Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
me/TheHindu_Zone_official
DEFAULTS BY IL&FS
MUST BE DECLARED
NPAs: IRDAI CHIEF
Financial sector may Jaypee Infra lenders
reject Suraksha bid
lose weight in Nifty
Insurance companies must declare their
exposures to Infrastructure Leasing &
Financial Services (IL&FS) non-performing NBCC top choice for homebuyers
assets (NPAs) if the infrastructure-
financing firm defaults on repayment, KARAN CHOUDHURY
said Insurance Regulatory and Bengaluru, 3 May
Development Authority of India Chairman NSE considering caps to reduce concentration of any one sector
Shubash Chandra Khuntia. Hence, The wait for the 25,000-odd homebuyers of the
insurance companies have to provide for SAMIE MODAK 24.93 per cent, followed by beleaguered Jaypee Group projects is set to RESCUE
bad investments in IL&FS and take a hit on
shareholder profit. 6>
Mumbai, 3 May financials at 21 per cent.
Similarly, the FTSE 100 index of
become longer.
According to a BSE filing by Jaypee PLANS
T
he National Stock the London Stock Exchange Infratech, the offer of the Suraksha Realty-led
Exchange of India has technology as the biggest consortium, the only player left in the race to
ECONOMY & PUBLIC AFFAIRS P6 (NSE) is considering sector with 19.6 per cent weight, acquire Jaypee Infratech, has been rejected by
REC's higher offer capping
weights in the benchmark
sectoral followed by consumer durables
and real estate at around 15 per
the Committee of Creditors (CoC) after it was
not able to get the 66 per cent votes required to
stirs up bond market Nifty50 index, a move that cent each. Japan’s Nikkei 225 get the go-ahead.
SURAKSHA REALTY’S OFFER*
Bond market participants were baffled by could trigger a sell-off in finan- has communications and tech- According to the filing, only 23.47 per cent of ~18.55 cr as upfront
an unusual deal done by government-
backed REC Ltd, which raised ~1,247 crore
cial stocks. The proposal is
aimed at providing more diver-
nology as the two biggest sec-
tors with weights of 31 per cent RESTORING BALANCE the votes were in favour of Suraksha while 41.85
per cent were against giving Jaypee Infratech
payment to lenders
from the market for bonds maturing in two
years, seven months and 15 days.
sity and reducing the concen-
tration of one sector.
and 28 per cent, respectively.
“The weight of financial
With 37%weightin Nifty50, financial stocks have
disproportionatelyhigh influence on the market
projects to them. The rest abstained from vot-
ing. Almost none of the banks voted in favour
~5,000 cr worth of land
parcels
The AAA-rated public infrastructure finance The Nifty, considered a services is at odds with the sec- Nifty Overall Sector weight (%) of Suraksha’s plans, a closer look at the Jaypee
company offered 8.5 per cent for the
money. ANUP ROY & SHREYA JAI write
barometer of the Indian econo-
my, has the representation of 13
tor’s weight in the economy. It
simply doesn’t have that kind Current Decade ago
filing shows.
“Since the members representing 23.47 per
~3,000 cr capital
infusion to complete the
sectors through 50 stocks. of share in our GDP,” said 37.36 21.87 cent of the voting rights assented to the matter,
However, financials, which Saurabh Mukherjea, founder FINANCIALS the decision on the item stands rejected,” the
construction of over
31.88 20.72 20,000 flats
include banks and non-banking and chief investment officer at papers on Voting Results for the Ninth Meeting
ON financial companies (NBFCs), Marcellus Investment Man- ENERGY
14.59
11.77
24.78
19.13
of the Committee of Creditors (CoC) of Jaypee
OTHER OFFERS
SPECIALS
SATURDAY alone account for over 37 per
cent of the index weight, exert-
agers, calling for more realign-
ment between market perform-
IT
14.14 10.51
Infratech Ltd submitted in the BSE stated.
Voting on the issue started on April 30 for NBCC
ing a disproportionately high ance and economic growth. The 10.92 8.83 banks and financial institutions as well as | ~5,000 crore worth of
WEEKENDRUMINATIONS: influence on the market. In oth- NSE has sought market feed-
CONSUMER 11.54 8.91 homebuyers and fixed-deposit holders. The land
Coldshowerafterthepolls 9> er words, the fortune of the stock back on whether it should go process ended on May 3.
