Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Lydia G. Ripley
Does discrimination against minority groups exist in our daily lives and in the American court
system? It is this question that this paper will attempt to illuminate. It will examine the motives
why discrimination against minority groups in the American court system exists. The research
has shown that racial discrimination is still a common thread throughout the American judicial
system. The Court's decisions are predicted from three things: race, gender, and the amount of
money that the convicted earn. This paper outlines the social injustice that is happening towards
minorities in the judicial system. This paper reviews the history of racial discrimination starting
with when it first came to Colonial America. Then it goes on to the topic of how minorities race
and socioeconomic status affects their sentencing outcomes. Then it will discuss the sentencing
differences, which unsurprisingly show that minorities suffer more than Caucasians. Lastly, it
will review court cases that have attempted to find justice in this heated subject.
3
THE LAW IS WRITTEN IN BLACK AND WHITE
The Law is Written in Black and White: Racial Discrimination Against Minorities in the
The African-American population makes up about 14% in the United States in 2016
(U.S. Census Bureau QuickFacts, 2016). In just 2016 alone, 27% of the black population was
arrested, double the amount of the total African-American population (National Center for
Health Statistics, 2018). With such high statistics, it is hard to see the truth behind it all, which is
that racial prejudice is a common thread throughout the US criminal justice system. The United
States judicial system prevails over the rights of the minorities and the poor. One in three
2013). Most of these minorities live in poor neighborhoods and don’t usually get fair
representation due to not having the funds to pay an excellent lawyer. Despite that the majority
Since the beginning of slavery African-Americans have suffered due to the erasing of
their identity. Race has been a major factor in American society since race played a powerful
role in the political system throughout the colonial American government. African-American’s
history of racial segregation created a clear view of how most racial minorities have been treated
throughout history. Through this inhumane practice of the dehumanization of humans, it led to a
The beginnings of racial discrimination started with the inhumane practices of slavery,
documented as far back as 11,000 years ago. Slavery came to the Americas in 1619 shortly after
4
THE LAW IS WRITTEN IN BLACK AND WHITE
the first European explorers settled (The History of Slavery, 2018). Roughly 60 years later is
when the settlers started to seek after the trade of slavery so they could have free labor to work
on their farms. Slavery became so popular that many farmers became slave owners. Throughout
the world, the use of indentured servants declined, with a rise in the use of slaves, with the
advantage of having free labor, and owners could treat them however they pleased (The History
of Slavery, 2018). This widespread experience of Africans as slaves was the start of how
African-Americans have fought for equal rights since 1865 due to the Emancipation
Proclamation, which was a document that freed African-Americans from slavery in the southern
states. Unfortunately, the Emancipation Proclamation did not get rid of discrimination against
African-Americans. After the Civil War, economic depravity, segregation and the discrimination
against Blacks were still prevalent in the South. After the war, even the victorious North started
to lose interest in the equal rights of African-Americans, and therefore, the South had the
opportunity to step in with the creation of Black Codes, Jim Crow Laws, and the Grandfather
Clause. With the creation of the Ku Klux Klan, and the voting tests were also, examples of racial
more and more trouble to have rights such as voting, which privileged White authority figures
Civil-Rights Protests
The 1930s were a frenzy of tense race relations in America. Decades after the
the problems of the Great Depression affected almost every group of Americans, no group was
5
THE LAW IS WRITTEN IN BLACK AND WHITE
harder hit than African-Americans. For example, by 1932, about half of black Americans were
out of work (Race During the Great Depression, 2018). In some Northern cities, whites called for
blacks to be fired from any jobs as long as there were whites out of work. Racial violence again
became more common, especially in the South. “Lynchings, which had declined to eight in 1932,
surged to 28 in 1933” (Race During the Great Depression, 2018, n.p.). This highlighted an
economic situation which started major political developments among the African-American
community. For example, in 1929, one store had a majority of black customers but would only
hire white employees. Due to this, the St. Louis Urban League launched a national movement
boycotting these stores. “Efforts to unify African-American organizations and youth groups later
led to the founding of the National Negro Congress in 1936 and the Southern Negro Youth
Congress in 1937” (Lynch, 2018, n.p.). There were many boycotts in the 1930s such as the
Montgomery Bus Boycott, as a civil-rights protest where African-Americans refused to ride the
city buses with hopes of desegregating discriminatory bus seating. In Martin Luther King Jr.’s “I
Have a Dream” speech he stated that he had a dream for a better America where everyone would
be treated fair and that there would be no more racial discrimination. That is the kind of ideal
that everyone should have in mind when it comes to equal rights. This history of racial
discrimination in the United States is one of the major reasons that discrimination exists in the
judicial system.
