Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
ZENA LIM, SHEHLA RUBAB, YIONG HUAK CHAN, AND ALEX V. LEVIN
● PURPOSE: To study the etiology and characteristics of genital cataracts was reported as 2.49 per 10 000 children
pediatric cataracts in a large sample from 1 institution. in the first year of life, increasing to 3.46 per 10 000 by 15
● DESIGN: Observational case series. years.3 In the United States, the incidence rate has been
● METHODS: The study population included 778 con- reported as 2.03 per 10 000 births.4 In a large cohort
secutive cases (1122 eyes) of children presenting with prospective study of 55 908 pregnancies in the United
any type of pediatric cataract over a 10-year period. States, the prevalence of infantile cataracts was reported as
Age at presentation, laterality, cataract morphology 13.6 per 10 000 infants.5
and etiology, and presence of strabismus were re- Data on the characteristics of pediatric cataracts are
corded. Association with systemic diseases or syn- useful for the purposes of diagnosis, genetic counseling, and
dromes and coexistent ocular anomalies were noted. selection of treatment options. Prevention strategies also
Snellen or Allen picture charts were used to record require information about etiology. Many studies that
visual acuity, when able.
examine variables other than overall aggregate incidence
● RESULTS: Unilateral cataract accounted for slightly
are restricted to small numbers of patients. At The Hos-
over half of the cases. The etiology was idiopathic in the
pital for Sick Children (HSC) in Toronto, we were able to
majority of patients. The most common systemic associ-
review a large, diverse cohort of patients under care during
ation was diseases with steroid treatment–induced cata-
racts. Cataracts, when associated with other isolated a 10-year period to better study the etiology and charac-
ocular anomalies, tended to occur unilaterally. Among teristics of pediatric cataracts.
syndrome-associated cataracts, Down syndrome repre-
sented a third of the cases. Posterior subcapsular cataract
was the most common morphologic type. Almost half of
METHODS
the patients presented with Snellen 6/9 or better or
“central, steady, maintained” vision where it was not WE RETROSPECTIVELY REVIEWED THE HEALTH RECORDS OF
possible to obtain quantitative vision data. all patients who presented at HSC from January 1, 1992
● CONCLUSIONS: Despite the diverse nature of cases with
through December 31, 2002 with any type of cataract
frequent systemic associations, unilateral cataracts and id- cared for by the senior author, Dr Alex Levin, or another
iopathic etiology accounted for the majority of cases. (Am ophthalmologist (Dr David Rootman), who managed all
J Ophthalmol 2010;149:887– 892. © 2010 by Elsevier Inc.
the childhood cataract cases at our hospital during that
All rights reserved.)
time period. Patients who required surgical intervention
were identified using the hospital surgical data program
C
ATARACT IS A MAJOR PREVENTABLE CAUSE OF
Surgiserver (McKesson Corporation, San Francisco, Cali-
childhood visual impairment and blindness in the
world. Its prevalence has been reported as 1 to 15 fornia, USA). Those who were managed without surgery
per 10 000 children.1 In developed countries, the preva- were identified from the outpatient billing records of the
lence of blindness from childhood cataracts is 0.1 to 0.4 per Department of Ophthalmology and Vision Sciences as well
10 000 children and approximately 10 times more in as the clinical database of patients seen by Dr Levin. For
developing countries.1 Globally, an estimated 200 000 billing purposes, cataract types and related conditions were
children are bilaterally blind from cataracts.2 coded using the International Classification of Diseases,
Most of what is known about the epidemiology of Ninth Revision, Clinical Modification (ICD-9-CM). The
childhood cataracts is restricted to studies of congenital following codes were utilized for case identification
cataracts. In the United Kingdom, the incidence of con- through the billing records: infantile cataract (366.0),
congenital cataract and lens anomalies (743.3), and apha-
kia and other disorders of lens (379.3).
Accepted for publication Jan 5, 2010. Individual case records were reviewed to confirm the
From the Department of Ophthalmology and Vision Sciences, The
Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto, Canada (Z.L., S.R., A.V.L.); and
presence of cataracts. Patients who had cataracts prior to
the Biostatistics Unit, Yong Loo Lin School of Medicine, National January 1, 1992, with or without surgery, but who received
University of Singapore, Singapore (Y.H.C.). subsequent care during the 10-year interval of interest,
Inquiries to Dr Alex V. Levin, Chief, Pediatric Ophthalmology and
Ocular Genetics, Wills Eye Institute, 840 Walnut St, Philadelphia, PA were also included. Data were entered into SPSS for
19107-5109; e-mail: alevin@willseye.org Windows version 12.0 statistical software (SPSS Inc,
Number of Patients
Etiology (n ⫽ 778) [%]
RESULTS
Where specific disease patterns could not be identified,
A TOTAL OF 1122 EYES IN 778 CHILDREN WERE IDENTIFIED. isolated central nervous system anomalies such as micro-
55.5% (432/778) had unilateral cataracts. The right eye cephaly, ventriculomegaly, and sensorineural hearing loss
was involved in 25.4% (198/778) of cases and the left in were most likely to be associated with cataracts (Table 3).
