Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
MAY 3, 2019
VOL. LXXXVIII NO. 33 $1.00 88 2019
THEJEWISHSTANDARD.COM
Teaneck, NJ 07666
1086 Teaneck Road
in North Jersey and Rockland
Jewish Standard
Your values and beliefs understood and respected.
Jewish services and amenities at Englewood Health
englewoodhealth.org
JS-3*
Page 3
Romani and Yiddish had historical importance. urskola.se, an official Swedish website featuring
Sweden has about 20,000 Jews. Its Yiddish-speak- educational videos in a variety of languages: Titled Candlelighting:
ing Ashkenazic community dates back only to the “Charles och arternas uppkomst” in Swedish, which Friday, May 3, 7:36 p.m.
18th century, when it joined the Sephardim who Google translates to “Charles and the origins of
had been there for centuries. Perhaps 1,500 Jewish species,” it’s a Yiddish-language video providing a Shabbat ends:
Swedes are native Yiddish speakers, most of them basic introduction to the theory of evolution. Com- Saturday, May 4, 8:41 p.m.
elderly. bining nature videos and animations, it features a
If this strikes you as a slim basis for an official mi- Swedish-accented Yiddish narrator, animation, and
nority language, we wouldn’t disagree. Nonetheless, Yiddish words like selektzia — selection — and yeru- For convenient
that is official policy. sha — inheritance. home delivery,
Which means that Yiddish has a higher legal sta- One more reason for chasidim to insist on filtering call 201-837-8818 or
tus in Sweden than it does in Israel and the United their internet. LARRY YUDELSON
bit.ly/jsubscribe
MOVIE MELANGE:
Romance beckons
and so do seniors
“Long Shot,” a seems plausible. Most Sage co-starred as Uninterrupted” was
romantic critics say that Rogen Alara Kitan in the first created by by NBA
comedy/drama and Theron make us two seasons of “The star LeBron James,
starring SETH ROGEN, like their characters Orville,” a Fox sci-fi se- who hosts, and by
36, and Charlize and believe in their ries. Sage’s character’s African-American
Theron, opens on May characters’ romance. recent departure from businessman Maverick
3. Rogen plays Fred “Long Shot” was di- the show was written Carter. It began as a
Flarsky. He’s a brash rected by JONATHAN so that she can come web series; HBO
reporter for a liberal LEVINE, 42, who also back easily. It appears picked it up in 2018.
alt-weekly — but the helmed “50/50” in that Sage left “The Or- The premise is that a
job he loves disap- 2011. “50/50” was a ville” to free herself up number of mostly
pears when a conser- quite good movie, in for other projects. African-American
vative media baron which Rogen gave his Jonathan Levine Halston Sage Early in April, I wrote celebrities gather at a
buys his paper. Shortly best dramatic perfor- about the Netflix se- barbershop and have a
thereafter, he runs into mance to date. The ries “No Good Nick,” wide-ranging unscript-
Charlotte (Theron), his “Long Shot” screen- which began stream- ed conversation. Race
old babysitter, who play was co-written by ing on April 15. I said it and career issues have
now is the Secretary of DAN STERLING, 50ish, was about a teen girl been major topics in
State. Fred charms her who has written for who infiltrates a nice past episodes. The
with his self-deprecat- many smart TV come- family with hidden bad second HBO episode
ing humor and his dy series. By the way, intentions. I said that premieres on May 4 at
memories of her Flarsky is revealed to Sean Astin, who plays 10 p.m., with Seth
youthful idealism. As be a Jewish charac- the family’s nice father, Rogen as one of the
she prepares to make ter early in the film. A discovered as an adult barbershop guests.
a surprise presidential friend who accurately that his biological The other six guests
run, she hires Fred to monitors such things father is Jewish. I also include NFL star DeAn-
punch up her speech- says that Flarsky is the Kalama Epstein Lauren Lindsay Donzis noted that KALAMA dre Hopkins, songwrit-
es. They have chemis- first explicitly Jewish EPSTEIN, 19, who plays er/singer Pharrell
try and begin a lead character in a ma- group. Judy holds back Sean’s son, has a Jew- Williams, and actor
New offerings
romantic affair. That jor 2019 film. on telling Jen some- ish father and identifies Don Cheadle.
affair threatens to “POMS,” opening air on netflix thing that would rock as Jewish. Well, I just The documenta-
torpedo her campaign May 3, is a feel-good ED ASNER, 89, Jen’s already shaky learned that LAUREN ry “At the Heart of
because Fred has a lot movie comedy about has a supporting world. LINDSEY DONZIS, 14, Gold: Inside the USA
of foibles in his past. a woman, played by role in “Dead to “The Last Summer,” who plays Astin’s other Gymnastics Scandal”
Advance reviews are Diane Keaton, who Me,” a 10-episode series an original Netflix film, child, is Jewish. Both premieres on HBO on
quite good. Rogen has moves into a retire- that begins streaming also starts on May 3. her real-life parents May 3 at 8 p.m. Dr.
become a better actor ment community May 3. Christina The plot is familiar: High are Jewish. Her previ- Larry Nassar, who sex-
over the years and and starts a cheer- Applegate plays Jen, a school grads wrestle ous credits include a ually molested hun-
Theron is very adept leading squad with sardonic widow set on with love and friendship recurring role on the dreds of young gym-
in seemingly every her fellow residents. solving her husband’s during their final sum- Disney series “Liv and nasts, is at the story’s
film genre. A romantic RHEA PERLMAN, 71, recent hit-and-run mer together before Maddie.” center, and Olympic
comedy lives or dies plays one of the squad murder. She bonds with heading off to college. star ALY RAISMAN,
on whether we like the members. I hope this Judy (Linda Cardenalli), HALSTON SAGE, 25, Over on HBO 24, will be featured in
main characters and flick is not too old- an upbeat woman she has a large role as Erin, The HBO series the documentary.
whether their romance folks cute. meets at a support one of the grads. “The Shop: –N.B.
Want to read more noshes? Visit facebook.com/jewishstandard California-based Nate Bloom can be reached at
Middleoftheroad1@aol.com
Museum of
Exhibition Tickets Jewish Heritage
at Auschwitz.nyc A Living Memorial
to the Holocaust
Lower Manhattan
D
They were part of it in the Clin-
ennis Ross doesn’t need ton parameters I was working
much of an introduction. on.” (Maale Adumim and Gush
He’s the former State Etzion both are suburbs of Jeru-
Department official who salem, home to many Israeli
worked with Secretary of State James Jews, and for a long time the
Baker on the Madrid peace confer- understanding has been that
ence during the Bush administration, they will stay with Israel, no
who played a lead role in negotiations matter what else happens.)
between Israelis and Palestinians “It shouldn’t just be done uni-
during the Clinton administration, and laterally,” he continued. “Where
who President Obama called back for the context is created because the Pal- “The level of fatigue with the Pales-
another round of peace efforts. He now estinians have said no once again, if tinians by Arab leaders is growing. The
is a fellow with the Washington Insti- in exchange the administration gets a recognition of their common security
tute for Near East Policy. commitment that areas east of the bar- interest with Israelis is growing. But
And next week, he’s speaking in rier will not have Israeli sovereignty — they wouldn’t come out and say the
Paramus. (See box.) and I would say stop building there as Palestinians should accept something.
At the core of his talk is his next well — that would be giving the Israelis The most you’ll get is for them to say
book, due out in September: “Be something and also getting something that a plan is serious and the basis for
Strong and of Good Courage: How in return. The U.S. could use it with serious negotiations.” For that to hap-
Israel’s Most Important Leaders Dennis Ross Arab leaders, to get Arab leaders to say pen, though, the plan “must cross a
Shaped Its Destiny.” they’ll stay engaged with some kind certain threshold. If not, they won’t
The book profiles Israeli leaders decision on the part of the prime min- of peace diplomacy. It’s a way to take expose themselves to charges that they
David Ben-Gurion, Menachem Begin, ister to say that we’re going to build advantage of the plan at a time where betrayed the Palestinian cause. They
Yitzhak Rabin, and Ariel Sharon. within the settlement blocs but not out- prospects are at best uncertain.” just won’t do that.”
“It points out how they evolved, how side them. We’ll build to the west of the What does he think of the Trump
and why they made what were tough separation barrier but not to the east. administration taking a tough line with
decisions,” Mr. Ross said. This will preserve the option of separa- the Palestinians?
This is not meant as abstract history. tion, even if the IDF stays where it is. “There’s a certain logic to it,” Mr.
“My book says what lessons can we
draw from the past to see if it can be
“It’s not a simple decision. It takes a
courageous decision on the part of the
If Israel stays Ross said. “The problem is that what
should have been done at the same
applied to the future,” Mr. Ross said. prime minister. But if you don’t make on the path it time was some effort to show that there
And the book looks at “the role the
U.S. played in making some of the deci-
a conscious decision, you’re headed to
one state for two people. With 105,000
is on, by was some recognition of and concern
for Palestinian needs as well.
sions easier, by making commitments Israelis living to the east of the sepa- default it will “The administration’s approach
and assurances that could be offered
to Israel to make more tailwind for the
ration barrier already, you may soon
reach a tipping point.”
become one has two elements that make sense,”
he continued. “One is that the Pales-
Israeli prime minister to make more So how does this plan fit with the state for tinians should understand that every
difficult choices.”
In other words, while the book looks
increasing talk within Mr. Netanya-
hu’s Likud party of annexing parts of
two peoples. time you say no to what’s on offer, the
next time there is less. That’s abso-
back, its key message is addressed to the West Bank? And with the Trump lutely the right approach.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Net- administration’s promised plan for And public support from Arab “Number two, the fact that there
anyahu and is about Israel’s future, and Middle East peace? leaders for any peace plan is key to needs to be an adjustment to reality.
the “tough decision” Mr. Ross wants Mr. Ross said that depends on how it its success, Mr. Ross said. That’s what That too was right, both conceptually
Mr. Netanyahu to make. is couched. the “Clinton parameters” that Pales- and logically. The problem is that you
“If Israel stays on the path it is on, He would advise the Trump admin- tinian leader Yasser Arafat rejected in haven’t given the Arab leaders or Pales-
by default it will become one state istration to tell Prime Minister Net- 2000 lacked. tinians anything for them to know that
for two peoples,” he said. Avoiding anyahu: “Don’t do any unilateral “We did get Arab support. The prob- this is an administration that will take
that undesirable outcome “requires a annexation before we release our lem was that it was private support. their concerns into account.
hard decision.” peace plan. If the Palestinians reject Private support means nothing. You “I didn’t have a problem with the
The decision he has is mind is not to the plan in advance, we could be in a have to create a new reality” — and that U.S. decision to move its embassy to
accede to the Palestinian demand for position where we tell the Arabs that takes public support. Jerusalem. But it wasn’t prepared the
statehood immediately. “That’s not if they reject the plan, and there’s no “You’re not going to get Arab leaders way it should have been,” he said.
possible because the Palestinians aren’t diplomacy, we would support the prin- to stand up and say a plan that doesn’t Mr. Ross thinks that Mr. Trump
ready for it,” he said. ciple of Israeli annexation, with the provide for a Palestinian state or a cap- could have told the Palestinians that he
Instead, the decision he would understanding that the final border still ital in some part of Arab Jerusalem is was committed to keeping his promise,
approve would be “to adopt a posi- has to be negotiated. serious,” Mr. Ross said. and that it should matter that the pres-
tion that would preserve the possibil- “The truth is, in any peace agree- But the time is ripe for the right plan, ident fulfills his promise. And he could
ity of separation. It takes a courageous ment Maale Adumim and Gush Etzion he believes. have asked them, “what would make it
6 JEWISH STANDARD MAY 3, 2019
Local
The way it’s been done creates a bar. It makes Who: Ambassador Dennis Ross
it harder for the Arabs to do the things you When: Sunday, May 12, 6:15 p.m.
want them to do. There isn’t an Arab leader Where: JCC of Paramus/
other than Assad who thinks Israel shouldn’t Congregation Beth Tikvah,
E 304 Midland Ave., Paramus
be in control of the Golan Heights with Iran in How: (201) 262-7691 or
Syria, but they condemned the move. jccparamus.org
more manageable for you?” programs we’ll provide through a dif- Netanyahu and for the Trump admin- other country in the Middle East where
And when Mr. Trump announced ferent mechanism? istration, does Mr. Ross have advice for the attorney general, appointed by the
his decision, “when he said we’re not “The way it’s been done creates a bar. American Jews? leader, intends to indict him.” (He’s talking
recognizing the boundaries of Israeli It makes it harder for the Arabs to do “The one thing for American Jews, as about Attorney General Avichai Mandel-
sovereignty, all he had to do was add the things you want them to do. There it relates to Israel, is to keep in mind that blit, whose department has indicted Mr.
a clause: because we understand the isn’t an Arab leader other than Assad you have your counterparts there. One Netanyu on three charges of corruption.)
Palestinians have claims and it has to who thinks Israel shouldn’t be in control shouldn’t lose sight of that. For the more “There’s a lot of polarization here,
be solved in negotiations.” of the Golan Heights with Iran in Syria, progressive Jews, you have your counter- a lot of alienation from the adminis-
Similarly, “I’m quite sympathetic but they condemned the move. The bal- parts in Israel you can completely iden- tration,” Mr. Ross said. “That affects
with the decision that was made to ance you should be striking is to send a tify with and it helps you. Build bridges views of Israel as a result. Don’t forget
stop funding UNWRA,” the United message that’s adjusting to reality, but to them. that Israeli is a genuine democracy. You
Nations organization that oversees creates a climate where you give them “Understand and recognize what Israel may not like the results of elections,
Palestinian refugees. “Why not on the something they can point to.” is. It’s a country with a vibrant free press. but the potential for accountability is
same day say, here are the specific Having offered suggestions for Mr. It’s a country ruled by law. There’s no always there.
American Friends of
MIGDAL OHR
2019 Gala Dinner
Tuesday, May 14th
9 Iyar
CNVS
635 West 42nd Street, NYC
To purchase gala tickets please call 212-397-3700 or visit
www.migdalohrusa.org/2019gala
Migdal Ohr, founded by Israel Prize Laureate, Rabbi Yitzchak Dovid Grossman,
provides essential educational and life-changing programs and services
to thousands of at-risk children across Israel throughout their lifecycle.
T
welve-year-old Ayelet Poupko of Englewood
has never forgotten how the child-life special-
ists at Joseph M. Sanzari Children’s Hospital
brought a measure of comfort and joy to her
younger sister Chana Tova while the little girl was being
treated for cancer.
She recalls that in those heartbreakingly difficult
months before Chana’s death in June 2014, at 2½, activi-
ties such as “art projects and little push trolleys you could
ride on” brought a smile to Chana and her two older sis-
ters when they’d visit her at the Hackensack facility.
Earlier this year, Ayelet decided that in lieu of gifts
for her bat mitzvah she would ask well-wishers to
donate to Tackle Kids Cancer, which raises money for
pediatric cancer research and patient-care programs
as part of the Children’s Cancer Institute at Hacken-
sack Meridian Health.
Ayelet, now a sixth grader at Ben Porat Yosef in Para-
mus, requested that the gifts be designated specifically
for the Child Life Program as a way of memorializing From left, Maureen McLaughlin of Tackle Kids Cancer; Dr. Michael Harris of Hackensack Meridian Health
Chana and bettering the lives of other children in treat- Hackensack University Medical Center; Ayelet Poupko; her mother, Dr. Shoshana Klein Poupko, holding
ment at the hospital. baby Rachel; Elana Poupko; Rabbi Chaim Poupko; pediatric hematologist-oncologist Dr. Alfred Gillio,
“I didn’t want any stuff,” Ayelet said. “Those kids and Lauren Willis of the Hackensack University Medical Center Foundation.
need it more.”