Though the United States has become more racially diverse, it is unequal in terms of
citizen’s income and wealth (Shin, 2016). There is still discrimination happening against towards
minorities that is mostly due to their wealth and income. According to a recent study called The
Racial Wealth Gap: Why Policy Matters, “the typical black household now just has 6% of the
6
THE LAW IS WRITTEN IN BLACK AND WHITE
wealth of the typical white household; the typical Latino household just has 8%” (Dietrich,
Meschede, Shapiro, & Sullivan, 2015, n.p.).” This means that white households in America are
making about $104,033 more than black households and $102,798 more than Latino households
(Munk, Eggleston, 2018). This shows that racial animosity plays a role in the disadvantage of
economics for most families of color. Every family in America needs some sort of income in
order to live with economic security. Economic security is a cornerstone of social peace and
opportunity for progress. With the racial economic gap, it means that the families of color are
not able to give their children the security to invest in opportunities for their future.
There are three main factors that drive the income gap between minority households in
America: Households, education, and labor markets. Homeownership for most American
families is their one of their largest assets. Though there are discrimination inconsistencies
towards minorities regarding homeownership. White households are more common than Latino
and Black households by about 30%. (Shin, 2016). Much of this disparity comes from the gap
regarding home values in usually white neighborhoods versus minority neighborhoods. This
dates all the way back to the National Housing Act which was passed in 1934, which “redlined”
black neighborhoods, marking them as credit risks (Shin, 2016). The effects of redlining still
exist today even though it was outlawed in the ‘60s. This is shown mostly in neighborhoods that
are usually a minority-majority especially those with high poverty rates, declining infrastructure,
and low home values (Shin, 2016). This creates a self-perpetuating feedback loop that keeps low-
income minority community members in poverty since their homes do not gain value. In
addition, discriminatory lending exists today as well through mortgages have higher interest rates
world today, most people need a technical or college degree in order to be stable economically.
There has been a large decrease in minorities attending college (Shin, 2016). Many minorities
don’t usually have the money to afford to go to college; instead, they go straight into the
workforce. The debts of low-income minorities usually outweigh the ones of Caucasians since
many they don’t initially have the money to pay for college in the first place (Shin, 2016).
Homeownership disparities are another important factor towards the discrimination of minorities.
Residential segregation gives a disadvantage for minorities as students are placed in low-income
schools who don’t have the necessary tools for a proper education, which ultimately affects the
Labor Markets. The last main reason for discrimination against minorities affecting
their socioeconomic status is the labor markets in America. The labor markets equate economic
security for people through income, health insurance, paid leave, and retirement funds for
people's plans for the present and the future. “But inequality in the labor market is responsible
for 20% of the growth in the racial wealth gap in the last 25 years and unemployment another
9%” (Shin, 2016, n.p.). The outcomes in the labor market can sometimes lead to disparities
against different races and create the geographical barriers that limit most minorities from
“The typical white family earns $50,400, while the typical black family earns $32,038
and the typical Latino family, $36,840” (Shin, 2016, n.p.). Black and Latino families receive a
lower return rate on the money that they have earned, so this makes it harder for these families to
turn this income into wealth they can live off of. Due to this, it is less likely for Latinos and
8
THE LAW IS WRITTEN IN BLACK AND WHITE
African-Americans to achieve jobs that offer substantial support in areas of income and obtain
various insurances. The result is that most families of color spend almost all their income their
earned income on necessary living items. Other factors go back to the factors of lower education
and the area of living. Parents who have raised their children in low-income neighborhoods and
schools have a lower chance of going to college, therefore, getting a better job opportunity. All
of these factors combine to create a disparity in economic conditions for African-Americans and
Latinos in America today compared to their White peers. These economic factors are a major
African-Americans usually live a harder life than most other Americans, and this is also
true in the judicial system. They receive heavier sentencing, longer probations, are arrested and
prosecuted more, and have fewer paroles than those of Caucasians (Rabuy & Wagner, 2017).
