Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 6

BANKS AND FINANCIAL INTERMEDIARIES

JANUARY 15, 2019

A. Banks and the Business of Banking of summons on an individual defendant. Makati RTC noted that because corporate officers
1. Traditional / Core functions: Intermediation and Liquidity services are often busy, summonses to corporations are usually received only by administrative
 Legal definition of banks – General Banking Law assistants or secretaries of corporate officers in the regular course of business. Hence, it
3.1. "Banks" shall refer to entities engaged in the lending of funds denied the motion for lack of merit. Respondents filed an MR but withdrew it before the Makati
obtained in the form of deposits. RTC could resolve the matter.

 BDO EPCI vs. JAPRL Development Corp, GR 179901, 14 April 2008 On February 20, 2006, JAPRL filed a petition for rehabilitation in the Calamba RTC. Finding
FACTS: After evaluating the financial statements of JAPRL for fiscal years 1998-2000, BDO- The Calamba RTC issued a stay order. In view of the order, respondents hastily moved to
EPCI, Inc. extended credit facilities to it amounting to P230K on March 28, 2003. suspend the proceedings pending in the Makati RTC. Makati RTC granted the motion with
Respondents Rapid Forming Corporation (RFC) and Jose Arollado acted as JAPRLs regard to JAPRL and RFC but ordered Arollado to file an answer. It ruled that, because he
sureties. was jointly and solidarily liable with JAPRL and RFC, the proceedings against him should
continue. Respondents moved for reconsideration but it was denied.
JAPRL defaulted in the payment of 4 trust receipts soon after the approval of its loan.
Petitioner later learned from MRM Management, JAPRLs financial adviser, that JAPRL had On August 11, 2006, respondents filed a petition for certiorari in the CA alleging that the
altered and falsified its financial statements. It bloated its sales revenues to post a big income Makati RTC committed grave abuse of discretion in issuing the October 10, 2005 and July 7,
from operations for the concerned fiscal years to project itself as a viable investment. The 2006 orders. They asserted that the court did not acquire jurisdiction over their persons due
information alarmed petitioner. Citing relevant provisions of the Trust Receipt Agreement, it to defective service of summons. Thus, the Makati RTC could not hear the complaint for sum
demanded immediate payment of JAPRLs outstanding obligations amounting to P194M. of money. CA granted the petitioner. Petitioner moved for reconsideration but it was denied.

On August 30, 2003, JAPRL (and its subsidiary, RFC) filed a petition for rehabilitation in the ISSUE: WON respondents maliciously evaded the service of summonses to prevent the
Regional Trial Court (RTC) of Quezon City, Branch 90 (Quezon City RTC).[10] It disclosed Makati RTC from acquiring jurisdiction over their persons
that it had been experiencing a decline in sales for the three preceding years and a staggering
loss in 2002. HELD/RATIO: YES. They employed bad faith to delay proceedings by cunningly exploiting
procedural technicalities to avoid the payment of their obligations. Respondents abused
A stay order was issued. However, the proposed rehabilitation plan for JAPRL and RFC was procedural technicalities (albeit unsuccessfully) for the sole purpose of preventing, or at least
rejected by the Quezon City RTC. Because JAPRL ignored its demand for payment, delaying, the collection of their legitimate obligations. Their reprehensible scheme impeded
petitioner filed a complaint for sum of money with an application for the issuance of a WPA the speedy dispensation of justice. More importantly, however, considering the amount
against respondents in the RTC of Makati. Petitioner asserted that JAPRL was guilty of fraud involved, respondents utterly disregarded the significance of a stable and efficient banking
because JAPRL altered and falsified its financial statements. system to the national economy.