GOODS 13.31 9.23 | 100 per cent equity of
market is tied closely to the per- ahead with the proposal to have According to sources close to the matter, in
The danger is that a post-poll 6.9 3.88 Yamuna Expressway, the
government might be tempted to take formance of financial stocks. a threshold on sectoral weights. AUTOMOBILE the worst-case scenario if the insolvency reso-
Experts say most popular Based on the response, the 7.1 4.67 lution professional (IRP) does not come up with
only cash generating
comfort from moderate inflation and opt asset with Jaypee Infra
for expansionist policies in order to global indices don’t have a sec- exchange could cap a sector’s Note: Overall is representation in all NSE-listed stocks Source: NSE any plan, Jaypee Infratech might head for liq-
deliver on unaffordable poll promises, toral cap, but the weight of the weight at 25 per cent, or align uidation. If that happens homebuyers are in | Promise of giving house
writes T N NINAN top sector in markets like the with the broader market. The | NSE, which has sought market feedback, the danger of not getting their apartments. keys in three years
US, Japan and the UK is little share of financial companies in could cap a sector’s weight at 25 per cent, or However, sources close to the CoC are cer- Jaypee Group
NATIONALINTEREST: Modi compared to India. Also, sector the overall listed universe is tain that Jaypee Infratech projects will now
meetshismatchinMamata 9>
align it with the broader market | Chairman Manoj Gaur has
weights in the developed world 31.88 per cent — high but still head for a third round of bidding. This would
Modi & Shah are street-fighters trying to are more in sync with the real below its Nifty weight. | Plan is aimed at providing more diversity and allow not only state-run NBCC to participate in promised to infuse
win Bengal through Hindu-Muslim economy. For instance, in the In a discussion paper, the bidding but also give a chance to the promoters ~2,000 crore to complete
bringing sector weights in sync with real economy
polarisation. But Mamata is fighting Dow Jones Industrial Average, NSE has said sectoral caps of Jaypee Group as well as Adani Group to pending apartments over
their poison with her own. an index of 30 large US-listed would lead to diversification but | Experts say the weight of financial services is throw their hat in the ring to grab the project, the next four years
SHEKHAR GUPTA writes companies, the technology sec- has also listed several negative at odds with the sector’s weight in the economy worth over ~8,000 crore. *Offer rejected on Friday
tor has the highest weight at aspects. Turn to Page 10 > Turn to Page 10 >
YES,BUT...: Celebritycouples
sparkleforbrands 9>
The era of the Celebrity Couple is finally
here, writes SANDEEP GOYAL, in the
first of a fortnightly column for CYCLONE FANI BATTERS EAST COAST N EARNINGS CENTRAL N
Business Standard
HULvolume Cognizantprojects
PAGE 16
POLITICS & PUBLIC AFFAIRS growthlowest slowestgrowth
Cong leaders to take insixquarters initshistory
general coaches to spread
NYAY message Thecountry’slargestconsumergoods US-basedinformationtechnology(IT)
Up to phase VI, number of company,HindustanUnilever(HUL), servicesfirmCognizantslasheditsfull-
women in fray crosses 600 reporteditslowestvolumegrowthinsix yearrevenueguidancefor2019byalmost
POLL quartersfortheJanuary-March2019 halfonFriday.ThisistheITfirm’sslowest
VAULT TMC digs deep, doesn’t
2019 periodasruraldemandmoderated.Forthe growthprojectionever.Thiswasdueto
rule out queen’s chair quarterunderreview,HULsaw7percent executionissuesandslowgrowthinitskey
volumegrowth,asagainst11percentinthe verticals—financialservicesandhealthcare.
