The unauthorized and unlicensed sale of Nexgrill’s Infringing Gas
23 Products is likely to cause consumer confusion because of the similarity in appearance
24 and look between Nexgrill’s and Weber’s products. Consumers will believe that
25 Nexgrill’s Infringing Gas Products are either manufactured, licensed, affiliated with,
26 or sponsored by Weber, or are being placed on the market with Weber’s consent
27 and/or actual or implied authority. As a result, Weber has been and will continue to
28 be irreparably injured by Nexgrill’s improper acts.
COMPLAINT
35
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 36 of 54 Page ID #:36
1 170. Nexgrill has willfully, deliberately, and with predatory intent, created
2 such confusion by copying and reproducing the distinctive and unique design and
3 overall product appearance of Weber’s Q® grills; and has advertised and sold its
4 Infringing Gas Products so as to cause public confusion and deception for a
5 substantial portion of the people who perceive the advertisements, which confusion
6 and deception is likely to influence purchase decisions. Further, Nexgrill’s sales and
7 offers for sale of its Infringing Gas Products have caused Weber the loss of its
8 valuable goodwill and reputation for making and selling distinctive, unique, and high-
9 quality grill products under the Q® grill design.
10 171. Nexgrill’s aforesaid acts constitute unfair competition and the use in
11 commerce of false designations of origin and false and/or misleading descriptions or
12 representations, tending to falsely or misleadingly describe and/or represent Nexgrill’s
13 Infringing Gas Products as that of Weber in violation of Section 43 of the Lanham
14 Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a).
15 172. Weber has expended considerable time, effort, and resources to design,
16 develop, and protect the unique and distinctive appearance of its Q® grill products.
17 The Q® grill design has been featured prominently in Weber’s in-store, on-site, and
18 other advertisements and promotions for its portable grill product line. This unique
19 trade dress has become associated with the success of Weber’s Q® grill products and
20 has become an indication of a single, high-quality source for those products in the
21 minds of the relevant purchasing public. As a result, this trade dress has obtained
22 secondary meaning and is a valuable, irreplaceable asset of Weber’s business.
23 173. Since at least 2004, Weber’s Q® grill product line has consistently
24 incorporated the following unique, non-functional design features, which individually
25 and in combination and sub-combinations, describe the overall appearance
26 constituting Weber’s asserted trade dress in this action: 1) a generally oval-shaped
27 cooking chamber with an upper portion and a lower portion; 2) a horizontal handle
28 located on a generally semicircular front face of the upper portion of the cooking
COMPLAINT
36
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 37 of 54 Page ID #:37
1 chamber; 3) two generally semi-elliptical frames under and spaced apart from the
2 front and back lower portions of the cooking chamber, which semi-elliptical frames
3 generally follow the curvature of the lower portion of the cooking chamber; 4) legs
4 projecting downwardly from the semi-elliptical frames; 5) the bases of the legs
5 defining a rectangular shape; and 6) two horizontal handles extending between the
6 semi-elliptical frames.
7 174. Weber’s asserted trade dress is non-functional, and Nexgrill could have
8 designed a grill with the same functionality without any of the elements in Weber’s
9 asserted trade dress as shown, for example, in the Original Outdoor Cooker 11000-
10 BTU 220-sq in Portable Gas Grill, Cuisinart 14,000-BTU 243-sq in Portable Gas
11 Grill, Urban Dual Burner Portable Propane Gas Grill, Blaze Professional Portable
12 Grill, Char-Broil Stainless Portable Gas Grill 200, and Char-Broil Grill2Go X200 Gas
13 Grill.
14 Original Outdoor Cooker 11000- Cuisinart 14,000-BTU 243-sq in
BTU 220-sq in Portable Gas Grill Portable Gas Grill
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
Urban Dual Burner Portable Blaze Professional Portable Grill
22 Propane Gas Grill
23
24
25
26
27
28
COMPLAINT
37
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 38 of 54 Page ID #:38
10 175. None of Weber’s asserted trade dress features defined in paragraph 173
11 above, individually or in combination or sub-combinations, is essential to the use or
12 purpose of a barbeque grill and does not affect the cost or quality of a barbeque grill.
13 Indeed, Weber’s Q® grill design does not result from a comparatively simple or
14 inexpensive method of manufacture in relation to alternative designs for barbeque grill
15 products, and the cost of manufacturing Weber’s Q® grill products is comparable or
16 greater than competing barbeque grill products. Likewise, Weber’s right to
17 exclusively use these trade dress features would not put Nexgrill (or any other
18 competitors) at a significant non-reputation-related disadvantage.
19 176. Nexgrill’s selection and use of a substantially similar look and
20 appearance for its Infringing Gas Products is likely to mislead and confuse the public
21 as to the source, sponsorship, and affiliation of Nexgrill’s Infringing Gas Products.
22 Because of the nearly-identical look of Nexgrill’s Infringing Gas Products to Weber’s
23 non-functional trade dress associated with Weber’s Q® grill products, the public is
24 likely to believe that Nexgrill’s Infringing Gas Products are in some way affiliated or
25 associated with, or sponsored by, Weber.
26 177. Weber has suffered actual damages as a result of Nexgrill’s trade dress
27 infringement, unfair competition, and false designation of origin in an amount to be
28 proven at trial. In addition, Nexgrill’s acts have caused, and will continue to cause,
COMPLAINT
38
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 39 of 54 Page ID #:39
1 great and irreparable injury to Weber, and unless such acts are restrained by this
2 Court, Nexgrill will continue such acts, thereby causing Weber to continue to suffer
3 substantial and irreparable harm for which it has no adequate remedy at law.
4 178. Nexgrill’s actions have been knowing, intentional, wanton, and willful,
5 entitling Weber to increased damages, statutory damages, prejudgment interest,
6 attorney fees, and costs.
7 COUNT XIII
8 FEDERAL TRADE DRESS INFRINGEMENT, UNFAIR COMPETITION,
9 AND FALSE DESIGNATION OF ORIGIN OF WEBER’S 3-LEGGED
10 KETTLE GRILL DESIGN
11 179. Weber repeats and incorporates by reference the allegations contained in
12 the preceding paragraphs as if set forth fully herein.
13 180. This Court has jurisdiction over the subject matter of this claim for trade
14 dress infringement, unfair competition, and false designation of origin arising under
15 Section 43 of the Lanham Act, codified in 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a).
16 181. Nexgrill is fully aware of the popularity of the Weber 3-legged kettle grill
17 line and the clear association of the kettle grill design with that line of products.
18 182. Nexgrill’s Infringing Kettle Products were designed to have the same
19 distinctive overall appearance and look as the Weber 3-legged kettle grill products and
20 are confusingly similar in total image, appearance and overall aesthetic look. As a
21 result, the public is, and is likely to be, confused.
22 183. Based on Weber’s continuous and exclusive use, extensive advertising,
23 sales, and the massive popularity of the Weber 3-legged kettle grill line, the Weber 3-
24 legged kettle grill design has acquired secondary meaning. Indeed, since the
25 introduction of the Weber 3-legged kettle grill design, Weber has spent tens of
26 millions of dollars advertising and promoting its famous 3-legged kettle grill products
27 online and in magazines, newspapers, on billboards, bus stops, buildings, television,
28 and the like. (See, e.g., Ex. L (depicting various advertising mediums of the Weber’s
COMPLAINT
39
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 40 of 54 Page ID #:40
1 3-legged kettle grill products). For example, Weber has extensively advertised and
2 promoted its 3-legged kettle grill, including:
3 (a) The landmark Weber restaurant (located at 539 N. State Street in
4 Chicago, Illinois) and similar Weber restaurants throughout the country feature
5 prominent mock-ups of Weber’s iconic 3-legged kettle grill:
6
10
11
12
13
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
COMPLAINT
40
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 41 of 54 Page ID #:41
1 signs with a silhouette of the 3-legged kettle grill design prominently shown, as well
2 as a 20+ foot mock up displayed at the building’s entrance:
3
10
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23 184. To date, Weber has sold tens of millions of its 3-legged kettle grills, with
24 hundreds of millions of dollars in wholesale revenues. Since that time and to date,
25 Weber continues to successfully sell, market, and advertise its 3-legged kettle grill
26 line. The commercial success of Weber’s 3-legged kettle grills has also generated
28 185. The Weber 3-legged kettle grill design obtained secondary meaning well
COMPLAINT
41
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 42 of 54 Page ID #:42
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
COMPLAINT
42
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 43 of 54 Page ID #:43
1 187. Nexgrill has used in commerce, and continue to use in commerce, the
2 Weber 3-legged kettle grill design to unfairly benefit from Weber’s success by selling
3 the Infringing Kettle Products bearing the same design in this jurisdiction and
4 throughout the United States.
5 188. Nexgrill could have selected an alternative aesthetic design and achieved
6 the same functionality as its current Infringing Kettle Products, as discussed in
7 paragraph 196-197 below.
8 189. The Weber 3-legged kettle grill products have a distinctive, non-
9 functional design that the relevant consuming public associates with Weber.
10 190. Nexgrill has used Weber’s 3-legged kettle grill design on its Infringing
11 Kettle Products with the express intent to pass off Nexgrill’s Infringing Kettle
12 Products as those of Weber and to cause confusion and mislead the purchasing public
13 into believing that Nexgrill’s Infringing Kettle Products are authorized, sponsored,
14 affiliated with, or associated with Weber, and to trade upon Weber’s reputation for
15 high-quality grill products and to improperly appropriate Weber’s valuable trade dress
16 rights.
17 191. The unauthorized and unlicensed sale of Nexgrill’s Infringing Kettle
18 Products is likely to cause consumer confusion because of the similarity in appearance
19 and look between Nexgrill’s and Weber’s products. Consumers will believe that
20 Nexgrill’s Infringing Kettle Products are either manufactured, licensed, affiliated
21 with, or sponsored by Weber, or are being placed on the market with Weber’s consent
22 and/or actual or implied authority. As a result, Weber has been and will continue to
23 be irreparably injured by Nexgrill’s improper acts.
24 192. Nexgrill has willfully, deliberately, and with predatory intent, created
25 such confusion by copying and reproducing the distinctive and unique design and
26 overall product appearance of Weber’s 3-legged kettle grills; and has advertised and
27 sold its Infringing Kettle Products so as to cause public confusion and deception for a
28 substantial portion of the people who perceive the advertisements, which confusion
COMPLAINT
43
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 44 of 54 Page ID #:44
1 and deception is likely to influence purchase decisions. Further, Nexgrill’s sales and
2 offers for sale of its Infringing Kettle Products have caused Weber the loss of its
3 valuable goodwill and reputation for making and selling distinctive, unique, and high-
4 quality grill products under the 3-legged kettle design.
5 193. Nexgrill’s aforesaid acts constitute unfair competition and the use in
6 commerce of false designations of origin and false and/or misleading descriptions or
7 representations, tending to falsely or misleadingly describe and/or represent Nexgrill’s
8 Infringing Kettle Products as that of Weber in violation of Section 43 of the Lanham
9 Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1125(a).
10 194. Weber has expended considerable time, effort, and resources to design,
11 develop and protect the unique and distinctive appearances of its 3-legged kettle grill
12 products. The 3-legged kettle grill design has been featured prominently in Weber’s
13 in-store, on-site, and other advertisements and promotions for its charcoal grill
14 product line. This unique trade dress has become associated with the success of
15 Weber’s 3-legged kettle grill products and has become an indication of a single, high-
16 quality source for those products in the minds of the relevant purchasing public. As a
17 result, this trade dress has obtained secondary meaning and is a valuable, irreplaceable
18 asset of Weber’s business.
19 195. Since at least 1960, Weber’s 3-legged kettle grill line has consistently
20 incorporated the following unique design features, which individually and in
21 combination and sub-combinations, describe the overall appearance constituting
22 Weber’s asserted trade dress in this action: 1) a generally dome-shaped kettle with a
23 circularly-shaped vent unit located on an upper portion of the kettle; 2) three tubular
24 legs, in a tripod arrangement, supporting the kettle and projecting downwardly and
25 outwardly from the kettle; 3) the bases of the legs defining a triangular shape; 4) two
26 of the legs bearing wheels, with an axle in-between; and 5) a webbed brace unit
27 extending from the two legs bearing wheels to a third leg.
28 196. The Weber 3-legged kettle grill design is non-functional, and Nexgrill
COMPLAINT
44
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 45 of 54 Page ID #:45
1 could have designed a grill with the same functionality without any of the elements in
2 Weber’s asserted trade dress as shown, for example, in the Aussie 21.25-in Kobalt
3 Kettle Charcoal Grill, the Char-Broil American Gourmet 32.28-in Barrel Charcoal
4 Grill, the PK Grills Original Grill and Smoker, and the UniFlame Deluxe Outdoor
5 Charcoal Grill.
6
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
COMPLAINT
45
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 46 of 54 Page ID #:46
1
PK Grills Original Grill and Smoker UniFlame Deluxe Outdoor Charcoal
2
Grill
3
10
11
12
13
14 197. None of Weber’s asserted trade dress features defined in paragraph 195
15 above, individually or in combination or sub-combinations, is essential to the use or
16 purpose of a barbeque grill and does not affect the cost or quality of a barbeque grill.
17 Indeed, Weber’s 3-legged kettle grill design does not result from a comparatively
18 simple or inexpensive method of manufacture in relation to alternative designs for
19 barbeque grill products, and the cost of manufacturing Weber’s 3-legged kettle grill
20 products is comparable or greater than competing barbeque grill products. Likewise,
21 Weber’s right to exclusively use these trade dress features would not put Nexgrill (or
22 any other competitors) at a significant non-reputation-related disadvantage.
23 198. Nexgrill’s selection and use of a substantially similar look and
24 appearance for its Infringing Kettle Products is likely to mislead and confuse the
25 public as to the source, sponsorship, and affiliation of Nexgrill’s Infringing Kettle
26 Products. Because of the nearly-identical look of Nexgrill’s Infringing Kettle
27 Products to Weber’s non-functional trade dress associated with Weber’s 3-legged
28 kettle grill products, the public is likely to believe that Nexgrill’s Infringing Kettle
COMPLAINT
46
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 47 of 54 Page ID #:47
1 Products are in some way affiliated or associated with, or sponsored by, Weber.
2 199. Weber has suffered actual damages as a result of Nexgrill’s trade dress
3 infringement, unfair competition, and false designation of origin in an amount to be
4 proven at trial. In addition, Nexgrill’s acts have caused, and will continue to cause,
5 great and irreparable injury to Weber, and unless such acts are restrained by this
6 Court, Nexgrill will continue such acts, thereby causing Weber to continue to suffer
7 substantial and irreparable harm for which it has no adequate remedy at law.
8 200. Nexgrill’s actions have been knowing, intentional, wanton, and willful,
9 entitling Weber to increased damages, statutory damages, prejudgment interest,
10 attorney fees, and costs.
11 COUNT XIV
12 FEDERAL TRADEMARK DILUTION OF THE WEBER KETTLE MARKS
13 201. Weber repeats and incorporates by reference the allegations contained in
14 the preceding paragraphs as if set forth fully herein.
15 202. This Court has jurisdiction over the subject matter of this claim for
16 trademark dilution arising under Section 43 of the Lanham Act, codified in 15 U.S.C.
17 § 1125(c).
18 203. Nexgrill’s use of the Weber Kettle Marks on its Infringing Kettle
19 Products constitutes Nexgrill’s commercial use in commerce of the Weber Kettle
20 Marks.
21 204. Based on Weber’s extensive sales, marketing, and advertising of the
22 Weber 3-legged kettle grill design and the Weber Kettle Marks, the Weber Kettle
23 Marks have become distinctive and famous pursuant to 15 U.S.C. § 1125(c). As a
24 result, the Weber Kettle Marks are recognized by the general consuming public as a
25 designation of the source of Weber’s goods and services.
26 205. The nearly identical style, look, and overall visual appearance of the
27 Infringing Kettle Products, as well as Nexgrill’s efforts to pass off its Infringing Kettle
28 Products as being made, marketed, sponsored, licensed, or otherwise approved by
COMPLAINT
47
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 48 of 54 Page ID #:48
1 Weber, are eroding the distinctiveness of the famous Weber Kettle Marks.
2 206. Nexgrill’s use of the Weber Kettle Marks began only after such marks
3 became famous to the general consuming public.
4 207. Nexgrill’s actions have caused dilution of the Weber Kettle Marks by
5 lessening the capacity of the marks to identify and distinguish Weber’s charcoal grills
6 and grilling accessories.
7 208. Weber is threatened with injury through this dilution of its trademark
8 rights, as well as immediate and direct injury to its name, image, and business
9 reputations.
10 209. Nexgrill has willfully intended to trade on Weber’s reputation and to
11 cause dilution of the Weber Kettle Marks.
12 210. Weber has suffered actual damages as a result of Nexgrill’s acts of
13 trademark dilution in an amount to be proven at trial. In addition, Nexgrill’s acts have
14 caused, and will continue to cause, great and irreparable injury to Weber, and unless
15 such acts are restrained by this Court, Nexgrill will continue such acts, thereby
16 causing Weber to continue to suffer substantial and irreparable harm for which it has
17 no adequate remedy at law.
18 211. Nexgrill’s actions have been knowing, intentional, wanton, and willful,
19 entitling Weber to increased damages, statutory damages, prejudgment interest,
20 attorney fees, and costs.
21 COUNT XV
22 FEDERAL TRADE DRESS DILUTION OF WEBER’S 3-LEGGED KETTLE
23 GRILL DESIGN
24 212. Weber repeats and incorporates by reference the allegations contained in
25 the preceding paragraphs as if set forth fully herein.
26 213. This Court has jurisdiction over the subject matter of this claim for trade
27 dress dilution arising under Section 43 of the Lanham Act, codified in 15 U.S.C. §
28 1125(c).
COMPLAINT
48
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 49 of 54 Page ID #:49
COMPLAINT
49
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 50 of 54 Page ID #:50
1 causing Weber to continue to suffer substantial and irreparable harm for which it has
2 no adequate remedy at law.
3 223. Nexgrill’s actions have been knowing, intentional, wanton, and willful,
4 entitling Weber to increased damages, statutory damages, prejudgment interest,
5 attorney fees, and costs.
6 PRAYER FOR RELIEF
7 COUNTS I-IX
8 WHEREFORE, Weber respectfully asks this Court to enter judgment against
9 Nexgrill, and against its subsidiaries, successors, parents, affiliates, officers, directors,
10 agents, servants, and employees, and all persons in active concert or participation with
11 Nexgrill, granting the following relief:
12 A. The entry of judgment in favor of Weber and against Nexgrill;
13 B. An award of damages adequate to compensate Weber for the
14 infringement that has occurred, but in no event less than a reasonable
15 royalty as permitted by 35 U.S.C. § 284, together with prejudgment
16 interest from the date the infringement began;
17 C. Additional remedies for design patent infringement as permitted under 35
18 U.S.C. § 289;
19 D. Increased damages as permitted under 35 U.S.C. § 284;
20 E. A finding that this case is exceptional and an award to Weber of its
21 reasonable attorney fees and costs as provided by 35 U.S.C. § 285;
22 F. A permanent injunction prohibiting further infringement, inducement,
23 and/or contributory infringement of each of the Patents-in-Suit; and
