19/2/2019 GUIDELINES HELP SELECT STORAGE TANK CALIBRATION METHOD - Oil & Gas Journal

Aging paper and print quality made scanning dif cult on some of the older magazines. Please
excuse any misprints or typos.

GUIDELINES HELP SELECT STORAGE

TANK CALIBRATION METHOD
02/05/1990

S. Sivaraman
Exxon Research & Engineering Co.
Florham Park, N.J.

Guidelines have been developed to help owners and operators of vertical, cylindrical storage
tanks determine the best technology to calibrate their speci c tanks, and the circumstances
under which they are used.

For more than half a century, vertical, cylindrical storage tanks have been calibrated by the
manual strapping method. In that method, calibrated measuring tapes are used to measure the
circumference of the tank at several elevations.

But during the past decade, new technologies for tank calibration have emerged, and many of
these methods are in the nal stages of standardization by national and international
standards organizations. These new technologies offer advantages toward improved safety,
accuracy, and ef ciency in the overall spectrum of tank calibration.

Guidelines are presented in this article for xed-roof designs and for both internal and external
oating-roof designs. The guidelines also take speci c construction details into account.

BACKGROUND

The manual strapping method, the oldest method of tank calibration, was introduced as a
standard in the early 1960's by standards organizations such as the American Petroleum
Institute (API) and the Institute of Petroleum (IP).

https://www.ogj.com/articles/print/volume-88/issue-6/in-this-issue/refining/guidelines-help-select-storage-tank-calibration-method.html 1/6
19/2/2019 GUIDELINES HELP SELECT STORAGE TANK CALIBRATION METHOD - Oil & Gas Journal

The optical methods developed during the early 1970's are now commercially available for
routine application. These new methods have attained a level of maturity comparable to, and in
many instances better than, the manual method. Table 1 summarizes all available methods and
the appropriate industry standards for their application.

Here is a brief overview of the different methods of calibration. It is a quick and easy reference
and will help promote better understanding of the guidelines for their applications.

TECHNOLOGIES

Only those methods which are already standardized or which are currently in the process of
standardization are discussed, although there are other methods such as the photogrammetric
and the laser imaging technology which are also commercially available. These methods may
well be considered for standardization later.

MANUAL STRAPPING

The manual strapping method involves strapping each ring of a tank with a certi ed tape. As
the tank diameters and the tank heights increase it becomes dif cult to tape the tank
uniformly due to tape sag, tank indentations, and the limited length of tapes. Nonetheless, it is
a popular method, and may still be a cost-effective application in many cases.'

LIQUID CALIBRATION

Liquid calibration is considered the most accurate and the most preferred method of
calibration where and when possible. This method consists of metering a known quantity of
liquid and gauging the tank at regular height intervals to develop a capacity table .2

It is time consuming and may not lend itself for easy and quick application. However, under
certain circumstances this may be the only available option for calibration.

OPTICAL REFERENCE LINE

The optical reference line method, which can be applied internally or externally, uses an optical
theodolite to establish a perpendicular ray in a vertical plane.'

With this optical ray, the deviations in the tank diameters at various course heights are
measured with respect to a reference offset at the bottom course.

In addition, the reference circumference is measured at the bottom course. These deviations
together with the reference offset and the reference circumference are then translated into
https://www.ogj.com/articles/print/volume-88/issue-6/in-this-issue/refining/guidelines-help-select-storage-tank-calibration-method.html 2/6
19/2/2019 GUIDELINES HELP SELECT STORAGE TANK CALIBRATION METHOD - Oil & Gas Journal

appropriate tank diameters.

OPTICAL TRIANGULATION

Optical triangulation can be applied internally or externally.4 The principle of this method is
that a tank pro le can be de ned by triangulation with two theodolites and a target point on
the tank, or with one theodolite and two target points on the tank at a number of stations
around the tank.

For external application, depending on the tank height, a minimum space around the tank will
be required to apply this method. This method, already in use in some countries, is in the nal
stages of standardization within the International Standardization Organization (ISO).

ELECTRO OPTICAL DISTANCE RANGING

Electro-optical distance ranging currently under development towards standardization within

ISO, is primarily intended for internal calibration. With 'a single optical laser, and a distance
ranging device and on-line computer, circumferential target points on the tank shell wall, for
any given course, are mathematically and statistically analyzed almost instantaneously to give
the required course diameter. The calibration can be accomplished from the ground level by
one person. This method is presently in use in Europe.

SELECTION FACTORS

The type of calibration method that one may select may often be dictated by a number of
factors. These factors are broadly grouped into the following:

Type of tank: oating or xed roof

Operational constraints: entry or no entry

Insulation or no insulation
Riveted or welded
Other parameters such as number/size of wind girders.

Selection of any speci c method for each of the above factors is presented in the form of
decision charts (Figs. 1, 2, and 3). In the development of these guidelines, it is assumed that the
insulation requirements pertain only to the xed roof tanks.

