Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 34

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines

The outpatient journey

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
Contents
. Introduction  This guidelines document was produced for
the Department of Human Services as part
. The six steps: process to improve hospital wayfinding for clinics 
of the Victorian Outpatient Improvement
. Step  Establish a case for investigation 
Strategy and was auspiced by the Outpatient
. Step  Is there a wayfinding problem? 
Experience Sub-Committee.
. Step  Review existing wayfinding system: gaps 
. Step  Business case development 
. Step  Develop wayfinding solution for outpatients 
. Step  Implementation 
. The patient journey: core principles 
. Mapping the patient journey 
. Setting expectations 
. Core wayfinding principles for outpatient wayfinding 
. Wayfinding design guidelines 
. Non-sign elements 
. Deciding on sign content 
. Graphic design of signs 
. Wayfinding system for visits to specialist clinics 
. Appointment: verbal instructions at GP offices 
. Appointment letter from hospital 
. Hospital site entrance 
. Car park directional 
. Building entrance (interior) 
. Liftwell directory 
. Key internal decision point 
. Hub destination arrival 
. Clinic name 
. Sub-destinations 
. Appendices 
. Appendix : what is wayfinding? 
. Appendix : benefits of good wayfinding 

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. Introduction
This guidelines document is intended to What is wayfinding? How to use this guidelines document Existing hospitals:
assist public hospitals in Victoria improve
Wayfinding is the system that assists Who should read this document: Even hospitals with existing investment in
the experience of patients visiting specialist
patients to find their way from one place to signage or other wayfinding systems can
clinics within the hospital grounds (known Anyone responsible for managing patient
another, often through a complex or new benefit from this guidelines document. All
within the medical fraternity as outpatient experience or outcomes, hospital capital
environment. A professional wayfinding hospitals can go through the Six Steps process
departments or clinics). works, or building management in Victoria’s
system will identify the most effective way which helps identify the wayfinding problems
public hospitals, particularly in outpatient
Why focus on specialist clinics? to direct people through a space, based and provides a means to make the business
departments or clinics.
on research evidence collected from the decision on future wayfinding investment. In
Outpatient visits constitute a large proportion
particular space it relates to. The tools to Principles not prescription: some cases, that may mean small changes to
of total patient visits to hospitals – anywhere
assist people in wayfinding can include: This document is intended as a set of an existing system, in others it might mean
from – of total patient visits, depending
– Printed information guidelines to assist hospitals to improve the a wholesale replacement of the existing
on the hospital. Specialist clinics are therefore
– Architectural features and design elements experience of patients finding their way to a system.
key destinations within hospitals, and have
– Permanent signage specialist clinic appointment in the hospital.
a large impact on the overall impression of Greenfields sites:
– Digital devices (e.g. kiosks or information
service that patients have of their public It is not to be read as a specific prescription
screens) New hospitals should engage the services
hospitals. for an individual hospital, but rather as a set
– Human interactions (e.g. with information of a wayfinding consultant as part of the
officers) of principles to be adapted to each unique
Note: the recommendations in this document briefing process to the architect, to ensure
hospital.
relate to the specialist clinic wayfinding See chapter , page  and appendix , page the hospital design takes into account good
experience only.  for more detail on wayfinding definitions. wayfinding principles. The chapters on the
patient experience and wayfinding principles
Wayfinding matters and design should be provided to the
architects and wayfinding consultants as a
Patient experience is emerging as an
guide to their recommendations.
important factor in overall patient
satisfaction. Poor wayfinding systems
can increase anxiety, confusion and
dissatisfaction with a person’s hospital
experience. Inadequate wayfinding systems
can also represent a significant hidden cost to
a hospital, often in the form of lost time from
staff members giving directions to visitors or
appointment delays.
The complexity of many hospital sites,
combined with the locations of clinics and
the varied mobility and cognitive needs
of many patients, gives rise to a need for
improving patient wayfinding in many of
Victoria’s public hospitals.

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. The six steps: process to improve hospital wayfinding for clinics
The following six steps take you through
a process to improve patient wayfinding
for outpatient visits to existing hospitals
     
in Victoria. Wayfinding is about taking an Establish case for Is there a wayfinding Review existing Business case Develop wayfinding Implementation
evidenced-based approach to assist people investigation problem? wayfinding development solution
to move through complex spaces with the system: gaps
minimum confusion. We strongly recommend
you follow each step in sequence to improve Take the quiz: Simple sites can Review your hospital’s The outcomes of steps Use the problem Execute the
the final outcome. How complex is undertake a self- current signage – will help reveal assessment to develop wayfinding solution:
your hospital? assessment using: against the principles whether the problems wayfinding solutions – Pilot new signage
– Anecdotes from outlined in this identified are for your site. in specific area of
A quick self-
front office guidelines document. sufficient to justify an the hospital
assessment using the For example:
– Patient complaints investment in making – Roll out to all
complexity diagnosis An example checklist – Identify key
– Simple observation changes to your relevant areas
will help identify a for self-assessment is destination hubs
hospital’s wayfinding – Monitor and review
‘prima facie’, or first Complex sites require provided on page  for outpatients
system wayfinding system
cut, case for further a more detailed – Review the
over time
exploring wayfinding evidence-base and appointment
in your hospital the services of a letter template
wayfinding consultant: against the
– Traffic analysis standards outlined
– Observational in this guidelines
research document

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. The six steps: process to improve hospital wayfinding for clinics

Step  Establish a case for investigation

A quick self assessment using the complexity How complex is your hospital site for wayfinding? How did your hospital rate?
diagnosis on this page will help identify a ‘prima
The answers you provide to the following questions about your hospital will help determine how Scored  points or less: simple site
facie’, or first cut, case for further exploring
simple or complex the site is in terms of wayfinding
wayfinding in your hospital Your hospital site is a relatively simple. First time
visitors may not need assistance to find their
Question  points  point Your score way around your hospital.
Scored more than  points: complex site
 Is your hospital located No – on a single site Yes – on two or
Your hospital is a complex site. Wayfinding is
on multiple sites? more sites
likely to be more difficult and most first time
visitors are likely to require assistance to find
 Does your hospital No – one main building Yes – two or more their way in and around your hospital.
campus have multiple and possibly some main buildings
main buildings? smaller outer buildings

 Is your hospital located No – the site is flat Yes – on a sloping site


on a sloping site?

