Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/316239503
CITATIONS READS
0 226
7 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Modern approaches to the development of special bearings in mechanical engineering and medical
prosthetics," TR 35025 View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Jovan Vukman on 19 April 2017.
Abstract: Determining the production cost is the basis for better decision-making in manufacturing practice. The
inability of enterprises to quickly and effectively determine the costs can significantly endanger their economic survival
on the global market. The cost estimation is usually performed in the initial stages of product development, while the
later stages consider the detailed cost calculation. The main subject of this research is related to the importance of cost
estimation in the conceptual process planning stage. Process planning is a complex activity divided into several
hierarchical levels. First level represents a conceptual process planning. One of the main tasks of the conceptual
process planning is the estimation and reduction of manufacturing costs. The paper shows the classification of methods
for cost estimation with the detailed representation of the one analogical method for cost estimation. Its verification is
performed for the case of cost estimation of proposed product – housing, for different variants of manufacturing
technologies, through the application of the developed software for cost estimation.
3. MANUFACTURING COST ESTIMATION The given table shows that the analogical and parametric
methods are recommended for the conceptual process
Determination of manufacturing costs is the basis for planning. The cost estimation within these methods is
making good decisions in manufacturing practice because performed on the basis of known costs of similar parts,
production systems that are not able to quickly and i.e. product and process parameters taken for comparison.
successfully determine costs have the problem of Appropriate information about conceptual model of a
development and survival in the global market. product, selected material and conceptual process is
Depending on the stage of product development, there are necessary for the cost estimation. Specific costs in this
different ways to determine these costs; in the initial stage of product development are orientational (level of
stages the estimation is commonly performed, while the error is 15-30%), which can aggravate the quality
cost calculation takes place in the later stages. assessment of product design. However, these costs can
Many researchers have studied the problem of cost be very important and sufficiently reliable for this level of
estimation, such as those in [3 - 6, 8 – 11, 14] and many process planning, because the main goal at this stage is
others. A number of methods and techniques for the not to determine actual or final costs, but to estimate costs
calculation and estimation of manufacturing costs are and select appropriate and most favorable variants of
developed. Some authors have attempted to include as manufacturing technologies.
many manufacturing processes as possible, while the For the detailed or final process planning, analytical
others have oriented solely to certain groups of similar methods for cost calculation are recommended, such as
processes. In the papers [5, 6], the classification of ABC (Activity-Based Costing) method, or TD ABC
methods and techniques for the determination of costs is (Time-Driven Activity-Based Costing), and others. In
given, according to the way of realization, stage of metalworking industry modern methods are based on
application in the process of product development and features (feature based methods) [14].
precision of the methodology, Table 1.
Table 1. The classification of methods for cost calculation and estimation [5, 6]
Accuracy (level
Method Description Best application
of error)
Global production
Intuitive Evaluation of cost regarding personal knowledge and intuition 30-50 %
planning
Global production
Comparative Evaluation using similar parts 30-50 %
planning
Case-based evaluation, definition of main parameters for
Analogical Conceptual design 15-30 %
comparison with previous cases
One or several parameters are chosen to be critical. They are
Parametric Conceptual design 15-30 %
used along with coefficients to evaluate the cost.
Direct and indirect costs are considered. Each cost is calculated
Analytical Detailed design 5-15 %
and then they are all summed to get the product cost
84
Dejan Lukić, Mijodrag Milošević, Stevo Borojević, Mića Đurđev, Jovan Vukman, Aco Antić: Manufacturing Cost Estimation in the Conceptual
Process Planning; Machine Design, Vol.8(2016) No.3, ISSN 1821-1259; pp. 83-90
By the content of activities the conceptual process Costimator® (www.mtisystems.com) is designed for
planning substantially matches with the DfM/DfMA- easy configuration of products assuming the
Design for manufacturing and assembly, where capabilities of a manufacturing facility. The system
manufacturing cost estimation is also included. The most contains hundreds of process and cost models which
famous DfMA methodologies are: Boothroyd-Dewhurst assumes a wide spectrum of manufacturing processes
(DFMA) [9], Lucas (DfA) [15] and Hitachi-AEM (eng. and features that are implemented for prebuilt, ready-
Assembly Evolution Method) [16], which are represented to-use manufacturing cost models.
in more detail in [17]. On the basis of these three aPriori Production Cost Management
methodologies the corresponding softwares are (www.apriori.com) is a tool for manufacturing cost
developed, including the most famous among them, estimation for machining, casting and plastic injection
DFMA software, Boothroyd Dewhurst Inc. USA [18], moulding.
within which the DFM Concurrent Costing module is
CustomPartNet (www.custompartnet.com), is an
covered. This module is focused on the selection of
online tool for manufacturing cost estimation. It
manufacturing processes and quick estimation of
allows users to perform quick and efficient
manufacturing costs.
calculations on the basis of which the product design
In recent years, major software companies in the field of
and cost estimation are facilitated.
