Warehouse Technology in the Supply Chain Management Systems
Ralph L. Harper, Jr., DBA, CISM, Florida Institute of Technology
Key Words: Distribution Requirements Planning, Integration of SCM, Management Information Communication Systems, Material Requirements Planning, Ware House Management Systems, Standard Army Maintenance System. SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION businesses. A warehouse may also be called a distribution center, Warehouse management is the process of coordinating The linkage between communication technology, the the incoming goods, the subsequent storage and tracking of supply chain environment and end-consumer needs assists in the goods, and finally, the distribution of the goods to their better communication between all activities across supply proper destinations. chain tiers. Successful supply chain management depends on When the supply exceeds demand, a warehouse will store tight coordination between supply chain partners. The Internet product in anticipation of customer requirements, the provides the perfect communications channel for the warehousing process may smooth out market supply and information, decisions, transactions, and processes that form demand fluctuations. A classic example is the build-up of supply chain management. It is a journey of change that is retail inventory in anticipation of the Holiday season. already under way. To keep up with the evolution of supply Warehousing can link the production facility and the chain management, and remain competitive in their markets, consumer, or suppliers and production facilities information future supply chain leaders will need to simultaneously exhibit with today’s Communication technology. Warehousing tight coordination in all areas: integration, collaboration, and supports production by consolidating inbound materials and synchronization with a better understanding of distributing them to the production facility at the appropriate communications systems function. Integration is the time. The use of warehousing communication can reduce time coordination of supply chain activities such as purchasing, needed to transport spares for maintenance action as well as manufacturing, distribution, spares management needed for increase operational availability (A’O) in the military system. maintenance and operational availability of military systems, Warehousing also helps marketing to serve current and customer service within a single enterprise of customers and expand into new markets. Outbound technological readiness. Many leading companies have made warehouses help consumers buy on demand without a nearby great strides with internal integration of their communication production plant. systems. This is just a beginning. The future will see an Warehousing is a key component of the overall integrated accelerated development and rollout of these tools and supply chain. The supply chain consists of the facilities and techniques, which soon will become common place in all distribution options for the procurement of materials from aspects of managing the supply chain. manufacturer to customer, and all points in between. It Supply chain management will continue to have a includes the production of materials into components and significant influence on company success and shareholder finished products, and then distribution to customers. Basic value. Supply chain disciplines and Internet communication functions of warehousing include movement, storage, and innovations will combine to synchronize all supply chain information transfer. To store a product properly, movement activities tightly to best satisfy customer needs. Leaders who is necessary. It takes place in four distinct task areas. enhance their supply chain prowess with e-commerce Receiving inbound goods from transportation carriers capabilities and bring supply chain skills to bear in the e- including quality and quantity checks; transferring goods from economy will be unstoppable. the receiving docks and moving them to specific storage World-class product quality, accurate inventory tracking, locations throughout the warehouse; order selecting the lean operations, customer-focused service, and a rationalized products for filling customer orders including checking, supply base will all be expected as the entry price to packing, and transporting to the outbound dock; shipping synchronization. Companies striving to master these techniques goods outbound to customers by some form of transportation. have looked to supporting changes in technology platforms. The information can be used to assess warehousing Enterprise Resource Planning Communication technology effectiveness by examining equipment utilization rates, labor systems and best-of-breed software packages such as productivity, and space utilization (Bloomberg 2002, p345). warehouse management systems and transportation A warehouse plays a multifaceted role in the integration management systems are helping to define, standardize, and of Supply Chain Management (SCM). It can serve as a automate operational processes at world-class levels. transportation consolidation facility. Companies can transport less than loads into a warehouse, consolidate them into full 1.0 INTRODUCTION loads, and then transport them out again. Warehouses act as A warehouse is a storage facility that receives goods and safety valves in plant strikes, supplier stockouts, or products for the eventual distribution to consumers, or other transportation delays. If a carrier strike is likely, the