 Does your hospital have No – only one carpark Yes – multiple carparks
multiple car parks?

 Does your hospital have No – one clear Yes – more than one
multiple entrances (not patient entrance patient entrance
including Emergency)

 Is the key clinic reception No – less than m Yes – more than
close to the main walk or in line of sight m walk or with
hospital entrance? of main entrance multiple intersections
on the journey

 Are there multiple No – one location Yes – multiple clinic


clinic areas? for all specialist areas (e.g. clinics on
clinics / outpatients different areas)

Total

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. The six steps: process to improve hospital wayfinding for clinics

Step  Is there a wayfinding problem?

A wayfinding problem exists when the existing Complex sites: more detailed evidence-base Example of data collection:
wayfinding system (whether deliberately
Sites identified as complex (from step one
devised or built up through ad-hoc growth)
above) should consider engaging an external – Interview a sample of  hospital staff
is inadequate for patient needs, and fails to
wayfinding consultant to help establish a e.g Medical, Nursing, Clerical.
assist people to find their way to their clinic
fact base to assist in decision making about – Rank the number of Direction Giving
appointment.
wayfinding investment. Incidences (DGI) to various locations, e.g
The following tools can be used to help identify specialist clinics, emergency, wards, car park,
Activities that should be considered include:
the extent of your hospital’s wayfinding exit, lifts, cafe, pathology, medical imaging,
– Patient complaint analysis (as mentioned
problems. etc.
in simple site section above)
– Result:  DGIs to specialist clinics per day,
Simple sites: quick self-assessment – Observational research – depending
e.g  x average  minute interruption =
on the site, this research may involve a
Sites identified as simple (from Step ) can  minutes per day =  hours per year in
consultant observing visitors to a space, and
use existing sources of information within the wasted staff hours.
identifying their initial natural choices of
hospital and collect objective data about the
direction. Professional observation of human
nature of any wayfinding problem. Possible
behaviour often points to specific wayfinding
sources include:
problems in a space.
– Traffic analysis – by collecting data of the
– Anecdotes from front office - talk to the
total number of journeys taken through
information office / reception clerks about
specific spaces, the wayfinding consultant
the number of people who ask for directions
can identify critical decision points and build
to an outpatient clinic each day or week.
a case for wayfinding investment.
Ask them to record the requests on a sheet
– Data collection of ‘Direction-Giving
of paper for a week to establish a baseline
Incidents’ - identifying how many times
number of requests.
per day/week/month site visitors are asking
passers-by for directions. This information
– Patient complaint analysis - other officers
can uncover hidden costs in staff time,
in the hospital may be responsible for
missed appointments and other internal (and
collecting and tracking patient complaints.
avoidable) operational costs.
Sift through this information in relation
to issues that may be caused by a poor
wayfinding system, such as finding their way,
being late for appointments, expectations
about waiting, confusion about the process,
etc.

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. The six steps: process to improve hospital wayfinding for clinics

Step  Review existing wayfinding system: gaps

In constantly seeking to deliver best practice Wayfinding design self-assessment checklist Yes No
systems to the public, the hospital should
do a quick internal review of its existing . Does the appointment letter present time and place information
wayfinding system against the proposed clearly as indicated on page ?
wayfinding system for specialist clinics
(outpatient clinics) detailed in Chapter  of . Does the appointment letter clearly set the key expectations
this guidelines document. of patients relevant to the hospital in question?
The process can include collection of samples . Are carpark entrances identified clearly with numbers or letters
of existing appointment letters and taking for multiple entrance sites?
photos of existing signage along the patient
journey to and from a specialist clinic in the . Where there are multiple buildings on a site, are they labelled
hospital. with easy to understand and sequential numbers or letters,
or architecturally relevant descriptions to assist wayfinding?
This evidence can then be compared with the
standards in this document. . Do the major signs at building entrance identify only the
The checklist in this section can be used key destination hubs?
to assist the process of assessment. If you
answer ‘no’ to three or more of the questions, . Can you identify the – major hubs / receptions in the hospital
then there is a case to make changes to the on focus signage in these areas?
existing wayfinding system.
. Is the typography on signs legible and appropriately sized
for the viewing distance?

. Is the colour and contrast used sufficient to provide legibility


for low vision visitors?

. Do key decision points in the hospital only provide information


on the key destinations (e.g are there too many signs irrelevant
to the major journeys)?

. Are signs labelled with the appropriate content and naming
conventions?

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. The six steps: process to improve hospital wayfinding for clinics

Step  Business case development

The outcomes of steps – will help decision- Case study: Austin Hospital
makers identify whether the problems identified
About one year after the opening of new
are sufficient to justify an investment in making
facilities at both the Austin Hospital and the
changes to the particular hospital’s wayfinding
Mercy Hospital for Women, Austin Health
system. A business case will likely be required to
management and Major Projects Victoria
demonstrate and seek approval for wayfinding
remained concerned by ongoing wayfinding
investment.
problems caused by the size and complexity of
A typical business case might cover: the site.
Wayfinding consultants were engaged to
– Current costs of existing wayfinding system undertake a detailed analysis of these issues.
– costs of Direction Giving Incidents The analysis demonstrated that the existing
– estimated total visits wayfinding provision was costing the hospital
– estimated missed appointments due a significant amount each year in missed
to wayfinding errors appointments and staff time spent giving
– summation of total potential hidden costs directions.
– Evidence of negative impact on patient
Problems were identified using specific survey
experience - complaints and anecdotal
tools, and a plan was developed to improve
evidence
patient wayfinding.
– Need for aligning wayfinding system with
best practice and quality systems (ISO ) The first phase of the wayfinding strategy
– Best practice case studies for complex public focused on the confusing vertical circulation
environments and the ‘legibility’ of primary pathways. The
– Wayfinding system improvements – effect on patient and visitor experience, as well
costs/benefits of the two options: as staff efficiency and job satisfaction, has been
– Outpatient clinic experience only within a significant. The changes made created a 
legacy system reduction in complaints about wayfinding.
– Complete hospital wayfinding
“The most urgent of these recommendations have
redevelopment
just been implemented and the improvements
are astonishing! It is clear that wayfinding is not
signage, but a holistic view of navigation and
human behaviour”.
– Megan Gray,
Manager, Capital Works and Infrastructure

