Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
5 2 RELATED TITLES
6.2K views
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
case of stock corporations, to the extent and municipalities, upon the recommendation of the
of at least fifty‐one (51) of its capital sangguniang concerned provided that the same shall
stock. (Leyson, Jr. v. Office of the be effective only upon ratification in a plebiscite
Ombudsman, G.R. No. 134990, April 27, conducted for the purpose in the political unit
2000) directly affected. (R.A. 7160, Sec. 13)
a. Province – P 20M
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
A: Upon the election and qualification of its chief 2. The challenged “cities” claim that it
executive and a majority of the members of its was the intent of Congress anyway to
sanggunian, unless some other time is fixed grant them exemption from the
income requirement, as per the
therefor by law or ordinance creating it. (Sec. 14, th
deliberations of the 11 Congress.
R.A. 7160)
What became of the cityhood bills and
their deliberations that were pending
th
Q: What is the rule relative to the merger and at the adjournment of the 11
division of local government units? Congress?
A: A:
1. Such division or merger shall not reduce 1. Yes, The 16 cities covered by the Cityhood Laws
the income, population or land area of not only had conversion bills pending during the
the LGC concerned to less than the 11th Congress, but have also complied with the
minimum requirement requirements of the LGC prescribed prior to its
2. That the income classification of the amendment by R.A. No. 9009. Congress
original LGU/s shall not fall below its
undeniably gave these cities all the considerations
current income classification prior to
that justice and fair play demanded. Hence, this
the division
3. A plebiscite must be held in LGUs Court should do no less by stamping its
affected imprimatur to the clear and unmistakable
4. Assets and liabilities of creation shall be legislative intent and by duly recognizing the
equitably distributed between the LGUs certain collective wisdom of Congress. (League of
affected and new LGU Cities of the Philippines (LCP) v. COMELEC, G.R.
No. 176951, April 12, 2011)
The municipalities filed, through their respective Q: May Congress validly delegate to the ARMM
sponsors, individual cityhood bills containing a Regional Assembly the power to create
common proviso exempting them from the new provinces, cities, and municipalities within the
income requirement. The Congress approved the ARMM, pursuant to Congress’s plenary
same. Concerned parties protested such laws legislative powers?
allowing a “wholesale conversion” of
municipalities as being unconstitutional. Decide. A: No. There is no provision in the Constitution
that conflicts with the delegation to regional
1. Are the cityhood laws valid? legislative bodies of the power to create
municipalities and barangays. However, the Constitution. (Aladaba v. Comelec, G.R. No.
creation of provinces and cities is another matter. 188078, Jan. 25, 2010)
Only Congress can create provinces and cities
because the creation of the same necessarily Q: Congress enacted a law reapportioning the
includes the creation of legislative districts, a composition of the Province of Camarines Sur
power only Congress can exercise under Section 5 and created legislative districts thereon. Aquino
Art. VI of the Constitution and Section 3 of the challenged the law because it runs afoul to the
Ordinance appended to it. (Bai Sandra S.A. Sema constitutional requirement that there must be
v. COMELEC, et al. G.R. No. 178628, July 18, 2008) 250,000 population create a legislative districts.
Comelec argued that the mention requirement
Q: Considering the legislative power validly does not apply to provinces. Is the 250,000
delegated to the ARMM Regional Assembly, population standard an indispensible
what is the limitation of such that prevents the requirement for the creation of a legislative
same to create legislative districts? district in provinces?
A: The ARMM Regional Assembly cannot enact a A: No. Section 5(3), Article VI of the 1987
law creating a national office like the office of a Constitution which requires 250,000 minimum
district representative of Congress because the population requirement apply only for a city to be
legislative powers of the ARMM Regional entitled to a representative but not for a
Assembly operate only within its territorial province.
jurisdiction as provided in Section 20 Art. X of the
Constitution. (Sema v. COMELEC, G.R. No. The provision draws a plain and clear distinction
178628, July 16, 2008) between the entitlement of a city to a district on
one hand, and the entitlement of a province to a
Q: Congress enacted a law creating the district on the other. For while a province is
legislative district of Malolos based on a entitled to at least a representative, with nothing
certification of the demographic projection from mentioned about population, a city must first
NSO stating that by 2010, Malolos is expected to meet a population minimum of 250,00 in order to
reach the population of 250,000, hence entitling be similarly situated. (Aquino and Robredo v.
