Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 11

International Journal of Information Management xxx (xxxx) xxx–xxx

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

International Journal of Information Management


journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/ijinfomgt

Mobile edge computing based QoS optimization in medical healthcare


applications
⁎ ⁎
Ali Hassan Sodhroa,b, Zongwei Luoc, , Arun Kumar Sangaiahd, , Sung Wook Baike
a
Sukkur IBA University, Sukkur, Sindh, 65200, Pakistan
b
DISP LAB, University Lumiere Lyon 2, Lyon, France
c
Shenzhen Key Laboratory of Computational Intelligence, Department of Computer Science and Engineering, Southern University of Science and Technology, Shenzhen,
518055, China
d
School of Computing Science and Engineering, Vellore Institute of Technology, Vellore, 632014, Tamil Nadu, India
e
Intelligent Media Laboratory, Digital Contents Research Institute, Sejong University, Seoul, Republic of Korea

A R T I C LE I N FO A B S T R A C T

Keywords: Emerging trends in mobile edge computing for developing the efficient healthcare application such as, remote
Mobile edge computing monitoring of the patients with central electronics clouds (e-Clouds) and their increasing voluminous multi-
Medical healthcare media have caught the attention of everyone in industry and academia. So, clear visualization, big sensing level,
QoS and better quality of service (QoS) is the foremost priority. This paper proposes the window-based Rate Control
Window-based rate control algorithm
Algorithm (w-RCA) to optimize the medical quality of service (m-QoS) in the mobile edge computing based
BSA
healthcare by considering the network parameters for instance, peak-to-mean ratio (PMR), standard deviation
(Std.dev), delay and jitter during 8 min medical video stream named “Navigation to the Uterine Horn, trans-
ection of the horn and re-anastomosis’ transmission over 5 G networks. The performance of the proposed w-RCA
is evaluated and compared with the conventional battery smoothing algorithm (BSA) and Baseline by using
MPEG-4 encoder for optimizing m-QoS at the source or the server side. The experimental results demonstrate
that the w-RCA outperforms the BSA and Baseline by optimizing QoS in remote healthcare application i.e., Tele-
surgery. Besides, it is observed and analyzed that w-RCA produces better and effective results at small buffer and
window sizes unlike BSA and Baseline by adopting large buffer size during QoS optimization.

1. Introduction attracted the several healthcare industries due to emerging revolution


in the state-of-the art technologies such as 5 G, internet of things (IoT)
Mobile edge computing is the paradigm shift for the every corner of Big Data, cloud computing, etc. The quality of service (QoS) in terms of
the medical world, in the mean-time remote Sensing (RS) is an en- end-to-end delay guarantees to real-time applications is especially im-
couraging ingredient which plays very vital role in several fields spe- portant for the new generation of Internet applications such as, video
cifically, the efficient remote healthcare domain with big and bright on demand (VoD) and other consumer services (Karambakhsha et al.,
picture of the incident, healthcare surveillance, disaster monitoring, 2018; Mukhopadhyay, Navyashree, & Meenakshi, 2015; Sodhro, Li, &
etc. Close and effective coordination between physical and digital Shah, 2016; Clark, Gross, & Wu, 2013; Sodhro, Kumar Sangaiah et al.,
worlds promise the high quality of service (QoS) for human life in order 2018; Sodhro, Sekahri et al., 2018; Sodhro, Kumar Sangaiah, Pibhulal,
to make medical world smart and sustainable landscape. Remotely- 2018a; Sodhro, Kumar Sangaiah, Pirbhulal, 2018b; Zingoni et al.,
sensed information, combined with location and application informa- 2017). Basic network performance indicators are throughput, delay,
tion gathered locally or through wearable sensor nodes, depicts several jitter and packet loss ratio (PLR).
bright sides for building medical smart landscape with mobile edge (Enayet & Fortino, 2018; Sodhro et al., 2012), present the novels
computing. High medical resolution data are remotely sensed and techniques for the dynamic resource management such as, quality of
monitored by many healthcare industries to entertain the claims and service in the healthcare application with the key focus at power and
needs of various users. QoS is one of the most important assets during battery lifetime of the tiny wearable devices. Detecting the sensing of
remote sensing and monitoring of healthcare data to fulfil the demands the objects during video transmission with big and better visualization
of society as shown in Fig. 1. The medical media streaming has is very challenging due to several features for instance, size, contrast,


Corresponding authors.
E-mail addresses: luozw@sustc.edu.cn (Z. Luo), sarunkumar@vit.ac.in, arunkumarsangaiah@gmail.com (A.K. Sangaiah).

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijinfomgt.2018.08.004
Received 3 March 2018; Received in revised form 6 August 2018; Accepted 9 August 2018
0268-4012/ © 2018 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Please cite this article as: Sodhro, A.H., International Journal of Information Management, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijinfomgt.2018.08.004
A.H. Sodhro et al. International Journal of Information Management xxx (xxxx) xxx–xxx

Fig. 1. 5G Architecture for Mobile Edge Computing based Medical Healthcare Applications.