On April 12, Ayelet presented Tackle Kids Cancer with for some of the items and bringing them to the hospital said New York Giants quarterback Eli Manning matched
a check for $12,000. Days later, the grand total contrib- herself. Because my kids spent so much time there, they the $17,500 the girls had raised. That came to a total of
uted in Ayelet’s honor by 100 people climbed to $13,250. go back and visit often, and we take gifts at holiday time.” $35,000 to benefit pediatric cancer research.
Ayelet plans to write a thank-you note to each donor. Amy Glazer, the executive director of development for
Ayelet did not think that her fund-raising appeal would the children’s hospital and Tackle Kids Cancer, said the
raise so much money. staff feels “incredibly grateful” for Ayelet’s contribution.
She had asked for a wish list from Tara Mullen, a senior The Child Life Program is not funded by insurance and
child-life specialist at Sanzari Children’s Hospital.
Ms. Mullen has many strong memories of Chana.
depends largely on philanthropy, she explained.
“As a family-centric program, the Joseph M. Sanzari
Earlier this year,
“I had the pleasure of working with Chana during her Children’s Hospital boasts a robust Child Life team to Ayelet decided that
treatment,” she said. “As a child life specialist, my focus
is to help children cope with the many demands of
provide socio-emotional support to the patient and his
or her siblings,” Ms. Glazer said.
in lieu of gifts for
treatment through play, expressive activities, and edu- “Our Child Life staff integrates play therapy, perfor- her bat mitzvah
cation. I had the honor of working with Chana and her
sisters over the course of her treatment. Chana loved
mance, music, and art into the treatment of children.
Their work helps children to better understand their
she would ask well-
playing, especially with her sister, and spending time diagnosis, channel their emotions during their illness wishers to donate to
out of her room.
“Much of my time spent with Chana was walking her
or injury, and provide an alternative method for them
to communicate.
Tackle Kids Cancer,
around the unit in a little red wagon, often accompanied “Ayelet’s generosity and kindness will impact which raises money
by ‘Mickey baby’ and a couple of other stuffed friends. countless patients and their siblings.”
“Chana was an incredible little girl, with the wisest This is not the first time that the Poupko family’s for pediatric cancer
blue eyes and playful and warm spirit. I feel so honored
to have spent time with her and to have met her sisters
contributions have made an impact at the hospital
where Chana was treated.
research and patient-
and parents, all of who are still so invested in the care and In 2017, the family learned that the Alfred N. San- care programs.
treatment of children at the Children’s Cancer Institute at zari Family Foundation was planning to renovate the
Hackensack Meridian Health Hackensack University Med- Audrey Hepburn Children’s House and asked to par- Ayelet, who turned 12 on February 24, and Elana, 10,
ical Center, as well as the child life department.” ticipate by creating specially equipped rooms for Sab- welcomed a new baby sister, Rachel, two months ago.
So when she was asked to chose items in Chana’s mem- bath-observant families on the Hackensack University The whole family went to the children’s hospital to pres-
ory, Ms. Mullen was glad to pick four expensive but very Medical Center campus. ent Ayelet’s bat mitzvah gift money.
useful pieces of equipment: Pack ‘n Play portable crib/ The Poupkos raised $100,000 in just two weeks, pri- Last year, Ms. Mullen came to talk to Ayelet’s class at
play yards, white-noise machines to help children sleep marily from members of Englewood’s Congregation Ben Porat Yosef about the Child Life Program. Ayelet said
through the beeping of monitoring equipment, LEGO Ahavath Torah, where Rabbi Chaim Poupko then was that hearing about the work of child-life specialists helped
sets, and premium modeling clay. associate rabbi and now is rabbi. The rooms have been raise awareness for the good it accomplishes. Judging by
“Ayelet set a goal of $3,600 to cover all this, but our in regular use since they were completed that March. their generosity, adults in the local Jewish community
community has been unbelievable,” said her mother, And last June, proceeds from the annual “Heartbeats” clearly were touched as well.
Dr. Shoshana Klein Poupko, a therapist at Family Service student production at Ma’ayanot Yeshiva High School “I think people understood the real need for
League in Montclair. for Girls in Teaneck were donated to Tackle Kids Cancer. the money because they saw an example of how it
“We’ve talked about the possibility of Ayelet shopping Dr. Poupko, then a faculty adviser for the production, helped,” Ayelet said.
8 JEWISH STANDARD MAY 3, 2019
Jewish National Fund Women for Israel Presents
Siggy Flicker
Relationship Expert, TV Personality, and Author
WOMEN
FOR ISRAEL jnf.org · 800.JNF.0099
I
n the beginning was the friendship.
Cinematographer Boaz Yeho-
natan Yaakov and director Joseph
Madmony had worked together on
two of Mr. Madmony’s films.
They clicked, despite the fact — or per-
haps because of the fact — that Mr. Mad-
mony had left the religious world of his
youth, and Mr. Yaakov embraced Ortho-
dox Judaism and Chabad as an adult.
“I think that we have a lot in com-
mon because both of us made a drastic
change,” Mr. Madmony said. “It’s about
telling yourself a different story. We both Boaz Yehonatan Yaakov
chose another story than the one that we
were raised with.”
So it was natural that Mr. Yaakov
would bring his idea for a film to Mr.
Madmony. The fictional idea concerned
a baal teshuva who left his life as a rock
star when he embraced religion, only to
rejoin his band on a reunion tour years
later in hopes of raising enough money to
treat his daughter’s cancer. They worked
together on the script of what became
“Redemption,” which went on to win the
audience award at the Jerusalem Film Fes-
tival and will play in Closter next week as
part of the IAC Cinematec. (See box.)
“At first, the story sounded a little bit
too melodramatic,” Mr. Madmony said. Joseph Madmony
“But Boaz was a really good friend of
mine. I started to write it almost unwill- helpful as studying in yeshiva.
ingly. Because I knew it was so important “Many times we see stories about peo-
to him, I couldn’t tell him no. Step by step, ple who fight something that is trying to
I fell in love with the story.” hurt them. What’s special about this story
The final film is not melodramatic, is that Menachem is in a fight for himself,
he said. with himself. It’s a story which each one
“It’s more like a slice of life. The text is of us lives. We grow up and get taught
very realistic.” about all the enemies that are on the
For Mr. Yaakov, the beginning of the a lot of sacrifice on both sides. A very big or three seconds — that happened in my outside, but the most important enemy
story was another friendship — his friend- and deep appreciation. life, when I was going to have my picture which you have to deal with is yourself.
ship with the man who led him to become “I wanted to tell a story about friend- taken for my ID card. This enemy disturbs your basic ability to
Orthodox, and to whose memory the film ship. And being an Orthodox Jew who is “Slowly we started building the charac- just be happy.”
is dedicated. very close to Chabad, the whole essence ter in a certain way, close to my life story Mr. Yaakov grew up on movie sets. His
“This friendship was maybe the most of redemption is in the air all the time. I — though I always kept working as a cine- father, Rony, now retired, was a film pro-
significant event in my life,” Mr. Yaakov understood and felt the fuel of the redemp- matographer during the whole process of ducer, “one of the main ones who estab-
said. “It was a very strong friendship, with tion is what you sacrifice from yourself and becoming Orthodox.” lished the film industry in Israel. I always
give of yourself to someone else.” As Menachem came into focus, so did knew that dealing with movies and films is
What: Film “Redemption, Friendship, Mr. Yaakov said, “turns life the lessons he learned from reuniting my life.”
showing as part of the IAC better for people who give from them- with his friends in the band. In high school, he took a film class and
Cinamatec, with discussion led selves to someone else. It has the biggest “He starts to see his faults — faults which realized that cinematography gave him an
by Rabbi Paul Kerbel effect when it is hardest to do it.” I had and have, in a certain different vol- outlet for his emotions and feelings. In the
Where: Temple Emanu El, 180 When it came time to expand the initial ume. Having a true partner like Yossi, who army, he worked as a cinematographer in
Piermont Road., Closter synopsis they had prepared to get fund- knows me well, helps me to be able to see the educational corps. At 24, he went to
ing into a full script, they realized that the those faults from the side. It’s very hard Los Angeles where he worked on films —
When: Thursday, May 9. 7:30 p.m.
reception and refreshments, 8 p.m. main character — Menachem — was “basi- for a person to see his own faults because and had an existential crisis.
screening and discussion cally underdeveloped,” Mr. Yaakov said. he loves himself very much. “L.A. showed me something which was
“I started to see some pictures and “This movie is an event in my life which very hard to understand. In L.A., the life
How much: In advance, $22, $18 for
events from my own life. The first scene, is much more than making a movie. It’s an of a simple human being who isn’t rich
Temple Emanu El members. $25 at
the door. where he gets his picture taken and finds inner process that is part of my whole life enough or beautiful enough or powerful
he can’t hold a smile for more than two journey, which can be as fulfilling and as enough is useless,” he said. “It was very
10 JEWISH STANDARD MAY 3, 2019
Local CELEBRATING 40 YEARS OF PRACTICE
REPRESENTING BUSINESSES,
FAMILIES AND INDIVIDUALS
We are looking forward to continuing to serve you.
Steven Morey Greenberg, Esq.
hard for me to live with. I came from Israel, which is a
Greenberg & Lanz, LLC
very small place, a very warm place. Suddenly to see
people just walking in the street and nobody cares about Please phone us for a free consultation
them, was very hard.
“I said to myself, ‘You came to the end of the world regarding these matters
where all your dreams are. And it’s a place you don’t
want to live in. What do you do now?’ Two University Plaza · Hackensack, NJ 07601
“I was feeling stuck for two years, which created a
certain kind of darkness. Then I met my friend Yosef, Phone: (201) 487-7755 · Fax: (201) 487-0087
the movie is in his memory. He was a baal teshuva. He smg@greenberglanz.com · www.greenberglanz.com
started to talk to me about the essence of God, who cre-
ated this big black feeling I was in, but it’s okay. Slowly,
slowly, I started to see things differently.”
He compares this experience to when he first
picked up a movie camera in high school. “It was the
second light that came into my life after cinematog-
raphy,” he said.
Mr. Yaakov was able to nurture both lights. In
“Redemption,” Menachem wasn’t able to do that.
A
s the sun fell on the town
of Łódź, Poland, dozens
of people crowded inside
a cattle car. Among them
was Manny Buchman, who had been
forced to do this when he was 17 — and
now, at 92, he was doing it again. This
time willingly.
Seventy-six years ago, Manny expe-
rienced unbelievable suffering and sur-
vived. He hid in Hungary, was captured,
jumped out of the cattle car into a snow-
Holocaust survivor Manny Buchman is surrounded by students as he Students drape themselves in the flag of Israel as they walk the train
relives his experiences both in Nazi captivity and fleeing from it. tracks leading to Auschwitz.
12 JEWISH STANDARD MAY 3, 2019
JEWISH STANDARD MAY 3, 2019 13
JS-14*
Local
‘kaddish.com’
Novelist Nathan Englander will discuss
life, work, and everything else in Teaneck
Joanne Palmer
Y
ou look at the photograph of Nathan
Englander — he’s handsome, pensive, still,
in an empty, dramatic space, sitting there
like the pure quintessence of novelist. You
know. A Writer.
And then you talk to him, maybe a little intimidated by
his work — he’s just finished a new novel, “kaddish.com,”
and he’s going to be talking about it in Teaneck on Sun-
day night (see box) — and he’s not at all what you expect.
He’s warm, charming, incredibly fast-talking, jumping
from idea to idea with unassailable if unfollowable logic.
Even on the phone, you (or at least I) are totally dis-
armed, entirely charmed, thoroughly if abstractly in love.
Okay. Enough of that.
Nathan Englander began his career about 20 years
ago with his first book, a short story collection called
“For the Relief of Unbearable Urges.” He’s published
four books since then, some of them short-story collec-
tions, some of them novels. He grew up in the Orthodox
community on Long Island, went to the school then
Joshua Meier
called the Hebrew Academy of Nassau County — bet-
ter known as HANC — lived in Israel for five years, now
lives in Brooklyn, and is both no longer Orthodox and
as thoroughly deeply, authentically, and inescapably
Jewish as anyone possibly could be.
Like the main character of “kaddish.com,” he’s Sholom on Sunday night. She’s known him for more Judaism — that you can be secular and Jewish.”
nearly 50 now; as with that book’s Larry, his father than 20 years, since before his first book came out, and What can be more Jewish than the concept of saying
died in 1999. That’s when the book opens, after a page has watched him change and grow. kaddish?
dedicated “For my sister,” for real, with a description “He is very exuberant,” she said. “He talks a mile a “‘kaddish.com’” is “a journey book,” Mr. England
of the relationship between Larry and Dina as the little minute. He starts in one place and then will talk about said. “It is about somebody trying to find something.”
brother stays with his big sister for their father’s funeral something else and quotes a lot of people and he always The book’s premise is the need to say kaddish. “There
and shiva. Dina lives in Memphis, Tennessee. The rest makes sure to attribute the quote. It’s very circular. is a father who is religious, who needs an advocate,” the
of the book is set 20 years later; Larry’s evolved into “He talks about how he talks in a circular way, and man who will say kaddish for him, three times a day, for
Reb Shuli — formally Shaul — returned to the Orthodox his writing is very clear. And how that circular way of 11 months. “There can be nothing clearer. If you don’t
life he’d once rejected, a husband, father, teacher, and talking is very Jewish.” (It was one of his first writing say the kaddish right, he’s burning in the fire for real. If
son. But whoops! He didn’t handle his obligation to say teachers, the writer Marilynne Robinson, who taught you are traditional or Orthodox, the expectation is that
kaddish for his father properly. him at graduate school at the University of Iowa Writ- someone will do it. If you are not, then not. Just not.
From there, the book takes off, part fable, part magic ers’ Workshop, who’d pointed that out to him, she said.) “That set up the story for me.”
realism, part mystery, deeply touching, occasionally On Sunday, they will talk about “his career, how he It feels necessary to say that the book takes the need
weird, almost always funny. has gotten to where he is now,” she said. “He looks up to say kaddish absolutely seriously. It is not a joke.
Not that everyone finds it funny, Mr. Englander said. to both Malamud and Roth, and in some of the scenes Nothing about the Orthodox life that Shuli leads is a
He’s been chasing around the country talking about the you can see his connection to Philip Roth.” (There joke; it’s his interactions with the outside world that are
book, and he’s struck by how varied the reactions to it aren’t many of those scenes, but they are pretty hard funny, and they come from him.
have been. “My mom thinks it’s a sad book,” he said. to miss.) “We will talk about the book and Orthodoxy “Resilience is not rejection,” he said. “It is a form
Other people have laughed their way through it. and faith and religion, and how he is secular now but of love.”
“When I was in grad school, I would think that I had he is really drawn back in.”
written the funniest story in the world, and I’d put it “I have all my high-falutin’ reasons for books to get Who: The Jewish Week’s Sandee Brawarsky will
up, and my friends would be like, ‘I cried.’ And I would written,” Mr. Englander said. “There are so many sin- interview writer Nathan Englander; after they talk,
there’ll be a question-and-answer session and
put up something sad, and they’d say, ‘I laughed my cere reasons, emotional reasons, literary and conscious
book signing.
head off.’ and intellectual reasons, but I always compare it to being
“What the reader thinks is really interesting to me, a gymnast. With writing, you are always starting again, When: On Sunday, May 5, at 7:30 p.m.
and it has been comforting and lovely.” and figuring it out again. Reflecting on your own life.” Where: At Congregation Beth Sholom, 354
One of the most striking parts of the book is how Okay. So his life. He may be secular — no, he is secular Maitland Ave.
good-natured it is; it leads its hero through unlikely — but his pull toward Jewish life is so strong that you can Why: As part of the shul’s series, “New Horizons in
and perilous adventures in Memphis, Brooklyn, and practically see it between the words on the pages of his Jewish Literature.”
