Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
BACHELOR OF TECHNOLOGY
In
CIVIL ENGINEERING
Submitted By
1. ARUN KUMAR KONDAJI 12R01A0122
2. AVARI VIJAY KUMAR 12R01A0102
3. PALA SAI KRISHNA 12R01A0135
4. PASULOLLA SHARAVAN 12R01A0136
5. RIKKALA RAJESHWAR 12R01A0143
Mr.J.RAGHAVENDER REDDYM.TECH
Asst. Professor, Dept. Of Civil Engineering
This is to certify that, the project entitled “SOIL STABILIZATION USING FLY ASH
AND RICE HUSK ASH”, being submitted by
1. ARUN KUMAR KONDAJI 12R01A0122
2. AVARI VIJAY KUMAR 12R01A0102
3. PALA SAI KRISHNA 12R01A0135
4. PASULOLLA SHARAVAN 12R01A0136
5. RIKKALA RAJESHWAR 12R01A0143
in partial fulfilment for the award of the degree of BACHELOR OF TECHNOLOGY in CIVIL
ENGINEERING in CMR INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY, Kandlakoya, Hyderabad, under my
guidance and supervision.The results embodied in this project record have not been
submitted to any other university or institute for the award of any degree or diploma.
Mr.M.JANGA REDDY
M.TECH.(IT),PhD, MISTE
Principal External Examiner
DECLARATION
Page | ii
We hereby declare that the matter embodied in the report of main project entitled
“SOIL STABILIZATION USING FLY ASHAND RICE HUSK ASH” is a bonafide & genuine
research work carried out by us under the guidance of Mr.J.RAGHAVENDER REDDY
SIR Associate professor, Department of Civil Engineering, Hyderabad. The work embodied
in this report is original & has not been submitted to the basis for the award of degree,
diploma, association or fellowship of any other university or institution.
Page | iii
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
It is with immense pleasure that we would like to express our indebted gratitude to our
guide Mr. J.RAGHAVENDER REDDY SIR, who has guided us a lot and
encouraged us in every step in the project work. A valuable moral support and
guidance throughout the project helped us to a greater extent.
We are highly indebted to principal prof. M.JANGA REDDY SIR, for giving
the permission to carry our project.
Our special thank to our faculty. Not to forget, our non-teaching staff, and our
friends who have directly or indirectly helped and supported us in completing our
project in time.
1
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
INDEX
1. Introduction
1.1 General 6
1.2 Discussion of various investigations
On black cotton soil 8
1.3 Importance of stabilisation 10
1.4 Usage of waste material 17
1.5 Need for study 17
1.6 Objectives of the study 18
1.7 Organisation of the project 19
2. Literature review 20
2.1 General 20
2.2 Literature review 20
2.3 Behaviour of black cotton soil 23
2.4 Problems associated with black cotton soil 23
2.5 Stabilisation of black cotton soil 24
2.6 Uses of rice husk ash 26
2.7 Uses of fly ash 28
2.8 Summary 29
3. STUDY METHODOLOGY31
3.1 General 31
3.2 Materials used
31
3.3 Laboratory studies 32
3.4 Laboratory testing 35
2
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
ON RESULTS
4.1 General 45
4.2 Laboratory test results 45
4.3 Compaction test & CBR test results
For soil & rice husk ash 45
4.4 Unconfined compression test results
Black cotton soil
4.5 Proctor compaction results for black
Cotton soil with various % of
Fly ash & rice husk ash 55
4.6 CBR results for black cotton soil
With various % of fly ash
& rice husk ash 62
4.7 summary 66
5. CONCLUSIONS
5.1 General 67
5.2 Conclusion 67
5.3 Further scope of work 68
3
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
LIST OF TABLES
4
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
ABSTRACT
Stress strain behavior of unconfined compressive strength showed that failure stress and
strains increased by 106% and 50% respectively when the flyash content and rice husk ash
were increased from 0 to 21%. Therefore, an RHA and Fly ash contentwere increased by
21% are recommended for strengthening the expansive subgrade soil. Proctor compaction
test of soil with material content of 15%,18% and 21% are conducted and results are
noted.The test shows maximum dry density and optimum moisture content at material 21%.
Therefore ,RHA and fly ash content of 21% of soil and in the ratio of 3:1 are recommended
for strengthening the black cotton soil because of its satisfactory performance in laboratory
tests.
5
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
Chapter 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1. GENERAL
Soil is the indispensable element of this nature. It is attached to everyone in one or another
way. All the basic amenities of life, whether it is concerned with food, clothes and house,
have been fulfilled by the soil .Without the soil it is just next to impossible to think about life
on this earth. The word soil is derived from the Latin word solium which according to
Webster dictionary means the upper layer of the earth that may be dug or plowed;
specifically, the loose surface material of earth in which plant grows. The term soil in soil
engineering is defined as an unconsolidated material, composed of solid particles produced
by disintegration of rocks. The voids space between particles may contain air, water or both.
