Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
48)
Do you agree with this statement in the context of the society portrayed in La casa de Bernarda Alba?
Para: Sexual Expectations of men vs women . Women are seen merely as things to be desired rather
than being alowed to desire themselves
Prostitution is tolerated (the son of Poncia) Man needs to give vent to his sexual instinct so it is
understandable that he goes to a whore to satiate his desires. Adela exclaims "They are forgiven
everything" and adds Amelia "being born a woman is the greatest punishment"
In the same way, Poncia blames Adela for being responsible for what happens with Pepe, since she has
provoked him and "a man is a man".
Paca la Rosette.
Counter- has nothing to do with being a women in general bit a women in this context and a certain
class
Adela
Paca la Roseta
THe sins of the father carry thrpugh to the women of the family
Adela
No me acostumbrare
Quotations:
119 Poncia: The old lady. Is she The old lady is locked up as she
locked up tight? is considered mad due to her
Maid: With two turns of the key outspoken nature, which, in this
Poncia: You should fasten the society, is dangerous as certain
bolt, too. She has fingers like five things have to be kept secret.
skeleton keys!
120 Poncia: On that day I will lock The maid’s jealousy/anger for
myself in a room with her, and Bernarda is overflowing as the
spit at her for a whole year! maid wants to corner Bernarda
and let her feelings be known.
121 “the walls trembled, and when he This shows that that even the
sang ‘Amen’, it was as if a wolf walls that are powerful enough to
had come into the church” keep anyone out or in even give
into the power of the church as
they trembled. It shows that
amount of power and control the
church has to flex its influence
over society and social order.
123 Bernarda: Have them leave they It reveals the power that
way they came in. I don’t want Bernarda has in the house as
them coming through here. she controls how and where
people move.
126 Bernarda: Well, look for another This is a key quote as it illustrates
– you’re going to need one. what Bernarda is presently
During our eight years of doing; sealing up the house. It
mourning, no wind from the also reveals her motives behind
street will enter this house! it (her father and his father did it).
Pretend we have sealed up the
doors and windows with bricks. This quotation also shows that
This was how it was in my Bernada is imposing the social
father’s house and in my rules and orders upon her family
grandfather’s house. and herself, which implies that
the social order of society is kept
up because we impose it upon
ourselves to obey and suffer.
127 Bernarda: It’s not that – out there, Bernarda says why her mother
the neighbours can see her from shouldn’t be seen and through
their window. this, reveals that the actions of
her mother are unacceptable to
her as it reflects poorly on her in
the eyes of society.
127 “I saw her peering through a This quotation shows how the
crack in the front door. The men daughters of Barnarda Alba are
had just left” denied their freedom which is
represented by the world outside
which can be seen through the
crack in the front door. It also
shows the desperation of the
daughters that they are willing to
peer through the front door
through a small crack rather than
try to open the door itself.
128 Poncia: …And she stood at the This obviously illustrates the
window, listening to the men’s spying that goes on in society,
conversation – which as always, and the fact that women were not
was not fit to hear. allowed to mix with the men but it
also suggests that cracks in
windows and doors provide
women the opportunity to find out
the gossip and news of towns
from their comfort of home and a
sense of freedom.
136 Bernarda: Until I leave this house Bernarda once again asserts her
feet first, I will make the decisions dominance in the house and
– my own, and yours! makes it clear that she and only
she has the power in this
“prison”.
137 Amelia: Open the door to the As the daughters are only able to
patio, to see if we can get a little open the door and not go out, this
fresh air. quote reinforces the entrapment
of the daughters.
138 Poncia: …Angustias was still at This dialogue here shows the
her window with Pepe. importance of the window in
Poncia: Tell me Angustias – what Spanish society for the women
did he say to you, the first time he as men propose to them from
came to your window? there. It reveals that the window
Martirio: It really is strange how represents the hope of freedom
two people who have met for women as they can look at the
suddenly see each other through outside through it (which is
a window grating and – just like emphasised in the play by the
that – they’re engaged! fact that women rarely leave the
Angustias: Not me, because house).
when a man approaches a
window grating, he already This also suggests the existence
knows – from people who come of the society of male
and go, who fetch and carry – predominance- that women’s
that the answer will be yes. lives will forever be controlled by
men’s actions, needs and wants
as it is up to them to approach the
windows.
139 Poncia: The first time my Shows the reader that men in this
husband, Evaristo the Birdman, society typically go up to
came to my window – ha, ha, ha! windows to propose.
139 Amelia jumps up and peers out of This shows the fear of social
the door. rules and expectations as Amelia
is clearly nervous about whether
or not their conversation and
laughter has been overheard.