Jerusalem, and it’s got an unfashionably, satisfactorily book. Ms. Brawarsky sees it. “He is decidedly secular, How much: It’s free.
happy ending. but his friends tease him about how soulful he is,” she
For more information: email or go to
Sandee Brawarsky of Teaneck, the Jewish Week’s said. “He will catch himself doing all sorts of halachic
www.cbsteaneck.org
culture editor, will interview Mr. Englander at Beth things. And now he has discovered the world of secular
Shaare Zedek medical professionals lead the way with ground-breaking solutions.
Israel’s preeminent hospital in the heart of Jerusalem for more than a century helps
patients heal through compassionate care and cutting-edge treatments.
Tanya Steel, center, featured speaker, and Jordan Shenker, the JCC’s CEO, with the Lavish Brandi Rubin and Lorin Cook, event co-chairs,
Lunches committee. serving at the senior lunch.
Israel Bonds-Bergen
meets in Cresskill
From left, Vered Buskila, Lee
On March 28, Israel Bonds Bergen County Women’s Division held a
Schwartz, executive director of
parlor meeting in Cresskill which resulted in more than $100,000 in
Israel Bonds Metro NJ, Annette
purchases and intentions to invest. It was hosted by Annette Stern.
Stern, and Marc Rosen, Israel
Vered Buskila, a former Israeli Olympic sailor and vice president
Bond’s registered representative
of the Olympic Committee of Israel, was the guest speaker.
for Bergen County. COURTESY
For more information about the event or investing in Israel
ISRAEL BONDS
Bonds, call Marc Rosen at (201) 881-1596 or email him at marc.
rosen@israelbonds.com.
t zm a u t
Yom Ha’ a
Sponsoring Shuls
Congregations Beth Aaron, Beth Abraham, Bais Medrash of Bergenfield,
Bnai Yeshurun, Jewish Center of Teaneck, Keter Torah, Netivot Shalom, Ohr Saadya, Rinat Yisrael,
Shaare Tefillah, Shaarei Orah, Young Israel, and Zichron Mordechai
We thank our generous sponsors Drs. Morton and Esther Fridman,
Ellen and Dr. Richard Gertler, Nathan J. and Shari Lindenbaum and Rochel and Joseph Stechler.
Faith leaders
meet with
Gottheimer
Faith leaders met with Congress-
man Josh Gottheimer, the Demo-
crat who represents New Jersey’s
5th District. The gathering takes
PHOTO PROVIDED
Fighting stigma
Not alone May is mental health awareness month. Here are stories about
three programs, two in Bergen County and one in Rockland,
about mental health and the Jewish community.
Local groups partner to offer on substance abuse and addiction Although both she and Ms. Croog are
awareness education and prevention, Orthodox, both of their organizations
symposium on mental health issues we partnered with Refa’enu. The pur- and the May 5 symposium are “open
pose of the partnership is to say that to everyone,” she said. “Ours has never
Y
Joanne Palmer 700 people, far more people than chairs addiction is a mental health disease, and been aimed only at Orthodox Jews.
or even standing room — at the Torah there are other, broader mental health It’s aimed at Jewish schools. These are
es, of course sunlight is the Academy of Bergen County. Since then, issues that we want to tackle together. issues that touch everyone.”
best disinfectant. they’ve created their own group, Com- “Addiction is a disease,” she said. “Sub- The symposium will open “with a key-
But it’s not as if all you munities Confronting Substance Abuse, stance abuse is a symptom, like depres- note conversation” between two people,
have to do is tug a bunch and have held other meetings. The com- sion. You can be addicted to anything — to Dr. Norman Blumenthal and Lisa Twer-
of problems out into the munity’s interest has remained strong. gambling, to shopping, to sex, to overeat- ski, she said. (Dr. Blumenthal is a clinical
backyard at noon and let the sun bleach Now, Communities Confronting ing, to anything that produces a feeling psychologist who, among many other
them clean. Substance Abuse is partnering with of completeness. It is self-medicating, and impressive credits, works with children,
It’s a process. Even metaphorically, Refa’enu, a Teaneck-based group started you cannot break away from it.” specializes in trauma, and heads a pro-
it’s a process. In order to heal mental by local writer and activist Dena Croog Many people can gamble, shop, over- gram at RIETS at Yeshiva Univer-
health issues, you have to be able to to combat the stigma and increase the eat, or do many other things without sity; Ms. Twerski is a highly
developing an addiction to them, she credentialed social
Cover Story
A
Joanne Palmer to go to the Orthodox boarding school that had
such a good reputation. It offered stability, aca-
t his first High Holy Day sermon at demic and spiritual growth, and friendship.
his new shul, in 2007, Rabbi David- Gabriel came home from that first year of
Seth Kirshner told the congregation school changed, his brother David said. He did
about his brother Gabriel’s suicide. not go back. In some ways, he never came back.
Rabbi Kirshner, still in his 30s, But eventually he went on with his life, got mar-
new at his job, was standing at the bimah in the ried, got ordained, had a daughter. Seemed
big, packed sanctuary at Temple Emanu-El of Clos- okay.
ter; there was another, similarly sized congrega- But he wasn’t. When he was 36, in 1996, he
tion, the other part of the Emanu-El community, died of suicide. Later, his devastated family
to whom he’d tell the story the next day. It’s a learned that the principal of the school he’d
wealthy, committed, well-educated, self-assured gone to was a monster. As Rabbi David Kirsh-
group, and it would have been understandable had Rabbi David-Seth Kirshner Dr. Jennifer Ashton ner wrote in an op-ed in the Jewish Standard,
Rabbi Kirshner decided to wait for a less high-pro- “When silence equals death,” on August 3, 2012, his
file, arguably less risky time to tell his story. He per- when the family headed to their father’s next stop — brother “was molested and raped from 1973 to 1975.
haps could have decided never to tell his story. his father, Sherman Phillip Kirshner, was a Conser- “He was not alone. Dozens of his classmates and
But that’s not what he did. vative rabbi, and he had taken a new pulpit in Penn- hundreds of boys before and after Gabriel were sexu-
Instead, he told them about his oldest brother, who sylvania. His wife and their three younger sons, of ally molested and raped by the ‘rabbi.’
begged his family to be allowed to stay in Baltimore course, went with their parents, but Gabriel longed See suicide page 26
Cover Story
Cover Story
ever since then, she’d struggled with ran- or at least far worse than anyone else’s. comes from the story of Elijah; the he said.
dom thoughts and with mood changes. “I do a lot of work with domestic vio- group’s tack is unusual in that it works Elijah’s Journey also stresses the
“She got engaged young, and then, lence, and once, years and years ago, I with Jewish texts to show how some importance of “listening to the best
on the eve of her wedding, she had a was asked to be on a multicultural panel Jewish foundational figures, who are practices from experts in mental health
full-blown psychotic break of some sort. on domestic violence,” she said. “I was shown to be flawed but overcome those organizations,” he said. “Many syna-
Obviously that was devastating. You the last speaker. And everyone said the flaws, face — and face down — thoughts gogues say that they want to do pro-
wonder what might have been different same thing. Everyone went into it think- of suicide. Elijah, the great prophet who grams, ‘and there is somebody in the
if her mood had been stabilized and the ing I will say what is different about our we evoke at times of transition and lim- synagogue who is a social worker, so
problem had been attended to and dealt culture, but it was all the same.” In the inality, who we call to at Havdalah as let him run it.’ The research is very cut-
with, from the time she started showing end, she didn’t say much about the Jew- day turns to night and Shabbat to the ting edge. To be a mental health profes-
some problems. ish community; instead, she told them week, was so overcome that he wanted sional, you have to be trained in suicidal
“She was fairly well stabilized after that she’d sound just like everyone else. to end his life. In Mr. Epstein’s transla- ideation. Synagogues do not.
that; medication was really helpful, “I think we have similar struggles,” tion of the Book of Kings, “I have had “So there are two separate things,
and therapy was really helpful, but it she said. enough — let me die!” Elijah said. “I texts and best practices.” Both matter.
put a bomb in her relationship and in “We are very family oriented,” she have dreams, goals, and values that I “The stories about mental health are
her plans, and it seemed to come out of added. “That is our strength. We take will never achieve. What reason is there so very much part of our heritage, just
nowhere. care of our children.” But the need to for me to live?” And God, speaking like stories about tzedakah, or about car-
“I understand the concerns that a show that your children always are spec- softly, told him to “go on a journey and ing for the elderly. In the Book of Ruth,
parent would feel, putting a teenager on tacularly wonderful can get in the way reassess.” And he did. we learn about the kindness Boaz shows
medication and into the network of ther- of acknowledging them as real people, “In the context of Jewish texts, it is to Naomi and Ruth. In many other sto-
apy. It’s a hard choice. You have to make with problems. And that is not at all more organic” to discuss the idea of ries as well, we learn about acts of
hard choices.” unique to the Jewish community. suicide and its prevention,” Mr. Epstein chesed, about how to support some-
Is there anything particularly Jewish Efrem Epstein, the founder of Elijah’s said. “It is easier to assimilate it as a Jew- body who is struggling.”
about any of this? Not really, Ms. Twer- Journey, will run one of the workshops. ish issue. That’s exactly the support the com-
ski said, although each group thinks that Elijah’s Journey advocates for suicide “That’s the hiddush,” the innova- munity, at its best, can give people suf-
the stigma its members face is unique, awareness and prevention. Its name tion, the new insight — “that we offer,” fering from mental illness, he said.
Cover Story
Lo Levad
the family, and they never mentioned to me how the
son had died. They really didn’t want to talk about it.”
So he thought about it, and “I decided to tell a piece
of my own story,” Rabbi Leiken said. Not all his story,
he added. “Just a real small piece.” But still.
No one should have to feel alone “When I was a freshman in college, at Brandeis, I had
a panic attack during orientation week,” he said. “I was
sitting at an event where they were talking about junior
R
Joanne Palmer Leiken grew up in Shaker Heights, out- year abroad, discussing the options and the possibil-
side Cleveland; he’s been gone from ities. I remember feeling sweaty, and also incredibly
ecently, Rabbi Brian Leiken there for a long time, but “my mother depersonalized, as if my body were not connected to
of Temple Beth Sholom in called this summer to tell me that a my mind. As if I were out of my body.” It was a strange
New City knew that he had friend who I hadn’t spoken to in 20 and scary feeling.
to talk. years had just passed away,” he said. “I “I remember feeling disoriented a lot during orien-
As a rabbi, as a leader, talked to a number of friends, trying to tation week — I think a lot of people feel that, but I was
he had to make clear that he also is a per- figure out what had happened.” Rabbi feeling it on a different level.
son in order to lead. And as a person, he Leiken is in his 40s. That’s not a time “So I told my new friends — and they were very new
had to make clear that he is imperfect — in of life when you expect your friends to friends, brand new friends — and they called an ambu-
other words, as fully human — as the peo- start dying off. “Nobody knew, and the lance, and I went to the emergency room at Beth Israel
ple it is his job to lead. family wasn’t saying. Deaconess Hospital right down the road. And they
So, at the High Holy Days this fall, he Rabbi Brian Leiken “Later, I learned that it was suicide. brought me a brochure that said, ‘So you have panic dis-
talked about suicide and mental illness. “It was only when my mother was order,’ and they gave me Xanax, and they sent me home.
He’ll be talking about it again on Wednesday, May talking to his stepmother, when she said something like “I was back in the emergency room the next day.”
15, at the launch of Lo Levad — “you are not alone” — a ‘It was what you think it was.’” No one would use the “I stayed in school that year” — it was the 1994-95
joint project of the Rockland Board of Rabbis and Rock- word suicide. school year — “but it took a number of months for me
land Jewish Family Service. (See box.) “It reminded me of when I was just out of rabbini- to begin the process of healing. And it began a lifelong
The sermon was triggered by two things, Rabbi cal school and had to officiate at a funeral for a family ongoing battle with anxiety and depression that most
Leiken said. that had lost an 18-year-old son to a drug overdose. I likely I inherited from my family, and it’s been quite a
The first was the death of a high school friend. Rabbi remember spending two and a half hours talking with journey for me.”
Helen’s of Course!
RCBC
One-of-a-Kind
Handbags,
Fashions,
and Jewelry
that Spark
Conversation! Show mom your lve
with a beautiful
♥
gift basket!
Join us for
Mother’s Day
Stop in for a wide selection
Sunday, May 12
of chocolates, candies, nuts, 515 Cedar Lane, Teaneck
delicious dried fruit, and much more.
196 S. Main Street 201-530-5665
New City, NY World of Goodies LOCAL Sun-Thur 12-10pm
845-638-1988 W. Englewood Avenue, Teaneck DELIVERIES
WE SHIP www.estihana.com
Mon.-Sat. 10-6 Call for Sunday Hours 201-833-9950 • worldofgoodies.com THRU USA
Cover Story
As a rabbi — and as a person — he can learn from world not simply to talk about mental health issues, will talk about mental health issues on two Shabbatot
it. “It has offered me a lot of context for understand- but to open our spaces and bring in resources, to have during May, according to Carol King, a social worker
ing other people’s journeys and battles,” Rabbi Leiken other people talk, teach, advocate, lessen the stigma. who is a clinician with Rockland Jewish Family Service
said. “So I decided, this last year, to tell that part of my We have to normalize our conversations, to make it so and is heading the initiative. “This is a launch,” she said.
story, knowing that it really runs much deeper than I that mental health isn’t something you just leave out.” “We are not doing the equivalent of National Broth-
was sharing. Rabbi Leiken has been greatly influenced by the work erhood Week,” a one-and-done nod to feeling good.
“The results of what I was sharing blew me away. of Brené Brown, and most particularly by her book Instead, she said, this “is the beginning of something
“All of a sudden, I had people coming over to me, tell- “Daring Greatly.” “She speaks about the importance of that we chose to make a lifelong part of our Rockland
ing me their stories. Telling me their challenges. I had vulnerability, of opening ourselves up,” he said. “She Jewish community.”
a lot of parents who were talking to me about the paths says that we have a fear of being vulnerable because we “We decided to start small,” Rabbi Leiken said. “This
their children were walking.” fear that it will hurt us. But the truth is that vulnerabil- year, our goal is just to make clear that we want to do
Those parents suffered from a twofold problem, ity is how we feel connections.” something. We are going to unveil a poster in our area
Rabbi Leiken said. “First, there is the stigma. The Synagogues should offer those connections, but too synagogues that will designate it as a safe space. The
embarrassment. And then there’s the other part, that I frequently they do not, he added. “Modern synagogues goal is to use this launch as a way of beginning the con-
didn’t know would be as much of an issue as it is. have become a place of disconnection,” demanding versation in the community this year. Next year, we
“It’s helplessness. People feel helpless. Mental health individuality in all things. “It has ripped apart what hopefully will have something bigger.
is not simply a science, but also an art.” (That of course community has meant, to become just another exam- “My hope is that we can build a leadership circle
is true of all medicine, he added, but it’s particularly ple of consumer culture. The synagogue has become around this issue, and I hope that the team can find a
true of mental health.) It involves both minds and bod- another extension of our individualistic world, but tra- way of helping this issue permeate our walls. It is not
ies, and the connections aren’t necessarily clear. “And ditionally it has been a place where people connect to enough for me to just tell a story and Carol to just bring
when it comes to kids and adolescents, who don’t really each other, and to God. a panel. It has to find a way to live and breathe within
know what’s going on with their bodies anyway….” And “The first thing in the Bible that isn’t good is loneli- the life our community.”
the more confusing everything seems, the more people ness,” Rabbi Leiken said; that’s when God created Eve
“feel very much alone,” he said. to complement Adam. “That’s why we want to empha- Who: rockland Board of rabbis and rockland
“We are not so good at understanding the way that size Lo Levad. You are not alone. Jewish Family service
our emotions and our feelings and our bodies affect “Remember that the word ‘synagogue’ comes from
When: wednesday, May 15, from 7 to 9 p.m.
us,” Rabbi Leiken continued. “We have become very the Greek word for ‘gathering space.’”
fixated on finding quick fixes.” That doesn’t work. The program that will launch on May 15 will involve Where: rockland Jewish Community Campus,
450 w. nyack rd # 25, west nyack, n.Y.
