Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Proc Indian Natn Sci Acad 82 No. 2 June Spl Issue 2016 pp. 329-340
Printed in India. DOI: 10.16943/ptinsa/2016/48424
Research Article
Bending and Buckling Analyses of Composite Laminates with and without
Presence of Damage and its Passive Control with Optimized Piezoelectric
Patch Location
DIPAK KUMAR MAITI1* and V M SREEHARI2
1Professor,
Department of Aerospace Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur, WB 721302,
India
2Research student, Department of Aerospace Engineering, IIT, Kharagpur, WB 721302, India
This work presents an efficient technique to enhance the bending and buckling characteristics of a smart composite plate.
This paper discusses about the employment of piezoelectric fibre composite patches (PFCP) in their optimized location
using unified particle swarm optimization (UPSO) for enhancing the performance and thereby reducing the effects of
internal flaws. A finite element formulation based on Inverse Hyperbolic Shear Deformation Theory (IHSDT) for handling
bending and buckling analysis of a smart composite plate is used in the present work. In addition to the best performance,
reduction in weight of piezoelectric material is obtained as we employ a segmented piezo patch to overcome the degradation
in buckling strength due to damage in a composite plate, which indeed addresses the design issues.
Keywords: Composite Plate; Finite Element Method; Piezoelectric Fibre Composites; Optimization
mathematical model depends mainly upon above theory (ITSDT), and an inverse hyperbolic shear
transformation and solution techniques. For getting deformation theory (IHSDT) and concluded that it
the exact responses three-dimensional (3D) elasticity shows improved performance similar to all prevailing
methods can be employed. But 3D solutions can be higher order shear deformation theories involving
used only for specific boundary and geometry shear strain function. A brief classification of plate
conditions. Due to above reason, it is better to use theories based on choice of variable description is
two-dimensional (2D) models in the investigation of shown in Fig. 1.
composite structures. Because of the large ratio of
elastic modulus to shear modulus, effects of shear Damage can be said as a function of variations
deformation are noteworthy in composite structures in the material properties, geometrical properties,
and therefore it plays an important role in modelling boundary conditions, and structure connectivity, which
composite structures. Many plate theories are present harmfully affect the present or future performance
which combine the effects of shear deformation in of structure (Sohn et al., 2004). We have to consider
distinctive ways. These are categorized as classical existence, prediction of location, and prediction of the
laminated plate theory (CLPT), first order shear amount or extent for the effective damage evaluation
deformation theory (FSDT) and higher order shear of structures. Therefore, at foremost, the crucial
deformation theory (HSDT) where all these theories concern of structural damage assessment is to analyse
have polynomial nature. Over the past few years, the state of the structure by comparing the response
various shear deformation theories having non- measurements of damaged and undamaged
polynomial nature and expressed in terms of shear- structures. Researchers (Prabhakara and Datta, 1993;
strain function have been proposed. Some of the Rahul and Datta, 2013) have examined the vibration
nonpolynomial higher-order theories were proposed and parametric instability characteristics in damaged
by Mantari et al. (2012a, 2012b), Karama et al. plate in beam structures, where the formulation
(2009), Meiche et al. (2011), and Aydogdu (2009). considers the in-plane membrane effect of the plate
Recently, Grover et al. (2013) proposed new in the beam problem. They used a parametric model
nonpolynomial shear deformation theories and of damage which was proposed by Valliappan et al.
implemented for structural responses of laminated (1990). A continuous parameter that can be correlated
composite and sandwich plates. They explained shear- to the density of defects is presented in general
deformation theory based upon secant function continuum damage mechanics. This technique is
(SDTSF), an inverse-trigonometric shear-deformation useful in describing the weakening of the material
Bending and Buckling Analysis of Composite Laminates 331
before the initiation of micro-cracks. Studies by with intelligent systems. Many advantages compared
Pidaparti (1997), Zhang et al. (2001), etc. established to other algorithms make PSO a perfect method to
that the formulation by Valliappan et al. (1990) has be employed in optimization problems. PSO provides
more influence than some other and appreciated that faster results compared with many other optimization
a parametric model is convenient in framing problems methods like the genetic algorithm (Pratihar, 2008;
related to structural health monitoring. Rao, 2009; Mohan et al., 2014). Currently researchers
are using optimization methods for enhancing the
Regarding the thermal buckling, it is important performance of smart structures. Frecker (2003)
to explore few significant works done in this area. reviewed the works done related to optimization
Tauchert (1987), Tauchert and Huang (1987), analysis in smart structures design since 1999. Correia
Thangaratnam et al. (1989), Chang and Huang (1991), et al. (2003) obtained the optimal location of
Meyers and Hyer (1991), Noor et al. (1993), Singha piezoelectric actuators (PZT) and also the optimal
et al. (2001), etc. have conducted structural analysis fiber reinforcement angles using simulated annealing
under thermal environment using finite element optimization algorithm. Finite element models using
method. higher order shear deformation theories were used.