CAx expanded their products/softwares towards the
development of PLM systems. So, for example, PTC The next chapter presents the software for cost estimation
which developed PTC/Creo, is also responsible for which is based on analogical costing methodology and
Windchill (www.ptc.com/product/windchill/cost), suitable for cost estimation in the early stage of product
Siemens which developed UniGraphics (NX) has its PLM development, i.e. at the conceptual process planning
system (www.plm.automation.siemens.com/en_us), stage.
Dassault Systems which developed CATIA and
commercialized SolidWorks has its own PLM Solutions 4. MANUFACTURING COST ESTIMATION
(www.3ds.com). All these systems offer cost-estimating
4.1. Development of cost estimation software
capabilities during product life cycle, and also including
the manufacturing cost estimation [19]. In developing the observed software, a method that
In addition, a significant number of CAD-based software belongs to the group of analogical methods is applied,
is developed for the cost estimation and/or according to Swift [10]. This method is based on the cost
manufacturability analysis of product design. These estimation for similar parts, whereby basic parameters for
softwares can be integrated and embedded as specific comparison with previous solutions are defined. The
modules in the corresponding CAD systems [8, 19]. Some parameters match the data from manufacturing practice of
of these softwares are the following: Great Britain industry that are systematized and analyzed
DFMPro (dfmpro.geometricglobal.com) which is statistically, and then embedded in appropriate tables and
successfully integrated within various CAD platforms. dependency graphs. The algorithm structure of cost
It is designed for the manufacturability analysis in estimation software as well as the module of developed
CAD environment (DFMPro-Rule Manager). Based conceptual CAPP system is shown in Figure 2.
on the rules and guidelines, corrections of design can Manufacturing cost model (T) of specific component is
be made within this environment, as well as the cost composed of: material cost (Tm), processing cost (Ti) and
estimation in machining, sheet metal processing, surface coating and/or heat treatment cost (Tt):
plastic injection moulding, casting and assembly.
n
SolidWorks Costing (www.solidworks.com) which is
fully integrated into SolidWorks, is designed for the
T Tm Ti Tt (1)
i 1
cost estimation for sheet metal and machined parts.
Autodesk Simulation DFM (www.autodesk.com)
Material cost (Tm) are defined as the volume of raw
which can be integrated into various CAD platforms,
material VP multiplied by the cost of material per unit
is designed for the manufacturability analysis for
volume Cmt:
plastic parts, manufacturing cost estimation and
environmental impact assessment.
SEER-DFM (www.galorath.com), designed for users TM V p C mp (2)
in the area of management, finance, engineering,
industrial design, as well as manufacturing. It is used The total volume of raw material is easily determined
for the evaluation of process parameters and trade-offs when it comes to simple shapes such as rod, sheet and
impacting various factors (such as, ease of others. However, when the total volume of raw material is
manufacturing and assembly, material and process complex or not known, then it can be calculated as the
selection, failure and repair rates, cost estimation). finished volume of component Vf and waste coefficient
MicroEstimating (www.microest.com) developed by WC, which takes into account the amount of material to be
Micro Estimating System Inc., offers computer-aided removed and is dependent on particular manufacturing
process planning and computer-aided cost estimation process and the shape complexity of component. Thus,
for the machining and fabrication industries. the formulation is the following:
MicroEstimating employs Machine Tool Emulation,
Knowledge-Based Machining, and Automatic Feature V P V f WC (3)
Recognition.
85
Dejan Lukić, Mijodrag Milošević, Stevo Borojević, Mića Đurđev, Jovan Vukman, Aco Antić: Manufacturing Cost Estimation in the Conceptual
Process Planning; Machine Design, Vol.8(2016) No.3, ISSN 1821-1259; pp. 83-90
INPUT DATA
START
PRODUCT DRAWING AND MODEL - TYPE OF MATERIAL
- ANNUAL PRODUCTION QUANITITY
- TOTAL NUMBER OF MANUFACTURING PROCESSES (n)
- TYPE OF MANUFACTURING PROCESSES-OPERATIONS
- MINIMUM WALL THICKNESS
- THE STRICTEST TOLERANCE AND NUMBER OF
ORTHOGONAL PLANES IN WHICH IT LIES
- THE STRICTEST SURFACE FINISH AND NUMBER OF
ORTHOGONAL PLANES IN WHICH IT LIES
YES
ENTER VOLUME OF RAW VOLUME OF RAW MATERIAL IS
MATERIAL (VP ) KNOWN
NO
i=1
array (1,..n)
DETERMINE TOLERANCE
f ( The strictest tolerance, Number of orthogonal planes in which it lies, Type of process )
COEFFICIENT (Ct )
YES NO
Cft = Ct Ct > Cf Cft = Cf
CALCULATING RELATIVE
COST COEFFICIENT
RC=Cc*Cmp*Cs*Cft
i = i+1
NO
i>n
YES
T P
i 1
ii
i 1
Ci RCi
END
86
Dejan Lukić, Mijodrag Milošević, Stevo Borojević, Mića Đurđev, Jovan Vukman, Aco Antić: Manufacturing Cost Estimation in the Conceptual
Process Planning; Machine Design, Vol.8(2016) No.3, ISSN 1821-1259; pp. 83-90
As a basis for deterimining the manufacturing cost (Ti), This type of aluminium alloy belongs to the alloy series
the cost of "ideal product", with the correction of the 2000, so called “hard alloys” which are commonly used in
relative cost coefficient that shows the difference between aerospace and defence industries. They are characterized
the observed and the ideal product, depending on the type by high firmness but require annealing or long-term aging
of material, shape complexity, specific dimensions, in order to achieve maximal characteristics. Good
tolerances and surface finish: machinability is a positive characteristic of this series but
it lacks good corrosion resistance.