Instead, “it is necessary for us in the synagogue Rabbi Leiken and another guest on a panel, and rabbis
MOTHER’S DAY
SALE
50% OFF 40% OFF
All Diamond Engagement Rings All 14K Gold Chains
Diamond Earrings · Tennis Bracelets & Bracelets
30% OFF
All 14K Jewelry & Sterling
20% OFF
All Other
Arielle’s Gallery
Silver Jewelry & Selected Watches Jewelry & Giftware Hand-Crafted
FREE WATCH
BATTERY
One-of-a-Kind American Crafts
NO PURCHASE NECESSARY. With Coupon.
Cannot be combined with any other offer. Exp. 6-30-19 Fine Custom Framing
Jewish World
Suicide is all prevalent and rampant.” added. “For every 100,000 kids who ago, her newly ex-husband killed him-
from page 21 As a result not only of theoretical are diagnosed with a mental health self. He was a successful physician, and
“Gabe did not tell anyone he was understanding but also of experience, challenge, there are only 17 licensed he jumped off the George Washington
molested. He only acted out. His abuse “I believe that we have a responsibility doctors to work with them.” Bridge, which she could see from her
was one of many facts we learned after to destigmatize mental health issues,” And then there’s the stigma. “There Fort Lee window.
his suicide. I also learned that Gabe’s he said. isn’t anyone in the synagogue who The two will talk about suicide and
wicked temper, severe homopho- Not only are mental health issues doesn’t have someone in the family or stigma, Rabbi Kirshner said. “My goal is
bia, fear of intimacy and of touching prevalent, even “rampant, and every- in the family orbit who has not suffered to destigmatize it so we can talk about
another person, as well as the addic- where, but the number of children from cancer or from mental illness,” it. I want people to be able to talk to
tions that plagued him, all came from between 5 and 18 who have gone to he said. “The difference is that we talk their clergy and physicians about it,
the abuse, not his DNA. His attendance the emergency room with suicidal much more openly and more responsi- and to know that good support, good
at this school led to these behaviors ideation has doubled in the last eight bly about cancer, and we’re still whis- medicine, good therapy can make the
and ultimately to his premature death.” years,” Rabbi Kirshner said. (That’s pering about mental illness.” situation better.
Rabbi Kirshner’s anger practically according to a report by CNN, which To open up the conversation, to “I think it’s a Jewish responsibility
burned through the newsprint; it still quotes an April 2019 paper in the jour- destigmatize it, to legitimize it, Rabbi to be in front of this,” he added. “We
nearly burns through the computer nal JAMA Pediatrics. The startling jux- Kirshner and Temple Emanu-El are choose life. Our community has to be
screen. But he harnesses it through taposition of 5-year-olds and suicide presenting a conversation between prepared.”
action. comes from JAMA.) Rabbi Kirshner and Dr. Jennifer Ashton Emanu-El is billing the evening as
When he spoke about his brother’s “I’m not a physician or scientist, but on May 16. (See box.) an “intimate conversation,” and in fact
suicide, he said, “I spoke in the first clearly there is so much more pressure Dr. Ashton, who belonged to Tem- Dr. Ashton and Rabbi Kirshner have
person, as the brother, the survivor on them that they didn’t feel before,” ple Emanu-El at one point in her life, much to talk about. Most of Dr. Ash-
of suicide, and I also spoke as a rabbi Rabbi Kirshner said. “It is very signifi- is the chief medical correspondent for ton’s book tells her story, but she also
who deals every single day with people cant that social media has poured fuel “Good Morning America” and ABC includes interviews with other people
dealing with mental health issues of all on the issue. News. She’s a practicing ob/gyn. She’s who have been affected by the suicides
varieties. Depression is the most com- “There also is a significant dearth of also the author of the about-to-be-re- of people close to them. She includes
mon, but I also deal with people who licensed therapists and psychiatrists leased memoir “Life After Suicide,” Rabbi Kirshner’s story.
have bipolar disorder, anxiety, OCD. It who focus on kids and adolescents,” he which she wrote because two years Dr. Ashton’s story, as she tells it in her
2 15
% APY
2 50
% APY
Visit our Monsey branch today! 75 Route 59, Monsey Town Square (Evergreen Kosher Market Center)
Anita Levine, VP, Branch Manager • 845-425-0189
Open Sunday from 9AM - 1PM
Annual Percentage Yields (APYs) disclosed are effective as of 1/1/2019 and may be changed by the Bank at any time. *CDs require a $1,000 minimum balance to open and earn interest. Early withdrawal
penalty may apply. CDs must be opened in person at an Apple Bank branch. Offer may be withdrawn at any time without prior notice.
26apple
Jewish Standard
bk - JEWISH MAY
STANDARD - TWO 3, 2019
CDS 1-1-2019.indd 1 1/7/2019 11:59:34 AM
JS-27
Jewish World
book, is of a family of super high achiev- dreams, in semi-awake moments, or survivors. It is important to tell the
ers; both she and her husband were in the appearance of objects that are story, she has learned over the course
relentless strivers, apparently effort- connected to him and hadn’t been of these two years. It can’t bring any-
lessly reaching goals and then immedi- there before. one back to life, but maybe it can keep
ately refocusing on other, harder ones. She talks about the unexpected dif- the next person from climbing over the
She has, she points out in the book, two ficulties that widowhood brings. Some guard rails, taking a deep breath, and
full-time careers, as well as two children, of them even are tragicomic — how do jumping.
a son now in Columbia and a daughter, you get a cremated ex-spouse’s ashes? Those all are questions that Rabbi
an ice hockey player who went to high Who do you bring with you when Kirshner and Dr. Ashton will explore
school as a boarder at Lawrenceville, you pick them up? And how do you together.
now headed to Harvard. She and her dispose of them? (She figured out the
husband had a once-close relationship answers to the first questions. The dis- Who: rabbi david-seth Kirshner
that loosened gradually but apparently posal one — not yet. There’s no hurry, and dr. Jennifer ashton
inexorably. They ended up divorced but she’s learned.) What: will talk about her new
still not only co-parents but also tenta- Dr. Ashton had been somewhat pub- book, “Life after suicide: Finding
tive friends, apparently about to work lic about her husband’s suicide since it Courage, Comfort, and Communi-
out the terms of their new relationship, happened — as a public figure, she says ty after Unthinkable Loss.”
when he jumped. repeatedly, she really has little choice When: On thursday, May 16, at
The book traces the family’s regroup- anyway — but it wasn’t until about a 7:15 p.m.
ing, their pain, their resilience, their year later, when first Kate Spade and
Where: at temple emanu-el, 180
working together toward new under- then Anthony Bourdain very pub- piermont road, Closter.
standing, their fragility, their stumbles, She talks a bit about spirituality, licly killed themselves, that she made
How much: the evening is free,
their growth, and over all their love for which some of the other people she the choice to tell her story. At the end
but reservations are required.
each other. Dr. Ashton grieves for her interviews find in many places — in of her book, she describes going on
marriage as well as for her husband, churches, in new age understandings “Good Morning America” not as a dis- Reservations: go to templeema-
and her children have to figure out how of life and death. She tells stories of passionate expert but as a bereaved nu-el.com/drjenniferashton or call
(201) 750-9997.
to redefine themselves. her ex-husband appearing to her, in widow, a survivor, the mother of
WELCOMES
Wishing our Community a
TAL BRODY!
Sweet & Healthy New Year
as we celebrate
annuaL Rosh Hashanah & Yom Kippur
One-hour
Q&A Session 5777
BREAKFAST with the
Sunday, May 19th “Michael Jordan”
honoring of Israel
SARA BlAu AlAn lEvinE
young Leadership Community
award Leadership award
register: http://bit.ly/May1919
201-244-6702 | info@areyvut.org
Come meet Tal and be inspired by his
Welcome to Templeon
achievements Beth
andRishon...
off the basketball court!
SUNDAY, MAY 19 AT 10:00AM
High Energy, Participatory Worship Services
Adult Education Programs Avenue,
585 Russell & Speakers Wyckoff, NJ
201-891-4466
Social Action Committee & Caring Committee
$10 per&adult,
Sisterhood $5 per child—Walk-ins welcome
Men’s Club
For more
Festival Programs, ServicesGoldberg:
info: Michael & Meals mgtlcdds1@gmail.com
Jewish standard MaY 3, 2019 27
Jewish Musical Concerts & Theatre Trips
Religious School, Hebrew High & Youth Group
Bar & Bat Mitzvah Preparation
Preschool, Mom & Tot Programs & Summer Camp
Jewish World
Life!
Museum’s Elie Wiesel Award for their chief of the Gestapo in Paris.
Bright lifetime of hunting Nazis and forcing
Europe to confront its past.
As the publisher of a recent joint
biography, “Hunting the Truth,” puts
In their final years, the Klarsfelds it, “they were born on opposite sides
have taken to arguing that the best of the Second World War”; Beate to a
means of preventing the return of German father who served in the Weh-
anti-Semitism and corrosive prejudice rmacht, Serge to a Jewish father who
is protecting institutions like the Euro- was deported to Auschwitz.
pean Union. (In 1986, the couple got the Holly-
The rise of nativism in the United wood treatment. They were portrayed
States and Europe, the persistence by Farrah Fawcett and Tom Conti in a
of anti-Semitism, and a number of well-received made-for-TV film.)
high-profile anti-Semitic attacks — these The Klarsfelds are using the influence
elements do not surprise the couple. they have accrued through their lifetime
Independent Living: It’s the carefree Instead, they take the long view. Live of work to help the institutions they say
retirement you’ve dreamed of! At Brightview, long enough, said Serge Klarsfeld, have protected Jews and other minori-
Let Your all you have to do is what you want to do. who is 83 (Beate is 80), and what went ties. They have published ads in France
Life
around will come around again. urging votes for the pro-European
“It’s an atmosphere like the begin- Union parties in the next European Par-
Bright Assisted Living: Highly trained
associates provide the care you need.
ning of the ‘30s, and the authority
of the state is at stake,” Serge Klars-
liament elections at the end of May.
“The fight against anti-Semitism is
JCCOTP.ORG/RUBINRUN
8K TRAIL RUN *
10K RUN
5K RUN/WALK
NEW! HEALTH EXPO
For more info: rubinrun@jccotp.org or 201.408.1404
supporting individuals with special needs * Trail run open to ages 15+; recommended for experienced runners.
All giveaways while supplies last. Please arrive early on race-day. Shuttle parking available.
KAPLEN JCC on the Palisades TAUB CAMPUS | 411 E CLINTON AVE, TENAFLY, NJ 07670 | jccotp.org
JEWISH STANDARD MAY 3, 2019 29
Jewish World
Poway, a California
haven, left shaken
as hatred hits home
GABRIELLE BIRKNER
and louder; we can’t afford to sit on the sidelines. that in a post-Pittsburgh world, all Jewish com-
munities are possible targets. (“Yes, even Poway.”)
“After 9/11, when they first started with all the
Come make a difference on NORPAC’s Mission to Washington D.C. [synagogue] security — with the cameras and the
locks and the security glass — I always thought,
‘This is overkill for Poway,’” said Janet Pollack,
57, who is a member of the city’s Reform con-
gregation, Temple Adat Shalom. “That it came
to this small, very peaceful community is a lit-
tle overwhelming.”
Rabbi Mendy Rubenfeld, the Hebrew school
director at Chabad of Poway, said the city is a
warm, welcoming place for religious Jews. In the
16 years that he’s lived here, “I never received an
Roundtrip transportation to DC from NY-NJ. Glatt Kosher meals included. unkind statement. No one has so much as shown
Additional Information and Registration at NORPAC.net or call (201) 788-5133 me the finger.”
After a gunman motivated by his antipathy for
REGISTER BEFORE MAY 12TH Jewish support for immigrants killed worship-
pers inside Pittsburgh’s Tree of Life synagogue,
Adults -- $185, Students/Young Professionals (Under 30) -- $125 Rubenfeld knew such an attack was likely to hap-
Call about special Clergy and College Student rates. Minimum age: 12 pen again somewhere. He just never thought it
would be here.
But Douglas Stone, 70, a friend of Rabbi Gold-
stein, said that since the Pittsburgh murders,
he’s been keenly aware that hate-fueled violence
could happen in any Jewish community, includ-
ing his own.
“We always say ‘never again,’ but here we
Paid for by NORPAC are,” said Stone, a member of Adat Shalom and
an active participant in Chabad’s programming
for people with disabilities. (Stone’s son has
Down syndrome.)
30 JEWISH STANDARD MAY 3, 2019
Jewish World
P E S A C H T O S H AV U O T 5 7 7 9
The crowd at the vigil included Muslim women in hijabs and Sikh men MRS. RIVKA ALTER MRS. RACHEL BESSER DR. RIVKAH BLAU MRS. DANIELLE BLOOM
in turbans. GABRIELLE BIRKNER DAT Minyan Cong. KINS Cong. Schara Tzedeck Beth Jacob Congregation
Denver, CO of West Rogers Park Vancouver, Canada of Irvine
Chicago, IL Irvine, CA
Given the threat, Stone said, also compelled her family to spon- JEC Elmora Avenue Shul
Elizabeth, NJ
“I’ve thought about getting a gun” sor an event last month at Chabad of
for protection. Poway featuring the stepsister of Anne
Saturday’s shooting took place Frank, Eva Schloss.
on the last day of Passover and six Not two months later, the building
months to the day after the Pitts- where Schloss told her story of sur-
burgh massacre. It closely followed viving the Holocaust and stressed the MS. RAIZI CHECHIK MRS. CHANNAH COHEN MRS. ESTHER MS. ELANA
two other deadly attacks on houses importance of speaking out against Suburban Torah East Denver EISENMAN FLAUMENHAFT
Livingston, NJ Orthodox Synagogue Cong. Sha’arei Torah Young Israel of Holliswood
of worship, one targeting Muslims in injustice “to make it a safer and bet- Denver, CO Cincinatti, OH Holliswood, NY
New Zealand and another targeting ter place for everyone” was a scene
Christians in Sri Lanka. of violence.
