Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Review Article
ABSTRACT
Aim: This paper reviews the use of high fidelity simulation (HFS) in nursing education.
Methods: An integrative review was used to assess the effectiveness of high fidelity simulation in
nursing education. Data search was between 2007 to 2016 using CINAHL, Cochrane, EMBASE,
ERIC, MEDLINE, Ovid, Proquest, PsycINFO, Scopus, SciVal, Web of Science, Joanna Briggs
Institute and EBSCO host. A total 45 articles met the eligibility criteria.
Discussion: Themes materialised were: learning in a safe, supportive and simulated environment,
self-satisfaction and confidence, critical thinking and clinical reasoning, clinical decision-making and
clinical judgement, knowledge retention and gain, skill acquisition and performance, interprofessional
collaborative practice and nursing care, teamwork and communication, development of cognitive,
psychomotor and behavioural skills.
Conclusion: HFS provides diverse learning experiences, promotes decision-making and skill
acquisition to develop assessment and safe practice.
Implication: Nurse educators can create a variety of patient conditions for collaborative nursing care
for increasing learning outcomes.
Key words: high fidelity simulation, technology, learning outcomes, students, nursing education
Highlights
HFS contributes to diverse learning experiences, knowledge retention and skill acquisition in a safe
and supportive environment.
HFS improves the quality of learning, organization of care, team work and promotion of clinical
decision-making.
HFS nurtures and develops cognitive, psychomotor and behavioural skills for interprofessional
collaborative practice.
words and index terms recognised by the and replaces time spent with patients in the
initial literature scoping. Defined search and clinical placement (Berragan, 2011).
retrieval methods were used in searching Registered nurses also play a vital role for
databases like PubMed, CINAHL, final year students to facilitate teaching-
Cochrane, EMBASE, ERIC, MEDLINE, learning (D‘Souza, Jolly& 2013). HFS was
Ovid, Proquest, PsycINFO, Scopus, SciVal, useful in increasing clinical reasoning skills
Web of Science, Joanna Briggs Institute and among nursing students (Lapkin, Fernandez,
EBSCO host. A total 368articles were Levett-Jones & Bellchambers, 2010).
identified after excluding the duplication Nursing student (n=151) responses had
from the nursing literature. positive perceptions of simulation as useful
A total of 45 articles had common to realizing learning objectives (Howard,
consensus between the two reviewers with Englert Kameg, & Perozzi, 2011).
the aim of the review. Among the 45 Literature shows that simulation
articles, 18 articles were experimental, 15 improves communication, accountability,
were quasi-experimental, and 12 were awareness of nursing action, performing to
analytical studies. The findings of each the best ability, practice and repetition of
study were considered with codes for skills, errors and omissions. It improves
identification from the literature, critical thinking, clinical judgment, skill
summarization, synthesis and inferences, acquisition, clinical reasoning, patient safety
and discussion of findings for clarifying the and interprofessionalism (Bussard, 2015).
interpretation themes. Nursing students (n=147) had significant
core competencies and professional attitude
Methods of the review in active learning compared to traditional
Assessment of methodological quality learning group (Shin, Sok, Hyun &Kim,
Articles selected for retrieval were 2015). Nursing students (N=5) showed that
assessed for methodological validity by two simulation experience provides skill
independent reviewers prior to inclusion in acquisition in a safe, controlled environment
the review. Critical appraisal assessment and is an integral part of nursing education
and review was done with agreement (Henneman & Cunningham, 2005).