140 “You would know better than me, This may suggests that walls can
since you sleep with only a wall keep things (mainly gossip and
between you.” news) from travelling, but two
things cannot be stopped by
walls. They are the church and its
influence over everyone and
spying on one another that even
members of the same family do.
Similarly the activities and events
that occur within the house can
suggest that another power that
is great enough to travel through
the walls are family matters that
are hazardous to destroying the
family and the whole ‘house’.
141 Poncia: Why were you standing This quote uses a number of
at the open window, half naked, motifs to strengthen the belief
with the light burning – the that Adela wants to be free. The
second time Pepe came to talk open window, lack of clothes (as
with your sister? clothes are restrictive), and the
light (suggesting hope) all
combine effectively to express
Adela’s wish for freedom from
her mother.
145 Chorus: Open your doors and The fact that the men are singing
your windows, Ladies who live in the song to persuade(?) the
this pueblo! Harvesters beg for women to come out and ‘show’
your roses, Roses to trim their themselves to the men suggests
sombreros! the power the men have over
Adela: Let’s go and watch them women. It also shows the
from the window in my room! relationship between men and
Poncia: Be careful not to open it their freedom that contrasts
too wide – they’re bold enough to greatly with that of the women as
give it a push to see who is they watch from their open
looking. windows who can see the
freedom, but never actually
experience it.
145 “Let’s go watch them from the This is a very important quotation
window in my room” in the play as it is juxtaposition to
the normal representation of
windows as a barrier because
here the window seems to be a
provider of freedom.
147 “The neighbors must have their Shows that most of the
ears glued to the wall“ townspeople are always on the
lookout for other people’s gossip.
This also could suggest that the
gossip creates but is also
fostered by the imprisonment
and boredom of women that are
stuck within the house.
148 “Because if I talk, the walls will The image of collapsing walls
collapse in shame!” suggests the destructive results
of going against the conventional
social rules. It is in order to avoid
this shame that Bernarda (and
others) have constructed such a
cage around themselves.
153 Maid: There’s a big crowd up the This quote reveals that people
street! And all the neighbours are feel in power and control when
at their doors! they stand next to their doors and
this makes the door a symbol of
power.
153 They stand listening, not daring It might appear that they are
to take another step towards the fearful of the outside world
outside door. (nature/freedom), but it is rather
the consequences that they
would face if they were caught.
Their fear comes from the strict
and powerful Bernada that instills
fear into them through violence
and her status as the widower of
the house.
154 Four white walls lightly bathed in The scene color now changes to
blue. The décor must be one of a blue suggesting a of tragic, sad
perfect simplicity. The doors, atmosphere that will occur in this
illuminated by the light from act. This also suggests that the
inside, cast a delicate glow on atmosphere that will happen
the scene. inside the house will not affect
the outside world, for the lightly
bathed blue light cannot escape
and is entrapped within the 4
walls. This relates closely to the
theme of imprisonment and
captivity of the girls in the house.
154 Poncia: …But some dogs, with The door is once again a symbol
more feelings than many of power as it claims that God
creatures, pulled it out, and as if himself placed on the most
by the hand of God, they put it on prominent location of the house
her doorstep. … that everyone can see.
155 Prudencia: You know how he is. Out of shame, he stops using the
Ever since he fought with his front door to prevent allowing the
brothers over the inheritance, he eyes of society to look at him. It
hasn’t used the front door. He shows the pressure that society
puts up a ladder and climbs over can exert upon a person.
the wall and the corral. However, he still enters the
house, only this time by a ladder.
This story helps to suggest how
ludicrous our adherence to social
rules is.
155 The breeding stallion, locked up This quotation reveals the theme
and kicking the walls of nature against social rules
which may imply that the social
rules of the pueblo are unnatural.
The stallion represents nature as
he tries to kick down the walls
built by the society which box him
in the small space of the corral. It
also shows how the males, man
or animal, are granted freedom
because Bernarda commands
that he be let out of the corral.
157 Adela: I’m going to the front door This is the first time that a woman
to stretch my legs and get a little goes outside the house and it
fresh air hints at the rebellion building up
within Adela.
158 Angustias: I often stare very hard It is important to note that the
at Pepe, until he goes blurred windows have bars covering
behind the bars of the window, as them and this enforces the prison
if her were being covered by a like atmosphere within the
cloud of dust like the ones the house. Also, it reveals
sheep stir up. Angustias’s own hopes of being
free from her mother.
163 She looks furtively from side to This quotation shows the fear
side and disappears through the created by breaking the rules.
door to the corral
163 Maria Josefa: Are you going to The “mad” woman wants to be
open the door for me? escape and be free but is unable
to do it herself as Bernarda has
banished her away from the eyes
of society.