Also, the term entry, as applied to the oating roof tanks, refers to access onto the top of the
oating roof with the roof resting on its legs. The bottom calibration requirements are not

https://www.ogj.com/articles/print/volume-88/issue-6/in-this-issue/refining/guidelines-help-select-storage-tank-calibration-method.html 3/6
19/2/2019 GUIDELINES HELP SELECT STORAGE TANK CALIBRATION METHOD - Oil & Gas Journal

considered separately, because they would belong to the same category where entry is
required or permitted.

For each category, technology selections are presented in a prioritized order. The priority
recommended is based upon the most expedient way of calibration for a given set of
conditions, ensuring overall accuracy.

However, the recommended priority is not intended necessarily to optimize the overall cost of
calibration. The cost factor associated with any given method is dependent on many factors.

CALIBRATION COSTS

Generally, the on-site cost of calibration of one tank may be expensive compared to the
conventional manual method when new technologies are considered. However, with routine
application and with the support and encouragement of the petrochemical and re ning
industries, the new technologies can be cost effective in the long run. In general, the following
factors can be expected to affect the cost of calibration:

Number of tanks available at any given time

Size of tanks: diameter and height

Cost of auxiliary and support services necessary such as power supply, scaffolding (if
required)

Cost of stripping and reinstallation of sections of insulation where and when required

Ultrasonic thickness measurements, if required, as part of calibration

Cost of bottom surveys where and when speci ed

Availability of calibration contractor locally or on-site proximity to minimize travel costs

Calibration work done on a straight-time basis or on overtime basis.

In addition, there are indirect costs involved. These include such costs as the down time, cost of
gas freeing and preparing a tank for safe entry, removal of insulation across the whole tank,
and its reinstallation where needed.

https://www.ogj.com/articles/print/volume-88/issue-6/in-this-issue/refining/guidelines-help-select-storage-tank-calibration-method.html 4/6
19/2/2019 GUIDELINES HELP SELECT STORAGE TANK CALIBRATION METHOD - Oil & Gas Journal

The direct cost of calibration is dependent on the type of method and the factors detailed
above, while the indirect costs are site dependent. In the selection of any speci c method, both
the direct and indirect costs may have to be considered in some cases. In most instances,
however, only the direct cost may be the deciding factor. The indirect costs may often be
treated as an integral part of the plant's operating or maintenance expenses.

It is appropriate to point out that the cost of calibration of tanks often becomes an issue for
intense debate and lengthy discussions. It is important to relate the cost to the frequency of
calibration.

Considering the fact that tanks undergo recalibration once every 10-15 years, the cost of
calibration, when prorated over this period, will indeed prove to be small if not insigni cant.
While the cost factor is no doubt important, it may not necessarily be the most decisive factor
in the selection of any one method. Other advantages a speci c technology has to offer, such as
safety, accuracy expediency, and ef ciency, should also be considered in arriving at a nal
decision in the overall technology selection and its application.

New technologies using optical devices provide quicker, safer methods with accuracy
comparable to, and most likely better than, the manual method. The tank owner now has a
much wider choice and exibility in the selection of any method.

Application of guidelines presented here will facilitate tank owners in selecting the most
desirable if not the optimal technology for application.

Using the decision charts, once a set of options is chosen, a calibration contractor may be
requested to bid for each of the options. Such a bid should be based on a sound and a well-
documented technical speci cation. Depending on speci c site conditions and local
requirements, any one method could prove to be cost effective.

Finally, it is hoped that by assisting in the selection of the right technology, the guidelines will
promote technology application in its entirety, and avoid combination of different methods
that could lead to erroneous applications and compromise on recommended procedures. The
guidelines developed here are based on the experience of the author and most certainly do not
re ect the views of individual companies or standards organizations. The nal decision toward
selection of any one method may eventually be dictated by internal policies, local regulations,
and budget constraints.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

The author acknowledges the contribution of H. (Hank) S. Moore and D. (Dale) A. Rose of E.W.
Saybolt Co., Inc. in preparation of these guidelines.

https://www.ogj.com/articles/print/volume-88/issue-6/in-this-issue/refining/guidelines-help-select-storage-tank-calibration-method.html 5/6
19/2/2019 GUIDELINES HELP SELECT STORAGE TANK CALIBRATION METHOD - Oil & Gas Journal

REFERENCES

1. API Standard 2550 "Method for Measurement and Calibration of Upright Cylindrical
Tanks," American Petroleum Institute, Washington, D.C.

2. API Standard 2555 "Method for Liquid Calibration of Tanks," American Petroleum
Institute, Washington, D.C.

3. API Chapter 2, Section 2B "Calibration of Upright Cylindrical Tanks Using the Optical
Reference Line Method," API, Washington, D.C.

4. ISO, DIS 7507-3 "Volumetric Calibration of Upright Cylindrical Storage Tanks by Optical
Triangulation Method," ISO Draft International Standard.

Copyright 1990 Oil & Gas Journal. All Rights Reserved.

    

About Us | Site Map | Privacy Policy | Terms and Conditions

© 2019 PennWell Corporation. Tulsa, OK All rights reserved.

https://www.ogj.com/articles/print/volume-88/issue-6/in-this-issue/refining/guidelines-help-select-storage-tank-calibration-method.html 6/6