year-agoperiod.Intheperiodbetween TheTeaneck-headquarteredfirm,which
COMPANIES P3 December31,2017andDecember31,2018, misseditsrevenueguidanceforthefirst
Big Four can’t offer legal HULreportedvolumegrowthintheregion
of10-12percent. 2>
quarter(January-March),saiditwould
considervariouscostoptimisation
services: Bar Council measures,includingadditionalemployee
In a double-whammy for the Big Four “FACTORS SUCH AS A STABLE separationprogrammes,aspartofits
audit-cum-consultancy firms — Deloitte,
EY, KPMG and PwC — the Bar Council of Delhi
GOVERNMENT AND A GOOD realignmentefforts.Thefirm'sfinancial
yearisfromJanuarytoDecember.Accor-
has directed the four firms to refrain from MONSOON WILL PLAYA dingtotherevisedguidance,Cognizantis
providing legal services to clients till further KEY ROLE, BUT I REMAIN likelytoclockfull-yearrevenuegrowthin
notice. The Society of Indian Law Firm said in
its complaint that the Big Four were actually
OPTIMISTIC therangeof3.6-5.1percentfor2019,as
againstitsearlierguidanceof7-9percentin
accounting firms, but were engaged in ABOUT THE constantcurrencyterms. 2>
“doing law practice”. FUTURE”
SANJIV
MEHTA
Q1 REPORT CARD
> SENSEX YoY QoQ
THIS WEEK A view of the destruction caused by Cyclone Fani in Puri, Odisha, on Friday PHOTO: PTI
Chairman & MD,
HUL Parameter growth growth
Landfall Magnitude Victims Damage Flights MARKETS P10 Revenue $4.11 bn 5.1% -0.5%
39,200 Fani,orthe Thestrongesttropical Eightpeople Roadandpower Operationsat > THE COMPASS: HUL investors need to cool Net profit $441 mn -15% -32%
39,067 39,100 hoodofsnake, cyclonetohitIndiain20 killedin infrastructure Bhubaneshwarand
39,000 madelandfall years.Itunleashedheavy separate severelyhitin Kolkataairportsremained
expectations after weak Q4 show Operating
COMPANIES P2 16% -170* -350*
38,900 around8am rainandwindstorm incidentsin severaldistricts; suspendedformanyhours; margin
38,963 38,800 inPuri gustingupto200kmph Odisha Purisufferedworst likelytoresumetoday > GODREJ CONSUMER PBT FALLS 32% *Basis points Note: Cognizant follows Jan-Dec financial calendar
38,700
Apr26 2019 May3
IN BRIEF
Vodafone Idea, IBM sign Now, farmers seek damages from PepsiCo
multi-million dollar IT deal Unions say farmers’ ‘right to seeds’ is non-negotiable
India's largest telecom operator
Vodafone Idea on Friday announced a VINAY UMARJI PepsiCo had on Thursday said it had for pressuring PepsiCo to agree to their
five-year multi-million dollar IT Ahmedabad, 3 May agreed to withdraw cases against potato demands for compensation. “We are not
outsourcing deal with tech giant IBM. growers in Gujarat after discussions with the going to approach the courts for compen-
“...this engagement will also eeking an unconditional withdrawal government. The company had sued nine sation but will take a call as and when
contribute to Vodafone Idea's merger
synergy objectives by reducing its IT
related costs,” the telecom firm said in
S of the case, the potato growers in
Gujarat, who were sued by PepsiCo
India Holdings, said on Friday that they
potato farmers in Gujarat, including five last
year and four this year, for allegedly buying
seeds and selling potato of the FL 2027 vari-
PepsiCo files for withdrawal of cases in the
courts,” the farmers said.
On Friday, farmers and activists also
a statement. The company did not have sought compensation from the cola ety registered by PepsiCo. This variety is used announced forming of a new outfit called Bij
divulge the size of the deal but some reports pegged it at about $700 and food giant for the harassment caused by PepsiCo for making ‘Lays’ chips. Adhikar Manch (Rights for Seeds Forum). A
million. “The collaboration will provide Vodafone Idea with a to them due to the lawsuit. “After discussions with the govern- meeting of 30 members under the new enti-
hybrid cloud based digital platform to enable more intimate In a press briefing on Friday, three of the ment, the company has agreed to with- ty, comprising farmers, farm leaders, civil
engagement with its over 387 million subscribers (as of December 31, potato farmers sued by PepsiCo along with draw cases against farmers. We are relying rights representatives, lawyers and scien-
2018), enhancing business efficiency, agility and scale plus farmer union leaders and farmers’ rights on the discussions to find a long-term and tists, was also held in Ahmedabad on Friday
simplification of its business processes,” it said. The new activists asserted that Indian farmers’ 'right amicable resolution of all issues around where the forum decided to call for a nation-
infrastructure platform will remove constraints to exponential to seeds' was non-negotiable. seed protection. The company remains wide boycott of PepsiCo products.