This idea is not understood enough by the public mainly due to society believing the stereotypes
of criminal behaviors of the minority community. The higher arrest and prison rates for
minorities are a de facto supporting reason for discrimination in the system, perpetuating racial
discrimination. Most of society is not even willing to acknowledge this bias in the criminal
justice system that makes the majority of the attorney’s to not want to take up their cases (O,
Felix, personal communication, 2018). When minorities finish their sentencing in prison, they
will be viewed differently by society. For example, it will be harder for minority former inmates
to be able to get respectable jobs, along with people in their community will never be able to
trust them again. (O, Felix, personal communication, 2018). Former inmates with social
awareness are already aware that they are receiving this negative stereotype which puts them in a
box that they feel like they cannot escape from. (O, Felix, personal communication, 2018).
9
THE LAW IS WRITTEN IN BLACK AND WHITE
Incarceration Rates
America has the highest incarceration rate in the world. There are about 2.2 million
people that are incarcerated in local, state, federal, and youth prisons (Rabuy & Wagner, 2017).
In 2017, The black population only consisted of 13% of the total amount of the American
population (Rabuy & Wagner, 2017). Of the amount in prisons, 876,400 are African Americans,
which consists of 40% out of the total amount of prison inmates (Rabuy & Wagner, 2017). This
is almost three times the amount that is incarcerated than the number of people in the African
American population. The Latino population, in 2017, only consisted of 13% of the American
population (Rabuy & Wagner, 2017). Of the amount in prisons, 416,290 are Latinos, which
consists of 19% out of the total amount of prison inmates (Rabuy & Wagner, 2017). Thus,
making this 6% more than the total amount of people in the Latino population in America
Probations
What is saddening is that in the year 1992, the number of black men in prison exceeded
the amount in college. In this day and age, a quarter of African-American males are either on
probation, locked up, or on parole. Poverty as a causal factor comes into play as well regarding
cases of minorities. Small crimes such as robbery are usually committed by people with lower
incomes. Forty-five percent of African-American children in the year 1992 were below the
poverty line, which compared to the 16 percent of white children was startling. Since many
African-Americans on trial do not have enough money to obtain a good lawyer, their cases
usually aren’t defended as vigorously, and they could get more years than what is deserved.
African-Americans make up 13 percent of the U.S. population but then make up 30 percent of
those on parole (Probation and Parole Systems, 2018). The incarceration rates show a wide racial
10
THE LAW IS WRITTEN IN BLACK AND WHITE
gap between the races. “Black adults are about 3.5 times as likely as whites to be supervised”
(Probation and Parole Systems, 2018, n.p.). Along with the disproportionate representation of
Hispanics under the supervision of the law are undercounted, so this makes this data false.
Arrest Rates
The first issue in racial differences in the judicial system is in arrests. A large amount of
black arrests in the American justice system puts a heavy burden on the black community.