30.0% (234/778) of cases, with the remaining 44.5% Of the syndromes observed with cataracts, Down syn-
(346/778) bilaterally involved. Males comprised 56.2% drome comprised almost a third of cases (Table 4). The
(437/778) of patients. The median age at presentation was median age at presentation of these 18 children was 2.0
42.0 months. months. A third (6/18) had dense total or near-total
The most common diagnostic classification was idio- cataracts, followed next by posterior subcapsular (18.2%
pathic (58.2% [453/778]), followed by traumatic (12.9% [3/18]) and nuclear (15.2% [2/18]) cataracts. The majority
[100/778]) and inherited (11.7% [91/778]) cataracts (Ta- (72.2% [13/18]) had bilateral cataracts. Sixteen of the 18
ble 1). As a group, the most common systemic associations patients (88.9%) required cataract surgery, with a median
were diseases with steroid treatment–induced cataracts age at surgery of 3.3 months. Ten patients (55.6%) had
(44.2% [57/129]) and juvenile idiopathic arthritis (18.6% strabismus. Six (33.3%) had other ocular anomalies.
[24/129]) (Table 2). Of the 68 patients who were on For cataracts associated with all syndromes, 70.0%
steroids, 54.4% (37/68) were on systemic steroids only, (39/56) were bilateral (P ⬍ .001, odds ratio 3.2).
16.2% (11/68) on topical steroids only, and the remaining A total of 84.0% (942/1122) of eyes had a record of
29.4% (20/68) were on both. There were 11 cases of cataract morphology. The most common type of cataract
congenital infections, with rubella the etiology in 6 cases. was posterior subcapsular cataract, of which 22.6% (79/
Among isolated cataracts, 61.9% (280/453) were uni- 349) were related to steroid usage. Table 5 depicts the
lateral (P ⬍ .001, odds ratio 1.9). Among bilateral cases, frequency distribution of the various morphologic types of
50.9% (176/346) were isolated. Among cases with a cataracts. Of the 778 children studied, in 9.2% (32/346) of
systemic cause other than syndromes, only 36.0% (46/129) bilateral cases the morphology was not concordant be-
were unilateral (P ⬍ .001, odds ratio 2.4). For those with tween the 2 eyes.
a family history, 82.4% (75/91) were bilateral (P ⬍ .001, The prevalence of strabismus in our series was 21.5%
odds ratio 7.2). (167/778). When comparing presence of strabismus in
A total of 73.7% (73/99) of cataracts associated with patients with unilateral versus bilateral cataracts, almost
other isolated ocular anomalies occurred unilaterally. Per- two thirds (61.7% [103/167]) with strabismus had unilat-
sistent fetal vasculature (PFV) accounted for 10.6% (46/ eral cataracts (P ⫽ .066). Of those with strabismus
432) of all unilateral and 1.7% (6/346) of all bilateral preoperatively or postoperatively, 13.2% (22/167) had
cases. Overall, there were 6 cases of bilateral PFV among PFV, compared to 5.7% (3/52) with PFV without strabis-
the 52 PFV-associated cataract cases (11.5%). mus (P ⬍ .0001).
Type of Cataract Right Eye (n ⫽ 470) [%] Left Eye (n ⫽ 468) [%]
Posterior subcapsular 170 [36.2]; 43 occurred in patients on oral or 179 [38.2]; 36 occurred in patients on oral or
topical steroids (includes patients with iritis) topical steroids (includes patients with iritis)
Total 102 [21.7] 95 [20.3]
Nuclear 75 [16.0] 72 [15.4]
Anterior polar (dot, traction congenital iris 43 [9.1] 45 [9.6]
strand, anterior lenticonus, anterior
subcapsular, and pyramidal)
Lamellar 28 [6.0] 22 [4.7]
Cortical 24 [5.1] 28 [6.0]
Othera 20 [4.3] 18 [3.8]
Pulverulent 8 [1.7] 9 [1.9]
a
Includes traumatic, sutural, cuneiform, oil droplet, zonular.