it to one legislative district. Is the law valid? Comelec, G.R. No. 189793, April 7, 2010)
A: No. Congress cannot establish a new legislative Q: Congress passed a law providing for the
district based on a projected population of the apportionment of a new legislative district in
National statistics Office (NSO) to meet the CDO City. The COMELEC subsequently issued a
population requirement of the Constitution in the resolution implementing said law. B now assails
reapportionment of legislative districts. the resolution, contending that rules for the
conduct of a plebiscite must first be laid down,
A city that has attained a population of 250,000 is as part of the requirements under the
entitled to a legislative district only in the Constitution. According to B, the apportionment
“immediately following election.” In short, a city is a conversion and division of CDO City, falling
must first attain the 250,000 population, and under Section 10 Art X of the Constitution, which
thereafter, in the immediately following election, provides for the rule on creation, division,
such city shall have a district representative. merger, and abolition of LGUs. Decide.
There is no showing in the present case that the
City of Malolos has attained or will attain a A: There is no need for a plebiscite. CDO City
population of 250,000, whether actual or politically remains a single unit and its
projected, before May 10, 2010 elections. Thus, administration is not divided along territorial
the City of Malolos is not qualified to have a lines. Its territory remains whole and intact. Thus,
legislative district of its own under Section 5(3), Section 10 Art. X of the Constitution does not
Article VI of the 1987 Constitution and Section 3 come into play. (Bagabuyo v. COMELEC, G.R. No.
of the Ordinance appended to the1987 17690, Dec. 8 2008)
Search VILLAMOR.
Upload EN
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
Q: May a nuisance be abated without a judicial profession. (Acebedo Optical v. CA, G.R. No.
proceeding? 100152, Mar. 31, 2000)
Q: What does the power to issue licenses and Note: A resolution will not suffice for a
permits include? LGU to be able to expropriate private
property; a municipal ordinance is
A: It includes the power to revoke, withdraw or different from a resolution in that an
restrict through the imposition of certain ordinance is a law while a resolution is
conditions. However, the conditions must be merely a declaration of the sentiment
reasonable and cannot amount to an arbitrary or opinion of a lawmaking authority on
interference with the business. (Acebedo Optical a specific matter.
Company, Inc. vs. CA, G.R. No. 100152. March 31,
2000) 2. For Public use, purpose or welfare of for
the benefit of the poor or landless
Note: Only the Sanggunian, not the mayor of the 3. Payment of just Compensation
city, has the power to allow cockpits, stadiums, etc. 4. A valid and definite Offer has been
Without an ordinance, he cannot compel mayor to previously made to the owner of the
issue him a business license (Canet v. Decena, G.R. property sought to be expropriated, but
said offer was not accepted.
No. 155344, Jan. 20, 2004)
(Municipality of Paranaque vs. V.M.
Realty Corporation G.R. No. 127820.
Q: Distinguish between the grant of a license or
July 20, 1998)
permit to do business and the issuance of a
license to engage in the practice of a particular Q. What are the due process requirements in
profession. eminent domain?
Q: What are the requisites for an authorized these limits, it usurps the legislative functions of
immediate entry? the municipal council or president. Such has been
the consistent course of executive authority.”
(Velazco v. Blas G.R. No., L‐30456 July 30, 1982)
A:
1. The filling of a complaint for
expropriation sufficient in form and
2.c. Taxation
substance
2. The deposit of the amount equivalent
to fifteen percent (15%) of the fair Q: What is the nature of the power of taxation?
market value of the property to be In LGUs?
expropriated based on its current tax
declaration. (City of Iloilo vs Legaspi: A: A municipal corporation, unlike a sovereign
G.R. No. 154614, November 25, 2004) state, is clothed with no inherent power of
taxation. The charter or statue must plainly show
Note: Upon compliance, the issuance of writ of
an intent to confer that power or the municipality
possession becomes ministerial. (City of Iloilo vs
cannot assume it. And the power when granted is
Legaspi, G.R. No. 154614, November 25, 2004)
to be construed strictissimi juris. (Medina vs. City
of Baguio, G.R. No. L‐4060 August 29, 1952)
Q: What are the two phases of expropriation
proceedings?