Makati RTC denied the application for the issuance of WPA for lack of merit as petitioner was Banks are entities engaged in the lending of funds obtained through deposits from the public.
unable to substantiate its allegations. It ordered the service of summons on respondents. The They borrow the publics excess money (i.e., deposits) and lend out the same. Banks
summonses were issued and served upon respondents. Respondents moved to dismiss the therefore redistribute wealth in the economy by channeling idle savings to profitable
complaint due to an allegedly invalid service of summons. Because the officers return stated investments.
that an administrative assistant had received the summons, JAPRL and RFC argued that
Section 11, Rule 14 of the Rules of Court contained an exclusive list of persons on whom Banks operate (and earn income) by extending credit facilities financed primarily by deposits
summons against a corporation must be served. An administrative assistant was not one of from the public. They plough back the bulk of said deposits into the economy in the form of
them. Arollado, on the other hand, cited Section 6, Rule 14 which mandated personal service loans. Since banks deal with the public’s money, their viability depends largely on their ability
1
BANKS AND FINANCIAL INTERMEDIARIES
JANUARY 15, 2019

to return those deposits on demand. For this reason, banking is undeniably imbued with ACCORDINGLY, the petition is hereby GRANTED. The June 7, 2007 decision and August
public interest. Consequently, much importance is given to sound lending practices and good 31, 2007 resolution of the Court of Appeals in CA-G.R. SP No. 95659 are REVERSED and
corporate governance. SET ASIDE.

Protecting the integrity of the banking system has become, by large, the responsibility of  Bañas vs. Asia Pacific Corp, 343 SCRA 527 (2000)
banks. The role of the public, particularly individual borrowers, has not been emphasized. FACTS: Sometime in August 1980, Teodoro Bañas executed a Promissory Note in favor of
Nevertheless, we are not unaware of the rampant and unscrupulous practice of obtaining C. G. Dizon Construction whereby for value received he promised to pay to the order of C.
loans without intending to pay the same. G. Dizon Construction the sum of P390K in installments of "P32,500 every 25th day of the
month starting from September 25, 1980 up to August 25, 1981." Later, C. G. Dizon
In this case, petitioner alleged that JAPRL fraudulently altered and falsified its financial Construction endorsed with recourse the said Promissory Note to Asia Pacific Finance
statements in order to obtain its credit facilities. Considering the amount of petitioner’s Corporation.
exposure in JAPRL, justice and fairness dictate that the Makati RTC hear whether or not
respondents indeed committed fraud in securing the credit accommodation. To secure the payment, C. G. Dizon Construction, through its corporate officers, executed a
Deed of Chattel Mortgage covering 3 heavy equipment units of Caterpillar Bulldozer Crawler
A finding of fraud will change the whole picture. In this event, petitioner can use the finding Tractors, and Cenen Dizon executed a Continuing Undertaking wherein he bound himself to
of fraud to move for the dismissal of the rehabilitation case in the Calamba RTC. The pay the obligation jointly and severally with C. G. Dizon Construction. In compliance
protective remedy of rehabilitation was never intended to be a refuge of a debtor guilty of therewith, C. G. Dizon Construction made three installment payments to Asia Pacific.
fraud. Meanwhile, the Makati RTC should proceed to hear Civil Case No. 03-991 against the Thereafter, it defaulted in the payment of the remaining installments, prompting Asia Pacific
three respondents guided by Section 40 of the General Banking Law which states: to send a SOA to Cenen Dizon for the unpaid balance.

Section 40. Requirement for Grant of Loans or Other Credit Accommodations. Before As the demand was unheeded, Asia Pacific filed a complaint for a sum of money against
granting a loan or other credit accommodation, a bank must ascertain that the debtor is Teodoro Bañas, C.G. Dizon Construction and Cenen Dizon. In their answer, while defendants
capable of fulfilling his commitments to the bank. admitted the genuineness and due execution of the Promissory Note, the Deed of Chattel
Mortgage and the Continuing Undertaking, they nevertheless maintained that these
Towards this end, a bank may demand from its credit applicants a statement of their assets documents were never intended by the parties to be legal, valid and binding but a mere
and liabilities and of their income and expenditures and such information as may be subterfuge to conceal the loan with usurious interests.
prescribed by law or by rules and regulations of the Monetary Board to enable the bank to
properly evaluate the credit application which includes the corresponding financial During the pendency of this case, Teodoro Bañas died, and Asia Pacific assigned the
statements submitted for taxation purposes to the Bureau of Internal Revenue. Should such disputed Promissory Note to International Corporate Bank (now Union Bank of the
statements prove to be false or incorrect in any material detail, the bank may terminate any Philippines). After trial, the Pasig RTC ruled in favor of Asia Pacific. On appeal, CA affirmed
loan or credit accommodation granted on the basis of said statements and shall have the in toto the decision of the trial court.
right to demand immediate repayment or liquidation of the obligation.
ISSUE: WON the disputed transaction between petitioners and Asia Pacific violated banking
Under this provision, banks have the right to annul any credit accommodation or loan, and laws, hence, null and void; and
demand the immediate payment from borrowers guilty of fraud. Petitioner would then be
entitled to the immediate payment of P194M and other appropriate damages. HELD/RATIO: No. Court ruled that the transaction between petitioners and respondent was
one involving not a loan but purchase of receivables at a discount, well within the purview of

