Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 19

5/2/2019 Semi-Realistic Transfers : reddevils

left or 
MY SUBREDDITS - DASHBOARD - HOME - POPULAR - ALL - RANDOM - USERS - FRIENDS - SAVED - EDIT | add shortcuts from the my subreddits menu at↑↓ click th < >
rahul_21 (1 · 18) | | | preferences |  | logout

REDDEVILS comments show images (0)

Semi-Realistic Transfers (self.reddevils) search


25 submitted 10 hours ago by RedDevil132 
You can comment any transfers that you this post was submitted on 02 May 2019
think we have a semi-realistic chance of 25 points (86% upvoted)
completing. Here are some I think we can
shortlink: https://redd.it/bjpq6u
get:
RW- Hakim Ziyech Fee: 25million Release
Submit a new link
Clause
CM- Tielemans Fee: 35 million Submit a new text post
CM-Partey Fee: 43 million Release Clause
CB- Alderwireld: Fee 25 million Release
Clause
RB- Wan Bissaka Fee: 50 million
Get an ad-free experience with special
144 comments source share save hide give award benefits, and directly support Reddit.
report crosspost hide all child comments
Get Reddit Premium
all 144 comments navigate by  subscribe
»

sorted by: best

reddevils
Use subreddit style

subscribe +shortcut +dashboard

152,915 readers
1,659 users here now
Show my flair on this subreddit. It looks like:
save content policy formatting help
rahul_21 (edit)
Upcoming Fixtures
H'field vs Man Utd 4th May| 16:30
[–] MT1120 Inconsistent FC 13 points 10 hours ago BST
Man Utd vs Cardiff 12th May |
Bruno Fernandes, Alderweireld, Wan Bissaka, Icardi, 15:00 BST
Pepe/Lozano/Bergwijn 1-1
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply Premier League
hide child comments
Pos Team Pld GD
[–] IlliBois  3 points 7 hours ago
3rd Tottenham 36 +29
Chuckyyy
4th Chelsea 36 +21
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report
5th Arsenal 36 +19
give award reply hide child comments
Manchester
6th 36 +13
 SAF 1 point 5 minutes ago
[–] steveisredatw Utd
Is he worth the hype? When I watched him the Recent Results
world cup he seemed to be spirited but I only
Comp Date Opponent Resu
found him to be decent at best.
28
permalink source embed save save-RES parent Chelsea 1-1
Apr
report give award reply
24
Man City 0-2
Apr
21 Everton
4-0
Apr (a)
https://old.reddit.com/r/reddevils/comments/bjpq6u/semirealistic_transfers/ 1/19
5/2/2019 Semi-Realistic Transfers : reddevils
[–] jroades267  27 points 4 hours ago
Comp Date Opponent Resu
Manolas, alderwereild, wan bissaka, Pepe, icardi.
16 Barcelona
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply
3-0
Apr (a)
hide child comments
13
West Ham 2-1
Apr
[–] kartwose Rashford 6 points 2 hours ago
Isn't Godin available for free? Don't mind a solid two 10
Barcelona 0-1
Apr
years from him. Plus def a stable midfield presence
like Rice and a proper box to box like Tielemans. Top Scorers

Getting AWB would be insane too. How much ever I Player PL CL FA LC Tot
want Dalot to start every game, think he's better as Paul
13 2 1 0 16
a WB or further forward as of now. Pogba
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report Romelu
12 2 1 0 15
give award reply hide child comments Lukaku

Marcus
[–] MexicansInParis  Javier Hernandez, Little Pea 13
Rashford
10 2 1 0 13
points 2 hours ago

Godin is 99% an Inter player Anthony


10 1 1 0 12
Martial
permalink source embed save save-RES parent
report give award reply hide child comments Juan
2 1 1 1 5
Mata
[–] bluecrabcakes  Deadwood FC 4 points an
Jesse
hour ago 4 0 1 0 5
Lingard
Inter also got De Vrij on a free last
Top Assisters
summer and Woodward sat twiddling his
thumbs and signed Lee Grant. Player PL CL FA LC Tot

permalink source embed save save-RES Paul


9 1 1 0 11
parent report give award reply Pogba
Marcus
7 1 1 0 9
Rashford
Romelu
2 1 1 0 4
[–] Moyes2men  Bruno Meunier Declan Tuanzebe 2 points an Lukaku
hour ago
Alexis
Roma fans are very unhappy with Manolas's Sanchez
3 0 1 0 4
performances this season. Toby and Axel would do
Jesse
the work. 3 0 0 1 4
Lingard
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report
Ashley
give award reply 2 1 0 0 3
Young