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. The six steps: process to improve hospital wayfinding for clinics

Step  Develop wayfinding solution for outpatients

For simple sites, hospital staff can conduct A typical process a wayfinding consultant
their own review of the outpatient journey may follow includes:
and identify changes that need to be made, – Problem assessment (as described in steps
using the wayfinding system outlined in  and  above)
Chapters  and . – Review of existing wayfinding system to
We recommend for complex sites that an identify gaps compared with best practice
– Development of the business case for
external wayfinding consultant is appointed.
investment in wayfinding
A good reason to appoint independent – Mapping the journeys of patients to the
professionals is that they will put forward a specialist clinics
plan that minimises the total number of – Development of recommendations on new
signs required. wayfinding elements, and which elements to
remove (e.g. existing signage)
– Identification of key destination hubs for
outpatient visits, and appropriate labelling

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. The six steps: process to improve hospital wayfinding for clinics

Step  Implementation

In large hospitals, it may be preferable to


pilot the new signage in a specific area of
the hospital for one specialist clinic, and
pending the results, roll-out new signage to
all relevant areas in the hospital.
Implementation of the wayfinding solution
may require redesign of the appointment
letter, and testing this with patients in terms
of its clarity and usefulness.
Note: this guidelines document covers
only the specialist clinic (or outpatient)
wayfinding journey. Hospitals should
consider how these principles apply to
outpatient areas only, but they may have
implications for the wayfinding in other parts
of the hospital. Separate whole-of-hospital
wayfinding guidelines and standards should
be sought for the design of wayfiding across
the entire hospital.

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. The patient journey: core principles
What is the patient journey?
The patient journey encompasses the complete Although each patient is different, the
experience a patient encounters from referral to outpatient journey follows a predictable process.
follow-up. The typical stages are:

Patient Stage GP referral Notification Appointment Tests required Physical Arrival and Appointment Follow-up
of referral letter from prior to journey to wait
hospital appointment the clinic
What patients Why am I being How it works, why, When, where, why, When, where and How do I get there? When will I be Medical instructions, What should I
need to know referred? how long likely, next expectations what’s expected What’s expected? called? What can actions do next? Next
step I do while I am appointment
waiting?
Process GP contacts Acknowledge- Appointment letter Tests: MI, Pathology, Patient arranges for Clerk takes time of Name called in a) reviewed
outpatient ment of referral; generated and sent; etc. Internal or transport, assistance, arrival and details waiting room; taken
b) discharged
department, data Letter generated call made if within external to hospital interpreter, time off to consulting room;
entered, triaged by and sent one week of referral work, etc. may be baseline c) possible further
clinician observations; sees tests: radiology,
specialist pathology, ECG, etc.

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. The patient journey: core principles

. Mapping the patient journey

Example: Metro Hospital consultation journey

Metro
Health

m m m

m m m m m

Depart from home Enter Hospital Turn left then right Park car in Carpark Enter Central Turn right then Take lift to Level Turn right then Arrive at Arrive at
by car. site via Rose St towards Carpark B B. Walk towards Tower via South left towards lifts, , following right following Reception C. Consultation.
Entrance. following carpark building. Entrance. following internal lift directory to internal
Find Metro directional signs. directional signs to Receptions A–D. directional signs to Present
Hospital, Rose St Find Carpark B Find South Entrance Find Reception C Receptions A–D. Receptions A–C. Appointment letter,
Entrance (based (based on Parking limitations? on Central tower (based on remain in waiting
on instructions on instructions on building (based instructions on Walk past area until called.
Appointment letter). Appointment letter). on instructions on Appointment letter). Receptions A and B
Appointment letter). Nurse calls name
and room.

* This document uses the fictitious ‘Metro Hospital’ as a sample hospital for illustrative purposes

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. The patient journey: core principles

. Setting expectations

Customer satisfaction research indicates that


one of the keys to improving satisfaction is Patient question Content of answer Method of communication
setting appropriate expectations prior to
the experience. Patient research indicates Where do I go? Standard way-finding instructions – Appointment letter
that patients have a range of questions [warn of distance if it will be an issue] – On signage
throughout their journey. This table indicates
general content and the different channels When do I go there? Clear date and time – Appointment letter
that can be used to communicate answers to
How long will it take? Estimated duration range: – In an appointment letter
these questions to optimally set expectations
may be expressed as a time range (e.g. - hours) – Verbal updates at clinic reception
of an outpatient visit.
– Possibly on signage

What preparation do I need? Relevant to visit: – Appointment letter


e.g. for initial consultation, mention there is no need to fast

What do I need to bring? X-rays, appointment card, medicare card... – Appointment letter

What is the purpose of the visit? What I’m being treated for – GP or specialist verbal advice
What stage this is – Appointment letter
The type of visit, e.g. consultation with a doctor for diagnostic purpose
Whether surgery or procedure will be done on the day

How much will it cost? Public hospital – no charge – Verbal on request

What can I expect the Typical process of diagnosis, treatment plan, treatment, follow-up – Specialist verbal advice in at
next stage to be? a consultation

Who will see me? An individual doctor’s name if possible, or the nature of the specialist – Specialist or GP verbal advice