between the reviewers and a third reviewer Use of remote communication
was consulted when needed. devices, information sharing, skills and
Data collection coping in emergencies showed significant
Data was extracted from the differences in the haemorrhage and
literature included in the review using respiratory simulated scenarios. This helps
standardised data extraction using specific to trigger cognitive processes for efficient
details about the interventions, populations, orientation and awareness in situ-
study methods and outcomes of significance interventions (Chapelain, Morineau &
to the aim of the review. Gautier, 2015). Advanced novice to
competent intensive care registered nurses
RESULTS OF ANALYSIS (n=53) showed significantly higher scores in
Review articles show that simulation assessments and team performance in the
and debriefing is an interactive forum to simulated emergency and cardiac arrest
transform knowledge to practice for safe scenarios in different specialties in Ottawa
and effective patient care in a non-risk (Ballangrud, Persenius, Hedelin & Hall-
learning and environment and impacts the Lord, 2014). Adult health nursing students
quality of learning (Bradley, 2011). It is (n=143) reported high satisfaction and acute
effective for improving performance and care knowledge and skills in simulated acute
organization in intensive care (Nimmo, units and supportive learning environments
Shippey & Fluit, 2008). Engagement in (Nickless, 2011). Nursing students (N=16)
simulation increases learning experience
simulation scenarios (Ahn & Kim, 2015). These studies show that HFS is an effective
Nursing students (n=107) perceived HFS as teaching-learning tool to improve clinical
promoting critical thinking, confidence, competence, critical thinking, self-
competence, theory-practice integration and confidence, and integration of knowledge in
knowledge identification (Kaddoura, safe, controlled environment. It reinforces
Vandyke, Smallwood &Gonzalez, 2016). knowledge in a safe patient care
Nursing students (n=42) have higher mean environment and enhances newly learned
clinical judgement scores and improved skills.
over time in the intervention group
compared to the control group. They DISCUSSION
expressed structured debriefing as learner In this integrative review, common
focused and holistic (Mariani, Cantrell, themes emerged were learning in a safe,
Meakim, Prieto, & Dreifuerst, 2013). supportive and simulated environment, self-
Interdisciplinary health care satisfaction and confidence, critical thinking
communication performance, SBAR, and clinical reasoning, clinical decision-
physician reporting blood pressure and making and clinical judgement, knowledge
oxygen saturation and client identification retention and knowledge gain, skill
were higher among senior nursing cohorts acquisition and performance,
exposed to repeated simulation learning. It interprofessional collaborative nursing and
helps to organize information, care, nursing care, teamwork and communication,
complete reporting and decision-making development of cognitive, psychomotor and
(Krautscheid, 2008). Inter-professional behavioural skills in nursing.
collaboration simulation scenarios benefit Review studies revealed that BScN
students to think critically, and apply students and Registered nurses, at various
theoretical knowledge to manage levels, ages and disciplines had higher
emergencies and varied patient conditions to satisfaction, self-confidence to face real
ensure safe patient care (Ying et al., 2011). clinical situations in a safe controlled
Nursing students (n=15) had positive environment. Higher satisfaction and self-
feedback about participation in confidence were observed in anticipating
interprofessional teamwork and cohesive scenarios related to assessment, readiness to
team in delivering care to the dying patient intervene appropriately and interpreting the
and their families in a simulated palliative situation comprehensively. Satisfaction and
care environment. They felt the need for self-confidence are internal outcomes of
patient and family-centred care and focus on simulation experience (Norman, Dore, &
patient and family needs (Gillan, Arora, Grierson, 2012) and have presented
Sanderson & Turner, 2013). Nursing improvements in critical cue recognition
students (N=41) had significant and problem identification (Rodriguez,
improvements in knowledge retention and 2015). Moderate-fidelity simulation
translation to patient care with simulation received significantly higher scores in
compared to didactic lectures and MCQs in students‘ satisfaction and self-confidence,
critical care (Solymos, O‘Kelly & Walshe, while the high-fidelity simulation showed
2015). better implementation of the simulation
Pre-briefing on expectation in the design (Wang et al., 2013). Higher age,
simulation environment and debriefing higher GPA, completion of clinical courses
model as a guided reflection improves in and senior cohorts was associated with the
complex interventions and simulated patient Student engagement mean scores (D‘Souza,
deterioration scenarios. It improved Isac, et al., 2014).
perceptions of deterioration and Pre-briefing, simulation and
development of appropriate responses in debriefing was beneficial in sequencing of
practice (Lavoie, Pepin & Cossettee, 2015). the learning experiences, especially in the
http://www.degruyter.com/view/j/ijnes.2011 http://www.scirp.org/journal/PaperInformati
.8.issue- on.aspx?PaperID=28714.