The solid particles may contain organic matter. The soil particles maybe separated by such
mechanical means as agitation and water. Soil deposits in nature exist in an extremely erratic
manner producing thereby an infinite variety of possible combination which will affect the
strength of the soil and the procedures to make it purposeful. So is the particular case of
black cotton soil with a wide range of challenges associated with the construction at sites
with black cotton soil. In case of coarse grained soil, the mineralogical composition of the
grain hardly affects the engineering properties of the soils perhaps the grain to grain friction
is influenced to a degree. Is such soils, inter particle forces other than those due to gravity are
of no consequence, but the finer particles, the more significant becomes the forces associated
with the surface area of the grains. The soil structure means the mode of arrangement of soil
particles related to each other and the forces that are acting between soil particles to hold
them together in their positions. The concept is further extended to include the mineralogical
6
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
composition of the grains, the electrical properties of the particle surface, the physical
characteristics, ionic composition of pore water, the interactions among the soil particles,
pore water and the adsorption complex. The formation of soil structures is governed by
several factors in coarse grained soils, the force of gravity is the main factor, while in fine
grained soils, and the surface bonding becomes predominant. The specific surface (the ratio
of the surface area of a mineral to its mass or volume) is a parameter which is often used to
decide the importance of surface bonding forces relative to forces of gravity. Smaller
particles have much larger surface area than the larger particles .For the same void ratio
water content are more for fine grained soil than for the coarse grained. Clay is understood to
mean a clay soil whose grains are predominantly composed of clay minerals and which has
plasticity and cohesion. Though the clay soils are fine grained but, not all fine grained soil
possess plasticity and cohesion. The presence of water, its content plays a decisive role in the
engineering behaviour of a clay soil. On the other hand, grain –size distribution and grain
shape RESEARCH ARTICLE OPEN ACCESS Miss K S. Gaikwad et al Int. Journal of
Engineering Research and Applications www.ijera.com ISSN : 2248-9622, Vol. 4, Issue 5(
Version 3), May 2014, pp.25-32 www.ijera.com 26 | Page influence the engineering
properties of granular soils and hardly affect the behaviour of clays. The expansive soils
occur all over the world. India has large tracks of expansive soil known as Black Cotton soil
(BC soil), covering an area of 0.8 million square kilometre, which is about 20% of total land
area. The major areas of their occurrence are states of Maharashtra, Gujarat, southern parts of
Uttar Pradesh, eastern parts of Madhya Pradesh, parts of Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka.
This type of soil is available up to a depth of 3.7 meters on an average in the above parts of
India. Expansive soils occurring above water table undergo volumetric changes with change
in moisture content. Increase in water content causes the swelling of the soils and loss of
strength and decrease in moisture content brings about soil shrinkage. Swelling and
shrinkage of expansive soil cause differential settlements resulting in severe damage to the
foundations, buildings, roads, retaining structures, canal linings, etc. The construction of
foundation for structure on black cotton soils poses a challenge to the civil engineers.
Chemical stabilization is one of the oldest methods of stabilization of problematic soil. In
general, all lime treated fine-grained soils exhibit decreased plasticity, improved workability
and reduced volume change characteristics. However, not all soils exhibit improved strength
7
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
PROBLEM SUMMARY:
1.2.1. Problems Arising out of Water Saturation .Typical Cracks in Black Cotton Soil in
Dried State It is a well-known fact that water is the worst enemy of all structures, particularly
in expansive soil areas. Water penetrates into the foundation from three sides viz top surface,
and from bottom layers due to capillary action. Therefore, specifications in expansive soil
areas must take these factors into consideration. The surfacing must be impervious, sides
paved and soil beneath well treated to check capillary rise of water. It has been found during
handling of various investigation project assignments for assessing causes of structural
failures that water has got easy access into the foundations. It saturates the soil and thus
lowers its bearing capacity, ultimately resulting in heavy depressions and settlement. Water
lubricates the soil particles and makes the mechanical interlock unstable. In the top surface,
ravelling, stripping and cracking develop due to water stagnation and its seepage into the
bottom layers. Generally, construction agencies do not pay sufficient attention to the aspects
of construction and maintenance of sides. In expansive soil areas, unpaved offsets pose the
maximum problem as they become slushy during rains, as they are most neglected a lot.
All over the world, problems of black cotton clay have appeared as cracking and break-up of
pavements, railway and highway embankments, roadways, building foundations, irrigation
8
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
systems, water lines, canal and reservoir linings. The estimated damage was very expensive
to the pavements running over the Black cotton soil sub grades.