24 G. Such other relief that Weber is entitled to under the law, and any other
25 and further relief that this Court or a jury may deem just and proper.
26 COUNTS X-XV
27 WHEREFORE, Weber respectfully prays for the following relief:
28 A. That judgment be entered in favor of Weber and against Nexgrill on each
COMPLAINT
50
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 51 of 54 Page ID #:51
COMPLAINT
51
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 52 of 54 Page ID #:52
1 4. using the Weber Kettle Marks and trade dress rights or marks
2 confusingly similar thereto;
3 5. engaging in any conduct that tends falsely to represent that, or is
4 likely to confuse, mislead, or deceive purchasers, potential purchasers,
5 Nexgrill’s customers, and/or members of the public to believe that, the
6 actions of Nexgrill, the products sold by Nexgrill, or Nexgrill itself
7 are connected with Weber, are sponsored, approved, or licensed by
8 Weber, or are in some way connected or affiliated with Weber;
9 6. otherwise competing unfairly with Weber in any manner; and/or
10 7. diluting and infringing the Weber Kettle Marks and Weber’s trade
11 dress rights in its 3-legged kettle grill design, eroding the
12 distinctiveness of the Weber Kettle Marks and Weber’s trade dress
13 rights in its 3-legged kettle grill design, and damaging Weber’s
14 goodwill, reputation, and business;
15 C. That Weber be awarded damages in an amount sufficient to compensate
16 it for the injuries it has sustained by reason of Nexgrill’s unlawful acts,
17 including Weber’s loss of goodwill, loss of past and/or future sales, and
18 damages caused by Nexgrill’s acts of trademark and trade dress infringement,
19 unfair competition, false designation of origin, and trademark and trade dress
20 dilution. That Weber be awarded increased damages based upon the intentional
21 and willful nature of Nexgrill’s conduct of the kind complained of herein. That
22 Weber be awarded all gains, profits, and advantages received by Nexgrill from
23 the sale of its Infringing Gas Products, its Infringing Kettle Products, and any
24 other products that infringe upon and/or dilute Weber’s trademark and trade
25 dress rights;
26 D. That Weber be awarded all additional remedies provided for in 15 U.S.C.
27 § 1117;
28 E. That Nexgrill be ordered to deliver up for destruction all advertisements,
COMPLAINT
52
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 53 of 54 Page ID #:53
1 circulars, brochures, and any other items in its possession, custody, or control
2 bearing the ‘743 Mark, the Weber Kettle Marks, the Weber Q® grill design, the
3 Weber 3-legged kettle grill design, or any other similar designations;
4 F. That Nexgrill be ordered to (a) prepare and send to its customers and the
5 general public corrective statements approved by Weber, correcting all false
6 statements made and all misrepresentations made concerning Weber’s ‘743
7 Mark, the Weber Kettle Marks, and trade dress rights; (b) disclaim any
8 association between Nexgrill and Weber and/or Weber’s products; and (c)
9 recall and make reasonable efforts to obtain the return of any infringing or
10 confusingly similar products from its customers;
11 G. That Weber be awarded punitive damages for Nexgrill’s willful and
12 malicious acts of common law unfair competition and deceptive trade practices;
13 and
14 H. That the Court provide Weber with such other and further relief as it
15 deems just and proper, or that Weber may be entitled to under the law,
16 including but not limited to attorney fees, costs, and interest.
17
26
27
28
COMPLAINT
53
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 54 of 54 Page ID #:54
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
COMPLAINT
54
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 1 of 13 Page ID #:55
([KLELW$
1/29/2019
Exhibit A, Page
2:46:16
55 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 2 of 13 Page ID #:56
Ʋ³³²³Æ²² ³²³²³Æ² Ƴ³²² Ƴ³²²³Æ³²² ³Æ²³² ²Æ³²³³²Æ?@ @ @??@@ @??@@ ?@?@?@@?@? @ ?@@??@Æ
%;çR<<RñNŀ
¸ m|¸ hu¸ `u¸ K *4E9>EK (?K 0+K ō ō
,<?95K #' ¸ #4E9K?:K*4E9>EK ,9@
K
'# ¸ &5^ 83/#3^ 9(6'^ $,.#^
< < < !KZCKE[
56(,(;6(1/^ 5638 683#^
< <
< !KZCKE[
< < < A:MMYAKEI:P[
+' ¸ E_ă . SL =PPEC^5L SE?^ ªă x2ă $ < <
< !KZCKE[
< <
< 0@ESJ7[
Eăt:ă
< < < CQ6A[
< < < A:MMYAKEI:P[
+ ¸ [
_ă 9 E?EV
5Y ETL EQ^ 2 VSCZ AY X^ S
^
2ă
< < < !KZCKE[
Eăt:ă
< < < !KZCKE[
< < < :6DA0I[ :Q[ 0E[
ă ŀ J_ă : "Qăă ă
2ă ăăă ă
< < < !KZCKE[
ă ă Bă ă Q ă ă '¸ < < < !KZCKE[
t:Xă '#] ¸ "ă , ă < <
< *6AEKPP:M[
< < < MKAI0JJ[
< < < $SMLAY[ :Q[ 0E[
¸ [
ă J _ ă ^
< < < (0YI:M[ :Q[ 0E[
¸ N
_ă . =V
^ ^ ^
< < < (0YI:M[ :Q[ 0E[
< < < (C:AE[
ă)' ¸ 2VMSV^ 2Z?OM A=YMSQ^ "=Y =^
< < < 0MD:M[
< < < :M@:M[
-*[ <3< *:L[ < <
< < < !KZCKE[
^
< < < :>CJ@[ :Q[ 0E[
' ¸ (QY
^ O
[ $"^ ^
< <
< #KJ@[
' ¸ 8
5
^ )/¸ Pă
O
^ [ ^
< <
< $KKM:[ M[ :Q[ 0E[
'- ¸ $MEOC^ SG^5 E=VAL^ [ #'#2¸ )/¸ P2ă
< <
< *KI:MUCEE:[
)#¸
< < < A0MEPKJ[ :Q[ 0E[
ă ă ă
ăăăă" ăăă
< <
< !KZCKE[ ă
ă
ă
ă ă" ăăă<ă"
G
ă
< < < ,0J0D0[ :Q[ 0E[ K ă
ă ă <ă "
G
ă ă ă ă Bă
< < < 0MMCP[
ă ă
ă
ă ă ă " ă ă D ă
< < < !KZCKE[ ă ă K ă ă ă <ă "
Gă K7
< < < CQ6A[
ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă
< < < !KZCKE[
" ă ă ă ă ă ă ă B
ă <ă
$< < < 0PQCJ@P[
< < < &:M:Z[
< < < M:4:M[ ^ O=MPX^ ^ "V=\MQK^5L EEY X^
1/29/2019
Exhibit A, Page
2:46:16
56 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 3 of 13 Page ID #:57
'%< "& &< !' &%< < < < *ICMJKU[
< < < ,AKMJ7YD:[
< < < *6AMK:Q:M[ :Q[ 0E[
< < < #:M6A[ :Q[ 0E[
< < < C:4:E[ :Q[ 0E[
< < < *Q:LA:J[ :Q[ 0E[
< < < < (K7@:MP[ ---------------------A <
< 3< < C:4:E[ :Q[ 0E[
< <
< *6AMK:Q:M[ :Q[ 0E[
< 3< < 0YJ:P[
< < < :MMCJ@[
< < < < .KK7[ :Q[ 0E[ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - A
<
< < < #CJJ:4SM[ :Q[ 0E[
< 3< <
< #0P0@JC[ :Q[ 0E[ - - - - - - - - - - - - - A
<
< < < #KJ@[
< < < *6AEKPP:M[ :Q[ 0E[
< < < #KJ@[ :Q[ 0E[ Î +09-,< *;< -:(405-6<
1/29/2019
Exhibit A, Page
2:46:16
57 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 4 of 13 Page ID #:58
°ħ
AÎ
67u
"
Mu
1/29/2019
Exhibit A, Page
2:46:16
58 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 5 of 13 Page ID #:59
7ŀ
Þħ
?X
7ŀ
CC
îħ *u Î
C
Êħ
C
Î
7ŀ
ãħ
Ru ¡Î
CC
Yu
CC
Î
Éħ
Lu
ŌĴō
Óħ
1/29/2019
Exhibit A, Page
2:46:16
59 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 6 of 13 Page ID #:60
*80
X
èÒō
+90X
,:1X
ąfúăĉō òfĎō
¾ÍÉō
1/29/2019
Exhibit A, Page
2:46:16
60 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 7 of 13 Page ID #:61
[`[ō
)7/ X
Zæ«ō
L ©ō
Ä`ō
ÅÛTō
(5-
!X
ĔÇÌ®ō
øċō
ÆËTō
¶¸
(6."X
Zç¬ō
1/29/2019
Exhibit A, Page
2:46:16
61 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 8 of 13 Page ID #:62
3-K
ŀ !K
K K
&5^ 83/#3^ 9(6'^ $,.#^ [ă ă ă NEW:ă ^ ă" ă "
ă ^
ă
56(,(;6(1/^ 5638 683#^ ă ă@ă" ă "ă ^ ăă" ă "ă ^ ă
ă" ă^ ăăă "ă^ } ăăă ă
" ă ă >
ă
ă ă
"
ă ă ă
DxXJEX[ăNExză ă ă "ă ă ă ă ă ă
D ă ă ă
ă ă ă
ă " ă iă X
ă
ă " ă "
2ă
ă ă
@
2ă ăăă
ăăă
ă" ă "ă " ă
ă ă" ă "2ă ă ă"ă 7
ă ă
ă ă"
GăK ă ăăă "
ăă <ă "ă ăă"ă ă"ă
ă
"
Gă ă <ă
ă ă ă " ă "ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă
UNÎ @"Bă[ă "ă ă ă <ă B
ă ă " ă
7
ăă
ă ă B
2ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ă 2ă ă
ă ă
ă" ăă ăă
ăă ă
ă ă ăă ă@"Băă ă ă <ăă®<%¯ă
>@ăăEăăă
ă"" ă
2ă ă
±ă ă "ă
ă ă ă
2ă ă ă ă 7
"" ă
ă
ă ă " ă "
ă ă q ă ă
" "
ă < 2ăăB
2ăăă
ă
2ă ăă "ă ă ă ă K ă ă ă ă <ă ă "ă
K
ă ă s" ă
ă ă
ăă
ăă ă
ă
ăă
ă " ă "
ă ă
ă
ă ă 2ă
ă q ă
ă ă ă
> ă 2ă ă ă
ăă ă ă @"Băă "ă ă ă
ă "
ă ă ă @
ă ă ă
ă B7
ă }ă 2ă
ă ă ă @ă K ă ă ă
D ăă ă
ăăj
ăK ă
ă
ă"
2ă ă"
ăă<ă "ă
ă " ă "
ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ZjÎ
ă B
ă
ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă %
ă "ă D ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ă ă ă
ă " ă K ă
[ă B
ă ă ă
ă" ă "
ă
ă ă
" ă "ă
ă ă ă >
ă K ă ă dNÎ :tii[P¼ă }NăDxă EJxJDE}Jă
ăă ă"
ă
ă"" ă
ă ă
Gă ă
ă " ă "ă ă ă @ă ă ă <ă ăEă ăă "Qăă ăă 7
ăă ăK
ă ăăăăă ăăă ă ă ă ă " ă "
ă wă ă "" ă
ă ă
D ă" ă "ă ăăăăă" ă
ăă ă ă ă " ă "
ă
ă ă
ă ă
ă
ă ăK
ăBă ă <ă ă x ă ăă " ă "ă ă
ă ă
ă ă " ă
ă ă
ăăăăăăă
ăă
>
ă K ă ă ăăă ă
ă
ă" ă ă " 2ă ăă ă ăă
ăăăă ăă
ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă
ăD ă ă
ăăăă<ăă ăăă ă" ă[ăăă K ă ă ă " ă "
ă ă ă ă
ă
ă ă " 2ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă "ă
ă ă t:ă
ă Jă
, ă :
ă ă
2ă ă{ă ă
1/29/2019
Exhibit A, Page
2:46:16
62 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 9 of 13 Page ID #:63
3-K
ŀ !K
K K
sPExNă zx:XPE
DE}Jă }NăDxă zP[VEJW:ă ă
ă ă
NEWă ^ ăăăăăă"" ă
ă"
ă [
2ă ă " ă ^ ă "ă ă ă ă
ă ă" ă "ăă ăvă
ă ă "
2ăăă ă
ă" ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă ă
ă D ă " ă "ă ^ ă
NEWă ^ ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă " ă "ă ă NEWă ^
ăă ăK
ă ăă ăă @ă ă ă
ă ă " ă "ă ă ă
ă <ă "
G
ă
wă <ă ă ă K
ă D ă " ă "ă ^ ă ă
vă
ă ^
NEWă ^ ă ă >ă ă ă " ă "ă %ă
ă ă ă @"Bă ^ [ăă ă ă " ă "ă ^ Bă
ă ^ ă ă
NEWă ^ ă ă
ă >ă ă ă@ă" ă "ă @"Bă ^ ^
ă ^ ă ă ă
ă K
ă ă ă <ă
±ă
%ă
ă
ă ^ ă NEWă ^
ă ă <ă "7
ă ă" ă "ă ^
G
ă K vă P
ăă ă"ă ăăNEWă ^ ă" ă
NEWă ^ ăă
ăăăă
ă" ă "ă ^ ă ă
ă
ă @
ă ă
"ă
ă ă >
ă K ă "ă ă ă B
ă
ă ^ ă
ă
ă
ă ^ ă ă
ă ă" ă vă YmÎ
ă ă ^ D ă " ă "ă ^
ă ă ă @ă <ă
NEWă ^ ă ă
ăă
ăăăă" ă "ă
ă "
G
ă ă ^ ă ăă<ă"
G
ăK7
ă <ă "
G
ă K ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă^ ă ăăăăăă"
Gă ă
vă <ă ă ă " ă <ă
ă
ă
ă ă
ă
NEWă ^ ă ă >ă ă ă " ă "ă %ă
ă
ă ă ă" ăă ^ D ăB
ă
ă
ă ^ ă NEWă ^ 2ă ²ă ^ ă ă ă "ă ă ă ă K
ă 2ă 2ă ă K
ă
ă %
ă "
ă 2ă ă ă ă :ă Jă
, [
ă ă ă
ă ă
ă ă ă 2ă ă " ă ă
Gă ă ă ă ·ă ®
> ¯ă ă ®z> ¯ă @
2ă ă @
ă
@
ă ă ă "
ă ăăă ă" ă "ă ^ ăăNăB
2ă
[ă "" ă
ă "
ă ^ ă ă ă NEWă ^ D ă ă " ă "ă ^ ă ă ă 2ă q 2ă ă
ă
"" ă
ă "
ă ^
ă
ă ă %
ă @
ă[
2ă ă " ă "ă ^ ă ă ă
"ă ^ ă ă ă {ă "
ă ^ D ă {ă
ă@
ă ăB
ăă
ă
2ă ă
"
ă ^ ă ă ă ă ă ă ă %
ă ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă
"ă ^ D ă%
ă "ă ^
ă ă ă ^ [ă ă ă NEWă ^ ă " ă "ă ^ ă ă
"
ă ă ă ă @"Bă ^ D ă "" ă
ă ^ ă{ă
ă ^ ăK
ă ă[ă
ă
ăă"ă
ăă
ă
ăăă
ă
ă
2ă
ă t:ăă
ă :ă Jă
, @
2ă ă
ă
ă ^ ă ă ă 2ă
, @
ă ă iă , , 2ă ăă ă q 2ă ă
ă@
ă
ă "ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ă "" ă
ă D ă
ă
ă ^
ă ă "%ă ^ ă ă
2ăă ă ă
ă" ă2ă
ă "ă ă ă ă ă ăB
ă
ă ^ ă ă
ă ă
ă ăă ă
ă"ăă ă ©ă @"Bă ^ ă ă" ă "ă ^ ă ă@"Bă^
[
ăă ăă"2ă ă" ă "ă ^ [ăăă
ăă ă ă ă@ă
ă ^
ăă
ăă
ă
ă ăă
ă>ă ăă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă wă
1/29/2019
Exhibit A, Page
2:46:16
63 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 10 of 13 Page ID #:64
3-K
ŀ !K
K K
ă ă ă "%ă 5=ă D ă "%ă 5=ă ă ă P
ă ă NEWă $2ă ă "
G
ă ă $#2ă $/ă ă
ă 5Iă "ă ă ă ă " ă "ă FIă ă ă ă"ă ăăă
ăă F#ă
"
2ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă "ă
ă ă ă "
G
ă ă $#2ă $/ă "ă ă ă "ă ă
@"Bă&ă
"
2ă ă"%ă5=ă ă
ăă ă" ă ăăăF#2ă 2ă ă"
G
ă ă $#2ă$/ăă
"ă FIă "ăă
ăă ăă ă ăăQăăF#ă
P
ăă NEWă R2ă ă" ă "ă FIă ă ă
ă ă ^
ă$#÷ăă ă "
G
ă ă$#ăBăă ă
ă ă ă ă F#ă {ă ă ă <ă Nă Bă ă
ă 7
ă ă ă ă ă ă ă " ă "ă FI2ă ă
ă ă ă @ă "
ă
ă <ă
ă #Ră
ă ă
ă <ă ă ă ă ă
ă FRă @ă "ă ă @ă ă
ă ##ă z"ă ă ă jă
"
2ă ă
ăăF#ăăăă ă ă
ă
ă ă ă ă <ă
ă #$ă
D ă
ăăF#ă@ă ă<ă
ă#Iăă ă " ă
\PÎ
ă ăăă
ă #&ăz"ăă ăjă2ă
"ă FIă
ă ă ă ă
ă "
ă Iă Eă ă
ă ă <ă "
G
ă K ă $#ă ă ă
"ăăă" ă ăă
ă@
2ă ă
ă "
ă
ă <ă
ă #$ă @ă "ă ă
" ă "ă FIăă ă ă "ăăă <ă
ă
#I§ ăăă ă"ă ă
ăă@ă <ă ă ă
ă #&ăD ă @ă <ă "
G
ă K ă $#ă
ă #Ră ă ă ă <ă
ă #$ă D ă <ă
ă ăăăă ă ă
ă$&2ă"
ă
#R2ă #$ăăă
ă "
ă Iă D ă ă <ă "
G
ă K ă $/ă ă ă
ăNEWă$ăD ă "ăă<ă
ă#R2ă#$ăă ă ăă ă@ă <ă "
G
ă ă$#2ă7
ă @
ă ă ă " ă "ă FI2ă
ă ă 7 "
ă"ă ă
ă
ă $Răă ă
ă ă
ă ă "ă ă
ă ă 5#ă NăB
2ă ă $$ăD ăă"ă ă@ă<ă"
G
ă ă
b $#ă ă ă ă <ă "
G
ă K ă $/ăă ă
ă" ă "ăFIă ă ă ă<ă
ăD ă PÎ
ăă F#ă ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă " ă "ă FIă
ÈhăăÈrZă ] Z
Ză¶]rZă
hă ##ă hăă]hă] Z
Ză¶]rZă
hă Ó
Z ]
ă Z mă" rhmră FIă ă ]hă ă h
ă Z]ă ümă
#&ăD ăă
ă##2ă#&ăăăăă
ăăF#ă "
G
ă K ă $#2ă $/2ă ă " ă FIă ă ă ă
ă ă ă <ă Nă Bă
ă ă ă ă "ă ă <ă "
G
ă K ă
ă ă
ă
"" ă
ă "
ă Iă z ă ă ă
ă ·ă <ă "
G
ă K ă Eă ăă ă ă" ă "ă
@
2ă ă" ă "ăFIă ă
ăă
ăD ă FIă ăă
ă <ă "
G
ăK 2ă ăK ă ă
ă"ă ăă ă N
ă
ă" ă "ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă F#ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă
ă ##2ă #&ă
ă ă5Ră Eă ă ă ă ă " ă "ă FIă ă ă
2ă ă "
ă
ă
ă ă7 ă ă <ă "
G
ă K 2ă ă K ă ă "ă
ăăB
2ă ăăă" ăă F#ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ă " ă "ă FIă
ă ă
ă ă
ăă"ă ăăăă "
ă
ă
ăă 5#ă
" ă
ă ă <ă D ă ă ă ă <ă "
G
ă K ă $#2ă$/ă
D ă @ă <ă "
G
ă K ă $#ă ă ă ă ă ă ă
ăăă ă " ă "ă FIăEă
<ă"
G
ă ă$/ă ăă
ă
ăă ăă "2ă ă " ă "ă FIă ă ă ă "ă
®
¯ă @
ă ă ă ă Vă ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă , ă ă
, 2ă
"
2ă ă@ă<ă"
G
ă ă$#ăăă ă ă <ă "
G
ă K ă $#2ă$/ă ă ă
ă ăă
<ă "
G
ă ă $/ă ă ă ă @
2ă , ă ă ă ă Vă ă , ă Eă ă ă ă
2ă ă@
ăăjăăăăP7 @ă ă ă
ă " ă FI2ă ă ă > ă
ă ă NEWă F2ă ă "
G
ă ă $#2ă$/ăă "
ă "ă ă
ă ă
ă " 2ă ă "
G
ă K7
ăă ăă
ă/Iăă" ă "ăFIă z"ăă ă ă$#ăăă ă
ă ă ă ă
ăă" ă
ă jă 2ă ă "
G
ă K ă $#2ă $/ăă 7 ă F#ă ăă ă ăă ă" ă FIă Qă ă
ăăă ăăă ă" ă "ăFIă"ăă
ă ăă F#ă Nă B
2ă ă ă ăă ă
ă
ă/$ă ă ă" ă "ăFIăD ă ă ă" ă ă ăăăăăF#ă
ă ă ăă ă
ă ăă ă "
G
ă ă $#2ă $/ă ă
ă ă ă " ă
ă
ă ă
ă B
ă {ă ă
ă ă ă
ăăEzăă ă" ă "ă FI2ă 2ă ă
ă ă ă"ă ă ă " ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă F#ă
ăă ă ă
ă ă ă ă " ă "ă FIă D ă
ăă ă
ăă ă ăă ă
D ă ăă ă"
G
ă ă$#2ă$/ăăă"ă " ă FIă ă >2ă ă
ă ă ă "
G
ă K7
ă %ăă ă" ă "ăFIă[
ăă ă ă ă$#ăBăă
ăăBă"ă ă
ăăă
ă ă2ă ă "
G
ă ă $#ă ăă
ă ăă F#ă ăă ăă
ă
ă "ă ă Bă ă ă ă ă ă "ă FIă"ă rPÎ z
ăă ă ă"" ă
ă"
ă I2ă K
ă
ă
ă
ăă ă" ăă F#ă )ħ "ă <ă
ă ă " ă "ă FIă ă Bă ă ă F#ă
"2ă ă ăă F#ă ăă
ă ăă
ă E
ă ăă"ă
1/29/2019
Exhibit A, Page
2:46:16
64 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 11 of 13 Page ID #:65
3-K
ŀ !K
K K
FIăăK
ăBă ă
ăă F#ă
ăă ă ă " ă 2ă ă ă Bă ă Qă ă ă ă
ă "
ă Iă wă ă @ă <ă
ă #Ră ă ă " ă
2ă ă "
G
ă ă $#2ă $/ă ă ă
ă <ă
ă#$ă:@
2ăK
ă ăBă ăă "
G
ă <ăă ăăăă "
ă B
ă
F#ăă ă@ăă
ă##ăwă ă@ă<ă
ă#Răă "ă" ă ă z ăă ă < ă ă ă ă K
ăă
K
ă ă Bă ă ă F#ă ă ă ă ă
ă #&ă wă ă
ăă ă<ă "
G
ă K ă$#2ă$/ă ă
ă ă <ă
ă #$ă Eă 2ă K
ă ăBă ă ăă <ă
ă#R2ă#$2ă ă <ă "
G
ă ă
<ă "
G
ă ă$#2$/ăă " ă)ħ ă
2ă $#2ă $/ă Kă ă ă
>
ă ă
ă ă <ă Nă
K
ă ăBă ă@ă"
G
ă ă $#ă
ă7 ăă B
2ă
ă ăă ă <ă
ă
ăă ă
ă"
ăIăăăăă ă@ă<ă #R2ă #$ă [
2ă ă <ă "
G
ă K ă $#2ă $/ă
ă #RăăK
ă ăBă ăă"
G
ă ă ±ă Kă ă ă
>
ă ă ă ă B7
$/ăăăăă ăă <ă
ă#$ăz ăă ă
ă ă ă wă ă
ă ă B
ă
ă
ă ă ă "
G
ă K ă $#ă $/2ă ă <ăNăă ă<ă
ă #R2ă #$ă ă
ă ă" ă "ă
ă ă ăK
ăBă ă"
G
ă K ă $#2ă $/ă FIă
ăă ă
ăăF#ăXq
2ăăă ă D ă K ă ă ă ă ă ă
"
ă
ăNEWă$2ă ă <ăNÄăăă ă"
G
ăK ă $#2ă ±ă {ă ăă
ă" ă ăăă
$/ăă
ă
ă ă ă<ăNăăB
ăăă ă <ă {ă ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă
ă ă F#ă [
2ă ă <ă NÄă wă ă ă "
G
ă ă [
2ă ă ă ă
ă "ă ă ă
ă $#ă ă
ă
ă ă ă ă ă " ă
ă "
ă Iă ă FIă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă #Ră ă ă ă
ă ă ă"
ă%ă ă ă
ă FR2ă ă ă #ă ă ă
ăF$ăD ă@ăăă
ăăF#ă@ă
ă
ă "ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă [kÎ ă@ăă
ă #$2ă
ă ăăăă
ăă #Ră
ă ă ă V ă ă ă #ă ă ă ă ă @ă ă ă ă
ă ##ăD ă " ă "ă FIă ă ă
ă ă NEWă 2ă ă ă q ă ă
ăăă K ă ă ă ă
ăF&ăă
ă"ă ă
Găăă
ă "
2ă ă
@ă
ăăă @ă ă ă
ă rrh
hZ2ă ă ]
măZ]ăăKm
ă] rmăhăă
]mă]rărmăm]hămhă
@ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă " ă "ă FIă ă
D ă "" ă
ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă "
ă ă F#ă ă ă" ă "ă FIă ăăă ă%
ă
ă ă B
ă ă " ă <ă ă ă
ă ă ă @"Bă
Băă"ă ă@"Băăă@ă2ăăă D
ă
ăăD ă<ăB
ă ă" ă "ăă ă
ă ă ă
"
ă ă ă ă
ă ă "2ă
ă ă @"B2ă "ă q
ă ă
ă
ă /Iă ă "ă 7
<%
ă ă
2ă ă B
ă :ă ă ă ă ă "ă
ă ă ă "ă ă B
ă ă 2ăK
ă ă<ă
ă ă
ă
ă/Iăă@ă
ă <ăB
ă ă " ă "ă FI2ă ă " ă "ăFIăă
ă s ă ă
ă <ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă "
ă Iă ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă /Iăăă 2ă
ăă ăă
ăFR2ă
D 2ă
ă
ă ă "" ă
ăF#2ăK
ăB
ă ă@ăăăă
ă ă ú
ă ă "ă <ă "2ă ă ăă#R2ă #$ăă
ăEă ă 2ă ă
ă
ă
"ă "
ăăă ă ă2ă ăăă /Iă ă >
ăă ăă ăă #R2ă #$ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă t
%ă ă
ă
ă" ă "ăFI2ă ă" ă
D ă <ă "
G
ă K ă $#2ă $/ă ă ă ă kkÎ "ă FIăă ăăăăă <ă"
G
ă
" ă "ăFIă
ăă ă B
ă ă K ă $#2ă $/ă ăă ă
ă ă" ă 2ă ă
ă <ă NăB
ă ă " ă "ă FIă :ă ă"
G
ă Bă ă Qă ă ă ă " ă
ă [
2ă ă ă
ă$#2ă$/ă ă ă
ă @
ă ă
ă ă ă "2ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ă ă F#2ă ă <ă NăÄă wă ă ă "
G
ă <ă "
G
ă ă $#2ă $/ăăă ăă
ă
ă$#2ă$/ăă
ă ă ă<ăNăăă ă
ă ©ă /Iăă ă" ă "ăFIăă ă
ă <ă ăă
ăF#ăXq
2ă ă <ă "
G
ăK ă$#2ă$/ă ă ă ă %
ă
ă FRă Eă 2ă ă @ă
ă
ă "
ă ă ă B
ă {ă " 7 <ă "
G
ă ă $#ăă ă@ăă
ă ##ă
ăă ă ă
ă
ă ăă #ăD ă ă ă ă <ă "
G
ă ă $/ă ă ă
ă <ă NÄă ă
%
ă ă ă
ă ă ă <ă "
G
ă ă ă
ă #&ă Eă ă ă ă
ă " ă
ă $#2ă $/ă ă " ă ă [
2ă " ă ă ©ă "ă FI2ă ă ă @ă <ă "
G
ă K ă $#ă ă
"
G
ă K ă $#2ă $/ă
ă ă <ă ă ă ă ă ăă <ă"
G
ăK ă $/ă ă q ă ă "ă
1/29/2019
Exhibit A, Page
2:46:16
65 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 12 of 13 Page ID #:66
3-K
ŀ !K
K
K
Eă ăă"ă ăăNEW:ă#è2ă ă Iă[ă
ă" ă "
ă ă ă ă ă"" ă
2ă
" ă "ă RFIă ă ă <ă "
G
ăK ă R$#ă ă ă
_ă
jă @
ă {ă ă ă ă NEW:ă Ð$ă D ă ă" ă "ăă < ă ă ăă K
ă 2ă
<ă "
G
ăK ăR$#ăăăăăă
ă
ă ă ă
ă ă" ă "ă RFIăD ă" ă "ăRFIă ă ă
ă
ăăăăă
ă <ă
2ă ă
R/Iă ă @ă ă <ă
ă R#Ră
ă ă ă ă
ă
ăă <ă "
Gă
ăăQăă ă
" ă "ă RFIă D ă <ă "
G
ă K ă R$#ă ă
ă
ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ă <ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă <ă
ă R#Ră
>
ăă ă <ă
2ă ă"
Gă
ă
ă
D ă
ă ă RF#ă @ă ă ă
ă R##ă ă ă <ă WPÎ
ă ă
ă ă Bă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă
"
G
ă ă R$#ăăă
ă >
ă ă ă ă"
Gă
ăBă ă ăă
ă
t
Û%ă ă<ă"
G
ăK ă$#ăNEW: æð2ă ă ă ă " ă
<ă"
G
ăK ă R$#ăăăă ă
ăă ăD ă " ă "
ă ă
ă I2ă ă ă <ă
WlÎ
ăă ă <ă"
G
ă ă R$#ă ăă ă
ă ă {ă ă ă
ă ă ă B2ă ă
ă
ă R5Iă ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă {ă ă ă
ă ă ă B2ă ă
ă
PÎ
ă X
ă @
ă ă " ă
ă
Üħ Éþ¢ñă 5êăD mă" rhmrăm"
ă]¾ăØ
ăåă mrmhăZ măÈrZă
]Ză
ă[ă
ă" ă"
ăăă"" ă
ă ă
&ă[ă
ă" ă "
ă ă ă ă ă"" ă
2ă
RăD ă " ă "
ăă
ă 2ă ă ă
ă ă ă
flÎ
vă
ă
ă ă ă
ă ă ă
$ăD ă" ă"
ăă
ăR2ă ă ă "ăă lPÎ @ă ă" ă <ă
ăăă ă
ăă"ă ă <ă
ăăă"ă ă@ăăă ă
1/29/2019
Exhibit A, Page
2:46:16
66 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-1 Filed 01/29/19 Page 13 of 13 Page ID #:67
3-K
ŀ !K
K
K
RRăD ă" ă"
ăă
ă&2ă ă ă
ă ă ă ăă "
Găă ă ă
ă ăă ă
ă
ă ă ă " ă "ă ă ă ă 2ă ă " ă "ă
ă ăăă ă
ă
ăă ă "ăăă R#ă D ă " ă "
ă ă
ă &2ă ă ă
ă
ă B
ă ,
ă
ă ă ă
ă , ă
R$ă D ă" ă "
ă ă
ă RR2ă ă ă "ă
1/29/2019
Exhibit A, Page
2:46:16
67 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-2 Filed 01/29/19 Page 1 of 22 Page ID #:68
([KLELW%
1/29/2019
Exhibit B, Page
2:46:20
68 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-2 Filed 01/29/19 Page 2 of 22 Page ID #:69
Ʋ³³²³Æ²² ³²³²³Æ² Ƴ³²² Ƴ³²² Ʋ³³²²Æ³³²² Ʋ³³³³Æ@@ @ ?@?@? @ ?@? @?@ ?@@?@? @ ?@@??@Æ
.
`¸ l{¸ gs¸ ^s¸ ¸ *4E9>EK (?K 0+K ō ō
AI>?K 9EK 4=K !%¸ $4E9K?;K*4E9>EK &I=K
KK
)%¸ 2UMRU^ 2Z>OM@<YMRQ^ "<Y<^ Pyd¸ d¢d¥¸ {®d¥{¸ ®{cd¢¸ W¸ ^{v¸ vW¥d¸ i¸ ©¢d¸
RO¸! )¸4
¸ àčxħ +
¸!¸
°{¥y{¸ W¸ [W[d^©d¸ v{¸ W¢¢d[´¸ ^{¢{v¸ W¸ ^{v¸
^yW[d¸Wc¸W¸vW¢¸[©d¸¢{¥{dc¸{¸ W¸°d¸¦{¸ h¸
% ¸ (QY
^ !O
^
¥yd¸^{v¸^yW[d¸Pyd¸vW¥d¸yW¢¸W¸©W{¥´¸h¸dvW¥dc¸
("*ħ'!%ħ )¸ d[d¢¸cdj|{v¸W¸^{v¸¢©iX^d¸Wc¸©¥{d¸d{v¢¸
Pyd¸ vW¥d¸ u¦yd¸ yW¢¸ W¸ vdW¢d¸ ^¥¸ W¢¢d[´¸ ¥yW¥¸ {¢¸
%¸ ¸ ==°$Oă //!!%1¸//!%1¸
8
5
^ !O
^
^dW¥{®d´¸¢{¥{dc¸®d¸W¸[©d¸kWd¸dv{¸¥¸c{d^¥¸
)!¸ M¸
Wc¸^¥¸¥yd¸k°¸h¸vdW¢d¸vddW¥dc¸[´¸^{v¸ic¸¸
%-¸ %MDOB^ RF^!O<WWMI@<YMRQ^ 5D<U@L^ ¸ //!%
¸
¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ Pyd¸ vdW¢d¸^¥¸ W¢¢d[´¸ yW¢¸ W¥¸ dW¢¥¸ d¸ {[¸
//!!%
¸!!)
¸!%
¸!
¸! 1 ¸ )!¸ M¸
v©¸ Wc¸ W¥¸ dW¢¥¸ d¸ dcvd¸ Pyd¸ {[¸ v©¸ ^{¢d¢¸ W¸
Odd¸Y}_Y§}¸j|d¸ i¸_d§d¸£dY_y¸y}£§´¸
©W{¥´¸h¸{[¢
¸dW^y¸{[¸yW®{v¸W¸j|¢¥¸{^{dc¸¢©hW^d¸Wc¸
W¸¢d^c¸{^{dc¸¢©hW^d¸Pyd¸vdW¢d¸^¥¸W¢¢d[´¸W¢¸
%)¸ 3DHUDQ@DW^ !MYDB^
yW¢¸Î ©¥d¸{cvd¸Wc¸Î {d¸{cvd¸cddc{v¸i¸W¸°d¸
RO¸J4P:HP¸ 9I7RF:HPO¸ ¢©iX^d¸h¥̧yd¸vW¥d¸T{¥y¸¥yd¢d¸¢¥©^¥ªd¢
¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸d®d¥¢¸
vdW¢d¸Wc¸[´c©^¥¢¸ i¸cW{{v¸ ¥¸ ¥yd¸[©d¸kWd¸
[ [
[ KE9H0J[
[ [ [ K9M[
dv{¸
[ [ [ [ [ /KEDO[ [ [ [ [ [ [ [ [ [[ [
[ [ [ EQ9M[ *$ă !O<MPW^ ă "U<[MQJ^5LDDYW^
J¹ħ
1/29/2019
Exhibit B, Page
2:46:20
69 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-2 Filed 01/29/19 Page 3 of 22 Page ID #:70
2.K K K
JWvd¸¸
[ [ [ 9M?9M[
[ [ [ $5KJ0E7[ 9Q[ 0E[
[ [ [ [ 0MOKJ[ 9Q[0E[ [
[ ([ [ ħ
[ *5AEKOO9M[ 9Q[0E[
[ [
[ *Q9V2[
[ [
[ *5AEKOO9M[ 9Q[ 0E[
[ [
[ 9OQ[ [ [ [ *5AEKOO9M[ 9Q[ 0E[
[ [ [ *5AEKOO9M[ [ [ [ *5AEKOO9M[ 9Q[ 0E[
[ [ [ JSQA[ 9Q[0E[
[ F[
[ B939E[ 9Q[0E[
[ [ [ BQ5A[ 9Q[0E[ [ F [
1/29/2019
Exhibit B, Page
2:46:20
70 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-2 Filed 01/29/19 Page 4 of 22 Page ID #:71
@Î
:u
5
1/29/2019
Exhibit B, Page
2:46:20
71 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-2 Filed 01/29/19 Page 5 of 22 Page ID #:72
Qu
Î
Æ
Î
âħ
ħ
Ku Ŀŀ
1/29/2019
Exhibit B, Page
2:46:20
72 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-2 Filed 01/29/19 Page 6 of 22 Page ID #:73
¸
1/29/2019
Exhibit B, Page
2:46:20
73 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-2 Filed 01/29/19 Page 7 of 22 Page ID #:74
?Î
Æ
3
W¸
¸
?Î
[Æ
3
1/29/2019
Exhibit B, Page
2:46:20
74 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-2 Filed 01/29/19 Page 8 of 22 Page ID #:75
1/29/2019
Exhibit B, Page
2:46:20
75 P
;\u _t
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-2 Filed 01/29/19 Page 9 of 22 Page ID #:76
¸
XdĄŀ
.ō(ō
235ŀ
(
-6ō
ELō
:/1
#ō ō
ÅÆ
2
B1C ÃÆ
/
-./Æ ÄÆ
0
Î
'X
ŀ
Æ
1/29/2019
Exhibit B, Page
2:46:20
76 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-2 Filed 01/29/19 Page 10 of 22 Page ID #:77
z¸
Î
[Æ
Ju
1/29/2019
Exhibit B, Page
2:46:20
77 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-2 Filed 01/29/19 Page 11 of 22 Page ID #:78
gÆ
V¸
1/29/2019
Exhibit B, Page
2:46:20
78 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-2 Filed 01/29/19 Page 12 of 22 Page ID #:79
ùZÏŀ
C¸
D1w¸ õĮō
A
úZ×ŀ ûöyō
čĎĸŀ ½łģō
÷Ąō
1/29/2019
Exhibit B, Page
2:46:20
79 P
Z\u _t
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-2 Filed 01/29/19 Page 13 of 22 Page ID #:80
¸
Xdąŀ
.ō(ō
235ŀ
ōČŀ-6ō
ō
ĐLō
:/1
#ō ō
1/29/2019
Exhibit B, Page
2:46:20
80 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-2 Filed 01/29/19 Page 14 of 22 Page ID #:81
Æ
U¸
1/29/2019
Exhibit B, Page
2:46:20