Current Injuries
 vnl is better than vvd
[–] jnysa 1 point an hour ago
Expec
Which pepe Player Injury Position
retu
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report Phil
give award reply TBA CB TB
Jones
Ander
TBA CM TB
[–] Hippotopmaus 1 point 2 hours ago Herrera
Isn't pepe already going to Bayern? Antonio
TBA RB TB
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report
Valencia
give award reply hide child comments
Resources
 19 points an hour ago
[–] O_G_Loc
Subreddit Rules Subreddit Wiki "Where to
He must have typed bebe upside down Watch?" Transfer Tier Guide /r/reddevils Discord
permalink source embed save save-RES parent Server
report give award reply
Misc

https://old.reddit.com/r/reddevils/comments/bjpq6u/semirealistic_transfers/ 2/19
5/2/2019 Semi-Realistic Transfers : reddevils
[–] Moyes2men  Bruno Meunier Declan Tuanzebe 2 points Tickets FAQ Buying & Selling Tickets Utd Players
an hour ago on Social Media Match Thread Templates Match
They are going after Chiesa if the Italian media Highlights Fantasy League Code: 315293-110550
USA Soccer Bar Finder
can be trusted.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent
report give award reply

created by [deleted] a community for 8 years

[+] RedDevil132 [S] comment score below threshold (8 children)


MODERATORS message the moderators

zSolaris  Park Ji-Sung



[–] MexicansInParis Javier Hernandez, Little Pea 10 points 4 hours ago lukejames1111  Beckham
D1794  Viva Ronaldo
Alderweireld (25m), Manolas (30m), Meunier (25m), Rice
rdzzl  Mason Greenwood
(50m), Icardi (swap) and Lozano would be my line up. Pedantic_Pat  Fan Favourite David De Gea
Cost: 120m seaders  *THE* Paul Parker
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply yiyiyiyi  Pogba
hide child comments ballsywallsy  Robbo
AutoModerator 
[–] beewebco  1 point an hour ago sauce_murica  Vidić
Icardi has serious attitude problem. He has quality, about moderation team »

and would fit better than Lukaku for sure, but you
RECENTLY VIEWED LINKS
don’t want the guy in your dressing room and all the
Semi-Realistic Transfers
guys around him to be around your club.
24 points | 144 comments
If we need striker to replace Lukaku (we probably
Mourinho: I'd have loved backing like
do, but I am not sure we will go for it this summer), Guardiola or Klopp at Man Utd
I would go for Luka Jovic. He is young, strong, 518 points | 154 comments
talented with the ball, right movements all the time.
Flooding her tight body
Looks really good. Unfortunately, I think he will opt NSFW 256 points | 2 comments
for Real or Bayern.
clear
Lozano is injured.
account activity
Manolas? Not sure honestly that he is improvement
to what we have plus he needs to adapt to PL.
Alderweireld is better option in that case, if we can’t
get someone better and younger like Varane/De Ligt
or Koulibaly.
Meunier or Bissaka I guess.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report
give award reply

[+] ColonialRebel  comment score below threshold (11 children)

[+] sndi1765  comment score below threshold (0 children)

 Sell Them All 8 points 4 hours ago* (last edited 2 hours ago)
[–] jorgelucas7

Partey very recently commited himself to Atleti


Crystal Palace don't want to sell AWB, and they don't need; Zaha is leaving.
Someone has to be fired if we don't get Toby, and I'll take anything (Manolas) over looking to the
XI on game match and seeing "Jones" or "Smalling" on it.
Those wingers from PSV (Lozano and Bergwjin) are pretty much there for the taking, as is Pepe and
Meunier.

https://old.reddit.com/r/reddevils/comments/bjpq6u/semirealistic_transfers/ 3/19
5/2/2019 Semi-Realistic Transfers : reddevils

It won't happen regardless of how bad we want it:


Koulibaly: has a "fuck you" fee from ADL, and if we're really thinking long term, there's no
point in to put all that money on a player who's on the wrong side of his prime while we
rebuild, unless Ole believes we can sort this shithole in less than two seasons.
Sancho: Zorc every week comes out to say "We're not selling, get fucked"
Varane: common, son.
Edit: ADL
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply hide child comments

 3 points 52 minutes ago


[–] drripdrrop

Crystal Palace are 100% selling AWB


permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

 Rashfordinho 2 points 58 minutes ago


[–] JLingzzzzz

I can guarantee to you that Palace will sell Wan Bissaka. Also what Zorc means nothing. If we
offer them the money for Sancho they'll sell. They have a history of it
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply hide child comments

[–] drripdrrop 1 point 53 minutes ago


it'll have to be a fuck off fee though
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply hide child comments

 Rashfordinho 1 point 40 minutes ago


[–] JLingzzzzz

Around Dembeles fee, which 95 million up front, 135 million including add ons
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[–] AhmedZubairGCU 3 points 3 hours ago


Ndidi would be a good signing
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply hide child comments

 Jose Mourinho 2 points an hour ago


[–] doesnt_like_pants

He’s on a very long contract and Leicester aren’t short of money but I would love him too
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[–] Flanelman  Jessi 10 points 4 hours ago

If Ziyech's release clause is actually 25m and we dont go in for him...


permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply hide child comments

[–] BBQ_HaX0r  Zlatan 16 points 3 hours ago

Where would we play him? He's a #10. That's a wonky fit in our squad where we play
basically a 442 (do we play a diamond now and shackle Pogba?) or 433. End up with the Juan
Mata Shinji Kagawa problems. Have him on the bench as our Pogba backup?
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply hide child comments

 6 points 3 hours ago


[–] Colinjames322

We’ve mostly been playing a diamond with lingard at the point.