velocity and trajectory, etc. Besides, the dynamic nature of the wireless (Ferdous, Alamri, Fortino, & Zhou, 2017). The basic aim of these state-
channel deteriorates or reduce the QoS. Many previous researchers of-the art networks is to provide continuous, quick and cost-effective
achieved good performance merely in some specific fields but the health services to patients and doctors at remote location. One of the
medical QoS optimization during video transmission for healthcare most interesting services offered by 5 G networks is the end user in-
over mobile edge computing networks and smart cities is not en- teractive multimedia transmission of video. In addition to typical cor-
tertained in-depth. Rate control algorithms remarkably improves the porate applications 5 G is widely used in medical applications where
visual video playback quality by properly adapting the variations in the latency and high resolution imaging are very important. It ensures
wireless channel, because the dynamic nature of the wireless link af- uninterrupted and lossless delivery of data regardless of high inconstant
fects the QoS as well as the perception level of the users. (Kaba, 2018), bandwidth of wireless channel and comparatively high data bit rates.
develops the internet based approach to classify the users on their The long lasting interconnection between Real-time Transport Protocol
socio-economical level. In addition they present the limitations and (RTP) and User Datagram Protocol (UDP) offers the sustainable media
possible solutions to further improve that technique in near future for services in the heterogeneous networks (Aloi et al., 2016; Fortino,
sustainable and better options.Ultra-high resolution-enabled medical Gravina et al., 2017; Fortino, Russ et al., 2017) because of their com-
videos can be downloaded within seconds with the state-of-the art 5 G patibility and economical service provisioning capability. In addition
technology, besides it handles big data with lesser delay and provides one of the other emerging media transmission protocols such as, Real
more bandwidth. Telemedicine is the physical networks which with Time Control Protocol (RTCP) is playing an important role in m-QoS
different interconnected technologies e.g., Wi-Fi, Bluetooth and Cel- monitoring and optimization by transforming the control packets be-
lular on a single platform and requires high data, high speed and better tween the transmitter and the receiver. RTCP’s function is to deliver
QoS with reliable connectivity. All these hard requirements are fulfilled data distribution quality information to the streaming server. Traffic
by dynamic and superfast capabilities during remote sensing and ef- parameters’ feedback of the real time video streaming like jitter, free
fective, economical treatment. (Chen et al., 2015; Zhao, Cai, & Zhao, residual client buffer space, playout delay and sequence number of
2016), develop the video frame rate control based scheme for max- received packets is also provided by RTCP. The control packets of RTCP
imizing the quality of experience of the user, but the QoS optimization periodicity of the RTCP is normally from one second (9000 frame times)
during medical video transmission is not the center of their attention. to five seconds. The value of control packets are determined at the start
The technological development and dynamic revolution in wireless of session (Fortino, Giordano, Guerrieri, Spezzano, & Vinci, 2016;
Telemedicine applications have broadened the innovative ideas and Fortino, Gravina et al., 2017; Fortino, Russ et al., 2017). The feedback
services; their unique and fundamental ideology is to smooth the provided by the streaming server i.e. frames information at the client
variable bit rate (VBR) medical video by reducing high peak data rate side for buffering or playout during medical video transmission can
and rate variability over flexible and high capacity network to optimize help to optimize the quality of service at server end. As per the size of
the m-QoS. 5 G networks has been developed with relatively high buffer and compressed data type characterized by the user, bit rate of
bandwidth requirements to provide m-QoS guarantees with dynamic data transmission is maintained by the streaming server. Users of
cost management in real time applications such as, smart grids wireless network receives data thorough wireless link, which is the

2
A.H. Sodhro et al. International Journal of Information Management xxx (xxxx) xxx–xxx

bottleneck of whole transmission system due to high peak data rate and Besides, they found the impact of that developed system on the hospital
rate variability of wireless VBR channel. To overcome these short- management platform (García, Tomás, Parra, & Lloret, 2018), design
comings, a window-based rate control algorithm for m-QoS optimiza- the promising mechanism for recognizing the cerebral stroke detection
tion in Telemedicine system over 5 G network is proposed. The two by adopting the cloud to store and interpret the data to facilitate the
well-known characteristics of MPEG compressed videos i.e. high bit rate common citizens. Moreover, signs and symptoms of the cerebral related
and high variability rate in short and long sessions. This variability (in diseases are examined with some practical trends and data analysis
compressed stream bit rate) is mainly because of the use of different tools (García et al., 2018; Liu et al., 2016a, 2016b, 2016c; Van Ma et al.,
coding techniques but transmission of inconstant bit rate stream needs 2017; Xu, Zhao, & Ji, 2011), discuss the efficient and secure healthcare
to transport burst traffic in an effective manner over the Telemedicine monitoring tricks for example, window-enabled data rate smoothing,
networks. In interactive medical video applications the sender knows fuzzy-based decision making, artificial intelligence for dynamic mobile
that small size of video frames imposes strict delay bounds to clients. care, and m-health based on cloud-computing mechanism. Besides, they
Because of this constraint, interactive video quality can be improved by presented the rate control algorithm to smooth picture quality and
employing such methods which can cope-up with the changing sizes of buffer occupancy, but their work did not consider the medical video
video frame, bandwidth and available buffer size. This can be achieved stream and QoS optimization over LTE networks. (Van Ma et al., 2017),
by averaging the transmitting frame sizes and approximating the new develop the fuzzy logic based adaptive video transmission algorithm to
frame sizes on the basis of current frame sizes at server side. For adjust the high peak rate fluctuations with respective to the networks
building mobile edge computing based healthcare platform with big conditions. However, they do not emphasis the QoS estimation during
sensing and portraying bright picture of the incident is the key target of medical video transmission (Chen, Zhou, & Fortino, 2016; El &
this paper. For clear and better visualization at the edge of the networks Ghalwash, 2016; Szpyrka & Biernacka, 2016), design the human emo-
QoS optimization is very vital, because high rate variability, large tions enabled systems, energy efficient video streaming and rate control
peaks, delay and jitter values during medical video transmission gives based approaches for the sensor and healthcare platforms. Besides, they
un-satisfactory level to the patients and doctors. So, in order to remedy propose energy aware and adaptive cross layer scheme for multimedia
these challenges two algorithms such as, w-RCA, BSA, and Baseline are content transmission over WSNs. Their scheme only emphasized on
compared while optimizing the QoS in terms of network metrics i.e., energy-efficient transmission, nevertheless, rate control and offline
PMR, Std.dev, delay and jitter. smoothing algorithms during multimedia transmission is not high-
Contribution of this paper is threefold. lighted in their study. (Majedi, Naeem, & Anpalagan, 2016), examine
the emerging role of communication technologies in the healthcare
• First, to propose window-based rate control algorithm for the with key focus at the efficient resource management.
medical video application such as, Tele-surgery over 5 G networks to (Pace, Frustaci, Aloi, Gianluca, & Fortino, 2017; Pirbhulal, Zhang,
remotely access the incident and portray it with big and clear pic- and Wu, (2016)), develop the novel security frameworks and algo-
ture. rithms for the protecting the healthcare environment. In addition their
• Second, a mobile edge computing-based 5 G framework for QoS research presented adaptive streaming technique for 3GPP packet
optimization in medical media healthcare is proposed. switched streaming service, however, they did not consider rate control
• Third, to establish tradeoff between client buffer size, window size and offline algorithms for medical video transmission in remote health
and network metrics; such as, standard deviation, peak-to-mean monitoring applications. (Alwakeel & AlGhanmi, 2011; Banerjee &
ratio, delay, and jitter to optimize QoS level for interactive medical Sharif, 2016; Gupta, Kar, Baabdullah, & Al-Khowaiter, 2018; Ou &
application. Somayazulu, 2015; Pirbhulal et al., 2016; Sodhro & Fortino, 2017),
propose the various human biological signal transmission, video, image
The rest of the paper is organized as follows. Section 2 proposes the and other vital sign signals with main focus on the energy, security and
window-based rate control algorithm. Section 3, develops the mobile quality of service optimization in the medical healthcare. Moreover,
edge computing based medical video transmission framework. Section they proposed energy-efficient transmission power control algorithm
4 demonstrates the experimental results with detailed discussion. Sec- for patient's vital sign signals transmission over wireless body area
tion 5 concludes the paper. networks, however, they do not focus at medical video stream with QoS
optimization over 5 G networks. Moreover, they developed media
2. Related work transmission algorithm between patients and physicians at remote lo-
cation over WBSNs for healthcare applications i.e. Tele-Education. In
Mobile edge computing is rapidly changing the entire scenario of addition their work focuses at the energy-efficient and friendly video
the digital medical world, especially in the medical healthcare domain. streaming, but medical video stream with network metrics is not dis-
There are various techniques and tools for building smart medical cities cussed. Also their research addressed one of the hot methods for re-
with effective and clear visualization, and better QoS during video moving the repeated video sequences, and hence the power drain.
transmission at remote location i.e., Telemedicine. Several researchers Whereas, their work did not discuss medical video stream transmission
already have investigated the role of emerging technologies in various with RCA over 5G. Also they develop the augmented reality based
fields with the significant contribution for example, (Sodhro et al., framework to enhance the teaching and learning performance in the
2012) design optimal smoothing algorithm for QoS optimization in medical institutes. Besides, neural network enabled gesture and posture
Telemedicine system, although medical video stream with rate control recognition techniques are proposed to clearly understand and examine
algorithm is not considered. (Zingoni et al., 2017), present the effective the structure of the human behaviour (Gupta et al., 2018), rigorously
technique to detect the path of the moving objects in the real-time video reviewd the previous and on-going trends and practices for Big data and
transmission, but do not consider the medical domain and QoS opti- cognitive computing and their strong association. Besides, several da-
mization challenges. (Abdalla & Venkatesan, 2015), propose a perva- tasets from world popular databases for example, ISI web of sceicnes,
sive healthcare platform with real-time window based local call ad- scopus and DBLP are taken into account for further realization (Ying,
mission control algorithm to achieve QoS in IP networks (Cui et al., Jia, & Du, 2018), present the case-study based information is revealed
2016; Liao, Qi, & Wang, 2016; Wua, Kao, & Sambamurthy, 2016), de- about the airlines from Hainan district and then e-commerce enabled
velop the various different methods of self-adaptive, human motion security mechanism is proposed known as blockchain for providing
tracking and e-health management with great trends and practices high security, by protecting the information. Wang and Zhao (2014)
(Wua et al., 2016), propose the theoretical model with main three en- developed joint resource allocation and multimedia stream authenti-
tities related to healthcare in association with IT supporting system. cation technique to preserve the video quality while offering security

