Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Abstract—This work reports about the Taguchi approach for models and analyses cannot provide accurate process
parametric optimization for WEDM parameters like peak prediction for better quality control and higher throughput [2].
current, pulse on time and pulse off time for material removal Hence, an efficient method is needed to determine the optimal
rate, kerf width and surface roughness. Experiments were machining parameters.
designed and planned using Taguchi L-9 orthogonal array. In the case of WEDM, the most significant performance
Signal-to-Noise ratios have been calculated from experimental
observations. The significant parameters that critically influence
indicators are metal removal rate (MRR), Kerf width and
the machining characteristics were examined by ANOVA. A surface finish. In WEDM, because it is a complex a stochastic
mathematical model is developed for predicting the response process, it is very difficult to determine the optimal machining
quality using regression analysis. Further experiments were parameters for the best machining performance. Moreover, the
conducted with optimized parameters to authenticate the performance measures, namely MRR, Kf and Ra, are
usefulness of proposed investigation. The confirmation conflicting in nature as it is desirable to have higher MRR with
experiment result shows that the model suggested by Taguchi’s lower value of kerf and surface roughness.
method is suitable for improving selected responses.
Index Terms—WEDM, DOE, ANOVA, Taguchi Method,
Wuyi Ming [3] conducted the experiments designed based
MRR, Surface Roughness, Kerf width.
on Taguchi method for processing off tungsten steel YG15 and
developed a linear model of MRR and 3D surface quality (Sq
I. INTRODUCTION and Sz). For SKH 57 high speed steel material, the effects of
Nontraditional manufacturing processes like Wire cut machining parameters under EDM were investigated by Yang
Electric Discharge Machining (WEDM) is used for precision Lin [4]. L18 orthogonal array by Taguchi method was
manufacturing of various industrial parts with closest proposed for experiments. Cryogenic treated AISI D2 tool steel
dimensional accuracy [1]. In WEDM process there is a was chosen by M.M. Dhobe [5] to optimize surface roughness
continuous moving wire between uptake pulley and down take after machining under WEDM. L9 orthogonal array was
pulley, the work is clamped on setup. When the conductive applied as a technique of DOE to plan experiment sequence
wire comes to the nearest point to work piece then the high and by signal to noise ratio, optimal parameters were contrived.
voltage produces an ionization channel in between, in the
second stage there will be a discharge of arc. This arc melts Kanlayasiri and Boonmung [6] have validated the model of
and evaporates the work metal. This sparking action will took surface roughness of DC 53 die steel, for which ANOVA
place over the periphery of wire electrode, and generates a shows that pulse-on time and pulse-peak current are significant
precise gap (kerf width) between two edges. Then the debris variables. Kiyak and Akir [7] have concluded that lower
generated by sparks will flushed away by a fluid known as die current and higher Pulse-off time on EDM produces a better
electric fluid, which carries the eroded particles. Throughout of surface finish on machining the tool steel (AISI P20), which is
process there won’t be any surface contact between wire and widely used in the production of mold and die. Hesam Shahali
work piece. So, without any upper limit of hardness any kind [8] have minimized surface roughness and white layer
of conductive material can be machined. With the advancement thickness of DIN 1.4542 stainless steel by signal to noise ratio
of NC technology, multi axis machining and submerged and micro GA optimization techniques under WEDM. The
machining, WEDM is one of the best alternative sometimes the discharge power and number of finish passes have
only alternative to implement. consecutively significant influence on the surface roughness
and thickness of the white layer.
In WEDM one of the most investigated research areas are
modelling and optimization as a result of which we have less A factorial design model was developed by Dan Scott to
production cost with improved job quality. In short, due to measure material removal rate and surface finish as a function
highly stochastic nature of process, the complicated of six different control parameters. Analysis of variance shows
interactions between process parameters, current analytical
that discharge current, pulse duration and pulse frequency were Chemical Composition of AISI D3 Material:
significant control factors for both MRR and SF while wire The compositional range for Cold-work tool steel D-3 is
speed, wire tension and dielectric flow rate were relatively provided in the table 1 given below.
insignificant.[9]
Shyam Lal and Sudhir kumar [10] have investigated the TABLE I. MATERIAL SPECIFICATION: COLD-WORK TOOL STEEL D-3.
order of significance of factors was pulse on time, pulse Element C Si Mn P S Cr Ti Fe
current, pulse off time and the wire drum speed on kerf width Value 2.01 0.67 0.35 0.023 0.025 11.41 0.3 B*
and surface roughness by ANOVA. The Taguchi-based grey *B= Balance.
relational analysis, a multi-response optimization technique, Different setting of three controlling factors such as peak
was used to find the optimal WEDM process parameter setting current, pulse on time and pulse off time were selected based
for Al7075/Al2O3/SiC hybrid composite, further converging on past literature. As literature review reveals that significance
the observation to MRR [11], pulse on time is the highest of wire tension and wire feed rate is least on chosen
contributing factor nearer to 50% and wire drum speed has the performance parameters more over considering machine
least significance. They found the optimum value of surface limitations values of wire tension and wire feed rate were kept
roughness nearer to 2.08 mm and the surface topography constant.
