Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Abstract: Leachate from mixed glass cullet 共crushed recycled glass containers兲 that is stockpiled before use as construction aggregate or
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by Lund University on 05/25/15. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.
sand substitute is a potential source of water pollution. Rainwater leaching through the stockpiles dissolves and suspends organic
compounds and nutrients from the glass. The objectives of this study were to investigate the effect of forced aeration on leachate quantity
and quality in the glass cullet stockpiles compared to mechanical turning/mixing. Three experimental stockpiles were set up in the field,
two with forced aeration treatment 共one with fine and the other with coarse cullet兲 and one 共coarse cullet兲 with mechanical turning. The
organic concentrations in the leachate in most cases were comparable to those of raw domestic wastewater. Organic constituents 共e.g.,
BOD5兲 were reduced by⬎ 70% from the initial levels 共⬃450 mg L−1兲 during a 1.5-month period with forced aeration, compared to an
85% decrease in the turned stockpile. Particle size affected temperature and oxygen levels under aeration conditions, resulting in more
biodegradation of organic contaminants in the stockpile of coarse cullet than the fine cullet.
DOI: 10.1061/共ASCE兲EE.1943-7870.0000183
CE Database subject headings: Solid wastes; Waste management; Recycling; Water quality; Stormwater management.
Author keywords: Aeration; Glass; Composting.
(b) 1.1 m
PVC aeration pipe (Ø = 100 cm) with
eight distribution outlets (Ø = 1.27 cm)
1.1 m
Multipurpose rubber hose (Ø = 2.54 cm),
connected to the blower
Fig. 1. 共a兲 Schematic of lined, aerated glass cullet stockpiles AC and AF; 共b兲 details of manifold distribution system, consisting of a perforated
PVC pipe square 共1.1⫻ 1.1 m兲 that was connected to the blower
The cullet from these two sources was mixed immediately after stockpile 共set up on July 24, denoted as TC兲 also consisted of
delivery to the study site. The fine cullet 共⬍4.75 mm兲 was from coarse cullet but was not placed on a liner to allow weekly turn-
a third facility. The two different particle sizes were selected to ing by front end loader.
assess the effect of particle size on the efficiency of the aeration Both lined stockpiles had manifold air distribution systems
treatment. consisting of perforated PVC pipe, arranged to form a 1.1-m
square, and placed at 0.43-m height in the middle of the stock-
Setup, Operation, and Monitoring of Glass Cullet piles 关Fig. 1共b兲兴. The pipe was connected to a blower 共Model R2,
Experimental Stockpiles Gast, Benton Harbor, Mich.兲, which operated at a maximum aera-
tion rate of 1.19 m3 min−1. The actual aeration rate of
0.65 m3 min−1 was calculated based on the measured inlet air
Setup of Stockpiles
pressure of ⬃7 kPa. The purpose of the forced aeration was to
Three experimental cullet stockpiles 共initial mass: ⬃35 Mg each;
height: 2.2 m; and base diameter: 6.3 m兲 were set up uncovered in maintain the temperature below 55° C and to ensure aerobic con-
the field. Two actively aerated stockpiles 共one of coarse cullet set ditions in the stockpiles. An automatic timer was controlled
up on July 24, denoted as AC兲, and the other of fine cullet set up manually based on pile temperatures, oxygen levels, and precipi-
on August 1 共denoted as AF兲 were placed on 45 mil 共1.1 mm兲 tation amounts. As a result, the stockpile AC was aerated for 30 s
Firestone Pondguard liners 共Webb’s Water Gardens, Fallston, every 30 min, from Day 3 to Day 8; and 30 s, every 90–120 min,
Md.兲 to allow the collection of leachate 关Fig. 1共a兲兴. The third on Days 11, 14, and 17 共when temperatures above 55° C were
measured兲 with no aeration thereafter. Stockpile AF was aerated washwater from this stockpile showed a reduction of the organic
for 1 min, every 2 h from Day 2 through the end of Week 5, after contaminants 共e.g., paper labels and food and beverage residuals兲
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by Lund University on 05/25/15. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.
which temperatures dropped below 55° C. over time 共Table 1兲, indicating the source of the microbially gen-
Temperatures were measured with thermocouple probes 共Type erated heat.
