Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 468

Сталик Ханкишиев

Базар,
казан
и дастархан

Фотографии автора

Издательство Астрель
УДК  : ..-
ББК .+(Рос=Рус)-
Х

Художественное оформление и макет


А Б и Д Ч

Х С.
Х Базар, казан и дастархан / Сталик Ханкишиев. — М.: Астрель,  —  с.

 ----
(ООО “Издательство Астрель”)

“Чтобы зритель разглядел величие короля, вокруг него должна быть свита!” — ска-
зал себе Сталик Ханкишиев, кулинарный гуру и известный кулинарный блоггер,
и вдогонку двум бестселлерам — “книге риса” (“Казан, мангал и другие мужские
удовольствия”) и “книге мяса” (“Казан, баран и дастархан”) написал “книгу повсед-
невной восточной еды” — увлекательную историю об альфах и омегах ежедневного
питания людей на Востоке. Получился обаятельный рассказ о подзабытом нами
вкусе самых простых натуральных продуктов: хлеба, чая, молока, фруктов, овощей,
специй... Обстоятельное, приправленное мягким юмором повествование о блюдах,
названия которых знакомы нам до боли (долма, самса и чебурек; халва, нуга и пах-
лава; и торт Наполеон сюда же!) и совсем не знакомы (“пармуда — не то, что вы
подумали”). Композиция книги так же продумана, рациональна и изящна, как ком-
позиция восточного стола: последовательность глав продиктована очередностью
подачи блюд на Востоке. Не будем лукавить: не все рецепты этой книги просты в
исполнении, но, как утверждает её автор, “труд делает жизнь вкуснее”!

УДК  : ..-


ББК .+(Рос=Рус)-

 ----
(ООО “Издательство Астрель”)

© С. Х, текст, иллюстрации, 


© А. Б, Д. Ч,
оформление, 
© ООО “Издательство Астрель”, 
YZ[\]^_`a\

-  .   . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

b_cde f\]g_h
  

ij_g_ k. b_l kp
  !"#", $% & '#"? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ()
  %*+ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(
/    + . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .0(
O 1%$ + . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .02

-$%! . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .03
4'5 +5. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .03
4 /$  . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 06
78  *+ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .23
9-+-+ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .2)
:'%, !*! :<, $%! . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2=
O /& !>+% $@  $%#? A 8'? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . BC
D&$  %? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .B(
9E. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .B3
F& $+$, ! +$, 5*$ . . . . . . . . . . . . B6

qr
ij_g_ m. nj\o
G<'$$5 !#$ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .3(
H, %$5 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .30
O $> . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 36

:<'*$ >%$ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .3)


7$!&  . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
O D%*%   . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6B

F !!&+ %+. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 63
O F*. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6=

F%+5$ – !%" $ '% . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6


  ! . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .)2
F +"8 >$+, $%I ++ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .)=
O F& . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . =0

J 5   5 &. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . =2


K$? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . =6
F  $%. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .=)
>5 $+ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ==
L5 $+. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0
O F> + . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
9'$  :<'* . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6

k~k ij_g_ t. Yj_[Zcda a u_vwcva


45 $ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (((
O D$ !" + . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ((0

F$5 +5 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(0C


M + ''%#$ F-& . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(00
 H  'I. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(03
D #'-+%+. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (0)
s D$5 !$5. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (2(
FE  $%*. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(2=
O
O 9"E  N$ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(BB
9

O%
O%5 '$5 !
 +
+$$ E. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(B6
O
O M'  ++ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(B
M

A
A > . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(3C
A!
A!$ !& ! %<E !> . . . . . . . . .(32
O
O F$ + !'5 8<"+ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(3
F$

P5 !$  *% . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (6(


P5"
- . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(60

 
   . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(62
 

  

   . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(6B
 
-  . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(63

-  . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (66

   . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(6)
 
   . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (6=
     . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (6

  . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .()C
 
 !" # . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ()(

b_cde gdZ]_h

   
k ij_g_ q. xZ[yZdZgaz _ff\dad
P" 'I!% . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .()
O 4"   . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(=C

9$>$ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (==
+& I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(3
 E Q . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (

m~p ij_g_ p. {\|\gZ a c}d`Z


D&+$ >'%$, %5<+&  !!5+&. . . . 0C6
:<& +$ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .0(2
ij_g_ s. €_wv_ c_zc}:
Zd d\Z]aa v f]_vdav\ mmp
A5 +&+ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 006
A5I5 + < & . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .02(
Q+5  . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 020
5  %!5. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 02=
+% —  , > & !%+. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0BC
O%"5, $$  !$ % R$>$ . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0B0
F+ “Q-'%@@”. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0B6

ij_g_ . d hl‚_! mq


A$% <" "? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 03C 
95 @<5. &  . . . . . . . . . 030
F <'*$ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 06C 
 E! 5   8#. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 06B

b_cde d]\deh

   
ij_g_ ƒ. …Z`\†`Z, [Zjz_! mt
/ + $. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .0)=
1$$5 @<5 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0=0
/ '$+ !E. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0=6
/ '$* . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 02
 >+ <" >'? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0B
J $%,  !< . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 06
“Q5 +”,  * “$8@
'&$5”,  * “! @” . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0
7% %#% +* $%#" . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .2C(
S@% — >$ %< . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2CB
A >+ >+! . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2C
K&'$ <"5+ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .2(B

ij_g_ r. …w]}, ‚}fjhd_, aja


xZ†\zw g ‡u\]o_l[^_`\
`\ jˆohd cw[_v_ tk
D%E !-#$$  %#$ M%+ . . . . . . . . . . . . .2(=
SE%<$ $%&  <'*$+ 5<&$ . . . . . . . 202
O T# . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 206

O"$  !@" . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .20)


F+ !5  . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22C
4& '$*& . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 220
T5 + ++ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 226
S&  $!> $%%+. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22=
D%  1$ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2B0
/ 5>$%!. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2B3
J % ! ##&>$ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2B
D!+, %#+, *+ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 233
b_cde †\dg\]d_h
!

   
tsp ij_g_ k~. ‰dZ]Z\ [}Š_`a\
T%$ !-'$ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .26)
F&  <  @%$ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26
95, +5, +5,   %$ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .2)C
D<$5 $$ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .2)0
 %%8 % D!5 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .2)3
O D% – !' $E +$ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2)6

5 ! . G $8 –  . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2=0


 F5 #5 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2=0
F+, $$ +& '5 8'+! . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2=3
ƒ / $ $ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .2=)
: !" >%>! . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2==
4!>& !"+  . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2=
M<+$ R$$8< . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2C
O@+E '$  . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23

tr ij_g_ kk. ‹_`d}: d\z_ a g_]a_‚aa


K<%$+  . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . BC3
D>$ +& . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . BC=
 ! 5  +"  !<$. . . . . . . . . . . . .B(0

qkr ij_g_ km. …_v ^\ o\u fjZg_?


F %$!+  E&!5+ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B0C
O %  E$, ,  >… . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B02

:<'*$ ! !-+$$. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B0B


 $<>&, $  '& . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B0
F 5 %#. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .B2(
 <&$&,  !E  '&> +. . . . . . B26
&  #>$, $$ 5 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . BB2
F$5  . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . BB3
O /& %$% . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . BB

   . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B3C

:@& %$<" E! . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .B6(


   !" #,
  # !" $%&'.

b\yZ-dZ `\ Šg_d_\d r

П
]\[cd_gjhˆ, †dZ g} [wz_\d\ Z ]_‚aZ`\ `_]Z- x]\[acjZga\
[Zg Y]\[`\l ‡uaa aja ‡u\]o_l[^_`_, f]Z-
_gdZ]_
†ad_g zZa f]\[}[wa\ v`aya! _|j}v-
fjZg, fjZg-|_|j}v, |w]f_ aja fada, _ fZ-
dZz c`Zg_ zhcZ, vw][ˆ†`Z\ c_jZ, gc\ \[]Z u_c}f_`Z
]acZz a ja|e au]\[v_ `_ cdZj\ fZhgjhˆdch cwŠZ‘]wv-
d}, Z]\Ša, z\[ aja †dZ-dZ “f]aja†`Z\” g]Z[\ u\j\`a
aja ‘]wvdZg.
‰ v`ay_Š “…_u_`-‹_`y_j” a “…_u_`-’_]_`” z} fZ[-
]Zo`Z ]_uZo]_jace c ]_u[\jvZl a u_yZdZgvZl zhc_, _
d_v^\ c f]ayZdZgj\`a\z zhc`}Š ojˆ[ a gc\gZuzZ^-
`}Š fjZgZg. …Zy[_-`aow[e z} Zohu_d\je`Z g\]`\z-
ch v zhc`}z ojˆ[_z. “\f\]e ^\ h f]\[ga^w gZf]Zc:
`\w^\ja zhcZ — c_zZ\ yj_g`Z\ `_ `_|\z gZcdZ†`Zz
cdZj\?
€_ c_zZz [\j\ gc\, o\uwcjZg`Z, `\ d_v. ‡ \cja `\ d_v,
dZ fZ†\zw ^\ fZg\cdgZg_`ah zZa cdZje Z[`ZcdZ]Z``a?
Yw[ad\ c_za. …Zy[_ g} f]a\u^_\d\ g v_vwˆ-dZ [_j\-
vwˆ cd]_`w, dZ v_va\ ojˆ[_ g_z u_fZza`_ˆdch f\]gZ-
`_f\]gZ? x]_gaje`Z, g} ow[\d\ fZz`ade c_z}\ yj_g-
`}\ ojˆ[_, d\, vZdZ]}\ g`Zchd dZ]^\cdg\``Z a [\j_ˆd
f]a ”dZz f]_u[`a†`Z\ ja‚Z. ‡ fZf]Zchd g_c ]_ccv_u_de
Z g_|\l cZocdg\``Zl `_‚aZ`_je`Zl vwŠ`\, v_va\ ojˆ-
[_ g} f]afZz`ad\? €\w^\ja dZ, †dZ \[ad\, v f]az\]w,
`_ u_gd]_v? •ja dZ, †dZ fZ[_\dch v cdZjw, v_v c_zZ cZ-
oZl ]_uwz\ˆ\\ch — g]Z[\ yZ]†a‚} aja (wf_ca iZ-
cfZ[e!) v\d†wf_? {_ `\d ^\, dZ†`Z `\d!
– u`_ˆ dZ†`Z — g} cd_`\d\ yZgZ]ade Z fa]Zy_Š, ^_-
]\`}Š fZ]Zchd_Š, y\‘ajd\ ‘a| a v_vZz-`aow[e “zhc\
fZ-‚_]cva”, wg\]hˆ g_c! €Z \cja g_z [_de c]_g`ade ”da
]_ccv_u} c fZ[ja``}z ]_‚aZ`Zz g_|\l c\zea, dZ ]_u-
`a‚_ ]_ccz\|ad vZyZ wyZ[`Z a g_c g f\]gwˆ Z†\]\[e.
“_v gZd, a w z\`h — dZ ^\ c_zZ\. – ]_ccv_u}g_j Z
yj_g`}Š ojˆ[_Š, Z ojˆ[_Š Zc`Zg`}Š, f]_u[`a†`}Š, Z
dZz, †\z wyZ_ˆd [Z]ZyaŠ yZcd\l. €Z h d_v a `\ cfZ[Z-
oajch ]_ccv_u_de Zo _je‘_Š a Zz\y_Š `_|\yZ fad_`ah,
Z dZz, †dZ `_ŠZ[adch `_ `_|\z cdZj\ fZcdZh``Z: Šj\o\,
†_\, zZjZv\, ‘]wvd_Š, ZgZ_Š a cj_[ZcdhŠ. {\jZ \\ a


 g dZz, †dZ a fZcj\[Zg_d\je`Zcde fZhgj\`ah `_ cdZj\
]_uja†`}Š ojˆ[ `_ ‰ZcdZv\ a g —Zccaa — ]_u`}\. €_-
k~ f]az\], †_l, cj_[Zcda a ‘]wvd} w `_c fZ[_ˆdch ]_`e-
|\ Zc`Zg`}Š ojˆ[, _ f]_u[`a†`}l Zo\[ `\f]\z\``Z
u_v_`†ag_\dch fjZgZz, _ `\ [\c\]dZz.
xZ”dZzw v`ay_, vZdZ]wˆ g} [\]^ad\ g ]wv_Š, az\\d
ZcZowˆ vZ`cd]wv‚aˆ — fZcj\[Zg_d\je`Zcde yj_g g `\l
f]Z[avdZg_`_ Z†\]\[`Zcdeˆ fZ[_†a ojˆ[ `_ gZcdZ†-
`}l cdZj. {jh dZyZ †dZo} zhc`}\ a f]Z†a\ ojˆ[_, Z
vZdZ]}Š h d_v z`ZyZ a fZ[]Zo`Z ]_ccv_u}g_j g f]\[}-
[waŠ [gwŠ v`ay_Š, `\ f]a[_g_ja Zo\[w auja|`ˆˆ
fjZd`Zcde a dh^\cde, aŠ fZ[_ˆd g c\]\[a`\ Zo\[_. ‰}
c_za zZ^\d\ ]\|ade, g v_vZ\ g]\zh aŠ fZ[_g_de, `Z
Z`a Zohu_d\je`Z [Zj^`} o}de Zv]w^\`} gc\z d\z, Z
†\z fZl[\d ]\†e g ”dZl v`ay\. x]ZcdZ fZf]Zowld\ ŠZde
]_u cZojˆcda f]\[jZ^\``wˆ fZcj\[Zg_d\je`Zcde, `\
`_]w|_de vZzfZua‚aˆ gZcdZ†`ZyZ cdZj_ — gch Z`_
f]Z[avdZg_`_ z`ZyZg\vZg}z `_]Z[`}z Zf}dZz — a
g} wga[ad\, †dZ gZcdZ†`_h vwŠ`h `\ z\`\\ ]_‚aZ`_je-
`_, †\z c_z_h f]Z[ga`wd_h \g]Zf\lcv_h. xwcde zhc-
`}\ ojˆ[_ a fjZg f]Z[Zj^_ˆd ay]_de yj_g`}\ ]Zja,
`Z †dZo} u]ad\je ]_uyjh[\j g\ja†a\ vZ]Zjh, gZv]wy
`\yZ [Zj^`_ o}de cgad_!
€Z g `_|\z ]_‚aZ`\ yj_g`Z\ co_j_`ca]Zg_``Zcde,
vZdZ]_h Zo]_uw\dch c_z_ cZoZˆ, \cja `_ cdZj fZf_[_\d
gc\, †dZ [_\d f]a]Z[_ Y]\[`\l ‡uaa a ˜_v_gv_ueh. xZ
c†_cdeˆ, oZje|a`cdgZ au ”daŠ f]Z[wvdZg gc\y[_ az\-
jace a g —Zccaa a f]Z†aŠ ]\cfwojav_Š o}g|\yZ cZˆ-
u_, _ †\yZ `\d — d_v ”dZ gc\ f]agZuhd! x]ZcdZ fZl[ad\
`_ ]}`Zv a cf]Zcad\ — g_z gc\ fZv_^wd. ‰\[e Z†\`e
a`d\]\c`Z a fZj\u`Z ZoZy__de cgZ\ fad_`a\ d\z ŠZ-
]Z|az, †dZ f]ZaugZ[adch w cZc\[\l a zZ^\d o}de
[Zcd_gj\`Z v `_z o\u cw\cdg\``ZyZ wŠw[|\`ah v_-
†\cdg_. •[\d ja ]\†e Z v]wf_Š a oZoZg}Š, cf\‚ahŠ a
f]h`ZcdhŠ — ”dZzw gc\zw `_l[\dch z\cdZ g `_|aŠ v_-
cd]ˆjhŠ a cvZgZ]Z[_Š.

() *"' +-')/


часть первая
Повод
к застолью
™
• g Y]\[`\l ‡uaa a ˜_v_gv_ue\ `_- kp
]Z[`Z\ Zd`Z|\`a\ v Šj\ow dZ†`Z d_vZ\
^\, v_v a g —Zccaa. nj\o — c_zZ\ yj_g-
`Z\! €Z d\z `\ z\`\\ h ŠZd\j o} `_†_de
zZa ]_ccv_u} `\ c Šj\o_, _ c dZyZ, †dZ
fZ[_ˆd yZcdˆ aja [_^\ f]ZcdZ f]ZŠZ-
^\zw f]\^[\ gc\yZ, fZ†da Z[`Zg]\z\`-
`Z c f]ag\dcdga\z — c †_h.
o}†`Z h fa|w dZjevZ Z dZz, †dZ,
v_v z`\ v_^\dch, h u`_ˆ Z†\`e ŠZ]Z|Z.
b_l €Z wu`_de Z †_\ gc\ — u_[_†_ `\fZcaje-
`_h. “\z `\ z\`\\ h ]\|ajch `_fac_de
Z †_\ ŠZdh o} fZdZzw, †dZ h Z†\`e jˆo-
jˆ †_l, a o\u †_h `\gZuzZ^`Z g`av`wde
g `_|w vwjedw]w a \\ g_^`wˆ cZcd_g-
`wˆ †_cde — vwja`_]aˆ.
€_fac_de d}ch†_ f\]g}l cf]_gZ†-
`av-fwd\gZ[ad\je fZ cZ]d_z †_h z`\
`\a`d\]\c`Z, [_ a g_z `a v †\zw. xZ”dZ-
zw jw†|\ h ]_ccv_^w Z dZz, `_ v_vaŠ cZ-
]d_Š †_h h Zcd_`Zgajch c\yZ[`h, g v_vaŠ
cjw†_hŠ h feˆ dZd aja a`Zl \yZ ga[, v_v
h \yZ u_g_]ag_ˆ.
€_[\ˆce, †dZ ”dZ `_cd]Zad `_|\
[_je`\l|\\ Zo\`a\ `_ f]_gaje`}l
j_[; h ŠZ†w, †dZo} g} fZ†wgcdgZg_ja
c\oh zZaza [Z]Zyaza, ^\j_``}za yZ-



cdhza, fZc\dag|aza zZl [Zz g ]_[Zcd- ›d]Zz f]Zc`wjch — †dZ f\]gZ\? b_l k
`}l, cZj`\†`}l [\`e. u_g_]ade! ˜_gd]_v — Z` fZdZz, Z` c_z
Zo]_uw\dch gZv]wy †_l`av_. xZ[Z|jZ
g]\zh w^a`_ — c`Zg_ `\ ZoZldace o\u
b_l `\ fe\|e, †_h, c `az g]\zh f]Zj\dad o}cd]\\, o\-
c\[_ fZd\†\d ]Zg`\\ a cZl[\d, v_v `\
Zdvw[_ caj} o\]\|e? o}jZ, [`\g`_h wcd_jZcde.
bdZ ^\ d_vZ\ — †_l? €_fadZv? œ\v_]-
b_l jˆojˆ! Š, v_v h jˆojˆ †_l! cdgZ? YfZcZo Zo\`ah?
‹`\ ^\ fZg\ujZ: h ]Z[ajch `\ `_ dg\dZz ow[\d d]Z\v]_d`Z\ “{_!”
vZ‘\l`Zl Zv]_a`\ šg]_uaa, _ w c_zZyZ ›`ag\]c_je`}l `_fadZv — [Z \[},
c\][‚_ z_d\]av_ — d_z, y[\ jˆohd †_l, gZ g]\zh \[} a fZcj\ `\\.
‚\`hd, wz\ˆd fade a o\uZ|aoZ†`Z u`_- œ\v_]cdgZ `_ gc\ cjw†_a ^au`a; g
ˆd, vZy[_ f]a cjw†_l`Zl gcd]\†\ fZ]_ v]_l`aŠ, u_fw\``}Š cjw†_hŠ — w[_†-
cv_u_de: `Z\ [ZfZj`\`a\ v j\v_]cdgw.
— xZl[\z vZ z`\, †_l c[\j_ˆ! {_ a c_zZ cjZgZ “†_lŠ_`_” ZoZu`_†_-
‰\[e c †_h gc\ `_†a`_\dch a †_\z gc\ \d `\ Š_]†\g`ˆ, _ zw^cvZl vjwo, z\cdZ
u_v_`†ag_\dch. Yv_^a: “Y_j_z _j\lvwz!”, [jh Zo\`ah.
a gZd Z` — †_l. b_l `_jeˆd, fZ[_[wd c [`az cjZgZz, †_l — c_zZ\ y\`a-
fZvjZ`Zz, g}^[wd, fZv_ f\]g}\ yjZdva _je`Z\ au y_cd]Z`Zza†\cvaŠ auZo]\d\-
wdZjhd ^_^[w a Zdv]Zˆd [w|w, a dZjevZ `al †\jZg\†\cdg_. …_v gc\ y\`a_je`Z\,
fZdZz: “…_v g}, v_v c_zZ†wgcdga\, c\- †_l fZ]_uad\je`Z z`ZyZZo]_u\`. ‹},
zeh, [\j_, v_va\ `ZgZcda?” Yv_^a: “‹`\ ]Z^[\``}\ g YYY—, wu`_ja Zo ”dZz Zd-
fZ]_!” — a c`Zg_ †_l — `_ [Z]Zyw, c fZ- `Zcad\je`Z `\[_g`Z. €_g\]`Z\, fZ”dZ-
^\j_`a\z c†_cdjagZyZ fwda, w[_†a a zw w z`ZyaŠ \\ Zcd_j_ce `Zcd_jeyah
v]\fvZyZ u[Z]Zgeh. fZ “dZzw c_zZzw [\gh`ZcdZ fhdZzw”
"#$ % 01

kƒ aja “`_cdZh\zw, a`[alcvZzw, cZ cjZ- cdZjava c o_zowvZg}za ]\|\dv_za


`avZz”. [jh †_\fadah — yZcfZ[a, [_ z`\ dZd
Y c_zZyZ `_†_j_ zZ\yZ wgj\†\`ah vw- z_y_ua` fZv_u_jch f\\]Zl ‡j_[[a`_,
ja`_]a\l h [Zy_[}g_jch, †dZ za] †_h d_va\ cZv]Zga_ Z` d_aj g `\oZje|Zz
`\ zZ^\d Zy]_`a†ag_dech ”daz `_oZ- fZz\\`aa!
]Zz a z\†d_j Z dZz, †dZ vZy[_-dZ [g\]e ‹\`h dZjevZ `_†_ja Zocjw^ag_de,
g ”dZd za] f]aZdv]Z\dch a h wga^w `\- Zdg\|ag_h g owz_^`}\ z\|Z†va dZ
†dZ ZcZo\``Z\. Z[a` cZ]d, dZ []wyZl, vZy[_ h u_z\daj g
€\ u`_ˆ v_v w g_c, _ zZa z}cja a fZ[cZov\ zw^†a`w-vad_l‚_. – cf]Zcaj:
fZ^\j_`ah az\ˆd Zo}v`Zg\`a\ co}- — ždZ ŠZuha`? x]ayj_cad\ \yZ cˆ[_!
g_dech, a gZd, g `_†_j\ [gwŠd}ch†`}Š • cd_j oj_yZ[_]ade †_\dZ]yZg‚_ u_
g v_vZl-dZ y_u\d\, cZcdZh\l au Zohg- oj_yZ]Z[`Z\ ]\|\`a\ Zdv]}de d_vZl
j\`al a ]\vj_z}, h ga^w: “…ad_lcval z_y_ua` g “_|v\`d\. …ad_l‚w, ga[azZ,
”jad`}l †_l, “_|v\`d, `_f]Zdag iZjw- f]ahd`} o}ja zZa cjZg_, a Z` wc_[aj
o}Š …wfZjZg, `\fZ[_j\vw Zd ‹‰{”. z\`h u_ `\oZje|Zl cdZjav, †dZo} fZ-
– gZZo\-dZ u`_ˆ, v_v cj\[w\d Zd- f]ZoZg_de `\vZdZ]}\ cZ]d_ †_h. – vw-
`Zcadech v cjZg\†v_z daf_ ”jad`}l, h faj gc\, `_ †dZ Šg_dajZ [\`\y g dZd
fZ`az_ˆ, †dZ ”dZ Zu`_†_\d `_ hu}v\ [\`e. ‡ fZu^\, †\]\u `\cvZjevZ z\ch‚\g,
`_|aŠ `Zg}Š oau`\cz\`Zg. €Z — gZd vZy[_ z} w^\ fZ[]w^ajace, ’_l xa`
†\cd`Z\ cjZgZ! — †_l g dZz z_y_ua- z`\ f]au`_jch:
`\ Zv_u_jch a gf]hze ”jad`}z. “_z — – Zdv]}j z_y_ua` a f]Zca[\j g
o}ja f]\[cd_gj\`} c_z}\ jw†|a\ cZ- `\z o\u \[a`ZyZ fZvwf_d\jh z\ch‚_
]d_ vad_lcvZyZ †_h g acfZj`\`aa jw†- d]a, d} cd_j f\]g}z, vdZ vwfaj w z\`h
|aŠ †_l`}Š z_cd\]Zg. ‹\d_jja†\cva\ ŠZde †dZ-`aow[e. • gZd c dZyZ [`h, fZ-
o_`Z†va c `\ga[_``}za cZ]d_za †_h, cj\ dgZ\yZ fZc\\`ah, w z\`h dZ]yZgjh
v]_cag_h †_l`_h fZcw[_, cf\‚a_je`}\ `_vZ`\‚-dZ fZ|j_!
   
 


’_l xa` — acv]\``al a [Zo]}l †\- fwcde a w[_†`Zzw coZ]w, vZy[_ c\yZ[`h kr
jZg\v — Zdv]}j [jh z\`h †w[\c`}l f\]\[Z z`Zl j\^_d [\chdva Zdz\``}Š
za] vad_lcvZyZ †_h, az\``Z †_l u_- cZ]dZg u\j\`ZyZ †_h! – f]ZcdZ g}o\-
cd_gaj z\`h guyjh`wde `_ …ad_l a \yZ ]w aja ŠZ]Z|al cv]w†\``}l †_l c g\-
vwjedw]w []wyaza yj_u_za. javZj\f`}z, `_c}\``}z gvwcZz a
‚g\dZz, aja dZd, †dZ `_u}g_ˆd “fZ]ZŠ”,
vZdZ]}l zZ^`Z u_g_]ag_de vafh\l
b_l c wg_^\`a\z gZ[Zl — g z\]w d\]fval, o}cd]Z wdZ-
jhˆal ^_^[w a c gfZj`\ d]_[a‚aZ`-
Y d\Š fZ] v_v h wu`_j, v_vaz ]_u`ZZo]_u- `}z [jh ›uo\vacd_`_ _]Zz_dZz.
`}z zZ^\d o}de u\j\`}l †_l, h `a-
vZy[_ g ^au`a oZje|\ `\ cd_`w acv_de U <"+% >5  !%  $>,
dZd u\j\`}l †_l Ÿ rp, †dZ `\vZy[_ o}j $ <5 '&  D. U !% $-
gZ^[\j\`a\z v_^[ZyZ ^ad\jh ›uo\va- !5$+ >$, + +% + !5"
cd_`_. €w †dZ z`\ `Zcd_jeya]Zg_de fZ  $& $&#$, !*% %%8 <-
m~
       




$%  '+  $!5$+. D!5$  za a ojˆ[\†vZ c Z]\Š_za a cZj\`}za mk


+ "  " #! <- _o]avZcZg}za vZcdZ†v_za — ”dZ f]_-
$ <%"5, <&#", $&" gaje`Z\ cZf]ZgZ^[\`a\ †_h, ”dZ u_z\-
 +. / !", >< !% +%, †_d\je`_h f]\jˆ[ah v wyZ\`aˆ!
+* <" >.
T $!5$, <$& $&#$%,
* +%& -  >… 
‰ cd]_`\ Zy`\l
$$ $<" ' R+  !-%$, a c_zZg_]Zg
>'& + +? A" + >5
 !%  &" *+ '  – `\ u`_ˆ, v_v w `aŠ ”dZ fZjw†_\dch!
>$. L"? / $ <   *- …w[_ `a f]a\[\|e — c_zZg_] dwd v_v
" — R 5 &. : !+ !. dwd. • w^\ vafad!
Y_zZg_] c_z}l Zo}†`}l, cZg\dcvZyZ
€\ `_[Z `_jag_de c]_uw fZj`wˆ fa_jw, aja \\ ‚_]cvZyZ f]ZaugZ[cdg_ — cj_-
`_jag_ld\ fZ`\z`Zyw, g †_l`av\ †_l g_ oZyw, z_cd\]_-z\[`av_ [_ jw[aje-
[Zje|\ Zcd_`\dch f]_gaje`Zl d\zf\]_- av_ g ‡u\]o_l[^_`\ `_lda f]Z\
dw]} — g z\]w yZ]h†az, `Z `\Zo^ay_ˆ- f]ZcdZyZ. • †_l`av [jh u_g_]va c_z}l
az. • d_z, `_ [`\, vZy[_ †_l w^\ ow[\d Zo}†`}l. • [_^\ cfZcZo u_g_]va †_h
vZ`†_dech, `_c ^[\d c_zZ\ gvwc`Z\ z\- dZ†`Z d_vZl, v_v g —Zccaa.
cdZ †_h — fZ”dZzw, f\]gwˆ fa_jw d]_- ‡ gZd †_l fZjw†_\dch []wyZl! x]ZcdZ
[a‚aZ``Z c_zZzw zZjZ[Zzw, _ fZcj\[- cjZg_za `\ f\]\[_de, v_vaz gvwc`}z
`ˆˆ, c v]\fvaz, d\]fvaz a gh^waz fZjw†_\dch c_z}l Zo}†`}l †_l g ‡u\]-
Zcd_dvZz — c_zZzw wg_^_\zZzw. o_l[^_`\.
iZcdˆ — dZjevZ c_z}l cg\^al †_l, {wz_\d\, [\jZ g †_o]\‚\, aja, v_v \yZ
c_z}l yZ]h†al, au c_zZl jw†|\l u_g_]- u[\ce `_u}g_ˆd, g v\vjav-Zdw? d†_cda
va. • `\ u_ow[ed\ d_]\jvw c cwŠZ‘]wvd_- [_. €Z [\jZ \\ a g Zd`Z|\`aa v †_ˆ.
"#$ % 01

mm ˜[\ce Zdja†`Z fZ`az_ˆd, v_v g_^`Z cd_v_`†av_ (_]zw[}) †wde yZ]h†\\, †\z
f]Zaug\cda f\]gZ\ gf\†_dj\`a\, fZ”dZ- z} f]ag}vja, `Z az\``Z d_v_h d\zf\-
zw f]a`az_ˆa\ yZcd\l ŠZuh\g_ cd_]_- ]_dw]_ fZugZjh\d †_ˆ `_aoZj\\ fZj`Z
ˆdch, u_g_]va `\ ^_j\ˆd! ]_cv]}de cgZl _]Zz_d, az\``Z Z`_ u_-
‰Z[w o\]wd [jh †_h ŠZ]Z|wˆ, oj_yZ cd_gad fade, |wz`Z gdhyag_h g c\oh
ŠZ]Z|\l, gvwc`Zl gZ[} g ‡u\]o_l[^_- gz\cd\ c †_\z cd]wa gZu[wŠ_, †dZo} `\
`\ f]\[Zcd_dZ†`Z.  _], wyja Zd fjZ[Z- Zo^\†ech, _ gz\cd\ cZ cd]whza gZu[wŠ_
g}Š [\]\ge\g — _]Zz_d cdZad w^\ a Zd g[}Š_de _]Zz_d.
[}z_ — d_vZl, v_v `_[Z. b_l`av ZfZj_- ‡ †dZ v †_ˆ?
cvag_ˆd, u_g_]va o\]wd [ZgZje`Z z`Z- ‹Z^`Z cZgc\z j_vZ`a†`Z — vZjZ-
yZ, ]_cc†ad}g_h `_ dZ, †dZ `_cdZl ow- d}l c_Š_]. ‰f]avwcvw! “ZjevZ `\ dZd,
[wd ]_uo_gjhde vafhdvZz, `Z †_ˆ [_ˆd o}cd]Z]_cdgZ]az}l, vZdZ]}l Zd cd_v_-
fZcdZhde `_ vZ`‘Z]v\ c_zZg_]_ `_[ `_ [Z ]d_ a `\ [Z`\c\|e, _ `_cdZhal
\\ z\]‚_ˆaza wyZjev_za. ‰c\ ”dZ ]_‘a`_[, vZdZ]}l cj\[w\d fZvZjZde
g]\zh †_l dZyZ yjh[a u_vafad, †_a`va af†av_za `_ `\oZje|a\ vwcZ†va. o-
g †_l`av\ gcfj}g_ˆd a dZ`wd, vZ`g\v- z_v`wde vwcZ†\v c_Š_]_ g cd_v_`, fZdZz
‚ah f]agZ[ad `_cdZl g [ga^\`a\, `Z `_ hu}v, a `\cvZjevZ yjZdvZg †_h \zw
u_vaf\de †_ˆ `\ [_[wd — `\ fZjZ^\`Z. g[ZyZ`vw!
 [_de f]a[\dch za`wd fhde, zZ^\d, €Z †_\ †_l fZ[_\dch g ]ZcvZ|`Zz
[_^\ [\chde, `Z Z^a[_`a\ Zv_^\dch Zo]_zj\`aa g_]\`al, z\[_, _ dZ a cj_-
Zf]_g[_``}z. ‰vwc †_h au c_zZg_]_ — [Zcd\l.
o\cfZ[Zo\`! — €w a †dZ d_vZyZ? — cf]Zcad\ g}. —
• c_zZ\ yj_g`Z\ — d\zf\]_dw]_ †_h ‰c\ dZ†`Z d_v, v_v g —Zccaa, a †_l d_vZl
fZjw†_\dch a`Zl, `\ d_vZl, v_v au f]Z- ^\, a c_zZg_]} — `_|ja †\z w[agade!
cdZyZ †_l`av_. b_l au y]w|\ga[`ZyZ {_, gZd ”da, a gf]_g[w, ]Zccalcva\.
Бухарский
самовар
А
 
&
  '
 && & (
  - mt
)
* . +(
, '
 /0/1 (2&? 3
,
&0* *! 5

6 . +,   (0&,
 , &
0
1 7/,  /
( 
0/8
(2&. 9  &,  / &1  &,  (  (
  &. 3 (
&-

(   (* , & :& 
1
&
& & (! ;   (  &    0 / -
&1,  &
 1
(/  
*& 
 
  .
9 :  
 — 
 0,  2 /2, * (-
8 / :
((,  
7&,  
( 6
/  / 
&
0/1 01&. ; < 
   0

 — '

  & =(8/, * 
&
01 
7 
  /  &
.
 - 


b_l-vwf\ ˜_oZ]acd_h zhd_ mp


x]a\Š_j — †_l, w\u^_\|e — †_l. ‡ †dZ xZz`ad\, h ]_ccv_u}g_j g_z acdZ]aˆ Z
fZ [Z]Zy\? “Z^\ †_l! zZ\z u`_vZzcdg\ c a`[alcvZl vwŠ`\l?
x\]\cdwv vZj\c, ]_uyZgZ]} g fZjwde- “_z ‘ayw]a]Zg_j Z[a` a`[alcval ]\-
z\ c `\u`_vZz}za fZfwd†av_za, fZvw- cdZ]_` g {wo_\.
]ade g d_zow]\… †\yZ `\ Šg_d_\d? “_v gZd, v]Zz\ u_z\†_d\je`Zl \[}
— x]ZgZ[`a‚_, †_ˆ! Y jazZ`Zz. {g_. dZd ]\cdZ]_` owvg_je`Z fZd]hc z\`h
…Zzw `\ u`_vZz_ ”d_ v_]da`v_, vdZ _ocZjˆd`Z ]ZcvZ|`}z †_\z. x\]g}l
u_o}j, v_vZg `_ Zwfe fZ[cd_v_``av? ^\ yjZdZv ”dZyZ `_fadv_ gZu`\c z\`h
• gZZo\ — †_l c jazZ`Zz ”dZ f]Z- vw[_-dZ g fZ[`\o\c`wˆ g}ce, h a `\ [w-
cdZ u[Z]ZgZ. ‰ z\]`Z ]_cv_†ag_ˆ\zch z_j, †dZ Zo}†`}l †_l zZ^\d g}ug_de
g_yZ`\ aja [Zz_, u_ ^w]`_je`}z cdZ- gZ z`\ d_va\ ”zZ‚aa. …Zy[_ h g\]`wj-
javZz — gc\ ]_g`Z. ij_g`Z\ — ŠZ]Z|al ch g ]\_je`Zcde, zZa ]wva fZdh`wjace
†_l, _]Zz_d`}l jazZ`, f]_gaje`_h fZ- v c\]\o]h`Zzw †_l`a†vw. ˜`_\d\, †dZ h
cw[_ (dZ`val cd_v_`), _ `_cd]Z\`a\ c_zZ d_z wga[\j? x_v\dav Zo}v`Zg\``ZyZ
f]a[\d. jafdZ`_ a g\dZ†vw c f_]Zl u\j\`}Š ja-
…cd_da, _ fZ\[\d vdZ g “_|v\`d, d_v cde\g.
`\ cf]_|ag_ld\, †dZ Zddw[_ f]ag\uda. — bdZ ”dZ? — cf]Zcaj h w Z‘a‚a_`d_-
x]ag\uad\ d_|v\`dcva\ dZ`vZvZ]}\, a`[wc_. • wcj}|_j g Zdg\d:
cj_[va\ jazZ`}. ‰Zd c `aza †_l d_v — ‹hd_, c”]!
†_l! ‰Zd — jazZ`} d_v jazZ`}! Š d}, ”dZ ^ `_[Z, au Zo}†`ZyZ f_v\-
dav_ a gZd d_v… z\`h?! “_v `\auyj_[azZ?
{_, gc\ gZd d_v f]ZcdZ. €\ Zohu_d\je-
`Z cj\fZ vZfa]Zg_de a`[alcval ]\cdZ-
]_` a o\^_de g z_y_ua` u_ †_\z au f_-
"#$ % 01

ms v\dav_. ‹Z^`Z f]ZcdZ guhde ŠZ]Z|al ˜_ ‰\javZl cd\`Zl


a`[alcval aja ‚\ljZ`cval †_l, u_-
g_]ade \yZ v_v cj\[w\d, `_cdZhde, `Z `\
…ad_lcval †_l — ‘\`Zz\`_je`Z\ f]Z-
dZ]Zfadech Zfwcv_de g †_l`av g\dZ†vw
hgj\`a\ †\jZg\†\cvZyZ y\`ah. •u ja-
cg\^\l zhd} c c_zZyZ `_†_j_, _ [Zo_-
cde\g Z[`ZyZ a dZyZ ^\ ]_cd\`ah (\cja
gade \\ dZjevZ f\]\[ fZ[_†\l. ‰Zd dZy[_
acvjˆ†ade a`[alcval _cc_z, vZdZ]}l
\\ _]Zz_d [Zcday`\d cgZ\l ‚\ja!
hgjh\dch ]_cd\`a\z fwcde a fZŠZ^\yZ,
xZg\]ed\ z`\, †dZ `\oZje|Zl vwcZ-
`Z `\z`ZyZ []wyZyZ ga[_) †\jZg\†\cdgZ
†\v `\Z†a\``ZyZ v]acd_jja†\cvZyZ
`_w†ajZce fZjw†_de `\fZcda^azZ\ vZ-
c_Š_]_ (j\[\`‚_) gZ ]dw gZ g]\zh †_\-
ja†\cdgZ ga[Zg a cZ]dZg `_fadv_, cfZ-
fadah f]ZcdZ Zohu_d\j\`, ŠZdh o} [jh
cZo`ZyZ w[Zgj\dgZ]ade \[g_ ja `\ jˆ-
dZyZ, †dZo} g fZj`Zl z\]\ fZ†wgcdgZ-
o}\ gvwc} a u_f]Zc}.
g_de gcˆ yjwoa`w Zo_h`ah d_vZyZ †_h.
bdZ zZ^`Z c]_g`ade c vad_lcvaz
†_\z fZ z`ZyZZo]_uaˆ? xZ^_jwl, `a-
†\yZ, v]Zz\ Šj\o_.
xZ”dZzw ]_ccv_u}g_de Z vad_lcvZz
†_\ zZ^`Z o\cvZ`\†`Z. €_fa|a vdZ
cf]_gZ†`av Z vad_lcvZz †_\ — wg\ca-
cd}Š, z`ZyZcd]_`a†`}Š dZzZg fZjw-
†adch c [\chdZv, — a f]a ”dZz gc\ ]_g`Z
d}ch†_z jˆ[\l Zcd_`\dch †dZ cv_u_de.
xZdZzw †dZ †_l g …ad_\ ”dZ `\ f]ZcdZ
`_fadZv, ”dZ ‚\j}l za] a, `_g\]`Z\,
`avdZ `\ zZ^\d cv_u_de, †dZ Z` u`_\d Zo
”dZz za]\ gc\.



m

€w d_v †dZ, d\f\]e a `\ o]_dech u_ za‘} Z dZz, v_v f]_gaje`Z u_g_]ag_de


]_ccv_u? €\d, d_v `\ yZ[adch. {_g_ld\ vad_lcval †_l, †_\ gc\yZ dZjevZ z\-
h fZf}d_ˆce ]_ccv_u_de ŠZdh o} c_zZ\ |_ˆd a g]\[hd `_cj_^[\`aˆ ”daz `_-
yj_g`Z\, c_zZ\, `_ zZl guyjh[, g_^`Z\ fadvZz.
au dZyZ, †dZ z`\ fZg\ujZ wu`_de Z va- xZcw[ad\ c_za: gc\ ]_u`ZZo]_ua\ ga-
d_lcvZz †_\. €_[\ˆce, ”dZyZ ]_ccv_u_ [Zg †_h cvj_[}g_\dch au cZd\` u_†_cdwˆ
ow[\d [Zcd_dZ†`Z [jh dZyZ, †dZo} d\ au _ocZjˆd`Z `\ fZŠZ^aŠ []wy `_ []wy_
g_c, vdZ fZv_ `\ fZjˆoaj †_l, fZjˆoa- cZ]dZg. žda cZ]d_, g cgZˆ Z†\]\[e, Zdja-
ja \yZ, _ d\, vdZ fZjˆoaj v_vZl-dZ Z[a`- †_ˆdch []wy Zd []wy_ ]\yaZ`_za f]Zac-
\[a`cdg\``}l cZ]d, u_[wz_jace `_[ ŠZ^[\`ah, g]\z\`\z coZ]_ jacd_ a fZ-
d\z, v_v z`ZyZ Z`a d\]hˆd, `\ u`_vZ- yZ[`}za wcjZgahza, f]a vZdZ]}Š jacd
zhce c †_\z gZ gc\Š \yZ f]Zhgj\`ahŠ. fZhgjhjch au fZ†\v a ]Zc [Z dZyZ zZ-
…_v a jˆoZ\ []wyZ\ g\javZ\ hgj\`a\, z\`d_, v_v \yZ cZo]_ja. x]a ”dZz `\gZu-
vad_lcval †_l Zv]w^\` cZ`zZz j\y\`[ zZ^`Z guhde a acvjˆ†ade a`[aga[w-
a za‘Zg. šcja j\y\`[} wv]_|_ˆd acdZ- _je`}l fZ†\]v †_l`ZyZ z_cd\]_ — dZyZ
]aˆ a f]Zow^[_ˆd a`d\]\c v †_ˆ, dZ fZc]\[`av_ z\^[w f]a]Z[Zl a `_za,
"#$ % 01

t~ †dZ [Z`Zcad [Z `_c \\ v]_cZdw a Zo_h`a\ gc\ yZ]_u[Z cjZ^`\\, a \cja z} ŠZdaz
g ga[\ ‘Z]z} †_a`Zv, ‚g\d_ †_l`ZyZ `_cj_[adech gvwcZz a _]Zz_dZz [Z]Z-
`_cdZh a \yZ _]Zz_d_. yZyZ vad_lcvZyZ †_h g fZj`Zl z\]\, dZ
“_v gZd, `\cvZjevZ ]_u z`\ [ZgZ[a- Z ]\vZz\`[_‚ahŠ fZ cfZcZow u_g_]ag_-
jZce f]acwdcdgZg_de f]a dZz, v_v wfZ- `ah v_^[ZyZ vZ`v]\d`ZyZ cZ]d_ cj\[w-
zh`wd}l g}|\ zZl []wy ’_l xa`, Zd- \d cf]_gjhdech g z_y_ua`\, vZdZ]}l az
v]}g_h f]ao}g|a\ au …ad_h wf_vZgva dZ]yw\d. šcja f]Z[_g‚} `\ zZywd Zdg\-
c †_\z, f]\[`_u`_†\``}z [jh dZ]yZgja dade dZ†`Z jaoZ ]_cf]Zcd]_`hˆd Z[a`
g]_ug\c, [Zcd_g_j au `aŠ u_facva Zd d\Š a dZd ^\ cfZcZo u_g_]ag_`ah `_ gc\ cZ-
c_z}Š †_l`}Š z_cd\]Zg. ‰ ”daŠ `\z`Z- ]d_, dZ cz\`ad\ z_y_ua` — zZ^\d o}de,
yZcjZg`}Š u_facv_Š cZ[\]^_jZce yj_g- g cj\[wˆ\z g_z fZg\u\d oZje|\!
`Z\: v_v u_g_]ag_de az\``Z ”dw f_]daˆ “Z†`Z d_v ^\ `\wz\cd`} a ]_uyZgZ]}
†_h. …Zja†\cdgZ u_g_]va, d\zf\]_dw]_ Z \[a`cdg\``Z g\]`Zl fZcw[\ [jh †_h.
gZ[}, ga[ fZcw[}, g vZdZ]Zz \yZ ^\j_- šcja, v f]az\]w, vdZ-dZ wdg\]^[_\d, †dZ
d\je`Z `_cd_ag_de, au v_vZl fZcw[} “c_z}l f]_gaje`}l vad_lcval †_l” u_-
fade, g]\zh `_cd_ag_`ah a Zfac_`a\ g_]ag_\dch dZjevZ g v\]_za†\cvZz fZ-
^\j_\zZyZ ]\uwjed_d_, dZ \cde v_vaz ]acdZz †_l`av\ aja y_lg_`\ (v]w^v\ c
[Zj^\` fZjw†adech †_l. ›[agad\je`Z, v]}|vZl, au vZdZ]Zl †_l feˆd Zo}†`Z
†dZ v_^[}l ]_u Z`a o}ja a`}za! a`[aga[w_je`Z), [_ `\f]\z\``Z `_ o_z-
xZ”dZzw gc\ ]_uyZgZ]} Z dZz, †dZ †_l owvZgZl [Zcv\, dZ ”dZ Zfhde dZjevZ z_-
cj\[w\d u_g_]ag_de `\ vafh\l gZ[Zl, j_h †_cde f]_g[}, _ `\ v_]da`_ g ‚\jZz.
_ dZjevZ gcvaf_ˆ\l, d_v `_u}g_\z}z ‰} zZ^\d\ g}oa]_de, ]wvZgZ[cdgw-
“o\j}z vjˆ†Zz”, `\ dZ †dZo} cZgc\z hce ZocdZhd\jecdg_za a cZocdg\``}za
`\g\]`} (g\[e a`Zy[_ az\``Z d_v_h f]\[fZ†d\`ahza, au †\yZ g_z fade †_l
d\zf\]_dw]_ gZ[} a zZ^\d Zv_u_dech a g †\z \yZ u_g_]ag_de. Yd]ZyaŠ f]_gaj
f]_gaje`Zl [jh [_``ZyZ ga[_ †_h), `Z u[\ce `\z`ZyZ. šcja g} f]aZo]\ja ŠZ-
      


]Z|al v\]_za†\cval †_l`av, dZ az\ld\ d\v_\dch d\fjZ Zd jZ^va ŠZ]Z|\yZ z\[_ tt


g ga[w, †dZ \yZ fZ]} ow[wd gfad}g_de aja z_ja`ZgZyZ g_]\`eh? “Z†`Z d_v ^\,
gvwc} a u_f_Ša, fZ”dZzw g d_vZz †_l- a a`Zy[_ [_^\ caje`\\, [\lcdgw\d ŠZ-
`av\ ^\j_d\je`Z u_g_]ag_de Z[a` a dZd ]Z|al †_l. €\cvZjevaŠ \yZ yjZdvZg [Z-
^\ cZ]d †_h. YZ g]\z\`\z d_vZl †_l`av cd_dZ†`Z [jh dZyZ, †dZo} fZ†wgcdgZg_de
f]aZo]\d\d ZcZowˆ ‚\``Zcde, fZdZzw c\oh `_z`ZyZ jw†|\ a oZ[]\\. b_\fada\
†dZ `_†`\d acdZ†_de _]Zz_d u\j\`ZyZ g ŠZ]Z|\l, [Zo]Z^\j_d\je`Zl Zocd_-
†_h c_z fZ c\o\, ow[w†a f]ZcdZ Z|f_]\`- `Zgv\ Zcg\^_\d a v_v ]wvZl c`az_\d
`}z. “Z ^\ c_zZ\ Zd`Zcadch a v v\]_za- wcd_jZcde — cvZjevZ ]_u h fZ]_^_jch
†\cvaz †_|\†v_z a fa_j_z. €Z, h [w- ”dZzw ‘\`Zz\`w fZcj\ †_\fadal c ’_l
z_ˆ, gc\z fZ`hd`Z, †dZ [_``Z\ f]_gajZ xa`Zz! …_^[}l ]_u f]ZacŠZ[ajZ †w[Z:
`\ ]_cf]Zcd]_`h\dch `_ †_l`ava, fZ- w^\ †\]\u m~–t~ za`wd `\cf\|`ZyZ †_\-
v]}d}\ yj_uw]eˆ aja `\ az\ˆa\ fZ]. fadah a cfZvZl`Zl o\c\[} h †wgcdgZ-
…cd_da, gZd ]_uz\] fZcw[} `_ c_zZz g_j c\oh d_v, v_v ow[dZ wz}jch f]ZŠj_[-
[\j\ az\\d u`_†\`a\! {jh ŠZ]Z|\yZ, `Zl gZ[Zl fZcj\ `\cvZjevaŠ †_cZg c`_.
[Z]ZyZyZ †_h oZj\\ wz\cd`} `\oZje- “ZjevZ `_[Z ja u_z\dade, †dZ h ]_c-
|a\ †_l`ava a fa_j}. šyZ feˆd `\ cv_u}g_j g_z Z `_cdZh\z vad_lcvZz
]_[a wdZj\`ah ^_^[}, `\ [jh dZyZ, †dZ- †_\, _ `\ Z fZ[[\jv_Š? x\†_je`Z, `Z [Z-
o} f]ZcdZ u_fade c\[\``Z\. nZ]Z|al ]Zya\ cZ]d_ vad_lcvZyZ †_h Z†\`e †_cdZ
†_l — [jh cz_vZg_`ah a `_cj_^[\`ah, fZ[[\j}g_ˆd, f]a†\z `\ y[\-`aow[e, _
\yZ [Zj^`Z o}de ]Zg`Z cdZjevZ, cvZje- g c_zZz …ad_\. xZ”dZzw, fZvwf_h †_l g
vZ `\ZoŠZ[azZ [jh dZyZ, †dZo} Z‚\`ade z`ZyZ†acj\``}Š d\f\]e †_l`}Š z_y_-
v]_cZdw \yZ ‚g\d_, _]Zz_d a gvwc. …]Zz\ ua`_Š, c`_†_j_ gZuezad\ `\z`ZyZ — `_
dZyZ, cj\[w\d az\de g ga[w, †dZ †_l — f]Zow. šcja †_l `_fZj`h\d _]Zz_dZz
`\ f]ZcdZ `_fadZv, ”dZ \\ a j\v_]cdgZ. gcˆ vZz`_dw — ”dZ ŠZ]Z|al f]au`_v.
‰_z [ZgZ[ajZce †wgcdgZg_de, v_v ]_c- šcja g} †wgcdgw\d\ g †_\ f]ahd`wˆ
"#$ % 01

tq vacja`vw, \cja Zd `\cvZjevaŠ yjZdvZg v_v g\]Š`a\ cjZa gZ[} wcf\ˆd `_y]\de-
†_h `_ jow g}cdwf_\d fZd — ”dZ dZ^\ ch [Z `\ZoŠZ[azZl d\zf\]_dw]} aja
ŠZ]Z|al f]au`_v. šcja †_l Zcg\^_\d a Zfwcdadech g`au a f\]\z\|_dech g ]\-
f]a[_\d caj — `_g\]`hv_ ”dZ `_cdZh- uwjed_d\ vZ`g\v‚aa. …wfad\ c\o\ d\]zZ-
al †_l. z\d] a wo\[ad\ce g f]_gZd\ zZaŠ cjZg —
bdZ z`\ \\ cv_u_de? —_ccv_u}g_de cZg]\z\``}\ ”j\vd]Z†_l`ava y]\ˆd
ja Z dZz, †dZ vad_lcval †_l o}g_\d o\- gZ[w `\]_g`Zz\]`Z. …cd_da, gc\ ]_g`Z
j}z, u\j\`}z a ^\jd}z, v]_c`}z, v_- ”dZd d\]zZz\d] g_z fZ`_[Zoadch, \cja
vaz ]_u`ZZo]_u`}z zZ^\d o}de wjw` g} ŠZdad\ f]_gaje`Z u_g_]ag_de ]_u-
(ZZjZ`y — `\vZdZ]}\ f]Zau`Zchd, v_v ja†`}\ cZ]d_ †_h.
`_fac_`Z), cvZjevZ j\d g}[\]^ag_ˆd €_g\]`Z\, fZ”dZzw d_vZ\ |a]ZvZ\
ŠZ]Z|al fw-”]? €\d, z`\ g zZ\z ]_c- ]_cf]Zcd]_`\`a\ fZjw†aja c_zZg_]},
cv_u\ `_ ”dZ z\cd_ `\ Šg_dad. – `_[\- y[\ gZ[_ `_y]\g_\dch oZj\\ ]_g`Zz\]`Z,
ˆce, †dZ g} jaoZ a o\u z\`h u`_\d\ gc\ y[\ vZ`g\v‚ah f]ZacŠZ[ad `\cvZjevZ
”dZ, jaoZ wu`_\d\ fZcd\f\``Z, fZjw†_h a`_†\, †\z g Zo}†`Zz †_l`av\ aja v_-
Zy]Zz`wˆ ]_[Zcde a w[ZgZjecdga\ Zd cd]ˆj\. œa†`Z h f]\[fZ†ad_ˆ acfZje-
u`_vZzcdg_ c v_^[}z `Zg}z ga[Zz †_h. uZg_de c_zZg_] `\ dZjevZ, vZy[_ cZoa-
€Z gZd Z d\zf\]_dw]\ gZ[}, d\zf\]_- ]_ˆce fZfade †_ˆ au ojˆ[\†v_ [_ c c_-
dw]\, f]a vZdZ]Zl †_l [Zj^\` `_cd_a- Š_]vZz gf]avwcvw, `Z a [jh dZyZ, †dZo}
g_dech, [_g_ld\ gc\ ^\ fZyZgZ]az. ždZ fZfade vad_lcval †_l. {wz_\d\, gZ[_
g_^`Z. au c_zZg_]_ Zv_^\dch cja|vZz yZ]h†\l
–c`Z, †dZ gZ[_ vafad f]a k~~ °Y. €Z [jh u_g_]ag_`ah o\jZyZ aja u\j\`ZyZ
\cja cZcw[, g vZdZ]Zz vafad gZ[_, `_- †_h? ‡ g} f]Zg\]ed\ c_za, [_ fZcjw|_l-
y]\g_\dch dZjevZ c`auw, [_ v dZzw ^\ d\ z\`h \\ za`wdvw — z`\ Zcd_jZce
[ZgZje`Z zZ`}z acdZ†`avZz d\fj_, cv_u_de g_z `\cvZjevZ cjZg, f]\^[\
dZ ow]j\`a\ `_†a`_\dch \\ [Z dZyZ, †\z Zdfwcdade g_c fade †_l.
  
 ,
  
  


    


 
  


‰Zd †_l`av, g vZdZ]Zz g} cZoa]_\- dZg v ]_oZd\, `_jag_ld\ g `\yZ gZ[w dZl tp
d\ce u_g_]ag_de †_l, — Z` az\\d vZz- d\zf\]_dw]}, `_ vZdZ]wˆ ]_cc†ad_`
`_d`wˆ d\zf\]_dw]w. šyZ z_cc_ u_†_- g_| †_l a… f]ahd`ZyZ †_\fadah!
cdwˆ c]_g`az_ c z_ccZl gZ[}, vZdZ]_h
g `\yZ fZz\_\dch. {_, \cde a d_vZ\ fZ-
`hda\, v_v d\fjZ\zvZcde. €Z gc\ ]_g`Z, ždˆ[ g ^\jdZz
\cja `_jade g †_l`av [_^\ ow]`Z va-
fhwˆ gZ[w, dZ †_l`av Zcdw[ad \\ — x]Zcd}ja, wf_ca iZcfZ[e? x]ZcdZ u_-
w^\ †\]\u vZ]ZdvZ\ g]\zh d\zf\]_dw]_ z\]uja?
gZ[} a †_l`av_ c]_g`hˆdch. x]Zg\]e-
d\ g_| †_l`av, zZ^\d o}de, [_^\ \cja 4 <& >, '  
`_fZj`ade \yZ vafhdvZz, dZ gc\ ]_g`Z +  +'". 9 %># '"
d\zf\]_dw]_ gZ[} g`wd]a †_l`av_ Zv_- !<*, %*  !%, $  '%
^\dch cw\cdg\``Z `a^\ a ow[\d v_v +" $+@%8 5 !"5 +!%-
]_u fZ[ŠZ[h\l [jh u_g_]ag_`ah. ždZ %. A $ + !5+  >$, 
g_^`Z w†ad}g_de a [jh dZyZ, †dZo} `\ +!% & &$, R <%-
Z|f_]ag_de c_z}\ `\^`}\ cZ]d_ †_h # !$>$  !<& 
cja|vZz yZ]h†\l gZ[Zl. …_v `a cd]_`- + — '"# @+, $-
`Z, `Z [_^\ [jh `_cd_ag_`ah †_h f]a &+ E %"& +,  !5
Zd`Zcad\je`Z `\g}cZvZl d\zf\]_dw]\ &$ +!%&.  5
cdZad c`_†_j_ fZ[Zy]\de †_l`av. x]Z- % + 5   * E",
cdZ `_j\ld\ g `\yZ vafhdZv a cj\ld\ \yZ > + '&>& , — $, -
†\]\u `\cvZjevZ za`wd. b_l`av `_y]\- + +. A%, +*, + +
\dch a `_†`\d “[}|_de”. “\f\]e Z` yZ- 5.
 
   


 
  
  
  
    
 ! 
  
 "
  

 -  -   


‹_j-z_j_-z_c_j_ $, '" !E — $E%, % t


& +'", <$%, $+ 
{]wy_h g\jav_h †_l`_h [\]^_g_ — •`- >& !E, —  <'%" '"
[ah — hgjh\dch \\ a yj_g`}z fZ-   !" >$…  !%, $-
cd_gavZz cf\‚al `_ za]ZgZl ]}`Zv. !". /"5 > * !+ 0C
€_[Z ja w[agjhdech dZzw, †dZ az\``Z +%. D>, % ", >'&
g •`[aa, fZzazZ Zo}†`Z u_g_]\``ZyZ  $! #$+ '%, !+#"
†_h (cwj\lz_`a, v_v \yZ d_z `_u}g_ˆd) *>$,  $ # !
Z†\`e jˆohd †_l cZ cf\‚ahza?   '%% <*& +-
YjZgZ “z_c_j_”, ZoZu`_†_ˆ\\ `_oZ] &+ !$+.
cf\‚al, f]Z`avjZ [_^\ a g wuo\vcval
hu}v — g ›uo\vacd_`\ cz\ce cf\‚al “_vZl †_l f]\v]_c`Z cZy]\g_\d g f]Z-
[jh Zf]\[\j\``ZyZ ojˆ[_ `_u}g_ˆd zZuyj}\ [`a, `Z, v_v `a cd]_``Z, ŠZ]Z-
“z_c_j}v”. €Z g ›uo\vacd_`\ a `\ [Zy_- |Z \yZ g}fade a g ^_]w. …_v yZgZ]ad-
[}g_ˆdch Z dZz, v_vaz u_z\†_d\je`}z ch — vja` vja`Zz g}|ao_ˆd.  _]_,
zZ^\d fZjw†adech †_l, \cja u_g_]a- [wŠZd_, _ cd_v_` d_vZyZ yZ]h†\yZ, Zo-
g_de \yZ v_v g •`[aa — cZ cf\‚ahza a ^ay_ˆ\yZ, `_c}\``ZyZ a v]\fvZyZ
zZjZvZz! †_h — a g} g[]wy cZu`_\d\, `_cvZjevZ
ŠZ]Z|_ ^au`e!
/<"+ > >5  $"$ < “ZjevZ `_[Z fZ`az_de, †dZ `_cdZje-
'"#, >+ & '&> $  - vZ v]\fval, `_fad_``}l cf\‚ahza †_l
& 'V+. 4  5>+ +- cj\[w\d fade fZ`\z`Zyw. Yd_v_`†av, `\
$+  +"8 $!5$  5> +- oZje|\ — gZd f]_gaje`_h z\]_!
  
   
  
("       #)
–    $
% $

"#$ % 01

tƒ ‡o[wjj_, fZ[^ay_l! %> !<5, '5&. A 


 $!5$  !"  ". +-
‡u\[[a`, ]_cvw]ag_l! #  >$ *$ $"$ +%,
>'& >"   !#& !$%
˜`_\d\, †dZ ŠZ]Z|a\ g\a o}cd]\\ gc\yZ  <!.
]_cf]Zcd]_`hˆdch, vZy[_ Z`a f\]\[_ˆd- /& $!5$, <&!" <$%, -
ch Zd []wy_ v []wyw? ˜[\ce, g ‹Zcvg\, w  + * $!5$, '&
z\`h fZhgajace []wueh-z_]Zvv_`‚}. ‡o- !+# <$%   !& -
[wjj_ a ‡u\[[a` oZje|a\ z_cd\]_ u_g_- , >'& !+&" >$.
]ag_de †_l a vZ‘\ [_ ]_cvw]ag_de v_jeh- * $"$ +%  <
`} [jh yZcd\l zZ[`}Š g\†\]a`Zv. ‡jj_Š >$ $!5$+, '"   "
c `aza, c v_jeh`_za [_ vZ‘\, fZczZd]a-  ". P,  "! A% $ + $<,
d\, v_vZl †_l! – `_w†ajch u_g_]ag_de d_- >  $+ , $$ >, +% %I-
vZl †_l w zZaŠ []wu\l. ‡ h — g_| []wy " $+&? O, >  5 D5,
a ŠZ†w `_w†ade u_g_]ag_de ”dZd †_l g_c! '8  5 9$$!
xZv_^\dch ja g_z cd]_``}z, †dZ O+ ' > >< $"$ +%
g ‹_]ZvvZ feˆd u\j\`}l †_l? “w[_, g $!5, $  ! 5 >-
‹_]ZvvZ, dZ]yZg‚} f]agZuhd ZcZo}\  '<&"5 $!$5, %>5
cZ]d_ u\j\`ZyZ †_h, oZj\\ gc\yZ d_z fZ- !,  >  '% !*" +5% 
fwjh]\` †_l fZ[ wcjZg`}z `_ug_`a\z '"5. < $$ +5 > %
“fZ]ZŠ”, `Z \cja g_z fZf_[\dch a`[al- <" ! $+, "<5, >'& +5
cval u\j\`}l [_][^aja`y — `_ zZl !+,  * " >-
gvwc, Z` fZ[Zl[\d jw†|\ gc\yZ. "  E.

/<"+ +>$ >$ — %># €Z cf]_g\[jagZcda ]_[a g_^`Z cv_-


+& ,  +" '!- u_de, †dZ o_[eh` [Zo_gjhˆd dZjevZ g c\-
 ,    !,  
 


g\]`Zl †_cda ‹_]ZvvZ — [jh dw]acdZg. v_^\dch, †dZ zZ^`Z ZoZldace a Z[`Zl tr
‡ `_ ˆy\ jˆ[a zZywd a `\ u`_de, †dZ d_vZ\ dZjevZ zhdZl aja zhdZl c o_[eh`Zz.
o_[eh`. ˜_dZ fZ gc\l cd]_`\ g †_l [Zo_g- ‰\[e [\jZ `\ cdZjevZ g cf\‚ahŠ a
jhˆd z\jaccw, u_ acvjˆ†\`a\z [gwŠ uaz- d]_g_Š, cvZjevZ g cfZcZo\ u_g_]ag_`ah
`aŠ z\ch‚\g, vZy[_ cg\^\l z\jacc} `\ †_h — f\]g_h cv]afv_-dZ fZ-jˆoZzw
o}g_\d. ‹Z^`Z, vZ`\†`Z, u_z\`ade cg\- Zcd_\dch u_ `az, u_ †_\z — g\ja†_l-
^wˆ z\jaccw cw|\`Zl, `Z cdZad ja? ‹`\ |az `_fadvZz gc\Š g]\z\` a `_]Z[Zg.
Вы почему кефир
не кушаете?
Не любите?

q~

В
Z gc\Š zZaŠ ]_ccv_u_Š Z \[\ gc\z c]_uw, h ]_ccv_^w Z c_z}Š g_^`}Š
fZcdZh``Z gcd]\†_ˆdch wfZ- zZjZ†`}Š f]Z[wvd_Š _u\]o_l[^_`cvZl
za`_`ah Z zZjZ†`}Š a zZ- a c]\[`\_ua_dcvZl vwŠ`a, fZcvZjevw
jZ†`Zvacj}Š f]Z[wvd_Š. Y _`_jZya†`}\ f]Z[wvd} ]_cf]Zcd]_`\-
zZjZ†`}Š f]Z[wvdZg `_†a- `} a w z`ZyaŠ []wyaŠ `_]Z[Zg.
`_\dch ^au`e gchvZyZ †\jZg\v_, Z`a cZ- ‰uyjh[ fwd\|\cdgwˆ\yZ fZ ‡u\]-
cd_gjhˆd g_^`wˆ †_cde ]_‚aZ`_ zw[]}Š o_l[^_`w ]_ugj\v_\d z`Z^\cdgZ gchvZl
[ZjyZ^ad\j\l g f\]aZ[ aŠ u]\jZcda a gZje`Z f_cw\lch [Zz_|`\l cvZda`}:
cd_`Zghdch \[g_ ja `\ c_z}za yj_g`}- †wde ja `\ †\]\u v_^[}\ cdZ |_yZg f_-
za f]Z[wvd_za g cd_]Zcda, gfjZde [Z cwdch o}†va, vZ]Zg} aja cd_[_ o_]_`Zg.
f\]\ŠZ[_ g za] a`Zl. ‹Z\ _ocZjˆd`Z\ …Zja†\cdgZ [Zz_|`\l ^ag`Zcda fZ-
wo\^[\`a\ cZcdZad g dZz, †dZ a g fZ]w ]_^_\d gZZo]_^\`a\ a ]_[w\d Z[`Zg]\-
]_c‚g\d_, vZy[_ Z]y_`auz vafad ”`\]ya- z\``Z — _ †\z \\ wcj_^[_de cgZl guZ]
\l, _ c\][‚\ f]Zcad fZ†da gc\y[_ Z[`ZyZ vwja`_]w-jˆoad\jˆ, v_v `\ ŠZ]Z|aza,
a dZyZ ^\ — ga`_ a zhc_, f]\`\o]\y_de `_dw]_je`}za f]Z[wvd_za, fwcde fZv_
zZjZ†`Zvacj}za f]Z[wvd_za `\ cdZad, \\ oj\ˆaza a z}†_aza? ‡ [Zo]Z-
_ `_ZoZ]Zd — g ‚\jhŠ wv]\fj\`ah u[Z]Z- cZg\cd`Z ZdvZ]zj\``}\ vZ]Zg} c g}-
geh Zohu_d\je`Z cj\[w\d `_†a`_de aza z\`\z, fZj`}z zZjZv_, — ]_ug\ ”dZ `\
cgZl u_gd]_v a u_v_`†ag_de w^a`. f]\v]_c`Z\ u]\ja\? €\ u`_ˆ, v_v w g_c,
{_, `\ w[agjhld\ce, zZjZ†`}\ f]Z- _ w z\`h f]a ga[\ [Zz_|`\l fda‚} a
[wvd}, ay]_ˆa\ g_^`\l|wˆ ]Zje g cvZd_ `_ c\][‚\ fZhgjh\dch wza]ZdgZ-
]_‚aZ`\ `_]Z[Zg —Zccaa a šg]Zf}, \\ ]\`a\, h cd_`Zgjˆce [Zo]\\, g\c\j\\ a w
oZj\\ ]_cf]Zcd]_`\`} Zd ‹Z`yZjaa [Z z\`h f]Zow^[_\dch ŠZ]Z|al _ff\dad.
Y]\[`\l ‡uaa, Zd •]_`_ [Z …_gv_u_ a €Z g\]`\zch v zZjZvw. …Z]Zg_-
Zd •`[Zcd_`_ gfjZde [Z ’ja^`\yZ ‰Zc- vZ]zaja‚_ — ”dZ fZ`hda\ ŠZ]Z|Z u`_-
dZv_. bdZo} `\ f}d_dech ]_ccv_u_de ZoZ vZzZ z`Zyaz `_]Z[_z, g dZz †acj\ a
_u\]o_l[^_`‚_z. xZzazZ vZ]Zg} fZ†- d_v ^\ cZŠ]_`ajace [Z caŠ fZ] ja|e
da g v_^[Zz ŠZuhlcdg\ Zohu_d\je`} fZdZzw, †dZ au zZjZv_ owlgZja‚ fZjw-
vZu} [_ Zg‚}, z\jval cvZd ]_ugZ[hd †_ˆd g}cZvZ ‚\`az}\ y_cd]Z`Zz_za
gc\-d_va f]\azw\cdg\``Z ]_[a zhc_ u_z\†_d\je`}\ c}]}. €Z dZ •d_jah,
aja |\]cda, zZjZv_ Zd `\yZ z`ZyZ `\ fZ`az_\d\ ja, d_z z`ZyZ `_ †dZ yZdZ-
[Zo}de, [Zade — fZ†da c\o\ g wo}dZv. g} fZlda ]_[a ŠZ]Z|\l \[}, [_ a dw-
€Z zZjZvZ w vZu a Zg\‚ †]\ug}†_l`Z ]acd} gc\y[_ yZdZg} ]_cvZ|\jadech, _
fZj\u`Z\, [_ a gvwc w `\yZ ZcZo\``}l, a u[\ce — ‡u\]o_l[^_`, Z[`_ au o}g|aŠ
ŠZuhlva a †_o_`} `\ j\`hdch — [Zhd! cZg\dcvaŠ ]\cfwojav, `Z Zd`Z|\`a\ v
€Z, †dZo} o}jZ fZ`hd`Z, `_cvZje- \[\ — dZ ^\ c_zZ\! —Zg`Z d_ ^\ yZdZg-
vZ g ‡u\]o_l[^_`\ ‚\`hd zZjZvZ a zZ- `Zcde fZ^\]dgZg_de cgZoZ[`}z g]\z\-

qk

jZ†`}\ f]Z[wvd}, h g_z [Zj^\` cv_- `\z `_ ]_[Zcde gvwcZg}z ]\‚\fdZ]_z,


u_de: d_z [Z caŠ fZ] ]_ugZ[hd owlgZjZg! yZdZg`Zcde `\ f]ZcdZ [Zo}g_de \[w f]a
‹\`h ”dZ w[agjh\d fZdZzw, †dZ yj_g`Z\, fZzZa v]\[ad`Zl v_]dZ†va `_ fZjv_Š
†\z g cgZ\ g]\zh o}j ‚\`\` [jh oZje- cwf\]z_]v\d_, `Z a d]_dade g]\zh `_
|a`cdg_ `_]Z[Zg ‡uaa owlgZj, — fZ- \\ g}]_ag_`a\ a, c_zZ\ yj_g`Z\, ZcZ-
zZe g c\jecvZz ŠZuhlcdg\. ‹ZjZvZ u`_`a\ dZyZ, †dZ g [_``}Š wcjZgahŠ ”d_
owlgZja‚, `\czZd]h `_ \yZ g}cZvwˆ \[_ — `\u_z\`az_ a hgjh\dch `\ZcfZ-
fad_d\je`wˆ ‚\``Zcde, _ua_d} c†ad_- ]azZl ‚\``Zcdeˆ.
ja v_v o} fZoZ†`}z f]Z[wvdZz, g [Z- Y[\j_ld\ gz\cd\ cZ z`Zl `\cvZjevZ
fZj`\`a\ v dhyjZgZl caj\. ‡ d\f\]e, Z†\`e f]Zcd}Š |_yZg ]_[a dZyZ, †dZo}
vZy[_ `_[Zo`Zcde g d_vZl fZzZa ‘_v- f]hzZ w g_c [Zz_ au Zo}†`ZyZ zZjZv_
da†\cva Zdf_j_ a g}]_cdade owlgZja‚w fZjw†ade Z†\`e gvwc`}\ a `\u_z\`a-
cdZad cdZjevZ ^\, cvZjevZ a vZ]Zgw, dZ z}\ f]Z[wvd}.
g}oZ] g fZjeuw owlgZjZg f]ZacŠZ[ad
au-u_ Z[`ZyZ dZjevZ zZjZv_. ‰\[e vZ]Z-
g} a o}†va [_ˆd \\ a u_z\†_d\je`wˆ
yZgh[a`w, _ jˆ[a gc\ ]_g`Z f]Z[Zj^_- …_d}v aja lZyw]d?
ˆd g}]_ag_de owlgZjZg, `\czZd]h `_
dZ †dZ zhcZ aŠ ^\cdvZ\! ‹ZjZvZ ZcZoZ\ Y_z}l f]ZcdZl, c_z}l ]_cf]Zcd]_`\`-
w owlgZja‚, c}]} gvwc`}\ fZjw†_ˆd- `}l a c_z}l yj_g`}l f]Z[wvd, vZdZ-
ch, vacjZzZjZ†`}\ f]Z[wvd} w`av_je- ]}l fZjw†_ˆd au zZjZv_, — ”dZ v_d}v.
`}\ — gZd g †\z [\jZ, gZd a g\ce ]\uZ` •`_†\ \yZ `_u}g_ˆd z_‚Z`a (gf]Z†\z,
g}]_ag_de owlgZjZg! vZ\-y[\ \yZ a yZdZghd ZcZo}z Zo]_uZz,
€\gZje`Z `_f]_|ag_\dch _`_jZyah z} \\ Zo ”dZz fZyZgZ]az) aja lZyw]d.
c •d_ja\l, cd_g|\l [jh z`ZyaŠ vwja- “£Zyw]d” — cjZgZ oZj\\ u`_vZzZ\,
`_]`Zl ‹\vvZl, y[\ owlgZj} dZ†`Z dZjevZ fZ[Z^[ad\, `\ dZ]Zfad\ce
qm

wdg\]^[_de, †dZ g} Z `\z u`_\d\ gc\. j_f_za, \[g_ dZjevZ u_ga[hd u_g\d`wˆ
“Z, †dZ w `_c fZjw†adch au zZjZv_, ow- o_`Z†vw.
[\d g\cez_ Zd[_j\``Z `_fZza`_de d\ šcde ja w z_y_ua``ZyZ lZyw]d_ a `_-
lZyw]d}, †dZ f]Z[_ˆd g z_y_ua`_Š. ‰\]- cdZh\yZ v_d}v_ `\†dZ Zo\\? ‰c\ dZ, Z
`\\, `_ZoZ]Zd, ”dZ z_y_ua``}\ lZyw]- †\z g_z yZgZ]hd g ]\vj_z\ lZyw]d_, —
d} ja|e cj\yv_ fZŠZ^a `_ fZ[ja``}\, g}cZv_h fad_d\je`_h ‚\``Zcde, ŠZ]Z-
fZ”dZzw [_g_ld\ Zdz\^w\zch Zd ”dZyZ |_h wcgZh\zZcde Z]y_`auzZz v_je‚ah
[acv]\[ada]Zg_``ZyZ `_ug_`ah “lZ- f]a wfZd]\oj\`aa ”dZyZ f]Z[wvd_, fZ-
yw]d” a [_je|\ ow[\z `_u}g_de `_| g}|\`a\ azzw`ad\d_, `Z]z_jau_‚ah
f]Z[wvd “v_d}v” aja “z_‚Z`a”. fa\g_]\`ah — gc\ ”da fZcwj} v_d}v
˜`_\d\, g †\z yj_g`Z\ ]_uja†a\ z\^- acfZj`ad `_g\]`hv_. ‡ gZd g Zo\_`-
[w v_d}vZz aja z_‚Z`a, c Z[`Zl cdZ]Z- `}Š cfZcZo`ZcdhŠ z_y_ua``ZyZ lZyw]d_
`}, a z_y_ua``}z lZyw]dZz — c []w- w z\`h gZu`av_ˆd c\]e\u`}\ cZz`\`ah,
yZl? bdZo} v_d}v aja z_‚Z`a cd_ja vZdZ]}za h c g_za fZ[\jˆce fZcj\
gvwc`}za a f]agj\v_d\je`}za, g `aŠ dZyZ, v_v z} gz\cd\ g f\]g}l ]_u c[\j_-
`\ `_[Z [Zo_gjhde `a vwcZ†va ‘]wvdZg, \z v_d}v.
`a _]Zz_dau_dZ]}, `a gvwcZg}\ [Z- {jh f]ayZdZgj\`ah v_d}v_ `_z fZ-
o_gva. ` gvwc\` c_z fZ c\o\, \yZ \[hd c `_[Zoadch zZjZvZ. o}†`Z\ zZjZvZ Zd
ZŠZdZl [\da, _ ]_uoa]_ˆa\ch g j_vZz- Zo}†`Zl vZ]Zg}. {_, h fZ`az_ˆ, †dZ
cdg_Š vZ|va — d_v f]ZcdZ c wz_ cŠZ[hd, oau`\c `_ f]Z[wvd_Š fad_`ah u_y`_j
`_†a`_ˆd `_ cfa`\ g_jhdech a [\]y_de `_cdZh\\ zZjZvZ g d_vZl [\‘a‚ad, vZ-
dZ]}l [_^\ a †\]\u “dZg_]Zg\[–u_go_- ZcZo}Š o_vd\]al, o\u vZdZ]}Š zZjZ†`Z-
uZl” `\ [Zcd_de, a z`Zya\ w^\ u_o}ja vacj}\ f]Z[wvd} fZjw†_ˆdch dZjevZ `_
cf\‚a‘a†\cval gvwc f_]`ZyZ zZjZv_. f]ZaugZ[cdg_Š gchvZl acvwccdg\``Zl
€Z… [Zzav g [\]\g`\ o}g_\d `\ dZjevZ []h`a c vwcZ†v_za ‘]wvdZg. xZ”dZzw h
`_ wf_vZgv\, a, \cja vZzw fZg\ujZ, d_v [g_^[} yZdZg f\]\fj_dade `\j\`agZl
a[ad\, ]_u}ad\ dw d\dvw, vZdZ]_h ^a- d\dv\: g f\]g}l ]_u u_ `_dw]_je`Zcde, _
g\d fZ cZc\[cdgw c g_|\l [_†\l a [Z caŠ gdZ]Zl ]_u u_ Zdcwdcdga\ vZ`c\]g_`dZg.
fZ] [\]^ad vZ]Zgw, [ZyZg_]ag_ld\ce ‹Zy o} f]afj_dade a g d]\dal ]_u — g
c `\l, fj_dad\ \l [\`eya a fZ[[\]^a- v_†\cdg\ cdazwjh‚aa f]ZaugZ[cdg_,
g_ld\ Zd\†\cdg\``ZyZ f]ZaugZ[ad\jh! fZdZzw †dZ o\u cgZ\yZ zZjZv_, `Z c az-
‰ vZ`‚\ vZ`‚Zg [_^\ a `_ ]}`v_Š, o}- fZ]d`}z zZjZ†`}z fZ]Z|vZz z} `\
g_\d, †dZ f]agZuhd zZjZvZ, f]Z[_ˆd ow- y_cd]Z`Zza†\cv_h [\]^_g_, _ v_vZ\-dZ
d}jv_za — zZ^`Z a d_z vwfade. Y_zZ\ `\[Z]_uwz\`a\, f]ajZ^\`a\ v fZjecvZ-
yj_g`Z\, †dZo} ”dZ `\ Zv_u_jZce zZjZ†- vad_lcvZzw fa\f]Zzw.
`}z fZ]Z|vZz, ]_ug\[\``}z oZy g\cde Yjw|_ld\, _ g} fZ`az_\d\ ]_u`a‚w
v_vZl gZ[Zl. xZdZzw †dZ g ”dZz cjw†_\
f]Z\ fZlda g dZd ^\ c_z}l d]\vjhd}l
z\^[w cjZg_za “f]Zvac`\d” a “f]ZdwŠ-
`\d”, vZdZ]}\ dZjevZ †dZ f]Zugw†_ja?
qt
cwf\]z_]v\d a vwfade zZjZvZ d_z — g {\jZ g dZz, †dZ f]Zvac|\\ zZjZvZ gZ-
w[Zo`Zl, v]_cagZl f_†v\, u`_vZzZl fZ gc\ `\ Zohu_d\je`Z g}jag_de, v_v g cjw-
f]Zcg\]jag|\l g\ce zZuy ]\vj_z\. †_\ c f]ZdwŠ|az. o}†`Z jˆ[a fZ[]_u-
“ZjevZ g} ^\ jˆ[a y]_zZd`}\, fZ- wz\g_ˆd, †dZ g d_vZ\ zZjZvZ \cd\cdg\`-
`az_de [Zj^`} `\vZdZ]}\ f]Zcd}\ `}z fwd\z fZf_ja ZcZo}\ o_vd\]aa,
g\a. ‰ ‚\`\, †dZ g} u_fj_dad\ u_ zZjZ- `\ g]\[`}\, _, cvZ]\\, fZj\u`}\, vZdZ-
vZ g cwf\]z_]v\d\, w^\ cZ[\]^adch ]\- ]}\ Zf]\[\j\``}z Zo]_uZz auz\`aja
vj_z`}l oˆ[^\d a `\z_j_h f]ao}je cgZlcdg_ zZjZv_. šyZ \\ zZ^`Z c\cde,
f]ZaugZ[ad\j\l. ‰}†dad\ ”da [\`eya d_vZl zZjZ†`}l f]Z[wvd `_u}g_\dch
a fZczZd]ad\, †dZ Zcd_`\dch. cd_`\d- “f]ZcdZvg_|_”.
ch ]Zg`Z `_ fZ]Z|Zv, gZ[w, wf_vZgvw a €Z jw†|\ gc\yZ `\ [Z^a[_dech, †\yZ
vZ`c\]g_`d}. {_, vZ`c\]g_`d}, fZdZzw d_z a cvZjevZ fZf_[\d g zZjZvZ au
†dZ `_dw]_je`Z\ zZjZvZ [Zj^`Z f]Z- Zv]w^_ˆ\l c]\[}, _ fZjZ^ade u_vg_-
vac_de, _ ”dZ `\ vac`\d, [_^\ ow[w†a Zd- cva — Zcd_dva g†\]_|`\l, w[_†`Zl `_
v]}d}z a Zcd_gj\``}z g`\ ŠZjZ[aje- gvwc, ŠZ]Z|\l a fZj\u`Zl f]ZcdZvg_|a.
`av_. ‰c\ fZ`hd`Z: hvZo} u_z\†_d\je- €_ c_zZz [\j\ w^\ [_g`}z-[_g`Z
`}\ cZg]\z\``}\ d\Š`ZjZyaa, hvZo} `avdZ `\ fZj_y_\dch `_ gZjˆ cjw†_h,
f_cd\]au_‚ah, `Z gc\ ]_g`Z — ”da zZ- †dZ g zZjZvZ fZf_[wd az\``Z f]_gaje-
jZ†`}\ `_fadva cvZ]\\ acfZ]dhdch †\- `}\ o_vd\]aa, a jˆ[a u_vg_|ag_ˆd zZ-
]\u `\cvZjevZ `\[\je, f]ZdwŠ`wd, `Z ”dZ jZvZ f]Zg\]\``Zl u_vg_cvZl. ždw vwje-
d_v `_u}g_\zZ\ zZjZvZ `\ f]Zvac`\d, dw]w o\]\ywd, cd_]_ˆdch u_vg_|ag_de
v_v fZjZ^\`Z `Z]z_je`Zzw f]Z[wvdw. zZjZvZ v_^[}l [\`e, `\ gc\ u_vg_|\`-
‰f]Z†\z, [_^\ a g cwf\]z_]v\d_Š `Z\ zZjZvZ c\[_ˆd, `Z Zcd_gjhˆd `\-
zZ^`Z fZacv_de, z`\ fZf_[_jZce zZjZ- z`ZyZ `_ u_gd]_, †dZo} u_vg_cade cg\-
vZ g f_v\d_Š c f]\[wf]\^[\`a\z Z `\- ^\\ zZjZvZ, vZdZ]Z\ v wd]w ow[\d d_v ^\
ZoŠZ[azZcda Š]_`\`ah g ŠZjZ[aje`av\ Zohu_d\je`Z, v_v cZj`‚\ gcd_`\d.
a g d\†\`a\ ja|e `\cvZjevaŠ [`\l, `Z •z\``Z d_vaz, _ocZjˆd`Z f]Zcd}z
`\ z\ch‚\g. ‰Zd ”dZ, cvZ]\\ gc\yZ, `_dw- cfZcZoZz fZjw†_ˆd v_d}v g Y]\[`\l
]_je`Z\ zZjZvZ aja ŠZdh o} ]_ug\[\`- ‡uaa. “Z \cde g \\ d\fjZ\, f_]`Z\ zZ-
`}l zZjZ†`}l fZ]Z|Zv o\u vZ`c\]- jZvZ u_vj_[}g_ˆd u_vg_cvw, cZ[\]^_-
g_`dZg. – o\cfZvZˆce Z vZ`c\]g_`d_Š `\ wˆ ZcZo}l ga[ o_vd\]al, a Zcd_gjhˆd
fZdZzw, †dZ c†ad_ˆ aŠ v_d_cd]Z‘a†\cva zZjZvZ wvwd_``}z, †dZo} Z`Z [Zje|\
g]\[`}za. ‰ dZz, †dZ Z`a `\ fZj\u`}, Zcd_g_jZce d\fj}z, [Z wd]_. ‰ d\fjZz
h `\ cZz`\g_ˆce, `Z c vZ`c\]g_`d_za w zZjZv\ o_vd\]aa ]_oZd_ˆd o}cd]\\, a
`_c `a†\yZ `\ fZjw†adch, `a v_d}v, `a wd]Zz v_d}v ow[\d w^\ yZdZg.
z_‚Z`a — `a†\yZ. xZ`az_\d\? …Z`c\]- •`d\]\c`Z, †dZ `_ Zy]Zz`Zz f]Z-
g_`d} ow[wd f]\fhdcdgZg_de ]_ugadaˆ cd]_`cdg\ Zd Y]\[`\l ‡uaa [Z ’Zjy_-
]aa ]_cf]Zcd]_`\`} [g_ ga[_ o_vd\]al, €\ Zohu_d\je`Z [Z^a[_dech wv_u_``}Š
cz\ceˆ vZdZ]}Š jˆ[a u_vg_|ag_ˆd zZ- gZceza †_cZg — \cja zZjZvZ cywcda-
jZvZ, — ”dZ oZjy_]cv_h f_jZ†v_ a d\]zZ- jZce, dZ \yZ cj\[w\d `\z\[j\``Z wo]_de
‘aje`}l cd]\fdZvZvv. €_ug_`a\ vacjZ- g ŠZjZ[aje`av, _ a`_†\ v_d}v Zv_^\dch
yZ zZjZv_ auz\`ajZce c f\]\z\\`a\z cja|vZz vacj}z. šcja d\zf\]_dw]_ a
gZ g]\z\`a a ]_ccdZh`a\z, \yZ `_u}g_- g]\zh cvg_|ag_`ah fZ[Zo]_`} g\]`Z,
ˆd “v_d}v”, “z_cd”, “z_‚Z`a”, “z_‚w`”, dZ v_d}v fZjw†_\dch ja|e c j\yvZl vac-
“lZyw]d”, “vac\jZ zjhvZ”, d\Š`ZjZyah ja`vZl, Z[`Z]Z[`}z a d_vaz fjZd`}z,
f]ayZdZgj\`ah `\z`ZyZ auz\`aj_ce, _ †dZ \cja fZjZ^ade `_ \yZ fZg\]Š`Zcde
vwjedw]} [jh u_vg_|ag_`ah Zcd_jace jZ^vw, Z`_ `\ wdZ`\d.
d\ ^\ c_z}\ — c]\[a cZd\` gZuzZ^`}Š! —_`e|\ wvwd}g_ja v_cd]ˆja a yZ]|-
va c zZjZvZz g Z[\hj_ a Zcd_gjhja aŠ
/ +$ <% ! $   +5 w f\†a, `\vZdZ]}\ a gZgc\ cd_gaja yZ]-
!E*5 +* !!" $$- |Zv c u_vg_|\``}z zZjZvZz g Zcd}g_-
$> ! '$,  , ˆwˆ fZcj\ f]ayZdZgj\`ah faa f\†e.
qq $& + %*&. J +* $<"5, – f]acfZcZoaj v ”dZzw [\jw ]acZg_]vw.
> R '$ $<5 $% $&$,  ¤_vda†\cva ”dZ oZje|Zl d\]zZc c `_-
I  %8I+ '<+ <%8 y]\g_d\je`}z ”j\z\`dZz. xZcj\ dZyZ
 # !"& '$, $& v_v zZjZvZ f]Zvaf\jZ, h f\]\jag_ˆ \yZ
5  '  ! < %$  g fZjjad]Zg}\ o_`va, u_vj_[}g_ˆ g
%$   <$$. R+% %># !- v_^[wˆ o_`vw fZ jZ^v\ u_vg_cva — f\-
$!5" +$, >'& '&" %&+ — ]\z\|ag_de `a†\yZ `\ `_[Z, gc\ f]Za-
 +  " $$ ! uZl[\d c_zZ cZoZl — a cd_gjˆ o_`va g
+$<+. J % !%%,  $%8 \zvZcde ]acZg_]va, [_^\ `\ fZ[vjˆ†_h
+& '%+ !" +$,  $ \\ v ”j\vd]a†\cdgw. ˜_v]}g_ˆ a Zcd_g-
+$ '% <$#"5, *  jhˆ \yZ [Z wd]_. ›d]Zz g o_`v_Š Zo]_-
I" !+&", &%#",  I %># uw\dch f]\gZcŠZ[`}l v_d}v, †_cde vZ-
<". * &+&%8 - dZ]ZyZ zZ^`Z fZ[_de `\fZc]\[cdg\``Z
$5%8 !%% $"$ +%  +$- v u_gd]_vw, _ †_cde wo]_de g ŠZjZ[aje-
$ — !I  * !' `av. {\jZ g dZz, †dZ \cja Zcd_gade v_-
<E  !%+". d}v g d\fj\, dZ o_vd\]aa a`d\`cag`Z
O!"  !*", !$ +$ f]Z[Zj^_d cgZˆ ]_oZdw, a gvwc v_d}v_
&. W !*" <$$%  5> a \yZ cgZlcdg_ `_†`wd z\`hdech. —_u-
+$,  R %'"  '$, !+% ja†_ˆd [_^\ Z[`Z[`\g`}l v_d}v (f]Z-
> !+"5 +!% 5 *<- cdZhg|al Z[`w `Z†e) a “cd_]}l” v_d}v,
5" +>$& '$ +23– vZdZ]Zzw w^\ [`h d]a. “_v gZd, Z[`Z-
B3 °F. D +$ &  '- [`\g`}l v_d}v a cd_]}l v_d}v [_^\ `_
+ +!%&,    !*" <- fa\g_]ad\je`wˆ cacd\zw [\lcdgwˆd
$$%, ! > " >  =–(0  fZ-]_u`Zzw.
!+ +,    '%% 5" €Z o_vd\]aa f]Z[Zj^_d cgZˆ ]_oZdw
* %>&+ #+ ! !%. [_^\ a g ŠZjZ[aje`av\, y[\ d\zf\]_dw-
]_ q–ƒ °Y. xZ”dZzw [Zje|\ `\[\ja v_-
‹ZjZvZ Zd ]_u`}Š vZ]Zg zZ^\d Zdja- d}v Š]_`ade `\ cdZad a g ŠZjZ[aje`av\.
†_dech cgZaz fZg\[\`a\z f]a u_vg_- {_ a `\ u_cdZadch Z` w g_c, gZd wga[ad\!
|ag_`aa. ‹Z^\d cd_dech d_v, †dZ fZcj\
u_vg_|ag_`ah zZjZvZ ]_u[\jadch `_ nZ]Z|Z wfZd]\oade v_d}v `_ u_gd]_v,
‘]_v‚aa — `_ c_z cywcdZv a c}gZ]Zdvw cZ cg\^az Šj\oZz, g ^_]val [\`e ŠZ]Z-
oj\[`Z-u\j\`Zg_dZyZ ‚g\d_. ‰ ”dZz `\d |Z u_f]_gade az ZgZ`Zl c_j_d v Zo\-
`a†\yZ cd]_|`ZyZ, `Z g cj\[wˆal ]_u [w, `Z a f\]\[ c`Zz, \cja c\cde jZ^vw
fZf]Zowld\ u_vg_cade d_vZ\ zZjZvZ f]a z\[_ [_ u_\cde fZ[Zy]\d}z [Z vZz`_d-
d\zf\]_dw]\ `_ [g_-d]a y]_[wc_ `a^\. `Zl d\zf\]_dw]} cd_v_`Zz v_d}v_ —
“Z†`Z d_v ^\ zZ^\d Zdja†_dech a `a†\yZ jw†|\yZ f]a[wz_de `\jeuh, [jh
g]\zh cvg_|ag_`ah, vZdZ]Z\ u_gacad `\ dZyZ †dZo} fZ^\j_de cgZ\zw Z]y_`auzw
dZjevZ Zd zZjZv_, `Z a cgZlcdg u_vg_cva. “cfZvZl`Zl `Z†a”.
xZyZ[ad\, [_g_ld\ d\f\]e gz\cd\ fZ- gade \yZ g c\da dZ]yZgja, f]ZaugZ[ad\-
[wz_\z. ‡ fZ†\zw ”dZ w `_c v_d}v, f]a- ja d_d\je`Z w`a†dZ^_ˆd gc\ o_vd\-
yZdZgj\``}l `_ `_dw]_je`Zz zZjZv\, c ]aa. xZ”dZzw †_\ gc\yZ z_y_ua``}l
fZzZeˆ `_dw]_je`Zl u_vg_cva, g _o- lZyw]d f]\[cd_gjh\d cZoZl zZjZ†`}l
cZjˆd`Z cd\]aje`Zl fZcw[\ zZ^\d Š]_- f]Z[wvd, fZjw†\``}l au zZjZ†`ZyZ fZ-
`adech `\ oZje|\ c\za [`\l, [_ a dZ g ]Z|v_, c Zcd_dv_za ^au`\[\hd\je`Zcda
ŠZjZ[aje`av\? ‰ z_y_ua`_Š-dZ lZyw]d o_vd\]al, fZ cjZg_z f]ZaugZ[ad\j\l
f]Z[_ˆd \[g_ ja `\ yZ[_za, a Z` gc\ ZoZy_\``}l gad_za`_za a vwcZ†v_za
]_g`Z \\ yZ[\` v wfZd]\oj\`aˆ? ‘]wvdZg, _ \\ vZ`c\]g_`d_za, v]_ca-
iZ[\`-dZ Z` yZ[\`, z_jZ ja †dZ d\jhza a _]Zz_dau_dZ]_za, cd}[jagZ
zZ^`Z c\cde a `\ Zd]_gadech. €Z `_- f\]\†acj\``}za c_z}za z_j\`evaza
cvZjevZ fZj\u\`? ‰\[e v_d}v fZdZzw owvg_za. ždZd f]Z[wvd zZ^\d Š]_`ade-
fZj\u`\\ cg\^\yZ zZjZv_, †dZ g `\z cZ- ch Z†\`e [ZjyZ, `av_v `\ auz\`hhce.
[\]^_dch fZj\u`}\ [jh `_|\yZ fa\- ‰ZZo\-dZ `Z]z_je`}\ ‘]wvd} dZ^\
g_]\`ah o_vd\]aa. •z\``Z o_vd\]aa [Zj^`} o}ja fZ]dadech, `w [_ j_[`Z,
c[\j_ja zZjZvZ “^ag}z”, Z`a ]_c\- gc\ a d_v hc`Z. qp
faja j_vdZuw, _ g}[\jag|_hch vacjZd_
auz\`aj_ cd]wvdw]w o\jv_, cZ[\]^_\-
yZch g zZjZv\, a d\f\]e ”dw `Zgwˆ ‘Z]- ‹_‚Z`a
zw zZjZ†`}Š f]Z[wvdZg zZ^`Z wfZ-
d]\ojhde [_^\ d\z, w vZyZ g Z]y_`auz\ W +$ $!5" ,  >" 
w^\ ac†\uja ‘\]z\`d}, Zdg\†_ˆa\ &!5. O "   ' $-
u_ f\]\g_]ag_`a\ zZjZv_. › `\vZdZ- E&+,   +"#+ 'V+
]}Š jˆ[\l ”da ‘\]z\`d} cZŠ]_`hˆdch '% *" '"# $> !-
`_ gcˆ ^au`e, _ w `\vZdZ]}Š, f]a†\z w "& I. /$%, !5" *, !%-
oZje|a`cdg_, aŠ g}]_oZdv_ f]\v]__- >5 ' 5$+, &I&+. / 5
\dch. “_v gZd v_d}v aja `_dw]_je`}l '&  $%  !*" $8-
lZyw]d zZ^\d c\cde jˆoZl a fZjw†ade 8  +"$+  >-%, 
gc\ ‚\``Z\, †dZ cZ[\]^adch g zZjZv\. !+#5, >'& '<%8I55  !-
€Z g z_y_ua``Zz lZyw]d\ c [jad\je-  !$  +# !8.
`}z c]ZvZz Š]_`\`ah d_vaŠ o_vd\]al : !+  > $ *, $$  '&>&+
`\d. šcja Z`a a acfZjeuZg_jace g f]Z- $&$+ — %"  BC °F, <$",
‚\cc\ f]ZaugZ[cdg_, dZ, f]\^[\ †\z "  !, >'& + &-
]_c‘_cZg_de yZdZg}l f]Z[wvd a Zdf]_-   %,  %+ !" $ %!
YjZ\`}l v_lz_v, šcja g} ŠZdad\ fZjw†ade oZje|\
dZfj\`Z\ zZjZvZ, f\`va, dZ g]\zh Zd g]\z\`a Zdv]}g_de
[wŠZgvw gc\ ^\ f]a[\dch — [jh dZyZ,
]h^\`v_ †dZo} f]adZfade w^\ Zo]_uZg_g|wˆch
f\`vw a [_de gZuzZ^`Zcde Zo]_uZg_dech
šcja w g_c \cde ŠZ]Z|_h [wŠZgv_, vZdZ- `ZgZl.
]_h wz\\d [\]^_de d\zf\]_dw]w ZvZjZ
r~ °Y, dZ c†ad_ld\, †dZ g_z fZg\ujZ. 4 +5, !$ +$ '% +"5, 
+ '<%5 !5, 5 !$. J
A E" +$  #$%8 !- !$  !5, !$,  '%$"+ +&-
%% — $+>$%8, R+%8,  , <5! D$ !% & 
$5%8 — < !> !  %  !55, $ +-
8'5. " +$  %$%  <-  R% < E !$%  %$&
'%"  + >  (C–(0. 5+  $&$%. O"$ !%! $:
 !$,  +E,  !$, 
qs iZgZ]h f]_g[w, u_o}de `\ Z†\`e-dZ fZ- +E. J !" $&$%  ! +
jw†adch, fZdZzw †dZ g_|\ ZoZ`h`a\ >  ,  !+ %'  "$.
ow[wd d\]u_de u_f_Ša, u_cd_gjhˆa\
gcfZz`ade dZ, †\yZ a `\ cjw†ajZce g ›d]Zz fZ[_ld\ ”dZd cjZ\`}l v_lz_v `_
”dZl ^au`a — [\]\g`ˆ, f\†e, v]\fval u_gd]_v c f]Zcd}z Šj\oZz. xZcj\[`al
v]\cdeh`cval [Zcd_dZv. v_f]auwjh c\cd a, [_^\ `\ wda]_hce, fZ-
€Z o\cfZvZadech a o\u vZ`‚_ u_yjh- f]Zcad \\! ‰ ”dZz u_gd]_v\ \cde gc\, †dZ
[}g_de g [wŠZgvw `\ `_[Z — v_^[}l zZ^\d o}de fZj\u`ZyZ g zZjZv\, a ”dZ
gu[ZŠ Zdv]}dZl [g\]‚} Zcdw^_\d \\, `\Zo}v`Zg\``Z gvwc`Z.
g\[e Z`_ ]_oZd_\d `_ [ZgZje`Z `auvZl
d\zf\]_dw]\! x]ZcdZ `_[Z u_fZz`ade, F<%, ! + <%+5#5 !$,
†dZ zZjZvZ f]a ”dZl d\zf\]_dw]\ `\ u_- ! !&#+ ++  $+, -
vafad, `\ wo\^ad, `\ f]ayZ]ad. €a†\yZ 5 # ! +$.   $$
fjZŠZyZ c zZjZvZz f]a d_vZl d\zf\]_- ", > %># $%$ +# '
dw]\ cjw†adech f]ZcdZ `\ zZ^\d. $ R+% +$%  !%+".
q
€Z c_z}z d\]f\jag}z a d]w[Zjˆoa-  $$ +5, !%" >" &$
g}z \\ f]\[cdZad w[agadech ]_u- >. %>5 % $+, $-
`a‚\ gZ gvwc_Š z_y_ua``ZyZ ^_jvZ-  # !"  ++  $
yZ fZ[Zoah a `_cdZh\l, [Zz_|`\l '%$.
]h^\`va. ‰vwc w [Zz_|`\l ]h^\`va
fZjwu_o}d}l, _ [jh vZyZ-dZ a gZgc\ €w gc\, gc\! xZ[`az_ld\ce c [ag_`Zg,
`\aug\[_``}l — g f\]g}l ]_u fZf]Z- Zd]}g_ld\ce Zd wˆd`}Š v]\c\j! “]w[
owˆd \\ `_|a [\da. • gZd ]w†_ˆce g_z, [\j_\d ^au`e gvwc`\\!
Zo\_ˆ, †dZ ”dw ]h^\`vw Z`a fZjˆohd šcja `avdZ au g_|aŠ u`_vZz}Š aja
]_u a `_gc\y[_ a `\ `_[Z ow[\d wyZg_- cZc\[\l `\ [\j_\d [_^\ Zo}†`Zl f]Z-
]ag_de [\d\l fZ\cde, Z`a c_za ow[wd cdZvg_|a, a `\d gZuzZ^`Zcda vwfade
\\ f]Zcade! ]_[a u_vg_cva z_‚Z`a `_ ]}`v\, dZ fZ-
f]Zowld\ fZacv_de f]Z[_g‚Zg u_vg_cva
D$  "? : >" !! 4$"- g •`d\]`\d\. šcja `\ fZg\u\d g ]wccvZl
 ! +$, !$  I !, †_cda •`d\]`\d_, dZ u_ ]wo\^Zz g} `_l-
qƒ  *$ '&> !$#. [\d\ `\ZoŠZ[azZ\ Zohu_d\je`Z! – cj}-
A , >'& ! +$ $- |_j, †dZ cZg]\z\``}\ [_dcva\ a ‘]_`-
" ><+ , !+% > 5*- ‚wucva\ u_vg_cva ]_oZd_ˆd f]ZcdZ u_z\-
$ ' $% < '&, >+ †_d\je`Z. €Z h gfZj`\ [ZgZj\` a d\za
! +$. A  * $  !- u_vg_cv_za, †dZ `_|jace g €•• zZjZ†-
%>",  >  R+ # ! `Zl f]Zz}|j\``Zcda fZ z\cdw zZ\yZ
" 5*$%  +& +#>$ `}`\|`\yZ ^ad\jecdg_.
¥
‰ yZ]Z[v\, y[\ ^aj_ `_|_ c\zeh, o}jZ qr
`\ z`ZyZ _u\]o_l[^_`‚\g. ‰\]`\\, cv_-
^\z d_v: g`_†_j\ aŠ o}jZ gc\yZ [gZ\ —
zZl Zd\‚ [_ \yZ cd_]|al o]_d. xZ”dZzw
h `\ zZyw cv_u_de, †dZ u`_ˆ gvwc _u\]-
o_l[^_`cvZyZ †w]\v_ aja j_g_|_ c [\d-
cdg_. ‰Zgc\ `\d. ‰ [\dcdg\ Zv]w^_g|a\
z\`h jˆ[a \ja []wyZl Šj\o. ‹`\ ŠZ-
]Z|Z u`_vZz c}d`}l a dh^\j}l gvwc
owŠ_`va fZ ks vZf\\v. – `avZy[_ `\ u_-
nj\o ow[w gvwc \\ yZ]h†\l yZ]ow|va, vZdZ-
]wˆ h Zo\[_j fZ [Z]Zy\ au Šj\o`ZyZ
z_y_ua`_, Zdj_z}g_h ]wv_za aja f]Z-
cdZ Zdy]}u_h uwo_za, — h g\[e u`_j, †dZ
gvwc`_h Z`_, dZjevZ fZv_ yZ]h†_h. ‡ \\
z`\ u_fZz`ajch vacjZg_d}l f]agvwc,
]ZcvZ|`}l yjh`‚\g}l g\]Š a `Zu[]h-
cd}l zhva| g}cZvZ fZ[`hg|\yZch Šj\-
o_, vZdZ]}l g]w†`wˆ z\caja a g}f\v_-
ja g `\oZje|Zl f\v_]`\ f]a cd_`‚aa
iZ]†_vZgZ “w]v\cd_`cvZl ^\j\u`Zl [Z-
]Zya, \\ [Z ]\gZjˆ‚aa `_ug_``Zl d_v
fZ az\`a ]wccvZyZ y\`\]_j_ a ja|e `_-
z`ZyZ fZu^\ f\]\az\`Zg_``Zl g oj_-
yZugw†`Z\ “‹_]yaj_`cval gZvu_j”. €Z
Šj\o, g}f\v_\z}l g dZl f\v_]`\, d_v
a `_u}g_ja — yZ]†_vZgcval, `\czZ-
"#$ > +/%

p~ d]h `_ [\chdaj\dah, f]Z|\[|a\ fZcj\ ch †_cdZ, `Z, fZg\]ed\, ”dZ d_v a o}jZ!
f\]\az\`Zg_`ah. ždZd Šj\o o}j ]\[vZ- x]\[cd_ged\ c\o\, v_vZl-`aow[e []wy
cdeˆ, u_ `az `_[Z o}jZ \Š_de f_]w va- Zd‚_, wuo\v, fZ[\u^_j v `_|\zw [Zzw
jZz\d]Zg — Zy]Zz`Z\, `\fZcda^azZ\ `_ z_|a`\, cay`_jaj a f]Zcaj g}lda.
a Zf_c`Z\ ]_ccdZh`a\ [jh v]ZŠZd`ZyZ €_ fZjZ†v\ z\^[w u_[`az ca[\`e\z
f]Zcd]_`cdg_, g vZdZ]Zz z} ^aja! “_- a cd\vjZz ]h[_za j\^_ja j\f\|va,
vaz Šj\oZz a`Zy[_ `_c o_jZg_j zZl [\chdva, \cja `\ cZd`a j\f\|\v! {Z-
[h[h, vZdZ]}l ]_oZd_j gZ[ad\j\z a, z_|`a\, `_cdZha\ j\f\|va, ]_u`}Š
Zv_u_g|ace fZ cjw†_ˆ ojau gZvu_j_, fZ- ]_uz\]Zg a ]_u`ZyZ ga[_, \\ Z†\`e yZ-
vwf_j `\f]\z\``Z [g\ owŠ_`va — Z[`w ]h†a\: `_g\]`Z\, aŠ f\vja [jh v_vZyZ-
c\o\, _ []wywˆ `_z. dZ dZ]^\cdg_ aja [jh †e\l-dZ cg_[eo}.
…_v []wy_h v]_l`Zcde, g f]ZdagZfZ- ‡ ”dZd []wy, f]Z\u^_h zazZ `_|\yZ
cd_gj\`a\ ”daz [gwz _ocZjˆd`Z ]wccvaz [Zz_, `\f]\z\``Z Zcd_`_gjag_jch
fZ ga[w a cZ[\]^_`aˆ Šj\o_z, `_ `_|\z a wyZ_j `_c yZ]h†aza j\f\|v_za,
cdZj\ a`Zy[_ fZhgjhjace wuo\vcva\ j\- f]\[`_u`_†\``}za, gZuzZ^`Z, [jh
f\|va. o}v`Zg\``Z g ow[`a zZa ]Z[a- []w^\cvZl fZca[\jva — vZ]fZ]_dag
d\ja `\ fZvwf_ja j\f\|\v. €_[Z o}jZ fZ-g_|\zw.
^[_de gZcv]\c\`eh, \Š_de vw[_-dZ `_ o_- – `\ czZd]\j `_ ja‚Z ”dZyZ [Zo]ZyZ
u_], _ d_z u`_de, vw[_ a vZy[_ †_cd`ava †\jZg\v_, `\ u_fZza`_j \yZ az\`a, g
f]agZuhd aŠ `_ f]Z[_^w g cd_]}Š [\d- jw†|\z cjw†_\ h zZy u_fZz`ade dZjevZ
cvaŠ vZjhcv_Š aja Zy]Zz`}Š fj\d\`}Š ‚g\d [_ z_]vw \yZ z_|a`}, fZdZzw †dZ
vZ]ua`_Š, wv]}d}Š Z[\hj_za, †dZo} j\- gc\ zZ\ g`az_`a\ g dZd zZz\`d o}jZ
f\|va `\ Zcd}ja fZ [Z]Zy\ a `\ ]_cd\- u_`hdZ j\f\|v_za, vZdZ]}\ cvj_[}-
]hja f]agj\v_ˆal fZvwf_d\j\l u_f_Š. g_ja `_ zZa fZ[cd_gj\``}\ ]wva. ‰Zd
€Z Z†\`e †_cdZ cjw†_jZce †w[Z. – oZje|_h, fjZcv_h, Zy]Zz`_h, Z†\`e yZ-
u`_ˆ, †dZ †w[\c_ `\ [Zj^`} cjw†_de- ]h†_h, `Z `a†\yZ, h fZd\]fjˆ. ‰Zd f_]_
"! # $ 
%

c]\[`aŠ, c ZoZ[Zz g ga[\ ‚g\dZg. ‰Zd


›uo\vcv_h pk
\\ z\je†\ — h c\z \\ f\]gZl. ‡ `_
c_z}l g\]Š — cj\fj\``}\ fZ †\d}]\ j\f\|v_
owjZ†va g Z[`Z, `\g}]_uazZ\ cjZg_za
gZj|\ocdgZ wuo\vcvZl vwŠ`a — |a]- • †dZ w[agad\je`Z: \[g_ ja `\ g v_^-
zZl — Šj\o `_ yZ]ZŠZgZl u_vg_cv\ c d_- [Zl Zoj_cda ›uo\vacd_`_, `Z, w^ dZ†`Z,
vaz ywcd}z u_f_ŠZz, †dZ u_f_Š c `\f]a- g v_^[Zz ]\yaZ`\ cgZl, ZcZo}l ga[ j\-
g}†va \cja `\ fZg_jad c `Zy, dZ f]Zau- f\|\v. {_ `\ Z[a`, _ `\cvZjevZ ga[Zg
g\[\d `\auyj_[azZ\ gf\†_dj\`a\. c]_uw zZ^\d g}f\†e jˆo_h ŠZuhlv_. ‡
‡]Zz_d w [Zz_|`aŠ wuo\vcvaŠ j\f\- †dZ w^ yZgZ]ade Z f]Z‘\ccaZ`_je`}Š
|\v o}j cZg\]|\``Z u_gZ]_^ag_ˆal, Šj\oZf\v_Š-z_cd\]_Š? “\ `_f\vwd d_vaŠ
`\f\]\[_g_\z}\ Zo^ay_ˆa\ Zw\- j\f\|\v, c d_vaza g}v]wd_c_za, Šad]Z-
`ah `_ vZ`†av_Š f_je‚\g Zd dg\][ZyZ cdhza a wv]_|\`ahza, †dZ dZjevZ ]wv_-
[Z`‚_, fZd]\cvag_ˆa\ `_ uwo_Š a cd]\- za ]_ug\cda. €Z Zo}†`Z z_j\`eva\ f\-
jhˆa\ _]Zz_dZz u\]`}|va vw`^wd_ v_]`a g}f\v_ˆd v_vZl-dZ Z[a` ga[ j\-
aja †\]`w|va, vZdZ]}za o}j Zoc}f_` f\|\v, fZdZzw †dZ ]h[Zz, fZ cZc\[cdgw,
aŠ g\]Š, v]_cZd_ g}[_gj\``ZyZ g ‚\`d]\ g ”dZz ^\ vg_]d_j\, vdZ-dZ `\f]\z\``Z
v]wy_ wuZ]_ a o\cvZ`\†`}l gZ g]\z\`a g}f\v_\d []wya\.
a f]Zcd]_`cdg\, `\cvZ`†_\zZ zhyval ‡ `_ o_u_]\ v_vaŠ dZjevZ j\f\|\v
ZoZ[ [\j_ja j\f\|vw gZ^[\j\``Zl g `\d — oZje|a\, z_j\`eva\, f}|`}\
jˆoZ\ g]\zh [`h a cwdZv. œ\f\|va o}ja a fjZcva\, Š]wcdha\ a d_va\ fj_cda†-
f]\v]_c`} c \[Zl aja o\u \[}, c vwcvZz `}\, †dZ `\ ]_ujZzade, c wv]_|\`ahza
[}`a aja cd_v_`Zz gZ[}, [_ †dZ d_z — a f]Zcd\`eva\, cj_[va\, `_ zZjZv\, `_
gZ[}, f]ZcdZ gcwŠZzhdvw — ”dZ o}jZ `\- z_cj\, cjZ\`}\, `_ Zo}†`}Š []Z^^_Š
f\]\[_g_\zZ gvwc`Z a… f]_g[w cv_u_de? aja `_ yZ]ZŠZgZl u_vg_cv\. • w^ cZg\]-
{_ h a [Z caŠ fZ] `\ \j \[} cZg\]|\``\\. |\``Z dZ†`Z dZ, †dZ w †\jZg\v_ f]a\u-
 -

& 
' 
 

"#$ > +/%

pm ^\yZ c`_†_j_ ]_uo\ywdch yj_u_ Zd ]_u`Z- , jw`Zjav_h!