81 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-2 Filed 01/29/19 Page 15 of 22 Page ID #:82
1-K ŀ ŀ
K K
!11+(0&^ &37#^ 9(7'^ &3#5#^ ¥yd¸®W{©¢¸d{v¢¸{¸W¸Wc¸Wd¸°{¥y©¥¸c{d^¥{v¸
!10731-^5738!783#5^ ¢©^y¸W¢¢Wvd¸4¢¸W¸d¢©¥
¸ ^®d¥{W¸vW¥d¢¸ ^W¥¸c{d^¥¸
¥yd¸ k°¸ h¸vdW¢d¸ Wc¸ [´c©^¥¢¸ W°W´¸ i¸ y¥¸ [©d¸
7MIOOM:=:M:H7:¸PI¸ M:E4P:9¸ W¢¢d[{d¢¸ c©{v¸ dW¥{¸ h¸¥yd¸ v{¸ C¸ Wcc{¥{
¸ ^
4JJEC74PCIHO¸ kÎ ®d¥{W¸vW¥d¢¸^W¥¸c{d^¥¸¥yd¸k°¸h¸vdW¢d¸Wc¸[´c·
©^¥¢¸¥¸W¸{¥dcdc¸^W¥{¸i¸cW{Wvd¸¸d®W¸i¸¥yd¸
H¥¸4{^W[d¸ v{¸7¢d©d¥´
¸ ^®d¥{W¸vW¥d¢¸d{¥¸¥yd¸W^^©©·
W¥{¸h¸vdW¢d¸Wc¸[´c©^¥¢¸°y{^y¸dvW¥{®d´¸Wpd^¥¢¸¥yd¸
=:9:M4EEV¸ OJIHOIM:9¸M:O:4M7B¸IM¸ diW^d¸ Wc¸dW¥{¸h¸¥yd¸[W[d^©d¸v{¸
9:S:EIJF:HP¸ VOÎ Pyddid
¸ ¥ydd¸ {¢¸W¸cdj|{¥d¸ddc¸i¸W¸vW¥d¸¥yW¥¸c{d^¥¢¸
Wc¸^¥¢¸¥yd¸k°¸h¸vdW¢d¸Wc¸[´c©^¥¢¸¥¸d¢©d¸¥yd¸
H¥¸4{^W[d¸ v¥d¸dhW^d¸Wc¸dW¥{¸h¸¥yd¸[W[d^©d¸v{¸
Pyd¸d¢d¥¸ {®d¥{¸{¢¸®{cdc¸¥¸ ¢®d¸¥yd¢d¸Wc¸¥yd¸
P:7BHC74E¸=C:E9¸ [d¢¸
VkÎ
Pyd¸d¢d¥¸ {®d¥{¸dW¥d¢¸¥¸ W¸^{v¸vW¥d¸ i¸©¢d¸ ORFF4MV¸I=¸ PB:¸ CHS:HPCIH¸
°{¥y¸W¸[W[d^©d¸v{¸Fd¸¢d^{j|^W´
¸¥yd¸d¢d¥¸ {®d·
¥{¸ dW¥d¢¸ ¥¸ W¸ ^{v¸ vW¥d¸ yW®{v¸ W¸ vdW¢d¸ ^¥¸ Pyd¸ d¢d¥¸ {®d¥{¸ dW¥d¢¸ ¥¸ W¸ vW¥d¸ i¸ ©¢d¸ °{¥y¸ W¸
W¢¢d[´¸¥¸^¥¸ Wc¸c{d^¥¸¥yd¸k°¸h¸vdW¢d¸vddW¥dc¸ [W[d^©d¸ v{¸ W¢¢d[´¸ Fd¸ ¢d^{j|^W´
¸ ¥yd¸ d¢d¥¸
[´¸ ic¸ ^dc¸ ¸¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ [OÎ {®d¥{¸dW¥d¢¸¥¸ W¸vW¥d¸°{¥y¸W¸ vdW¢d¸^¥¸ W¢¢d[´¸
¥yW¥¸ c{d^¥¢¸ ¥yd¸ k°¸ h¸vdW¢d¸ Wc¸ [´c©^¥¢¸ vddW¥dc¸
647D@MIRH9¸ I=¸ PB:¸CHS:HPCIH¸ c©{v¸ ¥yd¸ ^{v¸ ^d¢¢¸ ©¥¸ h¸¥yd¸ v{¸ W¢¢d[´¸ Pyd¸
[W[d^©d¸v{¸W¢¢d[´¸vddW´¸{^©cd¢¸W¸^{v¸^yW·
Pyd¸ ©W{¥´¸ h¸[W[d^©d¸ v{¢¸ Wc¸ ©¥c¸ ^{v¸ [d¸ Wc¸ W¸ ¢©¥¸ iWd¸ W¢¢d[´¸ Pyd¸ ^{v¸ ^yW[d¸
cd®{^d¢¸yW¢¸{^dW¢dc¸¥ddc©¢´¸®d¸¥yd¸W¢¥¸¥°d¥´j|®d¸ [kÎ {^©cd¢¸W¸^®d¸y{vdW[´¸^d^¥dc¸¥¸W¸j|d[±¸Pyd¸vW¥d¸
´dW¢¸@W¢¸[W[d^©d¸v{¢¸d´¸W¸[©d¸¥¸ ^¸ic¸¥yW¥¸ {¢¸ d®W[´¸ ¢{¥{dc¸ vddW´¸ °{¥y{¸ ¥yd¸ j|d[±¸ 4¸
{¢¸ ¢©¦dc¸ ¸W¸vW¥d¸ W[®d¸¥yd¸[©d¸7®d¢d´
¸ ^yW· [©d¸ddd¥¸¸¥©[d¸{¢¸¢{¥{dc¸vddW´¸°{¥y{¸W¸°d¸
^W¸ [W[d^©d¸ v{¢¸ ©¢d¸ ^[©¢¥{[d¸ ¢{c¸m¬d¸¥¸ ^¸ ¥yd¸ ¥{¸h¸¥yd¸j|d[±¸Pyd¸[©d¸yW¢¸ W¸©W{¥´¸h¸©¥d¥¸
ic¸P´{^W´
¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ yW¢¸ ©d©¢¸dvW¥dc¸[W¢¸ Wc¸ ¥¢¸ ¸ Wd¦©d¢¸ i¸ °y{^y¸ W¸ kWd¸ d±¥dc¢¸ ¥ydd[´¸
d{v¢¸ °y{^y¸^W©¢d¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸¥¸yW®d¸W¸ v{c{d¸ ^j|v©· aOÎ cdj|{v¸ W¸[©d¸kWd¸dv{¸ Pyd¸ ^{v¸^yW[d¸cd¢¸
W¥{¸F¢¥¸vW¥d¢¸Wd¸idc¸i¸d¥W¸¢©^y¸¥yW¥¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ ¥¸{^©cd¸W¸¢dW¸[W¸¸W´¸^®d¥{W¸^c©^¥{®d¸d¥W¸
aW¸ °}§y¤§Wc¸ §yf¸ y}vy¸ yfW§¸ vffW§fc¸ [´¸ §yf¸ [©f¸ ¸ ¤§ªa§ªf¸[f§°ff¸§yf¸vW§f¸Wc¸§yf¸[©f¸4¸cW}¸f}v¸
ydW¥{v¸ ddd¥¸ {¢¸ ¢{¥{dc¸ {¸ W¸ [¥¦¸ °W¸ h¸¥yd¸ j|d[±¸ Pyd¸ cW{¸
9©{v¸dW¥{¸h¸¥yd¸[W[d^©d¸v{
¸ic¸{¢¸W^dc¸¸ d{v¸{¢¸WcW¥dc¸¥¸cW{¸vdW¢d¸Wc¸¥yd¸[´c©^¥¢¸¥yW¥¸
¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ Wc¸ vdW¢d¸ Wc¸ ¥yd¸ [´c©^¥¢¸ Wd¸ vddW¥dc¸ akÎ Wd¸vddW¥dc¸[´¸^{v¸ ic¸{¸¥yd¸ ^{v¸ ^yW[d¸¥yW¥¸
c©{v¸ ¥yd¸ ^{v¸ ^d¢¢¸ Pyd¸ ©W¥{¥´¸ h¸ vdW¢d¸ Wc¸ Wd¸c{d^¥dc¸¥¸¥yd¸d{v¸[´¸¥yd¸vdW¢d¸^¥¸ W¢¢d[´¸
[´c©^¥¢¸vddW¥dc¸c©{v¸¥yd¸^{v¸^d¢¢¸®W{d¢¸°{¥y¸ JdieW[´
¸ ¥yd¸[W[d^©d¸v{¸ W¢¢d[´¸yW¢¸W¸^W^¥¸^·
W¸©[d¸h¸iX^¥¢
¸{^©c{v¸[©¥¸¥¸{{¥dc¸¥¸¥yd¸¥´d¸h¸ j|v©W¥{¸ dW{v¸ ¥yW¥¸ {¥¸ {¢¸ ¢Wd¸ ¥yW¸ ^®d¥{W¸
ic¸ ^dc¸ ¸¥yd¸ vW¥d
¸ ¥yd¸ W©¥¸h¸ic¸ ^dc
¸ ¥yd¸ ©{vy¥¸ [W[d^©d¸ v{¢¸ P´{^W´
¸ ^®d¥{W¸ [W[d^©d¸
W©¥¸ h¸ ydW¥¸ vddW¥dc¸ [´¸ ¥yd¸ [©d¸ ¥ª[d
¸ Wc¸ ¥yd¸ eOÎ v{¢¸yW®d¸W¸vdW¥d¸®dW¸yd{vy¥¸c©d¸¥¸ W¸iWd¸W¢¢d[´¸
W[{d¥¸ ^c{¥{¢¸ C¸ Wcc{¥{
¸ ^d¥W{¸ ¥´d¢¸ h¸ ic¢¸ ¥yW¥¸¢©¦¢¸¥yd¸^{v¸^yW[d¸C¸^¥W¢¥
¸¥yd¸[W[d^©d¸
c©^d¸W¸Wvd¸W©¥¸h¸vdW¢d¸Wc¸[´c©^¥¢¸¥yW¸¥yd¸ v{¸W¢¢d[´¸h¥̧yd¸d¢d¥¸{®d¥{¸^W¸[d¸dW¥dc¸°y{d¸
¥´d¢¸ =¸ d±Wd
¸ ^{v¸ W¸ dW¸ h¸^¸ ¸ ¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ ¢{¥{dc¸¸W¸¥W[d¸¥¸
c©^d¢¸ d¢¢¸ vdW¢d¸ Wc¸ [´c©^¥¢¸ ¥yW¸W¸ ¢¥dW¸ ¸yW· C¸W^^c¸°{¥y¸¥yd¸{®d¥{
¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸{^©cd¢¸¥yd¸vdW¢d¸
[©vd¸@dW¢d¸Wc¸[´c©^¥¢¸ Wd¸vddW´¸k©{c¸¢©^y¸¥yW¥¸ ekÎ ^¥¸W¢¢d[´
¸W¸©W{¥´¸h¸dvW¥dc¸d[d¢¸ ¸[W¢
¸
¥yd´¸ k°¸ ¸ ®d¸ {¸ W¸ W¥y¸ Pyd¸ c{d^¥{¸ h¸¥yd¸ W¥y¸ Wc¸W¸©W{¥´¸h¸d{v¢¸Tyd¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸{¢¸¢{¥{dc¸{¸
cddc¢¸©¸¥yd¸dpd^¥¢¸h¸vW®{¥´¸Wc¸¥yd¸¢¥©^¥ªd¢¸°{¥y{¸ ¥yd¸^{v¸^yW[d
¸ ¥yd¸vdW¢d¸ ^¥¸ W¢¢d[´¸ {¢¸¢{·
¥yd¸ ^{v¸ ^yW[d¸ h¸¥yd¸ [W[d^©d¸ v{¸ B°d®d
¸ ®d¸ ¥{dc¸ vddW´¸ ®d¸ ¥yd¸ [©d¸ ¥¸ d®d¥¸ vdW¢d¸ Wc¸
¥{d¸ Wc¸ddW¥dc¸ ©¢d
¸ vdW¢d¸Wc¸[´c©^¥¢¸ ^W¸W^^©©· [´c©^¥¢¸ vddW¥dc¸ [´¸ ^{v¸ ic¸ ¸ ¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ i¸
W¥d¸ ¸ ¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ Wc¸ °{¥y{¸ ¥yd¸ ^{v¸ ^yW[d¸ Pyd¸ kOÎ ^{v¸ {¥¸ ^¥W^¥¸ °{¥y¸¥yd¸ [©d¸ Pyd¸ [W¢¸ d±¥dc¸ ¢©[·
W^^©©W¥{¸h¸vdW¢d¸Wc¸[´c©^¥¢¸^W¸dvW¥{®d´¸Wpd^¥¸ ¢¥W¥{W´¸i¸W¸i¥¸dcvd¸h¥̧yd¸vW¥d¸¥¸W¸dW¸dcvd¸h¸¥yd¸
¥yd¸ diW^d¸Wc¸dW¥{¸h¸¥yd¸[W[d^©d¸v{¸W¢¢d· vW¥d¸ JdieW[´
¸ ¥yd¸ [W¢¸ Wd¸ vddW´¸ WWd¸ Wc¸ Wd¸
[´¸ ¢W^dc¸ W¸ c{¢¥W^d¸ WW¥¸ ¥¸ cdrd¸ W¸ v{c¸ Pyd¸ vW¥d¸ yW¢¸ W¸
7®d¥{W¸vW¥d¢¸¥´{^W´¸{^©cd¸W¸©W{¥´¸h¸d· ©W{¥´¸ h¸ d{v¢¸ °ydd¸ dW^y¸ d{v¸ {¢¸ ¢{¥{dc¸
vW¥dc¸d[d¢
¸ d{v¢
¸Wc¸^¢¢¸d[d¢¸¥yW¥¸cdj|d¸ W¸ kkÎ [d¥°dd¸[W¢¸
^{v¸ ¢©hW^d¸ i¸¥yd¸ ic¸ 4¸ d±Wd¸ h¸¥yd¸ ^®d· Pyd¸ vdW¢d¸ ^¥¸ W¢¢d[´¸ ^{¢d¢¸ W¸©d¸ vdW¢d¸
¥{W¸vW¥d¸{¢¸i©c¸{¸RO¸JW¥¸H¸ %
!/
!%¸¥¸O^y¢¢d¸ ^¥¸W¢¢d[´¸Wc¸W¸°d¸vdW¢d¸^¥¸ W¢¢d[´¸Pyd¸
d¥¸ W¸ Pydd
¸ ¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ ă {¢¸ idc¸ i¸ W¸ ©W{¥´¸ h¸ ©d¸vdW¢d¸^¥¸ W¢¢d[´¸vddW´¸^¡d¢c¢¸¥¸¥yd¸
dvW¥dc¸c¢¸*#ăW[©¥¸d{v¢
¸[¥y¸h¸°y{^y¸Wd¸°{¥y{¸ ©d¸¦{¸h¸¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ Wc¸ ^{¢d¢¸ W¸©W{¥´¸ h¸{[¸
W¸d{d¥d¸cdj|dc¸[´¸W¸^{^©W¸{v¸ ă 4¥yd¸d±Wd¸ qOÎ v©¢¸ Wc¸ W¸©W{¥´¸ h¸dcvd¢¸ :W^y¸dcvd¸ {¢¸ ¢{¥{dc¸
h¸¥yd¸ ^®d¥{W¸ vW¥d¸ {¢¸ ¢y°¸{¸RO¸ JW¥¸H¸ )
!-
¸ [d¥°dd¸¥yd¸{[¸ v©¢¸Wc¸dW¸W¸d{ydW¸dv{¸h¸¥yd¸
!¸ ¥¸ M{vd´¸ d¥¸ W¸ Pydd
¸ ¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ yW¢¸ W¸ vddW´¸ vW¥d¸ Pyd¸ {¥d¢d^¥{¸ h¸¥yd¸ {[¸ v©¢¸ Wc¸ ¥yd¸ dcvd¢¸
d^¥Wv©W¸¢yWd¸°{¥y¸©d©¢¸d{v¢¸ *ă Wc¸dvW¥dc¸ cdj|d¢¸ W¸ ^d¥W¸ dv{¸ h¸¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ Pyd¸ {[¸ v©¢¸ Wd¸
¢¥©^¥ªd¢¸&ă7®d¥{W¸vW¥d¢¸¢©pd¸i¸W¸{W[{{¥´¸¥¸ ^{¢dc¸h¸W¸©W{¥´¸ h¸{[¢¸ °ydd{¸ dW^y¸{[¸ {¢¸ WcW¥dc¸
c{d^¥¸¸^¥¸¥yd¸k°¸h¸vdW¢d¸Wc¸[´c©^¥¢¸vddW¥dc¸ qkÎ ¥¸ c{d^¥¸¸v©{cd¸¥yd¸k°¸ h¸vdW¢d¸Wc¸[´c©^¥¢¸vdd·
°y{d¸ ^{v¸ ic¸ ¸ ¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ C¢¥dWc
¸ ^®d¥{W¸ W¥dc¸°y{d¸^{v¸ic¸¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸Pyd¸{[¸yW¢¸W¥¸dW¢¥¸d¸
vW¥d¢¸dd´¸ W°¸ vdW¢d¸Wc¸[´c©^¥¢¸¥¸W¢¢¸¥y©vy¸ {^{dc¸¢©hW^d¸d±¥dc{v¸i¸¥yd¸^{v¸¢©hW^d¸¥°Wc¢¸
1/29/2019
Exhibit B, Page
2:46:20
82 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-2 Filed 01/29/19 Page 16 of 22 Page ID #:83
1-K ŀ ŀ
K K
W¸°d¸dcvd¸h¸¥yd¸{[¸Pyd¸{[¸ ^W¸yW®d¸W¸¢d^c¸{^{dc¸ =C@¸ ă {¢¸W¸¢^ydW¥{^¸ ®{d°¸ h¸¥yd¸dW¥{¸h¸¥yd¸v{¸
¢©iX^d¸°ydd{¸¥yd¸ {^{dc¸ ¢©hW^d¢¸^®dvd¸¥¸cdj|d¸W¸ W¢¢d[´¸Wc¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ h¸=C@¸ O ă
dW¸ I^d¸ vdW¢d¸ ^d¢¸{¥¸^¥W^¥¸°{¥y¸¥yd¸{[
¸ vdW¢d¸ =C@¸ ă{ ¢ ¸W¸¥¸d¢d^¥{®d¸®{d°¸ h W̧¸W¥dW¥d¸d[c{·
{vW¥d¢¸c°¸¥yd¸{^{dc¸¢©iX^d¢¸¥¸¥yd¸dcvd¢¸h¸¥yd¸{[¸ d¥¸ h¸¥yd¸vW¥d1¸ Wc
¸
C¸¥y{¢¸Wd
¸¥yd¸cW{Wvd¸h¸vdW¢d¸Wc¸[´c©^¥¢¸^^©¢¸ =C@¸ ă {¢¸W¸[¥¦¸d¢d^¥{®d¸®{d°¸h¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸h¸=C@¸
{¸ W¸^¥dc¸Wc¸c{d^¥dc¸Wd¸ ă
C¸ m¬¥yd¸ W^^c¸ °{¥y¸ ¥yd¸ {®d¥{
¸ ¥yd¸ °d¸ vdW¢d¸
^¥¸W¢¢d[´¸^{¢d¢¸W¸©¥d¸{cvd¸¥yW¥¸cddc¢¸i¸ 9:P4CE:9¸9:O7MCJPCIH¸I=¸PB:¸
W¸ °d¸ ¢©iX^d¸ h¸¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ Pyd¸ ©¥d¸ {cvd¸ yW¢¸ W¸ ©¥d¸ CHS:HPCIH¸
°W
¸ W¸ {d¸ °W
¸ Wc¸ W¸[¥¥¸°W¸ Pyd¸ °d¸^¥¸ V O Î
W¢¢d[´¸lª¦yd¸^{¢d¢¸W¸{d¸{cvd¸¥yW¥¸cddc¢¸i¸ Ty{d¸ ¥y{¢¸ {®d¥{¸ {¢¸ ¢©¢^d¥{[d¸ h¸ d[c{d¥¸ {¸
¥yd¸°d¸ Pyd¸ {d¸ {cvd¸ yW¢¸ W¸ ©¥d¸°W
¸ W¸{d¸°W
¸ W´¸ c{odd¥¸ i¢
¸ ¥ydd¸ {¢¸ ¢y°¸ {¸¥yd¸ cW°{v¢¸ Wc¸
Wc¸W¸[¥¥¸°W¸JdieW[´
¸d{¥yd¸¥yd¸{d¸{cvd¸¸¥yd¸ °{¸ydd{¸[d¸ cd¢^{[dc¸{¸cd¥W{¸die¡dc¸d[c{d¥¢¸h¸
©¥d¸ {cvd¸ {¥d¢d^¥¢¸ ¥yd¸ d{v¢¸ h¸¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ Pyd¸ ©¥d¸ ¥yd¸ {®d¥{¸ °{¥y¸ ¥yd¸ ©cd¢¥Wc{v¸ ¥yW¥¸ ¥yd¸ d¢d¥¸ c{¢·
Wc¸ {d¸{cvd¢¸ cddc¸ ¢©[¢¥W¥{W´¸ ddc{^©W¸¥¸ ¥yd¸ V k Î ^¢©d¸ {¢¸ ¥¸ [d¸ ^¢{cddc¸ W¢¸ W¸ d±d{j|^W¥{¸ h¸¥yd¸
°d¸ ¢©iX^d¸ h¸¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ Pyd¸ ©¥d¸ {cvd¸ Wc¸ ¥yd¸ {d¸ {^{d¢¸ h¸¥yd¸ {®d¥{¸ Wc¸ {¢¸ ¥¸ {¥dcdc¸ ¥¸ {{¥¸ ¥yd¸
{cvd¸ cdj|d¸W¸^W®{¥´¸ Pyd¸ ©¥d¸Wc¸ {d¸{cvd¢¸ Wd¸ ^· [Wc¸W¢d^¥¸h¸¥yd¸{®d¥{¸¥¸¥yd¸d[c{d¥¢¸{©¢¥W¥dc¸
dW¥{®d´¸¢{¥{dc¸°{¥y¸¥yd¸©d¸vdW¢d¸^¥¸W¢¢d[´¸ 4¸[W[d^©d¸ v{¸ W¢¢d[´¸ ă {¢¸ ¢y°¸ {¸ =C@¸ ă Pyd¸
Py©¢
¸ ¥yd¸ °d¸ vdW¢d¸ ^¥¸ W¢¢d[´¸ {¢¸ ^dW¥{®d´¸ [W[d^©d¸ v{¸ W¢¢d[´¸ ă vddW´¸ {^©cd¢¸ W¸ ^{v¸
¢{¥{dc¸°{¥y¸¥yd¸©d¸vdW¢d¸^¥¸W¢¢d[´¸Tyd¸¥yd¸ [OÎ ^yW[d¸ ă Wc¸W¸¢©¥¸iWd¸W¢¢d[´¸ $ă Pyd¸ ¢©¥¸
vW¥d¸ {¢¸ ¢{¥{dc¸ {¸ W¸ ©¢d¸ ¢{¥{¸ °{¥y{¸ ¥yd¸ ^{v¸ iWd¸ W¢¢d[´¸ $ă {¢¸ WcW¥dc¸ ¥¸ ®{cd¸ ¢©¥¸ ¥¸ ¥yd¸
^yW[d
¸¥yd¸vdW¢d¸^¥¸W¢¢d[´¸{¢¸¢{¥{dc¸vddW´¸ ^{v¸^yW[d¸ ă Wc¸yW¢¸W¸i¥¸¢¥ª^¥ªd¸ $HăWc¸W¸dW¸
W[®d¸¥yd¸[©d¸¥©[d¸C¸¥yd¸©¢d¸¢{¥{
¸{[¢¸i¸¥yd¸{[¸ ¢¥ª^¥ªd¸ $Tă Pyd¸ ^{v¸ ^yW[d¸ ă {^©cd¢¸W¸^®d¸ #ă
v©¢¸h¸¥yd¸©d¸vdW¢d¸^¥¸W¢¢d[´¸Wd¸¢{¥{dc¸ y{vdW[´¸^d^¥dc¸¥¸W¸j|d[±¸ &ă4¸vW¥d¸ă{¢¸¢{¥{dc¸
®d¸W¸¦{¸h¥̧yd¸[©d¸¥©[d¸Pyd¸j|¢¥¸¢©hW^d¸h¥̧yd¸{[¸ [kÎ vddW´¸ °{¥y{¸ ¥yd¸ j|d[±¸ &ă 4¢¸ d±W{dc¸ [d°
¸ ¥yd¸
{¢¸¢{¥{dc¸®d¸¥yd¸{¥ddc{W¥d¸Wc¸{d¸¦{¢¸h¸¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ ă yW¢¸ W¸ vdW¢d¸ ^¥¸ W¢¢d[´¸ ă ¥yW¥¸ c{d^¥¢¸ Wc¸
[©d¸¥©[d¸Pyd¸ dcvd¸ h¸¥yd¸j|¢¥¸ ¢©iX^d¸ d±¥dc¢¸ [d´c¸W¸ ^¥¢¸ ¥yd¸ k°¸ h¸ vdW¢d¸ Wc¸ [´c©^¥¢¸ vddW¥dc¸ [´¸
°W¸ h¸¥yd¸[©d¸¥ª[d¸ Pyd¸ ¢d^c¸ ¢©iX^d¸ h¸¥yd¸{[¸ {¢¸ ^{v¸ ic¸ ¸¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ ă Pyd¸ [W[d^©d¸ v{¸ W¢¢d[´¸
¢{¥{dc¸ ®d¸¥yd¸{¥ddc{W¥d¸ Wc¸©¥d¸¦{¢¸ h¸¥yd¸ ă h©¥yd¸{^©cd¢¸W¸s¢¥¸°¸¢©hW^d¸ăWc¸W¸¢d^c¸°¸
[©d¸¥©[d¸Pyd¸dcvd¸ h¸¥yd¸¢d^c¸¢©iX^d¸ d±¥dc¢¸[d´c¸ a O Î ¢©iX^d¸ *ă dW^y¸ {®¥W´¸ ^d^¥dc¸ ¥¸ W¸ ¥{¸ h¸¥yd¸
W¸°W¸h¸¥yd¸[©d¸¥ª[d¸Pyd¸dW¸h¸¥yd¸{[¸ {¢¸¢{¥{dc¸ ¢©¥¸ iWd¸ W¢¢d[´¸ $ă Pyd¸ sd[±¸ &ă yW¢¸ W¸ {¥d{¸
vddW´¸W[®d¸¥yd¸{¥ddc{W¥d¸¥{¸h¥̧yd¸[©d¸¥ª[d¸ vdd¥´¸¸^j|v©W¥{¸cdj|dc¸[´¸W¸s¢¥¸ ¢{cd¸ °W¸ $ă W¸
Tyd¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸{¢¸{¸¥yd¸©¢d¸¢{¥{¸c©{v¸dW¥{¸h¸ ¢d^c¸ ¢{cd¸°W¸ 5ă W¸ i¥¸ °W¸ #ă W¸dW¸°W¸ /ă Wc¸W¸
¥yd¸ v{¸ W¢¢d[´
¸ ¥yd¸ vdW¢d¸^¥¸ W¢¢d[´¸ c{d^¥¢¸ Wc¸ [¥¥¸°W¸ &ă 4¢¸¢y°¸{¸ =C@¸ ă ¥yd¸¢{cd¸°W¢¸ #ă /ă
^¥¢¸ ¥yd¸ k°¸ h¸vdW¢d¸ Wc¸ [´c©^¥¢¸ ¥¸ d¢©d¸ ¥yd¸ a k Î Wc¸¥yd¸[¥¦¸°W¸ &ă yW®d¸W¸¢dc¸¸^©¯dc¸^j|v©W·
d®W¸ ¸cW{Wvd¸ h¸¥yd¸ vdW¢d¸ i¸ ¥yd¸ j|d[±¸ Py{¢¸ ¥{¸4¸dcvd¸=ă{¢¸¢{¥{dc¸Wv¸¥yd¸{¥d{¸¥{¸h¥̧yd¸
d®d¥¢¸ ¥yd¸ [©{c©¸ h¸vdW¢d¸Wc¸[´c©^¥¢¸ °y{^y¸^W¸ j|d[±¸ &ă Pyd¸dcvd¸ =ă {¢¸ WcW¥dc¸¥¸ ¢©¥¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ ă
dvW¥{®d´¸ Wpd^¥¸ ¥yd¸ diW^d¸ Wc¸ dW¥{¸ h¸ ¥yd¸ {¸ W¸ vddW´¸ y{¶¥W¸ ¢{¥{¸ [d°¸ W¸ {¸ *ă h¸¥yd¸
[W[d^©d¸ v{¸ W¢¢d[´¸ =©¦ydd
¸ ¥yd¸ vdW¢d¸ ^¥¸ j|d[±¸ &ă 4¥dW¥{®d´
¸ ¥yd¸ dcvd¸ =ă {¢¸ {¥¥dc¸ Wc¸ ¥yd¸
W¢¢d[´¸c{d^¥¢¸¥yd¸k°¸W¥y¸h¸vdW¢d¸¢©^y¸¥yW¥¸{¥¸cd¢¸¥¸ eOÎ j|d[±¸ &ă yW¢¸W¸©W{¥´¸h¸{c{®{c©W¸ ¢¥ª^¥ªd¢¸¥¸ ¢©¥¸
Wd¸^¥W^¥¸°{¥y¸¥yd¸[©d¸¥©[d¸ c©{v¸ dW¥{¸ h¸¥yd¸ ¥yd¸vW¥d¸ ăPyd¸[W[d^©d¸v{¸W¢¢d[´¸ ă yW¢¸W¸^W^¥¸
[W[d^©d¸ v{¸ W¢¢d[´¸ ^j|v©W¥{¸dW{v¸¥yW¥¸{¥¢¸®dW¸yd{vy¥¸{¢¸d¢¢¸¥yW¸¥yW¥¸
I¥yd¸ ieW¥ªd¢¸ Wc¸ Wc®W¥Wvd¢¸ h¸¥yd¸ {®d¥{¸ °{¸ [d¸ h¸ ^®d¥{W¸ ©{vy¥¸ [W[d^©d¸ v{¢¸ 4¢¸ W¸ d¢©¥
¸ ¥yd¸
WWd¥¸i¸¥yd¸i°{v¸¢d^{j|^W¥{¸¥Wd¸{¸^©^· [W[d^©d¸ v{¸ W¢¢d[´¸ ă {¢¸ ^WW[d¸ h¸dW¥{¸ °y{d¸
¥{¸°{¥y¸¥yd¸i°{v¸cW°{v¢¸ ekÎ ¢{¥{dc¸ ¸ W¸ ¥W[d¸ ¥¸ =©¦ydd
¸ ¥yd¸ [W[d^©d¸ v{¸
W¢¢d[´¸ ă {¢¸ ¢{¶dc¸¢©^y¸¥yW¥¸{¥¸^W¸[d¸{tdc¸[´¸W¸¢{vd¸©¢d¸
6MC:=¸ 9:O7MCJPCIH¸I=¸PB:¸9M4TCH@O¸ Wc¸^W¡{dc¸[d¥°dd¸^W¥{¢¸ i¸©¢d¸
4¸ [©d¸ ddd¥¸ *ă {¢¸ ¢{¥{dc¸ vddW´¸ °{¥y{¸ W¸
=C@¸ ă {¢¸W¸d¢d^¥{®d¸®{d°¸h¸W¸[W[d^©d¸v{¸W¢¢d[´¸ °d¸¦{¸h¸¥yd¸j|d[±¸ &ăh¸¥yd¸^{v¸^yW[d¸ ă
¢y°{v¸ W¸vW¥d¸h¸¥yd¸{®d¥{1¸ kOÎ C¸¥yd¸°c¢
¸ ¥yd¸ [©d¸ ddd¥¸ *ă {¢¸¢{¥{dc¸[d°¸
=C@¸ă {¢¸W¸W¦{W¸i¥¸®{d°¸h¸¥yd¸v{¸W¢¢d[´¸Wc¸¥yd¸ ¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ ă C¸ ^¥W¢¥¸ ¥¸ ^®d¥{W¸ [W[d^©d¸ v{¸
vW¥d¸ h¸=C@¸ O ă W¢¢d[{d¢
¸ ¥yd¸ ^{v¸ ^yW[d¸ ă W^¢¸ W¸ ¢dW¸ [W¸ ¸
=C@¸ *ă { ¢ ¸W¸¥¸d¢d^¥{®d¸®{d°¸ h ¥̧yd¸ vW¥d¸ h ¸=C@¸ O ă ^c©^¥{®d¸ d¥W¸ ¢¥©^¥ªd¸ ¢{¥{dc¸[d¥°dd¸¥yd¸ [©d¸
ddd¥¸ *ă Wc¸ ¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ ă C¸ W¸ ^®d¥{W¸ [W[d^©d¸
=C@¸$ă {¢¸W¸W¦{W¸d¢d^¥{®d¸®{d°¸ h ¥̧yd¸vW¥d¸ h = ¸ C@¸ă
kkÎ v{
¸ ¢dW¸ [W¢¸ Wc¸ ^c©^¥{®d¸ ¢¥ª^¥©d¢¸ Wd¸ WcW¥dc¸ ¥¸
¢y°{v¸ W¸¥¸¥{¸h¸¥yd¸ vW¥d1¸
¢y{dc¸¥yd¸[©d¸i¸vdW¢d¸c{{v¸i¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸Pyd¸
=C@¸5ă {¢¸W¸W¦{W¸d¢d^¥{®d¸®{d°¸h¥̧yd¸vW¥d¸h¸=C@¸ă ^c©^¥{®d¸ ¢¥©^¥ªd¢¸ Wd¸ ©¢©W´¸ d¥W¸ ¢¥©^¥ªd¢¸ ¸ W¸
¢y°{v¸ W¸¥¸¥{¸h¸¥yd¸ vW¥d1¸ W¡Wvdd¥¸h¸ydW¥¸ ^c©^¥{®d¸ W®W¸W^¢¸ O{^d¸ ¥yd¸ vW¥d¸
=C@¸ #ă {¢¸W¸[¥¦¸d¢d^¥{®d¸®{d°¸h¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ h¸=C@¸ ă yW¢¸ W¸ vdW¢d¸ ^¥¸ W¢¢d[´¸ ă ¢dW¸ [W¢¸ Wc¸
Oă qOÎ ^c©^¥{®d¸¢¥ª^¥ªd¢¸Wd¸¥¸d©{dc¸{¸¥yd¸ v{¸ W¢¢d[´¸
¸ C@¸ă
=C@¸/ă{¢¸W¸W¦{W¸d¢d^¥{®d¸®{d°¸ h ¥̧yd¸vW¥d¸ h = ă 4¢¸ ¢y°¸ {¸ ¥yd¸ j|v©d¢
¸ ¥yd¸ [©d¸ ddd¥¸ *ă {¢¸
¢y°{v¸W¸[¥¦¸¦{¸h¸¥yd¸ vW¥d1¸ dieW[´¸W¸[©d¸¥ª[d¸¸¸ B°d®d
¸ W¸ ^®d¥{W¸
=C@¸&ă{¢¸W¸^¢¢¢d^¥{¸h¥̧yd¸v{¸W¢¢d[´¸Wc¥̧yd¸vW¥d¸ {dW¸¸B¢yWdc¸[©d¸^W¸[d¸d´dc¸{¸¥yd¸[W[d^©d¸
¥Wd¸ Wv¸ {d¸ &Ï&ă h¸=C@¸ Oă v{¸ W¢¢d[´¸ ă4¸¥{¸h¸¥yd¸ [©d¸ *ă {¢¸ ¢©¦dc¸
=C@¸ =ă {¢¸ W¸ ^¢¢¢d^¥{¸ h¸¥yd¸ v{¸ W¢¢d[´¸ Wc¸ W¸ qkÎ °{¥y{¸¥yd¸j|d[±¸ &ă[´¸W¸[^¸ *$ă d±¥dc{v¸i¸¥yd¸j|¢¥¸
W¥dW¥d¸d[c{d¥¸h¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸¥Wd¸Wv¸{d¸ =Ï=ă h¸ ¢{cd¸ °W¸ $ă Pyd¸ [©d¸ *ă yW¢¸ W¸ ©W{¥´¸ h¸ {dW
¸
=C@¸ Oă ^©®{{dW
¸Wc¸¥W¢{¥{¸¢dvd¥¢¸d¢©¥{v¸{¸W¸^¥{©©¢¸
1/29/2019
Exhibit B, Page
2:46:20
83 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-2 Filed 01/29/19 Page 17 of 22 Page ID #:84
1-K ŀ ŀ
K K
('
ă ) ă1ă*ă ă ă
ă ă ('
7 $#ă ăăă
ă5$ă\ă 3,8ă /^ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ('+ă &ă ă 5$ă ăă
ăăQ
ă ) ă .
ă $#ă ă ă
ă |ă
ă ă 1ă 4ă *ă ă
ă ă
ă ăă ă ă ă ăVă ă ('ă ăă \ÒVß|^ă ă ă
('+ă&ăC!L
ă ă1ă*ăăă
ă
ă
ă) ă
ăă ă ă
ăă.
ă9ă ăă
ăă
ă>ă ăă.ă
ă ă ^ .
ă ă ă ă ă *ă ă ăVăăă
ă|ă ă('ăă
ăă9¹ă ă
+ă
ă ă
ă *5ă \ă 3,8ă &^ă ă ă ă ă ăăă ă
ăă,ăă ă
ăă ăăă
ă
ă
ă ă
C!L
ă ă
ă ă
ă 0ă **ă ('ă ă 1ă V k Î P!Lg
ă ă 3,8:ă*¨5ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă
?Aă
ă9
ă ăă3,8:ă ă ăăă
ăă ăăă
ă
ă
ă5#ăăă
ă
ă
ă('
ă ă('
ăă ă
ă
ă
ă 5&ă ) ăă
ă
ă 5#ă
1ă?Aă
ăă ă ă
ăăă ă
ă ă
ă ă ă
ăă
ă ă ă ă ă ă
ăă %
ă [kÎ V ăă!-ăă ă('ăăăă
ă#ă
!6ăă ă
ă ă ă ăă ăă ă
ă *&ă #ă ă ăă .('
ăăă ă
ă
ă ă
ă
ă
ă ăYăăăjă ă $$ă ă ă ă
ă
ă ă
.ă ă ă
ă *&ă cdă ăă
ă!6ă ă
ă #ă#ă) ă ăă ă ('ăă
ă #ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă
ăăă !-ă ă ă ă ă
ă #ă ă ă
ă #$ă ##ă ('ă ă
%
ă ă ăYăă ă
ă
ă
ăă a O Î
ă
ă #&ă ă ă
ă ă 9ă ăă 3,8ă *ă ă
ă ăăă
ă.('
ăă ă
ă$ă5ă
ă
ă #&ă ă ă
ă
ă.('
ă
#ă/ăă&ă
ăăă?Aăă
ăă ă ) ă('ăăăă
ă#ă #ăă ăă
ă
ă
ă *&ă
ă
ă 5#ă ăăăă
ăăă /ă
9ă ă ă 3,8:ă ¨*ă ă
ă ă ă
ă a ăă /ăăăăăă
ă ă ?Aă ă
ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ('+ă &ă ) ă a k Î ăă
ă
ă%
ă!6ă ă ă
ă
ăă
ăă('ăă$ă+ăă('ăă$ăă ă9ă ăă3,8ă$ă ăă/ă ăă('ă
ă!;ă
ă
ăăăăăă$ă+ăăăă /ă ă ă ă
ă ă /$ă ) ă
ă ă
$*ăă ă
ăă) ăă$ă$ăă ăă
ă ă ă 1ă 4ă *ă ă ă
ă ă ekÎ ă ăă /ă
ă
ă ă ă
ă ă
ă
ăă%
ă!6ăă ă
ă ă!-ă /ă /$ă ă ă
ă/&ă &ăă ăă/ă ,ă ă.ă ă
ăă ă ă ă1ă4ă*ăa ă
ă
ă ă
ă ~ăă ă ăă
ă
ă ă ă $$ă ă ă ă !;ă $&ă ă ă ă ă .ă ) ă
ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ăăă!;ă$&ă('ăă%
ăă5ăă !;ă /ă /$ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă
ă ă ) ă%
ă !;ă 5ăăăă ă kOÎ
ă
ă
ăăV ăă!-ă ă ă ă
!6ăăă%ăă ă
ă ă) ă %
ă !;ă 5ă ă0ăă ăă /ă ă ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă
ă
ă ('
ă ă ă ă ăă/ăă ăăăă
ă.('
7
('
ă ă ă ă .('
ă ă ă
ă ă ăă ă ăă /ăăăăă ă
ă ă ă $$ă ) ă ă $$ă +ă
ă
ă ă ă >
%ă.('
ă ă ăă/ă+ă!-ă
ăă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă %
ă ă 5ă ă ă ă
ă
+
ă ă
ă $#ăăă
ă
ăă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă
ă #&ă :
ăă ă ('ăă ă
ă
ă ă ă
ă $#ă ă ă
ă
ăă ă ă
ă#ă #ă ăă&ă ă ăă.('
7
ă ă9
ă ă ă
ă ă
ă
ă qkÎ ă ) ă ă &ă ă ă %ă &Hă \ă 3,8ă 5^ă ă ă
('
ă ă ă ă ă
ă $#ăă ă ă !L
ă ă
ă ă ă ă 5ă ă ă
ăăă ă
ăă3ă+
ă ă
ă
ăă$$ă9
1
ă ă ă&ăă0ă
1/29/2019
Exhibit B, Page
2:46:20
84 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-2 Filed 01/29/19 Page 18 of 22 Page ID #:85
1-K ŀ ŀ
K K
ă ă
ă
ă #&ă ă ăă ă
ă $#ă 3,8ă=ă ăă
ă ă ăă
ăăă ăVăăă
ă ă ă ă ă
ă $#ă ă ă3,8ă*ă ă ă Căă :
ă ă .ă
ă $ă ă ă
ă
9ă ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă Õ ă ăVøă ă ă ă CÆă ă ă
ă >
ă ă ă ăă
ă #$ă ##ă P!L
ă ă
ă .('
ă
3,8:ă *¨5ă ă
ă #$ă ##ăăăă ă('ă kÎ ) ăă
ăăă ă.ă
ă$ăăăă
ăăă
ă #ă #ăăăă
ă
ăă #ă|%ă ă.ăăă
ă ă$ă ăă#ă
ă
ă ă 9ă
ă ă ă
ă ă $$Hă ă ăă
ă
ăă
ă
ăC!L
ă
ă ă !6`
ă ă ă $$Tă ) ă ăă#ăăăă ă.
ă$#ă ă ă
ă
ă #$ă ##ă ă +ă ă `ă ă $$Tă ă ) ă ă ă .ă
ă ă $ă ă
ă
Yă ă ă jă .ă ă
ă #$ă ##ă ă VOÎ ă ă ăă
ă
ă
ă 5#ă :7
ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ă $$Tă a ă ('
ăă ăă*ă
+1
ă
ă &&ă ă ă ă +1
ă
ă =ă ) ă !-ă :ă ă%
ă ăă
%ăă
ă ăă
+1
ă
ă &&ă ă ă+ă ă!-ă
ă 5ă ă ă
ă 4ă ă ă ă ă >
ă ă ă +1
ă
ă =ă ă ă +ă ă [kÎ ă
ă ă ă
ă ăă ă 1ă*ă9ă
ă
ă 5* ă) ăUăă ă+1
ă
ă&&ă =ă ă +
ăă
ă
ă
ă ă
ă
ă 7
ă ăă ă
ăă
ăă $$ă) ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ă?Aă ă
ă
ăă
('ă ă ă+1
ă
ă &&ă =ă +ă
ăă ă ă
ă
ăă ă
ăăC!L
ă ă+1
ă
ă&&ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă 1ă *ă ă +ă ă
=ăă ă
ăă ă
ă ă %
ă ă aOÎ %
ă ă ă
ă ă ă .
ă *&ă 3,8ă &ă
5ă C!L
ă ă +1
ă
ă &&ă =ă ă
ă ă ă
ă ăă ă ă%
ă ă
ă ă +1
ă
ă&&ă =ă ăă
ăăă ă ă ('ă ă ă ă CSă ) ă ă
ă ă ă
ă
ăă
ăăă
ăă%
ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă *ă ă
!6ă ă ă
ă ă ) ă ă ă ă Uă ă ă
ăă ă
ă 5ă 5*ăă ă
ăăă ă
+1
ă
ă&&ă=ăă
ă ă
ăă ă!-ăă akÎ
ă=ăă ă('+ă&ă,ă ăăăCSă ă
ă
ă
ă 5ă 5*ăP!L
ăă 3,8:ă *ă ă 5ă ă
ă ă
ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă
ăăăă
ă =ă ă ă
ă=ăă ă*ăYăăăjă.ă ă1ă *ă ă
ă ă ă
ă ă &ă ă ă `7
ă ă
ă
ă
ăăă ă
ă ă:ă
ă ă $$Tă ă ă ă $ă $ă ) ă
ă =ă ă ă1ă*ăă3,8:ă ă ăă
ă('
ă ă
!L
ă
ă ă ă %
ă ă 5ă ă ă eOÎ
ă
ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ă=ăăă
ăăă ă
ăă
ăă ă
ă
ăă ăă*ăC!L
ă ă
%
ă ă ă +1
ă
ă &&ă =ăă ă .
ă $#ă ă ă
ă
9ăăă ă
ă
ă
ăăă ă ă ă
ă ă ă 1ă 4ă *ă
ă ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă 5#ă ă ,ă ăăăCSă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă 5&ă :
ăă ă ă ekÎ 5&ă ă ă ă ă 1ă 4ă *ă ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă 5#ă ă
ă
ă
ă7
ăXă) ă
ăXăă ă
ăă
ă5&ăăăăă ă?Aăă
ăăă ăăă!;ăă ă1ăă *ă ăă
ă
ă ă %
ă !6ă ă ă
ă ă P!Lg
ă ă !;ăă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă5&ă) ăă
3,8:ă #¨/ă
ă
ă
ă
ă 5&ăă ă ă ă
ă Xă ă ă ă
ăă ă ă
ă ă Uă
ă ă ă ă !-ă ă
ă ă kOÎ
ă
ăă
ă ă
ăă ăU+ă&ăă
ă ă ă
ă ă ) ăă
ă ă ă ă ă
ă SMMTă ăă0ă
ă ăă
ă SMMHă ă
) ăă
ă ă ăă
ăă
ăă
ă ăă ăă0ă*Hă ă.ă
ăSMMTă
ă,ăă ăă
ă ă ă ă
ăă kkÎ ăăă ăă0ă*Hăă ă0ă
ă
ă ă ) ă
ă
ă
ă 5&ă cd0 ă SMMyăăăă ăăă*H\ă3,8ă ^ă
ă ă .ă
ă $ă ă ă !-ă ă
ă Yăăăjă.ă ăă
ăSăM MHă+ă
!;ăă) ă.ă
ă$ă ă ăă
ă $Tăă ă0ă
ă ă
ă SMMHăă ă
ă ă ăă
ă *ăă ă
$Hă $Tă $yă ăă
1/29/2019
Exhibit B, Page
2:46:20
85 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-2 Filed 01/29/19 Page 19 of 22 Page ID #:86
1-K ŀ ŀ
K
K
ă .ă
ă $ă ă
ă ă ă ă .ă ă /ă ă ă ă ă
ăă ă ă
ă
0ă*Tăă ă1ă4ă*ă:('
ă ăă
ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă
ă ă ă('ăă
$Hă ăă ă ă .ă0ă*Tă ă .ă
ă #ăă ă ăă
ă #ă,ă ă ă ă
ă $Hăăă
ă ă ă.ă
ă
ă ă!6ă
1ăă*ăYăăă ă.ă ă!;ă ă
ăă ă
ăăă
ăă ăăă
ă ăă
ă *ăă ă 1ă4ă *ă ăă
ă
ă ă%
ăăă
9
1
ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă 5&ăă7 ă ăă ă!;ă
ă ă ă
ă ă ă
('
ă ă ă ă .ă
ă $Tă +ă ă ă ă ă!6ă %ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă!6ă
.ă
ă
ă ă ) ă [OÎ ăă
ăă
ăjă ă!67
ă ă ă ă #ă ă
ă
ă ă
1ă?Aă
ă ă ă 1ă*ă C!L
ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ?Aă ă
#ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ă 1ă ă ă?Aăăăăă ă
ăăă ăjă
?Aă
ă 9
1
ă ă ă #ă ă ă ('
7 ă
ă) ă ăjă
ăă
ăă7
ă ă ă
ă
ă ă ă .('
ă ă ă [kÎ ăăă0ăăă ăă
ă
ăă
1ă *ă ă ă ă ă #ăă ă ă ) ă
ă ăă ă
ă ă ?Aă ă
ă ă
ăă?Aă
ă ,ă ă ă ă ă ă #ăă ăă ă ă
>`ă`ăă 7
ă!-ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă5&ăă ă ăă ăă
ă
ă ă)
ă %ă
ă ă
ă ă
ă SMMHă $Hă ă > a O Î ă ă ?Aă +
ă ă ă 4ă *ă 9ă ă 7
ă ă ă ă ă .ă
ă *ă *ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă!6ăă
ă ă
1ă *ă ă ă ă
ă :ă ă !6ă ă ă ă
,ă ăăăCSă ăă
ă
ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă
ă qă ă
ă
5#ăăă ă ă +ă ă ă1ăă *ă9ă ăăă ăă0ă ă ă
ă ă 9ă
ă ă 3,8ă &ă ă ă /ă ă ă ('ă ă
ă #ă ă a k Î ('ă qă ă ă
ă ăăă ăă
ă
ăăăăă ă1ă4ă*ă:
ă ă ă
ă$#ăă ă
ă ăăăăqăă ă
ă/ăă ăăă
ă#ăăăăă0ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ă 4ă
ă ă1ă4ă*ă ,ă ăăăCSă ă('ă!;ă ă ă ă
ă ăV ă ă Uăqăă
ăă
/ăă ăă/ăăăă ăăăă ăă ăă
ă$#ă ă
ă
ă ?Aă
0ă *Hă *yă ă ă 1ă ă *ă \ă 3,8ă ^ă eOÎ
ă ă
ă $#ă ă ă ă 0ă
ă &ă ă ă
ă ă
ă/&ăă ă('ă!;ă/ă+ăă ('+ă &ă \ă 3,8ă &^ă :ă ă 0ă
ă &ă ă
ăăă *Hă Yăăă jă .ă ă
ă
ă ă Qă ă ă
ă ă ă
ă/&ă+ăă ăă
ă ă ă 1ă 4ă *ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă
ă ăăP!Lg
ăă ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă3,8ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă ă 1ăă *ă ă0ăă ă ă /ă ă ?Aă
ă ăă /ăă ('ă
3,8ă =ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă kkÎ ă ?Aă ă 3Că ă ă
ă ă ă ă !-ă
ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă1ăă*ă)
1/29/2019
Exhibit B, Page
2:46:20
86 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-2 Filed 01/29/19 Page 20 of 22 Page ID #:87
1-K ŀ ŀ
K
K
ă ăă /ă ă ă
ă /&ă ă('ăă ă
ăă ă ă ăă0ăă ă
ăăăăă
ă
?Aă ă 3Că
ăă ă ă ă /ă ă ă ă ă
ă #ă ă ă
ă &ă 9ăă
ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă %
ă !6ă ă
ă ă
ă
ăăă
ă 3Căă ă
ă ă
ă ă ă
ă SMMHă
.ă) ă
ăă ăă ă
ă !;ă/ă /$ă
ă ă ă ă
ă
ă ă ă ă
ă SMMHă
ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă
ăSMMHă ă ă
ă !;ă /ă ă ă ă ă /ă ă ă >
%ă
ăă
ăă ă?Aă ă3Că
ăă ă ă [OÎ ('
ă
ă /ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă
P!Lg
ăă 3,8ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
0ă
ă*Hă
3C$ă ă ă?Aă ă3Că :ă ăă
ă SMMHă ă ă
ă.ă
ă *Tă ă ă ă
ă *yă a ă ă ă
ă
ă ă +ă ă ă ă
ă
ă ă ă
ăăăă ăă
ă
ă ă ă .('
7
ă %
ă ă 5ă ă ă
ă ă ) ă ă eOÎ ăă ă
ă
ă
ă ă:('
ă ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ăă
ă('
ăă ăă
ă #ă
ă ă
ă ă $$ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă ('
ă 9ă ă
ă ă
ă
ă 5#ă 9
ă ă ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă ăă
ă ă?Aăă
ăă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă 5&ă) ă7
ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă ăăă
ă
ă ă ă > ekÎ ă ă1ăăă?Aăă ăă
ăă ăă
ă
ă>%ă
ă ăăă?A>ă ă ă ('+ă
ă9
1
ă ă
ăăăă
ă ă%
ă ,ă ă !Lgă ă ă
ă
ă 7
ă ă ă ă ă
ă gă ă
ă
ă5&ăăă!-ă ă
ă
ă
ă
~ă>%ăă ă ă
ă ă 5#ă9ăă
ă ă
ăă
ă ăăă
ă
ă
) ă
ă ăă ăăăăă!6`ăăă k O Î
ă 5#ă ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă ăă
ă ă ă ă ă ) ă %
ă!6ăă ă
ăă8ăăă
ă
ă ă ă ă !6ă ăă ă.ă.