I’m not opposed to a diamond as an option, but we should also have a true RW.
https://old.reddit.com/r/reddevils/comments/bjpq6u/semirealistic_transfers/ 4/19
5/2/2019 Semi-Realistic Transfers : reddevils

And I agree, is ziyach really that big of an upgrade over lingard?


permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply hide child comments

[–] Bighairman 14 points 3 hours ago


Yes - Ziyech is definitely that big of an upgrade over Lingard ffs
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply hide child comments

 3 points 3 hours ago


[–] Colinjames322

It was a legitimate question.


I haven’t seen but 4 full Ajax games this season. was responding to the guy
about where he would play, which is the same position lingard plays, the
point of a diamond and then asking if it was thought he’s that big of an
upgrade because I’m not sure how consistent he is and what exactly he’d
contribute.
With having Pogba, mata and lingard that play that role, is he that much
better that we’d prefer to sign him over a traditional winger with all the other
positions we have to fill?
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply
hide child comments

 5 points 3 hours ago


[–] Bighairman

Ziyech, if he joined our team, would be the best player at the tip of the
diamond for sure.
The question as to whether we want a pure RW is a different and
lengthy debate. Perhaps signing a top RB and 10 (eg Wan Bissaka and
Joao Felix) solves our width issue as well as our attacking quality. In
my opinion, people often say a RW is the be all and end all - for me,
sort the back line first and get the formation Ole wants - full backs can
provide width if we have a good spine - rn we don’t.
Sorry for undermining your question earlier - I initially thought you
were solely comparing Lingard and Ziyech’s quality - in which case, I
would say Ziyech is better. Tactical fit is another debate.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply
hide child comments

 2 points 2 hours ago


[–] Colinjames322

Agreed, which i also said in one of my other comments up there.


Backline to me is the biggest priority along with our midfield. If
we can get that sorted then it’s figuring out the attack.
I do think if we get AWB we’ll need to play a traditional RW
however as he really doesn’t contribute much going forward. If
we’re playing a 442 I hope we get meunier and rotate him and
dalot for width and go all out for a better 10 and let mata move
along.
Either way, I hope we see a system get played with players
playing positions they excel at.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[+] iuthebest  comment score below threshold (1 child)

https://old.reddit.com/r/reddevils/comments/bjpq6u/semirealistic_transfers/ 5/19
5/2/2019 Semi-Realistic Transfers : reddevils

[–] BBQ_HaX0r  Zlatan 8 points 3 hours ago


If we're in for a RW we should just splurge for Sancho. He's a proper RW and he's
young and hopefully be entering his prime by the time we complete this rebuild.
Another "tweener" type player is a bit of a luxury and weird fit, even at a
discounted price. If you're LFC and you need a different look sometimes, get him,
we need too much help.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply hide child comments

 8 points 3 hours ago


[–] Colinjames322

Couldn’t agree more.


I’d be happy with Zaha or even Pepe. I’d rather us spend big to complete our
defensive line and midfield and risk our current attackers getting their act
together.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply
hide child comments

 1 point an hour ago


[–] IlliBois

Wilf would be good he's physical too can def hold up the ball
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[–] Flanelman  Jessi 2 points 3 hours ago

Peraonally I'd be keen on a 4-3-1-2, even similar to how we've played a few times under
Ole with Jesse as a false 9 dropping and Rom/Rash coming narrow but i have seen some
Ajax fans on r/soccer say hes really good on the right aswell but yeah you could be
right, i think we do need width, especially with Martial not reeeeally supplying a
consistant threat on the left
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[–] Telen 1 point 2 hours ago


Ziyech can play in a midfield three. it wouldn't be his natural position, but he knows the
position.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

 1 point 2 hours ago


[–] united_7_devil

False 9, or RW. He is as fast as Lingard. Has a mean left foot. And scores a lot of goals.
Has an attitude though.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[–] Thesatiricaltroll  1 point 3 hours ago

I’m not ever going to buy this argument that Pogba is being “shackled” or “held back” by
not being played as a #10. A supposed world class midfielder who is a world cup winner
and that has the talent that Pogba clearly has should not be rendered useless by being
played slightly deeper.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply hide child comments

[–] BBQ_HaX0r  Zlatan 5 points 3 hours ago


Sure, you're just not getting the best out of him. You're restricting your squad. You
can play Messi at #9 and he'd do fine. He's great. Pogba's great too (obviously not

https://old.reddit.com/r/reddevils/comments/bjpq6u/semirealistic_transfers/ 6/19
5/2/2019 Semi-Realistic Transfers : reddevils