Zo]_uah g Šj\o`}Š ]h[_Š, `Z `\f]\z\`-
`Z c]\[a j\f\|\v `_l[\dch Z[`_ d_v_h €w [_g_ld\ fZczZd]az, v_v g}f\v_ˆd
v]_c_ga‚_, †dZ `_gc\y[_ gjˆoadch f]a- c_z}\ f]Zcd}\ j\f\|va — Zoa-`Z`, `_
\u^al g wuo\vcvwˆ j\f\|vw. gZ[\, a`}za cjZg_za.
xZ”dZzw `\w[agad\je`Z, †dZ ”dZd
Šj\o cd_j d_v fZfwjh]\` a g —Zccaa. €\d, / !: !5 , **, ".
fZ^_jwl, `a Z[`ZyZ yZ]Z[_, y[\ `_ ]}`- F+" +%$ !  &# .
v\ `\ f]azZcdajace o} wuo\va cZ cgZaz >+%- + $. 4+#5 -
d_`[}]Zz — yja`h`Zl f\†eˆ, g vZdZ-   '+ 5+ %%$. O+
]Zl g}f\v_ˆd Šj\o.  _je dZjevZ, †dZ % %>#, %', >+  *< ,
fZ†da g\u[\ ”da d_`[}]} dZfhd ”j\v- %! Q!",  !+. : !+ 
d]a†\cdgZz, y_uZz aja wyj\z, _ `\ []Z-   %! &+#8.
g_za [_ ŠgZ]ZcdZz, v_v fZjZ^\`Z. •u-u_ F$&8 , '+8, !5"
”dZyZ j\f\|va caje`Z d\]hˆd gZ gvwc\. $&8. J $ !> '$>, 5 
‡ \\ aŠ `\g\]`Z `_u}g_ˆd “j_g_|ava”. <8, $"$ <  !" R% !-
€\d, [Z]Zya\ zZa, `av_vZl ”dZ `\ j_- E8,   + *  <,  >-
g_|, ”dZ — j\f\|v_, wuo\vcv_h j\f\|-  $, R !  %$+ !-
v_! ždZ Šj\o, c vZdZ]ZyZ ^au`e `_†a`_- >%", R $$ +" !+, $
\dch a vZdZ]}z Z`_ u_v_`†ag_\dch. €\ '$ %*   '"# %$>" 
cjw†_l`Z j\f\|v_ az\\d ‘Z]zw ZoZ[_, !  %*"  8"$%.
`_g\]`Z\ fZdZzw, †dZ z\`hˆdch dZjevZ O!"   %$&" >&+ !-
yZcda, f]aŠZ[ha\ `\`_[ZjyZ `_ ”dZd E+  " +% ! >$. 9-
f]_u[`av fZ[ `_ug_`a\z “^au`e”, _  '5  '< >:  *<-
c_z_ ^au`e a Šj\o, \\ [_ˆal, — o\c- & + !> %. H > <,
vZ`\†`}. >  <" >,  &!"  !#
&,   # 
%

- !&, !%"  ! '- A$$ $$! O"$ %$, "- pp
" "#! $ !"E&,  $>$ — >%"&,
A   <%, "$  >" !&&, !+8I. O"$ R+ %-
!55  '>  +. ++ +* <5"  $, >'&
H" +* !*".  !+, ! &!>$, !5" ,
O 5  & $%$, + $  !!$" +   $-
'  $%$ (! +%  $*%8 %$%) + '"#+ <5+, !<%+, < $-
 $+ ++>&+ *5+ &  &+ $%& <!.
$& <  !>$. F  $5 J!"<%5  <& >$>,  E
!>$ $5 *%, !+ !>$ !- !#$ 5 %$,  !+ 
>5,  *% $<&5 <%, $ +<&8 ++, $ $+% '<
%$ + * !8 !>- % !! $%*%.
$,  *% $$ '& $5 ! ++% O!" !%" !#$ I + !-
 &#$% —  R  '%  *, !+%5, >  I < -
!#$, %5I5, +$5, >%>$% !- $8, >'&   <"   !-
, >+  '. &.
!8%& <$ !#$ - A% ! N%$ $>". D*%8 -
!585  !$% — %"  !- !#$%  &!%$%8 +>%8 !%#$% 
5"5. & 5 $&8 !-  &!
E+, % &$&8 , +* : & <, $$ 5>? Q%-
'&", '%  …  !   & $&. O>-
$ !& + <+5 +,  + 8! &5-$  $,  $*-
 !> % &.  !#$. T!#$  !%#$%, $ -
O& !,  !" " &%, <5+   —  '
"$ > &+&"  &" %$  +? — ! % !#$%, !!",
!%!" $ ++% +%. < %8I.
Чакич

ps

В
&& 2& & (

(

( *&8 1. @& & &8


, 
 
&
( (
   (8&:  &,
 (2& 
0(  0 .    &-
   &*
 & /1
2& &  0( —  * /1 &
(
(&. ; 
 0-
&0 —  * 2
    & ( —  1
& . +6 -
/ / 
/ 2& /0 (2
(, 8
 / (, &&
2
 — & 0
)
,  (*& (
2(  (*(. 9*
  &
(* ( & & (20&  ) & &  / 6. !&0&
(  8 /, / ( 1 /, 
&  (0
, 0
 2& & -
/8  
&0
 (* 
(*. B  2  & &    /1
 0
,
  & 2
&8-. 
!
!   ' 
%

J  R >" '&, !#$ %* Zy]Zz`_h ]_u`a‚_! ždZ wv_u}g_\d ja|e p
! +"! F+", !, $% >, `_ dZ, †dZ z\jZ†\l g vwja`_]aa, _ d\z
>+ *". '& 5" !#$, " - oZj\\ Šj\oZf\†\`aa, `\d.
$ '& %+.
$, $$ % !&,   $E *-
55 $85. D+ R $8
+ !E!5 !#$%,   !
‡u\]o_l[^_`cval
!5+  . †w]\v
‰Zd Z`a — j\f\|va! ›Š, yZ]h†a\! ‰ ‡u\]o_l[^_`\ Šj\o f\vwd c_z}l f]Z-
€Z v_vaza o} Z`a `a o}ja yZ]h†a- cdZl, o\u v_vaŠ jaoZ cjZ^`Zcd\l. x\vwd
za, `a Z[a` ]\o\`Zv `\ w[\]^adch: j_g_|, Z vZdZ]Zz h ]_ccv_^w `a^\, _
— ‹_z_, [_l! djZza vwcZ†\v! \\ †w]\v, †dZ g f\]\gZ[\ `_ ]wccval a
‹_de ZdjZzad, fZ[w\d a — gc\ ]_g`Z Zu`_†_\d “Šj\o”.
\\ cja|vZz yZ]h†Z — `_vjZ`adch v
c}`w, yj_u_ g yj_u_, c_z_ f]Zdh`\d vwcZ- F+,   <+#8. 9%*>-
†\v: +  !<58, 5 “% +%*> -
— š|e! &  %$”. P +%*>&  >"- 
˜_z\daja? “\cdZ [jh wuo\vcvaŠ j\- %5, 5, 5 + $*%, <+" !5-
f\|\v `\Z[`Zv]_d`Z Zoza`_ˆd a c`Z- !%& +#$ +%$ —  >" -
g_ [_ˆd fZ[Zlda, [_ cZja g d\cd\ †wde $, *  +" +. H'&>5
oZje|\ — Zf}d`}\ f\v_]a fZlzwd, +%$, ", >%" !5 , +&
v_v ”dZ [\lcdgw\d `_ ]_oZdw []Z^^\l. !& % **, $& & +-
• fZ^_jwlcd_ — v_v_h ]_u`a‚_ gZ gvw- * $%!"  '*#+ %!+$.
c\ fZ c]_g`\`aˆ c Zo}†`}z Šj\oZz, _ / " —  %$,  %+5  +-
gc\ dZjevZ au-u_ d_vaŠ z\jZ†\l! x]ZcdZ .
"#$ >

€_ f\]g}l guyjh[ fZv_ oZje|Zl ]_u- 8 $"$ !$   —  &!


`a‚} z\^[w _u\]o_l[^_`cvaz a wuo\v- /,   &, !>. F-
cvaz cfZcZoZz u_z\|ag_`ah d\cd_ [jh >  ,  >%$ &!$8  $-
Šj\o_ `\d. ›uo\va c`_†_j_ d\cdZ [\j_ˆd & $,  !+  ,  +% -
fZ^a^\, _ fZdZz zwvw fZ[c}f_ˆd [Z % !%+5"5  !> $,
`\ZoŠZ[azZl vZ`cacd\`‚aa. ‡ g ‡u\]- / + & >%$ !$8 E-
o_l[^_`\ u_z\|ag_ˆd gcˆ zwvw c]_uw,   <  8I+ %5+.
_ fZdZz, fZ z\]\ g}z\|ag_`ah, fZ[-
jag_ˆd gZ[w — \\ a \\, fZv_ `\ fZ- › z\`h `\ fZjw†ajZce — fZv_ h fZ-
jw†adch dZ, †dZ `_[Z. €Z ]_u`a‚_-dZ gZ ua]Zg_j f\]\[ ‘ZdZ_ff_]_dZz, †w]\v
gvwc\ Zy]Zz`_! “_v †dZ czZd]ad\ [_je- f]ayZ]\j. f}d_ `\d, [_ a †wdeh `\ Šg_-
|\ \\ g`az_d\je`\\ a `\ f]Zfwcdad\ dajZ.
[\d_ja. €_g\]`Z\, az\``Z Zf}d fZvZj\`al,
g}]_^\``}l g o\cŠad]Zcd`Zl, f]Zcd\l-
O% 8 ! #" *&, "- |\l d\Š`ZjZyaa, fZugZjh\d fZjw†_de au
#  5  <$, %$+ <+- d]\Š c_z}Š Zo}†`}Š vZzfZ`\`dZg Šj\o,
8  !#$, !"E+ !>>- vZdZ]}l `\ f]a\[_\dch `avZy[_.
  (
  
%

hu}v. {_ †dZ d_z yZgZ]ade, [_^\ d\, [jh pr


vZyZ wuo\vcval — ]Z[`Zl, oZj\\ dZyZ,
u`_dZva ”dZyZ hu}v_ fZ]Zˆ d\]hˆdch,
vZy[_ ]\†e u_ŠZ[ad Z vwja`_]aa.
€w gZd, czZd]ad\: c ga[w Zo}†`_h j\-
f\|v_. “ZjevZ jˆoZl, ojauvZ u`_vZz}l
c wuo\vcvZl vwŠ`\l †\jZg\v dwd ^\ v
cjZgw “j\f\|v_” [Zo_gad c `ZdvZl gZc-
Ša\`ah — “f_d}]!”. ‡ fZ`az_ˆa\
žvcfZ]d`}l g_]a_`d jˆ[a gZv]wy u_vag_ˆd, cZyj_chdch — [_,
f_d}]! €\ f]Zcd_h j\f\|v_! {_g_l, jZ-
š[a`cdg\``Z\, †dZ `\ g}u}g_\d w z\`h z_l, ZdjZza a z`\!
cZz`\`ah, vZy[_ h ]_uz}|jhˆ `_[ cZ- €Z [\jZ g dZz, †dZ g Z[`Zz dZjevZ
g]\z\``Zl wuo\vcvZl vwŠ`\l, — ”dZ dZ, ‹_]yaj_`\ yZdZghd cdZjevZ ga[Zg f_d}-
†dZ Z`_ `w^[_\dch g d_d\je`Zl cacd\- ]_, cvZjevZ h a `\ u`_ˆ, ŠZde a f]Z^aj
z_dau_‚aa a u_v]\fj\`aa ZoZc`Zg_`- fZ[j\ ”dZyZ cd_]a``ZyZ wuo\vcvZyZ yZ]Z-
`}Š `_ug_`al u_ v_^[}z au vwja`_]- [_ oZje|\ cZ]Zv_ j\d. ‰ …Zv_`[\ ga[Zg
`}Š dgZ]\`al, vZdZ]}\ y\`a_je`}l f_d}]_ \\ oZje|\, _ fZ\[\|e [_je|\,
wuo\vcval `_]Z[ cZu[_\d Z[`Z u_ []wyaz. g “_|v\`d, d_v fZf_[\|e `_ ‚\j}l o_u_],
“ZjevZ h oZˆce, †dZ [jh Zfac_`ah `_ vZdZ]Zz f]Z[_ˆd dZjevZ f_d}]!
gc\yZ ]_u`ZZo]_uah ojˆ[ a au[\jal, ždaz o_u_]Zz ¤\]y_`cv_h [Zja`_ v_v
[jh fZj`Z‚\``ZyZ ]_ccv_u_ ZoZ gc\z o} f]Z_\dch c fwd`av_za a f]\[j_y_-
g\javZj\faa wuo\vcvZl vwŠ`a cjZg zZ- \d: “˜_o\]ad\ c cZoZl, g “_|v\`d, ‹Zcvgw,
^\d a `\ Šg_dade. • w^ dZ†`Z — `\ z`\ ’\]ja`, Yd_zowj, g “\je-‡gag — d_z
u_`az_dech ”dZl ]_oZdZl, fZcvZjevw h d_vaŠ j\f\|\v `\d! €\ f]Zf_[wd, `\ ac-
`\[Zcd_dZ†`Z ŠZ]Z|Z u`_ˆ wuo\vcval fZ]dhdch, [Zg\u\d\! YzZd]ad\, w z\`h c
 
  
   
    
    #  
  " # 
     
 

"#$ > +/%

s~ z_cjZz! ‰Zd — zZjZ†`}\! ‰Zd c g}^_]- x]a`‚afa_je`Z dZ, †dZ d\cdZ [jh f_-
v_za! ‹\[Zg}\! › z\`h Š]wcdha\! ‡ w d}]_ Zohu_d\je`Z yZdZgadch c f]az\`\-
z\`h — v_^[_h fZ vajZy]_zzw!” `a\z Zf_]}.
{g\-d]a j\f\|va fwd`ava c\[hd
\\ g z_|a`\, fZ [Z]Zy\, †dZ f\djh\d P5 !5 !&  ! +$
c]\[a yZ] a g\[\d g “_|v\`d. €_o\]wd &!" , !% *$ +%$, I!"
j\[h`wˆ, jZzhwˆ uwo} gZ[w au yZ]-   !*" '&>&,   % *-
`ZyZ vjˆ†_ a u_feˆd ”dw c}d`wˆ a _]Z- *. P**  I" !+#",
z_d`wˆ j\f\|vw — [Z w^a`_ Z \[\ a <"  $+>$  " !% 
gcfZza`_de `\ u_ŠZ†\dch. ‡ w^ Zcd_je- !+ +. D ++%, $ ! !-
`}\ j\f\|va — wyZ_de ]Z[cdg\``a-  — !+5 #!$ #!5I
vZg a u`_vZz}Š, g\uda c cZoZl g [_je- !&  > <" $& <-
`a\ v]_h, \cja f]a[\dch — c g\dZ†vZl !, —    !5" $++
ga`Zy]_[_, cZ cg\]dvZz vw]_ya a auˆz_, +%$. / E $  %%'
vwjevZz ua]} a f]Z†aza yZcda`‚_za.   !%  !,  
“wd f_d}] acfZj`ad ]Zje ojˆ[_, ]Zje 5>,  >%" &# $+ +!-
‘w`[_z\`d_ a Zc`Zg} wyZ\`ah au %& +. 9 +* '&" >,
›uo\vacd_`_. ",    !& '-
œ_[`Z, [_g_ld\ yZdZgade f_d}].  * — 5 , $ 8' %>.
x\]gZ\ a, fZ^_jwl, \[a`cdg\``Z\ /!>+, ' *  '5<"-
Zohu_d\je`Z\ wcjZga\ — d\cdZ [Zj^`Z  !", +*  !%'"  + 
o}de `\ f]Zcd}z, _ c[Zo]\``}z zZjZ- +%$ <,  # !5, >
vZz, z_cjZz, _ dZ a o_]_`eaz ^a]Zz. $%8$ <"  $ >+% —  $ 
{_je|\ `_†a`_\dch Zoj_cde wŠa]\- ! 5 *  !>$. D%8>&
`al a ZcZo}Š u`_`al, `Z [_g_ld\ Zcd_- * + ! !!"  !& "$ 
`Zgazch `_ yj_g`Zz, o_uZgZz ]\‚\fd\.  &*$ — '&8  $ !#$,
  (
  
%

  $& <+#8 $%8>&   & $ $5+   $,  st


&*$. < ' !"E& !+8  >%"
O &+#5  #$+ %+, ",  $ .
  * !, >+  '&>& - D !#$ ,  %
!#$,  55 $&&+ +%  $&8 ! !+I >$>, +<&-
2C–BC  !+ +. ##, !- 8 !&+ '"+ *+ 
5#5  !>,    $+  !&!8 $%*%+  -
<5"   $%$,  %># " .
 !"E+ "$  + +, $$ A !5" !#$%  !>" !
!$<  @@. A, >'&  I < (%*  )
D%$+  !5 $%5 @- 5" —  R < +% (C–(3.
+, %$ *& #" $%&, 5, > E !&& &!$-
+5$ *5, $$ '& !'5 $ E- 8   &,  ! !>-
% $5  * !*+5  $ .  !' +* &!>"   '&>
F * & <$ *& !- %$ —  !, , I %>#,
%>"5 $+  !+8I+ -  # <+ $+ 5 &!>-
'"# $. G*   @$% $ !EE&,  5 '&  '"# 
 %$ — <$+ %* I < >%% $$, $%8 $* 
!,  R < 0C–2C +% '% !" "  %$.
! >! / %$ !& %># &!$"  
5#5 <$ *  R!. F> ! 0CC °F, % !%-
* 58  !#$, !$" - % <% %$, >'& $ !-
'  R ++ + "$ $>- " E,  !$", > +<
$+ !"E, >'&  <" %*& ++  $+, ! +!%
%!.  R+ !"E& '%%I (3C °F, '&<5  %$% 5 '-
' !#$ !  $85, ' <5 !.
Кунжут и нигелла

sq

Н
,   82  (6(
. +6  & 
 & ( 
   &
1 1 (8&, *  (6(
* & & &
(6(
*    * 8
,    
(6(

 ( 0   *(*. /8&


, 
   1 ;&&
)& &

)
, 
/1 
'
    /2 
8 ! C/2  2 &001 * &,  8 
8    (*1,  &
( //1  (0
,   * 
 /2 8(


 6( (&.
577
 (6(
  28 
/

   —
 /

1 ;&& &* (, & & 0(2(.  
/8
 &8 /8  /-

“0(-
(”, 0
 6 
&  “ /   8 ”.  ) /
 /
“2) (&”, 0
 &/ 0&& *
/



“0 &”,
 / 0
  &
 ( 0&

 1. 3
/ (-


&* ( (/ , ,  8
 /  &
 & (*, (6-

  1 
.
C
,   &
 && '
1 )&& 
   , 

 0( 1  
/
1. 3& )&& & 8&

 & &8 
“ &8 '”, 0
 (  & 0
“0 ”, 
 6 , 0
 -
0
/
( :  1 &8 /8 “&* ”  (   “0(2”.
3 /
-
  1 ;&&  “ ”. ; “ ” — 
6&    7-
& — '
 “
&”,  “”, & 0& “” &
: & 
1  —
“2
(”. /8&
— & (0&
 “
& 2
(&”. 9 '
  
 &,
'
  / : & )&  &  & . D ,  ( 2( —
&
2
(& '
1 1 &* /,  (  (
6  2  ! '
( &8 &-
 
 )
 2&,  (6 (*  /
0 : — (6(
.

&
  
&& & &1
 —  & /2, '
 (6(
,

8*/, 
 & &&& — &* , , 0(2,  6
“0 ”,  6 “0/1 (&”,  6 “0/1 (6(
”. @& -
, /1
  8
&
, 

  0 6
,
  2
8 2
(  (
2(  !
 -
  

     "
     " 
*       # 
'  "   "  
 

)   ( *  


%

Y _ff\dad`}z v_v owŠ_]cva\ \g]\a yZdZgaja z_‚w `_ sp


c_^\, f]a[wz_j cfZcZo g}f\†va j\f\-
Š]wcdZz |\v, vZdZ]}\ a[\_je`Z fZ[ŠZ[hd fZ[
zZl gvwc.
›uo\vcv_h j\f\|v_ — Šj\o w`ag\]c_je-
`}l. ‹hva| \\ zhyvZyZ ZoZ[_ Zdja†`Z J<   <+" "
fZ[ŠZ[ad, †dZo} z_v_de g cZwc aja yw- %   " +% !5"5 — >
cdZl owjeZ`. n]wcdh_h c\]\[a`_, cjZ- ,  +"# !5 !*", !$
^\``_h fZfZj_z, u_z\`ad jZ^vw d\z,    >#$, %$% 5+.
vdZ wz\\d f]_gaje`Z \cde |w]fw aja K<"  & >  $"
z_|Šw][w. žd_ ^\ c_z_h c\]\[a`_ f]Z- $$  ' I 2–B ++.
cdZ †w[Z v_v ŠZ]Z|_ gz\cd\ c ywcd}za S%&+ !+  '&> $
cj_[vaza cjagv_za — v_lz_vZz. $" ' !  !, +-
– Z†\`e jˆojˆ c\]\[a`w ”daŠ j\f\- <" $+  !&!" $%*%+  -
|\v. “_v jˆojˆ, †dZ, gcfZza`_h Z dZz, . J &!$"!
"#$ > +/%

ss 1& '& % +5 ! %$ & — 5 +  ' . A  !-
'& &!$  &. :  &, 5 &- !"5  &*"   %8-
!$  + >%%+ *, $& I%8 !#$%, !$   %! I <
!!' ! %$%. A '& '& <"5,  *55  5
*, 5 '& <5 >%%%8 $$%  .   !* !#-
* ! !*  %$% $"- $%  #%+$ ! !"8 5 — <-
$ #+& $!>. O!" *  %+55 < +%%!
+& !& R$>$ %$
%8  " — - ˜`_\d\, v_vZl ”dZ Šj\o? bdZ-dZ c]\[`\\
+%. J *+ $$E !> %  z\^[w [Zz_|`\l v]wyjZl z_‚Zl a c\-
". /$8>" +%  $$E8 ]\[a`Zl vZv_`[cvZyZ f_d}]_. …_v ]_u
 +$+"%8 +!%%,  !- d_z, y[\ `_ŠZ[adch zZ\ c\][‚\ a y[\
*", !$ +<& ++ * $$ cjZ^ajace zZa gvwcZg}\ f]\[fZ†d\-
% !5. '" 5- `ah, — fZc\]\[a`\ z\^[w wuo\v_za,
   5, >'& ' !- ]wccvaza, \g]\hza, _u\]o_l[^_`‚_za
!$5 + — $$ <%, $  a [_^\ `\z‚_za.
%. nj\o Š]wcdhal, cwŠZl, o\u zhva-
1 &$&5  * +%  |_, `\ fZ]dadch Z†\`e [ZjyZ, _ `_ gvwc
3–=, +* '&", (C — 5  +% + >- j\yval, _]Zz_d`}l, Zdja†`Z fZ[ŠZ[ad
 $<",   $*% # <  ŠZde v cwfw, ŠZde v cd_v_`w ŠZjZ[`ZyZ
< — +  8. W * zZjZv_, _ ŠZde a v vacda ga`Zy]_[_ c c}-
$$ % ",  ' !!>5 ]Zz a oZv_jw ga`_ `_ w^a`.
Саж

В
 2&
 
0/8
   & 8  /
0:  * 
6 — * /(   (*  &
 6  & & (* 1
6 
& & 0(*(. /( 
&
/ . 
 (1


&
/0( (  (* & & & 0

6 2 —
& &*&
. 3 21 ( , )
 &
— & 
,  
 ! ;  & 
&
6 /( 1
1 &,
   ( 0
-
& 6&
 ( ((,   /01 .
&
,    *&  ,  6 & ( &
-
& — '

6?
9 6, 6 &*
&
8  * (*, 6  /8  &  -
 /8   '
* ( &8. 3 0
 * 
 
&(
 0 ,  
(
 &( ( 86&8 & (
 1 ( 6&
, 
 & 
 &,   ,
  6 
-
, &&/1 
&, 6&
* .  /

8  
9&&   &8
, 
* E &  6/8 * ;-
&1 *  (
.
F&2 & 
-
 
  /0(
&8 8  
/ — * &1
&0 1 7/ 0& 
/
1  8( * &1. E &(, /0/1
   1

/ 2,  
 0 1
&6, 0/01
( . 3, (/,     ( , 
  & .
) # —  +  * 
%

Ywz_jhv — f\]\z\|ag_de `\ g_]\gZ, _ c_za v_z`a. sr


žda v_z`a fZcd\f\``Z ]_cda]_ja u\]`Z
fwde v Šj\ow Z [`Z v_u_`_. ˜\]`Z f]hzZ gZ g]\zh g_]-
va auz\je†_jZce d_v, †dZ `\ Zcd_g_jZce
‹Z^`Z c\cde f]_vda†\cva jˆo}\ uj_- a v]wfa`va, a g ]\uwjed_d\ fZjw†_j_ce
va, f]ZcdZ cZo]_g aŠ c vZjZcv_. …_v z`\ `\ f]ZcdZ v_|_ au u\]`_, _ f]a`‚afa-
v_^\dch, au`_†_je`Z `avZzw a g yZjZ- _je`Z a`Z\ ojˆ[Z — ywcdZ\, Z[`Z]Z[-
gw `\ f]aŠZ[ajZ auz\je†_de u\]`Z, dZ- `Z\, †]\ug}†_l`Z _]Zz_d`Z\ a… cj_[-
jZ†e \yZ f\]\[ wfZd]\oj\`a\z. {_^\ vZ\!
c_z}\ f]Zcd}\ ]w†`}\ z\je`a‚} gZu- “\, vdZ ^aj aja o}g_j g Y]\[`\l
`avja fZu^\, fZdZzw †dZ f\]gZ`_†_je- ‡uaa, u`_ˆd `a c †\z `\ c]_g`az}l
`Z auz\je†\`a\ u\]`_ f]ZacŠZ[ajZ gvwc ”dZyZ j_vZzcdg_, fZdZzw †dZ v_^-
f]hzZ gZ g]\zh g_]va! [}l yZ[, g\c`Zl, \yZ Zohu_d\je`Z yZdZ-
{_, c`_†_j_ jˆ[a fZ`hja, †dZ u\]`Z ghd `\ dZjevZ g v_^[Zz va|j_v\, `Z a
zZ^`Z a g_]ade. šyZ d_v a yZdZgaja — g g v_^[Zl yZ]Z[cvZl z_Š_jj\.  \`a-
‚\je`Zz ga[\, fZ”dZzw yZdZgade f]a- `} u_]_`\\ [ZyZg_]ag_ˆdch Z f]_u[-
ŠZ[ajZce Z†\`e fZ[Zjyw. bdZo} ŠZde `a†`Zz [`\, vZy[_ Z`a ow[wd yZdZgade
v_v-dZ wcvZ]ade f]Z‚\cc f]ayZdZgj\- cwz_jhv. šcde g ”dZz Zo}†_\ a g c_zZz
`ah, g v_u_` vj_ja ]_uzZ†\``Z\ a [_^\ f]Z‚\cc\ f]ayZdZgj\`ah ZdyZjZcva
f]Z]Zc|\\ u\]`Z. {jh dZyZ †dZo} g_- v_vaŠ-dZ []\g`\l|aŠ d]_[a‚al a Zo-
]\gZ `\ f]ayZ]_jZ, v `\zw [Zo_gjhja ]h[Zg: cwz_jhv yZdZghd c g\†\]_ a [Z
z_cjZ aja ^a] a fZcdZh``Z \yZ f\]\- wd]_, fZ[ cd_]a``}\ f\c`a, ^\`a`}
z\|ag_ja. €Z gc\ ]_g`Z yZdZgade f]a- _vvZzf_`a]wˆd c\o\ `_ owo`_Š, _ g_]\-
ŠZ[ajZce Z†\`e [ZjyZ. xZ”dZzw vdZ-dZ gZ g v_u_`\ f\]\z\|ag_ˆd fZ Z†\]\[a.
[Zy_[_jch fZ[vj_[}g_de g v_u_` c g_- Y†ad_\dch, †dZ ”dZd Zo]h[ Zo\cf\†ag_\d
]\gZz `\cvZjevZ Zv]wyj}Š v_z`\l a fjZ[Z]Z[a\ `\ dZjevZ u\zj\, `Z a ^\`-
"#$ > +/%

m a`_z, f]a`hg|az w†_cda\ g \yZ f]a- hu}v\ f]Zcj\^ag_\dch cZg\]|\``Z _`_-


yZdZgj\`aa. iZdZg}l cwz_jhv [\jhd, jZya†`_h acdZ]ah Šj\o_! “Z†`Z d_v ^\ a
v_^[_h ^\`a`_ u_oa]_\d cgZˆ [Zjˆ g wuo\vcvZl, a g c]\[`\_ua_dcvZl vwŠ`\,
v c\o\ [ZzZl a wyZ_\d az `\ dZjevZ \cja yZgZ]ade |a]\, cw\cdgw\d ‚\j}l
cgZaŠ [ZzZ†_[‚\g, `Z a ]Z[cdg\``avZg ]h[ ojˆ[, f]\[cd_gjhˆaŠ cZoZl az\`-
a f]ZcdZ u`_vZz}Š. ždZ `_cdZjevZ gvwc- `Z fZŠj\ova — `_ Zc`Zg\ zwva, †\]-
`Z\ wyZ\`a\, †dZ h [Z caŠ fZ] v_^[}l cdgZyZ Šj\o_, _ dZ a ‚\je`ZyZ u\]`_, v_v
yZ[ fZ g\c`\ f]Z|w u`_vZz}Š au ›uo\- Zo]h[Zg}\ vw|_`eh cwz_jhv a Š_jaz.
vacd_`_: f]ag\uad\ z`\ ŠZde z_j\`e- {]Zoade u\]`Z g cdwf\ aja ]_cda]_de
vwˆ o_`Z†vw cwz_jhv_! \yZ z\^[w ^\]`Zg_za jˆ[a `_g\]`hv_
YzZd]ad\, _ g\[e cwz_jhv wcjZg`Z `_†_ja yZ]_u[Z fZu^\. • \\ `\aug\cd-
zZ^`Z c†ad_de a fZŠj\ovZl, `\czZd]h `Z, cvZjevZ c d\Š fZ] f]Z|jZ g]\z\`a,
`_ d_a`cdg_ gZv]wy ”dZyZ ojˆ[_ a cjZ^- f]\^[\ †\z †\jZg\†\cdgZ `_w†ajZce
`Zcda \yZ f]ayZdZgj\`ah. xZŠj\ov_, z\cade au zwva d\cdZ a f\†e au d\cd_
Šj\oZgZ, Šj\o — d_v g\[e a g ]wccvZz Šj\o.


   
%

x]_g[_ g f]ZcdZd\ ”da fZ†da g}cZŠ|a\, ]_cc}f_ˆa\ch t


jacd} cd]_``ZyZ Šj\o_, a u_†\z g `\yZ
x_]dah a ]\vdZ]_d fZcj_ja zZ\yZ Zd‚_ `_[Z u_gZ]_†ag_de ”dZd vacjZg_d}l
w†adech g _cfa]_`dw]w. • ]\|aja, †dZ c}], u\j\`e a vwcZ†va d_ˆ\yZ cjagZ†-
]_u Z` _u\]o_l[^_`\‚, dZ a w†adech `ZyZ z_cj_.
[Zj^\` g ‡u\]o_l[^_`\. ‰ ’_vw, zZj, {h[h wyZg_]ag_j z\`h:
`\fjZŠ_h |vZj_ g}c|\l z_d\z_dava a — YzZd]a, gZd d_v gZd fZo]}uy_\|e
gZZo\. gZ[Zl †wde-†wde, u_g\]`\|e g fZjZd\`-
›\Š_j Zd\‚, w†adech c `az u_ vZzf_- ‚\, j_g_| fhd`_[‚_de za`wd fZj\^ad
`aˆ w\Š_ja a `\vZdZ]}\ \yZ []wueh, fZ- a cd_`\d v_v cg\^al. ‰a[a|e, d\f\]e `\
dh`wjace [`a a z\ch‚} Z^a[_`al dZyZ jZz_\dch, zZ^`Z u_g\]`wde g j_g_| †dZ
[`h, vZy[_ Zd\‚ f]a\[\d `_ v_`avwj}. ŠZ†\|e, gZd, fZf]Zowl c u\j\`eˆ.
` f]a\u^_j Zo}†`Z g`\u_f`Z, f]a- – \j u_ vZzf_`aˆ, `Z fZcz_d]ag_j g
gZuh c cZoZl †\zZ[_` `\ga[_``}Š yZ- Zv`Z g\]_`[}, `\ fZcay`_jad ja vdZ, `\
cda`‚\g. nw]z_, _f\jeca`} a z_`[_- f]ag\u\d ja, cjw†_\z, wuo\vcva\ j\f\|-
]a`}, |\va`cv_h Š_jg_ a o_va`cv_h va g wyZ\`a\, wu`_g, †dZ Zd\‚ f]a\Š_j
f_Šj_g_, \\ v_va\-dZ cj_[Zcda, vZ`‘\- `_ v_`avwj}?
d} a vZ`ehv c auZo]_^\`a\z {\ga†e\l {_, zZh jˆoZge v j_g_|w gZu`avj_
o_|`a `_ ”dav\dv\ — cd_]|\zw o]_dw. `\ c]_uw, zZl fwde v fZ`az_`aˆ a f]_-
‡ \\ Z` Zohu_d\je`Z f]agZuaj c cZoZl gaje`Zl Z‚\`v\ ”dZyZ Šj\o_ o}j [Zj-
f\`[a] (d_v g ‡u\]o_l[^_`\ `_u}g_ˆd yaz. Y dZyZ zZz\`d_, v_v h gf\]g}\ fZ-
[Zz_|`al c}]) a j_g_| — cvZ]\\, [jh f]ZoZg_j ”dZd c_z}l cd_]}l `_ u\zj\
c\oh a [jh cgZ\yZ o]_d_, `\^\ja [jh `_c. Šj\o, a [Z zZz\`d_, vZy[_ h fZ`hj, †dZ h
‹`\, `_f]az\], o}jZ `av_v `\g[Z- jˆojˆ j_g_| a f]ZcdZ ^ade o\u `\yZ `\
z\v, Zd†\yZ ”dZ Zd\‚ a [h[h f]\[fZ†ad_- zZyw, f]Z|jZ… `w, g Zo\z, z`Zya\ au
ja f]ag\u\``}z cj_[Zcdhz a ‘]wvd_z g_c \\ a `\ f]Z^aja cdZjevZ!
"#$ > +/%

q – w^\ cv_u_j, †dZ j_g_| — c_z}l c_za — Zd u_z\|ag_`ah d\cd_ a [Z fZ-


cd_]}l Šj\o `_ u\zj\, a h wg\]\`, †dZ jw†\`ah yZdZgZyZ Šj\o_. €Z Z[a` au c_-
”dZ az\``Z d_v! z}Š gvwc`}Š Šj\oZg g cgZ\l ^au`a h \j
•z\``Z c j_g_|_ aja jˆoZyZ []wyZ- g c_zZl ˆ^`Zl dZ†v\ •]_`_ — yZ]Z[v\
yZ f]ZcdZyZ fjZcvZyZ Šj\o_ `_†a`_j_ce ’_`[_]-‡oo_c.
acdZ]ah g}f\†va. ‰\[e †dZo} acf\†e €\ u`_ˆ, v_v d\f\]e, _ g d\ yZ[} g
j_g_|, d]\owˆdch ja|e z\je`a‚_ [_ •]_`\ f]Z[_g_jch f]\azw\cdg\``Z
gZ[_, a `\ `w^`_ [_^\ c_z_h f]azadag- “yZcw[_]cdg\``}l” j_g_| au f\v_]\`,
`_h yja`h`_h f\†e — `_ ”d_f\ g}f\†va [\hd\je`Zcde vZdZ]}Š [Zda]Zg_j_ce
`\ `w^`Z gZZo\ `a†\yZ, v]Zz\ Zy`h [_ yZcw[_]cdgZz. ’}j Z` Z†\`e [\|\g, `Z
]_uZy]\dZyZ v_z`h aja oZje|Zl g}fw- d\z au g_c, vdZ `\ u`_\d, †dZ d_vZ\ v_-
vjZl cvZgZ]Z[va c_^, Z vZdZ]Zl z} w^\ u\``}l Šj\o, h ŠZ†w fZ^\j_de: [_l oZy,
yZgZ]aja g}|\. †dZo a `\ wu`_ja `avZy[_.
šcja `\d oZje|ZyZ fZ[ŠZ[h\yZ • gZd Z[`_^[}, vZy[_ z`\ `_[Z
v_z`h, dZ zZ^`Z acfZjeuZg_de \o\`- o}jZ fZ\Š_de g fZ]d ’_`[_]-‡oo_c_
vw. €_[Z f]ZcdZ ]_ug\cda vZcd\], [Z- fZ zZaz dZ]yZg}z [\j_z, d_vcacd, g}-
^[_dech, vZy[_ ZyZ`e f]ZyZ]ad a Zcd_- ug_g|alch fZ[g\uda z\`h, `\Z^a[_`-
`wdch wyja, `_ ”da wyja o]Zcade g\[]Z `Z Zcd_`Zgajch fZc\]\[a`\ [Z]Zya.
\o`h, ]_u]Zg`hde a w^\ Z†\`e cvZ]Z €_ ”dZz z\cd\ `a†\yZ `\ o}jZ, g[Zje
`_ `\z zZ^`Z g}f\v_de j_g_|. xZcjw- [Z]Zya dh`wjch `\cvZ`†_\z}l u_oZ],
|_ld\, Zdvw[_ h u`_ˆ Z d_vZz cfZcZo\. Zv]w^_g|al dZ ja fZ]d, dZ ja v_va\-dZ
b\jZg\†\cdgZ g cgZ\z f]Zy]\cc\ cvj_[}. “_vcacd cv_u_j: “Y\l†_c!” — a,
w|jZ [_je|\ `\vw[_, v_vaŠ dZjevZ f\- f]\^[\ †\z h wcf\j gZuzwdadech, †dZ
†\l `\ `_w†ajace cd]Zade, gc\ f]aj_g- Z` Zcd_gjh\d z\`h g z_|a`\ o\u vZ`-
va z_y_ua`Zg u_g_j\`} o}dZg}za Šj\- [a‚aZ`\]_ `_ cZj`‚\f\v\, |z}y`wj g
oZf\†v_za, vZdZ]}\ gc\ wz\ˆd [\j_de [}]w g u_oZ]\.


   
%

‰\]`wjch Z` †\]\u `\cvZjevZ za`wd jZf_d}. xZcj\ dZyZ v_v gc\ wyja f]ZyZ- p
c cahˆaz ja‚Zz. ‰ ]wv_Š w `\yZ o}jZ ]_ja, \o\`vw g}`az_ja au d_`[}]_,
`\cvZjevZ jacdZg j_g_|_, Z` ZdZ]g_j Zd Zd]hŠag_ja Zd uZj} a f\fj_ a acfZje-
Z[`ZyZ au `aŠ fZjZga`w a f]Zdh`wj z`\: uZg_ja a g cj\[wˆal ]_u.
— ’\]a, \|e! €\w^\ja a u[\ce, g •]_`\, vdZ-dZ f\-
‰} `\ f]\[cd_gjh\d\ c\o\, v_vaz †\d j_g_| dZ†`Z d_v ^\, v_v g \va? €Z
gvwc`}z o}j ”dZd j_g_|! €\cvZjevZ cvZjevZ vajZz\d]Zg, v_vZ\ ]_ccdZh`a\,
dZj\ f]ag}†`ZyZ z`\, dZja`Zˆ, `_- †wde `\ fZjvZ`da`\`d_ z\^[w ’_`[_]-
g\]`Z\, c fZjzaua`‚_, `Z \\ `\ d_vZl ‡oo_cZz a \va, _ j_g_| gc\ dZd ^\?
dZjcd}l, v_v wuo\vcv_h j\f\|v_. x]a €_ cj\[wˆal [\`e h c`Zg_ \Š_j g
”dZz v_vZl-dZ `\g\]Zhd`}l u_f_Š, zhy- fZ]d a fZf]Zcaj w^\ []wyZyZ d_vcacd_
vZcde, `\^`Zcde a gz\cd\ c d\z f]_gaje- Zcd_`Zgadech g dZz ^\ z\cd\. – f]Zj\u
`}l Š]wcd g `\vZdZ]}Š z\cd_Š — _l, ‡j- g [}]w g u_oZ]\, `Z Zo`_]w^aj dZjevZ
j_Š! …_v ”dZ c[\j_`Z, vdZ ”dZ c[\j_j? ]_u]w|\``}l d_`[}]. …dZ-dZ cjZ^aj
‰[]wy h Zo`_]w^aj, †dZ v j_g_|w \yZ `_cf\Š au va]fa†_ a v_z`\l, vdZ-dZ
f]avj\ajZce `\cvZjevZ `\oZje|aŠ v_- d_v ^\, `_cf\Š, a ]_u]w|aj. xZ[ va]fa-
z\|vZg. €\w^\ja \yZ yZdZgaja `_ \- †_za j\^_j_ \o\`v_, fZ[ \o\`vZl
o\`v\? {_, h cj}|_j Zd Z[`ZyZ †\jZg\v_ uZj_. ‰c\ dZ†`Z d_v, v_v z`\ Zohc`hj
]Z[Zz au c\j_ ojau _u\]o_l[^_`cvZyZ zZl f]ahd\je au \va.
yZ]Z[_ \va, †dZ Z`a f\vja j_g_| g ‰ ‡u\]o_l[^_`\ j_g_|, v_v a g oZje-
ZcZo}Š d_`[}]_Š, `_fZza`_ˆaŠ ad_- |a`cdg\ []wyaŠ cd]_`, †_\ f\vwd `_
jeh`cva\ f\†a [jh fa‚‚}, `Z c [ja`- c_^\ — d_v f]Z\.
`Zl, wuvZl yZ]jZga`Zl-dZ``\j\z. ` …_v f]_gajZ, gc\ ”j\z\`d_]`Z: zwv_,
az\``Z d_v a ]_ccv_u}g_j, †dZ `_ wyja \fZdv_ cZja, gZ[_. —\^\ — []Z^^a,
vj_ja \o\`vw, _ j_g_| wvj_[}g_ja `_ \\ ]\^\ — u_vg_cv_ `_ ga`Zy]_[`}Š
\o\`e f]a fZzZa ZcZoZl [ja``Zl Zd^azv_Š, a f]_vda†\cva `avZy[_ `av_-
  
  

  "   
' 
 . .  



   
%

vZl c[Zo}. ždZd Šj\o a ŠZ]Z|, `_g\]`Z\, U +% + $<",  $$ +!%- 
cgZ\ˆ f]ZcdZdZl a †\cd`Zcdeˆ. ‰\ce & % <" + —  03C–
gvwc — g c_zZl f|\`a‚\ a z_cd\]cdg\ 0)C °F,  > R + ,  %  
z\je`av_, [_ g Zf}d\ ]wv †\jZg\v_, vZ- E ++? P %>-
dZ]}l yZdZgad j_g_|. # !-%+% !!&+5 !5", $$ *
+  " $$%.
{wz_\d\, d]w[`Z? €a†\yZ d]w[`ZyZ, zZ^- / +, ! *+  -
`Z fZf]ZoZg_de a [Zz_.  !. T# &!$8 !+
+%%. 4 R +5 !!& *&
/<"+ **  !%  !- " $&+,    $+ %>
E, > $+ %$E    !>". : + # $  *
%!$$ 5 $++ +%$. K< "5 !$>$ '&+. A  -
>%8 *$% +%$  ! >#$ - # &!$5 %I "#, R
! &, '" **  " <>, > +!% * <$5, 
 !". T'  %  +& # '% !&",  & + !-
**,  !%!  + $, $$ -  %$.
!  %!$$, "$ $  /!>+,  R %$, R !&
+"# $+ $>. ' $++, !$ 5> — >% $$ -
P'" ", <+   !- #  $%>$+ >8I +
##+ **+, '5 % 5" > +  !&+, !
 +%$% !!, !$    +#, &+ — '&<, @ 
$+, $$ 5 !"+, +* '&", +E.
$"$ +5>. G*   !%%, O 5 #, $& & '-
%$ !E+, !%" !. " &!$"  *,  $&"
K< + ++ *  %%8 I8 $$  !"+. W & <-
>%%%8 $% '"# +.   < $++ +%$  0C -
"#$ > +/%

ƒ & $+>$, , >'& %  !%>" šcja g} gc\ ”dZ u`_\d\, fZ`az_\d\,
'%+5 I,  $&" dZ g} w^\ zZ^\d\ c†ad_de, †dZ wz\\d\
$*& $+>$  $% 2C + yZdZgade vwd_o}.
++.
  $$  $, 
 % 5"   — $ 
Y c\zeˆ `_†a`v_za,
!. K$ —  <%, +- d\vwa\ z_cjZz
 &!$". G' R " -
+, "$ 5  <% >% !%!": €w [_, `\cZz`\``Z, vwd_o} d_v a fZ-
5"  *+, $ !>" hgajace. …dZ-dZ fZ[wz_j: “b\yZ ^[_de?
 #  %%8 %,  & – Z†\`e yZjZ[\` a d_v ŠZ†w yZ]h†\yZ
# $&" $$+  <- j_g_|_ cZ cg\^\l u\j\`eˆ, †dZ f]hzZ
>"  @$% — <5, '<%, c\l†_c fZjZ^w `\z`ZyZ u\j\`a `_ g}-
. :  '" $$ - f\v_\z}l j_g_|, [_ f]av]Zˆ \\ []w-
" %. O$ > !5 '5- yZl fZjZga`Zl ]_cv_d_``ZyZ d\cd_. ‰Zd
< !. a gdZ]_h cdZ]Z`_ fZ[]wzh`aj_ce… žŠ!
‹_cj_-dZ u_o}j fZjZ^ade! €w `a†\yZ,
‰} ^\ u`_\d\, †dZ j_g_| gvwc`\\ gc\yZ, c\l†_c h cg\]Šw fZz_^w”.
vZy[_ g `\yZ †dZ-dZ u_g\]`wdZ. ‰Zd ŠZde {_ gZd g_z a g\ce vwd_o! ’\]ad\ cvZ-
†dZ — Zd cg\^\l u\j\`a [Z `\cvZje- ]\\, fZv_ yZ]h†al, `\vZy[_ ^[_de, `_[Z
vaŠ vwcZ†vZg dZjevZ †dZ fZ^_]\``Z- \cde `\z\[j\``Z, f]hzZ u[\ce, y[\ yZdZ-
yZ zhc_ c jwvZz. • \\ g} u`_\d\, †dZ ghd, c\[ad\ ”dZd — ow[\d yZdZg cj\[wˆ-
\cja `_ yZ]h†al j_g_| fZjZ^ade ŠZde al!
`\z`ZyZ cjagZ†`ZyZ z_cj_, dZ Z`Z • `_†a`va — Z `_†a`v_Š `_[Z fZo\-
\yZ f]Zfad_\d a c[\j_\d †]\ug}†_l`Z c\[Zg_de Zd[\je`Z, ”dZ h g_z c\]e\u`Z
gvwc`}z. yZgZ]ˆ.

   
        —    ,    -
.            “          ”,    
,                    
              ,      .
 
   : %!
  
 + 

      
 . .   .
  !: %   
:  ! ,  ",  !    #  

 "   -" 

) +  ' , .    


%

4"? $. 9 +$ !<- :    '5" $ < r


 <  " !5 >$ 5 $%- &, '" #% — &%#%8
'. @%$%8 !%, !<%8 '"-
O"$ 5 '58 $ < !- #+ $%>$+  <5 <+>%8 
&  !+ + %$. H'&>& !- 5> . T# ! <
>& %$  %$-! 5 *% !%$"- !$%8 $$%,  +  <>5
E+  $%  $$%  '"#+ $$ ,  , $*5, $ !<,
$>+ +. U  8 $%   ! $%,  $+ , R %*
#$+ ", +  , >'& %$ >5 >$ 5 $%'.
<+5  E. P> $"$ W %  + #&  +
+%, >'&   !<>&+  +5$+ ,   <, $$ R '&
 !  '5 + + —  - !< "8  <+,  !-
!" %$ ,  !"  +5> $% " @# 5: +# <+-
<   >$% 5 $%' - >%8 #%  +&+ +
+  >.  <+">&+  *&+  #
 $ <  %$+ +& !- $ %$+. !" @# I!$
 +# "& &, !* <&  '" + > !E,
 '$%8 '&<%, — R >$ - !%>5 <+>"5 >$ +
+ . !5". 9 5  !#8: “F +5-
"#$ >

ƒ~

+?” — “A,   +5+,  >" !- $+  !", >'& ! V-
*, !?”    ! <! &-
J >", ! >" $%& $%'&  ,   $E  %$. 7 @#,
&$!   < '8 * '&,
O> $ * >+  %$, $& +* " &&+ V",  %$% '%
'*+  $,  !+ !- >  $$+
'5+ $ +% &$%, !<%8 +- , > *   $%'. F+"
$. A$&+ $&#$,  !+#+ >$ — > <'<?
" >, +, >'& >  8,  $ + !55 $%-
!. A !",  !!- '&?
". /, "# >"  >" !, *
A$& !!58 &$% $E, 'V55" %'. K$ , !-
 R %* $$ + %. A '5<", *  !% $% @#, !$&
&#, '5<" —  <'%"    !   *. >%%,
$+ %>! — '"  & @# $  !%"? A? A% !!-
+  !5+ E&+ <+! + $  !+, $"$ <-
7 '& >$ + #"  #"  %+5" . M# <%+5",
!8+. $? O$ !>! : '%
A% ,  , +* "  , &$&  '8, +<&-
+5 @#. O"$  $ +5+% @#%  !&+ ++  !&! %+-
%$ 5 !8 !<" +$+ $%'- + — $ !5.
Сыр
В
Zd †dZ h g_z cv_^w — u_oZ- ]\yaZ`\ c ]_ugad}z c}]Zg_]\`a\z
dadech Z u[Z]Zge\ `_[Z Zoh- zZ^`Z `_c†ad_de [\chdva, \cja `\ cZd-
u_d\je`Z! • `_†a`_de ”dw `a cZ]dZg? xZ[ Zfac_`a\ gc\Š aug\cd-
ƒm u_oZdw cj\[w\d Zd c_z}Š `}Š z\dZ[Zg f]ayZdZgj\`ah c}]_ `\
Zc`Zg. ‰}]}ja `_ [_†\ vZ- Šg_dad z\cd_ a g oZje|Zl v`ay\, fZ”dZ-
jZ[\‚ — f]\v]_c`Z. €Z Zd`\cad\ gZ[w zw [_g_ld\ h ]_ccv_^w Z c_zZz f]ZcdZz
g j_oZ]_dZ]aˆ, fwcde f]Zg\]hd, zZ^`Z z\dZ[\, vZdZ]}l j\yvZ gZcf]ZaugZ[az
ja \\ fade. €_|ja Zf]hd`wˆ cZc\[vw c g wcjZgahŠ [_^\ cZg]\z\``Zl yZ]Z[-
vZ]ZgZl — Zdja†`Z, dZjevZ fZ†\zw o} cvZl vg_]da]}.
`\ f]Zg\]ade a zZjZvZ — u[Z]Zg_ ja c`Zg`_h u_[_†_ f]a auyZdZgj\`aa
vZ]Zg_? €\d ja, wf_ca iZcfZ[e, w `\\ c}]_ — vZ_ywja]Zg_de, ZcZo}z Zo]_uZz
v_vaŠ-dZ u_oZj\g_`al, Zd vZdZ]}Š zZ- gZu[\lcdgZg_de `_ cZ[\]^_alch g zZ-
^\d fZcd]_[_de a g_|\ u[Z]Zge\? jZv\ o\jZv a d\z auz\`ade \yZ cd]wvdw-
‰c\ ”dZ — Zc`Zg} Zc`Zg, `Z]z_je`}\ ]w. ‰ f]a`‚af\ `_ o\jZv zZ^`Z gZu[\l-
jˆ[a Zocw^[_ˆd aŠ `\ †_\ gZf]ZcZg cdgZg_de f]a fZzZa jˆoZl vacjZd} —
ja†`Zl yaya\`}. – wg_^_ˆ zZaŠ †ad_- ŠZde wvcwcZz, ŠZde jazZ``Zl vacjZdZl.
d\j\l, c†ad_ˆ aŠ jˆ[eza ]_uwz`}za a ‹Z^`Z acfZjeuZg_de dw vacjZdw, vZdZ-
cfZcZo`}za c_zZcdZhd\je`Z cZojˆ[_de ]wˆ g}]_o_d}g_ˆd au cZ[\]^_aŠch g
f]_gaj_ yaya\`} fad_`ah, ]wvZgZ[- zZjZv\ c_Š_]Zg `\vZdZ]}\ zav]ZZ]y_-
cdgwhce u`_`ahza, u[]_g}z cz}cjZz a `auz}. €Z g ]\uwjed_d\ d_vZyZ gZu[\l-
^au`\``}z Zf}dZz. xZz`h Zo ”dZz, [_- cdgah w `_c fZjw†adch f]Z[wvd, Z†\`e
g_ld\ fZyZgZ]az Z dZz, v_v zZ^`Z [Zz_ z_jZ `_fZza`_ˆal u`_vZz}\ `_z cZ-
c[\j_de c_z}l f]ZcdZl c}]. ]d_ c}]_.
‰ZZo\ c]\[a f]Z[wvdZg, vZdZ]}\ œw†|\ gc\yZ gZu[\lcdgZg_de `_ zZ-
jˆ[a fZjw†_ˆd au zZjZv_, c}] — c_- jZvZ f]a fZzZa c}†w^`ZyZ ‘\]z\`-
z}l z`ZyZZo]_u`}l. …dZ gZuez\dch d_, vZdZ]}l fZjw†_ˆd au ZcZoZyZ Zd[\-
Zfac_de gc\ ga[} c}]_, \cja g v_^[Zz j_ ^\jw[v_ d\jhd a hy`hd. ‰ f]\^`a\
g]\z\`_ ”dw †_cde ^\jw[v_ ZcZo}z ”j\z\`dZg f]az\]`Z g [\chde ]_u `a^\,
Zo]_uZz fZ[yZd_gjag_ja a g ]\uwjed_- `Z oj_yZ[_]h vZ`cd]wv‚aa ]acZg_]va
d\ fZjw†_ja ”dZd ‚\``}l a`y]\[a\`d. `_y]\g `_fZza`_\d gZ[h`wˆ o_`ˆ, d\]-
Y\yZ[`h f]Z\ acfZjeuZg_de yZdZgwˆ zZcd_d ”dZyZ ]\^az_ wcd_`Zgj\` `_ ƒt
u_vg_cvw, vZdZ]wˆ f]Zz}|j\``}z Zo- ƒt–ƒp °Y.
]_uZz g}fwcv_ˆd [jh jˆoad\jecvZyZ – acfZjeuwˆ ]acZg_]vw, vZy[_ z`\
aja vwcd_]`ZyZ c}]Zg_]\`ah. €_f]a- o}g_\d `w^`_ gZ[h`_h o_`h, vZy[_ `w-
z\], h w^\ `\ f\]g}l yZ[ acfZjeuwˆ ^\` oZje|Zl d\]zZc a vZy[_ †dZ-dZ `\-
hfZ`cvwˆ u_vg_cvw Meito, `_lda a f]a- ZoŠZ[azZ `_y]\de dZ ja o}cd]Z, dZ ja,
Zo]\cda vZdZ]wˆ gfZj`\ gZuzZ^`Z, ZcZ- `_ZoZ]Zd, z\[j\``Z. ‡ d_va\ u_[_†a `_
o\``Z d\z, w vZyZ \cde •`d\]`\d. ‰c\ vwŠ`\ gcd]\†_ˆdch [ZgZje`Z †_cdZ, fZ-
Zcd_je`Z\ `\ZoŠZ[azZ\ [jh f]ayZdZg- g\]ed\ z`\. ‰Zd, `_f]az\], a f]a [Z-
j\`ah c}]_, cvZ]\\ gc\yZ, w g_c [Zz_ z_|`\z auyZdZgj\`aa c}]_ ]acZg_]v_
w^\ \cde. Zv_u}g_\dch zZ\l `\u_z\`azZl fZ-
‹ZjZvZ jw†|\ guhde ‚\je`Z\, ŠZdh zZ`a‚\l. • Zo ZcZoZl c\dv\, vZdZ]wˆ
zZ^`Z f]az\`ade a vwfj\``Z\ g z_y_- g} zZ^\d\ ga[\de `_ ‘ZdZy]_‘aa, h
ua`\. ‰Zd w oau`\cz\`Zg c}] fZjw†_\d- dZ^\ yZgZ]aj. Y d_vZl c\deˆ w[Zo`Z
ch [_^\ au ]_ug\[\``ZyZ g gZ[\ cwŠZyZ yZdZgade, `_f]az\], Zdva[`Zl fjZg.
zZjZv_. xZzazZ ‚\je`ZyZ, `\ f_cd\- fwcdaja c\de g v_cd]ˆjˆ, ]_cf]_ga-
]auZg_``ZyZ, `Z f]Zg\]\``ZyZ zZjZv_ ja, Zfwcv_\d\ g gZ[w ]ac. …Zy[_ fZ`_-
fZ`_[Zoadch v_cd]ˆjh, y`\d, w[Zo`}l [Zoadch — fZ[`hja ]ac au gZ[} a `\
[w]|j_y a z_]jh. `w^`Z `av_vZyZ [w]|j_y_. ‰Zd a [jh
f]ayZdZgj\`ah c}]_ ”d_ c\dv_ Zv_u_-
• [jh ]ac_, j_ce Z†\`e w[Zo`Zl, ŠZdh gfZj`\ zZ^-
`Z ZoZldace a [w]|j_yZz, a [_^\ Zo}†-
a [jh c}]_ `Zl z_]j\l.
‹`Zya\ f]\[fZ†ad_ˆd f_cd\]auZ-
– w^\ yZgZ]aj Z g\cez_ fZj\u`Zz f]\[- g_de zZjZvZ f\]\[ f]ayZdZgj\`a\z
z\d\ — ]acZg_]v\. YzZd]ad\, gZ-f\]g}Š, c}]_. [`_vZ `_[Z fZ`az_de, †dZ gZ
\\ zZ^`Z acfZjeuZg_de v_v Zo}†`}l, g]\zh `_y]\g_`ah zZjZ†`}l o\jZv
`Z [Zcd_dZ†`Z f]ZcdZ]`}l d\]zZc. ‰Z- z\`h\d cgZlcdg_, _ `_ajw†|al c}] fZ-
gdZ]}Š, w ]acZg_]va \cde [g_ ]\^az_ jw†_ˆd au `\f_cd\]auZg_``ZyZ zZjZv_.
`_y]\g_. ‰ Z[`Zz ]\^az\ acfZjeuwˆdch xZ”dZzw g} c_za [Zj^`} ]\|ade, v_v
zZ`}\ `_y]\g_d\ja a cZ[\]^azZ\ `_- g} fZcdwfad\, g\[e g} †ad_ja f\]g}\
y]\g_\dch Z†\`e o}cd]Z, f]a [Zcda^\- [g_ _ou_‚_ ”dZyZ d\vcd_.
`aa Zf]\[\j\``Zl d\zf\]_dw]} fZ[-
[\]^ag_\dch ]_g`Zz\]`Z\ vaf\`a\ fZ J +$ 5, !* >+ -
gc\l fjZ_[a. •u ”dZyZ ]\^az_ ]acZ- " <  &.  5 !5
g_]v_ _gdZz_da†\cva f\]\vjˆ†_\dch gZ & +$ !8 — 5 
gdZ]Zl ]\^az, vZy[_ d\zf\]_dw]_ [`a-  $+>& <$$  8 +
_ fZcw[a`} [Zcday_\d kmp °Y. ‰Z gdZ- !'", >'& !" &"8 $-
]Zz ]\^az\ zZ`Zcde `_y]\g_ˆaŠ & $+>& !$%  >
%* <"  +>& '$.
J +$ 58 &<" — 
!$%",  ! !5" "- 
!+ +. A +* !" ƒp
&  < '&>, &<# +-
$. / 8'+ %> +$ % >"
* "  +!%& 23 °F.
W %   $  % !-
* !',  %># R " 
5 ' ' !" $88
>< $"  +& +& 
 > !+#". 7 ' !,
 %.
5 %" 5<  +, >
( ++ <$$ !<> 5 <-
5 & < (CC  +$. : <
3  +$ !%>5 * '"#
$++ +# &. A%* 
+ '"#?
R+%  <$$  " -
'+ $> !#$. W" %
 >& !>& &? G +5 *
. R+% !5 " !$$
  & >, R  I  
 . .,      !%>5,
> <$$ +5    “
<”. J R >* $> !-
 + !" ! 
$8. I  < <$$%
 >#$ ! &  '"   +-
$, ! > +$ I" <+-
#". A  $8>",  $%
<$&"  "  !$  '<-
5 %$. W &  '< -
$  +,  $88  %$%"
 !5I 5.
+ >< 2C–BC +%  $8
> '<&"5 +>& %$.
9* <<"   $%'$  <-
+#" — %$ %* > !&,
 +* <<" *+,  >< $-
 +5 %$  '<% -
, > ! . 5 + & $%. / -
P5 !5 $&  & < +,
 & %$ ! '<- &+  '% >< !% ",
ƒs 5  %!5 8, >+ !8  !%>5 ' &+  !$+.
+% '%8,
' 5%>%8 $E8. U !- A$& 58 &  !
!>8 ! !*" I +- &$,  + $ &  >" !-
, !$ %$  %!5 $, >  5.
 !" +* !*" >%8
*$%    !5.  R —avZdd_?
%$ ' $&8  %#, '
!+8 < $8  !#8 :   !" &$% $!" 
5 $5 # &$. '"#+ ,  '" +$+ -
9% >< 5" &$ !> + '$, $& '% '"5 
+ ! >".O & % !,  !%>5 I  
<<"  '"# $%>$   &, ' !+8I $E-
!". 7% !E8 % !-  >" *& . A $$ * 
" - <, $*& E$ <+  $%& — & '& <! L", > !%>-
'"# (C–(3 +%. F $*&+ <+ & 5  + +.
'% "5  !.
 R I < <<&  ‰_]a_`dZg f]ayZdZgj\`ah c}]_ —
$%>$ &  %*" ! ,  - Z†\`e z`ZyZ. €\vZdZ]}\ `_y]\g_ˆd
$%8 !". fZjw†ag|alch cywcdZv, vdZ-dZ g`Zcad
+ +% >< E" & g `\yZ ZcZo}\ vwjedw]}, c}] cw|_d a
 <<"  $%$, !&!" "8 Zcd_gjhˆd [Zu]\g_de g ZcZo}Š fZz\-
 !"  & $!$ - \`ahŠ [jh fZjw†\`ah dg\][}Š c}]Zg.
 . A (  & % +5 % iZdZg}\ yZjZgva c}]_ Zoz_u}g_ˆd
6–) & *$ . W  '% cf\‚ahza a d]_g_za, g}[\]^ag_ˆd g
+"#,  & !%>5 $%&+, $$ ga`\ — gc\Š g_]a_`dZg `\ wfZz`a|e
'&  !5" !E& “+ +- a `\ w†d\|e. {_ a f]Zz}|j\``}\,
"&+” &+. f]Z‘\ccaZ`_je`}\ z\dZ[} f]ayZdZg-
/  & * !*" 5 j\`ah jˆoZyZ f]Z[wvd_ zZywd cw\-
'& >". G+  %* +* !'". cdg\``Z Zdja†_dech Zd z\dZ[_ [Zz_|-
A %># I < $#"  %$+ `\yZ. “ZjevZ h gZd †dZ cv_^w: \cja o\u
 &+" !+ $ *, $$ &+- vZ`‚_ acv_de f]a†a`} [jh dZyZ, †dZo}
#8 . D,  R ++  & `\ c[\j_de cgZl f\]g}l [Zz_|`al
+* '" <".  R & c}], — Z`a `_l[wdch. ‡ d\ au g_c, vdZ
'8  %$&8  @+% ! !. ]\|adch `_ ”dZd Zf}d, wga[hd, †dZ `\d
  $$ &   + E- g ”dZz `a†\yZ cjZ^`ZyZ, _ Zdja†_dech
&+,  +* %'"  ,  <- [Zz_|`al f]Z[wvd Zd fZvwf`ZyZ ow-
, ' !+"   . [\d… `w, g} u`_\d\, v_v. ‰} w^\ [Zcd_-
P >< !5" &   dZ†`Z u]\j}\ g vwja`_]`Zz Zd`Z|\-
! <  ' $& `aa jˆ[a!
)  

 
%

YdZ cjZ\g gvwc_ • h fZ`az_ˆ — c\][‚_-dZ w `_c ZoZ- ƒ


aŠ cdw†_d g Z[a`_vZgZz ]adz\, g w`a-
€Z `\ \[hd c}] o\u Šj\o_! —wv_ Zo ]wvw cZ`.
a[wd ”da f]Z[wvd} `_ cdZj_Š gc\Š `_- ` Zfac}g_\d jˆoaz}\ z`Zˆ c [\d-
]Z[Zg, vZdZ]}z u`_vZzZ a dZ a []wyZ\. cdg_ j\f\|va v_v †w[Z, _ w z\`h g yZjZ-
xwcde Z[`a [ZfZj`hˆd _vvZ][ u\j\`eˆ, g\ ]Z^[_\dch z}cje Z dZz, †dZ a h `\
_ []wya\ hyZ[_za a ga`Zy]_[Zz, fwcde Zdv_u_j o} d_vaz fZcj_z, [_ a g]h[ ja
Z[`a u_fag_ˆd c}] a Šj\o ga`Zz, _ []w- o} vdZ gZZo\ cwz\j Zdv_u_de jˆ[hz,
ya\ †_\z a g_]\`e\z — `\auz\``Zl vZdZ]}\ f]a`Zchd g fZ[_]Zv Šj\o.
Zcd_\dch f_]_ c}] a Šj\o. ‰\]`\zch v {_, fZcjw|_ld\ zZ\yZ cZg\d_! •[a-
Šj\ow? d\ g yZcda c Šj\oZz g ]wv_Š. šcja fjZŠZ
‰Zd Z` `_†a`_\d ]_ccv_u}g_de Z dZz, f]azwd — `\ f\†_jed\ce Z d_vZz †\jZ-
v_v \yZ, _u\]o_l[^_`‚_, fZvZ]aja wuo\- g\v\. €Z h u`_ˆ, z`\ Zf}d gc\Š fZvZj\-
va. x]ZcdZ f]a\Š_ja a wyZgZ]aja c[\- `al, ^ag|aŠ f]\^[\ z\`h, fZ[cv_u}g_-
j_de dZ, †dZ az o}jZ `w^`Z. \d — f]azwd ŠZ]Z|Z!
— ‡ v_v h az zZy Zdv_u_de, vZy[_ Z`a x]ZcdZd_ a j_vZ`a†`Zcde Šj\o_ g cZ-
f]a\Š_ja vZ z`\ a f]ag\uja c cZoZl g]\z\``Zz ‡u\]o_l[^_`\ w[agjh\d.
g\ce ”dZd Šj\o? YdZjevZ ga[Zg j\f\|\v, €\ga[az}l cZo\c\[`av v_v o} yZgZ]ad:
Z[`_ j\f\|v_ jw†|\ []wyZl — `_[Z ^\, “‡ u_†\z d\o\ ja|`\\? ‰Zd †w]\v, gZd
g\uja au “_|v\`d_ g ’_vw! j_g_| — ”dZyZ [ZgZje`Z `_ gc\ cjw†_a
 

& 
' 
     "      
. "       
$  

"#$ > +/%

ƒƒ ^au`a”. YZZo]_^\`ah ]_uwz`Zl [Zcd_- x\†\`_h v_dj_z_


dZ†`Zcda g}yjh[hd wo\[ad\je`Z gfjZde
[Z dZyZ zZz\`d_, fZv_ `\ gcfZza`_\|e H'&> **  — +%$, ,
]_u`ZZo]_ua\ Šj\o_ g ›uo\vacd_`\. **, > $ *, $$  !&
bdZ u_cd_gajZ `_]Z[ f]a[wz_de '-, — &+#5 '&. F-
cdZjevZ cZ]dZg Šj\o_, fZ†\zw v_^[}l > %< !>+%.
]\yaZ`, [_ †dZ d_z, v_^[}l yZ]Z[ a /-!&,   $*& $%>$
\[g_ ja `\ v_^[_h wuo\vcv_h z_Š_jjh , <&  !E, I '%
cj_gadch cgZaza, v_vaza-dZ ZcZo}za &+#  <$%. F> '"#
j\f\|v_za? ‹Z^\d o}de, †wde oZj\\ !E !+ $%$  !,
cw]Zg_h c]\[_ Zoad_`ah a ^\j_`a\ v]_-  " !, '5  -
cZd}? ‡ Z[`Zl ja v]_cZd}?  E, !+ I <,  !% 
‰Zd, guhde ŠZdh o}, v_dj_zw — cjZ\- C %,  $   !, !$ %$ 
`wˆ j\f\|vw. !>%%8 — #! O ++>-
€a†\yZ cjZ^`ZyZ! Y\l†_c ]wva zZ\yZ  '8I  $&+, *-
u\zjhv_ fZv_^wd, v_v yZdZghd v_dj_zw &+ *5+ @+%8 $& 
g yZ]Z[\ cv_uZv — ‹_]yaj_`\. ‰ZZo\- $$%& '%>$ — !%"  !5
dZ, d_z `\ Z[a` ga[ v_dj_z} yZdZghd, a ! !E+, !% I <.
`avZzw `\ u_f]\\`Z g}[wz_de cgZl, O!" $* <$ +
`Zg}l. xZ”dZzw cj\[ad\ u_ ]wv_za g`a-  5 !"E. H*&+, -
z_d\je`Z, c\l†_c ”da ]wva f]ayZdZghd &+  $$%&+ *5+ !"E&
fhde ga[Zg v_dj_z}. !I8 '%>$% >  '.
x\]g}l ga[ au []Z^^\gZyZ d\cd_, f\- K%$ !!%8 ' +%$, $-
†\`}l. &8  !!+, >'& <+ !-
"  $ 5%". K<%  -
* I < !!+  , >'&

%

ƒr

!" > $+ * *5+ - E"? 9! 9& !*+   !&
" <  & $%.  +   %&,  % '%+
"E+ < $ — *, >'& <>"  %,  %  !%>5
 !", $$ '& %5 “, - 5,      !
, 55”,   **  / $, +,  !>"?
'< 5$ $$, 8 "$ *- : !" % !+  $  !-
"8  >"8 $&5  + $ %, *, >'&  !-
"  >#+ !+.  <%",   !"   $-
— 9 ! +$.
$ %$ <+<&8 ! %" !" R #' I !.
+  !& ' *,  O I < !+5, #' %-
+* '&", +"   % ! !- >5  <+,   +&   !-
 ,  5 I "- *+ '%,  !$ — %8I5 <-
#,  $% I #. $.
&%I !& <5 : / <$, $E, * ! !-
— O!" %" %+  !%" !- E+, !5,  !5 %* !-
! !, !  <  '"5. F
— M! — >8 %$. — P $"$ "$ !"E&, "$ +5$ !%#>$,
*   !%>5? P5"? P- >5  &,  5 '%%I
"#$ > +/%

rm $5,  +& +5$ '$, $& z_cjZz. • d_, †dZ o\u jwv_, — `\cZz`\`-
*& "5  !$. `Z, wuo\†v_, _ w^ d_, †dZ c jwvZz — c_-
A% $$, $$ '8 R %$, R z_h `_cdZh_h z_]yaj_`cv_h wuo\†v_!
!"E&, >  ! + !%# <-
>5  !#$%? / "  —
!"E& !'* ! $%%, !5  _]\`_h v_dj_z_
>%" " ! '$+,   — '&
! ,  !%>" !#$! x\]\g\ja [wŠ? ž, fZyZ[ad\, gc\ dZjevZ
Q >$> — #'& %+  `_†a`_\dch!
 '& '&+ %<+ <$? – g\[e \\ `\ cv_u_j g_z, †dZ g ‹_]-
— O, , ! — <5 +&, yaj_`\ v_dj_zw †_\ ^_]hd, †\z g}-
%& %$,  !#$ !$&" f\v_ˆd. €w g c_zZz [\j\, †\yZ g_z gZ-
%<+. uadech c d_`[}]Zz, aja c_^ g [wŠZgvw
/,  & ! :  &, !%- cd_gade, aja fZ[oa]_de [jh g_|\l [w-
! $, $$ +& !%!  $- — ŠZgva dh^\jwˆ †wyw``wˆ cvZgZ]Z[w,
 %$%,  & >%%& *. †dZo} `_ `\l, f\]\g\]`wdZl, g}f\v_de
f\†\`wˆ v_dj_zw? b\z f\†\`_h v_dj_-
YzZd]ad\, v_va\ v]_c_ga‚}! ‡ g} u`_\- z_ jw†|\ ^_]\`Zl? “\z oZj\\ †dZ [jh
d\, †\z ”da [g\ c\cd]} Zdja†_ˆdch Z[`_ ”dZyZ fZ[Zl[\d jˆo_h, c_z_h Zo}†`_h
Zd []wyZl? {_, Z`a ]_u`}\! [`_ c jw- cvZgZ]Z[_.
vZz, _ []wy_h f]ZcdZ c z_cjZz. “_, †dZ c €Z c`_†_j_ [_g_ld\ c d\cdZz fZ]_oZ-
jwvZz, o}j_ f]ayZdZgj\`_ dZ†`Z d_v ^\, d_\z.
v_v f]Zcd_h, dZjevZ vZy[_ z_cjZ fZ[Z-
y]\g_ja, g `\yZ [Zo_gaja fZ]\u_``}l A >",  %   !%>5
dZ`vaza fZjwvZje‚_za jwv, jwv f]Z-  ! < $ *, $$ % + <+5-
y]\jch a Zdf]_gajch `_ d\cdZ gz\cd\ c $, 5%" $%$ # &+#,

%

rt

+5$    & !&, +*- …H!! / # &+# . %"
% $&+ 5 #" "$5 !, ? P +% I +
!!$. O+,  !E!, > %- !5",  *", $ !I
 . & !"E ! , '"- !$, >'&  .
# !E ! $%$, ! 
!!& %$  <& &, !, bdZ, `\ czZ^\d\ d_v? €w [_, zZl u\z-
 — !   <$! jhv — ga]dwZu g ]_oZd\ c d\cdZz, w `\yZ
"  !$, >5  ]wva uZjZd}\. €Z a Z` vZy[_-dZ `_†a`_j,
$,  B3 % !%  Z` dZ^\ w vZyZ-dZ w†ajch! ›†ad\ce a g}
 "# !#, '<%5 ! '5 $ w `\yZ. xwcde fZjw†adch `\ dZ†`Z d_v
$ <I!, #  E — ! ^\, fwcde ]_oZd_de f]a[\dch `\z`ZyZ
%  ,  !" >" [Zje|\, `Z g\[e fZjw†adch!
, > '& * !$. bdZ [_je|\?
J I <, >5  $, >-
+ !%    $5I5 % P"#, +% >< $, $ -
%%  >% %.  '% ! ,  <5 
!E, $*%8 !E8 %$ <+% 
€\z`ZyZ z_yaa a z_cd\]cdg_ a… !#$%. Q% !!% +%$, !#$%

%

rp

+8  $$%  $8  +- ˜_yao_\d\ f_je‚}, c†ad_\d\, cvZjevZ


& ', $& > $ * +*% ga[Zg v_dj_z} fZjw†ajZce? {g\ f\†\-
++  ++  %$+. O> $ *, `}\, [g\ ^_]\`}\.
$$ & %* , <*% '  !- ‡ \cja g}, fZ[`_o]_g|ace Zf}d_,
&  %  #'%, $ % !- ]acv`\d\ au]_cŠZ[Zg_de `_ ^_]\`wˆ
. v_dj_zw `\ ]_cdad\je`Z\ z_cjZ, _ []_-
/ R #'& +*  $$ $- yZ‚\``Z\ dZfj\`Z\, dZ g} fZjw†ad\…
&", R  $ %* *&! O"$ — …czZd]ad\ oja^\ — ”dZ ^\ `\ f]ZcdZ
>%! — %: $&"   - fhd}l ga[ v_dj_z}, ”dZ w^\… f_Šj_g_?
&. P%5  * "5 - {_, h fZjaj yZdZgwˆ, \\ yZ]h†wˆ v_d-
!$, >  !%>5 ! j_zw ]_cdZfj\``}z z\[Zz, ŠZdh zZl
K$  <%  $$%  - u\zjhv wo\^[_j z\`h: “{_ dZjevZ c_Š_-
<&+ ++. A +!%% !- ]Zz fZc}f_ˆd, `\ d]_dhd z\[ `_ d_vZ\!”
'",  $ *". 1% + ‡ h [wz_j: “bdZ ^\, a `avZy[_ f]\^[\,
&+ — !5  , !%>5 [Z `_c, `avdZ `\ d]_daj z\[ `_ v_dj_-
$+ #$+ *,  $ >+% R. zw? • o\vz\u — wf_]\``}l ‘]wvdZg}l
1% #$+ 5>+ —   cZv — `avdZ `\ d]_daj g d\ g]\z\`_,
5,  % 5 & . vZy[_ \\ `\ u`_ja `av_vZyZ c_Š_]_-
7 + <>+? (3C–(6C °F,  f\cv_? “Zy[_ Zdvw[_ ^\ w `_c, w dˆ]v-
 ++&  *, !$ 5 cvaŠ `_]Z[Zg, guhj_ce f_Šj_g_? • Zdvw-
& # #'$ %& — !&. A  [_ guhj_ce f_Šj_g_ w d\Š, vdZ `avZy[_ `\
!%>5, > + 8! wz\j yZdZgade v_dj_zw?”

       "    —


          
 ,                #    .
    —  " 
   ,   " ,    -
   ,      "  $    ,   "      !
Сливочное
масло
З
`_\d\, fZ†\zw [ZgZje`Z †_- fZZo\_j, †dZ ow[w cvwf_de gc\ zZjZvZ,
cdZ h f]\[j_y_ˆ g_z f]ayZdZ- vZdZ]Z\ Z`_ `\ czZ^\d f]Z[_de. • z`\
gade c_zaz v_va\-dZ o_uZg}\ fZ]Zˆ f]aŠZ[adch fZvwf_de c]_uw fZ
rs f]Z[wvd} au d\Š, †dZ, v_^\dch, s– d]\Šjad]Zg}Š o_`Zv zZjZv_. Yf]Z-
zZ^`Z fZlda a vwfade g jˆ- cad\, vw[_ z`\ cdZjevZ?
oZz z_y_ua`\? šcja zZjZvZ, vZdZ]Z\ h fZvwf_ˆ,
– f]ZcdZ ŠZ†w, †dZo} g} wu`_ja a f]ZcdZad ŠZdh o} `Z†e, dZ `_ g\]Šw
gcfZz`aja gvwc `_cdZh\l \[}. ‰\[e v_^[Zl d]\Šjad]ZgZl o_`va Zo]_uw\d-
g}]ZcjZ w^\ ‚\jZ\ fZvZj\`a\ jˆ[\l, ch y]_zz |\cdecZd–gZc\zecZd cjagZv.
vZdZ]}z `_cdZha\ f]Z[wvd} v_^wdch €\oZje|az fZjZg`a†vZz z} c`az_-
z\`\\ gvwc`}za, †\z d\, †dZ g}jZ^\`} \z dZjevZ †_cde ”daŠ cjagZv — g\[e
`_ c_z}Š ga[`}Š fZjv_Š cwf\]z_]v\- Zcd_g|\\ch zZjZvZ, †dZ o} z} au `\yZ
dZg. • †dZ Zoa[`Z — y[\-dZ d_z ^\, `\- `a cd_ja yZdZgade, gc\ ]_g`Z [Zj^`Z
fZ[_j\vw, `_ †wde z\`\\ f]az\d`}Š az\de ŠZde v_vwˆ-dZ ^a]`Zcde!
fZjv_Š z_y_ua`Zg [Z^a[_ˆdch cgZ\yZ YZo]_``}\ cjagva zZ^`Z wfZd]\-
fZvwf_d\jh a `_cdZha\, v_†\cdg\``}\ oade fZ g_|\zw wczZd]\`aˆ, `\ yZgZ]h
f]Z[wvd}! €Z cv_^ad\ z`\, \cja vdZ-dZ w^ Z dZz, †dZ au `aŠ zZ^`Z coade c_zZ\
fwd_\d ŠZ]Z|\\ c ]\vj_za]w\z}z, _ `_cdZh\\ cjagZ†`Z\ z_cjZ. šcja g}
gvwc fZ[ja``}Š f]Z[wvdZg \zw f]ZcdZ f]a`hja d_vZ\ ]\|\`a\, dZ Zohu_d\je`Z
`\u`_vZz, dZ v_v \zw g}o]_de ŠZ]Z|\\? fZz\cdad\ cjagva g ŠZjZ[aje`av, Z`a
‰Zd a f]ZacŠZ[ad u_vZ`Zz\]`Z\: g}- [Zj^`} Zcd}de [Z m–q °Y a fZcdZhde f]a
yZ[`}\ f]Z[wvd} c zZ`}za ]\vj_z- d_vZl d\zf\]_dw]\ `\ z\`\\ mq †_cZg.
`}za oˆ[^\d_za cz\`hˆd ŠZ]Z|a\, €_g\]`hv_ z`Zya\ u`_ˆd, †dZ, [jh
v_^[Z\ Z†\]\[`Z\ fZvZj\`a\ g}oa]_\d dZyZ †dZo} coade cjagZ†`Z\ z_cjZ, g
cgZ\ f\fca, cf]Zc [avdw\d f]\[jZ^\`a\ [\]\g`hŠ acfZjeuwˆd wuvwˆ a g}cZvwˆ
a fZl[a d\f\]e, fZaa `_cdZh\\ — v_[w|vw, g vZdZ]Zl cjagva guoag_ˆd
`\d \yZ, ac†\u_\d `_ yj_u_Š! f]a fZzZa ZcZoZl f_jva c v]\cdZga-
Y []wyZl cdZ]Z`}, \cja jˆ[a cd_`wd `Zl `_ vZ`‚\.
]_uoZ]†ag\\ a gc\ z\`e|\ ow[wd fZvw- ‰ z\cd_Š, y[\ c yZ] o\ywd o}cd]}\ ]w-
f_de dZ, †dZ f]\[j_y_ˆd _j†`}\ oau`\c- †ea, jˆ[a `_w†ajace f]acfZc_ojag_de
z\`}, dZ, zZ^\d o}de, ’Zy [_cd, a fZh- [ga^wwˆ cajw gZ[} fZ[ cgZa `w^[}.
gadch cf]Zc `_ `_dw]_je`wˆ cz\d_`w,
ŠZ]Z|wˆ vZjo_cw, _ yjh[a|e, [\jZ [Zl-
[\d a [Z `_cdZh\yZ cjagZ†`ZyZ z_cj_?
‹_cjZoZlv_
– gc\ fZ`az_ˆ: g yZ]Z[_Š c ŠZ]Z|az g ‡u\]o_l[^_`\
•`d\]`\dZz fZ†da `\ vwfade [_^\ Zo}†-
`ZyZ [Zz_|`\yZ zZjZv_. €Z z} c g_za ‰Zd czZd]ad\: o}cd]}l fZdZv gZ[} g]_-
w^\ yZgZ]aja, v_v cj\[w\d o\]\†e a jˆ- _\d jZf_cda vZj\c_.
oade d\Š d\dw|\v, †dZ [Z caŠ fZ] [\]^_d g ‡ gZd v d_vZzw ^\ vZj\cw f]acfZcZ-
ŠZuhlcdg_Š vZ]Zg. `a — `_|_ `_[\^[_! oaja |_dw`, vZdZ]}l ]_cv_†ag_\d vZ]-
€_f]az\], w z\`h \cde d_v_h u`_vZ- ua`vw. ‰ vZ]ua`vw wjZ^aja vwg|a`,
z_h a h, wyZg_]ag_h \\ `\ ]\u_de vZ]Zg, cvgZue Z[`w au cd\`Zv vwg|a`_ f]Zfw-
r
cdaja v_z}|a`vw. b\]\u †_c-fZjdZ]_ # " !% !5+ >,   >#% 
cjagva, `_jad}\ g d_vZl vwg|a`, f]\- ++ " %  '" +$ $-
g]_dhdch g cjagZ†`Z\ z_cjZ a f_Šdw. & .
o}†`Z d_vaz z\dZ[Zz yZdZghd z_cjZ %" +$ !' I +- rr
au u_vac|aŠ \cd\cdg\``}z Zo]_uZz , , $ + '"5  $%!& $-
aja [_^\ cf\‚a_je`Z cvg_|\``}Š cja- +"5, & %, >  %  + -
gZv, fZ cwda, au cz\d_`}. Yvg_|\``}\ # > + !&. P5 %>#
cjagva fZjw†_ˆdch oZj\\ ywcd}za, fZ- >$ + % I < !$#"
”dZzw g vwg|a` [Zo_gjhˆd `\z`ZyZ zZ-  !" !E%%    "+.
jZv_ — f]ZcdZ [jh dZyZ, †dZo} cjagva A  $ '& *+, +-
cgZoZ[`\\ f\]\z\_jace fZ vwg|a`w. &+  $%&+,  !%  + >-
 "  . ! + <
A%  > " *+, % $&  $#$ '5  $"$ $+". W
 %<$ $$  $,  $%#  ! *"  !" +% @+%.
 5&+ $+? H>" 8", > %
 " 5 '& # +$. T%># “_vZ\ z_cjZ, v_v f]_gajZ, Š]_`adch
<5"  $ — ! !,  z\`e|\ f]Zz}dZyZ, `Z \yZ _]Zz_d a
<>&+ $+. gvwc ow[wd oZj\\ h]vZ g}]_^\``}z. {_
4   >#% $  >- a f_Šd_ — u_z\†_d\je`}l f]Z[wvd. š\
 <'". A  " $ zZ^`Z acfZjeuZg_de [jh f]ayZdZgj\-
 $ >#, "  <'5  'V- `ah d\cd_, _ dZ a [Zo_gade v zZjZvw, au
+ !! %>5,   $ vZdZ]ZyZ ow[wd yZdZgade dgZ]Zy.
+ > '"5  $+$, ! {jh auyZdZgj\`ah z_cj_, f]\[`_u`_-
 !$"5. A  <- †\``ZyZ [jh f]Z[Zj^ad\je`ZyZ Š]_`\-
" +$% #$+ &$%8 $"  `ah, a`_†\ yZdZghd a c_za cjagva: u[\ce
5"   R$>$ %# * w^\ `\ ZoZldace o\u c\f_]a]Zg_`ah
  —  !< + ', +- cjagZv a f_cd\]au_‚aa zZjZv_.
% >< E", $,    >< >. €Z, †\cd`Z\ cjZgZ, g [Zz_|`aŠ wcjZ-
/+5 <'5 + <  gahŠ `\d cz}cj_ [\j_de z_cjZ vajZ-
* $   , $"$ y]_zz_za, _ dZ vZja†\cdgZ, †dZ g} cZ-
 &< — $$ <+ $!"$ o\d\ au jad]_-[]wyZyZ cjagZv, g_|_
*  R $. /" $ +">- c\zeh c\cd \[g_ ja `\ u_ Z[a` f]ac\cd.
# $!"$ *  $  +$ ‰\[e gvwc v ŠZ]Z|\zw gZcfad}g_\dch
“>85” %  %+,  '<%8 o}cd]Z, u_dZ cZŠ]_`h\dch gcˆ ^au`e!
$!8 '"# <+. ! <- – f\]\f]ZoZg_j fZvwf`Z\ cjagZ†`Z\
+ *& $!$  $  ' z_cjZ c_z}Š ]_u`}Š cZ]dZg.
%>5, > %!I <- œa|e Z[`Z z_cjZ fZ ZfdZgZl ‚\`\
 +. kq~~ ]woj\l u_ vajZy]_zz o}jZ o\c-
< $ +5  $ !- cfZ]`Z gvwc`}z, _]Zz_d`}z a g}u}g_-
55 +55 $#$. jZ gZcŠa\`a\.
W $ '"   %  xZ zZaz Zw\`ahz, g z_cj\, vZ-
%* !55 !5& !$%,  %>- dZ]Z\ zZ^`Z vwfade g `_|aŠ Zo}†-
k~~

`}Š z_y_ua`_Š, g jw†|\z cjw†_\ cZ- `wˆ vZ]Zovw z_cj_ c dZl ^\ gZjZyZ[-
[\]^adch p~¦ `_dw]_je`ZyZ zZjZ†`Z- cvZl ‘_o]ava, h fZjw†aj dZ ^\ c_zZ\,
yZ ^a]_, gc\ Zcd_je`Z\ — d]_`c^a]}, †dZ g} zZ^\d\ vwfade g jˆoZz z_y_-
f_jezZgZ\ z_cjZ, _]Zz_dau_dZ]} a ua`\ — Zd caj} t~¦ cjagZ†`ZyZ z_cj_
v]_cad\ja. nw[|a\ Zo]_u‚} f]a f\]\- a ~¦ gchvZl []h`a, `_ Zowˆ cwzzw
d_fjag_`aa g[]wy `_†a`_ja au[_g_de q~~ ]woj\l u_ v_^[}l vajZy]_zz.
gZ`e fZ[dwŠ|aŠ yZgh^eaŠ vZcd\l — – `\ g\]ˆ g cjagva, vZdZ]}\ f]Z[_-
`\ w[agjˆce, \cja g `aŠ o}j acfZje- ˆd g `_|aŠ cwf\]z_]v\d_Š. b\z oZje-
uZg_` ^a] au vZcd`ZyZ zZuy_ aja v_- |al f]Z‚\`d ^a]`Zcda wv_u_` `_ `aŠ,
v_h a`_h y_[Zcde. d\z oZje|\ g `aŠ [Zo_gaja f_jezZgZyZ
€Z `a Z[`Z vwfj\``Z\ z`Zˆ z_cjZ ^a]_ — gZd a gc\.
`\ zZyjZ c]_g`adech c d\z, †dZ [\j_ja €_ z_y_ua``Zz zZjZv\ cjagva `\ cZ-
[jh z\`h `_ Z[`Zz u_gZ[\ g …]_c`Z[_]- o\]wdch — `\ ^[ad\, [_^\ \cja ”dZ `_-
cvZz v]_\ — fZ u`_vZzcdgw, fZ []w^o\ dw]_je`Z\ zZjZvZ, _ `\ dZjevZ `_[face
a fZ oZje|Zl f]Zceo\ f]ZcdZ guhja a `_ wf_vZgv\. ‹_y_ua``Z\ zZjZvZ ZcZ-
c[\j_ja z_cjZ au dZjevZ †dZ f]a`hdZ- o}z Zo]_uZz Zo]_o_d}g_\dch, v_f\je-
yZ c ‘\]z} zZjZv_. ždZ o}jZ `\ oadZ\ va ^a]_ auz\je†_ˆdch [jh dZyZ, †dZo}
z_cjZ, \yZ f]ayZdZgaja f]a fZzZa cjagva `\ cZoa]_jace g Z[`Zl †_cda
c\f_]_dZ]_ a Zo}†`Zl d\Š`ZjZya†\cvZl wf_vZgva. ‡ \cja a cZo\]wdch, dZ h jZz_-
ja`aa. –]†\ gc\yZ ”dZ z_cjZ fZv_u_jZ `ZyZ y]Z|_ `\ [_z u_ ”da cjagva — cvZ-
c\oh g dZfj\`Zz ga[\: \cja g u_f_Š\ jˆ- ]\\ gc\yZ ”dZ Zfhde cz\ce cZa a f_jezZ-
oZyZ fZvwf`ZyZ fZcj\ f\]\d_fjag_`ah gZyZ z_cj_. x]Zcdad\, \cja fZcj\cjZga-
Zd†\djagZ f]Zhgjhjace `Zdva ]_cda- \z h acfZ]daj g_z `_cd]Z\`a\.
d\je`ZyZ z_cj_, dZ v]_c`Z[_]cvZ\ z_c- ‰}ŠZ[ w `_c Z[a`: d]\oZg_de ŠZ]Z|\\,
jZ g dZfj\`Zz ga[\ f_ŠjZ ‚g\d_za a fZvwf_de ŠZ]Z|\\, f]Zg\]hde, g}hg-
j\d`az jwyZz. jhde, f]\[_g_de Zyj_cv\ a ay`Z]a]Zg_de
bwde cj_o\\ fZ gvwcw a u_f_Šw g}yjh- fjZŠZ\. › `aŠ dZjevZ _j†`Zcde, [\`eya
[\jZ z_cjZ gZjZyZ[cvZ\, f]ag\u\``Z\ w `_c. šcja z} `\ ow[\z yjwf}za a [Z-
z`\ g fZ[_]Zv Z[`az ŠZ]Z|az †\jZg\- g\]†ag}za, dZ Z`a ow[wd g}`w^[\`}
vZz g cwg\`a]`Zz [\]\gh``Zz oZ†Z`v\. fwcde fZcd\f\``Z, fwcde Z†\`e `\ZŠZd-
{_, ”dZ o}jZ `_cdZh\\ z_cjZ, fwcde a `Z, `Z wjw†|_de v_†\cdgZ f]Z[wvdZg.
v]\cdeh`cvZ\, m¦ ^a]`Zcda. [`_vZ, ‡ Zd ”dZyZ u_gacad a `_|\ u[Z]Zge\ a
vZy[_ h fZf]Zcaj f]ag\uda z`\ v_]dZ`- u[Z]Zge\ y]h[waŠ fZvZj\`al.
§
{ZjyZ `\ zZy ]\|adech, `\ u`_j, v_va\ k~k
cjZg_ fZ[Zo]_de, †dZo} `_fac_de Z f_Š-
j_g\. —\|aj, †dZ †\z f]Z\, d\z jw†-
|\. ‰Zd w z\`h u_fac_`_ f]hz_h ]\†e
z_cd\]a‚} fZ g}f\†v\ f_Šj_g} “w]_u-
Š_`wz au []\g`\yZ yZ]Z[_ ih`[^_, a u_-
†\z z`\ c_zZzw fZ[oa]_de v]_cag}\
cjZg_, \cja \\ ]\†e je\dch, v_v zwu}v_?
‰c\, †dZ h zZyw — `_fac_de f]az\†_-
`ah, a ”da f]az\†_`ah ow[wd ]_ccv_u}-
Yj_[Zcda g_de Z zZ\z ja†`Zz Zf}d\ f]ayZdZgj\-
`ah f_Šj_g}.
a u_vwcva YzZd]ad\, wu`_\d\? ›u`_\d\ y]\‚val
Z]\Š? –[]}|va? bacd}\, o\j}\ h[]}|-
va? €\ gZ gchvZ\ g]\zh yZ[_ Z]\Š ŠZ]Z|.
xZu[`\l g\c`Zl aja j\dZz Z]\Š `_†a-
`_\d yZ]†ade — z_cjZ, vZdZ]}z Z` `_-
fZj`\` [Z Zdv_u_, fZj\u`Z\, ŠZ]Z|\\ `_
gvwc a _]Zz_d`Z\ z_cjZ… f]ZyZ]v_\d.
‰ cvZ]jwf\ h[]Z jw†|\ Š]_`adch, †\z
Z†a\``Z\, [_ dZjevZ gc\ ]_g`Z Z]\Š
a[\_j\` ja|e g f\]g}\ fZjyZ[_ fZcj\
cZu]\g_`ah.
• gZd, g f\]g}\ fZjyZ[_ fZcj\ coZ]_
Z]\ŠZg, fZu[`\l Zc\`eˆ, uazZl, vZy[_ g\-
†\]_ [Zjya, _ `Z†a d\z`}, \[g_ ja `\ g
v_^[Zl c\ze\ fZ g\†\]_z ]_u[_\dch ]_u-
"#$ G

k~q

z\]\``}l cdwv: “dˆv-dˆv”, _ fZdZz `\- fZ[ gZcfZza`_`ah Z zw^\, vZdZ]}l


cf\|`Z, wz\] d_v ]_`Z, _ g\[e \\ g†\]_ Z`_
fZ[ Š]wcd cvZ]jwf} a fZ[ ]_uyZgZ]}; o}j_ `\g\cdZl;
fZ[ cv_uva; Z]\Ša †acdhd [Zo\j_, ZcdZ]Z^`Z, †dZ-
fZ[ zwy_z} cd_]|\l [Z†\]a, ay]_ˆ- o} `\ cjZz_de aŠ ]_`e|\ g]\z\`a, _
\l `_ y_]zZ`a [ZjyZ, cj_[vZ a fZ[Z- fZdZz fZ[cw|ade `\[\jˆ `_ gZu[wŠ\,
u]ad\je`Z cd]_cd`Z; _ vZy[_ f]ZcZŠ`wd — v_v ]_u `_cd_`\d
fZ[ Zcd}g_ˆal cd_v_` †_h; fZ]_ [\j_de f_Šj_gw.
h[]_ g}`az_ˆdch a cvj_[}g_ˆdch g ˜_†\z †acdade Z]\Ša d_v d_d\je`Z?
zacvw. …Zy[_ zacv_ `_fZj`h\dch, \\ u_ja- …Zzw z\|_\d vZ^w]_?
g_ˆd vafhdvZz a Zdcd_gjhˆd g cdZ]Z`vw. — ‡ Z`_ w g_c gZd u[\ce, g uwo_Š u_-
˜azZl gZ[_ o}cd]Z Zcd}g_\d, [_ a `\ cd]h`\d, f]ajaf`\d v uwo_z a ow[\d g_z
`_[Z z`ZyZ g]\z\`a, †dZo} ]_cf_]aj_ce `\f]ahd`Z, vZy[_ f_Šj_gw vw|_de cd_-
vZ^w]_. ‹a`wd [\chde, fwcde fhd`_[- `\d\! — “w]_u-Š_`wz fZv_u}g_\d f_je-
‚_de! “\f\]e fZ z_j\`evZzw `Z^a†vw ‚\z, vw[_ f]ajaf`\d vZ^w]_.
g dZ`\`eva\ [\ga†ea f_je†ava a… Z†a- {_, g c_zZz [\j\, `\f]ahd`Z o}g_\d,
_de vZ^w]w c v_^[Zl fZjZga`va h[]_: vZy[_ d_vZ\ cjw†_\dch!
fZ[ |\fZd, ]_ccv_u}g_ˆal Z [\ga- — €Z `_ gvwc-dZ vZ^w]_ f]_vda†\cva
†eaŠ d_l`_Š; `\ gjah\d, u_†\z dZy[_ d_v z`ZyZ g]\z\-
fZ[ ]_uyZgZ]} z_d\]a c \\ c\cd]Zl; `a d]_dade, †dZo} fZ†acdade?
fZ[ ]_uz}|j\`ah Z dZz, cvZjevZ [\- — ‰c\ ]_g`Z uazZl g\†\]Zz [\j_de
`\y wl[\d j\dZz `_ cg_[eow c}`_; `\†\yZ, †dZo} f]ZcdZ d_v `\ ca[\de…

/

k~p

‡ g ’_vw `\ †acdhd, d_v yZdZghd f_Šj_gw, gZuad\ce c Z†acdvZl y]\‚vZyZ Z]\Š_, gZue-
_ z} †acdaz, w `_c d_vZl Zo}†_l. zad\ [jh `_†a`va oj_`|a]Zg_``}l
x\]\[ c_zZl yZdZgvZl Z]\Ša f]Zfw- za`[_je, Z` cdZad f]_vda†\cva cdZje-
cv_ˆd †\]\u zhcZ]wovw. —_`e|\ cv_jva vZ ^\, cvZjevZ Z†a\``}\ Zd cvZ]jwf}
o}ja ZcZo}\, cf\‚a_je`}\, †dZo} Z]\- y]\‚va\ Z]\Ša. x]Zv_jad\ za`[_je [Z
Ša zZjZde. {\]\gh``_h cv_jv_, Zo}†- uZjZdacdZyZ ‚g\d_ a fZhgj\`ah f]ahd`Z-
`_h, dZjcd_h, _ g `\\ uwoeh z\d_jja†\- yZ u_f_Š_ g [wŠZgv\ f]a km~–kt~ °Y a ]_c-
cva\ gcd_gj\`}; Z]\Ša `_ [Zcvw a f]Z- v]Z|ad\… †\]d c g_za, zhcZ]wovZl. Y`_-
v_dade fZ `az d_vZl cv_jvZl `\cvZjevZ †_j_ f]Zfwcdad\ †\]\u v]wf`wˆ ]\|\dvw,
]_u dw[_, _ fZdZz Zo]_d`Z, [_ fZg\]`wde _ fZdZz \\ ]_u, †\]\u z\jvwˆ. “ZjevZ
a c`Zg_. “\f\]e zhcZ]wovZl gc\ fZjeuw- fZcj\ ”dZyZ f\]\z\|_ld\ za`[_je c c_-
ˆdch, _ cv_jva d_va\ w^\ a `\ [\j_ˆd. Š_]`Zl fw[]Zl, [Zo_ged\ u\j\`}l v_][_-
zZ`, [_ `\ u_ow[ed\ Z†acdade \yZ Zd cvZ]-
D  <+,  +#"   jwf}, g}`wde u\]`_ a ]_cdZjZ†e aŠ g cdw-
+. 9$  ,  !%%,  f\ c jZ^vZl c_Š_]`ZyZ f\cvw.
+$-+$ !$. %% * +*, šcja jˆoad\ c\oh, u_z\`ad\ p~~ y]_z-
"$  '&  !$ '& — I %>- zZg za`[_jh p~~ y]_zz_za Z†a\``}Š
# '& '&! J $+ '5<"  u\j\`}Š a]_`cvaŠ ‘acd_|\v. `a [Z]Z-
'" $ +  %. ya, `Z aŠ gvwc cdZad ”daŠ [\`\y. “ZjevZ
az\ld\ g ga[w, †dZ Z`a dZ^\ c}]}\, aŠ,
– fZ`az_ˆ, †dZ ^ad\jhz z\y_fZjac_ v_v a za`[_je, `_[Z f]Zy]\de g [wŠZg-
a uazZl \cde †\z u_`hdech. xZ”dZzw `\ v\ `_ f]Zdag`\ f]a kt~–kq~ °Y, fZv_ Z`a
!" 
 