1/ijnes.2011.8.1.2147/ijnes.2011.8.1.2147.x D‘Souza, M.S., Isac, C., et al., 2013.
ml [Accessed July 22, 2016]. Exploring nursing student engagement in
Bultas, M. et al., 2014. Effectiveness of the learning environment for improved
high-fidelity simulation for pediatric staff learning outcomes. Clinical Nursing
nurse education. Pediatric nursing. Studies, 2(1). Available at:
Available at: http://www.sciedupress.com/journal/index.p
http://search.proquest.com/openview/a1f74b hp/cns/article/view/2894 [Accessed July 22,
4696b0a03ffd6d938d4f156b55/1?pq- 2016].
origsite=gscholar [Accessed July 22, 2016]. D‘Souza, M.S., Karkada, S.N. & Castro, R.,
Bussard, M.E., 2015. High-Fidelity 2014. Exploring e-learning among nurse
Simulation to Teach Accountability to educators in undergraduate nursing. Journal
Prelicensure Nursing Students. Clinical of Nursing Education and Practice, 4(7),
Simulation in Nursing, 11(9), pp.425–430. pp.73–84. Available at:
Available at: http://www.sciedu.ca/journal/index.php/jnep
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ecns.2015.05.009 /article/view/3955.
. DeBourgh, G. & Prion, S., 2011. Using
Cardoza, M. & Hood, P., 2012. simulation to teach prelicensure nursing
Comparative study of baccalaureate nursing students to minimize patient risk and harm.
student self-efficacy before and after Clinical Simulation in Nursing. Available
simulation. CIN: Computers, Informatics, at:
Nursing. Available at: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/articl
http://journals.lww.com/cinjournal/Abstract/ e/pii/S1876139909005799 [Accessed July
2012/03000/Comparative_Study_of_Baccal 22, 2016].
aureate_Nursing_Student.5.aspx [Accessed Dowie, I. & Phillips, C., 2011. Supporting
July 22, 2016]. the lecturer to deliver high-fidelity
Cato, M.., 2012. using simulation in nursing simulation. Nursing standard. Available at:
education, http://journals.rcni.com/doi/abs/10.7748/ns2
Chapelain, P., Morineau, T. & Gautier, C., 011.08.25.49.35.c8651 [Accessed July 22,
2015. Effects of communication on the 2016].
performance of nursing students during the Duphily, N., 2014. Simulation education: A
simulation of an emergency situation. primer for professionalism. Teaching and
Journal of Advanced Nursing, 71(11), Learning in Nursing. Available at:
pp.2650–2660. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/articl
Chism, L., 2010. the doctor of nursing e/pii/S1557308714000304 [Accessed July
practice, 22, 2016].
D‘Souza MS, Jose, J., and Al-Jabri, S., Edward, K. et al., 2007. Simulation to
2013. perceptions of teaching undergraduate Practice: Developing Nursing Skills in
student. Journal of scientific research, Mental Health--An Australian Perspective.
111(3), pp.289–299. International Electronic Journal of Health
d‘Souza, M., Karkada, S. & Parahoo, K., Education, 10, pp.60–64. Available at:
2015. Perception of and satisfaction with the http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?dire
clinical learning environment among ct=true&db=eric&AN=EJ794196&login.asp
nursing students. Nurse education. &site=ehost-
Available at: live\nhttp://www.aahperd.org/iejhe/template
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/articl .cfm?template=currentIssue.cfm#volume10.
e/pii/S026069171500074X [Accessed July Edward, K. et al., 2007. Simulation to
22, 2016]. Practice: Developing Nursing Skills in
D‘Souza, M.S., Venkatesaperumal, R., et Mental Health--An Australian Perspective.
al., 2013. Engagement in clinical learning International electronic journal. Available
environment among nursing students: Role at: http://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ794196
of nurse educators. Open Journal of [Accessed July 22, 2016].
Nursing, 03(01), pp.25–32. Available at:
How to cite this article: D‘Souza MS, Arjunan P, Venkatesaperumal R. High fidelity simulation in
nursing education. Int J Health Sci Res. 2017; 7(7):340-353.
***********