Q: Under the Constitution, what are the three
main sources of revenues of local government
A:
units?
1. The determination of the authority to
exercise the power of eminent domain A:
and the propriety of its exercise in the 1. Taxes, fees, and charges. (Sec. 5, Art. X,
context of the facts involved in the suit. 1987 Constitution)
2. Share in the national taxes. (Share in
2. The determination by the court of “just the proceeds of the utilizations and
compensation for the property sought development of the national wealth
to be taken. (Brgy. Son Roque, Talisay, within their areas. (Sec. 7, Art. X, 1987
Cebu v. Heirs of Francisco Pastor, G.R. Constitution)
No. 138896, June 20, 2000) 3. Sec. 6, Art. X, 1987 Constitution)
Q: May the Sangguniang Panlalawigan validly Q: What are the fundamental principles that
disapprove a resolution or ordinance of a shall govern the exercise of the taxing and
municipality calling for the expropriation of revenue‐raising powers of local government
private property to be made site of a Farmers units?
center and other government sports facilities on
the ground that said “expropriation is
unnecessary considering that there are still A:
available lots of the municipality for the 1. Taxation shall be uniform in each local
establishment of a government center”? government unit
2. Taxes, fees, charges and other
A: No, The only ground upon which a provincial impositions shall be equitable and
board may declare any municipal resolution, based as far as practicable on the
ordinance or order invalid is when such taxpayer’s ability to pay; be levied and
resolution, ordinance, or order is ‘beyond the collected only for public purpose; not
powers conferred upon the council or president be unjust, excessive, oppressive, or
making the same.’ A strictly legal question is confiscatory; not be contrary to law,
before the provincial board in its consideration of public policy, national economic policy,
a municipal resolution, ordinance, or order. The or restraint of trade;
provincial board’s disapproval of any resolution, 3. The collection of local taxes, fees,
ordinance, or order must be premised specifically charges and other impositions shall in
upon the fact that such resolution, ordinance, or no case be left to any private person
order is outside the scope of the legal powers 4. The revenue collected shall inure solely
conferred by law. If a provincial board passes to the benefit of and be subject to
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
disposition by, the local government imposed by the national government for whatever
unit, unless specifically provided purpose." As a rule, the term "shall" is a word of
therein; command that must be given a compulsory
5. Each local government, as far as meaning. The provision is, therefore, imperative.
practicable, evolves a progressive (Pimentel, Jr. v. Aguirre, G.R. No. 132988, July 19,
system of taxation. (Sec. 130, R.A. 7160) 2000)
Q: Under the Constitution, what is the basis of Q: What are the fundamental principles
ARMM’s taxing power? governing financial affairs, transactions and
operations of LGUs?
A: The ARMM has the legislative power to create
sources of revenues within its territorial A:
jurisdiction and subject to the provisions of the 1. No money shall be paid out of the local
1987 Constitution and national laws. (Sec. 20[b], treasury except in pursuance of an
Art. X) appropriation ordinance or law;
Q: Distinction between the power to tax by 2. Local government funds and monies
shall be spent solely for public
ordinary LGUs and that of the Autonomous
purposes;
Regions.
3. Local revenue is generated only from
A: sources expressly authorized by law or
LGU’s outside LGU’s inside autonomous ordinance, and collection thereof shall
autonomous regions regions (i.e. ARMM) at all times be acknowledged property
Basis of Taxing Power
Organic Act which Sec. 4. All monies officially received by a local
Sec. 5, Article X, 1987 20(b), Article X, 1987 government officer in any capacity or
Constitution Constitution allows on any occasion shall be accounted for
Congress to pass
as local funds, unless otherwise
Governing Guidelines and limitatitons
provided
Local Government
Respective Organic Act 5. Trust funds in the local treasury shall
Code of 1991
not be paid out except in the fulfillment
of the purpose for which the trust was
Note: Unlike Sec. 5, Article X, Sec. 20, Article X of the created or the funds received
1987 Constitution is not self‐executing. It merely
authorizes Congress to pass the Organic Act of the 6. Every officer of the local government
unit whose duties permit or require the
autonomous regions which shall provide for
possession or custody of local funds
legislative powers to levy taxes upon their
shall be properly bonded, and such
inhabitants.
