Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Development of the Discipline “The diverse traditions of political science” Approaches to Research ‘dominant paradigms’
Problem: Political science had a “lack of distinct core” as a discipline Behavioralism
Neo-Institutionalism gave a clearer disciplinary identity - uses Dominant in 50s-60s
the framework of patterns, routine, and rules (Crouch 2005, p.2) Formed out of discontent with old-institutionalism
Political science was strongly developed in the USA. Systematic (mass surveys and sampling techniques)
80s - 80% of world’s political scientists were Americans Reaction against behavioralism
American Political Science Association (APSA) - 7,000 Failed with goals
delegates Undue emphasis on process
American contributions: arguments for European integration Ideologies penetrated polsc
(Wallace), theories in IR (Smith) Institutionalism
Early developments in US Institutions do matter (March and Olsen)
20s - ‘protobehavioral revolution’ - ‘reacting against the New Institutionalism
formal-legal-historical approach’ (Monroe) Normative Institutionalism
Other European countries: Historical institutionalism
France - “political science played played a very modest part in Rational choice institutionalism
its teaching… law and history, as well as economics dominated Rational/Public Choice
the syllabus” (Hayward) Psychology of decision making (Monroe)
Similar in Italy Contributions: Down’s Median Voter Theorem
Spain - restricted political scientists because of the threat to the Construtivism
regime, sociology was more welcomed (Clifton) IR - challenge to realism
Greece - no polsc depts before the fall of the Colonels’ regime 3 Checks for controlled eclecticism
in 1974 (Kakepaki and Sotiropoulos) Parsimony
Germany - dominance of abstract and theoretical traditions over Commensurability
empirical study of politics (Saalfeld) Coherence
Belgium - political science is split on linguistic lines
Denmark - 1st polsc dept 1959 ‘Political studies or science: methodological considerations’
Positivism (variant of Empiricism) - knowledge is gained from human
sense experience (inductive reasoning)
Objective
Responses:
Neo Positivism
Casambre
Conventionalism
Critical realism Lecture 3: Weberian Concepts, p. 17-22