 # 
   :   :
  " $   +#   ,   $
–          "
 $     ! #   
    " #    :
  #   #   "     
   !        

"#$ G *2"  3'!2'

k~s `\ `_y]\ˆdch [Z y]_[wcZg ~–ƒ~ a `\ &   '5. F%"   $$,


`_†`wd au[_g_de f]ahd`}l u_f_Š, `Z <%" !!$  <*" I <
f\]\z\|ag_ld\ aŠ g]\zh Zd g]\z\`a a  $,  !"  %%8 % — 
`\ [Zfwcv_ld\ fZhgj\`ah fZ[f_ja` Zd &   '5, $ $8,  &
cja|vZz yZ]h†\yZ f]Zdag`h. YjZl za`-   '5, >'& $% &# &+, >-
[_jh — cjZl ‘acd_|va, aja `a^`a\ '&  '& $-$, >'& '&
cjZa za`[_je, _ g\]Š`a\ — ‘acd_|v_!  ><  , "$ >'&  !-
", %! :!
O <+" >" !. D++ O$ !, %$+,   <"+#" R
+%$, !5" 5E, (CC ++ ! , >'& !*"   $-
+, 3C ++ < & — '< % — #$+ $. A%* +" 
  # $5 !%  8, —  $$%  !"  +< -
!+ I % +* '", $"- !&+ ++ $$, >'& $5
$ !'5. /&+" #  -
$&" * @$, !%" !.
/'I + !%  5, !-
+% > +  $  $-
#" — 5   *. A, >'&
! '&. R+% !% #
"8 ", <+ *,  A%< —
!$ !, !$  #, !$
  5.
K<*"   5" $%$, !%"
 >%"->%" '"# "& '% —
  +& < $+. P
$$,  &  $ $8,  -
"#$ G *2"  3'!2'

k~ƒ  +. O!"    - N@  <5", >"  %!,
. <", $$ >,  R+ #@+ $-
D% !"5? O$ I 5" <. >$ $$% !$", >'& -
4, $$%8 !% 5 + 8? & E '&, >'& ! ! #@-
H, $$5 ! '%! D <, $- +. FE '"  '%, < '%-
 "'&,  $ + !5 — !5 % "5.
!% !". O+  *%. : & < …Zy[_ `_cd_`\d g]\zh v]_cade f_Šj_gw
+ 9$&, ? G +5 +%* + %- |_‘]_`Zz, cz\|_ld\ p~ zajjajad]Zg
*. `_cdZh |_‘]_`_ c Z[`az ^\jdvZz. –
A*   >%"->%" I % acfZjeuZg_j `_dw]_je`}l |_‘]_`, \yZ
, *  5 +* I "- ‚g\d `\cvZjevZ cv]Zz`\\, †\z w fa\-
& ",  "& %* !%" '%% - gZyZ v]_cad\jh, vZdZ]}l gz\cdZ |_‘-
+ $+. ]_`_ acfZjeuZg_j_ “w]_u-Š_`wz: w `\\
   %*,  !" f]ZcdZ `\ o}jZ g}oZ]_, fZ”dZzw ‚g\d
$5 <I!"   '<" . fZjw†ajch d_vaz g\c\j\`evaz. €Z `\
/ $ % +5, +"$ * Zcw^[_ld\ \\ u_ ”dZ!
<"+%, > >* 8, *-
 — "$ +'$ *& !%- M#-# > $, <#"? 4 R +-
>"5, >'&  $&, $&! E5 %, $+& R <… : '<
H '"#,  +"$ — $ $ #-# !%  8! W <&#$
? * > >& '&8,   $!5-
1"# *   +>"   $+  !+  !E % —  
+  <", "$ *, >- $$ '& !%>85, >&. A $*-
'&  !5" <% , >'&  - & $%$,  R %$   R %$
  &#, >'&  !<" 5 " ! ->& <&#$ #-#. : 
!! % ! $%>$% . M>#",  -

&            ,   " ,  "  . ' "
 "    "  "  ,             — 
    "       —   "  

      . (   ,    
  ,    -
  ,        . )  -,     -
         ,    —    ,  ,
",     ".
"#$ G

kk~
$&  !*+,   $& — /, +, $$5 !! G +5 -
+"? ! &, & %*, !5+  5>%8
%, %" <*%. A, R !% !"+ , !%"  $*& <-
"#  & ,  5   - < !! !, " $#$, <" 
 *, 5  $  !$%,  %.  ! '&, >  >$,  <
95 ++, ''%#$ —  $ ,  >$, *,  <<, >'& 
%. %" <5, >& $!>  !!".
!%. " !:   * +*
J< & $ %" %'" , '" <%8 %. P'"  !
%,  %" , % !% !$ $  +,   $!5
&!8, >'&  !  %  %'" ", >'& $! '< <+-
!&.  $5+ " %" !%$ '%- 5 +!%& ! (CB–(C= °F (!
,   !!>5. $! $%!&+ !%<&5+,   +55
/, " !,  !>  E, 5" '&+) 5 '& +%
<!. O!" !&+ ++ '%% 5".  R +* !'" -
!", !%" + <$!, !%" !5-    !  (0( °F, !$  
+ *5. D5 +5$, +* *+ !' -<& E +,
!!5" — E !".   $!%"  %8 !",
/, <%  !, !" 5 *$ $!,   +5$+ #-
%  !!>". / $&#$ % +5, $+. %>5 %!$%& !,
>& #+!% !*%, >'& $&#$  & <+ >" & *&*-
$ !  !$",  #+!%& &+, !E*&+ !"&+ $+.
$&#$%,  $&#$% %". : <% * - A, > 5 <" !%  '%%,
+ %5 8. "<5,  ' <', >+, $

&      ,          ,  -


     "  ,        ,      *-, — 
  
 .         "   -  ,    ,  
 ",   "         —
  .      
           ,        ", 
       . ' *-     ,    -
 —   ",   "   .

/

kkk
! &, <*   > !- ˜ZjZd_h
!". J  ',  9$% <', <"
+, <" E" $++, - yZ]v_
>    %>5 ! , $%8
!%   1$%,   9$  8, šcja g} yZdZg} v fZ[gayw c dZfj\`}z
"$  Q5*! z_cjZz, `Z `\ Z†\`e yZdZg} v c\]e\u-
`Zl ]_oZd\ `_[ f_Šj_gZl, dZ `_ ”dZd
…wja`_]`}l fZ[gay, vZdZ]}l [\`e u_ cjw†_l w z\`h f]af_c\` ]\‚\fd fZf]Z-
[`\z cZg\]|_\d ”d_ cv]Zz`_h ^\`a`_, \. €Z cjZgZ “f]Z\” u[\ce Zd`Zcad-
[ZcdZa` dZyZ, †dZo} Z `\z wu`_ja. x]a- ch az\``Z v d\Š`ZjZyaa, _ `\ vZ gvwcw
yZdZged\ f_Šj_gw a wyZcdad\ \ˆ cgZaŠ ojˆ[_, Z vZdZ]Zz h cZoa]_ˆce c g_za
]Z[`}Š a ojauvaŠ! ‰c\ w g_c fZjw†adch! fZyZgZ]ade. ‰vwc ow[\d g\javZj\f-
Y Z[`az fZzZ`avZz [_ cZ gc\za cZg\- `}z — Zo\_ˆ g_z! Y_zZ\ yj_g`Z\ —
d_za, c Zo]\d\``}za u`_`ahza, cf]_- gZuezad\ ŠZ]Z|a\ f]Z[wvd}, _ w^ h fZ-
gad\ce, ’Zy [_cd, u_ fZj[`h. ‡ f]_u[`av zZyw g_z aŠ `\ acfZ]dade.
ow[\d [jadech `av_v `\ z\`e|\ `\[\ja. ‰Zd z\[. {wz_\d\, gc\ d_v f]ZcdZ c
Y_zZg_], g_]\`e\, †_l, f_Šj_g_, fZ[zZ- ”daz f]Z[wvdZz? ž, `\d! ’w[ed\ wg\]\`}:
cvZg`}l g\†\], cZg\d g_z [_ jˆoZge a gc\ †dZ zZ^`Z fZ[[\j_de — w^\ fZ[[\-
[\da|\v dZjcd\`evaŠ, wz`}Š a v]_cag}Š. j}g_ˆd, _ z\[ `_w†ajace fZ[[\j}g_de
x_Šj_g_ fZcfZcZocdgw\d, wg\]hˆ g_c. \\ g d\ g]\z\`_, vZy[_ gc\ f]Z[wvd}
xZjw†adch cwf\]f_Šj_g_, \cja g} o}ja `_dw]_je`}za a, ga[azZ, fZ”dZ-
`\ fZ^_j\\d\ [jh \\ f]Zfadva ca]Zf Zd zw aŠ `_ gc\Š `\ Šg_d_jZ. ‡ ]_u `\ Šg_-
ga|`\gZyZ g_]\`eh, \cja dZjevZ g} \yZ d_jZ, dZ a fZ[[\j}g_ja. Y_Š_] o}j fZ
f]_gaje`Z g_]ad\. ƒq vZf\lva, _ z\[ — w^\ ]wojh fZ d]a.

+   :     — /00       — 


 ,     . + 
     ,  "   
,           . )  #          #
 ,         ,    ,        -
     . )
  —         -
"  ,    ! "    —           -
 ", "  . (  ,       ,     !
Как топить
масло
З
`_\d\, h a`Zy[_ ]_ugj\v_ˆ c\oh
a cgZaŠ yZcd\l d_vaz ‘ZvwcZz.
‰ vZ`‚\ Zo\[_, vZy[_ gc\ w^\
kkm `_\jace a z\†d_ˆd Z dZz, v_v
o} g}o]_dech au-u_ cdZj_ a fZ-
cvZ]\\ u_`hde gZ` dZd vZg]av aja wˆd-
`}l wyZj `_ [ag_`\, h cd_gjˆ `_ cdZj
fZ[Zy]\dZ\ dZfj\`Z\ z_cjZ a vj_[w ]h-
[Zz Šj\o. • f]\[j_y_ˆ Zoz_v`wde Šj\o
g z_cjZ a fZf]ZoZg_de. “\, vdZ `_†a`_-
\d f]ZoZg_de, Zcd_`Zgadech `\ zZywd [Z
d\Š fZ], fZv_ `\ g}z_v_ˆd gc\ ojˆ[‚_.
• ”dZ c}d}\ jˆ[a! |aŠ z_y_ua`Zg. {_, au]\[v_ fZf_[_\d-
…Zy[_ z} gcd]\†_\zch g cj\[wˆal ch a `_cdZh\\ cjagZ†`Z\ z_cjZ, `Z
]_u, dZ ]_uyZgZ] Zohu_d\je`Z g`Zge gZu- \yZ ‚\`_ d_v g}cZv_, †dZ `\ v_^[}l ]\-
g]__\dch v dZzw ojˆ[‚w c dZfj\`}z |adch f\]\dZfade \yZ — g\[e Z`Z a d_v
z_cjZz — zZa []wueh ]_ccv_u}g_ˆd Z†\`e gvwc`Z!
z`\ Z dZz, †dZ Z`a acf}d_ja `_cdZh\\ €Z h `_[\ˆce, †dZ c]\[a g_c `_l[\dch
y_cd]Z`Zza†\cvZ\ fZd]hc\`a\. ‰\[e [Z ŠZde `\cvZjevZ †\jZg\v, vZdZ]}\ `\ fZ-
”dZyZ Z`a f]ZcdZ `\ u`_ja gvwc_ `_cdZh- ^_j\ˆd cg\^\yZ [Zz_|`\yZ cjagZ†`Z-
\yZ, ŠZ]Z|\yZ dZfj\`ZyZ z_cj_. Y\l- yZ z_cj_ a fZf]Zowˆd \yZ f\]\dZfade.
†_c h Zohc`ˆ, v_v ^\ d_v fZjw†ajZce. ‰Zd u_ ”daŠ jˆ[\l zZh [w|_ ]_[w\dch
š\ `\ d_v [_g`Z, vZy[_ `_ f]aj_gv_Š u_]_`\\!
gZ[ajZce `_cdZh\\ cjagZ†`Z\ z_cjZ, ‰Z-f\]g}Š, `\ `_[Z fwd_de dZfj\`Z\
\yZ f\]\d_fjag_ja, ja|e vZy[_ c]Zv z_cjZ a f]ZcdZ Z[`_^[} ]_cdZfj\``Z\.
Š]_`\`ah z_cj_ acd\v_j jaoZ Z`Z `_- ždZ h g_c f]\[wf]\^[_ˆ `_ dZd cjw†_l,
†a`_jZ fZ]dadech. Y†ad_jZce, †dZ f\]\- \cja g} ]\|ad\ vwfade o_`Z†vw c hvZ-
dZfv_ ŠZde v_v-dZ cf_c\d f]Z[wvd. €Z o} dZfj\`}z z_cjZz `_ ]}`v\. YvZ]\\
[\jZ g dZz, †dZ g dZz cjagZ†`Zz z_cj\ gc\yZ, \yZ f]ZcdZ Z[`_^[} fZ[Zy]\ja,
w^\ a c_z zZjZ†`}l ^a] z\`hjch gZ _ fZdZz [_ja \zw u_cd}de. €w [_, c]Zv
gvwc\ a fZ”dZzw, f\]\d_fjag_h z_cjZ, Š]_`\`ah Zd ”dZyZ wg\ja†ag_\dch, gvwc
zZ^`Z o}jZ [Zoadech ja|e wg\ja†\- z\`h\dch, `Z [Z `_cdZh\yZ dZfj\`ZyZ
`ah c]Zv_ yZ[`Zcda, _ ŠZ]Z|\yZ f]Z[wv- z_cj_ ”dZzw f]Z[wvdw gc\ \\ [_j\vZ.
d_ g ]\uwjed_d\ `\ fZjw†_jZce. ‰Z-gdZ]}Š, \cde `\vZdZ]_h ]_u`a‚_ a
‰c\, †dZ d\f\]e f]Z[_\dch fZ[ ga- z\^[w a`[alcvaz ya a d\z dZfj\`}z
[Zz dZfj\`ZyZ z_cj_, hgjh\dch, fZ cwda, z_cjZz, Z vZdZ]Zz z} yZgZ]az c\l†_c.
f]Z[wvdZz, auyZdZgj\``}z au ]_cda- x]Z\ gc\yZ [jh fZjw†\`ah ŠZ]Z-
d\je`}Š z_c\j, d_v †dZ Zo ”daŠ fZ[[\j- |\yZ dZfj\`ZyZ z_cj_ acfZjeuZg_de…
v_Š a yZgZ]ade `\ cdZad. —_uwz\\dch, `\ Zfhde ]acZg_]vw! €w †dZ fZ[\j_de, \cja
fZjw†adch ŠZ]Z|\yZ dZfj\`ZyZ z_cj_ f]Z‚\cc g}d_fjag_`ah z_cj_ [Zj^\`
a au fZ[[\jZv fZ[ z_cjZ cjagZ†`Z\, f]ZacŠZ[ade [ZjyZ\ g]\zh a f]a `\g}-
vZdZ]}za f\]\fZj`\`} f]aj_gva `_- cZvaŠ d\zf\]_dw]_Š? šcde \\ a z\[-
kkt

j\``Zg_]va — d_v gZd, ”da vwŠZ``}\ vZdZ]wˆ `_[Z o}jZ o} o\u vZ`‚_ c`a-
wcd]Zlcdg_ dZ^\ fZ[Zl[wd. ‡ †dZ [\j_de z_de. œaoZ f]a|jZce o} cza]adech c
d\z, w vZyZ `\d `a dZyZ, `a []wyZyZ? d\z, †dZ gch gZ[_ au z_cj_ g}f_]aj_ce,
šcde g}ŠZ[ a [jh `aŠ! ’\]ad\ [g\ _ †_cde o\jv_ f]ZcdZ g}cZŠj_ `_ [`\ a
v_cd]ˆja, d_va\, †dZo} Z[`_ gŠZ[a- [_^\ fZ[yZ]\j_, Zv]_cag cZg\]|\``Z
j_ g []wywˆ a `\ Zfwcv_j_ce `_ [`Z. `\`w^`}z u_f_ŠZz a ‚g\dZz gc\ z_cjZ.
‰ oZje|wˆ v_cd]ˆjˆ `_jag_ld\ `\- ‡ g ]\uwjed_d\ f]\[jZ^\``ZyZ z`Zˆ
z`ZyZ gZ[}, g z\`e|wˆ vj_[ad\ vajZ- z\dZ[_ aja g ]acZg_]v\, gvjˆ†\``Zl g
y]_zz_ [g_-d]a z_cj_ — c z\`e|az ]\^az fZ[Zy]\g_, f]a vZdZ]Zz g`wd]a
vZja†\cdgZz a cghu}g_dech `\ cdZad. fZ[[\]^ag_\dch d\zf\]_dw]_ ƒm–ƒq °Y,
šcja w g_c \cde d\]zZz\d], dZ ”dZ u_- z} fZjw†_\z †acd\l|al zZjZ†`}l
z\†_d\je`Z! xZdZzw †dZ ow[\d Z†\`e ^a] Zd[\je`Z, _ zZjZ†`}l o\jZv Zd-
ŠZ]Z|Z, \cja g} Zd]\ywja]w\d\ `_y]\g [\je`Z. Yjag_ld\ z_cjZ g []wywˆ fZ-
d_vaz Zo]_uZz, †dZo} z_cjZ az\jZ cw[w a \cja ^\j_\d\, dZ f]Zv_jad\ \yZ
d\zf\]_dw]w ƒ~–ƒp °Y, _ oZje|\ `\ `_- [Z d\zf\]_dw]} kmp °Y, dZ \cde vZy[_
y]\g_jZce. {jh ”dZyZ f]a[\dch `\cvZje- fZg\]Š`Zcde z_cj_ `_†`\d gZj`Zg_de-
vZ ]_u fZ[]\ywja]Zg_de `_y]\g, `Z ”dZ ch a fZhgadch dZ`\`eval [}zZv a yw-
gc\, †dZ `\ZoŠZ[azZ c[\j_de, a z_cjZ cdZl u_f_Š. €Z zZ^`Z ”dZyZ a `\ [\j_de,
fZcj\ ”dZyZ zZ^`Z Zcd_gade `_ `\- ZcZo\``Z \cja g} cZoa]_\d\ce Š]_`ade
cvZjevZ †_cZg. g_|\ dZfj\`Z\ z_cjZ g ŠZjZ[aje`av\.
€\ `_[Z c`az_de f\`w, `\ `_[Z fZz\- … cjZgw, fZcj\ Zcd}g_`ah o\jv_ c
|ag_de, `w^`Z f]ZcdZ fZ[Z^[_de, fZv_ `\vZdZ]}z vZja†\cdgZz z_cj_ `_ fZ-
zZjZ†`}l ^a] cZo\]\dch `_g\]Šw, _ g\]Š`Zcda \yZ dZ^\ `_[Z fZz\cdade g
g\ce zZjZ†`}l o\jZv, †dZ cZ[\]^_jch g ŠZjZ[aje`av. ‹_cjZ u_cd}`\d, cd_`\d
cjagZ†`Zz z_cj\, Zfwcdadch `_ [`Z. dg\][}z, _ o\jZv Zcd_`\dch \\ ^a[-
šcja o} z} [\j_ja dZ ^\ c_zZ\ f]Z- vaz. “Zy[_ z_cjZ `_[Z c`hde, f]Zz}de
cdZ `_ fjad\, dZ gZ[_, g vZdZ]Zl ]_cdgZ- fZ[ ŠZjZ[`Zl gZ[Zl a acfZjeuZg_de v_v
]\` zZjZ†`}l o\jZv, gcvaf_j_ o} a Zo}†`Z\ dZfj\`Z\ z_cjZ. ‡ dZd o\jZv
fwu}]a zZjZ†`ZyZ o\jv_ fZ[`az_jace u_z\†_d\je`Z fZg\[\d c\oh g g}f\†v\,
o} `_ fZg\]Š`Zcde z_cj_, Zo]_uwh f\`w, d_v †dZ a \yZ g}jag_de `\ cdZad!
$ - 
   :   :
     
– $      
       
     #  –   " # 
     –     #
      $  $  
 

"#$ G *2"  3'!2'

kkq —_[a d_vZl f]ao}ja `\vZdZ]}\ yZdZg} f]Zoj\z_, f_]_ jZ^\v c_Š_]_, s– ha‚ a
`\ dZ †dZ cZg\cde — z_zw ]Z[`wˆ f]Z- ]ˆzv_ gZ[va. ‰Zd c gZ[vZl… \cja guhde
[_de. Zo}†`wˆ gZ[vw, dZ g d\cd\ Z`_ c]_oZd_-
[`az cjZgZz, fZf]Zowld\ z\[. \d d_v, v_v `_[Z, `Z `\ Zcd_gad ŠZ]Z|\-
xZ[\]^ad\ \yZ gZ ]dw, fwcde ]_cd_\d. yZ fZcj\gvwcah. xZ”dZzw h o\]w gZ[vw
‰ yZ]j\ [Zj^`Z u_f\]|ade a g} f]Z- dwdZgwˆ, Zoj_[_ˆwˆ f]ahd`}z hyZ[-
cdZ `\z\[j\``Z [Zj^`} fZ†wgcdgZ- `}z gvwcZz. ‡ `\ o}jZ o} w z\`h dw-
g_de `\ f]ZcdZ cj_[Zcde gZ ]dw, `Z dZ, dZgva, d_v guhj o} h `\z`ZyZ ŠZ]Z|\yZ
†dZ c g_|az Z]y_`auzZz †dZ-dZ f]Zac- vZ`ehv_ — ^_jvZ, †dZ ja? bdZ d_v fade,
ŠZ[ad, †dZ d\fjZ ]_cŠZ[adch fZ gc\zw †dZ g d\cdZ g}jade — gc\ Z[`Z ”dZ [jh
d\jw, _ dZ a jZo fZv]}g_\dch acf_]a`Zl. `_c, ]_[a `_|\yZ ŠZ]Z|\yZ `_cd]Z\`ah!
šcja `\d h]vZ g}]_^\``}Š ‘]wvdZgZ- –l‚_ ]_u[\jade `_ o\jZv a ^\jdZv,
hyZ[`}Š `Zd g fZcj\gvwcaa (v_v g fZ- o\jZv guoade [Z wcdZl†agZl f\`}, [Z
]Z|v\ [jh f]ayZdZgj\`ah “cZvZg”), dZyZ cZcdZh`ah, Z vZdZ]Zz vZ`[ad\]}
\cja g} `\ Zw_\d\ hgcdg\``Z zhd- yZgZ]hd “^\cdva\ fava”.
`}l ŠZjZ[Zv, _ _]Zz_d `\ `_fZza`_\d ‡ cjagZ†`Z\ z_cjZ, c_Š_] a ^\jd-
g_z f_]‘ˆz\]`wˆ ‘_o]avw, dZ cvZ]\\ va cz\|ag_de gz\cd\ [Z d\Š fZ], fZv_
gc\yZ g} dZjevZ †dZ fZf]ZoZg_ja `_- cz\ce `\ fZo\j\\d. ‰\`†avZz, `avw[_
cdZhal z\[. › `_cdZhaŠ f]Z[wvdZg `\ dZ]Zfhce — gc\ fZjw†adch!
gvwc} a _]Zz_d} dZ`e|\, †\z w fZ[- ‰ ha†`Z-z_cjh`wˆ cz\ce fZcd\f\`-
[\jZv, — ”dZ Zo\\ f]_gajZ [jh Z†\`e `Z [Zo_gjhld\ gc\ a`y]\[a\`d} a u_-
z`ZyaŠ f]Z[wvdZg, az\ld\ g ga[w! z\cad\ d\cdZ c]\[`\l wf]wyZcda. š[g_
Y d\cdZz [jh `_|\yZ j_vZzcdg_ gc\ Z`Z `_†`\d Zdjaf_de Zd fZcw[} a cdZj_,
f]ZcdZ: ŠZ]Z|\\ zZjZvZ, zwv_ g}c|\- u_g\]`ad\ \yZ gZ gj_^`wˆ c_j‘\dvw a
yZ cZ]d_, \fZdv_ cZja, `_cdZh\\ cja- Zcd_ged\ Zd[ZŠ`wde za`wd d]a[‚_de-
gZ†`Z\ z_cjZ, vZdZ]Z\ [jh g_c w^\ `\ cZ]Zv.

/

kkp

“\cdZ ]_u[\jad\ `_ `\cvZjevZ vwcvZg,  \j_d\je`Z, †dZo} gZ g]\zh ^_]va


†dZo} v_^[}l vwcZv zZ^`Z o}jZ ]_c- d\zf\]_dw]_ z_cj_ o}j_ g ]_lZ`\ ks~ ¨,
v_d_de g jacd [a_z\d]Zz c_`daz\d]Zg dZy[_ vwcZ†va d\cd_, fZ^_]ag|ace [Z
t~–q~ a dZja`Zl zajaz\d]_ d]a. uZjZdacdZyZ ‚g\d_, `\ `_o\]wd z`ZyZ
€_]\^ed\ d\cdZ vZ]ZdvZl j_f|Zl, z_cj_, _ Zcd_`wdch j\yvaza, fwu}]a-
vg_[]_dav_za aja — v_v h, ]Zzoav_za. cd}za a _ff\dad`Z-_]Zz_d`}za.
šcja \cde g]\zh a wz\`a\, cv_d_ld\ au nZ†\|e `\ ŠZ†\|e, _ gZ g]\zh ^_]va
d\cd_ |_]ava ]_uz\]Zz c yZ]ZŠ. f]a[\dch [Zo_gjhde \\ z_cj_ — ŠZde
• dwd w^ `\ Zdvj_[}g_ld\: cvZ]\\ `\z`ZyZ, `Z d\cdZ gfad}g_\d \yZ g c\oh.
]_uZy]\g_ld\ y]_zz mp~ dZfj\`ZyZ z_c- €w a `a†\yZ — fwcde c\o\ gfad}g_\d,
j_ a zZ^\d\ [Zo_gade f]az\]`Z cd_v_` g\[e z_cjZ z} guhja `\ _o} v_vZ\, _
ŠZ]Z|\yZ ]_cdad\je`ZyZ. xZ[ ŠZ]Z|az ]ZcvZ|`Z\ dZfj\`Z\ a ŠZ]Z|\\ ]_cda-
h az\ˆ g ga[w z_cjZ aug\cd`ZyZ f]Zac- d\je`Z\! ‰vwc_ a u_f_Š_ d_vZ\ z_cjZ `\
ŠZ^[\`ah, az\ˆ\\ f]ahd`}l gvwc a acfZ]dad.
u_f_Š. —_uZy]\g_ld\ z_cjZ [Z k~–kƒ~ ¨ ]\Ša yZdZgaja? i]\‚va\ Z]\Ša
a `_†a`_ld\ ^_]ade vwcZ†va d\cd_ `\- jw†|\ f]Zv_jade `_ cwŠZl cvZgZ]Z[\
oZje|aza fZ]‚ahza. cd_g|\\ch d\cdZ [Z f]ahd`ZyZ u_f_Š_ a Š]wcd_ [_ a fZ-
jw†|\ `_v]}de gj_^`Zl c_j‘\dvZl, [_ ]\u_de aŠ `_ vwcZ†va f]az\]`Z dZyZ
a `\ `_[Z gc\ c]_uw ]_cv_d}g_de a ]\- ^\ ]_uz\]_, †dZ fZjw†ajZce ^_]\`Z\
u_de — g}cZŠ`\d, _ ”dZ `\ `_|_ u_[_†_! d\cdZ.
"#$ G *2"  3'!2'

kks šcja \cde `_cd]Z\`a\ |av_`wde, dZ \cja †_cde vwcZ†vZg d\cd_ Š]wcd`\d g
fZ†\zw o} `\ u_z\`ade y]\‚val Z]\Š ]wv_Š, yj_g`Z\, †dZo} gc\ cZ\[a`ajZce
‘acd_|v_za aja ŠZdh o} za`[_j\z? g \[a`Z\ ‚\jZ\. ‰}vj_[}g_ld\ yZ]vZl
• dZ a []wyZ\ cj\[w\d dZ^\ f]Zv_jade, aja ]Zg`}z cjZ\z `_ cz_u_``Z\ dZfj\-
`Z ‘acd_|va ]\u_de `\Zohu_d\je`Z. `}z z_cjZz ojˆ[Z a Zcd_ged\ Zcd}g_de
‰ z\[ cj\[w\d [Zo_gade c_Š_] a `_- a u_cd}g_de.
y]\de [Z fZj`ZyZ ]_cdgZ]\`ah c_Š_]_. x\]\[ fZ[_†\l fZ]\^ed\ vwcZ†v_-
“_v [\j_ˆd `\ ]_[a ”vZ`Zzaa, _ [jh za aja… fZ†\zw o} c]_uw `\ c‘Z]zZ-
dZyZ, †dZo}, Zcd}g_h, z\[ cvj\aj z\^- g_de gZd d_va\ fZ]‚aZ``}\ ‚aja`[]}?
[w cZoZl vwcZ†va d\cd_, a fZv]}j o} aŠ ‰Zuezad\ vZje‚_, vZdZ]}\ ]\cdZ]_`-
`\ jafvZl d\vw†\l z_ccZl, _ dg\][Zl `}\ fZg_]_ acfZjeuwˆd [jh g}vj_[va
yj_uw]eˆ, vZdZ]_h [Zj^`_ ]_cd_hde w^\ c_j_dZg aja y_]`a]Zg, cz_^ed\ aŠ au-
gZ ]dw, fZcj\ yjZdv_ †_h. `wd]a z_cjZz a `_oag_ld\ aŠ [ZfZj-
‡ fZv_ f\]\z\|ag_ld\ vwcZ†va Zo- `_ ]wv_za, c^az_h a cf]\ccZg}g_h cZ-
^_]\``ZyZ d\cd_ c z\[Zz, f\]\z\|a- [\]^azZ\. ˜_cd}`\d — wo\]ad\ vZje‚_,
g_ld\ f]hzZ ]wv_za, dZjevZ `\ u_ow[ed\ a gZd v_va\ _vvw]_d`}\ cdZjoava w g_c
aŠ czZ†ade ŠZjZ[`Zl gZ[Zl, †dZo} `\ fZjw†_dch!
Zo^\†ech. x]_g[_, gc\ yZ]_u[Z f]Z\, †\z g
Yz\|ag_ld\ vwcZ†va d\cd_, fZv]}- f_Šj_g\? ‡ z\^[w d\z f]Z[wvd} ac-
d}\ yj_uw]eˆ, c Z]\Š_za, c ‘acd_|v_za, fZjeuZg_jace ]Zg`Z d\ ^\ c_z}\! • d\-
_ \cja vdZ fZ^\j_\d, dZ fZ†\zw o} `\ cdZ gfad_jZ g c\oh †_cde z_cj_ a dZ†`Z
[Zo_gade `\z`ZyZ cwŠZ‘]wvdZg, `_f]a- d_v ^\ fZv]}dZ z\[ZgZ-c_Š_]`Zl vZ-
z\] auˆz? šcja auˆz g}cw|\` v_v cj\- ]Z†vZl, a Z]\Ša u[\ce d\o\ d\ ^\ c_z}\.
[w\d, az\\d f]ahd`}l gvwc, dZ \yZ vac- ‡ gvwc… gvwc ]_u`}l! d f\]\z\`} z\cd
ja`v_ dZjevZ wv]_cad yZdZgZ\ au[\ja\! cj_y_\z}Š auz\`ajch gvwc — gZd v_vZ\
Yf]\ccZg}g_ld\ gc\ ]wv_za, `\ o\[_, [\jZ!

/

kkr
—\‚\fdZg †_v-†_v_, `_g\]`Z\, cdZjevZ fa`y-fZ`y_, _ fZdZz Zoz_vag_ja g yZ]h-
^\, cvZjevZ d_d_]cvaŠ c\z\l, y[\ wz\ˆd †al z\[ a \ja.
ŠZ]Z|Z yZdZgade. xZ]Zl g\[wdch ^_]- {_ a \cde ja d_vZl `_]Z[, vZdZ]}l
va\ cfZ]} Z dZz, v_vZl ‘Z]z} [Zj^`} ZoZ|\jch o} o\u cj_[Zcd\l au ^_]\`ZyZ
o}de vwcZ†va d\cd_, Z dZz, zZ^`Z ja d\- aja u_f\†\``ZyZ d\cd_? ‰ œag_`\, `_-
cdZ [jh †_v-†_v_ `_]\u_de `Z^Zz aja f]az\], [\j_ˆd d\cdZ dZja`Zl †wde
gc\ `_[Z [\j_de ]wv_za, ]_cv_d}g_h dZj\ gZjZc_ a yZdZghd fZŠZ^a\ cj_[Z-
d\cdZ g ^ywd} aja |_]ava, `w^`_ ja g cda au `\yZ. ‹Za `\z\‚va\ o_ova ]\yw-
d\cd\ gZ[v_ a zZ^`Z ja [Zo_gade wvcwc jh]`Z o_jZg_ja z\`h v]\oje — ‘ayw]-
c cZ[Zl. `}za au[\jahza au d\cd_, vZdZ]Z\ f]a
“_d_]cvZ\ ojˆ[Z †_v-†_v ]_cf]Zcd]_- ^_]v\ ]_u[wg_jZce Zy]Zz`}za fwu}-
`ajZce [_j\vZ u_ f]\[\j} “_d_]cd_`_ — ]hza. •ja _‘y_`cval †\j_oaz — vZy[_
yZdZghd \yZ a fZ gc\l Y]\[`\l ‡uaa, a ^a[vZ\ d\cdZ cd]w\l g}fwcv_ˆd g yZ]h-
g …_u_Šcd_`\, a gfjZde [Z d\Š y]_`a‚, †\\ z_cjZ, u_v]w†ag_h \yZ g cfa]_ja, _
y[\ `_†a`_\dch ‚_]cdgZ f_Šj_g}. €Z fZdZz ”da cfa]_ja dZ†`Z d_v ^\ f]Zfa-
a g ˜_v_gv_ue\, g d\Š z\cd_Š, y[\ vZy[_- d}g_ˆd ca]ZfZz — zZ^`Z ja g Z[`Zl
dZ ^aja dw]va-z\cŠ\da`‚}, yZdZgaja v`ay\ ]_ccv_u_de ZoZ gc\z a †dZ-dZ `\
Z†\`e fZŠZ^\\ ojˆ[Z: d\cdZ, fZŠZ^\\ `_ wfwcdade? €\d, `\gZuzZ^`Z! xZ”dZzw
d\cdZ [jh fZ`†avZg, Zo^_]ag_ja vwcZ†- [_g_ld\ fZyZgZ]az Z yj_g`Zz, `_f]a-
v_za, ]_uz\]Zz a ‘Z]zZl c |_]av [jh z\] Z Š_jg\.
"#$ G *2"  3'!2'

km~ Yj_[v_h zZh! ‹_de gu[}Š_j_, †dZ `_`_ acfZjeuZ-


g_j_ z\`h d_vaz Zo]_uZz (`\d o} `_-
€\ f]a`hdZ g ‡u\]o_l[^_`\ yZgZ]ade f]hzwˆ cv_u_de, u_†\z ]\o\`v_ fZ[-
“ŠZ†w Š_jg}”. ‰\]`\\, cv_u_de-dZ zZ^`Z, c}j_de?) a |j_ g z_y_ua`. …Z`\†`Z,
`Z ”dZ f]az\d_ `\ŠZ]Z|_h, d_v v_v Š_j- cv]Zz`Zl w†ad\jecvZl u_]fj_d} `_ o_-
gw, v_v f]_gajZ, yZdZghd `\ dZjevZ `_ ow|va`} z_c|d_o} `\ Šg_d_jZ, `Z d\z
f]_u[`ava, `Z a g Zohu_d\je`Zz fZ]h[- ^\ g\†\]Zz `_`_ cZ cgZaza c\cd]_za
v\ `_ fZza`va. w^\ cw\daj_ce `_ vwŠ`\ gZv]wy v_cd]ˆ-
–, cZocdg\``Z yZgZ]h, dZ^\ wu`_j ja `_ fjad\.
gvwc Š_jg}, ja|e vZy[_ `_|_ o_ow|v_ ˜`_\d\, Zv_u}g_\dch, h u_fZz`aj,
f]a\u^_j_ g ¤\]y_`w g cvZ]o`}\ [jh v_v \\ yZdZgade, ”dw Š_jgw. ‰Zd g\[e —
`_|\l c\zea [`a. cf]_|ag_j w y_o_jja`cvZyZ Š_jg_†a
€_`_ (o_ow|v_) o}j_ ^\`a`_ ZcZ- _Šo_j_d-zw_jjaz_, v_v yZdZgade d_-
o_h, c Z†\`e `\f]Zcd}z Š_]_vd\]Zz a vwˆ Š_jgw, d_v Z`, wcj}|_g gZf]Zc,
hu}vZz, ZddZ†\``}z [Z Zcd]Zd} o]ad- Z^agajch a cd_j ]_ccv_u}g_de zZaz
g}. `_, `_f]az\], f]a z_d\]a Zo]__- cfwd`av_z:
j_ce vZ z`\: — ždZ ]_`e|\ `_ f]_u[`ava w `_c yZ-
— Yd_jav, cv_^a z_z\, †dZ `_[Z vw- dZgaja d_vwˆ Š_jgw! Y_z_h f]Zcd_h Š_j-
fade |\cde vajZy]_zz c_Š_]_, |\cde g_: d]a g\a yj_g`}\ — zwv_, c_Š_] a
vajZy]_zz cjagZ†`ZyZ z_cj_ a [\chde cjagZ†`Z\ z_cjZ.
vajZy]_zz zwva. “Zy[_ `_`_ f]ayZdZ- •, Zo]__hce vZ z`\, f]Z[Zj^aj:
gad Š_jgw. — ‹wvw fZ^_]a|e `_ cvZgZ]Z[\, †_-
—_uwz\\dch, h g f]\[gvw|\`aa Š_jg} cdZ fZz\|ag_h, [Z fZhgj\`ah Z]\ŠZgZ-
g\[]_za Zo]__jch v z_d\]a: yZ u_f_Š_, `Z cj\[a, †dZo} zwv_ `\ fZ[-
— ‹_z_, z_z_, `_`_ Š_jgw f]ayZdZ- yZ]\j_ a `\ auz\`aj_ce g ‚g\d\. xZdZz
gad! [Zo_ga|e v zwv\ ]_uZy]\dZ\ dZfj\`Z\
)  #  # 
/

z_cjZ. bdZo} z_cjZ ]_g`Zz\]`Z gfa- fZd\z`\de, \cja [h[h _Šo_j_d c_z kmk
d_jZce g zwvw, `_[Z fZcdZh``Z f\]\z\- dZjevZ †dZ yZgZ]aj Z dZz, †dZ zwvw ^_-
|ag_de a wo_gade ZyZ`e, †dZo} zwv_ `\ ]ade cj\[w\d d_v, †dZo} ‚g\d \\ `\ au-
auz\`aj_ cgZl ‚g\d — \\ ]_`Z. …Zy[_ z\`ajch? €w, [Zfwcdaz, [Zo_gaz g
z_cjZ gfad_\dch g zwvw a `\ ow[\d `a- zwvw dZfj\`Z\ z_cjZ, fZjw†_\z cg\djZ-
v_vaŠ vZzZ†vZg, [Zo_gjhˆd c_Š_]`}l ^\jd}l ‚g\d, †wde h]†\, †\z w u_z\-
ca]Zf. |_``ZyZ d\cd_, `Z vw[_ \\ cg\dj\\-dZ?
‰c\ f]_gaje`Z ]_ccv_u_j _Šo_j_d- “ohu_d\je`Z `_[Z fZf]ZoZg_de f]a-
Š_jg_†a, \\ Z` `\ [ZyZgZ]aj [Z vZ`‚_, yZdZgade Š_jgw, v_v w `_`}”, — ]\|aj
_ h w^\ gc\ gcfZz`aj, v_v f\]\[ yj_u_- h, `Z ZdjZ^aj ”dZ [\jZ [Z Z†\]\[`Zl yZ-
za gcd_jZ, v_v yZdZgaja zZh o_ov_ a \\ [Zga`} fZza`Zv fZ Zd‚w.
c\cd]} Š_jgw `_ d\ fZza`va… “ZjevZ …_v ^\ f]_gaje`Z yZdZgade Š_jgw,
Z`a `\ ca]Zf [Zo_gjhja v zwv\, _ f]Z- \cja g\u[\ \\ yZdZghd fZ-]_u`Zzw? —_u-
cdZl c_Š_]-f\cZv. ‡ v c_Š_]w-f\cvw fZ[- `}\ ]\yaZ`}, ]_u`}\ c\zea — ]_u`}\
jag_ja vafh\\ zZjZvZ, fZcd\f\``Z, a ]\‚\fd}.
[Zoag_hce d\vw†\l, v_v w d\cd_, vZ`ca- ‰Z`, g [_j\vZz Zd ‡u\]o_l[^_`_
cd\`‚aa a ]_cdgZ]\`ah c_Š_]_. ›uo\vacd_`\ dZ^\ yZdZghd Š_jg_ld_],
‡ _Šo_j_d-zw_jjaz cv_u_j f]Z zZ- ]Z[cdg\``Z\ Š_jg\ ojˆ[Z, a dZ^\, vcd_-
jZvZ: da, `\f]\z\``Z `_ fZza`va. “_v g ›uo\-
— šcja ŠZ†\|e, †dZo} w Š_jg} ‚g\d vacd_`\ [jh auyZdZgj\`ah ”dZyZ j_vZz-
cg\dj\\ cd_j, dZy[_ `_[Z [Zo_gade fZj- cdg_, f]aug_``ZyZ fZ[cj_cdade yZ]\†e
cd_v_`_ aja cd_v_` zZjZv_, — ga[azZ wd]_d}, acfZjeuwˆd… vw][ˆ†`}l ^a].
az\h g ga[w f]ZfZ]‚aˆ `_ vajZy]_zz {_, `\ w[agjhld\ce, g}d_fjag_ˆd
zwva. vw][ˆ†`}l ^a], [Zo_gjhˆd g `\yZ
YdZf, cdZf, cdZf! …_v ”dZ — ‚g\d zwvw — g ]_cv_j\``Zz ^a]\ zwv_
cg\dj\\ cd_j? ‡ Zd†\yZ Z` [Zj^\` o}j Z†\`e o}cd]Z z\`h\d ‚g\d `_ [ZgZje`Z

*    —    ? )  ,           -


" ,   ,      #        . +     -
! —  "    ,   "        . 1 
       . 2   ,      . 3  #  
  ? +    —      "   ,    .
% 
  
   " # 
    
   
   
  #   
" :   ,   

"#$ G *2"  3'!2'

kmm d\z`}l, g `\\ [Zo_gjhˆd c_Š_] a gZ[w — d\†\`a\ au f]Zcd}Š a Zo}†`}Š f]Z-
gc\ f]ZacŠZ[ad [ZgZje`Z o}cd]Z, gc\ g [wvdZg gc\ wcajag_ˆaŠch `\Zo}†`Z-
Z[`Zz v_u_`\, f]\[\je`Z j_vZ`a†`Z a f]ahd`}Š u_f_ŠZg a ]Z^[\`a\ v_vZl-dZ
]_‚aZ`_je`Z, v_v gch wuo\vcv_h vwŠ`h. Z†\`e f]ZcdZl, `Z f]\[\je`Z cg\djZl
n_jg_ld_] yZdZghd [ZgZje`Z ^a[vaz, fZ [wŠw a j\yvZcda cj_cda wcfZv_ag_\d
Z` az\\d vZ`cacd\`‚aˆ ŠZ]Z|\l cz\- [w|w acf}d}g_ˆaŠ yZ]\. iZ]\ v_v o}
d_`}, \[hd \yZ, Zoz_vag_h vwcZ†va j\- ZdZ[gay_\dch, a d} `_†a`_\|e fZ`a-
f\|va g fa_jw c Š_jg_ld_]Zz a u_fag_h z_de, †dZ ^au`e o\cvZ`\†`_ a Z[`Z hg-
†_\z. —h[Zz zZ^\d cdZhde a z\[, a v_l- jh\dch f]Z[Zj^\`a\z []wyZyZ, a dZjevZ
z_v (ywcd}\ cj_[va\ cjagva), vZdZ]}\ †dZ w|\[|al †\jZg\v f]ZcdZ wcdwfaj
\[hd d_vaz ^\ cfZcZoZz, `Z v_^[}l z\cdZ d\o\ a dgZaz [\dhz [jh f]Z[Zj-
Zohu_d\je`Z [Zj^\` c\cde ŠZde vwcZ- ^\`ah ^au`a `_ u\zj\, [jh f]Z[Zj^\-
†\v Šj\o_ c Š_jg_ld_]Zz — d_vZg Zo}- `ah \yZ [\j aja `_†_j_ `Zg}Š. œZ^v_
†_l. Š_jg}, yjZdZv †_h — a f\†_je cd_`Zgad-
‡ z} g\[e u`_\z, Zdvw[_ fZ|j_ d]_- ch cg\dj\\.
[a‚ah d_vZl Š_jg} a v_vaza o}ja fwda
]_cf]Zcd]_`\`ah ”dZl vwja`_]`Zl
a[\a. ‰\[e ”dZ gc\ Zd cwz_jhv_, Z vZdZ-
n_jg_ zZ\l
]Zz z} ]_ccw^[_ja \\ g yj_g\ Z Šj\- o_ow|va Y\[aya-`_`}
o\! xZ`hd`Z, †dZ fZhgj\`a\ Š_jg} aja
Š_jg_ld_]_, v_v wf]Z\``ZyZ g_]a_`d_ H'*"  %'$ $  $-
cwz_jhv_, cghu_`Z c vwjedZz fZza`Zg\- < $++ +%$  !55 -
`ah wcZf|aŠ, a, f]au`_dech, ”dw ‘w`v-  <!,  %%5  $+
‚aˆ d_v_h Š_jg_ g}fZj`h\d u_z\†_d\je- '<+, >'&  <+5 E +%$.
`Z. ‹\[ad_dag`Z\ fZz\|ag_`a\ zwva, D '* +%$ '" 6CC +-
g}d_fjag_`a\ z_cj_, fZcd\f\``Z\ ac-  ! +  <+#" +%$%.
0 
   $ )- ( 
/

/ R ++ $ +%$  +% ! *- * '&" ++"&+,  +*, * kmt
8 +* '" >" >  !" %  $" 
*$ $+  %8 *$% $- " !, I" <+#5. -
.  ++% +8, $ !-   $$ & ' !, 
 %># $+,  +* !- +*   + %>",
"  '< !E .  !*" !+#" %. D$
O$*  R ++ +* '" "$ < +  &5"5 +,
 % !$ $&  <+&   .
+5%'$ E$ , , $$ 5 %'- W & # ! ! !+% !%,
5, $% &  R "  +-  '"  +" +%$  + .
55.   $$ +%$  + ! O"$  +"  %, > !
++ ++  '%% !+#&, + — ! %, >& +>& *
'" $ + ' , ' !- '< $$-' . 9%$ !%# !
& !. '*. O$ > 5"5 %
H$  !  $<", >    >+. R+% + '5
+* '&"  %& —  6CC  +" +$. 9$ %># !"
++  '" 2CC +-  $!5  *"  ++ ++ .
 &  $!5"  (C)–(C= °F,   9$ +* %   $, '-
%   ++,  <"+ >" +, >'& "  5, 
!, $!   $%, !*+  !+", >  +%$  !&"
$ +% *$%  !+ : *& !- % < +$! R+% '5" 
5%"5 $ .  !!  $ * !! !-
H$ R ! #$+ 5> 5 &#" +!%%, !5 !+#-
+%$, +%  " &"  C–3 °F, 5, !"  &5 < + +.
 * * +" !+ $%8 A 5 %8 %  5>
* +!%%,  '&",  - !%, >'&   !   !-
& * 

. 
/

5 & <!, $&, !+8, cvZz hu}v\, g\[e Z gvwc`Zz zZywd cv_- kmp
<8  "$ ,   + '*- u_de “cj_[vZ”, [_^\ vZy[_ \[_ a gZgc\ `\
5 +%$  ! +. *- cj_[v_h.
 +%  $,  $&  '% • `\ cjw†_l`Z cjZg_ “cj_[vZ” a
!", !" %$. “gvwc`Z” `_ ‰ZcdZv\ a[wd ]wv_ Zo ]wvw —
O$5  !%>5 +5$, $$ - g\[e [jh ‰ZcdZv_ Š_]_vd\]`} h]va\
,  ! $+ +!%  '&- v]_cva, u_f]\[\je`}\ †wgcdg_ a vZ`-
 5%> , ', &!>. ‚\`d]a]Zg_``}\ gvwc} a _]Zz_d}.
F  $   * $- ˜[\ce f]a]Z[_ c_z_ [_]ad z`Z^\cdgZ
<"5. cj_[Zcd\l — fZ[ŠZ[a, c]}g_l c [\]\g_
a \|e. Yj_[Zv [Z jafvZcda fZcf\g|al
ga`Zy]_[, a`^a] a f\]cava d\vwd `\ cZ-
 Š_jg\ gZZo\ vZz, _ owvg_je`Z ca]ZfZz, [_ gc\Š cj_[-
vaŠ fjZ[Zg a `\ f\]\†acja|e. • g\[e
– u`_ˆ, †dZ c\l†_c \[g_ ja `\ v_^[}l z`ZyZ gc\yZ ]Z^[_\d u\zjh, w]Z^_l
au g_c yZdZg cŠg_dade z\`h u_ ]wv_g a c\cde `\ wcf\\|e, \cja `\ u_yZdZgade.
cf]Zcade: “‡ v_v ^\ d_ Š_jg_, au z_y_- ‹`Zya\ fjZ[} zZ^`Z u_cw|ade `_
ua`_, d_, †dZ au fZ[cZj`\†`}Š c\z\†\v uazw, ”dZ f]ZcdZ\ a j_vZ`a†`Z\ ]\|\-
aja vw`^wd_, Š]wcdh_h, ]_cc}f†_d_h, `a\. €Z \cde a []wyZl cfZcZo — g_]\`eh
j\yv_h a `\Zo}†_l`Z c}d`_h?” a o\vz\u}. Y g_]\`e\z gc\ fZ`hd`Z, ”dZ
€w, ”dZ cZgc\z []wy_h acdZ]ah! ŠZ]Z|Z u`_vZzZ\ f]_vda†\cva v_^[Zzw
€_[Z fZ`az_de, †dZ `_ ‰ZcdZv\ c†a- j_vZzcdgZ. ‡ o\vz\u?
d_jZce gvwc`}z. ‰Zd fZ-wuo\vcva, vZy[_ ›f_]\``}l [Z ywcdZd} cZv, gZd †dZ
ŠZdhd cv_u_de “gvwc`Z”, †_cdZ yZgZ]hd d_vZ\ o\vz\u. x]ayZdZgade \yZ zZ^`Z
“|a]a`” — “cj_[vZ”. “Yj_[vZ” a “gvwc- au v_vaŠ wyZ[`Z ‘]wvdZg a hyZ[ — Zd _]-
`Z” — \[g_ ja `\ ca`Z`az} g wuo\v- owu_ [Z y]_`_d_. …cd_da, c o\vz\uZz au
"#$ G *2"  3'!2'

kms y]_`_d_ z`Zya\ u`_vZz} ŠZ]Z|Z — gZd †dZo} \yZ fZg\uja v_]_g_`} a Z` `_†_j
Z`, fZgcˆ[w, `_ gc\Š f]aj_gv_Š, ŠZ]Z|Z ]_cf]Zcd]_`hdech fZ cg\dw. xZ gc\zw
u`_vZz}l `_]-|_]_o. €w [_, `_u}g_ˆd g}ŠZ[ad, †dZ f\]gwˆ Š_jgw yZdZgaja
a`_†\, _ fZ cwda o\vz\u a \cde. o\u c_Š_]_.
xZ†\zw h Zdgj\vch Zd `_|aŠ ]_c- …Z]`a Š_jg} `_[Z acv_de g f]Z-
cw^[\`al `_ o\vz\u? {_ fZdZzw, †dZ ‚g\d_ˆaŠ yZ]Z[_Š oj_yZcjZg\``ZyZ
c\yZ[`h [jh f]ayZdZgj\`ah Š_jg} g •]_`_, g cZc\[`\z ’_y[_[\, g []wyaŠ
oZje|a`cdg\ cjw†_\g acfZjeuw\dch gZcdZ†`}Š yZ]Z[_Š, y[\ ^au`e vZy[_-dZ
dZjevZ c_Š_]. €Z `\w^dZ [Z fZhgj\`ah o}j_ d_v f]agZje`_, †dZ f]a[gZ]`}\
c_Š_]_ `\ yZdZgaja Š_jgw — d_vZ\ fZ- [_ oZy_d}\ vwf‚} c w[ZgZjecdga\z
fwjh]`Z\ g Zy]Zz`Zz ]\yaZ`\ j_vZz- Zfj_†ag_ja wcjwya vZ`[ad\]Zg, †ea
cdgZ? €\ zZ^\d o}de d_vZyZ, g\[e, cw[h j_gva vZ`vw]a]Zg_ja z\^[w cZoZl `_
fZ gc\zw, Š_jg_ ]_cf]Zcd]_`hj_ce fZ u_jad}Š cZj`‚\z o_u_]_Š.
za]w `\ g g\v a`‘Z]z_‚aZ``}Š d\Š- €\aug\cd`Z, vdZ f\]g}z [Zy_[_j-
`ZjZyal, _ gZ g]\z\`_, vZy[_ v_]_g_`} ch [Zo_gade g ]_cd\]d}l vw`^wd aja
f]a`Zcaja c`_†_j_ cjwŠa, fZdZz “fZ- Z]\Ša c_Š_]`}l ca]Zf, gcf\`ade \yZ a
f]ZoZg_de”, fZdZz g}g\[_``}l ]\- [_de \zw v]acd_jjauZg_dech. €Z v_^-
‚\fd, `w^[_ˆalch g wdZ†`\`ahŠ a [}l Š_jg_†a ]\g`Zcd`Z ZŠ]_`hj f]a-
v_va\-dZ a`y]\[a\`d}, o\u vZdZ]}Š `\ [wz_``}\ az c_zaz aja fZjw†\``}\
ZoZldace. fZ `_cj\[cdgw d\Š`ZjZyaa Zd vZ`vw-
• v_v ^\ yZdZgaja Š_jgw [Z fZhgj\- ]\`dZg.
`ah f]agZu`ZyZ au •`[aa c_Š_]_ — Zd- €Z wd_a|e ja |ajZ g z\|v\? …dZ-
`Zcad\je`Z †acdZl c_Š_]Zu} g}f_]\`- dZ wu`_j, †dZ [jh gcf\`ag_`ah c_Š_]_
`Zl au cZv_ ZcZoZyZ d]Zcd`av_? ‰\[e c_- wfZd]\ojh\dch z}je`}l vZ]\`e, vdZ-
Š_]w `_[Z o}jZ `\ f]ZcdZ fZhgadech, `Z dZ fZf]ZoZg_j f]ayZdZgade Š_jgw cZ
a cd_de [Zcd_dZ†`Z ‚\`az}z dZg_]Zz, guoad}z ha†`}z o\jvZz, a Š_jg_ cd_-

/

km

j_ ]_cf]Zcd]_`hdech fZ gc\zw ]\yaZ`w,


ga[Zauz\`hhce a f]aZo]\d_h gc\ `Z-
…ZcŠ_jg_
g}\ ‘Z]z}, _]Zz_d}, gvwc} a a`y]\- _Šo_j_d-zw_jjaz_
[a\`d}.
‡ d\f\]e… d\f\]e d_v_h cwz_dZ|`_h › j\c_ `_ Zfw|v\, g cd_]\`evZl auow|v\,
^au`e fZ|j_, †dZ ZŠ]_`hde c\v]\d} uazZl a j\dZz Š]_`ad cgZl `\Šad]}l
f]ayZdZgj\`ah Š_jg} f]ZcdZ o\ccz}c- cv_]o [h[h _Šo_j_d. €Z ”dZ Z` dZjevZ
j\``Z! {_^\ \cja a fZ[\jadech gc\za fZ `Z†_z Š]_`ad f\†vw, f_]w d_uZg, c_-
c\v]\d_za, \\ fZacv_de `_[Z ow[\d zZg_], cdZj [_ `\cvZjevZ cd_]\`evaŠ
jˆ[\l, vZdZ]}\ ]\|_d guhdech u_ d_- †_|\v. ‡ fZ wd]_z Z` g}`Zcad cgZ\ [Z-
vZl d]w[. ‰Zd fZczZd]ad\, v_v yZdZgad o]Z `_ cg\^al gZu[wŠ, `_jag_\d g c_-
Š_jgw cd_]\l|al Š_jg_†a _u\]o_l[- zZg_] gZ[w au ]w†eh, ]_ugZ[ad ZyZ`e a
^_`cvZyZ yZ]Z[_ i_o_jj} _Šo_j_d- ^[\d, vZy[_ g`wv f]a`\c\d c_Š_]. šzw,
zw_jjaz. gZZo\-dZ, `a†\yZ oZje|\ fZvwf_de

# 

   
   / #   
  # $  

$  
½ . .      

1 * 
2 *  -  
/

a `\ `_[Z, v]Zz\ c_Š_]_. › `\yZ \cde u_- —  !" '5<" ! —  !- kmr
f_c y]\‚vaŠ Z]\ŠZg, cZo]_``}Š g Z]\ŠZ- $% +*% +, + ' <%+5.
gZl ]Z\, u[\ce, `\fZ[_j\vw. ‰ i_o_jj\ P, $ > +, $$  I -
u`_\|e, v_va\ Z]\Ša gvwc`}\ ]_cdwd? "  5? & $%& 5E?
“ZjevZ ”da Z]\Ša g\†\]Zz, vZy[_ [\j_de / <' $ <'! P R $%& 5
ow[\d `\†\yZ, `_[Z fZvZjZde, u_yZdZ- %-8, %-8, <+8 8, >-
gade `_ wd]Z. “Zy[_ wd]Zz `\ ow[\d fZ†- 5>$ 5, < $88,  $#$
da `av_vaŠ u_oZd. ' %5,  +,  5E —  
+ %, > !+ !+.
A% $$ + <'& % !& >? O"$ !$  !*+  !>$%,
H <, >  >& $++ - !%" <85.
 +% !'5   !- F  <, >& $ & 5-
>$ + $&. P,  !- > +", + $&, <+-
$ —  +& <! O$ < R !'- # , !$ !%"   . 1$
+? F %$ !,  +5 $  "  8,  R% '"#%8
 $>5 —  ,  !$$. !%    <'".
: >& $ 5> & — R — 4#",   R% !% "$ '$!
>, <'? / +,  . O"- F8 $$ %!   ", +-
$ >   <'&" <". H-  * $$  * !!". W
<+% %* $@! N'-+%+, !!,  > &+&", # &-
N'-> <   — #%- +&"  ++ !", >'& >
$ , 33  <  !& +5  ". ! >-'%" *,
 $*& "  %. / !"  '$  <'"85 $$ .
 >%% '5 ! <&+ >- — P  %* $$ >$,  %-
$+, ! !&&+  !'&+ " * ',  $: >$, >,
&. P, !"  $  : !5" +%, !5" +%… P >  +-
"#$ G *2"  3'!2'

kt~ #", R !? P !'#", $, !+#" , !5 !$
!%" $!  <%,  + <5, ! %, ! %+, ! $+ —  $ $
!% < !, !", >'& ! , <% .
5%> '&, <'% $%!&+ !%<&"- & !? P '$! O"$ 
$+. " <%, >  !!'". -
P"#  + !:  " +,  >5 ? A%  >, >
&" !%, !* >+ +#"  !$ $*& "    * -
 '$+. /" "<5 '$ <%  5- #"? T%># !" >,  #-
> $" — 5! $+  5> !,  !+ %* '-
H& !%$ !!,   5" " '$  !+#",  !-
"   %8 % <$  - +#".
!+,    &". P* ', P  !+#". OE"
 !+#" !, >'&  ,  +%! / > —  &5> < < R
$ <$   $<- E" +% #"  $ -
5. D$  !+  <+##"? / * !$.

/

1$ * <" ! !% - …_v_h jafv_h… ktk


+, '8 +. F+"
!  '$ * " '5, $$ • Zd Š_jg} [Z Z[`Zl au g\]|a` gZcdZ†-
'%+. : !" I <  !&#%8 `ZyZ vZ`[ad\]cvZyZ acvwccdg_ — `wya
!>$%, $ !"  !+#" Zcd_g_jch ja|e Z[a` |_y. ždZd |_y —
!5",  <'&"! a`g\]da]Zg_``}l ca]Zf.
/ !" ! A *, $  €_ c_zZz [\j\ _Šo_j_d-zw_jjaz
,   $++. J <+#" w^\ fZv_u_j `_z, v_v yZdZgadch a`g\]-
  !'#+  5> !& !, da]Zg_``}l ca]Zf. ‰ c_Š_] a gZ[w [Z-
+ !", >'& $* o_gjh\dch jazZ``_h vacjZd_ — gZd a
5&#$ $<"  R $, 5%- gc\, `a†\yZ oZje|\, `av_vaŠ c\v]\dZg.
> '>$. {Zo_gaj jazZ``wˆ vacjZdw a yZdZge
O5*? P,  %*! A%* , ca]Zf, [Zg\[a \yZ [Z cZcdZh`ah dZ`vZl
%* %!, >", '< - `ada (d\zf\]_dw]} k~–k~ƒ °Y) a g_]a
'&  8' $ 85+ *  '". f]a ”dZl d\zf\]_dw]\ mp–t~ za`wd, fZ-
A, !5+ $  !#" — I 5>5, cd\f\``Z fZ`a^_h `_y]\g (v_v ŠZ]Z|Z
* %$+  !#"! A, !$ - ”dZ wz\ˆd [\j_de cyZ]_ˆa\ []Zg_!).
5>5, !$ I 55, %$  %8 Ya]Zf, vZdZ]}l fZjw†adch g ]\uwjed_d\,
% '+$, <"+ $+$ &, '+- `\ ow[\d u_cd}g_de, [_^\ Zcd}g_h, fZ-
   %*  &%8 !$ @- cvZjevw c_Š_]Zu_ g ]\uwjed_d\ ]\_v‚aa c
+%, !%" <&  <. jazZ``Zl vacjZdZl †_cda†`Z ]_c\fa-
: < — ', < $% >#"! j_ce `_ ‘]wvdZuw a yjˆvZuw, _ yjˆvZu_
M>#" —  1$%, >#",  9$%, - c_z_ `\ cvjZ``_ v v]acd_jjau_‚aa a `\
>#" — <" !$+ !%'  +- [_\d v]acd_jjauZg_dech c_Š_]Zu\.
$ $%>$  !#"  >+! €_ c_zZz [\j\ zZ^`Z cg_]ade a
 <, &$. Zo}†`}l c_Š_]`}l ca]Zf, o\u jazZ`-
&'
  
    

 $   
   
  #0 ! #   "
 $  
   !  : 1  +,  $ # # 
   1    
" :   ,   

"#$ G *2"  3'!2'

ktm `Zl vacjZd}, `Z c [Zo_gj\`a\z yjˆ- +!%& (2C °F. W %   +-
vZu} a fZjw†ade g ]\uwjed_d\ ca]Zf, +,  $+ 5  !%" %-
vZdZ]}l `\ ow[\d v]acd_jjauZg_dech * $ !+ +  -
[_^\ f]a Z†\`e z_jZz cZ[\]^_`aa  !&, %'" $%8  .
gj_ya — k~–km¦, _ az\``Z ”dZyZ `_z :  6CC ++  '+ +-
a `_[Z [Zcda†e, vZy[_ z} ŠZdaz f]a-  $&  $>$ *, $ &
yZdZgade `wyw. ‹Z^`Z [Zo_gade ja-  $ 8$<&. %"   !% R
zZ``Zl vacjZd} oZje|\ `Z]z} a, `\   !>&+ <+,   '-
[Z^a[_hce, fZv_ gch vacjZd_ gcdwfad g *" < +  !$%  ,   !
]\_v‚aˆ c c_Š_]ZuZl, `\ld]_jauZg_de  +<,  !8 <>& -
\\ ]_cdgZ]Zz cZ[} — dZy[_ ca]Zf fZ- & 5 $. U, !+, $
jw†adch gcf\`\``}z. €Z [jh f]ayZdZg- '%* $%8 $%  P+-
j\`ah `_|\l `wya z} fZl[\z []wyaz $+ &$. D$5 8$< !-
fwd\z. 5   %, !<>, 'E-
 !, !>  '8I <!-
A%% +* " < %  - +. A  %   <+* $%!"
! — +  . / + %* 8$<%, '"   >%" '"#
*5  " '"#+ $>- + $& — " > *$,
 @%$<  8$<,   <& R '% ", "$   -
+ + +. ++ R  +  !'5  6CC ++,  =CC. -
!%%8  % . R+% $ " !  !%,   $!-
++% !% +& '5<" !'- 5, *" 5   -
+ & !, !>+  $> %%  $+ '<+, >'&
!+  $ %+. !  %   +5 E, — $!"
+ 2CC ++ + !+  * ! +!% (C)–(C= °F +-
"5 "  '%+ "  % 0C–03.
1  #  #… 
/

 R +* !'"  "$ +& ! &, >- ktt
, !5 !+#5 !,   +#"   5>& '$. A
+!%%  (3C °F. F! ! R+ <5" 5%8 !>$%  !+#-
<%  !' E  $- ", !+ !5 !$ ! %
E8 * +, $$+  '& !  $+ !%&. $"$% +!%
$+ +!%. 9#" * - + ! '% * 6C °F, 5>&
5I5 ! '+, !+% > ! '$  *$%8 $E8, >
+  <%I5 % !%& <+- !< + !" 
55 $$E5  " $, > % $ ! !%.  R +* '5"
  ! !5  !' $% &#  )C–=C °F & !. O$
** . : + '+, >- $$  '% " 5>+, R -
'& ! #" <+ E  +&   '% > 5 , >'&
!' $& +. !%<&"$ <%, <$8>&  ! 5>-
F+ !  5  !*  '$, !%> !%8 '>$% —
 +5  + !+#",  - " '$ 5.
5 <%" % $, %    !- J !"  "  !+-
,  " !", >'& 5 #", > $ *, $$ R !$< +
+ ! & +. N'-+%+. A !$"$% %  -
/<'  5>& '$, '"  ! '% +"#, !+#" !-
*$   !* <'"  5 +% (3–0C. A '"5, >'& %
! 5 . P*",  5, , >+ %I +-
$ +& ! & !+  $,  $"$ %I . /<5, $$
3C–6C °F. O"$    !"E+, % $  *$.
>'& !"  +!%%,  I%!- A% $ R+% ++% & %
 !%%, !+% > ! * ! $  $,  R <>, > + %
+!% '** $>$ !"E. D$ !!"5. J>  > ",
"#$ G *2"  3'!2'

ktq  %  !   , >'& +- 5>&+ '$+  +& !. D$-
#"  %% . !E, !+ $+  %#%8
P, . : $$? P $$ & 8'- +%8 E%, 5 '& <+  +
! O"$  <'%"  !$", -  !%&  ' '&   * ++.
"  +&+  $%&+. U <5 H$  < +& &
@#$, +"  E$  !- ++ %!  ++ $E.
+  & !!E5. :  %  H % <5" !% 
" #, $>& %@%$&,  !%>#5 % — ++ )CC.
&%#&, $$ !* —  % J !+ "$ * %@%$. /+-
%$ ! !   —   &+- #"   %@%$&  <%8I%8
<& "&+ ++ 5 !- !5+  < +% !. 9*,
5 '$   ,  !>+% '& $>, + !" %%,  -
   '"  %%? D%% 5 !< *, >'&  !*>" ,  5 R-
 B–6 >,    +$$  !5"  !5  I" !-
<8+  $$ ". +#". A %># !"5 %!"
A & +* !'" + +#" — !* %, !",
  %@%$ 5 % ! #- >'& % '$ $*& #$,
+% $%% —  E%$  $#"8. A + $*%8 <8+$%.
<5, # >" %@%$&  $- O!" +> %$ , <"+-
$  " *&   '&+  %+5 %$+ $+$ %,  ,
++. W '& 5 < !" % %!, '+ $$ %  <-
+"& +,  5 !$ '& 2–B * …  <" !'+!
 !&,  "$ +"& , T!! +, % !! U <-
!+% > + "$ +"& *   !", !$&& !I
   '  +& + +- !$. O$ ! %!'+ <+%>-
5, <+ '&   ' <%  < " R% !$% +". O"$ +$&+
ktp
1  #  #… 
/

%$+ — > $$. D @" — * caj vwcZ†\v, a dwd ^\ fZhgjh\dch fw- kt
!. U - !>, > +* !- y_ˆ_h z}cje, †dZ ”d_ z_cc_ `_ghu`\d
*" %%  +%$%. A R !5 5 — g uwo_Š, `Z `\d! €a†\yZ fZ[Zo`ZyZ! `_
$+% !5 $% & +%$? H'&- f]ZcdZ d_\d gZ ]dw, f]\v]_c`Z ^w\dch,
!" !%% + <+& ? 9- Z]\Ša f]ahd`Z Š]wcdhd a gc\ gz\cd\ g}-
* '&", R &, "$  +"  yjh[ad v_v a[\_je`_h cj_[Zcde v †_ˆ.
%, > *  ! *5,  " €Z gZd \\ f\]g}l vwcZ†\v `wya w d\oh
<+*5, % 5 +@. gZ ]dw, ŠZ†\dch \\ yjZdZv †_h, _ dwd…
H +,  I%+ >. ”dZ dg\][Z\ d\jZ f]hzZ g ]wv_Š z\[-
/ #"  < "$, $- j\``Z, `\u_z\d`Z yj_uw, f]\[_d\jecva
#"  $% , !$   %! !- d\†\d fZ f_je‚_z, a \yZ `_[Z `\u_z\[-
>"  !!%" $ $, <$+  %- jad\je`Z [Z\cde aja gfZ]w w^\ acv_de
&+ *5+ !$+ %'#" gj_^`wˆ c_j‘\dvw, `Z ]wv_-dZ c`Zg_
 !$,  !+  $%'$. A*+ %% c_z_, `\gZje`Z w^\, fZdh`wj_ce v d_]\-
 !*#" —  ! * $<" jZ†v\ u_ `Zg}z vwcZ†vZz!
,  %5, 5<$5, $$ +,  ‡ f]Zj\^ad `wy_ `_ d_]\jv\ `\cvZje-
% & — "$ !$+. vZ †_cZg, d_v c`Zg_ cZo\]\dch g vZzZv,
J +  $%  !". `_[Z c`Zg_ ZdZ]g_de \\ Zd fZcw[}, fZ-
H! %+! A%%  &$&" jZ^ade `_ [Zcvw a c f]ahd`}z [jh wŠ_
 $ % !>" —  &! Š]wcdZz ]_u]woade: `_, fZf]Zowl, v_v_h
w z\`h `wy_ fZjw†aj_ce!
‡ dZ g\[e g}jZ^a|e `_ d_]\jZ†vw, g}- Yf_caoZ d\o\, _Šo_j_d-zw_jjaz,
yjh[ad Z`_ _ff\dad`Z, gc\ \\ ŠZdhd, _ cf_caoZ, w†ad\je, u_ dZ, †dZ dgZl o\c-
jZ^vZl a `\ fZ[‚\fa|e, `_[Z ]wv_za. ‚\``}l w]Zv [_j z`\ g[ZŠ`Zg\`a\ [jh
‰Zuez\|e g ]wva, c`_†_j_ Zw\`a\, auw†\`ah f]\v]_c`\l|\l au gZcdZ†`}Š
†dZ ”dZ _ocZjˆd`Z dg\][Z\ d\jZ. dvw- cj_[Zcd\l — `wya.
( 
   # 
   :

      

     #   "
  #   
   
   !    
   " #  $  
" " 

"#$ G *2"  3'!2'

ktƒ YZj`‚\ g v]w^\g_Š ‡ vZy[_ h w^\ gc\]e\u wgj\vch vwja-


`_]a\l, dZ fZf}d_jch gZcf]Zaug\cda \\
‡ d\f\]e fZczZd]ad\, `_cj_[ad\ce ga- w `_c [Zz_, g ¤\]y_`\. €a†\yZ `\ g}|jZ!
[Zz ”dZl f_Šj_g}. ‰]Z[\ ]\‚\fdZg fZjZ` •`d\]`\d. ’\]a
˜`_\d\, v_vZg_ Z`_ `_ gvwc? ohc- jˆoZl, g}oa]_l a [_g_l yZdZge fZ `\zw.
`ade z`\, fZ^_jwl, d]w[`Z ow[\d — `\d €Z `\ dwd-dZ o}jZ! \va`cv_h f_Š-
fZ[ŠZ[haŠ cjZg, †dZo} f\]\[_de aza j_g_ au d\Š j_vZzcdg, f]ayZdZgj\`a\
d_vZ\ cjZ^`Z\ gf\†_dj\`a\, `Z cv_^w vZdZ]}Š `\gZuzZ^`Z, fZv_ `\ wga[a|e
Z[`Z: \\ gvwc z`\ u_fZz`ajch `_ gcˆ gc\ cgZaza yj_u_za, — ”dZ h d\f\]e, fZ-
^au`e, ŠZdh \j h \\ g fZcj\[`al ]_u j\d cj\ fZ\u[va g yZ]Z[ \va, fZ`hj.
d]a[‚_de fhde dZzw `_u_[, vZy[_ Zd\‚ ‰Zd czZd]ad\, g} u`_\d\, v_v `_[Z u_-
f]agZuaj \\ g †acj\ []wyaŠ wyZ\`al z\|ag_de d\cdZ au ]acZgZl zwva, †dZ-
au ’_vw. Y d\Š fZ] gcfZza`_j, cvw†_j, o} `\ o}jZ vZzZ†vZg? – dZ^\ [wz_j,
[wz_j: “‰Zd o} \\ ]_u fZf]ZoZg_de!” †dZ u`_ˆ.
1  #  #… 
/

€_fac_`Z gZ gc\Š v`ay_Š, gZ gc\Š $<" &>$  ' $%*$. /  ktr
a`d\]`\dZgcvaŠ ]\‚\fd_Š f]Z |\va`-  * '&" $+>$,  *
cvwˆ f_Šj_gw: zZj, gZueza zwva, [Zo_ge '&" '8 &+, >'& %
gZ[}, u_z\ca d\cdZ.  '& $+, &+  . .  . !.
– cf]_|ag_ˆ w g_c: ”dZ vdZ `_fac_j? /  ! $%*$% — $  !# !
€\d, vdZ d_v fa|\d ]\‚\fd}? ‰\[e `\ $%*$%! U- 5 '&  R% #$$%8
fZjw†adch `a†\yZ w †\jZg\v_, vZdZ]}l !%, !+, > $$+- '<+
cd_`\d yZdZgade fZ ”daz u_facv_z!  " #$%. A%  $$ '& & 
++ + # R% !'+%? -
/%  " + !+%! ", $$ #!E. A"
/  !$ $++   + #$%  !  !"  %-
 +%$  +, !5 %5. $%.
D &+ >" % , - :   !"! : !" '%-
'5 I + &   +-  '& &"   5>%8 $-
. 1% '5" %   !, !$ $%, +<%8 !&+ ++.
   *$+,  +* '%- 7 $ — +5, 5 5 %+8,
 %*  %$ +",  $$+- - > R  !E!". E!"-
%++, >'& %' '&.  %: $ * '&" '"-
U, !+, , !  $$ #5, >'& %$ # + "5
&+   +5$, !*  >" '&, #5 <+#&
 $%& $+'  $ 5 <+- *5   <*5"  -
#5   '5 &, !$  , !+% >, $$ "$ # %$
!%> , > %*. 5, ! $%*$ +  R
: $E8  %* !%>" ># $%* '<%5 %*E, 
$%8 *, $$ %  5 '. O R +  , > +& *& !%-
* "5 + %$ >"! L5 5 #>$ >"

"    .         ,    ,   
 ?     —        ,     ! 4  -
 ,         "        ,  
? (       ,
 ,     -
    . +   ,        "
  "  "! 2       ,
         " ". *     ,
  ,  #  .
"#$ G *2"  3'!2'

kqm '& —  %!   >& <5%". Q& #$ (“#” !-<'-


O  !E!5"  +>$+ *$ <&5)  <" 
!%+  $ $$-%$<$   >, ! +" #%$.
+", $&"  !$% -'%" G$&+ #$  @+%, $-
5+. 5 $"$ +"#  + ! +-
9&  R <  !% +, % %. W $ '& !+ +
 !%>"  >". /-!&, +&  +,  @+ — + )C,
  < $  +%$,  '"#.
  I%+ $%! #$$. A D5 #$ '&+, !$ 
'& & $+ <5",   +%$% — +5$  !>&. H'& $5
 >! 7 5 !" !5. %$&+ ! E& #$, -
: -&, !%" +&  <5 +%8 + !5+ !  !-
'"#%8 $%, ++ - .
+ BC,        O!"  E$ , <+-
<+, $& '+, >'& - &  +5%'$, !!& $+-
" $%8 $% '< %*E ! $5+. +  $+. J % !5" — -
: 5 %* , > $$ "$ %$ > '&$, !+ E& #$, 
5 "  $%%, ! +&   %$&+ #$
$%*$ '<%5 %*E. O$ , '"#,  ' ! <+% @-
 '&  ! $% $- +&. J $5 '"# #$ !>-
& <" @"  !" + ! !%>#5… % $$ R -
', $"$ >#", &5 < !& <"? ?
$&. %" %*E& '<%85 +, O!" '+  %$ $>$%  %+
 @" —  !+ +* '% - + #@  $ !$. D-
'"  < <+". A%   #'-  %+, + !% !5" 
$ %>5! $%  '%+ *". >+ *"
1  #  #… 
/

+& '%+ "$   &,  *- `_je`}, v_v f]Zcd a ]_‚aZ`_j\` |\- kqt
,  <+5 E, !$  <<- va`cval cwf fada. —_oZ†al jˆ[, cd\v_g-
5    %". |alch g \va `_ u_]_oZdva, oZje|\yZ
/   !$&+ !- a `\ d]\oZg_j — c}d`_h, [Zo]Zd`_h \[_,
%  @+%  <+ !+, !- †\yZ ^ \\ `_[Z?
&+ <   &  !!E 0:(. ‡ gZd [gZ]\‚ |\va`cvaŠ Š_`Zg — [Z-
M, +*  ! '" + — g\[\``Z\ [Z cZg\]|\`cdg_ g\javZj\-
 !+ R! !5, - fa\. €\d `a Z[`ZyZ c_`daz\d]_ fZg\]Š-
 — '" < &. `Zcda ”dZyZ [gZ]‚_, Zcd_g|\yZch o\u
O"$ " !" !%  !$, ‘ajay]_``ZyZ wv]_|\`ah. “Z`vZcde
 * !!"5, !%" * 8 |\va`cvZl f_Šj_g}, cjZ^`Zcde \\ au-
>", %+, $ >8, $ +%,  !*% yZdZgj\`ah `_fZza`_ˆd z`\ az\``Z
 !%! 9* * *"5  %,  ”dZd [gZ]\‚. €Z Zd`ˆ[e `\ \yZ Zoad_d\-
 $%&"  !* +? ja o}ja Zc`Zg`}za fZd]\oad\jhza
M5 #$$5 !  — ”dZyZ y\`a_je`ZyZ vZ`[ad\]cvZyZ f]Z-
!$  V. aug\[\`ah.
df]_gjhˆazch au \va g [_je-
bdZo} fZ`hde, v_v g `_]Z[`Zl vwŠ`\ `al fwde v_]_g_`_z fZzazZ dZg_]Zg
fZhgajZce `_cdZjevZ cjZ^`Z\ g au- [jh dZ]yZgja `w^`} o}ja \\ a yZ-
yZdZgj\`aa au[\ja\, v_v |\va`cv_h cda`‚}. …_^[Zzw ŠZd\jZce f]ag\uda
f_Šj_g_, [Zcd_dZ†`Z Zva`wde guyjh- [ZzZl `\†dZ [avZga``Z\, a vwf‚} [_
[Zz c_z yZ]Z[ \va a Zo]_dadech v \yZ fZyZ`ava c ZŠZdZl fZvwf_ja g\ce-
acdZ]aa. z_ `\[\|\gwˆ au-u_ d]w[Z\zvZcda au-
‰ f]Z|jZz \va o}j dZ]yZg}z yZdZgj\`ah f_Šj_gw — g\[e d_vZ\ j_-
yZ]Z[Zz. ‰Zd f_]_ cZŠ]_`ag|aŠch vZzcdgZ zZ^`Z o}jZ vwfade dZjevZ g
v_]_g_`-c_]_\g. `a f]Zcd} a ]_‚aZ- \va!

   ,      "             -
  ,  #      . )  ,       ,
  " ? *     ! 5          
 ,     !
Мельница
в Шеки

В
&*   ( 
2&
 &
,   . ; 

'

/, * :&1
kqq  , &

2-
&,  : ! &&
,
0

&
 '
 ? 3
-
, '
 
&& 7. H & (
&
/
7/,


&, 0
 (
&.
(
& */,  (

-  
 1 (*1? 3 ! 3
/ 6 :
 & 1 / &  (0&
 8  & (&,  
1
 /
& 
012( ((.  / 1  &).

&
, 6
, 0
 (
1
 — -/8, ( (
*(, ,
&&
& (. 3 /
'
 -
/8, &   '
1 (& 

(
1
 (& /1 (
— &- 0 82&1, 0
/1  -
( (( 0/01
* -
&,   0
/1 & '
( &
 .  /&& *

, 0

E   (0

1
1? ( /8&
&* / ( .
+   
 *( 
, 0
 / &&- ;  6 :
  ,

  6.  
&
, 
'
  
( 6,  &6&, &6-
 0-/0*, 0


  : - /  8&
, 

:&1  6. H &  &

(6
*, 
&  (0
 (
8
 
&
,
 

,  .
6 ,  
( 8(, & (- D  2&  &*
 -
 / 
 & . H & &   6- && 2& 1 8 / 
  
 
*,
 '
 &-
, 0
   
( ((.  /0-
&
8&1, : :&1   . ( , &&1 ( , (&  D , -
* '

&&
&/1 *( 
   K*(,
 *
&
8 (

& 
8 ,    -2& &,  (  &0*  /-
 
 
( ((, & &2 2 !

*   (
&
, - 9 0
 6   
? +  0* -
  /
 :  21 *- :
 ( &1 &* )
,

0 & . I
 &
 , & 
/1 /     6  -
/ 
   *(, … ( &
& ? 9 (  , &

&
? I&  /
 (- (6  , & / /,
* / (
&, (* /1 *, &   . */, *    '
 
? —

( 0
 8 (  J&  -  &
 /. ; *&
! B  



*
&

 
&&.    2& '
*  , &  -
 &
 ( :  0
  * 2(  
&
& — /-
 '
1  &), (6 &   & (21
  &   (
!
kqp
#   # 
     1 
  
  
. "   $  

"#$ G *2"  3'!2'

kqs “]\wŠ_h f\v_ˆd `_ c_^\ a acfZjeuwˆd v_v Z[`w


au ]_u`Zga[`Zcd\l j_g_|_. ‡ a`Zy[_
y_o_jja`cv_h f_Šj_g_ yZdZghd au ”dZyZ d\cd_ v_va\-dZ au[\jah.
a zZcvZgcva\ g_]a_‚aa {wz_ˆ, †dZ vwja`_]`Z fZ[vZg_``}\ †a-
d_d\ja w^\ Zo`_]w^aja cŠZ[cdgZ ˆŠa c
‰ i_o_jj\ yZdZghd \\ Z[`w w`av_je- d\cdZz ‘ajZ! • Z`Z Zd`ˆ[e `\ cjw†_l`Z,
`wˆ f_Šj_gw. “_vwˆ oZje|\ `\ yZdZghd \cja yZgZ]ade f]_g[w.
`a g Z[`Zz yZ]Z[\ ‡u\]o_l[^_`_. `_ a ‰Zd a ŠZ]Z|Z, gZd a fZf}d_ld\ce jaoZ
‘Z]zw az\\d ZcZowˆ. o}†`wˆ f_Šj_gw ]_cv_d_de d_vZ\ d\cdZ c_zZcdZhd\je`Z,
gc\y[_ `_]\u_ˆd ]ZzoavZz, _ ”d_ c]_uw jaoZ vwfade yZdZgZ\ d\cdZ ‘ajZ, vZdZ]Z\
auyZd_gjag_\dch g ga[\ d]\wyZje`avZg, a`Zy[_ f]Z[_\dch u_zZ]Z^\``}z g cw-
fZ”dZzw \\ a `_u}g_ˆd — d]\wŠZl. f\]z_]v\d_Š. “ZjevZ `\ f\]\fwd_ld\ \yZ
€_ c_zZz [\j\ yZdZgade \\ `_cdZje- c Zo}†`}z cjZ\`}z d\cdZz, ŠZ]Z|Z?
vZ f]ZcdZ, †dZ ŠZ†\dch gZcvjav`wde:
“…_v_h `_ŠZ[v_!” [`Z dZjevZ “`Z”. ‰} 1  , <   !-
czZ^\d\ ]_cv_d_de d\cdZ [Z dZja`} %  $%>  $%$. / $%$ &!-
y_u\d`Zl owz_ya, d_vZ\, v_v g ]wv_Š w  +" +& E$   -
z_cd\]a‚}, g}ug_g|\lch fZv_u_de `_z,  !$. D%$ $ !*+5, 
v_v yZdZghd y_o_jja`cvwˆ f_Šj_gw? !%>5 %"$.
ždZ [ZgZje`Z Zo}†`Z\ [jh ‡u\]o_l[- H#5 !$  $"$
^_`_ a z`ZyaŠ []wyaŠ cZc\[`aŠ ]\yaZ- < ' %"$ $, >'& 
`Zg d\cdZ — cZje, zwv_, gZ[_. ‡ \cja \yZ $*  & '& !  5 -
]_cv_d_de gZd d_v dZ`vZ, dZ w `\yZ fZ- ,  $>$ '<, !.
hgjh\dch ZcZoZ\ `_ug_`a\ — ˆŠ_ aja 9$&+ !"E+ ! ! $+$
ˆ‘v_, v_v \yZ `_u}g_ˆd g `\vZdZ]}Š   !$ $E !$ $ -
]\yaZ`_Š. •`Zy[_ ”dZ d\cdZ f]ZcdZ g}- %"$%.
"#$ G *2"  3'!2'

kqƒ H#5  % + i[\-dZ d_z — `_ fZjv_Š z_y_ua`Zg, †dZ
%$&" !$, !+% >   +- u_z\`aja g_z fZjh, c_[} a ZyZ]Z[},
+",  ! &&5 5 !- Zohu_d\je`Z `_l[\dch ]acZg_h owz_-
>"  5 +$+. y_. ‹`Zya\ au g_c ŠZ]Z|Z u`_ˆd \\, ac-
/ !E!    !&. 4- fZjeuwˆd \\ [jh gchvaŠ cf]a`y-]ZjjZg
$ ! $%8 !% +* "5  a f]Z†aŠ †w[_†\cdg c ˆyZ-gZcdZ†`}z
!$$,  "$ $"$ , _v‚\`dZz.
!$  !% . €\cad\ g_|w ]acZgwˆ owz_yw cˆ[_,
O !% ! !% +% '- z} c g_za c\l†_c f]ayZdZgaz y_o_j-
*8  !+ +  —  +, ja`cvwˆ d]\wŠwˆ f_Šj_gw cZ gvwcZz
!*%, — 5,  !&%,  *% f_Šj_g} |\va`cvZl!
" $ >8. 7 ! >" #, ‰_z †dZ-`aow[e `_[Z Zohc`hde?
!$  5>5. O  & - xZd]\`a]wld\ce, v_v cjZ^ade d]\w-
>$ %5,  ! +&+ - yZje`}\ vZ`g\]dava au v]w^v_ owz_-
!&+ ++,    >$ %> ya — gc\ w g_c fZjw†adch, — _ [_je|\
'%8 8 $" # %*. [_^\ a ]_ccv_u}g_de `\w[Zo`Z! o-
^_]ag_ld\ g dZfj\`Zz z_cj\ (h `_-
€w †dZ, fZ[ŠZ[ad? ›[Zo`Z\ ojˆ[Z? {_, cd_ag_ˆ `_ dZfj\`Zz z_cj\ a yZgZ]ˆ
g`\ gchvZyZ cZz`\`ah — ZcZo\``Z \cja dZ`Zz, `\ d\]fhaz gZu]_^\`al, g}
w g_c g ŠZjZ[aje`av\ \cde d\cdZ ‘ajZ cj}|ad\ z\`h?!) vZ`g\]dava au ]acZ-
aja vdZ-dZ ]_cv_d_j ˆŠw. gZl owz_ya, `_†a`\``}\ Z]\Š_za c c_-
Yjw|_ld\ z\`h, [\da v_z\``}Š Š_]`Zl fw[]Zl [_ a fZ[_g_ld\ v †_ˆ g
[^w`yj\l, f_c}`va cwf\]z_]v\dZg! f]_u[`a†`}l g\†\]!
Хлеб
с
маслом

Я
0  
: 0& 0 & 8     - kqr
&0  . L  0
 
 
&8-
  1.
* 
, * ( ,
,  9 ( * 0 , 
( 0 -


 
(. / 
, 0&
 (
 
,
 6 *
 
/ /-. 9 '

/ 2& <-
  , &
8, 0
 / & & &&
8  &     & &&.
 /(:&8
&)8,  (  3&0* *   &( . @
82* 8   . 3(,  &  
  


 &,  *

,
 8
 / 
&
- &0/  , ( &  

 82&1 (
 & , (
 . 5


 &*
 & -
 &/   . L  *

,  
( 6/1 &

 *
 0
/ , - /
   & & 6&,

/  6
 

:,
 82 &
   1 H,
&
 &0  . 5
  &&1 & &)& &*
 & 
01
(

  :& ( . 8 / 8& & & 2
( 
3   &
/
-   & &

6.
& & (6, 0
  (/8 -  XIX   &&1 7)( &1
&0
8        .  ;
& E 
8-
; : 
  * 0&
 & 6 *& &*
 &
*

 
) /. I /
, 0
  * 2
. @  6& -
>MM–GMM 

(  1 & 2&


 & (&, 
 -
*   & /.    


8 6  ,   2 
, 
   &,  * 2& &
&0  .

 *, &
*


&   & 6&  

 “3 ”,

 &* 
&& 81-
&.
 “& ”
   :
     # 
         " 
–      :
    " #    #     
   +#       
   " #  


      

"#$ G *2"  3'!2'

kp~ €_]Z[`Z\ dgZ]†\cdgZ O <", $$ !$<  @.


'& !5", > 5  + '%% "
€Z, oZ^\, †dZ cd_jZ c ”daz auwzad\je- "#, +& <'   -
`}z dZ]dZz, gZ †dZ \yZ f]\g]_daja `_- 5" $  !%+%  
]Z[`Z\ dgZ]†\cdgZ a ]\‚\fdava au Zd- !  % <.
]}g`}Š v_j\`[_]\l! • fZ[ vZ`\‚ \yZ D + ) %$&+  $-
[Zoaja _[\fd} dZ ja u[Z]ZgZyZ, dZ ja  B, !" +<  +-
]_u[\je`ZyZ fad_`ah — [_ d_v, †dZ c\yZ[- +. (- ! +< ++ )-
`h \cde dZ]d “`_fZj\Z`”, gc\ \\ au]\[v_  B-. / + %$&+  3-. =-
fZf_[_ˆalch g z\`ˆ `\ cja|vZz zZ[- ! ,  % 0-. H!5" !-
`}Š v_‘\ a ]\cdZ]_`Zg, h `\ cd_`w. >+  6-, +<&+ ++, $&-
˜_dZ h c w[ZgZjecdga\z f]\[_zch + 2-   +  -.
gZcfZza`_`ahz au zZ\yZ [\dcdg_ a /! / R $+   ++ %'-
f]ayZdZgjˆ \yZ c_z. Yjw|_ld\, h ow[w +  "$  !>.
v]_dZv. ‰Zd †dZ `_z fZ`_[Zoadch: < !> $&+ $+  
> $ *   !5+ !E%-
5" +%$% ><   +$%, +- %,  I >< !>, &  + -
#"  "8, " %$%, " % ", > $ * !%!+  #+-
 )3 ++ ! > 5 ++.
+. 4+"  !$, '%" 4"  > *: +  
 !$  %'"  "$   *& '&" $ $E.
>. O, * '%%> *&+, -
BCC ++ > + <" 5 " +5$+, + R  %.
  & >. K$"  < - W + '% &+  &+,
"$  $% I 3 ++    $  5 $+$+,   <-
!+<" ! >"8 > +. +*5 &+ + ! +5$+% %.
kpk
"#$ G

kpm

W +, !, '% #$+ !- *, %5I  *& + ! ', '%-
&+  +5$+,   +5 >5 % "&!
  !< <  I,  R  J $$ 5E  , & >, '*
# <>, !+? A+ * - %!! U>& '$ $%%5 !
" , ! !&I -   < %  -
>&+ ++! O  +5 &!$5 > !>&  %!% %$%&, $-
$* ($,    " #$+ & !  % +% !5"5.
$+, !&5" %" '"# $- F!"  &  !+ -
>   ) > +, - " $+? P >  R+ *-
*I5  , ! '5 +&+  , !" +!
'&>&+ '<+ — &  +$- F%>$  <*" ", %-
, $$  !%<&5  !5  +5  +, !*"  $%>$  '"-
5 —  !+ ,    +$. /$!5 +$,  -
 $$ '& &+  <%#&+. 7 $- 5"5  E ".

*  " ,       ,      -
 ,  -      -       .     ,  
     ,             . (   
        " . *   "   —  "
    .
3   
  (   ! 4 ' 
/

K< *$  +  '"- /& ! 'I "  $, $$ kpt
 $ + % $. +#5 +" + !I, "$  !+", > 
5E  +  $+, '" $  R+ %> & !%>   * +,
>" +$ , !  $$ +" - > +   R,    , $-
 , ! *+ & 5 !#%  $$-'%" !".
'  +$. F  +" P, 5  !+8,  R % +5. -
 $!5, %'  5, $ !- "  !+ % <  R "
$ !$ ! !- >  !%>5! 4 !%>5 <-
" $+  .  *- 5"5 $% — "  !& +*%
5 <' +" I <, >'& !- 5+  !" + & +*
"  +5$". <+"5  $% >+ %: "
F<% * >% <V5" "- '%"&  " @#, >" %$, -
 ! . A> #- !" !"+  $&" !#%, -
  R % “$”  .  '" $'%  +" !+&  -
'"# > R !#$ !5 ++ +, !+% >   * +
'8 $%8 @+% $%$%%< $+- > !55.
  !"<%5  + $$
<5  $> <%5. O$ >
$+  !"<+ R “+>$- €_fZj\Z`Zgcva\
”  —  # $5.
fj_`} fZ wdajau_‚aa
/& ! !"<" +  f\†\`a
"&   $<"5  #@-
. /& ! " > + “ZjevZ [_g_ld\ h, f]\^[\ †\z f]acdw-
 +  +#"   %I$ — fade vZ gdZ]Zl †_cda zZ\yZ ]_ccv_u_,
$ * !%>5 ! !". fZgZ]†w.
 
