Name of evaluator:

Evaluator’s section:
Date:

Dear evaluator,
The following guide questions should be answered in the paper you will be evaluating. Aside from
that, check the paper’s tense consistency, SVA, punctuation marks, spelling, and construction of sentences.
Feel free to write your correction on the paper. Use a pen other than black.

CONTENT
1. Is the main idea clear?
2. Is the explanation comprehensive and sufficient?
3. Does the explanation have depth?
4. Are the supporting details linked to the main idea?
5. Does the introduction state the title, author, etc.?
6. Does the paper present summary of the journal article?
7. Does the paper present positive points of the article?
8. Does the paper clearly point out the weaknesses of the article?
9. Are the claims in the review supported by evidences from other secondary sources?
10. Does the review present suggestions for a better paper?

ORGANIZATION
1. Does the paper use an organizational pattern and structure?
2. Are cohesive devices effectively used?
3. Are the ideas correctly placed?
4. Is the flow of ideas smooth and easy to read?

STYLE
1. Does the paper showcase the writer’s voice?
2. Does the paper use a variety of sentence structures?
3. Is the paper free from sexist language?
4. Does the paper use language appropriate to context?
5. Does the paper eliminate wordy expressions?

Disclaimer: This activity is meant for intellectual and academic purposes. No feelings should be harmed.
Take it easy, guys. 