African-Americans have higher arrest rates than any other races. Under Article 2 and Article 26
of the International Covenant on the Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), all of the citizens of the
United States are treated fairly and equally in the eyes of the law (The Sentencing Project,
2013). There is a paradox in the judicial system with some forces pushing fair treatment like the
ICCPR, and other systems that ignore severe racial disparities. One obvious difference that
African-American males tend to commit more violent and property crimes (The Sentencing
Project, 2013). Police officers across the whole country have a higher rate of arresting minorities
than Caucasians. Especially African-Americans who have a much higher arrest rate in almost
Research that was conducted by The Sentencing Project found that the majority of
Americans view black Americans as “dangerous,” “aggressive,” “violent,” and “criminal.” (The
Sentencing Project, 2013). This view can create an implicit bias where people expect black
Americans to be dangerous or criminal and perceive them as such. This plays a major impact on
police officers as they are required to make snap judgements in their heat of the moment
11
THE LAW IS WRITTEN IN BLACK AND WHITE
situations. Police officers are part of the American culture which as conveyed this negative
implicit bias (The Sentencing Project, 2013). This bias may ultimately influence the way the
officers perform their jobs which will ultimately lead to police brutality and aggression towards
minorities. A study conducted by the state of New Jersey saw results that were alarming. Racial
minorities made up 15% of drivers that drove on the New Jersey Turnpike. Forty-two percent of
the stops and 73% of the arrested were black drivers. Even though white drivers have violated
the same amount of traffic laws at the same rate (The Sentencing Project, 2013). Through the
communities that they have started calling it “driving while black” (The Sentencing Project,
2013). While some explicit prejudice likely exists among some handful of New Jersey Turnpike
officers, the implicit bias research offers an explanation as to why even well-meaning officers
might have disparities in their arrest rates leading to a large disparity in arrests.
Court Cases
There are many court cases that have been debated on the heated subject of racial
discrimination. Racial discrimination cases are ones that are constantly being tackled by the
courts. Discrimination threatens the integrity of sentencing outcomes. This can mean that
minorities get longer sentencing than what is justified. In the world there is two kinds of racial
bias. A significant piece of the racial disparity against minorities is that of implicit racial bias.
Implicit racial bias is a controversy in comparison to clear racism. Clear racism is often
intentional and is practiced by people who openly embrace racial discrimination (Implicit
Racism, 2018). When the courts of America have judges in place that practice any type of
racism, that is when the integrity of the American Court system is gone.
1954. In this landmark case, the Court prohibited racial segregation of public school. The case of
Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka is known as the “separate but equal” case. Every day,
Linda Brown and her sister had to walk a dangerous way to get to a bus stop to even get to their
all-black elementary school. There was a school that was closer to the girl's house, but it was
designated as an all-white school. They took their case to court believing that the segregation of
the schools was against the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. They stated
that if even the facilities are equal, segregated schools could never be equal to each other. The
plaintiffs were denied in the lower courts due to the case of Plessy v. Ferguson, which held that
“racially segregated public facilities were legal so long as the facilities for blacks and whites
were equal.” The court ruling stated that the segregation of public schools based on race was
unconstitutional. Through this case, it proved that in fact, the “separate but equal” mantra was
McCleskey v. Kemp
In the case of McCleskey v. Kemp (1987), the Supreme court ruled that the statistics
presented that the death penalty had clear evidence of racial discrimination was not a
constitutional violation. The Justices of the Court had created an equal protection case-law so
that it was difficult for minority plaintiffs to challenge a neutral state action. This means the
plaintiffs would need to first show proof that they were discriminated against. The court had
made this difficult to prove. After decades of this happening, the Court now has an equal
protection record which controlled by plaintiffs challenges the race-conscious civil rights
problem. In this case, used the “Baldus study,” which was a social science experiment which
showed that the race of the defendant and the victim played an important role in determining
13
THE LAW IS WRITTEN IN BLACK AND WHITE
who was selected for the death penalty in the state of Georgia (Siegel, R. B., 2018). The Court
dismissed this evidence as it was not enough to prove the discriminatory purpose in the
McCleskey case.
The larger question of the McClaskey case is whether discrimination has explained the
inconsistency in the criminal justice system and whether putting a moratorium in sentencing the
death penalty is warranted. By looking back on this case, it allows us to explore the
considerations that led to the Court’s decision to reject the statistical evidence of discrimination
in the case. Some Courts say that the restrictions on the statistical evidence help to show
openings for statistical evidence of bias in the criminal justice system today. Also, examining the
McCleskey case helps raise the deeper question of whether or not the court should have the
ability to discuss bias in the criminal justice system. This helps remind us that we should not
fully rely on a system that depends solely on judges for the correct prosecution.