warehouse can store extra inventory to reduce the chance of a transportation and distribution, decide which customers should stockout at the consumer level. get priority, and accommodate last-minute order changes even The primary role of a warehouse in the Supply Chain is to after the transportation system has already planned it, tendered provide customer service in the Supply Chain Systems. “An carriers, and the warehouse management system has started effective warehouse system means quicker delivery, fewer executing. stockouts, and better customer service communication. The In an effect to meet these needs, “advanced planning results are higher levels of customer satisfaction and more systems (APS) from such players as I2, Manugistics and sales” (Bloomberg 2000, p245). This is facilitated by Logility are being overlaid on traditional ERP systems. APS warehouse communications technology. Information transfer allows you to manage the flow of merchandise through the occurs when management captures data on inventory levels, supply chain, synchronizing demand with supply, dynamically locations, space utilization, and other data necessary to ensure planning needs and determining where to deploy inventory that a warehouse is functioning successfully. Improvements in throughout the supply chain. To serve this lofty mission, these Warehouse Communication have resulted in dynamic new systems are designed to help synchronize the use of resources, approaches to supply chain support. A seamless supply chain not only in manufacturing, but also on the transportation and system that ties all parts of the community into one network of warehousing sides.” (Trebuchon, 1998, p256). shared situational awareness and unified action can be ERP today is a Company's central nervous system achieved only in an environment dominated by global, orchestrating many functions, including order management, wireless, assured communications. Many world-class materials planning, warehouse management, payables, commercial companies have reduced inventories significantly receivables, and general ledger. “Companies spent more than and now rely on real-time information, coupled with rapid $70 billion on licenses for software in the ten year period from transportation, to meet customers' demands. Much of their 1997 to 2007. In addition, implementation resources cost them inventory is in transit in the logistics pipeline. To manage several times more than the license fees. Implementation time their reduced inventories, these companies employ global, ranged from six months to four years, depending on the wireless communications systems that give them up-to-the- number of business units, functionality scope, and the minute status on shipments and deliveries configuration's complexity. From the time of the initial “A successful supply chain is one that shares assets, investment decision, it took medium-size to large companies processes, technologies and customers” (Sanders, 2003). at least five years to achieve steady-state performance levels Supply-chain operation manages forward logistics, supplying and recoup their investment” (Welch, 2007,p401). customers with materials and service requirements. An effective ERP system requires constant support and Collaborative, not combative, relationships and agreements maintenance from the IT department, and the business itself. with suppliers and manufacturers allow both organizations to “Support must include the right processes and organizational understand costs and business structures. ”Alliance models, backed by the appropriate governance and relationships and vendor-managed inventory agreements championed by the executive team. Clearly, an ERP system further reduce required stocking levels” (Sanders, 2003). isn't simply another complex solution to hand off to the IT department and to a few tech-savvy business users. If the ERP 2.0 COMMUNICATION IN THE SUPPLY CHAIN system is to deliver a consistent performance advantage, it's By leveraging information technologies, the SCM system also the responsibility of senior business leaders to see it will be empowered to provide the right support at the right through” (Welch, 2007, p401). time at the right place. Managers of the SCM System can no “A 2005 study of 60 companies showed that having an longer rely on "historical" data. Rather, they now require real- advanced ERP system won't necessarily lead to better results. time, predictive information to make intelligent decisions and In fact, advanced systems tend to magnify process optimize force readiness. Global wireless communications deficiencies. And while mature business processes are will facilitate the ability to reach and see virtually anywhere in necessary for achieving desired business results… they are in the world. themselves insufficient. To achieve repeatable results, With implementation of state-of-the-art information companies must master business process management and IT systems, SCM Systems can now monitor consumption of tools (both software and hardware), thus establishing expendable supplies on a daily basis at the national as well as themselves in Quadrant I… in the mature processes and the unit level. Fully exploited, these systems can also mature systems” (Welch, 2007, p401). automatically deliver supplies at the level required, consistent “Even without advanced ERP systems, Companies with with available resources on a competing