3
A.H. Sodhro et al. International Journal of Information Management xxx (xxxx) xxx–xxx

and energy efficiency, but they have not focused at m-QoS optimization due to video data availability in W frames window and the pre-fetch
for video transmission over 5G networks. (Li et al., 2016) proposed Buffer of client. Proposed w-RCA is an offline server side algorithm
optimal smoothing algorithm to minimize the energy over the video where frame rate is controlled by overlapping of N video frames, size of
link, but their research did not focus on rate control mechanism for W window. Transmission schedule cannot be changed after allocating
online medical applications (Koga et al., 2018), propose the novel deep the N and W most of time, to remedy that problem size of the window
learning based vehicle detection technique, but do not focus at the W is increased upto the 600 frames or 20 s frame time for sustaining the
video transmission in medical applications. reasonable delay between the transmitting and the receiving parties.
(Xiao Chen, et al.) design adaptive video frame rate control algo- The W − RCA playing the fair rules of the game by intelligently con-
rithm for adjusting the deviations in the scene during the movement of trolling the frame rate and hence, the smoothed video transmission at
the object, while their research do not focus at the medical video and the transmitter side. It is very vital to select the W according to the size
QoS measurement. Authors in (Chen et al., 2016; El & Ghalwash, 2016; of the raw (i.e., unsmoothed video) stream in order to reduce the high
Majedi et al., 2016; Pace et al., 2017; Szpyrka & Biernacka, 2016), rate variability and the deviation in the different data packets. By un-
present the Green and secure methods for the IoT, BSN and WSN for the derstanding this game carefully, the raw video sequence is transformed
efficient and authenticated health facilities to the aging society, but into the smoothed form by assigning the length to the each video frame
they do not focus at the QoS-optimization in remote medical domain. as given in the Eq. (1)
(Zhao, Ni, & Zhou, 2017), adopt the real-time data sets from the almost
35 subjects and performed the statistical analysis for proposing the LN (1) = f 1f 2f 3
detailed guidelines in mobile healthcare from the age factor perspec- LN (2) = f 4f 5f 6
tive. (Du, Cui, & Su, 2018), present an efficient and customer conflict LN (3) = f 7f 8f 9
..................
management technique known as, online and offline channel conflict ..................
management and monitoring in the e-commerce world. (Nagai, LN (480) = f 1438f 1439f 1440 (1)
Okamawari, & Fujii, 2016), discuss the several techniques with novel
architectures for the IoT-enabled, AHP-based heart rate failure, and Whereas, fi is the ith media frame.
battery friendly techniques for the healthcare in this emerging world, N
but they do not focus at the QoS estimation techniques for the remote D (t ) = ∑ Lf (i)
healthcare environment. Also they addressed the various domains such i=1 (2)
as, hear-rate variability, routing protocols, electroencephalogram, se-
cure and green video transmission algorithms in medical healthcare, Whereas, D (k ) , k ≥ 0 , reveals the average size of the media frames (N )
but their research is not the key point to understand the QoS estimation and fk , k ≥ 0 , shows the kth media frame. The w-RCA smooths the high
in the medical landscape. (Koga et al., 2018) propose the method for peak rate video streams by adopting both the feedback information
recognizing the computational complex functionality with two novel over the initial and client buffer size. As the initial buffer fill level in-
methods for instance, temporal and adaptive multi-task oriented for formation is randomly provided by the (RTCP) in Δts seconds to the
classifying the distinct features. (Liu et al., 2016a, 2016b, 2016c), de- media server at starting client buffer of 64KB. For each sliding window
velop the state-of-the art human motion detection technique named of W frames, w-RCA generates a transmission plan that minimizes both
fusion formation for combining the low and high dimensioning state the high peak data rate and rate variability by taking care of D (t ) and
space vectors. In addition their research present the effective dynamic B (t ) curves as shown in Eqs. (2) and (3). When free buffer information
variation technique for identifying the actions of the human. Liu et al. from RTCP varies in time, then B (t ) curve is modified as in eq. (3)
(2016a, 2016b, 2016c), develop the career optimization method with B (t ) = min{D (t − 1) + Buffer , D (N )} (3)
the support of the network data. Besides they focus on the quality water
estimation by adopting the several learning methods. Liu et al. (2016a, Assume that the free buffer information holds for the entire peri-
2016b, 2016c) design the innovative approach based for predicting the odicity interval, until it is refreshed by grand new coming from client.
water quantity or level in the urban areas. Besides, a framework is The new buffer information as generated by the client is immediately
proposed by applying the famous Chinese policy for running the res- available at server side, so that smoothing can continuously be per-
taurant to predict the future items in the restaurant environment. formed without interruptions. In w-RCA frame size is L (t ) , whereby,
Previous researchers worked in different domains for instance, QoS t = 1, 2, 3, .........., N , buffer variation profile in a generic interval and
analysis in heterogeneous networks, algorithm development for re- maximum frame rate F max is calculated without overflowing.
source allocation, bandwidth maximization, etc, but they do not con- Similarly, F min and Fopt are the minimum and optimal frame rates
sider medical QoS optimization in smart medical cities in remote calculated without buffer starvation at client side. As S (t ) represents the
healthcare applications over 5 G networks. Besides, they have not fo- rate controlled (i.e., smoothed) bit stream in the discrete time slot. The
cused at the impact of client buffer size on m-QoS metrics such as, smoothed medical video transmission plan is given by a monotonically
standard deviation, peak-to-mean ratio, delay, and jitter. increasing and piecewise linear path that lies between D (t ) and B (t )
curves in Eqs. (2) and (3). There are a growing number of VBR inter-
3. Proposed window-based rate control algorithm for mobile edge active medical video applications in 5 G networks that require potential
computing healthcare applications methods to reduce high peak data rate and rate variability during vo-
luminous data transmission.
Because of voluminous medical health data collection from the
VF
mobile edge clouds such as, for Tele-medical news casts video trans- ∑t = 1 [D (t ) + Buffer ] − W
mission, server is not able to smooth the complete stream. The w-RCA is F max =
tB (4)
periodically applied while video is transmitted in new smoothing
window each time. For w-RCA development, a method is applied in B (t ) − q _buffer
which video source creates one data frame per unit time. Frames of tB =
t (5)
smoothening window given by W inserts a playback delay of W time
units at client side and the server should be able to secure a buffer space Whereby, tB is the starting time with the clear information about the
of W frames for Telemedical feeds. Finally, large values of W provides a filled level of buffer while transmitting video at F max , similarly, the
smooth video transmission but at the cost of large server buffer and minimum video frame rate is represented by F min by adopting the
greater client playback delay. In w-RCA, the pre-fetching is bounded initial buffer level i.e., q _buffer .