The Poway attack has shaken the At around 11:30 a.m. Saturday,
local Jewish community. (The city is as more than 60 congregants wor-
home to about 700 Jewishly affiliated shipped inside the sanctuary, a
families, according to Rabbi David 19-year-old gunman identified as John
Castiglione of Adat Shalom.) But its Earnest entered the building and DR. CHANNA GELB MISS CHANA GOTTLIEB MRS. MICHAL MRS. RACHEL
impact on how Jews live and pray in began firing shots. Goldstein heard a Cong. Shaare Tefilla Cong. Beth El - HOROWITZ KOSOWSKY
Dallas, TX Atereth Israel Cong. Adath Israel Cong. Rinat Yisrael
this quiet hamlet — home to a Reform, loud noise, went to investigate, and Newton, MA Hillside, NJ Teaneck, NJ
a Conservative, and an Orthodox syn- found a bloodied Lori Gilbert-Kaye
agogue — remains to be seen. lying on the floor in the lobby. She
Rene Carmichael, who works for had come to take part in the memorial
the city of Poway, said it’s common Yizkor prayer service for her mother,
to see Orthodox Jews walking to ser- who died last year.
vices along Rancho Bernardo Road,
one of the city’s main thoroughfares, MRS. LYNN KRAFT MRS. RACHELI MRS. NORMA MINTZ DR. RONA NOVICK
on Saturday mornings and Jewish Cong. Rodfei Sholom LUFTGLASS Beth Jacob Congregation Young Israel of Hollywood
San Antonio, TX Cong. Beth Aaron Oakland, CA Hollywood, FL
holidays. She said in the wake of the
deadly violence targeting Chabad, If you were Teaneck, NJ
NIGHTS!
*
n d Wednesdays 3 PM
n days a - 10 P
M
M o
Tilapia
Florentine
Buy One 141-147 N. Dean Street A family at the vigil prepares to light candles . GABRIELLE BIRKNER
Entree
Get One Free Englewood, NJ
from our regular-priced
menu only
Poway and Jonathan Morales, an off-duty
with purchase
of 2 beverages 201-568-8088 but three or four.
FROM PAGE 31 Border Patrol agent. Earnest was
apprehended and has since been
*Age 55 and up. Not valid with any other offer discounts or coupons. Dine-in only, for a “Literally, it was no less than three charged with one count of first-degree
limited time at participating restaurants. ©2014 IHOP IP, LLC cards for every occasion,” her friend murder and three counts of attempted
since childhood, Lisa Busalacchi, 61, said. murder. Local law enforcement is
® Gilbert-Kaye worked for a com- treating the shooting as a hate crime.
Never Clean Your Gutters Again!
GUTTER
S
G pany that made promotional goods, As unlikely a target as many con-
such as tote bags, for businesses sidered Poway to be, the Chabad had
ut
and sporting events, and often she convened a meeting about synagogue
Helm
donated the extras to Chabad. security last fall in the wake of the
et
$350
CUSTOMER LOYALTY SALE
ofin
g
OFF
* events to politics, on which “we attended the meeting with represen-
agreed to disagree — profusely,” tatives of the San Diego County Sher-
according to Silverstein, who said iff ’s Department. “Tips like, if you can
Gilbert-Kaye was a vocal supporter run away, run away; if you can hide,
of President Donald Trump. hide; if you can’t hide, challenge
“If you were sick, she’d be there the shooter.’”
FOR OVER
Expires May 31st!
38 giving you chicken soup,” Silver- During Saturday’s shooting in
0% Interest
YEARS stein said, adding that her friend Poway, “all of that happened, and
Call for a FREE Quote Until 2021
†
“would give and give and give, and I have no doubt that that meeting
Senior & Veteran Discounts she believed in giving anonymously contributed to saving lives,” the
FOR GUTTER PROTECTION
was the highest degree of tzedakah,” mayor said.
or charity. At the vigil Sunday evening, which
Last year, Gilbert-Kaye and Silver- brought together Jews and non-Jews
3 Eliminate clogged and overflowing gutters stein celebrated their 60th birthdays — the crowd included Muslim women
Handles
“
22RAIN
3 LIFETIME No Clog WARRANTY, transferable together, and they already had begun in hijabs and Sikh men in turbans —
3 Installed by trained & certified technicians discussing what they would do when Goldstein recounted what he said
/ hr
of 3 Approved by all major roofing manufacturers they turned 70. before being transported to the hos-
Gilbert-Kaye was buried on Monday pital following the shooting.
afternoon after a memorial service at Looking out at the fearful, despair-
Chabad of Poway. She is survived by ing congregants, who had made their
CALL: her husband, Howard Kaye, a phy- way out of the synagogue, the rabbi
201-754-5202 sician, and their daughter, Hannah
Kaye, 22.
got up on a chair, his hands bleed-
ing badly.
*Min. purchase of 50 linear feet required, offer expires 5/31/19. Offer applies to Gutter Helmet only and must be presented at time of estimate, cannot be combined
The gunman was chased off with “I said, ‘Guys, Am Yisrael Chai” —
with any other offers and subject to change without notice. Void where prohibited by law. †Subject to credit approval. Interest accrues during promotional period but
all interest is waived if paid in full within 24 months. Lednor is neither a broker nor a lender. Financing is provided by 3rd party lenders, under terms & conditions
the help of two Chabad congregants, the Jewish people live.
arranged directly between the customer and such lenders, satisfactory completion of finance documents is required. Any finance terms advertised are estimates only.
†Based on an independent 2014 national marketing study. DC# 420218000007 MD MHIC #48622 VA #2705036173 © 2019 Lednor Corporation.
Oscar Stewart, a U.S. Army veteran, JEWISH TELEGRAPHIC AGENCY
Yom Hazikaron
COMMEMORATION DAY FOR THE ISRAELI
SOLDIERS AND TERROR VICTIMS
KEEP LEARNING
Top professors and experts present
on a diverse array of topics. On May
16th in the morning Rutgers professor
Paul Clemens will present Leopold and
Loeb—The Trial of the Century and in the
afternoon Columbia Law School lecturer
Jess Velona will present Great Speeches
of the 1960s—From Kennedy to King.
Thur, May 16, 10:30 am-2 pm, $35/$42
Free Preventative Health Social Adult Day Care for Hazon CSA
Programs for Seniors People with Alzheimer’s COMMUNITY SUPPORTED AGRICULTURE
Stay healthy, access early treatment when and Dementia Enjoy fresh, organic produce on a weekly basis!
necessary, and reduce your overall medical Join our CSA community and build an evolving
Montessori-style social day care program
expenses. We offer blood pressure, nutrition relationship with your food, the land on which
promotes independence, self-esteem and
and pulmonary monitoring. Check out our it is grown, the farmers who grow it, and other
cognitive abilities for those living with dementia,
website for upcoming educational health CSA participants.
in a vibrant, community center atmosphere.
presentations by Englewood Health at Aides and companions are welcome. Registration Deadline May 24.
jccotp.org/seniors-special-events Season runs Tuesdays, Jun 11-Nov 5.
Mon-Fri, 9 am-4 pm, Sun, 11 am-4 pm
For more information call Judi Nahary Visit jccotp.org/csa for details and to sign up.
(Partial day options available)
201.408.1450 or email jnahary@jccotp.org
Ask for a FREE 3 day trial! For more information TO REGISTER OR FOR MORE INFO
visit jccotp.org/senior-services or contact VISIT jccotp.org
Judi Nahary at 201.408.1450 STAY IN THE KNOW! LIKE US ON
PA Program offered as part of the JCC Patron of the Arts
Program. Find out more at jccotp.org/patrons.
facebook.com/KaplenJCCOTP
KAPLEN JCC on the Palisades TAUB CAMPUS | 411 E CLINTON AVE, TENAFLY, NJ 07670 | 201.569.7900 | jccotp.org
Jewish World
I
MARCY OSTER
state,” it said. “We have been and remain stalwart sup-
n an editorial published on Tuesday, the New porters of Israel, and believe that good-faith criticism
York Times editorial board wrote that the news- should work to strengthen it over the long term by help-
paper’s publishing “an appalling political car- ing it stay true to its democratic values. But anti-Zion-
toon” is “evidence of a profound danger — not ism can clearly serve as a cover for anti-Semitism — and
only of anti-Semitism but of numbness to its creep.” some criticism of Israel, as the cartoon demonstrated, is
The Times also acknowledged its own historical con- couched openly in anti-Semitic terms.” This is the cartoon that appeared in the New
tributions to the rise of anti-Semitism. It also accused President Donald Trump of doing York Times’ international edition last week,
“In the 1930s and the 1940s, The Times was “too little to rouse the national conscience” against showing Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin
largely silent as anti-Semitism rose up and bathed anti-Semitism. “Though he condemned the cartoon in Netanyahu as a guide dog wearing a Star of
the world in blood,” it wrote. “That failure still The Times, he has failed to speak out against anti-Se- David collar and leading President Donald
haunts this newspaper.” mitic groups like the white nationalists who marched Trump, wearing a kippah. NEW YORK TIMES
The editorial said that “anti-Semitic imagery is partic- in Charlottesville, Va., in 2017 chanting, ‘Jews will not
ularly dangerous now,” citing last Saturday’s attack on replace us,’” the editorial board wrote. resulting in “a single editor working without ade-
the Poway of Chabad synagogue and the release, also The cartoon, which appeared in the opinion section quate oversight.”
on Tuesday, of the Anti-Defamation League’s annual of the newspaper’s international print edition on Thurs- The Portuguese cartoonist Antonio Moreira Antunes
audit of anti-Semitic incidents, which shows that the day, April 25, showed Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin told the Jerusalem Post in an emailed response to ques-
number of assaults against American Jews more than Netanyahu as a dachshund-like guide dog wearing a tions from the newspaper that he did not mean for his
doubled from 2017 to 2018. Star of David collar and leading a yarmulke-topped work to be seen as anti-Semitic.
“Jews face even greater hostility and danger in President Donald Trump. “To illustrate this situation, an analogy occurred to
Europe, where the cartoon was created,” the edito- In its first statement in response to the cartoon, me with a blind man (Trump) led by a guide dog (Net-
rial also said. the Times acknowledged that the image was “offen- anyahu) and, to help identify him, little known in Por-
The editorial also acknowledged that criticism of sive” and “included anti-Semitic tropes.” A second tugal, I added the Star of David, symbol of the State of
Israel can be couched in anti-Semitic terms. “This is also statement that Sunday, April 28, said the newspa- Israel and central element of its flag,” he wrote.
a period of rising criticism of Israel, much of it directed per was “deeply sorry” and that the decision to pub- Antunes did not explain why he drew a kippah on
at the rightward drift of its own government and some of lish the image was the product of “a faulty process” Trump’s head. JEWISH TELEGRAPHIC AGENCY
think again
ADDICTION SYMPOSIUM
Eliminating Stigma
May 5, 2019 • 9:00 am - 11:30 am
Refreshments served – 8:45 am
KEYNOTE ADDRESS
Dr. Norman Blumenthal
Director of Trauma at OHEL and
Educational Director at Yeshiva University
Workshops Include:
Pain and Opioids
Legalizing Marijuana
FOR MORE INFORMATION Mood Disorders
time2talkaddiction@gmail.com Vaping and Nicotine
Sexual Abuse
www.time2talkaddiction.org Peer Support
Suicide Awareness
Marijuana and the Brain
Eating Disorders
Communicating Concerns
Law Enforcement Response
TEACH NJ
ANNUAL DINNER
Host Committee*
In formation
Anonymous Susan Love and David Farber Debbie and Sam Moed
Cross River Bank Nancy and Dr. Eric Fremed
Leslie and Josh Ostrin
Susan and Dr. Yaakov Bagley Vicki and Sonny Gindi Sarit and Shai Perry
Harriet and George Blank Hadassah and Baruch Halberstam Leyla and Daniel Posner
Daniele and Steven Bleier Danielle and Ralph D. Hanan Cheryl Weiner Rosenberg
Roni and Yehuda Blinder Freida and Michael Harris Margie and Sammy Saka
Chedva and David Breau Alissa and Shimmie Horn Ronnie and Marc Schlussel
Naomi and Josh Caplan Shari and Nathan J. Lindenbaum Joy and Barry Sklar
Esther and Dr. Ben Chouake Elinor and Maury Litwack Dr. Beth Leiderman and Martin Statfeld
Tzippy and Daniel Cohen Sophia and Joe Mizrahi
*Host Committee Members invest a minimum of $1,800 in the important work of Teach NJ and receive
complimentary tickets to the dinner. To join the host committee please email teachnjdinner@teachcoalition.org
Teach NJ Executive Committee
CAMPS
ENOUGH
IS
ENOUGH
STRONGER TOGETHER.
In light of the horrific act of terrorism this
past weekend, the northern New Jersey Jewish
community stands strong with our brothers and
sisters in Poway, California.
ENOUGH IS ENOUGH!
@JFNNJ
www.jfnnj.org | 201.820.3900
Training worship generally, and we have seen an increase in tar- country, as well as with more than 50 partner orga-
FROM PAGE 36 geting of Jewish houses of worship specifically,” Masters nizations and 300-plus Jewish communities, to
surprise to Michael Masters, who heads the Secure said from Poway, where he is meeting with community provide security assessments. After conducting an
Community Network. SCN coordinates security for Jew- leaders in the wake of the shooting. assessment, it recommends security strategies tai-
ish organizations across the country and is affiliated “That coincides with an increase in anti-Semitic inci- lored to the needs and circumstances of the partic-
with the Jewish Federations of North America and the dents around the United States and around the world, as ular organization.
Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish well as an increase in hate crimes against our community Friedman said the threat picture itself also has
Organizations. and an increase in threats.” changed in recent years.
“We have seen an increase in targeting of houses of SCN has worked with 147 federations across the When CSS was founded in 2007, the primary
threats came from international terrorist groups
such as Hamas, Hezbollah, and al-Qaeda, as well
as large white supremacist organizations. Now they
often come from people who aren’t necessarily
affiliated with a group. That means the targets have
Celebrate Israel’s
changed too. As a result, less prominent commu-
nities, like the Squirrel Hill neighborhood in Pitts-
burgh or Poway, 20 miles north of San Diego, are
INDEPENDENCE DAY
more vulnerable.
“Ten years ago they probably wouldn’t be identi-
fied as targets of this kind of attack,” Friedman said.
“Now, due to these homegrown violent extremists,
Yom Ha’atzmaut
they’re able to attack more locally, with a focus on
their own locale.”
Since the 9/11 terrorist attacks, the federal govern-
ment has made more money available to houses of
worship, especially synagogues and mosques, and
other vulnerable institutions. This year’s spending
bill included $60 million for fiscal year 2019 to fund
the Nonprofit Security Grant Program, which helps
Join Jewish Federation of Northern New Jersey synagogues and other houses of worship, religious
day schools, and a variety of nonprofits improve
the security of their buildings.
GUEST SPEAKER
BERGEN COUNTY ISRAEL NITZAN, Israel’s Deputy Consul General
The Department of Homeland Security, which
administers the program, awards grants of as much
Thursday, May 9, 2019 PERFORMANCE as $150,000 to eligible nonprofits at risk of terrorist
11:30am THE MORIAH SCHOOL CHOIR attacks. The nonprofits use the funding to acquire
and install items ranging from fences, lighting, and
Bergen County Administration Building IN PARTNERSHIP WITH video surveillance to metal detectors and blast-re-
One Bergen County Plaza, Hackensack James J. Tedesco, Bergen County Executive
sistant doors, locks, and windows.
Board of Chosen Freeholders
The Poway suspect, a 19-year-old nursing stu-
dent, is believed to have posted an online manifesto
on a forum popular with the alt-right that said he
GUEST SPEAKER was inspired by the Tree of Life synagogue gunman
ISRAEL NITZAN, Israel’s Deputy Consul General
JERSEY CITY in Pittsburgh and the shooter who killed 50 people
at two mosques in Christchurch, New Zealand. The
PERFORMANCE
Thursday, May 9, 2019 SOLOMON SCHECHTER DAY SCHOOL
suspect also called President Donald Trump “Zion-
2:00pm ist, Jew-loving, anti-white.”
