Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Wherever you see this symbol, it is important to access the on-line course
as there is interactive material that cannot be fully shown in this reference
i manual.
Aims and Objectives
Aims
Objectives
Introduction 3
Supercritical Fluids 4
Modes of Chromatography 6
SFC Applications 7
SFC Instrumentation 12
Packed SFC 14
Capillary SFC 14
The Mobile Phase 15
Exhaust Gases 16
Organic Modifiers 17
Pumping Issues 19
SFC Columns 20
Packed Column SFC Stationary Phases 21
Capillary Column SFC Stationary Phases 22
Detection 24
Pressure Regulators 26
Advantages and Disadvantages of SFC 27
References 27
Different eluent systems have been used to undertake SFC separations; however, carbon
dioxide based systems are by far the most successful and widely used of all of them.
When considered as a mobile phase for SFC, carbon dioxide often requires the addition of
organic modifiers (such as alcohols) for the elution of polar solutes. The term “subcritical
chromatography” denotes chromatographic separations using subcritical fluids as the
mobile phase.[2,3]
Disadvantages of SFC are mainly mobile phase or equipment related and include:[4, 5]
Supercritical Fluids
Any substance that is maintained above its critical conditions (heated above its critical
temperature AND compressed above its critical pressure) is said to be in a supercritical
state and substances under these conditions are termed ‘Supercritical Fluids’.[6]
Critical Pressure (Pc): is the highest pressure at which a liquid can be converted to a gas
by increasing its temperature.
Critical Temperature (Tc): is the highest temperature at which a gas can be converted to
a liquid by increasing its pressure.
Above its critical temperature a gas will not condense into a liquid phase regardless of
how much the pressure is increased; in the same way, above its critical pressure a liquid
will never exists in the gas phase regardless of how much the temperature is raised.[7]
Supercritical fluids are neither liquids nor gases; rather they are compressible fluids with
the characteristic dissolving power of liquids, but diffusivities approaching that of gases.
That is why we cannot define the supercritical fluid as a liquid or as a gas but also what
make them so interesting as a mobile phase for chromatographic separations.
Using the correct conditions of temperature and pressure and mobile phase composition
are of critical in SFC separations. However for various reasons of instrument design and
operating principle, as well as the effect of modifier addition, workers may unwittingly
operate with slightly subcritical fluids –however it is the repeatability of the applied
conditions which is important, rather the absolutely surety that one is operating
supercritically. Variations in the concentration or type of organic modifier will change the
supercritical properties of the system.
For pure carbon dioxide the conditions of temperature and pressure that
define the critical point are: Tc = 31.1 oC, Pc = 73.8 Bar
Triple Point: The triple point of a pure substance is the temperature and
pressure at which three phases (for example, gas, liquid, and solid) of that
substance coexist in thermodynamic equilibrium.
For pure carbon dioxide the conditions of temperature and pressure that
define the triple point are: Ttr = -56.6 oC, Ptr = 5.17 Bar
Compared with liquids, supercritical fluids have higher diffusivity coefficients and less
resistance to mass transfer – both of which lead to sharper chromatographic peaks at
higher optimum linear velocities, which is demonstrated using the van Deemter curves
opposite.[8] As with all van Deemter plots, lower values of Reduced Plate Height indicate
higher efficiency.
In general terms, the optimum linear velocity for a supercritical fluid is around three times
greater than an eluent in the condensed phase, allowing SFC separations to be carried
out more quickly without loss in efficiency (or the resulting potential loss of resolution).
Unlike GC, low temperatures can be used when performing SFC separations. Working at
lower temperature gives the advantage of:
SFC Applications
Supercritical fluid chromatography has many of the features of both liquid and gas
chromatography; therefore, it’s application area occupies an intermediate position
between the two of them.
SFC is important in situations where neither GC nor HPLC is capable of performing the
required analysis. Consider oleo-chemical compounds, they are too heavy for GC but
they usually require detection capabilities not easily found with HPLC.
The main advantage of SFC over GC comes from the adjustable nature of the elutotropic
strength of the mobile phase which can be controlled through the addition of organic
modifiers. As a consequence, SFC has extended the applicability range of
chromatography in a way never seen before.