Ti PC RC (4)
Based on the, such as basic shape and complexity,
material, quantity and others, the following variants of
where: manufacturing processes are taken into consideration by
PC – The cost of producing the ideal product, using the software – module for manufacturing process
RC – Relative cost coefficient selection [20], Figure 2.
Relative cost coefficient is calculated based on the Table 2. Variants of manufacturing technologies for
following equation: housing part
RC CC Cmp CS C ft (max Ct orC f ) (5) Variant No. Primary manufacturing technologies
Variant 1 CNC machining from full blank (CNC)
where:
Cc – Relative cost associated with shape complexity, Gravity Die Casting (GDC) +
Variant 2
Cmp – Relative cost associated with specific material- CNC machining (CNC)
process compatibility, Pressure Die Casting (PDC) +
Variant 3
CNC machining (CNC)
Cs – Relative cost associated with a section thickness of
Closed Die Forging (CDF) +
the product Variant 4
CNC machining (CNC)
Ct – Relative cost associated with tolerances,
Cf – Relative cost associated with surface finish.
According to the classification system, the observed
housing belongs to the B3 class of parts - rectangular or
For the ideal component/product all the represented
cubic prisms, Figure 4. In order to analyse the cost, from
coefficients are equal to 1. After determining the relative
the aspect of planned production volume in an appropriate
cost associated with tolerances Ct and relative cost
production system, the quantities that belong to various
associated with surface finish Cf , the coefficient that has
methods of production are taken into consideration (10,
greater value is taken into account and is designated with
50, 100, 400, 1.000, 10.000 and 100.000 (parts/year).
Cft. For determining some coefficients that exist in the
These production methods vary from job and small-scale
formulations for calculation, it is first necessary to
production to large-scale production.
perform the classification of products according to
geometrical shape. All products/parts are divided into
three classses (A - rotationally-symmetrical and
rotationally-non symmetrical parts, B - prismatic and full
box parts, C - prismatic and thin-walled box parts), which
are further divided into five different subclasses according
to classification system given in [10].
Fig.6. Output results of the estimation of housing manufacturing cost for variant 3
88
Dejan Lukić, Mijodrag Milošević, Stevo Borojević, Mića Đurđev, Jovan Vukman, Aco Antić: Manufacturing Cost Estimation in the Conceptual
Process Planning; Machine Design, Vol.8(2016) No.3, ISSN 1821-1259; pp. 83-90
Variation of the data for all four given variants of Table 3. Cost estimation values (given in €/parts)
manufacturing processes for housing is performed by
changing the input values with the variation of production Q Manufacturing process
volumes as well. The estimated output values of (parts/year) Var 1 Var 2 Var 3 Var 4
manufacturing cost are obtained as the output result. 10 18.87 487.93 567.13 710.16
These results are given in Table 3.
50 12.53 174.21 195.22 210.75
Figure 7 shows the dependency graph representing
dependency of the estimated manufacturing cost on the 100 11.42 54.54 62.45 77.19
input quantities for the selected variants of manufacturing 400 10.72 19.52 20.31 24.40
processes for the observed part – housing, based on the 1.000 10.47 10.98 11.85 13.71
results from Table 3. According to the obtained results of 10.000 10.24 6.49 6.62 7.23
cost estimation, it can be concluded that the cheapest
100.000 10.00 5.90 5.87 6.37
variant for job and small-scale production is the CNC
machining, while the other variants are more favourable
for middle-scale and large-scale production.