growth of data usage driven by increasing consumption of video, With support from other farmer deeply committed to the thousands of The forum will now continue to fight for
streaming and digital commerce, the statement said, adding that it organisations and activists, including the farmers we work with across the country farmers’ sovereign rights seeds, said its co-
will also drive enhanced customer experience to millions of RSS-affiliate Bharatiya Kisan Sangh and towards ensuring adoption of best ordinator Kapil Shah.
connected consumers and businesses in India. PTI< (BKS), the potato growers have not only farming practices,” a PepsiCo India Friday also saw PepsiCo India officials
sought compensation but also called for spokesperson had stated. hold a meeting with Gujarat government
boycott of the food giant’s products. The sued potato farmers also called officials, including chief secretary of the
“PepsiCo should withdraw the cases for more awareness of the legislation state and additional chief secretary for agri-
RBI slaps ~11-lakh RBI slaps penalty unconditionally. The company has to also around plant varieties among farmers culture, in state capital Gandhinagar.
fine on YES Bank for on PhonePe, Voda pay us compensation for all the harass- across the country. Addressing mediapersons after the
violating norms m-pesa, 3 others ment we were put through even though
the law is clear on the subject,” said Bipin
“The court proceedings came as a shock
to us, including the amount of damages
meeting in Gandhinagar, Jagrut Kotecha,
vice-president snacks, PepsiCo India, said,
YES Bank on Friday said the The Reserve Bank of India Patel, one of the four potato growers that the company was claiming. It was “We had come to update the state govern-
Reserve Bank of India has Friday said it has imposed against whom PepsiCo had filed a suit, in clearly trying to intimidate and harass us. ment about the statement we had issued
imposed a penalty of ~11.25 penalties on five prepaid KEY POINTERS a media briefing on Friday. Its real intention may have been to wipe earlier on Thursday and are looking forward
lakh on it for violating money payment instrument (PPI) “We would like the state government out competitors from the market, but it to an amicable solution for everyone.”
> Potato growers seek rights on seeds
transfer norms. "(The) Reserve issuers, including Vodafone to reveal full details of the ongoing discus- chose to harass farmers,” they said. When asked about withdrawal of cases
Bank of India (RBI) vide its m-pesa and PhonePe, for unconditional withdrawal > PepsiCo had earlier sions with the company since we are On the other hand, Maganbhai Patel of against the potato growers, Kotecha told
speaking order dates April 22, violation of regulatory norms. of case with compensation offered an out-of-court demanding an unconditional withdrawal BKS said that it was possible to get a large mediapersons that PepsiCo India would
2019, imposed a penalty of Also, penalties have been > Seek details of govt’s settlement based on a reiteration of Section 39 (1) (iv) multinational company to back out very withdraw the cases as and when the mat-
~11,25,000 under the Payment imposed on Western Union discussions with PepsiCo of the Protection of Plant Varieties and quickly, given that the PPV&FR Act 2001 ter came up for hearing before the court.
> Food major works with
and Settlement Systems Act, Financial Services Inc and Farmers’ Rights (PPV&FR) Act 2001, and was clearly on the farmers’ side. The next hearing in the matter has been
> Invoke Section 39 of around 1,200 potato
2007," YES Bank said in a MoneyGram Payment Systems anything else is not acceptable,” the pota- The potato growers and farmer activists scheduled for June 12 at a commercial
regulatory filing. PTI< Inc, both US firms, for non- PPV&FR Act for asserting farmers in Gujarat to growers said. also sought support from the government court in Ahmedabad.