Various remedial measures like soil replacement, pre-wetting, moisture control, chemical
stabilization have been practiced with varying degrees of success. Unfortunately the
limitations of these techniques questioned their adaptability in all conditions. So work is
being done all over, to evolve more effective and practical treatment methods, to alleviate the
problems caused to any structures laid on Black cotton soil strata.
Investigation on chemical stabilization (Petry and Armstrong, 1989; Prasada raju, 2001)
revealed that electrolytes like potassium chloride, calcium chloride and ferric chloride may
be effectively used in place of conventionally used fly ash, because of their ready
dissolvability in water and supply of adequate cations for ready cation exchange.
Ashwani Kumar and Mehta (1998); Praveen Kumar and Ashwani Kumar (1999), reported on
the laboratory investigations on the stabilized granulated blast furnace slag in road
construction and concluded that the load carrying capacity of the sub grade has been
improved on addition of GBFS stabilized with lime and cement.
Gendut Hantoro (2000) found that rice husk ash is also a potential material to be utilized for
clayey soil improvement in addition to fly ash or any other pozzolonic materials.
Zhang (2002) undertook an experimental program to study the individual and admixed
effects of lime and fly ash on the geotechnical characteristics of soil. They observed
reduction in free swell and increase in CBR value. Later on it was observed that lime-fly ash
admixtures reduced the water absorption capacity and compressibility of soils.
Phani Kumar and Radhey Sharma (2004) reported that fly ash can be used as an additive in
improving the engineering characteristics of soils. They observed the decrease in plasticity
and hydraulic conductivity and increase in penetration resistance of blends with increase in
fly ash content.
Amir Kalhor (2007) used natural and artificial textiles as a method for homogeneous soil
reinforcing. He used metal fibres in kaolinite clay and found that there is a considerable
increase in the axial compressive strength of soil.
9
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
10
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
Fig 1: Thermalstabilisation
Plate 1 - Mechanical stabilisation
11
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
necessary to ensure the properties of stabilized geo-materials and their mixtures as applicable
for use in the design of foundations, embankments, shoulders, sub-grades, bases, and surface
courses.
12
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
The principal materials used for the cementitious stabilization and modification of highway
pavement materials are lime, fly ash, and portland cement. Whereas lime and Portland
cement are manufactured products, fly ash is a by-product of the burning of coal at electric
power generating stations. As a consequence, fly ash generally exhibits greater variability
than is seen in the other products. By-products such as kiln dust and fluidized bed ash from
various manufacturing and energy generating processes are used to a lesser extent.
Lime stabilization is a widely used means of chemically transforming unstable soils into
structurally sound construction foundations.Lime stabilization creates a number of important
engineering properties in soils,including improved strength; improved resistance to fracture,
fatigue, and permanentdeformation; improved resilient properties; reduced swelling; and
resistance to thedamaging effects of moisture. The most substantial improvements in these
properties are seen in moderately to highly plastic soils, such as heavy clays. Although lime
is generally used to transform fine-grained soils permanently, it may be used for shorter-term
soil modification—for example, to provide a working platform at a construction site.
14
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
15
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
Chemical stabilization includes the use of chemicals and emulsions as compaction aids to
soils, as binders and water repellents, and as a means of modifying the behavior of clay. It
also includes deep mixing and grouting. Chemical stabilization can aid in dust control on
roads and highways, particularly unpaved roads, in water erosion control, and in fixation and
leaching control of waste and recycled materials
16
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
Infrastructure projects such as highways, railways, water reservoirs, reclamation etc. requires
earth material in very large quantity. In urban areas, borrow earth is not easily available
which has to be hauled from a long distance. Quite often, large areas are covered with highly
plastic and expansive soil, which is not suitable for such purpose. Extensive laboratory /field
trials have been carried out by various researchers and have shown promising results for
application of such expansive soil after stabilization with additives such as sand, silt, lime,
fly ash, rise husk ash etc.
17
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
For a successful construction of road network, the pavement should be located on soil, which
requires the least thickness above it. The ancient road building material is soil itself on which
the pavement is placed. Hence for the stability and performance of a road, soil should be
stable and strong. The performance of the pavement largely depends on the strength of the
sub grade. However, in nature problematic soils do exist which are not suitable for any civil
engineering construction even for road pavements. Such soils have to be treated with
different types of materials to produce a new material, which imparts stability and durability
to the soil.
This work presents the result of laboratory investigations carried out to understand the
characteristics of black cotton soil withRice Husk Ash and Fly ash.