 Churchill, Surprenant
‘An Investigation into the Determinants of Customer Satisfaction’,
Journal of Marketing Research Vol 
 GSG patient research, selected Victorian hospital Outpatient Clinics, 

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. The patient journey: core principles

. Core wayfinding principles for outpatient wayfinding

   
Design for everyone – Address paradigm Use of key hubs Naming of destinations
including people with difficulties
To improve patients’ ability to find their way A key to simplifying a complex journey is to The term Reception has universal
Wayfinding needs to be designed for to a specialist clinic, wayfinding should use a break the hospital down into key ‘destination’ understanding and should be used to identify
everyone – including for people who have generic and standardized information system hubs that can be well sign-posted, with key outpatient hubs within the hospital.
the most difficulty in finding their way. These that treats destinations as ‘addresses’. secondary destinations indicated once a
A wayfinding system should use generic
people are more likely: hub is reached. Outpatient departments
Complex journeys can be broken up by and sequential labels and reduce medical
– To be first time visitors can effectively be broken down into a few
directing patients first to key navigation terminology so that it is well-understood
– To be elderly key destination hubs, based on total visitor
– To have limited English
points, then supplying secondary navigation by the general (uninformed) public.
numbers, rather than multiple destinations
– To have vision impairment or mobility issues information to find a specific location
across the entire hospital. Therefore, the word outpatient should not be
(start broad, then zoom in). A hierarchy of
used as a primary navigation word within the
information will use the minimum amount Therefore, not all destinations in a hospital
wayfinding system. As a transition, the word
of information and reveal more details on a need to have signage at key entrances.
‘outpatients’ can be used as a secondary label
‘need to know’ basis. This system is useful At each journey decision point, only
beneath the primary hub label of “Reception”.
because people generally only remember the destinations that ‘break off’ from the main
last couple of instructions in a journey. path need to be listed.
Wayfinding instructions should only include a
direction where there are multiple choices at
a decision point in the journey.

Rationale for avoiding the word “outpatient”


in a wayfinding system.
De-clutter!
Wayfinding is easiest if destinations within
A clear wayfinding system communicates the hospitals are named for the patient who is
minimum required for a smooth journey, and uninformed or has a low level of English. The
nothing more. That means signage should be in term “outpatients”:
spaces clear of other communications or visual
– Is unneccessary and confusing for wayfinding
clutter. Remove temporary posters, words or
purposes, as it can refer to multiple different
pictures in the vicinity of wayfinding signage.
destinations in the hospital.
Hospitals may need to allocate a role of
– Is not understood by the majority of
wayfinding management which involves
new patients.
removal of unnecessary posters, signs and
communications that distract from the core – Has a meaning that varies across hospitals, and
wayfinding information. has changed over time.

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. Wayfinding design guidelines
General principles Sign location
Verbal directions Signage must be visible and legible for all users.
Signage fixing heights play an important role
The wayfinding strategy should include
in the legibility of information, and reference
guidance for staff on giving verbal directions,
should be made to international standards.
especially the consistent naming of buildings,
zones, facilities and functions. External and internal signs
Management External signage must be tamper proof and
resistant to weather. Internal signage should
How a wayfinding system is managed is as vital
be tamper proof. Illuminated internal signs
to good wayfinding as the original design and
should generally only be used when required by
implementation. Without active management,
legislation.
a wayfinding system quickly becomes obselete,
and as the gap between the information Pedestrian and vehicle signs
provided by the wayfinding system and the
Vehicle signage must conform to local state and
users experience widens, trust in the system
national standards for all approach roads and
is diminished.
site circulation. Pedestrian site signing must be
The wayfinding strategy must therefore include distinct from vehicle signing to avoid confusion.
a plan for the onward management of the system.

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. Wayfinding design guidelines

. Non-sign elements

A wayfinding system is more than just signs; Architectural landmarks


it is a mutually reinforcing group of sensory
Architectural landmarks or decorative features
aids that form a language of visual clues that
in an environment can be used as powerful
enable people to make navigational decisions.
wayfinding devices. The best examples can be
Architectural environments provide a variety
easily described in basic English. Wayfinding
of clues that allow people to navigate unfamiliar
instructions such as ‘turn right at the green
places.
beanstalk’ encourage exploration and prompt a
Wayfinding is about creating a memorable person’s memory for return journeys.
environment which allows people to
Examples of features used for wayfinding include:
differentiate between areas. The north wing of a
– A giant green guitar sculpture acts as a visual
building might use a cool colour palette, while
reference adjacent to the main reception
the south might have a warm palette. While
area at the new Dell Children’s Medical
this cannot be directly referenced for direction-
Centre of Central Texas.
giving purposes, it helps to provide people with
– Previously, a giant red sphere acted as a
a sense of where they are in the building at a
piece of play equipment and a navigational
subconscious level.
aid in a central reception area at Austin
Non-sign wayfinding elements can include Children’s hospital in Texas, which was
landscaping, architecture, interior design, floor replaced by the Dell Children’s after closing
coverings, lighting, wall and window graphics. mid . The red sphere device was then
used on signage to help people navigate
Points of reference
back to that hub.
Some environments contain one or more
Location and arrangement of outpatient
highly visible landmarks that can be constantly
services
referred to from any location.
In an effort to ensure patient convenience,
These landmarks help people navigate even if
the new Women’s hospital in Victoria located
their journey does not take us via the landmark.
all outpatient services on a single level (Level
One example is the Eiffel Tower in Paris; an
), and provided dedicated lift access to the
unmistakable shape, highly visible amongst
car park below. Services on Level  include
other buildings, it provides an orientation point
Pharmacy, Pathology collection, medical
from which to build a mental map of the area.
imaging, ultrasound and other key services that
It is important that patients and visitors can encompasses the majority of outpatient services
identify key features and functions from a provided by the Women’s. The area is also close
distance, even when they are partly obscured to shops and food outlets
(such as lift lobbies and reception areas).