To list the full range of SFC application areas is prohibitive, its flexibility makes it suitable
to a multitude of application types. Examples of some interesting applications are shown
below:
Analysis of paraffin:[9] Paraffin is the common name for the alkane hydrocarbons with
the general formula CnH2n+2. Paraffin wax refers to the solids with 20 ≤ n ≤ 40
SFC Instrumentation
Supercritical fluid chromatography presents many of the features of both liquid and gas
chromatography; therefore, it occupies an intermediate position between the two of them.
Two major forms of SFC can be found:[17]
Capillary SFC: This mode of SFC presents similarities with conventional capillary GC.
Packed SFC: This mode of SFC presents similarities with conventional capillary HPLC.
The diagram opposite, illustrate a typical packed SFC instrument; however, from a
hardware point of view, the representation is equally valid for both capillary and packed
SFC systems.
• Eluent flow rates are in the order of a few millilitres per minute
• Injection volumes range from a few to hundreds of microlitre (one aspect which
makes packed column SFC very suitable for preparative work)
Capillary SFC
Capillary column SFC shows similarity to conventional capillary GC; capillary SFC uses
GC modified instrumentation to achieve supercritical separations. When performing
capillary SFC separations:
• Eluent flow rates are in the order of a few microlitre per minute
• Injection volumes are in the order of a few hundreds of picolitre (1pL = 10-12L)
• In general, SFC columns have smaller internal diameter than their GC
counterparts
As we have seen, carbon dioxide is the mobile phase fluid of choice for supercritical
chromatography, the main reasons including:[15]
• Low cost
• Modest critical conditions
• Available at high purity
• Safety
• Easy to use
• Lack of another viable alternative
The success of carbon dioxide is in great extent due to the addition of organic modifiers
(such as alcohols) that permit the analysis of polar analytes. The modifier increases the
polarity of the mobile phase to compete with the analyte for active sites on the stationary
phase, leading to reduced retention of solutes. This is highly analogous to the use of a
‘delocalising’ solvent in Normal Phase HPLC.
With the advent of preparative SFC, the consumption of carbon dioxide and organic
modifiers is constantly increasing. As expected, manufacturers are experiencing
increasing pressure to make SFC even more environmentally friendly while reducing
eluent flow rate costs by reusing it.
SFC exhaust gas collection systems usually consist of a set of decompression chambers
with temperature control. This devices permit carbon dioxide to regain its gaseous state
while the remaining components condense and are recovered. As expected, sample
components and organic modifiers tend to remain dissolved in the liquid organic modifier.
Once separated, sample components and organic modifiers can be disposed of according
to correct local disposal protocols. After purified, the flow of carbon dioxide can be
compressed and reutilised.
Note that as result of decompressing the SFC effluent, solid carbon dioxide (cardice or dry
ice) can form and clog the waste stream.
The use of modifiers will affect analyte retention and may even alter their elution order.[15]
Modifiers are added to the supercritical eluent system for the following reasons:
• To increase the polarity of the mobile phase (thus improving the solubility of polar
analytes)
• To facilitate desorption of polar analytes from the column
Analyte and organic modifier molecules will actually compete for active binding sites in the
stationary phase; therefore, analyte desorption is promoted by organic modifiers.
In practical terms only carbon dioxide with methanol or acetonitrile as modifiers are of
significant importance in SFC. However, the list of possible organic modifiers is long and
include different alcohols (with isopropanol being perhaps the most popular), cyclic ethers,
tetrahydrofuran, isopropylamine, hexane, etc.
The presence of modifiers in the mobile phase will determine its critical conditions; for
example, the addition of short chain alcohols will raise the critical temperature a few
hundred degrees Celsius (composition dependent) thus compromising the analysis of
thermally labile samples. For a given amount of substance the temperature, volume, and
pressure are interdependent variables, the relationship between them (under certain
conditions) can be represented by an equation of state.[16]
The addition of organic modifiers will preclude the use of detectors that respond to carbon
containing compounds (such as FID).
RT a
P= −
V − b V (V + b) + c(V − b)
a = ∑∑ xi x j aij
i j
b = ∑∑ xi x j bij
i j
c = ∑∑ xi x j cij
i j
Where
P: pressure of the mixture
T: absolute temperature
V: Volume of the mixture
xij: mol fraction of i-component
aij, bij, cij: Patel-Teja Parameters (component dependent)
A disadvantage with using organic modifiers is that certain detection modes (such as FID),
cannot be used, due to their response to carbon containing compounds.