analysis [12] depicted that SR is high at high level of process
parameters setting. Liquid-like formation was observed in all A block of 150×50mm having thickness of 5mm was cut as
the SEM pictures. work piece and the angle of cut was vertical. After considering
machining conditions, out of several available controllable
Ergun Ekici [13] proposed a Taguchi method based input parameters on the wire EDM machine, following
optimization of MRR and SR for Al/B4C composites. The L18 parameters were selected with maximum feasible range.
experiments shows that the most effective WEDM parameters
to be pulse-on time (30.22%) for surface roughness and wire TABLE II. VARIABLE PARAMETER AND THEIR SELECTED LEVEL FOR
speed (83.20%) for material removal rate while wire tension EXPERIMENT
was ineffective. K.P.Somashekhar [14] applied Taguchi and
Symbol Control Factors Symbol Unit Level 1 Level 2 Level 3
Gray Rational Analysis (GRA) for finding optimum machining
condition. Over cut and MRR increases with capacitance and Peak
eventually surface will become rough. A Ip Amp. 3 4 5
Current
K.H. Ho and S.T. Newman [15] reviewed the research Pulse on
work from the inception to the development of die-sinking B Ton µs 16 32 48
Time
EDM within the past decade. However, several means of Pulse off
improving the machining performance commonly measured in C Toff µs 4 8 12
Time
terms of MRR, TWR and SR have been made with an
overwhelming research interest being paid to the metallurgical TABLE III. CONSTANT PARAMETERS (MACHINING CONDITION).
properties of EDMed part. Dielectric De-ionized water
M.S. Hewidy [16] investigated that the development of Dielectric Conductivity 38 mohs
mathematical models for correlating the inter-relationships of Wire Tension 1.2 kg
Work piece material Cold-work tool steel D-3
various WEDM machining parameters of Inconel 601 material
Wire Type Molybdenum 0.18 mm diameter
such as: peak current, duty factor, wire tension and water Flushing pressure 1.2 MPa
pressure on the metal removal rate, wear ratio and surface
roughness. S. Sarkar [17] investigated the features of trim
cutting operation of wire electrical discharge machining of ɤ- III. EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN
titanium aluminide. A second-order mathematical model, in The experimental studies were performed on CONCORD
terms of machining parameters, was developed for surface CNC wire EDM machine, model no DK-7720, manufactured
roughness, dimensional shift and cutting speed using response by Jian Nan Saitec NC Co Ltd. The electrode material used is
surface methodology (RSM). 0.18 mm diameter molybdenum wire and di-electric fluid used
II. MATERIALS AND METHODS is demineralized water.
In the investigation cold worked tool steel AISI D-3 was
the target work material with a molybdenum electrode of
diameter of 0.18mm. Table 1 shows the material related
properties.
AISI D3 steel is oil-quenched and contains 1.5 to 2.35% of
carbon and 12% of chromium. It contains additional carbon,
which increases wear resistance.
(d)
Figure 1. (a) Experimental equipment of Wire-cut Electric Discharge
Machine, (b) Zoom in view of cutting zone, (c) Cutting process, (d) The
workpiece samples produced.
(a)
Measurement of Response Parameters:
This study investigates the machining characteristics such
as material removal rate (MRR), kerf width (Kf) and Surface
Roughness (Ra). This is the most common key indicators used
by many manufacturers. Theoretically, material removal rate is
expressed as the ratio of the multiplications of kerf width with
work piece thickness and length of cutting to the cutting time.
MRR (mm3/min) = Kf × t × l … (1)
Where, Kf = Kerf width in mm, t = Thickness of Work
piece in mm and l = Cutting length in mm per unit time.
Kerf width is defined as the measure of amount of material
wasted during machining process; kerf determines the
dimensional accuracy of the finishing part. Here kerf width is
measured by Almicro toolmakers microscope, model no. KW-
900 (L.C. 0.01 to 0.005 mm with goniometer. Fixed
magnification 30x.) Surface Roughness measure as the
arithmetic average, Ra (µm). The Ra value, also known as
center line average (CLA) is obtained by averaging the height
(b) of the surface above and below the centre line. The Surface
roughness measured using a surface roughness tester from
Mitutoyo, Model: SJ 210.
IV. EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS AND MODELLING RESPONSE
VARIABLES
Experiments were performed according to DOE based L9
OA design, and results of desired responses are illustrated in
table 4. In this work statistical models have been developed to
predict MRR, Kf and Ra in the Wire EDM process. The
influence of input WEDM parameter Ip, Ton and Toff on the
selected response variable have been assessed. Due to non-
linear behavior of process a multiple linear regression models
were postulated in obtaining the relationship between process
parameters and response variables. [18]
To perform experiments in systematic manner, statistical
software Minitab17 is used for DOE and ANOVA analysis.