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. Wayfinding design guidelines

. Deciding on sign content

Information hierarchy Incorporating hospital graphic identity Colour coding General colour use guidelines
The way information is organised on a sign is Each hospital has its own graphic identity Colour coding areas in a hospital can assist in – Navigation signage throughout the hospital
critical to speed of understanding. Keep these (possibly including a logo and associated memory of a space. This may, for example, be should use consistent and limited, high
principles in mind when selecting content for graphics and colours) that plays a role useful to identify different areas or levels in a contrast colour palette with white text
signs: in identifying the hospital as part of the multi-level car park, or between two major and appearing on a dark colour background,
– Signs are easiest to read and understand wayfinding system. The logo should be used on connected buildings. or dark text on a white background, or a
when they are uncluttered and the all written communications and at key external combination of these.
information is presented in a logical, entrances to the hospital site, which may There are, however, various downsides to – Use of a limited number of key generic
sequential layout. include signage on the main buildings. using colour coding for navigation: destination hub names (e.g. Receptions A-C)
– Directional signs should contain a maximum – People do not tend to remember distinctions to differentiate between spaces,
Once a visitor has entered the hospital building,
of five destinations. between more than  or  colours. rather than colour.
the relevance of the hospital logo diminishes
– Key hospital hub destinations should – Colours do not form a logical sequence to assist – Selective use of distinctive architectural
(the visitor now knows which hospital they are
be listed at the top of the hierarchy or with navigation as numbers or letters do. elements (which may themselves have a
in), and the generic wayfinding solutions should
highlighted as primary information. – Building usage changes would require distinctive colour) to assist in differentiating
be applied without the hospital logo.
Secondary destinations should be presented complete colour coding changes which may spaces visually
lower in the information hierarchy. The graphic designer should consider whether result in a ‘broken’ system of colour coding.
The navigational signage colour chosen is
– Destinations on signs should be grouped the hospital identity colours are of sufficient – Colour differences may be hard to read for
clearly different from other required signs that
and ordered with a logic relevant to the contrast to be able to be used in the wayfinding people with low vision or colour blindness.
co-exit in the hospital environment such as
destinations listed: either by alphabetical signage. – Colour used in an architectural space (e.g. on
fire exits (green), fire equipment (red), safety
order (for a longer list), by the direction to a wall) may not be read as a navigation aid.
Arrows warnings (black and yellow).
the destination in clockwise order, or by
the order of distance to destination (closer Arrows play an important role in sign design and Coloured lines on a floor
destinations first). are often over stylized by designers, affecting
Can be useful for specific, single destination
– It is important that people can quickly their legibility (especially for those with partial
navigation aids.
connect the destination with the directional sight). Arrow designs should be based on the
– Ensure high contrast with the floor (for
arrow - ensure labels are visually connected ISO arrow (ISO ) where the terminals of the
assistance for people with low vision)
to the arrows. arrow head are parallel to the shaft.
– Avoid using multiple lines with different
colours (which are difficult to distinguish for
people with low vision)
– Use only for point to point navigation
between two commonly used, but complex
journeys, e.g. between two key hubs in a
The ISO arrow (left) is an optimal design for arrows on hospital.
signage. Although triangular arrows look stylish, the
direction which they point is ambiguous.

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. Wayfinding design guidelines

. Deciding on sign content (continued)

Use accessible terminology Avoid acronyms and only use universally-


Physiotherapy 
understood symbols
To minimise patient confusion, medical
Ante-natal 
terminology should be used sparingly and, Acronyms and abbreviations will have no
where possible, replaced with common meaning for people who are unfamiliar with the Haematology 
references that everyone understands. For original name or terminology. To avoid patient
Mammography 
example, the term Eye Clinic would have confusion these should be avoided in all signage
meaning for more people than Opthamology. and other hospital communication. Psychiatric 
In addition, medical terms can sound and look
Some symbols and icons are universally Neurophysiology 
similar to each other, particularly for people
understood and can be useful aids to
with vision impairment, e.g. Opthamology can Radiology 
reinforce the meaning of a message and assist
look and sound similar to Orthopedics and
wayfinding. These symbols are typically for Ultrasound 
other words ending in ‘ology’, (Haematology,
amenities and public services, e.g. a picture of a
Pathology, etc). Orthopedics 
telephone handset to signify public telephones
Use terms consistently and male and female icons for toilet facilities. Paediatric 
Terms and destination labels should be used Symbols for medical services are much less Opthamology 
consistently across all hospital communications, commonly understood by people in the general
Pathology 
including the pre-visit appointment letter and public, and should therefore generally be
verbal communication by hospital staff. Where avoided in hospital signage. Endoscopy 
multiple different names are currently used
Many medical terms are not widely Podiatry 
for the same service, this may require some
understood
stakeholders to give up their historically-used Orthoptics 
names in order to achieve consistency. A study undertaken in  for NHS Estates in
Hysteroscopy 
the United Kingdom ranked a sample of medical
terminology in order of how many people Obstetrics 
understood the term. The results demonstrated
Colposcopy 
that people often do not understand medical
terminology. People who have little interaction Oncology 
with the medical sector, or have limited English
Cytology 
skills are likely to be even less familiar with
terms that hospital staff might perceive to be
common knowledge.

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. Wayfinding design guidelines

. Graphic design of signs

Colour contrast Mapping and directories


Sign colour must be chosen to provide clear Mapping is an important part of a wayfinding
contrast between the information content and system. Clear maps located at strategic points
its surrounding environment. throughout the site allow visitors to orientate
themselves.
An example of a good combination is dark
green or dark blue with white text reversed out. Map design is not included in this document,
however the following principles must be
Finish
observed:
The finish of the sign face can have a huge – Architectural plans do not make good
impact on the legibility of information. The wayfinding maps. Maps must be drawn for
proximity of light sources to signs can also play the specific purpose of wayfinding
an important role and gloss factors must be – Maps displayed must be in a ‘head up’
considered when specifying materials. orientation
– Colour coding should be consistent with
Symbols
signing
Symbols can be important when signing for – Typography must be clear and legible
a multi-cultural audience, but for symbols to – Large directories should list destinations
be effective they must conform to recognized alphabetically
conventions (ISO  and AS -). If new – All maps should be reviewed by relevant user
symbols are developed, they must be tested groups
with appropriate user groups.
Tactile and special needs signing
National standards for tactile and Braille signs
need to be applied consistently.