4
A.H. Sodhro et al. International Journal of Information Management xxx (xxxx) xxx–xxx

N
∑t = 1 D (t ) − q _buffer + W amount of data and is better able to take advantage of lookahead to
F min = workahead more aggressively. For bigger windows, the client buffer has
tD (6)
the limitation of workahead amount; the server holds sufficient data but
D (t ) − q _buffer is bounded by the comparatively smaller client buffer. For such buffer
tD =
t (7) sizes larger smoothing windows permits the w-RCA to attain reduction
in peak rate and rate variability close to the BSA. Nevertheless, rate
F min +F max controlling of VBR medical video stream is still effective to reduce high
Fopt =
2 (8)
peak data rate and rate variability. Further optimization of smoothed
By considering the W frames as [f , (f + W − 1)] whereby, f is the video transmission plan is obtained by applying w-RCA on time windows of
frame, and w-RCA calculates F max , F min , Fopt , tB and tD as shown in W frames and increasing client buffer size. The overlapping degree
Eqs. (4)–(8), in each discrete timet . If there is t ′ < f + W − 1, such that among consecutive smoothing windows will thus be N − W frames.
(t ′) Proposed w-RCA is thus applied and composed by N − W smoothed
F min > F max , surely a buffer underflow occurs in t ′, scheduled bit
frames calculated in the previous window, plus W new unsmoothed
rate will thus be F max in [α, t ′ − 1], then setting α = t ′ − 1.Similarly, if
(t ′)
frames. It is observed that performance of w-RCA is improved for higher
F min > F max buffer overflow occurs. The scheduled frame rate will overlapping degrees (N − W ) .
be F min in [α, t ′ − 1] and α = t ′ − 1. This process generates the var-
iation free i.e., smoothed transmission schedule accordingly as 3.1. Mobile edge based medical healthcare video transmission framework
[f , (f + W − 1)], which shows less rate variable based video stream. The
proposed w-RCA intends to reduce the high peak spikes and Stad.dev in In this section we propose the novel 5G-enabled mobile edge and
the raw video stream by considering the large window size, which ef- QoS-aware framework for the healthcare applications, there are three
fectively optimizes the m-QoS. The shifting margin of α is made in the main layers at the both server and client side with various protocols
window W as W − α to further obtain the smoothed and feasible video such as, Session Description Protocol (SDP), Real Time Streaming
transmission schedule as [f + α, (f + W − 1 + α )]. The entire informa- Protocol (RTSP), Transmission Control Protocol (TCP), Real-time
tion of the buffer filled level Buffer (f − α ) , the average video schedule Transport Protocol (RTP), Real-time Transport Control Protocol
S (f − α ) is preserved to smooth the whole video streams S (t ) by ap- (RTCP), User Datagram Protocol (UDP), Internet Protocol (IP), etc and
plying the smoothed window. When, the new α unsmoothed frames are L2, L1. There is a strong connection between server and client while
added into the smoothing window, then data underflow will be mini- exchanging video frames through the wireless channel. We classify the
mized by considering the W − α which is the final window length. proposed framework into three main levels for instance, level 1, level 2,
Proposed w-RCA modifies the transmission schedule accordingly during and level 3 as the streaming server, network performance indicators,
transmission of the video sequence in Δts sec, by following the previous and the streaming client accordingly. Level 2 or middle level is very
buffer fill level. Furthermore, at the beginning of the video stream, w- important to analyze the performance of the medical healthcare ap-
RCA calculates the stream schedule on the basis of W (video frames) plications during video transmission at remote location, as resented in
window length of α frames. When the first buffer information areal (Δts ) the Fig. 5.
arrives to server at frame time Δts , it calculates new upper bound B (t )
as in Eq. (7) 4. Experimental set-up for mobile edge computing healthcare
The transmission and rate controlling schedule of proposed w-RCA applications
is calculated through Eq. (8) starting from Δts , always sliding the W
frames window by α frames, until 2Δts and so on. Proposed w-RCA This section presents the detailed explanation of test-bed. We si-
computes video transmission rate on the basis of available frames and mulate in MATLAB a 8-minute pre-recorded medical media stream ti-
calculates pre-fetching more aggressively through effective heuristics tled, ‘Navigation to the Uterine Horn, transection of the horn and re-
by anticipating next frame lengths. In MPEG encoding, W denotes an anastomosis’ with MPEG-4 encoder (640 × 480). Medical quality of
integer multiple of frames quantity G in a group of pictures (GOP) to service (m-QoS) is optimized in mobile edge computing during
assure similar proportion of window in every I, P, and B frame, as healthcare video transmission at remote location. Better visualization
shown in the Fig. 3(a) and (b) (Table 1). with big sensing is analyzed during remote sensing for portraying the
Window or sliding window executes smoothing on overlapping clear picture of the incident throughout the experiment with single-hop
window of size W . To integrate the received video frames, the w-RCA communication scenario. Here, we assume media stream with high
calculates the transmission schedule on each α time units for future W variability such as, dissection during Tele-surgery of emergency pa-
frames, where α (slide length) is less than equal toW . At time t w-RCA tients, which causes more delay with high peak variable frame rates. In
smooths and sustains a segment of video at position p to p + W is addition, regardless of the encoder selection, m-QoS depends on the
shown in Figs. 2 and 4. During t + α , α extra frames are sent, smoothing complexity and content of the media sequence and its effect on overall
is made by algorithm from frame position p + α + 1 to p + α + W + 1. smart medical city. A comparison of QoS optimization is presented for
The present window smoothing at t + α contains a starting (W − α ) proposed w-RCA, and conventional BSA, Baseline as given in Table 2.
slots (grey colored region) which is included in some previous Experimental results in Table 2, reveals the performance analysis of w-
smoothing windows, and fresh frame positions given by α (non-colored RCA, BSA and Baseline depending upon various buffer size and start-up
area). The dark region represents smooth transmission schedule be- delay, t0 of 2 frame. It was observed that increase in idle time decreases
cause of smoothing completed at t . The benefit of sliding window for media sequence’s rate variability. Monte Carlo simulation is conducted
smoothing in w-RCA is based on the frequency of video source re- for attending 99% confidence level in the outcome, detailed parameters
computations of transmission schedule to include new frames at arri- are presented in Table 2.
vals. To calculate the sensitivity of the w-RCA to the computational
frequency, sliding window performance is compared at various α values 4.1. Video sequence and parameters for mobile edge computing medical
over different window sizes W such as; SLWIN (1), SLWIN (W /2), applications
SLWIN (W /3) and SLWIN (W /4) with different client buffer sizes.
However small slide length reduces the burstiness of the medical video In this sub-section the 8-min video stream named, ‘Navigation to the
streams. To check the performance of the w-RCA, we will use different Uterine Horn, transection of the horn and re-anastomosis’ with MPEG
window sizes W , start up latency of 0.5 s and slide length (α ) of encoder 640 × 480 is adopted. Basically, video comprises Left, Right
α = W /2 . For greater window size, the server could use a greater and Stereo parts with total capacity of 7.5 GB (2.5 GB for each section).