(c)
TABLE IV. FULL FACTORIAL L-9 ORTHOGONAL ARRAY OBSERVATION Ton 1 0.000134 0.000134 0.000134 12.31 0.072
TABLE SHOWING EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS. Toff 1 0.000016 0.000016 0.000016 1.49 0.346
Input Ip*Ton 1 0.000060 0.000060 0.000060 5.46 0.145
Output Parameters Ip*Toff 1 0.000007 0.000007 0.000007 0.63 0.510
Parameters
Ex. Ton*Toff 1 0.000007 0.000007 0.000007 0.63 0.510
S/N Kerf S/N MRR S/N
No. Ip Ton Toff Ra
ratio Width ratio (mm3/ ratio Error 2 0.000022 0.000022 0.000011
(A) (µs) (µs) (µm)
Ra (mm) Kf min) MRR Total 8 0.001058 0.001058
1 3 16 4 2.229 -6.96220 0.230 12.7654 4.100 12.7654 S=0.0033022, R-sq=97.94%, R-sq(adj)= 91.75%
(a)
(a)
(b)
(b)
(c)
Figure 2. Effects of Process Parameters on Material Removal Rate.
Regression Model
Multiple regression (MLR) models by regression analysis,
are suitable to formulate complicated problems with many
dependent and independent variables within a certain range. It
gives the relationship between independent variables and
out to estimate the surface roughness as a response. The (c)
Figure 3. Comparison between experimental and predicted values of
mathematical models suggested are as given in Eq. (2), (3) and MRR, Kf and Ra.
(4).
VI. CONFIRMATION EXPERIMENT Then the obtained optimal solution of this approach was
The results obtained by Taguchi’s design of experiments compared with validation tests. Minitab 17 used to analyze the
analysis are validated by conducting the confirmation variance of experimental data (ANOVA).
experiments. The experiments were conducted as per the The regression model has successfully predicted the result
optimized parameter combinations. The last stage in the that matches with the experimental values. Experimental
process is the confirmation. This is done by comparing results and present analysis confirm that the parameter levels
predicted values and the experimental result. Table 10 gives the obtained are useful for predicting the optimum combinations of
comparison between predicted values of roughness and S/N factors and corresponding responses for cold worked tool steel
ratio and trial results. The S/N ratio has been improved from D-3. Therefore, the cold worked tool steel D-3 can be widely
the initial machining parameter settings to that of optimum accepted worldwide as a standard material in manufacturing of
machining parameter combinations A3B2C1 (MRR), A2B1C3 forming tools to produce die castings, press tools in sheet metal
(Ra) and A3B3C1 (Kf). MRR increases as well as Ra and Kf industries, forging dies, etc.
are decreases. This shows that the approach used in this paper
is justified and provides corrective indication of improvement REFERENCES
in output parameters considerably.
[1] Ho, K. H., Newman, S. T., Rahimifard, S., and Allen, R. D. State of
The values of responses given by mathematical model and art in wire electrical discharge machining (WEDM). Int. J. Mach.
experiments are given in the below table for comparison, there Tools Mfg., 2004, 44, 1247–1259.
exists a close correction between experimented and predicted
values. Hence, it confirms the validity in applying the Taguchi [2] Warren Liao, T. and Chen, L. J. Manufacturing process modeling
and optimization based on multi-layer perceptron network. Trans.
method for selecting and optimizing machining parameters.
ASME, J. Mfg Sci. Engng, 1998, 120, 109.
TABLE XI. COMPARISON BETWEEN MATHEMATICAL MODEL RESULTS [3] Ming W, Zhang Z, Zhang G, Huang Y, Guo J, Chen Y. Multi-
AND EXPERIMENTAL OUTPUTS. objective optimization of 3D-surface topography of machining
Optimum YG15 in WEDM. Materials and Manufacturing Processes. 2014
May 4;29(5):514-25.
Mathematical Experimental Process
model model Error Parameters [4] Lin YC, Cheng CH, Su BL, Hwang LR. Machining characteristics
Response Goal and optimization of machining parameters of SKH 57 high-speed
(%) steel using electrical-discharge machining based on Taguchi
Ip Ton Toff method. Materials and Manufacturing Processes. 2006 Dec
Optimum S/N Optimum S/N (A) (µs) (µs) 1;21(8):922-9.
value ratio value ratio
[5] Dhobe MM, Chopde IK, Gogte CL. Optimization of wire electro
MRR discharge machining parameters for improving surface finish of
Maximize 5.0544 11.869 5.9751 15.526 15.48 5 32 4
(mm3/min) cryo-treated tool steel using DOE. Materials and Manufacturing
Processes. 2014 Dec 2;29(11-12):1381-6.
Kf
Minimize 0.2289 12.652 0.228 12.841 3.94 4 16 12
(mm) [6] Kanlayasiri K, Boonmung S. Effects of wire-EDM machining
variables on surface roughness of newly developed DC 53 die steel:
Ra Design of experiments and regression model. Journal of materials
Minimize 2.68762 -8.218 2.760 -8.818 2.62 5 48 4
(µm) processing technology. 2007 Oct 1;192:459-64.