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. Wayfinding design guidelines

. Graphic design of signs (continued)

Choice of typeface Size of type Case study: Frutiger –


a good signage typeface
Some typefaces are more appropriate for Type size and reading distance play a huge part are too tall in proportion to its x-height. This
signing than others. Before deciding on a in the accessibility of information. Variations The choice of typeface can have a significant means that for any given type size Futura will
typeface, test its legibility at the appropriate in typeface, sign colour, lighting and sign face impact on the legibility of a sign. always appear optically smaller than Frutiger.
reading distances. This does not apply to gloss mean that reading distances for all designs The example also highlights the difference
Frutiger is a typeface specifically designed for
typefaces used on tactile signs. will need to be tested with the appropriate user between some of the most frequently confused
signage* and is particularly good for reading
– All text must use both upper and lower case. groups. characters. It is clear that there is not enough
from a distance. It is less modular and geometric
– A sans serif font should be used with large differentiation between many of the characters.
Typical reading distances than other typefaces, which makes it appear
x-height and consistent stroke weight
larger and more legible to the human eye. These are some of the considerations that
– Decorative typefaces are not suitable; some (Based on a x-height : viewing distance ratio
should be incorporated into decision making on
typefaces contain similar characters and of  : ) In the example below Frutiger is compared
the appropriate typeface for signage.
should be avoided e.g. Futura lowercase a to Futura. Futura’s ascenders and descenders
and o. Viewing
     
Dist (m)
Effective and widely available typefaces
x-height
The spacing between letters (tracking) may      
(mm)
need to be increased from the default settings in
these typefaces when they are used for signage.

* Originally designed by Adrian Frutiger for the Charles de Gaulle airport in Paris

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. Wayfinding system for visits to specialist clinics
This chapter describes a journey by car, from Note: The illustrations in this chapter are
home to the hospital. It shows the choices that intended to set standards and are NOT
the patient has and the decisions they need to intended to be specific recommendations for
make at various stages of their journey. individual hospital sites.
The stages of the patient journey are: Sign size, content and design need to be
decided on a case–by–case basis.
. Appointment - verbal instructions at GP offices
. Appointment letter
. Hospital site entrance
. Car park directions
. Building entrance (interior)
. Liftwell directory
. Key internal decision point
. Hub destination arrival
. Clinic name
. Sub-destinations

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. Wayfinding system for visits to specialist clinics

. Appointment: verbal instructions at GP offices

Pre-visit information Where possible, GPs should be encouraged


to provide patients with critical information
Often the pre-visit information is the first
to assist in setting their expectations around
contact the patient will have with the Hospital.
visiting a specialist clinic. This may include key
This information will form the patient’s initial
elements about the nature of the visit, what’s
impression of the hospital and affect how they
expected, any available frequently asked
feel about their visit.
questions and direction to the Health Service’s
Poor pre-visit information can add to the level web site for further information.
of stress a patient experiences, as they are
“I’m referring you to a specialist in [discipline e.g.
unable to plan their visit with confidence. This is
cardiology] at [hospital].”
particularly relevant for patients with disabilities
who need to plan their route before their visit “The hospital will send you an appointment
and understand how long this might take. letter with all the details.”
Currently, pre-visit information is produced on a “The specialist will meet with you and [any
local level and as a result lacks consistency. special details regarding the appointment].”
Ideally hospitals should develop a standard for “They may order some tests or give you a plan
pre-visit information, to promote a consistent for treatment.”
approach to information structure, terminology,
typography, colour and mapping.

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. Wayfinding system for visits to specialist clinics

. Appointment letter


Metro First Floor, Central Tower

Health
Metro Hospital
 Rose Street
Information structure Note: Hospitals should aim to replicate this Yarra 
standard as closely as possible within the
Pre-visit information, in the form of an
constraints of their IT systems.
appointment letter, is a critical stage in the
patient journey and plays an important role in
setting patient expectations about their visit.
Simple changes to the appointment letter can Jane Smith
 Dennis Place
have a big impact. Carlton 

The primary purpose of the letter is to clearly  June, 


communicate essential information relating to
the appointment. This includes the appointment
Dear Mrs Smith,
date and time, location (including site, building,
Your doctor has referred you to see a
level and department), name of the specialist specialist at the Metro Hospital. Your
(if available), what, if anything, the patient must appointment is in the Orthopaedic Clinic
bring or do beforehand (e.g. bring Medicare (bones and joints).

card and pathology test results, do not ingest Your appointment details follow. Please
call   if you need to change your
food  hours before the appointment etc), and appointment time
hospital contact details (to change or query
appointment). Where possible, including When Thursday  June,  at .pm

distances and time duration estimates is very Allow  hours to be seen for your appointment.
helpful in preparing patients for their visit. You may be required to visit the radiology department
for an x-ray after your appointment.
Critical information is easily distinguishable Where Hospital Metro
when placed upfront and in plenty of white
Building Central Tower
space. Bold type and colour can be used where
required, but only where it assists readability. Destination Reception B

Critical vs secondary information should be Travel By car Enter Carpark C from Rose St
Enter Central Tower via Main Entrance
ordered accordingly and delivered in easily (approx m walk)
readable chunks rather than long paragraphs, By public Travel to Station by train or bus
with thin lines to visually separate the groups. transport
Follow signs to Main Entrance (approx
Underline, italics and all capitalized text should m walk)

be avoided. Preparation No preparation needed. There will be no surgery done


on the day.
To promote patient understanding, medical
Please bring – this appointment letter
terminology, abbreviations, acronyms, symbols – your Medicare card
and other language that may not be universally – something to read during the wait (if you wish).
understood should be avoided. Privately owned
sub-destinations should be identified by the
universally understood name for wayfinding,
not by the company name.