   :   :
    – . "    #  ! 
     #   $$ "
   +#     # - # 
   " #     "  # 
     #      
     "  % !  
–   
  
     $   " : " "  ,   ,
 ",   

"#$ G *2"  3'!2'

kpq x]az\]`Z dZy[_ ^\, vZy[_ g c]\[\ U , !+, < !*"  -
[ZzZŠZuh\v cd_ja fZfwjh]`} dZ]d}- , ! $ *, $$ 5 !-
`_fZj\Z`} a fZ[[\jva fZ[ `aŠ, gZZo- , +,  $+  R  >,
]_^\`a\ cZg\dcvaŠ vwja`_]Zg fZ]_uajZ ! +!% ((C °F  %$ ! -
\\ Z[`Z au[\ja\: f\†\`Z†`}l dZ]dav. *+ “$$E5” +" !+&.
Š, `\ f]Zau`Zcad\ f]a z`\ ”dZyZ cjZgZ- /-!&, 5 <8, > 5 % 
cZ†\d_`ah gcjwŠ! …_v ^\ h `\ jˆojˆ ”da "$ + > $> — +"
fZ[cZŠ|a\ j\f\|va au o\ugZug]_d`Z ac- + < & $>$  $-
fZ]†\``Zl f\†\`a! …_v `\f]ahd`_ z`\ .
a[\h wvj_[}g_`ah aŠ g fa]_za[w c f]Z- /-&, 5 <8, > > !>-
z_u}g_`a\z `}`\ a f]ac`Z a gZ g\va , !+  < '<$ "
g\vZg jˆoaz}z z_lZ`\uZz! €\ ]_ccv_- $!& $% $$.
u}g_ld\ z`\, h g_c f]Z|w, †dZ dw[_ \\ /-", 5 %, >  %* -
[Zo_gjhˆd ]_[a dZyZ, †dZo} ”dZ Zv_u_- !"<" !>"   ,  
jZce \\ `_^Z]acd\\ — `\ `_[Z ”dZyZ!  * !>> !#,  
‰\[e fZczZd]ad\, v_v gc\ f]ZcdZ. ‰c\ $> %I $%$E, , >
]_g`Z ”dZd f\†\`Z†`}l dZ]dav \[hd '% %*" R !$& $-
c Šj\oZz, d_v? • gc\ ]_g`Z g `\z `\fZ- $    !<5, 
z\]`Z\ vZja†\cdgZ v_vZyZ-dZ cZz`a- ! > %>#, >+ $* 5
d\je`ZyZ z_cj_, ^a]Zg, ”zwjey_dZ]Zg a !.
f]Z†\l Šazaa, au vZdZ]Zl f]ZaugZ[a- J$, 5 <+#5  +& -
d\je cZcd]hf_j cgZl z_lZ`\u, _ fZdZz !"<%+ " +, #5
f]Z[_j \yZ g_z f]a fZzZa ZdoZl`ZyZ  +5  + !+. F>
zZjZdv_ d\j\]\vj_z}. €w †dZ, z} c_za +  R <  <5" <  
`\ czZ^\z, †dZ ja, fZjZ^ade g `_| f\- +"#,   '% $, $$ , !"-
†\`Z†`}l dZ]d dZ, †dZ u_ŠZdaz?  +  %# "#.
3   
  (   ! 4 ' 
/

: !+& % !" ><   !',  % I - kpp
  !" $#$  !%> !- " <. >"  %$+ 5 <'8
  ". O!" !%  !!- '+, '55   5> -
" "8, +, !!$  +&+ $ (+* <+" +$+)  >
>. !E —  # $%. A- +. # 5 !!58 *+-
! !+#5,  !% % - &+ >&+ !E+  +%$&+ +,
'" -  ! <+#5 &!58 $%  "  !8 ><
& $#$   5 &5  .
<&5.
A$"$ >$ < '<$ ˜`_\d\, g} zZ^\d\ `\ f]Zda]_de †\-
 <" !+ (CC ++ ]\u cadZ `a fZza[Z]} (zZ^\d\ gZZo\
$!5$, " 5"5 (  $!5"!) guhde dZz_d`wˆ f_cdw), `a o_uajav, `a,
 <'" '<$ '+.  R d\z oZj\\, f_|d\d. €w †dZ d_z — v]w-
!" !%> !8 >< +$ fa`va a wu\jva g f_|d\d\? “Z, †dZ Zcd_-
  !"   ". A \dch g`wd]a cad_ fZcj\ f]Zda]_`ah,
'<$  !!" "8, + zZ^`Z [_^\ c\cde — ”dZ c\[Zo`Z.
 +&+ $+, >'&  ' • fZcj\ f]Zda]_`ah f_|d\d_ Zcd_`\dch
 "$ +,   $%. /  - `\cvZjevZ z\`e|\, †\z o}jZ. €Z fZcj\
'5+ -  !5+  . f]Zda]_`ah g} fZjw†_\d\ vwja`_]`}l
# < !>. A% %* &  |\[\g], _ o\u ”dZl f]Z‚\[w]} — f]ZcdZ
+  <, $$  !"? \[w. ‰}oa]_ld\ c_za!
U, !+, > '*8  -
'"#+ $< %$ —  !%   W &  !"& &', 
!>. D %$ > <"5, + " "$ '" # !>-
'58 !>", 8, !>%  '*- >& . D* !85 -
8   , >'& %* +5 + >$, $5 %  :
"#$ G *2"  3'!2'

kpƒ !>>& !#, +5 >$, o_ged\ ZgZ`Zl c_j_d aja `\cvZjevZ
'<$5 >$.  !& $- vwcZ†vZg ‘]wvdZg. ‰\[e `\ Zohu_d\je`Z,
* !+<&5 !#+, %8I †dZo} v_^[Z\ ojˆ[Z o}jZ co_j_`ca]Z-
$* ++, !+ $*  '<$+, g_`Z c dZ†va u]\`ah ^a]Zg-wyj\gZ[Zg-
I ! $*  !#+  ! o\jvZg, [ZgZje`Z dZyZ, †dZ `_| w^a`
$* $$ $&#$. / +". ow[\d co_j_`ca]Zg_`, _ \\ jw†|\ —
g\ce ]_‚aZ`.
‰}f\v_h fZcj\[`al vZ]^, zZ^`Z cz_- • w^ vZ`\†`Z, `\ cdZad cd_gade d_-
u_de \yZ ha†`}z ^\jdvZz fZfZj_z c vwˆ u_vwcvw `_ cdZj g cjw†_\ oZje|ZyZ
gZ[Zl, f]ac}f_de vw`^wdZz, zZ^`Z Zo\[_. šcja u_\cde ”dw u_vwcvw |_|j}†-
[_^\ `_[]\u_de \yZ vZj\cavZz u_]_`\\, vZz aja fjZgZz, av_dech ow[\d u[Z]Z-
`_z\†_h ow[wa\ vwcZ†va dZ]d_. €Z gZ, a jw†|\ o} cjZgZ “f\†\`Z†`}l” g
\cja g} ”dZyZ `\ c[\j_ja, guo\ld\ \\ [_``Zz g_]a_`d\ ZoZu`_†_jZ Zc`Zg`Zl
y]_zzZg p~ cjagZv, [_ guo\ld\ `\ f]Z- a`y]\[a\`d, _ `\ `_f]_gj\`a\ yj_g`ZyZ
cdZ d_v, _ c`Zg_ c o_uajavZz — gZd d_v, w[_]_.
†dZo} fZjw†ajch `\^`Z-u\j\`}l ‚g\d, €Z a`Zy[_, fZ`\z`Z^vw, fZ †wde-
vZdZ]}l v_v o} wyZg_]ag_\d: “Y\|e †wde, fZo_jZg_dech `_fZj\Z`Zz — ŠZde
z\`h, h j\yval, h [a\da†\cval!” vj_cca†\cvaz, ŠZde u_vwcZ†`}z, †dZ c
€_ c_zZz [\j\ `_[Z fZ`az_de, †dZ f\†\`eˆ — ZŠ v_v u[Z]ZgZ!
dZ]d, vZdZ]}l z} f]ayZdZgaja, cZ[\]- €_ u[Z]Zge\ g_z, f]ahd`ZyZ _ff\dad_!
^ad g c\o\ Z†\`e z`ZyZ gvwc`}Š a fa-
d_d\je`}Š f]Z[wvdZg. ‰Zd a `\†\yZ \cde
\yZ, v_v g_]\`wˆ v_]dZ|vw. €\oZje|Zl
vwcZ†\v dZ]d_, oZv_j ga`_ — gZd a g\ce
w^a`. €Z \cja ”dZyZ z_jZ, _ ^agZd f]a-
g}v v dZzw, †dZo} \yZ `_oag_ja, [Z-
Скоро нам понадобится
сюзьма
Д
_ `\ oZld\ce g} d_v ”dZyZ `Z- j\`eˆ, †\c`ZvZz, cZjeˆ a v]_c`}z f\]-
gZyZ cjZg_! €_ c_zZz [\j\ ‚\z — ”dZ u_z\†_d\je`}l _vvZzf_`\-
gc\ Z†\`e f]ZcdZ.€_[Z guhde z\`d v zhc`}z f]Z[wvd_z aja c_zZcdZ-
z_]jˆ, cjZ^\``wˆ g `\- hd\je`Z\ ojˆ[Z. xZjZ^ad\ `_ vwcZ†\v kpr
cvZjevZ cjZ\g, `_jade g `\\ j\f\|va `\z`ZyZ f]af]_gj\``Zl cˆue-
v_d}v aja z_‚Z`a a fZ[g\- z} — a wd]_†\``}l _ff\dad g\]`\dch
cade, †dZo} †\]\u z_]jˆ cd\vj_ c}gZ]Zd- `\z\[j\``Z. … ^a]`Zl \[\ a fZ[_g`Z —
v_. “Z, †dZ Zcd_`\dch g z_]j\, — cˆuez_, ”dZ f]ZcdZ `\ZoŠZ[azZ\ f]ajZ^\`a\. ‰
_ c}gZ]Zdv_, vZdZ]_h cd\vj_, dZ^\ Z†\`e •]_`\ a u_ cdZj `\ ch[wd, fZv_ `\ ow[\d
fZj\u`_ a g ŠZuhlcdg\ f]ayZ[adch — oja- fZ[_`_ cˆuez_ — c†ad_\dch, †dZ \[_ `\
`} u_z\cade, Šj\o zZ^`Z acf\†e ZcZo}l, fZl[\d gf]Zv. ‡ z}? €_czZd]\jace ]\-
_ vZzw fZ `]_gw — d_v fwcde a g}fe\d vj_z} a u_vwc}g_\z z\uazZz? {_ u_-
cd_v_`†av. †\z Z`a g_z `w^`}, ”da j\v_]cdg_, vZy-
– v_v-dZ ]_u fZf]ZoZg_j, a w z\`h [_ gZd — `_dw]_je`}\, fZ[ja``}\ f]Z-
gfZj`\ w[_†`Z fZjw†aj_ce cvZ]Zcf\j_h [wvd}, vZdZ]}\ ZŠZd`Z fZzZywd `_|\zw
cˆuez_. – fZf]Zcaj cwf]wyw au [ZgZje`Z fa\g_]\`aˆ, [_ \\ a `\cwd c cZoZˆ
fjZd`Zl dv_`a c|ade z\|Zv, fZ[ŠZ[h- gad_za`} a z_ccw []wyaŠ fad_d\je`}Š
al fZ ]_uz\]_z fZ[ ‚\`d]a‘wyw, g vZdZ- g\\cdg!
]Zl z} cw|az u\j\`e (vcd_da, fZj\u`_h šcja cˆuez_ fZjw†aj_ce cja|vZz
g\e g ŠZuhlcdg\, wg\]hˆ g_c!). ‰ ”dZd z\- ywcd_h, \\ zZ^`Z `\z`ZyZ ]_ug\cda gZ-
|Zv h wjZ^aj `\cvZjevZ jad]Zg v_d}v_ [Zl a [Zo_gade cg\^wˆ, z\jvZ fZ]\u_`-
a `_†_j g]__de ‚\`d]a‘wyw. ‰Z[w f]a- `wˆ zhdw, wv]Zf, cwŠZl †_o\] (†_o]\‚),
|jZce cjag_de `\cvZjevZ ]_u, `Z cˆuez_ †\c`Zv, y]\‚val Z]\Š a auˆz. €\ w[ag-
fZjw†aj_ce f]\gZcŠZ[`Zl — `avdZ o} `\ jhld\ce d_vZzw cZ†\d_`aˆ, \cja g} `\
fZg\]aj, †dZ h c[\j_j \\ u_ fhde za`wd. u_ow[\d\ \\ a fZcZjade, dZ gz\cd\ c j_-
•d_v — cˆuez_. xZcd_ged\ \\ `_ cdZj g_|Zz ”dZ ow[\d f]\gZcŠZ[`Zl u_vwcvZl
ŠZde f]ZcdZ d_v, ŠZde u_f]_gj\``Zl u\- v f]_u[`a†`Zzw Zo\[w.
Десять
напитков
в жару

В
Zd, ‡za, ŠZjZ[`_h za`\]_jv_! x\ld\! — cv_u_j h, f]Zdh`wg u_fZ-
d\g|al cd_v_` c gZ[Zl cgZ\zw [h[\.
— ‡, au ŠZjZ[aje`av_! — › [h[a f]afZ[`hj_ce Z[`_ o]Zge, _
g wyZjv_Š ywo fZhgaj_ce a]Z`a†`_h wj}ov_, ZoZu`_†_g|_h: “{_ ksk
†\zw g_c, zZjZ[}Š, dZjevZ w†_d g ”daŠ a`cdadwd_Š?”
— ‡ z} g “w]vz\`aa, u`_\|e, v_v [\j_ja ŠZjZ[`wˆ gZ[w? …Zy-
[_ ŠZjZ[aje`avZg \\ `\ o}jZ? – dZy[_ |Z‘\]Zz ]_oZd_j. ‰Zd
`_jag_\|e g o]\u\`dZgZ\ g\[]Z gZ[}, fZg\ca|e \yZ `_ f\]\[-
`\z o_zf\]\ a fZ\Š_j! ˜•Y-ª, u`_\|e, c v_vZl cvZ]Zcdeˆ \[\d? “]a[‚_de vajZz\d]Zg
g †_c!  _]_ — cZ]Zv fhde, _ g\[\]vZ d_z, gf\]\[a, g d\`\†v\ oZjd_\dch, g\d]Zz \yZ
Zo[wg_\d, _ gZ[_ †\]\u o]\u\`d fZdaŠZ`evw cZ†adch, a dwd ^\ g}c}Š_\d, acf_]h\d-
ch. ‰Zd d_v fZ\[\|e — †_c, [g_, _ fZdZz Zcd_`Zga|ech f\]\vw]ade, gZuez\|e g\[]Z,
fe\|e †\]\u v]_l, gZ[_ je\dch `_ d\oh, _ ŠZjZ[`_h — _^ uwo} jZzad!
…Z`\†`Z, d_vZl cfZcZo ZŠj_^[\`ah gZ[} f]a[wz_j `\ zZl [h[h a `\ \yZ dZg_]a-
a. YfZcZow ”dZzw w^\ z`ZyZ g\vZg, dZjevZ g f]\^`a\ g]\z\`_ gz\cdZ o]\u\`dZgZyZ
g\[]_ acfZjeuZg_ja ZcZo}l Šw]^w`, _ ]Zje ˜•Y_-ª c wcf\ŠZz ay]_j g\]ojˆ[. ‰f]Z-
†\z, a `_ cdZh`v\ ”dZd cfZcZo dZ^\ Zdja†`Z c]_o_d}g_j, ZcZo\``Z \cja f]a g\d\]v\.
nw]^w` c gZ[Zl — `_ |\cd, |\cd — g d\`e ˆ]d}, a gZd — ŠZjZ[`_h gZ[_ gc\y[_ fZ[
]wvZl. ‡ \cja u_g\]`wde zhcZ a Zfwcdade \yZ g ”dZd Šw]^w`? {_ gZd ^\ g_z fZ[Zoa\
ŠZjZ[aje`av_!
{_ †dZ d_z yZgZ]ade Zo wz\`aa ZŠj_[ade gZ[w g ]_cv_j\``Zl fwcd}`\, \cja g ’w-
Š_]\ v]wyj}l yZ[, g jˆowˆ fZyZ[w `_ o_u_]\ zZ^`Z o}jZ vwfade j\[!
– ”dZ gc\ v †\zw g_z ]_ccv_u}g_ˆ? ‰Zd cjw†ajZce f\]gZ\ `_ zZ\l f_zhda fZ-
`_cdZh\zw ^_]vZ\ j\dZ g —Zccaa. › vZyZ cf]Zcade, w vZyZ `_w†adech, v_v f\]\`Zcade
d_vwˆ ^_]w, †dZ \cde, _ c_zZ\ yj_g`Z\ — †dZ fade?
– g_c wg\]hˆ, †dZ gz\cdZ wfZd]\oj\`ah gchvaŠ u_y]_`a†`}Š y_ua]ZgZv vw[_ v_v
jw†|\ Zo]_dade cgZ\ g`az_`a\ `_ Zf}d `_]Z[Zg, d}ch†\j\dahza f]Z^ag_ˆaŠ g
^_]vZz vjaz_d\. xZcjw|_ld\ z\`h, h `\ cd_`w ]_ccv_u}g_de Z dZz, †dZ a d_v ŠZ]Z-
|Z aug\cd`Z a d]_[a‚aZ``Z acfZjeuw\dch g —Zccaa — Z zZ]c_Š, ‘]wvdZgZ-hyZ[`}Š
vZzfZd_Š, Z vg_c\ a f]Z†aŠ f]ZŠj_[ad\je`}Š `_fadv_Š. – ]_ccv_^w Z dZz, †dZ feˆd g
^_]w g Y]\[`\l ‡uaa a `_ …_gv_u\.
˜\j\`}l †_l — jw†|al `_fadZv g ^_]w, wg\]hˆ g_c. …_v o} `a o}jZ ^_]vZ, f\ld\
Z†\`e yZ]h†al u\j\`}l †_l o\u v_vaŠ-jaoZ cj_[Zcd\l aja gvwcZg}Š [Zo_gZv. “ZjevZ
`_jag_ld\ †_l fZ`\z`Zyw, owvg_je`Z [g_ yjZdv_ g Z[`w fa_jw. x\ld\ `\ dZ]Zfhce,
fZcj\ `\cvZjevaŠ fa_j ^_^[_ Zohu_d\je`Z Zdcdwfad. ˜[\ce g_^`Z `\ vZja†\cdgZ g}-
fadZyZ, _ g]\zh, g\[e †_l [Zj^\` wcf\de fZ[\lcdgZg_de! x]ayZdZged\ c_j‘\dvw, †dZ-
o} g}d\]\de fZd cZ jo_, — c\l†_c cd_`\d f]ZŠj_[`\\.
Яхна-чай

€Z `\ cf\|ad\ g}jag_de `\[Zfad}l †_l! {Zo_ged\ g †_l`av


vafhdZv, [_ld\ \\ `\z`ZyZ `_cdZhdech a f\]\j\ld\ `_cdZl
†\]\u cad\†vZ g †acdwˆ fZcw[w. …Zy[_ †_l Zcd}`\d, fZcd_ged\
ksm \yZ g ŠZjZ[aje`av. nZjZ[`}l u\j\`}l †_l dZ^\ u_z\†_d\je-
`Z wdZjh\d ^_^[w, a fade \yZ zZ^`Z w^\ `\ z_j\`evaza fa_-
j_za, _ v_v f]ag}vja a v_v ŠZ†\dch — cd_v_`_za. ‰c\ ]_g`Z —
”dZ ^ `\ gZ[v_ — z`ZyZ `\ g}fe\|e, `\ f\]\fe\|e!
€Z _ff\dad_ `\d, `\ o}g_\d g ^_]w _ff\dad_ — gZd †dZ o\c-
fZvZad! šcde Z[`_ dZjevZ ^_^[_. ‰Zd a `_[Z acfZjeuZg_de dZ,
†dZ \cde.
kst

Правильный айран

˜`_\d\, `\vZdZ]}\ fZvwf_ˆd _l]_` g z_y_ua`_Š. ždZ vZ|z_]. ‡ []wya\ f]ZcdZ ]_ugZ-
[hd v_d}v aja z_‚Z`a gZ[Zl, f]af]_gjhˆd a `_u}g_ˆd ”dZ _l]_`Zz. `a dZ^\ `\-
f]_gaje`Z [\j_ˆd, fZdZzw †dZ Z`a `\ u`_ˆd, †dZ d_vZ\ `_cdZhal _l]_`.
YzZd]ad\, gZd cˆuez_, h w^\ ]_ccv_u}g_j Z `\l. Y f]az\`\`a\z cˆuez} zZ^`Z
f]ayZdZgade z`Z^\cdgZ cZwcZg, c_j_dZg. ‹} \\ fZyZgZ]az Zo ”dZz, _ fZv_ az\ld\
g ga[w: \cja ]_ug\cda cˆuezw za`\]_je`Zl gZ[Zl, dZ fZjw†adch c_z}l jw†|al _l-
]_`, vZdZ]}l dZjevZ o}g_\d `_ cg\d\. —_ug\[\``}l gZ[Zl v_d}v aja, wf_ca iZcfZ[e,
z_y_ua``}l _l]_` `a g v_vZ\ c]_g`\`a\ `\ a[wd c [Zz_|`az _l]_`Zz `_ cˆuez\.
YzZd]ad\, gZd o}j v_d}v. šcja g} fZf]Zow\d\ c‚\^\``wˆ c}gZ]Zdvw, dZ cZyj_ca-
d\ce cZ z`Zl, †dZ \\ yZ]evZg_dZ-vacj}l f]agvwc `\ gc\z f]a[\dch fZ gvwcw. – f]\[-
j_y_ˆ w[_jade ”dw c}gZ]Zdvw a u_z\`ade ŠZ]Z|\l a gvwc`Zl za`\]_je`Zl gZ[Zl.
x]ZfZ]‚aˆ, g vZdZ]Zl cj\[w\d cz\|ag_de Zcd_g|wˆch fZcj\ c‚\^ag_`ah v_d}v_
z_ccw (cˆuezw) a gZ[w, Zf]\[\jade [ZgZje`Z f]ZcdZ — cvZjevZ c}gZ]Zdva cd\vjZ c
cˆuez}, cdZjevZ gZ[} a [Zo_ged\. ¤_vda†\cva z} fZjw†aja v_v o} gZccd_`Zgj\`-
`}l v_d}v, fZ†da d_vZl ^\ fZ fad_d\je`Zcda a cZ[\]^_`aˆ fZj\u`}Š [jh Z]y_`au-
z_ g\\cdg. ‹Z^`Z [Zo_gade [_^\ y_ua]Zg_``wˆ za`\]_je`wˆ gZ[w, g\[e fwu}]e-
va y_u_ fZzZywd ]_uz\|_de v]wfa`va cˆuez} c gZ[Zl.
iZdZg}l _l]_` f\ld\ [Z \[}, gz\cd\ c \[Zl a [_^\ fZcj\ \[}, \cja g_|_ \[_ o}j_
`\ cja|vZz ^a]`Zl — g ”dZz cjw†_\ o\u †_h `\ ZoZldace! €w a az\ld\ g ga[w, _l-
]_` — ”dZ a `_fadZv a \[_ Z[`Zg]\z\``Z.
ksq

Яблочный или айвовый


айран

šcja ŠZ†\dch wv]_cade gvwc _l]_`_, dZ ”dZ zZ^`Z c[\j_de cw|\`}za d]_g_za: †_-
o]\‚Zz, zhdZl, o_uajavZz a… [_^\ u\j\`}za hojZv_za. xwcde `_cdZadch, fwcde _]Z-
z_d f\]\l[\d g `_fadZv, _ fZdZz [Zo_ged\ j\[ a f\ld\ `_ u[Z]Zge\!
‡ v_v ŠZ]Z|Z Zc\`eˆ [Zo_gade g _l]_` _lgw [Zjev_za! “ZjevZ `_[Z ]_ugZ[ade \yZ
`\ gZ[Zl, _ `_cdZ\z _lg}.
xZ]\^ed\ _lgw [Zjev_za, u_j\ld\ vafh\l gZ[Zl a [_ld\ Zcd}de. xZjw†\``}l
`_cdZl u_z\†_d\je`Z y_]zZ`a]w\d c cˆuezZl, a _l]_` `_fZj`adch gvwcZz a _]Zz_-
dZz cZj`\†`ZyZ j\d_.
Райхон-щербет

Yg\^al ‘aZj\dZg}l o_uajav Zdja†`Z u_g_]ag_\d-


ch a [_\d `_cdZl ywcdZyZ, ‘aZj\dZgZyZ ‚g\d_. {Zo_ged\
g `_cdZl c_Š_], †dZo} g} `a [wz_ja Z cj_[vZz g d_-
vwˆ ^_]w. x]Z‚\[ad\ `_cdZl a [Zo_ged\ g `\yZ jazZ`- ksp
`}l cZv. €_cdZl zZz\`d_je`Z auz\`ad ‚g\d `_ h]vZ-
v]_c`}l, a w g_c fZjw†adch Zdja†`}l \]o\d. “Z†`Z
d_v ^\ |\]o\d zZ^`Z f]ayZdZgade au zhd}, d_]Šw`_ a
]ZuZg}Š j\f\cdvZg (dZjevZ ]Zu_ [Zj^`_ o}de ZcZoZyZ
cZ]d_, `\ f}d_ld\ce acfZjeuZg_de [jh f]ayZdZgj\`ah
|\]o\d_ owv\d, fZ[_]\``}l g f]Z|jwˆ fhd`a‚w).
Райхон-айран
kss

€_cdZ\z o_uajav_ zZ^`Z f]af]_gade a _l]_`. “ZjevZ


c_Š_] a jazZ` g ”dZz cjw†_\ w^\ `a v †\zw — _l]_` c
o_uajavZz a o\u dZyZ Zdja†_\dch u_z\†_d\je`Z co_j_`-
ca]Zg_``}z gvwcZz a _]Zz_dZz.
ks

Медовый айран

…cd_da, Z o_j_`c\! ‡l]_` az\\d


f]ahd`Z-vacj}l gvwc. «\fZdv_ cZja
cˆ[_ d_v a f]Zcadch! €Z †dZ, \cja
fZlda []wyaz fwd\z? ‰\[e `_z f]a-
hd`} `\ dZjevZ vacjZ-cZj\`}\ gvw-
c}, `Z a vacjZ-cj_[va\! “_v [Zo_ge-
d\ g cg\^al, dZjevZ †dZ guoad}l
_l]_` `\z`ZyZ z\[_! ‰} [_^\ `\
f]\[cd_gjh\d\ c\o\, `_cvZjevZ gvwc-
`Z fZjw†adch!
Шафрановый
щербет

‰Zd a \]o\d au |_‘]_`_ `\ cdZad fade


fZz`Zyw. ‰\[e [jh dZyZ, †dZo} \yZ f]a-
yZdZgade, f]a[\dch guhde cw|\`}\ zhdw
a o_uajav — d]_g}, vZdZ]}\ acfZjeuw-
ˆdch a g j\†\o`}Š ‚\jhŠ.
•d_v, \fZde |_‘]_`_ f\]\d\]\de
c †_l`Zl jZ^vZl c_Š_]_, [Zo_gade o_-
uajav a zhdw a u_g_]ade vafhdvZz. €_
fZj-jad]_ vafhdv_ fZjZ^ad\ [g\ cdZjZ-
g}\ jZ^va c_Š_]_, _ vZy[_ `_cdZl Zcd}-
`\d, g}f]_ged\ gvwc jazZ``}z cZvZz.
x]Z‚\[ad\ a ZŠj_[ad\ — w g_c fZjw†aj-
ch owvg_je`Z ‚_]cval `_fadZv!
Щербет
из кураги ksr

€Z vacjZ-cj_[val gvwc j\d`aŠ `_fadvZg


gZgc\ `\ Zohu_d\je`Z cZu[_g_de acvwc-
cdg\``Z, cZ†\d_h ]_uja†`}\ f]Z[wvd}.
‹Z^`Z f]ZcdZ guhde ŠZ]Z|wˆ vw]_yw
a u_jade \\ vafhdvZz. x]\v]_c`}l o_-
j_`c gvwc_ g ”dZz `_fadv\ cZu[_\d c_z_
f]a]Z[_! b\]\u `\cvZjevZ †_cZg, vZy[_
`_cdZl Zcd}`\d, fZcd_ged\ vwg|a` g ŠZ-
jZ[aje`av a f\ld\ wd]Zz, `_dZ_v. ždZ
`\ dZjevZ f]ZŠj_[ad\je`}l `_fadZv —
Z` \\ a j\†\o`}l! ‰ ^_]w Z` fZ[[\]-
^ad g_|\ c\][‚\, a c_z}z fZjZ^ad\je-
`}z Zo]_uZz fZgjah\d `_ cd_oaje`Zcde
_]d\]a_je`ZyZ [_gj\`ah.
‡ fZf]Zowld\ c[\j_de d_vZl ^\ `_-
cdZl au o_]o_]ac_ — dZyZ c_zZyZ, †dZ
wuo\va [Zo_gjhˆd g fjZg. ždZ Z†\`e gvwc-
`Z, dZjevZ ‘_]z_vZjZya†\cva\ cgZlcdg_
d_vZyZ `_fadv_ g}]_^\`} \\ h]†\, d_v
†dZ f\ld\ \yZ `\ cd_v_`_za, _ fZ `\cvZje-
vZ yjZdvZg.
Банановый коктейль

…_vZl u_z\†_d\je`}l vZvd\lje fZjw†_\dch au zZjZv_


a o_`_`_ u`_ˆd, `_g\]`Z\, gc\. ‡ †dZ, \cja fZf]ZoZg_de
f]ayZdZgade \yZ c _l]_`Zz? ’_`_`, f]Zdag `_|\yZ Z^a-
[_`ah, `\ f]a[_cd `_fadvw `\ZoŠZ[azwˆ cj_[vwˆ `Zd-
vw. “_v †dZ, ŠZdad\ aja `\d, f]a[\dch [Zo_gade `\z`ZyZ
c_Š_]_. €Z gvwc vZvd\ljh au _l]_`_ a o_`_`_ fZjw†_\dch
f]ZcdZ `\Zo}v`Zg\``}z! xZf]Zowld\ \yZ f]ayZdZgade,
a, h wg\]\`, ”dZ fZ[dZjv`\d g_c v `Zg}z ”vcf\]az\`d_z.
k~
~
kk

Малиновый эксперимент

—_uZd]ad\ z_ja`w c c_Š_]Zz, cz\|_ld\ c _l]_`Zz au cˆuez} aja


[_^\ f]Zcd}z lZyw]dZz. €\ u_ow[ed\ guoade. ‰\[e [_^\ c_z}l
jw†|al v_d}v aja z_‚Z`a, \cja \yZ `\z`ZyZ guoade, f]\g]__\d-
ch au \[} g u_z\†_d\je`}l `_fadZv. €Z cv_^ad\, †dZ ”dZ — `_fa-
dZv aja w^\ j_`†?
“_v †dZ a j\dZ a ^_]_ gZgc\ `\ fZgZ[ [jh dZyZ, †dZo} f\]\cd_de
dgZ]ade `_ vwŠ`\!
‰}[wz}g_ld\, f]Zowld\ a [_^\… Šwjay_`ed\!
‡za`e, ^_]_!
часть вторая
Вторая
перемена
блюд
¬
€_†_jZ jˆoZyZ c\]e\u`ZyZ Zo\[_ cZ k
ug_`}za yZcdhza fZ[]_uwz\g_\d d_vZ\
fZ`hda\, v_v u_vwcva. …Z`\†`Z, f]a-
cwdcdgwˆd Z`a a g `_|\l vwŠ`\. “ZjevZ
†_\ gc\yZ fZ[ ga[Zz u_vwcva g_z fZ[_-
[wd dZ, †dZ g []wyZl [\`e f]ayZdZgaja
o} c\o\ `_ u_gd]_v, `_ w^a`, _ a`Zy[_ a
gz\cdZ Zo\[_ — gch ]_u`a‚_ ow[\d cZ-
cdZhde g vZja†\cdg\ fZ[_``ZyZ. šcja
”dZ c_zZcdZhd\je`_h \[_, dZ fZ]‚aa
xZ[yZdZgaz ow[wd d_vaza, †dZo} aza zZ^`Z o}jZ
`_\cdch, _ \cja ”dZ u_vwcv_, dZ ow[\d
_ff\dad f]ayZdZgj\`Z cdZjevZ, †dZo} f]Z[\-
zZ`cd]a]Zg_de g_z g`az_`a\ ŠZuh\g a
f]Zow[ade g_|\ jˆoZf}dcdgZ — †dZ ^\
ow[\d [_je|\?
– zZyw `_fZz`ade g_z `\cvZjevZ u_-
z\†_d\je`Z fZ[ŠZ[haŠ [jh u_vwcZv
ojˆ[ au f]\[}[waŠ v`ay: [^au, [^au-
o}u, ]}ow fZ[ †\c`ZvZz a va`uZl, [Z-
gyw, hŠ`a a v_u}, fZ[_``}\ c cZwcZz au
cˆuez}, zZ^\d o}de, [_^\ `\oZje|a\
|_|j}†va — gc\ ”dZ fZ[ŠZ[ad [jh `_-
†_j_ Zo\[_. šcde a g ”dZl v`ay\ `\vZdZ-
]}\ ojˆ[_, vZdZ]}za ŠZ]Z|Z o} `_†_de
Zo\[. {_ gZuezad\ ŠZde d\ ^\ vwd_o},
o_vj_^_`}-jhg_`ya aja [Zjzw — †\z
5 + .  
6

g_z `\ u_vwcv_? ‰f]Z†\z, [Zjz_ — ”dZ w ”dZl d]_[a‚aa ]_cdwd au `\j\fZyZ, kr
w^\ `_†_jZ gfZj`\ c\]e\u`Zl \[}, `\- ‘_`d_cz_yZ]a†\cvZyZ, †w^\]Z[`ZyZ Zo-
czZd]h `_ ]_uu_[Z]ag_ˆwˆ _ff\dad ]_uZg_`ah — cZg\dcvZyZ Zo\fad_. ‰\]-
vacja`vw. `\\, au cZg\dcvZl ]\cdZ]_``Zl d]_[a-
€Z c\l†_c h ŠZ†w fZv_u_de g_z `\- ‚aa.
cvZjevZ ZcZo}Š g_]a_`dZg `_†_j_ g_- “_z v_va\ u_[_†a ]\|_jace? bdZo}
|\yZ Zo\[_, a [jh g_|\yZ w[Zocdg_ h vja\`d f]a|\j a vwjedw]`Z g}faj-
]_uoaj aŠ fZ d]\z y]wff_z. ‰}o\]a- u_vwcaj, cfjhc_j fZ[ Z]v\cd] a Zcd_gaj
d\ †dZ-dZ au v_^[Zl y]wff} [_ a f]a- g v_cc\ [\`\y. b\z wyZ[ade d_vZzw vja-
yZdZged\ g `\oZje|Zz vZja†\cdg\ d_v, \`dw? ‡ [_[az \zw c_j_dav fZ`_^Z]a-
†dZo} fZcj\ dZyZ, v_v yZcda fZfaja †_ˆ cd\\, cwf, gdZ]Z\ a vZzfZd — gc\, v_v g
cZ cj_[Zcdhza a fZf]ZoZg_ja g_| Šj\o, _]zaa, dZjevZ †wde-†wde wv]_caz f\-
zZyja wo\[adech g c\]e\u`Zcda g_|aŠ d]w|vZl a fZ[_g_de cd_`\z `\f]\z\`-
[_je`\l|aŠ `_z\]\`al. `Z c gZ[vZl-fagZz, †dZo} yZ]jZ `\ d_v
[]_jZ.
‡ g fhda[\chd}\ yZ[} cZg\dcvZ\
{_`e Zo\fadw f]_gad\jecdgZ a vZzzw`acda†\cv_h
f_]dah ]\|aja, †dZ Z[`aŠ f_gajeZ-
• gc\-d_va oZje|a`cdgZ ”vc-cZg\dcvaŠ `Zg `_‚aZ`_je`}Š ]\cfwojav `_ ‰{€n
jˆ[\l ]_ccz_d]ag_ˆd c_j_d `\ v_v _v- z_jZg_dZ ow[\d a `w^`} \\ cZZdg\d-
vZzf_`\z\`d v Zc`Zg`Zzw ojˆ[w, `\ cdgwˆa\ `_‚aZ`_je`}\ ]\cdZ]_`} g
v_v cZf]ZgZ^[\`a\, wjw†|_ˆ\\ o_- yZ]Z[\-y\]Z\ ‹Zcvg\. xwcde ow[wd f]\[-
j_`c Zc`Zg`}Š ojˆ[, `Z v_v `\†dZ, fZ- cd_gj\`} vwŠ`a y]wua`cv_h, wuo\vcv_h,
[_g_\zZ\ `_ ]_``\z, cd_]dZgZz ”d_f\ _u\]o_l[^_`cv_h, `w a d_v [_j\\…
Zo\[_, — g v_†\cdg\ fZgZ[_ [jh dZyZ, • g}ug_ja `_ ]_oZdw g ‹Zcvgw jw†-
†dZo} g}fade f\]g}l y]_‘a`†av. €Zya |aŠ fZg_]Zg au v_^[Zl ]\cfwojava. …Z-
Зелень

С
 
B-%MO   
-
01 0&  (2-
/ (8 & & 
kƒ~  & & &,  (
 (6

   
 */
“”. 3 E & ( & -
 

& ( , 0
/ *
0  &
& &* & -
0
&  *
1. & 
02*
 0   2&  8 — -
 , 0
 

&   '
,
0
   &
 &  & ( ,

 & &8 ( /!
“”  0  *   &-
 
& & & ( &), 


, &   0&   

& 0  6/8  (


  & (21 '
 /  :
& & /
&   * 
&-
( * 
. 3   , 0

  
 1 (
,  /-

*!
/8  *, “”  
 0   2   
(
“E /1 D
”, 
/1   * -
  *( 2(1 & *1
E(/,    *&)
8  (-
 &.  (0 6/
   

& &   &, 
.
9 0  
 / /


&0 &
0
1 6
1!
,   ! C & 

/   
  *, 0

 /   1 & 

, &,
6
, 6 &   ( & &
*0&. D  ,   &
  ,  & &   /,  -
& 7(6/, &  &  * 1 (-
1  & 
&    .
E&-
 &/ :&,  -
6/ & 6
 6 // —   / 
на столе

  
/, 0
   
&,
&/0&, '
* /   <
.
+ *- * / 6& & (&)/,
 22 /  
(6 & 
 — - kƒk
6 


  E(( & -
/2 
“
&  E( /,   &

,
  
& 
  & 

0& & & 6
,  6 & , -
 /
& 8”. 8&2&1 &
*(&-7&)&
 1   /
 E( &   
0& &  & :
“!
,  0&?!” — &   -
  : ( 
0  &.
0
    (
&-

 /   
&, 
21 
(
( (0&
 ,  2 /0-
/   && :1
/. L
/2 ,  (6 0, * /

 & &, 
*&  
)(:
“3(  0
 PM ( 1, "( 1?! C (&-
)( &

22 /?!”
“3
 6
   & 
 
/ !” — 
0 
).
5
( &
&   & 
(,
0
 &  /

   & .
% C  (
* , (2

 ,
 
* &0/, '
( -
  6


 
* -
* 
,  *
& &
(& & 
( , &  
 0& .
C
— (&
 & 1
  -
6( . 5
( 2( 6 / (2&
,
 : &*&
.
> C  0
  8
&
&

&
. E
-
  (-

( /
&  &
-
&   (. 3(   &   &

&  <
— 0

*? 
& /1
&
& ( &
  
,  / 6
   *  
  (  
& ?
)   “*+ 
 ”
  !      "  #
  ! " #    # $ "  1 0  , !    ,
     "      ,
   $ 1 0  . .  -+  
–   $ $  + $   
  :  ,  ",
  0!  —  #   ", !  ,
   #  # ! "   0

"#$ O 4$" /""

kƒm `\†`Z, v ”daz fZg_]_z o}ja f]acd_g- `_[j_z}g_de \\ z} `\ ow[\z, _ fZ-


j\`} fZg_]_ zZcvZgcva\, [_o} cv]Zade ]\^\z cZjZzvZl. • †dZ ”dZ u_ cˆuez_
z\`ˆ, cZZdg\dcdgwˆ\\ u[Z]ZgZzw Zo- w g_c d_v_h? …acjZzZjZ†`_h? €\d, ”dZ
]_uw ^au`a cj_g`ZyZ cZg\dcvZyZ `_]Z[_, `_z `\ fZ[Zl[\d, ”dZ o}cd]Z fZ]dadch,
Zoad_ˆ\yZ fZojauZcda Zd …]\zjh a z} jw†|\ z_lZ`\uZz u_f]_gaz. [`_-
wja‚} iZ]evZyZ. vZ, fZf]ZoZg_g fZjw†ag|alch c_j_d,
‹ZcvZgcva\ fZg_]_ cf]Zcaja wuo\v- wuo\vcva\ fZg_]_ cv_u_ja: “€\ wuo\v-
cvaŠ: “‡ †dZ w g_c ow[\d gz\cdZ c_j_d_ cval gvwc, `\ fZ-`_|\zw ”dZ!” — a [Zo_-
“YdZja†`}l”, vZdZ]}l Zjage\? b\z w gaja g c_j_d ^_]\`}l jwv. ‰Zd d\f\]e
g_c d_z, g ›uo\vacd_`\, f\]gwˆ ]ˆzvw gc\ v_v `_[Z! • fZ`\cj_ce cj_g_ Zo ”dZz
u_vwc}g_ˆd?” cZg\dcvZ-wuo\vcvZz c_j_d\ g `_]Z[, gc\
€_[Z cv_u_de, †dZ g ›uo\vacd_`\ v \yZ fZjˆoaja, cd_ja u_v_u}g_de g ]\-
dZzw g]\z\`a w^\ gfZj`\ u_vwc}g_- cdZ]_`_Š v f\]gZzw y]_‘a`†avw a u_-
ja a [_^\ g}fag_ja, fZ”dZzw d_vZl d_`‚\g_ja fZ[g}fag|a\ vja\`d}: dZ
gZf]Zc wuo\vcvaŠ fZg_]Zg `\ czwdaj. fZ[ “_`[a^_`cvwˆ fZjevw”, dZ fZ[ “g
`a Zdg\daja: “‡ u\j\`Zl ]\[evZl u_- €_z_`y_`\ hojZ†va”, _ dZ a fZ[ “›†vw-
vwc}g_\z, Z†\`e gvwc`Z. nZjZ[`}z [wv, d]a vZjZ[‚_”.
zhcZz — g_]\`}z aja u_f\†\``}z — ‡ z\^[w d\z zZ^`Z ”dZd c_j_d f]a-
u_vwc}g_\z. ‰Zd cˆuezZl \\ u_vwc}- yZdZgade g d_vZz g_]a_`d\, †dZ fZjw-
g_\z: u\j\`e, ]\[acvw dw[_ [Zo_gaz, [_ †adch Z` `_ c_zZz [\j\ Z†\`e gvwc-
a u_vwc}g_\z”. ‰c\ v_v \cde, f]_g[w cv_- `}z.
u_ja.
€w gZd a cd_j_ a`d\]`_‚aZ`_je`_h 95 5 $ %>5 %># <5"  -
o]ay_[_ fZg_]Zg cvj_[}g_de au gc\yZ ,  <!>, #! $%-
”dZyZ yj_g`}l wuo\vcval c_j_d. dg_]- 8$+  +$"8  >$+, 
`Z\ zhcZ — `Z]z_je`Z. —\[evw? €\d, !E+  <. !'% !"
5 + .  
6

$ 5*"8 &<$%, !%"   +%I- J -$ +&+ $&+ #+ kƒt
 $%8$ % 5& — !%>5 '& '& " 5 $  -
<+>", %58 ,  !  #, $%!& $%$ '& '< $,
"$  R ,   !  $> '*& +  %$+  +$"8
 <$%$ $ %. 5 !, %* !!& "8, <-
9* <5"   +5,     +, > + I !5. /"
 '"  !$>$ $$ $ > — !-   -
 5 (5 ! ' R+  $ “D<, " '%+,   — R $$ < >$%
'  ”). P5 R <"+- <$%"  * R !. ,
 # $%$ 5*" +5$, <- !$ 5 !, &%"  $%$
*"  &+ !+, ' +5 < $<, $$ "$  !*-
R 5 #, *& $%$ 5   ! ,  -
'" %$, !5* '>- *": !%" &, !* >+  -
$ +  +$"8, , !&!" *%.
$"$ # > !E, <&, F "$ % +$$ ! #
!*,  !5, & ,  , >   $+"  $.
  5, $% " $%$ $%- :  G<'$ "$% $ $  !-
8$, — '% 'I <. J R . H'&> <8  *+,  !+
+& $+ +5, '5<& '>- $$ '& +&8 $%>$  !%$8 
$,   > >  !%- %8 %8 %. K"$ !%>-
, !%  $!5$,  !+ +  5 I >, !"  <+>"
5   &" !5+  '%". 4- !* " +5& '8, "
+ &" +5   +% '%". 8+>$%. A $%>$ "$   '%-
A*" +$+  !  <- % &5" , !R+% %># -
$    <$%$,    #  <"  &+ *+ +$, >%"
 ! <+>"! $%!, >+ +$"  !.
"#$ O 4$" /""

kƒs :  %$ — >" *& $+! #  (, $, * # '&
R . A$&  ! '- !!" +"8 , > !E 
*8  +  $. F%#- <&, $%8  # $% -
, % R $%  5. H * '%  '& *" ). " %5I
+5$, $&, % > R $? T%$   $& %$& $E * +
<" &+ $"E+  '*"  %$#. / ++  "
 @8,  "  '"#+ $>  $+!, %I & $%&
+  + +  * *.  +&: %$, + +5, "$.
 *$  @8  '&!" W * ! <5"  !+%
%$ +%$,  !+ !*"    $%$+ !#$,  R %* !<%> $$
5%" #88 +%$% ('% %*,  <5 <$%$.
R +%$ !+ &!5  +,  A  !5 <!5"! +? A%
 +, ! &+ $%+  !-  +<&+ * +<+,  $E-
  E). 7 & !+ - $E! /", 5 $,  R
 '*& %$ !5 %5I+  !$$  $  <$+-
!< "  'V+  >". &+ <5+  +<+-  55-
D>, + < @8    85 — $, +" &, !5 $$
%*, !R+% '*& %$ %* +  '"# +.
'% &*"  @$%. $ %$ - J  *, > !",  # -
5>,  +* '&!" +"8 +$ +>$5 $$ 5  $5,
, $ !E  $ + &#5 < @E$ *$  <-
<&. & !$ $!$? A -
H'&> 5 '*%"  R+  '< ", 5"  <'&", $$ #&
& 5E,   %* & # ! ? A, 5, * $%5, $
! $>$+% !%,  5E, <-  5. P '%+ >&+ 5
& "$+, %># "  %$- '& +  ' … <"++   +

6          :          
   . &      7  ,    ,     
          ,    ,    " -
. *  ,      "      " ? ,    
        : ,       .
5 + .  
6

% ! !% +< — !E" 5  + ,   #+ $%+. kƒ
R . / +* !'"5 $ $
T%$  @8 *? E- +,   $E '" $  !&
 #5 +. /<"+  ,  +  ! R !!'%
$"$ !'5 5 *$ $%$ <!$%. P* I%I"5 “$% $%”:
+5. H'*"  + $%$ +5  - <! * %$, &" *
,   !* , 5  +5,  'I  * <" !-
!#%, $ ,  & !+ !+ !- $%, $$  !"55I-& '.
>+%. 9 ! *$ +5  &- / !" + +5 5 I -
 —  *   ' +   . %" R '% #+
* %$,  + +5,  !E, +"$+ $+,   <"++
$&+ & !!5 +5! H +  %$%,  -#'! /& * !5-
> !5.  ', $$5 <E !%>5  $%-
4%'$ >$  $, $ +% *$   +<? /+ 5*,
 ! 5E,   R " '-  !$%, $&  %$%, !-
+  . O!", !- %>5 @%$-$5 $  '&+
*5 '" '+, * "+ ++   +!
 + +, #5 ! +5,  A%,  , > E # +< !-
%* &#  $+ +!%&. %>5  !&> '&  $+&,
T"+ > $!5+, >&+ *>$-   $ — $ &,  <8,
+, +, >'&  + " +*  R $+%- !+#"? /"
!"8  +5 '+ +- $%  <! +$ * E.
 " . F %>+ A 5 $, 8<"+ -$
'V+ + +* " +. D- ' !" # 5 R -
 $>5 + <-! +5, <"+ ! F8<"+ — !$ '-
% " +,  '5<"- 5 <!$, , $+ ,  5

8 … (  ? +            "     ,


   
 ,  
   (),       ,   
        .        "     -
 ,  ",    ,   , ", 
, ,      
 . *     —      " ,        ?
. -

   
 "   
     # 
–
!   
% !   
  
  ,   "
 

"#$ O 4$" /""

kƒƒ  +$ & E. /" 8<"- ‹Z]vZgZ†v_


+% $  !"<%8 '&>: +#8 
<"8, $, $&+ !E+, &- ‰ …Z]\\ Z†\`e jˆohd z_]a`Zg_``}l
$&8 $ ! '8,  - d_]Z[a. “_v `_u}g_ˆd vZ]\|va ZcZoZ-
$% $&8 +5& <$%$. D yZ ]_cd\`ah, ]_cdw\yZ g[Zje yZ]`}Š
> — '+$ +5  <!- ]w†e\g. šcde [_^\ vZ]\lcv_h `_]Z[`_h
%8 8<"+%, $  > — ' + f\c`h f]Z d_]Z[a, a ”dw f\c`ˆ vZy[_-
8<"+& !#$,   8'+ %> !%- dZ acfZj`hj_ zZh u\zjh†v_ — g\jav_h
>5 >" +>  $%. [Z†e wuo\vcvZyZ `_]Z[_, _]zh`v_ fZ
f]ZacŠZ^[\`aˆ a `_]Z[`_h _]dacdv_
‰ Zo\z, \cja dZjevZ Zdo]Zcade `Z- gc\yZ YZg\dcvZyZ YZˆu_ “_z_]_-Š_`wz.
cd_jeyaˆ fZ cZg\dcvaz ]\cdZ]_`_z, d_- …Zy[_-dZ d_]Z[a o}j \[Zl o\[`}Š
vZl c_j_d ow[\d g}ay]}g_de w c_j_d_ jˆ[\l. €Z, v_v †_cdZ cjw†_\dch g vwja-
“YdZja†`}l, _-jh wuo\vacd_`” f]ZcdZ `_]aa, au \[} o\[`hvZg d_]Z[a cd_j
`Zv_wdZz. xZdZzw †dZ `\u_†\z fZ[- [\jav_d\cZz, a d\f\]e \yZ fZ[_ˆd g
z\|ag_de g cz\ce ‘]_`‚wucvZyZ c `a- ]\cdZ]_`_Š a ]_ugZuhd fZ gc\zw cg\dw,
^\yZ]Z[cvaz \\ a wuo\vcval. ˜[\ce fZ vZ]\lcvaz z_y_ua`†av_z — [jh
a d_v d]_y\[ah, cfjZ|`_h ‘]_`vZ- yw]z_`Zg, [jh jˆoad\j\l vZ]\lcvZl
ad_jeh`cv_h z_lZ`\u`Z-c}]`_h Zf\]_, vwŠ`a a [jh ˆ^`}Š vZ]\l‚\g, Zv_u_g-
]_cdh`wg|_hch `_ ‚\j}Š [g_ g\v_, _ \\ |aŠch `_ †w^oa`\. ‰Zcfad_``}\ `_
a z} j\u\z cZ cgZ\l ]\[evZl. €a†\yZ cgZ\Zo]_u`Zl `_‚aZ`_je`Zl vwŠ`\
cd]_|`ZyZ — Zdcdwfaz `_ |_y `_u_[, v vZ]\l‚} fZ[Zjyw ZoŠZ[adech o\u f]a-
d]_[a‚ahz, †dZo} †\]\u ”da d]_[a‚aa, g}†`Zl az \[} `\ zZywd, z`\ []wueh-
acfZjeuwh za]ZgZl Zf}d, f]alda v `Z- vZ]\l‚} yZgZ]aja: “šcja h d]a [`h
gZl vwŠ`\, v `Zg}z ‘Z]z_z, `Z j\yvZ vaz-†a `\ fZ\z — w z\`h ^agZd
wu`_g_\zZzw cZ[\]^_`aˆ! u_oZjad”.
"#$ O 4$" /""

kr~ x]\[cd_gjh\d\ c\o\, v_vZgZ o}jZ `_- …Z]\l‚}-dZ yZcd\f]aaz`}l, Šj\oZ-


|az, cZg\dcvaz vZ]\l‚_z, vZy[_ aŠ cZje`}l `_]Z[, [_^\ a g d]w[`}\ g]\-
`\cf]_g\[jagZ, `a u_ †dZ `a f]Z †dZ z\`_ gc\y[_ ZŠZd`Z [\jajace `\ dZjevZ
cZcj_ja au ]Z[`}Š z\cd `_ {_je`\z cgZaza ]\‚\fd_za, `Z a \[Zl. YZc\[a [_
‰ZcdZv\ g Y]\[`ˆˆ ‡uaˆ? š[_-dZ fZj- []wueh f]ZoZg_ja, Šg_jaja a… `_†a`_-
`Zcdeˆ []wy_h, j_`[|_‘d []wyZl, f]Z- ja yZdZgade zZ]vZgvw a c_za — oj_yZ,
[wvd} []wya\! `a†\yZ cjZ^`ZyZ g ”dZz [\j\ `\d.
ždZ w^\ fZdZz vZ]\l‚} fZjˆoaja • gZd c\yZ[`h o\u ”dZl zZ]vZgva fZ-
wuo\vcval fjZg a z_`d}, `_]h[w c vwv- vZ]\lcva f]ZcdZ `\gZuzZ^`Z f]\[cd_-
ca `_w†ajace yZdZgade Zdz\``}l j_y- gade vwŠ`ˆ c\yZ[`h|`\yZ ›uo\vacd_`_,
z_`, _ g`_†_j\ Z`a f]ZcdZ f}d_jace _ dZ a \[g_ ja `\ fZjZga`} fZcdcZg\d-
u_z\`ade f]ag}†`}\ az f]Z[wvd} cvZyZ f]Zcd]_`cdg_.
z\cd`}za. • d_v fZhgjhjace ojˆ[_ au “_v z_jZ dZyZ, g ›uo\vacd_`\ [jh ”dZ-
wuo\vcvaŠ f]Z[wvdZg, `Z f]ayZdZgj\`- yZ c_j_d_ a `_ug_`a\ f]a[wz_ja ZcZ-
`}Š fZ vZ]\lcvaz d\Š`ZjZyahz. oZ\. ‰ v_†\cdg\ vZ]`h acfZjeuZg_ja `\
‹Zyw cv_u_de, †dZ vZ]\lcv_h \[_, wuo\vcvZ\ `_ug_`a\ zZ]vZga, _ f]hzZ
f]ayZdZgj\``_h c _wd\`da†`}za f]Z- ]wccvZ\ cjZgZ “zZ]vZge” a f]ao_gaja
[wvd_za, u_†_cdwˆ g}ay]}g_\d w _[_f- v `\zw wz\`e|ad\je`Z-j_cv_d\je`}l
da]Zg_``}Š ojˆ[. €Z g cjw†_\ c d_]Z[a, cw‘‘avc “-†_”, a fZjw†ajZce zajZ\ a
vZdZ]}l [Zy_[_jace u_z\`ade zZ]vZg- u_o_g`Z\ cjZgZ zZ]vZg†_ — `_fZjZga-
vZl, fZjw†ajZce `_ZoZ]Zd. ‹Z]vZge, `w wuo\vcvZ\, `_fZjZga`w ]wccvZ\, `Z
z_]a`Zg_``_h f]az\]`Z d_v ^\, v_v ZoZu`_†_ˆ\\ vZ]\lcvwˆ u_vwcvw. i[\
d_]Z[a, fZjw†_\dch d_v gvwc`Z, †dZ ”dZd \\ zZyjZ ]Z[adch d_vZ\ cjZgZZo]_uZ-
c_j_d-u_yZdZgvw fZjˆoaja a gc\ []wya\ g_`a\? €ay[\, dZjevZ g ›uo\vacd_`\!
`_]Z[}, f]Z^ag_g|a\ oZv Z oZv c vZ- ‰Zd [_g_ld\ a fZczZd]az, v_v d\f\]e
]\l‚_za. yZdZghd d_vwˆ zZ]vZge.

2    ",   “    ”.   ,    ,    -
 . +       :     ,   ,  
  .    ,  # #        ,   !
       
   —    , ,  -
,      ? +    ,        
. 8          ? < -    ,
     .
 
' 
6

A %*,  +& !-+% '%+ - +$5 +$ ! R !E%& krk
". / $,  & *. $- * "5 E,   !"5
 +$" ! $ — $$ -  $#.
5,   !$  *". O"$  9$" +* *" +% 
  #$+ " !*+" $ - $  %  <5"5 !>+ !-
$,  , >'& $>$  !"E %$+. A!+,  +$ !<"
'. H $ !5*5 +$" >$. A &" <  $ >-
+* &$"<%" < %$  +& - $$,  !" ! +% !$-
!5I ++. :  $, !$ "8 *, <'*5 < '5 +
!*5,  !  *+ "5$ !,  ! <5"  !-
<,    + !  '5, - <" +$+ $%'$+. ", $>-
+  " !*+5 %>$% & <%" >" <   $
* $ $. +>!
F* +$   %  !- 4 %$ +* !<" "
& +$$  > $ * *+ $%!! H + %* "$ 5 ,
!" +$. / !%>5 < >'& '*"   +,  !+
'&, >+  $,  $$ . %'"  < + … &'".
 $++ +$ *5 +- /<"+ E& + $, !-
% < (3–0C,  ! '"# $     % $$  !-
 '&. $  %!$ $, >'& " I%-
O!" $*& $++ +$ +& $%!$ — !!5  <%', 
 !"   *$ ! <&85 $%+, <8 $-
. E. + +5? /- % -
J,  !5 #$+ '"# %- %8 *$%, '"#  !
,  !*" +$", +- '5 I ! & *$
 !+#5   "8. K<%+5,   % $& *%> !E. -

' ,   
 ? )   7         ,   
  -                —  -
.  ,           ",  ,     
     ,        —       
!"  -"" !
"#$ O 4$" /""

krq +, $$ 5 !%!8  R+ !%$- +& +< %$+. T"  
+: 5 8   %!$ +, !$ !E  >$,  $% $5,
<   !%>5 < E !%- !  +.
. W %* !5",  !%%8 $*E%
 !E &'". U   8'8  - ˜`_\d\, g ›uo\vacd_`\ o}jZ acfZje-
+  — $$ +$ !E  $#, uZg_ja ]_ug\[\``wˆ wvcwc`wˆ ”cc\`-
 $%>$  $*E& $  5 !- ‚aˆ. ‰_z ŠZ†\dch acfZjeuZg_de ”dZd
!%" $ <%'+. : % $$  $ <%'+ !- f]Z[wvd? ‹`\ `\d. ‰ vZ`‚\ vZ`‚Zg, ”dZ
!%,  $ %+% +% !I"- dZ^\ o}j_ u_z\`_ d]_[a‚aZ``ZyZ `_ dZ,
 $? A %*. 9* <5" ! †dZ o}jZ. ‰ …Z]\\ [_ `_ {_je`\z ‰ZcdZ-
+& !E,  "$ + >5 $$ v\ guhja o} ŠZ]Z|al ]acZg}l wvcwc; yZ-
+* ' + !" dZgaj o} h ”dZd c_j_d g ›uo\vacd_`\, d_v
*%>"  %. /& +* !%!" guhj o} ca]v_ — ga`Zy]_[`}l wvcwc,
$$ !&$, %  '% +5 — !!- vZdZ]}l dZ^\ g}[\]^ag_ˆd a fZjw-
'%, $$ 5 %8! †_\dch Z` `a†wde `\ Šw^\ o_jeu_za†\-
4 R +5 +$" !% $. cvZyZ wvcwc_. €w a fZ†\zw o} d\f\]e `\
F  $$%, "$ +  guhde `\cvZjevZ jZ^\v o_jeu_za†\cvZ-
% —  >" &. A <8 *, yZ wvcwc_, \cja Z` [Zcdwf`\\ ca]va a wv-
$$  +* !"<". : +$" cwc_ ]acZgZyZ? {wz_\d\, Šw^\ fZjw†ad-
 I < *"  I < " >" ch? {_ `a†\yZ fZ[Zo`ZyZ! “ZjevZ cja|-
$%. vZz z`ZyZ c]_uw `\ j\ld\, [Zo_gade
: !" +$" * $,  gc\y[_ zZ^`Z, _ gZd wo_gade… dZjevZ u_
% R $ &* >$, !- c†\d [Zo_gj\`ah zZ]vZga!
>& , $, *$%-%%8
> !E 5 +  !  A%*  $$ % !+#", !-
$!5I+ "&+ ++, $ !'", &!" $% "8, +,
! .-
 
–    
   -" $

 #   "
–
 "
–   "   

 
 
2    

 (
. 
6

!E+, %$%+. O"$ %>&, > `Zl \[Zl gZd w^\ z`ZyZ fZvZj\`al: `a- krp
$ 5, !%>5 ! vdZ `\ czZ^\d f]a[wz_de `a†\yZ jw†-
F$&  '$%, %+'&, |\yZ v |_|j}vw, `\^\ja u_f\†\``}\
 !%" 5.  >< !5"- `_ z_`y_j\ ZgZa. ‹`\ [_^\ `\w[Zo`Z
#" +* %*  !!'",  - ]_ccv_u}g_de Z d_vZz f]ZcdZz c_j_d\,
< !%>5 + #! F$"$ g\[e \yZ yZdZghd f]_vda†\cva gc\. €Z
+$> 5  "$? A%, gc\ ^\ fZcjw|_ld\.
>, > $ 5 %  $$-
 ",  <   + @$, P5 <!$5 > !% '-
 "$ %58  — + $ !- $*&, %$-!, '$ !E&,
5 " %8 !E8, * &- & !E&  !+&. J+  %,
'&" !>%8! > 5 !> % I   %>-
+ !5$,    ! !*-
xj_z\``}\ " !5, —  + +&-
, > '$*&  <!$" "#
ZgZa ,  !+&, ' $%!&
“$''-!+&”, '%% & '&
 _]vaz j\d`az [`\z, vZy[_ `_z\†_\d- . 4"  >$ +$ !*+. 4-
ch oZje|Z\ []w^\cvZ\ Zo\`a\ gZv]wy !>& I >+, *+ +-
z_`y_j_ a c zhcZz gc\ oZj\\ aja z\`\\ $+ $%'$+  +#+  >$+  <-
fZ`hd`Z u_]_`\\, gcd_\d []_z_da†\cval "8. O!" — !".
[jh gchvZyZ vwja`_]_ gZf]Zc: _ †dZ fZ- A$&  R+  >8
[_de v |_|j}vw? …_vwˆ u_vwcvw, v_vZl !E%% !5 $ -
c_j_d? €_g\]`Z\, f]_gaje`\\ gc\yZ fZ- ,   +* " + $%-
cdwfade u[\ce d_v, v_v f]a`hdZ w d\Š, . /-!&, $ + $ R+%
[jh vZyZ |_|j}v hgjh\dch d]_[a‚aZ`- % ! !5 — " +.
"#$ O

krƒ

!'%  <,   <%  : , $, > !$ !%+-
!5. /-&,  " < - ": >,  "  #+!% ! $%-
#, !->+% &I&  %- >$%  $* I  '%" 
  ! E+ !+,   !- "$+   $+  <!>"  +-
% % '%+%8 $$% — -    !E 5> 
> '"#  !'5. A, 5 $ ##&$%?
< !+, $& <8  ! YzZd]ad\, c_je`av g}cdwf_\d v_v o}
E+,   $, %* &+  ZoZjZ†vZl, g`wd]a vZdZ]Zl ZgZa `\
%!$&+, !  $ !'- f\]\c}Š_ˆd, `\ fZ[yZ]_ˆd. €\cvZjevZ
8, — 5 I%I8 5& $ $% v_f\je ^a]_, vZdZ]}\ fZf_[wd `_ ZgZ-
 +. a, fZzZywd ZgZ_z Zoz\`hdech gvw-
 "? 9* !"<" - c_za a u_f_Š_za, _ v]Zz\ dZyZ, _]Zz_d
+& $, '&& '&+ '<+ — Zd wyjh a v_f_g|\yZ g `\yZ ^a]_ [\j_\d
!+#+ $%'$ +  - ZgZa f]ZcdZ [\jav_d\cZz! • `\ o\cfZ-
+  !%8I+ *++ %$+. : vZld\ce, ]_[a oZy_, Z ^a]`Zcda — c`a-
+* <5" -#' — %&  zad\ ”dZd c_je`av gZgc\ f\]\[ wfZd]\-
%& ! & $. / R oj\`a\z, c_zZ\ yj_g`Z\ — oZv_j ga`_
'% ! >" #! `\ u_ow[ed\ `_jade!
% 

  #   
2    

  
 
 ,   #  ", ! 
 $ "  —   

 4   * 
6

x]a ‚_]\ iZ]ZŠ\ v yZ]ZŠw aja v_jjh-yw|d (wuo\vcval krr


g_]a_`d u\je‚_ aja Š_yyac_) [\j_ˆd
x]ZcdZ Z†\`e, Z†\`e ŠZ]Z|Z, \cja `_ u_gd]_v g\cez_ fjZd`}z. €Z g\[e a g
cdZj\, c]\[a f]Z†aŠ u_vwcZv, cdZad \\ _]_ocvaŠ cd]_`_Š Šwzwc fZ[_ˆd jaoZ c
a Šwzwc — Z[`_ au c_z}Š ]_cf]Zcd]_- ^_]\`}z zhc`}z ‘_]|\z, jaoZ c dw-
`\``}Š a c_z}Š f]Zcd}Š g f]ayZdZg- |\`}za o_vj_^_`_za — [_ z_jZ ja
j\`aa oja^`\gZcdZ†`}Š u_vwcZv, vZdZ- †dZ \\ zZ^`Z fZ[_de gz\cd\ c ”daz u_-
]wˆ yZdZghd au yZ]ZŠ_ `wd. z\†_d\je`}z vw|_`e\z!
‰ZZo\-dZ vj_cca‘a‚a]Zg_de ”dZ
ojˆ[Z acvjˆ†ad\je`Z v_v u_vwcvw, zZ- / 8'+ %>, 5  >'&  -
^\d o}de, `\ gfZj`\ g\]`Z. ‰\[e Šwzwc # 5,  '5<" 
zZ^\d g}cdwf_de a g v_†\cdg\ u_gd]_- <+>",  " R %># <.
v_. • gZd †dZ a`d\]\c`Z: g ›uo\vacd_`\ J !!5 *,  -
ojˆ[Z au Zdg_]\``ZyZ yZ]ZŠ_ — `ZŠ_d- '&  !%#& , $  !
Šw]_v — fZ[_\dch az\``Z `_ u_gd]_v. <+> '% >" '& —
“ZjevZ \cja [jh Šwzwc_ yZ]ZŠ f\]\-   >. A >I 5 , >'&
da]_ˆd g Z[`Z]Z[`wˆ f_cdw, dZ `ZŠ_d-  '% $$ %   &+ $
Šw]_v — ”dZ ‚\je`}\ yZ]Z|a`}, f]a- $, '%5 =,    (0 >. /!-
f]_gj\``}\ cZjeˆ, v]_c`}z f\]‚\z >+, "5 <>+: + *  -
a dZ`vZ `_]\u_``}z jwvZz. …Z`\†`Z, 5"  +  R +5, '%5 #"
g ›uo\vacd_`\ yZ]ZŠ g_]hd c Zohu_d\je- <"   ! !% "
`}z vwcvZz ^a]`Zl o_]_`a`} aja c 5>, >'& %$  !, ,
zZuyZgZl vZcdZ†vZl; c†ad_\dch, †dZ yZ-  !+ !% < <+" &#%8
]ZŠ, cg_]\``}l g f]ZcdZl gZ[\, z\`\\ %. A$& '58 ! <+>-
gvwc`}l a `\ d_v ŠZ]Z|Z ]_ug_]ag_\dch.  %,   ++  R '-
€\cvZjevZ fj_cda`Zv Zdg_]`ZyZ zhc_ +, "$   #$+ *$5.

+                   -
 ,   /0–=0>. (           ,    
  ,  #    . + ,    ,   “  ”   
 . + ,     . &#        —  -
 ,  
     . @    ? +     ,  
  ,           .   
      ",     . ),    
   ,   ,  —  .     —   -
 ,         A0>. '   ,  ,    #  …
 4   * 
6

9*% + 5 <+>5  ,  Q&  $"  %#,  m~t
% ''&,  *  $+%- %,  $  5, &" 
5 '" +%8 %>#%8 !"%8 % (!- !" —  I !5.
", $% & '8 >" "  P"# +* ! %+5 <&+
R <!), $5 !  + !%5+. & — ' !&, <
! '&" *$, $ >    +*- !5I $ ++% <%"%: -
 <'&". &  I >" 5>  
 <+>5  '5<"- !%"  '"#%8 +$"  
 # !+&"  !" "    !5+ + !" 5+,
+ 'V+ &. D$ "$ <$!,   5 , >'& <" #&,
%* 5" !%,  !+ !$&" $-  "$ >'&   " '>-
88 $&#$  %"  $. 7 '>$ ! !&%  !-
$, >'&  #$+ '%. ",  +5$"  5 
/ <+    +5 . 9* '&", !5 !" !-
$ +* ""5  >  - E8, ,  %, & %'", >
'"#+,  >&,    # >. $- '>$ ".
A '" !" %: '% <  +%, %!I+% %
%*,   5! D, !!-  $%8 +>", $$ '>$ #,
'% !!'" 5  $- +* +5   'I". O"$ 5
$% — $*5, R $$ <  %>, $ + * $<", > #5 $%-
 ! %+. A, $  >,  5 !#"  < %5 $
", >'&   &$!: -  “+>”  I" '85
> !"  $"$+ #- +> " *&…
+, >'& 5 $85  !' O!"  %*"5 '+
<! ,  $ %*  <'-  !"   %8 !%.
"5. /  R ++ & !+ !+,

+   (   )     # .
)  "  —  B0 C —      . D   ,   -
 —      #  ". +     —      .
"#$ O 4$" /""

m~q 5 > 5 !   &" 5>%8 # $%. /+ +* !'"5
%,  $  5. P'5 '" +,  $% !$*5 -
 — + +5! + +"> 5- > $+  &I&+, 
5 $%!$ , + '"#   + $,  %+% '% #$+
'%8 5 5 !",  $+,  >$  !E,  '%
#$+ % $E.  " &… /* I  !"-
D+ &  %8 !% !'%-  !",   <'" %+% #-
5 '" $ +, +& $+ *$, > %>5 % + !
$, >$, ", $& *%> !E   ! < “&+  !%$E”.
<%. J '5<" + !'5 $%- A   R+ %> $$ : -
*%5 ! — .  “ *" <$”   +5 !-
O$ +5 $ #+% %+%%. A &&- 5,  ! !> %+%  .
!  <& !!&  !8 \   & %+% %>#
<  <%, '" > !- $ +, %$"  +-
%  !+#  . +  !5&+  $%  %8I+ <
P"# & +* !"  !E5+,  %+% !%>5 $+, >
!&!" !+%,  <+  #  '%% I   ' !".

+  ,  —
   "     "  . 8   -
      ,  "  "         ! (    
    ,              . )-
,     ,       
       
 # . *    ,          ,  -
              . 8       —
    " " , "          , —       #"
    " .          !
ª
y]_oj\``}l gZ]_za a acd\]u_``}l m~p
Š_jdw]av_za, u_]\ywja]Zg_``}l †a-
`Zg`av_za a auzZ][Zg_``}l `_]Z[`}z
vZ`d]Zj\z, u_fwy_``}l Zo”Š_”cZz a _j†-
`}za c_`ad_]`}za g]_†_za cZg\dcval
Zo\fad f]\[cd_gjhj cZoZˆ v]_l`\ ^_j-
vZ\ u]\ja\, [_ \\ a o}j acvjˆ†ad\je-
`Z g]\[\` [jh u[Z]Zgeh y]_^[_`. …Z\-v_v
cza]adech zZ^`Z o}jZ c cw\cdgZg_`a-
\z ja|e d\Š dZ†\v fad_`ah d]w[haŠch,
{\|\gZ g vZdZ]}Š z\`ˆ cZcdZhjZ au [gwŠ-d]\Š
cd]Z†\v, _ Zc`Zg`Z\ ojˆ[Z f]\[cd_gjhjZ
a c}d`Z cZoZˆ Zo\fadZgcvwˆ a`d\]f]\d_‚aˆ
v_vZl-`aow[e d]_[a‚aZ``Zl `_]Z[`Zl
\[}: f\jez\`\l, fa]ZyZg, oZ]_...
{\jZ g dZz, †dZ \cde `_ cg\d\ y_cd]Z-
`Zza†\cva\ d]_[a‚aa `_cdZjevZ `\woa-
g_\z}\, ]\‚\fd}, `_cdZjevZ Zd|ja‘Z-
g_``}\ g]\z\`\z, †dZ `av_va\ Z][}
y]_oad\j\l a d]wd`\l `\ cfZcZo`}
wŠw[|ade aŠ [Z cd\f\`a `\c\[Zo`Zcda.
‡ au Zo}†`Zl ^_]\`Zl v_]dZ|va aja
o\jh|\l zZ^`Z c[\j_de d_vZ\ ojˆ[Z,
vZdZ]Z\ `a†wde `\ Šw^\, †\z \[_ au c_-
z}Š ug\u[_d}Š ]\cdZ]_`Zg za]_. dwv_
dZjevZ g dZz, †dZ g ”dZz cjw†_\ yZdZgade
`_[Z ‘ajay]_``Z, o\uwf]\†`Z...
$ 
   :
  0 #  
   *   +  "
         " "+
    +    
  !:     #  
  # $   , "
           #  $  

"#$ Q 5/)/  26"-

m~s …]}zcva\ acf]_g`Z ]_oZd_\d, f]a`Zcad ŠZuha`w


f]ao}je, a `\ g_^`Z, †dZ w^\ j\d fhd-
†\ow]\va, `\whugaz}\ `_[‚_de v_v g `\l `\ Zcd_jZce `a Z[`Z-
a `\fZdZfjh\z}\ yZ v]}zcvZyZ d_d_]a`_. ‰Zd v_v [\jZ
o}jZ fZcd_gj\`Z! b\ow]\va-dZ dZ†`Z
• gZd `\[_g`Z h yZgZ]ˆ Z†\]\[`Zl o]a- d_va\, v_v fhde[\chd j\d `_u_[…
y_[\ cgZaŠ fZg_]Zg: …Z`\†`Z, f]ayZdZged\, i_l]_d-_v_! –
— ‡ u_gd]_|`ˆˆ g\†\]a`vw z} `_†- fZz`ˆ d\ †\ow]\va j\d c fhda-c\za, c
`\z c †\ow]\vZg. xZv_ `_]Z[ cZoa]_\d- dZl fZ]}, vZy[_ zZa \\ zZjZ[}\ ]Z-
ch a ŠZuh\g_ [Z^a[_ˆdch Zcd_je`}Š [ad\ja o]_ja z\`h c cZoZl `_ o_u_].
yZcd\l, fZcd_gaz Z[a` fZcd w gc\Š `_ xZv_ gc\ fZvwfva u_g\]|a|e — f]ZyZ-
yj_u_Š a cd_`\z d_z ^_]ade †\ow]\va — jZ[_\|ech, gZd Zd\‚ a gcd_g_j g Z†\]\[e
fwcde u_vwchd a g}d]wd ]wva owz_^`}- v ZvZ|vw, au vZdZ]ZyZ †\ow]\va g}j\d_-
za c_j‘\dv_za. ja v_v au fwj\z\d_.
“wd Z[a` fZg_], i_l]_d-_v_, dZ^\ vZ- — ‹} d_z fZ gZc\ze †\jZg\v gcd_-
]\``Zl ‘\]y_`\‚, v_v a h, gcd]\f\`wjch: g_ja g Z[`w fZdZ†`wˆ ja`aˆ, †dZo}
— Yd_jav-_v_, _ [_g_ld\ h f]ayZdZg- o}cd]Z fZjw†_jZce. ‡ vZy[_ `_[Z o}jZ,
jˆ †\ow]\va. – ]_`e|\ ]_oZd_j c v]}z- cd_gaja [g\, [_^\ d]a fZdZ†`}\ ja-
cvaza d_d_]_za g †\ow]\†`Zl `_f]Zdag `aa: Z[a` d\cdZ z\cad, []wyZl v_d_-
o_u_]_, w z\`h †\ow]\va ŠZ]Z|Z fZjw- \d, d]\dal zhcZ ]woad, †\dg\]d}l jwv
†_ˆdch. ]\^\d… —_`e|\ `_z zhcZ `\ ]_u]\|_-
— bdZ? ‰} f]Z dw u`_z\`adwˆ †\ow- ja †\]\u zhcZ]wovw v]wdade: ]woaja
]\†`wˆ, †dZ [\]^_j_ c`_†_j_ d_ d\dv_ — g]w†`wˆ aja [gwzh `Z^_za, aja dZ-
v]}zcv_h d_d_]v_, _ fZdZz \\ c}`, a fZ]avZz. ‰ Zo\z, [_g_ld\ z`\ vajZ-
vZdZ]wˆ vwfaj w `aŠ …_Š]_zZ`-ŠZ[^a? y]_zz_ [g_ zwva, cZje, gZ[w, h u_lzwce
‡ u`_\d\, g\[e ”d_ †\ow]\†`_h a d\f\]e d\cdZz.

2        ,         "-   " 


"     ,        -  “  ” . ,
 ,  -    " "         — -
            # " "   ,     
  "  "  "    #,      "  
    .

7

bdZ a yZgZ]ade: i_l]_d-_v_ w^ dZ†`Z m~


fZjw†aj v]\fva\ a [ZcdZl`}\ u`_`ah,
d_v cv_u_de, au f\]g}Š ]wv, — Zd d\Š c_-
z}Š v]}zcvaŠ d_d_] g ‘\]y_`cvZl †\-
ow]\†`Zl, v vZdZ]}z fZf_j cZgc\z zZ-
jZ[}z, \\ [Z _]zaa. ‡ †\ow]\va d_z
o}ja f]ZcdZ g\javZj\f`} — gZd w^ `\
c]_g`ade c d\z woZ^\cdgZz, †dZ `}`†\
fZ[_ˆd g Z[`Zl u`_z\`adZl zZcvZg-
cvZl †\ow]\†`Zl, w^ g} f]Zcdad\ z\`h,
zZcvga†a a yZcda cdZja‚}. iZ[_ d]a `_-
u_[, fZ[[_g|ace wyZgZ]_z a gcfZza`_h
a`d\]`\d-gZcdZ]ya a`d\]`\d-[]wu\l
ZcvZ]Zzajch h g ”dZz u_g\[\`ea‚\ d_v,
†dZ [Z caŠ fZ] `\ u_ow[w dw au^Zyw. “_v
†dZ yZdZg \\ a \\ ]_u g_c wyZg_]a-
g_de: yZdZged\ †\ow]\va c_za a `\ ^_-
j\ld\ [jh ”dZyZ `a g]\z\`a, `a caj.
‡ caj} fZ`_[Zohdch, ZcZo\``Z [jh
dZyZ, †dZo} u_z\cade d\cdZ.

F+: 0 $++ +%$. Q++ 2CC


+  !!&, >'& $&", 
"%8 +%$% !+ $ !
. F  # $ %%'-
, &!+ % "  "+ '"#%8
5/)/  26"-

m~ƒ >" < +& )CC + -


 &. A>+ <+#" ,
!! '55  %%' +%$%.
F+ <<& $+>$  -
 E, !&$+ >"8 #-
5 &, 55 I >%"->%" ! <!,
, !5 +$+" %, &+-
#+, '5 ><&> % 
  $+$. F*+ !%>#5 !
$$+, <+  !I%8 !$%
 + !+  > — &*"5.
O+ ++ !++5 < @#. M-
# !%>5,  <5" !% +
5&  5&  +#"  '-
 (>%" '"# $++  %++),
 '"  @# <5& $%$ $%-
8> . D$ %'" @#, & <,
<" +  <$+. O"$ '5-
  @#  +5 %'$ %. /& !-
+, , <>+ $   'I!?
O$ ,   %* #$+ #"
%*" R% +%:  $>& <%"-
  % >" !".
P"#: +$ !<" %$ &+
*+. H*" +  +5  %$, 
!$  +#".

7

W !" R %$ $%! "8 m~r


 $"$ +% !" <  $
5*&+ !+  '" !$+,
!#+5,  >'%$ !%>5 +
> — + R  %.
O!"  I" &++: @#,
%$, %'%8 <" — %$!  !%#-
$% — >& !E  !E ! *8,
  !'I. A R+ R! "+
 !- # +5 '%".
F%#,  > & %5" '-
8 '"  @# '%"? /& +5
<& ! +, $$ @# %'"?
D, !$, *$ "? /  -
 < R '%",  +  !-
5!
O!"  %* <<"  
& $%$  &5%" <  &,
& *%&. H R *% %* '%-
 &" $%$  ++ ! 3C.
F+, + &",   <".
G*5 *%  %$  % +-
 &, %"5 !5 < $E
*% , 5% +  !5", <-
$  %$%  %  " $-
+$. + $"  $'$  !"
5/)/  26"-

mk~ $ %, @+ <  '"#%8 -


!#$%.
F+, $$ R  Q-$.
/ — <! — '"#+ !"E+  -
%. / — ! — $5 $ E%. / —
! — !. / — >&! — !-
   * +, <% <-
$%  C %. : !+ !"
#$  %'" & <$ 
!$$, !&!  +%$, >'& 
!". :  " +5   > -
 '& <+# ><&> $%,
 ++  5  '
!$+  5%>+.
O!" ' $$%  > $-
". K"$, "$,  !# — 
%  !%>5. A % !% >5
&*" !&- *$ @#, <-
5", *" >" !!+ …
A,  !"E+! F$$! F$$ !-
$& $5 >'%$, >'&   
$+ %>  !5,  !% ! #%,
 &!%  *+  +.
/" @8 ! R !5 +5".
A%  !$ '<" @%&+ $-
$+ ! #%.

7

J $& >'%$,  . mkk


P + *"  $ >+%, $$+ '& %!%-
+  %+  '& # .
L" >'%$  %'$ @8E.
9  *. A R$+"  ! &-
' +, <"+ !>, $ 
+ 5$ &* ' <!-
,  >$ &+5 5 '&  0BC ]. 7
*, !+% > *" >'%$  
>" 5>+ @8. 9& * >'%-
$  %$E !, +!% $-
 '& &  00C ]: ! $
+!%  *55  ! -
  "#  +%. D>, !
*$  % 5"  #
+%$, >'&  !" $% + &+.
A '% $$ %*& &$&" >'%-
$  @$, >'&   $ #
+ — # + !  '%,
%58 , 5 *"  !5  -
" '"#+ $> @8: %>#,
>'&  !E !5   $-
" % %,  !5 "
 !%. D, +5 %'5 !% 5
*$ >'%$ — #$,   %'$
$<,  I %># $$ $.

7

‰Zd g} `\ fZg\]ad\: vZy[_ `_|a v]}z- ‡u} z_]v\da`y_ mkt


cva\ †\ow]\va au ”dZl ‘ZdZc\ccaa w^\
^_]ajace, fZugZ`aj au _”]ZfZ]d_ zZl ‰c\-d_va z`\ c z\cdZz ]Z^[\`ah Z†\`e
ojauval []wy ž`g\] •uz_ljZg — ‘\]- fZg\ujZ. €w y[\, g v_vZl \\ dZ†v\ za]_
y_`\‚, v]}zcval d_d_]a`, yad_]acd- zZ^`Z o}jZ o} `_w†adech fZ[ja`-
ga]dwZu, — Zv_u}g_\dch, Z` dZjevZ †dZ `}z ojˆ[_z c_z}Š ]_u`}Š `_]Z[Zg
f]aj\d\j g ‹Zcvgw. `\fZc]\[cdg\``Z Zd aŠ f]\[cd_gad\-
— €\z\[j\``Z vZ z`\! — u_v]a†_j j\l, [_^\ `\ g}\u^_h au ]Z[`ZyZ yZ]Z-
h. — x]ZoZg_de †\ow]\va! …jh`wce, `\ [_? ‰Zd dZjevZ †dZ h ]_ccv_u}g_j g_z Z
fZ^_j\\|e! ojˆ[\ v]}zcvaŠ d_d_] — †\ow]\v_Š.
˜`_\d\, v_vaza Z`a fZjw†ajace, †\- €Z g\[e g ›uo\vacd_`\ ^ajZ `\z_jZ
ow]\va `_|a? xwu}]acd}\, j\yva\, \\ a v_u_`cvaŠ d_d_], _ ”dZ cZgc\z []w-
gZu[w|`}\. “Z`\`ev_h Š]wcdh_h a y_h `_‚aZ`_je`Zcde, a oZj\\ dZyZ, v_-
`\ ZdzZv_ˆ_h cZ g]\z\`\z uZjZda- u_`cva\ d_d_]} — a`_h g\dge dˆ]vcvaŠ
cd_h vZ]Z†v_. “Z`†_l|\\ d\cdZ fZ[ `\ˆ. `_]Z[Zg. ždZ dZjevZ `_ug_`ah cŠZ^a\,
YZ†`}l, acd\v_ˆal _]Zz_dZz ‘_]|. †\jZg\v `\cg\[wal cv_^\d: ““_d_]} a
• u`_\d\ †dZ? šcja g} c†ad_\d\, †dZ v d_d_]} — v_v_h ]_u`a‚_?”
†\ow]\v_z dZjevZ “fhde[\chd d]\dal” €Z `_ c_zZz [\j\ v_u_`cva\ a v]}z-
fZ]dg\|Zv [_ fjZ[ZgZg}yZ[`Z\ “†_|- cva\ d_d_]} `\ fZŠZ[aja []wy `_ []wy_
z_” fZ[Zl[\d, dZ g} Z|ao_\d\ce. x\]\- `\ dZjevZ g`\|`\. •Š vwjedw]_, hu}v,
jag_ld\ g [\v_`d\]} g_|a “y]_`[ v]ˆ” zwu}v_ a d_`‚} — gc\ az\jZ c\]e\u-
a “]\u\]g}”, `_jag_ld\ ga`_ g ŠZ]Z|a\ `}\ ]_uja†ah. —_uwz\\dch, a vwŠ`h w
oZv_j} dZ`vZyZ cd\vj_ — gZd ”dZ ow[\d ”daŠ [gwŠ `_]Z[Zg o}j_ cZg\]|\``Z
[ZcdZl`}l _vvZzf_`\z\`d `_|az †\- a`Zl, g\[e au`_†_je`Z Z`a ^aja g cZ-
ow]\v_z! g\]|\``Z ]_u`}Š vjaz_da†\cvaŠ wcjZ-
gahŠ, cw\cdg\``Z Zdja†_jch j_`[-
"#$ Q 5/)/  26"-

mkq |_‘d, [_g_g|al ”daz `_]Z[_z f]Z[wv- gahz jw†|\yZ, †dZ \cde g []wyaŠ vwŠ`hŠ,
d} fad_`ah, `\ yZgZ]h w^\ Z o}dZg}Š `\ c_z}l ja ”‘‘\vdag`}l fwde ]_uga-
wcjZgahŠ. dah cZocdg\``Zl vwja`_]aa?
€Z fZzazZ gc\yZ f\]\†acj\``ZyZ xZdZzw-dZ a Zo\fad `\ Zcd_jch g
\cde \\ Z[`Z ZocdZhd\jecdgZ, Zf]\[\- cdZ]Z`\ — cvZ]Z fZ gc\zw ›uo\vacd_`w
jhˆ\\ `_]Z[`wˆ vwŠ`ˆ. – yZgZ]ˆ Z cd_ja yZdZgade o\jh|a. {_, o\jh|a —
gvwcZg}Š f]\[fZ†d\`ahŠ a d]_[a‚ahŠ, v_u_`cva\ d_d_]} †_cdZ `_u}g_ˆd aŠ fZ-
cZŠ]_`ag|aŠch Zd v_vaŠ-dZ Z†\`e [_j\- []wyZzw: “f\]\zh†” — cd_ja `_cdZjevZ
vaŠ, `Z gc\ ^\ ZoaŠ f]\[vZg. fZfwjh]`}, †dZ fZf_[a vdZ g d\ g]\z\`_
• gZd gvwcZg}\ f]\[fZ†d\`ah a d_- g ›uo\vacd_`, fZ[wz_j o}, †dZ ”dZ wuo\v-
d_] v_u_`cvaŠ, a d_d_] v]}zcvaŠ f]a- cvZ\ ojˆ[Z.
|jace fZ gvwcw… wuo\vcvZzw `_]Z[w. {_ €w †dZ — w[Zo`Z ^\! oZ]w[Zg_`ah,
a `\ dZjevZ wuo\vcvZzw — cZ g]\z\`\z `\ZoŠZ[azZyZ [jh Z]y_`au_‚aa oZlvZl
gc\ `_]Z[}, f]Z^ag_g|a\ g dZ g]\zh g dZ]yZgja, `w^`Z cZgc\z †wde-†wde, f]Z-
›uo\vacd_`\, cd_ja yZdZgade vZ\-†dZ au [wvd} c_z}\ f]Zcd}\, fZjw†_\dch c}d-
v]}zcvZl vwŠ`a, _ vZ\-†dZ au v_u_`cvZl. `Z, gvwc`Z, _ f]ao}je d\†\d ŠZ]Z|az,
˜`_\d\, h c†ad_ˆ, †dZ g ›uo\vacd_`\ `_[\^`Z ^w]†_az ]w†\lvZz. • †dZ
f]Zcd}\ jˆ[a, [_ a ]wvZgZ[cdgZ f]\[- w[agad\je`ZyZ, †dZ dZ†va fZ f]ayZdZg-
f]ahdal Zo\cdg\``ZyZ fad_`ah Zd`Z- j\`aˆ o\jh|\l Zo}†`Z cZc\[cdgZg_ja
cajace v vwŠ`hz `ZgZf]ao}g|aŠ `_]Z- c z\cd_za, y[\ zZ^`Z o}jZ vwfade ywz-
[Zg Z†\`e f]_gaje`Z — Z`a f\]\`az_- zw — ŠZ]\uzcva\ fa]Z^va c jag\]Zz!
ja jw†|\\, o}cd]Z [\j_h ”dZ wuo\vcvaz. {_ a f\]\`_cd]Zade f]ZaugZ[cdgZ ywz-
bdZ c dZyZ, †dZ a cgZh vwŠ`h [Zcd_dZ†`Z z} `_ o\jh|a a Zo]_d`Z — [\jZ fhda
]_u`ZZo]_u`_ a oZy_d_? xZ†\zw o} `\ za`wd, dZjevZ v_]dZ``wˆ g}g\cvw fZ-
c[\j_de \\ \\ oZy_†\? • u_azcdgZg_- z\`hl. ˜_g\uja `\z`ZyZ zhc_? ’\jh|a,
`a\, f]acfZcZoj\`a\ v z\cd`}z wcjZ- [\chde vZf\\v! €\d a `\ ow[\d zhc_, _
!(    
7

\cde “wŠZ-yZ]jZ-`Zc”? x]\v]_c`Z! ‰Zd …ZzcZzZjecvZyZ Zu\]_. • o}j zZl [h[h mkp
g_z ywzz_ — †\d}]\ vZf\lva! Z†\`e vZjZ]ad`_h ja†`Zcde a `Zcaj
žl, cdw[\`d}! žl, ]_oZ†al! žl, o\[`Z- f]Zuga\ €Zje-€Zje.
d_! ˜_vwca, †dZo `\ v]w^aj_ce yZjZg_! – `\ u`_ˆ, Zdvw[_ guhjZce ”dZ f]Z-
xZcjw|_ld\ ]_ccv_u Z[`ZyZ zZ\yZ uga\, `Z w z\`h \cde z}cja fZ ”dZzw
[]wy_, u_z\†_d\je`ZyZ †\jZg\v_ xZj_ fZgZ[w. ‰z\cd\ c o\jh|_za Z` fZjw†_j
g_jeo\, †\l ^au`\``}l fwde `_†_jch [jh f]Z[_^a jZd\]\l`}\ oaj\d}, f]Z-
g fZcj\gZ\``}\ yZ[} g ›uo\vacd_`\ a [_g_de aŠ o}jZ gc\ ]_g`Z †dZ f]Z[_g_de
`\[_g`Z u_vZ`†ajch g ‡z\]av\. —_ccv_u gZ[w gZ g]\zh fZdZf_. ` Zfj_†ag_j aŠ
v_v ]_u f]Z o\jh|a a f]Z dZ, v_v Z`a cdZazZcde au cgZ\yZ v_]z_`_, d_v v_v
f]Z[_g_jace. g\]`wde aŠ o}jZ `\jeuh (`\g}fZj`\-
‰ krsk yZ[w… wo\^_ja au [Zzw czZ- `a\ fj_`_), a g `Z†e fZcj\ ]Zu}y]}|_,
d]\de ^au`e. €_z v_u_jZce dZy[_, †dZ u_jag_h oZje fZd\]e fZ]dg\l`Zz ““]a
^au`e a d]_g_ u\j\`\\ `_ []wyZz vZ`‚\ c\z\]va”, ]g_j oaj\d} `_ vwcva a g}-
`_|\yZ ja†`ZyZ yjZowc_ (†ad_l YZg\d- o]_c}g_j aŠ g dw_j\d, vZdZ]}l, v_v a gc\
cval YZˆu), a †\]\u `\[\jˆ z} Zv_u_- w[Zocdg_, `_ŠZ[ajch gZ [gZ]\. • `_ gZ-
jace g nj\o`Zz yZ]Z[\ (†ad_l “_|v\`d). f]Zc: “…dZ w vZyZ g}ay]_j — Z` w yZcw-
€_| o_y_^ cZcdZhj au cz\`} o\jeh, [_]cdg_ aja yZcw[_]cdgZ w `\yZ?” — Z`
zZ[`}Š g dw fZ]w wuvZ`Zc}Š dw‘\je `_ gc\y[_ Zdg\†_j: “€Zje-`Zje”, g cz}cj\
dZ`vZl fZ[Z|g\, fZ kp ]woj\l `_ o]_d_, fZ `Zjhz, aja `a†eh.
_ d_v^\ au fZj`Zl wg\]\``Zcda g dZz, “\Š`av_ f]Z[_^a o\jh|\l w `\yZ
†dZ u\zjh az\\d ‘Z]zw †\zZ[_`_. dZ^\ o}j_ `_ g}cZd\. Yd_]_hce f\]\-
› z\`h g “_|v\`d\ ^aj [h[h — [Z- v]a†_de a o\u dZyZ |wz`}l o_u_], Z`
o]\l|\l [w|a †\jZg\v, _jvZyZjav a f]agj\v_j fZvwf_d\j\l ]_u`}za ]\-
f]Z[_g\‚ o\jh|\l w gŠZ[_ `_ o_u_] (`_- vj_z`}za f]au}g_za. [a` au `aŠ h
ug_`a\ u_o}j). ’_u_] `_ŠZ[ajch gZuj\ u_fZz`aj `_ gcˆ ^au`e. ‰Zd Z`:
/
   :   !:
     # $ 
 $      
    ,
  0 #  
   #   ,  1    +    
        #  
'  3 ", "+
 .     , "
 . .        #  $  

"#$ Q 5/)/  26"-

mks “xZ cjw†_ˆ woalcdg_ zZ\l ^\`} (za- †_d\je`Z yZdZgaj_ zZh o_ow|v_-`\zv_,
zZj\d`_h f_wu_) `_w†ag|_hch Zd cZc\[Zv — v_u_`cvaŠ
f]Z[_\dch u_ fZj‚\`} (d_ ^\ f_wu_) d_d_]Zv.
`\ y`\dch a `\ jZz_\dch (u_dh^`_h YzZd]ad\, †ad_ld\ a u_fZza`_ld\.
f_wu_)
^\j\u`_h v]Zg_de”. /+ '&> $++ +%$ +&
“_v †dZ _u} z_]v\da`y_ Z` fZu`_j <5 "$ =CC ++, !+% > %
\\ u_[ZjyZ [Z f\]\cd]Zlva, [Z vZdZ]Zl  '& ># !+ "5$5
Z` `\ [Z^aj. +%$, !<>5 5 !5
Yg\dj_h f_zhde xZjw a \yZ [h[\, h !EE&. /" & <, >  <+
c Zy]Zz`}z w[ZgZjecdga\z yZdZgjˆ  !+   < "%5 $-
g cd_]a``}Š v_u_`_Š, vZdZ]}\ Z` vZj- > *$, '+ 5 <+-
j\v‚aZ`a]Zg_j a f]acj_j `\vZdZ]}\ #5 ?
”vu\zfjh]} z`\ g fZ[_]Zv, `Z, c_zZ\ : 5  + !'" 
yj_g`Z\, h a c\yZ[`h `_ŠZ^w g \yZ face- 5E, !- $&$ (+* <5" 8-
z_Š, `_fac_``}Š `\cvZjevZ j\d dZzw ' $ +$  * $@), (3C
`_u_[, cZg\d} fZj\u`}\ a _vdw_je`}\! + &  !>$ % **,
€_[\ˆce, †dZ vZy[_-dZ a g_z Zv_^wd- >5  $++ +%$. K<%+-
ch fZj\u`}za d\ f]Zcd}\, `Z `_[\^`}\ 5, " — >%" +"# > *$,
]\‚\fd} ojˆ[, Z vZdZ]}Š h g_z ]_ccv_- <%+5,  — !> !5 -
u}g_ˆ. – cd_]_ˆce g}g\[_de c\v]\d} 5 *$. " + —  + -
w z_cd\]Zg cgZ\yZ [\j_, c]_g`ag_ˆ ]\- + %>#, 5 !'  $  R$.
uwjed_d} c d\z, †dZ yZdZgaja w `_c g c\- / !%$& 5 <+#5 
ze\, a [\j_ˆ g}gZ[}, vZdZ]}za c w[Z- *& '&" !&+. O %># <+-
gZjecdga\z [\jˆce c g_za. €_fac_de Z #" %$+,  &+#"   !-
o\jh|_Š z`\ o}jZ `\d]w[`Z — aŠ u_z\- *+ #$+ '"# %  -

&      !    ":  "          -
  ,   . E          
,  !            -
. )   ,    
          !
4         !   —       ,     ,
        ,   #     . F  ,   ,
…         ?