5
A.H. Sodhro et al.

Table 1
Summary of Existing Works.
Ref. No Applications Proposed Techniques Component being Optimized Results

(Clark et al., 2013; Karambakhsha et al., 2018; Mukhopadhyay et al., 2015; Sodhro Mobile edge computing, IoT, BSN, Battery management Charge and energy Battery Aware
et al., 2016a; Sodhro, Kumar Sangaiah et al., 2018) healthcare
(Enayet & Fortino, 2018; Sodhro et al., 2018a; Zingoni et al., 2017) Mobile edge computing, Medical hospitals, Battery and energy-efficient TPC duty-cycle, data rate Less energy and battery
BAN, BSN driven and MAC based charge drain.
(Aloi et al., 2016; Chen et al., 2015; Ferdous et al., 2017; Fortino, Russo, Savaglio, Healthcare, 5G, milli-meter wave, smart TPC, and data rate based Security key, resource allocation Low power consumption
Shen, & Zhou, 2017; Kaba, 2018; Sodhro & Li, 2013b; Zhao et al., 2016;) mobile, security
(Abdalla & Venkatesan, 2015; Fortino, Gravina, Russo, & Savaglio, 2017, 2016) Healthcare, Security, IoT and ECG Algorithms, Architecture Authentication key, Duty cycle Minimize cost and energy
consumption
(Cui & Liu et al., 2016; Liao et al., 2016; Wua et al., 2016) IoMT, Telemedicine Battery-friendly, rate control Battery charge and modulation IoT longer media
level transmission
(García et al., 2018; Li et al., 2016; Van Ma et al., 2017; Xu et al., 2011) Wireless capsule, IoMT Predictive techniques Battery charge, data rates Improve mobility, battery
lifetime

6
(Chen et al., 2016; El & Ghalwash, 2016; Majedi et al., 2016; Szpyrka & Biernacka, IoT, DLM, wireless ad-hoc networks Window-based algorithms, Transmission rates Battery-friendly, and energy-
2016) Battery models efficient
(Pace et al., 2017; Sandeep, Zhang, Wu, & Zhang, 2016; Sodhro & Fortino, 2017) Mobile edge computing, Medical media, Energy optimization algorithms Novel Frameworks Smart medical healthcare
5G system
(Pirbhulal et al., 2017; Sodhro & Li, 2013a; Pirbhulal et al., 2016) IoT, PLM, Edge computing, Industries Ontology-based methods and Battery lifecycle Smart PLM, Smart CPS
architectures
(Ou & Somayazulu, 2015; Sodhro et al., 2012; Sodhro et al., 2018b) QoS, Edge computing WSN, Security, Dynamic game-based and energy TPC and data rate To extend the lifecycle of
management medical devices
(Alwakeel & AlGhanmi, 2011; Banerjee & Sharif, 2016; Sodhro et al., 2016b; Sodhro, Healthcare, Energy Harvesting, PLM and Battery-friendly and Energy Battery charge Lifetime of smart IoMT and
Sekahri et al., 2018) WPT Harvesting BSN devices
(Gupta et al., 2018; Sodhro & Li, 2014; Sodhro et al., 2018a, 2018b; Sodhro, Kumar Mobile edge computing, EEG, Security in Routing-based power control To optimize QoS in PLM To monitor IoT based
Sangaiah et al., 2018; Sodhro, Sekahri et al., 2018; Singh, Ott, & Curcio, 2014; BAN techniques healthcare
Wang & Zhao, 2014)
(Chen et al., 2013; Du et al., 2018; Koga et al., 2018; Nagai et al., 2016; Ying et al., Artificial Intelligence, security ECG, QoS Fuzzy-logic, HRV and energy- To optimize, transmission power To obtain energy-efficient
2018; Zhao et al., 2017) and Energy management Frameworks efficient techniques and battery charge IoT based
(Liu et al., 2016a, 2016b; 2016c; Liu, 2016) Complex pattern recognition, optimal Novel pattern recognition To optimize the path selection Optimal and predictive
career path, approach, career methods
International Journal of Information Management xxx (xxxx) xxx–xxx
A.H. Sodhro et al. International Journal of Information Management xxx (xxxx) xxx–xxx

Fig. 2. Window-based transmission mechanism in rate control Algorithm.