compliance of guidelines. PTI<
Embassy Office
Parks to raise ~3K cr SpiceJet to add NEARNINGS CENTREN
via debentures 12 more flights
from May 11
HUL volume growth declines
Embassy Office Parks, which
recently launched India's first
real estate investment trust
(REIT), Friday said it will raise
~3,000 crore through the
allotment of debentures on a
private placement basis. Emba-
ssy Office Parks, a joint venture
as rural show disappoints
between global investment firm
Blackstone and realty firm
SpiceJet has announced
introduction of 12 new flights
Revenue, net profit company was in terms of oper-
ating profit, or earnings before
Embassy Group, had raised from New Delhi and Mumbai to miss analysts’ interest, tax, depreciation, and
~4,750 crore through REIT. PTI< other destinations. Of the 12 amortisation, which rose 13.2
new services, which comm- estimates even as per cent in Q4FY19 over
L&T Technology
ence from May 11, six are to and margins improve Q4FY18 to ~2,314 crore. This
Services Q4 net
profit up 21%
from Mumbai while the rest
connects the national Capital,
SpiceJet said in a statement. VIVEAT SUSAN PINTO
was in line with the consensus
estimate of ~2,348 crore.
Operating margin expanded
Cognizant projects
slowest growth ever
The airline will deploy Boeing Mumbai, 3 May 90 basis points to 23.3 per cent
L&T Technology Services (LTTS) on 737 NG aircraft on these routes, in Q4. A basis point is one-hun-
Friday posted about 21 per cent it said, adding the new services Hindustan Unilever (HUL), the dredth of a percentage point.
rise in consolidated net profit to from Mumbai will be operated country’s largest consumer HUL also declared final
~191.5 crore for the fourth from Terminal 2. PTI< goods company, reported its dividend of ~13 per share on GIREESH BABU & “Cognizant’s growth and
quarter of 2018-19, helped by lowest volume growth in six Friday. When added to the DEBASIS MOHAPATRA performance in the quarter
broad-based growth across
industry segments. The comp- Birla Corp’s Q4
quarters for the January-
March period (Q4), on the back
KEY FINANCIALS interim dividend of ~9 per
share announced earlier, the
Chennai/Bengaluru, 3 May leaves room for improvement,”
said Chief Executive Officer
Reported
any's revenue from operations
stood at ~1,343.1 crore, up 27 per
net profit at of moderation in rural
demand. Quarter Net sales YOY Chg Profit After YOY Chg
total dividend stands at ~22 per
share for FY19. This is 10 per
US-based information tech-
nology (IT) services firm
Brian Humphries adding:
“While I am encouraged by our
cent year-on-year and two per ~128.19 crore For the quarter under (~ cr) (%) Tax (~ cr) (%) cent higher that the total divi- Cognizant slashed its full- client centricity, our employ-
cent on a sequential basis. "We Birla Corporation’s net profit review, HUL saw 7 per cent vol- Dec-17 8,323 10.8 1,326 27.7 dend of ~20 per share given in year revenue guidance for ees’ winning spirit and our
had an excellent year, growing during the quarter ended ume growth against 11 per cent FY18, said Chief Financial 2019 by almost half on Friday. innovation, we are not yet
Mar-18 9,003 11.1 1,351 14.2
ahead of the industry once March 31, 2019 fell by 2.23 per in the year-ago period. From Officer Srinivas Phatak. This is the IT firm’s slowest delivering against the market
again. Growth in the financial cent at ~128.19 crore as against the December 2017 quarter to Jun-18 9,356 11.4 1,529 19.2 Shares of HUL fell more growth projection ever. This opportunity. We are commit-
year 2018-19 was broad-based the net profit of ~131.12 crore December 2018 quarter Sep-18 9,138 11.5 1,525 19.5 than 2 per cent on Friday to was due to execution issues ted to strengthening our exe-
and we achieved our target of registered in the similar quarter (Q3FY18 to Q3FY19), HUL close at ~1,692.80 apiece on the and slow growth in its key cution to invest in growth.”