18
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
19
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
20
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
Chapter 2
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
2.1. GENERAL
1. Introduction
Black cotton soil are found in extensive region of Deccan Trap in Indian. They are of
variable thickness, underlain by black sticky material known as “black soil”.Black cotton soil
when comes in contact with water it either swells or shrinks and resulting in moments to the
structure which are generally not related to direct effect of loading. On account of its high
volumetric changes it is not suitable for construction. It swells and shrinks excessively due to
present of fine clay particles. Alternate swelling and shrinking of soil is responsible for
differential settlement of structure.So black cotton soil must be treated by using suitable
admixtures to stabilize it. In my research work stabilization of black cotton soil is done by
using lime as an admixture. The most common type of stabilization are listed below
Cement stabilization
Chemical stabilization
Bitumen stabilization
Salt stabilization
2.2. Literature Review
Black cotton soil in India Almost 20% area of is occupied by black cotton soil. These soil are
predominant in states of Andhra Pradesh, Western Madhya Pradesh, Gujrat, Maharashtra,
Northern Karnataka, Tamil Nadu and some parts of Southern Uttar Pradesh (Bundelkhand
area). They are mostly clay soils and form deep cracks during dry season. They are popularly
known as “Black Cotton Soils” because of their dark brown color and suitability for growing
cotton. They are black due to compounds of iron and aluminum. These soils are deficient in
nitrogen, phosphoric acid and organic matter but rich in calcium potash and magnesium.
Characteristics of Black cotton soil Black cotton soil are generally reddish brown to black in
color. They occur 0.50m to 10 m deep possessing high compressibility. Common
characteristics are listed in table-1 ID: NOV151161 290 International Journal of Science and
Research (IJSR) ISSN (Online): 2319-7064 Index Copernicus Value (2013): 6.14 | Impact
Factor (2014): 5.611 Volume 4 Issue 11, November 2015 www.ijsr.net Licensed Under
21
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
22
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
Shrinkage: A structure built at the end of the wet season when the natural water content is
high, shows settlement and shrinkage cracks during subsequent dry season. 2.5.Engineering
Properties of B. C. Soil The main engineering properties of soil are permeability, plasticity,
compaction, compressibility and shear strength.
Permeability: The permeability is defined as the property of a porous material which permits
the passage or seepage of water through its interconnecting voids
23
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
Plastic limit:- It is defined as minimum water content at which soil will just begin to crumble
water rolled into a thread approximately 3mm in diameter, Plasticity index is determined as
difference of L.L. and P.L.
Shrinkage limit: - It is defined as the maximum water content at which a reduction in water
content will not cause a decrease in the volume of soil mass. Figure 3: Interpretation of
Consistency limits.
The marine clays are highly compressible soft clays and also it exhibits moderate
swelling when comes in contact with moisture.This behavior is due to the
presence of clay minerals with expanding lattice structure. The marine clay is
very hard when it is dry but loses its strength on wetting. The marine clay got
cracks as shown in the fig2.3 on drying and in the worst cases the width of the
cracks is almost 250 mm to 500 mm and travel down to 1.00m beneath the
ground level.
24
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
Soil stabilization is a procedure where natural or manufactured additives or binders are used
to improve the properties of soils. Chemical additives, such as lime, cement, Rice Husk Ash,
and other chemical compounds have been used in black cotton soil stabilization for many
years with various degrees of success.
The clay minerals have the property of absorbing certain anions and cations and retaining
them in an exchangeable state. The exchangeable ions are held around the outside of the
silica-alumina clay mineral structural unit.
Compositional variation through ionic or isomorphism substitution within the clay mineral
crystal lattice can leave the structural unit with a net negative charge. Substitution also
reduces the crystal size and alters its shape. Exposed hydroxyl groups and broken surface
bonds can also lead to a net negative charge on the structural unit. The presence of this net
negative charge means that soluble cations can be attracted or adsorbed on to the surface of
25
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
the clay mineral structural units without altering the basic structure of the clay mineral. The
ability of clay to hold cations is termed as its cation exchange capacity. The most common
soluble cations are Na+, K+, Ca2+, Mg2+, H+, and NH4+.
Cation exchange capacity (C.E.C.) has major significance in determining clay mineral
properties, particularly the facility with which they adsorb water. Cation exchange capacity
(C.E.C.) measures two of the fundamental properties of clays:
1. The surface area and the charge on this surface area.
2. The surface of clay can be of two sorts; external and internal.
The external exchange capacity measures nothing more than the average crystalline size. The
surface capacity of adsorption is largely dependent upon broken bonds and surface growth
defects.