Each part contains two parameters such as, frame length and rate
variability which are the fundamental ingredients of any video se-
quence (Cui et al., 2016; Xu et al., 2011). Furthermore, the properties
and parameters calculation of aforementioned video stream are shown
in the Table 2.

4.2. Results and discussion

Experiment is performed by taking into account the client buffer


size, window (W ) and server, client buffer sizes, video stream
Transection of the horn and re-anastomosis with MPEG-4 encoder. We
compare w-RCA, BSA and Baseline for m-QoS optimization in terms of
different m-QoS metrics such as; peak-to-mean ratio, standard devia-
tion, delay, and jitter over 5 G network. We establish tradeoff between
window size, buffer size, peak-to-mean ratio, standard deviation, delay, Fig. 4. Transmission schedule of window-based rate control algorithm.
and jitter. It is analyzed that if window size (W ) and client buffer size
increase then peak-to-mean ratio and standard deviation decrease of 600 frames or playback delay of 20 s. and client buffer size of 16MB
which shows the smooth transmission of the real time VBR medical to optimize m-QoS in Telemedicine system.
video. The experiemtal results are demonstrated in Table 2 and Figs. 5–8.
On the contrary delay and jitter values increase with the increase of Proposed w-RCA reduces high peak data rate and rate variability dra-
the client buffer size but their range is below the range of threshold matically with window size ss (W ) of 600 frames and different client
values of delay and jitter for Tele-surgery. For example; threshold value buffer size than the BSA and Baseline for smart medical cities to opti-
of delay and jitter are 250 ms and 20 ms respectively, and our proposed mize m-QoS in terms of peak-to-mean ratio (PMR), standard deviation
algorithm provide 132 ms of delay value and 0.40 ms of jitter value. In (Std.dev), delay, jitter, average delay and average jitter in relation with
addition, from experimental results it is clear that if any one parameter different client buffer size. If buffer size increases then PMR and
from client buffer size and window size varies not in proportion to each Std.Dev are decreasing while delay is increasing for both algorithms.
other than the performance of proposed w-RCA will be affected. After But the performance of the w-RCA is better than the BSA and Baseline
experimental analysis it is found that our proposed algorithm performs because by using large window size and increasing client buffer size the
better than the offline optimal smoothing algorithm with window size w-RCA shows dramatic reduction in the PMR and std.dev then the BSA,

Fig. 3. Difference between packet and video frame transmission, (a) data packet, and (b) video frame.

7
A.H. Sodhro et al. International Journal of Information Management xxx (xxxx) xxx–xxx

Fig. 5. Proposed Framework for Mobile Edge Computing based Medical Healthcare Applications.

Table 2 5. Conclusion and future research


Experimental parameters for medical media transmission.
Parameter Value Parameter Value
In this paper, we develop window-based Rate Control Algorithm (w-
RCA) for the variable bit rate (VBR) medical video for remote health-
Total Video Frames 1440 Video frame total 8 mints care i.e., Tele-surgery over 5 G based mobile edge computing healthcare
(F) time (T) networks through work ahead transmission by delaying that video W
Video frame rate (r 3 per sec Video frame length 100 Bytes
time units. Besides, Baseline, BSA and proposed w-RCA are compred in
(t)) ( Lf )
Video frame arrival 5msec Inter-arrival time 1msec
terms of network metrics i.e., PMR, Std.dev, delay and jitter for m-QoS
time (t) ( Δ) optimization. Furthermore, a feedback information about real time
Buffer Size (Buffer) 64KB,512KB,2MB,4MB Initial buffer size 0 buffer fill level from client to server with real-time transmission control
Supply voltage 2.5 V Initial current (I) 200mA protocol (RTCP) is used to reduce the high peak data rate and Std.dev
which are the key components in m-QoS optimization. Medical server
or transmitter gets information about future frames and recomputes
and Baseline. The delay of w-RCA are is less than the suitable for the
transmission schedule as new frames arrive with the help of feedback
medical application such as, Tele-surgery and Tele-consultation be-
information from RTCP. A tradeoff between window size and Buffer size
cause the threshold values of delay and jitter for real time video medical
with m-QoS metrics is established mathematically and experimentally.
applications are 250 ms and 20 ms respectively, and our proposed w-
Experimental results show that proposed w-RCA outperforms the
RCA provides delay and jitter values 132 ms and 0.40 ms respectively.
Baseline and BSA by optimizing the m-QoS at remote location. Besides,
Figs. 6–8, reveals the peak-to-mean ratio (PMR), standard deviation
large window size, Buffer size and knowledge of future frames through
(Std.dev) and delay of different algorithms. In Fig. 6, PMR of Baseline,
RTCP server provides good transmission schedule for smart medical
w-RCA and BSA is compred at different buffer-size, and it is observed
cities at remote location such as,Tele-surgery. In addition, w-RCA bal-
that PMR of w-RCA reduces at larger extent with the increase of buf-
ances the use of processing, memory and network resources (i.e., peak-
fersize than the Baseline and BSA. Fig. 7(b), presents rate variability of
to-mean ratio, standard deviation, delay, and jitter). In near future, we
Baseline, w-RCA and BSA at different buffersizes for unsmoothed
will implement w-RCA on hardware for medical video transmission
(i.e.,raw video) and processed video, it is examined that rate variability
over joint body sensor networks (BSNs), bluetooth low energy (BLE)
of w-RCA decreases with the increase of the buffersize as compared to
and Internet of Things (IoT).
the BSA and Baseline. Fig. 8(a), the relationship between buffersize and
Following are the limitations of the proposed DAA.
delay at different buffersize for w-RCA, Baseline and BSA. It is ex-
amined that Baseline and BSA shows larger delay while w-RCA has less
delay. Fig. 8(b), presents the Std.dev of Baseline, w-RCA and BSA, it is • Due to static and less efficient nature of the conventional methods
QoS is not optimized properly in the medical healthcare application.
examined that w-RCA has less std.dev than the Baseline and BSA, and
Besides, the resource-constrained nature of the wearable sensor
becomes smaller with the increase of the buffersizeFinally, after ana-
devices it is very vital to carefully manage and monitor the QoS in
lysis and comparison of all algorithms we can say that w-RCA outper-
tiny sensor-based wearable devices.
forms the Baseline and BSA by optimizing m-QoS during video trans-
mission in smart medical cities at remote location. • Rate-control algorithms is applicable merely for the multimedia
application and big data platforms
• w-RCA shows relatively more delay

8
A.H. Sodhro et al. International Journal of Information Management xxx (xxxx) xxx–xxx

Fig. 6. Comparative Analysis (a),(b) Unsmoothed video stream; (c),(d) Buffer size = 64KB and Window size = 600; e),(f) Buffer size = 2MB and Window size = 600,
for Baseline, BSA and w-RCA, respectively.