ă ă ?Aăăă!-ă ăă
ă
ă
ă5#ăă
ăă ă3ă+
ăă('ă0ăă ă
ăă ă.ăă ă ăăă ) ă
ă
ăăăăă ăăăă ăă ăă
ăăă9
1
ă ă
ăăăă!6ă
ă
ă!-ă ă
ă/&ă&ă
ăă%ăă
!-ă
ă ă ă +ă ă
ă ă ă ă ăă *ă9ă ă
ă ă ăă
`
ă ă
ă ă ă ăă
ă
ă
ăăă
ăă
%
ăăă
9 ă!Lăăă ă ăă ă qOÎ ă ă ă *ă ă ă
ă ă :('
ă ă
ă 3,8:ă ¨ă ) ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă
ă
%
ă 4ă ă
ăă ă ăă
ăăă
ă ă
ăă $$ăăă
ă
ă
ă5#ăă ăă*ăC!L
ă ă
ă ă
ă $#ă) ă
ă
ă
ăă
%
ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ăă ('
ă ă !-ă ă ă ă 3,8:ă ¨=ă !;ă ă ă 1ă *ă ă ă
%
ă 44ă ă
) ă
ă
ă
ăăăăă
ă qkÎ
ăă ă ă1ă*ă) ă
%
ă
ă
ă 5#ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă 44ă ă ă!-ă
ă ă ă ă
ă >
ă
5&ă) ăă
ă
ă 5#ă
1/29/2019
Exhibit B, Page
2:46:20
87 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-2 Filed 01/29/19 Page 21 of 22 Page ID #:88
1-K ŀ ŀ
K
K
4ăăă ă
ă*ă) ă
%
ă44ăă ă ă ) ăă
ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă
ă ă%ă ă ă ă 4ă ă %
ă
ă ă ă
ă ă ă 1ă 4ă
ă >
%ă .('
ă ă ă ă 44ă ă ă ă ă %
ă
) ă
ă ă ă ăă ăă ăă
ăă ăă 4ă
ă
.('ă
ăă
ă
ă) ă
ă *ă9ăă
ă
ă
_ă
ă ă ă?Aă ă3Căă
ăă ă ă
ă ă%
ă Oă
ă
ăă ă
ă!-ă ă('+ă&ă) ăă ă
ă ă 4ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă
>ăă
ăăă ăă
ă %
ă ă ă ă4ă
ă ă
ă ă
jă ă ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ă ă 30 7
ăăă
ăă
ăă('.
ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă ?Aă ă 3Căă
ă ă ă %
ă ă ă
ă ă
ă ă
ă
ăă ă ă%ă ă ă ăăă*ă
ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă ă
ă
ă ă VkÎ
ă
ă
ă ă ă ă
ă
ă
V
ă ă ('ăă ăă
ă
ă
_ă
ă X
ă [OÎ ă%
ă Oă
Vă
_ă ă
ă ă 4ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă 9ăă
ă
ă
_ă %
ă ă ă ă4ă
ă ă
ă ă
ă %
ă Oă 1ă ?Aă
Oă
ă
ă ă 4ă ă ă ă
ă 0ă ă ă ă%
ă
ă
ăăăăăă
%
ă ăă
ă ă
ă ă1ă?Aă [kÎ ă ă%
ă ă ă
ă
ăă
ăă
Oă
ăăă
ăă
ăă('.
ă
ă%
ă
ă
ăăăăă0ă ă %
ă !;ă ă
ă 40 ă
ă ă ă
ă ă%
ă ă ă
ă
ăă
ăă
ă
ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ăă
ă ă %
ă !;ă ă
7
ă ăăă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă ă.
ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă a O Î
ă
ă ă
ă $ă ă ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă
ă
ăă
ă ă ă ăă #ă) ă ă
ă
ă ă
ă 5ă ă ă
ă ăă
ă ăă ăă
ă ă
ă eOÎ
ă!;ăă('ăăă
ăă
ă
ă ă +
ă !-ă ă %
ă ă ă
ă ă !6ă ă%ă ă ăă
ă ă
ăă ă ă%
ă ă /ă ) ăă
ă
ă ă
ă $ă ă ă
*ă ) ă ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă
ă ă ('ă ă
ă
ă ă
ă !;ă ă ă Uă ă ă
ă 7 ă
ă ă ăăă ă ă 1ăă
!;ă +
ă !-ă ă %ă ă ă ă ekÎ &ă) ă ă
ă
ă ă
ă $ă ă ă
$ă ) ă ă
ă
ă ă
ă *ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă cd0 ă ă ă ă
%ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă %
ă !;ă
ă ă ă .ă
ă ă
ă !-ă ă
ă
5ă) ăă
ă
ăă
ăă ă ăă !;ă ă ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă 0ăă ă 1ă =ă ) ăă
ă
ă ă
ă &ă ă ă
4ă kOÎ ă
ă ă
ă ă
#ă ) ă ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă 1ăă ă ă .ă
ă ă
ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă .ă
ă ă ă1ă4ă
ă!-ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ă) ăă
ă
ă ă
ă &ă ă ă
/ă ) ăă
ă
ă ă
ă #ă ă ă .ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ('ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ă ă
ă
ă ă
ă #ă ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ă ă
ă &ă ă ă qOÎ !;Oă
.ă
ă ă
ăă ă
ă ă.
ă ă ă
ă ă
ă 1ăă ă ă
ă ('ă ă
Oă ă
ă ) ă ă
ă
ă ă
ă &ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă
.ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ('ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă 1ăă
ă qkÎ !6`ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă ) ăă
ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă
ă ă ă ă ă?Aă ă
ă
ă ă ă ă ă .
ă
ăă %
ă !6ăă ă
ă
1/29/2019
Exhibit B, Page
2:46:20
88 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-2 Filed 01/29/19 Page 22 of 22 Page ID #:89
1-K ŀ ŀ
K
K
ă9ă%
ă
ă
ă !6ă ă ă ă %
ă = ă) ă %
ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă ('.
ă ă %
ă *ă9ăă
ă
ă
_ă
!;Oă ă %
ă ă
ă ă ('+ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă ă
ă ă Oă
ă ă .
ă ('ă ă
Oă ă ă
ă1ăăă ă('+ăă
ăă
ă
ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă ă 1ă ?Aă
Oă
ă
ă ăăă
ă
ă
ă ă%
ă
ă
ă ă ă ă('+ă ă
ăăăă ă?Aăă
ă
ă VOÎ
ă
ă ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă%
ă!6ăă ă
ă ă ăă
ă
ă
ă
ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă ăă
ăăă
ăăă
ă
ă ă
ă ăă ă ă
ă 7
ă
ă ă ă ă 1ă ă
ă
ă
ă
* ă) ă%
ă
ă
ă ă
ăă ă ă cd0 ă
ă ă Uă
ă
ă !-ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă
ă ăă ă ă
ă ă VkÎ !;ă ă ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă * ă) ăă
ă
ă ă
ă *ă ă ă
$ă) ă%
ă
ă
ă ă
ăă ă ă ('ă
ăă
ăă ă
ă
ă ă
ă*ă ă ă
5ă) ă%
ă
ă
ă ă
ă$ă ă ă [OÎ
ă
ă
ă 40 ă ă ă ă
ă
ăă ă
#ă) ă %
ă
ă
ă ă
ă5ă ă ă ă
.ă
ă ă
ăă ăă .ă0ă **ă) ăă
ă
ăă
ă*ă ă ă
ă ăă
ă [kÎ ă ăăăăăă
ăă
/ă) ă %
ă
ă
ă ă
ă5ă ă ă *$ă) ăă
ă
ăă
ă *ă ă ă
.ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ('ă ă ă %
ă
ă ăă+1
ă
ă ăă .ă !;ă ă
&ă) ă %
ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă
ă ăă
ă ăă
ă
ă
ă+7
ă
ă ă
ă ă ă
ă Î Î Î Î Î
1/29/2019
Exhibit B, Page
2:46:20
89 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-3 Filed 01/29/19 Page 1 of 21 Page ID #:90
([KLELW&
1/29/2019
Exhibit C, Page
2:46:31
90 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-3 Filed 01/29/19 Page 2 of 21 Page ID #:91
Ʋ³³²³Æ²²³²³²³Æ² Ƴ³²² Ƴ³²² Ʋ³³³³Æ²² ²Æ²³³³³Æ@@?@@?@ @ @???@?@@ ?@@?@? @ ?@@??@Æ
.
ă
\uo^ă 2UMRU^ 2Z>OM@<YMRQ^ "<Y<^
\o^ă 573!7^
l:ă ebbu~bbfuoă9Üă iă ă ebbuă
) ă ă ă ă ă %
ă
ă !6ă ă
3DO<YDB^ 8
5
^ TTOM@<YMRQ^ "<Y<^ ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă %
ă
ăă ă
ă 1ăă ă ă
ă 0ă ă
\u^ă Xăă
ăJă n b~ n fă ('
ăă
ă%
ă ă) ă
ă ă ă
ăă
ă
Yă năebbeă ăCă Jă bfeă
ă('
ăă%
ă!;ăă
ă.
ă
) ă
ă cd0 ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă
\o n ^ ă (QY
^!O
^
ăăăăă?Aă
ăăă
("*ħ'!%ħ \ebbubn^ă
ă
ă ă?Aăă
ă
ăă%
ă!6ăă
\oe^ă 8
5
^ !O
^ ă ==°$Oă~ffoOă~fobOă
ă
ă ) ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă
ă ă ă
neu~fnă Pă
ă ă ă
ă ă
ă ) ă ă
ă ă ă
\o^ă %MDOB^ RF^!O<WWMI@<YMRQ^ 5D<U@L^ ă ífobă
ăăă ăă
ă ă('ă
ă ăă
~fffă ffoă ffuăfbbOă neu~fnă Pă ăă
ăă) ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
:ă
ă('
ă !6ă
ă ă ă ăăă
ăăă.ă
ă
ă!-ăă
ă
\ou^ă 3DHUDQ@DW^ !MYDB^ !;ăă ă
ăV ă ă4ă ă
ăă
ăăă !-ă.
ă ă ăă?Aă
l:ăC9)aJ)ă YkXliaJ):ă
ă
[ [ [ 0MM0SW[
[ [
[ KE9H0J[ ă!O<MPW^ ă "U<[MQJ^5LDDYW^
1/29/2019
Exhibit C, Page
2:46:31
91 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-3 Filed 01/29/19 Page 3 of 21 Page ID #:92
2.K K K
C
ăeă
l:ăC9)aJ)ă YkXliaJ):ă
[ [ [ EEBKQR[ +++++++++++++++++++++++++++A
[
[ [
[ 0BQ[
[ [ [ (X30D[ 9Q[0E[ [ [
[ *5AEKOO9M[ 9Q[0E[ [
[
[ [ [ $SO9[ [
[
[ [ [ 0BQ[
[ [ [ 9M?9M[ [ [
[ [ [ (0XH9M[ 9Q[ 0E[
[ [ [ 0MOKJ[ 9Q[0E[
[ [ [ 0MD9M[
[ [
[ *Q9V2[ +++++++++++++++++++++++A
[
[ [ [ $5KJ0E7[ 9Q[ 0E[ [
[
[ [
[ 9OQ[ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++A
[ [ [ [ 0BQ[
[ [ [ 9M?9M[ [ ħ
[ *5AEKOO9M[ 9Q[0E[
[ [ [ *5AEKOO9M[ [
[
[ [
[ *5AEKOO9M[ 9Q[ 0E[ [
[
[ [ [ JSQA[ 9Q[0E[ ++++++++++++++++++A
[
[ [
[ A0MEOKJ[ 9Q[ 0E[
[ [ [ BQ5A[ 9Q[0E[ +++++++++++++++++++A
[ [ [ [ *5AEKOO9M[ 9Q[0E[
[ [ [ $9JQZ9E[ [
[ [ [ [ (B5AQ9M[
[ [ [ .9EEO[ [ [ [ *5AEKOO9M[ 9Q[ 0E[ [ [
[ [ [ .05D9MH1J[ +++++++++++++++++A
[ [ [ [ *5AEKOO9M[ 9Q[0E[ +++++++++++++A [
[ [ [ 9N0M7B[
[ [ [
[ .1M79EE[ ++++++++++++++++++++A
[ ([
[ [ [ "KAH9X9M[ 9Q[0E[ ++++++++++++A
[ )
[ [ [
[ .BQZ9E[ [
[
[ [
[ B1J5BKE0[ [ F [
1/29/2019
Exhibit C, Page
2:46:31
92 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-3 Filed 01/29/19 Page 4 of 21 Page ID #:93
*A
u
T¸
1/29/2019
Exhibit C, Page
2:46:31
93 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-3 Filed 01/29/19 Page 5 of 21 Page ID #:94
ìB Úō b ō
i hō B O\ B \O
=
" /**7=
3,
=
'<
=
¸
k f ¸ ] r
Î
Æ
.
bcu
1/29/2019
Exhibit C, Page
2:46:31
94 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-3 Filed 01/29/19 Page 6 of 21 Page ID #:95
®ħ
Õħ
¸
S¸
1/29/2019
Exhibit C, Page
2:46:31
95 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-3 Filed 01/29/19 Page 7 of 21 Page ID #:96
Y¸
Î
R¸
1/29/2019
Exhibit C, Page
2:46:31
96 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-3 Filed 01/29/19 Page 8 of 21 Page ID #:97
1/29/2019
Exhibit C, Page
2:46:31
97 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-3 Filed 01/29/19 Page 9 of 21 Page ID #:98
U\u _t
¸
ÿĖŁōPō
íō
235ŀ
(-6ō
E ō /
/ Öō ō
ñō
rŀ
WÆ
ĘĂō
1/29/2019
Exhibit C, Page
2:46:31
98 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-3 Filed 01/29/19 Page 10 of 21 Page ID #:99
~¸
6ħ
,ŀ
6ħ
8ō
)ŀ
ħ
ħ
x
( Æ VÆ Ē¼ŀ
Æ ¯ ijō
*ō
ħ
)ō º)ō
0!ō
Ăŀ Ûħ ½ ¾ ¿ŀ ²¸
³¸
;Æ
3X
X!!§ ħ
<=Æ
X
ěÿħ
~Î ħ
ħ
ħ
ħ
0kō
;ħ
>
âō ħ
ħ
~ħ
0ō
4ħ
ħ
3ħ
Ùō 78ħ
78ħ
5ō
0)ō FGħ
ħ
ŀō
ħ
ďħ
Dō
ħ
ñħ
ëŀ
ħ
1/29/2019
Exhibit C, Page
2:46:31
99 P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-3 Filed 01/29/19 Page 11 of 21 Page ID #:100
°¸
)A
ijŀ
)A
uō
w ' ÆYÆ eWō
WX(u
)ŀ
ħ
ħ
*ō
ħ
Ĺō
2X 2X
ęħ
Xħ
¸ÑÞō ¹ëÂō ħ
I./ħ
ħ
./ħ
./ħ
ħ
)(Wu
Ĉħ
?
ħ
)(u ħ
ħ
ħ
(0u
ħ
3ħ
ħ
ħ
5ō
)4u :ħ
ħ
Ŋō
ħ
Ęħ
ćō
ħ
ðħ
ģŀ
ħ
1/29/2019
Exhibit C, Page
2:46:31
100PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-3 Filed 01/29/19 Page 12 of 21 Page ID #:101
.<88FKK ?;K
K
ō
ō ō
lg¸ ^s¸ '4JKKK
ã^ō
&KX v&Æ: 2 Æ
ø đÎŀ );ō
=!^ō =°ō
X;'Ğō =!'kō
»;'ğō
¼!'lō
ùddlō
1/29/2019
Exhibit C, Page
2:46:31
101PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-3 Filed 01/29/19 Page 13 of 21 Page ID #:102
Î
'
Iu
1/29/2019
Exhibit C, Page
2:46:31
102PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-3 Filed 01/29/19 Page 14 of 21 Page ID #:103
&
Hu
¸
1/29/2019
Exhibit C, Page
2:46:31
103PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-3 Filed 01/29/19 Page 15 of 21 Page ID #:104
ă
ă iă ('
ă ă ă
Yă năebbeăăl:ăCăJăbfeă
ă¤X%7 ă
ă ă ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă 8ă ă8ă X
ă :4¥ă ă ă ă ?Aă ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă ă %
ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ă ) ă
s9X³8PklJYă k3ă )aă ,JaJ),kJă ă
ă
ă
ă
ăă%
ă 7
ă ă ă ă !-ă
ă ) ă %
ă ă
) ă
ă ăă
ă
ăă1ăă %ă!6ă ă ă
ăăăăă
ă ăă
ă
ă 0ă ăă
ă ă ăă X
ă 7 ă ă ă ('+ă ) ă1ă ă ă
ă ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă
ă
ăcd
ă ă %ă ă ă ă 0ă !-ă ă ă ?Aă +ă ă
!6ă )
ă !6ăă
ăă [OÎ ă
ăă %
ă !6ăă ă %
ă ă ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă ăă ă
ăă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă ă %
ă ă ) ă qă ă
ă ă C!L
ă ăă
ă
ă ă ăă 7
ă
ă
ă ă%
ăăă ă ('
ă
ă ă ă ă
ă )
ă
ă ă
!6ă %ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă!6ă %ă ă [kÎ
ă ăă ă
ă
ăăă ă!-ă
ă
ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă 4ă ă ă ă 0ă ă %
ă ă,ăă ăă
ă ă ,ă ă ă ă ă !6ă
ă
ăă ăăăăăă
ă
ăă
ăăă
ăăă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă
ă 3ă +
ă %
ă ă ă ă Êă ă ă
ă ,ăă ă ăă ă
ă
ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă ă ă %ă ă 7 a O Î
ă
ă ă
ă ă
ăă ăă
ă 8ăă ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ă %
ă !6ă ă ă
ă !-ă
ă ăă ă
ă ă ă ă 7 akÎ
ă ă ă ă ă 1ă ) ă ă +ă 7
ă
ă ă ă
ă !6`ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ă ă
ăă
7 ă ăă
ăă
ă ă ă ă ă('ăă ) ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă ă
ă
%
ă ă !6ă ă !6ă 9ă +
ă ă ă 7
ă
ăăă
ă
ă
ă
ă ) ă
ă
ăă!6ăăl:ăCă Jă ofbfoeăă:
ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă găă ă
ă
ă ) ă ă
ă ă ă !6ă !-ă ă
ă ă ă0ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ăă
ăă*#ăă
ă ăă ăă ă ekÎ
ă ă ă
ă ă
ă a ă
ă ă ă
ăă ('ăăă
ă
ă ă 9 ă +
ă ă ăă
ă ă ă ă
ă
ă ă ă
ă ă
ă
ă ă ă ăl:ă Că Jă uf n ă
ă ) ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă
ă
fă ă P
ă ă
ă ) ă ă
ă ă ă
ă ('ă ă
ă
ă ă ă
ă ) ă ă
ă ă
ă ă ăă
ă *ă ă
ă ăăă
ă ăă ă ă ă ă ă
4ă&ăX
ă
ăjă!-ăă
ăă kOÎ ă ă ă
ă ă ?Aă ă
ăăă
7
ăă
ă ă?Aăă
ăăă
ă ă
ă%
ă!6ăă ă
ă) ăă ăă
ăă
ă %
ă !6ă ă ă
ă ,ă
ă
ăă+
ă!-ă ă%
ă ăă
ă
ă
ă ,ă ă 7 ,ă ă.ă ă
ăă
ăăăă
ă
ă.ăă ă?Aăă
ăă7 ă ă
ăXq
ă
ă
ă`ă ă > qOÎ
ă
ăăăă
ă ăă!-ă
ă
ă ă .ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ) ă
ă
ă
) !6ă ă ăăăă!6ă ă
ă ă ă
ă ăăă.ă
ă ăă!-ă
ă
ă ă?Aăă
ăăăăă ă ă
ă ) ă .ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ă.ă
ă
ă qkÎ ăăă
ăC!L
ă ă ă.ă
ăă ă
) ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă
ă ă ă
ă ) ă ă
ă ă .ă
ă ă
ă
ă ă ă
1/29/2019
Exhibit C, Page
2:46:31
104PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-3 Filed 01/29/19 Page 16 of 21 Page ID #:105
ă
ăă ă ăă
ă
ă
ă 9ă ă
ă
ă
: ă ă ă 3,8ă
: ) ă
) ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă
ă
ă
:
ă
ă ă %
ă
ă ă ăă
ă
ă
ăV ă ă kÎ ă
: ă ă ă!-ă
ă
: ) ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ă %
ă !-ă
ă
: ă ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă
ă
ă
ăăă
ă %
ă ă
: ă ăă!-ă44ă
: ăăă
ă ă 1ăă,ă ă ă ăă !-ă ă ă 44ă
: ) ă%
ă ă
:
ă ăă
:
ă ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă
ă.ăăă('+ă
:9ă
ă :ăă
ăă0ăă ă1ăă) ă('ăăă ăă V O Î
ă ă ă1ă 4ă ) ă ă !;ă ă ă ă ă % ă !6ă ă ă ă : ) ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă `ă ă ă 0ă ă ă
: ă
ăăUă%ăă:ăăă%ă
1ăă) ă
ă ă ă ă!;ă +ă ă V k Î !;ă : ă
ăă ă`ăăă ăă4ă ă ă(' ă ('ăăă Uă ă
ă
: ă
V ă ă
ă ăă ăăă
ă ăă ă ă
ă : ă !-ă
ă : ăă
ă : ăă
ă
ă
ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă ă
ă : :
ă ă ?Aă ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă [OÎ ă ă 0ă
ă : ă ă
ăă ă .('
7
ă ă
ă ă ă
ă !-ă ă ('+ă ) ă ă9ă
ă: ăă
ă ăăăă ă
ă ă
>ă ă
ă ăă ă ă ('+ă
: ) ă
ă : ă ăă ă ă
ă :
ă jă ă !6`ă ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă G
ă ă
ă ă ă : ă ă
ă
ă
ă 30 `ă ă
ă
ă ('+ă
: 9
1
ă ă
ă : ă ă ă ă
ăă ă?Aă ăă
ă ă ăăăă [kÎ ('+ă
: ă ă
ăă
ă 44ăă ă
%ăă ă ă1ăă
ă ă ă ă ă
ă : ) ăă
ă
ă
: ă ăă
ă
ă
ă ('
ă.
ă ăă
ă
ăă
ă ă ă
k ă !L4ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă
ă
: ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă ă ă!6
ă
ă
: ăGă ă ăăăă
ăăă
ăă
sPºaÖă Ya:ÔPºC)ºkJă kÖă)aăYP9VºJ8:ă ă găă
ă !6ăă
9ă ă
ă : ă ă
ă ă ă
3,8ă
: ă ăăă ăăă
ă
ă
ă0ăă ă('+ă
: ă ă%
ă ă
:
ă ă
ăă ăOă akÎ ,ă ăă ă ă
ă : ă ă
ă
3,8ă : ăă0
ă!-ăăă ă
ă
ăă ă ă
ă : ,ă ă ă
ă ă
ă
ă ă3,8ă
:
ă ă %
ă ă
:
%ă ă ă ă ă
3,8ă : ăăă ă ă ă ă
ă ă3,8ă
: ă
ă 4ă ă ă ă 1ă
3,8ă
: ăă0
ăăă ă ă
ă 3 ă ,8ă
:
ă : ă ă
ă : ,ă ă
ă ă
ă ăă ă ă ă
Oă eOÎ
ă
ă 4ă ă ă
3,8ă : ăă0ăăăă ă
ă ă3,8ă g
ă ă ă ă
ă %ă :ă ă
ă
: ă ă
ă
ă
ă
: ă ă ~ă
:
ekÎ ă 44ă ă ăqăă ă
ă
ă
3,8ă : ăă0
ăăă ă ă
ă 3
ă ,8ă
:
: 9ă ă ă ă ('
ă ă 1ă
ă : ă
ăă0ă0ăă ă
Oă
!L
ă ă1ă 4ă ă
ă ă ă
ă
3,8ă: ăă>ăă ă
ă
ăă ă
ă
ăă> ă1ăăă
ăă ăă
%ă
ă
ă : ă3,8ă :
ă
ă
: 9ăă ă ă1ă : ă 0ă
3,8ă : ă ă >ă ă ă
ă
ă ă ă
kOÎ ă ă('+ă
: ăă
%ă
: +
ă!-ă ă('ă
1ă ă ă ă
ă %ă
ă
ă : ă
ă
ă
: ) ă 1ă : ă ă
ă ă
ă
3,8ă :
ăăă
ă
ăăăă
3,8ă
: ă ă ă ăă ă ă ă ă
ă ăă
: ă ă
ă ă ^
ă ă ă ă 1ă :
+ă
ă ă .
ă : \ă 3,8ă ~ŀ ă ă ă
Ya)9,|aYă Ya:XP,C),kJăk3ă )aă qOÎ ă
ă
ă
:
ă ă ă ă ă ă ă +
('ă ă ă C!L
ă ă
ă ă
ă ă : ('ă ă 1ă
1/29/2019
Exhibit C, Page
2:46:31
105PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-3 Filed 01/29/19 Page 17 of 21 Page ID #:106
ă
ă('
ă ă('
ăă ă
ă ă
ă ă ă
ă :
ă ('+ă
: ) ă ă
ă : ă ă ă ă V ăă!-ăă ă('ăăăă
ă :
ă ă ă ă ă ă
ăă %
ă V O Î : ă ăă .('
ăăă ă
ă
!6ăă ă
ă : ă ă ă ăă ă
ă : ă
: ă ă ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă
ă
ă
ă
: Yăăăjă ă
ă : : ) ă ăă ă ('ăă
ă :
.ă ă ă
ă : cdă ăă
ă!6ă ă ă ă
ă : ă ă
ă
: : ('ă ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă
ăăă !-ă ă
ă
ă : ă ă
ă : 9ă ăă 3,8ă : ă
%
ă ă
: Yăă ă
ă
ă
ă
: V k Î
ă
ă : ă ă
ă
ă.('
ă
ă ăăă
ă.('
ăă ă
ă ă ă 1ă 4ă : ă ă
ă ă a O Î :
: ă ă
ă : : ă ăă : ,ă ă.ă ă
ă
ăă%
ă!6ăă ă
ă : !-ă
ă ă
ă ~ăă ă ăă
ă
ăă ă ă ă1ă4ă : a ă
ă ă ă .ă ) ă
ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ă ă ă
: ă ă ă !;ă
: ă ă !;ă :
: ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ăăă!;ă
: ('ăă%
ăă : ă
ă
ă
ă
: V ăă!-ă ă ă ă
ă
ă : ) ă%
ă !;ă : ăăă ă a k Î ă0ăă ăă : ă ă
ă
ă ă
!6ăăă%ăă ă
ă : ) ă %
ă !;ă : ă ăă : ă ăăăă
ă.('
>
ă ă
ă
ă ('
ă ă ă ăă ă ăă : ăăăă ă
('
ă ă ă ă .('
ă ă ă
ă : ?Aăă
ăăă9
1
ă ăă : ă
ă ă ă
: ) ă ă
: +ă
ă !-ă ă .
ă ă ('ă
ă !;ă : ă ă ă ă : ă ă
!-ă
ă : ă ă
ă : ă ăă
ă : ă ă
ă eOÎ >
%ă.('
ă ă ăă: +ă!-ă
: C!L
ă ă ă
: ă
ă
ă ă ă ă %
ă !;ă : ă ă ă
ă
: : ă ă
ăă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă
ă ă ă
ă : 3ă ă ă
ă
ă : :
ăă ă ('ăă ă
+
ă ă
ă
: ăă
ă
ăă ă
ă : ă
ă : : ăă : ă ăă.('
7
ă
ă ă ă
ă
: ă ă
ă
ăă ă ă ) ă ă : ă ă %ă : \ă 3,8ă : ă ă
ă : 9
ă ă ă
ă ă
ă
ă kOÎ !L
ă ă
ă ă ă ă : ă ă
('
ă ă ă ă ă
ă
: ă ă ă
ăă
:9
1
ă ă ă : ă0ă
ăăă ă
ă : 3ă+
ă ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă : ă ă ă ă
ă
:
: ăăă
ă
: \ă 3,8ă : ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă
: ă ă3,8ă :
: ă ă
ă ăQ
ă ) ă
ă
: ă ă
ă |ă 9ă ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă
:
ă ă ăVă ă ('ă ăă \ÒVß|^ă ă ă kkÎ ă ă ă ăă
ă
: : P!L
ă ă
ă) ă
ă : ă ă
ăă.
ă9ă ăă 3,8:ă : ă
ă
: : ăăă ă ('ă
ăăă ăăă
ă ă
ă
:) ă
ă : ă ăăă
ă :: ăăă
ă
ă ă
ă ăVăăă
ă|ă ă('ăă
ăă9¹ă ă ă
ă : 9ă
ă ă ă
ă ă
: ă
ă ăăă ă
ă :,ăă ă
ă : ăăă ă ă !6`
ă ă ă
: ) ă
Pă ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă .
ă 9ă qOÎ
ă
: : ă +ă ă ă ă
:
ă ă
ă
ă ă9¹ ă) ă
ă : ă ăă Păă Yă ă ă jă ă ă
ă
: : ă
+
ă beoă ă ă ă Pă ă
ă !-ă ă ă ă ăă ă ă ă
: a ă
beb>bbă
ăăăăă!;ă
ă ă
ă
: : ăă!;ă
: : ăăă
ă
Găă ă
ă : ă ăăăGăă ă
ă ăă!;ă : ă ă
ăă
: 9
ă
: qkÎ ă
ă ă
: : ă ă ă
ă ă !;ă
P!L
ă ă 3,8:ă : ă
ă
ă
ă
:
: : ăă
ăă
ă) ăUă
ă
: ă ă
ăăă
ă
ă
ă : ăă
ă ăă .
ă
:ă ă
ăă
: ă ă
1/29/2019
Exhibit C, Page
2:46:31
106PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-3 Filed 01/29/19 Page 18 of 21 Page ID #:107
ă ă ăă*ă
+1
ă
ă &&ă ă ă ă +1
ă
ă =ă ) ă !-ă :ă ă%
ă ă ă
%ăă
ă ăă
+1
ă
ă &&ăăă+ă ă!-ă
ă 5ă ă ă
ă 4ă ă ă ă ă >
ă ă ă +1
ă
ă =ă ă ă +ă ă ă
ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă 1ă *ă9ă
ă
ă 5* ă) ăUăă ă+1
ă
ă&&ă =ă ă V O Î +
ăă
ă
ă
ă ă
ă
ă >
ă ăă ă
ăă
ăă $$ă ) ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ă?Aă ă
ă
ăă
('ă ă ă+1
ă
ă &&ă =ă +ă
ă.ă ă ă
ă
ăă ă
ăăC!L
ă ă+1
ă
ă&&ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă 1ă *ă ă +ă ă
=ă ă ă
ăă ă
ă ă %
ă ă %
ă ă ă
ă ă ă .
ă *&ă 3,8ă &ă
5ă C!L
ă ă +1
ă
ă &&ă =ă ă
ă VkÎ ă ă
ă ăă ă ă%
ă ă
ă ă+1
ă
ă &&ă =ă ăă
ăăă ă ă ('ă ă ă ă CSă ) ă ă
ă ă ă
ă
ăă
ăăă
ăă%
ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă *ă ă
!6ă ă ă
ă ă ) ă ă ă ă Uă ă ă
ăă ă
ă5ă5*ăă ă
ăăă ă
+1
ă
ă&&ă=ăă
ă ă
ăă ă!-ăă
ă=ăă ă('+ă&ă,ă ăăăCSă ă
ă
ă
ă5ă 5*ăP!L
ă ă 3,8:ă *ă ă5ă ă
ă ă [OÎ
ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă
ăă ă
ă =ă ă ă
ă=ăă ă*ăYăăăjă.ă ă1ă*ăă
ă ă ă
ă ă &ă ă ă `>
ă ă
ă
ă
ăăă ă
ă ă:ă
ă ă $$Tă ă ă ă $ă $ă ) ă
ă =ă ă ă1ă *ă ă3,8:ă ă ăă
ă('
ă ă
!L
ă
ă ă ă %
ă ă 5ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ă=ăăă
ăăă ă
ăă
ăă [kÎ ă
ă
ăă ăă*ăC!L
ă ă
%
ă ă ă+1
ă
ă&&ă =ăă ă.