OF BERGEN COUNTY Masters said that after Pittsburgh and Poway,
City Hall Council Chambers IN PARTNERSHIP WITH the conversation surrounding future attacks has
280 Grove Street, Jersey City The City of Jersey City | Mayor Steven M. Fulop changed.
The Municipal Council | Office of Culture Affairs “We used to say it’s a question of ‘not if but
Solomon Schechter Day School of Bergen County
when,’” he said. “Now we say ‘not when, but when
again?’” JEWISH TELEGRAPHIC AGENCY
Jewish World
Sandi M. Malkin, LL C
Interior Designer
(former interior designer of model
World War II Diary of S. Lane Faison, Jr. rooms for NY’s #1 Dept. Store)
coUrtesy of monUments men foUnDation
for the preservation of art)
Jewish World
Chai
Anniversary Benefit Luncheon
SUNDAY, MAY 19, 2019 AT 10:00AM
TEANECK MARRIOTT AT GLENPOINTE
Jewish World
Addressing Anti-Semitism
“Schools that continue to disregard our direction
during the outbreak will be closed down until they
can prove to the Health Department that they will
comply,” said the health commissioner, Dr. Oxiris
Barbot. “The reality is, the longer it takes schools
through Education Training
and individuals to comply with our order, the lon-
ger this outbreak will continue.”
Five schools closed by the Health Department for Wednesday, May 15, 2019
failing to comply with the regulations about barring
unvaccinated students, and compelling the schools 4:00 - 6:00 pm
Jewish Federation
50 Eisenhower Drive, Paramus
RSVP Today!
jfnnj.org/training
BIAS HATE
The book also says: “Does anyone seriously
suppose that a great war could be undertaken
by any European State, or a great State loan
subscribed, if the house of Rothschild and its
connections set their face against it?”
The Rothschild family is historically Jewish
and for centuries has been one of Europe’s
wealthiest families.
A Labour Party spokesman told the news-
paper that Corbyn’s praise was of the over-
all political analysis and that he “completely
rejects the anti-Semitic elements.”
The Board of Deputies of British Jews sent
a letter to Corbyn on Wednesday expressing
“grave concern” about the forward. The let-
ter called the book “pure and unequivocal
racism and there can be no apology for that.”
Jewish Telegraphic Agency AriellaN@jfnnj.org | 201.820.3946
Editorial
Feeling safe
KEEPING THE FAITH
W
think about safe spaces now.
A sanctuary is a holy space. hat will it take for us as individuals and as Make no mistake, either, about who has given cover to and
It’s set apart, separate, other than; it’s a place a community to finally rise up against the in turn is in part responsible for the increased violence from
where encounters with each other, with God, two great scourges of our day — gun vio- the extreme right: President Donald J. Trump.
with our own thoughts and assumptions and lence and the full-blown re-emergence of The column I referred to above came out the week
desires, can happen, and such encounters can Jew-hatred here and around the world? following the mass killings of Muslim worshippers in
be intense, even frightening. It’s a place where What will it take for us as individuals and as a commu- Christchurch, New Zealand. In it, I noted that repeated
music and words and ideas can transport us nity to get over the notion that protecting the fortunes of a remarks made by President Trump “have helped spur
to other places, other worlds, other states of political party or a particular candidate is more important on the hatred from the right (not just here but, as the
being. None of that is safe. than demanding action from our government officials of all horrific massacre in New Zealand and the murderer’s
But a sanctuary is supposed to be a place of parties on gun violence and hatred, especially Jew-hatred? so-called ‘manifesto’ show, around the world, as well).”
physical security. We are not supposed to be at Some weeks ago, my column dealt with the rise of A reader took exception to that and thereby dismissed
physical risk there. It is supposed to afford us the Jew-hatred in the United States and around the world. the point the article was making.
physical safety that allows our emotions and souls It included this: “Is it not time for a rally to combat The perpetrator of that horrific crime in Christchurch
to be open and vulnerable, to allow us to crack anti-Semitism; a rally for us to shout out was a 28-year-old self-identified white
enough to let life and light trickle and then pour in. loud that we are mad as hell and we won’t supremacist. It was he, not I, who pointed
It’s not just us. Terrorists have killed people in take it anymore?” So far, there has not been the finger at Trump’s rhetoric. While he
shuls, in churches, and in mosques. Guns erupt. a peep from anyone regarding that sugges- said he did not support many of Trump’s
Bombs explode. Evil is unleashed. tion or offering an alternative. policies, he did say, in his manifesto, that
We have been getting emails from our syn- The statistics regarding right-wing Trump was one of his role models. Trump,
agogues and our kids’ schools and our local extremist violence — Jew-hatred, in partic- he said, was for him “a symbol of renewed
Jewish institutions, telling us about security ular — are beyond frightening. I cited these white identity and common purpose.”
upgrades (and often about increases in dues, but statistics before. Here in the United States, The ADL’s national director and CEO
security isn’t free). When we go to those places, beginning in mid-2015, Jew-hatred suddenly Jonathan Greenblatt has said that some of
we see more guards. More of them are armed, exploded, going up 34 percent in 2016, and Shammai Trump’s rhetoric comes “right out of the
and fewer of them smile. another 57 percent in 2017. According to the Engelmayer white supremacist playbook,” as he put it
Last winter, a few months after the massacre FBI, more acts were committed against Jews to the Washington Post. He had this to say
in Pittsburgh, I was in a nearly empty shul social and Jewish institutions in the United States to the Los Angeles Times: “When leaders
hall. There were two children, maybe around 7 in 2017 than were committed against all other religious at the highest levels use incredibly intemperate language
or 8, playing together. I overheard one of them groups combined — and that trend, the FBI says, contin- and repeat the rhetoric of extremists, we shouldn’t be
point at the doors in the back of the room and ued in 2018. surprised when young people — let alone others — imi-
tell the other one that it was where the attack New York City, according to Police Department statistics, tate what they see.… Certainly, the president, among
would come from, and this, he said, pointing in saw more hate crimes against Jews in 2018 — up 22 percent everyone, has the biggest bully pulpit.”
another direction, is where we would run. He over 2017 — than for all other religious groups combined. Despite all the evidence of the severe uptick in right-
didn’t sound scared, just matter of fact, almost According to the Anti-Defamation League, there were wing extremist violence, Trump continues to downplay
nonchalant. He was just saying. I, on the other 50 murders committed by right-wing extremists in the the threat as nothing alarming. “I think it’s a small group
hand, was shocked and unnerved. United States in 2018 — with one out of every three vic- of people that have very, very serious problems,” he said
This is a grimly topsy-turvy time, when sanc- tims being Jews. Given the killing last Shabbat of 60-year- after Christchurch.
tuaries aren’t safe, when lies don’t matter, old Lori Gilbert-Kaye at the Chabad House in Poway, The actions of his administration match his words.
when reality is whatever the loudest person Calif., this year likely will be as bad, or worse. Despite its attempts at blowing smoke to obscure what
around says that it is. Make no mistake about who is committing these hei- it has done, the Department of Homeland Security
How to fix it? No clue. nous acts. Says the ADL: recently disbanded the very unit charged with moni-
But it is clear that it’s not by giving in to it. Not “Right-wing extremists collectively have been responsi- toring domestic terrorism, which is mainly right-wing
by lying in response to lies. Not by demonizing ble for more than 70 percent of the 427 extremist-related extremist terrorism.
others as we have been demonized. By remaining killings over the past 10 years, far outnumbering those Yes, Trump has had harsh words to say about neo-Nazis
clear-eyed and open minded. By paying attention. committed by left-wing extremists or domestic Islamist and white supremacists, but those words came only after
By being kind to each other. By understanding that extremists — even with the sharp rise of Islamist-extrem- almost unrelenting pressure from Republicans as well as
history has great arcs, but it doesn’t reverse fully. ist killings in the past five years.” Democrats. There is no getting around the fact, however, that
By understanding the humanity in each of us.
By continuing to show up. —JP Shammai Engelmayer is rabbi of Congregation Beth Israel of the Palisades, now in Fort Lee.
Jewish Editor
Joanne Palmer
Correspondents
Warren Boroson
Advertising Coordinator
Jane Carr
Production Manager
Jerry Szubin
Founder
Morris J. Janoff (1911–1987)
Standard Associate Editor
Larry Yudelson
Lois Goldrich
Banji Ganchrow Account Executives
Peggy Elias
Graphic Artists
Deborah Herman
Editor Emeritus
Meyer Pesin (1901–1989)
1086 Teaneck Road Abigail K. Leichman Bob O'Brien
Community Editor Miriam Rinn Robin Frizzell City Editor
Teaneck, NJ 07666 Brenda Sutcliffe
Beth Janoff Chananie Dr. Miryam Z. Wahrman Mort Cornin (1915–1984)
(201) 837-8818
Fax 201-833-4959 About Our Children Editor Advertising Director Administrative Assistant Editorial Consultant
Heidi Mae Bratt Natalie D. Jay Jenna Sutcliffe Max Milians (1908-2005)
Publisher
James L. Janoff International Media Placement Secretary
P.O. Box 7195 Jerusalem 91077 Ceil Wolf (1914-2008)
Associate Publisher Emerita
Marcia Garfinkle Tel: 02-6252933, 02-6247919 Editor Emerita
Fax: 02-6249240 Rebecca Kaplan Boroson
thejewishstandard.com Israeli Representative
Opinion
T
trary, and that he uses code words and Every synagogue should organize
dog-whistle phrases that are as good as petition drives with similar sentiments, he images have blurry edges and help when our babysitter quit. Perhaps we
a wink and a nod to the haters. and send copies to all candidates for deep shadows. had a new baby.
That being said, the Democratic every office at every level. Synagogues But there I am, playing guitar We bought our first camcorder in 1996,
Party has to assume some responsi- also should organize voter registration and singing “Twinkle Twinkle when our daughter was born. It was the size
bility, as well. The anti-Jewish rhetoric and get-out-the-vote drives, and publi- Little Star” to my daughter, who is a little of a hardcover book, and surprisingly heavy.
coming from Minnesota Representa- cize that they are doing so. more than a year old. The video is from the It cost a fortune, and the resolution wasn’t
tive Ilhan Omar is a case in point, as is Each of us should write letters to two short years when she was an only child, nearly as good as what we get on any cell
the response from the House Demo- Trump, our House members, our two before her brothers were born. Today she is phone today. Over the next few years, video
cratic majority, which, to quote House senators, and to the chairs of both married, and about to begin graduate school. recorders kept getting smaller and smaller.
staffers, passed a tepid “kitchen-sink major political parties. We should then Click. Now it’s summertime, we’ve put By 2010 we all owned flips. Flips faded out
resolution” because it could not bring follow up by calling their offices. Con- the Slip ‘N Slide out in the yard, and chil- when everyone graduated to smartphones.
itself to condemn outright anti-Jewish tact information appears at the end of dren are running and diving onto the slip- VCRs vanished as we replaced them with
speech. Most of the Democratic presi- this column. pery plastic sheet. At this point, we live in DVD players, and then the videotapes were
dential hopefuls either have been silent We should organize a continuous the suburbs and have three kids. We must packed away in a box, where they languished
regarding Omar’s hateful rhetoric, or stream of meetings with local churches have moved recently, because Son #2 is a for a decade and a half, gathering dust.
they have been supportive of her. and mosques to express solidarity — skinny toddler with long curls and no pants, A few weeks ago, Jon found our tapes and
The big question, of course, is what one-shot solidarity sessions are noth- my daughter sounds like she is perhaps 6, mailed them to a place called iMemories.
we can do about it. ing but photo-ops. We may be the and Son #3 doesn’t exist yet. The nice people at iMemories uploaded the
We need to let everyone know we biggest targets of the haters, but they Click. I hear my husband’s voice from contents of our videotapes to the cloud, in
are mad as hell and we won’t take it are targets, too, as recent events attest. behind the camera. “Helen,” no particular order, where
any longer. Dayenu! And we should make sure the media he calls. The box from our new we can watch them on any
It should not matter whether we are are there to cover each of those meet- lightweight double stroller is of our devices.
Democrats or Republicans, pro-Trump ings each time they are held. lying sideways on the floor. Pok- Click. The past passes
or anti-Trump. It should not matter that Finally, we should push our national ing out of it are two very small me by over and over
Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu organizations to convene a massive bottoms, and one little pair of again. I watch the ghosts
supports Trump and wants to name a rally on the National Lawn against hate sock-clad feet. Again, Jon calls, of our parents. I watch our
moshav after him on the Golan Heights. and against gun violence — and we “Helen! Have you seen the kids? sweet children. I listen to
What should matter is that we are not should attend that rally, and encourage I can’t find them!” Giggles issue their sweet voices.
safe even in our own sacred spaces. others to do so. from the box. It shakes as the lit- Younger me appears
What should matter is that we want our Here are the relevant addresses for tle feet wiggle excitedly. Helen in the frame. Look at my
children in day schools and yeshivot to those letters: Click. Son #2 is in a Jolly Maryles curvy figure! Look at my
be safe from the kinds of violence we President Donald J. Trump, The Jumper hung from a doorframe. Shankman glorious curls! My glowy
see elsewhere. What should matter is White House, 1600 Pennsylvania With great concentration, he skin! No wrinkles! No
that Jew-hatred is on the rise, along Avenue NW, Washington, DC 20500. bounces up and down on his glasses! No gray hairs!
with other forms of race hatred, and Phone: (202) 456-1111 little Fred Flintstone feet. His curls bounce, In the days that we were having a child
rather than doing anything construc- Senator Robert Menendez, 528 Hart too. He gives me a happy, toothless smile. every two years, I was always nursing some-
tive to reverse the trend, our politicians Senate Office Building, Washington, As I watch this video, son #2 is finishing his one. I never got more than four hours of
are giving license to the haters. D.C. 20510. Phone: (202) 224-4744. Fax: year at a yeshiva in Israel. sleep at a stretch. I was also working part
We cannot continue to sit on our (202) 228-2197 Click. Now there’s a party. I don’t know time as a graphic designer in the city. We
hands and hope it will go away. The Senator Corey Booker, 717 Hart Sen- what it’s for, but our nieces and nephew lived on the second floor of a brownstone in
problem is growing, not shrinking. ate Office Building, Washington, DC from Israel are visiting us in our apartment Brooklyn, and our pre-K was 10 blocks away.
Trump may be playing to his base, but 20510. Phone: (202) 224-3224. Fax: in Park Slope. I watch them on the screen. I didn’t have a license, so the double stroller
his Jewish supporters must remind (202) 224-8378 They are achingly young, adorable, playing was my vehicle. I’m sure the me in the video
him they are part of his base, too, and Senator Charles Schumer, 313 Hart with the toys that line the living room. Each is tired.
they will not support him in 2020 — Senate Office Building, Washington, of these children has already been through A rush of emotions overwhelms me. I want
not with votes and not with money D.C. 20510. Phone: (202) 224-6542 the Israeli army. They all are married now, to reach out with both arms, grab everything
— unless he changes his tune, and Senator Kirsten Gillibrand, 478 Rus- three of them with children. back and hold it tight. This time, I promise I
unless his administration puts battling sell Senate Office Building, Washington, My husband enters the frame. So hand- won’t let time slip through my fingers. I want
domestic terrorism back at the top of DC 20510. Photo: (202) 224-4451 some, so sexy! He walks over to talk to his to hit the pause button and keep everyone
the nation’s agenda in a forceful, effec- Rep. Josh Gottheimer, 213 Cannon mother. My heart catches. His mom passed just as they are on screen, right now. I want
tive way. The Democratic Party may House Office Building, Washington, away in 2006. to tell the Helen in the video to relax. I want
be playing to the anti-Jewish elements DC 20515. Phone: (202) 225-4465. Fax: Here are my brother and sister, who have to tell her to stop fretting, to stop thinking
within the left, but its supporters must (202) 225-9048 come in from the city for whatever event this about tomorrow, to stop cleaning, to stop
let them know that to do so will mean Rep. Bill Pascrell Jr. 2409 Rayburn is. My brother addresses the camera, though doing things, to cuddle the kids, to just be.
a loss of support. Financial and elec- House Office Building, Washington, I can’t hear what he is saying. The camera To stand still and enjoy the moment.
toral, from Jews. DC 20515. Phone: (202) 225-5751. Fax: pans to the left, and I see my mother. But of course, this is only a video.