Many literatures are available describing various Yet an optimization analysis of smart structures
optimization methods. A few methods are listed in employing PSO has not got much attention in past.
Fig. 2 and the selection of an appropriate one depends Structures should be able to survive maximum
on the nature of problem considered. The particle probable forces acting on them and overcome the
swarm optimization (PSO) algorithm was first effects of minor damages arising in them. We can
proposed by Kennedy and Eberhart (1995). use smart materials along with structural components
Parsopoulos and Vrahatis (2002) presented a review to make them survive more forces than what they
of recent results concerning the Particle Swarm are expected to. In the present investigation we apply
Optimization (PSO) method. They concluded that piezoelectricity to strengthen structures, thereby
PSO seems to be a very beneficial method and a controlling the deformations and increasing the critical
worthy substitute in cases where other methods fail. buckling load. Also the optimal locations for PFCPs
Reviews on PSO were conducted by Banks et al. are found out for a composite plate with and without
(2007 and 2008). Background and progress of PSO damage.
were discussed and recommended the requirement
for hybridization to avoid some demerits such as Mathematical Formulation
swarm stagnation and dynamic environments.
Hybridization of PSO and a variety of application areas Introduction
are discussed in second article. It is concluded that
Consider a laminated composite plate having
PSO is greatly effective and flexible to different
dimensions and geometry as in Fig. 3, where (x, y, z)
domain problems and its potential for incorporation
332 Dipak Kumar Maiti and V M Sreehari
z hk
represents the rectangular Cartesian coordinate ( x, y , z , t ) 0 ( x, y , t ) (2)
system. The plane z = 0 coincides with the mid- hk 1 hk
surface of the plate. A finite element formulation is
developed for handling bending and buckling analysis The z co-ordinates of laminates corresponding
of laminated composite plates with damage. The to the top and bottom surface of layer k relative to
fundamental idea of finite elements is that the structure the midplane are denoted by hk and hk+1. In a kth
is considered as an assembly of elements connected layer, the coupling effect due to the attachment of
at nodes. An isoparametric element has an advantage piezoelectric patches results in both mechanical and
that element geometry and displacements are electrical excitation. This can be expressed in terms
represented by same set of shape functions. In the of stress and electrical displacement using the direct
present analysis 8-noded isoparametric plate element and converse piezoelectric effect as:
is employed for the analysis. The benefit of 8 noded
element is that all the nodes are located on element Dk [e]Tk { }k [ K ]k {E}k
sides and hence there are no internal nodes and shape __ (3)
functions have quadratic variation in x and y direction. { }k [Q ]k { }k [e]k {E}k
Displacement and Potential Fields
The subscript k denotes the layer number. Here
Authors had explained the buckling of composite __
structures earlier (Sreehari and Maiti, 2015a). The {D} is the electric displacement vector, [Q] is the
chosen displacement field for structural analysis of transformed reduced elastic stiffness matrix, [K] is
the piezo attached laminated composite plate is on permittivity coefficient matrix, {} is stress vector
the basis of IHSDT given by: and [e] is piezoelectric constant matrix.
w0
u ( x, y , z ) u0 ( x, y ) - z 0 0 0 0 e15
x
where [e] T
0 0 0 e24 0
PZT
2r
x e31 e32 0 0 0
sinh (rz / h) - z
-1
h r 4
2
e11 e12 0 0 0 (4)
and [e]TPFC 0 0 0 e24 0
v( x, y, z ) v0 ( x, y ) - z
w0 0 0 0 0 e35
y
Governing Equation
sinh (rz / h) - z
-1 2r
y
h r 4
2 The global governing dynamic equation of the
piezoelectric attached laminated composite plate as
for bending control analysis can be modified and can
w( x, y, z ) w0 ( x, y ) (1) be represented globally as:
Bending and Buckling Analysis of Composite Laminates 333
Validation Studies
Few validation studies are presented in this section to
convey the efficiency of present model. As shown in
Fig. 5, analysis is conducted with side to thickness
ratio varying from 10 to 100 using FSDT and IHSDT Fig. 5: Buckling load using FSDT and IHSDT (for uniaxial
for validation of results. For this study, we have taken loading)
a (0/90)s laminated composite plate with simply
supported at all ends subjected to uniaxial inplane bottom of the composite plate with a net a/h ratio 10.