2
BANKS AND FINANCIAL INTERMEDIARIES
JANUARY 15, 2019

"investing, reinvesting or trading in securities" which an investment company, like Asia d. Relending shall refer to the extension of loans by an institution with antecedent
Pacific, is authorized to perform & does not constitute a violation of the General Banking Act. borrowing transactions. Relending shall be presumed, in the absence of express
stipulations, when the institution is regularly engaged in lending.
Moreover, the terms and conditions of the instrument are clear, free from any ambiguity, and e. Regularly engaged in lending shall refer to the practice of extending loans, advances,
expressive of the real intent and agreement of the parties. Likewise, the Deed of Chattel discounts or rediscounts as a matter of business, as distinguished from isolated
Mortgage and Continuing Undertaking were duly acknowledged before a notary public and, lending transactions.
as such, have in their favor the presumption of regularity. To contradict them there must be
clear, convincing and more than merely preponderant evidence. In the instant case, the X234.3 Transactions not considered quasi-banking. The following shall not
records do not show even a preponderance of evidence in favor of petitioners' claim that the constitute quasi-banking:
Deed of Chattel Mortgage and Continuing Undertaking were never intended by the parties to a. Borrowing by commercial, industrial and other non-financial companies through any of the
be legal, valid and binding. Notarial documents are evidence of the facts in clear and means listed in Subsec. X234.1 hereof, for the limited purpose of financing their own needs
unequivocal manner therein expressed. The decision of the CA was AFFIRMED. or the needs of their agents or dealers; and
b. The mere buying and selling without recourse of instruments mentioned in Subsec.
 Distinction of Banks from Quasi-Banks and Trust Entities X234.1: Provided, That:
(1) The institution buying and selling without recourse shall indicate in conspicuous
MORB, X234.1 Elements of quasi-banking. print on its instrument the phrase without recourse, sans recourse or words of
The essential elements of quasi-banking are: similar import that will convey the absence of liability or guarantee by said
a. Borrowing funds for the borrower’s own account; institution; and
b. Twenty (20) or more lenders at any one (1) time; (2) In the absence of the phrase “without recourse”, “sans recourse” or words of similar
c. Methods of borrowing are issuance, endorsement, or acceptance of debt import, the instrument so issued, endorsed or accepted, shall automatically be
instruments of any kind, other than deposits, such as acceptances, promissory considered as falling within the purview of these regulations: Provided, further, That
notes, participations, certificates of assignments or similar instruments with any of the following practices or practices similar and/or tantamount thereto in
recourse, trust certificates, repurchase agreements, and such other instruments as connection with a without recourse transaction is hereby prohibited:
the Monetary Board may determine; and (a) Issuance of postdated checks by a financial intermediary, whether for its own
d. The purpose of which is (1) relending, or (2) purchasing receivables or other account or as an agent of the debt instrument issuer, in payment of the debt
obligations. instrument, sold, assigned or transferred without recourse; or
(b) Issuance by a financial intermediary of any form of guaranty on sale
§ X234.2 Definition of terms and phrases. transactions or on negotiations or assignment of debt instruments without
a. Borrowing shall refer to all forms of obtaining or raising funds through any of the recourse; and
methods and for any of the purposes provided in Subsec. X234.1 whether the (c) Payment with its own funds by a financial intermediary which assigned, sold
borrower’s liability thereby is treated as real or contingent. or transferred the debt instrument without recourse, unless the financial
b. For the borrower’s own account shall refer to the assumption of liability in one’s own intermediary can show that the issuer has with the said financial intermediary
capacity and not in representation, or as an agent or trustee, of another. funds corresponding to the amount of the obligation.
c. Purchasing of receivables or other obligations shall refer to the acquisition of claims
collectible in money, including interbank borrowings or borrowings between FIs, or of § X234.4 Pre-conditions for the exercise of quasi-banking functions. No bank shall engage in
acquisition of securities, of any amount and maturity, from domestic or foreign quasi-banking functions without authority from the BSP: Provided, however, That banks
sources. authorized by the BSP to perform universal or commercial banking functions shall
automatically have the authority to engage in quasi-banking functions: Provided, further, That
3
BANKS AND FINANCIAL INTERMEDIARIES
JANUARY 15, 2019