ă $#ăă ă
ă
9ăăă ă
ă
ă
ăă ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă 1ă4ă *ă
ă ă
ă ăă
ă
ă
ă 5#ăă ,ă ăăăCSă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă 5&ă :
ăă ă ă 5&ă ă ă ă ă 1ă 4ă *ă ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă5#ă ă
ă
ă
ă> a O Î
ăXă) ă
ăXăă ă
ăă
ă5&ăăăăă ă?Aăă
ăăă ăăă!;ăă ă1ăă *ă ăă
ă
ă ă %
ă !6ă ă ă
ă ă P!Lg
ă ă !;ăă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă5&ă) ăă
3,8:ă #>/ă
ă
ă
ă
ă 5&ă ă ă ă ă
ă Xăă ă ă
ăăă ă
ă ă Uă
ă ă ă ă !-ă ă
ă ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă
ăă ăU+ă&ăă
ăă ă
ă ă) ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă
ă SMMTăăă0ă
ă ăăăă0ă*Hă
ă
ă ăă
ă SMMHă ă
) ăă
ă ă ăă
ăă
ăă
ă ăă ăă0ă*Hă ă.ă
ăSMMTă
ă,ăă ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ăă ăăă ăă0ă*Hăă ă0ă
ă
ă ă ) ă
ă
ă
ă 5&ă cd0 ă eOÎ SMMyăăăă ăăă*Hă \ă3,8ă ^ă
ă ă.ă
ă $ă ă ă !-ă ă
ă Yăăăjă.ă ăă
ăSăMMHă +ă
!;ăă) ă.ă
ă$ă ă ăă
ă $Tăă ă0ă
ă ă
ă SMMHă ăă
ă ă ăă
ă*ăă ă
$Hă$Tă$yă ăă
ă*ăă ă1ăă*ă9ăă
ă ă !;ă
9
1
ă ăă
ă ăÇă ă.ă
ă $ă kOÎ ă ă.ă
ă ăă
ă
8¸ ă ă T8¸ ăăăCÆă ăă
ă$Hă+ă
ăă
ă
ăă
ă
ăC!L
ă ă ă.ă
ă $Hăăă
ă ă ă .ă
ă *ă ă ă
ă ) ă ă ă .ă
ă ă $ă ă
ă qOÎ ăă*ăYăăă ă.ă ă!;ă
ă ă ăă
ă
ă
ă 5#ă :> ă ăă
ă *ă
1/29/2019
Exhibit C, Page
2:46:31
107PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-3 Filed 01/29/19 Page 19 of 21 Page ID #:108
ă
ă ă ) ă ăă
ăă
ăjă ă!67
ă ă ăă #ă ă
ă
ă ă
1ă?Aă
ăă ă1ă : C!L
ă ăă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ?Aă ă
#ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ă 1ă ă ă?Aăăăăă ă
ăăă ăjă
?Aă
ă 9
1
ă ă ă #ă ă ă ('
7 ă
ă) ă ăjă
ăă
ăă7
ă ă ă
ă
ă ă ă .('
ă ă ă ăăă0ăăă ăă
ă
ăă
1ă : ă ă ă ă #ăă ă ă V O Î ) ă
ă ăă ă
ă ă ?Aă ă
ă ă
ă ă ?Aă
ă ,ă ă ă ă ă ă #ăă ăă ă ă
>`ă`ăă 7
ă!-ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă5&ăă ă ăă ăă
ă
ă ă)
ă %ă
ă ă
ă ă
ă SMMHă $Hă ă 7 ă ă ?Aă +
ă ă ă 4ă : 9ă ă 7
ă ă ă ă ă .ă
ă !: #: ă ă VkÎ ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă!6ăă
ă ă
1ă : ă ă ă
ă :ă ă !6ă ă ă ă
,ă ăăăCSă ăă
ă
ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă
ă qă ă
ă
5#ăăă ă ă +ă ă ă1ăă : 9ă ăăă ăă0ă ă ă
ă ă 9ă
ă ă 3,8ă &ă ă ă /ă ă ă ('ă ă
ă #ă ă ('ăqă ă ă
ă ăăă ă ă
ă
ăăăăă ă1ă4ă : :
ă ă [OÎ ă
ă$#ăă ă
ă ăăăăqăă ă
ă/ăă ăăă
ă#ăăăăă0ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ă 4ă
ă ă1ă4ă : ,ă ăăăCSă ă('ă!;ă ă ă ă
ă ăV ă ă Uăqăă
ăă
/ăă ăă /ă ă ăă ăăăă ăă ăă
ă$#ă ă
ă
ă ?Aă
0ă : : ă ă 1ă ă : \ă 3,8ă ^ă
ă ă
ă $#ă ă ă ă 0ă
ă &ă ă ă
ă ă
ă/&ăă ă('ă!;ă/ă+ăă [kÎ ('+ă &ă \ă 3,8ă &^ă :ă ă 0ă
ă &ă ă
ăăă *Hă Yăăă jă .ă ă
ă
ă ă Qă ă ă
ă ă ă
ă/&ă+ăă ăă
ă
ă ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă3,8ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă ă 1ăă : ă0ăă ă ă /ă ă ?Aă
ă ăă /ăă ('ă
3,8ă : ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ?Aă ă 3Că ă ă
ă ă ă ă !-ă
ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă ă
ă e O Î ă ă ă1ăă :)
ă !: ă
: ă ă.ă
ă #: ă ăă4ă : 9
ă ă ă 1ă 4ă : ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă
+1
ă
ă &ă +ă ă ă +1
ă ă : ă1ă : ă ă ă ă ă0ă
ă &ă 9ă ă
ă ă ă
ă !: ă ă 1ăă : ă ă
ă ă ă ?Aă ă 3Că ă
ă ă
Y
ăăă ăă
ă
ăă!6ă
ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ăă ă
ăăă
ăă ăăă qOÎ
ă SMMHă
1/29/2019
Exhibit C, Page
2:46:31
108PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-3 Filed 01/29/19 Page 20 of 21 Page ID #:109
: ¥yd¸°d¸vdW¢d¸^¥¸ W¢¢d[´¸
[¥¦¸°W¸: h¥̧yd¸j|d[±¸
: Pyd¸{¥¸°ydd¸¥yd¸vdW¢d¸ : yW¢¸W¸¢{vd¸{cvd¸ :¥yW¥¸cddc¢¸i¸W¸°d¸¢©iX^d¸
¢d¢¸^¥W^¥¸°{¥y¸¥yd¸©¥d¸°W¸ *: cdj|d¢¸W¸i©¥y¸{¥¸ : h¥̧yd¸vW¥d¸ : Pyd¸{cvd¸ : yW¢¸W¸©¥d¸°W¸ :
=J ¸ h¸¥yd¸ k°¸W¥y¸=J¸ O{^d¸¥yd¸©¥d¸°W¸ *: h¸¥yd¸ W¸{d¸ °W¸ : Wc¸ W¸ [¥¥¸ °W¸ : :W^y¸ h¸¥yd¸
©¥d¸ {cvd¸
: d±¥dc¢¸ [d´c¸ ¥yd¸ ©¥d¸ °W¸ !: h¸¥yd¸ °W¢¸ : : : yW®d¸ W¸ vddW´¸ ¢¥y¸ ¢©hW^d¸
[©d¸¥©[d¸ : vdW¢d¸cd¢¸¥¸^¥W^¥¸¥yd¸[©d¸¥ª[d¸ : V O Î Pyd¸ {cvd¸ : cddc¢¸ ¢©[¢¥W¥{W´¸ ddc{^©W¸ ¥¸ ¥yd¸
W¢¸{¥¸cW{¢¸¥¥̧yd¸[¥¥¸°W¸ :Py©¢
¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ :®{cd¢¸ °d¸ ¢©iX^d¸ : h¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ : 4¥dW¥{®d´
¸ ¥yd¸{cvd¸
¥yd¸k°¸W¥y¸=J¸i¸vdW¢d¸Wc¸[´c©^¥¢¸vddW¥dc¸c©{v¸ : cddc¢¸ W¥¸ W¸ Wvd¸ i¸ ¥yd¸ °d¸ ¢©iX^d¸ : Pyd¸
¥yd¸^{v¸^d¢¢¸°ydd[´¸¥yd¸k°¸W¥y¸=J¸d^©cd¢¸¥yd¸ {cvd¸ : cdj|d¢¸ W¸ ^W®{¥´¸ : JdieW[´
¸ ¥yd¸ ^W®{¥´¸ :
vdW¢d¸Wc¸[´c©^¥¢¸ i¸^¥W^¥{v¸ ¥yd¸[©d¸¥ª[d¸ : cd¢¸ ¥¸ {¥d¢d^¥¸ ¥yd¸ d{v¢¸
: h¸¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ : Pyd¸
Pyd¸d^{¢d¸c{d^¥{¸h¸¥yd¸ k°¸W¥y¸=J¸{¢¸cd¥d{dc¸[´¸ V k Î ©¥d¸{cvd¸ : {¢¸ ^dW¥{®d´¸ ¢{¥{dc¸°{¥y¸¥yd¸ ©d¸
¥yd¸ ¢¥ª^¥ªW¸ W¢d^¥¢¸ h¸¥yd¸ vdW¢d¸ ^¥¸ W¢¢d[´¸
: h¸ vdW¢d¸^¥¸ W¢¢d[´¸ : Py©¢
¸¥yd¸^W®{¥´¸ : {¢¸ ^·
vW¥d¸ :{^©c{v¸¥yd¸®W{©¢¸^d¥¢¸h¥̧yd¸©d¸Wc¸ dW¥{®d´¸¢{¥{dc¸°{¥y¸¥yd¸©d¸vdW¢d¸^¥¸W¢¢d[´¸
°d¸ vdW¢d¸^¥¸ W¢¢d[{d¢¸ : : :
JdieW[´
¸ W¸¥d^¥{®d¸^W¥{v¸{¢¸W{dc¸¥¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ : C¸¥yd¸©¢d¸¢{¥{¸J¸°ydd¸¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ : {¢¸¢{¥{dc¸
¥¸ {^dW¢d¸ ¥yd¸ vd®{¥´¸ Wc¸ ^¡¢{¸ d¢{¢¥W^d¸ h¸¥yd¸ [ O Î °{¥y{¸¥yd¸^{v¸^yW[d¸
: ¥yd¸vdW¢d¸^¥¸W¢¢d[´¸
vW¥d¸ : C¸Wcc{¥{
¸ ¥yd¸ ¥d^¥{®d¸ ^W¥{v¸ {^dW¢d¢¸ ¥yd¸
: {¢¸¢{¥{dc¸vddW´¸W[®d¸W¸[©d¸ Pyd¸[©d¸yW¢¸
¢¥{^¸ d¥{d¢¸ h¸ ¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ : C¸ ¥y{¢¸ Wd
¸ ¥yd¸ W¸ ^j|v©W¥{¸¥yW¥¸ {¢¸ ¢©[¢¥W¥{W´¸ ¢{{W¸ ¥¸ ¥yd¸ ^j|v©·
¥d^¥{®d¸ ^W¥{v¸ dc©^d¢¸ ¥yd¸ Wcyd¢{¸[d¥°dd¸ ic¸ Wc¸ W¥{¸h¸¥yd¸vdW¢d¸^¥¸W¢¢d[´¸
: Od^{j|^W´
¸¥yd¸
¥yd¸ ^{v¸ ¢©hW^d¸ : h¸ ¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ : Pyd¸ ¥d^¥{®d¸ [©d¸yW¢¸W¸d^¥Wv©W¸^j|v©W¥{¸Wc¸¥yd¸{[¸v©¸ :
^W¥{v¸ {¢¸ W{dc¸ ¥¸ W¸ ©d¸ ¥{¸ h¸ ¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ : [kÎ yW¢¸ W¸ ¢{{W¸ d^¥Wv©W¸ ^j|v©W¥{¸ 4¢¸ W¸ d¢©¥
¸ ¥yd¸
{^©c{v¸ ¥yd¸ dvW¥dc¸ d[d¸
: Wc¸¥yd¸©d¸vdW¢d¸ vdW¢d¸^¥¸W¢¢d[´¸
: c{d^¥¢¸Wc¸^¥¢¸¥yd¸k°¸h¸
^¥¸ W¢¢d[´¸ : 4¢
¸ ¥yd¸ ¥d^¥{®d¸ ^W¥{v¸ ^W¸ [d¸ vdW¢d¸ Wc¸ [´c©^¥¢¸ ¢©^y¸¥yW¥¸ ¥yd¸ vdW¢d¸ W®{c¢¸ ^¥W^¥¸
W{dc¸¥¸ ¥yd¸ °d¸vdW¢d¸ ^¥¸ W¢¢d[´¸ : Pyd¸· °{¥y¸¥yd¸[©d¸W¢¸{¥¸k°¢¸¥¸¥yd¸cW{¸d{v¸{¸¥yd¸[¥¥¸
¥d^¥{®d¸^W¥{v¸^W¸[d¸W¸^dW{¸^W¥{v¸¸W¥yd¸^· h¸¥yd¸j|d[±¸
d^{W´¸W®W{W[d¸¢¥{^¸^W¥{v¸¢©^y¸W¢¸W¸¥dk[W¢dc¸ aOÎ C¸W¥yd¸die¡dc¸ d[c{d¥
¸¥yd¸°d¸vdW¢d¸ ^·
^W¥{v¸4¥dW¥{®d´
¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ : ^W¸[d¸W¥dc¸°{¥y¸{^d¸ ¥¸W¢¢d[´¸:{¢¸{¥¥dc¸i¸¥yd¸vdW¢d¸^¥¸W¢¢d[´¸
¸ ^zd¸ ¥¸ {^dW¢d¸ ¥yd¸ vd®{¥´
¸ ^¡¢{¸ d¢{¢¥W^d
¸ :4¢¸W¸d¢©¥
¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ : ´¸yW¢¸W¸©d¸vdW¢d¸^¥¸
Wc¸¢¥{^¸d¥{d¢¸h¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ : W¢¢d[´¸ : ¥¸ c{d^¥¸ Wc¸ ^¥¸ vdW¢d¸ vddW¥dc¸ °y{d¸
Pyd¸vW¥d¸ : h¸¥yd¸d¢d¥¸{®d¥{¸^W¸[d¸idc¸[´¸W¸ ^{v¸ic¸¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ :@dW¢d¸Wc¸[´c©^¥¢¸°©c¸
©[d¸ h¸°W´¢
¸ {^©c{v¸ d¢¢dc
¸ ^W¢¥
¸ ¸ ¢¥Wdc¸ Pyd¸ akÎ k°¸Wc¸cW{¸i¸¥yd¸©d¸vdW¢d¸^¥¸W¢¢d[´¸: {¸
vW¥d¸ : ^W¸[d¸idc¸{¸W¸y´[{c¸Wd¸^[{{v¸d¸ W¸Wd¸^¢{¢¥d¥¸°{¥y¸¥yW¥¸cd¢^{[dc¸W[®d¸Py©¢
¸vdW¢d¸
¸d¸d¥yc¢¸=¸d±Wd¸W¸j|¢¥¸¦{¸h¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ : Wc¸[´c©^¥¢¸°{¸k°¸¥¸¥yd¸dcvd¢¸ : : h¸¥yd¸{[¢¸ :
^W¸[d¸¢¥Wdc¸Wc¸^[{dc¸°{¥y¸W¸¢d^c¸¥{¸¥yW¥¸°W¢¸ Wc¸cW{¸®d¦{^W´¸c°°Wc¸ ¥yddi¸ O{^d¸¥yd¸©d¸
idc¸ i¸°{d¸¸ °{{v¸ Pyd¸vW¥d¸ : ^W¸[d¸ idc¸ vdW¢d¸^¥¸W¢¢d[´¸:{¢¸¥¸W{vdc¸°{¥y¸¥yd¸[©d¸:
i¸W¸©[d¸h¸W¥d{W¢¸ ¢©^y¸ W¢¸ ¢¥dd
¸ {^©c{v¸ °¸ ¸ eOÎ vdW¢d¸cW{{v¸i¸¥yd¸dcvd¢¸ : : °{¸¥¸Wd¸^¥W^¥¸
y{vy¸W´¢
¸¸{¸4¥dW¥{®d´
¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ : ^W¸[d¸idc¸ °{¥y¸¥yd¸[©d¸ : 4¢¸W¸Wcc{¥{W¸dW¢©d
¸ ¥yd¸[W[d^©d¸
i¸ W©{©
¸ ¸ W¸ {±¥©d¸ h¸ W©{©¸ Wc¸ W¥yd¸ v{¸W¢¢d[´¸
: ^W¸{^©cd¸W¸[^{v¸¢¥©^¥©d¸¢{¥{dc¸
¥ydW´¸^c©^¥{®d¸d¥W
¸ ¢©^y¸ W¢¸ ^d¸¸Wvd¢{©¸ [d¥°dd¸ ¥yd¸ [©d¸ : Wc¸¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ : Od^{j|^W´
¸ ¥yd¸
4¥yd¸diedc¸d[c{d¥¸h¸¥yd¸{®d¥{¸{¢¸ ¢y°¸ [^{v¸¢¥ª^¥©d¸{¢¸^dW¥{®d´¸¢{¥{dc¸°{¥y¸¥yd¸©d¸
{¸ =C@O¸
: Pydd
¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ : yW¢¸ W¸ vdW¢d¸ ^¥¸ ekÎ vdW¢d¸^¥¸W¢¢d[´¸: Wc¸¥yd¸[©d¸:JdieW[´
¸¥yd¸
W¢¢d[´¸
: W¸©W{¥´¸h¸dvW¥dc¸d[d¢¸
: Wc¸W¸ [^{v¸ ¢¥©^¥©d¸ {¢¸ ¢{¥{dc¸ ¢{vy¥´¸ W[®d¸ ¥yd¸ ©d¸
©W{¥´¸h¸d{v¢¸
: Pyd¸vdW¢d¸^¥¸W¢¢d[´¸
: ¢©iX^d¸ h¸ ¥yd¸ [©d¸ : Wc¸ ¥yd¸ [^{v¸ ¢¥ª^¥ªd¸ {¢¸
yW¢¸W¸^j|v©W¥{¸ c{¢¥{^¥¸i¸¥yW¥¸ ¢y°¸{¸=C@O¸
: ^dW¥{®d´¸c{d¢{dc¸°{¥y¸¥yd¸[©d¸:Pyd¸[^{v¸
Pyd¸vdW¢d¸^¥¸W¢¢d[´¸
: ^{¢d¢¸W¸©d¸vdW¢d¸ ¢¥ª^¥ªd¸ {¢¸ Wcd¸ i¸d¥W¸ Wc¸yW¢¸ W¸vddW´¸¥y{°W¸
^¥¸W¢¢d[´¸ : Wc¸W¸°d¸vdW¢d¸^¥¸ W¢¢d[´¸ kOÎ ^¢¥ª^¥{¸¢©^y¸¥yW¥¸ydW¥¸^W¸¥W¢ie¸¥z©vy¸¥yd¸[^{v¸
: Pyd¸©d¸vdW¢d¸W¢¢d[´¸ : vddW´¸^¡d¢c¢¸ ¢¥ª^¥ªd¸Wc¸¥¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸:Pyd¸[^{v¸¢¥ª^¥©d¸^W¸yW®d¸
¥¸¥yd¸©d¸¦{¸h¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ : Wc¸^{¢d¢¸W¸¢{vd¸ W¸Wvdc¸¸dWdc¸^¢¥ª^¥{¸°ydd[´¸¥yd¸ ¢¥ª^¥©d¸yW¢¸
{[¸ v©¸ : ¥yW¥¸ {¢¸ vddW´¸ ¢{¥{dc¸ {¸ ¥yd¸ ^d¥W¸ W¸¥d¥{d¸^j|v©W¥{¸
dv{¸ : h¸¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ : Pyd¸vW¥d¸ : h¸¥yd¸d¢d¥¸{®d¥{¸®{cd¢¸ W¸©[d¸
Pyd¸{[¸ v©¸ : {¢¸^{¢dc¸h¸W¸©W{¥´¸h¸{[¢¸ : kkÎ h¸¢{v{j|^W¥¸Wc®W¥Wvd¢¸®d¸^®d¥{W¸vW¥d¢¸Pyd¸vW¥d¸
°ydd{¸dW^y¸{[¸ : {¢¸WcW¥dc¸¥¸c{d^¥¸¸v©{cd¸¥yd¸ k°¸ : c{d^¥¢¸¥yd¸k°¸W¥y¸=J¸h¸vdW¢d¸¥¸ d¢©d¸¥yd¸d®W¸
h¸vdW¢d¸Wc¸ [´c©^¥¢¸ vddW¥dc¸°y{d¸ ^{v¸ ic¸ ¸ ¸cW{Wvd¸h¸¥yd¸vdW¢d¸i¸¥yd¸j|d[±¸
: Py{¢¸d®d¥¢¸
¥yd¸vW¥d¸ : 4¢¸ ¢y°¸{¸ =C@¸
: ¥yd¸{[¸ : yW¢¸ W¸ j|¢¥¸ ¥yd¸[©{c©¸ h¸vdW¢d¸Wc¸[´c©^¥¢¸°y{^y¸^W¸dvW¥{®d´¸
{^{dc¸ ¢©hW^d¸ : Wc¸W¸ ¢d^c¸ {^{dc¸ ¢©iX^d¸
: ¥yW¥¸ Wpd^¥¸¥yd¸ diW^d¸ Wc¸ dW¥{¸ h¸¥yd¸ [W[d^©d¸ v{¸
^®dvd¸ ¥¸ cdj|d¸W¸dW¸ : Pyd¸j|¢¥¸¢©hW^d¸ : yW¢¸W¸ qOÎ W¢¢d[´¸
: Pyd¸ vW¥d¸ : c{d^¥¢¸ Wc¸^¥¢¸¥yd¸ k°¸ h¸
dcvd¸ : Wc¸ ¥yd¸ ¢d^c¸ ¢©hW^d¸
: yW¢¸ W¸ dcvd¸ : vdW¢d¸Wc¸[´c©^¥¢¸¥¸d¢©d¸¥yd¸v¥d¸diW^d¸
°ydd{¸ dW^y¸ dcvd¸ : : {¢¸ WcW^d¥¸ W¸d{v¸
: Wc¸ dW¥{¸ h¸¥yd¸ [W[d^©d¸ v{¸ W¢¢d[´¸
: =©¦yd·
I^d¸ vdW¢d¸ ^d¢¸ {¥¸ ^¥W^¥¸ °{¥y¸ ¥yd¸ {[¸ : vdW¢d¸ d
¸ ¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ : c{d^¥¢¸ ¥yd¸ k°¸ W¥y¸ =J¸h¸vdW¢d¸ ¢©^y¸
{vW¥d¢¸ c°¸¥yd¸{^{dc¸ ¢©iX^d¢¸ :
: ¥¸¥yd¸dcvd¢¸ ¥yW¥¸{¥¸cd¢¸¥¸Wd¸^¥W^¥¸°{¥y¸¥yd¸[©d¸¥©[d¸ : c©{v¸
: : h¸¥yd¸ {[¸ : C¸ ¥y{¢¸ Wd
¸ ¥yd¸ cW{Wvd¸ h¸ qkÎ dW¥{¸h¸¥yd¸ [W[d^©d¸ v{¸ W¢¢d[´¸
:
vdW¢d¸Wc¸[´c©^¥¢¸^^©¢¸{¸W¸^¥dc¸Wc¸c{d^¥dc¸ Ty{d¸¥yd¸¢d^{j|^¸d[c{d¥¢¸yW®d¸[dd¸{©¢¥W¥dc¸Wc¸
Wd¸Pyd¸ ¢d¸¸{¥^y¸h¸¥yd¸{^{dc¸¢©iX^d¢¸ :
: cd¢^{[dc
¸ ©d©¢¸ c{j|^W¥{¢¸ ^d¸ ¥¸ {c¸ °{¥y©¥¸
1/29/2019
Exhibit C, Page
2:46:31
109PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-3 Filed 01/29/19 Page 21 of 21 Page ID #:110
1/29/2019
Exhibit C, Page
2:46:31
110PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-4 Filed 01/29/19 Page 1 of 24 Page ID #:111
([KLELW'
1/29/2019
Exhibit D, Page
2:46:41
111PM
Ʋ³³²³Æ²²³²³²³Æ² Ƴ³²² Ƴ³²² Ʋ³³³²Æ²³²³²Æ²³² Æ??@@ ?@??@@?@ @ ?@?@?@@?@? @ ?@@??@Æ
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-4 Filed 01/29/19 Page 2 of 24 Page ID #:112
.
+%¸ C®d¥¢0¸
[ [
[ KJ07BH0J[
#UM@L^ )
^ 5@LORWWDU^ 6W¡{v¥
¸CE¸O1¸
[ [ [
[ 0SQZ[ [ [
BUM<Q^
^ UZQR^ M{v¸FdWc°¢
¸CE¸
[ [ [ 0M<[9Q[0E[
RO1¸.<UN^)RLQWRQ^ 7W´
¸CE¸O¸ [ [ [ KEH1M[
[ [
[ $2BJ[
+¸ 4¢¢{vdd0¸ 9D>DU 5YDTLDQ^ 2URBZ@YW^!R
^ JWW¥{d
¸ [ [
[ E0O9M[9Q[0E[
¸ }ŀ H¥{^d0¸
CE¸RO¸ [ [
[ *Q9LA9J[
[ [
[ 0SO9M[
O©[d^¥¸¥¸W´¸c{¢^W{d
¸¥yd¸¥d¸h¥y{¢¸ [ [ [ *HBQA[
W¥d¥¸ {¢¸ d±¥dcdc¸ ¸ Wc©¢¥dc¸ ©cd¸ %¸
[ [ [ *Q9LA9J[
RO7¸ %![¸[´¸-+¸cW´¢¸
7¥{©dc¸
Py{¢¸ W¥d¥¸ {¢¸ ¢©[d^¥¸ ¥¸ W¸ ¥d{W¸ c{¢· =IM:C@H¸J4P:HP¸9I7RF:HPO¸
^W{d¸
[
[ F[ [
¸ 4¸H0¸
:
7¥{©dc¸
¸ ={dc0¸ "D@
^
: : 0),09:8,)-#06$7$.: 6¸ F^4{¢¥d¸
44)45-5:8,)-#01(: O©dd¥y¸
)%¸ 2UMRU^ 2Z>OM@<YMRQ^ "<Y<^
+!¸ 55/3%: '#-5: /0: >~
6Wd¸ ¸ F^Dd¶{d¸ EEJ1¸
RO¸! ))¸4
¸ H®¸!
¸!¸ 9W®{c¸C¸M^yd1¸9W{d¸4¸PW{¥¢^y¸
)¸ J®{¢{W¸W{^W¥{¸H¸)!
!-%
¸j|dc¸¸9d^¸ Pyd¸d¢d¥¸{®d¥{¸®{cd¢¸W¸^{v¸vW¥d¸i¸©¢d¸°{¥y{¸
¸¸ W¸\W\d^©d¸v{¸W¢¢d\´¸Qyd¸^{v¸vW¥d¸{¢¸^W¥dc¸°{¥y{¸
W¸^{v¸^yW[d¸h¸¥yd¸[W[d^©d¸v{¸Wc¸Wc¸W^¸ d¥¸¥yd¸ydW¥¸
% ¸ (QY
^!O
^
("*ħ'!ħ
¢©^d¸Pyd¸^{v¸vW¥d¸yW¢¸W¸ddv´¸d^d¥¸¦{¸Wc¸
)¸ ^{v¸ d[d¢¸ cddc{v¸ ¥yddi¸ Pyd¸ ddv´¸ d^d·
%¸ 8
5
^ !O
^ ¸
:3 ^//!!%1¸//!!)¸ ¥{¸¥{¸h¥̧yd¸^{v¸vW¥d¸d^d{®d¢¸ddv´¸i¸¥yd¸ydW¥¸
%-¸ %MDOB^ RF^!O<WWMI@<YMRQ^5D<U@L^ ¸ )!¸M
¸ ¢©^d¸Pyd¸ddv´¸d^d{®dc¸[´¸¥yd¸ddv´¸d^d¥{¸¥{¸
)%¸M
¸/¸61¸ //!!!
¸!!%
¸!!)
¸!!+
¸!%¸ h¸¥yd¸^{v¸vW¥d¸{¢¸¥yd¸^c©^¥dc¸¥y©vy¸¥yd¸^{v¸
Odd¸W{^W¥{¸j|d¸i¸^d¥d¸¢dW^y¸y{¢¥´¸ vW¥d¸¥¸^{v¸d[d¢¸¥¸^¸ic¸¥ydd¸Pyd¸d¢d¥¸
%)¸ 3DHUDQ@DW^ !MYDB^
{®d¥{¸W¢¸®{cd¢¸W¸vdW¢d¸^¥¸¢¥©^¥ªd¸i¥yd¸vW¥d¸
¥¸W¢¢{¢¥¸{¸c{d^¥{v¸¥yd¸k°¸h¸vdW¢d¸W°W´¸i¸¥yd¸[©d¢¸
RO¸J4P:HP¸9I7RF:HPO¸
[ [ [ 0MM0SW[
:!O<MPW^
: "U<[MQJ^5LDDYW^
1/29/2019
Exhibit D, Page
2:46:41
112PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-4 Filed 01/29/19 Page 3 of 24 Page ID #:113
%"= = K
JWvd¸¸
RO¸J4P:HP¸9I7RF:HPO¸
[ [ [ 0BQ[
[ [ [ [ 9MM0MK[ ((((((((((((((((((((((((A [
[ [ [ (X31D[9Q[0E[
[ [ [ (0XH9M[ 9Q[ 0E[
[ [ [ $SO9[
[ [ [ 0MD9M[
[ [ [ 9M?9M[
[ [ [ $5KJ0E7[9Q[0E[
[ [ [ 0MOKJ[9Q[0E[ [ [ [ 0BQ[
[ [
[ *Q9V0MR[ [ ħ
[ *5AEKOO9M[9Q[0E[
[ [
[ 9OQ[
[ [
[ *5AEKOO9M[ 9Q[0E[
[ [ [ 9M?9M[
[ [
[ A0MEOKJ[ 9Q[ 0E[
[ [ [ *5AEKOO9M[ [ [ [ [ *5AMK9Q9M[9Q[0E[ ((((((((((A
[ ([
[ [ [ JSQA[9Q[0E[ [ [ [ *5AEKOO9M[9Q[0E[
[ [ [ BQ5A[9Q[0E[ [ [ [ (B5AQ9M[
[ [ [ $9JQZ9E[
[ [ [ [ *Q1J9D[9Q[ 0E[ (((((((((((((A
[ ([
[ [ [ .9EEO[ [ [ [ *5AEKOO9M[ 9Q[0E[
[ [ [ .05D9MH0J[ [ [ [ *5AEKOO9M[ 9Q[0E[
[ [ [ 9N0M7B[ [
[ [ [
[ J8M9OO[ [ [
[ [ [ "KAH9X9M[9Q[0E[
[ F [[
[ 0MJ9BQ[ [ [
[ [ [ BQ5A[
[ F [
[ $KOA9M[ [9Q[0E[
(
[ [ [ 0AJ[
[ F [
[ B939E[ 9Q[0E[
[ [
[ KV9J[ 9Q 0[ [ F [
[ (B?J9X[9Q[ 0E[
[ [ [
[ &SM9EEK[ [
[ ([
[
[
[ MTJK[9Q[ 0E[
[ [
[ B1J5BKE0[
[ F[
[ MTJK[9Q[ 0E[
[ [
[ "0QKSM[9Q[0E[
[ [ [ SJ?9M=M7[ =IM:C@H¸J4P:HP¸9I7RF:HPO¸
[ [ [ EEBKQR[
[ [
[ KEK3[ [
[
[ [
[ 0BQ[ [
[ [ [
[ [ [
[ 0?ESJ7[ [
[ ([
[ [
[ *5AEKOO9M[ Î ^{¥dc¸[´¸d±W{d¸
1/29/2019
Exhibit D, Page
2:46:41
113PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-4 Filed 01/29/19 Page 4 of 24 Page ID #:114
Æ
Î
Gu
1/29/2019
Exhibit D, Page
2:46:41
114PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-4 Filed 01/29/19 Page 5 of 24 Page ID #:115
Î
Æ
$
Fu
1/29/2019
Exhibit D, Page
2:46:41
115PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-4 Filed 01/29/19 Page 6 of 24 Page ID #:116
Jŀ
hŀ
Vu
Fu
1/29/2019
Exhibit D, Page
2:46:41
116PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-4 Filed 01/29/19 Page 7 of 24 Page ID #:117
u %Æ
KÆ ¸
¸
A@ō
A?ō
ÂÆ
CSō ;
ēŀ
Ð@ō Ėħ
ú
d¸
ħ
yBħ
Bħ
ňō
èħ
¬¸
īō
z %Æ
KLÎM
ėħ
¯¸
PÆ HIJÎ
EFÎG
C>ō
î>ō
Ø?ō
pu
§£¤¥ħ¦
?@ō ®¸
¨éħ
ĀāħĂ
«¸
qu
1/29/2019
Exhibit D, Page
2:46:41
117PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-4 Filed 01/29/19 Page 8 of 24 Page ID #:118
1/29/2019
Exhibit D, Page
2:46:41
118PM
T\u_t
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-4 Filed 01/29/19 Page 9 of 24 Page ID #:119
¸
?@ cŀ
Pō ō
235ŀ
(
-6 ō
ELō
² :11ō
ō
¦ŀ
x
X
Î
<X
ō
ėāō
1/29/2019
Exhibit D, Page
2:46:41
119PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-4 Filed 01/29/19 Page 10 of 24 Page ID #:120
ou
,ŀ
'A
)ŀ
8ō
Đ»ŀ
t $ Æ UÆ %X
ħ
ħ
*ō
ħ
/¸ צō
ÿŀ Āŀ
Iŀ
½¾ħ
¦Î
fŀ
ħ
ħ
ħ
ħ
OMĞŀ
ħ
;ħ
OMŀ
>
ħ
ħ
ħ
4ħ
,GOÆ ħ
BCDÎ
ħ
ħ
Êaō 5ō
FGħ
ħ
Dō
^_ħ
Îħ
rō
µħ
1ħ
ġŀ
ħ
1/29/2019
Exhibit D, Page
2:46:41
120PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-4 Filed 01/29/19 Page 11 of 24 Page ID #:121
ou
,ŀ
Î
)ŀ
8ō
w ' ÆYÆ eWō
ħ
VXDX
ħ
*ō
ħ
)u
Iŀ
Î
¿ħ
fŀ
ħ
$4-u ħ
=ħ
ħ
=ħ
ćħ
?