Messi class -- no one is). Look at Kante at Chelsea this year. Still good, but not in
his best position. He's had to play more advanced and his game is a bit less than it
was.
There are certain players you build around... and Pogba is one of the best CMs in
the world and someone you should sorta build around. You give him a good squad
and let him do Pogba things and he'll impress. You can can definitely make him
play a more defensive role and he'll still do well (he did pretty good under Jose).
But that's not an ideal situation.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

 1 point 2 hours ago


[–] united_7_devil

I can totally see him ending up at arsenal or Tottenham.


permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

 14 points 4 hours ago


[–] daleedginton14

Declan Rice would be a solid addition.


permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply hide child comments

[S] 8 points 4 hours ago


[–] RedDevil132

There are many good options for us to go for the CM position.


permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply hide child comments

 13 points 4 hours ago


[–] daleedginton14

West Ham love overhyped wannabes so maybe they would do a straight swap for Fred...
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply hide child comments

[–] RedDevil132[S] 8 points 4 hours ago


I would definitely swap Fred for Rice.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply hide child comments

[–] daleedginton14  10 points 4 hours ago

I’d prefer Fred the Red out there


permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply
hide child comments

[–] doesnt_like_pants  Jose Mourinho 3 points 2 hours ago

We need both out there for some delicious Fred Rice


permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[–] IlliBois  1 point 2 hours ago

We'd have to buy someone that rhymes with Red then :/


permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[S] -1 points 4 hours ago


[–] RedDevil132

Well one is a promising young talent and the other is losing the ball so
many times... not to mention we paid 50 million for him.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply
hide child comments

[–] Feutus_On_The_Couch  2 points 2 hours ago


https://old.reddit.com/r/reddevils/comments/bjpq6u/semirealistic_transfers/ 7/19
5/2/2019 Semi-Realistic Transfers : reddevils

Fred is a baller. Give him another season before shipping him out
for a Poor mans Mctominay.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

 1 point 29 minutes ago


[–] Gillett1998

Freds only a young Brazilian aswell calm down


permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[–] Eton77  Bailly 5 points 4 hours ago

God no
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[–] retrotronica  F5 Crew 1 point 2 hours ago

The best young midfielder in the game.


Would piss off the Irish reds no end though
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

 3 points an hour ago


[–] Derridas-Cat

Well overrated in my opinion. Not saying he won't turn into a class player, but he's some way
off at the moment and we're not in a position to roll the dice.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[–] sndi1765  1 point an hour ago


Next fred...
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[–] Moyes2men  Bruno Meunier Declan Tuanzebe 0 points 1 hour ago

I'd rather sign Tonali for much less. He is way better at passing and has the potential to be
much better than Neves.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[–] Flanelman  Jessi 3 points 4 hours ago

RW - Ziyech/Pepe
CDM - Rodri/Rice
CM - Ndombele/Bruno Fernandes
CB - Koulibaly/Alderweireld
RB - Wan Bissaka/Hakimi
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply hide child comments

[–] young_crown  Rashford 3 points 1 hour ago

Ziyech is not rw
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply hide child comments

https://old.reddit.com/r/reddevils/comments/bjpq6u/semirealistic_transfers/ 8/19
5/2/2019 Semi-Realistic Transfers : reddevils
[–] sndi1765  2 points 1 hour ago

We should focus on strengtening LW and AMC this year. Like we do every other year...
I.e. please check whoscored on heatmap. You will see clearly where he plays... i.e. LW
not RW
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[–] Flanelman  Jessi 1 point 1 hour ago

I know, but ive seen a lot of Ajax fans say he plays well there and i want him in the
squad to rotate between a 433 and a 4312
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply hide child comments

[–] young_crown  Rashford 1 point 1 hour ago

He drifts inside like mata


permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[–] JLingzzzzz  Rashfordinho 1 point 54 minutes ago

Hakimi is on loan at Dortmund for another year


permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[–] Aba0416  CR7 5 points 4 hours ago

Id love to get Bruno Fernandes or Ziyech for the Midfield


Toby or Umtiti for the defence.
Surely Promote mason for the attack.
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply hide child comments

[S] 2 points 4 hours ago


[–] RedDevil132

We need 2 CMs to play alongside Pogba. Fernandes is an expensive but quality option. But we
also need a defensive minded CM like Partey or Neves.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply hide child comments

 CR7 2 points 4 hours ago


[–] Aba0416

Pogba, Scott, Fred, Matic, Andreas and a New MF must be enough and also garner can
be promoted. We aren’t going to win the title next year, while we are building why not
promote 2-3 youth and see if we can get away with that.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply hide child comments

[–] L4_no15ul_3D -1 points 4 hours ago* (last edited 3 hours ago)


Pogba is the only quality midfielder we have right now and who is good enough to
start.
Scott is very average and should be on the bench or send him out on loan where
he can get game time.
Fred is also a bench option.
Matic looks like he’s on the decline and is also a bench option.
Andreas is also very average and is a bench option at best. I would sell him now
because I don’t see him having a future here and he would be leaving on a free if
you let him go next season.
Herrera looks like he’s leaving to PSG.
https://old.reddit.com/r/reddevils/comments/bjpq6u/semirealistic_transfers/ 9/19
5/2/2019 Semi-Realistic Transfers : reddevils