7

, !+% >  !%>5 +5$+, - mk


#  $+, $$  >'%$.
 &+#5  +*"
"&+ ++ <,   '%-
 !", +*"  !"
,  $ > 5!>$ 
"  !+ + !". W
 $% !, %$  5-
+. H * <>" %>"-
5  'V+.
F+ +5 <5"5 @#+. 95
' !*" !%$%&+ *+, '
<%' !$+,  %$ !*" +$
 !  +  "8.  R
+# @#, !!" >&+ !-
E+  %'  ! +. S#
* +"5 5 '&  !>,
 '% I %>#,   ! >
!,    . T#" '&   *!
F @#+ 5 %++&  ' -
$"$ *. U  >% %>"  !-
+%,  >% $<&", $$ !-
" V'& @# < ! !%$.
/& *  '% R+ $+"! 9 -
 $<&"  +, > '-
+ " 5 , >'& &
!
  :
  0 #  

  $ ! "   

  "
  " 
  

  
 , "

5/)/  26"-

mkƒ !*$ !%>" % %+  !-


&+. R+% 5 $*% + 
!*,  &  < !!'% $
!",  + %* + # — !-
 + +   .
P5 #  @# 5 '%
!<& $%>$+ $%8$, +
+5 '< !$  *, !>", !>$, >%"
'"# E  " + %$.
&+  $$% !55
. W  &!% + * 
 %! I * <<"5, $$ $
% '55 %$. D$ "$ %$ -
 !<>&+,  $$% &$&-
5 +5. A  *", $  +5
'<%5 $>$. 1% "  ,
>    !%,  "
!'. O  $$% !5-
5 E, >< $ +5 !>$ ,
 !88 >", $$ +& *&
!%$, — !>".
O!"   !", !!"
>&+ !E+  '&>&+ %+ -
+ — !%#$  %$!+. %" -
*+ $$ &,  $$
&, +* !5"  +5%'$% 

7

$%! #$. /, @# ++ mkr


!%>5 <&+ —   #" !-
%? A> # —  !*$
   ! !
A +5 $ #+% %! H'&>,
$ '8  +,   !!&5-
8 +%$%. A + R " "<5, !-
+% > # E" — "  $+
* +5$+  *&+, $$+  %  !-
%>". R+%, >'& +%$ < !!&-
  !+#" $ %   <+5-
  $E8, +& +*+  %$ 
 "&+ ++.
G& "8 '+& $%-
$   !*+ , $$ '& &-
5 <%#& #$. D*& #-
$ * " !+ 6C ++,
<!++ R% E@%.
D  #$ '%% &,  
< <+#   !%>5 !-
+ 0C–00 #%$, %$  !I
!$  " I < !".
 #$    ,
'5 !%#>$+ !"E, -
 '"# %%', +
<5 <$%  <+ >
5/)/  26"-

mm~ '8E. G  * !%>"5 >,


!* @+  %<'$$%8 !#$%.
/ @#,  !%"  5 
$+ +!%&. / % -
!#$ !* BC–3C ++ @# 
!  ! %%'8 &+
+. F"  #$+ " -
"  @# — ! + * !
A+ >" * "  *".
1  < '$, 5 
  @+% <  $$.
F! $$ +*% ', 55
! $ !. A
'!$", > &>$ !%>5 #-
$+ '"#. 4$ 5 '5# !-
5 $&&+  , I < !-
%, <'%%,   +5 *$ <'%%
I '"#,  &>$  + +-
"$! :  + %*, > %<
<>+,  > %++% <+.
P5 %++& <5  +>-
&+  + %$+  '"# '.
J< @# $ $'$%  !*
!,  >%" !'* $ '. A-
$ $'$% + $+ , <-
+ <"+ < $5    !-

<      ,   


      " "
  .  "    -
,   
    .
        "  
      ,  -
   . &      
 , ,         -
,      " !
!(    
7

, !+ , + 5  !-  '<%5 #$+ , < R mmk
* %. O!" ! !$ +5  %! !!"5 ++ 
$'$%, >'&  %"  "  *&+.
  $ . / #& $*%5 <- "5 +!% *$ <-
$&&+ R+ $+. %" <$ 5  < **   >$ %-
%++& !*, ! +. 4 R  — (6C–()C ]. J >" *, >'&
+5  * &$ $5 + '. <5 ' !  +,  
/, !+ $ !! 4", % !&, - *  $$. /'I 5 *$
# #5 *% $& !&. $ < %' !"<" -
9& $ >'%$ * — + '"# $%& $<>$,   $-
< <5, !>  >$ &+- $%. /    " "$ +,
5. : 5 *$ '5#  %++& +- $"$  %8 $$%,  '5# 
 $ " <"  . 4" !*$  + !8 ', !%-
  >+  —  %  **, *85  + "$, $"$ R
 I  $+ +$,  >" !&#- '+,    '$  5
, !%<&>, $. K<%5"  +- ' !$ !* . A
 I '"#,  5 $$ '& - '!$", '5#  !%>5 <-
++  >" ! ! +!- # *&+, "    $>
%%  + %* %", $ @#%. +, $ & !"<% ! *$,
R+%, 5  >'&  @# !*-   +!%, ! $ *55 <-
5, '+ $ +5. W 5!
+!% + '% >" &$, 15# !%$8  + &>$
  %* '& <%+55,  <. A '!$", @# % 
@# 5 &+. &!! H !$5 *
/  * +5  *" '5# ! @#  $&+ ++  + +
<$ +!% +,  $>$  '& '<%5 !%<&", $&, -

&      ,              , -
    . +  ,           ,  
           ,          
   .
"#$ Q 5/)/  26"-

mmq ', '% "  @# <%, !- 5, R $ 5 >,   
+5 . !>5. A% , $ + !-
  $$ *55 >" <%+5- . O"$  *"  ,
5,  !%" '5#  % * " %- @# %* !$>$
"  &>$% *$% +. H *$ &. /, > +% %*, — R <-
$ + @# <!%<&5, "5 %  =C,  < R +5 -
<#$>,  R '% >, >-  %* !"5  !!&
'&  !' $% !* +5, !>$.
$& 5 # $. A '-
!$",  *$ + '5#  - ˜`_\d\ †dZ? šcja ŠZdad\, fZc}fed\ ywz-
% '+ *&+, < %* zw c_Š_]`Zl fw[]Zl c vZ]a‚\l a fZ[_-
!%>5,  @# % 5 g_ld\ \\ c †_|vZl ŠZjZ[`ZyZ a fZ[cZj\`-
&+, +&+. `ZyZ v_d}v_ aja v\‘a]_, f]af]_gj\``Z-
L" %++% %* > $ *, $$ yZ uwo†avZz g}[_gj\``ZyZ †\c`Zv_. €w
 '5#, — !%$5  +  - a †_l, vZ`\†`Z!
,  &$. W %++ > !- €_ v_^[wˆ yZjZgw fZ dˆo\d\lv\, g
  $<,  &  *,  ]wva fZ gj_^`Zl c_j‘\dv\ a f]ahd`ZyZ
+ !5  %*& ++. H _ff\dad_, zZa [Z]Zya\ d_d_]†_d_ a d_d_-
*$ !%<& <%   <%8- ]Z†va!
­
– gZ|\j gZ [gZ] a u_cd_j d_z cd]_``wˆ mmp
v_]da`w: fZj[ˆ^a`} cd]Zad\j\l o]Z-
caja ]_oZdw a, u_cd}g v_v acdwv_`},
zZj†_ wcd_gajace g Z[`w cdZ]Z`w. “_z,
g c_zZz wyjw, cd]Zaj_ce zZh j\d`hh
vwŠ`h a ŠjZfZd_j cZc\[ –Šeh: Z` fZzZ-
y_j z`\, f]a`hg `_ c\oh Zohu_``Zcda
u_gŠZu_ a v_|\g_]_. €\cvZjevZ [`\l `_-
u_[ g ”dZz wyjw wcd_`Zgaja `Zg\`eval
`\oZje|Zl d_`[}]; yja`_ a va]fa†a,
€_wv_ c_zc}: vZdZ]}za \yZ ZojZ^aja, f]ZcZŠja, a
g†\]_ \yZ w^\ ]_cd_fjag_ja, f]Zg\]hh,
Zd d\Z]aa ŠZ]Z|Z ja g}|jZ.
xZv_ h |\j †\]\u [gZ], ]_oZ†a\ cd_-
v f]_vdav\ ja cfwcv_dech c j\cZg, fZ[`az_dech au
d]_`|\l a dZ^\ fZ[ŠZ[aja gc\ oja^\,
cZoa]_hce g wyjw, gZv]wy –Šea. • dwd Z`
Zdva`wj cd_]\`evZ\ g_d`Z\ Z[\hjZ a [Z
z\`h `_vZ`\‚ [Z|jZ, g †\z dwd [\jZ.
‹\`h f]ZcdZ Zv_dajZ, z\`h `_v]}jZ
u_f_ŠZz. ‡ g\[e h †wgcdgZg_j \yZ, vZy[_
\\ dZjevZ cgZ]_†ag_j `_ `_|w wja‚w,
fZ[wz_j: `_[Z ^\, v_v cZc\[a gvwc`Z yZ-
dZghd. ‡ ”dZ, Zv_u}g_\dch, u[\ce, w z\`h…
“_v gZd [jh †\yZ –Šeh wd]Zz, fZjw†_h
]_cfZ]h^\`ah `_ [\`e, fZf]Zcaj [\`\y
`_ d]a vajZy]_zz_ o_]_`a`}!
"#$ P 7!' 226: " "/ ' '"'/

mms –Šeh c`hj v]}|vw. Y_zc_! ‰Zv]wy €_cd_gj\`ah


yZ]jZga`} f\†a Zo]_uZg_jch fjZd`}l
v]wy au yZjZg jˆoZf}d`}Š. zZjZ[}z
— ž, fZ[Z^[ad\, ”! dZl[ad\ Zdcˆ[_!
•[ad\, ]_oZd_ld\, \\ `\ yZdZgZ, `\ ga- — žl, z_je†av! ‹_je†av, a[a cˆ[_!
[ad\, †dZ ja?! •[a, h d\o\ †dZ-dZ ]_ccv_^w. ‹_je†av,
–Šeh cd_j u_†\]f}g_de f]ayZ]|`\l u[\ce c_[ace, z\`h cjw|_l. bdZ d_vZ\
gZ[w au vZg|av_ a o]}uy_de `_ ]_cv_- d_`[}], u`_\|e? xZ†\zw `\ u`_\|e? ž,
j\``}\ cd\`va d_`[}]_ a c_zcw, cZfh oZje|Zl z_je†av, d_`[}] u`_de `_[Z,
a wda]_h ]wv_g_za fZd. €_ ja‚\ \yZ u_- d_`[}] gZuj\ [Zz_ Zohu_d\je`Z cd]Zade
cd}jZ g}]_^\`a\ dZ]^\cdg_: cd]Zad\- `_[Z.
ja [Z caŠ fZ] `\ caje`Z Z[Zo]hja \yZ ‰ d_`[}]\ j\f\|va zZ^`Z [\j_de,
cd]hf`ˆ, _ gZd ”dZ o}j_ `_cdZh_h fZ- c_zcw zZ^`Z [\j_de, d_`[}]-yw|d,
o\[_. b\]\u za`wdw, wo\[ag|ace, †dZ zhcZ `_ _]†Zg}Š g\dv_Š zZ^`Z [\j_de.
d\zf\]_dw]_ cd\`Zv g d_`[}]\ cd_j_ nZ†\|e, d_`[}]-v\o_o zZ^`Z yZdZgade,
†wde `a^\ a d\f\]e c_zc_ f]Zf\†\dch gchvwˆ fda‚w g d_`[}]\ acf\†e zZ^-
[Zj^`}z Zo]_uZz, Z` gZ[]wuaj v]}|- `Z. nZ]Z|_h g\e d_`[}]! ’\u d_`[}]_
vw d_`[}]_ `_ z\cdZ, c`Zg_ d_d\je- d}, z_je†av, v_v gZZo\ yZcd\l gcd]\-
`Z wv]}j \\ g_d`}z Z[\hjZz, \\ ]_u †_\|e? — —wccval hu}v w –Šea o}j d_v
g}d\] fZd cZ jo_ a f]ac\j `_ `au\`e- c\o\, `Z z_je†av `av_vZyZ []wyZyZ hu}-
vwˆ d_ow]\dZ†vw ]h[Zz. xZdZz fZ[z_- v_ fZv_ `\ u`_j.
`aj f_je‚\z cZc\[cvZyZ z_je†wy_`_- — ‰Zd czZd]a, z_je†av, d} f_]_oZjw
vZ]\l‚_, u_|\[|\yZ gZ [gZ] ow[dZ u`_\|e? — –Šeh gcfZz`aj cgZa cdw[\`-
o} cj\[Zz u_ ‘wdoZje`}z zh†Zz, †\cva\ yZ[}, vZdZ]}\ Z` f]Zg\j g fZ-
_ `_ c_zZz [\j\, vZ`\†`Z, dZ^\ `_ jad\Š`a†\cvZz a`cdadwd\. — ’\]\|e
u_f_Š… f_]_oZjw, f\]\gZ]_†ag_\|e, gZd d_v v]w-
3 
#   ( 
8

da|e, gZv]wy ”dZl ja`aa — Zce f_]_oZ- |\]cda, f]ZcdZ au va]fa†_ dZ^\ zZ^- mm
j} `_u}g_\dch. xZ`hj? ‡ †wde-†wde `\ `Z, z} f]Zg\]hja, u`_\z. šcja w d\oh
[ZŠZ[h ‘Zvwc_ f_]_oZj}, ”dw ‘ayw]w ]\- ]wva o\j}\, c_z d} `a†\yZ `\ wz\\|e,
^\|e. xZ`az_\|e? ‹ZjZ[\‚, z_je†av! z_cd\]Zg fZuZga. xwcde Z`a oZjy_]vw
‡ d\f\]e o\]a Zy`\wfZ]`}l va]fa†, gZuezwd a `\vZdZ]}\ va]fa†a g g\-
o\]a yja`w Zy`\wfZ]`wˆ a cvj_[}g_l []\ c gZ[Zl u_z_†ag_ˆd. “Zy[_ va]fa†
au va]fa†_ ‘ayw]w, vZdZ]wˆ z} c dZ- oZjy_]vZl ]\u_de zZ^`Z a g}]\u_de
oZl g wz\ `_]acZg_ja. ‰`auw [a_z\d] au `\yZ vja`eh, †dZo} vj_[v_ |j_ v_v
fwcv_l c_`daz\d]Zg gZc\ze[\chd ow[\d. `_[Z, †dZo} ‘Z]z_ ŠZ]Z|_h fZjw†_-
‰}cZd_ dZ^\ gZc\ze[\chd. ‡ `_g\]Šw, j_ce. šcja u_ŠZ†\|e, zZ^\|e gZv]wy
y[\ yZ]jZga`_, Zo]_uZg_``_h wc\†\`a- f\]gZyZ cjZh va]fa†`Zl vj_[va gdZ]Zl
\z, c_`daz\d]Zg cZ]Zv Šg_dad. xwcv_l cjZl c[\j_de. ‹\^[w `aza v\]_zuad
v_v o} cgZ[ fZjw†adch, dZjevZ g cgZ[\ u_c}f_de. “Zy[_ d_`[}] z\`e|\ ow[\d
[}]v_. “} cg\]Šw †\]\u ”dw [}]vw ow- d\fjZ d\]hde, []Zg_ ”vZ`Zzade zZ^`Z.
[\|e czZd]\de, v_v d_z c_zc_ f\†\dch. {]Zg_ ow[\|e ”vZ`Zzade — oZy_d}l
‰`auw dZ^\ `_[Z o}jZ [}]vw Zcd_gade, cd_`\|e!
`_ fZjva]fa†_, †dZo} dhy_ o}j_. ‰ZZo\ g d_`[}] `\ []Zg_, _ ŠgZ]Zcd
žŠ, z_je†av! šcja \cde yja`_ ŠZ]Z- jw†|\ vj_cde. ngZ]Zcdw fZj`}l d_`-
|_h, |\]cde o_]_`eh, dZ zZ^`Z z_cd\]_ [}] `_vj_[}g_\|e, c`auw fZ[^ay_\|e,
fZug_de, z_cd\] `_z o} ŠZ]Z|al d_`- d_`[}] yZ]ad, au yZ]jZga`} fj_zh
[}] c[\j_j, `_cdZhal! “_vZl d_`[}] g}]}g_\dch, fZ[Z^[_de `_[Z. “_`[}]
`_[Z fZcd_gade `_ ‘w`[_z\`d, va]fa- c`_†_j_ g`wd]a †\]`}l c[\j_\dch, g\ce
†_za ZojZ^ade, va]fa† v_‘\j\z — gZd vZf†\`}l. …Zy[_ ]_uZy]\\dch ŠZ]Z|Z,
v]_cZd_ o}j_ o}! vZfZde gch cyZ]ad, d_`[}] o\j}l cd_-
œ_[`Z, o\u ŠZ]Z|\l yja`} zZ^- `\d, †acd}l. ngZ]Zcd cyZ]ad, `_ [`\ `\-
`Z guhde yZ]`}l j\cc, o\u o_]_`e\l z`ZyZ wyZjeva Zcd_`wdch — fwcde cdZhd.
"#$ P 7!' 226: " "/ ' '"'/

mmƒ •Š cZo]_de `_[Z v c\]\[a`\ d_`[}]_, f]aj\fade. Y_z dZ^\ fZd\fj\\ Z[\g_l-
\\ f]ayZ[hdch. [a` va]fa† gZueza, ch, dZy[_ `\ d_v ^_]vZ. …cd_da, \cja c_z-
\yZ d]hfZ†vZl ZozZd_l, c`auw [}]vw, c_ `\ ow[\d f]aj\fjhdech v cd\`v_z, d}
vZdZ]_h fZ[[wg_jZ, u_v]Zl. cZj\`wˆ gZ[w gZueza, c`auw c_zcw `_-
YzZd]a [_je|\, z_je†av. xwcv_l zZ†a a c]_uw g d_`[}] j\fa. “Zy[_ ŠZ-
^\`_ [Zz_ dwyZ\ d\cdZ c[\j_\d, g d\cdZ ]Z|Z f]ajaf`\d.
]_cdZfj\``Z\ c_jZ [Zo_gad aja z_cjZ, _ …_v f]aj\fa|e c_zcw, d_`[}]
d} jwv fZ]\^\|e, zhcZ fZ]\^\|e, o_]_- v]}|vZl ^\j\u`Zl u_v]Zl, _ `_ v]}|-
`e\ c_jZ fZ]\^\|e. “ZjevZ z`ZyZ jwv_ vw fZjZ^a g_d`}l vZg]av, v_v z_d]_c,
o\]a! ¤_]| fZcZja, dw[_-cˆ[_ f]af]_- †dZo} d\fjZ u]h `\ wŠZ[ajZ.
g} [Zo_ge, z_j\`eval vwcZ†\v v]_c`Z- • d\f\]e `\ dZ]Zface. YZ]Zv za`wd
yZ f\]‚_ Zcd]ZyZ fZjZ^a a j\fa c_zcw. aja [_^\ †_c ^[_de `_[Z, \cja c_zc_ v_v
Yg\]Šw c_zc} vw`^wd fZc}fe aja †\]- zw^cvZl vwj_v. šcja c_zcw z_j\`evwˆ
`w|vw fZc}fe — u_f_Š ŠZ]Z|al ow[\d! c[\j_\|e, v_v w [\g†Z`va vwj_v, dZy[_
“\f\]e `\ca c_zcw v d_`[}]w. ‰Z[w [g_[‚_de za`wd fZ[Z^[a aja d]a[‚_de,
gZueza c cZoZl. —wvZl gZ[w o\]\|e, gZd a Zdv]}g_l. xZ`ˆŠ_l, v_v f_Š`\d! ‰a-
d_v `_ cd\`va o]}uy_\|e. “_`[}] “fw‘- [a|e, v_v ow[dZ yZdZg_h c_zc_ — d_v f_Š-
fw‘‘‘‘” yZgZ]ad. i[\ c_^_ Zcd_j_ce, `\d. “ZjevZ c_zc_ fZv_ o\j_h-o\j_h. ›yja
d]hfZ†vZl f]Zd]a. g`auw fZdwŠja fZ”dZzw, †dZ ja?
ž, z_je†av, `_ cgZˆ o_|vw fZjZd\`- €\d, z_je†av, `\ fZ”dZzw. ždZ fZ-
‚\ gZueza, f]agh^a. ‡ dZ o_|v_ `_y]\- dZzw, †dZ d_`[}] — cjZ^`_h d\]zZ[a-
\dch, zZuya zhyva\ cd_`wd. ‡ `_ ]wvw `_za†\cv_h cacd\z_. YzZd]a, d} []Zg_
[ja``wˆ ]wv_ga‚w fZ jZvZde `_[\g_l, ]_u^ay_j? —_u^ay_j. Yd\`va d_`[}]_
g_d`wˆ, _ dZ caje`Z ^_]vZ ow[\d. m~, cZ]Zv za`wd f]Zy]\g_j? x]Zy]\g_j. “\-
[_^\ t~~ y]_[wcZg g d_`[}]\ g`wd]a f\]e cd\`va cvZjevZ Zcd}g_de ow[wd?
fZjw†adch. ‡ d\o\ `_[Z c_zcw `_ cd\`va l-\l, \\ [Z u_gd]_ d_`[}] yZ]h†al
3 
#   ( 
8

ow[\d. Yd\`va aujw†_ˆd a`‘]_v]_c`}\ fZ[c}Š_\d, Zfhde f_]. x_] fZdaŠZ`evw mmr
jw†a []wy `_ []wy_ a `_ gc\, †dZ g d_`- au-fZ[ v]}|va g}fZju_\d, u_f_Š Zd c_z-
[}]\ `_ŠZ[adch. šcja g`wd]a d_`[}]_ c} g}`Zcad. “ZjevZ f_]_ cd_`Zgadch gc\
vwcZv zhc_ fZg\cade, zhcZ u_]wzh`adch z\`e|\, _ gZu[wŠ g d_`[}]\ gc\ cw|\.
cZ gc\Š cdZ]Z` c]_uw, _ `\ dZjevZ c`auw, ‰Zd d}, z_je†av, ga[\j, g o_`ˆ vZy[_
y[\ \\ wyZjeva Zcd_jace. šcja c_zcw u_ŠZ[a|e — d\]zZz\d] fZv_u}g_\d cdZ
yZdZga|e, aja j\f\|va yZdZga|e, aja y]_[wcZg? ‡ `a†\yZ, ca[\de zZ^`Z. …_v
d_`[}]-v\o_o f]hzZ `_ cd\`vw d_`[}]_ g “_|v\`d\! Ya[a|e, wj}o_\|ech. xZ-
f]aj\faj, dZ cd\`va d_`[}]_ f\]\[_- dZz v_vZl `aow[e o]_d_` o\]\d vZg|av,
ˆd f]Z[wvd_z d\fjZ vZ`d_vd`}z cfZ- gZ[w `_ v_z\`e o]Zc_\d, g_l-[Z[, v_v
cZoZz. ‡ d_ cd\`v_, †dZ `_f]Zdag, aujw- ^_]vZ cd_`Zgadch! ždZ fZdZzw, z_je-
†_\d a`‘]_v]_c`}\ jw†a. • wyja g`auw †av, †dZ cwŠZl gZu[wŠ Z†\`e ŠZ]Z|al
dZ^\ a`‘]_v]_c`}\ jw†a fwcv_ˆd, fZv_ d\]zZauZjhdZ]. ‡ w gj_^`ZyZ gZu[wŠ_
`\ cyZ]hd. “ZjevZ [Z `aŠ [_j\vZ, a c_z- d\fjZ\zvZcde a d\fjZf]ZgZ[`Zcde fZ-
c_ Zd ”dZyZ ^_]_ `\ u_]wzh`adch. ‡ \\ g}|_ˆdch, fZ”dZzw Z` d\fjZ jw†|\ f\-
czZd]a, z_je†av. ‰`wd]a d_`[}]_ vZ`- ]\`Zcad, f\]\[_\d Zd Z[`ZyZ f]\[z\d_ v
g\v‚ah Zo]_uw\dch. iZ]h†al gZu[wŠ c`a- []wyZzw gZ g]\zh vZ`g\v‚aa.
uw a[\d, gZuj\ cd\`Zv yZ]h†aŠ f]ZŠZ[ad, ‰Zd a `_ c_zcw `_[Z gZ[w fZo]}uy_de,
]_uyZ`h\dch, [Z v]}|va [ZŠZ[ad, d_z dZy[_ gj_^`Zcde g d_`[}]\ wg\ja†adch
`\z`ZyZ Zcd}g_\d, g`au Zfwcv_\dch. œˆ- a c_zc_ u_ [\chde za`wd — c]_uw u_]w-
oZl f]Z[wvd g d_`[}]\ `_†a`_\d fZ[- zh`adch! xZo]}uy_l gZ[w, v]}|vw \\
c}Š_de. x_] au `\yZ g}ŠZ[ad. ‰Zu[wŠ g ]_u u_v]Zl, †wde-†wde fZ[Z^[a, Zdv]}-
d_`[}]\ cd_`Zgadch gj_^`}l. “ZjevZ g g_l, czZd]a — ga[a|e, v_v_h v]_c`_h,
d_`[}]\ gj_^`Zcde fZcdZh``Z z\`h\d- ]wzh`_h cd_j_? ‰Zd!
ch. Y`_†_j_ wyja [ZyZ]_ˆd a Zo]_uwˆd b\yZ d} d_z cv_u_j? d gZ[} d_`[}]
`\vZdZ]Z\ vZja†\cdgZ f_]_. xZdZz d\cdZ Zcd}`\d? …a]fa†, yja`w \cja fZc†a-
"#$ P 7!' 226: " "/ ' '"'/

mt~ d_de — fZjdZ``} `_| d_`[}] g\cad, • g c_zZz [\j\, fZv_ –Šeh c`az_j
`\ z\`e|\. xZj-jad]_ gZ[} ]_uo]}uy_- c_zcw cZ cd\`Zv d_`[}]_, fZv_ cvj_[}-
ja — `_ cvZjevZ Zcd}`\d ”dZd d_`[}], g_j \\ `_ ojˆ[Z, fZv_ [\]^_j \\ fZ[ fZ-
\cja g `\z y]_[wcZg fZ[ [g\cda o}jZ? jZd\`‚\z, †dZo} Z`_ cd_j_ †wde-†wde
š]w`[_, `_ cvZjevZ Zcd}`\d! ‡ gZd fZj- zhy†\, ZdZ|j_ fZcj\ d_`[}]_, o]ay_[a]
jad]_ gZ[}, vZdZ]}\ acf_]ajace g fZ- w^\ g\]`wjch.
jwvwoZz\d]\ g`wd]\``\yZ Zo\z_ — – fade `\ cd_j, fZdZzw †dZ `_ [w|\
gj_^`Zcde c\]e\u`Z wg\ja†aja. ‰Zd a w z\`h a o\u dZyZ o}jZ Z†\`e ŠZ]Z|Z.
g}ŠZ[ad, †dZ gZ[Zl fZjag_ja, _ c_zc_ ˜_ cdZjZz `_[]\u_j `\oZje|az `Z^Zz
ŠZ]Z|Z u_]wzh`aj_ce!.. c_zcw fZ v]wyw, c`hj dg\][Z\ [Z`}|vZ
— œ_[`Z, –Šeh, Šg_dad o_lva d]_gade, `_cwŠZ f]af\v|\yZch d\cd_. ‰ Zcd_g-
[_g_l, Zdv]}g_l, fZf]Zow\z, †dZ u_ c_z- |\lch fZjwc‘\]\ vwcZ†va zhc_, c_j_ a
c_ w d\oh d_z fZjw†aj_ce! — “wd w^\ h v]_c`ZyZ f\]‚_ fj_g_ja g owjeZ`\, Zo-
c_z `\ g}[\]^_j. ]_uZg_g|\zch au zhc`}Š cZvZg a jwv_.
— Yd_jav-_v_? — ZcdZ]Z^`Z cf]Zcaj x\]\jZzag [Z`}|vZ fZfZj_z, cd_j [Z-
o]ay_[a] ]_oZ†aŠ. — ‹Z^`Z… ]\ohd_ cd_g_de az, v_v jZ^vZl, vwcva zhc_ a
f]Zchd… †wde-†wde? — a fZv_u_j ]wv_- c_j_, a`Zy[_ Zdvwc}g_h a Zd _]Zz_d`Z-
za, †\yZ f]Zchd ]\ohd_. yZ d\cd_ a f]aŠj\o}g_h Z†\`e yZ]h†al,
— “ZjevZ o\yZz! — Zdg\daj h, Zdc†a- `\azZg\]`Z `_g_]acd}l owjeZ`.
d}g_h [\`eya `_ gZ[vw. ’}jZ fZ`hd`Z, YvZjevZ |dwv c_zc} zZ^`Z c\cde
†dZ c\yZ[`h, fZcj\ d_vZyZ y_cd]Z`Zza- u_ Z[a` ]_u? {g\ fZjwvajZy]_zzZg}\?
†\cvZyZ fZd]hc\`ah `avdZ w^\ ]_oZd_de •ja d]a fZ †\dg\]de vajZy]_zz_? Yv_^w
gc\ ]_g`Z `\ cd_`\d. g_z: cvZjevZ `a c\|e \\, gc\ Z[`Z — ow-
— – c\l†____c! — Zdg\†_j o]ay_[a], [\d ŠZd\dech \\, yj_u_ ow[wd d]\oZg_de,
gajhh cd_]\`evaz g\jZcaf\[Zz a cd]\- `\ `_c}_hce, vZ`†ava f_je‚\g ow[wd
zad\je`Z w[_jhhce fZ wja‚\. ^[_de \\ a \\ ]_u ”daŠ Zw\`al.

*      #    ". )  "  


   , "  " . )    "  -
      #  —  ,       #",   
 "   #    . 8      
  !      ,        -
",    "       . (      
 ,     :     "        ,
   ,    ,   "    ,    -
   . & 
         GH0 C —     .
)

   :   !:
,   " #   ,  $     

    ( "  , ! $$   )
    " #   #      # 
 
  0 #  
 , ", ! 
  "    ,  0 
    (+ )
$ " "  

)    #. #, ! ( 
8

Y_zc_ `_cdZh_h, +%$%  E  $ +* '% %* %- mtk
$+ '" $# < $+>$ 
au d_`[}]_  !5"    '"# $+$, -
 '&<5 #5 .
x]_g[w cv_u_de? D & %*  5,   '%-
 ade h `\ zZyw o\u `_cdZh\l d_`-  &5" $$ '"# $+ !#5
[}]`Zl c_zc}. $%>$, > '+"  $%-
š\ cv_u_de? $+, 5   + +  !*-
‡ au [wŠZgva a [_^\ au ”j\vd]a†\- 5 % %$ %*5 <!5"5, >-
cvZl f\†a [jh fa‚‚} — `\ dZ. '& $+  &%" $". : $
{Zo_gade? %, >   !5,  
{_ ]_ug\ ^\ ”dZ c_zc_, †dZ fZ[_ˆd g   $+, !5   5*"
zZcvZgcvaŠ “gZcdZ†`}Š” ]\cdZ]_`_Š?  . %"  !8I5 ! !-
{_ ]_ug\ Z`_ fZŠZ^_ ŠZde †\z-dZ `_   !+ I 0–2 -
dw, †dZ f]Z[_g_ja `_ wyjw `\fZ[_j\vw +, $&  !!+  I
Zd `_|\l |vZj}? ‡ `_ dw, †dZ gZuj\ o_- <  !  ! $+. -
u_]_ f]Z[_g_ja au f\]\[ga^`ZyZ d_`- " + — ! %$ %  > 
[}]_, czZ`da]Zg_``ZyZ `_ cz\|`}Š !%>5, "$ %+ '% R .
z_j\`evaŠ vZj\cav_Š? A "$ $  +  5!
Yjw|_ld\, v_v [\j_de c_zwˆ f]_-
gaje`wˆ c_zcw. ‡ dZ, †dZ d\f\]e [\j_ˆd ”da c_zc}|`a-
va — v `az g d_`[}] u_yjh`\|e, w `aŠ
9%$% !5" $  !+ - Z[`a c_zc} fZd]\cv_jace, fZg}d\v_ja,
. F"  $ %%', " []wya\ a gZgc\ Zdg_jajace Zd cd\`Zv…
+"#%8 >" &  "  % - “Z-dZ Z`a Zou_g\jace d\f\]e z`ZyZ-
!& 5> *. T*$ !&!" h]wc`}za ”j\vd]a†\cvaza ^_]Z†`}-
"#$ P 7!' 226: " "/ ' '"'/

mtm za |v_‘_za a f\vwd d_z †dZ fZf]Z- vZje‚_ ^yw†\yZ v]_c`ZyZ f\]‚_ Zd[\je-
\ — fZ[Zu]\g_ˆ [_^\, †dZ au yZdZgZyZ `Z. “\f\]e fZ]_ v_d_de d\cdZ `_ c_zcw a
cjZ\`ZyZ d\cd_… žŠ, cj_o_va! žŠ, _j†- j\fade. ‡? bdZ?.. €\ u`_\d\ v_v? €w, cv_-
`Zcde! ^\z d_v, vZ\-v_va\ c\v]\d} dwd \cde, `Z
‹\cad\ d\cdZ, []wueh, z\cad\. ‰c\ w cjZ^`ZyZ-dZ `\d `a†\yZ.
g_c fZjw†adch! €\jeuh, †dZo} u`_`ah a
wz\`ah o\ccj\[`Z fZd\]hjace `_g\va.
šcja ŠZde [\chde †\jZg\v au †ad_ˆaŠ i\Zz\d]ah d\cd_
”da cd]Zva `_w†_dch, u`_†ad, a g`wva
`_|a fZf]Zowˆd `_cdZhwˆ c_zcw, _ `\ / < +" . /<" 
dZjevZ z} [_ `_|a [\da.  <  & $%$ ++ !
‰}z\cad\ d\cdZ a ZdjZ^ad\ \yZ Zd- =C–(CC. K< $*& $%>$ $%-
[ZŠ`wde a ]_ccdZhdech — u_g\]`ad\ g $+, $5#$+ !"E  !#$%. 1-
fj\`vw, wv]Zld\, fwcde fZj\^ad †_cZv   $  !'  $ .
`_ cdZj\. ‹} u_ ”dZ g]\zh v_v ]_u ‘_]| O!" % $ '  !5
fZ]\^\z [_ jwv fZ]woaz. ‰Zd az\``Z — $ , !*+. + I  I
`\ fZ]\^\z jwv, _ fZ]woaz! {gwzh dZ- <. K!8I !%>#%85 <-
fZ]av_za aja Z[`az — `a†\yZ g ”dZz $%   E"%8 !$%  I <
d]w[`ZyZ `\d: ]_ujZ^ade fZjZga`va $& $5+ $ E%. / <%"-
jwvZga‚ `_ [Zcv\ [_ a fZ]woade \yZ d_v,  %   %$ * !%>"5 5,
†dZo} Z` acd\v_j cZvZz. v`Z Zdv]Zld\, $% @+& <$ —  - 
fwcde cvgZu`hv `\z`ZyZ f]Zdhyag_\d. '%+ $" $$ >< $"$ +-
€Z \cja a fZfj_†\d\ — cj\u} Z†a_ˆd %, $  $%>$  %  !-
[w|w, az\ld\ g ga[w. 55  $ &  $& >.
xZcZjade, fZf\]†ade, fwcde vwoa- / !"   $&" 
va vw][ˆ†`ZyZ c_j_ j\^_d Zd[\je`Z, . D $$% ! >5 
  #  
8

  $ $8,  + $5, !- '? / $? / $ %  !%- mtp
>+,  5. F>  % %,  >", $$ % +5? /:  +& —
'5, !+ < E  '5, !+ <- R  +& E , $& '&
%"  C %  !". %- >%" I. H !" 5%5,  
>5  <++  '8E,  " !5. : <% $$ , + 
&+ $5+. W !"  $- '"#, >+ %. A >'& <% $-
"   <++  $%. >$  '& <# , +& $5
F+ +": +& !-  $ "#. O!" %  
>>+ %, + $$% %+ +>,    !5. / $,
$ R+% +&+% <$%  $$  +& %5 %, $$ '& '%-
! $8  *++ — <! : 5 $$%  +  $!. A%*%, $<" !
<, >%"->%"  !!++. W , &% "$  <!, $&
 + !",   ! - '+&, >'& !'%" !!, 
8I5 $$ > I"5, " " 5 %,   % 
! >" !!&5 " + &5*$% 5E.
+%$, $5  '%% !%>"5 $- H$ !! < I   #-
+  !% ,   5  ,  $  $& 
>%" I. / R- +  ! +&!
*  R  !+ (3C +- A%    —  *$, $
+ @#,  % @# %* $%- +% *$% &, <+#  +<&-
'$  (R '% '&>  !  +% ! &!>$. 4+ !-
# !), !* $%>$ !E &!" +% $%*%+,  ! —
 ' $5 +&, %5 $$ '& >%#$, , $$  I <&8,
'$, !$5   $ %+%: !-   . 7  ! 5
E +* +5  + '+$" $&, R 5 !" +-
 !%  , >'& > $". / , !!  $!$ <"5.
mts

žŠ, †dZ ^\ fZ[\j_de d\z, w vZyZ `\d d_`- ]Z`_ fZjw†adch cZgc\z fZŠZ^\l `_ d_`-
[}]_?! €w †dZ d_vZ\ z\d_jja†\cval [}]`wˆ. xZdZz c_zcw `_v]Z\z v]}|vZl
f]Zdag\`e? €w [_, `_y]\\dch Z`, _ g}- o_]o\vˆ|`a‚} a ow[\z cj\[ade u_ d\z-
jZ^a|e `_ `\yZ gZd d_v c_zcw — zZz\`- f\]_dw]Zl g`wd]a: `_z `w^`Z m~–t~~ ¨
d_je`Z fZ[ `\ˆ Zcd}`\d. ‡ gZuez\z-v_ g `_†_j\ a kƒ~ g vZ`‚\. {jh ]\ywja]Zgva
jw†|\ v\]_za†\cval f]Zdag\`e aja ^_]_ zZ^`Z acfZjeuZg_de g\`dajh‚a-
v_z\`e [jh g}f\†va fa‚‚}. —_ug\[\z Z``}\ Zdg\]cdah c`auw a cg\]Šw.
^_]va\ wyja g o_]o\vˆ|`a‚\ a ]_uZ- • ow[\z d_v f\†e †_c a \\ k~ za-
y]\\z g `\l v\]_zavw [Z d\zf\]_dw]} `wd, fZv_ `\ u_je\z gcˆ fZ[zZcvZg`wˆ
mp~ ¨. xZdZz g}jZ^az c_zcw `_ v\]_za- [\]\g`ˆ [w]z_`haz u_f_ŠZz `_cdZh-
†\cvwˆ fZg\]Š`Zcde, a \\ `a^`hh cdZ- \l c_zc}.
)

 
   :   !:
   ,  $     
    ( "  , ! $$   )
–  $ #    # 
 "  #  
  0 #  
   , ", ! 
  "   
  # $ " "

"#$ P 7!' 226: " "/ ' '"'/

mtƒ x_
™]`_h 4+"  < $++ +%$, I-
!$   !- &, " +%
a [gwŠf_
™]`_h 5"5, >'& !+ $"  
>#%8 !&8, ++…  $
– `\ u`_ˆ, v_vaza cv_jv_za g} fZje-   +"? O %*  '% !-
uw\d\ce. ‹Z^\d o}de, w g_c ‚aja`[]a- +I"5  $,  !5 +&-
†\cva\, [\]\gh``}\, `_ cd\]^`\. •ja "  $$%, !!%5 +%$, >'&
]ZcvZ|`Z oj\cdha\ cd_je`}\, _ dZ a  !",  $" I, <+&"
[Z]Zywa\ — au ZjagvZgZyZ [\]\g_. €Z  +&"  %+ !. W
h dZ†`Z u`_ˆ, †dZ g ŠZ]Z|\l vwŠ`\, fZ- #8I5   $5 +* '%-
zazZ Zo}†`Zl ‚aja`[]a†\cvZl cv_j-  !5%" I + !"E+, >-
va, z_j\`evZl g\]\d\`ZZo]_u`Zl ([jh '& "  I "#, !> !-
]_cv_d}g_`ah d\cd_ `_ z_`d} aja z_- <>&+.
j\`evaŠ v]w^Z†vZg fZ[ f\jez\`a), `\- /" '"# $%>$ '" 
f]\z\``Z [Zj^`_ o}de [ja``_h dZ`- %  !!, !? O+ ' > 5
v_h cv_jv_. “_v_h [ja``_h, †dZ, ]_ug\[h !5    +% -
]wva g cdZ]Z`}, g} \[g_ [Zdh`\d\ce [Z   '5<" !"<" $%8>-
\\ vZ`‚Zg. “ZjevZ v ”dZl cv_jv\ \\ a  , +* <5"  %5, !>>-
[Zcv_ [Zj^`_ o}de cZZdg\dcdgwˆ_h,   '<  ! %#.
`_fZza`_ˆ_h †\]d\^`wˆ cgZaza ]_u- K! ,  &",   
z\]_za, aja oZje|Zl a yj_[val [\]\- <&5,  I +<& $-
gh``}l cdZj. &   !&+ *+.
šcja gc\ ”dZ w g_c w^\ \cde, dZ g} zZ- F>   %, $%>
^\d\ f]acdwf_de v auyZdZgj\`aˆ cjZ\-  $%    %$, >'& +*-
`Zl c_zc}.  '& $&" — !" &&-
.

       ,  "               !,


#           ,  
        -
    " . '  "   ,    , "     -
     "   "      ,   ,     
   ,     .
mtr
)
"'  "
   :   !:
       # 1 
       # 
    #        # 
   !   

 , " "  , ! 

"#$ P 7!' 226: " "/ ' '"'/

mq~ %"  ! I  !>, R- fZ †\d}]\, \cja z_j\`ev_h, [_ `\ cja|-
 + $$ < , >'& <" vZz, j\fad\ f_]_za. ‰ adZy\ ”d_ f_]_
>I  !$  * +5, +- aja †\dg\]v_ [Zj^`} fZjw†adech ]_u-
 $%8>   %$. /& %* <, z\]Zz c fa]Z^vZgwˆ d_]\jvw — v_v ]_u
> %$ *"  ,  I ! - Z[`_ fZ]‚ah.
'" $ @#% <%, >&  $& €Z zZ^`Z fZcdwfade a f]Z\, wvj_-
!E — ! #+% &'% — , $>, [}g_de c_zcw Z[`w v []wyZl, cj\fjhh
!" !". aŠ []wy c []wyZz, fZv_ `\ u_fZj`adch
K<< %   #'&, - f]Zdag\`e. ‰\]Š c_zc} ŠZ]Z|Z o} cz_-
I  !% +, !- u_de ^\jdvZz, ]_ug\[\``}z fZfZj_z c
  %$+, >'& !%>" & gZ[Zl, a f]ac}f_de vw`^wdZz aja †\]-
>. D >  $%  $+ `w|vZl (`ay\jjZl, c\[Z`Zl).
$5+  + (C–(3 ++, žŠ, d_`[}], d_`[}], d_`[}]! ˜`_ja
%$&   @#  ! $%%8 o} g}, v_vZˆ fZjw†_\dch d_v_h c_zc_ g
+%. d_`[}]\! x\†\dch Z`_ d_z za`wd m~, `\
oZje|\, vZy[_ \\ g}`az_ˆd a ]_u[_ˆd
x_]zw[_ — `\ dZ, cdZjfag|azch w d_`[}]_ \[Zv_z, Z`_,
jZf_hce Zd ]_cfa]_ˆ\yZ \\ _]Zz_d`Z-
†dZ g} fZ[wz_ja yZ f_]_, au[_\d _ff\dad`}l gu[ZŠ: f_-
f_Š! xZ”dZzw, fZzazZ Z‘a‚a_je`ZyZ
…j_ccav_ wuo\vcvZyZ vwja`_]`ZyZ ac- `_ug_`ah “f_]zw[_” d_v_h c_zc_ az\\d
vwccdg_ [avdw\d: czZ†ade oZv_ w c‘Z]- \\ a vja†vw — “f_-f_Š-c_zc_”.
za]Zg_``}Š au[\jal a cj\fade aŠ fZ- €w _ †dZ [\j_de, \cja `\d d_`[}]_,
f_]`Z aja fZ †\d}]\ |dw†va. ždZ u_ga- `\d a `\ f]\[ga[adch? {jh g}f\†va
cad, vZ`\†`Z, Zd ]_uz\]Zg. šcja c_zc_ c_zc} g Zo}†`Zl [wŠZgv\ h acfZjeuwˆ
w g_c fZjw†aj_ce z_j\`ev_h, dZ j\fad\ `\Zo}†`Z\ v\]_za†\cvZ\ ojˆ[Z, vZdZ-
mqk
"#$ P 7!' 226: " "/ ' '"'/

mqm ]Z\ zZ^`Z ]_uZy]\g_de o\u cd]_Š_, †dZ +$ !< $%5. O$ @#
Z`Z jZf`\d. !5 '&, >+ +5, !R-
€Z f]\^[\, vZy[_ w `_c `\ o}jZ `a +% > !5 " !+"#, 
d_`[}]_, `a ZcZoZyZ v\]_za†\cvZyZ $" !"#,  + + * !-
ojˆ[_, z} f\vja c_zcw `_ c_zZz Zo}v- %>"5  '"# $%!& !"+.
`Zg\``Zz f]Zdag`\. xZjw†_j_ce ja Z`_ “%E&” —  $>$ 5 R +&.
Šw^\? €w, `\ ZcZoZ! —_ug\ †dZ [Z`‚_ w /< '% — %*! A <, $$ !-
`\\ g}ŠZ[aja `\ d_vaza cwŠaza a Š]w- 58I %I %   <%"
cdhaza, [_ g}d\v_ˆal cZv a`Zy[_ !%>5? P %!!
cj\yv_ fZ[yZ]_j. €Z vdZ z\|_\d f]_-
gaje`Z Zd]\ywja]Zg_de [wŠZgvw, `_lda
[jh f]Zdag`h f]_gaje`Z\ z\cdZ, †dZo} “]\wyZje`_h,
a [Z`‚_, a v]}|\†va w c_zc} ]wzh`a-
jace Z[`Zg]\z\``Z? ‡ \cja y[\ Zd cZv_
v_v g f_j_dv\
Zcd_jace fZ[d\va — `\ \|ed\ aŠ, Zd- w ”j\vd]a†va
[\jad\ ]wv_za. ‰} ^\ Zd vw]hda`} `\
Zdv_u}g_\d\ce au-u_ dZyZ, †dZ gZ g]\zh [`_vZ †dZo} f]ayZdZgade cwf\]wyZ-
\[} f]aŠZ[adch Zdvj_[}g_de vZcdZ†va \`a\, `\ Zohu_d\je`Z [\j_de c_zcw gc\
g cdZ]Z`vw? z\je†\ a z\je†\. {_g_ld\ g\]`\zch v
c_zc\ Zo}†`}Š ]_uz\]Zg. {_g_ld\ f]a-
D,  !!'% !" +%  yZdZgaz Zo}†`wˆ, d]\wyZje`wˆ c_zcw.
 ',   $%5. T%$ 5 @- ‰c\ dZ†`Z d_v ^\, v_v [jh f_]zw[_-
# !%  #+, $%+ - c_zc}, dZjevZ ŠZ]Z|Z o}, †dZo ]wj\d
"+ +, '" $ +% + fZjw†ajch dZj\, [_ ]\u_de \yZ `_[Z ow-
>$, !!$   ++ $E !5 [\d `\ fZ [g_-d]a c_`daz\d]_, _ ‚aja`-
< 5 *5 $%  +#  []_za c_`daz\d]Zg g s–. xZcd_ged\

8

mqt

‚aja`[] `_ cdZj a _vvw]_d`Z f]a[_ga- ŠZ[hd v zhcw c jwvZz? {_ `\d, Zdja†`Z


d\ \yZ f_je‚_za, cd_]_hce, †dZo} cjZa fZ[ŠZ[hd, g [\chdv_Š ojˆ[ z} gcd]\†_-
]_g`Zz\]`Z ]_cf]\[\jajace fZ fZ- \z ”dZ cZ†\d_`a\! • cZvw g `aŠ — ja|e
g\]Š`Zcda cZ†`h, †dZo} `\ cvZcZoZ†a- o} wo\]\†e!
jZce gc\ g Z[`w cdZ]Z`w. xZjw†ajZce?
‰c\, ]_cv_d}g_ld\ v]wy [a_z\d]Zz m~– 4>, '+ $ @#% !+&, '-
mp cz a g}vj_[}g_ld\ `_ `\yZ `_†a`vw. $ !E  <",  $
€Z cv_^ad\, _ g} jˆoad\ cZv, vZdZ- !<$. U — $<%,  & + %* +
]}l g}d\v_\d au c_zc}, z_`dZg aja †\- +, > 8'. O"$ !>+%-
ow]\vZg? ‡ [_g_ld\ c[\j_\z d_v, †dZo} + $*5, > %$! %  +
cZvw g c_zc\ cd_jZ \\ oZje|\! {_ [Z- ++  %*+ !.
oe\zch ”dZyZ `\ wg\ja†\`a\z vZja†\- A% >,  $& $% , 
cdg_ jwv_ aja c_j_, _ f]ZcdZ gZuez\z @#. F+* !" %"%8 +-
\\ vZ\-v_va\ ZgZa, cZ[\]^_a\ gvwc- %? A> +  . 9& -
`}\, _]Zz_d`}\ cZva. %  $% %"$. S#  R
‰Zd czZd]ad\, w `_c \cde cd]Zl`}l, %"$,  '& +& 
wcdZhg|alch, d]_[a‚aZ``}l _vvZ][ &  @#,  %  %.
gvwcZg}Š cZ†\d_`al: d\cdZ, jwv, zhcZ. 5 $E& %"$, !$%>-
… jwvw a zhcw ŠZ]Z|Z zZ]vZge jZ^ad- 5  $, !%"  $55 #,
ch, [_ `\ wcf\\d Z`_ f]ayZdZgadech g  % %5I+. U 8'8 R %5-
c_zc\-dZ, a u_[_†\ “[Zo_gade cZ†`Zcda I %$ — $ $ +*% >-
‘_]|w” `av_v `\ fZzZ^\d. ‡ fZza[Z- , $%I '%"+ +, &+,
]} a oZjy_]cval f\]\‚, †dZ, fjZŠZ fZ[- '5I+ +  %5I+ %$+.
"#$ P 7!' 226: " "/ ' '"'/

mqs Y_zc_ 1 $+>$%8 $% ('"#%8 !%,


 $ '&> %! !8). A @@-
“i]_`[-ow‘‘” %8,  @5%8 —   $ '-
8,  $ !5 !. : + $-
€Z \cde jˆ[a, w vZdZ]}Š ]Zd yZdZg ]_- +>$%8 —  G<'$ !  "
[Zg_dech dZjevZ oZje|Zzw vwcvw. Yf\- $ 8,  !<5   K8  !-
‚a_je`Z [jh d_vaŠ \[ZvZg h f]a[wz_j 8  &$,   $  &$, $
c_zcw “i]_`[-ow‘‘”. Yjw†ajZce ”dZ g !+, > % $ " < $+$ —
dw fZ]w, vZy[_ h, Zow]\g_\z}l u_ojw^- *, !$& <%"8  !.
[\`ahza, fZj_y_j, †dZ ŠZ]Z|_h vwŠ`h F+*" !%% <% *+, %-
a cZgvZgZ-v_fad_jacda†\cval Zo\fad *   '"#  $ -
cZgz\cdaz}, a ]wvZgZ[aj vwŠ`\l dZyZ , * !  @#  '-
c_zZyZ ]\cdZ]_`_ g {Zz\ va`Z. + >& I, ! $& 5 "$
“_v, [_g_ld\ Z ŠZ]Z|\z. …wcZ†\v > $<&,  !>$ '%-
cfa`}, c fZhc`a†`Zl †_cda, fZv]}d}l "  !  !* $%$ '-
gvwc`\l|az cjZ\z c_j_ a `\cwal &  $>$. 4I! $5  !"-
`_ c\o\ [g_ vwcv_ ŠZ]Z|\yZ, cZ†`ZyZ   %$% >  !. D$ "$
zhc_ — v_v g} [wz_\d\, ŠZ]Z| ja Z` ow-  <%+55, %'"   %-
[\d g c_zc\? žŠ, v_v ŠZ]Z|! “Z†`Z d_v ^\, $,  !%" , +5, < <,
v_v g |w]f\. • gZZo\, vdZ cv_u_j, †dZ I$>  ++ #%!&  +& — %
c_zc_ a |w]f_ — `\cZgz\cdaz}? ># <$ '8.

x]ahd`ZyZ _ff\dad_, \|ed\ `_ u[Z]Zge\,


[Z]Zya\ zZa!
¯
€w, ŠZ]Z|Z, c_j_d} [_ c_zc_ — Zdja†- mq
`Z\ `_†_jZ Zo\[_. x\]g}l g_]a_`d `_-
|aŠ u_vwcZv ZoZ|\jch gZgc\ o\u zhc_,
gdZ]Zl — Zd]_[_ [jh zhcZ\[Zg, _ d]\-
dal… d]\dal [_g_ld\ fZf]Zow\z f]ayZ-
dZgade c f]az\`\`a\z ha‚. “\z oZj\\
†dZ ŠZ]Z|a\ hl‚_ Zd [\]\g\`cvaŠ vw] —
Zdz\``}l f]Z[wvd, vZdZ]}l u_cjw^a-
g_\d f]acd_je`ZyZ g`az_`ah.
€\ [wz_ˆ, †dZ z`ZyZ `_l[\dch jˆ-
d hl‚_! [\l, [jh vZdZ]}Š gZf]Zc, †dZ yZdZgade
`_ u_gd]_v, `\ f]\[cd_gjh\d `av_vZ-
yZ u_d]w[`\`ah. ’Zje|a`cdgZ j\yvZ
f]\[jZ^_d c [\chdZv z\`ˆ [jh ug_`ZyZ
w^a`_, `Z u_d]w[`hdch f]a[wz_de ]_u-
`ZZo]_u`}\ u_gd]_va ŠZdh o} `_ Z[`w
`\[\jˆ.
Y wd]_ yZjZg_ \\ `\ f]Zc`wj_ce, a
z}cja ŠZ[hd fZ f]ag}†`Zzw v]wyw. •
ha†`a‚} c Zzj\d_za fZ wd]_z g}]w†_-
ˆd z`ZyaŠ. ’j_yZ, oZy_dcdgZ aŠ g_]a_-
‚al f]_vda†\cva `\ac†\]f_\zZ.
‡ g `_|\z ]_uyZgZ]\, y[\ h gc\ g]\-
zh `_z\]\``Z gZug]__ˆce v cgZaz
_u\]o_l[^_`cvaz gf\†_dj\`ahz, f]a-
|jZ g]\zh Zo]_dadech v Z[`Zzw ojˆ[w,
vZdZ]Z\… `w [_, Z`Z dZ^\ yZdZgadch `_

9

Zc`Zg\ ha‚, `Z gc\-d_va caje`Z Zdja†_- fZj`ad\jhza ]_cf]Zcd]_`\`_ f]_vda- mqr


\dch Zd \g]Zf\lcvaŠ Zzj\dZg. {_ a fZ- †\cva fZ gc\zw ‰ZcdZvw, g dZl aja a`Zl
[_ˆd \yZ g ‡u\]o_l[^_`\ `\ dZjevZ `_ ‘Z]z\ a fZ[ d\za aja []wyaza az\-
u_gd]_v, `Z a `_ Zo\[, ZcZo\``Z vZy[_ `_za cw\cdgw\d fZ†da w gc\Š `_]Z[Zg,
cdZad ^_]v_h fZyZ[_ a [w|_ Zdg\]y_- `_†a`_h Zd Y\g\]`Zl ‡‘]ava a u_v_`-
\d gc\ z_jZ-z_jecva Zc`Zg_d\je`Z\. ‡ †ag_h •`[a\l.
zZ^`Z a gZZo\ f]ayZdZgade \yZ d_v, š\ yZdZghd c vw]hda`Zl, o_vj_^_`_-
†dZo} c yZ][Zcdeˆ fZ[_de [_^\ `_ ug_- za, oZo_za, †\c`ZvZz, u\j\`}z yZ]Z|-
`}l w^a` — g v_†\cdg\ Z[`Zl au yZ]h- vZz, zhcZz aja zhc`}z ‘_]|\z, c v_]-
†aŠ u_vwcZv, `_f]az\]. dZ|vZl a cZ |fa`_dZz, [Zo_gjhˆd jˆ-
€_u}g_\dch cz\|`}z [jh ]wccvZyZ o}\ ]_u`Zga[`Zcda lZyw]d_, za`[_je a
wŠ_ cjZgZz “vˆvˆ”. ‘acd_|va, z\[ a c_z}\ ]_u`}\ cf\‚aa,
‰Zuez\z ŠZ]Z|Z u`_vZz}\ f]Z[wv- wcd]_ag_ˆd z`ZyZcjZl`Zl aja ZoŠZ-
d}: hl‚_, ]_u`ZZo]_u`wˆ u\j\`e, dZfj\- [hdch Z[`Zˆ dZjevZ u\j\`eˆ. €_ uazw
`Z\ z_cjZ, cZje, f\]\‚… {_^\ vw]vwz_, cf\‚a_je`Z [jh vˆvˆ u_yZd_gjag_ˆd
vZdZ]_h g _u\]o_l[^_`cvZl vwŠ`\ ac- ZcZowˆ d]_gw — _g_jav, _ j\dZz [ZfZj-
fZjeuw\dch Z†\`e |a]ZvZ, `_ ”dZd ]_u `hˆd fZza[Z]_za aja hyZ[_za.
`_z `\ fZ`_[Zoadch. • d\z `\ z\`\\ vˆvˆ Zcd_\dch Z†\`e
[`_vZ ”dZ — dZjevZ Zc`Zg_, d_v cv_- f]Zcd}z ojˆ[Zz, `_ vZdZ]Zz w[Zo`Z
u_de, Zohu_d\je`_h f]Zy]_zz_. ‡ [_je- w†adech `_†a`_ˆaz, a g dZ ^\ g]\zh
|\ cj\[wˆd g_]a_‚aa. ‰} f]\[cd_gade \cde y[\ ]_ug\]`wdech Zf}d`}z vwja-
c\o\ `\ zZ^\d\, cvZjevZ ]_u`ZZo]_u`}Š `_]_z! xZ”dZzw z`\ `\ ^_jvZ fZcgh-
ojˆ[ zZ^`Z f]ayZdZgade `_ Zc`Zg\ dade \zw u`_†ad\je`wˆ †_cde ”dZl yj_-
”dZyZ `\u_z}cjZg_dZyZ y_cd]Z`Zza†\- g}. •z\``Z dwd — `_ y]_`a‚\ z\^[w
cvZyZ auZo]\d\`ah. • `\zw[]\`Z: g\[e u_vwcv_za a Zc`Zg`}za yZ]h†aza ojˆ-
u_f\v_`v_ au ha‚ c ]_u`ZZo]_u`}za `_- [_za ŠZ]Z|\yZ u_cdZjeh.
11 -  


$
–   !  !  !
. "  
 , "

"#$ R 8" 91;!

mp~ €\vw[_ u\j\`e Q5, > +*  *",  <!>"


 %$, ! +% !&+ ++,
[\g_de? $  5 %.
WI 5, > +*  +5 <-
F+& '&$&, '<&  !$5 <" +'$+, $$ !-
$8$8 ! '%$"  !>5. - %.
<" <", , >" + <-
 — 5 '& !"< 8, > &  žvcf\]az\`da]Zg_de c c_z}za ]_u`}-
 +$ (% %  #!, %$!, $<, za `_fZj`ad\jhza — Zd o_]_`a`} [Z
<& %$), +#"   5E, !- z\[_ — g}, `_g\]`Z\, `_†`\d\ w^\ g
", !!>"  &*"  $% cj\[wˆal ]_u, `Z [_^\ c\l†_c `avdZ
 <&+ !&+ ++. `\ zZ^\d u_f]\dade g_z f\]\[ fZ[_†\l
*", !%  <. A - fZc}f_de g_|\ c_zZ\ f]ZcdZ\ vˆvˆ dZj-
 >"5,   & <*- †\`}za y]\‚vaza Z]\Š_za. ‡ Zd vZz-
& $>$ <" + !+, oa`_‚aa c v_d}vZz aja z_‚Z`a vˆvˆ
$  * '&". dZjevZ g}ay]_\d.
'

 +  11

$  !   
    ("   ""  $ 
    " #    )   "    
          "     
   !  !  !  ,  ", 
     !  1   . "   $  
   -" $

"#$ R 8" 91;!

mpm ‹`ZyZcjZl`_h g}yjh[hd ja|e cghuwˆaz ”j\z\`dZz,


z_jZl dZjavZl ”dZyZ ojˆ[_. • \cja
‘_`d_uah. hl‚_ guoade, fZjw†adch dZjevZ jw†|\:
x_]_[`}l g_]a_`d oZje|al Zo\z, oZj\\ j\yv_h a fZ]a-
cd_h cd]wvdw]_ — gc\ ”dZ fZugZjad jw†-
|\ w[\]^ag_de u_f_Ša a gvwc} d]_g.
€w †dZ, _ [_g_ld\ gz\cd\ cZ z`Zl, `\ €Z \cja guoag_de, dZ jw†|\ o\jva Zd-
Zdvj_[}g_h v`aya, f]a[wz_\z oZj\\ [\je`Z. €w _ a[\h, vw[_ acfZjeuZg_de
cjZ^`}l a “dZ]^\cdg\``}l” g_]a_`d ^\jdva — Z`_ w `_c c c_zZyZ `_†_j_
vˆvˆ? gZu`avj_! ˜_z\caz c `aza “d\cdZ” [jh
‰Zd z} ]_cczZd]\ja c_z}l f]ZcdZl v_uz_Š_ — cz\|_\z ^\jdva c v_d}-
]\‚\fd, v_v yZdZghd vˆvˆ g ’_vw a gZ vZz a yZdZg}z ]acZz. €_[Z fZcZjade?
z`ZyaŠ []wyaŠ yZ]Z[_Š a c\j_Š ‡u\]- ohu_d\je`Z! – a g Zo}†`Zl ha†`a‚\-
o_l[^_`_. ˜`_\d\, †dZ z`\ g `\z `\ yj_uw`e\ cd_]_ˆce fZcZjade ^\jdva
Z†\`e `]_gadch? ‰vwc \cja `\ f]ayZ]\- oZje|\, `\^\ja o\jva, fZdZzw †dZ d_v
jZl, dZ cja|vZz caje`Z u_^_]\``Zl gvwc`\\. …w]vwzw gc\-d_va `_[Z [Zo_-
u\j\`a, vZdZ]_h cZf]av_c_j_ce c [`Zz gade, ŠZde z} ]_`e|\ Zd `\\ a Zdz_Ša-
cvZgZ]Z[} (aja f]Zdag`h, \cja z} u_- g_jace, — fwcde ‚g\d ow[\d v]_cag}l,
f\v_ja vˆvˆ, `_f]az\], g [wŠZgv\). fwcde u_f_Š ow[\d d]_[a‚aZ``}l [jh
€_g\]`Z\, g} a c_za u`_\d\, †dZ g vw- _u\]o_l[^_`cvZl vwŠ`a. b\]`}l f\-
ja`_]aa †_cdZ f]az\`h\dch d_vZl f]a- ]\‚ — cZgc\z `\z`ZyZ, `Z o\u `\yZ h o}
\z, v_v guoag_`a\ ha‚. – [wz_ˆ, _ fZ†\- `\ yZdZgaj — g\[e Z` d_v g}]_uad\je`Z
zw a [jh vˆvˆ `\ guoade hl‚_? {_, ”dZ _v‚\`da]w\d gvwc! ‡ ]_u w `_c cd]wvdw]_
`\ Zzj\d g d]_[a‚aZ``Zz fZ`az_`aa, ”dZyZ cjZh ow[\d oZj\\ †\dv_h — fjZd-
ŠZdh g Zzj\d dZ^\ zZ^`Z [Zo_gade u\- `_h a Š]wcdh_h, g Zdja†a\ Zd fZ]acdZl
j\`e. €Z u[\ce u\j\`a cdZjevZ, †dZ hl‚_ a gZu[w|`Zl cd]wvdw]} cjZh c u\j\`eˆ

+ ,    ? F         “2,   ”. 2   
 ""  ,  ,         —  -
   . 5              
    ,   ,   ,        -
. 8           ,       ,  -
  …    ,         ,        
 . I   —        :        ,  
     ,        
" "   #" -
 . 7,          ,            !
    # :  !#.   (
  
9

a o\jv_za, dZ fwcde a _v‚\`d gZ gvwc\ gZ[\ p–k~ za`wd, g u_gacazZcda Zd u]\- mpt
ow[\d oZj\\ h]vaz az\``Z g `a^`\z jZcda aja `\^`Zcda, _ fZdZz cz\|_de
cjZ\. c Zo^_]\``}z jwvZz, c †\c`ZvZz, [_
xZjw†_\dch, †dZ z} yZdZgaz [gwŠ- hl‚Zz u_jade — ”dZ ^\ Z†\`e f]ZcdZ,
cjZl`}l vˆvˆ. x\]g}z cjZ\z, cZf]a- Z†\`e j_vZ`a†`Z a Z†\`e gvwc`Z! €w
v_c_ˆazch cZ cvZgZ]Z[Zl, Zv_u}g_\d- ]_u a g_z dZ^\ ”d_ a[\h `]_gadch, d_v
ch v_uz_Š. xZg\]Š `\yZ — cjZl “vj_cca- fZ†\zw o} `\ guhde [jh `_|\yZ vˆvˆ
†\cvZyZ” vˆvˆ. €w a Zohu_d\je`Z `_[Z cg\^\l zZjZ[Zl ‘_cZja, d\z oZj\\ †dZ
v ”dZl Zc`Zg\ †dZ-`aow[e a`d\]\c`Z\ z} w^\ f]\[cd_gjh\z c\o\, v_v `_[Z c
[Zo_gade, †dZo} f]a[_de `_|\zw f]Z- `\l fZcdwf_de?
aug\[\`aˆ f]_u[`a†`}l ga[. ‡ jwv-fZ]\l? ‰} `avZy[_ `\ f]Z-
{_g_ld\ d\f\]e ]_uo\]\zch c Zc`Zg- oZg_ja \yZ f]ZcdZ u_f\†e `_[ wyjhza,
`}z a`y]\[a\`dZz, c u\j\`eˆ. ˜\j\`e ‚\javZz? xZf]Zowld\! xZdZz \yZ `_[Z
zZ^`Z guhde c_zwˆ ]_u`ZZo]_u`wˆ. fZ]\u_de vwcv_za, fZjade jazZ``}z
†\`e †_cdZ, `_f]az\], f]az\`h\dch cZvZz — a \|ed\, u_vwc}g_ld\ az zhcZ
cZ†\d_`a\ wv]Zf_, va`u}, f\d]w|va, [_ oZv_j [Zo]ZyZ ga`_ — g]h[ ja \cde
jwv_, |fa`_d_ a _g\jh aja v_vaŠ-dZ †dZ oZj\\ f]ZcdZ\ a f]a ”dZz `_cdZjevZ
a`}Š d]_g c vacja`vZl. c_zZ[Zcd_dZ†`Z\! “_v †dZ jwv-fZ]\l [_-
€_ ”dZz zZ^`Z o}jZ o} a Zcd_`Z- g_ld\ dZ^\ gZuez\z. €\z`ZyZ Zd u\j\-
gadech — `Z v_v ^\ f_]_[`Zcde? x]_u[- `Zl †_cda — vZj\‚ [\chde-fhd`_[‚_de
`a†`}l cdZj [Zj^\` jZzadech, gZd a `\ Z†\`e dZjcd}Š, a cdZjevZ ^\ Zd o\jZl.
vˆvˆ `_| fwcde f\]\jag_\dch cZ†\d_- bdZ g} [wz_\d\ Z †\c`Zv\, _? šcja ”dZ
`a\z Z†\`e gvwc`}Š a f]\v]_c`Z y_]zZ- zZjZ[Zl a `\^`}l g\c\``al †\c`Zv,
`a]wˆaŠ []wy c []wyZz cZcd_gjhˆaŠ. †dZ `_ ]}`v_Š f]Z[_ˆd fw†v_za fZ d]a
‰Zd h cd]_cde v_v jˆojˆ zZjZ[wˆ u\- |dw†va, — dZy[_ ŠZde ‚\j}l u\j\`}l
j\`wˆ ‘_cZje! š\ fZg_]ade g cZj\`Zl cd\o\je, _ \cja u]\j}l — `w ŠZdh o}
"#$ R 8" 91;!

mps f_]w uwo†avZg? {jh _ff\dad_? ›g\]hˆ †dZo u_oj\cd\ja — ”Š, v_v ^\ ”dZ ŠZ]Z|Z
g_c — `\ ow[\d d_vZyZ u_f_Š_, v_v Zd †\- ow[\d g}yjh[\de!
jZg\v_, fZ\g|\yZ †\c`Z†`Zl vZjo_c}! ‰Zd d\f\]e — fZ\Š_ja!
‹} c `az fZcdwfaz ZcZoZ, h †wde fZu-
^\ ]_ccv_^w v_v, a gvwc ow[\d, _ `_ghu- S" " +% 5". 9*
†agZyZ u_f_Š_ — `\d. '&",  !5" — & + ! -
€w, g]Z[\ fj_` yZdZg. “ZjevZ gZd †dZ !" . : '% *$, $ -
\\ Zcd_jZce. …Zy[_ ow[\z fZ[_g_de    !5E". O"$  
vˆvˆ `_ cdZj, gc\ ja fZlzwd, †dZ ojˆ-  !5" E, +  $E8.
[Z f]ayZdZgj\`Z c hl‚_za? €\ cdZad A   5" *. A
ja ZoZu`_†ade ”dZd zZz\`d ŠZde v_v-  " < R  -
`aow[e, `w ŠZdh o} wv]_|\`a\z?  +, + '   $" 
x\]\f\ja`}\ hl‚_ fZ[Zl[wd — jw†- !%&&+ ''&+, !%"  +&+.
|\ `\ f]a[wz_\|e. S" ? A+ ! -
žŠ, fZyZ[ad\! …acja`va `\ Šg_d_\d. %8 %. A> !< &  +-
xZ[_ˆd a`Zl ]_u vˆvˆ c v_d}vZz, a ,   $% <% . D+
fZjw†_\dch Z†\`e ŠZ]Z|Z. €Z ”dZ \cja , @" + !"  !<" 
[jh u_gd]_v_. ‡ z}-dZ cZo]_jace fZ[_de !*" +  %$+-!+,  !-
vˆvˆ v_v yZ]h†wˆ u_vwcvw, zZ^\d o}de, +&$  ,   '%  +-
`_ f_]_[`}l cdZj! bdZ [\j_de, v_v ]\- !%& —  %$-!,  @". A-
|ade u_[_†w? ‡ gZd v_v — fZza[Z]} "5  "5 '% +.
†\]]a. xZ`az_\d\ z\`h? €w †dZ ^\ dwd <& %$-! '%  +
`\fZ`hd`ZyZ! xZza[Z]} †\]]a, \cja '&,  +  -, "$ >'& 
aŠ f]a^_]ade, f]af\†e c_zwˆ z_jZcde,  !<>&+  > >" +.
[_ cZ cg\^az †\c`ZvZz, [_ c wv]ZfZz, c J$, *$ ! +,  
v]wf`Zl cZjeˆ, †wdZ†vw g z_cj\, dZjevZ !<& +$+ $%>$+ >$,
mp
    # :  !#.   (
  
9

+ %$-!  <% @". +- ,  +  *"5, $   mpr
#+,  $$ "$ %$  !<>&+  <, !$&& '$+, 5
 > 5" %!%", ++  $-    , > '$ %".
&  5+  <"8. O$,  R ++  !!%",  
W  #+ ' <  $&  > * !5 # $<+?
,  ! +" $+ +. A%  P &*+   #
!"  <'%". $8$8 !%  &*+  %  
O!"  " '"#%8, !- <  + $%. J +*-
%8 $$%, +<"  !&+  !<"  >& >,   < 
++  &*"   $<+. K<- %*"   %. +, > 5
5  ! $, !%" !#$> +8  %? K<<" $'<,
 + ,  + > &"-  $ !>$ !E!"  !-
5, ", &$& <", !- %"  . :  '#5
+#%8  <'&+ '$+. /, ! $&  <-
$"$ % +5 <? / >+  — '"+ !!& 5E   &, 
++ , 5 & R +. F  % %*+ !+& >. +-
++ '&  @, +* '&",  & !&!" %$!+, %'&+ >$+,
%$-!5 "$ *. : 5E  >&- "8, $ !"  !&+ ++.
 #%$! A +& #"$ <' '$, :  5E, $$  '&> 5>E, — "
 R $> $<" >,  !E, +*, $$ +$ <
>'& !$&" 8 <".  %$#5   5 <.
G'+   ++%+,   $- A% , ! H" "$, !-
 5*5, >%%5,   '& '&<" $- 5 + '"<-
I "# %'"  —  $ . +>$+ %$%+ —  !". %"
P,  " &, 5  !- "$ $* $-'%", > R '8
&, ! ! $<"  +- ! 5 <$%$! P  "  !-
2  
3
.1
  !     1  
 $ 
–   
   " # 
  !
 ,  

"#$ R 8" 91;!

ms~  — <+>", $, +- œˆohd cd]w†vZgwˆ ‘_cZje a g “w]-


, -!---+--<---- — ‚aa. iZgZ]hd, †dZ d_z [_^\ f]Z[_ˆd
 > I ,  $E- $E? W#", ZcZo}\ `Z^a, g]Z[\ `_|aŠ v_]dZ‘\-
*"! j\†acdZv, dZjevZ j\ugah `_ d\Š `Z^_Š
c [gwŠ cdZ]Z`: f]Zdhyag_\|e cd]w†Zv
Yd]_cda cvgZue d_vZl `Z^ a ^\cdva\ gZjZv`_,
]_cfZjZ^\``}\ `_ ]wo†av_Š cd]w†v_,
_u\]o_l[^_`cva\ c]\u_ˆdch c_za cZoZl.
€w \cja w g_c `\d d_vZyZ `Z^_, dZ Zo-
…Zy[_-dZ z`\ o}jZ [ZgZje`Z d]w[`Z Zd- ]\^ed\ w cd]w†vZg "`Zcava" a "ŠgZcdava",
ja†ade vad_l‚_ Zd vZ]\l‚_, _ vZ]\l‚_ [_ u_Z[`Z c]\^ed\ ^\cdva\ gZjZv`_.
Zd hfZ`‚_. ‡ g} wz\\d\ ]_uja†_de fZ “\f\]e fZ^_]az jwv.
Z[`Zl ja|e g`\|`Zcda f]\[cd_gad\- œ\yvZ ”daz _gdZ]_z vwja`_]`}Š
j\l v_gv_ucvaŠ `_‚aZ`_je`Zcd\l? ‰Zd v`ay yZgZ]ade "fZ^_]ed\ jwv". {_ u`_-
a h dZ^\ [Z caŠ fZ] `\ `_w†ajch! ˆd ja Z`a, †dZ g v_^[Zl cd]_`\ jwv
˜_dZ h u`_ˆ, v_v ZfZu`_de _u\]o_l[- ^_]hd fZ-cgZ\zw? ‰ ›uo\vacd_`\ jwv
^_`‚_ `_ ]}`v\. €\d-`\d, `\ dZjevZ fZ vj_[wd g caje`Z ]_uZy]\dZ\ z_cjZ,
‘Z]z\``Zl Z[\^[\ ]}`Z†`ZyZ dZ]yZg- vZy[_ fZ[ v_u_`Zz fZj}Š_\d c_z}l
‚_ aja `_ŠZ^[\`aˆ u_ f]aj_gvZz! h]val ZyZ`e. œwv g d_vZz z_cj\ Zo^_-
{Zcd_dZ†`Z ja|e gcd_de w f]aj_gv_, ]ag_\dch u_ c†ad_``}\ za`wd} — ]_u,
y[\ f]Z[_\dch cd]w†vZg_h ‘_cZje. • v_v [g_, a v]_c`}l, \[g_ ja `\ †\]`}l jwv
dZjevZ g} wga[ad\, †dZ w Z†\]\[`ZyZ yZdZg!
f]ZŠZ[h\yZ zazZ ja‚_ v_gv_ucvZl `_- ‰ •d_jaa z_cjZ jeˆd †wde-ja `\ `_
‚aZ`_je`Zcda u_yZ]_ˆdch yj_u_, _ `Zya ŠZjZ[`wˆ cvZgZ]Z[w a dwd ^\, `\ [_g
f]Zdag \yZ f]\^`aŠ fj_`Zg c_za a[wd dZjvZz ]_uZy]\dech, Zfwcv_ˆd `_ cvZgZ-
v f]aj_gvw — gZd Z`, _u\]o_l[^_`\‚! ]Z[w jwv a †\c`Zv.

9

mst

‰ ‡u\]o_l[^_`\ jwv †_\ gc\yZ ^_- ‡ gZd f]acwdcdga\ v]wf`ZyZ u\j\`ZyZ,


]hd `_ dZfj\`Zz jaoZ cjagZ†`Zz z_cj\. fZ†da cZgc\z `\ Zcd]ZyZ u\j\`ZyZ f\]‚_
YjagZ†`Zzw z_cjw [_ˆd fZ[Zy]\dech, [_cd a gvwc a _]Zz_d! €\ o\cfZvZld\ce —
Zdf\`adech, ^[wd, vZy[_ z_cjZ u_f_Š`\d Zcd]Z `\ ow[\d, wg\]hˆ g_c a y_]_`da-
Z]\Š_za a dZjevZ dZy[_ Zfwcv_ˆd jwv. ]wˆ, †dZ ow[\d ŠZ]Z|Z, \cja dZjevZ g}
€Z cvZgZ]Z[_ c fZ[cZj\``}z jwvZz `\ w[_jad\ au f\]‚_ c\z\`_ a o\j}\ f\]\-
`_y]\g_\dch cja|vZz caje`Z. ’Zj\\ yZ]Z[va.
dZyZ, gZ g]\zh ^_]va gc\ g]\zh co_g-
jhˆd ^_]. “_v `_[Z, †dZo} jwv fZjw- S" 5  '"#+ $>-
†ajch uZjZdacd}z a Z†\`e _]Zz_d`}z.   $!5I & 6–= +%, !-
‰Zd fZg\]ed\ — gvwc Zo^_]\``ZyZ jwv_  > $&5  %#  <%
Z†\`e gjah\d `_ ]\uwjed_d!  5%8 %.
‡ w^ vZy[_ jwv Zo^_]\`, `\f]\z\`- O+ ++  " +$ <-
`Z [Zo_ghd vw]vwz} `_ vZ`†av\ `Z^_ a, ' !5$ 5E, !   '"-
\cja d]\ow\dch fZ ]\‚\fdw, †\c`Zv.  8 <", > %! !<".

&      ,     ,             —
 G00. "     ,      " ,     ",
"  —   "  ,             !

@         —        , 
        ,      . 6, , -
             ,     ,     

     .
$ # 

   " 
 $ 
  
   " #
(     # ) 
– . 

"#$ R 8" 91;!

msq / <  *! …Z`\†`Z ow[w! x\]\z\|_ˆ \\ c vwcZ†-


4 *, > !E  '% !> v_za cZj`‚_ a c\z!
$$, $  — $% *  -
>+ + %$, $% >$, !E 
< —  > '% <" $% -
x]ZcdZl ]\‚\fd
# '! [jh [\d\l a ˆ`Z|\cdg_
UE  <"8 5 8  $%
<% ! , $$ % !5 @- ‡ gZd \\ Z[a` Z†\`e f]ZcdZl ]\-
". $% @" ! 5 & ‚\fd c acfZjeuZg_`a\z _lg}.
5, 5E %!8 %"5  $$ - {jh f]ayZdZgj\`ah ”dZyZ ojˆ[_ g_z
% !*"5, >'& 5>& '$ fZ`_[Zoadch za`az_je`}l `_oZ] f]Z-
*   $%  <! '8%! [wvdZg: jwv, dZfj\`Z\ aja cjagZ†`Z\
z_cjZ, vw]a‚_ aja ‚}fj\`Zv, |dwva
‹`\ `]_gadch, vZy[_ ‘_cZje `\ f\]\g_- [g\-d]a _lg} a [\chdZv ha‚.
]\`_ a `\ f\]\dw|\`_, vZy[_ Z`_ dZjevZ- b\z gvwc`\\ ow[wd acŠZ[`}\ f]Z[wv-
dZjevZ `_†_j_ z\`hde cgZl ‚g\d c h]vZ- d}, d\z gvwc`\\ fZjw†adch a c_zZ ojˆ-
yZ `_ f]ayjw|\``}l, `Z \\ `\ fZd\]h- [Z, fZdZzw †dZ `av_vaŠ Šad]Zcd\l g \yZ
j_ cfZcZo`Zcda cj\yv_ cZf]Zdagjhdech f]ayZdZgj\`aa `\d.
uwo_z.
 \jd}l, h]vZ-u\j\`}l — gZd ”da F+, !<" 6CC–)CC  %$ !%-
‚g\d_ cazgZjaua]wˆd [jh z\`h f]aŠZ[ $"E+ 5   !'+? A% 
g\c`}, ”dZyZ ojˆ[_ a ”dZyZ zZz\`d_ h ' '"#%8 $%  &-
^[w v_^[}l yZ[. ‡ `_†a`_\dch gc\ v_^- $,  #$ $  &$&
[}l ]_u Z[a`_vZgZ: u_ cg\^\l ‘_cZjeˆ   ! +. #  +-
f]a|\j? ’w[\|e fZvwf_de?  $%& <!? /&$& %$ 
msp

%'" "  . H'*  R !%>5  <,  "$ +-
 !5", >  +#,  %$% +, !*+ "!
!*"5  < E,  W + !<  & $%! +"-
+, >'&   ! — !- %8 $%E%,   E&!$  %!+$-
> %$ +5,  !*+ ,  ! %*55 
"!   #. D%E%  !%'" >
D " %$ '% !>  (- $ *, $$ E&!$, %*"  $
 <&+  > <" $%&,   5, <" , >'&  !-
&& <!), +* !&!"  !- $&. %"  $! — !!%$
 > *$ $%$%+&. A $%$%- $%E%, !$  '%*, > $%>$
+& —  !'+, !*+ ". !5 !>",  %!%+, 
^&!$ !%' '"#+ $%$- $& '* $>$. H$&-
+  '" $ %$%. +#  '-  $%E%  %#,  '%" !
*, !$  E&!$  > !- !!%$5  —  I !-
$&"5 < $>$. A ', 5. F $%>$+ $%E& !%!+ >-
"#$ R 8" 91;!

mss  $ *, $$ !%! '&  $%>$+ 4  +5, > $%E   %#-
E&!$, !*+ "! " +,  '& + <'"
F+, > '& & +  , (C–(0 5E. UE % !" "-
 E&!$  $%>$ !!%I . W # $ +* !" 
$%E& !$&" !! < %$%,  R <+>". :  ,
$>$, <+  '%"+,     <5" @+% 5 <!$5, !-
 '%" — $ " $+ &. "   %$  $$% !-
M# '& "$ !!" '%" - *"   $%E%, % +  ++,
&+  "8 #@+,   % %>- $+ '%"  %$+. / <+
# <5"  < ! $,  <" - 5E+  + !%%  %8 
$+ $!5$ I!"  #@- (6C ] %$% +%  BC, !$ !-
  !", !%" 5,   % " '8   $, $$  +-
 <! A$ $&#$, %'" $. O + '8 < %$  !-
"  !* "! +     * !%,  $ 
W %  '& E&!$,  >" * .
 !!"5  <% * %*"
!  "$ &. W R '& ˜`_\d\ ŠZde, v_v ”dZ `_u}g_\dch? ždZ `_-
$%E,  % +* !*" +% >- u}g_\dch “†aŠa]dz_”, [_. ‰ i]wuaa, h
< 0C. M, '" + <- cj}|_j, †aŠa]dz_ — ”dZ cvZ]\\ ywcdZl
$,   — $   '5. :%  cwf, _ g ‡u\]o_l[^_`\ yZdZghd gZd d_v —
"   !, !$    cZgc\z `\z`ZyZ cZwc_ a ”dZ — ‘_vda†\-
!&$"5 $>$+ <%'>$,  I cva Zzj\d. ‡lg_ g ”dZz ojˆ[\ — f]Z[wvd
'% > %!% —  ,  Zf‚aZ`_je`}l, g []wyZl c\uZ` zZ^`Z
 <5  !$5. / yZdZgade ŠZde c u\j\`eˆ, ŠZde c †\z wyZ[-
 ! *+ "! `Z, _ ŠZde a dZjevZ c jwvZz [_ vw]a‚\l.

     #          —   
   !
ms
часть третья
Третья
перемена
блюд
²
‹_jZ †dZ zZ^\d o}de gvwc`\\, †\z mt
oZje|Zl, f]_gaje`Z u_^_]\``}l aja
u_f\†\``}l vwcZv zhc_. [`_vZ \cja
zhcZ fZ]\u_de `\oZje|aza jZzdav_-
za aja vwoav_za, \yZ zZ^`Z f]ayZdZ-
gade \\ oZj\\ dZ`vaz a au}cv_``}z
cfZcZoZz, fZcvZjevw g d_vZz ga[\ Z`Z
f]\v]_c`Z cZ†\d_\dch c f]Z†aza ”j\-
z\`d_za y_cd]Z`Zza†\cvZyZ u_z}cj_ —
cZwc_za, ZgZ_za, y_]`a]_za. šcja ^\
…Z`\†`Z, zhcZ `_]woade cZgc\z z\jvZ, dZ au `\yZ
fZjw†_dch, fZ^_jwl, c_z}\ j_vZz}\
[Zjz_! ojˆ[_: d_v Z`Z ZŠZd`\\ gc\yZ gZcf]a`a-
z_\d c_zZ\ jw†|\\ au f]Z†aŠ a`y]\[a-
\`dZg, wfZd]\oj\``}Š fZg_]Zz g [\jZ,
\[]\\ [\jadch gvwcZz a _]Zz_dZz cZ
cgZaza cZc\[hza fZ d_]\jv\.
€Z \cde cfZcZo f]\g]_dade zhcZ g
_ocZjˆd`Z\ cZg\]|\`cdgZ: f]ayZdZ-
gade \yZ d_v, †dZo} `a Z[`_ v_fjh cZv_
`\ f]Zf_j_ [_]Zz a †dZo} Zv]w^\`a\
f]a[_jZ zhcw [ZfZj`ad\je`wˆ fa-
v_`d`Zcde, `Z g dZ ^\ g]\zh cZŠ]_`a-
jZ g\ce \yZ gvwc a _]Zz_d. YfZcZo ”dZd
cd_] v_v za] a u`_vZz, fZ^_jwl, v_^-
[Zzw: ŠZ]Z|Z f]af]_gj\``}l zhc-
`Zl ‘_]| u_g\]`wde g vwcZ†\v d\cd_.
"#$ S =-/#-, !

mq x]_vda†\cva v_^[}l `_]Z[ `_ cgZ\z [`a [Zy_[_jace [Zo_gade v ‘_]|w


y_cd]Z`Zza†\cvZz fwda f]a|\j g dZl jwv; []wya\ ]\|aja, †dZ jwv f]_gaje`\\
aja a`Zl ‘Z]z\ v fZ[Zo`Zl a[\\. …dZ- c`_†_j_ Zo^_]ade g dZfj\`Zz z_cj\;
dZ u_gZ]_†ag_\d ‘_]| g dZ`vZ ]_cv_- d]\dea fZ|ja [_je|\ a fZcd_`Zgaja,
d_``}\ jacdZ†va d\cd_ a g_]ad f\je- †dZ u[\ce `\ ZoZldace o\u ]ac_; †\dg\]-
z\`a. …dZ-dZ wf_vZg}g_\d `_†a`vw g d}\ f]a[wz_ja [Zo_gjhde \\ a v\[]Z-
oZje|Zl d\cdh`Zl fZjwz\ch‚, ^_]ad g}\ Z]\|va; fhd}\ fZ[z\|_ja g ‘_]|
\yZ `_ z_cj\ a `_u}g_\d fZjw†ag|\\- u\j\`e a d_d\je`Z fZ[Zo]_ja f]af]_-
ch ojˆ[Z †\ow]\vZz. …dZ-dZ u_f\v_\d g}; \\ vdZ-dZ [Z[wz_jch [Z y\`a_je`Z-
g yja`h`}Š []Zgh`}Š f\†_Š c_zcw — yZ [ZfZj`\`ah — f]af]_gade ‘_]| u\]-
Zv]wyj}\ fa]Z^va, Z[_]ag_h Zv]wyw `_za y]_`_d_. • d_v [_j\\, gc\ cjZ^`\\ a
z_`haza u_f_Š_za. cjZ^`\\, [Z o\cvZ`\†`Zcda. xZ[c†ad}-
€Z dwd c_zZ\ g]\zh gcfZz`ade, †dZ g_h cfZcZo} wcZg\]|\`cdgZg_`ah ”dZyZ
d\cdZ — [_j\vZ `\ \[a`cdg\``_h w[Zo- `\Šad]ZyZ ojˆ[_, `\zw[]\`Z coadech.
`_h wf_vZgv_ [jh ‘_]|_. b\yZ, `_f]az\], cdZad a[\h f]Zvj_-
[`_^[} vdZ-dZ ]\|aj u_g\]`wde [}g_de z\^[w ‘_]|\z a ga`Zy]_[`}z
‘_]| `\ g f]ag}†`Z\ d\cdZ, _ g ga`Z- jacdZz jacdeh []wyaŠ ]_cd\`al: _lg},
y]_[`}l jacdZ†\v. Y d\Š fZ] a fZ c\l jaf} a [_^\ vw`^wd_! —_[av_je`_h u_-
[\`e f]\[cd_gad\ja [Zo]ZyZ [\chdv_ z\`_ ga`Zy]_[`ZyZ jacd_ `\ dZjevZ v_-
`_‚aZ`_je`Zcd\l cfZ]hd Z dZz, †eaz fwcdZl, `Z a fZj}za fjZ[_za oZjy_]-
^\ f]\[vZz o}j ”dZd y\`al. •cda`_, v_v cvZyZ f\]‚_ fZ`_†_jw a gZgc\ [_j_ fZ-
gc\y[_, `_ŠZ[adch g}|\ jˆo}Š cfZ]Zg gZ[ yZgZ]ade Z cZu[_`aa `ZgZyZ ojˆ[_.
a, `_ zZl guyjh[, cZcdZad g cj\[wˆ\z: €Z g vZ`‚\ vZ`‚Zg ”dZ g\[e dZd ^\ c_-
v_^[}l `_]Z[, gvjˆ†ag|al g cgZl j\v- z}l f]a`‚af: `_†a`hde zhc`}z ‘_]-
cavZ` cjZgZ “[Zjz_”, g`\c g ]\‚\fdw]w |\z \[g_ ja `\ jˆo}\ ZgZa a ‘]wv-
”dZyZ ojˆ[_ cgZˆ j\fdw. d} — `_†a`_h Zd g\javZj\f`Z fZ[-

<

ŠZ[h\l [jh ”dZl ‚\ja _lg} a gfjZde `Z Zdja†_ˆ\\ch v_vaz-dZ `\Zo}†`}z mp
[Z v_]dZ|va c o_vj_^_`_za, g vZdZ]}Š fZg\[\`a\z: g ]_u`}Š dˆ]vcvaŠ hu}-
[jh ‘_]|_ cf\‚a_je`Z g}]\u_ˆd Zdg\]- v_Š Z`Z f]a`az_\d cZg\]|\``Z ]_u`}\
cdah. ‰c\ ”da o\c†acj\``}\ g_]a_‚aa, u`_†\`ah. • ”dZ cjZgZ — “[Zjz_”.
fZ cwda, a \cde [Zjz_. ‰ _u\]o_l[^_`cvZz hu}v\ cjZgZ
xZugZjaz c\o\ d\f\]e `\`_[ZjyZ Zd- “[Zjz_” ZoZu`_†_\d v_v ]_u dZ, †dZ z}
gj\†ech `_ dZ`vZcda hu}vZu`_`ah: zZ- †_\ gc\yZ f]ag}vja [ZjzZl `_u}g_de.
^\d d_v †dZ-`aow[e cd_`\d fZ`hd`\\. ‰ wuo\vcvZz, Zd`Zch\zch v dZl ^\
‰Zd, fZ^_jwlcd_, †ad_ld\ cjZg_, cd_gh dˆ]vcvZl y]wff\ hu}vZg, ”dZ cw\cdga-
w[_]\`a\ `_ fZcj\[`al cjZy, a cjw- d\je`Z\ dZ^\ f]acwdcdgw\d, Z[`_vZ zZ-
|_ld\ aŠ: “vZgw]z_”, “owyj_z_”, “o_cz_”, ^\d acfZjeuZg_dech g `_ug_`aa jˆoZyZ
“valz_”, “[azjhz_”, “[Zjz_”, “o_cdw]- au[\jah au ]woj\`ZyZ ‘_]|_. “Z \cde a
z_”, “oZu_]dz_”… ‘]av_[\jeva g cwf\, a d\‘d\ja g cZwc\,
‰c\ ”da cjZg_ — Zoa\ [jh z`ZyaŠ a vZdj\d}, Zo^_]\``}\ `_ cvZgZ]Z-
dˆ]vcvaŠ hu}vZg, a gc\ Z`a Zd`Zchdch, [\, — ”dZ gc\, `_ guyjh[ wuo\v_, a \cde
v_v g} w^\ [Zy_[_jace, v vwja`_]aa. [Zjz_. xZ]_uad\je`Z, `Z a g [ZgZje`Z
‰c\ Z`a Zo]_uZg_`} Zd yj_yZjZg, ZoZ- [_j\vZz Zd wuo\vcvZyZ hu}v\ v]}zcvaŠ
u`_†_ˆaŠ z\dZ[ vwja`_]`ZyZ gZu[\l- d_d_] cjZgZ “[Zjz_” az\\d ]Zg`Z dZ ^\
cdgah `_ dZd aja a`Zl f]Z[wvd. “…Zgw]- u`_†\`a\!
z_” — `\†dZ ^_]\`Z\, “owyj_z_” — †dZ- ’Zj\\ dZyZ: g ›uo\vacd_`\ u`_ˆd a
dZ vZf†\`Z\, “o_cz_” — f]a[_gj\``Z\, z`Z^\cdgZ g_]a_‚al v_v c_zaŠ vw|_-
“valz_” — ]woj\`Z\, “[azjhz_” — f_- `al d_vZyZ daf_, d_v a cZZdg\dcdg\``Z
]\`Z\, “o_cdw]z_” — cf]\ccZg_``Z\ (a aŠ wcdZhg|aŠch `_ug_`al. x]ZcdZ [Zj-
fZ^_]\``Z\) a d. [. a d. f. z_ u[\ce †_cdZ fZ[Zo`_ u]_u_z c v_vZl-
• g[]wy c]\[a ”daŠ cjZg Zo`_]w^a- `aow[e `_†a`vZl g]Z[\ ^_]\`ZyZ jwv_
g_\dch Z[`Z, hg`Z gc\z az ]Z[cdg\``Z\, aja u\j\`a. €Z \cde a cjZ^`}\ cZ†\d_-
"#$ S =-/#-, !

ms `ah: `_f]az\], “dwŠwz-[Zjz_” — vZdj\- [Zjz_ — dZ^\ gZgc\ `\ dˆ]vcvZ\, _ u_-
d_ c g_]\`}z hl‚Zz g`wd]a, aja [_^\ azcdgZg_``Z\?
“v_]dZ|v_-[Zjz_” ([_-[_!) — ”d_va\ v_]- • Zfhde `\ ow[\z dZ]Zfadech. œw†|\
dZ‘\je`}\ vZdj\d} c `_†a`vZl. fZ[wz_\z: vZy[_, y[\, vdZ zZy f]a[w-
€Z g\[e w ]woj\`ZyZ zhc_ g dˆ]vcvaŠ z_de fZ]woade ‘_]| a cj\fade au `\yZ
hu}v_Š az\\dch cZocdg\``Z\ `_ug_- z_j\`eva\ ‘]av_[\jeva? …Zy[_ ”da vZ-
`a\ — “valz_”. bdZ ^\ dZy[_ g dZ†`Zcda zZ†va ‘_]|_ Zo]\ja cgZˆ y\`a_je`wˆ
ZoZu`_†_\d cjZgZ “[Zjz_”? xZ[Z^[ad\, ZoZjZ†vw — ga`Zy]_[`}l jacd?
u`_dZva, dZ]Zfadech c Zdg\dZz, `_cd_a- ’\u cZz`\`ah, Y]\[`hh ‡uah w^\ a
g_h, †dZ “[Zjz_” — ”dZ `\†dZ “`_fZj- d}ch†w j\d `_u_[ hgjhj_ce Z[`Zl au f\-
`\``Z\”. ‰Z-f\]g}Š, ”dZ f]a acfZjeuZ- ]\[Zg}Š †_cd\l cg\d_, Z]y_`a†`Zl †_-
g_`aa d_vaŠ ZgZ\l, v_v oZjy_]cval f\- cdeˆ gZcdZ†`Zl ‚agajau_‚aa. • vZ`\†-
]\‚, ‘_]| `_oag_ˆd g`wd]e †\yZ-jaoZ. `Z, dˆ]vcv_h vwja`_]ah d\Š g]\z\`, v_v
‡ w wuo\vZg \cde Zd[\je`}\ `_ug_`ah †_cde z_d\]a_je`Zl vwjedw]}, d_v^\
a [jh vw|_`eh, f]\[cd_gjhˆa\ cZoZˆ o}j_ g\cez_ oZy_dZl: Z`_ az\j_ Zf}d
‘_]|, u_g\]`wd}l gZ †dZ-dZ fjZcvZ\: `\ dZjevZ f]ayZdZgj\`ah zhc_ `_ Zd-
\cja g ga`Zy]_[`}\ jacdeh — “v_g_dZv- v]}dZz Zy`\, `Z u`_j_ ojˆ[_ c v]wf_za
[Zjz_”, g v_fwcd`}\ — “v_]_z-[Zjz_”? a ZgZ_za, wz\j_ g}f\v_de Šj\o a dZ`-
‹\^[w d\z [jh “u_g\]`wdZyZ” g dˆ]v- vZ g}[\j}g_de d\cdZ. €w, d_v fZ[wz_l-
cvaŠ hu}v_Š dZ^\ az\\dch cgZ\ cjZgZ — d\ c_za: zZyjZ ja cjw†adech d_v, †dZ g
“c_]z_”. oj_yZ[\`cdgwˆ\l cd]_`\ c ]_ugadZl
“_v †dZ ^\, zZ^\d o}de, cjZgZ u_az- vwja`_]a\l, y[\ g auZoajaa ]Zc, g dZz
cdgZg_`Z w v_vaŠ-jaoZ `_]Z[Zg, c vZdZ- †acj\, a ga`Zy]_[, `avZzw `\ f]a|jZ g
]}za dˆ]va cd_ja cZc\[cdgZg_de Zd- yZjZgw u_g\]`wde vwcZv zhc`ZyZ ‘_]|_
`Zcad\je`Z `\[_g`Z — v_vwˆ-`aow[e g ga`Zy]_[`}l jacd? €\w^\ja zZ^`Z
d}ch†w j\d dZzw `_u_[? ‹Z^\d, a ojˆ[Z fZg\]ade, †dZ dwd `\ `_|jZce `a \[a-

<

`ZyZ ga`Zy]_[_]h, vZdZ]}l, Zo]}g_h fZ fZcd\f\``Zz cZg\]|\`cdgZg_`aa ]\ya- m


g\c`\ ja|`a\ jacdeh c jZu}, fZf]ZoZ- Z`_je`}Š ojˆ[ f]a`az_ˆd w†_cda\ gc\
g_j Z[a` au `aŠ a wo\[ajch, †dZ Z` c_z `_]Z[} ]\yaZ`_, a v_^[}l ZoZy__\d
fZ c\o\ Z†\`e gvwc\`? Zowˆ a[\ˆ †\z-dZ cgZaz, ZcZo\``}z.
{jh z\`h c_z ‘_vd, †dZ cjZgZ “[Zjz_” xZ`hda\ “`_‚aZ`_je`_h vwŠ`h” v_v
g wuo\vcvZz hu}v\ az\\d oZj\\ f]ZcdZl, cZgZvwf`Zcde d\Š aja a`}Š ]\yaZ`_je-
o_uZg}l, oZj\\ []\g`al, †dZ ja, cz}cj, `}Š ojˆ[, vZdZ]}\ †_\ gc\yZ yZdZgad
`\^\ja g _u\]o_l[^_`cvZz, a Zo`az_\d dZd aja a`Zl `_]Z[, az\\d f]_gZ `_
cZoZˆ ‚\j}l ]Z[ fZ`hdal — jw†|\\ [Z- cw\cdgZg_`a\. ‡ “`_‚aZ`_je`Z\ ojˆ-
v_u_d\jecdgZ dZyZ, †dZ ”dZ cjZ^`Z\ ojˆ- [Z” — ”dZ v_vZ\-dZ ]\[†_l|\\ acvjˆ†\-
[Z `\ zZyjZ fZhgadech c]_uw g u_vZ`- `a\: \yZ fZ†\zw-dZ yZdZgad dZjevZ Z[a`
†\``Zz, `}`\ aug\cd`Zz `_z ga[\. `Z `_]Z[ a oZje|\ `avdZ au \yZ cZc\[\l fZ
cZu[_g_jZce fZcd\f\``Z: Zd vZzZ†v_ c}- ]\yaZ`w.
]ZyZ ‘_]|_ g ŠZjZ[`Zl cd\fa [Z `}`\ … f]az\]w, |_|j}v d\f\]e d_v ]_c-
aug\cd`ZyZ j_vZzcdg_ g ga`Zy]_[`Zz f]Zcd]_`\` g —Zccaa, †dZ \yZ, `\cZ-
jacdZ†v\ c cZ†`Zl a `\^`Zl `_†a`vZl. z`\``Z, fZ]_ gvjˆ†_de g f\]\†\`e
‡ gc\ ”dZ gz\cd\ — \\ Z[`Z cga[\- ojˆ[ ]wccvZl vwŠ`a. • v_v_h `_z ]_u`a-
d\jecdgZ dZyZ, †dZ `\ o}g_\d `_ cg\d\ ‚_, vdZ f\]g}z f]a[wz_j `_`au}g_de
`av_vaŠ “`_‚aZ`_je`}Š ojˆ[”. šcde zhcZ `_ |_zfw]} a ^_]ade `_ wyjhŠ,
ojˆ[_, ]_cf]Zcd]_`\``}\ g Zf]\[\- d_v ja g_^`Z, †eaz az\``Z f]\[vZz
j\``}Š ]\yaZ`_Š fZ dZl f]a†a`\, †dZ g o}j ”dZd †\jZg\v? {_, zZ^\d o}de, \yZ
`aŠ \cde gc\ `\ZoŠZ[azZ\ [jh aŠ f]ayZ- `_]Z[ a gZgc\ `\ cZŠ]_`ajch `_ u\zj\,
dZgj\`ah. “—\yaZ`_je`}\ ojˆ[_” — gZd cya`wj g fw†a`\ acdZ]aa. “_v †dZ ^\ d\-
f]_gaje`}l d\]za`, vZdZ]}z h wyZg_- f\]e — `\ \cde |_|j}v, ]_u `avdZ `\
]ag_ˆ fZjeuZg_dech gc\Š fa|waŠ a w`_cj\[Zg_j _gdZ]cva\ f]_g_ a `\vZzw
g\_ˆaŠ vwja`_]Zg. ‰ auZo]\d\`aa a fj_dade ]Zhjda?
4
    
   +   #   

  $       # $ 
  0 #  
–     
  # ! #  
 ,   $ !  ,  "
4 +  "   !,  
   !   , "+ ,  "
 

"#$ S =-/#-, !

mƒ “Z†`Z d_v ^\ [Zjz_ gŠZ[ad g f\]\- $%!&+ $%>$+, >'& #$ +5-
†\`e d]_[a‚aZ``}Š ojˆ[ c_z}Š ]_u- %'$   ,  $$% !-
`}Š `_]Z[Zg — Zd y]\vZg [Z _]_oZg, Zd $ ! & *. / R+ %>
wuo\vZg [Z `_]Z[Zg …_gv_u_. • jˆoZl @# !% $ %*  +,    +5-
`_]Z[ gf]_g\ gvjˆ†ade \yZ g cfacZv %'$, !+ +5? / 'I+, <"+-
ojˆ[ cgZ\l `_‚aZ`_je`Zl vwŠ`a. €Z `\  BCC  > +5  (CC  $%8>
gf]_g\ f]acgZade \yZ c\o\ g \[a`Zja†- .
`Z\ gj_[\`a\. :  %$  +5%'$% 5 $$ !%"
‡ gc\ cfZ]} a wf]\va, zZj, vdZ-dZ  +%. A% !+  %$, &5I
†dZ-dZ w vZyZ-dZ wv]_j, [_ \\ a g v_†\- < #$ +5%'$ — + !$" 
cdg\ _]ywz\`dZg g z\^`_‚aZ`_je`Zz >5, 55  R% $#%? + 
a d\]]adZ]a_je`Zz cfZ]\, — cwde y]hu-  +%>$%  '<$ 55 —
`_h fZjadav_, vZdZ]wˆ `_ vwŠ`ˆ [Zfw- <& < <  !$%? O- *! A"<5
cv_de `\jeuh. $ ". /, & *  > '"-
#. H& *, <$ +$+ $%'-
‰ ga`Zy]_[`Zz $+  >'& " $ 5  %$ 
!&.
jacdav\ T%$ &*+  $%  !&+
 $&+ ++  + *",
 +5. 7 &  !- $%  !5": !%" > !-
 <, $ 5 <58 !"<- , !+  !<>&+  >
"  R E"8 +5%'$%. O"$ +5- <"5. /  R ++  $-
%'$ * '&" >" # —  % % '" >" >
&+ *+. :  +5 %* !- *$ $%$%+&, !% > *$
"8 %" !$  *$,  * + <&  >%8 *$% >
'&" " <>I&+, !<&+ !E,   !+#". A+,
"#$ S =-/#-, !

mƒ~ !$  !<, !&!+ I * $!5I%8 %  (C–(3 $%,  $#-
$<&  %# +5&,  $ >, +- & !5 !*"  $!5$ +%&
* !*" !+% I  '<$, , "  !$%" +*% $-
 %$!,  !%#$% — "$ # !- +. F< >$  ! -
%+,  ? 9*,   $ $   5E  <,
*& $$ '",  >"5 ## .
<%>+  , $<& K$& & !E @#
 +5&? / !'5 3C  +   > $. F+, -
" <. "5  " !*. 1"# !E
4"    *", -  @#, +<E %. 1<&+5& 
> !+#"  <-%, >'& @#, %$<"& %. J $" 
 !$&" ++. J !" + %'>$%, !+5 + !"E+, —
+5 '"  $$% @#.  + +. G$&   -
O"$ > +   *": +5 $,  $ &* &+ 
*  !'",   ! J  #$+ $%!&+  %'&+ "5+,
 $+ %> +5 @#  * %$& !, !*+5  -
!>"5 $+$+. >$ $ %+%.
P'"  $% $%& , $- D %* 8 +%, $ 
& &   !%. $  < '%"+. D$ '&>-
K,  >"8 +&, + >- : <&5 +5, +& $& 
 &5" $+  5<&" $, $% $, !$  *$, —  &-
$& '%% >" +5, %$  <- $&" * . O$ > !$ & <+-
". " @#+  <> +%, % 
1#% & "5 — * '& <  R "5 <-
* " '% ! $%%"  +>"& '%". /   

      
<

%, >'& !$& &*%8 +%, +>"&, <%+% E '%", mƒk
   $ $,  !+  - !! ><: + $$ '& '-
$% !" '"# %< — +*    '5, !&, %>5" 
%8 '$%  . 'V+  !55".
/, !"  !%,   ", D $ & $, > %$
"5 * !'%"$5. J +- %* !, — !,  +. /&-
, >'& !'58I  'V+ '%- $&  ! #+5 '%-
"  %'* >< $5. "+. / ! !* $&$,
>+% '%" % 5 '"- !!& >$+  "8…
#? A% -$ +& + < "
>& !%$,  $& + - ‰Zd Z`_ — `_cdZh_h [Zjz_, gZd [Zjz_,
. J, !5", *+ +& o]}uy_ˆ_h cZvZz, [Zjz_, `_cj_[adech
%!55, + >$ %$&8- vZdZ]Zl zZ^\d a o\uuwo}l zj_[\`\‚,
5  , !*+5" ! %<+ % [Zjz_, †eaz _]Zz_dZz u_Šj\o}g_\|ech,
$ %%,  55 +, —  '%"  v_v g\c\``az gZu[wŠZz, [Zjz_, [Z Zdv_-
!+5. u_ u_fZj`\``_h oZy_d}z gvwcZz, [Zjz_,
Q" ! >,  %# - vZdZ]_h a `_c}_\d, a f]Zow^[_\d _f-
$, %# +5, 5 <8. Q" !- f\dad, [Zjz_, v_^[Zl †_cda†vZl f]Z-
 >,  # $ $#&,  cj_gjhˆ_h cgZ\yZ o\u}zh``ZyZ auZ-
 *, +"$, +&, "- o]\d_d\jh a dZyZ dgZ]‚_, vdZ ]h[Zz, vdZ
$,  %*  —  >,   +"#. gZd ”dZd |\[\g] f]ayZdZgaj. {_l ’Zy
/&$8> "  + %<,  - \zw u[Z]Zgeh, a †dZo} ]wva \yZ `\ wcd_-
$% +* ". g_ja gZg\v!
%" +   $  !- • `\ cjZ^`\\ ŠZ]Z|aŠ f\jez\`\l.
! &. /& %, $$ '%" €\`_z`ZyZ cjZ^`\\, \cja f]_g[w cv_-
<!5# $  $, R <- u_de.