ħ
)(u (3u
ħ
¤Î
ħ
ħ
(/u pqħ
ħ
ħ
5ō
Ćħ
ħ
Dō
KLħ
çħ
(5u rō
ìħ
1ħ
eŀ
ħ
1/29/2019
Exhibit D, Page
2:46:41
121PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-4 Filed 01/29/19 Page 12 of 24 Page ID #:122
s#Æ 9 1 Æ
å£ŀ
¹¤ßŀ
º¥ÖĠŀ ´¥]ĕō
µ¤ÏĢō
1/29/2019
Exhibit D, Page
2:46:41
122PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-4 Filed 01/29/19 Page 13 of 24 Page ID #:123
j e ¸ \q }
¸ ?@ŀ &.ō
ŀ &
& ō
-Ĩ & &ō
3 ō V R
ō ō
Î
h
Æ
Eu
1/29/2019
Exhibit D, Page
2:46:41
123PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-4 Filed 01/29/19 Page 14 of 24 Page ID #:124
n ¸ \q }
¸ ?@ cŀ .ō
ŀ ō
ō
('ŀ ō
3 ō V R
ō ō
Î
fÆ
kl
Æ
1/29/2019
Exhibit D, Page
2:46:41
124PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-4 Filed 01/29/19 Page 15 of 24 Page ID #:125
1/29/2019
Exhibit D, Page
2:46:41
125PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-4 Filed 01/29/19 Page 16 of 24 Page ID #:126
°W
¸W¸{d¸°W
¸Wc¸W¸[¥¥¸°W¸Pyd¸{d¸{cvd¸yW¢¸W¸ =C@¸
: {¢¸W¸¥¸d¢d^¥{®d¸®{d°¸h¸W¸W¥dW¥d¸d[c{·
©¥d¸ °W
¸ W¸ {d¸ °W
¸ Wc¸ W¸ [¥¥¸ °W¸ JdieW[´
¸ rlÎ d¥¸h¥̧yd¸vW¥d1¸Wc
¸
d{¥yd¸¥yd¸{d¸{cvd¸¸¥yd¸©¥d¸{cvd¸{¥d¢d^¥¢¸¥yd¸d· =C@¸
: {¢¸W¸[¥¥¸d¢d^¥{®d¸®{d°¸h¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸h¸=C@¸
{v¢¸h¥̧yd¸vW¥d¸Pyd¸©¥d¸Wc¸{d¸{cvd¢¸cddc¸¢©[¢¥W
:
1/29/2019
Exhibit D, Page
2:46:41
126PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-4 Filed 01/29/19 Page 17 of 24 Page ID #:127
: Pyd¸ dcvd¸ : {¢¸ WcW¥dc¸ ¥¸ ¢©¦¸¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ : {¸ W¸ c PÎ ¢{¥{dc¸°{¥y{¸¥yd¸j|d[±¸
:
vddW´¸y{¶¥W¸¢{¥{¸[d°¸W¸{¸ :h¥̧yd¸j|d[±¸
: 4¢¸d±W{dc¸W[®d
¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ : {^©cd¢¸¥yd¸vdW¢d¸^·
4¥dW¥{®d´
¸¥yd¸dcvd¸:{¢¸{¥¦dc¸Wc¸¥yd¸j|d[±¸
:yW¢¸W¸ ¥¸W¢¢d[´¸
:W¸^c©^¥{®d¸ydW¥{v¸W¢¢d[´¸: W¸©W·
©W{¥´¸h¸{c{®{c©W¸¢¥ª^¥ªd¢¸¥¸¢©¦¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ : {¥´¸ h¸^{v¸d[d¢¸
: Wc¸W¸©W{¥´¸ h¸d{v¢¸
:
6d^W©¢d¸¥yd¸[W[d^©d¸v{¸h¥̧yd¸d¢d¥¸{®d¥{¸cd¢¸¥¸ Tyd¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ : {¢¸¢{¥{dc¸{¸¥yd¸^{v¸^yW[d¸
:
d©{d¸¢dWW¥d¸d[d¢¸®d¸¥yd¸vW¢¸[©d¢
¸¥yd¸v{¸yW¢¸W¸ c lÎ ¥yd¸vdW¢d¸^¥¸ W¢¢d[´¸
: {¢¸¢{¥{dc¸vddW´¸®d¸
^W^¥¸^j|v©W¥{¸dW{v¸¥yW¥¸{¥¢¸®dW¸yd{vy¥¸{¢¸d¢¢¸ ¥yd¸[©d¸¥©[d¸: ¥¸d®d¥¸vdW¢d¸Wc¸[´c©^¥¢¸vddW¥dc¸
¥yW¸¥yW¥¸h¸^®d¥{W¸©{vy¥¸[W[d^©d¸v{¢¸4¢¸W¸d¢©¥
¸ [´¸^{v¸ ic¸ ¸¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ : i¸ ^{v¸ {¥¸ ^¥W^¥¸
¥yd¸[W[d^©d¸v{¸W¢¢d[´¸
: {¢¸^WW[d¸h¸dW¥{¸°y{d¸ °{¥y¸¥yd¸[©d¸¥ª[d¸: O{{W´
¸ {¸¥yd¸die¡dc¸d[c{·
¢{¥{dc¸ ¸ W¸ ¥W[d¸ ¥¸ =©¦ydd
¸ ¥yd¸ [W[d^©d¸ v{¸ d¥
¸¥yd¸¦{¸h¥̧yd¸vW¥d¸ :W[®d¸¥yd¸[©d¸::i¢¸¥yd¸
W¢¢d[´¸
: {¢¸¢{¶dc¸¢©^y¸¥yW¥¸{¥¸^W¸[d¸{tdc¸[´¸W¸¢{vd¸©¢d¸ fPÎ ¢{c¸ddv´¸d^d¥¸¦{¸: h¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ :
Wc¸^W¡{dc¸[d¥°dd¸^W¥{¢¸i¸©¢d¸ Pyd¸vW¥d¸ :yW¢¸W¸^{v¸¢©hW^d¸ :¥yW¥¸{¢¸cdj|dc¸[´¥̧yd¸
4¸[©d¸ddd¥¸:{¢¸¢{¥{dc¸vddW´¸°{¥y{¸W¸°d¸ ©d¸¢©hW^d¸
: h¸¥yd¸©W{¥´¸h¸^{v¸d[d¢¸¸[W¢¸
¦{¸ h¸¥yd¸ j|d[±¸
: h¸¥yd¸ ^{v¸ ^yW[d¸
: Wc¸
: Pyd¸ ^{v¸d[d¢¸¸[W¢¸
: W´¸yW®d¸W´¸¢yWd¸
[d°¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ :C¸^¥W¢¥¸¥¸^®d¥{W¸[W[d^©d¸v{¸ °{¥y©¥¸cdW¦{v¸i¸¥yd¸¢^d¸h¥̧yd¸d¢d¥¸{®d¥{¸=¸
W¢¢d[{d¢
¸¥yd¸^{v¸^yW[d¸
: W^¢¸W¸¢dW¸[W¸¸^· flÎ d±Wd
¸¥yd¸^{v¸d[d¢¸
:W´¸[d¸d^¥Wv©W
¸^{^©·
c©^¥{®d¸d¥W¸¸W®W¸^¸¢¥ª^¥ªd¸¢{¥{dc¸[d¥°dd¸¥yd¸ W
¸S¢yWdc
¸ d¥^¸Pyd¸^{v¸¢©hW^d¸ : cdrd¢¸W¸©d¸
[©d¸ddd¥¸ : Wc¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ :C¸W¸^®d¥{W¸[W[d· ^{v¸Wd¸Wc¸{¢¸WcW¥dc¸¥¸d^d{®d¸ic¸¥¸[d¸^dc¸¸
^©d¸v{
¸¢dW¸[W¢¸Wc¸^c©^¥{®d¸¢¥ª^¥©d¢¸Wd¸WcW¥dc¸¥¸ ¥yd¸vW¥d¸ : Pyd¸ ^{v¸ ¢©hW^d¸ : W´¸yW®d¸W¸vddW´¸
¢y{dc¸¥yd¸[©d¸i¸vdW¢d¸c{{v¸i¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸O{^d¸ d^¥Wv©W¸^j|v©W¥{
¸y°d®d
¸¥yd¸^j|v©W¥{¸®W{d¢¸
¥yd¸vW¥d¸ : yW¢¸ W¸ vdW¢d¸^¥¸W¢¢d[´¸
: Wc¸W¸ ¢{c¸ lPÎ °{¥y¸¥yd¸ ^j|v©W¥{¸h¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ : Wc¸¥yd¸[W¢¸
: C¸W¸
ddv´¸ d^d¥¸ d[d¸ : ¢dW¸ [W¢¸ Wc¸ ^c©^¥{®d¸ die¡dc¸d[c{d¥
¸¥yd¸^{v¸d[d¢¸
: Wd¸vdd·
¢¥©^¥ªd¢¸Wd¸¥¸d©{dc¸{¸¥yd¸v{¸W¢¢d[´¸
: W´¸WWd¸Wc¸Wd¸¢W^dc¸W¸c{¢¥W^d¸WW¥¸¥¸cdj|d¸W¸v{c¸
4¢¸¢y°¸{¸¥yd¸j|v©d¢
¸{¸¥yd¸die¡dc¸d[c{d¥¸c{¢· 4¢¸¢¥W¥dc¸W[®d
¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ : yW¢¸W¸©W{¥´¸h¸d{v¢¸
:
^¢dc
¸¥yd¸[©d¸ddd¥¸ : {¢¸dieW[´¸W¸[©d¸¥ª[d¸¸ °ydd{¸W¸d{v¸
: {¢¸¢{¥{dc¸[d¥°dd¸[W¢¸
:Hd¸h¸
¸B°d®d
¸W¸^®d¥{W¸{dW
¸B¢yWdc¸[©d¸¸W´¸ llÎ ¥yd¸d{v¢
¸y°d®d
¸Wd¸®{cdc¸{¸¥yd¸¢{c¸ddv´¸d^d·
¥yd¸¢yWd¸¸¥´d¸h¸[©d¸^W¸[d¸d´dc¸{¸¥yd¸[W[d^©d¸ ¥¸¦{¸:h¥̧yd¸vW¥d¸ :Pyd¸d±W^¥¸©[d¸h¸d{v¢¸
v{¸W¢¢d[´¸
: h¸¥yd¸d¢d¥¸{®d¥{¸4¸¦{¸h¸¥yd¸
: ®W{d¢¸°{¥y¸¥yd¸cd¢{v¸WWd¥d¢¸h¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ : 4cc{·
[©d¸ : {¢¸ ¢©¦dc¸°{¥y{¸ ¥yd¸j|d[±¸
: [´¸ W¸[^¸
: ¥{W´
¸¥yd¸¢{¶d¸¸dv¥y¸h¸¥yd¸d{v¢¸
: ®W{d¢¸cddc·
d±¥dc{v¸i¸¥yd¸j|¢¥¸¢{cd¸°W¸
:Pyd¸[©d¸:c{¢^¢dc¸ {v¸©¸¥yd{¸^W¥{¸{¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ : =¸d±Wd
¸{¸d¸
yW¢¸W¸©W{¥´¸h¸{dW
¸^©¯{{dW
¸Wc¸¥W¢{¥{¸¢dvd¥¢¸ rPÎ d[c{d¥¸W¸d{v¸
: {¸W¸^d¥W¸dv{¸h¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ :
d¢©¥{v¸{¸W¸^¥{©©¢¸^j|v©W¥{¸Py{¢¸[©d¸:vd· {¢¸Wvd¸¥yW¸W¸d{v¸
: {¸W¸d{ydW¸dv{¸h¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸
d¥´¸¸^j|v©W¥{¸{¢¸¢{{W¸¥¸¥yd¸{¥d{¸vdd¥´¸h¸¥yd¸ :4¥y©vy¸¢y°¸W¢¸yW®{v¸W¸vddW´¸dvW¥dc¸^j|v©·
j|d[±¸
: ¢©^y¸ ¥yW¥¸¥yd¸[©d¸¥ª[d¸ : {¢¸ ^WW[d¸ h¸[d{v¸ W¥{
¸¥yd¸¢yWd¸h¸¥yd¸d{v¢¸
: ®W{d¢¸°{¥y¸¥yd¸cd¢{v¸
d^d{®dc¸[´¸ ¥yd¸ j|d[±¸
: JdieW[´
¸ ¥yd¸ [©d¸ : {¢¸ W¸ WWd¥d¢¸h¥̧yd¸vW¥d¸ :Py©¢
¸°y{d¸¥yd¸d{v¢¸
: yW®d¸
^´{c{^W¸ddd¥¸°{¥y¸W¸^{^©W¸^¢¢¢d^¥{¸°{¥y¸W¸{d¸ rlÎ W¸©cdc¸ dcvd¸
: W¢¸ ¢y°¸ {¸=C@¸ : ¥yd¸ dcvd¸
: ^W¸ [d¸
°W¸c{Wd¥d¸Wc¸W¸©¥d¸°W¸c{Wd¥d¸: {d¥¸¦{¸h¸ {dW
¸Wvvdc¸ ¸ W´¸ ¥yd¸ ¢yWd¸ :W^y¸ h¸¥yd¸ ©W{¥´¸ h¸
¥yd¸[©d¸: d±¥dc¢¸¥y©vy¸W¸d{v¸ : ¢y°¸{¸=C@¸ d{v¢¸
:yW®d¸W¸W±{¢¸¥yW¥¸{¢¸W{vdc¸®d¦{^W´¸Wc¸d±¥dc¸
1/29/2019
Exhibit D, Page
2:46:41
127PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-4 Filed 01/29/19 Page 18 of 24 Page ID #:128
1/29/2019
Exhibit D, Page
2:46:41
128PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-4 Filed 01/29/19 Page 19 of 24 Page ID #:129
1-K ŀ =
K =
ă
ă
ă
ă ă%
ă
ă ăăăă ă?Aă
ă ăăă
ă) ă ă !6ă ăă ă ă ă ă !6ă 9
1
ă ăă/ă ă
ăă('ă
ă ă/ă
ă!6ă%
ă ă ă ăă/ă ăă>
%ă('
ă ă ă
să ă
ă $#ă
ă ă +
ă !;ă /ă +ă !-ă ă %
ă ă 5ă ă ă
%¸ă ă!;ăăă ă
ă!;ăăă ă
ă
:
ă$ă5ăă ăă
ă9
ăă
ă#&ăă ă
ăă) ăUăăăă
ă#ă
ăQăă ă
ăăăă ă
ăă7
#ăăăăăă&ăă ă
ăă ă
7
ăă ă
ăăă ă
ăă ă ă
ăă ă :
ăă
ăă ăăăă
ă$#ăă ăă3,8ă*ă
9ă ă ăăă%
ă ăă ăă('ă
9ăăă ă
ă
ă
ăă7
ăă%
ăă,ă ăă!6ă ă ă
ă
ăăăăă
ă#$ă##ăP!Lg
ăă3,8:ă*>5ă
ăăăăă+
ă !¸ ă %¸ăÚ7
ă
ă #$ă ##ă ăăă ăUăăă
ă ăă%
ăă :
ă
ă#ă#ă ăă
ă
ăă ă
ăă
P!L
ă ă 3,8:ă *>#ă ă ă !Lgă ă ă
9ă
ă ă ă %
ă ă $$Hă ă
ă ă ă ăăă ă ă
ă
ă7
ă !6`
ă`ăă $$Tă ) ă
ă #$ă ##ă ă
ă ă ăă ăă
ă
ă
ă 5#ă
+ă ăăă$$ ăă ă
ă>
ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă 5&ă ) ă ă
ă
ă ăăă ă`ăă$$Tăa ă
ă#$ă
ă 5#ăă
ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă !;ă ă
4ă /ăăăă !;ă ă ă
ăă7 !;ă#$Hă ##Hă ă ăă
ă ă!;ă#$Hă ##Hăă
ă
ăă
ă) ă('ă
ă#$ă ăăăă .
ă
ă*/ăă ă%
ă
ăăiă('
ă ăă
ă!Lgăă ăă
ă
ăă &$ăă ă%
ăă$$Hăă ăăă
:
$$Tă9
1
ăă
ă
ă&$ăăăă
ăă
ăă
ă!6ăăăă ă
ăă
Z ăp
ă£ă $$öăZ ă
ppZp«ăZ ăpZpZă
ăăă
ă!6ăăăăă ă
ăă) ăă
ă$$Tă) ă ă
ă##ă
ă ăăăă .
ă &#ă
ă ă ă('ăă
ă #ă ă ăă
ă #ă ă('ă
ă ă%
ăă$$Hăă ă`ăă$$Tă
ă #$ă ă ă ă
ă ##ă ) ă ('ă ă ă ă
ă #ă #ă ă
4
ă 4ă ăăă
: 9ă ăă 3,8ă *ă ă
ăă cd ă
ă ă!-ă
ă ă Uăă ăă$ă$*ăă ă
ăăă +1
ă
ă &&ă ă ă ă +1
ă
ă =ă ) ă !-ă
ă+ă
ă ă
ăă ă
ăăă ă +1
ă
ă &&ă ă ă+ă ă !-ă
ă 5ă
ă
ăă0ă*/ăV ăă!-ăă ă ăă+1
ă
ă=ă ăă+ă ăă
ă ('ă ă ă ă
ă #ă #ă ă ăă
ă 5* ă ) ă ('ă ă ă +1
ă
ă &&ă =ă ă
('
ăăă ă%
ăă $$ă ă ă> : ăăă ă
ăă%
ăă$$ă) ă('ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă
ă #ă #ă ) ă ă ă +1
ă
ă &&ă =ă +ă
ă ă
ăă ă('ăă
ă#ă ăăă
ă#ă
ăă ă
ăăC!L
ă ă+1
ă
ă &&ă=ă
ă ă
ă #$ă##ă('ăă
ă
ă#&ăă ă
ă ăă
ă ă ă
ă ă%
ă ă5ă
ă9ă ăă3,8ă*ăăăă ă
ă
ă 3 ă ă +1
ă
ă &&ă=ă ă!L
ă
ă
#&ă ăă
ă
ă.('
ă
: ă ă+1
ă
ă &&ă =ă ăă
ăăă
) ă('ăăăă
ă #ă #ăă ăă
ă ă
ăă
ăăă
ăă%
ă
ă
ă5#ăăăăă
ăăă /ă !6ăă ă
ăă) ă ăă ă('ăăă+1
ă
a ăă/ăăăăăă
ă ă?Aăă
ăă
ă &&ă =ă ă
ă ă
ă ă ă !-ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă%
ă!6ăă ă
ăă9ă
ă5ă5*ăP!L
ăă3,8:ă*ăă5ă ă
ăă ă
ă ă 3,8ă $ă ă ă /ă
ă ă ă ('ă
ă
:
ă ă ă ă
ă =ă ă ă
ă =ă ă 7
!;ă /ă ă ă ă
ă !;ă /$ă ) ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ă &ă ă ă ă
!;ă/ă/ă$ă
ăăăă%ăă+ă/ă#ă9
ă ă $$Tă ă ăă $ă $ă) ă
ă =ăă!L
ă
ă%ă/#ăă ăă/ăă ăă
ă ăă
ăă ă %
ă ă5ă ă ă
ă=ăă
!;ă 5ă ă ă %
ă ă $$ă ă ă /ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ă
ă ă %
ă
('
ă ă ă%ă/#ăă
ă ăăă ă
: ă
ă!;ă5ă) ă('ă!;ă/ă ăă
ă/&ăă ă 9ăăă ă
ă
ă
ăăă ă
ă!;ă /$ă ăă
ă &ă ă ă
ă /&ă &ă
ă ă
ă
ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă5&ă
ă Qăă.
ă $#ăkă
ă ă ă ă :
ăă ă ă
ă
ă
ă 5#ă ă
ă
ă ăă /ă
ă
ă ă ă
ă !;ă
ă
ă
ă5&ăăăăăă
ă ă
/ă/$ăă ă
ă/&ă&ăă ăă /ă ,ă ă ă ă : ?Aăă
ăăă
ăă %
ă !6ăă
ă ă
ă~ăă ă ăă
ă ă
ăăP!L
ăă3,8:ă#>/ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ăă.ă ) ă
ăă ăă ă
ă 7
ă5&ăăăăăUă
ăă ăă
!;ă /ă /$ăă ă ă
ăă ă ă
ă !-ă ă
ă !;ă ăă ă
ă ă ă !L
ă ă
ă
ăă
ăăăă ă
ă
ă0ă*/ăă ă%7
V ăă!-ă ăăăăăă ăă/ă
:
ă
ă ă ,ăă!Lgăă ăă
ăă
ăă
ă
ă ă ă ăă/ăă ă ăăă
ăă :ă.ă
ă
ăăă
ă .('
ăă ă ăă /ă * : a ă ă ă
ă
1/29/2019
Exhibit D, Page
2:46:41
129PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-4 Filed 01/29/19 Page 20 of 24 Page ID #:130
&#= ŀ =
= =
ăă) ăă
ăă ăă
ă
ă ă
ă
ăăă*/ăă ă%
ă
ăă
ă
ă
ă,ăă ăă
ăă ă ă
ăSMMHă
) ă
ă
ă
ă
ă5&ăcd0 ăăă ă ă ă ă ă 0ă *Hă ă .ă
ă
.ă
ă$ă ăă!-ă ă
ăăă) ă
: SMMTăăăă ăăă*Hăă ă0ă
.ă
ă $ă ă ăă
ă $Hăă.ă
ă $Tă
ăSăMMHă+ăă ă
ăă
ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă
ă
ă C!L
ă SMMHăăă
ă ă ă
ă*ăă ă1ă4ă
ă ă.ă
ăăă ăă
ă$ăă : *ă9
ă ăăă ăă
ăSMMHă('ăă
ă
ă $#ăă ă
ă ă) ă ăă.ă
ă
ă ă
ăă ă
ăăă ăă
ă*ă
ă $ă ă
ă
ă ă ă
ă ă ăă4ă*ă9
1
ă ă
ă
ă
ă
!;ăăă ă
ăă9
1
ă ăă
ăă
ă 5&ă ă ('
ă ă ă ă .ă
ă SMMTă
~ă ă.ă
ă$ăăă ă
ă!-ă ă
ă +ăă ă
ă *ă
.
ă$ ăă
ă@Öħă ăVÕă ăăCÆă 9
ă
ă.('
ă
ă ă
ă$Hăăăă
#ă|%ă ă.ăăă
ăă$ă ăă#ă : ă.ă0ă*Tă ă.ă
ă $Tăăăă
ă ăă
ă
ăă
ă
ăC7 ă.ă0ă*Tăă ăă
ă $yăăă
ă ăă#ăăăă ă.
ă$#ăă ă ă ă.ă0ă*TăYăăă!½ă.ă
ă ă) ă ă ă .ă
ă ă $ăă 7 ăă
ă *ăă ă
ăă ă ăă
ă
ă
ă5#ă 1ă 4ă *ă ă ă ă ă
ăSă$Hă('ăă
ă ă
ăă
ă*ăă ăă4ă*ă
ă ă ă .ăă ă ă ('ă ă ă ă 9
1
ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă 5&ă ă 7
ă #ă#ăă ă
ă #$ă ##ă) ă ă ă #ăă ('
ă ă ă ă.ă
ă $Tă ('ă ă
ă ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă 5&ăă
ăă ă ('ăă ă.ă
ă*ă
ăă
ă
ă
ă5#ă ,ă ăă ă CSă ăă #ă ă
ă 7
9ă ăă3 ,8:ă ă ă ă
ăăăă ăăăă0ă*yăă ă1ă4ă*ă
ă ă%
ă ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă
: ă ă ă
ă 0ă ă ă ?Aă +ă !-ă
ă ă ă
ă
ăă) ăă
%
ă ă ă
%ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă #ăă ă ă0ă!;ăăă ă
ă
ăă
ă44ă ăăă44ăă
ă ă*/ăă ă%
ă
ăă) ăă ă ăă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă *ă 9ă +
ă ă #ă
ă ă
ă
ă ă0ă*/ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă : ă ă ă 1ă ?Aă
ă ă ă 1ă *ă
ă
ă ă?Aăă
ă
ăă%
ă!6ăă C!L
ă ăă#ăă
ăă ă
ă
ăăă
ă
ă ă ă('
7
ă ăă
ă*&ă ă ă ă 1ă *ă ă ă ă ă #ă ă
9ă ăă3,8ă&ă ă
ă ăăă ă ă
: ăă ă1ă?Aă
ă,ă ăă ă ă
%
ă ă ăă ă ăăăCSă) ă ă ă#ăă0ă!-ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ăăăăăă
ăăă ă1ă 5&ăă ăăă
ăă
ă
ă ă.ă
*ă ă
ă ă ă
ă 5ă5*ă ă ă
ă ă ăă
ăă$ă ăă
ă SMMHă$Hăă
ă ă
ă=ăă ă('+ă&ă,ă ăăăCSă ă ăă ă ăă.ă
ă *ă *ăă ă
ă
ă
ăăăă
ăă ă
: 1ă*ă
1ă*ă:ă ă1ă*ăă3 ,8:ăă ă ă ă ă
ă ,ă ăăăCSă ăă
ă
ă
ă
('
ă ă
ă
ă
ă ăăă 5#ăăăă ă
ă
ăă0ă*/ăă ă
ă ă
ăă
ă
ăă ă1ă*ă
ăăăăă+ăă ăă4ă*ă9ă ă
C!L
ă ă ă+1
ă
ă&&ă=ăă ă
ă ă3,8ă &ă ăă/ăă ă('ăă
ă #ă ăăă
$#ă ă ă
ăăă
ăă ăă4ă *ă
ă ă
ă !;ă ă ă ă
ă
ă 4ă *ă ,ă ă ăă CSă ă ă3,8ă ă ă ('ă
ă 0ă */ă ă ă %
ă
ă ă ă ă !;ă/ăă ăă/ăăăă ăăă
ă ă1ăă*ăă('ăă
ă 7¸ ) ă
> ăă*Hă*yăă ă1ăă ă ă
ă
ă 7¸ ă ă 0
ă ă ă ă ă : /&ă ă ă('ă!;ă/ă +ăă ăăă
!;ăă ă1ă4ă*ăăă
ăăă ă
ă *Hă Yă ă ă !½ă.ă ă
ă /&ă +ă
ă
ă
ă5&ăă ă
ă
ăă7 ă ăă
ă
ăă ă ă .ăă *Tă *yăă ă ă 4ă *ă
ă ă
ăă ă('+ă&ăă ă1ă4ă*ă
: ă ă
ă&ăă ăăă/ă$ă+ăă
,ă ăăăCSăă3 ,8ă&ă ăă
ăăă ă ă .ă 0ă *Tă Yă ăă ªă.ă ă
ă*ăă ăă4ă
1/29/2019
Exhibit D, Page
2:46:41
130PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-4 Filed 01/29/19 Page 21 of 24 Page ID #:131
: : 4¢
¸¥yd¸¥d^¥{®d¸^W¥{v¸^W¸[d¸W{dc¸¥¸¥yd¸°d¸
°{¥y¸¥yd¸vdW¢d¸^¥¸¢¥©^¥ªd¸
: h¥̧yd¸vW¥d¸ :Tyd¸¥yd¸ vdW¢d¸^¥¸ W¢¢d[´¸ : Pyd¸¥d^¥{®d¸^W¥{v¸^W¸[d¸W¸
j|¢¥¸©W¥{¥´¸hv̧dW¢d¸^d¢¸{¥¸^¥W^¥¸°{¥y¸W¸d{v¸ (
¸ ^dW{¸ ^W¥{v¸ ¸ W¥yd¸ ^d^{W´¸ W®W{W[d¸ ·
¥yd¸vdW¢d¸vddW´¸k°¢¸¥y©vy¸¥yd¸d{v¸ (¸Wc¸¥¸¥yd¸ ¢¥{^¸^W¥{v¸ ¢©^y¸W¢¸W¸Pdk[W¢dc¸^W¥{v¸4¥dW¥{®d´
¸
[¥¦¸ °W¸ : h¸¥yd¸ j|d[±¸
: ¢dd¸ =C@¸ : O{^d¸ ¥yd¸ ¥yd¸vW¥d¸ : ^W¸[d¸W¥dc¸°{¥y¸{^d¸¸^yd¸¥¸{^dW¢d¸
[¥¦¸°W¸ : {¢¸ c°°Wc´¸ ¢dc
¸ ¥yd¸ W{¥´¸ h¸¥yd¸ : ¥yd¸vd®{¥´
¸ ^¢{¸d¢{¢¥W^d
¸Wc¸¢¥{^¸d·
vdW¢d¸ cW{¢¸ ¸ W¢¢d¢¸ ¥y©vy¸¥yd¸ cW{¸ : 6d^W©¢d¸ ¥yd¸ ¥{d¢¸h¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ : =©¥yd
¸°{¥y¸^d¦W{¸W¥d{W¢
¸ ¢©^y¸W¢¸
d{v¢¸ (¸ h¸ ¥yd¸ vW¥d¸ : Wd¸ ¥¸ ¢{¥{dc¸ W[®d¸ ¥yd¸ ^d¥W{¸^W¢¥¸d¥W¢
¸¥yd¸W¥{v¸¸^W¥{v¸h¥̧yd¸vW¥d¸ : W´¸
[©d¸ ¥ª[d¸ : vdW¢d¸ ¥yW¥¸ k°¢¸ ¥y©vy¸ ¥yd¸ d{v¢¸ (¸ ¥¸[d¸d^d¢¢W´¸
cd¢¸¥¸^¥W^¥¸¥yd¸[©d¸¥©[d¸:[d^W©¢d¸¥yd¸[©d¸¥ª[d¸ Pyd¸vW¥d¸ : h¸¥yd¸ d¢d¥¸ {®d¥{¸^W¸[d¸ idc¸[´¸W¸
: cd¢¸¥¸[¢¥©^¥¸¢©^y¸k°¸
: ©[d¸h¸°W´¢
¸{^©c{v¸[d{v¸d¢¢dc
¸^W¢¥
¸¸¢¥Wdc¸
Mdie{v¸¥¸¥yd¸ ¢^ydW¥{^¸®{d°¸h¸=C@¸
: vdW¢d¸^d¢¸ =©¥yd
¸¥yd¸vW¥d¸ :^W¸[d¸idc¸{¸W¸y´[{c¸Wd¸^·
{¥¸^¥W^¥¸°{¥y¸W¸¦{¸h¥̧yd¸{[¸ :Wc¸k°¢¸Wv¸¥yd¸{[¸ [{{v¸d¸¸d¸d¥yc¢¸=¸d±Wd¸W¸s¢¥¸¥{¸h¥̧yd¸
1/29/2019
Exhibit D, Page
2:46:41
131PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-4 Filed 01/29/19 Page 22 of 24 Page ID #:132
ăă ă
ăăă9
1
ă ă
ăă ăă 1ă *ă 9ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă
!6ă !-ă
ă ă ă +4ă ă
ă ă
ă ă ă
ă ă
%
ă ă ă
ă `
ăă
ă ăăăă
7 ă ă 1ă *ă ă ă
ă ă :('
ă ă
ă
%
ă44ăă
ăă ă ăă
9 ă!Lgăăă ăăă ăă
ă
ă
ă5#ăă ă1ă*ăC!L
ă ă
3,8:ă>ă) ă ă
ăă ăă
ă
ăă
%
ă4ăăă
ăă ăă>
0ă*/ă
ăă
ă
ă
ăăă
ă X P Î !;ă ă ă1ă*ăă ă
%
ă 44ă ă7
ă%
ă ă $$ă
ă !-ă ă
ă
ă
ăă ă ă1ă*ă) ă
%
ă4ă
ă0ă*/ă ă ă
ă ă.
ă $#ă) ă ăă!-ă
ăă ăă
ă >
ăă
ă
ă
ăă ăă('
ăă!-ă ă ă ăă!Lă
ă ă
%
ă44ăă
ă ă ă 3,8:ă >=ă) ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă ă
ă*ă) ă
%
ă 4ăă ăă
ăă
ăăă
ă
ă
ă5#ăăă
ă
: %ăă ă ă 4ă ă ă >
%ă
ă
ă
ă5&ă) ăă
ă
ă5#ă ('
ă
ăăă+
ă ă
ăă9ă ăă3,8ăă ăă/ă ăă('ă
ă 3 ă ă
ăă ă ă
ă
ă4ăă ă
!;ă/ăăăă
ăă/$ă ă
ă
ă ăăă ă ?Aă ă3Căă
ăă ă ă
ăăă% /#ă) ăUă!;ă/ă ă
ă/&ăă \lÎ
ă ă
ăă ă
ă!-ă ă ('+ă &ă) ă
ă ă ă/$ă ă ă
ă&ă ă ă
ă
ă ă
>ă ă
ă ăă ă ă
/&ă &ăăQăă
ă$#ăkă
ăăă
ă!½ă ăăăăă ă7
ă ă ăă /ă
ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă ă ) ă
ă ăăă
ă ă
!;ă/ă /$ăă ă
ă/&ă &ăă ăă/ă,ă ă
.ă ă
ăă
ăÇăăăăă c PÎ ?Aă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă
>`ă
ă ă ă .ă ) ă
ă ă ă ă ă !6`ăăăă ăă
ă
ăă
ăă/ă/ă$ăă ă ă
ăă 3Z ā]ă Z ă
ZăăpZ£ăZ ă?A]ăZ ă3Că]ă
£ă
ă ă
ă
ă
ăă9
1
ă ăă/ă ă ă ă ăă%ă ă ă ăă 4ă *ă
ă
ăă('ă
ăă/ă ă ă ăă/ă ă
ăăă ăă
ă
ăă
ă>
%ă('
ă c lÎ V
ă ă ('ăă ăă
ăă
P!L
ă ă 3,8ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă ('ă ă ă ă ă
#ă ăă
ă
ă*ă ăă!-ăă
ăă
.('
ă
ă!-ă ăăă ăăă ă
*ăă ă
ăă) ă
ă*ă ă
ă *Tă ăă0ă
ă
ăX
ă
*Hă*Tă*yă ăă
ă
ăă ă
ăă ă9ăă
ă
ă
_ă
*ăă ă
ă ă9
1
ă ă
ă *ă ăă ă%
ă Oă
ă
ă!-ă ă
ăă*ă) ă
ă*ăăă ă
ă1ăăăă
ăăă ă %
ă
ă *#ă ă ă
ă !;ă *ă ă ă
ă ă Oă
0ă**/ăă ă
ăăC!L
ă ăă*#ăă ă ă%
ă
ă
ăăă ă%
ă 7
ă ă ă
ă $#ă ă ă
ă ă ) ă ă ăăQă ă
ă1ă ă%
ă
ă
ă
ă *ăă
ăă ă ăă
ă ă%
ă ăăăă!;ăăă
ă
ă
ă#ă) ă ăă *#ă ă
ă ă%
ăăă('ăăă%
ă
ă
ă ă ăă
ă
ă
ă#ă ăă
ă!;ă ă %
ă
ă40 ă
ăă
,ă ă ăăCSă ă ă
ă ă ăă lPÎ
ă
ăăăăă
ă+7
ă ă%
ă ăă ă
ă
ă
ă ăă ă1ă ă
ăă ă%
ăă
ă ăă
ă
ăă ă('
ă
ăă.
ăă ă%
ăă ă
ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă :('
:
ă
1/29/2019
Exhibit D, Page
2:46:41
132PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-4 Filed 01/29/19 Page 23 of 24 Page ID #:133
/:2.+: /0(&: /: &+##8: 0+&/5+/:0(:0: /(&: #ă: +2: +##: //%#8: (:#%: 5ă 6+&:0:
/:2.+: /0(&: &+8: +*0(+: *(+0(&: (:0: (("&: +0: *+(5/: (5+:
1/29/2019
Exhibit D, Page
2:46:41
133PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-4 Filed 01/29/19 Page 24 of 24 Page ID #:134
1-K ŀ =
= =
ăăă ăă
ăă!-ă ă
ă1ă ă
ă
ă
ăă%
ă ă ă
ăă0ă ăă
ă
ă
ă
ăă
ă 1ă
ăă
ă ăă
ă7 44ăăă
ă
ă ă.
ăăă
_ă !-ă ă1Oă ă
ă%
ă
ă
ăăăăă0ă ă+ăă ă
ă
ă 4ă
ă
ăăă
ă ă%
ă ăăQă ă
ăă ă
ă
ă ă%
ăăă ă%
ă
ă
%
ă
ă
ăăă%
ă
ă('ăă ă ă ă %
ă ă ă ă +ă
ăă%
ă!;ăă
ăă
ă('ă X P Î ăă+ăăă
ăă ă%
ă7
ăă
ă
ăăăă
ă
ă> !;ă
ăăă
ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă) ăă
ă
ăă
ăă ă ă
ăă
>
%ă%
ăă
ă!-ă ă
ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ăă
ă
ăăăăă
ăă
ă
ă ă
ă ă
ă !;ă +
ă ă
ă ă%
ăă ăă ă
ăă XlÎ ă ă
ă0ăă ă%
ă ă
ă
ăă+ă ăă
ă
ă
ăă
ăăcd0 ă7
+
ă
ă ă ă %
ă
ă ă `ă
ăă
ă
ă
ă 4ă
ă ă
ă
ă ă ă ă !-ă ă
ă 0ă ă ă
ă!-ă ă
ă
ăă!;ăă!67
%
ă ăă ă ă 0ă ă ă %
ă
ă ă
ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă
ă
ăă ă ăă \PÎ ăă
1ă.
ăă
ă
ăăăă7 $ă) ăă
ă
ăă
ă *ă ă ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă ă ă%
ă
ă ă
ă
ă
ă 4ă ă ă ă ă %
ă
ăă
ă+ăă ă1ăă ă
ăăăă+ăă ă
ă1ă
ă ă%
ă
ă
ă
ă ă 0ă ă ă
ă
ăă ă
ă!-ă.
ăă ă1ă?Aă
ă ă
ă
ăăă
ăă \lÎ
ăă ă
ă1ă
+ăă ă ă?Aă
ă +
ă !-ă ă
1ăăă
ă
ă!-ă ă
ă1ăă Î Î Î Î Î
1/29/2019
Exhibit D, Page
2:46:41
134PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 1 of 31 Page ID #:135
([KLELW(
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
135PM
Ʋ³³²³Æ²²³²³²³Æ² Ƴ³²² Ƴ³²² Ʋ³³²²Æ²³³²³Æ³² ²³Æ@?@? @ ?@ ?@?@? @?@ ?@@?@? @ ?@@??@Æ
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 2 of 31 Page ID #:136
.