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. Wayfinding system for visits to specialist clinics

. Hospital site entrance

Hospitals are normally on primary roads, and


often VicRoads has provided road signage.
These signs will normally take visitors to the
main entrance.
Perimeter signage needs to accommodate
drivers travelling at a speed of km/h. It may
need to indicate several entrances.
The sign will be used in conjunction with
VicRoads signs. The landscaping (tree-lined
driveway) can be used to signal the location
of the site entrance and the sign acts as
confirmation.
Small sites may only have one site entrance.

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. Wayfinding system for visits to specialist clinics

. Car park directional

Directional information to visitors carparks will


usually be read from a moving vehicle, and the
size of the panel as well as the size of the font
on the sign will have to be large enough to be
legible.
Locate the sign in such a way that it can be read
from the likely reading distance.
The sign should be positioned perpendicular to
the driving direction.
(Internal) illumination depends on the ambient
light available.
A site that has a number of carparks should
direct to these different carparks from the main
entrance, so if the appointment letter says
‘Carpark ’ then carpark  should be signed from
the main entrance.

Note: A simple site may only have one carpark,


which can be indicated with a ‘Parking’ sign plus
directional arrow.

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. Wayfinding system for visits to specialist clinics

. Building entrance (interior)

Hospitals should select the key internal ‘hubs’


within the hospital and clearly sign journeys to
these locations.
Signs to specialist clinics (outpatient
departments) could be labelled as reception
destinations e.g. Reception A, with other
receptions (e.g. Day Surgery) labelled as
Reception B, etc.
This would require a whole-of-hospital
wayfinding analysis, out of scope for this
guidelines document.
Key hubs should appear at the top of the
sign, with secondary destinations below them,
separated by a line. Local amenities may appear
at a third level. This helps establish a clear
hierarchy of information.
A good generic and high contrast colour for
directional signage is navy blue (as shown in the
illustration on this page).

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. Wayfinding system for visits to specialist clinics

. Liftwell directory

Once a visitor decides to change a level, they


need to know what level they are on. This
sounds obvious, but often hospitals are built
on slopes, and different entrances may bring
people onto different levels. It is important that
in these instances the level that a visitor enters
on is displayed prominently.
If a visitor is not on the right level, they will
look for the lift or stairs. It is helpful if their end
destination is confirmed near the lifts, and in the
lifts, e.g.
You are now on level 
Receptions D-H Level 
Receptions A-C Level 
Main Reception Ground Level

Complex hospitals may have multiple floors and


high traffic through main liftwells. Staff, patients
and visitors may all share the same lifts.
Key wayfinding hubs should be labelled at
the lift entrance on each floor and inside the
lift adjacent to the floor buttons. Secondary
destinations can also be labelled adjacent on lift
directories.
Lifts should conform to best practice, including
audio prompts for floors and key destinations,
plus tactile signals on lift buttons.

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. Wayfinding system for visits to specialist clinics

. Key internal decision point

Key decision points exist where there are


multiple choices at a junction of paths. Most
often this occurs at corridor crossroads. Given
the number of secondary destinations in
complex hospitals, the signage should be
limited to highlighting key hub destinations,
plus secondary destinations in the immediate
vicinity to the decision point.
Deciding which destinations to include involves
an analysis of the journeys taken in that area of
the hospital.
The notation in the letters D-H implies that there
is more than one reception, and it is logical to
expect them in some sort of sequential order
to confirm that you are walking in the right
direction.
If the distance between two Receptions is too
far, you need a confirmation that you are still
walking in the right direction, for instance with a
simple sign that says ’Receptions E-H‘.
Key hubs should appear at the top of the
sign, with secondary destinations below them,
separated by a line. Local amenities may appear
at a third level. This helps establish a clear
hierarchy of information.

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. Wayfinding system for visits to specialist clinics

. Hub destination arrival

Reception hubs need to be identified with


a clear and unmissable sign. It provides
confirmation to patients that they have arrived,
that they have found the right place.
The design can be bold, and should be clearly
visible from any direction of travel. Do not use
colours that are being used for other primary
items in the same area (such as doors or
columns).
There may be multiple clinics linked to each
reception point.

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. Wayfinding system for visits to specialist clinics

. Clinic name

General naming principles need to be followed


to ensure clinic names are clear and well-
understood. This includes limiting the use of
medical terminology where possible, using
terms consistently throughout the hospital,
avoiding acronyms and only using universally-
understood visual symbols.
Where there are multiple clinics, they could be
named using letters (A – D) or numbers ( – ).
There may also be room numbers that are
fed off from different clinics which may need
wayfinding signage.
In some cases, the clinic could be named
according to the medical service provided, e.g.
Eye Clinic instead of Opthamology. If the service
is easily understood this may assist patients
(as in the Royal Victorian Eye and Ear Hospital).
However, most clinics in multiple-service
hospitals should be generically named (Clinic A,
etc.) to allow for use of a single space for different
clinic types and to enhance patient privacy.
A complex site may have multiple clinics
clustered in one area, or spread over different
floors or parts of the hospital.
A simple site may not have separately signed
clinics, but one clinic area, and would therefore
not require additional clinic signage.

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. Wayfinding system for visits to specialist clinics

. Sub-destinations

Sub-destinations are key service areas and A journey from the clinic to a sub-destination
amenities of the hospital that people often visit may require directional signage at various
as part of their outpatient journey. The prime decision points in the journey, and needs to be
examples are Pathology, Medical Imaging and considered in relation to other patient journeys.
Pharmacy. Best practice in newly built hospitals
Specifications may depend on existing signage
is that these service areas are clustered close to
and may need to be incorporated within it.
outpatient clinics. However, in existing hospitals,
these destinations may be located remotely
from outpatient specialist clinics and at a
distance from each other.
Signage directing patients to key sub-
destination areas is required at key points in
their journey, particularly at exits from clinic
areas.
The labelling of sub-destinations needs to be
considered in a hospital-wide context given that
many patients who are not outpatients may also
need to access these services.
Seek to apply these principles
– Directional signs to these sub-destinations
should appear at the exit to the clinic /
outpatient area
– Depending on the location of these sub-
destinations, the hub and address concept
can be applied to simplify directions (e.g. to
direct people to another hub in the hospital,
then to the sub-destination)
– Use consistent terms across the hospital (e.g.
Xray, Medical Imaging, MRI etc.
– Privately owned sub-destinations should
be identified by the universally understood
name for wayfinding, not by the company
name, e.g. Pathology. The company name
can appear at the final destination.