double-digit growth in all five of the last fiscal year. Its net reported volume growth in the Dec-18 9,357 12.4 1,444 8.9 BSE, before the earnings verticals — financial services The firm’s operating mar-
of our industry segments," LTTS revenue, on the other hand region of 10-12 per cent, after Mar-19 9,809 9.0 1,538 13.8 announcement, which came and health care. gin dropped 350 basis points to
CEO and MD Keshab Panda said. grew by 13.44 per cent at gaining from price cuts under Source: Capitaline Compiled by BS Research Bureau after market hours. On the seg- The New Jersey-headquar- 16 per cent in Q1 of 2019. Based
PTI< ~1,872.76 crore as compared to the goods and services tax ment front, revenue from the tered firm, which missed its on current foreign exchange
the earning of ~1,650.81 crore regime, coupled with con- fast moving consumer goods HUL’s net profit rose 13.8 home care business rose 12.9 revenue guidance for the first rates, the company expects its
on a year-on-year basis. sumer uptick in urban and (FMCG) market grew 13.6 per per cent year-on-year (YoY) to per cent to ~3,502 crore. quarter (January-March), said second quarter and full-year
NDMC may charge BS REPORTER< rural areas. cent in Q4, versus 15.9 per cent ~1,538 crore in Q4, lower than Revenue from the beauty and it would consider various cost 2019 revenue growth to be neg-
Hotel Lalit ~8 cr per On Friday, Chairman and
Managing Director Sanjiv
and 16.5 per cent in the
December and September
the Bloomberg consensus esti-
mate of ~1,611 crore. Revenue
personal care segment grew 7.3
per cent to ~4,393 crore.
optimisation measures, incl-
uding additional employee sep-
atively affected by 130 basis
points and 90 basis points,
month licence fees Cement firms Mehta said that rural growth, quarters, respectively. (net sales plus other operating Revenue for the food and aration programmes, as part of respectively, translating to
Hotel Lalit in Central Delhi will
soon have to cough up around
under scanner for which was earlier 1.3 times
urban growth, was now in line
While Mehta said that the
FMCG market would bounce
income) rose 9.3 per cent YoY
to ~9,945 crore, marginally low-
refreshment segment rose 10.4
per cent to ~1,916 crore.
its realignment efforts. The
company follows a January-
growth of 2.6-3.6 per cent ($4.11-
$4.15 billion) for the quarter and
~8 crore a month as license over-loading with urban growth, indicating back in the near term, Nielsen er than the Street’s estimates of Kaustubh Pawaskar, rese- December financial calendar. 2.7-4.2 per cent ($16.55-$16.80
fees to the NDMC as the civic Truck over-loaded with slowdown in rural areas. lowered its forecast for CY19, ~10,001 crore. Net sales, mean- arch analyst at Sharekhan, said: According to the revised billion) for this year.
body is planning to revise the cement bags would now land Market research agency saying growth would be while, grew 9 per cent YoY to “Weakening demand in the guidance, Cognizant is likely to “Over the coming quarters,
charges. The revision of the even the manufacturer of the Nielsen had last month hinted around 12 per cent as against ~9,809 crore. rural market will impact per- clock full-year revenue growth we intend to bring our cost
license fees has been long due product into trouble in at the same, stating that the 14 per cent in CY18. The only respite for the formance in the near term. in the range of 3.6-5.1 per cent structure closer in line with our
for the hotel. The New Delhi Chhattisgarh. The state for 2019, as against its earlier revised revenue expectations,”
Municipal Council (NDMC) is government had taken a guidance of 7-9 per cent in con- said Karen McLoughlin, chief
supposed to renew the licence
fee every 33 years as per the
licence deed, which is for 99
years. However, the 33-year
decision to lodge FIR with the
police against cement com-
pany if vehicle ferrying its
product was intercepted with
‘Liquidity crunch, low food inflation stant currency terms.
Infosys guided for a revenue
growth rate of 7.5-9.5 per cent
for this financial year, while the
financial officer of Cognizant.