In SFC the retention of a solute is influenced by the density of the mobile phase and this
in turn is highly influenced by the system pressure. Therefore the design of the pumping
system, to achieve a constant pressure, is of overriding importance in SFC.
Pumping systems lacking the ability to dynamically change compressibility will deliver
accurate flow at only one (pre-selected) pressure and composition. In applications where
the analysis conditions need to be changed (like in gradient operation), then with each
small composition change the pump will become less accurate.
SFC Columns
SFC columns (as well as many other types of liquid chromatography columns) consist of a
stainless steel tube filled with the stationary phase. The stationary phase may be bare
silica or silica coated with a bonded phase. SFC columns use end-fittings that permit their
connection to the rest of the chromatographic system, and are identical to those used in
HPLC columns.
Packed SFC columns are usually made of stainless steel, however, ceramic columns are
also available.[32] The stationary phase is retained at each end of the tube by a sieve or
frit. SFC fittings and accessories are generally made of stainless steel.
SFC capillary columns are of similar design to their GC counterparts, with the stationary
phase being chemically immobilized onto the inner wall of the capillary, which is typically
made from silica coated with a polyimide to give it strength and flexibility. These columns
have very narrow external diameters; therefore, chemical means (rendering ceramic frits)
rather than external fittings are the preferred choice to immobilise the column bed.
In general terms, SFC can be regarded as a form of normal phase chromatography with
the added advantage of low viscosity (and high diffusivity) of supercritical fluids.
Therefore, SFC columns are of the same type as those currently used in normal phase
chromatography.
For practical reasons, only carbon dioxide based systems are useful as SFC mobile
phases; therefore, SFC applications typically require polar stationary phases such as
silica amino and diol.
It is worth nothing that low to non polar stationary phases (such as octadecylsiloxane-
bonded) can also be used with SFC.
Although there are not many clear rules for capillary SFC column selection, the polarity of
the stationary phase gives an indication of its applicability and is the key parameter to
start with. However, very often different stationary phases may need to be scouted before
obtaining a proper separation, in a rather familiar way to anyone working with chiral
Modern SFC instruments permit rapid scouting of columns of different nature while
altering (if required) the mobile phase. These systems are especially suited for column
selection under supercritical conditions and will usually contain automated switching
valves etc. One positive is the rapid short run times for SFC made possible due to the
unique properties of the eluent.
The tool opposite lists selected capillary SFC stationary phases and highlights situations
where they can be useful.
As was previously explained, SFC instruments are hybrids of their HPLC and GC
counterparts.
SFC systems implement pressure restrictors (or regulators) somewhere after the column
to keep the eluent system above its critical conditions. The position of the pressure
regulator will determine the type of detection system to be used. If the pressure restrictor
is placed after the detector, then the detection system operates as in LC but at much
higher pressures – requiring the detector flow cells to be specially designed and
manufactured to withstand these pressures without cracking the cell windows or leaking.
Schematic representation of the connection of SFC and a high pressure detection system
(in this case a UV/Vis detector). Here the pressure regulator is located AFTER the
detector.
After leaving the column, the supercritical mobile phase decompresses into a gas,
allowing SFC to be coupled to many GC detection methods;[9, 21, 24, 29] however, a number
of LC devices, have also been used.[22, 23, 25, 26, 27, 28]
Schematic representation of the connection of SFC and a low pressure detection system
(in this case a FID detector). Here the pressure regulator is located BEFORE the
detector.
Acting as pressure regulators, flow restrictors are commonly used to meet pressure
requirements of the SFC system.
The outlet of the pressure regulator is usually heated to prevent adiabatic cooling of the
expanding supercritical fluid. Adiabatic cooling of SFC mobile phases could render dry ice
(solid form of carbon dioxide) formation and flow path blocking.
A basic variable pressure regulator design includes a sensor that measures the actual
system pressure, this reading is sent to the pressure control system to be compared with
the required setting, as a result of this comparison a piston (acting as a flow restrictor) is
acted and the pressure increased or decreased as needed.
References