26
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
aqueous solution containing a salt, usually chloride or ammonium hydroxide. The soluble
ions adsorbed with the water onto the interlayer structure can affect the adsorbed water
arrangement in several ways. Principally, they act as a bond of varying strength holding the
structural layer together and controlling the thickness of adsorbed water. Their effectiveness
will depend on the size and charge. Thus Na+, K+ will tend to be weak and a clay-water
system containing these ions will be capable of adsorbing large amounts of water. Ca2+,
Mg2+, on the other hand, will have stronger links and a clay-water system containing them
will possess substantially lower water content. Inclusion of Fe3+ or Al3+ would reduce the
water content and plasticity and this is in fact the basis of the electro-chemical or electro-
osmotic method of clay stabilization
In this study, Granulated Blast Furnace Slag (GBFS), Granulated Blast Furnace Slag-FeCl3
Blends (GBFS-FeCl3) will be utilized as cementitiousmaterials while trying to stabilize the
marine clay sample.
2.6.RICE HUSK ASH
Rice milling generates a by-product know as husk. This surrounds the paddy grain. During
milling of paddy about 78% of weight is received as rice, broken rice and bran. Rest 22% of
the weight of paddy is received as husk. This husk is used as fuel in the rice mills to generate
steam for the parboiling process. This husk contains about 75% organic volatile matter and
the balance 25% of the weight of this husk is converted into ash during the firing process, is
known as Rice Husk Ash (RHA). This RHA in turn contains around 85% - 90% amorphous
silica.So for every 1000 kg of paddy milled, about 220 kg (22%) of husk is produced, and
when this husk is burnt in the boilers, about 55 kg (25%) of RHA is generated. India is a
major rice producing country, and the husk generated during milling is mostly used as a fuel
in the boilers for processing paddy, producing energy through direct combustion and/ or by
gasification. An about 20 million tone of RHA is produced annually. This RHAis a great
environmental threat causing damage to the land and the surrounding area in which it is
dumped. Lots of ways are being thought of for disposing them by making commercial use of
this RHA.
27
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
S. No PROPERTY % FINER
0.6 mm 80
0.425 mm 50
0.21 mm 29
0.075 mm 8
CONSTITUENTS COMPOSITION
SiO2 86 %
Al2O3 2.6%
Fe2O3 1.8%
CaO 3.6%
MgO 0.27%
Loss in ignition 4.2%
28
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
29
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
c) Other uses
The low density of the compacted Rice Husk Ash over a wide range of moisture contents,
coupled with small pore size and high permeability should make the material very suitable as
a final filter for water supply. Unburnt Rice Hull might be used as a first stage filter. Because
of their cheapness, both materials could be replaced frequently if necessary.The low
compacted Rice Husk Ash would suggest its use in light weight concrete.
2.8.FLY ASH
Fly ash produced in modern power stations of India is of good quality as it contains low
sulphur & very low unburnt carbon i.e. less loss on ignition. In order to make fly ash
available for various applications, most of the new thermal power stations have set up dry fly
ash evacuation & storage system. In this system fly ash from Electrostatic Precipitators
(ESP) is evacuated through pneumatic system and stored in silos. From silos, it can be loaded
in open truck/ closed tankers or can be bagged through suitable bagging machine. In the ESP,
there are 6 to 8 fields (rows) depending on the design of ESP. The field at the boiler end is
called as first field & counted subsequently 2 , 3 onwards. The field at chimney end is called
as last field. The coarse particles of fly ash are collected in first fields of ESP. The fineness of
fly ash particles increases in subsequent fields of ESP. Pulverized Fuel Ash is versatile
resource material and can be utilized in variety of application. The pozzolanic property of fly
ash makes it a resource for making cement and other ash based products. The Geo-technical
properties of bottom ash, pond ash & coarse fly ash allow it to use in construction of
embankments, structural fills, reinforced fills low lying area development etc. The physico
chemical properties of pond ash is similar to soil and it contains P, K, Ca, Mg, Cu, Zn, Mo,
and Fe, etc. which are essential nutrients for plant growth. These properties enable it to be
used as a soil amender & source of micronutrients in agriculture /soil amendment.
30
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
2.9.Summary
In this chapter the experience of the various researchers in the field of black cotton soils,Rice
Husk Ash, fly ash and other admixtures were presented.
In the next chapter details of laboratory experimentation carried out will be discussed.
31
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
Chapter 3
STUDY METHODOLOGY
3.1GENERAL
A brief literature on various problems posed by black cotton soil for the civil engineering
structures have been discussed in the previous chapter. An outline of soil investigation and
the test procedure adopted in the course of the investigation are discussed in this chapter.
This chapter also presents the results obtained from various laboratory tests
There after fly ash was added to the optimum mix of black cotton soil and rice husk ash in
the ratio of 3:1by weight of the total mix.
The soil used in this study is black cotton soil, obtained from medchal lake, collected at a
depth of 1.5m from ground level. The Index &Engineering properties of black cotton soil are
determined as per IS code of practice and determined & presented in table 3.2.