T or K, Omega Engineering, Inc., Stamford, Conn.兲 at 9 points at In the aerated stockpiles the highest temperature was measured
selected heights and depths for each stockpile 共Tsai et al. 2009兲. for both piles 1 week after setup, with the highest temperature
Oxygen levels were monitored 共model K25, Jewell Elec. Insts., measured in stockpile AF 共71° C兲. Compared to pile AC, generally
Inc., Bacharach Inc., Pittsburgh兲 at the same times and locations higher temperatures and lower oxygen levels were found in stock-
as temperatures, except that only six points were used 共Tsai et al. pile AF 共Fig. 2兲. However, the prolonged low oxygen levels found
2009兲. Measurement of oxygen helps in evaluating if sufficient by Tsai et al. 共2009兲 in the stockpile of fine cullet were not found
oxygen is available for rapid decomposition. with the forced aeration. Oxygen levels reached near ambient
levels throughout both aerated piles within 40–50 days after setup
共Fig. 2兲, which is about 30–50 days earlier than in the unaerated
Sampling of Cullet and Leachate and Leachate
stockpiles of Tsai et al. 共2009兲.
Quantification
The lower temperature and higher oxygen concentrations mea-
Cullet samples were collected from the lined, aerated piles at the sured in the aerated stockpile AC compared to AF suggests an
beginning and end 共6–7 weeks兲 of the experiment. From the un- effect of particle size on temperature and oxygen levels with
lined, turned pile, sampling of the cullet was conducted at 0 共be- active aeration. As a result 共higher than optimum temperatures,
ginning兲, 1, 3, and 6 weeks. reduced oxygen兲 the biodegradation of the organic contaminants
Leachate sampling followed the methodology developed by was less in stockpile AF 共see BOD5 and COD, Table 1兲.
Tsai et al. 共2009兲. Leachate quantities in the 1,900-L tanks were
continuously recorded by pressure transducers 共model WL16 with
Leachate from Cullet Stockpiles
accuracy of ⫾0.015–0.038 m, Global Water, Gold River, Calif.兲.
Precipitation was determined using an on-site tipping bucket rain
Leachate Quantity
gauge, containing a data logger 共RainWise, Bar Harbor, Me.兲. The
readings were verified by three wedge-shaped rain gauges 共Tru- Leachate quantities were determined for the two lined, aerated
Chek, Edwards Manufacturing Co., Albert Lea, Minn.兲. stockpiles. Due to a series of heavy rainfall events 共⬃3 , 000 L兲
in the second half of August, with little opportunity for evapora-
tion, both stockpiles were saturated quickly and released similar
Analyses of Glass Cullet, Washwater, and Leachate amounts of leachate 共Fig. 3兲. There was no obvious difference in
Analyses of glass cullet, washwater, and leachate followed the the water holding capacity of the two stockpiles after these
analytical procedures of Tsai et al. 共2009兲, which were based on events, which likely presented a worst case scenario in terms of
or adapted from ASTM methods 共ASTM 2003a,b兲 or Standard leachate release/wastewater treatment. Because of the difference
Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater 关American in rainfall pattern, the findings by Tsai et al. 共2009兲, that the fine
Public Health Association 共APHA兲 1995兴. The washing procedure cullet pile retained more water, were not confirmed. The percent-
for glass cullet 共cullet:deionized water= 1 : 3 by weight兲 provides ages of the accumulated leachate divided by the accumulated
an estimate of maximum leaching potential that might occur in rainfall after the intensive rain were around 76 and 80% for stock-
the field 共Tsai et al. 2009兲. piles AC and AF, respectively 共data not shown兲. This can also be
seen in the difference between accumulated rainfall and accumu-
lated leachate, which equals the sum of evaporated water plus
Results and Discussion water retained in the stockpile 共Fig. 4兲. Thus, the piles delayed the
release of water after rain events.