Garner looks great but is nowhere near first team football. He can be used a little
here and there but that’s it. Same goes for our other youth prospects like Chong,
Gomes and Mason.
So if you look at it, Pogba is the only top midfielder we have right now who would
definitely start and even he might be leaving this summer.
One midfilder is not enough. We need at least two, one to replace Herrera and
another to replace Matic. Fred and Matic can be on the bench next season. If
Pogba leaves, we need three midfielders.
Fuck, this summer could be a nightmare for Ole with the amount of positions we
need to upgrade and players who are leaving/could leave on top of all that.
Hope it all goes well.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply hide child comments

[–] JLingzzzzz  Rashfordinho 1 point an hour ago

I don't think you've seen our youth players if that's what you think
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply
hide child comments

 2 points an hour ago


[–] L4_no15ul_3D

Youth players meaning the likes of Garner, Chong, Gomes etc.? I know
they can be good players but right now they are far from playing first
team football. Let’s not overhype them and be a little more realistic.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply
hide child comments

 Rashfordinho 1 point an hour ago


[–] JLingzzzzz

Garner and Greenwood could absolutely do stuff now. I know


because, as you might guess, I watch them, not just parrot
statements while having no clue what I'm on about
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply
hide child comments

 1 point 56 minutes ago* (last edited 24 minutes ago)


[–] L4_no15ul_3D

What I’m saying is we can slowly start integrating them into


the team but there are not ready to be first team players.
How on earth would you depend on 18 year old Garner and
17 year old Greenwood who’s barely had any experience in
top level football to carry us for next season? It’s wishful
thinking.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award
reply hide child comments

[–] JLingzzzzz  Rashfordinho 1 point 39 minutes ago

They've been training with the first team all year. No


one says that they will start, but they are absolutely
good enough to be squad players next year
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report
give award reply hide child comments

 1 point 38 minutes ago


[–] L4_no15ul_3D

That’s what I’m saying.


permalink source embed save save-RES parent report
give award reply

https://old.reddit.com/r/reddevils/comments/bjpq6u/semirealistic_transfers/ 10/19
5/2/2019 Semi-Realistic Transfers : reddevils

[–] Aba0416  CR7 0 points 4 hours ago

Matic is not a bench option, Scott is not average. It’s not the 90s where we
could afford to have 5 good midfielders in one team.
Matic is just not an option viable for 60 games a season, play him for 35
games and he is still solid. Scott is more than good to play FA cup and league
games.
Pogba and the new MF can easily play all the league games and CL with a
CDM like Matic, while the other 3 can rotate for places in smaller games.
There is no chance we get CB, RB 2 CM and 1 RW this summer.
Our best chance is one RB, one CB and one CM and maybe if we are lucky a
RW.
I’m quite sure we will get 2 defenders, but the others I just hope we get
someone
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply
hide child comments

 Tony M. 8 points 3 hours ago


[–] D-V-Ant

We have to be looking past Matic already. Seems like the kind of player
who will decline very suddenly, as he has shown, so we need a decent
replacement in already.
Also let's not assume Pogba will stay. The guy is in his prime and if
we're not in the CL next season AND one of Real/PSG come knocking,
he's gone.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

 1 point 47 minutes ago


[–] drripdrrop

Playing Matic has cost us loads of games this season, he makes our
midfield leaky as fuck
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

 0 points 3 hours ago* (last edited 3 hours ago)


[–] L4_no15ul_3D

Have you seen Matic this season? He’s so slow in moving the ball
around and it’s clear he’s on the decline. He should not be our first
choice CDM.
Scott is average. He scored a goal and he puts in the work rate and he
plays for the badge and suddenly everyone thinks he’s good enough to
start for us. He’s very limited and lacks the creativity. I would be okay
with him being a bench option but I would rather him go on loan to
another club where he would get more game time and could develop
more and have his spot taken by Fred or Matic.
It’s not the 90s where we could afford to have 5 good midfielders in
one team.
I’m not saying we need 5 world class midfielders. We need midfielders
who are better than the ones we have now because they aren’t good

https://old.reddit.com/r/reddevils/comments/bjpq6u/semirealistic_transfers/ 11/19
5/2/2019 Semi-Realistic Transfers : reddevils

enough. Pogba, a new CM, a new CDM, Fred and Matic are good enough
for me next season. And let’s not forget, Pogba might still leave.
There is no chance we get CB, RB 2 CM and 1 RW this summer.
It will be hard but that’s what we need if we want to even be in top 4
next season. The players we have now are just not good enough.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply
hide child comments

[–] Aba0416  CR7 1 point 3 hours ago

People over mistake playing simple with being average. We need


Scott in our midfield. He is only going to improve technically and
intelligence.
He has the physical qualities and the passion and the technique,
all he needs is to improve the intelligence.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply
hide child comments

[–] L4_no15ul_3D -3 points 2 hours ago* (last edited 2 hours ago)