the authority to obtain funds from the public, which shall mean twenty (20) or more persons traditional and alternative product offerings that might not be
under Section 8.2 of R.A. 8791, is not a condition but an authorization for the bank or quasi- available to the average investor.
bank, once the Monetary Board has granted the quasi-banking license. In addition to the  Real estate services – refers to buildings or land intended to
Standard Pre-qualification Requirements for the Grant of Bank Authorities enumerated in generate a profit, either from capital gain or rental income.
Appendix 5, a TB securing BSP authority to engage in quasi-banking functions must meet 
the following requirements: 2. Bank Powers and Liabilities
a. The bank must have a networth or combined capital of at least P650.0 a. Corporate Powers
million computed in accordance with Sec. X111; b. Banking and Incidental Powers
b. The bank is well capitalized with risk-based capital adequacy ratio of not
lower than twelve percent (12%) at the time of filing the application; 3. Classification of Banks
c. The bank’s operation during the preceding calendar year and for the MORB, Sec. X101 - A. Classifications and Powers of Banks
period immediately preceding the date of application has been profitable; The following are the classifications, powers and scope of authorities of banks, as
d. The bank has elected at least two (2) independent directors and all its well as the prerequisites for the grant of banking authorities.
directors have attended the required seminar for directors of banks a. Classifications of banks. Banks are classified into the following subject to the
conducted or accredited by the BSP; power of the Monetary Board to create other classes or kinds of banks:
e. The bank has established a risk management system appropriate to its (1) Universal banks (UBs);
operations characterized by clear delineation of responsibility for risk (2) Commercial banks (KBs);
management, adequate risk measurement systems, appropriately (3) Thrift banks (TBs), as defined in Republic Act (R.A.) No. 7906, which
structured risk limits, effective internal controls, and complete, timely and shall be composed of: (a) savings and mortgage banks, (b) stock savings
efficient risk reporting system; and and loan associations, and (c) private development banks;
f. The bank has a CAMELS Composite Rating of at least “3” in the last (4) Rural banks (RBs), as defined in R. A. No. 7353;
regular examination with management rating of not lower than “3”. (5) Cooperative banks (Coop Banks); and
(6) Islamic banks (IBs), as defined in R.A. No. 6848.
 Other non-bank financial services b. Powers and scope of authorities The following are the powers and scope of
 Unit trusts / mutual funds – The main difference between these authorities of banks.
two is that UITFs are offered by banks, while mutual funds are their (1) UBs. A UB shall have the authority to exercise, in addition to the powers and
own companies. By buying into a UITF, you own units of this fund. services authorized for a KB as enumerated in Item “b(2)” and those provided by
By buying into a mutual fund, you own shares and become a other laws, the following:
shareholder in the mutual fund company. (a) the powers of an investment house (IH) as provided under existing laws;
 Insurance – A contract of insurance is an agreement whereby one (b) the power to invest in non-allied enterprises;
undertakes for a consideration to indemnify another against loss, (c) the power to own up to one hundred percent (100%) of the equity in a
damage or liability arising from an unknown or contingent event. TB, an RB, a financial allied enterprise, or a non-financial allied
 Stock brokerage – buys and sells stocks and other securities for enterprise; and
both retail and institutional clients through a stock exchange or over (d) in case of publicly-listed UBs, the power to own up to one hundred percent
the counter in return for a fee or commission. (100%) of the voting stock of only one (1) other UB or KB.
 Asset management – the direction of a client's cash and securities
by a financial services company, usually an investment bank. The A UB may perform the functions of an IH either directly or indirectly through a
institution offers investment services along with a wide range of subsidiary IH; in either case, the underwriting of equity securities and securities
4
BANKS AND FINANCIAL INTERMEDIARIES
JANUARY 15, 2019