ăX9ă
%)¸ 3DHUDQ@DW^ !MYDB^
\l:^ă
l:ăC9)aJ)ăYkXliaJ):ă
+¸ 9
_ă 9D>DU 5YDTLDQ^ 2URBZ@YW^!R
^ C
ă
[ [
[ U9MX[
,|ă\l:^ă
\ă {ŀ J_ă
[ [ [ $KM?0J[
[ [ [ BE39MR[
:Qăăă
ă ăăµă [ [
[ +0BQ[9Q[# ħ
ă ă +ă ă Qă ă %¸ [ [
[ E3MB?AQKJ[
[ [
[ KE9H1J[
l:Xă %![¸ă-¸ă
[ [
[ "9AH1J[
[ [
[ 9JDBJO[
) ă ă ă Qă ă ă `
ă 7
[ *[
[ *QSEBD[
ă
[ [ [ 'SBJEBJ[
¸ 9
ăJ_ă °$*¦/*&ă \X^ă
ă
ă
ăă%
ă ă
ăă
ă'+Oă ă
3DO<YDB^8
5
^TTOM@<YMRQ^ "<Y<^ '+ă ă ă ă ă ă
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
136PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 3 of 31 Page ID #:137
l:ăC9)aJ)ăYkXliaJ):ă
[ [
[ (0XH9M[9Q[0E[
[ [
[ (0XH9M[9Q[0E[
[ [ [ 0J5K5D[ 9Q[ 0E[
[ ħ
[ &0M9JQ[ 9Q[ 0E[
[ [ [ K9M[
[ [
[ KEEBJO[9Q[ # ħ
[ [ [ 9OQ9M[
[ [ [ "BOD9M[
[ [ [
[ $KKJ[9Q 0[ [
[ ([ [ [ [ 0BQ[
[ [ [ 0JB9EOKJ[
[ [ [ 0MMBO[9Q[ # ħ
[ [ [ 9MZ9M[ [ [
[ BM7[9Q[# ħ
[ [ [ &BMZ[ [ [ [ SQ5Z0D[
[ [ [ HKQK[
[ [ [ [ KH9[ &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&A [
[ [
[ (B5A0MR[
[ [ [ *DB7HKM9[9Q[0E[
[ [ [ UBE0[ [ [
[ *5AEKOO9M[ 9Q[0E[
[ [ [ *Q9LA9J[
[ [ [ *5AEKOO9M[ 9Q[0E[
[ [ [ *V0JOKJ[
[ [
[ 05A[9Q[0E[
[ [
[ AK9[
[ [
[ .S[
[ [ [
[ 0?E9[ M[
[ ([
[ [
[ *5AEKOO9M[ 9Q[0E[
ħ
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&A
[
[ 0HHKJ[
[ [
[ *ASH1D9M[
[ [
[ VBQ[ 9Q 0[
[ F [
[ $1MMBKQQ[9Q[0E[
[ [
[ 0SO9M[
[ F [
[ (BU9M0[
[ [
[ 9NB9M[
[ F [
[ KAJOKJ[
[ ħ [ A0J[
[ *[
[ $90OKH[
[ [
[ M07=M7[
[ *[
[ 9[$0MO[
[ 9[$0MO[
[ [
[ &0MD9M[
[ *[
[ 9[$0MO[
[ F[
[ KAJOKJ[
[ [ [ "KAH9X9M[9Q[0E[
ħ
[
[
[ 9[$0MO[
[ [ A0J[
[ [ [ [ *5AJ05D[9Q[0E[ [
[ Î ăă+ă
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
137PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 4 of 31 Page ID #:138
j e ¸ \q }
¸ 16 _Fŀ .Cŀ
ŀ
ŀ
('
ŀ
j ō ō2
#ō ō
q !Æ 8Æ
r "Æ FÆ
¶Sō
mu
n "'u
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
138PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 5 of 31 Page ID #:139
n ¸ \q }
¸ 16 `Fŀ .Dŀ
ŀ
ŀ (
'
ŀ
3 ō ō2
#ō ō
æħ
3
Æ
}Î
vħ
eÆ
i
Du
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
139PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 6 of 31 Page ID #:140
j e ¸ \q }
¸ 16`Gŀ .Cŀ
ŀ
]] ŀÑ ('
ŀ
j ō ō2
#ō ō
¢ŀ
ķŀ
aÆ
>Î
TU X
8
%u
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
140PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 7 of 31 Page ID #:141
p ~ Æ NÆ
.& u
.+ lu
!1u
p ~ Æ RÆ
!+u
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
141PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 8 of 31 Page ID #:142
Î
_Æ̀
Cu
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
142PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 9 of 31 Page ID #:143
lg¸^s¸ ;1=
=
= "0++7= 3- =
ō ōō
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
143PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 10 of 31 Page ID #:144
n | Æ XÆ
GG¢Æ
' ¨¸
o ± ZI Æ 7 0 Æ
UÀō
Ňō ! #
U¢ō
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
144PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 11 of 31 Page ID #:145
o}Æ6 6 Æ
¸9ŀ
¶äŀ
·99ŀ
]ō
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
145PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 12 of 31 Page ID #:146
lg¸^s¸ ;1=
=
= "0++7= 3- =
ō ōō
Î
{Î
`au
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
146PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 13 of 31 Page ID #:147
i h ōōbō
lg¸^r¸ ;1=
=
= "0**7= = 3,==
0ħ
0ħ
>X ëħ
ċħ
z{ħ
Æħ
SX
i u
0ħ
]ħ
Zħ
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
147PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 14 of 31 Page ID #:148
x¸
,ŀ
5ħ
5ħ
8ō
)ŀ
QQŀ
C
OPħ
ãÌŀ
ħ
*ō
MNħ
ĕħ
Íħ
À
éŀ
ħ
ħ
Dħ
ħ
Dħ
ĉħ
Ï
Î
ħ
Î
ħ
ħ
ħ
|}ħ
ħ
íħ
- 5 ¸
.+¸
ġō
:ħ
m¦Æ 5 TÆ
¡¢ħ
ņō
Ü¿ō ³ħ́
ħ
{ō
1ħ
þħ
eŀ
ħ
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
148PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 15 of 31 Page ID #:149
Ķō
QX
AÆ
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
149PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 16 of 31 Page ID #:150
¬ħ
ý
±ħ
@A
(C
[ħ f
ßħ
Åħ g
9ħ Uħ
9ħ
ąħ
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
150PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 17 of 31 Page ID #:151
ªħ
ăħ
0C Ċħ
Äħ
êħ
Òħ
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
151PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 18 of 31 Page ID #:152
ŀ
Ĵŀ
/C
Ou
Pu
PX
´Æ
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
152PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 19 of 31 Page ID #:153
- âÝ OX ª « Ûŀ
gu
Ĝŀ
uħ
ÀÆ
>
ľŀ
RSħT
ēħ
H
Cħ
IĚħ
Cħ
ħ
ħ
ħ
Ąħ
ÁÂ
ħ
ħ
ÈLÒŀ
ħ
ħ
²ħ
ùħ
ħ
ħ
ħ
L "Üŀ
k¬¨Æ HÆ
¯ Ó "ŀ
" "ŀ
- - Pŀ
T Sŀ
K P Ëŀ É
ŀ
Ê
Ļŀ
- K Ôŀ
T Sŀ
hu
l¬©ÆEJÆ ă¬ Çŀ l¬¥ÆDMÆ ®"ŀ
WQħ
¦¸
Aħ
zō
©ħ
Yħ
Ľŀ
Aħ
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
153PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 20 of 31 Page ID #:154
lg¸^r¸ ;1=
=
= "0**7= = 3,= =
ōōō
éŀ
ÁÚŀ
ěŀ iŀ
iª§Æ B Q Æ
§Ùŀ
ÅÆ áŀ
¨Âŀ
Ðŀ
j«¤Æ C S Æ
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
154PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 21 of 31 Page ID #:155
n ¸ \q
} ¸ 16_Gŀ .Dŀ
ŀ
ŀ
('
ŀ
3 ō ō2
#ōō
Hŀ
Ģŀ
tŀ
ðō
Uŀ
Hŀ
~ō ¸
¥¸
Uŀ
NX
¿Æ
ôŀ
sŀ
õŀ
ŀ
êŀ
öŀ Ĕŀ
\ħ
Ôħ
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
155PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 22 of 31 Page ID #:156
1-K ŀ ŀ
= =
3#!8#^ &3(--^9(7'^ %3.#^0"^ ă
ăă ă0ăă ă
ăăă ă%
ă
.1807(0 &^55#.-:^ ă!ă
ăă
ă ăă7
Pa|9)aYă9CC|,X9),kJă ăă!-ăă0ă4ăă
ă ă%
ă ă
lÎ ă
ă
ă!ăă9
ăă
ăă
ă
) ă
ă ăăă
ăă
ă
ăă%ă
ăăăă!ă
ă!ăă
l:ă
ă :ă Jă n n~eefă
ă ¤să
ă ă
ă ă
ăV ă3
ă:
¥ă ăă('
ăă:ănfăebboă ă ă ă 0ă !ă ă ă
ă ă ă
ăăăă
ăăl:ă
ă:ă ă ă
ă
ă ,ă
ă
ă
ă
Jă n n~be n ă
ă¤să8
ăă
ă
ăăă
ă7
Că Jă uufoOă ă ă ă ă
ă ă
ă >ăă
l:ă
ă :ă Jă nb~ n fe n ă
ă ¤să kă +
ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă
ă ă
8
ăă:0ă3ă9
¥ă ăă('
ăăYă ăăl:ăCăJăfuufăă| ăă
ă,ă3,8ă
n ăebbeăăă ă l:ăCăJă unbfuOă9JYă ă XlÎ fă ă%
ă ă oeăă ăă oăă ă
ăă
ăăă
ăăl :ă
7 ('+ăouă9ă1ă
ăueăă ăăă
ă
ă
ă:ăJă nb~fffeă
ă¤C
ăX%
ă97 ă ă ('+ă ouă ă ă
ă uuă ă ă ă ă ă
¥ă ăă('
ăăiăeăebbăă l:ăCăJă
ă ă ă ('+ă ouă9ăăă ă
ă
ă ă
un făă ăăă
ă ăJă ă9
ăă ă
s9X³8PklJYă k3ă)aă,JaJ),kJă ăoă) ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă0
ăăeeă ă
\ lÎ
ă ă
ă
ă oeă ă ă
ă
ă
) ăă
ăăăă%
ăăă cd ăăă%
ăă ăăă%
ăă
ă0
ăăăă
ăă
ă
ăă ă%>
c PÎ
eă Yăă ăP
ăÐħ
ăăn eă ăăă.ăă ă0ăeeăăă
ă
3pĂă]Z]]ă('
£ă]ă£ă ăă%]ă!ă ăă 0ăăăă nfă
ăă)
ă ă('
ăăăă7 Yă ă
ăă
ă ă
0
ă ă U
ă ă ă ă ă ă !-ă 4ă ăă
ăă
ăă
c lÎ
%
ă : ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ăăă ă!-ăă ă%
ă ă
ă
ă!-ăă
ăă ă ăă ăă !ă
ăă ă
ăă
%ă ă
ă 0
ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă!-ă44ă ă0ăă ă
ăă
~ă
ă ă
ă ă
ăă
ă ăăă fPÎ
ăă
ă ăă ăă
) ă ăă ă ă ăă
ă
ă
_ă
ă
ă ă
ă 4
ă
ă )
ăă
ăă('ă
ăă
ăăă
ă
ăă
ă1ăă
ăă1ăă%ă!ă ăă ă
ă ăă
ă
ă.%ăăă7
ăăă
ăă ă\^ă) ăcd
ăă!ă
ă) ăă ă ă%
ăă ăă Ú>
ă ă
ăă
ă
qăă ă4
ă
ă f lÎ
ă%ă
ă ă%
ăă,ăă ă
:
ăcd
ăă
ăă
ă
ă4
ă
ă ă ă
ăP
ă
ă
ăă0ăă ăăăă ăăă
ă ă ă ăă
ă
C!L
ă ăăăă ă
ăă ă ă
ă !ăă
ăă ă ă ă ă ă 0
ă %ă
ă
ă
ă !ă %
ă ă
ă ă
ă ă ă
ăă ăă
ă!-ă ă!ă
ă
ă
ă%
ă) ă ,ăăă ăăă
ă ăă7
qăă
ă
ă
ă ă%
ăă>
ăă
ă
ă
_ăă%
ă ă
ă ăăăă!;ă
ăăă
ăă ă rPÎ
ă ă('ă
ă ăăăOă ă ă
ă ă
ăă!ă%ă ăăă!ă%ă ăă
ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă ăăă
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
156PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 23 of 31 Page ID #:157
1-K ŀ ŀ
= =
,ă ă ă ă
ă ă0ăă ă
ăă
ăăă ăă!-ăOăăă
ă7
4ăăăăă ă%
ă ă7
ă ă ă %
ă ă ,ăăcd ă ă ă
ă ă
ă ă ,ă
ă0 ăăă
ăăă ă
ă !-ă ă
ă
ă !6
ă ă ă ('ă
ă
ă ă
ăă ăă!-ăă
ă ăă+
ă!-ă ăUă
ă
ă ă
,ă
ăă ă('ă
ă,ă ă
ă
ă ă ă1
ă
+
ă!-ă ă('ă
ă
ă ă
ăă ,ă ă,ă ăă ă 4ă ăăă
ă
ă
_ă ă %
ă
ă,ăă ăăUă
ăăăă
ă
ă ă('ă
ăăăă Oă ăă c PÎ
ăăă0ăă ă
ăă
ăăă ă
ăă
ă
ă
ăă
ă ăă ă
ă0ă
,ă
ă
ă
_ă ă
ăăă
ă
ăăăă7
%
ă ă
ăă('ă
ăăăăOă fPÎ
ă ă ă +ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă
ăă
ăă
ă
ă
ăă
ă0 ăă
ăăăăă ă ă 0
ă !;ăă ă
ăă ă
ă
ă!6
ăă ă('ă
ă
ă ă
ăăăă ă+ăăă ă('ă
ă ă ă ă !-ă ă ('ă
ă
ă ă
ăă
ă40 ă!-ă ă 0
ăă ă ă
ăăă
ă ăăă ă
ăă
ăă ă ă ă +ăăă ăă ă
ă('ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă
ă ă ă('ă flÎ
ăă
ăăăă
,ă ăă ăăă
ă
ă ,ăăăcd0 ăă ă
ăă ă
ăă
ă ă0
ăă
ă
ă
_ă ă%
ă ăă%
ă !;ă,ă
ăă
!-ăă
ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă ăăă ă ă
ă
ăăă ă
ă,ă
ăă
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
157PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 24 of 31 Page ID #:158
1-K ŀ ŀ
= =
,ă ăă ă('ă
ăăăă ă ,ă
ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ă
ăăă0ă ăă ă+ăă
ă ,ă ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ,ă ăă ăăă
ăă ă
%
ă ă ) ă %
ă 4ă ă ă ă ă XlÎ ă ă!;
ă ă %
ă 4ă ă ă
ăăăăă!6ăăăăă
_ă
ă ă('ă
ă
ă ă 1
ă 7
Oă
ăă
ă
ăă
ăă
ăă ă('ă
ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă ('ă
ă
ă!6
ăă ă('ă
ă
ăă
ă7
ZNÎ
ă ăă
ăă
ă+
ă ă ă('ă
ă
ăă +
ă!-ă ă ('ă
ă
ăă
ă7
ă,ă ă ăă ă('ă
ă ă
ă ă
sP,a3ăYa:XP,C),kJăk3ă)aăYP9V,J8:ă
ă ă
ăă ă ă
ăăă ă
ă
ă
) ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă
,ă
ă
ă
^NÎ
ăăăă ăă
ăă
ăăă ă
ăă ăăă
ăă!-ă4ă
¡hă ph«ă ¡p«hă ¬ă ûă ¬h¬ă µă Épă Ëýh«ă ă ¡¬«ă ăă]]%p
ă răpă
]Ìă¶]ÌpZp]òă
ă 3,8ăăăăăăă ă
ă
ăă3,8ăă
,ă
ăăă ă
ăă
ă
ăă3,8ăă
ă
ă ,ă
ă
ăăă +ă ăăOă
!6ăh
ă1
ă
ă ăă
ă 3,8ă$ăăăăăă ă
ă
ăă3,8ă *ă
,ă ăă ă ă 40 ă
ă ă dNÎ
ă ă %
ă ă ă ă ăăă ă
ăh%ă ăh%ăăă ă ă('ă
ă
ă
ă ăă ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ăăă+1
ăă ă('ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ă hă ă ă ă
ăă ,ă
ă ăă3,8ă
ă ă
>h
ă
ăă ă
ă,ăă ă dlÎ *ă
ă ă
ăăă ă
ăă!-ă
ăăă
ă ă ('ă
ă
ă ă 0ă ă ă 7 ăă ă
ă
ăă ăăOă
ăă ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ăă0
ă ăă
ă ă+ă!-ăă!6ăăăăăă ă 7 ă ă ă ă ăă 0ă ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă7
,ăăcd0 ăă ăăă
ăăă
ă ă ă 3,8ă ă
ă
ă ă ă
ă ăă
%
ăă
_ăăUă
ă
ăă1
ă !-ăăă ă%
ă ăă
ă
ăă
ă ă
ă
ă µă ă 1
ă Oă ă
ă llÎ ă
ă
ăăă ă!-ă
Oă
ăă ă('ă
Oăăă
ăă
ă ăă 3,8ă &ăăă
ăăă ă
ă ăă3,8ă *ă%ă
ă
ăă
ă
('ă
ă ă ă
ă ă
ă +
ă ă ă ('ă ăă3,8ă*ă
ă ă
ăă
ăă!-ă
ăÙtħ ,ă ă ăă ăUă
ă4ă pNÎ
ăg
ă ă ă
ăă ă ă ăă
ă ăă
ăăă
ă ă
ăă
ă ă ăă ă
ăOă
ă,ă
ă
ă>ăă
ăăă ăUă
ă
ăăă ăă 3,8ă* O ă
ăă
ăă ăă
ă
ăă('ăă ă 3,8ă ăă ă
ă
ăă3,8ăă ă ăăă
ă
ăă
ăă, ă ăă ăăă rlÎ
ă%
ă
ăăăăă ă
Oă
ăăăă
ăă ăăăăă 3,8ăăăăă
ă ă ăăăă ă
ă
ăă ă
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
158PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 25 of 31 Page ID #:159
1-K ŀ ŀ
= ŀ
3,8ă*ăăă
ăăăăăăăăă Qă ă ă
ă
ă) ă
ă
ă
ă
ăă3,8ăă
ăăăă
ă.%ă ăă0ăă ă ('ăă
ă+
ă
ăăcd
ă
ă ă ă
ă.%ă
ăă ă ă7 ă ă ă ă ăă
ă ă
ă ă ă
ă
Oă Qăă!Lă ă
3,8ă$ăăăăăă ă%
ă4ăă ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă %
ă Ya)9,|aYăYa:XP,C),kJăk3ă)aă ,JaJ),kJă
4ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ă
ăă ă('ă
ăă ă
ă
ăă ă07 9ăqă
ăăă ăăă
ă!-ăăăăOă ă
ă Oă ă ăăăăă ă ă
3,8ă 5ăăă>
ăă
ă ă
ă
ă T N Î
ăă ă
ă+
ă ă ă 7
ă ă0
ă!-ăă ă%
ăă%ă
ă ă ăăăăăă !6`ă) ă('
ăă
ăă ăăă
ăă ă
ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă ă
3,8ă/ă ăă>
ăă
ă ă
ă
ă ²ă 3
ă ă ă ă ) ă ă
ă
ă ă
%ă
ă
ă $>$ăă3,8ă #Oă
ă
ăă%
ă ăăăăă!-ă
3,8ă &ăăăăă ă ă %
ă ă ă
ă $ă ) ă0ă !-ă
ă $ăă ăă
ăă
ă ăăă
ă
ăOă ă 0ăă ă %
ă ă ăă ă ă!-ă
3,8ă =ă ă ă ă ăă ă ă ă 44ă $Hăăăă4ă$Tă) ă%
ă ă
%
ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă %
ă ZjÎ ă
ăăă#ă ăă!L
ă.ăăă('+ă
4ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ă &ăăă
ă ă/ă) ăă#ă ăă
ă
ă
ăă ă('ă
ăă ă
ă
ăă ă07 =ă ăă ăă
ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă ăă
ă
ă ă ă ă ('+ă&ă) ă
ă$ă('ăă%
ăăă ă
ă +ă ă ă ă %
ă ă ă !6ăă
ă
ăăă ă
ă
ăă,ăă
ă!6ă
Oă !Lgăăă
ăăă
ăăă
3,8ă*ăăă ăăă
ă G
ăQ7
.ă!6ă ă
ă
ăă ă%
ăăă ă ă%
ă ăă ă
ăă
ă
ăă%ă
ă
ă*>*ăă3,8ă $Oă G
ă
!6ăă ă%ăă&ă
3,8ă /ă ă ă ă ă ă ă %
ă 4ă V ă ă
ăăăă ă
ăg
ăTă
ă ă
ăăăăăă ă
ă
ăă ă ă
ă ăăă ă
ă
ă#ă ă ă ă%ă
+ăă ăă ă
ăă!6ă
ăă ©ă !;ă&ăăă!;
ă ă
ă$ă ă ă%
ă
ă%
ă4Oăă ăă9ă ăă3,8ă ă ă
ăă ă ăă
3,8ă&ăăăăăă ă('ă
ăă ă%
ă ă Tă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă
ăă
4ă
ă ă
ă
ăă!-ă ă
ă ă ă%
ă ă ă 0ăă ă 7
ăă ă
ă+ăă ăăă ă
ă$ă,ă ă.ă ă
ăă
9
ă ă('ă ăă ă ă ă pjÎ !-ă ă
ă
ă#ă Qăăă ă U+ă &ă
ă ăQăă
ăă ăă
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
159PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 26 of 31 Page ID #:160
1-K ŀ ŀ
= =
$ă ,ă ă !Lgă ă ă
ăă ă ăă ăă$#ăăQă$ & ă ăăă ă
ă
ăă ă ă%
ă ă ă ă ă ă $*ăă
ăă
ăă0ăă ă
ă$*ă !-ăă('ă
ăă ă ăă ă%
ă ă ă ăă ă$=Hă ă ăQă$&ăă ă ăă
,ă ăă ăă ă('
ă ăăă $#ă ă ăăă$=Tă ă ăQă$&ăăă
ă ă
ă
ăăQ
ă!;ă!-ă ă
ă jÎ ă ă ă $#ă ă ă
ă $*ă ă ă ă
ăăă
ăă ă *ă ă ă
ăă ) ă ă *ă ă ă\3,8ă ^ă
ăă ă
ă ă *ă \3,8ă ^ă !6ă ă ) ă!-ă
ă$ăăăăăă
ăă!-ă
ăăăă 0ăăăăă ă%
ă ă ă ) ă !-ă ă ă !L
ă ă ă7
ăă!L
ăă ăă
ăă ă ă('+ă &ă,ă !6ăă
ăăăă5ăăă
ă
ăă ăă ă('
ă ă
ăă!6`ăă T N Î ă 5$ă ,ăă ăă ă!-ă
ă
ăă ă
%ăă ăă*ăăă ăă
ă ă ă ă ăă
ăă!-ăă
ă ă
ăă ă
ă ă ă
ă ă *ă 9
ă ă ă ('ă!-ăă#ăăăă!-ăă#ă ) ă
ă ă ă *ă +ă ă !-ă ă %ă ('ăăă!-ăă#ă#ăăăăă
!;ă&ăă ă
ăăă ă
ăă*ă !6ă0
ă ă%
ă ăăă
ăăă
ăă
ă !-ă ă U+ă &ă ă
ă T j Î ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ă ă+ă ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă %ă ă
ă ă ă ă#$ăă ă!-ăă#ă#ă\3,8:ă/ ^ă
%
ă ă ă ăă ă ăăTă ) ă!-ăă#ă#ăăăă ăă+ă#$ă
) ă
ăă0ă
ăă ă.ăă ă ăăă ă!-ăă#ă#ăă ă('+ăă
ă ă ă ă !-ă
ă $ă
ă
ă
ă #ă ă
ăă
ăă##ăQ.
ă ă!-ăă
ă ă0ăăăăă
ă0ăă ă Z N Î #ă #ăă ă U+ă &ă ă ă %
ă ă ă,ă ă
ăă ă('ăăHă,ă ăă ăă ă ăă ă3
ă ă
ăă##ă
ă('
ă ă
ăă!-
ă
ăăăă ă
ă ă
ăăă \3,8ă&^ă+
ă!-ă ă ('7
ă
ă#ă!-ă ă('ăăHăă ăăă +ă &ă ă
ă
,ă ă ă ăă ă('
ă ă
ăăăă ă ă
ă ă ă !-ăă ă ('+ă &ă ă ă
ă 0
ăcd
ă ă ă
ă !6ă ă !-ă $ă ă ă
ăăă('ă
ă$ăăăă
ă$ă) ăUă
ă %
ă ă ă ă ă U+ă ă ă ă
$ă ă
ăăă ă ă ă%
ă ă ă ă ă
ă ăă ă
ăăă
ă\
^ăă ă
ă
ă$ă ă
ăăă
ăă ă('+ă
ă
ă
$ă ă ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă #ă ă
ă ă ă
ă ă
ă ă ă
ă ă
ă
ă('ăăă
ă
ăăTă
ă
ă ăă ă!Lăă ă!-ă$ă
ă ă
ă $ă 3 ă ă
ăă
ăă
ă ă ,ă ăăă ăă ă
ăă ăă
ă
ă
ă$ă!L
ă
ăă ă7 jjÎ ăă/&ă) ăăăă ă
ăă
ăă ăă
ă!;ă*=ăă ă
ă) ă
ă
ă$ăă ă ă
ă
ă#ăă ă('+ă&ă ă ă
ă
ăă
ă%
ă
ă$*ăă ă
ă!6ă
ă ăă ă('ăăHă ă
ăă
ă ăă
ă ă
ă $*ă ă ă
%
ă ă $$ă ă ă ă ă
ăă ăăă ă('+ă &ă) ă
ă
ă!-
ă
ăă ă
ă$*ăăă7 ă ă
ăă ăă!6ă ă
ă!-ă ă ă
ăă ăăă ăă
ăăăă0ă pNÎ 0ăă ă ăă ă('+ă
ă4
ă ă ă
ă ă
ă\ă3,8ă ^ăa
ăă ă
ă$*ăă
ăă ă ă
ă V ă ă
ăă ă
ăă ă
ă
%
ă ă $$ă !L
ă
ă
ă ăă ăăTă ăăă/&ă+ăăăă ă
ă$#ăăăQă$&ă ,ă ăă ă ă ăă ă ăăă
ă&ă!6ă ăăă
ă$#ăăăă ă
ă$*ăă ăQă$&ă ă ă
ă
ă
ăă ă
%
ăă $$ă ă ă
> pjÎ ,ăă ă ă ă ă ă ă !-ă $ă ă
ă ă ă
ă ă $#ă ă Qă $&ă ă ă ă !6ă ă
ă
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
160PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 27 of 31 Page ID #:161
1-K ŀ ŀ
= =
ăăă!-ăă
ăă
ă/#ăă ă #ă#ă ă ă0ăă
ă ă ăă!;ăă ă
ă
ăă
ăă
ăăă
ă ă $ăă
ăă ă!-ă ă
ăă
ă /#ă ,ă ă ă
ă=ă \3,8ă =^ă9ă
ăă
ă ă ă
ă ă
ă ă ăU+ă &ăă ă!-ă
ăăă#ă ăă
ă
ă
ă ă4ă ă
ă=ă ă 0ăă ăăă ă
ă) ă
ăă!6ăă('ă44ă+
ă!-ă !-ăă #ă#ăăă
ă ă
ă ăă
ă
ăă0ă/#ăăă+ă ă('ă T N Î ă
ăă
ă&ă!6ă ă
ăăă 0ăă
ăăă ă%
ă ăă ă
ăăă ă
ăăă!-ă
ă
ă
ăă ă
ă#$ă ă ăă!6ăăă
ă
ă ă/ă
ă
ă
ă ,ă ă g
ă ă
ă
ă ) ă
ăă
ă
ăă
ăăă ă
ă
!-ă$ă ă!6ă
ă!-ăă!-ă
ăQă ă1ă
ă ăă!L
ăă
ă1ă ăăă
ăăăăăăă ă!-ă $ăă> T j Î ăă ă 3
ă ăă¿
ăă ăăă¿
ă.%ă
ăă ă
ăQăă ă('+ăă ăăă ă ă) ă
ă
ăă
ă 4ă
ă$ăăă
!-ă $ă 0ăă ă ăăăă ă!-ă
ă$ăă
) ăăă\^ă/ă
ă ă
ă &ă ăă ăă
ăă ă
ă
ăă ăă
0ăă ă('ăăHă
ăă ăăă ă ăă%ăăăă0ăă ă.%ăăă ă
ă
ăăă ă
ă
ă#ăăăă ă .%ă
ă ăă ă
ă .!6
ă $ă ă ă
ă
ă ă ă ă ă&ă ă ăăă/ă ă,ă ăă ăă3,8ă *ă ă0ă%ă
) ă
ă
ă ă
ă
ă ă ă
ă =ă ^jÎ ă ăă
ăă ăăăă!-ă
ă#ă
ă ă ă('+ă&ăă0 ăă ă!-ă$ă !L
ă ăă!-ă44ă$Tă) ă
ăă ă
) ă ă
ă=ăă!L
ă!6ăăă
ăă %ăă
ăă ăă#ă ă+ă!-ă
ă
ă ă %ă) ă ă
ă=ă
ă
ăă
> ă !-ă $ă ă
ă ă %ă ă ăă !6ă
ă ă=ă!L
ă ăă
ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă.%ăă
ă =ă !6ă
ă ă ă
ă ă ă !-ă ă dNÎ P!Lg
ă ă 0
ă ă 3,8:ă $ă ă &ă ă ă
('+ă &ă) ă('+ă&ă ăă
ă=$ăă
ă ăUă
ă ă
ăă7
ă!L
ăăăăăă
ă
ă=#ă 4ăă
ăăă) ăă$ă ă ă ă
ăăă
ă ă.
ă=$ă djÎ ă ă ă ă ă ă $ă ă
ă ă
) ăă ă
ă=ăă
ă ă=ă
ăă ă1
ă ă#ăă ă('ă
ăă) ă('ă
ă !L
ă ăă ăă
ă ă ă
ă ă
ă
ăă!-ă&ăăă%ăă) ă ă ă
+ăă ăă#$ăă ă!-ăă#ă#ă) ă ă!-ăă%ă &ăăă
ăă ă('ă
ă ă
ă
ă=ă ăăăăgăă ă0ăă ă
ă ă
ă +ă!-ă ă +ă ) ă7
ă('+ă&ăă ăă ă ă ă
ă=ă) ăă jNÎ ă$ăă
ăă
ăă ăă!-ă!-ă&ă
ă !Í
ă !6ă ă
ă ('
ă ă ă ă ă%ă ă) ă!6
ăă ă('ă
ăăăă+Gă ă
3
ă
ă ăă
ă ă ă
ă ă ă ?A
ăă
ăă ă!-ă ă
ăăă ă
ă!-ă$ăăă
ă!6ăă
>ă
ă
ă9
ă ă ă ă ă1
ă ă #ăiă ă ă
ă ă
ă
ă ă0 ăă ă 0ă ă \ă ăăă ă1
ă ă#ă ă ă%
ă
ă$ă,ă
^ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă ă !-ă ăă7 jjÎ ăăăă ă ăă
ăă ă!-ă&ăă%ăă
4ă
ă ă0ăăăă *ăă
ăă+ă ă ă !-ă ă \3,8ă ^ă ,ă ă 7 *$ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă
ă ă ă
ă
!Lă!6ăă ăă ă
ă0ăă=&ăă ('
ăV ă ă
ăăă ă('ă
ăă
ă ăă
ă ă !6ă ă ă ('ă ă ă a+
ăă ăă*ăă*$ăă ăă
!-ă
ă#ă #ă) ă
ăă
ă!6`ă *#ăă*&ă) ăUă
ăăă('+
ăăă ăă
ă
ă
ă
ăă
ă
ă ă
ă
ăă
ă pjÎ ă*#ăă*&ăăă$ă
ă) ă
ă
ăăăăăă ă!6ă ă ă kăăă ă0
ă!-ă*ăăăă
ă
ăăăă ăă#$ăă ă!-ă
ă $ă ă ă ăăă ă 0
ă !-ă *ă `>
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
161PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 28 of 31 Page ID #:162
1-K ŀ ŀ
= =
ăăă
ă$$ă) ă
ă$ăă
ă
ăQ7 3,8ă#ă ă
ă&&ăă=ăă
ăăQ+ăă
ăă
ăă!-ă ă
ăă#ă) ă
ă$$ăă ă
ÿă ,ă3,8ă&ă ă
ă&&ă ă=ă ăă
ă
ă
ă Qă ă
ă ă!-ă ă
ă ăQ+ă ă
ă ă
.ă ) ă
ă &&ă ă ă
ă &ă
ă%
ăă=ăă
=ă ăă
ă%
ă
) ă ă ă *ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă 5ă ă 5$ă TNÎ ăăă!;
ăă ă ă
ă&&ăă=ăă
ăă ăăă*ăă*$ă) ă
ăă ă ă
ă ă ăă3,8ă#ă) ăăă
$&ă
ă
ă 5#ă ă 5&ă ă
ă 5#ă
ă
ă ă
ă &&ă ă =ă
ă ă
ă ă>ă
ăă ăăă5ăă ăăă*ăă
ă ăă =#ă ăă ă
ă ă=&ă) ă
ă5&ă
ă
ă#ă
ă ă) ă
ă#ăă
ăăăăă ă ă ă ă ă ă 0
ă !;ă /#ă ă
ă#$ăă ă ă*ăa+
ăă ă
ă#ă
ă+ăă ă('ăăì ă) ă!6ăăă ă
ă
ă ăă ă
ăă ă
ăă5ăăăăă ZNÎ .%ă#ăăăăăăQă ăă0ă&ă
##ă ăăăăă ă 0
ăă/#ă,ăăă
) ă
ăă $&ăă 5ăăă
ăăăă ă ă !6ă ă ă ă
ă .%ă #ăă ă ă
ă
ă
ăă ă0
ă!-ă*ă ă
ă
ă ăă ăă ă
ă.%ă#ăăă!6ă ă
ă
ăăă#ăăQă ăă ă#&ă!6ă .%ă#ăă
ă
ă
ă
ă ăăăă ă
ă ăăă*ă ă ăăă##ă
> ZjÎ
ăăăX
ă ă ă
ă !-ă ă .%ă #ăă ă
ă ăă ă/ă!6`ă ă ăăă*ăV ă
ăăăăăă
ă&$ă,
ăă ă
ă ă
ă
ă ă $ă ă5ă ă ă ăă ă
ă ă
ăăă
ă
ăă
ăăăă
ă$&ă
ăăă
ă+ă/ăă/$ă ă ă
ăă ăăă
ă ă ăăă
ăăă
ăăă
ă!;ă/#ă ,ăăăăă ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă ă *ă ă *$ă
ă ă ^NÎ ) ă
ă $ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ăă
ă
ă
ăăă ă0
ăă/#ă
ă
ă
ă ă
ăă ă
ă+ă ă
ă
ă
ăă ă1
ă ă#ăă
ăă ă
ă
+ă/&ă
ă ă $ă
ă!-ă ă('ă
ăăăă ăă3,8 #ă
V ă ă
ă ă $&ă ă ă
%ă ă ă ^jÎ Că.%ă#ăă ăă ăăă
ăă ă
+ăă ă ă
ă ă 5ă ă 7 ă3,8 &ăă ăăăă.ăăăă
%ăăă+ăă ă
ăă/&ăă .ă ăăă ăăă ă0ă $ăă
ă ă1
ăă$#ăă ăăăă*ă ă('ă
ăă) ă
ăă
ă ăă!6%ă$ăă
V ă ă
ă +ă /&ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă &&ă ă ă ă
ă
1
ă ă $#ă ă
ă('ă ă
ă ăă ă dNÎ
ă ă ă ă ă
ă $ă ă
ă =ă ă
ă
ă
ă ă 5ă ă ă +ăă : ă
ă ă ă ăă ă
ă
ăăăă ă
ă$$ă
ă!6ă ă
ăă$&ă ă ă
ă+ă/ăă/ă$ă ) ă
ă ă ă 4
ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă
ă $ă ) ă
ă$ă
ă ă
ă
ă
=ă ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă
ă pjÎ &ă ă ăă
ă ă ă ă &ă ăăă
%ă ă
!-ă ă
ăă ăă3,8ă #ăăă +ă ă ă
ă$ă ăăăă ă
ă
ă7
ă ăă3,8ă&ă,ă ă
ăă ăă ă ăă ăă3,8ă $ă
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
162PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 29 of 31 Page ID #:163
1-K ŀ ŀ
= =
,ă ăă
ă ă ă ă
ăă ă
ă
ă
ă ă ă
ă##ă ă0ăă5$ă ăă ă ăă
`
ăUăă ă
ă ă ă('ă
ă ăăăă!-ă ă07
ă$&ăă5ăă ă+ăăă ăă
ă!;ă ăă
ăă ă ăăăă ă
ă
ă $ă!-ă ă('ă
ă ă) ăă.%ă#ăă ăă ăăăă5#ăă
ăă ă
ă
ăăăă$ăăă!-ă ă%ă ă jÎ
ăă#&ă
ă ă
ă &&ă ă =ă ) ă
ă &&ă ă =ă ă ă a ăă ă ăă 5#ă ă 5/ă ă !6ă ă
ăă ă+ăă ăă ăă 3,8ă &ă ă ă !;ă ăăă
ă /ă ă ă
ăă
) ă4
ăăă
ăăQă ă ă
47
ă##ăa ăăă $#ăă$&ăă
ă.ă
ă
ă&ă ă
ă ă ă
ăăQă ă ăă
ăăă
ă /ă ă
ă
ă ăă
ă
4
ă
ă ă ă ă !6%ă $ă ă
ă ă TNÎ ă5$ăă ăă ă ă3,8ă=ăă ă7
Qă ă ă
ă
ăă) ă
ă$ăă
ă ) ă ă ă
ăăă ă 0ă ă 5$ă
ăă
ăă ă
ăăăQă ăă ăăăă
Gă ă ă ăă *ăă
+ă$ #ă).
ăă ă%ăă
ă%ăă ă
P!L
ă
ă ă 3,8:ă =ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ăă&#ăă%
ăă
ăcd ăă*ăă%
ăăă ă ) ă ă !;ă ă ă ('ă
ă&&ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ) ă ă *ă
ă ă Uă
ă ă ă ă !;
ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ăăă$ăă1
ă ă#ăăă&ă 4
ă/ăă ă!6%ă/ă$ă iăă ăăă
ăăiă ă ă1
ă ă#ăă ă
ă ZjÎ ă
ă=ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă !6`ă ăăăăă
ăă
ă5ă) ăUă
ă#ă
ă ăă!6ăă#ăă
ă /#ă ă/&ă) ăă
ă/#ăă/&ă .ă
ăăă&ă).
ăă%ă ăă%ăăăă ă ăă.%ă&ăV ă ă
=ăăăă
ăă
%ă*ăăă ă +ă!;ăă ă ă
ă
ă!-ă ăă ăă3,8ăăă
ă&ă) ă%ăă ă('+
ă.ă ăăă*$ă ăă ăă3,8ăă ăă ă+ăă
Pă*$ă+ă
ăă
ă!6ăă ăă&ăăă ^ N Î ă ă
ă=ăă.%ă &ă
ă ă
ă ăă
('+ăă %ă*#ă%ă*#ăăăăă
ă
ă ăă!;ăă ă
=ăăăă ă
ă ă *&ă Pă *&ă ă ('+
ă ă ă ă
ăă+
ăă 0ă
ă
ă
ă)ă
ă ăă ă
ă $ăV ă ă
ă %ă ăă
ăăăăă!6ă ăăăă ă
41ă
%ăă ă+ă ă %ă*#ă
ă ?Aăăă
ă.ă
ă ă.
ă ă&ăă
ă ă ăă *&ă ă ă ăă3,8ă ăă ă ^jÎ ă1ăă ăăă ă,ăăăăă ă ă
ăiăă ă
ă%ăăă
ă ăă*ăăăă
ă`ă ă
ă ă
ă
ăă ă
ă /ăă/ă$ăă
ă
ă $ăă ăăă ă
ă.ă
ă
ă ăăăă ă
ăă ăăăă ă
ă
ă ăă
ă ăă3,8ă ăă ă
ă dNÎ
ă ăăăă ă
&&ă) ă
&&ăă3,8ă
) ă
ă$ă ăă
ă
ă
ă$ă ăăă ă ă ă ă %
ă !;ă &&ă ă ă ă ă
ă.ă ăăă
ă.