Temperature and Oxygen Levels in Stockpiles Leachate Quality
The initial moisture content, organic contamination level, particle Leachate quality is affected by the amount of rainfall and the
size distribution 共data not shown兲, and washwater analyses 共Table frequency of rain events. Due to the intense storms in this study,
1兲 of both coarse and fine glass cullet were similar to the findings organic contaminant levels in leachate from aerated stockpiles
by Tsai et al. 共2009兲. For both the turned and the aerated stock- were not compared to those from the unaerated stockpiles of Tsai
piles, self-heating was observed 共Fig. 2兲. The highest temperature et al. 共2009兲. It is noted, however, that nutrient levels in the
in the weekly turned pile, 68° C, was measured on Day 10 in the leachate did not decrease over time in both aerated 共data not
middle and upper half of stockpile 关Fig. 2共a兲兴. The analysis of shown兲 and unaerated stockpiles 共Tsai et al. 2009兲.
55
45
35
25 Temp. in aerated
stockpile of fine cullet
15
6
5
25
31
12
18
24
30
11
25
31
12
18
24
30
11
5
25
31
12
18
24
30
11
8/
9/
8/
9/
8/
9/
7/
7/
8/
8/
8/
8/
9/
7/
7/
8/
8/
8/
8/
9/
7/
7/
8/
8/
8/
8/
9/
Date Date Date
20
15
O2 (%)
10
7/ 25 7/ 31 8/ 6 8/ 12 8/ 18 8/ 24 8/ 30 9/ 5 9/ 11 7/ 25 7/ 31 8/ 6 8/ 12 8/ 18 8/ 24 8/ 30 9/ 5 9/ 11 7/ 25 7/ 31 8/ 6 8/ 12 8/ 18 8/ 24 8/ 30 9/ 5 9/ 11
date date date
Fig. 2. Temperatures and oxygen levels in three field stockpiles: 共a兲 and 共d兲 weekly turned stockpile of coarse cullet TC; 共b兲 and 共e兲 aerated
stockpile of coarse cullet AC; and 共c兲 and 共f兲 aerated stockpile of fine cullet AF. For TC, all measurements were made at least 24 h after mixing
except for the third set, which were measured within 19 h of turning 共resulting in a sudden drop兲. Note: in the legend, the first number represents
the height above ground and the second number the distance into the pile of the measurement point 共in meters兲.
The leachate quality from both aerated stockpiles 共Tables 2 easily degradable components. Anionic surfactant levels in the
and 3兲 in many cases was similar to the contaminant levels de- leachate decreased over time, but were still above 2 mg L−1 at
tected in the washwater 共Table 1兲. The pH of the leachate ranged the end of the study 共Tables 2 and 3兲, similar to anionic surfactant
between 8.0 and 9.7, generally increasing over time. This pH levels in typical untreated domestic sewage 共Tchobanoglous et al.
range is similar to that observed during composting 共Krogmann 2003兲. The total coliform levels in the leachate of the stockpile of
and Woyczechowski 2000兲. The initial leachate BOD5 levels, 255 coarse cullet decreased from 106 to 102 cfu mL−1 by the end of
and 285 mg L−1, were comparable to those of untreated domestic the experiment 共Tables 2 and 3兲. These levels are similar to those
sewage 共Tchobanoglous et al. 2003兲. While the BOD5 levels de- found in urban storm water 共103 to 108 cfu mL−1兲 共Novotny and
creased over time, this was not true for the COD levels 共Tables 2 Chesters 1981兲. For the stockpile of fine cullet, however, lower
and 3兲. BOD5 / COD ratios for both stockpiles, ranging from 0.14 total coliform levels were found, corresponding to the low level
to 0.02, also decreased over time, indicating decreases in the more detected in the initial washwater 共Table 1兲.
2000
4500
4000
1500
3500
L / Pile
3000
1000
2500
L / Pile
2000
1500 500
1000
500 0
0 7/24 7/29 8/3 8/8 8/13 8/18 8/23 8/28 9/2 9/7 9/12
7/24 7/29 8/3 8/8 8/13 8/18 8/23 8/28 9/2 9/7 9/12 Date
Date
Effects of Forced Aeration and Turning on Cullet 458 mg L−1兲, compared to the 85% decrease in the mixed/turned
Stockpiles stockpile 共Table 1兲. This suggests the importance of mixing/
turning when handling cullet stockpiles. As known from compost-
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by Lund University on 05/25/15. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.