officer shall be accountable and
responsible for said funds and for the
Q: The president, through AO 372, orders the safekeeping thereof in conformity with
withholding of 10 percent of the LGUs' IRA the provisions of law;
"pending the assessment and evaluation by the
Development Budget Coordinating Committee of 7. Local governments shall formulate a
sound financial plans and local budgets
the emerging fiscal situation" in the country. Is
shall be based on functions, activities
the AO valid? and projects, in terms of expected
results
A: No, A basic feature of local fiscal autonomy is
the automatic release of the shares of LGUs in the 8. Local budget plans and goals shall, so
national internal revenue. This is mandated by no far as practicable, be harmonized with
less than the Constitution. The Local Government national development plans, goals and
Code specifies further that the release shall be strategies in order to optimize the
made directly to the LGU concerned within five utilization of resources and to avoid
(5) days after every quarter of the year and "shall duplication in the use of fiscal and
not be subject to any lien or holdback that may be physical resources
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
of the preceding calendar year of ensuing quarter and the taxes, fees, or charges
P50,000 or less, in the case of cities and due shall begin to accrue therefrom. (Art. 276, IRR
P30,000 or less, in the case of of LGC)
municipalities, at a rate not exceeding
1% on such gross sales or receipts. Q: The Province of Palawan passes an ordinance
2. services rendered
requiring all owners/operators of fishing vessels
3. barangay clearances
4. commercial breeding of fighting cocks, that fish in waters surrounding the province to
cockfights and cockpits invest ten percent (10%) of their net profits from
5. places of recreation which charge operations therein in any enterprise located in
admission fees Palawan. NARCO Fishing Corp., a Filipino
6. Billboards, signboards, neon signs and corporation with head office in Navotas, Metro
outdoor advertisements. (Sec. 152 R.A.
Manila, challenges the ordinance as
7160)
unconstitutional. Decide the case.
Q: When shall a tax ordinance take effect? Q: What is the nature of a community tax?
A: In case the effectivity of any tax ordinance or A: Community tax is a poll or capitation tax which
revenue measure falls on any date other than the is imposed upon person who resides within a
beginning of the quarter, the same shall be specified territory.
considered as falling at the beginning of the next
Q: Who are exempted from the payment of the Q: What are the requisites for a real estate tax
community tax? protest?
A: A:
1. Diplomatic and consular 1. The taxpayer has already paid the tax
representatives; 2. The protest must be in writing
2. Transient visitors when their stay in the 3. Must be filed within 30 days from
Philippines does not exceed 3 months. payment of the tax to the local
(Sec. 159 R.A. 7160) treasurer concerned who shall decide
the same within 60 days from receipt of
Q: What are the remedies available to the local such protest.
government units to enforce the payment of
Note: Payment of tax is precondition in protest
taxes?
questioning the reasonableness of the assessment or
amount of tax; but not when the issue raised is the
A:
authority of assessor or treasurer. (Ursal, Philippine
1. Imposing penalties (surcharges and
Law on Local Government Taxation, 2000 Ed.)
penalty interest) in case of delinquency
(Sec. 167 R.A. 7160)
Q: How much real property tax can be imposed
2. Availing local government’s liens (Sec.
173 R.A. 7160)
by the local government units?
3. Administrative action through distraint
of goods, chattels, and other personal A: A real estate levy may be imposed by the
property (Sec. 174(a) R.A. 7160) province or city or a municipality w/in metro
4. Judicial action (Sec. 174(b) R.A. 7160) manila as follows:
Q: What are the other sources of revenue? 1. By the province, not exceeding 1% of the
assessed value of the property; and
2. By the city or a municipality w/in metro
A: The local government units are entitled to
manila, not exceeding 2% of the assessed
definite shares in:
value of the property. (Sec. 233 R.A.
7160)
1. The proceeds from development and
utilization of mines, forests, and marine Q: Bayantel was granted by Congress after the
resources up to 40% of the gross effectivity of the Local Government Code (LGC),
collections there from by the national
a legislative franchise with tax exemption
government. (Sec. 290 R.A. 7160)
privileges which partly reads “the grantee, its
2. The proceeds of government owned or successors or assigns shall be liable to pay the
controlled corporations engaged in the same taxes on their real estate, buildings and
utilization and development of the personal property, exclusive of this franchise, as
national wealth up to 1% of the gross other persons or corporations are now or
sales or 40% of the gross collections hereafter may be required by law to pay.” This
made by the national government there
provision existed in the company’s franchise
from, whichever is higher. (Sec. 291 R.A.
