Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
DECISIONS AT OVANIA
CHEMICALS
1
SYNOPSIS OF THE CASE STUDY
2
The company decided to redesign it’s employees jobs.
The plant needed new System Analysers to monitor the individual steps
3
Pneumatics Job
Hydraulics Specification
IT
Programming
Electrical Wiring
Finger Dexterity
Mechanical Compensation
Numerical Ability,
Spatial Ability
Visual Pursuit,
4
Detection.
Three men currently working and three new men were to be recruited.
The consultants did job analysis and found out the job description.
5
Job
Description
Trouble Shooting
Record Keeping
Routing Maintenance
6
The panel will qualify a candidate only if he/she had all the above qualities
mandatory.
The committee decided to recruit the new blood as well as promote within
the organization.
7
For next two years, no change in positions.
For the recruitment, only ability and aptitude factors are considered and not
Some of the committee members doubt if women and the minority members
8
A concern that Ovania will be accused of prejudices if women or members
analyzers-2/3.
candidate.
9
For the specific job of system analyzer, no normative or validity data.
10
SOLUTIONS
As two of the three existing System Analysts are re-applying for the job,
it shows they are interested to work with the new technologies. So, the
organization must motivate them by training them for the new job and
allow them to continue in the same field of work. And also since they
have been working for so long in the same field, they already must be
having basic knowledge about the field even though new technologies
are coming-in.
11
The organization could collaborate with a consultancy to carry on
and understand the recruitment process better and also the same
prejudice charges.
12
The company can also consider other System Analysts working in
13
QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS
Strategic analysis
14
Take the subject matter experts, managers, supervisors , etc…
identified and tasks and KSA’s having greatest changes are isolated
15
2. Do you think the abilities chosen for selection are content valid?
selection?
Yes , the abilities chosen for selection are content valid as the abilities
match the skills required for the job of a systems analyzer. The other
16
3. What reasons did the selection committee have for selecting only those
The company was ready to take up candidates with the skills that could
the requirement of the job was not immediate, they wanted to hire
17
4. Should the concern for women getting down into the dirty treatment tanks
have been a selection issue ? How might you include this factor in a
selection battery?
Yes, the concern for women getting down into the dirty treatment tanks
have been a selection issue . The management feels that women might not
This factor could be resolved by asking for the approval of the women
candidates during the time of their selection for the system analyst position.
18
5. For the abilities termed critical what score should someone receive in order to
be considered scoring “well” on that test? How should the test scores be
the test.
people who are good in each of these critical areas. If we used a compensatory
or combination method, candidate who are very good in one field and
average or below average in another might also get selected, which would
19
6. Which three candidates seem most qualified? What are your reservations ,
if any , about this recommendation?
The three candidates who qualify the most are Sara E, Sherman A, and
2 W &1 B
20
7. Would this test battery and selection procedure be defensible in
court?
Yes, they can be defensible because the candidates are selected based on the
scores given here. Hence the factual data provided supports our selection .
21
IMPLICATIONS
22
THANK YOU
23