If we receive a funding solicita- (202) 225-5782 This December, Mom will be gone 10
tion from one political candidate or Rep. Nita Lowey, 2365 Rayburn years. But in the video, she’s smiling and Helen Maryles Shankman of Teaneck is an
another, we should answer it with: House Office Building, Washington, chatting. She has grown out her hair, artist and writer. Her work appears in many
“I will be glad to donate when you D.C. 20515. Phone: (202) 202-225-6506 though it’s pinned back for this occasion. I fine journals, including The Kenyon Review,
come out with a comprehensive pro- Ronna Romney McDaniel, Chairman, feel like I could touch her if I just reached Gargoyle, Jewishfiction.net, and Cream City
gram to battle the growing hatred Republican National Committee, 310 out my hand. Why is she in New York? Per- Review. Scribner recently published her
in America, especially anti-Semi- First St. SE, Washington, DC 20003 haps this is one of the times she flew in to second novel, “In The Land of Armadillos.”
tism, and when you propose and Don Perez, Chairman, Democratic
fight for effective gun-control legisla- National Committee, 430 S. Capitol St. The opinions expressed here are those of the authors, not necessarily those of the newspaper’s editors,
tion. Pious statements are no longer SE, Washington, DC 20003 publishers, or other staffers. We welcome letters to the editor. Send them to jstandardletters@gmail.com.
Opinion
T
“ he only thing that worries me is the depersonal- medical treatment in places where the state the highest quality care to our veterans
ization and dehumanization of politics that has runs the health care system. Rarely covered somehow needs to be fixed, optimized, tin-
come about with the progress of civilization. An in the press, most incidents are told directly kered with until we don’t even recognize it
ordinary human being, with a personal con- by the people that came to the U.S. to get anymore.”
science, personally answering for something to somebody the care they required in a timely manner. Translation, 22 veterans a day killing
and personally and directly taking responsibility, seems to Yet, this reality seems to elude many of themselves doesn’t register as an issue for
be receding farther and farther from the realm of politics. those elected to represent us. AOC. Neither do the thousands of veterans
Politicians seem to turn into puppets that only look human A recent example is Congresswoman who killed themselves waiting for health
and move in a giant, rather inhuman theatre; they appear Alexandria Ocasio Cortez, a proud social- care. In fact, in the past 18 months, 22 vet-
to become merely cogs in a huge machine, objects of a major ist, who made clear that she is a fervent Martha erans took their own lives at VA centers
civilizational automatism which has gotten out of con- believer in the single payer health system Cohen according to a recent article in the Atlanta
trol and for which nobody is responsible.” based on, as she puts it, being “successful Journal-Constitution, and more than 6,000
in many different models, from Finland to veterans commit suicide each year. An
— Vaclav Havel, playwright, dissident, President of Czecho- Canada to the U.K.” She must not have spoken to Charlie inordinate percentage of suicides are by veterans, but
slovakia and the new Czech Republic upon acceptance of Gard’s parents or all those waiting in line in Canada for that won’t stop her from blasting the privatization of
the Onassis Prize for Man and Mankind, Greece, May 1993 months just to see a specialist. Or perhaps she doesn’t even a portion of the VA, so that these brave soldiers can
care about the loss of work or suspension of life, some- access care in a more timely manner. It also allows sol-
As the discussion about single-payer health care is heat- times for over a year, waiting for commonplace surgeries diers who live far from a VA facility to get care closer to
ing up as the 2020 presidential election season begins, I like cardiac bypass or hip and knee replacement. Or per- their home. Starting in June, the VA Mission Act will allow
can’t help but think about little Charlie Gard. If you hav- haps she hasn’t taken the time to read about the patients at least 1.5 million VA patients to seek care from the pri-
en’t heard about Charlie, he was born in the United King- that were being treated in hospital hallways and being vate sector with taxpayer funds if they wish, according to
dom on August 4, 2016, with a genetic disorder called kept in ambulances in the U.K. until there was a place to Military Times.
mitochondrial DNA depletion syndrome (MDDS) and treat them due to inadequate government funding. And that is what seems to bother AOC. No, you can’t
he died on July 28, 2017. Although MDDS is fatal, there My own understanding of how desperate the situation determine your own health care, even with the docu-
is at least one experimental therapy that shows promise, is in Canada dates back years when working with Cana- mented inadequate care, secret waitlists, and long driv-
and Charlie’s parents wanted to give him this chance. dian artists and production people who bought Ameri- ing times to reach a facility. Interestingly, when people
Although they raised private funds to enable him to can insurance for their relatives so that they could access asked her to become a recipient of VA care and forgo her
try this therapy, the state would not allow them. With a care when the Canadian system’s labyrinth was too pain- medical insurance options as a member of Congress, she
socialist (or as some politicians use the term single-payer) ful for their loved ones to endure. But those promoting seems to be eerily silent. Oh yes, the rules are for thee,
health care system, as in the United Kingdom, once a per- single-payer health care don’t seem to be aware of this, not for me — she is a socialist.
son is admitted to a hospital, they are no longer even min- nor of the crisis in the Department of Veterans Affairs. And though she is the recent poster child with her bom-
imally in charge of their own care, even if they are willing As AOC said this month regarding the VA, “All I can bastic rhetoric, so many in the current field for president
to pay directly. Charlie’s only possibility for life rested think of is that classic refrain that my parents always share her vision, and many Americans don’t have the
with the state, not with his parents. taught me growing up: ‘If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it,’” SEE SINGLE-PAYER PAGE 56
State-provided health care sounds like a great idea, but she said. “That is the opening approach we have seen
is it? Over the years we have all heard stories of people when it comes to privatization, it’s the idea that this Martha Cohen is an award-winning producer and creative
that couldn’t access not only the best but even adequate thing that isn’t broken, this thing that provides some of executive. She lives in Fort Lee with her husband and son.
LETTERS
Guide dogs (and their owners) distinguished pediatrician over many decades, under- It doesn’t matter that he says he is smarter than all sci-
should be welcome in shul scores the danger of trusting perhaps well-intentioned entists and has destroyed any progress we have made
I was wondering if you could hear me screaming over but clearly ill-formed laymen who gratuitously dispense against climate change. Offshore drilling is now restored
Rabbi Shammai Engelmayer’s March 29 op ed, “A short- medical advice. In particular, Orthodox rabbis lacking and it is killing our wildlife. It doesn’t matter that he
sighted approach to guide dogs in shul.” As a mother either scientific or medical background, who nonetheless makes fun of how people look. It doesn’t matter what
of a son who is legally blind and has a guide dog, I am advise their followers to oppose vaccinations, are espe- happened in Charleston — which was a white suprem-
saddened to think that there are rabbis who could be so cially culpable in the spread of measles our community acy event — because “both sides were at fault.” It doesn’t
narrow minded. (And that is putting it nicely…) As I read is currently experiencing. matter that his children have used their personal emails
through the perceived justifications for not allowing a Such individuals would be better advised to stick but Hillary should go to jail. His children were declined
guide dog in a synagogue, I was livid. to advice in matters spiritual and leave the medical for security clearance but he approved them.
Thankfully, the column ended on a high note. opinions to others who are more eminently qualified, Immigration has always been at the heart of Juda-
I would hope that Rabbi Engelmayer’s readers come like Dr. Banschick. ism. He is an ignorant, hateful human being but, hey,
away feeling as I do; that what we need in our Jewish com- Fraser P. Seitel, Fort Lee as someone is quoted in your article said, “The stock
munity is to support one another, and that the idea of market went up — I’ve made tons of money.” Same
excluding an individual or individuals because they are Shame on Trump supporters person is quoted as saying Trump is doing away with
different, i.e. blind with a guide dog, should not be toler- I can’t begin to express the anger I have towards the Obamacare. Have you seen a new plan? Obamacare is
ated just because a rabbi (mis)interprets the meanings of National Council of Young Israel’s constituency (“An not perfect, but wanting to eliminate it without a new
words in our Jewish teachings. Not for one minute. Orthodox organization’s gala dinner is mostly a tribute plan because it has the name ‘Obama’ on it is more
Simone Wilker, Washington Township to Donald Trump,” Jewish Telegraphic Agency,” April 2). than foolish. It’s disastrous. He speaks of eliminating
Under the pretense of religion, these ‘observant Jews’ pre-existing conditions. Is that OK?
Get medical advice from doctors are shameful. They are similar to the Christian Right that Being an honest, compassionate human with true
Kudos to Dr. Harry Banschick for his learned and dis- espouse righteousness but truly hate. It doesn’t matter family values doesn’t seem to matter to these “obser-
passionate explanation of why children should be vac- that Trump has told so many lies the world has lost count. vant Jews.” Trump’s support of Israel should not be
cinated for measles and other diseases. (“Vaccines do (His father was born in the Bronx!) It doesn’t matter that the deciding factor in choosing Trump as their presi-
not harm children. They save lives,” April 12). we have made enemies of our allies. It doesn’t matter that dent. Shame on them!
Dr. Banschick’s view, honed by long experience as a he is a crook, that he has ripped off many of his workers. Sandi Kleinman, Old Tappan
44 JEWISH STANDARD MAY 3, 2019
Keeping Kosher
The Moishe House Hoboken has a Southern Jewish cooking gathering on Tuesday, May 14, at 7:30 p.m.
Foster Village DINE
IN OR
Jewish recipes will be given a southern twist, and refreshments will be served. For location information Kosher Delicatessen TAKE
OUT
and to RSVP, text (704) 907-5803 or email moishehousehoboken@gmail.com. For upcoming events, go to
Moishe House Hoboken on Facebook.
APPETIZERS · SALADS
SOUPS · ENTREES
SIDE DISHES · DESSERTS
Take me away
W
hen you think about that was going to be kosher for Pass-
it, the holiday of Pass- over, they were all going crazy! Any
over is a truly a unique relative Velvel had was crawling out of
time for the Jews. We the woodwork to ask if he could get a
are celebrating and commemorating deal. “My vife ees good wit de kinder-
our freedom from slavery. Our escape lach. Maybe she runs camp?” Ahh and
from an evil empire. There is an entire the first barter for service was born….
book dedicated to telling the story. The When my mom’s parents were alive,
Hagaddah. It is the only book, I think we had Passover together in our house
— and don’t quote me because I totally and it was really special. They died pretty
don’t know what I am talking about — young, and after that, we would go with
that has a song just for the youngest my dad’s parents to the Concord every
child to sing. The manishtana. It is a other year. The other year, we went with-
book that religious and non-religious out them to the Concord. The food at the
Jews alike read together. The seders Concord was the best. Was it actually
are like Thanksgiving for some Jews; kosher for Pesach? No one is really sure.
everybody gets together for a really big But there have been some really frum
meal. Some of these families want to be hotels that we have been at that served
together and want to see each other and ice cream that was definitely not parve.
others, well, don’t and don’t. But it was really really good and totally
And for the Orthodox Jews, and pos- worth it to eat it right after a steak…
sibly some others as well, even though My point is this. No one messes with
it is a holiday celebrating the release Passover. No one gets a rabbi to say,
from slavery, we are enslaved to clean “Naa, matzah isn’t going to work for you
the entire house from top to this year. Just buy a pizza
bottom and use a whole new and eat it in the closet.”
set of dishes, utensils, pots, It’s just not happening.
pans, glasses, and food, for But the invention of the Across Down
1. Ride the waves 1. The Kings of the NBA, on scoreboards
that matter. I am not sure Hotel for Passover is a
5. ___ Asar (book of twelve prophets) 2. Mysterious obj. in the skies
how that makes any sense at totally different thing.
9. Former Laker Odom 3. Went wild
all, but it has been going on Now that is people cel- 14. Off in the distance 4. Like many samples
for thousands of years, so I ebrating their freedom! 15. They lay eggs 5. Destination of many a disappearance?
guess it just stuck. No rabbi Eating breakfast and 16. Not quite right? 6. Common crossword puzzle actor
is finding a way around that then tea room and then 17. Andy Samberg and Elon Gold, e.g. Stephen
19. Jackie who also could have been men- 7. “Raggedy” doll
one. Matzah is matzah and lunch and then barbe-
8. “After all ___ and done... “
bread just isn’t. Banji cue and then Chinese
tioned in 17-Across
20. Low laborer 9. Rabbi Norman or keyboardist Robert of
Over the holiday, I was Ganchrow food and then dinner 21. Subject of the film “Goodbye Chicago
trying to see if I could find and then more tea room. Christopher Robin” 10. Antioxidant berry
the history of going away for You’re away from 23. Org. for Woods 11. Mecca visitor
Passover. That has become a true mon- home, so you don’t have to worry about 25. Sam who directed “Spider-Man”, and 12. “This instant!”
ey-making proposition for those in the how clean the inside of your oven got others 13. Fleming or Zellweger
28. Skating surface 18. Lt. Worf portrayer Michael
business. For those of you who don’t or which of your kids’ friends will still
29. “Business” for Meir Lansky and Arnold 22. Yiddish author Sholem
know about the whole “going away for insist on bringing Oreos over in his Rothstein 23. North or South
Passover” deal, allow me to explain it to pocket, for you to find all over the car- 33. Actor Schreiber 24. Show pleasure
you. (Though, I must say that I think that pet. (True story, but not mine.) You are 34. Producer on “Frasier” 26. It’s not the same company as Lacoste
going to a hotel for Passover came from on vacation from food shopping at ridic- 35. Sinai or Ararat 27. Bracha made on most cakes
a rebbetzin in some teeny-tiny village off ulously hiked up prices — ridiculous!!! 36. “The ___ near!” (doomsayer’s phrase) 30. “___ Malkeinu”
38. What can come before the starts of 31. Bad, in Bethlehem
the beaten path in Yemensvelt who com- You are on vacation from your kids,
the circled letters in this puzzle 32. Furious
plained to her rosh-yeshiva husband that because these programs have the best 40. Middle-East terrorist group 37. Body of water
in between the 17 kids, three part- time day camps — and even if they aren’t, 44. He often annoys Homer 39. Parshat Ki ___
jobs, and a shaital machar business, she what could really happen to your kid in 46. Twizzler bit 41. “The War of the Worlds” invaders
isn’t going to have time to kasher the a seven-hour day? (I am kidding. Every- 48. Folded Mexican food 42. Sulfuric, for one
house for Pesach. one is vetted, more or less…) 49. A Jewish founder of Facebook (no, not 43. Gideon had 71
that one) 45. First Bond flick
And since he is the chief rabbi of So there you have it. Going away for
53. Modern prefix with friendly 47. Lair for Wayne and Grayson
Yemensvelt, he certainly can’t help. Pesach was originally from the great 54. Add comments to a text 49. Bakery treat
So he sent a telegram to his friend who rabbis of Yemensvelt, and for those who 55. 6-pointers, in the NFL 50. In the realm of possibility
owned a hotel and owed him a favor for can afford to go away or are related to 56. London’s Scottish counterpart 51. He plays a very famous Stark
a bris he performed when the actual someone who can afford to take you 59. Flushing Field 52. Artery’s opposite
mohel got caught in a snowstorm. away, just know that you have the bless- 61. “Gone With the Wind” star Clark 53. Encouraged, with “on”
62. He took a bullet rescuing Jewish hos- 57. BBQ side dish
His friend replied back, “For you, my ings of all of these shtark rebbes who
tages in 1972 58. Obtains
chaver, for you, my dear friend Velvel — came before you. 67. Where to snorkel in Israel 60. Tot
for you I will make my hotel kosher for 68. Hebrew eve 63. Trump’s is still happening
Passover so you and your wife and your Banji Ganchrow of Teaneck was very 69. Be aware 64. Aviv preceder
17 children could be away and relax and upset when she saw her pool was 70. Brees and Bledsoe 65. Like January in Melbourne
not have to worry about a thing!” replaced by a swing set and then when 71. Bulldog’s school 66. NYC hood with many Jewish singles
72. Approximate figures: Abbr.
Well, when word got out in the vil- she went to 1 p.m. lunch, there was no
lage that there was going to be a hotel table or lunch…. Oh well…. The solution to last week’s puzzle is on page 55.