loads. Similar comparison analysis with biaxial inplane The detailed validation studies are presented in
loads is done and results are shown in Fig. 6. It is Sreehari et al. (2016). Table 2 presents a comparison
noticed that nondimensional critical loads are larger study after including the effects of damage for a simple
for uniaxial loading. And as thickness decreases, the plate. The present results are compared with the
nondimensional buckling load increases. Numerical results obtained by Prabhakara and Datta (1993). The
results for a smart plate are validated and shown in buckling coefficients for a plate with 3 different aspect
Table 1. The non-dimensionalised critical buckling load ratios are calculated and matched with those of
is presented when piezolayers are attached to top and reference as shown in Table 2, and validates the finite
Bending and Buckling Analysis of Composite Laminates 335
Fig. 8: Deflection control under voltages of a cantilever plate Fig. 10: Deflection control under voltages of a cantilever
(PFCP/0/90/0/90/90/0/90/0) with PFCP plate (PFCP/45/45/-45/-45/-45/-45/45/45) with PFCP
Fig. 12: Optimal positioning of 4 piezo patches in a simply Fig. 15: Optimal positioning of 8 piezopatches in a cantilever
supported plate plate
reduction in weight of smart material happened due It is also noticed that by applying voltage on PFC
to the placement of segmented PFCPs (instead of patches, deformations of the plate with damage
piezo layer) to overcome the effects of damage and got counteracted to large extent and failure due
hygrothermal environment in the bending and buckling to hygrothermal environment is prevented.
analysis for a composite plate. It seems to have major
practical significance and these applications prove the For optimum designs, the structures should be
contribution of present investigation to be of realistic capable of withstanding maximum possible
nature. forces acting on them. Also the structures should
be able to overcome the effects of small
Conclusion damages occurring in them. To enhance this
capability we can use smart materials along with
This work has been done for bending and buckling structural components in order to make them
analyses of laminated composite plate equipped with withstand more forces than what they are
PFCPs. The governing equations are solved by using expected to.
finite element method considering an eight noded iso-
parametric element and using inverse hyperbolic shear In addition to other reasons, if we use segmented
deformation theory. The present theory helps to PFCPs over a composite substrate, considerable
analyze complex problems under less computational weight reduction is obtained.
complexity. The results got are quite accurate and
The present work provides the optimal
show excellent performance of the present
placement of PFCP actuators. Investigations are
formulation. Validation of the current analysis showed
carried out on application of optimized piezo
desired outputs. The subsequent important conclusions
locations in strengthening structures, thereby
are noted from the present investigation,
controlling the deformations (due to external
The capability of centrally located PFCPs in forces or caused as an effect of a flaw present
controlling the deflection of plate was analysed in the system) and increasing the critical buckling
for symmetric and anti-symmetric composite temperatures.
plates.
It is observed from this work that UPSO is a
It is observed that employing a centrally located very promising optimization technique and can
PFC patch above top surface of composite plate be successfully applied to find the maximized
reduces the hygrothermal effects and effects buckling temperatures of smart structures.
of internal flaw.
Compos Struct Paisley, UK, 1424-1435 in Aeronautical and Mech Eng ISBN:978-981-07-2683-6
Thangaratnam K R, Palaninathan R and Ramachandran (1989) Zhang W, Yunmin C and Yi J (2001) Effects of symmetrisation of
Thermal buckling of composite laminated plates J Comput net-stress tensor in anisotropic damage models Int J Fract
Struct 32 1117-1124 109 345-363
Valliappan S, Murti V and Zhang Wohua (1990) Finite element Zhou Y L (2001) Modeling of piezoelectric composite laminates
analysis of anisotropic damage mechanics problems Eng using a third-order plate theory In: Int Offshore and Polar
Fract Mech 35 1061-1071 Eng Conf 4 131-139
Wankhade R L and Bajoria K M (2012) Stability of simply Zienkiewicz O C (1971) The Finite Element Method, 3rd ed.
supported smart piezolaminated composite plate using Tata McGraw-Hill publishing.
finite element method In: Proc of the Int Conf on Advances