dealing shall be subject to pertinent laws and regulations of the Securities and (c) issue domestic letters of credit;
Exchange Commission (SEC): Provided, That if the IH functions are performed (d) extend credit facilities to private and government employees;
directly by the UB, such functions shall be undertaken by a separate and distinct (e) extend credit against the security of jewelry, precious stones and articles of
department or other similar unit in the UB: Provided, further, That a UB cannot similar nature, subject to such rules and regulations as the Monetary Board
perform such functions both directly and indirectly through a subsidiary. may prescribe;
(f) accept savings and time deposits;
(2) KBs. In addition to the general powers incident to corporations and those provided (g) rediscount paper with the Land Bank of the Philippines (LBP), Development
in other laws, a KB shall have the authority to exercise all such powers as may be Bank of the Philippines (DBP), and other government-owned or -controlled
necessary to carry on the business of commercial banking, such as accepting corporations;
drafts and issuing letters of credit; discounting and negotiating promissory notes, (h) accept foreign currency deposits as provided under R.A. No. 6426, as
drafts, bills of exchange, and other evidences of debt; accepting or creating amended;
demand deposits; receiving other types of deposits and deposit substitutes; buying (i) act as correspondent for other financial institutions (FIs);
and selling foreign exchange and gold or silver bullion; acquiring marketable bonds (j) purchase, hold and convey real estate as specified under Sections 51 and
and other debt securities; and extending credit, subject to such rules as the 52 of R.A. No. 8791;
Monetary Board may promulgate. These rules may include the determination of (k) offer other banking services as provided in Section 53 of R.A. No. 8791; and
bonds and other debt securities eligible for investment, the maturities and (l) buy and sell foreign exchange. With prior approval of the Monetary Board,
aggregate amount of such investment. and subject to such guidelines as may be established by it, TBs may also
perform the following services:
It may also exercise or perform any or all of the following: (m) open current or checking accounts;
(a) invest in the equities of allied enterprises as provided in Sections 31 and 32 (n) engage in trust, quasi-banking functions and money market operations;
of R.A. No. 8791; (b) purchase, hold and convey real estate as specified under (o) act as collection agent for government entities, including but not limited to,
Sections 51 and 52 of R.A. No. 8791; the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR), Social Security System (SSS) and the
(c) receive in custody funds, documents and valuable objects; Bureau of Customs (BOC);
(d) act as financial agent & buy & sell, by order of & for the account of their (p) act as official depository of national agencies and of municipal, city or
customers, shares, evidences of indebtedness & all types of securities; provincial funds in the municipality, city or province where the TB is located;
(e) make collections & payments for the account of others & perform such other (q) issue mortgage and chattel mortgage certificates, buy and sell them for its
services for their customers as are not incompatible with banking business; own account or for the account of others, or accept and receive them in
(f) upon prior approval of the Monetary Board, act as managing agent, adviser, payment or as amortization of its loan;
consultant or administrator of investment management/advisory/consultancy (r) invest in the equity of allied undertakings;
accounts; (s) issue foreign letters of credit; and
(g) rent out safety deposit boxes; and (t) pay/accept/negotiate import/export draft/bills of exchange.
(h) engage in quasi-banking functions.
(4) RBs. In addition to the powers provided in other laws::
(3) TBs. In addition to the powers provided in other laws: (a) extend loans and advances primarily for the purpose of meeting the normal
(a) grant loans, whether secured or unsecured; credit needs of farmers, fishermen or farm families as well as cooperatives,
(b) invest in readily marketable bonds and other debt securities, commercial merchants, private and public employees;
papers and accounts receivable, drafts, bills of exchange, acceptances or notes (b) accept savings and time deposits;
arising out of commercial transactions; (c) act as correspondent of other FIs;
5
BANKS AND FINANCIAL INTERMEDIARIES
JANUARY 15, 2019