3.2.2. Rice Husk Ash
Locally available Rice Husk Ash was used in the present work. The physical properties are
determined and presented in Table 3.3.
Commercial grade Fly ash mainly consisting of 58.67% CaO and 7.4% Silica was used in the
study.
32
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
3.3.LABORATORY STUDIES
The laboratory studies were carried out on the samples of BC soil, BC soil + Rice Husk
Ash+Fly ash mixes.
a) Liquid limit
Liquid limit test was conducted on Black cotton soil, Black cotton soil+20% Rice Husk Ash,
usingCasagrande’s liquid limit apparatus as per the procedures laid down in IS: 2720 part 4
(1970).
b) plastic limit
Plastic limit test was conducted on Black cotton soil, Black cotton soil+20% Rice Husk Ash
as per the specifications laid down in IS: 2720 part 4 (1970).
33
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
c) Shrinkage limit
This test is also conducted on to Black cotton soil, Black cotton soil+Rice Husk Ashas per
IS: 2720 part 4 (1972).
34
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
Preparation of soil sample for proctor’s compaction test was done as per IS: 2720 part-6
(1974).
35
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
36
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
37
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
the soil sample in the container is dried in an oven at a temperature of 110°±5°C for 24
hours.
Water content, w= Mw/ Ms = (M2-M3)/ (M3-M1)
Where M1 = mass of container, with lid
M2 = mass of container, lid and wet soil
M3 = mass of container, lid and dry soil
38
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
content in the arithmetic scale on the y-axis. The flow curve is straight line drawn on this
semi-logarithmic plot, a nearly as possible through three or more plotted points. The moisture
content corresponding to 25 blows is read from this curve rounded off to the nearest whole
number and is reported as the liquid limit of the soil.
40
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
Based on extensive CBR test data collected, empirical design charts were developed by the
California State Highway Department, correlating the CBR value and flexible pavement
thickness requirement. For various traffic volumes different design thickness curves are
available.
41
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
3.5.1. General
The soil was initially air dried prior to the testing.The tests were conducted in the laboratory
on the Black cotton soil to the study the behaviour of black cotton soil, when it was
untreated, treated (with chemicals, GBFS and reinforcement techniques) for the modal
flexible pavements and also for the foundation soil beds. The following tests were
conducted as per IS Codes of practice.
i. The grain size distribution
ii. Index properties –Liquid Limit, Plastic Limit, Shrinkage Limit
iii. Swell Tests- Differential Free swell, Swell Pressure
iv. Strength tests- California bearing ratio
43
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
S. No PROPERTY VALUE
0.6 mm 80
0.425 mm 50
44
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
0.21 mm 29
0.075 mm 8
45
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
Chapter 4
PRESENTATION AND DISCUSSIONS ON RESULTS
4.1. GENERAL
Details of the laboratory experimentation carried out with different combinations of materials
have been discussed in the previous chapter. In this chapter a detailed discussion on the
results obtained from various laboratory tests are presented.
4.3. PROCTOR COMPACTION AND CBR TEST RESULTS FOR SOIL AND
RICE HUSK ASH
46
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
1.36
1.35
1.34
1.33
Dry density 1.32
1.31
1.3
1.29
1.28
1.27
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
water content
47
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
1.38
1.36
1.34
1.32
Dry
1.3
density
1.28
1.26
1.24
1.22
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
water content
CHART 1: compaction curve for soil+ rice husk ash +Fly ash
48
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
1.32
1.3
1.28
1.22
1.2
1.18
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
water content
CHART2: compaction curve for Soil + Rice Husk Ash + Fly ash
49
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
1.4
1.38
Dry density
1.36
1.34
1.32
1.3
1.28
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
Water content
CHART 3: compaction curve for soil + Rice Husk Ash +Fly ash
50
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
0.35
0.3
0.25
0.2
STRESS
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05
STRAIN
51
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
1.4
1.2
STRESS 0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06
STRAIN
The graph showing results of unconfined compression test results of 21% of material at 0
days of curing.