)         ,  ,         
  ",        !   . 2, 
   -
       . )   
       
,        .
)' -
"     "  
   " #    

      $     $  
  !: 
      "
     

"#$ S =-/#-, !

mƒm ’_jv_`cv_h €Z gZd, Zv_u}g_\dch, †dZ ”dZ ojˆ[Z


ŠZ]Z|Z aug\cd`Z a g Y\]oaa, a g ’Zc`aa.
‘_`d_uah €\ u`_ˆ, v_v az\``Z yZdZghd \yZ d_z,
`Z j\yvZ zZyw gZZo]_uade aja guhde [_
{_, fZj}\ g`wd]a oZjy_]cva\ f\]‚} a cZ†a`ade `\†dZ fZ o_jv_`cvaz zZda-
v_v ow[dZ cZu[_`} [jh dZyZ, †dZo} aŠ g_z.
`_‘_]|a]Zg_de, _ jacdeh ga`Zy]_[_ a YzZd]ad\, `w ”dZ ^\ Z†\ga[`Z: d_vZ\
v_fwcd} — †dZo} g `aŠ u_g\]`wde †dZ- ojˆ[Z f]Zcadch `\ g v_cd]ˆjˆ, `\ g v_-
dZ gvwc`Z\. ‡ ‘]wvd}? ‡lg_, f\]cava — u_`, _ g f\†e! ‰Zd a gZuez\z ŠZ]Z|wˆ
dZjevZ w[_ja vZcdZ†va, ]_u]\^e `_ fZ- ‘Z]zw [jh u_f\v_`ah. šcde v\]_za†\-
jZga`}, a gZd f]\gZcŠZ[`_h \zvZcde cv_h — Zdja†`Z, `\d v\]_za†\cvZl —
[jh v_vZyZ wyZ[`Z ‘_]|_! gZuez\z dw, †dZ \cde.
{_^\ Zo}†`}l ]\f†_d}l jwv zZ^`Z …_v jwvZga‚w acfZjeuZg_de g v_†\-
‘_]|a]Zg_de, a g cgZaŠ f]\[}[waŠ cdg\ ZoZjZ†va? €w, `\ vZg}]hde ^\ `Z-
v`ay_Š h w^\ fZv_u}g_j, v_v ”dZ [\j_\d- ^Zz c\]\[a`w? šcde cfZcZo f]Z\! €_[-
ch. ‡ dwd zZl []wy, c\]o Y\]^ ‹_]vZga†, ]\^ed\ jwvZga‚w fZ z\]a[a_`w a _vvw-
yZgZ]ad: “‡ u`_\|e, †dZ d_vZ\ Yáy_`- ]_d`Z c`az_ld\ cjZl u_ cjZ\z. ‰cd_ged\
[Zjz_?” Z[a` cjZl g []wyZl a †wde-†wde fZg\]-
— €\d, `\ u`_ˆ. — Zdg\†_ˆ h. • `\- `ad\ g`wd]a, †dZo} “|g}” Zv_u_jace g
z`ZyZ fZg]__g ”dZ gvwc`Z\ cjZgZcZ- ]_u`}Š z\cd_Š. ‰Zd, czZd]ad\: `w †\z
†\d_`a\ `_ hu}v\ gZcvja‚_ˆ: — YZyá`- g_z `\ ZoZjZ†v_ [jh [Zjz}?
[Zjz_?! {Zjz_ g jwv\? “YZyá`” — ”dZ ^\ bdZo} cjZa jwv_ cd_ja z\`\\ Š]wfva-
“jwv” fZ-_u\]o_l[^_`cva! €w d} `_|\j, za a jZzvaza `w^`Z Zfwcdade jwvZga-
w vZyZ cf]_|ag_de! ›[_]\`ah f]_gaje- ‚w `_ `\cvZjevZ za`wd g vafhwˆ gZ[w.
`Z vZy[_ `_w†a|ech cd_gade? …Z`\†`Z xZcj\ d_vZl Zo]_oZdva ZoZjZ†v_ cd_`\d
u`_ˆ. fZ[_djagZl, _ v wŠw[|\`aˆ vZ`\†`ZyZ
mƒt
"#$ S =-/#-, !

mƒq ]\uwjed_d_ ”dZ `\ f]ag\[\d — g\[e [Zj- P @#" %$& '>-
z\ gc\ ]_g`Z f]\[cdZad d\]zZZo]_oZdv_! $. \!"  %" $*,  !-
€w a v_v_h ]_u`a‚_ — g_]aja g} jwv `_ 5 @#+, !*5 "8 -
fhde za`wd [Zje|\, †\z ‘_]|, aja `\d? &#$. A'" % — > $% 
'% &&!"5 — " @#-
S# +& * !" !- & %$E&  @+%.
+, !>+ + R  5 <+5 : < >? D $<, > @#-
 $E,  5 !5 +% - " % + "$ +5+? +
' $%!  % % @#? /<5" 5 '&
F+, %   '5" +$ E$ , '&<%  $%! +&
<& %$  @#, $& '% !- !>& %. D R +  -
+I  %$%8 '>$%? A ! :  *  !5& + — +
>  +& '+ !++ <!- $+!% R < > $ !-
 $!5$+ ? A%,  >$,  +- & . U ' '<$  +5%,
$ <5 +$",  !5 !"  $ +# + !<'"5 $$+
+! D  $%  *$ % &+ >5+?
# + > +$" — !%" J  +: %$E&- '& 
> >" <!, !+ !+%8 $&,  $%$E5 '>$ >-
+%, >%" !<* >$  % *, '%$-  $5, $$ % +#$! /  !%>-
" +, — %' +5. %" " %  + + + +"#. F+%8
+5 !'  !  '5 $%&  % %$E # '& <%'" 5
+&, $& !5"  $- %.
$,  , !!5 >&+ : $$ '&"  c%+,   <"
!E+, '5 , !'% — - & %$E& E$+? U  >%, >'&
#  $%? / ,    +%? % !! %" @#, + %* <-
/  >%! E  $%, 5  *8 <+<

2  ,   #,      "   "  


       "   "   — " 
  ,  
          !

<

mƒp

! +% '8% $%! / & — '- +, %$%+  -#'+  
*" $%>$ '&  %*  $&"  !  @+.
 @+& 5 <!$5. H '%% %- /! Q! P $!5$+ $, >-
#"5 , %%>#5 + %, &%!5 - '& %  <$ %" +&,  !-
>&+ @%++-!$ 5 +-  —  %$%, >  , *  !
"$ +%#$,    %$5 - T%$5 '>$  % 
 '8! 5, !R+%, >'&  " !-
F% '%+ " !5+  + +, " %%, ! <$!5 !  !-
 "$ > '* $%>$ '-  @+& %'"  %-
&. A% > % I $+  * - $  (3C ],  $ <! $$ -
+ %$, !*  <  '8,     (0C ], $
E, +$, '$ !E, + @", >'& %  %&  "
 #  !!$? $? T- I  "$ +, $"$ !-
& ? D$- % $"5 — '5  !  — %*  , I
", !%#$%  !>%8 "-  8#5 < " " $, 
", > *  <' !- *+ '5+, <! < !> $*
+ "$? F'* +! * <, '%" %&!
*, !%#, ' +- FV5  * '< !*5 !5-
 &, !, &! $% -  !!!
-
  #   "   :
  :
–       # 
  $ ,         !   !  # #   
 !   #    "    
  # ! #   *  
   % #   "
  
, "
   $   :  ! ,  !  

"#$ S =-/#-, !

mƒs ‰ oZjy_]cvZz f\]‚\ o]_ja ŠZ]Z|Z u_†a\``Z\ Zd fj\`Zv


a ^ajZv zhcZ, ^\j_d\je`Z o_]_`a`w
€w, ]_u w^ z} g}hc`aja, †dZ `\vZdZ]}\ Zd u_[`\l `Zya, g v]_l`\z cjw†_\ Zd
`_]Z[} [ZjzZl `_u}g_ˆd `\ dZjevZ jZf_dva. €_[Z w†ad}g_de g]\zh, u_
dZ, †dZ u_g\]`wdZ g `\†dZ fjZcvZ\, `Z a vZdZ]Z\ wcf\\d f]ayZdZgadech zhcZ
dZ, †dZ fZz\\`Z g `\†dZ fZjZ\, — Zo- a u_ vZdZ]Z\ ow[\d yZdZg f\]\‚. ‰\[e
]_dazch v c_zZzw ]_cf]Zcd]_`\``Zzw f\]\g_]\``}l f\]\‚… ‰} ga[\ja d_-
g_]a_`dw. {_-[_, h fZ`az_ˆ, ”dZ dZ, †dZ vZl, f]_g[_? €a cd]wvdw]}, `a u_f_Š_,
gc\ a d_v yZdZghd, `Z `_u}g_ˆd ‘_]|a- Zdcj_ag_ˆ_hch |vw]v_…
]Zg_``}z f\]‚\z. ‰Z-gdZ]}Š, jwv [jh ‘_]|_ jw†|\
€Z gc\ ^\ fZcjw|_ld\ z\`h ŠZde `\- Zo^_]ade [Z f]Zu]_†`Zcda, f]\^[\
[ZjyZ. †\z cz\|ag_de \yZ c zhcZz. ‰z\cd\ c
•u †\yZ w g_c cZcdZad ‘_]|, v]Zz\ jwvZz g ‘_]| fZf_[\d a `\z`ZyZ z_c-
zhc_? j_, ”dZ dZ^\ ow[\d ŠZ]Z|Z.
•u v_vZyZ az\``Z zhc_ g} [\j_\d\ €Z f]\^[\ †\z Zo^_]ag_de jwv, fZ-
‘_]| [jh f\]‚\g? ^_]ed\ g dZz z_cj\ z\jvZ fZ]\u_`-
‡ cf\‚aa v_va\? `wˆ zZ]vZge — ”dZ Z†\`e fZj\u`Z
‡ †dZ, f]ZcdZ gZ[Zl u_jag_\d\ f\]‚} [jh gvwc_ ‘_]|_, fZdZzw †dZ au zhc_,
g v_cd]ˆj\ aja cZwc v_vZl-dZ ZcZo}l yZ- jwv_ a zZ]vZga cvj_[}g_\dch g\javZ-
dZgad\? j\f`}l gvwcZgZl _vvZ][.
…Z]Z†\ yZgZ]h, g ”dZz [\j\ — v_v a nZ]Z|wˆ cd]wvdw]w ‘_]|_ a f]_-
fZ†da g jˆoZz []wyZz, az\ˆ\z Zd`Z- gaje`}l o_j_`c fZzZ^\d cZu[_de
|\`a\ v vwja`_]`Zzw acvwccdgw, wcf\Š Zdg_]\``}l [Z fZjwyZdZg`Zcda v]w-
]\|_ˆd [\d_ja. yj}l ]ac, d_vZl, †dZo} j\yvZ g}[\-
‰Z-f\]g}Š, h ŠZ†w fZf]Zcade g_c, †dZ- jhj v]_Šz_j, _ `\ f]Zf_]\``}l, v
o} [jh [Zjz} g oZjy_]cvZz f\]‚\ g} f]az\]w.

<

mƒ

…Z`\†`Z, g ”dZd ‘_]| `_[Z [Zo_gade !+ '" +$", !<%8 +-
cf\‚aa, ŠZdh o} †\]`}l f\]\‚, _ fZ ^\- $+,  #%, $%'$+,  !&!"
j_`aˆ — \\ a ua]w. !E5+, 5 $&5 $& '-
‰-d]\deaŠ, `avZy[_ `\ fZjw†adch + !% +: <  -
f]ayZdZgade ŠZ]Z|al cZwc, g vZdZ]Zz a '&+ >&+ !E+.   $$
ow[wd yZdZgadech d_va\ “f\]‚}-[Zjz_” +$"  %$ >% <" !5&
o\u \\ Z[`Zl fZ]‚aa jwv_, Zo^_]\`- <! (!*  !),  +$" 
`Zl yZjh|va aja v_vaŠ-dZ []wyaŠ †_- +5$  ! %", '"
cd\l o_]_`a`}, `_]woj\``Zl `\v]wf- +$ <& !+&. /!>+,
`}za vwcv_za, cZ[\]^_a\ oZje|Z\ !+& %># >"  #$%$, $-
vZja†\cdgZ cZ\[a`ad\je`Zl dv_`a, 5  % %* >  %*,  +*-
zZ]vZga, fZza[Z]Zg a f\]‚_.    — !" >< , 
 %  !!% *  +,  
K<"  '"#+ $< +  % + +#8.
*. W  ! $<+ '&,  W %  " +5, ! %
'*"  % $>$,  !- *%8 !E8: <, I  -
+ %'"  +5 5#$,   - > !5 %, <!$ 
 >&,  '*" !<& $& '$ !E E$+  -
>"-$"E+ %$ !5+ +  # < %$. H> 
5#$+. L"   > $-  !! #$%$, % + 
+<E %$  <+5  E, !*$%  <+"> '+.
"#$ S =-/#-, !

mr~ P'" R% !% $ <*&+ %$% #+, &I&+  <+  !
 +$ +  !++. E+, , <+*, 5 '$
++  '*"5, !+- $% !5 '"  % I  -
# $"$ <, !*, !$ +  — !5$  
$  !+ &!5 !>  *$  $88  <+.
$E,  5 + !" ( ++  J + # !" <
R+ +& " !&: !+&  %: <+>"  " !-
$& $ <&+ @$%+). J $ & "  !%,  <
!+, >  5  +"#,  %$ '8  E+.
+#", >'&  !, !5 O!" + +5 @#" !-
 >I,   <*$% <- E&. F&! %" $* !E +-
&  '%". "$%8 I!$%  —  + '% 
1%", $$ , %  !%>5 ".
!  !&>$ R$+":   H'+ $+$ @#, ! +%
!% $>$, *$, '<$ +5, - @+% '"# $% 5E  !%-
!"<  @#. M5, +*, '%-   !E, !5 % '"#+
" %  5  $$- !&%- !"E+. F+ !E + ++ “'-
I $% <'$  +5+? +” #$, >'&   !%. A-
  $$ ' '%", - ' !, ! '+ ',
  % 5#$  > + & * @+%5   $ &#$, -
 ++ >   +% <$!", !- $, >'& %  <$ %" I.
 > !!'%  ,  %*- 9*, $>, !& @#+
. F% !$*5 >%>$% !&+, !E& *"  $$%8-'%" $88,
 & *& !+", >  ++  %># -$ !*"   
 $ !> < $   %'$+ $, $& &
 +. D,  !+& '& +* !" !+  %$%.
     4 
<

A  !%% + %  A  &#    $- mrk
" !E& $+ $<% > ! !5, %&# < ! $&#$ '%"$",
$%%, " $,  !+ <!55  %'" "  *"  !55 !-
%, ! '  &#$ 5 <!. A, !E+ !-
<*$. H R  !E !%>5 5 !5"  '"#+ , !
&*&+ $$ '& $%!+:  $%!"5 $&#$, !& BC +%. :  !
$%$E5, $$ <, + ! ' (C +% $ !%%  !" 
>" %>. %8 %$% — !%"  @#, >
Q- * " +>$ 5 &%! < !E, + <%+5-
!>$ *%> %>$& !>$, % 5, !' !"%8 +%8
5 '& 5 <!! J  '" &, %.
 '":   "$ !>$+ -
+"5  !%". šcja fZcw[_, g vZdZ]Zl yZdZgajace f\]-
A ! >$ #5 %. ‚}, fZugZjh\d, fZ[_g_ld\ `_ cdZj f]hzZ
A & " <, > %  * g `\l, wv]_cag u\j\`eˆ, †dZo u_ g\]cdw
'&" #$+ +? $ @#- v]wyZz gc\ u`_ja, †dZ c\yZ[`h g} yZdZ-
& !E& %, $  >5 %*"  gaja c_z}l gvwc`}l g ”dZz yZ]Z[\ ‘_]-
    $,  % $*5 +. |a]Zg_``}l f\]\‚!
: $$ !E& >% %"5, % '- • `\ Zohu_d\je`Z — ZcZo\``Z \cja g
+5$"  !" '>$+ % $ %% vZzf_`aa jˆ[a fZ†d\``}\ — `_cd_a-
 !,  %- %%  - g_de `_ dZz, †dZ ”dZ `_cdZh_h [Zjz_. –
5 > %, $$ &'" %*%  u`_ˆ, g} u`_\d\, _ Zcd_je`}\ fwcde d_v
!>$" !%. \[hd, o\u ja|`aŠ fZ[]Zo`Zcd\l. ‰vwc
P,   +&  # '& %*" ]_ug\ Zd ”dZyZ z\`h\dch?
<+>&  %  !$&" R %
>$+ @ '<$  $<&.

)                . 8      


      :        -    
  " !,               ",  "   ".
D        .
mrm
/  " -
–             
  :
     
  0 #  
– "      
     
, "
 
   $  

     * 
<

‰ o_vj_^_`_Š u_f_Š, v_v ow[dZ o} Z`Z fZ†da yZdZgZ, `Z mrt


`_ c_zZz [\j\ Z`Z Zcd_g_jZce fZjwc}-
‰ZZo\, h wo\[ajch: d]_dade caj} `_ ]}z, [_ a jwv `\ u_]wzh`ajch, _ wcf\j
cfZ]} Z dZz, v_vZl ]\‚\fd f]_gaje- dZjevZ cd_de f]Zu]_†`}z. šcd\cdg\``Z,
`\\ — `\ cZgc\z ]_‚aZ`_je`Z. fZv_ zhcZ a ZgZa dw|ajace, aŠ wcf\-
Yaj}, vZdZ]}\ g} fZd]_dad\ `_ fw- ja a fZcZjade, a fZf\]†ade. ‰Zd a gc\,
cd}\ cfZ]} Z `_cdZh\l [Zjz\, jw†|\ `a†\yZ cjZ^`ZyZ, Z†\`e f]Zcd_h a o\c-
f]ao\]\†e [jh f]ayZdZgj\`ah cj\[wˆ- Šad]Zcd`_h `_†a`v_.
\yZ ojˆ[_, vZy[_ g} f]ayZdZgad\ [Zj- › o_vj_^_`Zg — nwc`ah] g}o]_j `\-
zw `\ g ga`Zy]_[`Zz jacd\, `\ g oZj- v]wf`}\, [ja`Zl f]az\]`Z c j_[Z`e, —
y_]cvZz f\]‚\, _… g o_vj_^_`\! Zcd_jace g `\f]avZc`Zg\``Zcda u\j\-
€w †dZ ^\, ]_u cZo]_jace yZdZgade `}\ |_fZ†va a †\]\`va, u_ vZdZ]}\
[Zjzw, u`_†ad, `_[Z g f\]gwˆ Z†\]\[e fZdZz ow[\d w[Zo`Z ”dw u_vwcvw f]a[\]-
fZ[wz_de Z ‘_]|\. ‰ _u\]o_l[^_`cvZl ^ag_de, fZv_ \|e. …_^[}l o}j `_[]\-
œ\`vZ]_`a, y[\ z`\ [Zg\jZce czZd]\de, u_` fZ gZy`wdZzw oZvw g[Zje, `Z `\ `_-
v_v acfZj`h\d Z[a` au cgZaŠ vZ]Z``}Š cvgZue, _ dZjevZ †wde yjwo^\ c\]\[a`}.
`Zz\]Zg d_j_`djag}l z_cd\] fZ az\- xZdZz aŠ fZcZjaja au`wd]a a Zcd_gaja
`a nwc`ah] (z} c `az †wde fZu^\ \\ `_ fZj†_c_, †dZo} fwcdaja cZv.
fZu`_vZzazch fZoja^\, vZy[_ wyjw- xZcj\ ”dZyZ f]hzZ ]wv_za nwc`ah]
oazch g dZ`vZcda j\`vZ]_`cvZl vwŠ- Zd^_j ”dZd cZv au v_^[ZyZ o_vj_^_`_
`a), g `_†a`vw fZ|ja f]Z[wvd} gfZj- a fZdZzaj aŠ Zd[\je`Z, o\u `_†a`va, g
`\ f]\[cv_uw\z}\: gc\ d_ ^\ o_]_`a`_, oZje|Zz vZja†\cdg\ dZfj\`ZyZ z_cj_.
vw][ˆ†`Z\ c_jZ, jwv a fZza[Z]}. ‰c\
”dZ o}jZ z\jvZ fZ]\u_`Z a dw|ajZce & $+ '<+ '$*-
g cvZgZ]Z[\ [Z fZjwyZdZg`Zcda. “Z \cde & > @#+  %* '
zhcZ wcf\jZ auz\`ade ‚g\d, fZhgajch  $%,   * + +,  $-
$ -
 
*  
     
2#

     
: "+ ,  " . .
  ",  
  :
     # 
    

"#$ S =-/#-, !

mrq +  "$ > +". J  wz\cd`Z. €Z g} gc\-d_va cdZld\ `_ cgZ-
 +"$+  I  >" >. \z, fZdZzw †dZ acdZ]a†\cv_h f]_g[_ `_
F$% ! R+ '5<" % g_|\l cdZ]Z`\.
$&" $&#$, >'& <!  &
  <5 <5.
/ % 5 !5, !>+% x]a †\z
>  '$*& '*85 "-
$  !%,  >$ !-
u[\ce †_o_`?
5   $E. %$ !" +-
 +55, !%$ +5 $% ! {_g_ld\ `\`_[ZjyZ cz\`az d\zw. {\jZ
 '$*&,  ,  8 >", 8 gZd g †\z: z`Zya\ fZ`az_ˆd c_j_d v_v
 $% @#%. O$  !%>5 - Zd[\je`Z\, gfZj`\ c\o\ c_zZcdZhd\je-
" > '8,   $$- `Z\ ojˆ[Z, v_v `_†_jZ Zo\[_. ’}jZ [\jZ,
 <& !%$, $& %> z} w^\ fZyZgZ]aja Zo ”dZz. €Z h f]\[-
%*& 5+  % $%  <" fZ†ad_ˆ fZ[_g_de c_j_d} v v_^[Zzw
> %  %  5. Zc`Zg`Zzw ojˆ[w. €w, fZ†da v_v y_]`a],
aja, \cja wyZ[`Z, v_v wv]_|\`a\ Zc`Zg-
‰\]ad\, †dZ ”dZ Z†\`e gvwc`Z? ‰\]a- `ZyZ ojˆ[_. ‰\[e f]ZdagZfZcd_gj\`ah
d\, h u`_ˆ. • h g g_c g\]ˆ, u`_ˆ, †dZ g} zhc`ZyZ a ZgZ`ZyZ, g_]\`ZyZ a c}]Z-
`\f]\z\``Z f]ayZdZgad\ ]_`Z aja yZ, c}d`ZyZ a _ff\dad`ZyZ fZzZy_ˆd a
fZu[`Z d_vwˆ [Zjzw. – w^\ f]\[wf]\- jw†|\ fZ`hde Zc`Zg`Z\ ojˆ[Z a c[\-
^[_j g_c u_]_`\\: u_ cdZjZz `_g\]`hv_ j_de Zo\[ y_]zZ`a†`\\.
`_l[\dch ŠZde Z[a` “u`_dZv gZcdZ†`Zl €_f]az\], v jˆoZzw zhc`Zzw ojˆ[w
vwŠ`a”, vZdZ]Zzw f]a[\dch Z†\`e [Zj- fZl[\d †_o_`-c_j_d. ‰Zd ”dZd c_j_d —
yZ [Zv_u}g_de, †dZ cjZgZ “[Zjz_” g Zd- gZgc\ `\ []\g`al. €_ c_zZz [\j\ ”dZ —
`Z|\`aa d_vZl \[} dZ^\ cZg\]|\``Z auZo]\d\`a\ dw]\‚vZyZ Zo\fad_, `Z,

<

mrp
mr

f]au`_ˆ, g\cez_ w[_†`Z\. `a, fZ`a- A% > — ' @& $ %$,
z_\d\ ja, `\ ^\j_ja ]\u_de jwv dZ`vZ, ' !+&, ' %E&   !-
fZza[Z]} dZ`vZ, Zyw]‚} dZ`vZ, d_v †dZ *" $&+ $%'$+  -
guhja [_ a `_]\u_ja gc\ [ZgZje`Z v]wf-   +-!. T"5 
`}za vwoav_za, d\z oZj\\ †dZ wcf\Š "$ !,  ",   
y]\†\cvZyZ c_j_d_ `\ [_g_j fZvZh, [_ a *+. 4" — !%#$%–%$! — <-
`_ug_ja ”dZd c_j_d †_o_`cvaz, — zZj, %8. M — <"+  + >$
†_o_`_z `\vZy[_ ca[\de a `_]\u_de dZ-  %>$& !E: R %* !"# 
`\`evZ, az ja|e o} g ]Zd f]Zj\ujZ! ‰Zd !+">. A%  !+# , !-
d_v_h ‘ajZcZ‘ah w ”dZyZ Z†\`e f]ZcdZ- ,  !!" +"8 $
yZ c_j_d_, u_z\†_d\je`Z fZ[ŠZ[h\yZ v +  + $  #
ojˆ[_z au d\cd_ a zhc_, g]Z[\ z_`dZg,  $ +%.
Ša`y_j_, aja ojˆ[_z, y[\ f]acwdcdgw- D, > + $. -
\d zhc`Zl ‘_]|, Zd fZ[Zo`}Š d\z, †dZ  " +,  !#,  %8I+
z} Zocw^[_\z g ”dZl yj_g\ a gfjZde [Z E! 5 + $*%, $$ R %>#
jˆjh-v\o_o_, u_g\]`wdZyZ g jacd j_g_|_. ".
(  -
 
      +"  
    + "   
  "    
     *  
–  # 01$ 
  01  " 
     # 
   #  
    

"#$ S =-/#-, !

mrs • gvwc`Z, a fZj\u`Z v_za r~¦ _]Zz_d_ jazZ`_, cZ[\]^_\-


yZch g ‚\[]\! —_ug\ u_f_Š jazZ`_ g_z
YZ |fa`_dZz yZdZghd z`Zya\ ojˆ[_ a `\ [Z]Zy? —_ug\ \[a`cdg\``Z\, †dZ g}
g ‡u\]o_l[^_`\, a g •]_`\, a g “w]vz\- ŠZdad\ fZjw†ade au ”dZyZ u_z\†_d\je-
`aa. €Z h `\ ga[\j, †dZo} y[\-dZ \yZ `ZyZ fjZ[_, — \yZ vacjZd_? €\ d_v `_[Z,
acfZjeuZg_ja [jh f]ayZdZgj\`ah c_- `\ d_v!
j_dZg. ‡ z\^[w d\z c_j_d} au |fa`_d_
a f]Z†aŠ “\g]Zf\lcvaŠ” a`y]\[a\`dZg / +. *" + $%'$-
g\javZj\f`Z cZ†\d_ˆdch cZ z`Zyaza +, $$ > < I 5 >'-
`_|aza d]_[a‚aZ``}za ojˆ[_za. ‰ . *"  !&!" +,
fZcj\[`\\ g]\zh v jˆjh-v\o_ow h `\- >'&  !$& +. %" -
auz\``Z fZ[_ˆ Z[a` a dZd ^\ c_j_d,  $ !+ > — <+" !$
cfjZ|e cZcdZhal au ad_jeh`cvaŠ a`- %+ +. : >< > > -
y]\[a\`dZg, u_ acvjˆ†\`a\z ]_ug\ †dZ " + !5+ %$+. P $, >-
|fa`_d_, vZdZ]}l, v_v z} w^\ g}hc`a- '& $%!$  E! E%, <
ja, a [jh `_c `\ z\`\\ ]Z[`Zl, †\z [jh E& '% '&<" R@ +, 
ad_jeh`‚\g.   +, $& +&  *+ !-
‰ ”dZz c_j_d\ `\d `av_vaŠ c\v]\dZg, 5". 7@ + !!  $,  
v]Zz\ cfZcZo_ g}^az_`ah cZv_ au ja- !%>5 # &+ — <
zZ`_. …_u_jZce o}, †\yZ f]Z\ — gZd ' +&+. : , >  $ '%
cZvZg}^az_jva [jh ‚ad]wcZg}Š, _ *"5 + , — !"
zZ^`Z a f]ZcdZ ]wv_za, aja, g v]_l`\z +   — "$ %$  $%.
cjw†_\, gZdv`wg g fZjZga`vw jazZ`_ N! !+, !%#.
gajvw. žŠ! €w v_v ^\ g} `\ fZ`az_\d\, D*& $ #! $&+
†dZ, g}^az_h d_vaz Zo]_uZz cZv, g} " !!+  5+  '5  *$%,
f]ZcdZ g}o]_c}g_\d\ gz\cd\ c Zd^az-  "$ &5  +%,   &-

6- !   ##"     " "      —


   #,        " .
mr

5 < & $ E"%8 O+ ++ !*" $+ +-
*$%. + +5? P R %- $+ ++ 2C–3C & Q 
 — - 0CC  #!…  %   + & 
Q'& #+!"&, +& +"$, !*"  ++ !+ >
$& & "$ +* , !- !!+.
*" "$+ !$+. : %  /&*  '"#%8 %8 +$%
" 8@"? P + + + "5 #!, &* % #+!"-
 — $"$ ++  %!$$% &, E   +,  !+#
#+!"! A% #,  8@5 — %$+ $+ '<+, >'& "5 
  , %>, 8@" !&? !" +*% ',  '& !-
/<"+ ++ 5". J 8@" "  " +. /&*-
!& ? A% > ", !5 <5"  ! + &, !+&  !
! > *$ 8@" +, + ++, > 5 ! #+!-
5 5 R   '58. " — R  '% <!$ 5 .
O8@"%8 !%  8@"
+  <+#"  3C  $- xZ[_g_ld\ d_vZl c_j_d oja^\ v u_g\]-
 +, '" % +& $, |\`aˆ Zo\[_, f\]\[ c_z}za gvwc`}za
<'" $$ %  <" $ !- a c}d`}za ojˆ[_za, [jh dZyZ †dZo}
<& #+!"& — !%" !+%8- Zcg\^ade gvwc w g_|aŠ yZcd\l, †dZo}
5 +% E". f]Zow[ade w `aŠ \\ `\z`ZyZ _ff\dad_.

<

“iZj_h [Zjz_”, 5 @# < '<$, @#, - mrr


*I " + "
Z`_ ^\ “vˆ‘d_ $. O"$ &+"  !5 -
Zo}v`Zg\``_h”, Z`_ + I", !> $$  85-
$''.
^\ “f]ZcdZ d\‘d\ja” / R @# *  '" .
A !+": ! &+#5
€\ Z†\`e-dZ fZg\ujZ y_cd]Z`Zza†\cvZl   !<>&+! / $+ 5
—Zccaa: cˆ[_ ”dZ ojˆ[Z f]a|jZ `\ `_-   @# '% !&"  '5 $,
f]hzwˆ au Y]\[`\l ‡uaa, _ cZg\]|ag &58I5 < +5  !> -
au]h[`}l v]ˆv g f]Zcd]_`cdg\ a gZ 58I , <5", <!5" '8
g]\z\`a, fZf_jZ w^\ c ˜_f_[_, Zd`Z- !558I5 !&. J R '% #!
cad\je`Z `\[_g`Z a g ga[\ o_`_je`}Š O@ ! !5 % -
d\‘d\j\l. $+  <,  " >&+, 
€Z d_v ja ”da d\‘d\ja o_`_je`}? !5 +5> $%& !!,  @# 
‰c\ ja z} c[\j_ja [jh dZyZ, †dZo} ”dZ '% &!"5 ! ! !$-
ojˆ[Z cd_jZ f]_u[`a†`}z `_ `_|aŠ 5 $.
cdZj_Š? €\ wfwcv_\z ja z} g d\‘d\jhŠ A !* >+ !" @ %-
fZ[]Zo`Zcda a [\d_ja, vZdZ]}\, v_v z} #"5  %,  % $ '*-
w^\ `\Z[`Zv]_d`Z wo\[ajace, a \cde c_- ". 9*, $$ , <!>"  %-
zZ\ g_^`Z\ g vwja`_]aa? $, + # '& '& '*" 
 @8, $ >'&  !%*"
7 +& @  '5<" -  + !"8. A,  $+ %>,
" < $ * @#, $& !- +* ! '*"  $$, 
'5 '& 5 +&  & '&>+ +. , ! $+ !-
"5   '$ !E. F8 '   #'< @+& 
"#$ S

t~~

 +>,  "$  "  !<"  !'"#? J,


 *$  % @#, —  R # !%>5  R$ “& @#-
@# *, +5$  !! & !E”  '%  R !* !
P5 !5 % !'5 $%%  !E%8 “!E-+%”?
 * +& & ' - 58 + <+*" !R$!-
, > !"<5  % 5 - +" +5".
+&  '$+ !E. H!&" !- A%,  <+ +* !*" <&$-
' !5 % 5  %, 5. A!+, '"  % $#$,
!+8 "$, > '%",  $>  @ %*" %* %  %#"
 *$, % < !!- ! <$& $&#$ >-!. J
>" ! &. !!'" <*" @ ! -
/!>+,  " -$ <- #>$+, <" %+  + !-
+*. / % — ' + — +"… / 'I+, @<8 *" 
!%% '$ !E. : >, …
  
'
– " #+   0 #  
  #   " – "  
 "      
            
  :  , ", !
         $  

  $   $ + 
<

ždw y]w|w ]\uwjed_d} u_d]_†\``}Š wcajal? ›g}, t~k


†_\ gc\yZ `\d. b_\ gc\yZ cd_]Z\, Zd]_-
zZ^`Z cvw|_de oZd_``Z\ fZvZj\`ahza fZg_]Zg a ZddZ-
†\``Z\ `_]Z[Zz u_ cdZj\dah, Zv_u}g_\d-
€w, gZd cv_^ad\ z`\, †dZ g} [wz_\d\ Z ch z`ZyZ jw†|\, †\z `ZgZg}[wz_``Z\.
dZz, v_v `_ cg\d fZhgjhˆdch `Zg}\ ]\- xZ”dZzw v_^[}l `Zg}l w[_†`}l
‚\fd}? xZj_y_\d\ ja g}, †dZ vdZ-dZ |_y cdZad ‘avca]Zg_de a u_fZza`_de,
wjed]_y\`a_je`}l [ZjyZ ca[ad g fZu\ †dZo}, `_vZfag ”da |_^va, cZg\]|ade
z}cjad\jh, `_f]h^\``Z [wz_\d, dw- Z[`_^[} f]}^Zv `_ `Zg}l w]Zg\`e a
^adch, _ fZdZz g[]wy gcv_vag_\d c v]a- cv_u_de c yZ][Zcdeˆ: gZd, w z\`h fZjw-
vZz “”g]av_!” a o\^ad `_ vwŠ`ˆ dgZ]ade †ajZce `ZgZ\ ojˆ[Z!
`\†dZ f]a`‚afa_je`Z `ZgZ\? x]Z\ gc\yZ a[da fZ f]ZdZ]\``}z
“]a[‚_de d]a ]_u_ `\d! [Z]Z^v_z. – w^\ `\ ]_u yZgZ]aj Z dZz,
—_oZd_ vwja`_]_-`Zg_dZ]_ yZ]_u[Z †dZ g f]\^`a\ g]\z\`_ gz\cdZ v_]dZ|-
oZje|\ fZŠZ^_ `_ v]ZfZdjagwˆ ]_oZdw va a fZza[Z] g Y]\[`\l ‡uaa †_cdZ ac-
a`^\`\]_, vZdZ]}l fZcd\f\``Z, |_y u_ fZjeuZg_ja ‘]wvd}. • gZd, [_g_ld\ fZ-
|_yZz zZ[\]`aua]w\d cd_]Z\, _ vZy[_ f]Zow\z c[\j_de Z[a` |_y g ”dZz ^\
vZja†\cdgZ auz\`\`al [Zcday_\d Zf]\- `_f]_gj\`aa.
[\j\``Zl g\ja†a`}, dZ Z` fZjw†_\d `Z- ‰} ^\ u`_\d\, †dZ `_‘_]|a]Zg_de
gZ\ v_†\cdgZ, d.\. `ZgZ\ ojˆ[Z. zhc`}z ‘_]|\z zZ^`Z \[g_ ja `\ jˆ-
€Z g vwja`_]aa, y[\ gc\, v_^\dch, au- o}\ ZgZa — o_vj_^_`}, oZjy_]cva\
g\cd`Z, v_^[}l `Zg}l |_y [_\dch c f\]‚}, fZza[Z]} a v_fwcd`}l jacd.
oZje|az d]w[Zz. ‹} vZzfaja]w\z {_, _ v_v u_z\†_d\je`Z fZjw†_\dch ‘_]-
|a]ZvZaug\cd`Z\ a auz\`h\z a`y]\[a- |a]Zg_``_h _lg_? (ždZd ]\‚\fd o}j
\`d}, w `_c \cde gZuzZ^`Zcde cvZ]]\v- aujZ^\` g zZ\l f\]gZl v`ay\ “…_u_`-
da]Zg_de [_^\ d\Š`ZjZyaˆ, `Z cdZhd ja ‹_`y_j.”)
"#$ S =-/#-, !

t~m †\`e †_cdZ g cZg]\z\``}Š ]\‚\f- S#,  "$   < >" -
d_Š acfZjeuw\dch v_]dZ|v_. ‡ †dZ \cja #, I" @ +5,
fZf}d_dech guhde `\ v_]dZ|vw, `\ jwv, * %># !%" !"
`\ _lgw, _, `_f]az\], y]w|w? ! ''$.
‰\[e fZf_[_ˆdch a`Zy[_ Z†\`e dg\]- / !" !+&, '$ !-
[}\ y]w|a, vZdZ]}\ w^\ az\ˆd [Zj^- E, '$*&  @# '%% & 
`}l u_f_Š a f]aja†`}l gvwc, `Z `_ uwo  +5,   !%>5 <+>"
dg\][}, v_v v_]dZ|v_. {_ g\[e d_va\ !&+ — >  !5,
y]w|a f]ZcdZ f]Zchdch g v_u_`, †dZo}  >  5 &&+  *$+!
c `aza f]ayZdZgaja †dZ-dZ gvwc`Z\! • H" + !. D$ "
gZgc\ `\ Zohu_d\je`Z ‘_]|a]Zg_de y]w- <$ 5 ! <? A%   "-
|a, _ [Zcd_dZ†`Z dZyZ, †dZ Z`a fZg_]hd- ! /<"+ $"$ # $>$
ch g cZwc\ gz\cd\ c ‘_]|a]Zg_``}za  +5+, '*", '" %$, +$",
ZgZ_za, u_`az_h g v_u_`\ dZ z\cdZ, vZ- +, '*"  $$ %  -
dZ]Z\ Zo}†`Z Zdg\[\`Z v_]dZ|v\.  &. M# '& '" , '-
', %  …   — !"&
/ 'I+, +& '%+ " , $$ '&>. ++ 5 # %#! %" !55.
/ !& @#  $$, D & %, >  !> -
 + >58 I. 1$ !E&  ,  <$  !<>&+  !%>
!+& '%% & >" $, !R- !5& $%, %$&  $< @-
+%  5+ &&+. : '$*& #& I. H 5   —
'%8 !" +>$ *. A  +"5 $ +%, >-
!$,  +&  +  !- '& I '& !$&& %+. H>"
 , *+, $+  *++ $  % +5$+, !%# !-
<  %, + +&+ 5  "+ +% @+% $%*8I &,  % +
!>&+. ' !$ .

&      ,     !    ,        -


. '       "     , 
    
      !    ,    #  .
"#$ S =-/#-, !

t~q ‰Z gchvZz cjw†_\, vZy[_ g} cd_`\d\ fZ- |\ [jh [Zjz} zZywd Z†\`e |a]ZvZ g_-
[_g_de fZjw†ag|\\ch ojˆ[Z `_ cdZj `\- ]ea]Zg_dech — Zd Z[`ZyZ dZjevZ zhc_ c
[Zcd_dv_ g cZwc\ `\ ow[\d. €_[\ˆce, †dZ `\oZje|az vZja†\cdgZz jwv_, [Z cZ†\-
a `\[Zcd_dv_ g f]ahd`Zz _ff\dad\ dZ^\ d_`ah zhc_ c ]acZz, yZ]ZŠZz, u\j\`eˆ,
`\ Zv_^\dch! ‘]wvd_za a [_^\ y]_`_dZz.
{_g_ld\ fZf]Zow\z cvZ`cd]wa]Zg_de
¤_cd‘w[ — dZ†v_ wu cgZˆ cZocdg\``wˆ [Zjzw. – g_z zZyw
u_]_`\\ cv_u_de: c_z}\ a`d\]\c`}\
€w, †dZ ^\: g}hc`aja, †dZ [Zjz_ zZ- `Zg|\cdg_ Zo`_]w^ag_ˆdch `_ cd}v\
^\d o}de a gZgc\ o\u ZoZjZ†va, _ zZ^\d ]_u`}Š vwjedw]. €\Z^a[_``}\ a [_^\
o}de u_g\]`wd_ g jˆoZl jacd — ga- f_]_[Zvc_je`}\ cZ†\d_`ah f]Z[wvdZg
`Zy]_[`}l, _lgZg}l, dwdZg}l, jafZ- a d\Š`ZjZyal u_†_cdwˆ f]agZ[hd v u_-
g}l — gfjZde [Z v_fwcd`ZyZ. xZl[\z z\†_d\je`}z ]\uwjed_d_z. €Z a ]acv
[_je|\. dwd `_aoZje|al: cdZad wfwcdade †dZ-dZ
‰_^\` gvwcZgZl dZ` jacd_-ZoZjZ†va: v_^w\\ch z_jZg_^`}z, a g\ce f]Z\vd,
^\j_d\je`Z, †dZo} g `\z o}j u_z\d\` g\ce u_z}c\j ^[\d g jw†|\z cjw†_\ cZ-
vacj}l dZ`. • \\ g_^`\\ — \yZ _]Z- o_†eh zacv_. nZ]Z|Z, \cja a gZgc\ `\
z_d. €w a vdZ zZ^\d u_f]\dade acfZje- zwcZ]`Z\ g\[]Z.
uZg_de [jh _]Zz_dau_‚aa [Zjz} jˆ- ‰Zd d_v h Z[`_^[} fwcdajch g ”vc-
owˆ []wywˆ u\j\`e, ŠZde o} a v]_fagw, f\]az\`d} `_[ o_czZl — d]_[a‚a-
(czZ]Z[a`Zg}l aja ga|`\g}l jacd). ‡ Z``}z wuo\vcvaz ojˆ[Zz au zhc_,
†dZ, \cja — `\ g v_†\cdg\ c_zZcdZhd\je- dw|\``ZyZ g oZje|Zz vZja†\cdg\
`Zl Zo\]dva, _ g vZzoa`_‚aa c []wyaz ZgZ\l, c]\[a vZdZ]}Š Zohu_d\je`Z
jacdZz? f]acwdcdgwˆd v_fwcd`}\ jacdeh, jwv,
‰ dZ ^\ g]\zh fZ`hd`Z, †dZ f]ZfZ]- zZ]vZge, f\]‚}, v_]dZ|v_. ‡ v `az [Z-
‚aa zhc_ a []wyaŠ a`y]\[a\`dZg g ‘_]- o_gjhˆdch, g u_gacazZcda Zd c\uZ`_,
"#$ S

t~s

fZ†da jˆo}\ ZgZa, _ u_ `aza a ‘]wv- `}\ ZgZa au o_cz}. ‡ cd_`\|e ^[_de
d}… ‰\[e u_z\†_d\je`Z\ ojˆ[Z! €Z u_- yZcdh — `avdZ `\ u`_\d u_]_`\\, vZy[_
z\†_d\je`}z Z`Z o}g_\d, dZjevZ vZy[_ \\ u_v_^wd. €\d\Š`ZjZya†`Z!
f]ayZdZgj\`Z `_ gcˆ c\zeˆ aja oZje- €Z `\ g Z[`Zz dZjevZ ]\cdZ]_`\ [\jZ.
|wˆ vZzf_`aˆ, [_ fZ[_`Z `_ oZje|Zz ’Zy o} c `az, `Z g\[e a [Zz_-dZ dZ^\
ojˆ[\, y[\ gc\zw `_l[\dch cgZ\ z\cdZ: cZgc\z `\ gc\y[_ \cde gZuzZ^`Zcde fZ-
[Zj^`Z o}de d_vZ\ ]_u`ZZo]_ua\, †dZ [_de Zo\[ gc\l c\ze\ c]_uw. ’}g_\d, †dZ
yj_u ]_[w\dch. a `\ f]ayZdZga|e oZje|Z\ Zo\\ ojˆ-
‡ v_v fZ[_g_de o_czw fZ]‚aZ``Z? [Z, [_ a u_ cdZjZz Z[`Zg]\z\``Z gc\Š
…_v yZdZgade a fZ[_g_de o_czw g ]\- \[ZvZg `\ cZo\]\|e.
cdZ]_`\? iZ]|Z†va, z_j\`eva\ d_[- ‰ Zo\z, cjw|_ld\, v_v_h a[\h w
^a`} — †dZ dZjevZ `a o}jZ f\]\f]Z- z\`h ]Z[aj_ce.
oZg_`Z. €Z, gZ-f\]g}Š, g yZ]|Z†\v `\
wz\_\dch gc\, †dZ ŠZ†\dch fZjZ^ade, _ *+ +$ , > +& '-
gZ-gdZ]}Š — [ZjyZ! x]ayZdZga|e u_]_- +5 !*"  '+%. 95, +
`\\ — `\d `a†\yZ Šw^\, †\z f\]\g_]\`- $%8$, + %$, !+% +$,
/ '-
  :    

      
  0 #   "
   1   
     :
 $       
  #   "    
 "      " # 
        " 
     " "

=  : — ' ! 
<

$@5, 5'$  &, '$ !5*+ R% $%$E8…  " %- t~
!E, >$, <", !+&, '$- $+ !+!
*&  > I 1 !#. T"5  $- F++  <&   %$-
!%& ++ $ *, $$  %'E& — !5, !%+   $!5$  +%%,
!" #!  * - >'&   ' !>&+   -
 !'#. J <+ >$%  +5  <', <*+  !$ 
"5. !5*+ + #% +%-!$.
O"$ <>" '%+ '&+ '- A% , +, "$ >" '"#5,
<+. !'%+ '8  +& !-  +   $ — $$ <.
5$,  $+ %$&85 - D$  I <", R > !-
&  '"# $< 5 E I  &  & @-
'+&:  !& $!%&  — , @%? 1-+ —  +& <.  $%%
!+ +5, %$, +$"  $ ,   % R %*  # <$+5 +
<. : !"   '+ !5$, '+,  R  '<$  !+ 
!%"  $*5 $$ '& !!-   +&, <&  . 9&
&+,  % +& !*++  &+ - ! !%>  '8. M#,
+. '& ! !*" !%$& % $%, +!>  . J *-
$ %%, $$ R %*  '+,   $$ < $, $$ ! +-
"#$ S

t~ƒ

!*&+  '&+ @&+ %- š\ zZ^`Z fZjZ^ade, `_f]az\], zZ-


$+: !  !%, + +5, jZ[wˆ cd]w†vZgwˆ ‘_cZje, _ dZ a cf_]-
+ +, > *… ^w? ‰ c_zwˆ-dZ c\]\[a`w zZ^`Z! , gZd
A>? A%,  %*! P, " +*- \\ — d}vgw! • †dZ, \cja fZf]ZoZg_de
 !-<+%, "  !$  $, `\ gc\ ]\u_de Z[a`_vZgZl `\v]wf`Zl cZ-
$$ 5   R <: !%# +% jZzvZl? €_f]az\], fZjZ^ade g`wd]e
 '"#+ $> $!$ +5- zZjZ[wˆ v_]dZ‘\ja`vw ‚\javZz aja
 '%". 1& $%. A 5 !5, > zZ]vZge fZ]\u_de fZv]wf`\\? YZ†`}\
%  *  . U … <- a`y]\[a\`d}, d_va\, v_v jwv, oZjy_]-
*$. O> $, $$%8 5 '&> 8, cval f\]\‚, fZ]\u_de cZjZzvZl, o_vj_-
$ 8 +%  '$+ !E. ^_` — `_acvZcZv, jZzdavZz g fZjc_`-
J % : " %  <- daz\d]_. o^_]\``Z\ [Z ]wzh`Zcda ]\-
"8. 9 !*" %$  !+ o]}|vZ, _?
+, '"   $%$%+%, >& €w, fZŠZ^\, `_c w^\ a `\ Zcd_`Zgade…
!E  <%, + <,   <" '%-
"+, 5   *. O* '% #.
5


 + - 
 "   
   
  
–
      # 
 
"

 

3 '  
'  
<

€_ †acdZz oj\l. ‡ \cja guhde f]Z[wvd `\[Z]ZyZl, t~r


]woj\l u_ fhde[\chd? €w, fZ]_oZd_ˆd
cjagZ†`Zz! `_[ `az fZg_]_, [_ a f]Z[_[wd u_ [g\-
cda fhde[\chd — g\[e ŠZ]Z|_h f]a-
‹`\ ŠZd\jZce o} ZcZoZ fZyZgZ]ade f]Z o}je [g\cda ]woj\l-dZ? {_, d_v-dZ Z`Z
z_cjZ. xZdZzw †dZ z_cjZ — Z[`_ au d_v. €Z †dZo} fZjw†ade dw d}ch†w, `_[Z
f]a†a`, fZ vZdZ]}z h cd_]_ˆce `\ \cde a fZ]_oZd_de ]_u g [\chde oZje|\, a Zo-
`a†\yZ o\u ZcZoZl `w^[} g ]\cdZ]_`_Š. cjw^ade `\ Z[`ZyZ vja\`d_, _ fhd\]}Š,
Y\l†_c h gc\ Zohc`ˆ. _ cj\[Zz u_ `aza f\]\z}de fZcw[w, fZ-
—\cdZ]_dZ]} w^\ fZ`hja, †dZ ]_oZ- z\`hde cv_d\]da, [_ z_jZ †dZ \\!
d_de c f]Z[wvd_za [Z]Zyaza g}yZ[`\\, [`az cjZgZz, ]\cdZ]_dZ]} gc\ fZ-
`\^\ja c [\|\g}za. ‰Z-f\]g}Š, †_\ `hja, a h c aŠ g}gZ[_za cZyj_c\`. €Z,
gc\yZ, f]Z[wvd [Z]ZyZl dZyZ cdZad — Z` u`_\d\, \cja ca[ad g †\jZg\v\ ^jZocvZ-
gvwc`\\ cgZ\yZ [\|\gZyZ _`_jZy_. Y `az Š_j[\lcv_h ^ajv_, dZ Z`_ `avw[_ `\ [\-
f]Z\ ]_oZd_de, Z` `\ d]\ow\d wŠa]\- `\dch, [_^\ \cja Z` cd_`\d f]Z[_g_de
`al a ZcZo}Š d\Š`av, †dZo} au `\yZ fZ- ‘w_-y]_, wcd]a‚ a g}]\uvw fZ[ d]ˆ‘\je-
jw†aj_ce gfZj`\ f]a\zj\z_h fZ gvwcw `}z cZwcZz.  jZocdgZ f]Zhgadch g ”vZ-
\[_. ‰Z-gdZ]}Š, f]Z[_g_de [Z]ZyZl f]Z- `Zzaa `_ z\jZ†_Š. €_f]az\], `_ z_cj\.
[wvd g ]\cdZ]_`\ — g}yZ[`Z! ‰uhj acŠZ- {Zfwcdaz, `w^`Z ^jZow z_cjZ, †dZo}
[`wˆ ‚\`w, wz`Z^aj `_ f]ZaugZje`Z\ cz_u_de cvZgZ]Z[vw [jh ^_]va f]Z[wvd_
‚\jZ\ †acjZ Zd d]\Š [Z [\chda, gZd d\o\ u_ d}ch†w ]woj\l. …_vZ\ z_cjZ Z` [jh
a ‚\`_ g v_jevwjh‚aa. šcja, v f]az\]w, ”dZyZ gZuez\d? {wz_\d\, f]aja†`Z\?
guhja vwcZv zhc_ [jh cd\lv_ u_ fhdecZd …_v o} `\ d_v! ` gZuez\d †dZ-dZ ]w-
]woj\l, _ fZcj\ `\Šad]}Š z_`afwjh- oj\l fZ d]a[‚_de u_ owd}jvw, a u_f_|-
‚al f]Z[_ja \yZ u_ d}ch†w fhdecZd, dZ vZz ”dZyZ z_cj_ u_ywoad c_z}l jw†-
c]_uw fZjw†aja f]ao}je g d}ch†w ]w- |al, c_z}l [Z]ZyZl f]Z[wvd, f]Z[wvd,
"#$ S =-/#-, !

tk~ vZdZ]}z yZ][adch, gZuzZ^`Z, jw†|al €Z guhde c g_c Zo\_`a\, †dZ g} `a-
‘\]z\] ¤]_`‚aa aja `_aoZj\\ w[_†ja- vZy[_ `\ cd_`\d\ ^_]ade ŠZ]Z|wˆ ]}ow
g}l ]}o_v Y]\[au\z`ZyZ zZ]h. g fjZŠZz z_cj\, h `\ zZyw a fZ”dZzw
€w †dZ ^ d} [\j_\|e-dZ? €w fZ- f]\[jZ^w c\l†_c Z[`Z au cd_]}Š, jˆ-
†\zw d} [jh ^_]va ”dZyZ |\[\g]_ `\ oaz}Š z`Zˆ a f]Zg\]\``}Š g]\z\`\z
guhj fZ[Zo_ˆ\\ z_cjZ? “\o\ ^\ `_[Z ojˆ[, `Z c `\vZdZ]}za g_]a_‚ahza.
o}jZ gc\yZ p~ y, d} c”vZ`Zzaj-dZ g ]\- ‰ v`ay\ “…_u_`, z_`y_j” h `_ug_j ”dZ
uwjed_d\ ]woj\l fhde, _ fZd\]hj z\`h ojˆ[Z “—}oZl c †\c`ZvZz a va`uZl fZ
v_v vja\`d_ `_ g\va g\†`}\, fZdZzw ]\‚\fd_z owŠ_]cvaŠ \g]\\g”. “_z ]}o_
†dZ au^Zy_ u_ `\cvZjevZ d}ch† ]w- v_v ]_u c`_†_j_ Zo^_]ag_\dch g z_cj\,
oj\l — `\ c_zZ\ ]_‚aZ`_je`Z\ f]aZo- _ h ŠZ†w f]\[jZ^ade g_z []wyZl cfZcZo
]\d\`a\! f]ayZdZgj\`ah ”dZyZ ojˆ[_, cfZcZo, j\-
xZcjw|_ld\ z\`h, zZa [Z]Zya\ †a- ^_al `_ fZg\]Š`Zcda a fZugZjhˆal
d_d\ja! €\ wfZ[Zojhld\ce ”daz ]\cdZ- gZgc\ auo\^_de f]az\`\`ah z_cj_.
]_dZ]_z, `\ yZdZged\ ŠZ]Z|a\ f]Z[wv- {_g_ld\ gc\ fZ fZ]h[vw.
d} `_ fjZŠZz z_cj\! ‰ZZo\ `a†\yZ `\
yZdZged\ `_ fjZŠZz z_cj\, fZdZzw †dZ P!%+, !! +  %$ &'  >#%-
z_cjZ g d\Š ojˆ[_Š, y[\ Z`Z `\ZoŠZ[a- , #5, '< +$ $,  +-
zZ, ”dZ v_v ŠZjcd [jh Šw[Z^`av_, ”dZ v_v &+ '&+ $%+  <!+ — 5
vZ`‚\]d`}l u_j [jh zwu}v_`d_. €\je- <5 &  F<++ +
uh cjw|_de caz‘Z`a†\cval Z]v\cd], ac- +$ $%5, 'I+ + $++
fZj`hˆal ‹Z‚_]d_, g o\dZ``Zz y_]_-    !.
^\, fZ`az_\d\ z\`h? ˜_j [Zj^\` o}de Q%, !$  , $$  !-
fZ[Zo_ˆaz, ŠZjcd [Zj^\` o}de v_†\- * ! E!%, %*  '"#%8 $-
cdg\``}z, z_cjZ [Zj^`Z o}de oj_yZ- 8"$%, < '"#+ $>+
]Z[`}z a gvwc`}z. &, ' %$E%, +$", !E
3 ' 
' 
'  
<

#$+, ! ", 5  !- '<"5,  %, %


 &' %! '<" tkk
* +5 !%%  ' ! $- ',  " & !.
E ' +&
& .
 %>& / *$ &'&  $ $
 " 
$!$ '%" !E , !  $$ $. W " <+*",  -
 + &, !! +$ !-   *88  88 > $, !-
< $<  >$+. *, >+ %$&"   &'%. T%>#
F+% &'% !<  $ I- 'I !" $%  +, "
   !"E, !&! +"8 ,  $"5,  !+ &*"  
!>& %, + $- &'%  !*"  >"8. D
, % +"5, I! $+ &' '% ,   <5 
 # !E > !E. +- $%$ <-< , > !! $ !-
,  &', $%8 & '% - $. H ':  &' %5 >&
", *5,  '"  +" 5 !!&, $% $& 5  +.
'& %8 *$% # $ A   R %> " $: %*
+ — R '+, 5  >'& &'%  $%,   < 88
!E $&  $%  +. >". * $%  &'  +, 
K&'% %*  !>%8 $%   >< (C–(3 $% !  !!-
!*  +,   #$+ - + *88 >" $, !$ &' I
5>+ %5+, $+, >'&  $>$  %! $  !!%". O!" '&
4 +  
  3 


  
     # 
 . . 
    #   
   #  
½   # 
6 1 
 

"#$ S =-/#-, !

tkq I < !. < +%% R —}ov_ y]Zu[ehza


E$ +* !$" — !"  &', 
$ & !+ $, > …dZ `\ \j ]}ow g ga`Zy]_[`}Š ja-
 !!  !!  5! cdehŠ — z`ZyZ fZd\]hj. {_^\ \cja f]Z-
cdZ fZjZ^ade ]}ow, Zo\]`wdwˆ ga`Z-
‰Zd a gc\ — `_|_ u_z\†_d\je`_h ]}o_ y]_[`}z jacdZz, `_ y]aje, [_^\ \cja
yZdZg_. “\f\]e, fZv_ Z`_ \\ yZ]h†_h, \\ o_`_je`Z fZ^_]ade \\ `_ z_cj\ — ]}o_
`_[Z fZjade cZwcZz au owjeZ`_, va`u} u[Z]ZgZ g}ay]}g_\d Zd dZl vacja`va
a †\c`Zv_ a… zZ^`Z Zcdw^_de. {\jZ g a _]Zz_d_, vZdZ]}l cZZo_\d \l ga`Z-
dZz, †dZ d]_[a‚aZ``Z d_vwˆ ]}ow fZ[_- y]_[`}l jacd. oz_v`ad\ ]}ow g z_c-
ˆd g ŠZjZ[`Zz ga[\, vZy[_ owjeZ` f]\- jZ, f]ac}fed\ cZjeˆ a fjZd`Z Zo\]`a-
g]_dadch g []Z^_\\, _]Zz_d`Z\ ^\j\. d\ ga`Zy]_[`}za jacdehza — ”dZ gc\,
‡ \cja fZ[_de \\ yZ]h†\l? †dZ `\ZoŠZ[azZ c[\j_de f\]\[ d\z, v_v
‡ ŠZdad\ \\ Z[`w g_]a_‚aˆ ”dZyZ wjZ^ade \\ `_ ]\|\dvw `_[ wyjhza aja
ojˆ[_, ]_u w^ g c_zZz `_†_j\ z} u_g\- g cvZgZ]Z[vw c z_cjZz…
ja ]_uyZgZ] Z cZ†\d_`aa ]}o} a ga`Z-
y]_[`ZyZ jacd_? ‰Z g]\zh g_]va [Zo_ge- H$ !!'% !" ''%"-
d\ g owjeZ` [\chdZv-[]wyZl ga`Zy]_[- $% (+* <+"  $%!%8 @")
`}Š jacde\g. …Zy[_ owjeZ` ow[\d yZdZg, $"$ >. O+ ' > $-
g}`ed\ aŠ, [_ld\ Zcd}de, fZv]Z|ad\ E5 !+ +8 '8 $!-
z\jvZ-z\jvZ a g\]`ad\ g owjeZ` gz\- $ 8'+ #$+ &+ ++,
cd\ c va`uZl a †\c`ZvZz. ‡vvZ][ gvwc_   , 8", '+  %>#+
cd_`\d \\ `_c}\``\\, \\ _]Zz_d`\\, '<+ — $   5, > -
\\ oj_yZ]Z[`\\. • ”dZ ow[\d f\]g}l <5 R$+  +<.
`_| |_y g cdZ]Z`w u_g\d`Zl ‚\ja — K!%, $ !+%, (CC  >-
[Zjz} au ]}o}.  +  $  &!"  , !-
tkp
"#$ S =-/#-, !

tks 5 !+#5, 0–2 & *$ ,  $+ 8 +%I 5
+%$. ", >'&  '& $- “$+ !”.
+>$. P'" $ '*+ +%$ : & +  %, > !  -
 +%$  — !& $+,  , # .
 !. D !>%%, > <- P5 !5 % 5 <-
! +%$ <+5  &  *&, $ &'& $ % % < +%$ 
 <+, > +"  5 > > + !*  5>
+", '" 0–2 !$ $!5I- '%" , !+#5,   $!-
 &' '%"  <+#  - 5. A ! !& !%<&"$ !$
. F+ $  %&+ $$   +  !&. A# '%-
+ %+  5. ,  + 5  %. F%
#%8  >I%8 &'% !- * +" $E8 *$ +-
, +*" %&+ %+  %* &.
 &  > 3–(C +% - G* &'%  $%  < %+.
& "5. 4 &'%  "5. W '& 5 <5  &'& 'I+ + (,0–
O+ ++ <  %!$ 5- (,2 $,  % +5  &'& $<" '&
$ &>$ #@  $%! "8  !$&&+ %+.
!!" + #5 &'& '%", / %$, ! +!% (=C ]
$& * 5"  !. '8 5 0C +%, I 3–6 +%
1%" !%> %8I%8 $- " %+55 $>$ ! -
$%  !' !5& <! #@- + +.
³
‰} ^\ u`_\d\, v_v h `\ jˆojˆ Zo\fad, tk
[_? ‰\[e h, cZocdg\``Z yZgZ]h, fZdZzw a
`_†_j yZdZgade, fZdZzw a fZjˆoaj vw-
ja`_]aˆ, †dZ cja|vZz caje`Z `\ jˆ-
oaj Zo\fad.
€Z o}j f\]aZ[ g zZ\l ^au`a, vZy[_
z`\ Z†\`e †_cdZ f]aŠZ[ajZce o}g_de g
“_|v\`d\. • Z[`_^[} cjw†ajZce †w[Z.
‹`\ ]_ccv_u_ja Zo Zdv]}g|\zch g
“_|v\`d\ _u\]o_l[^_`cvZz ]\cdZ]_`\.
…w]}, ‚}fjhd_, ’\u ZcZoZl `_[\^[} gvwc`Z fZ\cde h fZ-
\Š_j g ”dZd ]\cdZ]_`. ` Zv_u_jch cZgc\z
aja xZ†\zw `\oZje|az. {Zcv_ w gŠZ[_ c v]_dvaz
Zfac_`a\z z\`ˆ Zv_`†ag_j_ce `_[fa-
g ‡u\]o_l[^_`\ chza “i_zow]y\]”, “nZd-[Zy”. – †wde `\
]_ug\]`wjch, †wde `\ w|\j. …_v ŠZ]Z|Z
`\ jˆohd cw[_v_ fZcdwfaja g ”dZd zZz\`d zZa `Zya, vZ-
dZ]}\ gZf]\va u[]_gZzw cz}cjw, gc\ ^\
f\]\cdwfaja fZ]Zy ”dZyZ u_g\[\`ah!
— ‹Z^`Z z\`ˆ fZczZd]\de?
— ‹\`ˆ z} \\ `\ Zdf\†_d_ja, w `_c
ow[\d z\`ˆ…
— › g_c \cde _u\]o_l[^_`cva\ ojˆ[_?
— {_, w `_c \cde vwd_o}, jhg_`ya,
fada, [ˆ|o_]_…
— ‡ fjZg? xjZg _u\]o_l[^_`cval
\cde w g_c? — ždZ o}j w[_] `a^\ fZhc_
"#$ T =!6, ;69",  4#/!  >3/%1?-/ -/ @%9" 2!'

tkƒ c zZ\l cdZ]Z`}. – u`_ˆ, cvZjevZ g]\- gZ[}… ‰c\ _u\]o_l[^_`cvZ\ z\`ˆ wz\-
z\`a `_[Z fZd]_dade `_ _u\]o_l[^_`- _jZce `_ Z[`Zz jacdZ†v\.
cval fjZg, fZ`az_ˆ, `_cvZjevZ `\g}- — …wd_o}, [Zjzw, vw]a‚w fZ-|\va`-
yZ[`Z\ ”dZ ojˆ[Z c dZ†va u]\`ah Zo\- cva, fjZg g} w^\ fZcd_gaja, vw]a‚_-
fad_. jhg_`ya… bdZ fZ[_[ad\ v fjZgw?
— xjZg z} zZ^\z f]ayZdZgade, `Z — ’_]_`a`w?
`_[Z u_v_u}g_de ŠZdh o} u_ [g_ †_c_, Z` — nZ]Z|Z!
cdZhde `_ fjad\ [Zj^\`… xZcjw|_ld\, []wueh zZa! “nZ]Z|Z”
— Yd_ged\! –… z} f]a\[\z. ”dZ `\ dZ cjZgZ! ždZ o}jZ g\javZj\f`Z,
– `\ f]ag}v cw[ade Z u_g\[\`ahŠ fZ fZd]hc_ˆ\!
g`\|`\zw ga[w, `Z a`d\]e\] ”dZyZ v_‘\, {Zjz_ cgZ\ˆ cZ†`Zcdeˆ, _]Zz_dZz,
z\o\je, fZcw[_, c\]e\u`Zcde a Z[`Z- `_c}\``Zcdeˆ gvwc_ c oj_yZ]Z[`Zl
g]\z\``Z cv]Zz`Zcde f_]`h, vZdZ]}l vacja`vZl fZ]_uaj_ gc\Š. €\z\[j\`-
o\c\[Zg_j cZ z`Zl w gŠZ[_, o}ja Z†\`e `Z u_v_u_ja \\. …w]a‚_ fZ-|\va`cva…
wo\[ad\je`}. d_vaza vw]} o}ja g zZ\z [\dcdg\, _ c
d\Š fZ] d_vaŠ vw] oZje|\ `\ [\j_ˆd. –
`\ zZyw Zfac_de cjZg_za, `_cvZjevZ ŠZ-
…w]a‚_ ]Z|_ o}j_ ”d_ vw]a‚_ g cgZ\l f]ZcdZd\
fZ-|\va`cva a o\u}cvwc`Zcda. …wd_o}… – ŠZd\j o}
u_gd]_v_de v_^[}l [\`e d_vaza vwd_o_-
Zd d\dw|va nw]_z_` za. xjZg… z_z_ [Z]Zy_h, u_†\z h gc\z
yZgZ]ˆ, †dZ wz\ˆ yZdZgade _u\]o_l[-
‹} f]a\Š_ja `\oZje|Zl vZzf_`a\l ^_`cval fjZg? ’_]_`a`_, f]ayZdZg-
z\`e|\, †\z †\]\u †_c. š\ ]_u f]ZczZ- j\``_h c cwŠZ‘]wvd_za a v_|d_`_za,
d]\ja jacdZ†va, u_z\`hˆa\ z\`ˆ… fZ[_``_h v ”dZzw fjZgw, v_u_jZce, f]\[-
c_j_d}-|z_j_d}… `_fadva-vZj}-cZva- `_u`_†_j_ce `\ [jh y]\|`}Š u\zjh`,
  - 

  
  "  # 
*     
 !  ,    ,  "
 

14  -$  $ 0   


>

`Z [jh `\oZ^ad\j\l. …w]a‚_-jhg_`ya… … `_z g}|j_ Z†\`e cv]Zz`_h, `\g}- tkr


iZcfZ[a, v_vZˆ v]_cagZl Z`_ o}j_, v_v cZv_h ^\`a`_ fZ az\`a nw]_z_`. šl
_ff\dad`Z `_ `\l jZf_j_ce vZ]Z†v_, Zo- o}ja f]ahd`} cjZg_ `_|\l yZ]h†\l
`_^_h o\jZ\, cZ†`Z\ zhcZ, fZ[ vZdZ]}z oj_yZ[_]`Zcda, v_v zZywd o}de f]ahd-
cv]}g_j_ce `_†a`v_ au y]\‚vaŠ Z]\- `} _fjZ[acz\`d} `_cdZh\zw _]dacdw,
ŠZg, _jeowŠ_]}, j_g_|_`} a vZ]a‚}! oj\cdh\ acfZj`ag|\zw cgZˆ ]Zje.
‰c\, †\yZ `\ ]Z[ad u\zjh wuo\vcv_h, `Z — x]Zoj\z_ w z\`h c `\l, — ]_ccv_-
†dZ `\ZoŠZ[azZ [jh `_cdZh\l _u\]- u}g_j €_dav. — x]ag\u\|e †dZ-`aow[e
o_l[^_`cvZl vwŠ`a, f]acwdcdgZg_jZ g c o_u_]_ `\ d_vZ\, †wde-†wde dZjevZ `\
ojˆ[_Š g fZj`Zz Zo\z\; ga[azZ, gc\ d_v, v_v Z`_ d]\oZg_j_, _ Z`_ gc\ o]Zc_\d,
”dZ f]ag\uja au ’_vw. • gc\, gc\ ojˆ[_ ca[ad — fj_†\d a `\ yZdZgad.
o}ja f]ayZdZgj\`} f]_gaje`Z, `\ v bdZ \\ zZ^`Z ]_ccv_u_de Z [Zo]ZcZ-
†\zw o}jZ f]a‚\fadech, gc\ dZjevZ gZc- g\cd`Zl ^\`a`\ a y\`a_je`Zz fZg_]\
Ša_jZ. nw]_z_` fZcj\ ”daŠ cjZg? ‹`\, `_f]a-
— …dZ ŠZuha` ]\cdZ]_`_? z\], [Zo_gade `\†\yZ, \cja dZjevZ `\
— –. ‹\`h €_dav uZgwd. — …Z z`\ fZ- fZ[\jadech c g_za ŠZdh o} c_z}z f]Z-
[Z|\j dZd c_z}l f_]\`e, vZdZ]}l [_- cd}z ]\‚\fdZz au c`Zyc|ao_d\je`ZyZ
g\†_ gcd]\†_j z\`h w gŠZ[_. u_f_c_ d\dw|va nw]_z_`.
— ’]_d, _ zZ^\|e d} cd\]\de cjZg_ …w]a‚_ `w^`_ ŠZ]Z|_h. €Z]z_je`_h
“y_zow]y\]” a “ŠZd-[Zy” au cgZ\yZ z\`ˆ, [\]\g\`cv_h vw]a‚_. ‰c\ Zcd_je`Z\ w
†dZo} z`\ `\ cd}[`Z o}jZ f]agZ[ade g_c \cde, `Z Zo ”dZz †wde fZu^\, c`_†_j_
cˆ[_ []wu\l? Yf_caoZ d\o\. Yf_caoZ, h ]_ccv_^w, †dZ d_vZ\ ŠZ]Z|_h vw]a‚_ a
†dZ Zdv]}j d_vZl ]\cdZ]_`, ^\j_ˆ, †dZ- v_v Z`_ [Zj^`_ g}yjh[\de.
o} d} a [_je|\ fZ[[\]^ag_j d_vZl ^\ – g\]ˆ g †\jZg\†\cdgZ a ]_cc†ad}-
w]Zg\`e. ‡ vdZ fZg_]? ‹Z^\|e fZg_]_ g_ˆ, †dZ ”dw v`ayw ow[wd †ad_de a g d\
fZug_de? oj_yZcjZg\``}\ g]\z\`_, vZy[_ `_ f]a-

J     ,            :  -
 ,  ,    ,    —  . I      
   ,    " . &#   "      
 ,            : “   ”. )
   "     “”     —    
    .
"#$ T =!6, ;69",  4#/!  >3/%1?-/ -/ @%9" 2!'

tmm j_gv_Š z_y_ua`Zg g`Zge fZhghdch `Z]- A !* >+ "5 <+>-
z_je`}\ vw]} — c o\jZl y]w[vZl, ^\j- "&+ ++  $%E&, +
d}z ^a]Zz fZ[j\ ywuva a ca`aza `Zy_- !5 ! >< "< !&-
za. i[\ c\yZ[`h guhde d_vwˆ vw]a‚w? €w . /& !5 ', > <>
a[ad\ fZv_ `_ ]}`Zv — oZje|\ z`\ fZ- !$%" 3 $ %$ >< +5%'$%?
cZg\dZg_de `\†\yZ! •ad\ d_z, d]\owl- J  '$  !" +5%'-
d\, g}oa]_ld\, cZoj_u`hld\ f]Z[_g‚Zg $% % $& $. 4+ +* <*>"
]woj\z, fZdZzw †dZ vw]a`Z-‚}fjh†e\ <%8 $@$%  $8>"  !%8
auZoaja\ `_ o\u^au`\``Z-ŠZjZ[`}Š +I" &5*$%. W +5%'$% -
fZjv_Š cwf\]z_]v\dZg `a†\z `\ jw†|\ !*" !'<,  $> !-
f]ac`Zf_zhd`}Š “`Z^\v ’w|_”, g\[e & < $ %+"#5.
g}]_\`} Z`a fZ dZl ^\ c_zZl d\Š`Z- J< !%> %$ + 
jZyaa. •, zZ^\d o}de, Z†\`e cvZ]Z z} *" $. D% " *+$, & %<-
\\ ]_u wo\[azch g f]_gZd\ ‘Z]zwj}  < R * $ >%" !<*,  !$
“cf]Zc ]Z^[_\d f]\[jZ^\`a\”, v_v Z[-  <"+ %$&+ $+ $%E%.
`_^[} w^\ cjw†ajZce c wuo\vcvaz ]a- '& $  5 $, <"+
cZz “[\g-ua]_”, cf\‚ahza a v_u_`_za. $88 !+"#, >'& $%E 
%+"  . W $ '%  -
/ 'I+, $ &  $%8 $%E%, ", %, > ", '" $-
&  !+, !%#,  ! $$ &,   $%E !$*5 ><+
%  + < $@$, I- +,  '" $ %$+% $% $
!,  > "  $*, >'    $%! +. A <'%"
!"$  !,  !%#$. W #$% !*"  $88 +"$%8 !>$%
$-  <%" R !E !%- $E&, - '%>$ <$, -
+55, $ R > — "$ +- %8 *$% > !E #$+ 
 '%. " $%E% ".

4       "          " " -
 (. #  ). *"            
      ,       “2,   ”,    
.         ,       ,    -
         !
6 - '
 " 
  
   /  
  "0 ! 
  !     + 
   " # 

= 4! (  !    #!( 


>

/" %  ,  " 5 '& $"$ >,   . / - tmt
  ++, $ +5  - <%" $@"  5E !'8
"  *$, '*5 $>$. W '&>& E, $E8  $%. O$
$%E !"5,  R !<  $-  '%$  5
"#, >+ ><  >. W *  %'' ',  + *", >  
'% , , <+*, !5 < $ !5 $%E& !-
!" > , *   !. #$$, $& !" < &!
A !" $%E% * "<5, -
>  !%>5 #$+ %.
L$", > 5 ! $ ¤]_`‚wucva\ vw]}
$%E&, '&> &8, R  >"
$%. A + $%E !%>5 -
`_ _u\]o_l[^_`cvZz
"! hu}v\
J !$"$% ! R $%-
E&  !,  #$+ !, !- A> E&!5  "$ !, >
" $  . * %' $<&". ^&!$,
7 &  !% $@"  + , <"+ #, !-
5E. F$  — "  , + <% $$ %, % ,
"#$ T =!6, ;69",  4#/!  >3/%1?-/ -/ @%9" 2!'

tmq > + + "5 ! !#5 aŠ g}]_ag_ˆa\, fZ`az_ˆd, †dZ ]_oZ-
 >%"->%" !. d_ˆd c [\jav_d\cZz, _ `\ c |a]fZd]\oZz,
a fZ”dZzw [wz_ˆd a Z gvwc\ vZ`\†`ZyZ
–, `_f]az\], `_|\j a u[\ce, g ‹Zcvg\, f]Z[wvd_. [`az cjZgZz, g zZaŠ o\[-
ŠZ]Z|aŠ o]\ccvaŠ vw] au ¤]_`‚aa, cdg\``}Š wcjZgahŠ az\``Z ‘_u_` u_†_-
f]_g[_, cdZhd Z`a f]az\]`Z v_v o\cfa- cdwˆ \[a`cdg\``Z\, †dZ z\`h g}]w†_-
jZd`}\ c_zZj\d}. €Z ”dZ, g c_zZz [\j\, \d, vZy[_ `\ `_l[\dch g f]Z[_^\ `a†\yZ,
Z†\`e ŠZ]Z|a\ vw]}, ZdvZ]zj\``}\ ac- v]Zz\ f\`Zfj_cdZg}Š o]Zlj\]`}Š vw] c
vjˆ†ad\je`Z f|\`a‚\l, u_zZ†\``Zl g fda‚\‘_o]ava, g}]Zc|aŠ `_ cfjZ|`}Š
zZjZv\. › v_^[Zl d_vZl vw]a‚} o}ja _`_oZjav_Š “[jh cvZ]\l|\yZ wg\ja†\-
fZjZ^\``}\ \l u_vZ`Z[_d\jecdgZz `ah z}|\†`Zl z_cc}”.
vg_[]_d`}\ z\d]} u\j\`ZyZ jwy_ [jh “\f\]e cjw|_ld\. Y\l†_c g_z ow[\d
g}ywj_, Z`_ ga[\j_ cZj`‚\, a au-fZ[ `\\ cz\|`Z, fZdZzw †dZ h gc\ g]\zh yZgZ]ˆ
woa]_ja fZz\d. “`\d zhcZ]wov\”, _ dwd c`Zg_ gcfZza`_ˆ
•`Zy[_ z`\ g\u\d, a h `_ ]}`v\ fZ- \\ a yZgZ]ˆ “[_ j_[`Z, fZjeuwld\ce”. €Z
vwf_ˆ [ZgZje`Z f]aja†`}Š vw] aja c\l†_c zhcZ]wov_ ow[\d acfZjeuZg_`_,
‚}fjhd, c f]_gaje`}z ^a]vZz, c f]_- f]a†\z fZ cgZ\zw f]hzZzw `_u`_†\-
gaje`}z _`_dZza†\cvaz cd]Z\`a\z. `aˆ, g\]`\\, c[\j_\d dZ, †dZ Z`_ wz\\d
€Z, vZy[_ `\ g\u\d, h u`_ˆ f_j_dvw, y[\ [\j_de jw†|\ gc\yZ, — ow[\d g}[_gja-
gc\y[_ f]Z[_ˆd f\]\f\jZg aja ‘_u_`Zg. g_de cZv.
– fZ`az_ˆ, †dZ ‘_u_` dZd u_o}j, vdZ
au \yZ f]\[vZg ywjhj fZ oZjZd_z a u_]Zc- 4>, > $, $$  %#$
jhz. – u`_ˆ, †dZ a ”daŠ ‘_u_`Zg g}]_a- M%+: ' $&+$ $ %$,
g_ˆd `_ ‘\]z_Š cZ gc\za g}d\v_ˆaza >   #%, * %'&+
fZcj\[cdgahza. €Z dZ ja gvwc w ‘_u_`_ $%>$+  !!%$ >< +5%'-
`_cdZjevZ `\woag_\z}l, dZ ja ‘\]z\]}, $%. H *  !!%" — '&>-
= 4! (  !    #!( 
>

& E$ . O$ > +* >- \yZ [jh z_]a`Zgva zhc_? ‰\[e dZjevZ tmp
 ,  !+, *   !+& +5- cZv d_z a `w^\`, _ `\ †dZ-dZ []wyZ\.
%'$%, — %$. O"$ <"+ 5 %$ …cd_da, \cja w vZyZ \cde fZ[ŠZ[h_h
%8 !%%. +% > !%- cZvZg}^az_jv_, dZ [_gad\ jwv †\]\u
+% %$% I  !E5 !: `\\, `\ cjw|_ld\ zZaŠ ]_ccv_uZg f]Z
 *" <  " # $:  zhcZ]wovw a z_]jˆ. “ZjevZ, g} w^\ fZ-
$, $$ '&> *+% $ < <+">- `hja, [_, †dZ `_z `w^\` `\ jwvZg}l
& 5, — >< +8. P% & $ cZv, _ Zd^azva?
< %$    &*+,  , >
  <%" *+5 >< / R *+$ '*+  + 
+8,  "  <$& !% !55 !5 <! * %$,
("$ !). +#+  %! &>  <'%-
#  !+#   -
– `_[\ˆce, †dZ g}, zZl †ad_d\je, `\ ja- 55 #. J '5+ % .
cd_\d\ v`ayw u_[Zz `_f\]\[, _ `_ZoZ]Zd, /& +* !" +  , > 
†ad_\d\ gc\ fZ fZ]h[vw, a ŠZ]Z|Z u`_\- R @#   $" $$ !E?
d\, vw[_ d\dw|v_ nw]_z_` acfZjeuZg_j_ /'I $$: * ? A ++,
jwvZg}l cZv. {_ [jh g_]va d\Š ^\ c_z}Š >, '8 #+ '% , >
vw]! ‡ \\… fZ†\zw o} `\ acfZjeuZg_de & !!&" % '". 
tms

Лавашана

Е
& (  ,   *8,     61  /0&, 0
/  -


& (&
  0&&,
 (&
   &612 / -
2(. / 
, 0
 '

, /  
 & &:  /
 
& &   )&&, & &
, *  *
0(08 (
&
( /  & 
. @/0 2 — / (2-
 
&  & (*   /8 7(
, 
   && , —

  &
&8 &    2( (.
E0,  &  2 — '
  /0,  
  6
-

&

(
7
&
? &0 6 6  
 &
  -

 7(
: 
 & &&
, &, (  /8   & &2&. 
  0
  
'
 0 
: 2( * & &   &8 & 

& & 
(&   & ( 0&,  & , ( 6&

 2( & ( &  &
&
. H & / 8
 &  /
,
 '
 
/   
 2, *
  
 & 
 2* (*  (
(6*
. /
, (
, 
 1,   ( 2&
  &
 &
&
,   (6 *& .
 
  



    –, 
  
   " # 
  + #  $
 #   
– "     + 
  1  + $  + $


>

+   $, $$ . W I  “ZjevZ tm
E&!$ $, $$+  '& <%+ 5
>$ :+,  ! >5 , g f]Z‘aje
'+*" $+ #&, *
+% *$, $$ % %+8I '5  + H'*" $%E%    5 
', <!"  !< $&&#$  ! .
"  %$%, <%8  (C ]. ! !*5 +!%% '-
O * +& +, >   &': *" $++ %$  !+ +-
!! *+ , *+5, .  , $$ %$ 5 +
$ +!% % %$ E&!- +   '% $+<, -
$  =3 ] ($%! ',  $E $- '" & !E: $%$%+%, >&
E, ++-!E%, $"$ + I !E, <%, $E%, !% '%>$ <-
 %"!..),  &$8>+ ". $  !". P'" $#&
A8", > E&!$ %  <%+55 +" ( E$ ), <+>%8
 ++ > $, $ +!%- #% (!& %# @%$
 '& > &$. :  +  5 !8), " ! '-
 5  E  $   !5- + &  !"  <%5.
"  + *5 %5I5 $- H'*%8 $%E% !%'"  !E-
>$, $ +*"  I < #- & $%$, %*"  @+% 5 <!$-
  " !  " ! %- 5, <" %+, !&!" '&+
&!&+, !+%&+ <+. @#$+  !+"  ". A$&"
$&#$  +"   !, !$ %" 
{wz_\d\ gc\, u_vZ`†ajace `_ ”dZz jh- $  <$>5.
g_`ya? "  $&+ !+.
"#$ T =!6, ;69",  4#/!  >3/%1?-/ -/ @%9" 2!'

tt~ YZgc\z [_ g œ\`vZ]_`e! …_v ^\ o}jZ u[Z]ZgZ


wu`_de, †dZ c dZ†`Z d_vaz ^\ ‘_]|\z
f]Zcd_h d_l`_ yZdZghd g œ\`vZ]_`a a ]}ow.
—}o_-vwdwz — vwjedZg_h [jh _u\]-
— ‡j\lvwz c_j_z, nwc`ah]! bdZ ow[\z o_l[^_`cvZl vwŠ`a. – `\ u`_ˆ, u_ †dZ
c\yZ[`h yZdZgade? \yZ d_z d_v jˆohd. —}o_, v_v ]}o_ — `\
‡ gZd cf]_|ag_de w fZg_]_-d_j}|_, ZcZoZ ^a]`_h, g †\|w\ a, v_v gc\ v_]fZ-
†dZ Z` ow[\d c\yZ[`h yZdZgade… [_^\ g}\, [Zcd_dZ†`Z vZcdacd_h. ‰Z[adch g
cz\|`Z! xZdZzw †dZ a d_v gc\ fZ`hd`Z: ‡u\]o_l[^_`\ a []wy_h ]}o_: a Zc\d]Z-
Z` Zohu_d\je`Z ow[\d yZdZgade jhg_`ya. g}Š fZ]Z[, zZ]cv_h a Zo}†`_h — ]\†-
xwcde `Z^va cdZj_ y`wdch fZ[ dh^\cdeˆ `_h. Yw[_v, `_f]az\], fZf_[_\dch. €Z c
[\chdvZg []wyaŠ wyZ\`al, fwcde ow[wd cw[_vZz gc\ fZ`hd`Z, fZ†\zw Z` `\ cd_j
fjZg} a |_|j}va, ZgZa a u\j\`e, [Zj- d_vaz fZfwjh]`}z. ‰\[e g ‡u\]o_l[-
z_ a `\ga[_``}\ f]\^[\ cwf}, `Z o\u ^_`\ cjZg_ †_cdZ w[g_ag_ˆdch, `_f]a-
jhg_`ya d_j}|a yZcd\l `\ gcd]\†_ˆd. z\], yZgZ]hd “|_|j}v-z_|j}v”. • v_v
x\]gZ\ u`_†\`a\ cjZg_ “jhg_`ya” — dwd fZyZgZ]ade Z cw[_v\?
”dZ ZcZo}l ‘_]| au Z]\ŠZg, jwv_ a wf_- xZ”dZzw Zcd_gaz cw[_v_ g fZvZ\ a
]\``Zl [Z cZcdZh`ah fZga[j_ f]Zd\]- g\]`\zch v vwdwzw. •u ”dZl ]}o} yZdZ-
dZl _j}†a. ‡ gdZ]Z\, a `\ z\`\\ g_^- ghd z_ccw c_z}Š ]_u`}Š ojˆ[, Zd fjZ-
`Z\, — ”dZ cfZcZo f]ayZdZgj\`ah \[} g g_ [Z ]_u`Zga[`Zcda Zzj\dZg — vˆvˆ.
d_`[}]\. š\ vwdwz vZfdhd, `\ dZjevZ [jh dZyZ,
x\]gZ\, †\z z\`h wyZcdaja g œ\`vZ- †dZo} g}fade c `az fag_, `Z a u_d\z,
]_`a, o}j ‚}fj\`Zv-jhg_`ya — dwyZ, †dZo} f]ayZdZgade ZcZo}\ ojˆ[_.
[Z Zdv_u_ `_oad}l ‘_]|\z a Zoz_- ‰Zd vwdwz, dZjevZ `\ ghj\`}l a `\
u_``}l Zcd_dv_za _j}†a. €Z d_v yZdZ- vZf†\`}l, _ cg\^al, g}jZgj\``}l c\-
gade vw] a ‚}fjhd h wz\j a [Z f]a\u- yZ[`h wd]Zz, Z†a\``}l a fZd]Z|\`}l.
)
   #  
>

…wdwz — u_z\†_d\je`Z gvwc`_h ]}o_ ]w [Z kp~ ¨, _ \\ †\]\u kp — a gZgc\ [Z ttk


(Zo}†`Z g\cZz vajZy]_zz_ g fZjdZ]_), kt~ ¨. €\u_†\z o\cfZvZadech — gj_^-
vZdZ]wˆ jZghd g x]av_cfalcvZz ]\yaZ- `_h `_†a`v_ g`wd]a ]}o} `\ [_cd \l
`\. ` [_je`al ]Z[cdg\``av v_]f_, d_v f\]\cZŠ`wde, `Z vZ`\†`Z, [jh dZyZ, †dZ-
†dZ f]a `\ZoŠZ[azZcda v_]fZz ”dZyZ o} c_z_ `_†a`v_ f]Zy]\j_ce a `_†_j_
vwdwz_ a zZ^`Z u_z\`ade… acdZ†_de _]Zz_d} — dZ^\ g]\zh fZ`_-
nwc`ah] ja|e cj\yv_ f]acZjaj \yZ [Zoadch. x\]\[ c_zZl fZ[_†\l `_ cdZj,
au`wd]a a `_†a`aj ‘_]|\z, u_Z[`Z Zo- zZ^`Z gvjˆ†ade g\]Š`ˆˆ cfa]_je aja
z_u_g dZ`vaz cjZ\z `_†a`va a cfa`w y_uZgwˆ yZ]\jvw-c_j_z_`[]w, [_ fZ[cd_-
]}oa`}, †dZo}, u_f\†\``_h `_ c\dv\ gade ]}oeˆ cfa`w ^_]w, fZcdZh``Z cj\-
g`wd]a d_`[}]_, Z`_ fZjw†aj_ \\ a ]w- [h u_ d\z, v_v o}cd]Z z\`h\dch \\ ‚g\d
zh`wˆ, Š]wcdhwˆ a _]Zz_d`wˆ vZ]Z†vw. c `\_ff\dad`ZyZ o\j\cZyZ `_ ]wzh`}l,
{_je|\ gc\ Z†\`e f]ZcdZ. —_uZy]\- v_v fZg\]Š`Zcde cd_`Zgadch Š]wcdh\l.
g_\dch d_`[}] [ZjyZ, [ZjyZ a Zcd}g_\d. ‰Zd vZy[_ ow[wd a ga[ f]\v]_c`}l, a u_-
nZ]Z|al fZg_] u`_\d, g v_vZl zZz\`d f_Š Zdz\``}l, dZy[_ a fZ[_g_ld\ ]}ow.
fZjZ^ade g d_`[}] zhcZ aja vw]a‚w a ‰f]Z†\z, zZ^\d\ a fZ[Z^[_de, `a†\yZ
v_v_h d\zf\]_dw]_ Zcd}g_ˆ\yZ d_`- c ”dZl ]}oZl `\ cjw†adch, \cja fZ[_de
[}]_ jw†|\ gc\yZ fZ[ŠZ[ad [jh ]}o}. \\ ŠZjZ[`Zl: Z`_ Zcd_`\dch gc\ d_vZl
‰_^`} g\[e `\ dZjevZ g]\zh u_f\v_`ah, ^\ gvwc`Zl, dZjevZ u_f_Š `\ ow[\d c]_uw
`Z a d\zf\]_dw]_ a dZ, v_v_h gj_^`Zcde g_jade `_fZg_j, _ cd_`\d Zw_dech yZ-
g`wd]a f\†a! ]_u[Z [\jav_d`\\, vZy[_ vwcZ†\v ]}o} c
{]wyZ\ [\jZ g [wŠZgv\: f]Zy]\j \\ `_†a`vZl Zv_^\dch w^\ gZ ]dw.
v_v cj\[w\d, wcd_`Zgaj d\zf\]_dw]w `_ n\Š! {_ v_o} u`_ja g}, †dZ dZjevZ `\
k~ ] a cd_ge vajZy]_zzZgwˆ ]}ow: `\ yZdZghd c ”dZl `_†a`vZl! ‰Zd guhde, v
oZje|\, †\z `_ †\dg\]de †_c_. …Zy[_ ”da f]az\]w, o_vj_^_`}-jhg_`ya, yZdZgade
kp za`wd acd\vwd, fZ`aue d\zf\]_dw- vZdZ]}\ z\`h `_w†aj gc\ dZd ^\ nwc`ah].
/  " - '
 +  "  
    
  
   / #   
  "0 !  
 !     + 
   " #  $  

"#$ T =!6, ;69",  4#/!  >3/%1?-/ -/ @%9" 2!'

ttm ˜ZjZd}\ o_vj_^_`} O$ 'I"5  '$*+ +& %*


!' *&, $  
“ZjevZ Zcd_ged\ ”dZd fjZ[ZazfZ]d +. 1$*  + !5+, -
Zy]Zz`}Š ]_uz\]Zg. €\w^dZ g} \yZ ? J<'5. / % <' *"
Zcajad\ ‚\javZz, [_^\ \cja `_fZj- *+ % >$%  #$%& —  !-
`ade \yZ d_vZl c}d`Zl a gvwc`Zl `_- *$  !>  + $. J -
†a`vZl? ždZ ^\ z`ZyZ ow[\d! €_z `w^- !" !*"  ! R ! ",
`} o_vj_^_`} d_vZyZ ]_uz\]_, †dZo}  >" %'$. P* !%>5 I",
†\jZg\v u_ cdZjZz guhj c\o\ `_ d_]\j-  $%8  !+5 !+ >$.
vw ]Zg`Z Z[`w |dwvw, c\j, a ”dZ o}j_ O"$  & '$* <% <-
o} v_v ]_u cd_`[_]d`_h fZ]‚ah u_vw-  >+- '", > %   !%-
cva, — y]_zzZg km~–kp~. xZ`az_\d\ >5:  &+    !>, $
z\`h? “ZjevZ `\ [wz_ld\, †dZ h ZdyZ- > !!% . A%, * + !-
g_]ag_ˆ g_c Zd c_zZyZ gvwc`ZyZ! ›g}, g '+,   $ #. P $-
vwja`_]aa gc\, v_v g ^au`a. €\ gc\y[_ + '$*& !  #$% $ 
]_uz\] f]ZfZ]‚aZ`_j\` v_†\cdgw a !+  +%  !5"  & $!5-
gvwcw. b_cdZ c_z}za gvwc`}za o}g_- $. W & +5  !%#  -$
ˆd v_va\-dZ z\jva\ fjZ[}, `\v]wf`_h $%! “'&” & !&,
fda‚_, `w a d_v [_j\\ a dZzw fZ[Zo`Z\.     (C +%,  '!$",
‡ gZd v]wf`}l o_vj_^_`, Z`… g Zo\z, > !  +  !<. O-
Zcd_ged\ \yZ! !"  &%" '$*& < $8-
‰}o\]ad\ `\oZje|a\, `\ f\]\u]\j}\   %*"   +>$ !.
a [_g_ld\ ]_oZd_de. …_v c[\j_de `_†a`- P"# &  + ", !?
vw, g} w^\ u`_\d\, `\ ow[w gc\ fZgdZ]hde " % $,  $% — %<
fZ d]a ]_u_: Z]\Ša, Zd^_d}l jwv, _j}†_ , , !% < !5 " &-
aja j_g_|_`_. 58I5 $.

D   ,      #    "     -
   ,     ,     . .,   ,  ,   ? + " 
  :         ,          
,      ,         
  . (       ,        .