priority basis. mature business practices are 38% more profitable, have 22% “Logistics execution systems represent a fusion of the less inventory, and achieve 10% better delivery performance warehouse and transportation management systems and will than companies with less-mature business processes. eventually replace them in the logistician's lexicon as ERP is Companies combining mature business processes with transformed” (Trebuchon ,1998). advanced ERP systems achieve a further 27% profitability This link will give business the ability to plan capacity advantage and as much as a 40% gain in performance across within its distribution centers, and make available-to-promise the full range of supply chain metrics, including delivery commitments to customers, identify the effects of labor issues performance and inventory” (Welch, 2007, p401). on a day-to-day basis, develop alternative service plans, These types of communications systems are being provide customer service with visibility of what's going on in developed for a global commercial market; also have broad applications for military use at the strategic, operational, and supply chain optimization techniques have become the catalyst tactical levels. These technologies can provide the capability for integrating each functional area of the enterprise into a to receive, transmit, store, and retrieve information in a single finely orchestrated operation. The ultimate goal is to seamless logistics. “synchronize the activities of all supply chain participants, both within and outside the company, to the demands of the 3.0 MANAGING INFORMATION IN WAREHOUSES end-consumer” (Bauknight, 2000). Using the enhancements Today’s supply chain environment involves the flows of made possible through applications conducted over the material, information, and finance in a network consisting of Internet, leaders are introducing “new business models that customers, suppliers, manufacturers, and distributors. take advantage of the most dramatic of all new technological Information flows involve order transmission and delivery innovations – the World Wide Web” (Bauer, 2001). status. Financial flows include credit terms, payment schedules, and consignment and title ownership arrangements. These flows cut across multiple functions and areas both within a company, across companies, and sometimes industries. Coordination, integration, and communication of these flows within and across companies are critical in an effective supply chain management system. Managing these flows effectively is a daunting task, particularly for global corporations. There are complex relationships such as multiple suppliers, serving multiple customers, and suppliers who may be both customers and even competitors in different parts of the chain. “The network complexity, communication between entities, and accurate and timely transfer of information can be extremely difficult. The multiple layers in a supply chain can distort demand information and lead to excessive inventory, idle capacity, high manufacturing, and transportation costs, not to mention increasingly dissatisfied customers. Achieving supply chain efficiency requires accurate and timely information” (Lee, 2000, p234). Information integration is the foundation of broader supply chain integration. For companies to coordinate their material, information, and financial flows, they must have access to information reflecting their true supply chain picture at all Figure 1: Ware House Management Systems (WMS) Keymas times. Without information being relayed at the right time Ltd, Pensnett House, Pensnett Estate, Dudley Road, and to the right place, there would be no purchase orders, no Kingswinford, Dudley, West Midlands DY6 shipment messages and no payments resulting in a collapse of The Internet provides a new platform and system of the supply chain. Managing the flow of information in the global communication that has dramatically “shrunken” the supply chain may be as important as managing the flow of the planet and all of the traditional cycle times required for products. Technology is the enabler, and the backbone of business commerce. The key to success will require most corporate supply chains. Information technology is at communications of data across the full supply chain network the center of virtually every aspect of business, especially in that connects suppliers, manufacturers, distributors, business today's dynamic, uncertain, and highly competitive customers, and the ultimate consumers (Bauer, 2001, p6 ). environment. The rate of technological innovation has never Wireless devices and mobile business solutions are another been greater, and is expected to continue to accelerate. “E- option to improving supply chain management. commerce applications and e-enabled capabilities that rely on The supply chain is transformed from a reactive, digitally efficient information transfer have the potential to completely enabled, linear process to a proactive supply web that acts revolutionize the existing business environment” (Meltzer, much like a nervous system. Web, wireless, and satellite 2000). There are many goals in making investments in new communications allow the supply chain to sense requirements, technology. Improved inventory management, reduced cycle problems, and changes throughout the network instantly. This times, improved fill rates, and increased visibility of access to real-time information will enable faster decision- information