7160) prior to the effectivity of the LGC. Quezon City
then enacted an ordinance imposing a real
Q: What are real property taxes? property tax on all real properties located within
the city limits and withdrawing all exemptions
A: These are directly imposed on privilege to use previously granted. Among properties covered
real property such as land, building, machinery, are those owned by the company. Bayantel is
and other improvements, unless specifically imposing that its properties are exempt from tax
exempted. under its franchise. Is Bayantel correct?
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
Q: What are the special levies on real property? regulations to promote health, morals, peace,
education, good order or safety and general
A: welfare of their constituents. (Batangas CATV,
1. A special education fund may also be Inc. v. CA, G.R. No. 138810, Sept. 29, 2004)
assessed in provinces, cities, or
Metropolitan Manila municipalities up
to a maximum of 1% of the assessed 2.d. Closure of Roads
value of a real property. (Sec. 235 R.A.
7160)
Q: What are subject to the power of an LGU to
2. Idle lands in provinces, cities or open or close a road?
municipalities in Metro Manila may be
additionally taxed at not exceeding 5% A: Any local road, alley, park, or square falling
of their assessed value. (Sec. 236 R.A. within its jurisdiction may be closed, either
7160)
permanently or temporary. (Sec 21(a) R.A. 7160)
3. Lands benefited by public works
projects or improvements in provinces,
cities and municipalities may be levied a Q: What are the limitations in case of permanent
special tax of not exceeding 60% of the and temporary closure?
actual cost of the project. (Sec. 240 R.A.
7160) A:
1. In case of permanent closure:
Q: What are the requisites so that the President a. Must be approved by at least 2/3
may interfere in local fiscal matters? of all the members of the
sanggunian and when necessary
A: provide for an adequate substitute
1. An unmanaged public sector deficit of for the public facility
the national government; b. Adequate provision for the public
safety must be made
2. Consultations with the presiding officers c. The property may be used or
of the Senate and the House of conveyed for any purpose for
Representatives and the presidents of which other real property may be
the various local leagues;
lawfully used or conveyed, but no Note: He shall certify within 10 days from the
freedom park shall be closed passage of ordinances enacted and resolutions
permanently without provision for adopted by the sanggunian in the session over which
its transfer or relocation to a new he temporarily presided. (Sec. 49(b) R.A. 7160)
site. (Sec 21(a&b) R.A. 7160)
Note: Any city, municipality or barangay may, by In the event of inability of the regular presiding
ordinance, temporarily close and regulate the use of officer to preside at the sanggunian session, the
a local street, road, thoroughfare or any other public
members present and constituting a quorum shall
place where shopping, Sunday, flea or night markets
elect from among themselves a temporary
may be established and where articles of commerce
presiding officer.(Gamboa v. Aguirre, G.R. No.
may be sold or dispensed with to the general public.
134213, July 20, 1999)
(Sec 21(d) R.A. 7160)
Note: The PO shall vote only to break a tie. (Sec. If there is no quorum:
49(a) R.A. 7160) 1. Declare a recess until such time that
quorum is constituted
2. Compel attendance of the member
Q: In the absence of the regular presiding officer,
absent without justifiable cause
who presides in the sanggunian concerned?
3. Declare the session adjourned for lack
of quorum and no business shall be
A: The members present and constituting a transacted (Sec. 53(b) R.A. 7160)
quorum shall elect from among themselves a
temporary presiding officer. Q: How are sessions fixed?
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
A:
IF REGULAR SESSIONS IF SPECIAL SESSIONS
When public interests
st
By resolution on the 1 so demand may be General and
day of the session called by the local chief permanent
immediately following the executive or by a character
election the elections of majority of the
its members members of the
sanggunian
Third reading is
necessary for an
Q: What are the requirements of a sanggunian ordinance
session?
