Comparison between the book "Grow with English" and

"Fun with English" class 3

Class 3 books Class 3 books

No Rated aspect
Grow with english Fun with English
1. fill in the material This book how to convey This book is a simple way to
material is rather convey the material, the
complicated, because there commands at each point are
are several chapters that are constant, the way the
self-developed, each delivery is easy for students
command that is used is not to understand.
constant, and many points
are too burdensome for 3rd
grade students.
2. Competency In this book there are In this book there are several
Points several words that words that are in accordance
correspond to the basic with the basic competencies
competencies that must be that must be achieved, for
achieved, for example example look, listen and
listening and repeat, look repeat, let 's practice, let' s
and say, complete the complete, read loudly.
sentences
3. Translation notes This book does not have an This book does not have an
Indonesian translation, Indonesian translation, even
although at the command on at the command on each
each point, the vocabulary point, but at the end of each
list that includes all material chapter there is a vocabulary
is only at the end of the related to the chapter being
book. studied so that if students do
not understand the meaning
of the chapter being studied
can immediately see the
 vocabulary list
4. Explanation of Explanation of each Explanation of each
each order command in this book is command in this book is
quite clear, but for grade 3 quite clear, although not
elementary school should be given a translation at each
given a translation, so that command point, at the end of
even if the teacher has not the chapter there is a
explained students can vocabulary that includes the
understand themselves material, so students can
understand themselves
5. Display This book displays many This book displays many
interesting and neat images, images, but there is no color
the colors used are cheerful, combination, only dominant
the paper used is also thick, colors are black, blue, white,
so students can easily so it seems boring to
understand the images. students.
6. Evaluation In this book there are many This evaluation book used is
interesting evaluations such almost the same in each
as matching, puzzle, chapter, there are MCQs at
crossword puzzles. But in the end of the book and in
this book there is no unit reviews 1-7 and unit
evaluation of multiple reviews 8-13
choice forms.
7. Language The language used in this The language used in this
book is quite clear and easy book is uncomplicated and
to understand by students. easy to understand.
8. Material core In this book there is a brief In this book, there is a brief
note to explain the material note to explain the material at
at the end of the book the beginning of the chapter
9. Book thickness This book is thicker than the This book is thinner than the
book "Fun with English" book "Grow with English”
because this book features because every material is
 many examples of delivered simply
interesting sentences, varied
games, and songs
10. In accordance Some of these books are not This book is in accordance
with SK KD in accordance with the KD, with the existing KD, and the
there is more material delivery of the material in
development in this book sequence