ML = 共OSH-ISH兲关共AR ⫻ TA兲/air兴 Continuing interest in using mixed glass cullet in large construc-
tion projects requires a better understanding of alternative ways of
= 共0.132 − 0.015兲关共0.65 ⫻ 202兲/1.204兴 handling stockpiles to reduce their potential to cause water pollu-
= 12.76 kg tion. This study showed that forced aeration for cullet stockpiles
can improve the temperatures and oxygen levels inside the stock-
where ISH= specific humidity of inlet air, kg/kg 共26° C, 74% rela- pile without resulting in excessive drying; however, biodegrada-
tive humidity兲; OSH= specific humidity of off-gases, kg/kg tion of the organic contaminants in these stockpiles did not appear
共60° C, 100% relative humidity兲; AR= aeration rate, m3 / min; to be as rapid as in the mixed/turned stockpile. This also suggests
TA= total aeration time over 17 days, min.; and air = density of the importance of incorporating mixing/turning when forced aera-
air, kg/ m3 共20° C兲. tion is implemented in treating cullet stockpiles.
The ISH was calculated based on average humidity and tem- Overall, the characteristics of glass cullet and leachate quantity
perature monitored at the on-site weather station in Mansfield, and quality in this study confirmed the findings of Tsai et al.
N.J. OSH was calculated based on the assumptions of saturation 共2009兲 suggesting that glass cullet can be stockpiled before use as
in the off-gases 共Haug 1993兲, and the same average temperature construction aggregate. However, leachate from these stockpiles
in the off-gases as measured for stockpile AF. Pressure is assumed should not be released to surface water and only be infiltrated to
to be 1 atm. groundwater after aging and when best management practices are
With a stockpile mass of 35 Mg and a moisture content of implemented.
3.46% 共data not shown兲, the stockpile contained 1,211 kg of Alternatively, washing of glass cullet, applied in this study to
water 共35⫻ 0.0346⫻ 1 , 000兲. Based on these assumptions, forced generate washwater, may provide a way of cleaning the cullet
aeration removed only 1% of the water 共12.76/ 1211⫻ 100兲 over before stockpiling. Andela Pulverizer, Ltd. 共Richfield Springs,
17 days. Excessive drying is also not an issue for the stockpile of N.Y.兲, as an example, washes recycled cullet to obtain clean cullet
coarse cullet 共AC兲 because the aeration rate was even lower. While for higher value markets such as the filter material for aquariums,
aeration did not remove much water with the low aeration rates or gardening materials for landscaping mulch. Whether the wash-
used here, water is removed from the stockpile through other water can be reused for cleaning and if this approach is economi-
mechanisms, such as evaporation and natural convection. cal requires further assessment.
Overall, forced aeration for cullet stockpiles can improve the
temperatures and oxygen levels inside the stockpile without re- Acknowledgments
sulting in excessive drying. However, biodegradation of the or-
ganic contaminants in these stockpiles during a 1.5-month period The writers would like to thank the Burlington County Board of
was about 70% of the initial levels 共e.g., BOD5 : 438– Chosen Freeholders for providing the site; Robert Simkins, Coor-
Table 3. Leachate from Lined, Aerated Stockpile of Fine Glass Cullet 共AF兲
Sampling date 8/18 8/20 8/21 8/22 8/27 9/11 9/12
Volume 共L兲 254 890 564 606 68 95 189
pH 9.3 8.7 8.3 8.4 9.3 9.7 9.3
BOD5, unfiltered 共mg L−1兲 285 205 83 112 33 89 82
COD, unfiltered 共mg L−1兲 3,475 1,620 683 1,325 978 3,111 2,520
Anionic surfactants 共mg L−1兲 ND 3.6 0.95 ND ND 2.4 2.7
Total coliforms 共cfu mL−1兲 4.7⫻ 103 5 ⫻ 102 ⬍101 7 ⫻ 102 8.2⫻ 102 2.2⫻ 103 1.5⫻ 102
Note: ND= not determined.
ASTM. 共2003b兲. “Standard test method for particle-size of soils.” ASTM Tsai, C. L., Krogmann, U., and Strom, P. F. 共2009兲. “Handling leachate
D422-63, West Conshohocken, Pa. from glass cullet stockpiles.” Waste Manage., 29, 1296–1305.