on production, delivery, and shipment and of making and greater communication among all parts of the course to remain competitive, maximize shareholder profit” supply chain. It is not simply an add-on to the e-supply chain, (O’Brien & McNerney, 2002, p18). Companies striving to “wireless devices, also known as mobile business solutions, improve their supply chain management functions will have to have the fundamental capability to reshape supply chain support changes in their technology platforms. management” (Shankar & O’Driscoll, 2002, p 86). The widespread introduction of Enterprise Resource Companies adopting leading communication business Planning (ERP) systems has provided shared data and practices consistently improve their performance. Supporting operational processes across the supply chain functions which technology is a critical success factor for performance, usage are the bedrock of integration. Building on this foundation, of supply chain software, while not the most critical part of the holiday rush is over” (Holstein, 1998,p 2). Synchronizing and supply chain improvement, is a first-order accelerator. As optimizing the supply chain relies on real-time availability of strategies and processes increasingly depend on underlying ever-changing information for decision making, and constant systems, business leaders must consider the technology flow of information between applications. component earlier in the performance improvement planning It is critical that data integration be both effective and process. Strong business process plus technology wins” efficient. “The foundation for Supply Chain Management has (Gens, 2003, p5). always existed, but today's technology and business The concept of integrated communication system philosophy are responsible for its mainstream adoption and the support, its eagerness to maximize readiness and optimize success it has achieved” (Holstein, 1998) with communication costs influences the data exchange requirement, and is part of up and down the supply chain. The Wal-mart system was the designing a system for reliability, maintainability, and benchmark used by the Department of Defense (DOD) in supportability as can be seen in Figure 2. The development of their systems. Time-Phased Planning (MRP, communication and information transfer systems are primary MRPII, DRP, DRPII) are forward-looking and demand-based components of the Supply Chain Framework. management tools used in the SCM systems. Software providers such as QAD Enterprise, SSA Global, ORACLE, and SAP Business solutions are the major sources of MRP Supply Chain Framework and MRPII software. The concept of integrated communication system support, its eagerness to maximize readiness and optimize costs R PRODUCT- PRODUCT-SERVICE VALUE FLOW E influences the data exchange requirement, and is part of E MARKET ACCOMMODATION FLOW N designing a system for reliability, maintainability, and S D supportability as can be seen in Figure 2. O BEHAVIORAL CONTEXT Relationship 4.0 MANAGEMENT COMMUNICATION SYSTEMS U C PLANNING AND CONTROL CONTEXT During Operation Desert Storm, about 40,000 R U C Measurement Technology and Planning S containers of supplies and materiel were shipped to the E OPERATIONAL CONTEXT T theater of operations. Shipping the containers to the Material and Persian Gulf was relatively easy, after all the Military Service Supplier Internal Customer O Operations Integration has been shipping supply containers all over the world for B Integration M years. The problem was, by the time the containers arrived A INFORMATION FLOW E in the Persian Gulf, no one knew what was inside them. S FINANCIAL FLOW R About half of those containers had to be opened and E S manually searched or inventoried to ascertain the contents. Radio frequency identification (RFID) technology is getting a big push from end users, with everyone from consumer Figure: 2. Mentzer 2000 Supply Chain Management goods manufacturers to the Department of Defense singing the technological praises, and clamoring for better Wal-Mart distributes the freight through a network of 20 standards. Wal-Mart and Proctor & Gamble have used their regional distribution centers (DC's) across the country. Wal- positions in the industry to force suppliers and competitors Mart and Retail Link were responding to the customers and to adapt these technologies. their needs. The Wal-Mart warehouse management system Standard Army Maintenance Information System uses a flexible location system in a user-defined warehouse (STAMIS) is an Army approved computer system, management system with a built-in level of integration and comprising both hardware and software that automates diverse data collection system. The strength of the system is that logistical supply chain functions to fulfill customer support about 5,000 manufacturers are tied into it through the requirements and provide information management over company's Retail Link program, which is accessed via the resources. Communication is an important part of the overall Internet. Pepsi, Disney, or Mattel, for example, can tap into SCM system support infrastructure which supports automated Wal-Mart's data warehouse to see how well each product is critical supply and maintenance functions. selling at each Wal-Mart store. Wal-Mart can look at how In order to support the vast number of Army systems, things are selling in individual areas and make decisions about logistics information and data must properly flow