A:
1. Shall be open to public unless it is a
closed‐door session Q. What are t
2. No two sessions, regular or special, may not be CUPPU,
be held in a single day
3. Minutes of the session be recorded and A:
each sanggunian shall keep a journal
1. Must
and record of its proceedings which
and an
may be published upon resolution of
2. Must
the sanggunian concerned.
3. Must
4. In case of special sessions:
4. Must
trade
a. Written notice to the members 5. Must
must be served personally at least 6. Must
24 hours before Consis
b. Unless otherwise concurred in by vs. Pr
2/3 votes of the sanggunian G.R. N
members present, there being no
quorum, no other matters may be
considered at a special session Local In
except those stated in the notice.
(Sec. 52 R.A. 7160)
Q: Distinguish l
Q: How
VICE CHAIR FOR ADMINISTRATION AND FINANCE: JEANELLE C. LEE
is a review of the ordinances or resolutions? F a c u l t a d
VICE CHAIRS FOR LAY‐OUT AND DESIGN: EARL LOUIE M. MASACAYAN & THEENA C. MARTINEZ
resolutions done?
A:
A: GR: Within 10 days
REVIEW OF posted in a bulletin
COMPONENT CITY AND conspicuous spaces.
REVIEW OF BARANGAY
MUNICIPAL
ORDINANCES
ORDINANCES OR XPN: Unless othe
RESOLUTIONS ordinance or resol
Who reviews 7160)
Sangguniang
Sanggunian Panlalawigan Panglungsod or Q: What ordinances req
Sangguniang Bayan effectivity?
When copies of ordinance or resolutions be
forwarded A:
Within 3 days after Within 10 days after 1. Ordinances tha
approval its enactment sanctions. (Sec.
Period to examine 2. Ordinances and
Within 30 days after the highly urbaniz
receipt; may examine or component citie
may transmit to the
provincial attorney or Q: What are the inst
provincial prosecutor. Within 30 days after ordinances?
If the latter, must submit the receipt
his comments or A:
recommendations within If the chief e 1.
10 days from receipt of the same, affixing h
document every page ther
When declared valid 2. If the local chi
If no action has been taken LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
same, and the v
vote of all mem
within 30 days after Same
submission
Q: What
Note: is Chie
Local the
When invalid (grounds)
A: ordinance
and only
liability of t
If inconsistent with
1.
Item/s of an appropriation ordinance. the ordinance is
the law or city or
2.
Ordinance/resolution adopting local to public
A: Where welfa the
municipal ordinance
If beyond the powerdevelopment plan and public communicated t
and by which lia
conferred on theinvestment program a. 15 days = p
Effect: Brgy ordinance state is at liber
3. Ordinance
sangguniang panlungsod directing the payment of b. 10 days = c
is suspended
money or creating until
liability to satisfy the j
such time as the Hagonoy Bulaca
Q: What are the item
Note: Ordinances enacted revision by called
theis sangguniang No. 168289 Ma
executive may veto:
barangay shall, upon approval by a majority of all its
members bePOLITICAL LAWbyTEAM : punong barangay. The
198
signed the Q: May LGU f
ADVISER: ATTY. EDWIN REY SANDOVAL; SUBJECT HEAD: RACHEL MARIE L. FELICES; ASST. SUBJEC
latter has noHveto power.
ERAZEUS underRODEL
CHRISTINE Y. UY; MEMBERS: LAWRENCE PAULO H. AQUINO, LEANDRO writs o
V. ATIE
CARLO R. BALA, WILFREDO T. BONILLA, JR., KEEL ACHERNAR R. DINOY, Asatisfy
PRIL V. ENRILE, KENNET
judgmen
G. MENDOZA, ROGER CHRISTOPHER R. REYES, ROMILINDA C. SIBAL, JASMIN M. SISON, ZARAH P
VILLAMOR.
2.f. Corporate Powers A: No, The uni
gives its conse
Q: What are the corporate powers of an LGU? either by gene
claimants actio
A: proceedings an
1. To have continuous succession in its and that the po
corporate name judgment is re
2. To sue and be sued
and properties
execution or
Note: Only the Provincial Fiscal or the Municipal
judgments, is b
Attorney can represent a province or municipality in
lawsuits. This is mandatory. Hence, a private public policy. D
attorney cannot represent a province or be covered by
municipality. as required by
services render
3. To have and use a corporate seal to be paralyzed