52
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
1.4
1.2
STRESS 0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06
STRAIN
53
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
2.5
STRESS 1.5
0.5
0
0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07
STRAIN
54
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
STRESS 1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06
STRAIN
55
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
1.06
1.04
1.02
1
0.98
0.96
0.94
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
water content (%)
56
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
Table 4.10 Optimum moisture content and dry density values of 75%Soil+25%Rice
Husk Ash+5%Fly ash
SI.no Water Content (%) Dry Density(g/cc)
1. 30.33 1.114
2. 33.47 1.137
3. 39.48 1.198
4. 41.58 1.164
5. 43.55 1.126
1.17
1.16
1.15
1.14
1.13
1.12
1.11
1.1
0 20 40 60
water content (%)
57
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
Table 4.11 Optimum moisture content and dry density values of 75%Soil+25%Rice
Husk Ash+6%Fly ash
SI.no Water Content (%) Dry Density(g/cc)
1. 28.32 1.219
2. 32.07 1.238
3. 37.48 1.311
4. 42.85 1.267
5. 48.93 1.119
1.3
dry density (g/cc)
1.25
1.2
1.15
1.1
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
water content (%)
58
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
Table 4.12 Optimum moisture content and dry density values of 75%Soil+25%Rice
Husk Ash+7%Fly ash
SI.no Water Content (%) Dry Density(g/cc)
1. 18.56 1.346
2. 21.36 1.394
3. 22.68 1.401
4. 23.65 1.386
5. 23.21 1.342
1.4
1.39
dry density (g/cc)
1.38
1.37
1.36
1.35
1.34
1.33
0 20 40
water content (%)
59
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
Table 4.13 Optimum moisture content and dry density values of 75%Soil+25%Rice
Husk Ash+8%Fly ash
Table 4.14 Optimum moisture content and dry density values of 75%Soil+25%Rice
Husk Ash+9%Fly ash
2. 19.36 1.403
3. 20.65 1.432
4. 23.56 1.412
5. 26.78 1.395
60
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
1.43
1.42
dry density (g/cc)
1.41
1.4
1.39
1.38
1.37
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
water content (%)
Table 4.15 Optimum moisture content and dry density values of 75%Soil+25%Rice
Husk Ash+10% Fly ash
2. 19.64 1.387
3. 19.96 1.412
4. 21.36 1.382
5. 23.65 1.322
61
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
1.38
1.37
1.36
1.35
1.34
1.33
1.32
1.31
0 20 40
water content (%)
62
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
(1)CBR Curve for 75% soil + 25% Rice Husk Ash + 4%Fly ash
72.28
62.28
52.28
Load(kg)
42.28
32.28
22.28
12.28
0.5 2.5 4.5 6.5 8.5 10.5 12.5 14.5
Penetration(mm)
CHART21: CBR curve for 75% Soil + 25% Rice Husk Ash+ 4%Fly ash
Soaked CBR:3.136 %
(2)CBR Curve for 75% soil + 25% Rice Husk Ash + 5%Fly ash
68.42
63.42
58.42
53.42
48.42
Load(kg)
43.42
38.42
33.42
28.42
23.42
18.42
0.5 2.5 4.5 6.5 8.5 10.5 12.5 14.5
Penetration(mm)
63
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
CHART22: CBR curve for 75% Soil + 25% Rice Husk Ash+ 5%FlyAsh
(3)CBR Curve for 75% soil + 25% Rice Husk Ash + 6%FlyAsh
78.42
68.42
58.42
Load(kg)
48.42
38.42
28.42
18.42
0.5 2.5 4.5 6.5 8.5 10.5 12.5 14.5
Penetration (mm)
(4)CBR Curve for 75% soil + 25% Rice Husk Ash + 7%FlyAsh
88.42
78.42
68.42
Load(kg)
58.42
48.42
38.42
28.42
18.42
0.5 5.5 10.5 15.5
Penetration(mm)
64
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
CHART24: CBR curve for 75%Black cotton Soil + 25% Rice Husk Ash+7%FlyAsh
(5)CBR Curve for 75%Black cotton soil + 25% Rice Husk Ash + 8%FlyAsh
72.28
62.28
52.28
Load(kg)
42.28
32.28
22.28
12.28
0.5 2.5 4.5 6.5 8.5 10.5 12.5 14.5
Penetration(mm)
CHART25: CBR curve for 75% Soil + 25% Rice Husk Ash+ 8%FlyAsh
Soaked CBR:3.136%
(6)CBR Curve for 75% soil + 25% Rice Husk Ash + 9%FlyAsh
110.7
90.7
70.7
50.7
30.7
0.5 2.5 4.5 6.5 8.5 10.5 12.5 14.5
Penetration (mm)
CHART26: CBR curve for 75% Soil + 25% Rice Husk Ash+ 9%FlyAsh
65
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
(7)CBR Curve for 75% soil + 25% Rice Husk Ash + 10%FlyAsh
138.4
118.4
98.4
Load(kg)
78.4
58.4
38.4
18.4
0.5 2.5 4.5 6.5 8.5 10.5 12.5 14.5
Penetration(mm)
CHART27: CBR curve for 75% Soil + 25% Rice Husk Ash+ 10% FlyAsh
66
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
10
8
CBR (%)
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
FlyAsh (%)
4.7. Summary
The laboratory test results have been discussed in this chapter. The summary of work done
and scope of further work will be presented in the next chapter.