167 Adela: Get away from that door! Adela is rebelling against her
family and is trying to break free
from the prison she feels she is
in.
168 “Open up! Don’t think these walls Echoes the quotation on page
can hide your shame!” 148 about the walls collapsing in
shame; that the shame of
disgracing your family with their
sinful acts cannot be hidden by
the walls. This implies that the
sinful acts are too powerful and
that even the strong walls cannot
withstand the burden of a huge
secret. On the other hand,
however, it appears that
Bernarda is powerless to open
the door suggesting that Adela
currently has the upper hand.
Key moment:
Adela’s suicide is by far the most important scene in the play for this motif. The door plays a pivotal role in
showing Bernarda’s loss of control in the house as she is unable to open the door. The door itself used to
be a barrier for Adela to break down but as she gains control over her life and Bernarda loses her authority,
this role reversal is reflected by who controls the door, “Open up, or I’ll break down the door! Adela!”. The
door also sheds light on Bernarda’s character as her overbearing and cruel personality is apparent. The
importance of the door in this scene is further highlighted by the fact that it is the climax of the play and it is
part of the very last scene, which is the scene the audience will remember when they leave. The door also
plays a key role in the plot as it prevents Bernarda from trying to stop Adela committing suicide. Neighbours
are also denied the opportunity to spy on Bernarda, “the neighbours are awake”, due to the door that is
blocking their view, and this shows the extent to which spying and gossip stretch in this society.
The quote on page 131 shows the priorities in those times where the idealistic ideas of marriage based on
love is not in practice. Like Martirio, Pepe el Romano is marrying Angustias for her wealth and land. This is
contrasting to Maria Josefa’s intention of marrying for love and be happy. She links this to the sea, feeling
that marriage will grant her freedom. However, this is ironic as given an example from previous pages;
marriage is simply another form of imprisonment.
Quotation Analysis
123 ‘Standing very near your aunt.’ Bernarda hints indirectly that the
aunt was behaving improperly.
Her proximity to the ‘widower
from Darajali’ hints at an
attraction between the two but
the fact that something so
insignificant is looked down upon
reveals how strictly controlling
the social rules in this town are
and also how much of a vicious
gossip Bernarda is. This is
confirmed on p.124 when
Bernarda exclaims that
‘Whoever turns her head is on
the prowl for a man.’ where the
use of ‘prowl’ is meant to
insinuate how base, animalistic
and immoral any woman who
would do such a thing is.
127 “What were you looking at? And This is when Bernada is
who? terrorizing her daughters and is
angry that they dare look at men
during their father’s funeral
mass. This reveals how the girls
have no freedom whatsoever
and their lust for a man is so
strong that they will take every
opportunity they have to study
the men around them. They are
reduced to ‘peering through a
crack in the door’ and this is the
closest they can get to a man.
128 ‘They say she rode with her Paca le Roseta is obviously a
topless with her breasts hanging symbol of sexual freedom. The
out.’ open clothing suggests her lack
of inhibitions and the fact that she
is associated with animals like
the horse, distant places like the
olive grove and other symbols of
nature like the crown of flowers
reinforce this idea.
130 ‘Her father killed his first wife’s This is the story of Adeleida’s
husband in Cuba so he could father and it is a good example of
marry her himself. Then, here, he the kinds of stories of sexual
deserted her and ran off with gossip that Bernarda, Poncia
another woman who had a and, presumably the other
daughter. And then he had an members of the town are
affair with this girl, Adeleida’s constantly on the look out for. It
mother, and he married her after appears that Bernarda ‘needles’
his second wife went made and Adeleida about this every time
died.’ that she visits and it is clear that
possession of this kind of
information has given Bernarda
some kind of hold over Adeleida
as she is anxious for the truth to
remain hidden.
137 As if she had a lizard between The sexual imagery here is used
her breasts to suggests Adela’s jittery nature
and her desire for Pepe.
138 “It really is strange how two This quotation reveals how
people who have never met restrictive the society is at the
suddenly see each other through time. People are not given an
a window grating and – just like opportunity to get to know their
that – they’re engaged!” future partner before agreeing to
marry them – everything is
arranged in advance so that
nothing inappropriate can
happen. The travelling to the
window for the first time also has
a symbolic or performative
aspect to it – it is more of a
gesture to the other townspeople
of the intention to marry rather
than a gesture of love. As such it
reinforces how many actions are
done for the sake of appearance
and how the town is watching
you all the time.
141 Why were you standing at the This quotation is clearly meant to
open window half naked? suggest Adela’s desire for Pepe
but also the rebellious and
unconstrained nature of her
character. It also reveals how
closely watched Adela is and
how nothing can escape
Poncia’s eyes.