ă.ăă !;ăăăă
ă
ă =ăă =ăV ă ă
ă!-ă
ă$ăă ăUă
ăăiăă ă !6%ă/ă$ăăăăăăQ ă=$ă!-ă ă
ă
+ăăă ă
ă$ă ăăă
ăă7 ă ă ă +ă ă ă ă ă ă ă
!;
ă
ă
ă$$ă djÎ ă ă
ă =ăă ă ă !6%ă/$ăă
ă
ă
3+
ăăă ă+ă!;ăă ă0ă$ăă ă ă%
ă!;ăă ăă!Lă ă ă
ăăă
ăăăăă$#ăă$&ă) ă
Găă ă%
ăă&&ă) ăăăă!6 ă
ă ă $#ăă$&ăă ('+
ăăă ă0ă 4
ă /ă ăă ăă!-ăă
ăăă
$ăăăă 0ăă 5ă) ăăăă ăă ăQă =#ăă ă+ăăăă ă
ă$# $&ă ăă
ă ă5ă) ăăă jNÎ ă
ă=ă
$#ăă$&ă ă
ăăă ăă &ăăă P!Lg
ă0
ăă3,8:ă*ăă&ăă ă
ă
:
ă ă 0
ă ă 5$ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ăcd ă ă &#ă ă%
ă
ăăăăăăă5#ăă 4ăă ăă) ăă&#ăăăă ă
5/ă X.
ă ă ă ă ă 5#ă ă 5/ă
ăă ăăăăăă Găăă ă
Qă ă ă ăă .
ă ă 5&ă ă jjÎ
ă ă0
ă ă ă ă ă ă *ă
#ăV ă ă+ă
ă#ăă ă ă5#ăă ) ăUă
ăăă ă ăă&#ăă
ă
ă ă ă ă ă 0ă 4
ă !Lă #$ă 9
ă
ăă Gă ) ă%ă ă ă
ă$ă
ă ăăă
!6ă ă ă +ă
ă #ă ă ă ă ă
ă ##ă ăăă =&ă ăăa ă4ă
Xăă$#ăăă.ă ăăăă ă
ă##ă ă =&ăăă ăă.ă ăă
ă!6ăă ă('ă
ă
ă##ă
ă ă5#ăă ă ă
ă##ă pNÎ
ă ă ă
ă
ăă
ă ă) ă
ă ă ă
ă ă ăăă 5/ă ă ă
ă ă ăă
ăăă!6`ăă ă!-ă
ă$ăă ă('ă
ă
!-ăăă 5#ă :
ă ăă$&ăăă ă ă ) ă.ă
ăă ăă
.
ă ă ă
ăă ă
ă
ă ##ă ) ă =&ăă ă
ăăă ă ăă
ăă ă
ă$ăă
.ăă ăăă$# $&ă ă ă7 ăăăăăăăăă ăă
ă
ă##ăăăă
ă.ăă ă ă0ăă5$ă pjÎ ă ă
ă$ă
ăă
ăă
ăă
ăăăăQă ă ăăă 3+
ăăă ă0ă$ăă ă('ă
ă ăă
$#ăă$&ăV ă ăăă$#ăă$&ăă
ă !6ăăă 0ăă$ă)ăă ă 0ăă$ăă
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
163PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 30 of 31 Page ID #:164
1-K ŀ ŀ
= =
('+ă ăăă#ă ă ă
ăăăăă
.('
ă
ă!-ă ăă ăăă ă
ă
ăă$ă
ă('+ăă ăăă&ă) ăă ăăăă .
ă
ăă ăăă ă7
ă#ăă&ăă('+ăăăăăăă
ăX
ă
ăăăă ă 0
ă!-ă$ă) ă
ăăă ă V ăă
ă_ă
ă !-ă $ă ă ă ă
ă #ă ă ă kÎ ă9ă0
ăă
ă
ă
_ă
ăăă ă
ă!-ă$ă`
ăăă
ă ă
Oă
ă) ă>ăă
ă
%ă ă
ă
ă$ă Å ă ă!-ă
ă
ăă
ăă!-ăă
ăăăă ăă ăă3,8ă *ăă ă7 ăăă!-ăăăăQăă ă
ăX.ăă ă
ăă#ăă&ăă ă ăă
ăă
ăăă('+Oăă
ă
ă $ă ă ăă*ă) ă
ă
ăă ăăă ă
ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă
ă
ă
ă*ă *$ă
ăăăăă ă
ăă ăă
ăăăăă
ăă
) ă
ă *ă ă *$ă ă ă
ă
ă ă VkÎ 0
ăă
ă
ăăă0ăă ă
ă*#ăă*&ă ăă!6ă
ă ă ăăăă0
ăă
ă
ă0 ăăă
ă$ă ă$ă ăă('+
ăăă ăă
ăăăăă0ăăăU+ăăă
*ăV ă ă
ă
ăăă
ăă ăăgă ăăă('ă0
ăă
ă
ă.ăă
$$ă ă
ă*ăă*$ăăă!-ă ăă ă
ă ă ă ă ă ('ă !-ă ă ă ă
ă*#ăă*&ă ă
ăă ă
ă
ă$ă [OÎ ă ă ăă ă0
ă ă
ă
ă
ă ăăă ă
ă +
ăă ăă .ă ă ă
ă ă 0ă ă ă ă !-ă
3,8ă/ă,ă ă
ă+
ăă%ă *#ăă ăă ăăăăăă%7
ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă
ă ă
ă
ă 5ăă ă ă ă ă
ă
a O Î
ăăă
ă!6ă
ăă ăă
+ă ă 9
ă %ă 5ă ă ă ă
ă
ă!-ăă
ă
ăăă
ăăăă
ă
ă ă ăă ă
ă
ă 5ă ă ă
ăă
ă0 ăă ăăăă7
ă +ă ă ) ă
ă
ă 5ă ă ă
ăăăă!-ăă
ă
ă5$ăă5#ă) ă
ă5$ăă5#ă!;
>
* ă) ă
ă
ăă
ăă ăă
ăăăă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ă
ăă
ăă ăă
ăăăă
ă ă ă ă ă
ă
ă 5ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă 0ă ăă
ă
ăă ă
ă
ă$ă ăă ăăă
ăăă('+ă
ăă ăă3,8ă* ă) ă
ă
ă5ăă
ă 5ă) ă
ă
ăă
ăă ă ăăă!-ă
ă
ăă ă
ă
ă$ă ăă ă>
ă ă > ă ă ă ă
ă ă
ă ă
ă+ăă
ăă ăă3,8ă /ă
ă !6`ăă×> ă!-ă
ă
iăă ă
ă$ăăăăă
ă&&ăă=ă) ă
#ă) ă
ă
ăă
ăă ă ăăă!-ă
ă!½ăă ăăă ă Găă ă('ă
ă ă
ă
ă
ăă ă
ă
ă ă
ă
ăă
ă
ăă ă1ă ă
ekÎ
ăă
ăă
ă ă
ă
ă.ă
ă 1
ă ă ă ă ('ă
ă ă ) !6ă ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă
1ă ă ă ă ă ă ăă.%ă ă ă !-ăă
ăăă.%ă&ă
ăăă
ă/# /&ă
/ă) ă
ă
ăă
ăăcd ă
ăă
ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă.%ă5&ă
ăă ă
ă
ă ă
ă
ă&&ăă=ă
kOÎ
ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă ('+ă ă
ă
9
ă ă ă
ă #ă ă #ă ă ă ă
ă ă 4ă
ă ă ă !-ă ă %
ă
ăăă
ăăă ă
ă&&ăă=ă ăăăăă('+ă
ăă
ăă04ă
ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă $ă ă
ă ă ă 4ăă ă
ă ă
ăă
ăă#ă) ă
ăă#ă &ă ) ă
ă
ă ă
ă /ă ă ă
ă
ăă
ă!-ă ă%ăă
ă& &ăăă kkÎ ă40 ă
ăă
ăă ă
ăă ă
ă ă
ă=ăăă ăă3,8ă&ă) ă
ă#ăă ăăăăă
ă
ăă
ă/ă ă ăăă!-ă
ă+ăă ă
&&ă
ă0ăă ăăă
ăă
ă ă!-ăă
ă
ă #ă ă
ă=ă
ă0ă ă ă
ă qOÎ
ă
ăă ă ă
ăă
ăăă
ă
&ă ă
ă#ă ă !6%ă#ăă ă
ă #$ăăă G
ă
ă ă
ă
ă #$ă ă ă ă ă ă
ă ă ă %
ă ăăă('+ăă ăă ă
ăăă
!;ăă ă
ă&&ă qkÎ
V
ă ă ('ăă ăă
ă
ăă
ăă ăă!-ă7
ă ă ('ă ă ă ă ă ăă > ă ăăă!-ăă
ăă
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
164PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-5 Filed 01/29/19 Page 31 of 31 Page ID #:165
1-K ŀ ŀ
= =
ăăăă
ăă ă ă ă!-ă7 /ă ) ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă 40 ă ă ă
ă
ă ă ă
ă 0ă ă
ă ă ăă
ă
ă
ăă
ăă
ă7
ăăăă!-ăă
ăQăă ă ă ă
ăă ăăă
ăă
ă
ăăăă
ăă
ăQăăă ă
ă
ăă ă0ăă ăă ăă
ă
ă ă
ă ă 40 ă
ă ă ă
ă
ă.ăă ă('ă!-ăăă
ăăă
ă ă
ă
ăă
ă
ăă
ă/ă ăă
ă
ă9ă
ăă
ă
ă
_ă
ăăă
ă!6ă
ăă ăă
ă
ă
ăă
ăă ăă
ă
ă!-ă
ă
ăă
ăă!-ăă ă
ăăăă
ăă
ă!6ă
ăăă!-ăă
ă4ăQăă
ăă
ă
ă
_ă
ă!-ăă
ăă
ăă
Oă
ă
ă
ăă
ăăăăă
ăă
> ă0ă4ăăă
ăă7
0
ă ă
ă
ăăă0ăă ă
ă
ă
ăă
Oă
ăăăă0
ăă
ă
ă0 ăăă
ăă
ăă
ă0
ă ă
ă
ăăă('ă0
ăă
ă
ă.ăă ^NÎ
ăă
ă
ăăăU+Oă
ă
ă ă
ă ă!6ă
ăăăU+Oă
ă
ăă
ăăăăăă
ă ă
ăă!-ăă dNÎ ă
ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă
ă
*ă ) ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă !-ă ăă
ăăăăă
ăă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă
ă ă
ăăă 0
ăă
ă
ăăă0ăă ă
ă
ă G
ă
ă ăăăă0
ăă
ă
ă0 ăăă
$ă) ă
ă
ăă
ăă ăă
ă
ăăăăă0ăăăU+ăăă
ă ă
ăă
ăă ă
ă djÎ ăăă('ă0
ăă
ă
ă.ăă
5ă ) ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă !-ă ă
ă ă ă ă ă ('ă !-ă ă ă ă
ăă .ăăă
ăăăăă0ăă ă ă ăă ă0
ă ă
ă
ă
ă('+ă .ă ă ă
ă ă 0ă ă ă ă !-ă
#ă ) ă
ă
ă ă
ă ă ă ă !-ă ă
ăă.ăăă
ăă0ăăă
ăă jNÎ
ă('+ă Î Î Î Î Î
1/29/2019
Exhibit E, Page
2:46:52
165PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-6 Filed 01/29/19 Page 1 of 9 Page ID #:166
([KLELW)
1/29/2019
Exhibit F, Page
2:46:59
166PM
Ʋ³³²³Æ²²³²³²³Æ² Ƴ³²² Ƴ³²² ³Æ²³³²Æ³² ² Ƴ³²³³Æ@@?@?@@?@@?@ ? @ ?@?@? @ ?@?@ @??@Æ
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-6 Filed 01/29/19 Page 2 of 9 Page ID #:167
%0:/Nŀ
, m|¸ hu¸ E¸ `u¸
, !(8*28= 4= 0+K
ō +K
402642= *8= (1=
, (8*= 4.= !(8*28= ħ @AK K
K
t:!ŀ
< G[ [ < .<)78< <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< <
CVM =Q^ VZQS^ P
Eă t:!ŀ
, [
_ă 9 E?EV
5Y ETL EQ^ 2 VSCZ AY X^ S
^
2ă %!"%+, *"!#%)( , iÀă
!ŀ D_ă
, ''$&+, #', $%, ¸ÁçV
2ă V
ă ¸
P%2ă »ă
^ :E=VX^
, ,(.^
, [
ă J _ ă ^ Vă
ă ă
ă z
ă ă ă ă "" ă
, N
_ă "EA
^ ^ ^
ă "
2ă ă ă ă"ă
, ,1 ^ ^ O
^ ^
^ "#5 3(26(1/^
ă
, $MEOC^ SG^5 E=VAL^ ă ,
, "
ă
ă ă ă
vă
,
, P2ă , s2ă , P2ă ,[2ă NEWă ^ ă ă {ă ă vă
, s2ă , ,
,
, P2ă ,
,
, P2ă NEWă ^ ă ă ă ă vă
, ,
,
,
,
,
, NEWă ^ ă ă ă
ă ă vă
,
, NEWă ^ ă ă ă ă vă
NEWă ^ ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ăNEWă ^ 2ă
, 3 EGEVEQ AEX^ MYEC^
NEWă ^ ă ă"ă ă ă
t:ă
[DxJDă z}XtixJD:ă D ă
ă ă ă "%ă
ă wă ă ă ă ă
ă
ă
< *[ [ < )2< < <
< *[ [ < #)1< <<
< *[ [
< .)78< < < ^ O=MP^ ^ "V=\M Q K ^5L EEY X^
1/29/2019
Exhibit F, Page
2:46:59
167PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-6 Filed 01/29/19 Page 3 of 9 Page ID #:168
$A
u9u
Q¸
1/29/2019
Exhibit F, Page
2:46:59
168PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-6 Filed 01/29/19 Page 4 of 9 Page ID #:169
Î
Æ
1/29/2019
Exhibit F, Page
2:46:59
169PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-6 Filed 01/29/19 Page 5 of 9 Page ID #:170
Î
8u
P¸
1/29/2019
Exhibit F, Page
2:46:59
170PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-6 Filed 01/29/19 Page 6 of 9 Page ID #:171
Æ
Î
1/29/2019
Exhibit F, Page
2:46:59
171PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-6 Filed 01/29/19 Page 7 of 9 Page ID #:172
X¸
dÆ
Î
O¸
1/29/2019
Exhibit F, Page
2:46:59
172PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-6 Filed 01/29/19 Page 8 of 9 Page ID #:173
Bu
1/29/2019
Exhibit F, Page
2:46:59
173PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-6 Filed 01/29/19 Page 9 of 9 Page ID #:174
cÆ
Î
N¸
1/29/2019
Exhibit F, Page
2:46:59
174PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-7 Filed 01/29/19 Page 1 of 9 Page ID #:175
([KLELW*
1/29/2019
Exhibit G, Page
2:47:05
175PM
Ʋ³³²³Æ²²³²³²³Æ² Ƴ³²² Ƴ³²² ³Æ²³³²Æ³² ² Ƴ³²³³Æ@@?@?@@?@@?@ ? ?@@ ?@? @ ?@?@ @??@Æ
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-7 Filed 01/29/19 Page 2 of 9 Page ID #:176
%0:/;ŀ
, m|¸ hu¸ E¸ `u¸
, !(8*28= 4= 0+K ō +K
402642=
, (8*= 4.=!(8*28= ħ @AK K
K
, $3 .#^ 55#. ,:^$13^ ^ 3# 8#^
< *[ [ < .)78< < <
< < [ < .)78< < < < <<< < < <
Eă nt:yŀ
Î ă "ă Bă
, [
_ă 9 E?EV
5Y ETL EQ^ 2 VSCZ AY X^ S
^
2ă
m xŀ D_ă
%!"%+, *"!#%)( , iÀă
, ''$&+, #', $%, ¸ÁçV
2ă V
ă ¸
^ :E=VX^
P%2ă »ă
, [
ă J _ ă ^ , ,(.^
, N
_ă "EA
^ ^ ^ Eă
ă ă
ăz
ă ă ă {ă "
ăă ă
"" ă
, $MEOC^ SG^5 E=VAL^ ă ,
, NEWă ^ ă ă ă ă ă ă ă "
ă wă ă
,
, P2ă , s2ă , P2ă ,[2ă "" ă
, NEWă ^ ă ă ă
ă ă vă
NEWă ^ ă ă ă ă vă
, 3 EGEVEQ AEX^ MYEC^
NEWă ^ ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ă ăNEWă ^ 2ă
t:ă
[DxJDă z}XtixJD:ă NEWă ^ ă ă"ă ă ă
D ă
ă ă ă "%ă
ă wă ă ă ă ă
< *[ [ < )2< < <
ă
ă
< *[ [ < #)1< <<
< *[ [
< .)78< < <
< *[ [
< .)78< < < ^ O=MP^ ^ "V=\M Q K ^5L EEY X^
1/29/2019
Exhibit G, Page
2:47:05
176PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-7 Filed 01/29/19 Page 3 of 9 Page ID #:177
^_u
1/29/2019
Exhibit G, Page
2:47:05
177PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-7 Filed 01/29/19 Page 4 of 9 Page ID #:178
Î
Æ
Au
1/29/2019
Exhibit G, Page
2:47:05
178PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-7 Filed 01/29/19 Page 5 of 9 Page ID #:179
1/29/2019
Exhibit G, Page
2:47:05
179PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-7 Filed 01/29/19 Page 6 of 9 Page ID #:180
1/29/2019
Exhibit G, Page
2:47:05
180PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-7 Filed 01/29/19 Page 7 of 9 Page ID #:181
ó ô ÷ õ öħ
Q h { ÆLÆ
Ńō
¸ <u >A :A
Q
C
<
? Î
=#X
.A
;A 76¸
\Æ £Æ0A
¹Æ
ō
9
ýō1 2 8 34 5 3 A ēō
1/29/2019
Exhibit G, Page
2:47:05
181PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-7 Filed 01/29/19 Page 8 of 9 Page ID #:182
@u
1/29/2019
Exhibit G, Page
2:47:05
182PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-7 Filed 01/29/19 Page 9 of 9 Page ID #:183
BFbiIGIB?iF¸[G¸ B[ccFBiI[Z¸
. . . . . YĝĩĤŀ IJħ ŀ
.. . .
Øħ
ħ ,Eħ ħ ħ--
ħ ħ ħ +Ďa Eħ -ħ ħ ħ
ħ á
ħ åħ
ħ +Đħ , ,ħ
ħ
Hħ +üH»ħ
ČĬ%į$ōĵ+ĩ$9ōc%$IJō|àÕō+mmō%JōcHľ$H%JKïō
gGĪI,4ōFI4ō g,Fİ,4ō7nGĸō
čĿ,I7q7nGp4ōôFqō oħōĀĠ7oĚ,pō Y ± Y ō
1/29/2019
Exhibit G, Page
2:47:05
183PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-8 Filed 01/29/19 Page 1 of 7 Page ID #:184
([KLELW+
1/29/2019
Exhibit H, Page
2:47:10
184PM
Ʋ³³²³Æ²²³²³²³Æ² Ƴ³²² Ƴ³²² ³Æ²³³²Æ³² ² Ƴ³²³³Æ@@?@?@@?@@?@ @ @??@?@? @ ?@?@ @??@Æ
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-8 Filed 01/29/19 Page 2 of 7 Page ID #:185
%0:/<ŀ
, m|¸ hu¸ E¸ `u¸
, *4E9>EK (?K 0+K ō +K
%?<>C?>K 9EK 4=K
, #4E9K ?:K*4E9>EK ħ @AK K
K
Eă *t:+ŀ
, [
_ă 9 E?EV
5Y ETL EQ^ 2 VSCZ AY X^ ##é2ă
2ă Î ă "ă Bă
* +ŀ D_ă
%!"%+, *"!#%)( , iÀă
$ă :E=VX^
, ''$&+, #', $%, ¸ÁçV
2ă V
ă ¸
P%2ă »ă
, [
ă J _ ăR=Ñ=5Î/IIă
, ,(.^
, N
_ă "EA
^ #Îă RIIFă
Vă
ă ă
ă
ăă ă ă ă wă ă
, à/âă O
^ ă I/çIRă
,1 ^ "" ă
, NEWă Fă ă ă ă ă vă
NEWă $ă ă ă ă
ă ă vă 2ă
, 3 EGEVEQ AEX^ MYEC^ NEWă5ăăăăă 2ă ăă ă"
ăăă
ă
t:ă
[DxJDă z}XtixJD:ă D ă
ă ă ă "%ă
ă wă ă ă ă ă
< *[ [ < )2< < <
ă
ă
< *[ [ < #)1< <<
< *[ [
< .)78< < < ă O=MP^ 5ă "V=\M Q K ^5L EEY X^
1/29/2019
Exhibit H, Page
2:47:10
185PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-8 Filed 01/29/19 Page 3 of 7 Page ID #:186
Æ
Î
?u
1/29/2019
Exhibit H, Page
2:47:10
186PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-8 Filed 01/29/19 Page 4 of 7 Page ID #:187
Nu
Î
Æ
]u
1/29/2019
Exhibit H, Page
2:47:10
187PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-8 Filed 01/29/19 Page 5 of 7 Page ID #:188
[u
Î
Æ
>u
1/29/2019
Exhibit H, Page
2:47:10
188PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-8 Filed 01/29/19 Page 6 of 7 Page ID #:189
1/29/2019
Exhibit H, Page
2:47:10
189PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-8 Filed 01/29/19 Page 7 of 7 Page ID #:190
Æ
X
Î
Æ
1/29/2019
Exhibit H, Page
2:47:10
190PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-9 Filed 01/29/19 Page 1 of 9 Page ID #:191
([KLELW,
1/29/2019
Exhibit I, Page
2:47:14
191P
Ʋ³³²³Æ²²³²³²³Æ² Ƴ³²² Ƴ³²² ³Æ²³³²Æ³² ³²Æ²³² Æ??@@? ?@@?@@?@ @ ??@@?@? @ ?@?@ @??@Æ
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-9 Filed 01/29/19 Page 2 of 9 Page ID #:192
%0À;/ŀ
, m|¸ hu¸ E¸ `u¸
, *4E9>EK (?K 0+K ō +K
%?<>C?>K
, #4E9K ?:K*4E9>EK ħ )7EK
K
K
, $3 .#^ 55#. ,:^$13^ ^ 3# 8#^
< *[ [ < .)78< < <
< < [ < .)78< < < < <<< < < <
Eă kt:vŀ
Î ă "ă Bă
, [
_ă 9 E?EV
5Y ETL EQ^ 2 VSCZ AY X^ S
^
2ă
j uŀ D_ă
%!"%+, *"!#%)( , iÀă
, ''$&+, #', $%, ¸ÁçV
ă V
ă ¸
^ :E=VX^
P%2ă »ă
, [
ă J _ ă ^ , ,(.^
, N
_ă "EA
^ ^ ^ Eă
ă ă
ă
ăă ă ă "
ă wă ă
"" ă
, $MEOC^ SG^5 E=VAL^ ă ,
, NEWă ^ ă ă ă ă ă ă ă "
ă wă ă
,
, P2ă , s2ă , P2ă ,[2ă "" ă
, NEWă ^ ă ă ă ă vă
NEWă ^ ă ă"ă ăă ă ă "ă vă
, 3 EGEVEQ AEX^ MYEC^
NEWă ^ ă ăă ă ă NEWă ^ 2ă
t:ă
[DxJDă z}XtixJD:ă NEWă ^ ă ă {ă ă ăNEWă ^
D ă
ă ă ă "%ă
ă wă ă ă ă ă
< *[ [ < )2< < <
ă
ă
< *[ [ < #)1< <<
< *[ [
< .)78< < <
< *[ [
< .)78< < < ^ O=MP^ ^ "V=\M Q K ^5L EEY X^
1/29/2019
Exhibit I, Page
2:47:14
192P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-9 Filed 01/29/19 Page 3 of 9 Page ID #:193
;Î
u
¸
1/29/2019
Exhibit I, Page
2:47:14
193P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-9 Filed 01/29/19 Page 4 of 9 Page ID #:194
M¸
1/29/2019
Exhibit I, Page
2:47:14
194P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-9 Filed 01/29/19 Page 5 of 9 Page ID #:195
Î
u
L¸
1/29/2019
Exhibit I, Page
2:47:14
195P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-9 Filed 01/29/19 Page 6 of 9 Page ID #:196
yÎ
*C
zÎ
Î
bÆ
1/29/2019
Exhibit I, Page
2:47:14
196P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-9 Filed 01/29/19 Page 7 of 9 Page ID #:197
1/29/2019
Exhibit I, Page
2:47:14
197P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-9 Filed 01/29/19 Page 8 of 9 Page ID #:198
y¸
:Î
u
M¸
1/29/2019
Exhibit I, Page
2:47:14
198P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-9 Filed 01/29/19 Page 9 of 9 Page ID #:199
Î
u
K¸
1/29/2019
Exhibit I, Page
2:47:14
199P
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-10 Filed 01/29/19 Page 1 of 6 Page ID #:200
([KLELW-
1/29/2019
Exhibit J, Page
2:47:18
200PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-10 Filed 01/29/19 Page 2 of 6 Page ID #:201
1/29/2019
Exhibit J, Page
2:47:18
201PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-10 Filed 01/29/19 Page 3 of 6 Page ID #:202
1/29/2019
Exhibit J, Page
2:47:18
202PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-10 Filed 01/29/19 Page 4 of 6 Page ID #:203
1/29/2019
Exhibit J, Page
2:47:18
203PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-10 Filed 01/29/19 Page 5 of 6 Page ID #:204
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JVzOyrlm3zs
1/29/2019
Exhibit J, Page
2:47:18
204PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-10 Filed 01/29/19 Page 6 of 6 Page ID #:205
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FP1jMagnrGs
1/29/2019
Exhibit J, Page
2:47:18
205PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-11 Filed 01/29/19 Page 1 of 5 Page ID #:206
([KLELW.
1/29/2019
Exhibit K, Page
2:47:20
206PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-11 Filed 01/29/19 Page 2 of 5 Page ID #:207
1/29/2019
Exhibit K, Page
2:47:20
207PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-11 Filed 01/29/19 Page 3 of 5 Page ID #:208
1/29/2019
Exhibit K, Page
2:47:20
208PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-11 Filed 01/29/19 Page 4 of 5 Page ID #:209
1/29/2019
Exhibit K, Page
2:47:20
209PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-11 Filed 01/29/19 Page 5 of 5 Page ID #:210
1/29/2019
Exhibit K, Page
2:47:20
210PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-12 Filed 01/29/19 Page 1 of 9 Page ID #:211
([KLELW/
1/29/2019
Exhibit L, Page
2:47:22
211PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-12 Filed 01/29/19 Page 2 of 9 Page ID #:212
1/29/2019
Exhibit L, Page
2:47:22
212PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-12 Filed 01/29/19 Page 3 of 9 Page ID #:213
1/29/2019
Exhibit L, Page
2:47:22
213PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-12 Filed 01/29/19 Page 4 of 9 Page ID #:214
1/29/2019
Exhibit L, Page
2:47:22
214PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-12 Filed 01/29/19 Page 5 of 9 Page ID #:215
1/29/2019
Exhibit L, Page
2:47:22
215PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-12 Filed 01/29/19 Page 6 of 9 Page ID #:216
1/29/2019
Exhibit L, Page
2:47:22
216PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-12 Filed 01/29/19 Page 7 of 9 Page ID #:217
ŚƚƚƉƐ͗ͬͬǁǁǁ͘ďŝŶŐ͘ĐŽŵͬǀŝĚĞŽƐͬƐĞĂƌĐŚ͍ƋсǁĞďĞƌнƚĞůĞǀŝƐŝŽŶнĐŽŵŵĞƌĐŝĂůƐΘĚŽĐŝĚсϲϬϴϬϮϭϰϰϲϭϲϴϲϭϮϯϴϯΘŵŝĚсϲϭϴϰϰϵϲϯ&ϯϲϳϯ
ϲ&ϭϲϭϴϰϰϵϲϯ&ϯϲϳϯϲ&ϭΘǀŝĞǁсĚĞƚĂŝůΘ&KZDсs/Z
1/29/2019
Exhibit L, Page
2:47:22
217PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-12 Filed 01/29/19 Page 8 of 9 Page ID #:218
1/29/2019
Exhibit L, Page
2:47:22
218PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-12 Filed 01/29/19 Page 9 of 9 Page ID #:219
1/29/2019
Exhibit L, Page
2:47:22
219PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-13 Filed 01/29/19 Page 1 of 6 Page ID #:220
([KLELW0
1/29/2019
Exhibit M, Page
2:47:26
220
PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-13 Filed 01/29/19 Page 2 of 6 Page ID #:221
1/29/2019
Exhibit M, Page
2:47:26
221
PM
KWWSZZZZHEHUFRPZHEHUQDWLRQEORJERUQLQFKLFDJRORYHGDOORYHUWKHZRUOG
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-13 Filed 01/29/19 Page 3 of 6 Page ID #:222
$SULO
'$11<(&.(521632576
7KHVLOKRXHWWHRIDURXQG:HEHUJULOOZLOODGRUQWKHOHIWFHQWHUILHOGZDOODW:ULJOH\
)LHOGWKLV\HDUXQGHUDQHZVSRQVRUVKLSGHDOEHWZHHQWKH&KLFDJR&XEVDQGWKH
3DODWLQHEDVHGFRPSDQ\
7KH1RUWK6LGHUVWKLVPRQWKVLJQHGDPXOWL\HDUDJUHHPHQWZLWK:HEHU6WHSKHQ
3URGXFWV//&DVWKHRIILFLDOJULOORIWKHWHDP
,W
VD&KLFDJREDVHGFRPSDQ\WKDW
VV\QRQ\PRXVZLWKWKLQJV\RX
GWKLQNRIZKHQ
\RXWKLQNRIWKH&XEVDQG:ULJOH\)LHOGOLNHVXPPHUDQGJULOOLQJVDLG&ROLQ
)DXONQHU&XEVYLFHSUHVLGHQWRIVDOHVDQGSDUWQHUVKLSV
:HEHUZLOOQRWEHSDUWRIWKHWHDP
VQHZ/HJDF\3DUWQHUSURJUDPZKLFKFXUUHQWO\
FRQVLVWVRI8QGHU$UPRXU$QKHXVHU%XVFK,Q%HY19DQG6WDUZRRG+RWHOV
5HVRUWV:RUOGZLGH,QFDVWKHWHDP
VELJJHVWVSHQGLQJVSRQVRUV
%XWLW
VRQHRIPDQ\QHZVSRQVRUVWKDWZLOOKHOSWKHWHDPILOOWKRXVDQGVRIVTXDUHIHHWRIQHZO\DSSURYHGDGVLJQDJH
DURXQGWKHSDUNXQGHUWKH:ULJOH\)LHOGUHQRYDWLRQSURMHFW
6HSDUDWHO\WKH&XEVVLJQHGDQHZRQH\HDUGHDOZLWK.UDIW)RRGV*URXS,QFWRKDQGOHWKHWHDP
V'HFDGH'LQHU
GRZQWKHULJKWILHOGOLQHIRUPHUO\NQRZQDVWKH6KHIILHOG*ULOO
.UDIWZKLFKLVFHOHEUDWLQJLWVWK\HDURIFKHHVHPDNLQJLQZLOOEHPDNLQJWKHPHGUHFLSHVWRJRDORQJZLWK
WKHWHDP
VGHFDGHWKHPHGKRPHVWDQGV
7KHSDFNDJHGIRRGVFRPSDQ\SUHYLRXVO\KDGDVSRQVRUVKLSGHDOZLWKWKHWHDPWKDWSXWDODUJHPDFDURQLDQGFKHHVH
QRRGOHRXWVLGHWKHEDOOSDUNLQUHFHQW\HDUV
7+(
&8%%,(
'28*+187
&XEVVSRQVRU'XQNLQ
'RQXWVWRGD\LVRIIHULQJ7KH&XEELH²D&XEVWKHPHGGRXJKQXWWKDWZLOOEHRQVDOHLQWKH
&KLFDJRDUHDWKURXJK$SULO
8SWRLQSURFHHGVIURPWKHVDOHRIWKHVSHFLDOW\GRXJKQXWZLOOJRWRZDUG&KLFDJR&XEV&KDULWLHV
)RUPHU&XEVJUHDW)HUJLH-HQNLQVZLOOEHDWWKH'XQNLQ
ORFDWLRQRQ$GGLVRQ6WUHHWQHDU:ULJOH\)LHOGEHIRUHWKH&XEV
KRPHRSHQHURQ$SULOWRJUHHWIDQVDQGKDQGRXWGRXJKQXWV
1/29/2019
Exhibit M, Page
2:47:26
222
PM
KWWSZZZFKLFDJREXVLQHVVFRPDUWLFOH%/2*6FXEVLQNQHZVSRQVRUVKLSGHDOVZLWKZHEHUJULOONUDIW
&RPPHUFLDO6HULHV%X &RPPHUFLDO6HULHV%X )LUHER[*
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-13 Filed
01/29/19 Page 4 of 6 Page ID #:223
%8<12: %8<12: %8<12:
FKDUEURLOFRP
CHICAGO -- When the Chicago Cubs kick off the 100th anniversary of Wrigley
Field celebration Friday, they'll do so without a giant Budweiser sign in the
outfield.
The much-debated Bud sign won't be up for Opening Day, the Cubs confirmed
to ESPN Chicago. The sign, and the planned videoboard in left field, have been
at the forefront of the year-plus squabbling with the rooftop owners, who have a
contract to protect their views. The Cubs had intimated the Budweiser sign, part
of a new 10-year, $140 million exclusive marketing deal, will be up this season.
1/29/2019
Exhibit M, Page
2:47:26
223
PM
KWWSHVSQJRFRPEORJFKLFDJRFXEVSRVWBLGQREXGVLJQEXWZHEHUWRGHEXWIRURSHQHU
Instead, the Cubs will debut a much smaller outfield wall sign.
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-13 Filed 01/29/19 Page 5 of 6 Page ID #:224
The Cubs inked a new multiyear partnership with Weber and the Chicago-based
grill manufacturer is getting ad placement on a small outfield door. Joining
Target and Under Armour, there will be a white silhouette of Weber's signature
round grill mixed in the iconic ivy-covered wall.
"We think it's a company that's synonymous with baseball, the summer,
drinking beer, and it's a local Chicago-based company," Cubs vice president of
sales and partnerships Colin Faulkner said.
The Cubs were approved to add 45,000 square feet of new advertising in regard
to the $500 million planned expansion of Wrigley Field and the surrounding
campus, but don't expect to see a glut of new ads around the park this season.
As of Tuesday, the Cubs could only confirm the Weber sign.
But that doesn't stop the Cubs from signing new deals. Weber joins Kraft and
Giordano's as high-profile new sponsors this season. Kraft is partnering with
the Cubs at the "Decade Diner," formerly known as Sheffield Grill near Gate D,
to serve themed food to honor the Wrigley centennial.
The Cubs are also implementing a pilot program to introduce mobile ticketing
for season-ticket holders. A cross-section of season-ticket holders will be invited
to participate in the program, which will allow them to manage, distribute and
scan season tickets for use at the park. The White Sox instituted a similar
program last year and have expanded it this season to all ticket holders who buy
online.
The Cubs are also testing out a rewards program in conjunction with the mobile
option in a control group of season-ticket holders. Fans who make use of the
mobile option will be given points that are redeemable for experiences and
prizes.
"We want to test the rewards program and see if it influences people's
behavior," Faulkner said.
While the Cubs are intent on going digital with tickets, they've also managed to
1/29/2019
Exhibit M, Page
2:47:26
224
PM
KWWSHVSQJRFRPEORJFKLFDJRFXEVSRVWBLGQREXGVLJQEXWZHEHUWRGHEXWIRURSHQHU
create a good problem by making their ticket presentation so well designed.
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document
Even fans who 1-13
buy tickets Filed
online 01/29/19
often Page
ask the ticket 6 of 6 Page
department ID #:225
for paper
copies.
5HFRPPHQGHGE\
1/29/2019
Exhibit M, Page
2:47:26
225
PM
KWWSHVSQJRFRPEORJFKLFDJRFXEVSRVWBLGQREXGVLJQEXWZHEHUWRGHEXWIRURSHQHU
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-14 Filed 01/29/19 Page 1 of 4 Page ID #:226
([KLELW1
1/29/2019
Exhibit N, Page
2:47:27
226PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-14 Filed 01/29/19 Page 2 of 4 Page ID #:227
1/29/2019
Exhibit N, Page
2:47:27
227PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-14 Filed 01/29/19 Page 3 of 4 Page ID #:228
1/29/2019
Exhibit N, Page
2:47:27
228PM
Case 5:19-cv-00179 Document 1-14 Filed 01/29/19 Page 4 of 4 Page ID #:229
1/29/2019
Exhibit N, Page
2:47:27
229PM