In the 1992 Los Angeles Riots, four policemen of Los Angeles were exonerated for the
beating of Rodney King, an African-American man. This was the spark of the destructive riots,
which only went downhill from there. When Reginald Denny was taken from his truck and
beaten by several black men, stricken television viewers watched with attentiveness and fear.
Many people believed that though what the men did to Denny were terrible, these men that were
accused would not receive a fair trial due to their race. None of the five young men who were
arrested could post bail, which some bails exceeded $500,000. Through this case, it reinforced
the opinion that African-Americans cannot get fair justice in our society (Bates, K. G., & Sastry,
A, 2018).
police, especially those in the New York Police Department. According to the Fourth
Amendment, police officers must have a reasonable suspicion that a crime has been committed
by the suspect. If the police officer views the suspect as a risk and is potentially dangerous, then
they may frisk the suspect by gently patting the outside of their clothing. The frisk is also called
a Terry Stop due to the Supreme Court case of Terry v. Ohio (1968). This case upheld that a
stop-and-frisk must adhere to the Fourth Amendment. If the frisk does not follow the Fourth
Amendment, then it is unlawful and can be tried in court as criminal law. (Busby, J. C., 2017).
Racial Profiling is also supported by the case of Floyd v. City of New York (2013) which was a
challenge towards the New York Police Department’s common practice of racial profiling and
Biased Juries
The courts of America are mostly attempting to attack the problem of racism. They are
generally viewed as the ideal place of true justice. The courts have a system of checks and
balances that make sure their work is helping the people. Though when the courts are faced with
a serious racial problem that cannot easily be avoided, they tend to seek a solution that is not
always in the interests of minority victims. Moreover, the courts are choosing cases that endorse
constitutional ideals while still leaving the most complicated cases unaddressed (Costly, A.
1992). Minorities have consistently been excluded from having an equal and unbiased jury of
their peers, which every American has this right. Though having an ‘unbiased’ jury becomes
almost meaningless without limitations on the courts and the prosecutors. Though in the case of
Swain v. Alabama the Court upheld an unfair prosecutorial privilege by only considering the
procedural issues and ignoring the substantive effect (Batis, T. C., n.d.). Even a different result in
15
THE LAW IS WRITTEN IN BLACK AND WHITE
Swain v. Alabama would not have given the black defendants the ideal jury of their peers. There
is no law or judicial reform in the published literature that has suggested any possibility of
Conclusion
Discrimination is still common among many nations and American society today. Many
people suffer because of their color, gender or ethnic background. The majority of black
defendants are put in a class which is bearing the brunt of living in poverty and dealing with
racism. They not only deal with the effects of economic deprivations and racial bias but with
some of society believing that blacks are less valuable humans. Minorities are an oppressed
group, especially African-Americans and Latinos. They are constantly trying to speak out and be
heard, this is an effort that comes with complications. When the American society bands together
to stop this racial bias, that is when everyone can be seen as equals in the eyes of the court and in
the rest of society. The future of criminal justice sentencing in America needs to take a step
Racism has been a long-standing problem in the country. By educating those in charge of
the country such as judges and officials, it can make the problems of discrimination improve. By
allowing more resources of legal representation for the people who are on the lower end of the
economic status, it can better the representation for minorities. One additional solution would be
to have the courts of America and judges make their sentencing and decision process more
publicly known. This way they can have a check on their power, so they don’t convict people
wrongly especially with racial bias. By educating the people of America on this problem, we can
better benefit not only the country but the world. Only by wanting a better future will we finally
References
Bates, K. G., & Sastry, A. (2017, April 26). When LA erupted in anger: A look back at the
https://www.npr.org/2017/04/26/524744989/when-la-erupted-in-anger-a-look-back-at-
the-rodney-king-riots.
Batis, T. C. (n.d.). Swain v. Alabama: Case & summary. Retrieved December 18, 2018, from
https://study.com/academy/lesson/swain-v-alabama-case-summary.html.
Bell, D.A., Jr., (1973) Racism in American courts: Cause for black disruption or despair, 61.
https://scholarship.law.berkeley.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?referer=https://www.google.co
m/&httpsredir=1&article=2602&context=californialawreview.
Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka. (n.d.). Oyez. Retrieved October 9, 2018, from
https://www.oyez.org/cases/1940-1955/347us483
Busby, J. C. (2017, December 24). Stop and frisk. Retrieved December 10, 2018, from
https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/stop_and_frisk.
Correll, J., Judd, C., & Park, B. (2002) The police officer’s dilemma: Using ethnicity to
1-c-does-the-criminal-justice-system-discriminate-against-african-americans
Costly, A. (2018). Race and voting in the segregated south. Retrieved November 28, 2018, from
http://www.crf-usa.org/black-history-month/race-and-voting-in-the-segregated-south
Dietrich, L., Meschede, T., Shapiro, T., & Sullivan, L. (2015). The Racial wealth gap: Why
policy matters. In A. Traub, C. Ruetschlin, & T. Draut (Eds.). New York, NY; The
Eggleston, J. & Munk, R. (2018, August 27). Net Worth of Households: 2014. Retrieved
https://www.census.gov/content/dam/Census/library/publications/2018/demo/P70BR_15
5.pdf.
FBI Criminal Justice Information Services Division. (2011). Crime in the United States.
u.s.-2011/tables/table-43.
Felix, O. (2018, October) Personal interview with doctoral candidate studying racial disparities
"Implicit Racism." Encyclopedia of Race and Racism. Retrieved December 12, 2018 from
Encyclopedia.com: https://www.encyclopedia.com/social-sciences/encyclopedias-
almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/implicit-racism.
18
THE LAW IS WRITTEN IN BLACK AND WHITE
Knafo, S. (2013, October 4). 1 In 3 black males will go to prison in their lifetime, report warns.
disparities-criminal-justice_n_4045144.html.
Lynch, H. (2018, May 11). African Americans. Retrieved October 7, 2018, from
https://www.britannica.com/topic/African-American/African-American-life-during-the-
Great-Depression-and-the-New-Deal.
https://www.oyez.org/cases/1986/84-6811.
National Center for Health Statistics. (2018). Health, United States, 2017, with special feature on
Petersilia, J. (1983). Racial disparities in the criminal justice system. U.S. Department of Justice,
Probation and parole systems marked by high stakes, missed opportunities. (2018, September
analysis/issue-briefs/2018/09/probation-and-parole-systems-marked-by-high-stakes-
missed-opportunities.
Rabuy, B., & Wagner, P. (2017, March 14). Mass incarceration: The whole pie 2017. Retrieved
Race During the Great Depression - Library of Congress. (n.d.). Retrieved October 7, 2018, from
http://www.loc.gov/teachers/classroommaterials/presentationsandactivities/presentations/
timeline/depwwii/race/.
19
THE LAW IS WRITTEN IN BLACK AND WHITE
Shin, L. (2016, January 25). The Racial wealth gap: Why a typical white household has 16 times
https://www.forbes.com/sites/laurashin/2015/03/26/the-racial-wealth-gap-why-a-typical-
white-household-has-16-times-the-wealth-of-a-black-one/#3fd14aa1f45e.
Siegel, R. B. (2018). Blind Justice: Why the court refused to accept statistical evidence of
from https://search.proquest.com/docview/2059605109?accountid=3785.
The History of Slavery. (2018, September 11). Retrieved November 10, 2018, from
https://restavekfreedom.org/2018/09/11/the-history-of-
slavery/?gclid=CjwKCAjwpeXeBRA6EiwAyoJPKlMtm18iaiKFAf6mzmBjW7Ejo4TQq
JvYOXQWBekjyWI9TtCEvhadUxoC-coQAvD_BwE.
The Sentencing Project. (2013, August 31). Shadow report to the United Nations on racial
disparities in the United States criminal justice system. Retrieved December 6, 2018,
from https://www.sentencingproject.org/publications/shadow-report-to-the-united-
nations-human-rights-committee-regarding-racial-disparities-in-the-united-states-
criminal-justice-system/.
U.S. Census Bureau QuickFacts: United States. (2016). Population estimates: Quickfacts
https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/US/PST045217.
20
THE LAW IS WRITTEN IN BLACK AND WHITE