142 “- I’d fight my mother, to put out Here Adela is being openly
this fire that rises from my legs honest with Poncia. The fire that
and mouth.” rises from her legs is referring to
her passion and desire for Pepe
and probably freedom in general
and an escape from the house.
155 “The breeding stallion, locked up The heat she refers to is the
and kicking the wall. Shackle passion and lust while ‘locked up’
him and let him out in the corral! suggests how little freedom the
He must be hot.” daughters have. Ironically
animals, however, are free.
162 “They are women without men, This quotation sums up their
that’s all.” continuous lust for sex in order to
claim a man and marry them to
be free.
165 “Stay away from that man!” Their passion to escape from the
house is so deep that their even
‘He loves me! He loves me!’ willing to betray their own sisters
in order to get out. The repletion
and exclamation also suggest
the extent of Adela’s fervor.
166 “Let my breast explode like a This release of anger shows how
bitter pomegranate!” much they long for passion or
some form of love but how, after
continually having to repress
these desires the daughters have
become bitter and rotten inside.
166 “If one of us has to drown, let her This quotation re-enforces how
drown! Pepe el Romano is mine!” badly the daughters want to
escape with a man that their
willing to sacrifice their own
sisters for a life of their own. The
idea of being carried away by a
river which is also mentioned
here suggests the uncontrollable
force of Adela’s passion.
Key Moment:
One key moment for the motif “Sex and Passion” is the end of Act three, where everything is in chaos. This
is the part where Adela hangs herself because she feared that Bernarda has killed Pepe. This was clearly
an act of passion, giving the audience a sense of how much Adela loved Pepe. Furthermore, Bernarda’s
announcement that “She died a virgin”. is important because it tells the audience that the whole play
revolves around rumors, gossip and the keeping up of appearances: Bernarda said this to protect the Alba
family name.
Another key moment is when Adela ‘bursts into angry tears’ on page 134 and says she ‘can’t be locked up!’
and she doesn’t want her ‘body to dry up like’ her sister’s and she doesn’t want to ‘waste away and grow
old in these rooms’. These quotations shows what all the other daughters are thinking, even though Adela
is the only daughter unafraid to speak out. The quotation suggests how the daughters don’t want to die
alone, or die a virgin or die without ever having felt love, but due to their surroundings and the way they’ve
grown up, it’s already too late for some of the daughters to change this.
She’s the only one who knows A clear example of how marriage
the true story of her father and is no longer special: now
how he got his land. Her father everybody marries just for the
killed his first wife’s husband in wealth or the land.
Cuba so he could marry her
himself. There, here, he deserted
her and ran off with another
woman who had a daughter. And
then he had an affair with this girl,
Adelaida’s mother, and he
married her after his second wife
went mad and died.
131 A wedding lasted ten days and Again we can see that weddings
wagging tongues were not the have changed. In the past there
fashion. Today, there is more seemed to be more celebration,
finesse, brides wear white veils
like in the big cities and we drink more happiness while today
bottled wine. there is more gossip.
132 Pepe el Romano wants to marry This reveals how men were the
Angustias. He was circling the ones in control in the patriarchal
house last night, and I think he’ll society of the time. In this image
send someone to ask for her we can almost literally see the
hand soon. picture of knight on horseback
coming to rescue a helpless
maiden. The women have no
control, no self determination,
they just have to wait until their
hand is asked for.
139 Anyway its best for single women Once again this makes it clear
like you to know that fifteen days that men do not marry for love. It
after the wedding, a man leaves also makes it clear that there are
the bed for the table, then the very different roles assigned to
table for the tavern. men and women – the man is
allowed, even expected, to go
out drinking with his friends while
the implication is that the woman
must stay at home
150 Why didn’t you let her marry When Bernada says “his father
Enrique Humanas? Why did you was a field hand” it reveals how
send him a message not to come concerned she is with
to her window, the very day he maintaining her position in
was coming? society and not allowing her
daughters to marry beneath
My blood will never mix with that themselves. It also makes it clear
of the Humanas family – not as how vicious Bernarda is and how
long as I live! His father was a concern for public appearance
field hand. can have destructive effects on
the individual as it is presumably
(at least partly) the
disappointment suffered with
Enrique Humanas that has
turned Martirio into the bitter
person she is.
156 Engagement rings are supposed The fact that the ring is not a
to be diamonds. diamond (for strength) but a pearl
(for tears) foreshadows the
unhappy results of Pepeand
Angustias’ marriage.
The dragging of the daughter of Librada - “Mirror image of Adela” “Recalls Christ’s walk to calvary”
Title Text & Presentation, 2012
Volume 9 of The Comparative Drama Conference
Series
Editor Graley Herren
Edition illustrated
Publisher McFarland, 2012
ISBN 0786471093, 9780786471096