without fail categories where there may be opportunity to expand. This between each STAMIS. This becomes particularly tight information link helps Wal-Mart work with its suppliers challenging on the battlefield. How do you maintain to replenish stock of products that are selling in high volume communication links and connectivity in such an austere and and to quickly pull those that are not. Since the dynamic environment? This question has plagued manufacturers are so deeply involved, in some cases Wal-Mart maintainers and suppliers on every deployment and military even has them handle their own distribution, saving the operation. Lieutenant General Claude V. (Chris) Christianson retailer big bucks and increasing profit margins on cheaper states that, “We will solve this problem by connecting Army goods. “Clearly, Wal-Mart's investment in information Logisticians…This connectivity will cover the battlefield, and technology will be shaking up the retail industry long after the it will give Army Logisticians the agility and flexibility to quickly plug into, and unplug from, a dedicated network with Networks are Reshaping the Supply Chain an asynchronous (stand-alone) capability” (Army Deputy 10. http://www.supplychainlink.com Supply Chain Chief of Staff G-4, 2003). The supply chain is transformed Management Review, July/August 2002, 44-51. Retrieved from a reactive, digitally enabled, linear process to a on 20 May, 2008, from the World Wide Web. proactive supply web that acts much like a nervous system. 11. Sanders Mike (2003, June). Signed, sealed and Web, wireless, and satellite communications allow the supply delivered. Transmission & Distribution World, 55(6), 18. chain to sense requirements, problems, and changes Retrieved August 14, 2008, from ABI/INFORM throughout the network instantly. This access to real-time Global database. (Document ID: 357803141). information will enable faster decision-making and greater 12. Trebuchon Maurice A, (1998, December). Logistics communication among all parts of the supply chain. It is meets the enterprise. Material Handling not simply an add-on to the e-supply chain, "wireless Engineering, 53(13), SCF6-SCF10. Retrieved August 14, devices, also known as mobile business solutions, have the 13. Welch Jim, Dmitry Kordysh. (2007). Seven Keys to ERP fundamental capability to reshape supply chain Success. Strategic Finance, 89(3), 40-47, 61. Retrieved management. August 14, 2008, from ABI/INFORM Global database. (Document ID: 1339921401). REFERENCES BIOGRAPHY 1. Army Deputy Chief of Staff G-4, Class IX Summit Overview, PowerPoint presentation given at the Council Ralph L. Harper Jr., DBA, CISM, Professor of Colonels, 25 July 2003 U.S. Department of the Army. Nathan M. Bisk College of Business 2. Bauer, Mr., Poirier, C.C., Lapide, L. Ph.D., & Bermudez, Florida Institute of Technology J. (2001). E-Business: The Strategic Impact on Supply 150 West University Boulevard Chain and Logistics, Council of Logistics Management. Melbourne, Florida 32901-6975, USA http://www.clm1.org/pubs/pubs_bookDetail.asp?ctbl_acct E-mail: rharper@fit.edu =00344 (abstract of the actual book), pp. 1-7, Retrieved 10 May, 2008 from the World Wide Web. Before Dr. Harper joining Florida Institute of Technology as 3. Bauknight, Dow N., (2000). The Supply Chain's the Academic Chair for Management and Professor, College FUTURE in the e-Economy ..., Supply Chain of Business, Dr. Harper had Over 42 years of experience in Management Review, March 1, 2000. Acquisition and Logistics Management focusing on product http://www.bettermanagement.com/library, Retrieved 10 application and development. Thirty-seven years experience May, 2008 from the World Wide Web. in the aerospace industry in the development and delivery of 4. Blanchard, Benjamin S., (2003), Logistics Engineering logistics products and services to government and commercial and Management, 6th Edition. Upper Saddle River, NJ: customers in the U.S. and overseas. He Defined and Prentice Hall, 2003 developed a global logistics network management system, 5. Blanchard, Benjamin S. Logistics Engineering and configuration management system, and production control Management, 6th ed. (Pearson Prentice Hall: 2004), p. 12. management system for use in support of multiple defense 6. Bloomberg, LeMay, Hanna (2002). Logistics. Upper systems. Dr Harper was Logistics Configuration Manager for Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall, 2003 Air Defense, Raytheon Technical Services Company 1967 to 7. Holstein, William J. Jill Jordan Sieder; Danielle 2004, President of HarCon Inc. 1988-2007, Adjunct Professor Svetcov, Data-crunching Santa, U.S. News & World of Management, Florida Institute of Technology, 2001-2007, Report, 12/21/98, Vol. 125 Issue 2. Adjunct Professor, Franklin Pierce College, School of 8. Lee, H.L., (2000). Creating Value Through Supply Chain Graduate & Professional Studies 2001-2007, Adjunct Integration.http://www.manufacturing.net/scm/index.asp? Professor, Southern New Hampshire University, School of layout=article&articleid=CA151843 Supply Chain Graduate & Professional Studies 2001-2007. Dr. Harper is a Management Review, Sept/Oct 2000. Retrieved 10 May, member of the Sigma Beta Delta National Honor Society for 2008 from the World Wide Business, Management and Administration, AAIA, SRE, and Web.http://www.supplychainlink.com CLEP. Dr Harper has 22 Published papers and Presentations. 9. Shankar, V., & O’Driscoll, T., (2002) How Wireless