Jewish Standard MAY 3, 2019 47
JS-48*
Calendar
educational director at Israel with Professor
Yeshiva University, and Alan Dershowitz in
Lisa Twerski, author conversation with
of “I’m So Confused, JNF’s CEO, Russell
Am I Being Abused?” Robinson, at the
speak at “It Can Rockleigh, 26 Paris
Happen to Anyone,” Ave., Rockleigh.
a mental health and Registration, 9:30 a.m.;
addiction symposium program at 10. JNF.
on eliminating stigma, org/NNJbrunch or
at Yeshivat He’Atid. Jacqueline Yehudiel,
Refreshments, 8:30 (973) 593-0095, ext.
a.m.; program at 9. 823.
Sponsored by CCSA
and Refaenu. 1500 Speaker in Wyckoff:
Queen Anne Road. Rabbi Jeffrey K. Salkin,
Time2TalkAddiction@ senior rabbi of Temple
gmail.com or Solel in Hollywood,
Time2TalkAddiction. Fla., is the guest for the
org. distinguished speaker
series at Temple Beth
Rishon. Breakfast
buffet, 9:45 a.m.,
followed by the talk,
“American Jews are
from Mars: Israeli
Jews are from Venus,”
10:30 a.m. 585 Russell
Ave. (201) 891-4466 or
bethrishon.org.
Calendar
Calendar
Tenafly High
School stu-
dents rehearse
May art exhibit in Tenafly
“The Curious The Waltuch Gallery at the Kaplen JCC many solo exhibitions at the Lucian
Incident of on the Palisades presents “Taming Krief Gallery. His more recent exhi-
the Dog in the Tigers: Paintings by Noah Elam,” on bitions include solo shows at the Pat-
Night-Time.” display through May 30 at the Waltuch erson Museum and the Etervana and
PHOTO PROVIDED Art Gallery. Atrium Galleries in New Jersey, and
Elam was born in Brazil, where he the Riverdale Y in New York. His works
attended the Escola Nacional de Belas are also prized in private international
Artes in Rio de Janeiro. In the early collections as well as permanent collec-
Teens to stage ‘Curious Incident’ 1970s, he began exhibiting in one-man
shows at popular galleries in both Sao
tions in museums worldwide, including
the Museum of São Paulo, Brazil.
and benefit autism programs Paulo and Rio de Janerio. In the 1980s, The Waltuch Art Gallery is a commu-
he won an international award in Bra- nity space that exhibits thematically
Tenafly High School’s award-winning per- for people with autism at the Kaplen zil, was featured in a group exhibition Jewish artwork, or art produced by
forming arts department presents “The JCC on the Palisades in Tenafly. The at the Taipei Art Museum in China and Jewish artists. For more information,
Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night- thought-provoking play by Simon Ste- at the World Trade and Cultural Cen- call Nina Bachrach at (201) 408-1406
Time” from May 2 to 4. The cast will hold phens is based on the best-selling novel ter in Amsterdam. In 1989 he moved or email her at nbachrach@jccotp.org.
a talkback at the end of the performances of the same name by Mark Haddon. to Jerusalem’s Old City, where he had
to raise awareness for autism and will be For more information, email sahncoo-
collecting donations to support programs per@tenafly.k12.nj.us.
JEWISH STANDARD MAY 3, 2019 51
Jewish World
On the social media battlefield, the Israeli army has weaponized snark
SAM SOKOL
Obituaries
Correcting
Jerry will be sorely missed.
errors is the We continue to be Jewish family managed,
responsibility knowing that caring people provide caring service.
May the Nathans family be comforted
of the GUTTERMAN AND MUSICANT
funeral home. among the mourners of Zion and Jerusalem. JEWISH FUNERAL DIRECTORS
800-522-0588
WIEN & WIEN, INC. MEMORIAL CHAPELS
Jewish Federation
OF NORTHERN NEW JERSEY
800-322-0533
402 Park Street, Hackensack, New Jersey 07601
ALAN L. MUSICANT, Mgr., N.J. Lic. No. 2890
Roberta Abrams Jason M. Shames MARTIN D. KASDAN, N.J. Lic. No. 4482
President Chief Executive Officer
Advance Planning Conferences Conveniently Arranged
at the Funeral Home or in Your Own Home
50 Eisenhower Drive, Paramus, NJ 07652 | 201.820.3900 GuttermanMusicantWien.com
SINAI Schools is seeking motivated and Northern NJ Jewish funeral home seeks an burial crypts
qualified professionals to work as part of its experienced licensed funeral director. Candidate at Sanctuary of Abraham & Home Repair Service
Sarah at New Cedar Park
highly collaborative and interdisciplinary must be familiar with Jewish law and rituals Cemetery in Paramus. The Carpentry Painting
regarding burials and possess excellent crypts are on the 2nd floor, units Decks Kitchens
team for the 2019-20 school year. 3117 & 3118, level 5. Currently Locks/Doors Electrical
interpersonal skills. We offer a professionally worth $15,000; asking $10,000. Basements Paving/Masonry
Positions are available in our Elementary, satisfying work environment and excellent benefits Bathrooms Drains/Pumps
Ruth 516-314-4310
Middle and High Schools in Livingston, including paid vacation, pension plan and health
Plumbing Maintenence
Tiles/Grout Hardwood Floors
River Edge, Teaneck, NJ and Riverdale, NY. insurance. Email resume to dt3191@yahoo.com. General Repairs
PoSITIoNS INcLudE: Get results! NO JOB IS TOO SMALL
Special Education Teachers General Studies
Florida Condo For Rent Crypts For Sale Advertise on 24 Hour x 5 1/2 Emergency Services
Shomer Shabbat Free Estimates
(SINAI at JKHA and SINAI at TABC)
Special Education Teachers Judaic Studies boca WEST
this page. 1-201-530-1873
2 indoor double crypts (”True
(SINAI at JKHA and SINAI at TABC)
Boca Raton, Forida
2 Bedroom penthouse apartment
Companion”) in Sanctuary of 201-837-8818
Abraham and Sarah, Cedar Park
with beautiful views.
Assistant Teachers Lovely, furnished
Cemetery in Paramus.
Prime location in main building,
(SINAI at TABC and SINAI at Ma’ayanot) Best area in Florida
40% off current cost. Email Antiques
Call Mrs. G
Speech Therapist 914-589-4673
aandssanctuary@outlook.com
LET THE
VOTING
Handyman Plumbing
APL Plumbing & Heating LLC
Your Neighbor with Tools
Home Improvements & Handyman Complete Kitchen &
Bath Remodeling
PAINTING · FINISHING Boilers · Hot Water Heaters · Leaks
CARPENTRY · HANDIWORK EMERGENCY SERVICE
BEGIN
Shomer Shabbat · Free Estimates Fully Licensed, Bonded and Insured
Over 20 Years Experience NO JOB IS TOO SMALL!
Ask us about our 201-358-1700 · Lic. #12285
investment property rates
Adam 201-675-0816 Roofing
amark2@hotmail.com · NJ Lic. #13VH05023300
Instagram: yourneighborwithtools
READERS’
201-753-1315 Free Estimates
Unlock your talent. 36 yrs exp
Start playing today! NJHIC# 13VH07259700
Roofing
ROOFING · SIDING
Free
Estimates
201-487-5050
HACKENSACK
ROOFING
OOFING
CO.
INC.
GUTTERS · LEADERS
Roof
Repairs
83 FIRST STREET
HACKENSACK, NJ 07601
2019
CHOICE 2019
Insidious But each propaganda poster, each rally, each pub- and community leaders. Non-Jews usually pity them
FROM PAGE 12 lic shaming, subtly changed people’s perceptions. So as victims. My generation hears the incredible stories
fabric. But somehow, for me, that particular photograph when the atrocities began, perpetrators did not merely — and some of us are lucky enough to have surviving
encapsulated the total magnitude of the Holocaust. believe their actions were justified — they saw vermin, grandparents — but unfortunately, we will remember
When that old man stood before the Nazis, they did and treated them like vermin. survivors as elderly.
not feel the light behind his eyes, the wisdom in his This tactic to control people has been used for millen- Therein lies another layer of tragedy. We are the last
face, the weight of his spiritual presence. Nazi ideology nia, and the Nazis perfected it. Certain ways of thinking generation to know these heroes, but we know them
blocked that off, and supplanted it with a different per- can undermine the way we experience reality itself. If only as old men and women. It’s difficult for kids to
ception. The SS guards saw a weak, parasitic, wrinkled, the Nazis could deny fundamental truths about human see that survivors once were outwardly vital, young,
and (worst of all) Jewish organism that needed a crutch worth, how can we avoid falling into the same trap? It and exceptional — and inside, that’s still who they
to walk. And they all instantly knew where to send him. should terrify us that our beliefs can so readily skew are. Thanks to my experience on this program, I have
This picture is not only evil, but alarming. Hitler had our perceptions, crippling our ability to discern reality. learned how to see past the surface.
mastered the ability to manipulate basic human cog- We all perceive each other through different lenses. My generation is the last personal link to these sto-
nition. If the perpetrators of the Holocaust had only Truth comes to us by working to see the nuanced whole ries. It is our responsibility to learn them, and to truly
an ideology of racism, they could not have carried out of each person — not just one fragmented perception or know the people behind them. I hope we can bear
their monstrosities. Even if a man absolutely hates his fleeting idea. witness to more than a vague tale and an old wrinkled
neighbor, he cannot cause him harm — unless he no As Holocaust survivors age, each generation per- face. And I pray we can convey the strength of the sur-
longer perceives the neighbor as a conscious entity, a ceives them differently. The children of survivors know vivor to our own descendants, so that their light shines
living soul, fundamentally his equal. them as complicated parents, powerful family builders, brightly through the ages.
debate, “…it takes a long time to do the necessary personal liberty, the freedom to choose our path, and the
Single-payer administrative steps that have to be taken to put the ability to be judged as an individual.
FROM PAGE 44
legislation together to control the people.” Providing health care directly from the state may
information or the experience of what this single-payer The famous writer and freedom fighter Vaclav Havel, seem like a good idea, and there are well-intentioned
experience means when this is your only option. imprisoned for his fight for human rights in Czechoslova- people who support this. But these decisions cannot
One of the most fervent backers of universal kia against the communist, totalitarian repression of the be taken lightly nor be made by assuming it will all be
health care was the late Congressman John Dingell. Soviet Union, became the country’s President after the good. Sacrificing personal liberty is a tremendous and
He was the longest-serving member in the House Velvet Revolution. He understood this dangerous phe- irrevocable price.
(1955-2015) and was succeeded by his wife, Debbie nomenon of empowering politicians and bureaucrats to Asked what he learned after leaving Scientology after
Dingell, representing their Michigan district. Lesser create rules dor which they are never held responsible. 30-plus years, the multiple Oscar winning screenwriter/
known is that Dingell’s father served before him, Health care is just one area that many in the current producer/director Paul Haggis said in Alex Gibney’s doc-
meaning a Dingell has represented the district since political and bureaucratic class are working hard to cede umentary “Going Clear: Scientology and the Prison of
1932. Why is this important? When you are removed to the state to operate. If we let this happen, we do it at Belief”: “What I take away from it is that we lock up a
from the life of a constituent for too long, as Dingell our own peril. The American character is based on our portion of our own mind. We willingly put the cuffs on,
was, you get funny ideas. Rather than understand- thirst for liberty, free from the imposition of oppressive we willingly avoid things that will, could cause us pain if
ing that an elected leader is a servant of the peo- restrictions on the way we live our lives, and on rejection we looked. If we can just believe something then we don’t
ple as President Harry Truman reminded so many, of having the state make choices for us; and the impor- really have to think for ourselves, do we?”
there are those that begin to believe that their con- tance of personal responsibility. Ceding the power to decide our own destiny is guaran-
stituents are to follow them. As dingell said in an This is especially important for the Jewish people, who teed to end in pain and, for some, death. Don’t be fooled.
interview in March 2010 during the health care have been able to live freely and prosper here because of Remember Charlie Gard.
C/A/C. EZ to NYC.
Ma S OP
-4
benefit others.
Age-Friendly Englewood is a community-wide
39 Hillside Ave. $379,000
Move In Cond. Spac 3 BR, 2.5 Bath Col. LR, Den, DR open to Quartz Countered Kit.
project that is working to ensure that residents of Game Rm Bsmnt. 2 Car Gar.
Englewood can age in place in their homes and in
the community with dignity and independence. 550 Maple Ave. $319,900
Perfect Starter Home. Univ Area. Charm Col. Encl Porch, LR/Fplc+Alcove, Stained
Age-Friendly Englewood seeks to help the commu-
Glass Windows, DR, Screened Porch. 1st Flr Laund. Nice Sized BRs, 2 Full Baths. Fin
nity become more livable for people of all ages, with Bsmt. Gar.
particular attention to the rapidly growing number of TEANECK - TUDOR STYLE! $420,000 ALL CLOSE TO NY BUS / HOUSES OF WORSHIP /
older adults. An age-friendly community is one that is Prime Location, 3Br, 1bth, LR w/fplc , FDR, Den w/ pwdr rm, HIGHWAYS / SHOPS / SCHOOLS
a great place to grow up and grow old. Kit, partially fin bsmnt, rec room, storage & 2 car garage.
www.RussoRealEstate.com
490 Standish Road
For more information, contact Janet Sharma at app.russorealestate.com
(201) 410-6645. TENAFLY
ALPINE/CLOSTER
Orna RIVER VALE
Jackson, TENAFLY
Sales Associate CRESSKILL
201-376-1389
201-768-6868 201-666-0777 201-894-1234 201-871-0800
894-1234
(201) 837-8800
JEWISH STANDARD MAY 3, 2019 57
Real Estate & Business
Jimmy J
J im
im More than 411,000 likes.
Monthly maintenance, year-end closings and openings, we can even stock your
pond with colorful new fish or plants to create your ideal pond environment!
For 28 years, WaterWorks has been the pond and aquarium specialist – for
residential and commercial properties.
Traditional Ponds
(973) 664-9880
Pondless Waterfalls (973) 722-0664
Salt & Fresh
Fully Insured
Water Aquariums
NJ Lic: 13VH09842000
Est. 1991