STATUS OF COMMENTS ON DILUENT STORAGE TANK DESIGN REPORT

PROJECT : THERMAL ARUMA PILOT(TAR) PROJECT

AECPL PROJECT NO: 18029
CLIENT: TATWEER PETROLEUM
DISCIPLINE: MECHANICAL
SR. NO. COMMENTS BY AECPL ACTION BY RAMSIS ENGINEERING (COMMENT STATUS) REMARKS

DOC. NO.:- TP-RSIP-01312-CAL-A4_REV A2

TITLE:- DESIGN CALCULATION REPORT FOR DILUENT
STORAGE TANK
The Yield Strength of the material(S275JR) as per design
temperature(100 DegC) shall be as per Annex M clause M.3.2, based
1 Refer respective document/drawing.
on this the design stress(Sd) and hydrotest stress(St) are calculated.
(Sht. 7 of 41)
The bottom shell course height mentioned is 6m, but it shall be 3m.
2 Refer respective document/drawing.
(Sht. 7 of 41)
The tensile strength of the material(S275JR) is 410MPA(for plate
thickness 3-100mm thick), but in calculations it is considered as
430MPA. Based on this the design stress(Sd) and hydrotest stress(St)
are calculated. (Sht. 7 of 41)
The Yield Strength of the material(S275JR) as per design
10 temperature(100 DegC) shall be as per Annex M Table M.1a. (Sht. Refer respective document/drawing.
17 of 41)
The Formula for required compression area at roof to shell junction as
per API 650 clause 5.10.5.2 mentioned is not correct, Please correct it.
3 Also the meaning and value used for claculations of the term "Fa" shall Refer respective document/drawing.
also be corrected as per API 650 clause 5.10.5.2
(Sht. 10 of 41)
As per our review the DLR value used in compression area calculation
4 shall be 31973.53N, but it is considered as 17524.81N. Please
check/correct. (Sht. 11 of 41)
In Point no. "B", it is mentioned that the "Figure F-2 (Detail d)", but
actually it shall be "Figure F-2 (Detail b)" as also this detail given in
5 Refer respective document/drawing.
drawing no. TP-RSIP-01313-DGA-A1(G.A. of Diluent Tank-T-0702)
(Sht. 11 of 41)
The meaning and value of term "Fy" mentioned in the formula for
required compression area at roof to shell junction shall be corrected
6 Refer respective document/drawing.
for modified design temperature as per API 650 Annex F clause F.4.1
(Sht. 11 of 41)
The curb angle size mentioned in design calculation report is 80x80x6
mm but in drawing no. TP-RSIP-01313-DGA-A1(G.A. of Diluent
7 Refer respective document/drawing.
Tank-T-0702) it is 80x80x8 mm. Please correct it in design calculation
report. (Sht. 12 of 41)
As per above given comments the areas mentioned in sht. No. 10, 11
8
and 12 of 41 will be revised. (Sht. 10,11,12 of 41)

Mentioned adapted design wind speed, Vd = 165 Km/hr is not clear as

9 Refer respective document/drawing.
the basic wind speed is 144.84Km/hr. (Sht. 12 of 41)

The value of modulus of elasticity(E) shall be as per max. design

9 Refer respective document/drawing.
temperature (100 DegC). (Sht. 15 of 41)

The Yield Strength(Fby) of the material(S275JR) for bottam plate as

10 per design temperature(100 DegC) shall be as per Annex M Table Refer respective document/drawing.
M.1a. (Sht. 17 of 41)
As per our review the DLR value(corroded weight due to roof load) shall
11 be 23.902KN, but it is considered as 18.016KN. Please check/correct. Refer respective document/drawing.
(Sht. 17 of 41)
As per our review the MDLR value(corroded moment due to roof load)
12 shall be 56.2890KNM, but it is considered as 42.428KNM. Please Refer respective document/drawing.
check/correct. (Sht. 17 of 41)
As per above given comments the load condition 1 & 2 mentioned in
13 Refer respective document/drawing.
sht. No. 18 of 41 will be revised. (Sht. 18 of 41)
The Min. Yield Strength(Fty) of the material(S275JR) for bottam shell
14 course as per design temperature(100 DegC) shall be as per Annex M Refer respective document/drawing.
Table M.1a. (Sht. 18 of 41)
As per our review the PWR value(wind uplift pressure on roof) shall be
15 1.086KPA, but it is considered as 0.431KPA. Please correct it. Refer respective document/drawing.
(Sht. 18 of 41)

The calculations provided on the Sht No. 19 & 20 of 41 for W1, W2,
W3, uplift load cases, all. Anchor bolt stresses, P, Pmax, Pt, U/N, shall
16 Refer respective document/drawing.
be revised as per API 650 12th Edition, Addendum 2, Jan 2016.
(Sht. 19&20 of 41)

At Sht. No. 19 of 41 the MOC of anchor bolt mentioned is SA36 and At

Sht. No. 22 of 41 the MOC of anchor bolt mentioned is S275JR.
17 Refer respective document/drawing.
Please confirm which one is considered? As per our understanding it
shall be S275JR. (Sht. 19&22 of 41)

The yield stress of anchor bolt material(Fy) mentioned is 200MPA, but

18 Refer respective document/drawing.
it shall be 250MPA as per S275JR material. (Sht. 19 of 41)

Selected bolt size is M20, but as API 650 12th edition the minimum
19 Refer respective document/drawing.
anchor bolt size shall be 25.4mm plus the corrosion allowance.

20 Refer respective document/drawing.

No. of stiffeners in drg & BOM is 3

21
deleted in R1 revision

22 Refer respective document/drawing.

23 Refer respective document/drawing.

24 Refer respective document/drawing.

25 Refer respective document/drawing.

26 - New Comment

27 - New Comment

28 - New Comment
29 - New Comment