>

ttt

“_v [jh †\yZ ^\ z} oj_`|a]Zg_ja o_- YjZgZ “f]h^ade” `\ nwc`ah] wfZd]\-


vj_^_`} g vafhdv\, u_†\z g}[_gja- oaj, ”dZ h g_z `_fZza`_ˆ, v_v oZy_d ]wc-
g_\z au `aŠ cZv? ‡ [\jZ g dZz, †dZ z} cval hu}v: g `\z az\\dch cf\‚a_je`}l
fZjw†_\z d_vaz Zo]_uZz `Zgwˆ, oZj\\ yj_yZj [jh ZoZu`_†\`ah f]Z‚\cc_ Zo^_-
fjZd`wˆ, `Z gz\cd\ c d\z fj_cda†`wˆ ]ag_`ah g oZje|Zz vZja†\cdg\ z_cj_.
cd]wvdw]w zhvZda. “\f\]e Z`_ ja|\- xZz`ad\ cv_uZ†`ZyZ …ZjZov_, vZdZ]}l
`_ dZl ]}ŠjZcda, oj_yZ[_]h vZdZ]Zl gZ o}j, v_v aug\cd`Z, “`_ z_cj\ f]h^\`”?
g]\zh ^_]va gfad}g_\d z_cjZ ‚\j}za
cd_v_`_za, d\f\]e o_vj_^_` zZ^`Z `_- O$ : &*  $$% !
†a`ade ‘_]|\z, a Z` `\ d]\c`\d g c_- +,  , %* "
z}l `\fZ[ŠZ[hal zZz\`d. €w, [_g_l- ! @#& '$*&  !-
d\, ]_u gc\ fZ`hd`Z a gc\ fZ[yZdZgj\`Z, !&" $ >", >'&  +-
`_†a`az o_vj_^_`} ‘_]|\z jhg_`ya  !%>5 5 '&  !- -
a cd_`\z f]h^ade aŠ g dZfj\`Zz z_cj\. + %', , <%+5, '$-
"#$ T =!6, ;69",  4#/!  >3/%1?-/ -/ @%9" 2!'

ttq *&  *&  + !". A  fZ]_uad\je`Z `_fZza`_\d zhcZ. x]hzZ
" *+ $$ #- v_v_h-dZ ŠZ]Z|_h o_]_`a`_, cz\|_``_h
$+ ",  , >'& #$>  c †\z-dZ Z†\`e gvwc`}z, — gZd v_v_h
'&<", +!%  $$ cd]_``Zcde.
 * !+"5 &#, >+ (0C ]. œhg_`ya ojˆ[Z †]\ug}†_l`Z c}d`Z\.
/ $, $%  !5"  “!5*- €_g\]`Z\, fZ”dZzw \yZ yZdZghd f]\azw-
” '$*&, >   &, \cdg\``Z g ŠZjZ[`Z\ g]\zh yZ[_ — `_-
 !+  %.  <!% !+, > †a`_h c fZu[`\l Zc\`a a [Z g\c`}. €_
,    *" $%>$   !- …_gv_u\ ”dZ cghu_`Z \\ a c c\uZ`Zz
!'%: !+ +% 2C !'5, cZu]\g_`ah y]\‚vaŠ Z]\ŠZg a c d\z, †dZ
>'& '$*& !!$",  >$ oja^\ v j\dw Z`a `_†a`_ˆd yZ]†ade.
!"  !! , '*- xZ”dZzw, vZy[_ f]aŠZ[ad ^_]_, g
5  5 '&>&,  'I+-, !%$ œ\`vZ]_`a f]\[fZ†ad_ˆd yZdZgade
#+ $% $%. j\d`\\ jhg_`ya, o\u Z]\ŠZg, o\u Zd^_dZ-
yZ jwv_, `Z c oZjy_]cvaz f\]‚\z, fZza-
“\f\]e c`azad\ o_vj_^_`} cZ cvZgZ- [Z]_za, u\j\`eˆ a f]Z†aza [Zo_gj\-
]Z[}, fwcde Zcd}`wd. `a a g ŠZjZ[- `ahza, Z†\`e wz\cd`}za g ”dZ g]\zh
`Zz ga[\ ow[wd d_v f_Š`wde, †dZ [_^\ yZ[_.
]_uyZg_]ag_de ]h[Zz cZ cdZjZz cd_`\d €_†a`hˆd, v f]az\]w, ]}ow, [_ a yZ-
d]w[`Z: Z[`_ z}cje g yZjZg\ — †dZ ”dZ dZghd v_v a Zo}†`wˆ ]}ow-jhg_`ya g
d_v f_Š`\d a fZ†\zw h d_v ŠZ†w \cde… • d_`[}]\, a dZ^\ ZvZjZ †_c_. …cd_da yZ-
fZ†\zw-dZ gc\ gc\y[_ cf]_|ag_ˆd f]Z gZ]h, gZd a ”dZ f]_gajZ, †dZ ]}o_ yZdZ-
jhg_`ya: gadch Z†\`e o}cd]Z, `\ gc\y[_ o}g_\d
— ždZ c zhcZz? g\]`}z. xZg\]ed\, a`Zy[_ ]}ow zZ^-
€\d, zZa [Z]Zya\, ”dZ `\ c zhcZz, ”dZ `Z dZzade Z†\`e [ZjyZ a Z`_ f]a ”dZz
gz\cdZ zhc_, `Z gvwc, a g c_zZz [\j\, Zcd_`\dch [ag`Z gvwc`Zl. ‰Zd ”dZ v_v

>

ttp

]_u dZd cjw†_l — f]_gaje`Z fZ[Zo]_`- ]}o_, ZgZa [jh `_†a`va dZjevZ c ZyZ-
`}l d\zf\]_dw]`}l ]\^az, vZy[_ d\z- ]Z[_, a f]ayZdZgade cZ u`_`a\z [\j_,
f\]_dw]_ g f\†a fZcd\f\``Z c`a^_\dch, [_ c [w|Zl.
acfZjeuw\dch Z†\`e cZ†`_h `_†a`v_, ‰f]Z†\z, j\d`al g_]a_`d zZ^`Z
`\ fZugZjhˆ_h ]}o\ f\]\cZŠ`wde, a g f]az\`ade gZgc\ `\ dZjevZ v ]}o\. ‡
]\uwjed_d\ fZjw†_\dch acvjˆ†ad\je`Z †dZ, _ [_g_ld\ c_za, acfZjeuwh vZ\-
gvwc`Z. {_^\ Zo}†`}l c_u_` — ]}o_ v_va\ cg\[\`ah, fZjw†\``}\ Zd nwc-
cwŠ_h, fjZd`_h, y]woZg_d_h — zZ^\d `ah]_ — u_z\†_d\je`ZyZ u`_dZv_ d_-
o}de d_vaz gvwc`}z f]a c_zZl f]Z- j}|cvZl a _u\]o_l[^_`cvZl vwŠ`a, _
cdZl yZdZgv\. …_^\dch, [Zj^`_ dwd o}de vZ gc\zw f]Z†\zw ŠZ]Z|\yZ †\jZg\-
v_v_h-dZ dZ`vZcde, v_vZl-dZ fZg_]cvZl v_ — cZ†a`az j\d`\\ jhg_`ya, [_ ŠZde c
c\v]\d. €w [_, c\v]\d \cde: cg\^_l|_h d\za ^\ o_vj_^_`_za?
   '
  
½ $  -" $
  #   "

 "  
– !   
"
 
2     $  

"#$ T =!6, ;69",  4#/!  >3/%1?-/ -/ @%9" 2!'

tts œhg_`ya  +$ '+ '$ !E, 


I >%" !<* — !E >. W ,
j\d`az z_`\]Zz '" $ I+ % *$% '"<+-
>$ %$%  I" !+#,
‰Zuezad\ Z[`w v]wf`wˆ zZ]vZge, vwcZv >'&  + !5. -
cd\ojh fZ]\h [ja`Zl c_`daz\d]Zg k~– $  <" +& !*+, $ ++
kp, ]_u`Zl u\j\`a, `\z`ZyZ oZjy_]cvZyZ $%  5, — #5 !
f\]‚_ — fZjZga`} Šg_dad, dZ†`Z yZgZ- , 5  >'&   >"
]ˆ, — f_]w uwo†avZg †\c`Zv_ a fZjZga-  + +%.
`w f\]‚_ †aja. 'E  +"5  <++ +
'& !*"  $  +5 *$,
/ !>", !<" +$ ( +  R %* ! #+% *8,   -
>  %$-!, $  %>#  ,  +* !%!"  $: '"
$  %* +),  <"   + $ ($<%) ++  >-
+ >$+, %'+ "$ * & !E #$+.
%'& '. A%  . 1$*& !&, -
D$ !%!"  '$*+, +& %* >$ . 1  !5. /,
<+: " !"& <, $- '$*& !" !>&,   "-
", '#"  $!5$, *" ! $ +* '", > % $$ +5>$.
%<+. A  #  +%, !".
O"$ >$%  * '&+ : !"  I < "+
'<+ !+. F$ <+  $ +  $%, +
$ 2–B *$ $ +  ,    &+,   $+ %>, %-
 !++  + > %$  +- *+ '$*&  +  '*+ 
$", !+5, >'&   <+-  , $+ , < $ 
 E,  "$ " +5>. D %$% >$.
tt
"#$ T =!6, ;69",  4#/!  >3/%1?-/ -/ @%9" 2!'

ttƒ 1$*&, !& $ - ‰Zd cv_^ad\ z`\, cfZcZo`} g} c\o\
$ >$, > "  '- f]\[cd_gade, †dZ au vZf†\`Zl ]}o}
I * +% 0C. M# '& ! zZ^`Z †dZ-`aow[e f]ayZdZgade? xZ-
*$ %*"  !  $  <- g_] nwc`ah], vZdZ]}l u`_vZzaj z\`h
" + ++,  $+  *". c j\`vZ]_`cvZl vwŠ`\l, cv_u_j: “x]ayZ-
%" !5 ! $&#$  <. dZgjˆ — f_je†ava Zoja^\|e”. • fZjZ-
^aj ]}oa`w g d_uav c ŠZjZ[`Zl gZ[Zl —
œhg_`ya ja ”dZ? €w, fwcde vdZ-`aow[e g}z_†ag_de.
cv_^\d, †dZ `\ jhg_`ya! ‡ c_z d\z g]\z\`\z f]a`hjch yZdZ-
gade ZgZ`wˆ `_†a`vw [jh ]}o}.
¤ayZg}l jacd x]_g[_, fZ`hda\ Zo ZgZ_Š w nwc`ah-
]_ ]_c|a]\``Z\, v jwvw a oZjy_]cvZzw
vZf†\`ZyZ vwdwz_ f\]‚w Z` `\ dZjevZ \[]Z [Zo_gjh\d
u\j\`e (cd_`[_]d`}l “za`az_je`}l
‰ ‡u\]o_l[^_`\ g\u[\ gvwc`Z. …w[_ `a v_gv_ucval `_oZ]” — va`u_, wv]Zf, f\-
f]a\[\|e, g\u[\ Zdja†`}\ f]Z[wvd}, d]w|v_), `Z a `\cvZjevZ vacj\`evaŠ
g\u[\ fZg_]_ u`_ˆd, v_v c `aza ZoŠZ- hojZv, cZ]g_``}Š c oja^_l|\yZ [\]\-
[adech. €Z c_za _u\]o_l[^_`‚} yZgZ- g_. {wz_ˆ, fZf_[ace \zw `_ yj_u_ \\
]hd: “nZ†\|e gvwc`Z fZvw|_de, fZ\u^_l †dZ gvwc`Z\ — Z` `\[ZjyZ o} ]_uz}|-
g œ\`vZ]_`e”. _Š-iwc\l` — g}[_ˆ- jhj, `_|\j o} ”dZzw f]az\`\`a\, f]a-
alch o_va`cval fZg_] — `_fwdcdgwh [wz_j o} d_vZ\ cZ†\d_`a\, vZdZ]Z\ z}
z\`h, cZoa]_ˆ\yZch g œ\`vZ]_`e, yZ- c\o\ a f]\[cd_gade `\ zZ^\z.
gZ]aj: ‡ vcd_da, Zo]_dad\ g`az_`a\, `_-
— • fwcde Zohu_d\je`Z vZf†\`}l cvZjevZ `\v]wf`}z g}]_cd_\d u[\ce
vwdwz f]ayZdZghd g jacdehŠ a`^a]_! oZjy_]cval f\]\‚. • ”dZ g œ\`vZ]_`a,
ždZ — cd_]a``Z\ ojˆ[Z! y[\ f_jvw [_^\ g u\zjˆ gd}v_de `\
=
(   '    
>

`_[Z, gc\ c_zZ ]_cd\d [_^\ g [avZl f]a- ‚}, z`ZyZ u\j\`a a f_]Z†v_ Z†a\`- ttr
]Z[\, `\ yZgZ]h w^\ Z c_[_Š a ZyZ]Z[_Š, `}Š Zd |vw]va fZza[Z]Zg.
Z[`aŠ au jw†|aŠ g ‡u\]o_l[^_`\. ‡ f\- “\f\]e f_]w cjZg Zo a`^a]\, vZdZ-
]\‚ g}]Zc d_vaz, †dZ g j_[Z`a `\cvZje- ]}l ŠZ]Z|Z u`_vZz [_^\ ^ad\jhz c\-
vZ |dwv fZz\cdadch. ždZ fZdZzw, †dZ Z` g\]`}Š yZ]Z[Zg, fwcde ŠZdh o} g \yZ
`\ fZjw†_j c\jad]} a []wyaŠ w[Zo]\- `\[Zu]\jZl, g_d`Z-d]_`cfZ]d_o\je`Zl
`al. ` ]Zc v_v \cde, v_v fZjZ^\`Z f]a- afZcd_ca aja o\cf]Zay]}|`Zz cwŠZ-
]Z[Zl, †dZ zZy guhde Zd u\zja — guhj, ‘]wvdZgZz ga[\. ˜`_\d\, nwc`ah] ZoZ-
†dZ zZy fZjw†ade Zd cZj`‚_ — fZjw†aj. |\jch o\u a`^a]_, `Z guhj a`^a]`}\
˜`_\d\, `_cvZjevZ gvwc`\\ a _]Zz_d`\\ jacdeh, d\ c_z}\ ‘ayZg}\ jacd}, vZdZ-
”dZd oZjy_]cval f\]\‚ g c]_g`\`aa c ]}za ‡[_z a šg_ f]av]}g_jace g —_ˆ,
d\za, †dZ f]Z[_ˆdch g cwf\]z_]v\d\? a u_g\]`wj g `aŠ ]}ow, †dZo} g d_vZz
šcde dZjevZ Z[`Z “`Z”. šcja \yZ cZ]g_de ga[\ u_f\v_de fZ[ wyjhza.
c y]h[va, dZ †\]\u d]a [`h Z` w^\ u_- …Z`\†`Z, Z[a` cjZl jacde\g `\ f]\-
gh`\d. €Z ”dZ `_dw]_je`}l f]Z[wvd, a [ZŠ]_`ad ]}ow Zd fZ[f_ja`. Yj\[Zg_-
`_z Zcd_\dch dZjevZ gu[ZŠ`wde a fZf}- jZ o} u_g\]`wde gcˆ ”dw vZ`cd]wv‚aˆ g
d_dech ŠZdh o} f]\[cd_gade c\o\, v_vZˆ yja`w aja d\cdZ, `Z vdZ zZ^\d u_f]\dade
zZ^\d o}de \[_, f]ayZdZgj\``_h au d_- acfZjeuZg_de g d\Š ^\ ‚\jhŠ ‘Zjeyw?
vZyZ f]Zga_`d_! …_u_jZce o}, _ u_†\z gZZo\ `w^`}
€w, g} u`_\d\, [_, †dZ [_^\ au c_zZyZ ”da jacdeh? {_ dZjevZ [jh _]Zz_d_ —
ŠZ]Z|\yZ a gvwc`ZyZ oZjy_]cvZyZ f\]- `a [jh †\yZ oZje|\! œacdeh oZje|a`-
‚_ cj\[w\d `\ dZjevZ w[_jade c\z\`_, cdg_ fjZ[Zg}Š [\]\ge\g az\ˆd f]a-
`Z a g}]\u_de gc\ o\j}\ f\]\yZ]Z[va? hd`}l u_f_Š, `\ wcdwf_ˆal c_zaz
“]a f\]‚_ — a v]_c`}l, a u\j\`}l, a fjZ[_z. €\vZdZ]}\ jacdeh, `_f]az\]
Zcd]}l — `_]\u_ˆd z\jvaza vwoav_za. ga`Zy]_[`}\, `\ y]\Š a c\cde, Zd fZ\-
… `az — f_]_ hojZv, fZjZga`_ jwvZga- [_`ah []wyaŠ jw†|\ Zdv_u_dech, `Z dZ,
tq~
=
(   '    
>

†dZ Z`a zZywd wv]_cade cgZaz _]Zz_- ow[\d ŠZ]Z|Z, `_g\]`Z\, [_^\ gvwc`\\, tqk
dZz ojˆ[Z, Zohu_d\je`Z `_[Z acfZjeuZ- †\z c ]}oZl vZf†\`Zl.
g_de! • g} u`_\d\ d_vZl f]az\], fZdZzw ‡ fZv_ h g_z [Zj^\` ]_ccv_u_de, †dZ
†dZ gc\z ŠZ]Z|Z u`_vZz j_g]Zg}l jacd, ]}o_, wjZ^\``_h `_ yja`h`Z\, f]\[-
vZdZ]}l v_v ]_u acfZjeuwˆd dZjevZ [jh g_]ad\je`Z ]_uZy]\dZ\ Zc`Zg_`a\ z_`-
_]Zz_dau_‚aa. y_j_ a wv]}d_h wyjhza f]Zj\^_j_ d_v
€\d, zZ^`Z o}jZ o}, vZ`\†`Z, a g fZ†da †_c. {_, Z`_ cd_j_ `\z`ZyZ cZ†-
Zo}†`}l f\]y_z\`d u_g\]`wde, fZ[w- `\\, \\ fjZde c[\j_j_ce fZ[_djag\\,
z_\|e, z_j\`evZl dZjava gvwc_ a _]Z- ZgZa f]aZo]\ja a`d\]\c`}l vZf-
z_d_ ja|ajace o}. †\`}l _]Zz_d, `Z c_z vwdwz Zcd_jch…
€Z ”dZ `\ `_| fwde, f]_g[_? Zo}v`Zg\``Zl vZf†\`Zl ]}oZl. x]ZcdZ
€_| fwde — ”dZ guhde, v f]az\]w, d\f\]e Z` cd_j `_fZza`_de ]}ow yZ]h-
ŠZ]Z|al vwcZv zhc_, Zo\]`wde \yZ g [w- †\yZ vZf†\`ah, _ `\ ghj\`Z-vZf†\`wˆ,
|acdZ\ cg\^\\ c\`Z, Zoj\fade fZg\]Š a, vZ`\†`Z, f]aZo]\j a`d\]\c`}\ ‘]wv-
d\cdZz a fZcd_gade g f\†e, †dZo} †\]\u dZg}\ a ZgZ`}\ `Zdva.
fZjZ^\``Z\ g]\zh g}`wde, gcv]}de €_cvZjevZ h fZ`az_ˆ, g f]\^`a\
Šj\o`wˆ vZ]vw, wo]_de c\`Z a fZ[_de g]\z\`_ ”dZd cfZcZo f]ayZdZgj\`ah
zhcZ, fZ]\u_g \yZ jZzdav_za — fwcde o}j cghu_`, cvZ]\\, c `\ZoŠZ[azZcdeˆ
yZcda y_[_ˆd, †\z ”dZ d_v f_Š`\d? cZŠ]_`ade wjZg a wfZd]\oade \yZ gfZ-
‡ \\, vZy[_ `_cdwfad j\dZ, z} cj\[cdgaa g v_†\cdg\ yZ]h†\yZ ojˆ[_.
gcfZz`az nwc`ah]_ a \yZ cfZcZo u_- “\f\]e u_f\†\``}l vZf†\`}l vwdwz
f\v_`ah ]}o} a u_f\†\z dZ†`Z d_v ^\ [jh Z[`aŠ — gZcfZza`_`a\, [jh []w-
cg\^wˆ ]\†`wˆ ]}ow, dZjevZ jacdeh yaŠ — [avZga`v_.
gZuez\z czZ]Z[a`Zg}\ aja ga|`\g}\. €Z fZjeu_ Zd dZyZ, †dZ z} `_ ”dZ fZ-
– o} a g`wd]e ]}o} fZjZ^aj `\cvZje- czZd]\ja, `\cZz`\``Z, \cde. ‰Z-f\]-
vZ hyZ[ ga|`a — f]ZcdZ wg\]\`, †dZ ”dZ g}Š, “yZ]auZ`d” vwja`_]`}l ]_c|a]a-
 
 '
   : – .     $ 
    "   ! +

     ! ,  ", "+
 . .    
  : . "  
  #   " $  !  $   
½   

"#$ T =!6, ;69",  4#/!  >3/%1?-/ -/ @%9" 2!'

tqm ja. ‰Z-gdZ]}Š, owv\d a[\l c [Zo_gvZl €Z †a]! ba] fZg\j c\oh, f]hzZ cv_^\z,
v ]}o\ fjZ[Zg a jacde\g ‘]wvdZg}Š g\cez_ v_f]au`Z! oj_[_h h]vaz gvwcZz
fZjw†aja. ‰Zueza ]}ow cg\^wˆ a yZ- a []_u`haz [Z `_Š_je`Zcda h]vaz u_-
dZge dZ†`Z d_v ^\ — ow[\d \\ gvwc`\\, f_ŠZz, Z` f]Zcaj fZ[_de v `\zw g vZz-
dZ†`Z yZgZ]ˆ! {_ a yZdZgade zZ^`Z f_`aˆ dZ c_zZyZ jw†|\yZ fag_, dZ c_zZ-
g c_z}Š cf_]d_`cvaŠ wcjZgahŠ. “_v_h yZ oj_yZ]Z[`ZyZ fZ gvwcw cZ\gZyZ cZwc_ a
]}o_ — ]Z[`_h c\cd]_ f\†\``Zl g uZj\ Š]wcdhal jacdZ†\v `Z]a, _ dZ g[]wy v_-
v_]dZ|va. ‡ †dZ zZ^\d o}de f]Z\ a f]au`Z d]\oZg_j f]_g_ cZja]Zg_de, `_z\-
fZ”da†`\\? v_h, †dZo} a \yZ \ja v_v [_g\|`ˆˆ `\je-
zw, o\uZ gchvaŠ wv]_|_d\jecdg.
…w]_ a ’_lv_j — xZyZ[a, fZyZ[a! bdZ-dZ g\]dadch `_
hu}v\, `av_v `\ wŠg_†w, †dZ ^\ c[\j_de
z`\ c ”daz †a]Zz… vZyZ ^\ Z` z`\ `_-
x]Z|jZ [g_ yZ[_. fZz`aj? ‡ g\[e gZd Z` — v_cfalcval
• ŠZ]Z|a\ jˆ[a f]ag\uja z`\ au Ya- o]_d \yZ — vwdwz! ‰Zd d_v ^\ a \yZ, aja
oa]a ‘_`d_cda†\cvwˆ fZ gvwcw z_jZcZje- \\ jw†|\ — g vwd_o}, g vwd_o} ”dZyZ
`wˆ ]}ow `\jezw a `\ z\`\\ †w[\c`wˆ †a]_!
vZf†\`wˆ ]}ow c vZ]Zdvaz a g\c\j}z €w [_, d_v a ]\|aja c[\j_de vwd_o} c
`_ug_`a\z †a]. €\jez_ o}j_ †]\ug}- †a]Zz. ‡ †dZ? ‰c\ dZ ^\ c_zZ\ g `_†a`-
†_l`Z f]\v]_c`_ ga[Zz, `\f\]\[_g_\zZ vw, g vZzf_`aˆ v †a]w, †dZ o]_j nwc`a-
`\^`Zl `_ gvwc a Zoj_[_j_ d_vaz dZ`- h] [jh ‘_]|a]Zgva vZf†\`ZyZ vwdwz_.
vaz _]Zz_dZz, †dZ \\ c\ja v_v \cde — –ojZvZ, jwv, oZjy_]cval f\]\‚… y[\ u\-
fZ]\u_ja Zcd]}z `Z^Zz a vwcZ†\v u_ vw- j\`e?
cZ†vZz, jZzdav u_ jZzdavZz, o\u Šj\o_ a
f]af]_g — gZd d\o\ a w^a`, ^_je dZjevZ, 4+# ! +5$ , 
†dZ u_o}ja `_jade a g}fade. +% !5" ! +$  $ 

>

 $$  '"# $%. $- tqt


&5 >$% <  &+
$%+.
F+>   ! $8,  %
!% >$%, $&"  !*" -
"8, !5 +% @+%, %'%8 5
*$  % $$.
D$ !$5  !<, !-
>,  I >< $"$ +-
% +  '8,  +<&
!"  <&+ !&+
++.
#5 !" $%' !&-
 + $$ %'$, ! +% <5
!!& <!…

€Z fav `_cj_^[\`ah f]aŠZ[adch `_


dZd zZz\`d, vZy[_ `_cdwf_\d g]\zh ]_c-
vwcade f\]g}l vwd_o. “ZjevZ d\f\]e
z`\ cd_j fZ`hd\` u_z}c\j vZf†\`ZyZ
vwdwz_, u_f\†\``ZyZ c ZgZ_za, u\j\-
`eˆ a ‘]wvd_za! ‰\[e ”dZ w`av_je`Z\
cZ†\d_`a\ gvwcZg, a g\[e `\ u]h v `\zw
f]\[j_y_jch j_g_|! ‡ u[\ce — gZd Z`Z
gc\, v_v f]ZcdZ: w^\ ]_u[\j_``_h, o\u
vZcd\l a †\|wa ]}o_, hojZvZ a ZgZa a
=!6, ;69",  4#/!  >3/%1?-/ -/ @%9" 2!'

tqq gc\ w^\ u_g\]`wdZ g a`[aga[w_je`}l


v]w^Zv j_g_|_ a c[Zo]\`Z dZfj\`}z
z_cjZz. bdZ zZ^\d o}de jw†|\?
• gZd, `_ ojˆ[\: — u[]_gcdgwl,
o_dˆ|v_-’_lv_j! ´g\da, f]\v]_c`_h
œ\`vZ]_`e!
xZ`az_\d\, v_v fZjza]_ zZ^\d wz\-
cdadech z\^[w [gwzh j_[Z|v_za, g fZ-
jwz\ch‚\ au dZ`vZ ]_cv_d_``ZyZ d\cd_?
xZl[a, Zd`aza w ”dZyZ vwd_o_ caoa]-
cvZ\, g}†j\`a _u\]o_l[^_`cvZ\! —wŠ-
`\d gch y_]zZ`ah, a vZyZ wd\|ad cvw-
[Zwza\ cv]hya Ҡw^ZyZ `\ \z, cgZ\yZ `\
Zd[_z”?
’}cd]\`evZ-o}cd]\`evZ gcfZza`_-
\z u_v]}d}\ ca‚ajalcva\ fa‚‚} —
†dZ d_z a[\d g `_†a`vw? ‡ \g]\a-dZ, \g-
]\a v_vZg} zZjZ[‚} cZ cgZaz ‘Z]|z_-
vZz! €_ `\cvZjevZ cdZj\dal Zf\]\[aja
zZˆ cj\[wˆwˆ a[\ˆ: gc\ a`y]\[a-
\`d} [jh `_†a`va czZjZde a yZdZgade
vwd_o} d_v ^\, v_v h yZdZgaj vwd_o} c
‘_]|\z-jhg_`ya. ‰\[e ŠZ]Z|Z [Zj^`Z
fZjw†adech!
xZ[wz_ld\ `_[ cZocdg\``}za a[\h-
za `_†a`Zv!
     
      *    "  " # $ !
:   :
  +  "   "  . .  $   
 #          #  ! ! " 
 . .   &       
 . .      , c 
    *     
  "    —  " !

 # ' 
>

‰ [\chdZ†vw! …Z`\†`Z, vZy[_ ]\†e a[\d Z z_]a`Z- tqp


g_``}Š fZza[Z]_Š, dZ g f\]gwˆ Z†\]\[e
YZj\`eh, zZ†\`eh, vg_|\`eh — gc\ ”dZ gc\ gcfZza`_ˆd d]_[a‚aZ``}\ vZ`c\]-
`\auz\``_h a Z†\`e g_^`_h †_cde ]wc- ga]Zg_``}\ z_]a`Zg_``}\ fZza[Z]},
cvZl vwŠ`a. €\gZuzZ^`Z f]\[cd_gade f]ayZdZgj\``}\, v_v f]_gajZ, g Zc`Zg-
c\o\ ]wccval u_vwcZ†`}l cdZj o\u gc\Š `Zz f]a fZzZa wvcwc_. —_uwz\\dch,
”daŠ ]_u`ZcZjZg, o\u y]aoZg, Zyw]‚Zg a g z_]a`_[ `_ Zc`Zg\ f]Zvafh†\``Zl
hojZv. ‡ gZd z_]a`Zg_`a\ `avZy[_ `\ gZ[}, fZzazZ wvcwc_, [Zo_gjhˆd a cZje,
o}jZ Š_]_vd\]`}z [jh ]wccvZl vwŠ`a a a c_Š_], a v_va\-dZ f]af]_g} cZ cf\‚ah-
gZ|jZ g ZoaŠZ[ Zd`Zcad\je`Z `\[_g`Z. za, `Z yj_g`}z [\lcdgwˆaz g\\-
•u`_†_je`Z z_]a`Zg_`a\ fZ[]_uw- cdgZz Zcd_\dch az\``Z wvcwc.
z\g_jZ u_z_†ag_`a\ †\yZ-jaoZ g zZ]- €_[Z az\de g ga[w, †dZ fZza[Z]},
cvZl aja cZj\`Zl gZ[\, `_ ”dZ wv_u}g_- v_v a z`ZyZ\ []wyZ\, zZ^`Z cZŠ]_`ade
\d c_z vZ]\`e cjZg_, f]ZacŠZ[hal Zd a g ]_ccZj\, g ”dZz cjw†_\ g gZ[w [Zo_g-
cjZg_ “marine” — “zZ]cvZl”. ‡ [jh †\yZ jh\dch cdZjevZ cZja, †dZo} g ]_cdgZ]\
u_z_†ag_ja f]Z[wvd} g cZj\`Zl gZ[\? `\ gZu`avjZ o]Z^\`a\. œaoZ zZ^`Z u_-
{_ [jh cZŠ]_`\`ah, auz\`\`ah cgZlcdg yZdZgade aŠ f]a fZzZa cvg_|ag_`ah,
a… f]a[_`ah az `ZgZyZ gvwc_! y[\ cZja `\z`ZyZ, `Z g ]\uwjed_d\ [\l-
‰ cZg]\z\``Zl vwja`_]aa z_]a`Zg_- cdgah zav]ZZ]y_`auzZg g c]\[\ Zo]_uw-
`a\ f]\[wcz_d]ag_\d fZz\\`a\ f]Z- \dch [ZgZje`Z z`ZyZ vacjZd}, f]\[Zd-
[wvdZg g v_vwˆ jaoZ c]\[w [jh `_c}\- g]__ˆ\l fZ]†w fjZ[Zg, `Z ”dZ gc\
`ah gvwc_za f]af_g a cf\‚al, auz\`\- []wya\ acdZ]aa a []wya\ cfZcZo} cZ-
`ah aŠ vZ`cacd\`‚aa, v_v g cjw†_\, vZy[_ Š]_`\`ah fZza[Z]Zg.
z} z_]a`w\z zhcZ [jh |_|j}v_ jaoZ [`_vZ ]_u w^ z} u_g\ja ]_uyZgZ] Z
c ‚\jeˆ aŠ f]Z[Zj^ad\je`ZyZ Š]_`\- c_j_d_Š a u_vwcv_Š, h o} fZyZgZ]aj c\l-
`ah — †_\ gc\yZ d_v z_]a`wˆd ZgZa. †_c Zo Z[`Zl g_]a_‚aa [ZgZje`Z ]_c-
"#$ T =!6, ;69",  4#/!  >3/%1?-/ -/ @%9" 2!'

tqs f]Zcd]_`\``ZyZ cfZcZo_ z_]a`Zg_`ah G !+  & !*$ *$ -


fZza[Z]Zg. • dwd `_|\l ‚\jeˆ ow[\d '"#+ *+ &<+ $&#>$. . D&-
`\ fZ[yZdZgv_ fZza[Z]Zg v [jad\je- #>$  &'&+,  + >
`Zzw Š]_`\`aˆ, _ auz\`\`a\ aŠ gvwc_, !55. /%" $* !+>$
>$
a`}za cjZg_za, z} cZoa]_\zch d_- $+ I!$% ,  " +#+
#+ 
vaz cfZcZoZz fZjw†ade ojˆ[Z, vZdZ]Z\ <+">&+ %$!+  >$+.
zZ^`Z Z†\`e cvZ]Z fZ[_g_de v cdZjw / $*& !+ !*+ !" " !
v_v u_vwcvw. *>$ <+"> %$!  >-
xZczZd]ad\ `_ ”da fZza[Z]}. €_ $  !$+ $&#>$. / !E! ! +&
f]aj_gv_Š Z`a fZhgjhˆdch Zo}†`Z %*  . 9* %*" R !-
fZ[ `_ug_`a\z “o_va`cva\” aja “v\o_o- +&  !%%  #$+ +,, !-
fZza[Z]}”. •Š a `_ c_zZz [\j\ w[Zo- *"  $ +5  !,  !+
`Z `_c_[ade `_ |_zfw] a u_f\†e `_[ !"  "$ 5 5 ,
wyjhza Z[`Zg]\z\``Z c |_|j}vZz, [_ + ' <%+5, !! %!-
gZd d_v, g `_dw]_je`Zz ga[\ a fZ[_de v '5.
zhcw. €av_vZl v\d†wf `\ c]_g`adch fZ A 5 >% %*" <>%. P,
oZy_dcdgw gvwc_ a _]Zz_dw c d_vaza fZ- $+  !>, $ #$%+
za[Z]_za, u_f\†\``}za “c [}zvZz”! +$"  !%+   $
…cd_da, fZza[Z]} ”da o}g_ˆd ]_u`}Š +  ++ $  >$+,
]_uz\]Zg. xZf]Zcad\ w f]Z[_g‚Zg “gZce- !>+ + <"++ $"$ '"#,
z\]vw” aja “[\chdvw” — Z`a fZlzwd, Z >+ '&>. P  +, > +& !%-
†\z ]\†e. {\jZ g dZz, †dZ ”da fZza[Z- + +$"  !+%, >  %*5
]} v_jao]wˆdch g u_gacazZcda Zd dZyZ,  ! ''$,  5 , >'&
cvZjevZ aŠ fZz\_\dch g Z[`Zz ]h[w g +$"8, >$+  !E5+ (+*-
cd_`[_]d`Zz [\]\gh``Zz hav\, g vZdZ-  '"  >& !E #$+, 
]Zz aŠ ”vcfZ]da]wˆd au ‡u\]o_l[^_`_. & ,  + % ! #-

>


tq
t

+% *8) +<" + - !+-!!& +. 1<


" +. 7 " + $  '" —   +
+& !++  +.  +& <!, '< $ /$ —
9$"   !" #-  /$.
$+ :  * " !+5>,  O!" *+ +$"  % 
 * $ %5I. P" '%- !+ +  . / $!5I%8
,   ! !5, >'& % '+ ", , *+5 -
+&  $%& I > 5, %'+   '+ -
!#  +. P%+8, > -$ - & %$%, 5  !5 $%, 
$5 *%>" '+,  5 '- $+ '% !'" $5 $,
8  5> + + !<  "  " '%% !%-
$+ &+ !$+ $ " *. 9*,  !E!, -
 !E —  ! %  '"  "$ %$%,  <5" I -

6  
           “ ”   “ ”, 
 #  “     ”.     
"       “
 
” —         —   . )-,       

     # ,           ,
     . )- , "           -
,   ". *            -   -
     #,  ,     -     "   .
"#$ T =!6, ;69",  4#/!  >3/%1?-/ -/ @%9" 2!'

tqƒ +&, +&  * & +  +$ !"+ !+&, '%
$ —  <  # @<  * ,  $"$ $!"
# $%,  * %+" I   + !! ! !+%8 $&#>-
#+  '8, $ %  !%- $%, "$ %$"5 R+  . :
>5. D$ '% +, !-  !" *, >'&  !!
&  +&+ '"<+>$+ %$%+? : %" !+, ! >$, "+
$$ E   !%>5 +$", 5> +. A '%+ " 
 <5" & $? A, > , >'& !$& !+&. / $,
, 5  > +& +  R ! $&#>$%.
<, %>#  ! + '&>-   $$ + &, !%-
& & %$%. D *" %  '% ! <$&"  %'" 
'" %$%%8 RE8. /<"+ - "$. "   +* %*
# %$%,  R$+"  $ +>,  %8I ",   !E!, R !-
#   , >'& '&" I&- +& 55  "$ 
+! D%5 $85 ' '&+ +",  "$   V5 "#.
+: >   !*#",  <  K<%+5,  ++  $%  $-
 <"+#". A '& $, >'& !- E5 '%% +5"5,  % +5>,
*  $88 ! $+!&,  % + !+ +5$ '<%-
 <%" !%> >- $%. A 5 !$>$ *$ $,   R
'& — %&!   % %*!
/ !", $ %  " $%&
!+&, $%5 +$", + xZ[_g_h fZza[Z]} `_ cdZj, az\\d
+  <+>"& +, - cz}cj g}jZ^ade `_ d_]\jZ†vw c`_†_-
+ R    !%. j_ zZ]vZge a fZjZcva f\]‚_, zZ^`Z
+, > 5 %*%  wv]_cade a cg\^\l u\j\`eˆ, g\dZ†v_za
+$. O!"  !+. 9- wv]Zf_, `_f]az\], _ fZg\]Š g}jZ^ade

6 ,    "        “”   (“ -


 ” - ),    ,  ,       
  . 6       ,         
       ,   .
! +.
  
 "   
 . .    " 
 !   
     # 
3
"
 


>

fZza[Z]}. cd_g|a\ch g fZcw[\ z_cjZ • g[]wy tqr


a z_]a`_[ fZ[_g_de `\ cdZad. `a w^\
c}y]_ja cgZˆ ]Zje — z_cjZ hgajZce f_]_ |_|j}†vZg
d]_`cfZ]dZz [jh f\]\`Zc_ _]Zz_da†\-
cvaŠ a gvwcZg}Š g\\cdg, _ z_]a`_[ au- €\ u`_ˆ a ]\|ad\je`Z Zdv_u}g_ˆce fZ-
z\`aj cgZlcdg_ v_v c_zaŠ fZza[Z]Zg, `az_de [jh †\yZ jˆ[hz `w^`} ]\‚\f-
d_v a zZ]vZga. d} |_|j}vZg.
‰f]Z†\z, fZza[Z]} u_z_]a`Zg_- ijwfZcde ^\ `\cwcg\d`_h!
jace o} a c_za fZ c\o\, o\u z_cj_ a z_- ’\]ad\ ŠZ]Z|a\ f]Z[wvd}. šcja `\-
]a`_[_. Y_Š_], vZdZ]}l z} fZ[c}f_ja ZoŠZ[azZ aja ŠZ†\dch — f]a[_ld\ az
g c_zZz `_†_j\, c}y]_j ]Zje v_d_jau_- gvwc u_ c†\d cf\‚al, z_]a`_[Zg aja Zo-
dZ]_ [jh ]_oZd} ZcZo}Š cvg_|ag_ˆaŠ z_uZv (Z, `ZgZ\ cjZgZ!).
o_vd\]al, vZdZ]}\ f\]\]_oZd_ja a c_z • ^_]ed\!
”dZd [ZfZj`ad\je`}l c_Š_], a d\ c_Š_- ‰Zd czZd]ad\: cga`a`_.
]_, †dZ au`_†_je`Z cZ[\]^_jace g c_-
zaŠ fZza[Z]_Š, g vacjZdw a gZ[w. YZja, A%,   !5,  +* $<",
vZdZ]_h a d_v o}j_ g wv]Zf\ a †\c`Zv\, <5, !+% > R +5  '-
o}jZ [Zcd_dZ†`Z, †dZo} cd_oajaua]Z- $ ",  $ <'  -
g_de ”dZd f]Z‚\cc. ‡ Š]_`\`a\ fZza- +,  + " > !!. 9 —
[Z]Zg g ŠZjZ[aje`av\ f]aZcd_`ZgajZ &<$.
cvg_|ag_`a\ aja o]Z^\`a\ f]_vda†\- H  + ! ', R &<$, >"
cva fZj`Zcdeˆ. $%. K<- '*"  !"-
˜_vwcv_ fZjw†aj_ce _]Zz_d`_h, c d\- !!>"   +. A $ + $<,
fj}z, cZy]\g_ˆaz gvwcZz f\]‚_, †\c- >  " '&>%8 %,  !-
`Zv_ a f]h`Zcd\l, c f]ahd`Zl vacja`- %>5 + %*? A', !5
vZl, f]Zow^[_ˆ\l _ff\dad. '%  < '"# ! 
"#$ T

tp~

'5 $$ "5,  R, '$5, >+- F+, 5   <" &<$% $%-
* !*  5%, > . A%   '$+,  <<  ",  !&.
'  , <"    R+. :   9 5, $$ '+<$  '5 
+, > $$ 5  <"+%  %$ %, $ ! +5 — R <,  -&,
+5   +5  $ $$  <  %$  !<5 !*-
5 , >'& !" '+<$%. " &<$% — "  >% +"
+ '+<$%: %$, !<& !&+! +? / !+%  !%-
$%'$+, *8  "+ + >5, >  ! $ (3C, 
>5   +!%&, 8, <%+5",  % =B ] — !*-
!+#8  !! !*8 +- 5 5 '<! +!%.
!%%. J $   !, !$ %$  $- A " $ !%$&, $& *-
+<%5. P 8 %8 !%, "  '<!& +!% % $$
 !E, >$, %$% —  R "<5!
 '" $ %$%, " &, !%- / %5 %$. H>" $%5, 
#", &!" "8  %$%+ $%- <$!". : && %& %$ !-
 '  %". 1+ R  &, ! >& !%$… 5
I" +#",  %8 !% —  ##&$.
'>$%. D !'5 —  ! P > 5 + 8:  + -
5.  !5 %$% !&+ $-

>

tpk

$+  %!&+ E!+! / !>- A>  ,  %'  .
+%, $"$ 5    !*,  $$ /<"+ "$ *, !* %$%
  + E. A *&, #%- +5+  <>%8 $%  <
$ , 5  <  ##&$  !  $*%. F&#? D*%, #$%%, &+ -
<! Q '&85  %$%, +,   +5 ! . P  +, >
$5 % % $$ '5$  <!- ! R $* % %$ '& # -
5 < I$  $%$, >  %! !- $  , $ $   $%-
*". E! / '& '&  % $%E&  %$ *
F$"$ <  5 R% %$%, $ $>, R, E& '& R !E 
"$ < +5 * <+& %!! '&!
T#" *&, $ 5 !5  /+5 $ %$: >+ >I &  -
%& !55 " ##&$  *, + '"# * &!5 <
!!> E$ (, %! !$*   +5 *$  +
!5), ##&$ !%>5 $+ *, $$ < '% !%&" <*5
'&> %5 %$ !%>5  - #$%$ ( $*? $$ !"?). Q%-
. P  +, >  !"  < $% % <<" ", !!+.
'%$" % $, $&+ 5 - U * $<, > '"# > -
>  +, $  '&", !8". / 'I+, '  ! A%* "$ !E,
%#. $& "$ > < %!$, #5,
"#$ T =!6, ;69",  4#/!  >3/%1?-/ -/ @%9" 2!'

tpq $%5, $%!5 "  '$ 5I  '. A !>+! / 
# $"5$ 5 +. A-, E$-, # !", !-
 , $& & !' 5 +- %, %$< + "+5- % '5 + &-
,   ++  #, '< %- &+ "!" :   '&! A '&
$. A% >, *$ + )C–=C + # *"   !, !$ #$%$  !'-
$"5$,  &  !% R %$ %*   ,  $& +& +>
!& &I ? F5# %  + >,  + %*  — 
! +  !>%!   '$ !+%&, !+  %,
O+ ' > $"5$   !!   & +5 %*   !'5
+, R 5 + %8. G"- .
&+ '<+  !> " !&5 K*+ %$% %*  .
 %%8 !" < $$  '%" >, !$ /, $"$ $% '*  ? :
%$ !' $%-$+%8 $ $* "R $"", … $+… !$ 
+!%%. >" <'5  !5 R '8.
/, !  +! 7  $", $"  '& !<>,
/ *$  + " I  - R + $, R $   '$ $"5-
",  $ 5 'I + $- $, $& &  !*  !' +
<". 4>, %" *>"  &, $$ < R, '& & 8. D$  $%&,
!*,  !+ <'"  $%>$ R $,  &+$"  '+!
   <*" ! !+% +- : ##&$  " +5, !5+
, $%  +,  '% *"5 <%. 7 $$- >" !"&
%$. " !>$ !$. 1< ##&$. H   +5 $ !
!$ $%. G& * !& $$ + ##&$+, <!   <-
'<! / 'I+, !$ !  %- 5 < $+& $%  !$
$% #$%-$* < (<, <, <)  * $<" <$&&   $, <+-
++, >'& '$ % $ #+!% 5   $.

>

tpp

…Zfdaz, a… c_Š_]_. ohc`hˆ: yZjh|va wvj_-


[}g_ˆdch †wde g cdZ]Z`\ Zd `\cvZjevaŠ
dw|az, ^_]az wyZjevZg, `_ wyja fZc}f_\dch c_Š_], f\-
]\z\|_``}l c u\j\`}z †_\z a ]acZz.
‹`\ Z†\`e `]_gadch, v_v fZjw†_ˆd- …Zd\j u_v]}g_\dch [Z d\Š fZ], fZv_ [}z
ch cga`}\ yZjh|va, \cja aŠ yZdZgade g `\ f]\v]_dadch. “Zy[_ cj\[w\d c`Zg_ [Z-
`\cvZjevZ f]a\zZg, acfZjeuwh ]_u`}\ o_gade `_|\l cz\ca, _ f]a `\ZoŠZ[azZ-
z\dZ[}. Y`_†_j_ h gcwŠwˆ u_c_jag_ˆ yZ- cda a wyZje.
jh|va g d\†\`a\ [gwŠ-d]\Š [`\l gz\cd\
c dZj†\`}za cf\‚ahza: vZ]a‚\l, o_[eh- / <%"  $$? 7 5#-
`Zz a ygZu[avZl (cf\‚aa f\]\†acj\`} $ $!" !+ ! >. 4
g fZ]h[v\ wo}g_`ah aŠ vZja†\cdg_, `Z R +5  " %  3C–6C,
zZ^`Z ]wvZgZ[cdgZg_dech a cZocdg\`-  %! !$&"5 % %+5
`}z gvwcZz a ZoZ`h`a\z). “\]za†\cv_h $>$. P, $>$ + >&
Zo]_oZdv_ cZcdZad au `\cvZjevaŠ ”d_fZg. $& !$%, +  +&  -
x\]g}l ”d_f — vZf†\`a\. '".
“ZjevZ vZf†w h aŠ `\ _]Zz_d`}za U  !%  $<, %>-
\fv_za a `\ g vZfdajv\, _ g c_zZz &5 & , $  & 5#-
Zo}†`Zz vZdj\ o_]o\vˆ a f]a fZzZ- $ * +"  +*.

4-  :   "          , -


         !   —           
     ".
"#$ T

tpƒ

O> $ * +* !"  %$%. @"  !"  # <%8


/ , !8'%", $$5 $E! %$%.   $$ % > !-
/ > $ *, $$   &+ - '%"$", %'" +!%%  (2C ]
5#$+, "$ &'" %>#  %-  <'%"  %$ >  ,   
$,  <%8 '". W ! $*  >&. /+5 $ !5+%8 <
% $*5 #$+ + *,   < !$  %$.
*" $*%  % $>$ — W" "$  $":  %
# *  &!5.  !"8 !$& 5#$  %$%,
$ %$  5#$ $!55, %   +5  + !%$& %
" ' +5 5 , >'& !- !>". R+% %># &'"
" % 5 %#5. !%% $ <+, >'& !%$&
/ '"#+ $> + '- - !+I"  ,  %,
*" <& $%'$+ %$, +- $ , , >'&  '& !-
$", '" & +'"  >$, $&  # <# +5 
%8 !% , !! '55 % '".
 !'55 "  %$%,  % $  %$   + >+,
 !5 + $%. %"  '% + " >+ <5"5: "  $$
$"$ **, >+ " '& — <%- 5 %#, !+&"  !%#" <" 
"  I %!. & "5,  '"  .
/ R % %$& 5#$  A  !'55 $"$
%$%, $ !%% $&#$  & <$%$. U &' +&
  
  (    # $+ ) 3,  
       $  
½     :
 . .  #  $   
– !      
 . .    "  7 

1  , $,   


>

$%*%& "5, $+-> < %E, - <>%. A%   * , >'& V" tpr
 ($#$ $, %I " %- !'"# +&  ?
>"  D, +* +  <+- /'I- %$% % ! !>
" “$$” +$$),  $+->  !5+   !<"  !E-
< '&> $!%&. / $> !! & $%>$. A 5 !%!5 !
! & %, %"$%8 !>%8  $&. /  — >" $%5
!%, %8 !% (> ,    %$.
% !8  + +< 9- :  '& !<"  $, $$ 5
$&)  '8>$  $&+ ++  !< 5#$%, % $ +5 %* -
>$+. 1& '& !" !" + !  $.
'8E  $%*%&+ ++, !!-
&+ >&+ !E+  "8,  >$ ’\]ad\ jacd c_j_d_. xZjZ^ad\ g jacd
 %>$& !E $"E+ !" vZzZv ]ac_, vwcZ†\v zhc_. ‹hcZ fZ ^\-
! 5+. A R '& + &',  & j_`aˆ zZ^`Z Zoz_v`wde g z_cjZ aja
 . cZ\g}l cZwc. {Zo_ged\ †dZ g_|\l [w|\
G$%  5#$  &%" < %, wyZ[`Z — vaz-†a aja Z[`w au f_cd,
!+$%" '%+*&+ @$+, " [Zjevw †\c`Zv_ aja vZj\†vZ f\]‚_. xZ-
$ '%"  #$.  R jZ^ad\ u\j\`e, u_g\]`ad\ jacd, g}f\ld\
 $<   '"# $$ <- ]ˆzvw m~-y]_[wc`Zl fZ[Zy]\dZl gZ[va a
" +  '*" %$%  5#$, u_vwc}g_ld\. …_^[}l cj\[wˆal cg\]-
!$  #$%   %5I. dZv fwcde ow[\d c `Zg}z cZ†\d_`a\z.
F% * +* !" $ %. 9- ij_g`Z\ wcjZga\ — ”dZ fZ[[\]^ag_de
* '&", + !5,  <+"- vZ`d]_cd a ]_u`ZZo]_ua\. iZ]h†\\ zhcZ
>"  '+,  +*, & #  a ŠZjZ[`}l jacd, f]\c`}l ]ac a Zcd]_h
 !" $&, !+% > %, >- f]af]_g_, †wde cj_[vZg_d_h a Š]wcdh_h
 5, %* &! 8 %8 |vw]v_ a Z†\`e zhyvZ\ a `\^`Z\ zhcZ.

'  ,       ,           ! I      ,


            ",           
  !  . K-      ! 6    .
часть четвертая
Четвертая
перемена
блюд
™»
‰ yZ]Z[\ i_o_j\ a \yZ Zv]\cd`ZcdhŠ u_- tsp
z\†_d\je`_h vwŠ`h. • ŠZdh v`ay_ ”d_ Z
vwja`_]aa, g f\]gwˆ Z†\]\[e z`\ Z†\`e
ŠZ†\dch ]_ccv_u_de `\ dZjevZ Z vwŠ`\,
`Z a Zo ”daŠ w[agad\je`}Š z\cd_Š, a Z
jˆ[hŠ, vZdZ]}\ d_z ^agwd. – z`ZyZ y[\
fZo}g_j a z`Zya\ wyZjva u\zja z`\
fZ`]_gajace, `Z fZg\]ed\: \cja o} z`\
[_ja g}oa]_de, y[\ ^ade, dZ h o} g}-
o]_j az\``Z Zv]\cd`Zcda i_o_j}. ‡
‰dZ]Z\ [}Š_`a\ fZv_ h ow[w \u[ade dw[_ Zd[}Š_de, fZdZ-
zw †dZ jw†|\ Zd[}Š_ `w f]ZcdZ `\ f]a-
[wz_de. • f]\^[\ gc\yZ ”dZ `_cdZhal
]_l [jh y_cd]Z`Zza†\cvZyZ dw]auz_.
€\ g fZcj\[`ˆˆ Z†\]\[e i_o_j_ cj_-
gadch cgZaza cZj\`ehza. • f]_g[_,
gvwc`\\ aŠ o\j}Š Zyw]‚Zg ([_-[_, d_z
]_cdwd ZcZo}\, o\j}\ Zyw]‚} a o\j_h
‘_cZje) a cZj\`al `\ \j. †\`e gvwc-
`}\ Zyw]‚}, fZza[Z]}, v_fwcd_, ]_u`_h
u_cZj\``_h u\j\`e.
€Z gZd †dZ z\`h w[agajZ oZje|\
gc\yZ. xZczZd]ad\ `_ ”dw d_]\jvw. ždZ
dZ^\… cZj\`eh! b\]\|`ˆ, ]_``a\ hojZ-
va, `\[Zu]\j}\ cjag} cZjhd f]hzZ g
Z[`Zl o_`v\. œZzdava _lg} a zw|zwjw
(dwd \\ \\ `_u}g_ˆd “_uyaje”, _ o}g_\d
"#$ %M

tss

“u}v}]” — []wyZl fjZ[, `Z au dZyZ ^\ c\- ‹`\, vcd_da, fZ[wz_jZce, †dZ, fZza-
z\lcdg_) cZjhd Zd[\je`Z, Zc\`eˆ. œ\dZz zZ |_jZd_, [jh z_]a`Zg_`ah f]\v]_c`Z
cZjhd vauaj a _j}†w. ‰Zd dZjevZ jwv- fZ[Zl[\d jwv “^\z†w^`}l”: ”dZ d_va\
|_jZd u[\ce `\ cZj\`}l, _ z_]a`Zg_`- cZgc\z z_j\`eva\ jwvZga†va, vZdZ]}\
`}l. ‹_]a`Zg_` Z`… g y]_`_dZgZz cZv\. †_\ gc\yZ gcd]\†_ˆdch g ga[\ vZ`c\]-
– u`_ˆ, †dZ g} c\l†_c [_^\ f]\[cd_- gZg, w^\ g o_`v_Š, g wvcwc`Zl u_jagv\…
gade c\o\ `\ g cZcdZh`aa, v_vZyZ ”dZ gc\ €Z f]a ^\j_`aa ^\z†w^`}l jwv zZ^-
gvwc_. ‡ zZ^\d\ fZg\]ade z`\ `_ cjZgZ? `Z `_lda a cg\^al. ˜_z_]a`Zg_de \yZ
ždZ gZcŠadad\je`Z a Z†\`e wz\cd`Z v g cg\^\z y]_`_dZgZz cZv\ `\cjZ^`Z,
Zo\[w: fZjw†_\dch u_z\†_d\je`}l y_]- `_[Z dZjevZ [Zo_gade g z_]a`_[ cZje a
`a] v zhcw, [_ a g v_†\cdg\ u_vwcva — cf\‚aa fZ g_|\zw gvwcw.
ŠZde v ga`w, ŠZde v gZ[v\ — dZ^\ Zdja†-
`Z fZ[ŠZ[ad. ‡ gZd c y]_`_dZg}z cZvZz, g\]`\\, c c_-
€_cdZjevZ gvwc`Z, †dZ w[\]^_dech Zd zaza y]_`_d_za gZ z`ZyaŠ yZ]Z[_Š
gZcf]Zaug\[\`ah ŠZde v_vZyZ-dZ fZ[Z- —Zccaa `\g_^`Z. €\d, ]_uwz\\dch zZ^-
oah ”dZyZ g\javZj\fah h `\ czZy. `Z vwfade ŠZde y]wuZgav ”daŠ y]_`_dZg,
Yv_^\z, gZd ”dZd jwv-|_jZd — zZ^\d `Z gc\ [\jZ g dZz, †dZ y]_`_d}, f]Z[_ˆ-
ja v_vZl a`Zl cZ]d fZ[Zlda [jh z_]a- a\ch `_ `_|aŠ ]}`v_Š, azfZ]da]Zg_-
`Zg_`ah jw†|\? `} au [_je`aŠ cd]_`, g}]_\`} fZ cZ-
    
       —  . .   !
“  # ”   +    # ! # "
       
   :  . . +  $
 . .     –
. .  !  # 
, . .  
 . .   


?

g]\z\``}z _y]Z`Zza†\cvaz d\Š`ZjZ-


œwv ts
yahz a f]\[cd_gjhˆd cZoZl ]\uwjed_d
d]w[_ c\j\v‚aZ`\]Zg, vZdZ]}Š u_oZdhd fZ-y_o_ja`cva
f]\^[\ gc\yZ d\ cgZlcdg_ ”dZyZ †w[\c`Z-
yZ fjZ[_, †dZ a oZje|a`cdgZ fZd]\oa- H#!" >I& %$, <*  
d\j\l. €w gZd gcfZz`ad\: †dZ g} cf]_- <%8 !%8 '$%, -
|ag_\d\ w f]Z[_g‚_, vZy[_ fZvwf_\d\ '" , > <!, $8>5
y]_`_d}? '',  < $!5$+, $&
— ‡ Z`a cj_[va\? I  +5 $!5  !", -
— Yj_[va\, cj_[va\! — Zdg\†_\d f]Z- '" , !!", $ !+%,
[_g\‚ a g\[e yZgZ]ad f]a ”dZz f]_g[w! +"8 '  < !E, $+-
žda y]_`_d} `_ c_zZz [\j\ cj_[va\. ‡  + + … %# +5&, ?
[jh dZyZ †dZo} u_z_]a`Zg_de g y]_- : >,  I  + <", 
`_dZgZz cZv\ jwv, `_z `w^\` vacj}l, !%" +%5 +  %$+, !%"
f]ZcdZ Z†\`e vacj}l y]_`_dZg}l cZv! '  +  8I
• †dZ [\j_de? i[\ guhde? ˜gZ`ade []w- $& +% — R * '% #!
uehz g ‡u\]o_l[^_`, d]\owh f]acj_de c J  >:  '+ 2–B -
Zv_ua\l vZ]ZoZ†vw d\Š c_z}Š y]_`_dZg, & *$ '"<+>$ %$%.
aja acv_de g}ŠZ[ au fZjZ^\`ah, acŠZ- G$% '$%, !%" !  !
[h au az\ˆaŠch wcjZgal? ",  !+ %'    *,
‰dZ]Zl fwde fZv_u_jch z`\ oZj\\ ! * $"$ , !$ %$
f]\[fZ†dad\je`}z, a h f]a[wz_j cZo-  !+%5    !$&+
cdg\``wˆ g\]caˆ z_]a`Zg_``ZyZ jwv_ $$+!++ $ +5&+ '8+  -
fZ y_o_ja`cvaz zZdag_z. +5" <+>" <$%$.
š|ed\ `_ u[Z]Zge\ — cfjZ|`_h fZjeu_
a f]ahd`Zcde [jh _ff\dad_.

)   ,      -   "  ? &       -
                 , ,  ? 7 
     "     "  ",  "     -
         : “F  "! )" !”
4 
  " #  !    +
   !        
  0    $#   $# 
1  — + ,    ,  
 " $ 1   $   
* "  " 1   #  !   ,
"   —  
 

) (   !  * :



?

‡ zZ^`Z fZf]ZoZg_de c_zZzw cZ- cd_j `_ `_|aŠ yj_u_Š [_gade gc\ fZ[]h[ tsr
o]_de `\Zo}†`}l j\d`al c_j_d, f]Z- [Z`}|vZz cd_v_`_.
cdZl [Z auwzj\`ah. …_v z`\ ]_ccv_u_- – cv_u_j fZg_]w:
ja, d_vZl c_j_d oZje|\ `ay[\ `\ [\j_- — ˜_†\z `w^\` ”dZd cd_v_`? {_gade
ˆd, `a g Z[`Zz ]_lZ`\ ‡u\]o_l[^_`_, hyZ[} a ‘]wvd}?
v]Zz\ i_o_j}. ‡ zZ^\d o}de, a cZgc\z ‡ fZf]ZoZg_g fZ[_gade \\ Z†\`e
`ay[\. dg\][}\ cjag} ]wv_za, fZ`hj, †dZ o\u
`\yZ `\ ZoZldace.
YZj\`}l c_j_d €Z dwd v_v ]_u f]ayZdZgj\`a\ c_j_-
d_ u_vZ`†ajZce: dZjevZ a Zcd_jZce, †dZ
au j\d`aŠ ‘]wvdZg f\]\z\|_de gcˆ z_ccw, Zdo]_c}g_h vZ-
cdZ†va g cdZ]Z`vw. • c]_uw g}jZ^ade
‰Zd v_va\ ‘]wvd} fZcf\ja, d\ a vj_- `_ d_]\jvw yZ]vZl a fZ[_de.
[wd g c_j_d fZ[ `_ug_`a\z “[Zlz_†”. ‡ ‰ yZ]Z[_Š, y[\ f\]g_h vjwo`av_ fZ-
†_\ [_^\ acfZjeuwˆd `\[Zu]\j}\: g hgjh\dch `_ f]aj_gv_Š v |\cda wd]_,
^_]w vacja`v_ ja|`\l `\ ow[\d. ‰ vZ`- yZdZgade [Zlz_† zZ^`Z †wde ja `\
‚\ aˆjh, vZy[_ z} o}ja g i_o_j\, fZ- v]wyj}l yZ[. xZf]Zowld\ cZ†\d_de
cf\ja vauaj a _j}†_. vjwo`avw `\ dZjevZ c o_uajavZz, `Z a c
xZg_] g}`\c z\d_jja†\cvZ\ fjZ- ]wvvZjZl — fZg\]ed\, g}l[\d †w[\c`Z!
cvZ\ ojˆ[Z, ‘]wvd}-hyZ[}, fZ]\u_``}\ {Z c_zZyZ Zvdho]h g ‹Zcvg\ `_ ]}`v_Š
wv]Zf a ‘aZj\dZg}l o_uajav, cZje. • gZgcˆ f]Z[_\dch vauaj. ‡ gz\cdZ _j}-
"#$ %M ("/ 6-/

t~ †a aja `\[Zu]\jZl cjag} zZ^`Z guhde ‹hcZ, zhcZ, zhcZ,


a cf\j}\ cjag}. šcja c_j_d fZv_^\dch
cja|vZz cj_[vaz, fZ[f]_ged\ gvwc ja- d\cdZ a jwv
zZ``}z cZvZz.
…]Zz\ vjwo`ava aja vauaj_ g ”dZz ’w[ed\ v]_dva. Yv_^ad\ dZjevZ: “xjZg”,
c_j_d\ ow[wd ŠZ]Z|a jˆo}\ vacj}\ a a jˆ[a dwd ^\ Zdvjav`wdch: “›uo\vcval!”
vacjZ-cj_[va\ hyZ[}, fZcf\g|a\ v zZ- — ’Z], y_jw|va!
z\`dw \yZ f]ayZdZgj\`ah. … f]az\]w, — ›v]_a`_!
Zdz\``Z gvwc`}z d_vZl c_j_d fZjw†_- — Y_‚aga, |_|j}v, ga`Z!
\dch au ga|`a, [_ a vjˆvg_ aja v_v_h — i]wuah!
[]wy_h hyZ[_ — dZ^\ `\ fjZŠa! — «a, y]ao}, f\jez\`a!
{_z g_z \\ Z[a` cZg\d. šcja cja- — —Zccah!
g} fZf_[wdch v]wf`}\, dZ [_gade aŠ `\ — ‹_v_]Z`}!
`_[Z, zZ^`Z f]ZcdZ fZ]\u_de `Z^Zz, — •d_jah!
f]ZŠZ[h zazZ vZcdZ†va. “Z†`Z d_v ^\ €\d `a†\yZ w[agad\je`ZyZ g dZz, †dZ
cdZad fZv]Zzc_de a vauaj. • wv]Zf c o_- w jˆoZl cd]_`} az\\dch cgZ\ ojˆ[Z —
uajavZz [Zo_gade `_[Z Zohu_d\je`Z. • vwja`_]`}l cazgZj [\]^_g}. €_g\]`Z\,
`\ cd\c`hld\ce cZjade: ”dZ [Zj^\` o}de cdZad g}]_uadech [_^\ \\ ]_[av_je-
az\``Z cZj\`}l c_j_d. `\\: o}jZ o} cd]_``Z `_lda `_]Z[ c ]_u-
˜_o}j `_fac_de! œwvw, jwvw v]}z- gadZl z_d\]a_je`Zl a [wŠZg`Zl vwjedw-
cvZyZ ‘aZj\dZgZyZ g ”dZd c_j_d ŠZ]Z|Z ]Zl, w vZdZ]ZyZ `\ ]Z[ajZce `a Z[`ZyZ
fZ]\u_de vwoav_za! ‡ fZ[_g_de \yZ fZ- a`d\]\c`ZyZ a w`av_je`ZyZ ojˆ[_.
`az_\d\ v †\zw, [_? … ^_]\`Zzw zhcw, €Z o}g_ˆd d_va\ ojˆ[_-cazgZj}, vZ-
v ŠZ]Z|az vZdj\d_z, a [_^\ v o\|- dZ]}\ owvg_je`Z fZv]}g_ˆd cZoZˆ `\
o_]z_vw aja Ša`y_jw, Z vZdZ]}Š c\l†_c Z[`w cd]_`w, _ ‚\j}\ ]\yaZ`}, \cja `\
fZl[\d ]\†e! vZ`da`\`d}.
) (   !  * :

?

YzZd]ad\, cdZad dZjevZ f]Zau`\cda €Z w[agad\je`Z dZ, †dZ ”dZ ojˆ[Z, tk
Z[`Z cjZgZ “o\|o_]z_v” — a w [Zo]Zl fZ- ]_cf]Zcd]_`hhce fZ cg\dw a [_^\ z\-
jZga`} cjw|_d\j\l c\][‚\ u_oe\dch †wde `hh fZ fwda `_ug_`a\, cZŠ]_`ajZce g
o}cd]\\, f]\[gvw|_h f]_u[`av. x]_u[- _ocZjˆd`Z f\]gZu[_``Zz ga[\ [_^\ g
`av, u`_vZz}l c [\dcdg_, f]_u[`av, u_- d\Š u\zjhŠ, y[\ f]a]Z[_ g\cez_ zajZ-
`\c\``}l g `_|a [w|a `_ y\`\da†\cvZz cdag_ v †\jZg\vw a `\d `av_vZl `w^[}
w]Zg`\. yZdZgade cdZje _cv\da†\cvwˆ fZ `_oZ]w
…Zy[_ fZhgajch o\|o_]z_v? “]w[`Z a`y]\[a\`dZg \[w. ‰ c_zZz [\j\, ow[e
cv_u_de. €_g\]`Z\, c]_uw, v_v dZjevZ †\- dZ o\|o_]z_v g Y\g\]`Zz …_u_Šcd_`\,
jZg\†\cdgZ `_w†ajZce zZjZde u\]`Z a [\- v_a| g “w]vz\`aa, Ša`y_j g {_y\cd_`\,
j_de au `\yZ d\cdZ. €Z fZhgajch Z` g Z†\`e a`y]\[a\`d} Zcd_ˆdch Z[`aza a d\za
cjZ^`Zz [jh f]Z^ag_`ah †\jZg\v_ ]\- ^\: zhcZ, d\cdZ, jwv a vacjZ\ zZjZvZ. €w,
yaZ`\, g c_zZz ‚\`d]\ šg]_uaa, fZc]\[a zZjZvZ fZv_ [_g_ld\ Zcd_gaz g cdZ]Z`\,
o\cv]_l`aŠ cd\f\l, g dw fZ]w f]ayZ[`}Š Z`Z g\[e acfZjeuw\dch dZjevZ [jh cZwc_,
dZjevZ [jh vZ†\gZyZ cvZdZgZ[cdg_. ‰fZj- _ u_lz\zch Zc`Zg`}za a`y]\[a\`d_za.
`\ \cd\cdg\``Z, †dZ cf_]d_`cva\ ^au`\`- ‰c\yZ-`_gc\yZ au d]\Š ”daŠ cZcd_g-
`}\ wcjZgah a [Z f]\[\j_ ]_‚aZ`_je`}l jhˆaŠ — zhc_, d\cd_ a jwv_ — †\jZ-
o}d f]Z[avdZg_ja ]\‚\fd ”dZyZ ojˆ[_. g\†\cdgZ cZu[_jZ [\chdva c_z}Š ]_u-
šcja w d\oh \cde zhcZ — cg_]a \yZ, a `ZZo]_u`}Š fZ gvwcw, ga[w a ‘Z]z\
\[} Šg_dad `_ gc\Š [\d\l a [ZzZ†_[‚\g. ojˆ[. xZczZd]ad\, u[\ce a ŠZ]Z|Z au-
šcja w d\oh \cde zwv_, `Z `\d f\†a, dZ ]_c- g\cd`}\ f\jez\`a cZ gc\za aŠ g_]a_-
v_d_l d\cdZ a cg_]a \yZ g zhc`Zz owjeZ- ‚ahza — y\u_ a †w†g_]_, [ˆ|o_]_ a
`\ — ”dZ o}cd]Z a gvwc`Z. š|e jwv, †dZo} Ša`v_ja; u[\ce a f]Zcd}\ a †\cd`}\
dgZl ]Z[ `\ g}z\] Zd oZj\u`\l. ˜_fag_l f_]Zg}\ ]wj\d} ŠZ`w` c ]_u`ZZo]_u`}-
\[w cgZˆ vacj}z zZjZvZz, fZdZzw †dZ za wvjZ`\`ahza, g ]\uwjed_d\ vZdZ]}Š
\yZ w d\oh z`ZyZ. fZjw†_ˆdch auh`}\ z_`d} a o_Z‚u};



    
      , #    "   +
(   !     , #  , + )    :
  " $  # $    
   ! & 
   $

 +      

"#$ %M ("/ 6-/

tm u[\ce [_je`\gZcdZ†`}\ fh`c\ a fayZ[a, xZdZzw †dZ g ”dZz ojˆ[\ `\d `av_-
_u\]o_l[^_`cva\ vwd_o} a v]}zcva\ vaŠ c\v]\dZg, `Z wz\`a\ \yZ yZdZgade
†\ow]\va, d_d_]cva\ o\jh|a a ”†fZ†z_- f\]\[_\dch dZjevZ au ]wv g ]wva.
va, ]wccva\ fa]Zya, vwj\ohva a ]_ccd\- ‰Zd d_v yZdZgad `_cdZhal o\|o_]-
y_a. €a u_ †dZ `\ wfZz`ade gc\yZ. • †dZ z_v Ywja\, v_u_|v_ fZ `_‚aZ`_je`Zcda,
Zoa[`Z, `\f]\z\``Z wfwcda|e au ga[w, fZg_] Z[`ZyZ ŠZ]Z|\yZ d_|v\`dcvZyZ
f]a`hg|ace f\]\†acjhde, †dZ-jaoZ `\- ]\cdZ]_`_.
cZz`\``Z g\javZ\, g]Z[\ c_zc}. • g\[e
v_^[Z\ ojˆ[Z gvwc`Z fZ-cgZ\zw, a `\
cfwd_de Z[`Z c []wyaz [_^\ fZ u_f_Šw, …_u_Šcv_h vj_ccav_
`\ yZgZ]h w^\ Z g`\|`\z ga[\ a ZcZ-
oZz [jh v_^[ZyZ ojˆ[_ _`dw]_^\. ‡ g K$& F%  $+ $%-
c_zZz `_†_j\ ”dZyZ ]h[_ o\cvZ`\†`}Š + ++ !>  +:   -
auz\`\`al a wcZg\]|\`cdgZg_`al cdZ- $ $% '5 !$ +%$,  5E,
hj f]Zcd\l|al a oj_yZ]Z[`\l|al o\|- ". /& '58, $"$ !'%-
o_]z_v. 5 5 %,  R> . D$ 
ždZ v_v ]_u dZd ]\‚\fd, vZdZ]}l f]Z- !#%.
\ gc\yZ [avdZg_de fZ d\j\‘Z`w, fZ- K$ $, %  
cvZjevw `\d `a†\yZ d]aga_je`\\, †\z $$%  ! *+ !   .
cg_]ade zhcZ, `_]\u_de d\cdZ vg_[]_da- D% !5  $$%& !&
v_za [_ fZ]\u_de jwv. €Z fZcjw|_ld\ $ #&.
z\`h gc\ d\, vdZ yZdZgaj o\|o_]z_v fZ H5  !<"  $$%&
]\‚\fd_z au v`ay, a `avZy[_ `\ f]ZoZ- $&.
g_j o\|o_]z_v, f]ayZdZgj\``}l v_- O!" !++5 $ +5%. F*
u_Š_za: dZ, †dZ g} \ja, — f]ZcdZ zhcZ,  !  '#'+$  5, !
d\cdZ a jwv. A '#'+$ '%  $, $$ 
"#$ %M ("/ 6-/

tq @: !%# $%!&+ $%$+, <- / R * +5 !  ! '%-
 !&! "8, ! *8 " $&8 "5 $%$ ,
 !E5+ (!>+, R '% %*  - 5 < +, >'&  ! ',
+ %>). 7 5. Q5%   '" $+$+. P5 R, $-
!#8  $ 5 '&   >, %* '"# $<  #$5,
5,  %># *  !"# +% !%- !5 $85. 18,  $+
#"5. J< $ +5 '%" !%>5 '% !"5 '#'+$, + +-
>I  +. + * !8 $!5I+ '%"+,
A # '#'+$ 5  < >'&   !".
  +5,  5 '& < .  %$ 5 $*% '. <& %$
G+& <5 '58 ! $ $&8  '"# "& $-
'%" *%8 '%,  I  $<& — <>$,  $& '8 *  !-
&5%8 $'%,  $%8  D-  '%",   + %$  *5, 
<, <%+5,   5,  "$ $ !5.
$. / < $  !%>5 Q  &$&8  '8,
# '#'+$. P,  !E  '%" !8  '%"+  %$+, + 
%* $$! O"$  +$$ >%"- *+,  $+  $!.
>%",   <,  "$  `*+ D- J  "$ !" ! >
<… +5  $<&. J &8 < '%"
95  $<& 8  '"# $-  $&8 ! . 9*, I
<. 95 &+8, 8 &", - '%" !"? : , $   !-
<8 $$%&+ +5+  !%$8  5 " '%"  '"# !&,
$"$ +%  $<,  !* <!"  $&+ +$+   $
$!" '%", — <"5. !", 5+  '8+   +5.
-# ' 
   "  
     #  
$   "$   
   #  —    :
 8   $/       
“#”,    +  #   & 

 +      $
 

     1 # 
?

xZ []wywˆ vw c v_d}v_, a fZjw†ag|alch fjZd`}l tp


dgZ]Zy (cˆuezw) g}cw|ag_ˆd, _ fZdZz
cdZ]Z`w …_cfah cv_d}g_ˆd g |_]ava ]_uz\]Zz c zh†av
[jh `_cdZje`ZyZ d\``ac_, _ dZ a z\je-
• `_[Z ^\ z`\ o}jZ cfwcdh z`ZyZ j\d †\ — c f\]\f\ja`Z\ hl‚Z. “_v vw]d f]Z-
Zv_u_dech g ‡u\]o_l[^_`\, †dZo} wcj}- cw|ag_\dch ]_g`Zz\]`Z, `\ ]_cd]\cva-
|_de, v_v o_va`cva\ []wueh c`Zg_ a c`Z- g_\dch a Š]_`adch fZdZz Z†\`e [ZjyZ. ‡
g_ yZgZ]hd z`\: _ g “Zgwu\ aja g ‡vcd_- gZd g _u\]o_l[^_`cvZl ‡vcd_‘\ fZjw†_-
‘\ fwcde d\o\ Zohu_d\je`Z f]ayZdZghd ˆd owlgZja`}l vw]d ]_uz\]Zz c oZje-
vw]d-Ša`y_j. “_z [Z caŠ fZ] acfZjeuw- |Zl cd_v_`, a gZgc\ Z` w `aŠ `\ ]_ug_-
ˆd zZjZvZ w owlgZja‚ — cZg\]|\``Z jag_\dch. €avZy[_ o} `\ fZg\]aj.
ZcZo\``Z\, Z†\`e ^a]`Z\ a gvwc`Z\, — ždZzw vw]dw fZdZz f]\[cdZad c}-
au `\yZ v_d}v cZgc\z []wyZl fZjw†_- y]_de ZcZowˆ ]Zje g f]ayZdZgj\`aa
\dch. Yjw|_ld\, `w h g\]aj, †dZ zZjZvZ u`_z\`adZyZ u[\|`\yZ Ša`y_j_. [`_^-
owlgZja‚ `\ d_vZ\, v_v vZ]Zge\, `Z gc\- [} c]_uw d]a _vcd_‘a`cva\ ŠZuhlva guh-
d_va `av_v `\ Z^a[_j wga[\de v_d}v, g jace fZv_u_de z`\, v_v ”dZ d]_[a‚aZ`-
vZdZ]Zz cywcdZv c_z Zd[\jh\dch Zd c}- `Z\ a †w[\c`Z\ ojˆ[Z yZdZgadch.
gZ]Zdva a az\\d f]a ”dZz d_vwˆ fjZd-
`Zcde, †dZ zZ^`Z `Z^Zz ]\u_de. /-!&,     ', 
…_d}v ”dZd owlgZja`}l cw|_d, fZjw- $$-'%" I +5, … E&!5. M-
†_h dZ, †dZ u[\ce `_u}g_\dch “yw]wd”. €w #, !"& E&!5-!+&, +
[_, ”dZ f]hzZl _`_jZy vw]d_, vZdZ]}l %* +5E ! >&-!5" !",
zZ^`Z gcd]\dade fZgcˆ[w g Y]\[`\l    <  + + I  '<-
‡uaa: d_z dZ^\ c‚\^ag_ˆd c}gZ]Zd- $  !'5 $ $++%. ^&!5
Курт –
способ консервации молока

ts

Д
jh f]ayZdZgj\`ah vw]d_ c`_- iZgZ]hd, †dZ g …_u_Šcd_`\ cˆuezw, f]\-
†_j_ yZdZghd cˆuezw (c‚\- ^[\ †\z cw|ade, g_]hd, _ a`Zy[_ g_]hd a
^\``}l lZyw]d) aja, v_v cZ cjagv_za. €Z g Zcd_je`}Š z\cd_Š yZdZ-
g_]a_`d, f]a fZzZa c}- ghd Z†\`e f]ZcdZ — f]az\]`Z d_v, v_v h a
†wy_ auyZd_gjag_ˆd dgZ]Zy, Zfac_j. …w]d zZ^`Z cŠ]wzv_de v_v \cde,
cZjhd, fZ[cw|ag_ˆd, cv_d}- zZ^`Z c fagZz, `Z g f]\^`a\ g]\z\`_
g_ˆd |_]ava, cw|_d `_cwŠZ fZ[ cZj`- vw]d yZdZgaja `\ ]_[a u_o_g}: ”dZd f]Z-
‚\z. x]\[fZ†dad\je`\\ acfZjeuZg_de [wvd az\\d za`az_je`}l Zo\z a g\c,
vZue\ zZjZvZ, `Z dZ†`Z d_v ^\ yZdZghd _ \cja \yZ ]_uzZ†ade g gZ[\ a [Zo_gade
a au vZ]Zge\yZ. ˜_ `\az\`a\z cZj`‚_ h cwŠZl Šj\o, dZ fZjw†adch gfZj`\ fad_-
cw|aj g [wŠZgv\, g ]\^az\ Zo[wg_ yZ]h- d\je`_h \[_ [jh fwd`avZg. •`d\]\c`Z,
†az gZu[wŠZz, f]a p~ °Y, f]az\]`Z cwd- †dZ lZyw]d, gZccd_`Zgj\``}l au vw]d_,
va. …_^\dch, `_[Z o} fZcw|ade \\, `Z az\\d []wyZl gvwc, `\ d_vZl, v_v cg\^al
a d_v fZjw†ajZce Z†\`e, f]ZcdZ Z†\`e lZyw]d. ždZ v_v cZj\`}\ a cg\^a\ Zyw]-
ŠZ]Z|Z! iZ]_u[Z gvwc`\\, †\z gc\ dZ, †dZ ‚}, v_v zZ†\`}\ a cg\^a\ hojZva. €Z
h fZvwf_j f]\^[\, vZy[_ f]Z\u^_j †\]\u az\``Z d_vZl, gZccd_`Zgj\``}l lZyw]d
yZ]`}l f\]\g_j g va]yaucvaŠ a d_[^av- f]\[fZ†ad_ˆd acfZjeuZg_de g v_†\cdg\
cvaŠ va|j_v_Š. cZwc_ v _u\]o_l[^_`cvZzw Ša`y_jw.
     1 # 
?

'8 >&  R$>$ >- '* %$ *5 !-+%,  $, t
$ <5, +#, &#  <, $$, !+,  G<'$. G +5 
$%!  %>& >5>$, > %- , 5  >'& !*" %$, +-
"   . A5$,  '%%  > !+ < '& 
$+ * $%&+, $$+ '& +!- &+$. : <" !$>$  %8
>&+ ! *<. A% , I! , $88 !% %$ —   :$@
!, !%'  !E& $%$. +&, +-$ E, — '-
D>,  <5" $$-'%" &-  +   *" $+ '<+,
I&  !E@'$ ', >'& $>$ " !! 
$&+ %-  (=–0C,   %*    $ E  %$-
<%"  $+'$+  ++  ,  " *&+, ! <-
+  $++ <+, &+  +&+.
 $   !#". /" 5 - /-",  R '& $%, 
 R E&!5 !5 "  * “%%”: , $<&5, % -
!%,  "$ !+ *"  $#", <+>"  !" ><
!%+5". O$  @'>& E&!5 , %55 $#$. D<" '&,  -
!  R !E% >  - >  <5" ! $&$? 4>+ $
5 — '% $# < <#5 - *? / '&& + $ !%!-
$  $ ". R+% 5 $-  !%#$, $&+ !"
 '8  '& !$" 5I%8 - '"  ' $%,  %!'5  
$%8 !E%  5 '& %!& $%, !%,     * +$, 
$& !8   &$. $&$,  > $ * <+>"  
/-&, %$:  !58  $- . A !"-,  +# %5,
88 "#  " — - <>+? :   +, > R ! 
+"5  *"5  !+ - <& $% — % * $&$  % -
>+ +. J,
, >  :<-
:< $%…
 < $%
     1 # 
?

/->&, . O> $, $$ 5 $ %$%  +, $& $$ < %! tr
% #$$ $<#$ F%. J $- <<"5. “7, — !%+ 5, —  R
&8   :<'* > $ * * $ !*  # <$+& +
 > $ * $$. J *% " *<!” O"$ < !E  $%$%+,
$$ + * *+ *, + &-$a$, $$  <&8  R +, 
 , >   F :<. F%#,  !'"  !+%, >  $%
 " $" —  ,   !-  + + <*  !-
!"#"! /  $<,  <'*- + + %$ >-  !5" —
E&, >" % % %  <'%,  %* !  !+%, > $ !5, !-
  !* E+ %  % +,  +% > $%$%+ ' <+>"&+
%#" >- $ 'I, $$ & !>$+ +,  
$%& !+,  !+#": 5. '8  8 '%  "5 '<
O$ , $ $ , !<- 5$ "$. : E&!5  + !
 $%>$+, +& +  " $!5- ' % "$ $%, > <$>#"5!
I    '%". 7  '% F'5 &  !: -
 # . D$ "$ &   #+5 ! $ E&-
!&%, <>  , +* - !5 '%" , <+>& $%,
+", $&"  %#. !!& >$+  "8,  E&-
A$E, &, !%& E&- !5  <&+ %$+  !&+
!5 < $8 !5+$+ !58- ++. / R %"!
4" +-# ' 
,     #     :
        
    #  #  & 
   $
  
. "   $  

"#$ %M ("/ 6-/

tƒm x\c`h f]Z Ša`y_j. • ow[w g_c wyZg_]ag_de o]_de ”dw \[w
†acd}za ]wv_za a \cde c Zdv]}dZl [w-
› v_cd]ˆja — _gdZ] |Zl, fad_h †acdZ\ c\][‚\ a acfZj`hhce
[Zo]}za `_z\]\`ahza.
‹`\ dZ^\ \cde †dZ cv_u_de cgZ\yZ cZo-
cdg\``ZyZ `_ d\zw Ša`y_j_ a o\|o_]-
z_v_. YZj\`_h ga|`h
– cg_]ˆ o_]_`al oZv ‚\javZz. …Zy[_
zhcZ Zcd}`\d, ]_u]wojˆ \yZ `_ vwcva. – fZ`az_ˆ, †dZ zZl ]_ccv_u ugw†ad `\-
Y[\j_ˆ ŠZ]Z|\\ d\cdZ au ad_jeh`- f]ag}†`Z. “…_v ”dZ — hyZ[} a ‘]wvd}
cvZl zwva “[w]wz” a f_]} ha‚. cZjade? …_v ”dZ — zhcZ c hyZ[_za fZ[_-
g_de?” €Z ”dZ v_v ]_u dZd cjw†_l, vZy[_
+8 %$  !+ +,   $E `\f]ag}†`Z\ `_ cjwŠ a dZ, †dZ `\gZu-
'8 $ +% !%8 " !<- zZ^`Z f]\[cd_gade, `_ gvwc Zv_u}g_\d-
 +$ <: #!, $<&, %$! ch f]ZcdZ u_z\†_d\je`}z!
 +, < >$. ‰Zd ga|`h, `\ †\]\|`h, _ az\`-
%  $ >& '& '  `Z jˆoaz_h `_|_ ga|`h — `\ f]ZcdZ
!*8 $#$  !+ +, >- cj_[v_h, _ c au]h[`Zl vacja`vZl. …_v
'&  <<", <!, <%. ŠZ]Z|_ Z`_ g g_]\`e\ — †w[Z, v_v ŠZ]Z-
P"# '*8 $%$  '- |_. €Z †dZ, \cja a \\ u_cZjade?
&, $$  *<,  !&!8  "8 
!E5+. 7 >" !. A  & 
A$E, 8   ! $- <5" !+ 3C ++ , $!5-
8, $%, !+#8  %$+  <- ", ", " &"  3C–6C °F
"8, !!8 %5+  !&+  <" #8.  &5 %>#
++. %'" '$%  #  "$, 

) # “”     ,   "   —  , .
6  "       ,  " , , -
  . 
              
  ! 8"   ,          ,      -
    ,   
    ,   “”     
  "  "!
tƒq
) ,   ( #  
?

%!'5" +* %* 5 >< ,  €w, gZd Z`_. Yv]Zz`_h, fZcjw|`_h, tƒp
 +"  %, >  ++ $% cv_u_ja \l [ˆ|o_]w c[\j_de, zZj†_
<$ '% +5"5 , <+*, gcd_j_, fZ|j_ d\cdZ u_z\|ag_de.
%>#   $% $*5 #5, $-
5 "  . 9*  '&" >- *   5
!"+? A, , $$ '&>.
YzZd]a, /&+#" < > I" '&$-
  " !5" ! +$,
v_v z} d\oh jˆoaz! " $&"  !5 >"
$.
— – [ˆ|o_]w yZdZgjˆ, w z\`h g Z[`w K$, <<  +"$
jZ^vw fhde |dwv fZz\_ˆdch! $$, <5 +& '&$&
— ’_, `_ `\\ czZd]a! €_|j_, †dZ cv_- @# < '&  %$, $>$+ %$-
u_de! › z\`h [ˆ|o_]w g Z[`w jZ^vw [\- <" !"E  @# — $"$ !-
chde |dwv fZz\_ˆdch! ! —   $$. J > 
— €\ ccZ]ed\ce, [\gZ†va! ‰_z gc\ ]_g- *"? A+ !"!
`Z [_j\vZ [Z €ay_]-Š_j_, w vZdZ]Zl [ˆ|- : +& >&, +& '-
o_]_ o}j_, v_v `ZyZdva `_ zaua`‚\ w fh-  '%" —  # <'-
daj\d`\l [\gZ†va, `avdZ `\ zZy [\j_de *$ $% — % N-Q% 
d_vwˆ [ˆ|o_]w, v_v [\j_j_ fZvZl`_h! . :+    $, >
{ˆ|-o_]_, [ˆ|-o_]_… $*5, +* <5"  !$ !-
iZgZ]hd, w _Š-iwc\l`-zw_jjaz_ g "  R + —  %!. N@-
]\cdZ]_`\ Z[`_ [\gw|v_ [\j_\d d_vwˆ  I!$%  %!$%,  $%!$ ,
^\ [ˆ|o_]w, v_v [\j_j_ j\y\`[_]`_h >'& '& ",   !$-
€ay_]-Š_j_. YŠZ[az, fZczZd]az, v_v ”dZ " '%" !!&+ E+  '-
w `\\ fZjw†_\dch. &+ ++ +   -
41 
  !:    :
,        
    & 
    $
   "    
. "  
"
 

"#$ %M ("/ 6-/

tƒs + !$  + !E,  > — YzZd]a, v_v z} d\oh jˆoaz! YzZ-
#  , > & I +*#" - d]a, v_va\ z_j\`eva\ f\jez\`a [jh
'"  $ '%"   !"  d\oh `_j\faja, czZd]a, v_v cd_]_jace!
! R+? Yv_^a ”dZ gvwc`Z\ cjZgZ “[ˆ|o_]_” a
/ 8#'%, !>+, +*#" - \|e, \|e `_ u[Z]Zge\, \|e, jˆoaz}l,
'", %  '5 $. 95& % \|e, [Z]ZyZl.
I!>$% * +*#",  R ! *- ˜`_\d\, [ˆ|o_]_ v_v ojˆ[Z `_cdZje-
8. M5 > +5&  + '- vZ cZg\]|\``Z, †dZ wjw†|_de \yZ —
" '%" >" %>, 5 + !% dZjevZ fZ]dade. xZ”dZzw g zZ\z [Zz\
$*%. J > !%#-<& [ˆ|o_]w ow[wd [\j_de dZ†`Z d_v ^\, v_v
$!$ +5&  @ !! \\ [\j_ˆd g ’_vw. €Z h `_cdZhd\je`Z ]\-
#@+ '%" % <. 7 $- vZz\`[wˆ g_z fZf]ZoZg_de [ˆ|o_]w,
, $ $, > > %  !'- fZ[_``wˆ `\ c o_]_`eaz, _ c vw]a`}z
"   %'". owjeZ`Zz. b\z Šw^\ owjeZ` au ŠZ]Z|\l
cwfZgZl vw]a‚} owjeZ`_ au o_]_`a`}?
‰c\! ’\]a jZ^vw [_ cZc†ad_l, \cja czZ- …jh`wce, `a†\z! ‡ gZd cZ†\d_`a\ [ˆ|-
^\|e, cvZjevZ |dwv v]Z|\†`}Š f\je- o_]} c o_]_`a`Zl a vw]a`ZyZ owjeZ-
z\`\l g `\\ fZz\cdajZce. ‡ jw†|\ `\ `_ — Zdz\``Z!
c†ad_l, jw†|\ fZ[wz_l, fZ†\zw g ‡u\]- ‡ †dZ, [ˆ|o_]_ — `\ zhc`Z\ ojˆ[Z?
o_l[^_`\ Zo}†`}\, g Zo\z-dZ f\je- xZf]Zowld\ \yZ c cZj\`Zl ga|`\l, yZ-
z\`a, [\j_ˆd d_vaza z_j\`evaza? dZgade vZdZ]wˆ `_c `_w†aja g i_o_j\,
`a †dZ, gvwc`\\ Zd ”dZyZ? •ja aŠ w[Zo- gf]avwcvw. •ja zZ^`Z [_^\ f\]\z\-
`\\ \cde, †\z d\, †dZ fZz\_ˆdch g jZ^- |_de Zdg_]\``wˆ [ˆ|o_]w c z_]a`_-
vw ]Zg`Z fZ Z[`Zl |dwv\? €\d, ”dZ gc\ [Zz au-fZ[ ga|`a — ”dZ u[Z]ZgZ, ”dZ
`\g\]`}\ Zdg\d}. Z†\`e gvwc`Z. “_v zZ^`Z c\cde \\
‰\]`}l Zdg\d ugw†ad d_v: oZje|\ [ˆ|o_]}. €Z ]_ug\ g vZja†\-

?

cdg\ c\[\``ZyZ [\jZ? ‰\[e [ˆ|o_]_ ‰Zd d_va\ g_]\`ava tƒ


v_v fZ‚\jwl. xZ\j a gcfZza`_l!
{ˆ|o_]_. …w[_ fZcd_gade w[_]\`a\?
YjZgZ-dZ cZcd_g`Z\: gZd “[ˆ|”, _ gZd /&+" # , " +% -
“o_]_”. [`Z w[_]\`a\ `_ f\]gwˆ †_cde %", >"…  " $@"&+
cjZg_ a gdZ]Z\ w[_]\`a\ `_ fZcj\[`al @#+,  !+  %$+, +-
cjZy gdZ]ZyZ. xZf]Zowld\ f]Zau`\cda, &+  !+ +,  $%$%+ , +*
w g_c fZjw†adch! ‡ †dZ ^\ Z`Z u`_†ad? '&", *  +$+ $%>$+ $%8$,
‰dZ]_h †_cde cjZg_, `\cZz`\``Z, ac- <I!" ! $8 … '*". A '!-
v_^\``Z\ Zd “g_]_v” — jacdav. YjZgZ $", R  '% ><+ *, !-
“g_]\`ava” — [wz_\d\, Zd cjZg_ “g_]ade” +% > $ !" *5 #
f]ZacŠZ[ad? {_ `\d, ”dZ v_v ]_u Zd cjZg_ ,   !& +, $$ %'$,
“g_]_v”, wg\]hˆ g_c a ]\|ad\je`Z Zdv_-   $"$- + !
^wce Zd o\ccz}cj\``ZyZ cfZ]_. +  5  + $-
œw†|\ fZczZd]ad\, v_vaza zZywd $, $ $$5 '? W#",  '5-
o}de g_]\`ava. !", R >" $%!
tƒƒ

‡ d\f\]e †w†g_]_! vg_[]_dav d\cd_, cjZ^\``}l vZc}`-


vZl fZ [a_yZ`_ja c `_†a`vZl g`wd]a a
nZ]Z|Z, †_cde cjZg_ “o_]_” — ”dZ Zd cjZ- Zo\]`wd}l gZv]wy zw^cvZyZ zaua`‚_.
g_ “g_]_v”. ‡ f\]g_h †_cde “[ˆ|” — ”dZ ‰Zd ]_uz\] †w†g_]}. Y v]wf`wˆ †\]\|-
†dZ Zu`_†_\d? {_ ”dZ ^\ “g_]ade”, ”dZ `ˆ, d_v f]az\]`Z, `\ oZje|\.
g_z jˆoZl f\]c cv_^\d! i[\-dZ yZgZ]hd ‰Z-gdZ]}Š, `\ o\j}l owjeZ`, _ ow-
“[ˆ|”, y[\-dZ “†w†”, a gZd g ›uo\vacd_`\ jeZ` `_ u_^_]v\ au zhc_ a ZgZ\l —
`\ [ˆ|o_]_, _ †w†g_]_. • †dZ? šcde ]_u- …ad_l ]h[Zz, cv_u}g_\dch gjah`a\!
`a‚_ z\^[w _u\]o_l[^_`cvZl [ˆ|o_-
]Zl a wuo\vcvZl †w†g_]Zl? P5 <*$  *5 $%'$+: -
šcde! €\oZje|_h, `\u`_†ad\je`_h, + +5, %$, +$", !+&.
`Z gc\ ^\ \cde. K<" + +, >" '&,
‰Z-f\]g}Š, c_za f\jez\`a `\cvZje- !5 !+#5, '*" +5,
vZ v]wf`\\ [ˆ|o_]}. x]\[cd_ged\ c\o\ '" %$  *"  !5 <-
tƒr

!, <+  +$"  $<, " ˜_f\†\``}\


+* %'"  +#" %* * ,
$  '% !$>$ , !- f\jez\`a g [Zgy\
*" !+&  +%8 !%,
!*" +, >'& 5" $- YzZd]ad\, h dZjevZ †dZ f]\[j_y_j ^_-
%, !!" $&+ +&+ !- ]ade, _ `\ g_]ade g_]\`ava. ‡ g\[e o}-
E+ — $+  *%>+, "8, <. g_ˆd a zhc`}\ f\jez\`\Zo]_u`}\ au-
4*$% '"  '%". A+ [\jah, vZdZ]}\ az\``Z ^_]hd, _ `\ g_-
!5, > %" —   ! ]hd. • \cde g\javal — `\ fZoZˆce ”dZyZ
!" R +   >%>- cjZg_ — cwf [Zgy_.
, ,   !5+  !%>- {Zgyw z`Zya\ u`_ˆd v_v ŠZjZ[-
#+5 '%"-%,  , $ - `}l, j\d`al cwf. €Z vZ\-vdZ `_g\]`h-
 "  '"  $% ! v_ cj}|_j, †dZ [Zgy_ o}g_\d a uaz-
!>. `\l: yZ]h†\l, c z_j\`evZl vˆ‘dZl-
"#$ %M ("/ 6-/

tr~ ‘]av_[\jev_za. bdZ, \cja Zo\[a`ade w g_c fZj`}l [Zcd_dZv, \cde zhcZ `_
”da [g\ u_z\†_d\je`}\ vwja`_]`}\ cdZj\, †\yZ d\o\ `\ w†adech v_v cj\[w\d?
a[\a? ‰Zf]Zc} w†\o}, vZ`\†`Z, Z†\`e g_^-
`}! €Z [_g_ld\ fZyZgZ]az Z dZz, fZ†\-
F+& '&>&, +"& <+ zw ojˆ[Z, g vZdZ]Zz zhcZ u_z\`\`Z `_
!"+  ' +* <!>"  vw]a‚w, _ vw]a‚_, cv_^\z, `_ hl‚_, c†a-
+<+ ++ !  %$. J d_\dch Šw^\? ‹`\ v_^\dch, †dZ ”dZ `\-
+, <% < %$, !$ !- cf]_g\[jagZ!
#  I  !&", !- • `\cf]_g\[jagZcde d_vZyZ `_]Z[`Z-
*"   5>%8 %. P +%& yZ z`\`ah `_aoZj\\ Zd†\djagZ ga[`_ `_
+ !$!,  <% !, !%" f]az\]\ Z[`ZyZ Z†\`e f]ZcdZyZ ojˆ[_,
   $   %! vZdZ]Z\ `_u}g_\dch dwŠwz-o_]_v. €}`\
<+$%" $>", !%" %* $ d_vwˆ \[w yZdZghd dZjevZ jˆ[a z_jZZ-
'%,   I !%& $-. o\cf\†\``}\, [_ a dZ `_cdZjevZ ]\[vZ,
†dZ Z`_ \[g_ `\ u_d\]hj_ce. ‡ z\^[w d\z
‰vwc`Z ja ”dZ? ‰} ^\ \ja f\jez\`a cZ jˆ[hz, vZdZ]}\ w^\ g[ZgZje `_\jace
cz\d_`Zl? ˜_f\†\``}\ f\jez\`a g [Z- |_|j}v_, fjZg_ a gchvaŠ-]_u`}Š ‘_]-
gy\, fZ z`\, gvwc`\\ z`ZyZv]_d`Z! |a]Zg_``}Š ywc\l, ojˆ[Z fZv_^\dch a
Z]aya`_je`}z, a Z†\`e gvwc`}z, wg\-
nZ]\uzcval ]hˆ g_c! “_vZgZ w^ cgZlcdgZ f]ZcdZl
v]\cdeh`cvZl \[}, †dZ fZcj\ gc\gZu-
”vcvjˆuag zZ^`}Š ]\cdZ]_``}Š aug]_\`al Z`_,
f]ayZdZgj\``_h au c_z}Š Zo}†`}Š, `Z
— • fjZg-dZ d} [Zz_ \|e c zhcZz, _ `\ c v_†\cdg\``}Š f]Z[wvdZg, g[]wy u_ay]_-
hl‚_za! — d_v fZ]Zˆ wvZ]hˆd `\]_[a- \d `Zg}za v]_cv_za, a [wz_\|e: _ g\[e
g}Š w†\`avZg g ›uo\vacd_`\. ‹Zj, [Zz_ gZd Z`Z, `_cdZh\\!
# -  
  !:    :

$   

. .    #  & 

. .    $
 , "  


0 ! @!

?

‰Zd czZd]ad\, v_v g}yjh[ad dwŠwz-   $$  <, +>- trk
o_]_v — jacdava c hl‚_za, \cja f\]\-   & !5+%"$ 
gZ[ade [ZcjZg`Z. €w g_]\`ava a \cde!  $ $$. G$ $-
œa|e [g_ Zdja†ah — ‘Z]z_ `\ fZjwz\- $ !'8  !$8 — "
ch‚\z, _ vg_[]_davZz, [_ `_†a`v_ — `\  *$ @# !>,  +&+ -
v_]dZ|v_ c jwvZz, `\ dgZ]Zy, `\ ga|`h, '&+ ++ # $ $*%5
_ Zo}†`}\ hl‚_. + %$!
Yv_^\d\ — †\yZ u[\ce cjZ^`ZyZ? d- : > * @#? P%+, R !
g_]a ha‚, `_v]Z|a aŠ, ]ac_ dw[_, jwv_, <'& 5E? A,  >%>$%
[_ a j\fa g_]\`ava — [\jZ-dZ aug\cd- *,  <  + $%! A
`Z\, vdZ ^ `\ \j d_vaŠ? €Z g dZz-dZ gc\ a $* 5E '55 ! 
[\jZ, †dZ dwŠwz-o_]_v u_fZj`hˆd `\ Zd- *$ # " +
g_]`}za hl‚_za, _ c}]}za!  !  *$ +$. K<%+-
5, +"  !"  !!>" !
F+, $$ R 8. D$ '&>, $%%.
 $$ $&8 $  : I  5E +* '" $$%8
. O +&8  $$%,  !- >#" <" —  #!  <
+ &$&8 $$ '& +#$, - %$. U, $>,  !+8 — *+
5+. +& !" #  !> $*&, -
: !+ <8  &, & - !& !"E&, $*: “A%  5- '8
$&8 ! %  <  <8  '& >,  '<$, #@  I <-
$& !5+%"$. W  R + $$   "!” J '%  !!
!$*5 + #+ *5+,  F+5 !5 <",  <
<"+,   !*"  $, $$ %$, '% <" %+  — "
+ !I. O"$ 5  %58: !%- '8- + < >" '&
+ +  " + !!  $%+ # +,   -
A :  4       
?

5  8 !&,   !&&! cd}Š a cZŠ]_`ag|aŠ ”dZd ]\‚\fd [jh trp
R+% 5 <5 ! <& %$  - `_c — v_v ]_u cg_]\`Z, v_v cj\[w\d!
' + $%$%+&.
O!" + +",   '& $  !" +*% -
+5 !5  <! '   I $%, !  
A <& $$ $ '8 !&+ ++  '*&+
!. A>$% — 8 *. %"  $-  < % '&+ $#$+
8 $! !5 .  ! +, $, !$ 
A  +"$ $$ - I 5>  ' $ $%'+ !
>$%, <!5 $$, +>   $%&+ <!+ !,  &!
$ 5> +"8  +  $!5-
$! J $  < +, '&-'&,
"$ %!! 4$"  < 
“]_`c‘Z]z_‚aa
"  + $  !- y_o_ja`cvZyZ c_j_d_
%>5 — >$ !>. :  $!5$ —
%, !%" !!'% !>",  $!5$ '- ›o\[ag|ace g `\auz\``Zz wcf\Š\ y_-
$ % *  <5  #& !%>5 o_ja`cvZyZ c_j_d_ [Zlz_†, h †_cdZ az-
$!>, >+ . f]Zgaua]wˆ fZ \yZ zZdag_z. YzZd]ad\
`_ v_]da`vw — g\[e w^\ gc\ hc`Z, _ †dZ
— ‡Š, _Š! — gZcvjav`wd jˆoad\ja ad_- `\hc`Z, d_v h c\l†_c Zohc`ˆ.
jeh`a`}. — [`a g_]\`ava f\]\g_- €\v]wf`_h vjwo`av_, cj_[val v]}z-
]hdch, []wya\ `\ [Zg_]hdch a `\ ow[\d cval jwv, ‘aZj\dZg}l o_uajav — ]_l-
`_z `av_vZyZ _je-[\`d\! ŠZ` fZ-`_|\zw. ‰c\ ”dZ u_jadZ u_f]_g-
€w a fwcde `\ _je-[\`d\, fwcde `_ vZl… `\d, `\ au z_lZ`\u_, `\ wy_[_ja!
†\l-dZ guyjh[ Z[a`-[]wyZl f\]\g_]\`, _ €_ajw†|\l u_f]_gvZl h c†ad_ˆ
\cja cw[ade c dZ†va u]\`ah jˆ[\l f]Z- cˆuezw. {\jZ g dZz, †dZ cˆuez_ cZ[\]-
"#$ %M

trs

^ad g c\o\ gc\, †dZ `\ZoŠZ[azZ [jh ŠZ- `}l f]Z[wvd, gc\ dZ, †dZ Zdja†`Z cfZ-
]Z|\l c_j_d`Zl u_f]_gva — Zdja†`}l cZocdgw\d ŠZ]Z|\zw fa\g_]\`aˆ.
vacjZ-cj_[val o_j_`c a `\z`ZyZ ^a]_. cd_jZce dZjevZ f]a[_de \l `\ZoŠZ[a-
‰cfZz`ad\ gc\ ”da zZ[`}\ ]\cdZ]_`- z}l gvwc.
`}\ u_f]_gva — g\u[\cwal a `_oag-
|al ZcvZza`w o_jeu_za†\cval wvcwc, " 8<"+ !$>$ 8' $%
wvcwc ga``}l, z_ja`Zg}l, †\z-dZ _]Z- > $! P5 R  5 '-
z_daua]Zg_``}l a `\f]\z\``Z Zjag- 58  8<"+% %$$%  "8   -
vZgZ\ z_cjZ. 8 !%*&+ '+.  R -
€Z cˆuez_, fZzazZ `\ZoŠZ[az}Š  !E%& 8<"+ " '
[jh c_j_d`Zl u_f]_gva gvwcZg}Š v_- $%>"  <+>" '$
†\cdg, `\c\d, v_v a jˆoZl vacjZzZjZ†- & & !

3,  *   
"  "         ,  
     ,      #   ,     ? 8  
    , ,   ,      ,      -
?    , ? (      , , 3?
3,   *       ? * ,    -
,    ,    "    ,    # 
              ? 6  ,   -
           "          -
       #  .  *-    ?
™™
—_u w^ z} u_`hjace ay]_za cZ cjZg_- tr
za, f]Z[Zj^az ”da w]Zva vwja`_]`ZyZ
hu}vZu`_`ah.
‰} g cjZg\ “z_`d}” vw[_ w[_]\`a\
cd_gad\? ‡ `\ fZj_y_\d\ ja g}, cjw†_l`Z,
†dZ “z_`d}” — ”dZ cjZgZ gZ z`Z^\cdg\`-
`Zz †acj\? • `\ c†ad_\d\ ja, †dZ “z_`d”
aja, dZyZ Šw^\, “z_`d_” \cde ‘Z]z_ ”dZyZ
cjZg_ g \[a`cdg\``Zz †acj\? šcja g_z
d_v fZv_u_jZce, dZ g} `\ f]_g}, †\cd-
‹_`d}: d\z_ `Z\ cjZgZ: `_ug_de Z[`w \[a`a‚w ojˆ[_
“z_`d}” `_ ]wccvZz aja jˆoZz []wyZz
a g_]a_‚aa hu}v\ [_^\ a f}d_dech `\ cdZad. ždZ cjZ-
gZ az\\d dZjevZ z`Z^\cdg\``Z\ †acjZ,
v_v `Z^`a‚}, aja, \\ jw†|\, cjagva.
{_ a c†ad_de z_`d} ca[h u_ cdZjZz —
fZcj\[`\\ [\jZ. š|ed\, `\ c†ad_ld\.
š|ed\ cdZjevZ, cvZjevZ gj\u\d — gZd a
gc\ f]_gaj_, vZdZ]}\ g_z `\ZoŠZ[azZ
g}w†ade, [jh dZyZ †dZo} `_cj_^[_dech
”daz ojˆ[Zz.
“ZfZ]av a f\`\v [jh ]wova zhc_,
cv_jv_ a [Zcv_ [jh ]_cv_dva d\cd_, hav
[jh ]wova jwv_ a []wyZl hav [jh u_-
z\|ag_`ah d\cd_, v_u_`, gzw]Zg_``}l
g u\zjh`Zl Z†_y, [_ `\cvZjevZ o_zow-
vZg}Š ]\|\dZv — gZd a g\ce `\Šad]}l
"#$ %% A-"6: "/  ;

trƒ a`g\`d_]e, vZdZ]}l o}j `\ZoŠZ[az, [jh ‡]Zz_d, vZdZ]}l au[_ˆd z_`d} `_
dZyZ †dZo} d]a †\jZg\v_ zZyja wcd]Zade o_u_]\, f]ZcdZ `\gZcf]ZaugZ[az [Zz_.
`_ jˆoZz c]\[`\_ua_dcvZz o_u_]\ “dZ†- ‰\[e o_zowv j\yvZ gfad}g_\d u_f_Ša,
vw Zo\fad_”, cfZcZo`wˆ o\cf\]\oZl`Z ]\|\dva acfZjeuwˆdch v_^[}l [\`e a
vZ]zade g\cez_ g`w|ad\je`}l fZdZv fZcd\f\``Z u_f_Š owvg_je`Z f]Zfad}-
fZc\dad\j\l. g_\d aŠ `_cvgZue. YdZad ja|e gZ[]wuade
iZdZg}\ z_`d} au c_zZl g\]Š`\l ”dw fa]_za[w `_[ f_]Zz, a fZ o_u_]w
o_zowvZgZl ]\|\dva g}vj_[}g_ˆdch `_ w^\ fZfj}ja dhyw†a\ cd]wa ZcZoZyZ
ojˆ[Z f\]\[ \[Zv_za, ZcgZoZ[ag|_hch _]Zz_d_, vZdZ]}l `a c †\z `\ f\]\fwd_-
]\|\dv_ dwd ^\ u_fZj`h\dch dZjevZ †dZ \|e — d_v f_Š`wd dZjevZ z_`d}.
cj\fj\``}za ”vu\zfjh]_za, d\ ]\|\d- ¤_`d_cdav_? ‰} o}g_ja g Y]\[`\l
va, †dZ w^\ cdZhd `_ f_]w, f]afZ[`az_- ‡uaa a `avZy[_ d_vZyZ `\ ga[\ja? ‡
ˆdch, ]\|\dv_ c c}]}za z_`d_za cd_- [\jZ g dZz, †dZ ”dZ h ]_ccv_u_j g_z, v_v
gadch g c_z}l `au. x]Zl[\d za`wd d]a[- yZdZgaja z_`d} gc\yZ ja|e cdZ j\d
‚_de, z_vcazwz cZ]Zv, a ”d_ ]\|\dv_ dZzw `_u_[, vZy[_ Z`a o}ja zZ[`}z
Zfhde Zv_^\dch `_ c_zZz g\]Šw, z_`d} v ojˆ[Zz, u_g\u\``}z au …ad_h [_ au
dZzw g]\z\`a v_v ]_u ow[wd yZdZg}. šcja …_|y_]_.
fZdZv fZc\dad\j\l oZje|Zl, dZ g ZoZ]Z- €Z gZd `\u_[_†_ — o_zowv g ›uo\va-
d\ `_ŠZ[hdch gc\ az\ˆa\ch ]\|\dva. ‡ cd_`\ `avZy[_ `\ ]Zc. • o_zowvZg}\ ]\-
vZy[_ fZdZv wz\`e|_\dch, dZ Šg_d_\d a |\dva f]agZuaja au …ad_h g …_|y_], _
d]\Š. “_vaz Zo]_uZz, z_`d} gc\y[_ yZdZ- au …_|y_]_ gz\cd\ c []wyaza dZg_]_za
g} dZ†`Z d_v, v_v d]\ow\dch: Z`a `\ f\]\- Z`a ]_cf]Zcd]_`hjace fZ gc\l Zcd_je-
g_]\`}, `Z a `\ c}]}\. `Zl Y]\[`\l ‡uaa. €Z y]_`a‚_ f\]gZyZ
…_†\cdgZ ojˆ[_ gc\y[_ a[\_je`Z — g za]\ yZcw[_]cdg_ ]_oZ†aŠ a v]\cdeh`
g\[e y[\ \\ guhde c_zZ\ cg\^\\ zhcZ a Z†\`e cvZ]Z Zv_u_j_ce `_ u_zv\, `\ cd_-
c_z}l cZ†`}l jwv, \cja `\ `_ o_u_]\? jZ `\ dZ †dZ v_]_g_`Zg c dZg_]_za au



…ad_h, `Z [_^\ a g\]ojˆ[} fZg}g\jace {\jZ g dZz, †dZ `_ acf_]\`a\ gZ[}, `_ q~k
u_ `\`_[Zo`Zcdeˆ. Zd]}g zZj\vwj, `_ f\]\ŠZ[ gZ[} au ^a[-
›uo\va fZdZcvZg_ja Z o_zowvZg}Š vZyZ _y]\y_d`ZyZ cZcdZh`ah g y_uZZo]_u-
]\|\dv_Š, fZf]ZoZg_ja [\j_de [\]\gh`- `Z\, ]_cŠZ[w\dch g\cez_ u`_†ad\je`_h
`}\, `Z w^\ Z†\`e cvZ]Z z\cd`}\ vwcd_- ”`\]yah. • ”d_ ”`\]yah `avw[_ `\ ac†\u_-
]a f]\[jZ^aja z\d_jja†\cva\ z_`d}- \d. x_] vZ`[\`ca]w\dch `_ fZg\]Š`Zcda
v_cv_`} — d_v `_ug_ja dZ, †dZ d\f\]e z_`d}|`a‚} a `_ c_zaŠ z_`d_Š. ‰ dZd
fZ-]wccva `_u}g_ˆd vdZ gZ †dZ yZ]_u[: zZz\`d, vZy[_ f_] (y_u) c`Zg_ f]\g]__-
“z_`d}|`a‚_”, “z_`d`a‚_” a [_^\ “z_`- \dch g ^a[vZcde, g}[\jh\dch d_ c_z_h
dZg`a‚_”. ˜`_\d\, h g_c fZf]Zcade ŠZ†w: ”`\]yah, †dZ o}j_ au]_cŠZ[Zg_`_ `_ f_-
fZvw[_ `_ug_`a\ ”dZyZ vwŠZ``ZyZ f]a- ]ZZo]_uZg_`a\. •z\``Z fZ”dZzw f_] Zo-
cfZcZoj\`ah \\ `\ f]Z`avjZ g Z‘a‚a- ^ay_\d [_^\ caje`\\, †\z vafhdZv.
_je`}\ cjZg_]a ]wccvZyZ hu}v_, [_g_ld\ •z\``Z fZ”dZzw ^\ gZ gj_^`Zl o_`\
ow[\z `_u}g_de \yZ \cja `\ f_]Zg_]- `_z ^_]†\, †\z g cwŠZl. • fZdZzw ^\
vZl, dZ az\``Z z_`d}-v_cv_`Zz. šcja dZ†`Z ]\[va\ [`a, vZy[_ g ‹Zcvg\ o}-
^\ g_z `\ Z†\`e ŠZ†\dch ggZ[ade g cgZl g_\d t~ °Y, f\]\`Zchdch dh^\j\\, †\z
ZoaŠZ[ `ZgZ\ y]ZzZu[vZ\ cjZgZ, dZ fwcde q~-y]_[wc`_h ^_]_ g ›uo\vacd_`\: f]ZcdZ
Zcd_`\dch ŠZdh o} z_`d}|`a‚_ — gc\- d_z gZu[wŠ cw|\.
d_va `\ d_v vZ]hgZ… €Z [_g_ld\ g\]`\zch v c_zZl vwŠZ`-
‡ gZd \cja vdZ-dZ f]ag}v a`d\]\cZ- `Zl f]a`_[j\^`Zcda. xwcde z\d_jja-
g_dech d\Z]a\l, u_[wz_\zch `_c†\d f_]_. †\cvwˆ ([_, o\uwcjZg`Z, Z`_ yZ]_u[Z ya-
{_, gZ[_ vafad f]a k~~ °Y. • f_], f]a ya\`a†`\\ a [ZjyZg\†`\\ o_zowvZgZl),
wcjZgaa `Z]z_je`ZyZ _dzZc‘\]`ZyZ fwcde o\u [w|a, g\]`\\, o\u u_f_Š_, — gc\
[_gj\`ah, `\ zZ^\d az\de d\zf\]_dw]w ]_g`Z v_v cd\vjh``_h vw]ad\je`_h d]wo-
g}|\ d\Š ^\ k~~ °Y. “_v v_v_h ]_u`a‚_ — v_, — `Z v_^[_h c\zeh, gZug]__hce au
g_]ade g gZ[\ aja yZdZgade `_ f_]w? Y]\[`\l ‡uaa g ]Z[`}\ v]_h, `\f]\z\`-
1 2
3




`Z g\uj_ c cZoZl ”dw |a]Zvwˆ v_cd]ˆjˆ q~t


cZ c\z`}z ‚aja`[]Zz, u_fZj`\``}z
z\d_jja†\cvaza ]\|\dv_za. ‰z\cd\ c
†wyw``}z v_u_`Zz, `\cvZjevaza fa_j_-
za [jh †_h Z`_ gŠZ[aj_ g `\f]\z\``}l
f\]\†\`e c]\[`\_ua_dcvaŠ f]aZo]\d\-
`al zajjaZ`Zg ]wccvaŠ a wv]_a`‚\g, d_-
d_] a vZ]\l‚\g, a o\u ”dZl wdg_]a c\zea
f\]\c\j\`‚\g au Y]\[`\l ‡uaa w^\ a `\
z}cjaja cgZ\l vwŠ`a.
‡ gZd cfZcZoZg, vZdZ]}za g ]_u`}Š
c\zehŠ f]ag}vja j\fade z_`d}, `_o\-
]\dch, `_g\]`Z\, `\ Z[a` [\chdZv.
{_g_ld\ h fZv_^w ŠZdh o} d]a au `aŠ.
x\]g}\ [g_ cfZcZo_ gfZj`\ d]_[a-
‚aZ``}: Z`a f]\[wcz_d]ag_ˆd Zd`Zca-
d\je`Z y\]z\da†`wˆ wf_vZgvw `_†a`va
g d\cdZ. €a†\yZ cjZ^`ZyZ u[\ce `\d —
f]ZcdZ czZd]ad\ `_ ‘ZdZy]_‘aa a fZgdZ-
]hld\ gc\ [\lcdgah, w g_c Zohu_d\je`Z
fZjw†adch!
“]\dal cfZcZo a`d\]\c\` d\z, †dZ `_-
†a`v_ Zcd_\dch Zdv]}dZl [jh f_]_, a ”dZ
`\ [\j_\d z_`d} Šw^\ aja jw†|\ — Z`a
f]ZcdZ cd_`Zghdch []wyaza. {_, w[aga-
d\je`Z, f]a d\Š ^\ c_z}Š cj_y_\z}Š
"#$ %%

q~q

gvwcZg_h cwzz_ fZjw†_\dch a`Zl. ždZd d}|vw (gc\ ^\ \cde \[a`cdg\``Z\ †acjZ,
cfZcZo ŠZ]Z|, vZy[_ g ‘_]| [Zo_gjhˆd `Z f]_g[_ u[Z]ZgZ, †dZ Z`_ ugw†ad d_v
v_]dZ|vw. j_cvZgZ?) — ow[\d gvwc`Z a _]Zz_d`Z!
€\ w[agjhld\ce ”dZl v_]dZ|v\ g ‘_]- xZhgaj_ce g\c\``hh fZj\g_h u\-
|\: v d]_[a‚aZ``Zzw `_oZ]w au z\jvZ j\`e — Z[wg_`†ava, f_cdw|eh cwzv_,
`_]\u_``ZyZ zhc_, jwv_ a vw][ˆ†`ZyZ |fa`_d? xZdw|ade jwv c ]_cdad\je`}z
c_j_ f]\v]_c`Z fZ[ŠZ[hd fZ†da jˆo}\ z_cjZz, f]af]_gade, fZcZjade, f\]\z\-
ZgZa. …_]dZ|v_, ]\f_, d}vg_, u\j\`e, |_de c u\j\`eˆ, wf_vZg_de ”dw cz\ce g
fZza[Z]} a oZjy_]cval f\]\‚ — gc\ dZ`vZ ]_cv_d_``Z\ d\cdZ, — a Zd d_vZyZ
”dZ zZ^\d fZcjw^ade v_v [Zo_gvZl v `_- ojˆ[_ fZdZz u_ w|a `\ ZdZ]g\|e!
†a`v\, d_v a Zc`Zg`}z \\ a`y]\[a\`dZz. €_cdwfaj_ Zc\`e a fZcf\j_ d}vg_?
x]_gaj `\d, g\]`\\, fZ†da `\d, azf]Zga- Yjw|_ld\, [_ ”dZ ^\ f]ZcdZ f]_u[`av!
u_‚ah a fZj\d ‘_`d_uaa g ]_‚aZ`_je`Zz xZ]\u_de d}vgw cZjZzvZl, fZdw|ade c
acfZjeuZg_`aa dZyZ, †dZ ’Zy fZcj_j, dwd jwvZz g ]_cdad\je`Zz z_cj\ — gZd u_-
gch†\cva f]ag\dcdgwˆdch. z\†_d\je`}l `Zg}l ‘_]| g z_`d}!
€\d zhc_, `Z \cde `\z`ZyZ cjagZ†- ‡ _lg_? {Zo_ged\ \\ g d]_[a‚aZ``}l
`ZyZ z_cj_? ˜_z\†_d\je`Z! —\^\z jwv, ‘_]| au jwv_ a zhc_, dZjevZ a vw][ˆ†-
]\^\z v_]dZ|vw vwoav_za, cz\|ag_\z, `ZyZ c_j_ `\ u_ow[ed\ fZjZ^ade au]h[-
cZjaz, f]af]_gjh\z a gvj_[}g_\z fZ `wˆ fZ]‚aˆ, †dZo} vZzf\`ca]Zg_de
vwoavw cjagZ†`ZyZ z_cj_ g v_^[wˆ z_`- vacja`vw _lg}, — fZjw†ad\ c`Zyc|ao_-
B !   


d\je`}l _]Zz_d a gvwc, vZdZ]}l dZjevZ cd\ c j_g_|_`Zl! ‰\[e gc\ ]_g`Z vj_c- q~p
fZ[cd\yag_\d _ff\dad. ca†\cva\ z_`d} c `_†a`vZl au zhc_ a
nZdad\ \\ Z[`w _g_`y_][`wˆ a[\ˆ? jwv_ f]a`hdZ \cde gz\cd\ c v_d}vZz aja
o^_]\``}l [Z uZjZdacdZyZ ‚g\d_ g dZ- cz\d_`Zl — dZ \cde vacjZ\ f]ZcdZ f]Z-
fj\`Zz cjagZ†`Zz z_cj\ jwv, auˆz, cadch v z_`d_z. ‡ g ”dZz cjw†_\ f]ahd-
Zcd]}l v]_c`}l f\]\‚ a _lg_. ˜a]_ Zoh- `_h vacja`v_ Zd ‘]wvdZg a hyZ[ ow[\d
u_d\je`_. ›[Zgj\dgZ]\`a\ c_zZyZ gu}- cZ[\]^_dech w^\ g d\cd\! …cd_da, u_Z[`Z
cv_d\je`ZyZ yw]z_`_ y_]_`da]Zg_`Z. a d\cdZ f]aZo]\d\d `\Zo}†`}l ‚g\d a
Z†\`e a`d\]\c`wˆ vZ`cacd\`‚aˆ — †wde
fjZd`\\ a yj_^\ Zo}†`ZyZ, zZ^\d o}de,
—_uwv]_caz d\cdZ \cja ‘]wvdZgZ\ fˆ]\ f]Zd\]\de †\]\u
z\jvZ\ cadZ, dZ v]wfa`va Zd vZcdZ†\v
{wz_\d\, g_]a_‚aa gZuzZ^`} dZjevZ g aja vZ^w]} fjZ[Zg `\ ow[wd z\|_de, a
`_†a`v\? ‡ †dZ, \cja a `_[ d\cdZz fZ- d\cdZ w[_cdch ]_cv_d_de Z†\`e dZ`vZ. [-
cd_gade f_]w ”vcf\]az\`dZg? `az cjZgZz, f]Zowld\, ’Zy g fZzZe!
šcde u_z\†_d\je`}l f]Z[wvd — j_g_- €Z gc\ g}|\cv_u_``Z\ `\ Zdz\`h\d
|_`_, Z vZdZ]Zz z} w^\ yZgZ]aja. x]\[- dZyZ, †dZ a c_z}\ Zo}†`}\, d]_[a‚aZ`-
cd_gjh\d Z` cZoZl jacd} g}cw|\``ZyZ `}\ z_`d} c o_]_`a`Zl a jwvZz Zo\_-
‘]wvdZgZyZ aja hyZ[`ZyZ fˆ]\. o}†`Z ˆd f]_u[`av `\ dZjevZ [jh ^agZd_, `Z
j_g_|_`w acfZjeuwˆd g v_†\cdg\ vacjZ- a [jh [w|a. ’Zje|Z\ ojˆ[Z fZc]\[a`\
yZ a`y]\[a\`d_ g cZwcZfZ[Zo`}Š ojˆ[_Š cdZj_, o]}uya cZv_, [ag`}l _]Zz_d, dZ`-
aja g `_†a`v_Š. †_l|\\ d\cdZ, cz\d_`_ aja cˆuez_ c †\c-
‡ †dZ, \cja acfZjeuZg_de ‘]wvdZgZ- `ZvZz g fa_j\ ]h[Zz, — a [ZjZl gajva,
hyZ[`Z\ fˆ]\, gZccd_`Zgj\``Z\ au j_- g\[e dZjevZ ]wv_za a [Z`\c\|e [Z ]d_
g_|_`} g v_†\cdg\… a`y]\[a\`d_ d\cd_? gc\ dZ jw†|\\, †dZ [_j_ f]a]Z[_ a †dZ
‰Zd f]ZcdZ guhde a u_z\cade d\cdZ gz\- gjZ^aja g z_`d} ]wva fZg_]_.
 