People over mistake playing simple with being average.
I’m not calling him average because he plays simple passes
but because he has very little in his locker. He has good
work rate, he has the physicality, he can tackle. That’s it.
Playing simple is great and all, but right now we need
another creative midfielder alongside Pogba so that we don’t
rely on Pogba as our only attacking outlet. We need
someone who can move the ball forward, is not afraid to
dribble past players and can pass forward better. Scott can’t
do that.
He has the physical qualities and the passion and the
technique, all he needs is to improve the intelligence.
People need to stop looking at “passion” as one of the
qualities to play for Man United. We need quality. You can
put me in a Man United shirt and stick me in that team and I
will give you passion for about 20 minutes, because then I
will be subbed off and booed off the pitch because I’m shite.
And you say he has technique? Sorry, I’ve seen him play but
he has very little of that.
I agree with you on intelligence as that comes with more
experience.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award
reply hide child comments

[–] Demonhunter910  1 point 1 hour ago


McTominay is a striker turned advanced midfielder,
and he's been playing in a holding role all season. He
hasn't been playing in a position or role that allows
him to move the ball forward much all season, and the
few times he has he's done well. Play him in the right
role with the right structure around him and he'll

https://old.reddit.com/r/reddevils/comments/bjpq6u/semirealistic_transfers/ 12/19
5/2/2019 Semi-Realistic Transfers : reddevils

improve creatively. Play him the wrong way and he'll


stagnate/go nowhere.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report
give award reply hide child comments

[–] L4_no15ul_3D 1 point 1 hour ago* (last edited 1 hour ago)


He’s been playing the b2b role. Fred has been
playing the holding role.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report
give award reply

[–] Aba0416  CR7 1 point 2 hours ago

So you are telling me you know better than SAF, MOU


and OlE combined about Scott?? Coz every single one
of them said he will be a great player.
Coz as far as I remember, whenever Mou speaks about
someone as young as Scott , they are really good.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report
give award reply hide child comments

[–] L4_no15ul_3D  1 point 2 hours ago* (last edited 2 hours


ago)

We are all basing our opinions on players by how


we see them actually play on the pitch, not
because of what previous managers has said of
what could be of said player.
It’s pretty obvious no one here knows more than
SAF or Mou, so I don’t know why you even need
to claim that.
And of course our own managers managing our
club will talk good about an academy product.
They are not going to go “Yeah, he’s pretty
average and I don’t see him having a future
here”, are they?
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report
give award reply hide child comments

continue this thread

 1 point 1 hour ago


[–] IlliBois

Stone or some Tier 2 (can't really recall) said Ole's looking for 2 CMs, an RB and an RW
as priority.
But we need CB Ole
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[–] Feutus_On_The_Couch  1 point an hour ago


https://old.reddit.com/r/reddevils/comments/bjpq6u/semirealistic_transfers/ 13/19
5/2/2019 Semi-Realistic Transfers : reddevils

Poggone
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[–] Hamish219 2 points 4 hours ago


How old is Ziyech? Watching this Ajax run he has seemed like a really good player, 25 million in
today’s market is mad.
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply hide child comments

[–] MT1120  Inconsistent FC 3 points 4 hours ago

Turned 26 a month ago. He's a phenomenal player to be honest. And he can play in the
middle and on the wing.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[–] Flanelman  Jessi 2 points 4 hours ago

Ive seen a lot of Eredevisie fans saying last 2-3 years hes been head and shoulders the best in
the league. Ive only seen a few eredevisie games so i wouldnt know personally tho.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[–] BBQ_HaX0r  Zlatan 2 points 3 hours ago

RW - Sancho (100m)
CB - Toby (25m)
RB - Meunier (35m stop gap if they see Dalot as a future RB) or...
RB - AWB (65m)
CM - N'domele (65m)
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply hide child comments

[–] lynxl  Lindelof 2 points 3 hours ago

N'domele wouldn't want to come here when Real Madrid & Juventus are sniffing around.
Could've sworn there was some article/rumor that said he was unsure about us depending on
if we are even competing in the CL next year
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[–] amalgamatedchaos  "These 4 managers are Fantastic." "Say that again..." 1 point an hour ago

Agree with all your choices, but your list is unfinished.


Circumstances have changed a lot within the last couple months. We are hearing reports that
many players will be leaving, so we have to bring in more replenishment. Also, even if no one
leaves, we still need two mids (at least.) 1 CM & 1 DM. If we lose more than one midfielder,
then we'll need a third. Then there is also a ST. Lukaku is poised to leave, but we need one
anyway, since we have a terrible goal tally. Also, a LB should be considered b/c Young is past
it, and 2 true FBs are leaving. So what happens if Shaw gets injured?
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[–] lynxl  Lindelof 2 points 3 hours ago* (last edited 2 hours ago)

Hypothetically, if we are going to still play with two forwards uptop and the rumors of Lukaku
wanting to leave are to believed. Do we really need a RW still?

https://old.reddit.com/r/reddevils/comments/bjpq6u/semirealistic_transfers/ 14/19
5/2/2019 Semi-Realistic Transfers : reddevils