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. Appendices

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. Appendices

. Appendix : what is wayfinding?

Wayfinding is behaviour. It is not the same as How people find their way Points of reference
signage. Good wayfinding means knowing
Most people possess innate abilities and If we are lucky, our environment contains one
where you are, knowing your destination,
strategies that allow them to navigate unfamiliar or more highly visible landmarks that can
following the best route to your destination and
environments, without the need for signs and be referred to constantly from any location.
recognising your destination when you arrive.
arrows. By understanding these abilities, it These landmarks help us navigate even if our
More than signs is possible to develop wayfinding strategies journey does not take us via the landmark.
that do not clutter a space with expensive and An excellent example is the Eiffel Tower in Paris.
A wayfinding system is more than just signs; it
unnecessary signs. An unmistakable shape, highly visible amongst
is a mutually reinforcing group of sensory aids
other buildings; which provides an orientation
that form a language of visual clues that enable Creating legible environments
point from which to build a mental map of Paris.
people to make navigational decisions.
An environment is easy to navigate when the
Understand the audience
Architectural environments provide a variety user can easily ‘read’ that environment. A good
of clues that allow people to navigate unfamiliar example is a church in a historic European In order to create an environment that is
places. When these clues are consistently town. There is a good chance that the church is legible, it is important to consider the person
presented, people find their way effortlessly. relatively central in town and when you walk up who is trying to find their way through the
When they are inconsistent, people get lost. to the building you have a good idea where the environment. Someone new to a hospital
entrance will be, what to expect when you enter environment will know less about what to
Hospitals
and how to behave inside. All of this is achieved expect than a person who is familiar with
Hospitals are large and complex environments. without any signage. the space. They may be more anxious and
Many have grown in an ad-hoc manner emotional and less able to remember verbal
This example demonstrates that the
with buildings or departments next to each directions from staff. Wayfinding systems must
surrounding environment can play a powerful
other that are unrelated, while areas that also account for people with limited English
role in assisting understanding, expectation
are related are often connected by long and skills, mobility and vision impairments and their
setting and wayfinding without the use of
complex pathways. Destinations may have carers.
directional signs
incomprehensible names, or may be hard to
remember or pronounce by users with limited Inference
English proficiency. All of this makes it difficult
Humans are excellent at identifying patterns
for people to find their way.
and sequences. Some coding systems, such
as numbers and letters, lend themselves to
sequencing while colour coding and shapes
do not. We use sequences to find our way all
the time – from identifying house numbers
to finding our car in a multi-story car park.

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 
. Appendices

. Appendix : benefits of good wayfinding

Good wayfinding promotes healing Good wayfinding promotes fiscal health Benefits of good wayfinding
When users are able to understand their Successful wayfinding systems make financial In summary, good wayfinding promotes
environment, it gives them a sense of control sense. Costs associated with wayfinding – Reduction of stress and frustration for the
and empowerment, key factors in reducing problems are often hidden. For example, visitor
stress, anxiety, and fear—feelings that consider the indirect cost of lost productivity – Functional efficiency
undermine the body’s ability to heal. as concerned staff members take time away – Visitor accessibility
from patient care to give directions or walk lost – Safety
When analysing the relationship between
visitors to their destination. – Patient empowerment, improving cognitive
disorientation and design it was found that: “It is
skills in spatial understanding
important to consider that wayfinding problems Another indirect cost of poor wayfinding is that
– Improved bottom line
have their own particular cost in the healthcare lost visitors are late, miss their appointments or
environment”. Stress caused by disorientation are too upset for testing to take place.
may result in feelings of helplessness, raised
Good wayfinding promotes the
blood pressure, headaches, increased physical
healthcare facility
exertion, and fatigue. In addition, patients
may be affected by the wayfinding troubles of Ensuring visitors feel comfortable with
visitors who, because they became lost, may navigation from the minute they enter the
have less time to spend with them. facility not only reduces stress and frustration, it
also communicates to everyone that the facility
Good wayfinding promotes safety
is organised, professional, and capable.
Visitors that are stressed are more likely to act
In today’s economy, with many institutions
aggressively towards staff, patients or other
vying for increasingly scarce consumer
visitors. Stress caused by disorientation can be a
healthcare dollars, it’s more important than
contributing factor. Another safety related issue
ever that providers consider the image they are
is that staff that are working in sensitive areas or
presenting to the outside world.
with medication distribution, may be distracted
from their primary work objectives, and with Further, successful wayfinding systems can
this create an unsafe environment. contribute to a reduction in complaints.
Acknowledgements
Growth Solutions Group wishes to thank the
following people and organisations for their
contribution to the Outpatient Wayfinding
Guidelines:
– Patient interviewees
– Reference hospitals and staff from Austin
 Arthur, P, and Passini, R. (). Hospital, Heidelberg Repatriation Hospital,
Wayfinding: People, Signs and Architecture. Royal Victorian Eye and Ear Hospital, Ballarat
McGraw-Hill
Base Hospital, Box Hill Hospital
 Carpman and Grant () – Outpatient Experience Sub-Committee
 Arthur, P, and Passini, R. (). – IDLab
Wayfinding: People, Signs and Architecture. – Department of Human Services
McGraw-Hill

Specialist clinics wayfinding guidelines The outpatient journey August  www.gsg.com.au page  of 

Вам также может понравиться