      ( "  ,   , +$)

  0 #  

 +    
  , "   
 
   :
   “ ”
 $
   
   

"#$ %% A-"6: "/  ;

q~ƒ …j_cca†\cva\ u_ dZ, †dZ Z`_ f]ZcdZ j\^ad `_ vZj\`hŠ.


‹} fZf]_gjh\zch Zd dZyZ, †dZ \[az
z_`d} oZje|\, †\z [gay_\zch, oZje|\, †\z
]_oZd_\z. ‰Zd ŠZ]Z|a\ fZg_]_, v f]az\-
…cd_da, _ †dZ az\``Z Z`a [Zj^`} ]w, †_\ gc\yZ Zcd_ˆdch g ‘Z]z\. nZdh
wz\de, ”da ]wva? o} fZdZzw, †dZ az f]aŠZ[adch v_^[}l
x]\^[\ gc\yZ — `_dZ†ade v_v cj\[w- [\`e f]\[f]a`az_de c\]e\u`}\ ‘aua-
\d `Z^. Yg\^\\, \\ []Z^_\\ zhcZ `\ †\cva\ wcajah.
d_v-dZ f]ZcdZ fZ]\u_de ]Zg`}za Z[a`_- ‹\cade d\cdZ. x]_gaje`Z\ d\cdZ `_
vZg}za vwoav_za. {jh ‘_]|_ fZ[Zl[\d z_`d} — Z†\`e dwyZ\, Zo}†`Z au zwva
fZ†da jˆoZ\ zhcZ — jZf_dv_ a u_[Zv, f\]gZyZ (`\ g}c|\yZ!) cZ]d_, dZ \cde
o]ˆ|a`_ a |\h — dZjevZ `\ j\`ace ]\- `\ c_zZyZ dZ`vZyZ fZzZj_. Y hl‚_za
u_de z\jvZ a woa]_de ^ajva a v]wf`}\ aja `_ Z[`Zl gZ[\ — u_gacad Zd g_|aŠ
fj\`va. f]acd]_cdal, `Z g}z\cade \yZ `_[Z
€\ ^_j\de jwv_. ‹_`d} o\u jwv_ `\ v_v cj\[w\d a Zohu_d\je`Z [_de g}-
o}g_ˆd. €\ jˆoa|e jwv? “Zy[_ ZdZl[a, j\^_dech.
`\ z\|_l `_z a `\ cz\l fZ[`ˆŠag_de! x]af]_gade ‘_]|. Y`_†_j_ fZcZjade
€\ ”vZ`Zzade `_ ^a]\. nZ]Z|a\ jwv, ]_uzhde \yZ, fwcde `_†`\d fwcv_de
z_`d} — c ^a]`}z, cZ†`}z ‘_]|\z. cZv. xZdZz f\]\z\|_de c zhcZz a c_-
“l, z`\ `\jeuh, h fZf]_gjˆce!” €w vdZ jZz, [Zo_gade †\]`}l f\]\‚ a ua]w —
cv_u_j, †dZ fZf]_gjhˆdch Zd ^a]`ZyZ? ]Zg`Z cdZjevZ, cvZjevZ fZd]\ow\dch,
‰Zd vZ]Zg_ a o_]_` — \ja Z[`w ja|e †dZo} ]_cv]}de gvwc zhc_. YZ cf\‚ahza
d]_gvw, _ czZd]a, v_vaza ^a]`}za cd_- gc\y[_ d_v: gc\ [\jZ g augj\†\`aa gvw-
ja, _ vZ]Zg_ \\ a `\fZgZ]ZdjagZl. ‡ c_ a u_f_Š_ au c_zaŠ f]Z[wvdZg, _ c_za
vZ|v_ \j_ zhcZ a cz\d_`w, _ Zcd_j_ce Z`a `\ u_oag_ˆd, _ dZjevZ fZ[†\]vag_-
y]_‚aZu`\\ j_`a, a gc\ \\ jˆohd w^\ ˆd aŠ gvwc. …dZ-dZ [Zo_gjh\d zZjZdwˆ
1 '   ( 


q~r

`\Zcd]wˆ f_f]avw [jh _]Zz_d_, vdZ-dZ |wˆ g\]\d\`ZZo]_u`wˆ cv_jvw a v_d_-


a\d []wya\ fwda — ”dZ gc\ [\jZ gvw- \d ga]dwZu`Z, “c fZ[gZ]ZdZz”: dZ \cde
c_, `Z yj_g`Z\ `\ u_oade, `\ u_[w|ade c v_^[}z [ga^\`a\z cv_jva v]w^Zv
u_f_Š c_zZyZ zhc_, Zo]_uwˆ\yZ u_- d\cd_ `\z`ZyZ fZgZ]_†ag_\dch a ]_c-
z\†_d\je`}l _vvZ][ c jwvZz a d\cdZz. v_d}g_\dch d_v, †dZ g ‚\`d]\ Zcd_\dch
xwcde f\]\z\|_``}l ‘_]| fZcdZad, †wde dZj\, _ v v]_hz dZ`e|\. {_je|\
fZ[z_]a`w\dch. xZczZd]ad\ fZdZz: d_v jacdZv d\cd_ wvj_[}g_\dch `_ vZj\†vZ,
ja `\ZoŠZ[az} d\ cf\‚aa, vZdZ]}\ g} Zo]_uZg_``Z\ oZje|az a wv_u_d\je-
ŠZd\ja [Zo_gade? ‡ zZ^\d, jw†|\ o\u `}z f_je‚\z. ¤_]| g[_gjag_\dch fZ-
`aŠ ZoZldace? c\]\[a`\, a jacdZv f]Zg_jag_\dch `_
—_cv_d_de d\cdZ. …Z\-vdZ au f]Z‘\c- j_[Z`e. “Z`\`eva\ v]_h cZoa]_ˆd g
caZ`_jZg v_d_\d u_yZdZgva `_ z_`d} “fjacc\”, Zcd_gjhh fZc\]\[a`\ Zdg\]-
au z_j\`evaŠ cZ†`\l ]_uz\]Zz c `\- cda\ [a_z\d]Zz c f_j\‚. Ywf\], u[Z]Z-
v]wf`}l Z]\Š. ’\]\d g ]wva `\oZje- gZ, z} gZcŠa\`}!
"#$ %% A-"6: "/  ;

qk~ ‡ vdZ-dZ o\]\d z\d]Zgwˆ dZ`vwˆ cv_j- …cd_da, g_]ade z_`d} cj\[w\d `_[
vw a ]_cv_d}g_\d oZje|Zl jacd d\cd_, ow]`Z vafh\l gZ[Zl. šcja fZ[ ]\|\d-
v_v `_ o\|o_]z_v. {_je|\ d\cdZ ]\^wd v_za vafad ghjZ, z_`d} `\ fZjw†_d-
`_ vg_[]_dava, a gc\ fZjw†_\dch Z†\`e ch — d\cdZ w^\ ]_cvac`\d, _ `_†a`v_ d_v
o}cd]Z. “Z^\ ŠZ]Z|Z! a Zcd_`\dch ^\cdvZl a cwŠZl. iZdZg`Zcde
YZojˆ[_de ]_uz\]} a f]ZfZ]‚aa. “Y cj\[w\d Zf]\[\jhde fZ u_f_Šw zhc_ a d\-
[\ga†al vwj_†Zv” — ŠZ]Z|al ]_uz\], cdw — \cja `\ jaf`\d, u`_†ad, d\cdZ yZ-
\cja ‘_]| f]ayZdZgj\` Z†\`e d_d\je- dZgZ, _ \cja f_Š`\d wzZfZz]_†ad\je`Z,
`Z, \cja zhcZ o}jZ fZj`Zcdeˆ Z†a\`Z dZ yZdZg} a jwv c zhcZz.
Zd fj\`Zv a ^ajZv a `_]woj\`Z [ZgZje- €w, a `_fZcj\[Zv — gZd g_z zZ\ cZo-
`Z z\jvZ. “_va\ z_`d} f]ayZdZghdch cdg\``Z\ cjZgZ g z_`dZg_]\`aa.
za`wd u_ mp, z_vcazwz t~. YZg\]|\`cdgZg_de cZg\]|\``Z\, wjw†-
Y zw^cvwˆ j_[Z`e — \cja d\cdZ |_de a[\_je`Z\ — u_`hda\, vZdZ]Z\ `_-
o}jZ `\ cja|vZz dwyaz a ]_cv_d_`Z g]h[ ja f]ag\[\d v c\]e\u`Zzw wcf\Šw
`\ d_v w^ dZ`vZ. œˆoZl ‘_]| g d_vaŠ vZyZ-jaoZ, g dZz †acj\ a z\`h. xZ”dZzw
z_`d_Š Zv_^\dch gfZj`\ yZdZg}z †\- h f]\[fZ†ad_ˆ cZojˆ[_de d]_[a‚aa. €Z
]\u qp za`wd. “ZjevZ `\ dZ]Zfad\ce [Z- vdZ cv_u_j, †dZ h [Zj^\` cZojˆ[_de d]_-
cd_g_de: Zdv]Zld\ z_`d}-v_cv_` a f]Z- [a‚aa dZjevZ wuo\vcva\? xZ†\zw h `\
g\d]ad\ \yZ, fZz_Šag_h cg\]Šw vwŠZ`- zZyw Zyjh`wdech a fZ[czZd]\de, †dZ ŠZ-
`}z fZjZd\`‚\z, †dZo} g}y`_de g\ce ]Z|\yZ f]a[wz_ja []wya\ `_]Z[}?
f_]. xwcde z_`d} †wde-†wde ZocZŠ`wd, ‰Zuez\z f]az\] c ad_jeh`‚\g c aŠ
dZy[_ aŠ ow[\d j\y†\ c`hde a `\ fZ- u_z\†_d\je`Zl f_cdZl. œw†|_h f_cd_
]g_de f]a ”dZz, [_ a cjagZ†`Z\ z_cjZ, yZdZgadch au zwva “[w]wz” a “y]_`[
vZdZ]}z aŠ cj\[w\d cz_u}g_de, gfad_- [w]wz”. žd_ zwv_ Z†\`e v]wf`ZyZ fZ-
\dch a `\ ow[\d fZ]dade `\]g} g\†`Z zZj_, fZ†da v_v z\jv_h ^\jd_h z_`-
Šw[\ˆaz… `_h v]wf_.

L       "? ,  " . (     "   "


"          .  "  #       
 (
      )    (   ,   ). F -
  ,  ,         #   . 8 -
, 
    ?  ! *, ,  ,    .
  ,     ,     ,         
      "  !
1 '   ( 


A $++ “[w]wz” +%$ <"++ $   !E! +* '% $ qkk
2C + &   $%& 5E, !& $". A <   !I%8
> *$  —  # !- !$%  "  >. /& '% !-
!E. A &+" $  '% *& !<##+ <+5+: 
!, !%!*8 . 7 '- " !-!*+% %+, * >"
8  *$ : '" <<- %+,   !>&+, &+,
& $#$  "  +, $%!$ +%$  I%!" %* #
+ + + "   $%$,  I%I85.
>'& <"   ', I8
 + , *"  !!+ €w †dZ cv_u_de? ‰ag_, •d_jah! x]ag\d-
  " $%$+ <",  <",  cdgwˆ d\oh zZaza wuo\vcvaza z_`d_za
<". >% *  5, > - au dgZ\l u_z\†_d\je`Zl zwva!
 +   '


   :   :
    " 
        "    0 #  
 "       $ "  
       
 . .       1 
 $  , "

"#$ %% A-"6: "/  ;

qkm x]ZcdZl fa]Zy  + !"  +%$.


+ +5? 7 * ! +%*$5
[jh gc\l c\zea <> — +    #"? O+ +-
g f]_u[`av + !%> #+ +>E+ "
# !%8 '%: !"
– u`_ˆ, †dZ z`Zya\ zw^†a`} — jˆoa- $ +$  +!%& 2)–2= °F,
d\ja vwja`_]aa g`wd]\``\ cZ[]Zy_ˆd- &!"   !$$ **, >-
ch, vZy[_ cj}|_d cjZg_ “fa]Zy”, “g}f\†- &  $++ +%$, %8 *-
v_”, “d\cdZ”. ›^ v_v-dZ fZg\jZce, †dZ gc\, $% , !% *$ +%$, <+#" 
cghu_``Z\ c d\cdZz a g}f\†vZl, [\jZ "  !+, %$++ +  
cwywoZ ^\`cvZ\, _ w zw^†a` Z`Z, v_v yZ- !, !$ !" +$  !$5
gZ]adch, “`\ a[\d”. !. 7 <>, > ** * 
€Z h u`_ˆ vZ\-†dZ \\! – u`_ˆ, v_v c[\- > 8 '%,  , > %  !%>-
j_de, †dZo} a w zw^†a` ]wva c_za fZ- ", +& !" '%+ <&" !.
f]Zcaja ”dw ]_oZdw, h u`_ˆ, v_v fZ[oade  !%  !%% 5 <+-
”dw ”`\]ya†`Z-j\`agwˆ fZjZga`w †\- #5 . /<' $  5E
jZg\†\cdg_ `_ fZvZ]\`a\ `Zg}Š ]wo\-  <+#   !. 
^\l vwja`_]aa! #5 !$++ +%$  % *
!%%  > <+#" .
/ ' !$++ +%$, !>>-  > *$ , '"
 , &&!   $%  %' +%$%  %'&+ *+  I $ 
*+ !5+ $<" +%$%. A +$ !- >%" '"# $$-'%" *$. 7
$< + > !E,  'I +* '&"  +$,  $&$,  &-
% '"5 , >'&  '& $, #55 ! <5 
<%'  $%>$ +">   >'&  8<"+&. U <5 !%  5 >"
$*& $%>$ '& !$& +%$,  >'& . A, > 5, +* '& '&

)      -    ,            "


? 5  -" , - , -  ,  , ,      #
          #      ! &  ,    ,
          . K
 ",
  " ,   ,    ,         
. &,       ,       "  -
" ",       M    . ' ,         -
? 4 :         ! &      ,    -
     ,      ,     .
qkt
     #
 +
 ! 


!" $ , '  !- qkp


 &.
&!" +%$    !*
 5 &+#5. W  !-
 !%" ("$   <%" %+-
 !&!5 +%$,   <%"
&+#5), !%     -
 . A  >  <>"!
/&   ! +. Q-
5, > +*, % <%   !-
I%8 !$%, !"   "-
$,   !& < 5 !#%  !%!"
$, $$ 5 %8 —     .
P  +, > >< $ +5
** &!5 8 '%: &5
 %$&+ <+, %>  'V-
+,   !&. $% !&+%
E" %> 'V+   <+-
  $E  < "
*. : +  + & '&-
 '<#'>!
++ '<5 % !%<&"$
%$ <,  + !<% 
% <+5, !+,  + <-
"5 $$. W '& +& <5 5
!5  $$- "-
"#$ %% A-"6: "/  ;

qks  +  !& *,  +-   " '& &* $%8>&+ -
 +# '& '<8 $$&  +.
 !%>" '& $"$ %+ — K5 I  $% , +-
!+8I+ !>. : > %  + '"# !*. /&*" < 
!%>" … !,  & >$% + %  #"5 (R '-
5 ! !? +, 5  >'&  %" 
A% > * & $? $    !+% '< , , '<%5 $%)
  "$ — + +5 <-  <I!&  &$  $5, 55
5"5 >$! /-!&, !<" -  % !+& '"# *, >-
$+ +$+ $%8> . P5 R- < $  +5 &!$5 '% &-
 > '  : "$  " # !.
"  * >". J< #5 +  &*"-
O$, > +? F, +5 !$+,  $"$ ! 5 %$#5. P5
%$, $@"   I  E&- +<$  <'  *$ 
!$ —  '% ! %+! #@&+ +. F+*"   '-
4  <!+: **  &!" ! $%*%+  .
 $8 $$! F+*"  <- F" &!$" ! +!% (6C °F,
&+ !&+ ++  5 !! *5   (2C °F. '&
, * '5  + "$ %$+.  "$  !!$",   >$
*    @+&  &$- !" $$ %, !'%5
& % >$% 5+, %*  + !% >. K>&
 %,  !*$% < $@5  +!%% $+ '<+, >'& 
 E&!$.   %># E $$ <
H'$& !E% 5+ , %$, $ +% +. W  ! $$ ,
$@5  +5,  <'& "  ! !%>5  + %5I
>$%  !>" >&+ !E+,  $>$,  +  '% !%$" -
!+% $+ '<+, >'&  $, >  %+  +*.

4              , 


   -
 ,        ,  ",   ,      -
,       "        . &   
        ,      ,       
          ,     .
     #
 +
 ! 


qk
qkƒ

…Z`\†`Z, gZf]Zc Z Š]_`\`aa `_cdZje- dZ^\ Z†\`e gvwc`Z, dZjevZ g}f\v_de d_-
vZ gvwc`ZyZ fa]Zy_ `\ cdZad. YvZ]\\ vZl fa]Zy zZ^`Z w^\ a `\cvZjevZ o}-
gc\yZ, w g_c gcd_`\d gZf]Zc, †dZ [\j_de cd]\\ — za`wd u_ cZ]Zv fhde, fhde[\chd.
c Zcd_g|azch d\cdZz. €w, f]ayZdZged\ €_†a`_ld\ c d\zf\]_dw]} k~ °Y, _ u_-
au `\yZ fa]Z^va aja Z[a` `\oZje|Zl v_`†ag_ld\ g}f\†vw f]a kp~ °Y — gc\
fa]Zy c u\j\`eˆ, hl‚Zz a [Zz_|`az ow[\d `Z]z_je`Z, wg\]hˆ g_c! ‰} dZje-
c}]Zz daf_ cwjwyw`a aja o]}`u}. ždZ vZ ]wv_g_-dZ u_cw†ad\.
™¥
˜`_\d\, o\u †\yZ g_c `\ Zdfwcdhd, g v_vZl qkr
o} yZ]Z[ ‡u\]o_l[^_`_ g} `a f]a\Š_-
ja? ‰} `\ wl[\d\, `\ fZ\g fjZg_. ‰ jˆ-
oZz ]\yaZ`\, g jˆoZz yZ]Z[\, v_va\ o}
gvwc`}\ ojˆ[_ d_z `a yZdZgaja, c_zZ\
yj_g`Z\ ojˆ[Z, vZdZ]Z\ Zohu_d\je`Z
[Zj^`Z o}de `_ cdZj\ [jh [Z]ZyaŠ yZ-
cd\l, — ”dZ fjZg. ‰Zd a au i_o_j} z\`h
`\ Zdfwcdaja o\u fjZg_, cv_u_ja: “` w
`_c ow[\d ZcZo\``}l”.
…_v ^\ [`_vZ `_ f\]g}l guyjh[ gc\ o}jZ
v_v Zo}†`Z. €w, ]ac, [ja``Zu\]`}l ]ac
o\u fjZg_? aja o_cz_da — u_zZ†\``}l a f]Zz}-
d}l. YjagZ†`Z\ z_cjZ — [_, h w[agj\`,
†dZ `\ dZfj\`Z\. …_d}v, hl‚_ a vw]vwz_,
fZ gc\l ga[azZcda, [jh v_uz_Š_. {w]|-
j_ya, zacva, d_uava — ”dZ gc\ fZ`hd-
`Z. €Z gZd dZ, †\yZ h `\ ga[\j g []wyaŠ
_u\]o_l[^_`cvaŠ fjZg_Š: fZ]\u_``}\
u\j\`e a jwv, f\]\z\|_``}\ c vauajZz,
[_ f_]_ Zdg_]\``}Š [Z fZjwyZdZg`Zcda
‚}fjhd.
‰ v_cd]ˆj\ `_ vZcd]\ ow]`Z vafad
fZ[cZj\``_h gZ[_. fwcdaja ]ac g v_-
cd]ˆjˆ — a Zohu_d\je`Z `w^`Z fZz\-
|ag_de, †dZo} Z` `\ Zfwcdajch `_ [`Z
a `\ f]ajaf. yZ`e jw†|\ c[\j_de fZ-
!  
  
    ! #       $#   ! 
 1 !    +    !  "
" $   *  ! "+  !
4    / "     " # 
$     :    ,  $
  , " #  + , # !        #
    , ", 

"#$ %> =' ?/ %/3 ?

qm~ caje`\\, fwcde gZ[_ vafad v_v zZ^`Z R '+ !+#", &*" 
oZj\\ ow]`Z. ˜_ fZjza`wd} [Z yZdZg- +< ++  $8  <-
`Zcda ]ac_ g gZ[w [Zo_gjh\dch z\jvZ 5": !%>5 <+>"5 %5I5
`_]\u_``}l wv]Zf, d_v Z` ]_g`Zz\]`Z $>$, '< $ <'*$
f\]\z\|_\dch c ]acZz a Zcd_`\dch h]vZ- !  !.
u\j\`}z, _ \yZ u_f_Š a gvwc wcf\ˆd f\]\- O!" <-! $8 ! &%" 
[_dech †\]\u gZ[w yZdZgZzw fjZgw. ‡ 5I , 85  %"$, !-
\cja \yZ [Zo_gade ]_`e|\, Z` f\]\g_]ad- +% > ! !" * "5 
ch a ]_cvac`\d. !#, !!. H*+ " I
$$%8- >"   !+#+  $%$%-
Y wv]ZfZz +. O % E&!5 !+? / !" 
 %$&8   $8. : < <-
a ‚}fjhd_za   $<  *" %$+ " $ —
#55  +  %*. A % -
Q"  !55 >" !- % $8 $$ < %+" E&!5, 
 —  I%!":  <&#$ $ <-  %%8 — <"  $<. /  -
+5 +*% !"E+, <>, %* " >" '&. K- %* 5, 
.  I 5>, * $  %# 
A > <"++ < $8 - !* + '5 “"”. O$ >
'"#%8 >" , I   $E !-  !!"5! H#+5 +
, 5  >'& !" %$& % E&!5  <"  $<+. D-
$<+ — !$% +*% + $8- 88 $&+ $&#$,  ! $&#$%
   + ,  $ 5 !$&+ >%8 @$%, >'& 
+ %*  < $<&. K<'  $" .
!% 5E, +#  +, ++  $- O!" 5 "$ !*" !-
&$ % *, >%8 *$% $%$%+&. / + ! >, >'&  55

2  ,                 , 


 -  !  ? ', "? +  ,     #   , -
    ",             . @   
   —   ,        !  ,    "
   .
(       …  . +       ".
("  ,    ! *     ,            .
2  ,           "  ,   -,
?
"#$ %> =' ?/ %/3 ?

qmm   5I+ !+.   - f\]\dZfade a gZd d\f\]e f]a`\cja g
5 '&, + <! cd_]\`evZz †_l`av\ a f]ZcdZ fZjaja
H$&+ $88. A5I+ <- v_uz_Š a fjZg. Y\l†_c z_cjZ gfad_\dch
'*$+ !+ !! F>  g v_uz_Š a ]ac, gc\ cd_`\d \\ gvwc`\\.
'8 &$&5 ! . 4+ ‰Zd dZjevZ c[_\dch z`\, †dZ \cja vdZ
%8I  — <"  $<. F% fZ\cd v_uz_Š_ au ”dZyZ fjZg_, dZ oZje|\
$% E&!5. ^&!5 $ !!$", w^ `a†\yZ \cde `\ u_ŠZ†\d! [`_vZ fjZg
> ! <85, !85 fZf]ZoZg_de `_[Z `\f]\z\``Z — ”dZ
 $%>$, $5 $$+ $+. K, [\lcdgad\je`Z Z†\`e `\Zo}†`}l fjZg!
$& '& !+#  $%$%+,  – c`Zg_ ŠjZf_j c\oh fZ vZj\`v_z, c`Zg_
 %$# !,  +& .  w[agjhjch:
!%>5  <& E: <% '- — €w v_v ”dZ z`\ c_zZzw `\ f]a|j_
&, %  $-<%8 $!- a[\h [Zo_gade g fjZg vauaj! {Z †\yZ ^\
$%, % *&. A %  I 5 \yZ vacja`v_ wv]_|_\d fjZg! • fZ†\zw
$<+ — +5 $%5 >"  !. owŠ_]cva\ \g]\a, cZd`a j\d yZdZgha\
 %", $<+  !  cgZl o_Š| — fjZg c u\j\`eˆ — `\ [Z-
 + +, !%>5 $ $- y_[_jace yZdZgade \yZ c vw]a‚\l, _ `\ c
 E. 9* <"  $$%- o_]_`e\l f\†\`eˆ [_ zhcZz? • ”dZ f]a
&+ +'$+  ++,  +*- aŠ-dZ jˆoga v ŠZ]Z|\l vw]hda`\!
  !-!+%: &*" ! !, ždZ gc\ fZdZzw, `_g\]`Z\, †dZ vdZ-dZ
  ,    <'% !&+, d_z, `_g\]Šw, ŠZ†\d, †dZo} h `\ f\]\cd_-
'* 8 $% #5 '8. g_j w[agjhdech. • g} cZ z`Zl.

‡ fZz`ad\ cjagZ†`Z\ z_cjZ, vZdZ]Z\


w[agajZ z\`h g c_zZz `_†_j\? ˜_ dZ
g]\zh, †dZ yZdZgajch fjZg, \yZ wcf\ja

6         ,       #  "   “2-
6  ” —         "         #
          ! .          ,   
         . 8          .
Петух и цесарка, qmt

они, если честно…

В
   ,  & 
,    *,      
 && :
. -  ,  8 7(),  ( 

(8 —   
,  - & 
  8&
/ (0-

…   & '


  /1

(8  1 / & /-
  
&/& & *
/-
2& / (.
& /2 7&   -
)
 2* 
&) 7/,
& 8&. +, /
& 

- ) &, 2& (/  
(8& —
1 / —  &2 (/, &
/1, (
& *1 /8
 
 0 ( /. =1 -  
8 ( &, 
  6 

-

   0

   /
 

&)/    )

&
, 
8 
(8, 0
 &  & - & 
&21  &&1.
  & & 
&  
&0  3( 
8, 
 2&
 (

-
    
(, (
( 
&)(,   6 (&
: *-
0
 
&
  &.

  
/ & & / -
;  ) ( 6( 
: (0- )
. +  *
&  /
2 & (  
&)(  : & 
. )
, * (&( *((  &-
 0
,  & * 

&
  6, 
&
  &(
,  “0”
(&
 &  (1
.  6&

)
, (02 &
&
 *
& )  
 
, 0
 
 (
8 — 
&  (&) (
 
*
&
 * 2 ,  & *0 (
.

3 + 
    ! #   % +  "  !
  +  1 !  "+ ,  !,  "
4       "  $    " # 
    $ 1 !  :  ",  $
  , " "  ,  , $
  
 . .    #  *, 
 "    
   –  
     $  ! 
   $#  0

"#$ %> =' ?/ %/3 ?

qmq ‡u\]o_l[^_`cval “_v \cja a Šj\o Zo}†`}l d_v g}a-


y]}g_\d Zd cgZ\l `\Z[`Z]Z[`Zcda, cdZ-
fjZg fZ-zZcvZgcva ad ja ‘_u_`_, oj_yZ]Z[`wˆ fda‚w, yZ-
dZgade w`}jZ a Z[`ZZo]_u`Z, v_v [jh
xZz`ad\ ja g}, []wueh zZa, cvZjevZ “[a\d} `Zz\] fhde”? “\z oZj\\ †dZ, wg},
g_^`}\ g}gZ[} z} c[\j_ja, ]_uyjh[}- gc\ ]_g`Z `\ [Zcda†e ”dZzw ‘_u_`w f]\-
g_h g v`ay\ “…_u_`-’_]_`” dZ, v_v ‹w- gZcŠZ[`ZyZ gvwc_ d\Š ‚}fjhd. •Š [Z-
Š_zz_[ yZdZgaj zhcZ `_ v_z`hŠ? cd_dZ†`Z o}jZ f]ZcdZ cj\yv_ Zdg_]ade,
‡ `\ fZ]_ ja `_z f]az\`ade ”da u`_- f\]\[ d\z v_v fZz\_de g fjZg. {_ a
`ah `_ f]_vdav\? Zdg_]ag_ja-dZ ja|e u_d\z, †dZo} `\ cZ-
{\jZ g dZz, †dZ, `\czZd]h `_ g\javZ- Zoade ]acw u_f_Š c}]Zl vw]hda`}.
j\f`}l fjZg, Zdg\[_``}l z`Zˆ g i_- ‰\[e ]ac d\z a ‚\`\`, †dZ j\yvZ a c
o_j\, h ŠZd\j o} f]\[jZ^ade g_z cgZl w[ZgZjecdga\z gfad}g_\d g c\oh d\ u_-
g_]a_`d ”dZyZ fjZg_. Y\l†_c fZhc`ˆ, g f_Ša a gvwc}, vZdZ]}\ \yZ Zv]w^_ˆd g
†\z [\jZ. v_u_`\.
– jˆojˆ, vZy[_ f]Z[wvd Zo]_oZd_` {_|e ]acw ŠZ]Z|\\ dZfj\`Z\ z_c-
d_v, †dZ az\\d `\ Z[`Z]Z[`wˆ, _ cjZ^- jZ — gZd Z`, g\javZj\f`}l Z]\ŠZg}l
`wˆ vZ`cacd\`‚aˆ. ‰Zuezad\ Šj\o! f]agvwc g ]ac\!
[a` zhva| — \cde zZ^`Z, [_. ‡ Šj\o ›cd]Zaj fZ[ ]acZz v_uz_Š ŠZ]Z-
c Š]wcdh\l vZ]Z†vZl? {_ vZy[_ `au w |al — ]ac fZjw†aj fZd]hc_ˆal, z_-
`\yZ Z[`Zl cd]wvdw]}, zhva| c_z cZ- `hal u_f_Š Šj\o_, Zo^_]\``ZyZ g dZ-
oZl, _ g\]Š`hh vZ]Z†v_ f\]\jag_\dch, fj\`Zz z_cj\.
v_v j_va]Zg_``_h, a v_^[}l vwcZv Šj\- xZjZ^a u\j\`e, hyZ[}, [_ †\yZ ŠZ-
o_ ugw†ad g [w|\ fZ `ZgZzw? ‰\[e `\ g †\|e ]h[Zz c ]acZz — gc\ Zdd\`va gvw-
Z[`Zz Š]wcd\ [\jZ, a gvwc ]_u`}l w ]_u- c_, gc\ _]Zz_d} Zo`_]w^a|e g f]ayZ-
`}Š †_cd\l ŠZ]Z|\yZ Šj\o_! dZgj\``Zz fjZg\.

%

qmp
[`az cjZgZz, cZoa]_hce yZdZgade H'+*+ @<$ !-++,
fjZg, gchval ]_u [wz_ld\ Z dZz, †dZ fZ- <+  !I%8 !$%   +
jZ^ade v ]acw. šcja v_vZl-dZ f]Z[wvd, !+"5 >  >&,    
v_va\-dZ a`y]\[a\`d} `\[Zcd_dZ†`Z #".
gvwc`}, zZ^\d, `w aŠ — g vZ`‚\ vZ`‚Zg, W" %  '"#5 >%%5 $-
\cja \cde ŠZ]Z|_h gZ[_, gvwc`Z\ a _]Z- ? D$ & '<  *   ! — 
z_d`Z\ z_cjZ, v_†\cdg\``}l ]ac, dZ ”dZ !+8!
w^\ fjZg! P &*+  $% +-
 ! +, !"+ !>#$
/+5 $ @<%. 4 >, - &  %*+ !E%. A  " -
  <+%+! P, % @< $$ < " $%! M# '&, >'& -
$ +5, >   <+". $,  %  <5 !, 5
F", !E, !!$, >$, %5 +5  < $"$ $E, >'& $
>'E —  # !+#+  - " +. O " 
'"#+ $>+ +, >'& !E- %"  +& ++%+,  @<>-
5+ <", "5,  $& >%- $ !*" $$ +* !.
$  !+#. 9* '" *$% U, !+, !* ! !E&
$&$,  +*   !+ !- !$%8 $%,   $% !
" $<" . !5%8 '%&"  . $
P <*+ @< ! %$, !!
  <+ , $$ E&!5-'$ 9% (3   &, !$  !-
<>8, !%>+ ! +%, !-  $%& <!  >. O"$
+ !$%8 @+% — <5 5 +, > ,  !%"   '  $% <! !E-
9%++, $& +5  $+5 - , $& !  + > -
, +$? $. A%  , >'& $> &
"#$ %>

qms
 %+"#" %I — $ . . S< %* " I. /+
W +"  !'5   +. O>, ! +, !+
'55,  %># !" — + +&?
%<,   !!+ !E%. W &- ˜[\ce h [Zj^\` c[\j_de Z[`Z Zdcdwfj\-
5 $$  @@,  !>- `a\, c`Zg_ fZza`_h `\c†_cd`}Š, f]Z-
. 9* '&", !'5 '" vja`_\z}Š fZg_]_za a`vwo_dZ]cvaŠ
&. ‚}fjhd c fda‚\‘\]z}.
D '% !>   5 - ‰Zd z} yZdZgaja ‘_u_`_ w^\ fZj`}Š
, !+ !E%  $$, q~ za`wd.  _]aja. “\f\]e, v_v g} fZ-
'" &, !%"  <$!,  - `az_\d\, h cZoa]_ˆce fZjZ^ade \yZ fZ[
$' !>$   $& ]ac a yZdZgade \\ †_c, v_v za`azwz.
!!$#5 $, !%"  55, — {_ gZ †dZ ^\ Z` f]\g]_dadch! —
>'& !%>" >  %. H!%- gZcvjav`wd Z[`a au g_c.
 !E% '  $%. WI ! — …w], ‚}fjhd `_[Z o}cd]Z ^_]ade,
3 +%  $* & —  & !%>- ZcZo\``Z y]w[vw! — u_jZzhd ]wva g
 <+>"%8, %5I%8  +- cd]_[_`aa []wya\.
%8 $>$%! ‡ h wd\|w g_c, wd]w g_|a cj\u} fZ
A !,  #" !E% !5+ o\uga``Z u_ywoj\``}z [Zz_|`az
$, $$ "! G R @<, $$ % 8' ‚}fjhd_z, o]\ccvaz vw]_z a ‘\]z\]-
!" &I !E&,  %#$ cvaz ‘_u_`_z. ‰c\ ow[\d ŠZ]Z|Z! ‰ g_c
+5 " + " yZgZ]ad Zf}d, vZdZ]}l g} f]aZo]\-
$. H I  !5 %!%,  ja, yZdZgh f_]w fZcj\[`aŠ [\chdaj\-
'%   & *. / $+ dal c`_†_j_ “`Z^va ’w|_” (cghd, cghd,
 !E !$*5 + %  *- cghd!), _ fZdZz `_|aŠ, Zd\†\cdg\``}Š
$,  '% %  !E +- ‚}fjhd, vZdZ]}Š v dZzw g]\z\`a cd_-

%

qm
ja g}]_ag_de fZ dZl ^\ d\Š`ZjZyaa, O$ , <  +5, > @< '% -
†dZ a _z\]av_`cvaŠ. •Š u_oag_ˆd gZ +"5 ! + ,  "-
zj_[\`†\cdg\, fZ”dZzw g ”daŠ ‚}fjh- & $ $$ < %!8 &" "
d_Š — c ga[w u[Z]Zg\``}Š a ZdvZ]z- *, +5  $ " 
j\``}Š vw]Zf\dwŠ_Š — cZ\[a`ad\je- $, !%>5 >&+, +&+, 
`_h dv_`e \\ dZjvZz `\ c‘Z]za]Z- $>$ $%  5 —  %!
g_j_ce, `\ fZhgaj_ce w `aŠ a ^a]Zg_h P, >  *&… O$, !, R 5
f]ZcjZlv_ fZ[ |vw]Zl, `\ yZgZ]h Z < ! <'8.
fZj`Z‚\``Zz gvwc\. xZ”dZzw, a f]_g- F + +& !%!+ > $, $$ !-
[_, \[a`cdg\``}l cfZcZo f]ayZdZ- %! !  Q'. O"$ %8
gade `Z]z_je`Z ”daŠ ca]Zd — dZjevZ >" <  $8$%, $ 5 #
Z†\`e o}cd]Z\ Zo^_]ag_`a\. ‰_]ade <+" %%8I !> $%&
aŠ fZ†da o\ccz}cj\``Z. €_g_]w v_v c  $<, '+ %*  & 
owjeZ``ZyZ vwoav_. '"#+ $> &, $%& 
€Z h-dZ wyZg_]ag_ˆ g_c yZdZgade %#  !!$& 5> 
`Z]z_je`wˆ fda‚w — [\]\g\`cvwˆ, .
aja, †\]d c `az, ‘_u_`_! – f]au}g_ˆ 1&, !!5 $ , $-
g_c c”vZ`Zzade: guhde [Z]Zya\, ŠZ]Z- & — $$ *  +  'I5 —
|a\ f]Z[wvd} a f]ayZdZgade [Zz_ dZ, $5 !!$  !E !-
†dZ g ]\cdZ]_`\ cdZajZ o} o_c`ZcjZg- >" !+&5. H$<&5,
`}Š [\`\y, ow[w†a f]ayZdZgj\``}z % +* <5 !+>" !"-
[_^\ _o} au †\yZ. • ]_oZd_ c ŠZ]Z|aza 5 ".  ! % 5 -
f]Z[wvd_za — ”dZ cZgc\z []wyZ\ [\jZ, $  $%>, >+ '&>,   5
u[\ce []wya\ f]_gaj_, u[\ce a`}\ cfZ-  '+ $E,  <-
cZo} a… `Z]z_je`}l gvwc! #". 5, >  R 5


.1
   
,  1  $ ,
 !  # "   

   #  
9   # " #  
  
   
   " # 
   "
6 1 ,   ,   , c 


%

"$ 5 $ !, 5 $ xjZg cv_uZ†`}l, qmr


 > 8,  !+ !+&-
8 ! %  &. d_vZyZ `\ o}g_\d
O$, !" <++ + ,
$$  !#% (5E, + + & “Z, †dZ g} f]Z†d\d\ [_je|\, — †acd_h
 +%$ '5", !$  !%>+ - vwja`_]`_h ‘_`d_uah. {\cv_de, _ gZd
+" ), $+  $ '. v_o} cd\]jh[e fj_g_j_ fZ Y}][_]e\, [_
/ $< ! +,  +  R wuo\va cfjZ|e a ]h[Zz yZdZgaja ]_u-
$ $ , !+ +- [\je`}\ fjZg}, dZ Z[a` au g_]a_`dZg
   $> !$ (!+% > fjZg_ zZy o} g}yjh[\de d_v…
  !! $ % $<+ — R ˜_[_†_ f\]g_h: ]ac a jazZ`. …_v cZ-
'% >,   !E —  R '% \[a`ade ”da [g_ f]Z[wvd_, †dZo} Z`a
!), !" + @<  %$&"  u_ugw†_ja y_]zZ`a†`Z? €w [_, zZ^`Z
+ "&+ +. wjZ^ade jazZ` g ]ac ‚\javZz f\]\[
/& $$ ,  5 !*% ! $&#$% d\z, v_v `_v]}g_de \yZ v]}|vZl — `\-
% @" !E, >'&  2C– vZdZ]}l u_f_Š ow[\d f\]\[_` ]acw, `Z
BC +% !& !58I%85 <  vacja`va g `\z `\ fZhgadch. ‹Z^`Z a
%. : !+ 5 !"8 # $+  `_ZoZ]Zd: f]ZcdZ fZjade jazZ``}z cZ-
<%#&+  !&+ ++,  !%" vZz w^\ yZdZg}l fjZg. €\vZdZ]}\ cd_-
 !& R +, !%" &I- ]ava jˆohd Zv]Zfade fjZg ŠZ]Z|az
5 ++ * @<  %+5 ga``}z wvcwcZz ]_[a wjw†|\`ah fa-
$>$, !%" !55 %58I+ \g_]\`ah. ‰Zd dZjevZ jazZ``}l cZv
'&+ <!+ <* $<+! f]a[_cd fjZgw ja|e vacja`vw a cj_-
o}l f]agvwc, f]_vda†\cva o\u `_z\v_
š|ed\ `_ u[Z]Zge\, dZjevZ ]wva Z cv_- `_ u_f_Š.
d\]de `\ g}da]_ld\! “_v g\]`}\ ja ”dZ ]\|\`ah?
"#$ %> =' ?/ %/3 ?

qt~ P !%!+  $: *+  +- +& $  $+, ' %$-
 E%, <+>+   $!5$, "+ !  <"+ #+ &'&+ '%"+,
&#%8 %, <+>+ I <  !- >'& "$ !$& +$"  <".
*+ E%  $#$%. J!"<%+ !%>-  !%>#5 !%#$ &*+
  $>  !E  %* 5"  '+ #5 '%" $,
<$++ E   !E5+ < >'& 5" $<" !%* 
$ “D<-9”.  !%. A$+  !+  %-
A+ ! +, '*+  $%, <%8  (=C °F !+ 
+ %$, !<& $%'$+,  '+ 0C–03 +%,   &'&.
E%. D$ !>%%+ +& +, A  ", $" " <
'+ # !+&&   '*+ $%  '8  !"<
  +, > !+#5. 4"+ $- &' '%"? P5  !5
!5I !   '+ - 5 ' !+ BCC  #$%&  5I -
 #@. D$ "$  &!5 &, % +$", %$E%, $%$ +-
   !> &+, %+"#+ - '5 !$+, < !! <
  ! <$+ !  2C +%.  5$ # !E  ! >%"
/ " >%% !% '*+ $%> '&>, !+% > 5" -
%$ $"E+  &*+   !&  "  '5  !E!.
@$%. / #+5 + !*+ + %8 &'%  !, $$  $-
+$", !<%8 +$, '+ $,  *+ + !5 !!.
)   +


 
 " $ 
  
       
 !   
  0!     

)  # $ 
%

Y_j_d [jh [w|a šcja v_vZl-dZ au a`y]\[a\`dZg a qtk


g}oag_\dch au ]h[_ g cajw cgZ\l f]a-
šcja yZgZ]ade f]_g[w, dZ h `\ cZgc\z ]Z[} ([_ guhde ŠZdh o} v\[]Zg}\ Z]\|-
fZ`az_ˆ, u_†\z jˆ[hz gZZo\ `w^`} va), dZ `_[Z acfZjeuZg_de ”dZ acvjˆ†\-
]\‚\fd} c_j_dZg. ‰\[e yZ]_u[Z g_^`\\ `a\ v_v _v‚\`d. {_-[_, fZdZzw †dZ \cja
]\‚\fd_ c_z_ a[\h — v_va\ a`y]\[a- g c_j_d\ `\d _v‚\`d_, dZ `\d a c_zZyZ
\`d}, v_v_h u_f]_gv_. • [jh fZ[oZ]_ c_j_d_!
a`y]\[a\`dZg a cZcd_gj\`ah c_j_d`}Š ‰Zd fwcde _v‚\`d a ow[\d d]\deaz
u_f]_gZv az\ˆdch Z†\`e f]Zcd}\ f]a`- f]a`‚afZz c_j_d_, a vjh`wce g_z, ”daŠ
‚af}. u`_`al [Zcd_dZ†`Z, †dZo} c_zZcdZh-
x\]g}l f]a`‚af: vZ`d]_cd}. ˜[\ce d\je`Z cvZ`cd]wa]Zg_de c_j_d au dZyZ,
gc\ Z†\`e f]ZcdZ! šcja g u_f]_gvw fZ- †dZ o}jZ.
|jZ †dZ-dZ vacjZ\, v_v, `_f]az\], ja-
zZ``}l cZv, dZ ]h[Zz [Zj^`Z o}de `\- D !+%, % +5 ! !5
†dZ cj_[vZ\ jaoZ ^a]`Z\, z_cjh`acdZ\, 'I " $. P  !
[jh dZyZ †dZo} vZzf\`ca]Zg_de vac- $,  <!>5  %$,  @"-
jZdw. šcja g a`y]\[a\`d_Š c_j_d_ \cde , !  >" &$ +!% 
†dZ-dZ zhyvZ\, dZ ]h[Zz [Zj^`Z o}de a (3C %. / <%" ! >$
`\†dZ Š]wcdh\\.  $*%& R <!>5 $ 5
‰dZ]Zl f]a`‚af: Z[`Z]Z[`Zcde Zd  %># $>:  ' -
`_]\uva a [Z gZu[\lcdgah `_ \[Zv_. ›^ &I&+ $%+,  %$%%,
vZja fZ|ja ]\u_de cZjZzvZl — d_v gc\   !%!<>  $!
cZjZzvZl a ]\^\z. šcja o\]\z `\†dZ, W !+", $$ ' $
`\|wdZ†`Z ]_u^ay_ˆ\\ _ff\dad, dZ %  !I,  <$-
fwcde a Zcd_je`}\ a`y]\[a\`d} ow[wd  + * !" 
fZ[Zo]_`} fZ ”dZzw ^\ f]a`‚afw. ! ,  -$, -
"#$ %> =' ?/ %/3 ?

qtm , $& '% >" # %&,  !+ !*" %"&+
$$  +5 !<$, $  + +$+.
! . /, !' ! $% $%
H" !'" !> $+!- 5 + !. : ! $E?
&. A R $! F$ +5$5, + * +5$. %"
K%*+ ! !E!% $. %$% %  <5,  >5 >-
F$ $5? T+ $&! F- %5I! :     +.
", %8I+ $+!+ !%" '%- /55  >" > ! 5
 +. , >'& &"  E&.
F'8 !E!  - : *55 >" ' !5, -
<$  R+ $+!+ >" !. "$ !5, > +%8 %, $
'& !" 5 !"<5  $<" '", %>#  &<".
 +, !%! %8I+ '- H#55 '5 >"  > !-
<+. H'*" $$% + $, >'&   $> " 
'*"  +5$". : !" <"+ 5 !
+  %$  &< <  "$ O!"  !%++  <!$.
$, >'& ! ++ '>$,  $- H$ +? : > <5" $ $-
%8 $*5 "$ %!$. HI%I- +% +%  $> $ -
5  $ + '%%  + < ,  %     $ %* "
 5>,  !5, *  +, !-  $,  $? P  ! +& !-
< $%$+,  '< %5 R &+ *$+,  !%>5  %
'>$ —  "$&,  $&.  >, !%"  $"$ -
:$$% !*" "$ +  & ?
%"$. A " $ !& *$,
F $  < !I. A*"- $&  !5 $ %!%. U +8
  "$+, +%8I+ "$ E-  % *$, !& 
)  # $ 
%

$%. F8<"+ — , > +* !- $5 +,  & !!'%  * qtp
%*" > <!$ 5 $ " < !" <!$% < 8<"+&,
! 5 '&  , >'& %'"5 — -
%"   +%I , >  - $5 >$  &$!  !5-
!+ $ *$  +5$ ,  +"   !%$+, $& $
> $E5 %   ! !5- ! $%& '$, 55  
I5 5 <!$. 1  %$ ' $%   $.
 !!'% <'" 8<"+%. J >< !- /  ! F' , %$&-
+%& %   %$ !%$  %5   5+, !+*  <!-
!+8I +%. F8<"+  + ! $  !  .
' ! ! '% $%: <"
"  ",  $5, !"5 $- YdZf-cdZf-cdZf! ‡ †dZ ^\ c _v‚\`dZz?
$,  * *    "$, {_, w `_c \cde vZ`d]_cd fZ gvwcw a fZ
$"$ ! <+. 9*  >- vZ`cacd\`‚aa, [_ w `_c cZojˆ[\`_ Z[-
'"  8<"+%, %  +#"- `Z]Z[`Zcde `_]\uva a Z[`Z]Z[`Zcde
5  #? U <5 + >- a`y]\[a\`dZg fZ gZu[\lcdgaˆ `_ Z]-
$  , >'& !'%" " $$- y_`auz. › `_c gc\ ŠZ]Z|Z, v]Zz\ _v-
 !! % $, ", !+% > + ‚\`d_!
 !5, $$ !% '5 $%!$ €w, [_g_ld\ ”dZ ow[\d g_|az [Zz_|-
  ! !'& - `az u_[_`a\z — f]a[wz_ld\, †dZ [Z-
, !!$% 5 !& $%  - o_gade v ”dZzw c_j_dw, _ z`\ [ZgZje`Z
+ $!"$% $$ !E, >'& a dZyZ, \cja g ]\uwjed_d\ f]Z†d\`ah
!*" !!,  I < '' zZaŠ ]_ccw^[\`al aja [_^\ o\yjZyZ
8<"+% '+. guyjh[_ `_ ‘ZdZy]_‘aa w g_c fZhgadch
A, $ R+% % ! !- _ff\dad aja ŠZdh o} ^_^[_ dgZ]†\-
# '&  <'& $,   #$+ cdg_!
!
-
    ! #     1   
 1 !    +         
  #"  "     :      +  !   $ 
   ,   , " #  + ,      
# !          #   
   9   #  
   
   + $  ! 
   " #  *,  , + 1 
   # !     . .   
   # !0  

"#$ %> =' ?/ %/3 ?

qts xjZg au}cv_``}l, +,  " — $ <&+&+ !"5+.


K<*" >I%8 %$E% !!+
c fda‚\l a `\Zo}†`Zl ",  !" > $ *, ",  $-
[ZjzZl #$ $ $% <  !$-
+. H %  !%5  !>$ —
“ZjevZ, †w], wcjZgazch, †dZ z_jZ z}  +  .
d_vZyZ fjZg_ yZdZgade `\ cd_`\z. ’w- / >+ ,  >+ $, > +&  $
[\z yZdZgade v_v za`azwz au [gwŠ va- !< %$,   !!$? : !+, 
jZy]_zzZg ]ac_, g m~-jad]ZgZz v_u_`\. #$  %$ '$ +
xZ`hd`Z\ [\jZ — ‡u\]o_l[^_`, Zdva[- %$ ! +$$!+: $$ @+& '&
`Zl fjZg, cj\[Zg_d\je`Z, `_[Z o]_de  $$, $$  '& !*&?
[ja`Zu\]`}l ]ac, _ jw†|\ w^ c]_uw &   !*& "
o_cz_da aja c\j_. %$E&. / !R+% %$, !<&
",   !!$, !5 +"# $
4+>  5> (6C °F) , !- ! $. W + %* %$& $,
. 9&" !$  ,  !". $$  %,  'I %># !<" $%-
D  &, !+   — '$+. :  + %* + %$,  I
$$  +? W '%,  "5 !  $+<&,  %># !<"
+,  +* %* !+&"  " ". :+".
,   ,   " &#%8 <& %$  <*"  !-
%  <+>" I < 5>. 9&" %8 $%  $<  *"
 '%+ ! + $,    !#. A>"    -
R ++, !$  <+>5, ,   !E *$  !+-
 '&  > ". % %'5", >'&   $+ %> 
<" (,3 $ %$ '&+ '<+: *" %$  >&,   
 !!$,  $"E+  !%$"E-  < E  !%>" %+!+-

!( (,   4   ('     
%

>" $%& <!. A , > “f]avZ]zade” v_vZyZ-`aow[e ]}`Z†`Z- qt


*& %$ +* !%" $%? - yZ f]Zg\]\``ZyZ dZ]yZg‚_, c[\j_g|ace
$I >  +#  $%8! fZcdZh``}z fZvwf_d\j\z Z[`ZyZ a
F<% !%!*%, >  !"%8 dZyZ ^\ dZg_]_, f]Zg\]\``ZyZ fZ f]Zac-
!*$% ( $ %$ %  % +% 2C. ŠZ^[\`aˆ a `_[\^`ZyZ fZ v_†\cdgw. €Z
J $"5 "<5,  > !+- ”dZ dZ^\ w[_\dch `\ g\u[\ a `\ gc\z. “Zy-
#". 1% !"5  '" ! [_ f]aŠZ[adch jaoZ a[da `_ c\]e\u`}\
@%, —  !. A " & ]_cŠZ[}, jaoZ Šad]ade. €Z vZy[_ z`\ `\
< !*5. $"$% %$, !*& ŠZ†\dch a[da `_ ]_cŠZ[}, h Zdf]_gjhˆce
$+ '<+, +* !"5  E+ v ŠZ]Z|Z u`_vZzZl z`\ f_j_dv\ `_ ]}`-
!$ <'*$ '8,  I  v\, y[\ gc\y[_ zZ^`Z vwfade ‘_u_`Zg.
 @E%<$+ %$+ %!, & +* xZ ŠZ[w f]ayZdZgj\`ah ‘_u_` `\
*"  <  "  +- d]\ow\d `av_vZyZ f]acd_je`ZyZ g`a-
  +> !%  "$. z_`ah. ‰c\yZ-dZ a [\j: fZ]woad\ f_]w
O!" + !'%85 '"# $%- ‘_u_`Zg `_ vwcva d]_[a‚aZ``}z Zo-
E& 5 $,  E&!5,  @<. ]_uZz, †dZo} ]_u[\jade v_^[wˆ fda-
/ R %* '&  “^&!5-5”. J ‚w `_ gZc\ze aja [g\`_[‚_de †_cd\l a
% !5 " %!. Zfwcdad\ aŠ g_]ade gz\cd\ c jwvZga‚\l,
g vZdZ]wˆ `\ u_ow[ed\ gZdv`wde [g_ ow-
€_c†\d ‚}fjhd g ´\`d]_je`Zl —Zccaa, a dZ`†av_ ygZu[ava, a c zZ]vZgeˆ, fZ]\-
ZcZo\``Z g cdZja‚_Š, gc\ Z†\`e a Z†\`e u_``Zl vwoav_za. “ZjevZ a `_[Z ow[\d,
`\f]ZcdZ. “Z \cde f]Z[_ˆdch ‚}fjhd_ †dZ c`hde f_]w ]_u f\`w. ¤_u_`_ `\ `_[Z
`_ v_^[Zz wyjw, `Z `_lda fZj`Z‚\``}l g_]ade [Zje|\ †\z q~ za`wd.
f]Z[wvd, Zoj_[_ˆal cvZjevZ-`aow[e
g}]_^\``}z gvwcZz — ”dZ `_[Z c\]e\u- D !E  ! , -
`Z fZd]w[adech. œw†|\ gc\yZ, vZ`\†`Z, "  < $8  !* $
"#$ %>

qq~

%$% — !%"  *85 +, P *+ !> %8 !E%  %$
> 5 + $*% $$.  +  <++5 %+ +.
A !$ +  5" $88  !- / %  %@%$&: @$, $%-
%>#+5 '%"+  !&  "  , <8+, ''. 1+ $%$ @",
+ &", ' <%. M- $&+  ,   $, 
#,  " #$, >'& !*" &$&+     %@%$-
 ! $88, >'& $ &. . $&+ $ + '%$ !
D &  !,  $$5 ", + (, < >"   '%$ —
5  ,  '%" $$% !- !5 )  <>+   R-
"  %%8 !%%, < !E*- $%8 $@$%, $%>+ $E&, >'&
5. 7 '%" + >" !5! >  &$, $ + .
P,  !E% !"  '*" : E%  !" $$ '&>: !-
+  %$+, !!55 "8, >&+ '#%+ !% <, + !5" 
!E+  $%$%+. D%$%+% %># '- $!5$, "+ %, !*+ $+
"  ++ $E, $ !E %* <%- !>$+  !+  $% 
+55, > '%, >'& $%$%+ !&+ ++, +5 *$+ & 
"$ <#" + ! +%. %+5 — , >'& $%>$ !$&"

!( (,   4   ('     
%

$+"8. 9* !&!" E% +- ! !+#5. O +# qqk
 <,  . %$  #%  '" $ R+% 
9$"  !<" $$  !,   <8+.
!"#  '*" $ *, $$ E%,  A $<", $$ !, #
+ * !E5+. " $5. R+% '% '-
WI… H, 5 !+8, R '% !- 5" $    <8+ !+%, !-
! A <5" & $ (< 5 !'%5  '5" #, '-
'$,   <)   ! '-  $-$ $% 
#" ,  '%$" !" @#'< $E. A% %
+% (C–(3, !$   % +5$+ + !%", $"$ $ $-
"$, >'& +* '& !*" *5 # #  $"$ -
'< %. J 5 @#$ R - $+ '% <8+… ", !!>" 
$  !" '& @#. - <'%", +* '" +& $-
$% >< +5%'$% $&  ,  *.
("$  <'%" !%#"   %- O!"  >" !: < R @-
$ ! (CC °F +% 0C,   %  #  & "  "
> %5I  +&)  +&. /& *  !5 ',
<8+. : I !$% %$, &*  $"$ R '% $%, !R+% !-
 > $% !E  *+- " ++ +: R !&
 <  $. F$ # '& " %!
5 +5 5&  $ $%. Q%8 +% <%", $$  "-
A > +   R, !+% > I & %@%$&  @"%, “$@$+”.
<5  '& !<" #% +- K  +  '%", -
$+ $$+  <+>"  5> #+5 ! $ !E&. O"$ ,
,   *"5, >'&  <+$- >'& '%" '% <$!,   <'%"
  !"  %8 +%  !" $!>, >+ 5 %!. H-

   ?    -


     ,  "   
 ,       !!
"#$ %> =' ?/ %/3 ?

qqm &  $+  %#  + !$  —  * '&" >$ 03,
>" #+% '%"%.  +"#, —  !85.
/ !" +* '" # ! D  <$8, $$% -
5 ! R! !5. + $&#$%,  5 $!#5 
/ $< ! # %*+ %$  !- >"   (  $&#$   $-
E. &!+ '"#+ $>+ %5, $"$ <  +5 !-
.   +$". 1  , !%" E  %).
 ++. 7    '% !$- O!" * "   -
"5  ++  + > — + " $%, '5"  “$@$”:   &%"
  %$   @< !%% +.  !" !+I$+, >'&   -
J…  !>+% '&  %*" +$" !5- * <>   +  +-
+  @<? A, -$ +  " $%. 7 + > !'5.
'&, >'& $%  +$  @<  %$+ A> !+#" , 5"
+# !*+!  <" *   !E. %"
O!" I >" ,  <*+  +$"  E !+#85 ! %
# “$@&” < @"  %@%$- +. : !$ !+#, !%"
+  +. P, !5+  @". S" !+I$ !8 ! ++ < “$-
%  !I5,  < @+? / @$”  %@%$+.
 %$&, >  '". G$+ D !+, > *+ $<
“$@&” +, !+ E% &*+ #  $%  !5  , &$&-
 I < %$+ +. /! H"    '"# '8  . -
"$ !" ! — ++ — - $>  +, <* $% $%>$
+ #@ ($"$ >$ <+  !E&  %$+,  +*% + +%. H"-
> $ $!5$). &+ %@%$+ !5" -
O!" —  @"& >& !-  #+ %*&+ $%+, %$"-
E ! $&#$%, $&+  *+,  + '8, $$ +*,   $ %.

3  "  ""  "    ", , , !-


 ,         " .           -
        ,  ,     -  # 

 ? '            " —      
   . (    "      :     "
,         ! …
'  —    ,       !

%

qqt

xjZg} YdZhde ]h[Zz c ”daz cdZjZz `\jeuh


o}jZ, Zd u_f_ŠZg v]w^aj_ce yZjZg_, ŠZ-
g yZ]|Z†v_Š, v_v a[\h d\jZce `\z\[j\``Z wvwcade gZ` dZyZ
‚}fj¼`v_ jhg_`ya, c\cde vwcZv vwdw-
Yv_^ad\ z`\, d_v zZ^`Z, _?! z_ a cf]Zcade: “bdZ ”dZ w d\oh, nwc`ah],
‹} \Š_ja v `\zw g œ\`vZ]_`e, z} gZ` g d\Š yZ]|Z†v_Š?”
ugZ`aja fZ d\j\‘Z`w, f]\[wf]\^[_ja, €\d, cjw|_ld\ z\`h, g} ga[\ja, †dZ-
zZj, f]a\[\z, ow[\z c`az_de, v_v d} o} †\jZg\v, `_v]}g|al cdZj, Zdg\†_j
yZdZga|e. `\ “xjZg!”, _ “xjZg}!”?
˜`_\d\, †dZ Z` c[\j_j? ` f]ayZdZgaj †\d}]\ ga[_ fjZg_
` gc¼ f]ayZdZgaj v `_|\zw f]a\u[w! c]_uw, g} f]\[cd_gjh\d\ c\o\?
‰Zd f]ZcdZ guhj a g}cd_gaj `_ cdZj ‰Zd ”dZ [_! ‰Zd ”dZ — ‹_cd\]!
|dwv [g_[‚_de ojˆ[ a v_^[Z\, owvg_je- ‰c\ fjZg} — g yZ]|Z†v_Š. €w †dZ,
`Z\ v_^[Z\ — Z[`Z jw†|\ []wyZyZ! u[\ce gc¼ Z†\`e f]ZcdZ. dva[`Zl _u\]-
"#$ %> =' ?/ %/3 ?

qqq o_l[^_`cval fjZg. “ZjevZ fZcj\ Zdg_- Zdg_]ade owjeZ` au o_]_`eaŠ yZjh|\v?
]ag_`ah ]ac_ a c‚\^ag_`ah c `\yZ gZ[} “_v, †dZo} yZjh|v_z \¼ o}jZ, †dZ cv_-
]ac f\]\vj_[}g_\dch `\ g v_u_`, [_ `_ u_de, _ aŠ w^\ au owjeZ`_ g}`az_ˆd?
ZyZ`e, _ g yZ]|Z†va, _ yZ]|Z†va — g ‰Zd d_v a cg_]ad\. ‡ g owjeZ`\ cg_]ad\
d_`[}]. ‰Zd d_va\ f]Zcd}\, `\Zojag`}\ ]ac, dZ†`Z d_v ^\ [Zo_ged\ wv]Zf, a Zd-
yZ]|Z†va, g vZdZ]}Š w^\ cZd`ˆ-[]wywˆ va`ed\ `_ [w]|j_y g fZjZ^\``Z\ g]\zh,
]_u yZdZgaja fjZg, Zd †\yZ Z`a f]Zfad_- _ [_je|\ gc¼ Zfhde f]Z\ f]ZcdZyZ — g
jace u_f_ŠZz fjZg_ a au[_ˆd \yZ f]ZcdZ yZ]|Zv, g d_`[}], fZ[j\ wyj\l, fwcde
d_v — dZjevZ gZueza aŠ g ]wva. xjZg}- cdZad, fwcde dZzadch, fwcde yZjh|va
dZ dZ^\ Z†\`e f]Zcd}\! [a` gZZo\ — f]af\v_ˆdch v [Z`}|vw yZ]|v_, fwcde
dZjevZ ]ac [_ dZfj\`Z\ z_cjZ. f]Zfad}g_ˆd ]ac oZ^\cdg\``}z cgZaz
{]wyZl — c wv]ZfZz. ˜`_\d\, v_v yZ- _]Zz_dZz. {ZjZl †_c}, [ZjZl g]\zh a
dZgade fjZg c wv]ZfZz? xZ†\zw `\ za`wd} — z} a o\u dZyZ c†_cdjag}!
u`_\d\? €_[Z wv]Zf fZ]\u_de, vZy[_ ]ac €Z fjZg c d}vgZl. ½, gZd ”dZ v_d_cd]Z-
cd_`\d\ g_]ade, u_ za`wdw [Z ZvZ`†_- ‘_! ždZ v_-d_-cd]Z-Z-Z-Z-‘_! – cdZjevZ
`ah g_]va ]ac_ [Zo_gade g gZ[w wv]Zf j\d fjZg yZdZgjˆ a `\ [Zy_[_jch, †dZ
a c]_uw Zdva[}g_de `_ [w]|j_y — ]ac `_[Z yZdZgade Zo}v`Zg\``}l Zdva[`Zl
a wv]Zf ]_g`Zz\]`Z f\]\z\|_ˆdch, fjZg c vwoav_za ŠZ]Z|\l d}vg}? ‡ g}
]ac gfad_\d _]Zz_d wv]Zf_, wv]Zf a f]\[cd_gjh\d\ c\o\, c d}vgZl, c _]Zz_d-
fZd\z`\de-dZ `\ wcf\\d! • gc¼, a g yZ]- `}z dZfj¼`}z z_cjZz, c |_‘]_`Zz, [_
|Z†\v, a jZ^vw-[]wywˆ dZfj¼`ZyZ z_c- g yZ]|v\? …_d_cd]Z‘a†\cva gvwc`Z, yZ-
j_, a g d_`[}], a fwcde cdZad, cvZjevZ gZ]ˆ ^\ g_z. …Zy[_ h wfZd]\ojhj cdZje
u_ŠZ†\|e — `\ Zcd}`\d a cd_`\d dZjevZ caje`}\ g}]_^\`ah o\u g\cZzZl v dZzw
jw†|\, dZjevZ _]Zz_d`\\! f]a†a`}?
‡ c wv]ZfZz a yZjh|v_za u`_\d\, v_v
yZdZgade? “Z^\ Z†\`e f]ZcdZ. ›z\\d\
)   (  
    +  " "   
   #  ,   # —
  1  ,   
–  ! #    #
# "   ,  !   
 !    

)  #
 
%

Yj_[v_h gZ[_ :   ' <$ I. qqp


P ! !5$%. / & %$ $$ >-
‰ ›uo\vacd_`\, vZy[_ ]\†e u_ŠZ[ad Z ? H'< $#$, < !
fZza[Z]_Š, f\]g}z [\jZz gcfZza- +%, 5 #%%,  $ *
`_ˆd `\ ZoZ gc\Š ”daŠ z_]a`Zg_``}Š '<? /  !",   
au}cv_Š, _ Z c_zZz f]ZcdZz, `Z `\g}- '<" — <  >" %' *"
]_uazZ f]\v]_c`Zz c_j_d\, o\u vZdZ]ZyZ %$E%  +5 <$.
`\ fZ[_\dch `a Z[a` fjZg. ‰ “_|v\`d\ : $$ &  <? A $? A%,
”dZd c_j_d `_u}g_ˆd “_†av-†w†wv” aja $>, +*  $,   5 -
v_v-dZ \\, _ gZd g ¤\]y_`cvZl [Zja`\ $*% +, $$ <8 %$  G<'$-
Z` `_u}g_\dch “|_v_]Zf”, d_v †dZ fZ- , $ 5 !"<"  5 !-
ugZjed\ a z`\ f]Z[Zj^_de \yZ `_u}g_de '& . W *%…  %. P-
d_v, v_v h f]ag}v c [\dcdg_. “\z oZj\\ * %$E% < $  %$, *
†dZ cjZgZ ”dZ cj_[vZ\ a †]\ug}†_l`Z '% % %$, 'I5 <+ $
fZ”da†`Z\. `Z cZcdZad au [gwŠ †_cd\l: ',  <8  %$ >" $%8, "-
“|_v_]” — “c_Š_]” a “Zo” — †dZ g f\]\gZ- # '%+, !>$%. H% %$E%
[\ c f\]ca[cvZyZ Zu`_†_\d “gZ[_”. !<" —   '"# *, 
'5, ! !5 ! %$% *+, *
A  ,   + 5 !- + * $$ . P? P. : $% -
5   !'55. /, > %* — !"5? F- $ !%, !$ ! -
R >" & *  !%,  +& !- 5,  * >+- <5"5. D +%
+#+ , %   & - * $5 <$  '% 
& — %$  !+&. H& * %*&  — %   %$E, % -
!>$ — <&  $&, +5 ! '$ %5, ++  %$, <-
<% — +* !%",    +,   # I <
'5<,   + . !+.
"#$ %> =' ?/ %/3 ?

qqƒ P, !+& > $ * — !+&, % !%%,  !", !+#-
$$ $*E&  ++, !+% > , .
R +& %>#, +& !&  +& M  !E+? P  ', " 
$$* !+&. $%!5 , $ <"8 — $ + <!I? A  *
 %+ ' R$+, !+% > ' $$ — R $ "$ %$  !+-
5 '5,      5 — $ !- &, !+% > R  $ !$,  -
%. P  > + -, %- !+- ' !$ $, $& '5 
& <++  +%*$ $%$    E& >< !>$:  R
"+ '"#%8 $+!8,  !<" $ &!" ! +5 !+ *-
> $ * $, $$ %$. / R — - $+ !! D$-$ +<+-@?
<&, R — “'&>" E”   R — N$! "? W#" #$!, ! #$!,
“5'>&”! /&', ', !>5, '%#" $$ < ! !'$ ! 
!# $ — ! *! +%*$%8 %  %" +E$%8!
A> <" !+   › z\`h gZf]Zc fZhgajch. –c`Z-fZ`hd`Z,
'$, !+ >%"->%" !%, !<- †dZ c_j_d []\g`al. €Z v_v \yZ [\j_ja,
, !5" !%  >" $  %$ vZy[_ `\ o}jZ g ›uo\vacd_`\ fZza[Z-
5 "$ !*$  + ]Zg? •u †\yZ? •u jwv_ a cd]w†vZgZyZ
!+ +5$ $%  — V#" f\]‚_? x\]\‚-dZ ]_`e|\ fZza[Z]Zg g
+,  , %*  — <$%, >+ Y]\[`ˆˆ ‡uaˆ fZf_j: \yZ fZ]dwy_je-
"! ‚} †\]\u vZjZ`aˆ `_ ‹_v_Z v vad_l‚_z
< — " !+&, - u_g\uja, [_ a g •`[aˆ Z` fZf_j Z[`az
" %$. O!" !$ +$%  %- au f\]g}Š fjZ[Zg €ZgZyZ Yg\d_. ddw[_
$+ $, %*  + %- d_v_h ŠZ]Z|_h g\e ]_cf]Zcd]_`aj_ce
+5 %$+  " !5 -<, [Z Y]\[`\l ‡uaa a …_gv_u_ zy`Zg\``Z,
$ ", >'& %$ '5  !%%. a f]ZauZ|jZ ”dZ d_v [_g`Z, †dZ cdaja-
/, !$& %$  !+&  uZg_``Z\ auZo]_^\`a\ f\]‚_ wcf\jZ
Виноградный уксус qqr

Н
/0  ( &1 & 
1 D    21  & 0
&
&
  &1  &0 &1 ( ( . @/0  && & (

(-

& *
 , (/ :  *& * & 86&, —
 &1. 9*,  & '

( ( &
 21  /6&, 
6

&
6, 0 82&1  . 3   
,  6&-

 1 1 ;&&, 


,    (  &*/1 ( ( & 
8 8!
3 8,
 6, * 
)&&, 6 (&

, 0
 /
 “ &-
” — '
   & 
/6/1 &*/1 (( .    

 /1 ( ( — *(, &  *  * &*, /6& (


/ &
( (   6&  ) 
0& 
.
D*&
&&  
1  2( (
/ 0( ( (  —   &, *
&*  
 .  ) 8 ( (02& &:& & &


6  
  &&  & ( ( . L  —  (0
 0 ( ,  ,
  :  , '
  &  0(.
"#$ %> =' ?/ %/3 ?

qp~ wvZ]\`adech `_ wuo\vcvZl dˆo\d\lv\, xjZg g ]\cdZ]_`\


`_ f\]ca[cvaŠ wuZ]_Š, `_ _u\]o_l[^_`-
cvaŠ d]_[a‚aZ``}Š dv_`hŠ a vZg]_Š ‹Z^`Z h f]_g[w cv_^w?
(ŠZdh `\vZdZ]}\ acdZ]ava c†ad_ˆd, †dZ YjZgZcZ†\d_`a\ “wuo\vcval ]\cdZ-
”dZ `\ f\]\‚, _ za`[_je). {_, f\]\‚ zZy ]_`” — †acdZl gZ[} ZvcˆzZ]Z`. ‰Zd fZ-
f]acwdcdgZg_de fZcj\[`a\ j\d †\d}]\- cjw|_ld\ z\`h. ›uo\vacd_` \cde, wuo\-
cd_, `Z fZza[Z]-dZ fZhgajch j\d kt~ `_- va — \cde, wuo\vcv_h vwjedw]_ — o}j_,
u_[ z_vcazwz. bdZ ^\ o}jZ ]_`e|\? \cde a ow[\d a, v_v cj\[cdga\, — \cde,
‡ ]_`e|\, g}ŠZ[ad, o}j f]ZcdZ dZ`- ^ag\d a ]_ugag_\dch wuo\vcv_h vwŠ`h.
vZ fZ]\u_``}l jwv? – zZyw [Zfwcdade, €Z [\jZ g dZz, †dZ vwŠ`h ”d_ fZ cgZ\l
†dZ \yZ f]af]_gjhja cwz_ŠZz aja o_]- f]a]Z[\… `\ ]\cdZ]_``_h.
o_]acZz, †dZ v `\zw [Zo_gjhja u\j\`e — …_v ^\ d_v, — cv_^wd z`\ ]Zccal-
(gZd Zdvw[_ ”dZd ZdyZjZcZv g cZg]\z\`- cva\ †ad_d\ja. — ‹} `_ f]Z|jZl `\-
`Zcda), _ dZ a c[_o]ag_ja ga`Zy]_[`}z [\j\ o}ja g wuo\vcvZz ]\cdZ]_`\ a `_z
wvcwcZz. {_, cvZ]\\, jwv a ga`Zy]_[`}l Z†\`e fZ`]_gaj_ce d_zZ|`hh \[_!
wvcwc, u_z\`\``}l d\f\]e fZ†da fZ- nZ]Z|Z, \cja fZ`]_gaj_ce. €Z [\jZ g
gc\z\cd`Z fZza[Z]Zz. œwv a ga`Zy]_[- dZz, †dZ g} fZ\ja dZ, †dZ Zo}†`Z yZdZ-
`}l wvcwc — a dZ a []wyZ\ u_z\†_d\je- ghd g jˆoZl wuo\vcvZl cdZjZgZl, dZ, †dZ
`Z cfZcZocdgw\d fa\g_]\`aˆ, [_ a `\ yZdZghd w o_u_]`}Š gZ]Zd [_ `_ _gdZowc-
cdZad wfwcv_de au ga[_ fZd]\o`Zcde g `}Š Zcd_`Zgv_Š. [a` g Z[a` — g\]ad\
gad_za`_Š! g} z`\ aja `\d? €w, zZ^\d, g dZ, †dZ \ja


   
%

g}, fZjZ^aja †wde oZje|\ zhc_, ŠZdh a [w_je`Z a a`[aga[w_je`}\ u_v_u} fZ- qpk
`\ ‘_vd. ‰ fZcj\[`\\ g]\zh a g ›uo\va- c\dad\j\l cvZ]\\ acvjˆ†\`a\, †\z f]_-
cd_`\ ”da c_z}\ cdZjZgcva\ ]_cvj_[} gajZ. YZyj_c`} cZ z`Zl?
f]Z[wvdZg g\cez_ \[]}\! —}`Zv a vZ`- €w fZ[wz_ld\, z}cjazZ ja [jh v_^-
vw]\`‚ah ]_oZd_ˆd a [\j_ˆd cgZ\ [\jZ. [ZyZ yZcdh yZdZgade Zd[\je`wˆ |w]fw,
€Z gc\ ”dZ c_z_h Zo}†`_h, c_z_h f]Z- `_ vZdZ]wˆ, \cja g_]ade fZ ŠZ]Z|\zw —
cd_h `_]Z[`_h vwŠ`h. x]\^[\ gc\yZ Z`_ wl[\d f_]_ †_cZg? ‡ []wya\ cwf}, d\,
cjw^ad u_[_†_z `_vZ]zade c\zeˆ, dZ †dZ c v]wf_za, c oZo_za? ‰c\ ”dZ yZdZ-
\cde hgjh\dch [Zz_|`\l fZ cgZ\l cwda. gadch Z†\`e [ZjyZ, gc\ ”da ojˆ[_ w[Zo-
žd_ vwŠ`h `\ d]\ow\d z`ZyZ wdg_]a, `Z yZdZgade az\``Z g u`_†ad\je`Zz
v_vZyZ-dZ cjZ^`ZyZ ZoZ]w[Zg_`ah aja vZja†\cdg\!
au}cv_``}Š d\Š`ZjZyal. ‰ch wuo\vcv_h ‰ f]a`‚af\, `_g\]`Z\, au `}`\|`\l
\[_ j\yvZ gZcf]ZaugZ[az_ g cd_`[_]d- wuo\vcvZl vwŠ`a fZjw†ajace o} `\fjZ-
`}Š o}dZg}Š wcjZgahŠ Y]\[`\l ‡uaa. Ša\ “]\cdZ]_`} Z[`ZyZ ojˆ[_”, ZcZo\`-
œa|e gZ gdZ]wˆ Z†\]\[e ”dw vwŠ`ˆ `Z \cja _[\vg_d`Z fZ[Zlda v ‚\`ZZo]_-
zZ^`Z f]au`_de fZ[ŠZ[h\l fZ[ u_[_- uZg_`aˆ g d_vaŠ ]\cdZ]_`_Š. – ŠZ]Z|Z
†a u_g\[\`al, vZdZ]}\ `_ ]wccvZz hu}- f]\[cd_gjhˆ c\o\ fjZg`wˆ, y[\ v_^[}\
v\ f]a`hdZ `_u}g_de Š_]†\g`hza. fZj†_c_ aja †_c yZdZgadch cg\^al fjZg.
bdZ d_vZ\ Š_]†\g`h? ‹\cdZ, y[\ zZ^- œ_yz_``_h — fZ†\zw o} a `\d? _|-
`Z `\[Z]ZyZ a gvwc`Z fZ\cde dZ, †dZ c\- j}†`_h, †\ow]\†`_h — ”dZ a gZgc\ vj_c-
yZ[`h f]ayZdZgaja. €_ f\]gZ\ — gZd cav_. €Z vdZ au `}`\|`aŠ a`g\cdZ]Zg
”dZ, `_ gdZ]Z\ — dZ, _ \cja ŠZ†\|e, dZ ]acv`\d fZlda `_ d_vZ\, v_u_jZce o},
\\ a †_l \cde. “Z \cde z\cdZ, ]_oZd_ˆ- jZya†`Z\ ]\|\`a\?
\\ ‘_vda†\cva o\u z\`ˆ, o\u ZcZoZyZ {_, zZ^`Z `_c†ad_de \\ `\cvZjevZ
g}oZ]_, y[\ `_ gc\Š fZc\dad\j\l yZdZ- ojˆ[, vZdZ]}\ fZ[ŠZ[hd fZ[ d\zf} a
ghd g Z[`Zz Zo\z vZdj\, _ `\ a`[aga- u_[_†a cZg]\z\``ZyZ ]\cdZ]_`_: z_`-
"#$ %> =' ?/ %/3 ?

qpm d}, c_zc_, w^\ wfZzh`wd}\ |_|j}v cdwf`}Š ‘]wvdZg a ZgZ\l — gc\ ”dZ
a †\ow]\va — gZd f\]gZ\, †dZ f]a|jZ f]agZ[ad `_|\ fad_`a\ v ]_uwz`Zzw
g yZjZgw. €Z cv_^ad\, fZjZ^_ ]wvw `_ o_j_`cw. ‡ \cja yZgZ]ade Zo ”daŠ ojˆ-
c\][‚\: ]_ug\ ”dZ ojˆ[_ [jh ]\cdZ]_`_? [_Š v_v \cde, o\u d]_[a‚aZ``ZyZ [jh
xZczZd]ad\, v_vaŠ g}cZd [ZcdayjZ fZ- `_|aŠ z\cd _vvZzf_`\z\`d_, dZ cj\[w-
g_]cvZ\ acvwccdgZ g aug\cd`}Š a f]\- \d f]au`_de — `_z `_[ `aza \\ `_[Z
cda^`}Š ]\cdZ]_`_Š za]_. “‹Z^\z ja fZ]_oZd_de, f]\^[\ †\z f}d_dech u_-
z} gcd_de g Z[a` ]h[ c `aza c d_ua- `az_de cgZˆ `a|w `_ ]}`v_Š u_ f]\[\-
vZz `_|\l c_zc}?” — ŠZ†w cf]Zcade j_za Y€i, y[\ wuo\vcvwˆ vwŠ`ˆ oZj\\-
h w zZaŠ u\zjhvZg a Zd†_cda vZjj\y — z\`\\ u`_ˆd a jˆohd.
wuo\vcvaŠ fZg_]Zg, ]_oZd_ˆaŠ g ]Zc- d`Zcad\je`Z `\[_g`hh acdZ]ah
calcvaŠ ]\cdZ]_`_Š. fZv_u}g_\d, †dZ ”dZ gZuzZ^`Z. ›cf\|-
‹Zl Zdg\d — `\d! žda ojˆ[_ — Zd- `Z _[_fda]Zg_`_ a u_gZ\g_j_ z\^[w-
ja†`_h _jed\]`_dag_ _z\]av_`cvZzw `_]Z[`Z\ f]au`_`a\ vad_lcv_h vwŠ`h.
‘_cd‘w[w, f]a†\z g cjw†_\ v_†\cdg\`- x]az\] hfZ`cvZl a ad_jeh`cvZl vwŠ`a
`ZyZ acfZj`\`ah ”da ojˆ[_ g}ay]}g_- [Zj^\` g[ZŠ`Zgade jˆoZyZ f_d]aZd_
ˆd fZ gvwcw a f]agj\v_d\je`Zcda, `Z a jˆoad\jh wuo\vcvZl vwja`_]aa. ‰Z
`\ oZj\\ dZyZ. ‹} `\ zZ^\z f]au`_de z`ZyaŠ cd]_`_Š wcf\|`Z ]_oZd_ˆd a`-
aŠ oZj\\ co_j_`ca]Zg_``}za, †\z dZd [alcva\, vZ]\lcva\ a []wya\ ”d`a†\-
^\ y_zow]y\] aja cw|a, aja [_^\ f]Z- cva\ ]\cdZ]_`}.
cdZ `_ug_de aŠ ŠZ]Z|Z fZ[ŠZ[haza ˜`_\d\, †\yZ `_z `\[Zcd_\d? €_z
[jh fad_`ah cZg]\z\``ZyZ yZ]Z^_`a`_. `w^`_ f]_gaje`_h, ŠZ]Z|Z g}g\]\``_h
{_^\ a w c\oh [Zz_ z} `\ \[az d_vwˆ a[\ZjZyah `ZgZl wuo\vcvZl ]\cdZ]_`-
\[w v_^[}l [\`e, a `\ `_[Z u_o}g_de, `Zl vwŠ`a.
†dZ `_| ]_‚aZ` g u`_†ad\je`Zl cd\f\- ‹Z^\d fZv_u_dech, †dZ g f\]gwˆ Z†\-
`a cZcdZad au zZjZ†`}Š f]Z[wvdZg, [Z- ]\[e `\ZoŠZ[azZ Z†\`e c\]e\u`Z fZ-


   
%

]_oZd_de `_[ o_j_`cZz `_|aŠ ojˆ[, fZ _ccZ]daz\`dw). Yj\[w\d acvjˆ†ade qpt


cz\\`a\z _v‚\`dZg c v_jZ]al`Zcda d\Š`ZjZyaa, vZdZ]}\ `_`Zchd Z†\ga[-
a c}d`Zcda `_ dZ, †dZ d\f\]e f]a`hdZ `}l g]\[ u[Z]Zgeˆ \[ZvZg.
`_u}g_de “u[Z]ZgZ\ fad_`a\”. ‰ Zo\z, €Z yZ]_u[Z g_^`\\ d\Š`ZjZya†\cv_h
u_[_†_ `_ c_zZz [\j\ _vdw_je`_h. _[_fd_‚ah dZyZ `_cj\[ah, †dZ z} fZjw-
Yw[ad\ c_za. ›uo\vacd_` — cd]_- †aja Zd f]\[vZg. bdZ h az\ˆ g ga[w fZ[
`_, y[\ ]_cdwd g\javZj\f`}\ ‘]wvd} a ”daza cjZg_za? xZ^_jwl, fZcj\ cdZje
ZgZa. (•z\ld\ g ga[w, wg_^_\z}\ ]Zc- [ZjyZyZ gcdwfj\`ah cdZad f]ag\cda
calcva\ †ad_d\ja, †dZ g r~¦ cjw†_\g dZ, ŠZdh o} Z[a` f]az\].
†dZ g_z f]Z[_ˆd fZ[ ga[Zz wuo\vcvZl
f]Z[wv‚aa zazZ ›uo\vacd_`_ [_^\ a €_|\ yj_g`Z\ ojˆ[Z, ojˆ[Z — cazgZj
`\ f]ZgZuaja.) €Z f\]gZ\, †dZ gcfZza- ›uo\vacd_`_, o\uwcjZg`Z, fjZg. • c_z_h
`_ˆd fZd]\oad\ja Zo wuo\vcvZl vwŠ- oZje|_h o\[_ g ]\cdZ]_`_Š f]ZacŠZ[ad
`\ — zhcZ, ^a], ]ac. › `_c []\g`\l|a\ v_v ]_u az\``Z c fjZgZz. iZdZgadch Z`
a g}g\]\``}\ g\v_za ]\‚\fd} vacjZ- g [ZgZje`Z oZje|aŠ v_u_`_Š a fZg\u\d
zZjZ†`}Š f]Z[wvdZg, _ fZd]\oad\ja d\z fZc\dad\jhz, vZdZ]}\ fZf_ja g ]\-
gcfZza`_ˆd d\cdZ a fZ[`az_ˆa\ch cdZ]_` g dZd zZz\`d, vZy[_ fjZg dZjevZ
`_[ v_u_`Zz c ŠjZfvZg}z z_cjZz vjw- f]ayZdZgajch. ‡ Zcd_je`}\? …ZdZ]}z
o} [}z_. ”dZd fjZg ow[wd fZ[_g_de f\]\cdZhg-
…Z`\†`Z, cj\[w\d cz\_de _v‚\`d} |az g v_u_`\, wcf\g|az Zcd}de? bdZ
a zZ^`Z `\ Zf_c_hce [\j_de ”dZ ]_[a- z} zZ^\z cv_u_de d\z jˆ[hz, vZdZ]}z
v_je`Z! ‰`wd]a Z[`ZyZ Zo\[_ aja w^a- [Zcd_`\dch u_g\d]\``}l, `Z ]_[a dZg_]-
`_, g ]_zv_Š [gwŠ-d]\Š ojˆ[ fZc\dad\je `ZyZ ga[_ Zojad}l z_cjZz ]ac? ‡ v_v
wuo\vcvZyZ ]\cdZ]_`_ [Zj^\` fZjw†ade Zd`Zcadch v fjZgw, vZdZ]}l ]_uZy]\ja g
d\ ^\ f]Z[wvd}, †dZ z} \[az g d\†\`a\ zav]ZgZj`ZgZl f\†a, [_ \\ a `\ fZ`a-
`\cvZjevaŠ [`\l (`\ vZja†\cdg\``Z, _ z_h f]a`‚af_ ]_oZd} Y‰b?
  ' #

 
    ! #  
  $
  
–   
 . . ! 
  
  !0
 . .    
 

"#$ %> =' ?/ %/3 ?

qpq ‹`\ v_^\dch, h `_wf}g_ˆ gZuzZ^- *5  >" # ! 
`}\ ]\|\`ah _[_fd_‚aa ”dZyZ ojˆ[_ + +%. P5 <& — + +5.
fZ[ ]\cdZ]_`. YzZd]ad\ a cjw|_ld\ 4 * * !"  $% 
g`az_d\je`Z. + +  +! L +$
(CC ++, <& — >5 *$.
1< +<E + %$+  '-
" — R '<5 58I5 $%- …]_c`_h zZjZ[_h zZ]vZge az\\d Z[`Z
 # !. A " +  `\ZcfZ]azZ\ f]\azw\cdgZ — Z`_
>$ &+5  !*" %$ $, cj_[v_h a f]ahd`_h `_ gvwc. ‰Zd a [_-
>'& <! !55  8 $%- g_ld\ fZ[†\]v`\z ”dZd gvwc auˆzZz a
%  $ >+%. o_]o_]acZz — Z[a` `_ dZ` cj_\, []w-
+: %$E% + )C +- yZl `_ [g_ dZ`_ vacj\\, — fZjw†_\dch u_-
+ 5 !< !%$"E+  '*  z\†_d\je`}l _vvZ][. €Z v]_c`wˆ zZ]-
3C + + < & $>$ - vZge z} ^_]ade `\ cd_`\z — fZ[Zje\z
>5  +!%& + (=C °F  ! fZ[ `\\ `\z`ZyZ gZ[}, wo_gaz `_y]\g a
!!+ !*  (3C °F. /- f]av]Z\z v_u_`. xwcde v]_c`_h zZ]vZge
, %$ <<5? 9$+%+  <!- ja|e `\z`ZyZ fZdw|adch, Zozhv`\d.
 5 <" —  +  ++ %$.
7 <!  , %58 , W '& % +5  '& * +$, 
 " $>$ $% %<'$$ !- '& "$ R $5,  5 '& %*
 '% .  !5+ ! %$,  ! , $$
O!" +$". W " *5 ! +!% +, ! '& &.
%<'$$5 — '*+ ,  !5"-$    $!5I & > !
<&#5 +!%% '*$ '< %*&. +$" —  '!$". : + !-
 +!% + % $<  +5  '  '5 <!  $% 
$$ (3C °F +$" * > +$. D +$ (3C ++.

) <   ,        ,    .  -
      ,              ",  
    . J   
    ,   .


   
%

T%$  +$" % 5"  $% O$ >  !%!+ >: - qp
 %#  " >" +% ' 5%  +%8 '% %*+ 
 $<. P  +, > R + !" $88 $%!&+ $%$+, <"+ -
' —  +< %$+, , +  $!5, !+ (3 +-
+$"8, <  <8++. /$% ! — %, $+ $&#$  + &"
 R+ +. : '*& %$  %#5  $+ +!%&. 95 &%",
+$" — <$, $5 '< %I' " >", %*"  #$%  "
5 $% '% "5  !8+ - '%". 4%"  @"%  %'" 
"$. "$  '+. 1%"
Q +5? :  . 5 , !E"  !"<" ! <>8.
+&  * +5  +$+" 95 — 2CC ++.
$+ +  R *-
 %+5 $>$  !! …Zy[_ gZu`av_\d fZd]\o`Zcde g fjZg\
$% * +5. M#  R? P zhcZ `_]\u_\dch vwcv_za a Zo^_]ag_\d-
$ ',  >. /" *  # ch g _]Zz_daua]Zg_``Zz z_cj\. Yj\[w-
%<'$$ $% " 5, !%- \d az\de g ga[w, †dZ g cjw†_\, \cja zhcZ
+8I5 < ' I5I%8 o}jZ fZcd`}z, dZ Z`Z gfad_\d g c\oh
+''$% +5 — 5 +8  % [ZgZje`Z z`ZyZ z_cj_. šcja fZg\]Š-
*<. 95 !!%$5,  !+ #" `Zcde zhc_ fZv]}d_ ^a]Zz, dZ †_cde
+ '*5. A <%"- ^a]_ zZ^\d g}dZfadch g z_cjZ, `Z ”dZ
!  *5! 95 !%>- `\ acfZ]dad \yZ gvwc.
5 *, >,  $ + 5
 + 'V+  ! R+ +  K 5     '-
% * +%8 $>$%, >  +5 < ! + !   $&-
( <  "$ $>$  - 5  %#.  '+ 
5I, $). !+&5 $!5> . /&
"#$ %> =' ?/ %/3 ?

qpƒ  +* "5  +  - $ I  +5, ',  R %>#
$  (= >,    R "? >5  $%+ , $$+- $-
A $%  % (C–(0 +% +$- >&+ ++. A!+, 5 !"-
+%+,    $% * $!" !- < 0 & *$ ! +,
5. R+%  %># " !- !$"$% <8, >  + '+ $%
 ! <$$. R + >5 + %>#. A
/ $+>$ #$ < !  !* " +" +, +
& <$&+ +5, %$-+$"- @#$,  $E $E — $.
<8+-'', ! %$&+ . >+% '&  5" # $
  $+ %>  +'%5. F+  +  !E+, >$+  !E5+  
%$% ' !$$+  (3C °F, !"<"  5 !? , < !
*"  '5+. + !5? A# $&  <%*
H  > &#  !- > %>#, >+ !$ !-
 $+$, 5 #55  <  > +  <*?
!55. A5"  #$,  5
 , 5 $+, <%#&+. A- b\]\u fhde–[\chde za`wd fZcj\ dZyZ,
5" +5  I >8 >" v_v ]ac c[Zo]aja z_cjZz, yZ]|Zv zZ^-
+&, $&   !&. `Z fZ[_g_de. x]ag\[\``_h ]_cvj_[v_
/ #$ ! +* !5"   c ]acZz o_cz_da [_j_ ZvZjZ k,tp vy yZ-
> ! %, > >< !> !- dZgZyZ fjZg_. ¤_vda†\cva †\d}]\-fhde
 <$$ +!%  %$ '% fZ]‚al, dZ \cde v_v ]_u `_ Z[a` cdZj.
*  (0C °F,    (CC °F. W +- …dZ z\|_\d f]ayZdZgade fZ d_vZl ^\
!% % #$ 5  - d\Š`ZjZyaa fjZg g a`[aga[w_je`}Š
 =3 °F,  R  %># <%". yZ]|v_Š? …dZ zZ^\d u_f]\dade acfZje-
A<  !>  % '- uZg_`a\ g ”dZz fjZg\ a []wyaŠ f]Z[wv-
" ' ++, #+5 ! *- dZg — gfjZde [Z _lg} a cw|\`Zl ga|-


   
%

`a, u\j\`a a vw]a‚}? {\chde ga[Zg `Z a `_|aŠ [\d\l, `_|aŠ fZdZzvZg, \cja qpr
fjZg_ g Z[`Zz ]\cdZ]_`\ — j\yvZ! • g} fZ`az_\d\, †dZ wuo\vcv_h vwŠ`h \\
v_^[_h fZ]‚ah ow[\d cg\^\l a a`[aga- Z†\`e [ZjyZ\ g]\zh zZ^\d Zv_u_dech
[w_je`Z f]ayZdZgj\``Zl. \[g_ ja `\ \[a`cdg\``}z acdZ†`avZz
š\ ]_u Zo]__ˆce v zZaz zZjZ[}z [ZŠZ[_ [jh g_|aŠ c\z\l, dZ `_[ `\l `_[Z
a `\ Z†\`e u\zjhv_z, Zd†_cda vZjj\y_z, fZcdZh``Z ]_oZd_de, fZcdZh``Z ]_uga-
vZ gc\z d\z, vdZ ]_oZd_\d g wuo\vcvaŠ g_de, [ZyZ`hde []wya\ vwŠ`a, f\]\`a-
]\cdZ]_`_Š. z_de `ZgZ\ a cgZ\g]\z\``Z w[_jhde cZ]-
šcja g} ^\j_\d\, †dZo} `_|_ ]_oZd_ `hva a wcd_]\g|\\. Y_[, au vZdZ]ZyZ dZje-
vZ]zaj_ `\ dZjevZ `_c, u[\ce a c\l†_c, vZ o\]wd, — ]_`Z aja fZu`Z g}cZŠ`\d…
‡j‘_gad`}l
wv_u_d\je ]\‚\fdZg

:@& %$<" * 5  E!


<  $ F$ M$#:
“D<, +  % +%*$ %"5” ('<>5 ),
“D<, '  ” ('<>5 ),
 $ * < R $ ('<>5 ).

; 1 +    $ " -   , <<


;  ' !
qsk
—   , =>< —  !-! , >=,
— "   , =>? —   , C<
—   -   , =>> —  !-! , <?,
— $     , =>@ ' # , ?=C
'   , ?>E
%    ' 
—    -$ # , ??A — “  $   ” , AEE