Fig.7. Grapical representation of the dependency of cost estimation on production volume for the adopted variants of
manufacturing process for housing part
89
Dejan Lukić, Mijodrag Milošević, Stevo Borojević, Mića Đurđev, Jovan Vukman, Aco Antić: Manufacturing Cost Estimation in the Conceptual
Process Planning; Machine Design, Vol.8(2016) No.3, ISSN 1821-1259; pp. 83-90
[2] Unger, D. & Eppinger, S. (2011) Improving Product International Journal of Computer Integrated
Development Process Design: A Method for Manufacturing, Vol. 24, No. 1-3, pp. 1-31, ISSN
Managing Information Flow, Risk and Iteration, 0951-192X.
Journal of Engineering Design, Vol. 22, No. 10, [13] Feng, S. & Song, E. (2000). Information Modeling on
pp.689-699, ISSN 0954-4828. Conceptual Design Integrated with Process Planning,
[3] Adithan, M. (2007). Process Planning and Cost Proceedings of Symposia for Design For
Estimation, New Age International (P) Limited Manufacturability, Orlando, Florida, pp. 160-168,
Publisher, ISBN 978-81-224-2655-7, New Delhi. International Mechanical Engineering Congress and
[4] Kesavan, R.; Elanchezhian, C. & Vijaya Ramnath, B. Exposition.
(2009). Proces Planning and Cost Estimation, New [14] H’Mida, F.; Martin, P. & Vernadat F. (2006). Cost
age International (P) Limited Publisher, ISBN 978- Estimation in Mechanical Production: the Cost Entity
81-224-2941-1, New Delhi. Approach Applied to Integrated Product Engineering,
[5] Creese, R.C. & Moore. L.T. (1990). Cost Modeling International Journal of Production Economics, Vol.
for Concurrent Engineering, Cost Engineering, Vol. 103, No.1, pp.17-35, ISSN 0925-5273.
32, No. 6, pp. 23-27, ISSN 0274-9696. [15] The University of Hull: DFA Analysis Overview,
[6] Martin, P.; Dantan, J.Y. & Siadat, A. (2007). Cost http://www2.hull.ac.uk/discover/mapp/sandpit/dfa/df
Estimation and Conceptual Process Planning, In a_analysis.aspx
Digital Enterprise Technology: Perspective and [16] Ohashi, T.; Iwata, M.; Arimoto, S. & Miyakawa, S.
Future Challenges, Cunha, P.F. and Maropoulous, (2002) Extended Assemblability Evaluation Method
P.G. (Ed.), pp. 243-250, Springer Science+Business (AEM), JSME International Journal Serie C, Vol.
Media, LLC., ISBN 978-0387498638, New York. 45, No. 2, pp. 567-574, ISSN 1344-7653.
[7] Ullman, D.G. (2002) The Mechanical Design [17] Todić, V.; Lukić, D.; Milošević, M.; Jovičić, G. &
Process, 3 edition, McGraw-Hill, ISBN 978- Vukman, J. (2013) Manufacturability of product
0072373387, New York. design regarding suitability for manufacturing and
[8] Chang, K-H. (2013) Product Cost Estimating, In assembly (DfMA), Journal of Production
Product Manufacturing and Cost Estimating using engineering, Vol. 16, No. 1, pp. 47-50, ISSN: 1821-
CAD/CAE, pp. 237-294, Academic Press is an 4932.
imprint of Elsevier, ISBN 978-0124017450, Oxford. [18] DFMA software,
[9] Boothroyd, G.; Dewhurst, P. & Knigh, W. (2011). http://www.dfma.com/software/dfma.htm
Product Design for Manufacturing and Assembly, [19] Lukić, D.; Milošević, M.; Jovičić, G. & Đurđev, M.
3rd Edition, CRC Press, Taylor and Francis group, (2014) State and development trend in scope of
ISBN 978-1-4200-8928-8, New York. design for manufacturing – DfM, ISBN: 978-86-
[10] Swift, K.G. & Booker, J.D. (2003). Process 7083-838-3, Proceedings of XXXIX Jupiter
Selection: From Design to Manufacture, 2nd edition, conference, pp.3.75–3.81, Faculty of Mechanical
Butterworth-Heinemann, ISBN 0-7506-5437-6, Engineering, Belgrade. (In serbian)
Oxford. [20] Lukić D.; Todić V.; Milošević M.; Jovičić G. &
[11] Feng, S. & Song, E. (2003) A manufacturing process Vukman J. (2013). Software Development for
information model for design and process planning Conceptual Process Planning, Proceedings of 11th
integration, Journal of Manufacturing Systems, Vol. Anniversary International conference an
22, No. 1, pp. 1-14, ISSN 0278-6125 accomplishments in Electrical and mechanical
[12] Xu, X.; Wang, L. & Newman, S.T. (2011). Engineering and Information Technology, 31 May –
Computer-Aided Process Planning - A Critical 1 June, pp. 375-381, ISBN 978-99938-39-46-0,
Review of Recent Developments and Future Trends, Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, Banja Luka.
90