ST - Icardi (Swap/+Cash for Lukaku)


RW - Sancho/Lozano (Depending on the system? unless we force them to play RCM or CAM)
CM - Bruno Fernandes/Neves (Have no clue if Fernandes would work as a RCM/box-box in a
midfield three rather than a CAM/CF to spear the diamond if we didn't have a flexible winger
on the right)
CDM - Declan Rice (Partey/Rodri committed future to Atleti)
CB - Toby Alderwireld/Koulibaly/Manolas (Toby would be the obvious bargain choice but if we
wanted to invest in a world class CB that is a little younger, then Koulibaly would be it)
GK - Jan Oblak/La font/Donnaruma
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply hide child comments

[–] young_crown  Rashford 1 point 2 hours ago

Like only 2 years younger?


permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[–] Hippotopmaus 2 points 2 hours ago


Ziyeck is wasteful af. We already have rashy for that.
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply

[–] epwondra15  De Gea 2 points an hour ago

I am going to write this for anyone who needs to hear it. Greenwood is not a solution for our
dreadful attack. Maybe in a couple years, maybe.
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply

[–] 4114HU_4KB4R  Thank you 1 point 3 hours ago

Ndidi/Rice
Tielemans(?)
AWB
Barco
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply hide child comments

[–] doesnt_like_pants  Jose Mourinho 2 points an hour ago

Barco is such an FM signing


permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply hide child comments

[–] Moyes2men  Bruno Meunier Declan Tuanzebe 1 point an hour ago

Never heard of him until now. Where / what the hell is he playing?
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[–] 4114HU_4KB4R  Thank you 1 point an hour ago

permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

 1 point 2 hours ago


[–] frihetensofa

AWB and bring back Zaha.

https://old.reddit.com/r/reddevils/comments/bjpq6u/semirealistic_transfers/ 15/19
5/2/2019 Semi-Realistic Transfers : reddevils
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply

[–] Memokerobi  1 point 2 hours ago


Some possible names I could think of for every position, ? Means idk if transfers are even semi-
realistic. You be the judge of if they are United material or not, I tried to think of everyone who has
played fairly well at their position over the last 1-2 years or have good potential.
GK - Oblak, Donnaruma ?, Yann Sommer, Anthony Lopes, Schmeicel
LB- Grimaldo, Chilwell, Alex Sandro ?, Alex Telles, Rousillon
RB- AWB, Meunier, Florenzi, Trippier, Kenny Lala, Djibril Sidibe, Danny Da Costa, Kevin Mbabu
CB- Koulibaly, Boateng, Godin, Romagnoli?, Alderweireld, Skriniar, Manolas, Ake, Upamecano,
CDM/CM- Milinkovic Savic?, Saul?, Rodri?, Ndombele, Aouar, Rabiot, Partey, Allan, Zielinski,
Doucoure, Neves, Ndidi, Brozovic, Rice
AM- Bruno Fernandes, Ziyech, Fekir, Kai Havertz, Van de Beek, Lee Kangin
Winger- Thauvin, Pepe, Brahimi, Perisic, Brandt, Leon Bailey, Guedes, Lozano, Suso, Insigne,
Callejon, Chiesa, Under, Bergwijn, Sisto, Sessegnon, Richarlison
Striker- Griezmann?, Rodrigo, Icardi ?, Lautaro Martinez ?, Belotti, Werner, Jovic, Marega,
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply hide child comments

[–] lynxl  Lindelof 1 point 2 hours ago

What is confusing me is if we even still need a winger that is willing to be benched when we
play a diamond with 2 strikers up front. Unless this winger will have to play RS at the top with
Rashford/Greenwood?
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply hide child comments

 1 point 2 hours ago


[–] Memokerobi

I don’t know what their tactical approach will be. I just listed semi-realistic players for all
positions
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

 1 point 2 hours ago


[–] drripdrrop

Alderweireld - 25 mil
Wan Bissaka - 40 mil
Ndidi - 50 mil
Fernandes - 70 mil
Brooks - 25 mil
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply

[–] ThePurpleBoy  Becks 1 point 2 hours ago

Swap lukaku with Icardi, look to get either Ziyech or Pepe. Toby in the back and maybe someone
like Bissaka, although I like more attack minded/capable full backs.
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply

 1 point 2 hours ago


[–] united_7_devil

If we get the list you have mentioned, I will be very happy.


permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply

https://old.reddit.com/r/reddevils/comments/bjpq6u/semirealistic_transfers/ 16/19
5/2/2019 Semi-Realistic Transfers : reddevils

[–] amalgamatedchaos  "These 4 managers are Fantastic." "Say that again..." 1 point 2 hours ago

OP, you're missing a ST and LB.


CF is needed whether Lukaku leaves or not. We're woeful in front of goal.
LB is also a must b/c Shaw & Dalot will be our only real FBs next season. Darmian & Valencia are
leaving, and we only have makeshifts to rotate if either of those two get injured.
P.s. You put CM twice. I think you meant DM next to Partey.
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply

 1 point an hour ago* (last edited 1 hour ago)


[–] AlephEpsilon

RW: Malcolm/ chukwueze 30m / Brais Mendez 25m.