Presenting vision levels are depicted (Figure). The various protocols for systemic investigation. Perhaps more
majority presented with Snellen 6/9 or better vision important is the appropriate screening for cataracts in pa-
(21.2% [165/778]) and CSM vision (27.8% [216/778]), tients at risk because of family history, systemic disease or
which was obtained in the younger patients when quanti- treatment known to be associated with cataract.
tative measures of vision could not be used. Another affected family member was found in 11.7%
(91/778) of our cases. An Australian study found familial
cases accounting for one fifth of congenital and pediatric
DISCUSSION cataracts.8 The Danish study found the incidence of
hereditary cataracts to be 23% of congenital/infantile
SLIGHTLY OVER HALF OF THE CATARACTS IN OUR STUDY
cases.6 A study in the United Kingdom found 56% of
(55.5% [432/778]) were unilateral. One study found that bilateral cases and 6% of unilateral cases associated with
overall, 47% of cases were unilateral, although isolated
hereditary disease, although these figures included cases
cataracts were more often unilateral whereas infants with
with associated systemic disorder as well as those with
multiple defects or syndromes more often had bilateral
multi-system dysmorphic syndromes.9 We are uncertain as
cataracts.4 Another study found a lower unilaterality rate
to why our incidence of genetic cataracts was lower than
of 36.4%.6 Our larger data set suggests a higher incidence
other studies. Some of our idiopathic cataracts will likely
of unilateral cataract perhaps because we included nonsur-
be heritable but remain unrecognized as such until future
gical cases.
generations with affected individuals arise or molecular ge-
Slightly over half of our patients had cataracts of
netic testing becomes commonly available for clinical use.
unknown etiology despite examination of their parents and
siblings and, where indicated, laboratory investigations. Where associated with systemic disease, we found that
We do not do extensive routine systemic investigations, more than half of cataracts were steroid-induced or other-
although infectious, metabolic, and/or genetic testing were wise iatrogenic (eg, radiation). The next most common
pursued when there were other clinical indicators. A cause was juvenile idiopathic arthritis–associated iritis,
Danish epidemiologic study of congenital/infantile cata- although some of these cataracts may have been steroid-
racts found the proportion of idiopathic cases to be 63%.6 induced as well. Studies have not clearly established a
Others state that at least 50% of bilateral cataracts and an relationship between the incidence of cataracts and the
even higher percentage of unilateral infantile cataracts are dosage or duration of steroid therapy.10,11 Uveitis itself can
idiopathic.7 As The Hospital for Sick Children in Toronto also cause cataract and often the relative contribution of
is a regional tertiary and quaternary center for pediatrics, it the iritis versus the steroids is impossible to determine.
may be the preponderance of other systemic and ocular With regard to intrauterine infection–associated cases,
diagnoses that diluted the incidence figures for our “iso- implementation of rubella immunization has likely re-
lated inherited cataracts” group. sulted in our very low reported numbers of infection-
Idiopathic cataract is a diagnosis of exclusion. A metabolic associated cataracts, even though rubella still accounted
and genetic examination tailored, with the assistance of a for the majority of cases, with the next most common
pediatrician, according to the medical and developmental being cytomegalovirus infection.
history may be indicated when there are no other clear Where associated with isolated ocular anomalies, uni-
etiologic factors (eg, trauma, ocular malformation syn- lateral cataracts comprised almost three quarters of cases.
dromes). Our study was not designed to examine the utility of In the United Kingdom study of associated factors in
THIS STUDY WAS SUPPORTED IN PART BY BRANDAN’S EYE RESEARCH FUND, VAUGHAN, ONTARIO, CANADA. HOWEVER, THE
funding organization had no role in the design or conduct of this research. None of the authors has any financial or conflicting interests to disclose.
Involved in design of study (Z.L., S.R., A.V.L.); conduct of study (Z.L., S.R., A.V.L.); collection (Z.L., S.R.), management (Z.L.), analysis (Z.L., Y.H.C.),
and interpretation of data (Z.L., Y.H.C., A.V.L.); and preparation (Z.L., A.V.L.), review (A.V.L.), and approval of manuscript (Z.L., S.R., Y.H.C.,
A.V.L.). This study was approved by the Research Ethics Board of The Hospital for Sick Children (HSC), Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
From Ferris FL III, Kassoff A, Bresnick GH, Bailey I. New visual acuity charts for clinical research. Am J Ophthalmol 1982;94:91–96.