(d) rediscount paper with the LBP, DBP or any other bank, including its branches (e) act as correspondent of banks and institutions to handle remittances or any
and agencies. Said banks shall specify the nature of paper deemed acceptable fund transfers;
for rediscount, as well as the rediscount rate to be charged by any of these (f) accept drafts and issue letters of credit or letters of guarantee, negotiate notes
banks; and bills of exchange and other evidence of indebtedness under the universally
(e) act as collection agent; accepted Islamic financial instruments;
(f) offer other banking services as provided in Section 53 of R.A. No. 8791; and (g) act as collection agent insofar as the payment orders, bills of exchange or
(g) buy and sell foreign exchange. With prior approval of the Monetary Board, an other
RB may perform any or all of the following services: commercial documents are exclusive of riba or interest prohibitions;
(h) accept current or checking accounts: Provided, That such RB has net assets (h) provide financing with or without collateral by way of leasing, sale and
of at least P5.0 million; leaseback, or cost plus profit sales arrangement;
(i) accept negotiable order of withdrawal (NOW) accounts; (i) handle storage operations for goods or commodity financing secured by
(j) act as trustee over estates or properties of farmers and merchants; warehouse receipts presented to the bank;
(k) act as official depository of municipal, city or provincial funds in the (j) issue shares for the account of institutions and companies assisted by the
municipality, city or province where it is located; bank in meeting subscription calls or augmenting their capital and/or fund
(l) sell domestic drafts; and requirements as may be allowed by law;
(m) invest in allied undertakings. (k) undertake various investments in all transactions allowed by the Islamic
Shari’a in such a way that shall not permit the haram (forbidden), nor forbid the
(5) Coop Banks. A Coop Bank shall primarily provide financial, banking and credit halal (permissible); depository, or its branches, subdivisions and
services to cooperatives and their members, although it may provide the same instrumentalities and of government-owned or-controlled corporations,
services to non-members or the general public. In addition to the powers granted particularly those doing business in the Autonomous Region;
to Coop Banks under existing laws, any Coop Bank may perform any or all of the (m) issue investment participation certificates, muquaradah (non-interestbearing
banking services offered by rural banks under Items “4.a” to “4.g” above. A Coop bonds), debentures, collaterals and/or the renewal and refinancing of the same,
Bank may likewise perform any or all of the banking services offered by rural banks with the approval of the Monetary Board to be used by the IB in its financing
under Items “4.h” to “4.m” as well as any or all of the banking services offered by operations for projects that will promote the economic development primarily of
other types of banks, subject to prior approval of the Bangko Sentral. the Autonomous Region;
(n) carry out financing and joint investment operations by way of mudarabah
(6) IBs. In addition to the general powers incident to corporations and those provided purchasing for others on a cost-plus financing arrangement, and invest funds
in other laws, as well as in Circular No. 105 (Appendix 44), insofar as they are not directly in various projects or through the use of funds whose owners desire to
inconsistent or incompatible with the provisions of R.A. No. 6848, an IB may invest jointly with other resources available to the IB on a joint mudarabah basis;
perform any or all of the following services: (o) invest in equities of the following allied undertakings:
(a) open savings accounts for safekeeping or custody with no participation in (1) Warehousing companies;
profit and losses except unless otherwise authorized by the account holders to (2) Leasing companies;
be invested; (3) Storage companies;
(b) accept investment account placements and invest the same for a term with (4) Companies engaged in the management of mutual funds but not in the
the IB’s funds in Islamically permissible transactions on participation basis; mutual funds themselves; and (5) Such other similar activities as the Monetary
(c) accept foreign currency deposits from banks, companies, organizations and Board has declared or may declare as appropriate from time to time,
individuals, including foreign governments; subject to existing limitations imposed by law.
(d) buy and sell foreign exchange;
6

Вам также может понравиться