Striker/2nd striker: Rafael Leao/ Yusuf poulsen 25m/ Wesley Moraes 40m
RB: Yucef Atal 30m / Reguilon 20m.
right CB: Ibrahima konate 40m / Jule Kounde 30m. /Joachim Andresen 25m.
Left CB: Evan N'Dicka 30m / Malang Sarr 30m.
DM: Partey 43m/ Labotka 30m/ Wylan Cyprien 25m.
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply

[–] beewebco  1 point an hour ago


Partey and Ziyech looks like no brainer to me at those prices in situation we are in. Although CL
football will be a problem for both of them I guess and both will have options. They are bot young
enough so they can give us 5-6 years at top level I guess.
Alderweireld is also good option, but at his age he is short term fix. I am not sure if he is a solution,
but I am not sure what are available options beside him. If we can go for some top defender like De
Ligt, Koulibaly or Varane, I would maybe miss him and opt for new CB/Lindelof partnership, ans
with Smalling, Bailly, Jones, Tuanzebe as backup (one of Smalling/Jones can be sold in that case)
Bissaka would be nice, not sure about price tag in his case. Also, not sure about playing time Dalot
and maybe Laird (looks like a gem at the moment) in the future will have if we have three kids
fighting for one spot. On the other hand he looks like a beast long term.
I guess Rice from West Ham is also on the radar.
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply

[–] ashu54  Please don't take my solksjaer away! 1 point an hour ago

Tielemans moved to Leicester in January.


permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply hide child comments

[–] Stebro1986  1 point 59 minutes ago


On loan
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

 1 point an hour ago


[–] teeshake

RW - Lozano
CM - Bruno Fernandes
CM - Declan Rice
CB - Toby
RB - Meunier/AWB

https://old.reddit.com/r/reddevils/comments/bjpq6u/semirealistic_transfers/ 17/19
5/2/2019 Semi-Realistic Transfers : reddevils
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply

[–] ags_rule 1 point 49 minutes ago


I can't believe so many want us to get Icardi.
We want players with the right attitude and folks here think the man whose every moment in life is
controlled by his wife is what we need?
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply

 1 point 48 minutes ago


[–] Stebro1986

Toby 25 million
Felix 90 million
Van Beek and Ziyech 70 million.
AWB 40 million
Neves 70 million
Inspired by sexy Ajax, this team will last 7 seasons
Rashford---------------ziyech
--------------felix-----------------
-------pogba----van beek----
---------------neves--------------
Shaw---toby-----lindelof---awb
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply

[–] FenrirXXVIII  Henrik Larsson 1 point 4 hours ago

Assuming we don't get CL football next season,


CB - Alderwereild
RB - Wan Bissaka or Meunier
CM - Rice
RM - Ziyech
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply hide child comments

[–] basalamader  Scholesy 2 points 4 hours ago

I haven't watched ajax much but isn't Ziyech an AMF


permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[–] young_crown  Rashford 1 point 2 hours ago

Those are West ham level signings except icardi


permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply hide child comments

[–] L4_no15ul_3D  1 point an hour ago


That’s a bit harsh. Partey, Toby and maybe even Ziyech could slot into any of the top 6 teams
atm.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply hide child comments

[–] young_crown  Rashford 1 point an hour ago


He's attitude is bad. And he's weak.
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply hide child comments

https://old.reddit.com/r/reddevils/comments/bjpq6u/semirealistic_transfers/ 18/19
5/2/2019 Semi-Realistic Transfers : reddevils

[–] L4_no15ul_3D  2 points an hour ago


Who?
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply hide child comments

[–] young_crown  Rashford 1 point 50 minutes ago

Ziyech
permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply
hide child comments

 1 point 38 minutes ago


[–] L4_no15ul_3D

I agree. He wouldn’t be my no. 1 choice at RW.


permalink source embed save save-RES parent report give award reply

[–] idodessins  Ji-Sung Park, Ander Herrera 0 points 3 hours ago

Zaha over Ziyech imo if we can't get Sancho.


With Herrera seemingly leaving...Partey could be a good chouce albeit different stylistically. Might
still provide that space for pogba to operate. Think Meunier might be better if we want to let Dalot
grow. Wan Bissaka could be great if Dalot converts to RW i guess.
permalink source embed save save-RES report give award reply

about help apps & tools <3


blog site rules Reddit for iPhone reddit premium
about Reddit help center Reddit for Android reddit coins
advertising wiki mobile website redditgifts
careers reddiquette
mod guidelines
contact us

Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy. © 2019 reddit inc. All rights reserved.
REDDIT and the ALIEN Logo are registered trademarks of reddit inc.

Advertise - sports

https://old.reddit.com/r/reddevils/comments/bjpq6u/semirealistic_transfers/ 19/19

Вам также может понравиться