Fig. 7. Peak-to-mean ratio of the w-RCA, BSA and Baseline.

9
A.H. Sodhro et al. International Journal of Information Management xxx (xxxx) xxx–xxx

Fig. 8. (a) Relation between delay and buffer size, (b) trade-off between time and standard for Baseline, BSA and w-RCA, respectively.

In near future, we will implement w-RCA on hardware for medical 16(21), 7792–7802.
video transmission joint body sensor networks (BSNs) and Internet of Enayet, A., & Fortino, G. (2018). A mobility-aware optimal resource allocation archi-
tecture for big data task execution on mobile cloud in smart cities. IEEE
Things (IoT). Communications Magazine, 56(2), 110–117.
Ferdous, J., Alamri, A., Fortino, G., & Zhou, M. (2017). Optimal dynamic pricing for
Disclosures trading-off user utility and operator profit in smart grid. IEEE Transactions on Systems,
Man, and Cybernetics Systems, 12(4), 22–30. https://doi.org/10.1109/TSMC.2017.
2764442.
There is no conflict of interest between all authors. Fortino, G., Giordano, A., Guerrieri, A., Spezzano, G., & Vinci, A. (2016). On the design of
smart homes: A framework for activity recognition in home environment. Journal of
Medical Systems, 40(9), https://doi.org/10.1007/s10916-016-0549-7.
Acknowledgement
Fortino, G., Gravina, R., Russo, W., & Savaglio, C. (2017). Modeling and simulating in-
ternet-of-things systems: A hybrid agent-oriented approach. Computing in Science &
This work is funded by HEC Pakistan under the START-UP Engineering, 19(5), 68–76. https://doi.org/10.1109/MCSE.2017.342154.
Fortino, G., Russo, W., Savaglio, C., Shen, W., & Zhou, M. (2017). Agent-oriented co-
RESEARCH GRANT PROGRAM (SRGP)#21-1465/SRGP/R&D/HEC/
operative smart objects: From IoT system design to implementation. IEEE Transactions
2016, and Sukkur IBA University, Sukkur, Sindh, Pakistan, and DISP on Systems, Man and Cybernetics: Systems, PP, 99, 1–18.
LAB University Lumiere Lyon 2, under Erasmus Mundus’s SMARTLINK García, L., Tomás, J.ús, Parra, L., & Lloret, J. (2018). An m-health application for cerebral
Program2017. This work is partially supported by Natural Science stroke detection and monitoring using cloud services, International Journal of Information
Management. Elsevier22–31.
Foundation of China6171101169, Guangdong Education Bureau Gupta, S., Kar, A. K., Baabdullah, A., & Al-Khowaiter, W. A. A. (2018). Big data with
Fund2017KTSCX166, the Science and Technology Innovation cognitive computing: A review for the future. International Journal of Information
Committee Foundation of ShenzhenJCYJ20170817112037041, Science Management, Elsevier, 42(1), 78–89.
Kaba, B. (2018). Modeling information and communication technology use continuance
and Technology Innovation Committee Foundation of Shenzhen (Grant behavior: Are there differences between users on basis of their status? International
No. ZDSYS201703031748284), SUSTech Startup FundY01236215/ Journal of Information Management, Elsevier, 38(2018), 77–85.
Y01236115. Karambakhsha, A., Kamela, A., Sheng, B., Li, P., Yang, P., & Dagan Fengd, D. (2018). Deep
gesture interaction for augmented anatomy learning. International Journal of
Information Management, 1–9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijinfomgt.2018.03.004.
References Koga, Y., et al. (2018). A CNN-based method of vehicle detection from aerial images using
hard example mining. MDPI Remote Sensing, 10(1), 1–21.
Li, L., et al. (2016). Recognizing complex activities by a probabilistic interval-based model.
Abdalla, I., & Venkatesan, S. (2015). QoE preserving resource scheduling for M2M
Proceedings of the Thirtieth AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence (AAAI-16)
terminals and human users in LTE networks. International Journal of Ad Hoc and
1266–1272.
Ubiquitous Computing, 19(3-4), 254–265.
Liao, J., Qi, Q., & Wang, J. (2016). A dual mode self-adaption handoff for multimedia
Aloi, G., Caliciuri, G., Fortino, G., Gravina, R., Pace, P., Russo, W., et al. (2016). Enabling
services in mobile cloud computing environment. Multimedia Tools and Applications,
IoT interoperability through opportunistic smartphone-based mobile gateways.
75(8), 4697–4722.
Journal of Network and Computer Applications, 81(1), 74–84. https://doi.org/10.1016/
Ye, L. (2016). Urban Water quality prediction based on multi-task multi-view learning.
j.jnca.2016.10.013.
Proceedings of the Twenty-Fifth International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence
Alwakeel, S. S., & AlGhanmi, S. S. (2011). A real time window-based local call admission
(IJCAI-16)2576–2582.
control algorithm for IP networks. 163–167.
Ye, L., et al. (2016a). Action2Activity: Recognizing complex activities from sensor data. 1–7.
Banerjee, S., & Sharif, H. (2016). A survey of wireless communication technologies & their
Ye, L., et al. (2016b). From action to activity: Sensor-based activity recognition.
performance for high speed railways. Journal of Transportation Technologies, 6(1),
Neurocomputing, 181(12), 108–115.
1–15.
Ye, L., et al. (2016c). Fortune teller: Predicting your career path, AAAI publications. Thirtieth
Chen, C., et al. (2015). Rate adaptation and admission control for video transmission with
AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence.
subjective quality constraints. IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Signal Processing, 9(1),
Majedi, N., Naeem, M., & Anpalagan, A. (2016). Telecommunication integration in
22–36.
e‐healthcare: Technologies, applications and challenges. Transactions on Emerging
Chen, M., Zhou, P., & Fortino, G. (2016). Emotion communication system. IEEE Access:
Telecommunications Technologies, 27(6), 775–789.
Practical Innovations, Open Solutions, 2016. https://doi.org/10.1109/ACCESS.2016.
Mukhopadhyay, A., Navyashree, V., & Meenakshi, M. (2015). Handover from LTE to
2641480.
VSAT with an analysis to provide optimized performance in telemedicine ambu-
Chen, X., et al. (2013). Adaptive rate control algorithm for H.264/AVC considering scene
lances. International Journal of Applied Engineering Research and Development, 10(10),
change. Mathematical Problems in Engineering, 2013(2013), 1–6.
26127–26137.
Clark, A., Gross, K., & Wu, Q. (2013). RTP control protocol (RTCP) extended report (XR)
Nagai, Y., Okamawari, T., & Fujii, T. (2016). A novel streaming method using QoS control
block for delay metric reporting2070-1721.
function of LTE to prevent video freezing. IEEE Wireless Communications and Networking
Cui, J., Liu, Y., et al. (2016). Tracking generic human motion via fusion of low- and high-
Conference (WCNC)1–6.
dimensional approaches. IEEE Transaction on Systems, man and Cybernetics, 43(4),
Ou, S.-H., & Somayazulu, V. S. (2015). On-line multi-view video summarization for
996–1002.
wireless video sensor network. IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Signal Processing,
Du, Y., Cui, M., & Su, J. (2018). Implementation processes of online and offline channel
9(1), 165–179.
conflict management strategies in manufacturing enterprises: A resource orchestra-
Pace, P., Frustaci, M., Aloi, Gianluca, & Fortino (2017). Evaluating critical security issues
tion perspective. International Journal of Information Management, Elsevier, 39(2018),
of the IoT world: Present and Future challenges. IEEE IoT Journal, 20(5) 1-1.
136–145.
Pirbhulal, S., et al. (2017). Analysis of efficient biometric index using heart rate varia-
El, M. E. E. D. A., & Ghalwash, A. Z. (2016). Energy aware and adaptive cross-layer
bility for remote monitoring of obstructive sleep apnea. Neuropsychiatry, 2017.
scheme for video transmission over wireless sensor networks. IEEE Sensors Journal,
Pirbhulal, S., Zhang, H., Wu, W., et al. (2016). A novel secure IoT-based smart home