67
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
Chapter 5
CONCLUSIONS
5.1. GENERAL
In this chapter the summary of the work carried out is presented along with the conclusions
drawn from the laboratory study. The scope for further research in this area is also suggested
at the end.
5.2. CONCLUSIONS
It is noticed that the liquid limit of the black cotton soil has been decreased by 16.21% on
addition of 25% Rice Husk Ash and it has been further decreased by 29.86% when 9%
Fly ash is added.
It is observed that the plastic limit of the black cotton soil has been improved by 7.40%
on addition of 25% Rice Husk Ash and it has been further improved by 16.29% when
9% Fly ash is added.
It is observed that the plasticity index of the Black cotton soil has been decreased by
29.78% on addition of 25% Rice Husk Ashand it has been further decreased by 56.38%
when 9% Fly ash is added.
It is found that the O.M.C of the Black cotton soil has been decreased by 18.52% on
addition of 25% Rice Husk Ashand it has been further decreased by 42.63% when 9%
Fly ash is added.
It is found that the M.D.D of the Black cotton soil has been improved by 17.00% on
addition of 25% Rice Husk Ashand it has been improved by 12.70% when 9% Fly ash is
added.
It is observed that the C.B.R. value of the Black cotton soil has been increased by
282.0% on addition of 25% Rice Husk Ash and it has been further improved by 449.14%
when 9% Fly ash is added.
It is observed that the DFS value of the Black cotton soil has been decreased by 72.80%
on addition of 25% Rice Husk Ash and it has been further decreased by 77.28% when
9% Fly ash is added.
68
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
The soaked CBR of the soil on stabilizing is found to be 9.632 and is satisfying standard
specifications. So finally it is concluded from the above results that the stabilized Black
cotton soil is suitable to use as sub grade material for the pavement construction and also for
various foundations of buildings.
69
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
BIBLOGRAPHY/REFERENCES
70
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
11. Bansal, R.K., Pandey, P.K. and Singh, S.K (1996), Improvement of a
Typical Clay for Road Subgrades, Proc. Of National Conf. on Problematic
Subsoil Conditions, Terzaghi-96, Kakinada, India, 1996, pp. 193-197.
12. Can Burak Sisman and Erhan Gezer(2011), Effects of rice husk ash on characteristics of
the briquette produced for masonry units
13. Chandrashekar, B.P., PrasadaRaju, G.V.R (1999), Calcium Chloride on
Properties of Expansive Soil For Pavement Subgrades, Proc. Of IGC -99,
Calcutta, 1999, pp 279-282.
14. CIRIA Publication (2002); BS EN 15237 (2007); TRL Projects Reports PPR
341(2008), represented the advantages of using the band drain in soft soils.
15. D. Koteswara Rao (2004), The performance studies on Geo-grid as reinforcement in the
flexible pavement construction, IGC-2004.
16. Desai, I.D. and Oza, B.N (1977), Influence of Anhydrous Calcium Chloride on the Shear
Strength of Expansive Soil, Proc. of the 1st
17. Fidelis O. OKAFOR and Ugochukwu. N. OKONKWO9(2009) Leonardo Electronic
Journal of Practices and Technologies.
18. G.V.R. Prasada Raju (2001), Evaluation of Flexible Pavement Performance with
Reinforcement and Chemical Stabilization of Expansive Soil Subgrade, a Ph.D. thesis ,
Kakathiya University, Warangal,(A.P, INDIA).
19. Ganapathy, 1977; Jones and Jones, 1995; Abduljauwad, 1995; Osama and Ahmed,
2002; Zhan, 2007)
20. Ghassan Abood Habeeb and Hilmi Bin Mahmud(2011), Study on properties of rice husk
ash and its use as cement replacement material.
21. Gopal Ranjan, A.J.R. Rao, a text book on “Fundamentals of soil mechanics.”
22. Heaton, B.S (2001), presented the utilization of waste products from Steel
plants in the pavements. Australia Civil Engineering Transaction, IE Aust.,
Vol. CE35, No.1.
23. IS: 2720 part- 4 (1975): Grain size analysis.
24. IS: 2720 part- 5 (1970): Determination of Liquid limit and Plastic limit.
25. IS: 2720 part- 6 (1972): Determination of Shrinkage limit.
26. IS: 2720 part- 6 (1974): Determination of Dry density and Optimum moisture content.
71
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
72
Stabilization of black cotton soil using Rice Husk Ash and Fly ash
44. Sudip Basak, Amartya Kumar and Paira, L.K., 2004. “ Utilization of fly ash in rural road
construction in India and its cost effectiveness”. EJGE paper 2004 –0436.
******
73