10
A.H. Sodhro et al. International Journal of Information Management xxx (xxxx) xxx–xxx

automation system using a wireless sensor network. Sensors, 17(1), 69. Sodhro, A. H., Li, Y., & Shah, M. A. (2016b). Green and friendly media transmission
Sandeep, P., Zhang, H., Wu, W., & Zhang, Y.-T. (2016). A comparative study of fuzzy vault algorithms for wireless body sensor networks. Multimedia Tools and Applications,
based security methods for wireless body sensor networks. IEEE 10th International 75(23), 1–25.
Conference on Sensing Technology (ICST)1–6. Sodhro, A. H., Kumar Sangaiah, A., & Sodhro, G. H. (2018). 5G-based transmission power
Singh, V., Ott, J., & Curcio, I. (2014). RTP control protocol (RTCP) extended report (XR) control mechanism in fog computing for IoT devices. MDPI Sustainability, 10(4), 1–17.
block for the bytes discarded metric2070-1721. Sodhro, A. H., Sekahri, A., & Ouzrout, Y. (2018). Energy-efficiency comparison between
Sodhro, A. H., & Fortino, G. (2017). Energy management during video transmission in data rate control and transmission power control algorithms for wireless body sensor
WBSNs. 14th IEEE International Conference on Networking, Sensing and Control networks. International Journal of Distributed Sensor Networks (IJDSN), 14(1), 1–18.
(ICNSC), 1–8. Szpyrka, M., & Biernacka, A. (2016). Tools and methods for RTCP-nets modeling and
Sodhro, A. H., & Li, Y. (2014). Battery-Friendly packet transmission strategies for wireless verification. Archives of Control Sciences, 26(3), 339–365.
capsule endoscopy. IFMBE The International Conference on Health Informatics, Van Ma, L., et al. (2017). A fuzzy-based adaptive streaming algorithm for reducing en-
Internation Federation for Medical and Biological Engineering (IFMBE) tropy rate of DASH bitrate fluctuation to improve mobile quality of service. MDPI
Proceedings236–239 42. Entropy, 19(9), 1–18.
Sodhro, A. H., & Li, Y. (2013a). Novel key storage and management solution for the Wang, W., & Zhao, M. (2014). Resource optimized TTSH-URA for multimedia stream
security of wireless sensor networks. TELKOMNIKA Indonesian Journal of Electrical authentication in swallowable-capsule-based wireless body sensor networks. IEEE
Engineering, 11(6), 3383–3390. Journal of Biomedical and Health Informatics, 18(2), 404–410.
Sodhro, A. H., & Li, Y. (2013b). Medical quality-of-service optimization in wireless tel- Wua, J.-H., Kao, H.-Y., & Sambamurthy, V. (2016). The integration effort and E-health
emedicine system using optimal smoothing algorithm. ETSN Journal, 2(1), 1–8. compatibility effect and the mediating role of E-health synergy on hospital perfor-
Sodhro, A. H., Hyder, S., & Shah, F. (2012). Impact of transmission control protocol mance. Elsevier, 36(2016), 1288–1300.
window size on routing protocols of wireless sensor networks. Sindh University Xu, L., Zhao, D., & Ji, X. (2011). Window-level rate control for smooth picture quality and
Research Journal (SURJ), 44(2AB), 143–148. smooth buffer occupancy. IEEE Transactions on Image Processing, 20(3), 723–734.
Sodhro, A. H., Li, Y., & Shah, M. A. (2016a). Energy-efficient adaptive transmission power Ying, W., Jia, S., & Du, W. (2018). Digital enablement of blockchain: Evidence from HNA
control in wireless body area networks. IET Communications, 10(1), 81–90. group. International Journal of Information Management, 38(2018), 1–4.
Sodhro, A. H., Kumar Sangaiah, A., & Pibhulal, S. (2018a). Convergence of IoT and Zhao, C., Cai, Z., Zhao, Y., et al. (2016). HEVC video quality assessment database toward LTE
product lifecycle management in medical health care “future generation computer system. 11th International Conference Computer Science & Education (ICCSE)357–362.
systems: Special issue on emerging edge-of-things computing: Opportunities and Zhao, Y., Ni, Q., & Zhou, R. (2017). What factors influence the mobile health service
challenges. Elsevier, 86(1), 380–391. adoption? A meta-analysis and the moderating role of age International Journal of
Sodhro, A. H., Kumar Sangaiah, A., & Pirbhulal, S. (2018b). An energy-efficient algorithm Information Management, 1–9. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijinfomgt.2017.08.006.
for wearable electrocardiogram signal processing in ubiquitous healthcare applica- Zingoni, A., et al. (2017). A flexible algorithm for detecting challenging moving objects in
tions. MDPI Sensors, 8(3), 923. real-time within IR video sequences. MDPI Remote Sensing, 9(11), 1–21.

11

Вам также может понравиться