The IT services firm, which
has a majority of its employees
in India, incurred $2 million in
period for Lalit Hotel had
expired in 2014. The five-star
hotel currently pays ~12 lakh
over load. The company would
also face legal action for dam-
aging state’s resources as over-
contributed to rural slowdown’ TCS management was confi-
dent of achieving double-digit
revenue growth during this
costs associated with the CEO
transition, apart from the
departure of its president in Q1.
per month as license fees to loaded trucks would damage Hindustan Unilever (HUL) navigated a challenging March quarter as the period. In the first quarter of It is likely to incur another
the civic body. PTI< the roads. BS REPORTER< sector witnessed a slowdown. In a press conference, Chairman and this year, Cognizant posted 15 $23 million during the rest of
Managing Director SANJIV MEHTA responded to questions from per cent decline in net profit to 2019. Owing to the Supreme
Viveat Susan Pinto on what lies ahead for the company. Excerpts: $441 million, compared to $520 Court's order, the IT firm is also
Bharti Airtel plans to kick off How long do you see the demand. Rural growth is
million in the year-ago period.
Revenue stood at $4.11 bil-
expecting additional liability
arising out of defined contri-
slowdown lasting? Nielsen now in line with urban lion in Q4, a rise of 5.1 per cent bution obligations towards
IPO of $5-bn Africa phone unit has given a lower forecast growth, which wasn’t the on a year-on-year (YoY) basis. employees this year.
for CY19 versus CY18. What case earlier. Rural growth In constant currency terms, rev-
BLOOMBERG being boosted by emerging- are your thoughts on this? was 1.3 times that of urban enue growth was 6.8 per cent. More on business-standard.com
London/Mumbai, 3 May market companies seeking a I see the market bouncing growth, a few quarters ago.
wider investor pool. Finablr, back in the near term. Yes, But factors such as
Bharti Airtel, India’s second- the currency-exchange firm
biggest wireless carrier, is controlled by an Abu Dhabi-
factors such as a stable
government at the Centre
liquidity crunch and food
inflation being on the lower
Godrej Consumer PBT falls 32%
preparing to kick off the initial based billionaire, starting and a good monsoon will be side (which has impacted PHOTO:KAMLESH PEDNEKAR FMCG major Godrej Consumer Products (GCPL) reported a 32 per
public offering of its Africa unit taking orders this week for a key, but I remain optimistic. farm income), have cent decline in its consolidated profit before tax from ~737.59
in a deal that could raise about share sale that could raise as The market has a seen a contributed to the slowdown we will have to wait. improvement in operating crore in March 2018 quarter to ~500.57 crore in the fourth quar-
$1 billion, people familiar with much as $677 million. West reversal after a few quarters in rural areas. Wages have margins in the Q4? What ter of 2018-19. It reported a 51.5 per cent increase in conso-
the matter said. Asian payments of robust growth, but I am not also not grown significantly, Will price growth return to strategy do you have in place lidated net profit to ~935.24 crore in the fourth quarter ended
Airtel Africa is Airtel Africa is processor Network giving up. The new impacting consumer the market or will you cont- to improve margins? March 2019, but that was largely due to write-back of tax credit
planning to make a planning to International government that confidence. Having inue to depend on volume There is no big differentiator. on account of minimum alternative tax. Adjusted for the tax
formal announce- make a formal Holdings Plc comes to power will said that, I believe the growth, which is now slo- What we are focusing on is adjustments, which include other deferred tax treatment, the
ment about the announcement raised £1.1 billion make an effort to kick- tide will turn. FMCG wing? our product mix. We are net profit declined by 35.7 per cent year-on-year to ~500.57
London listing this about the ($1.4 billion) last start the economy. This growth rates have not Price growth happens when managing our costs crore. Total revenue from operations during the quarter fell
month and aims to London listing month in the should improve vanished. So, there is there are reasons such as efficiently and looking to 3.06 per cent to ~2,481.72 crore, compared with ~2,560.14 crore
start trading in June, this month and largest London sentiment and demand. no panic situation here. input cost pressures rising, or drive savings. We will in the corresponding quarter of the previous fiscal.
the people said, ask- aims to start IPO this year. when you put a compelling continue to look at 7 per cent GCPL executive chairperson Nisaba Godrej said, “We
ing not to be identi- trading in June Valuation and Apart from rural areas, What kind of an impact do proposition in terms of a of cost savings as an engine delivered a relatively weak performance in the fourth quarter of
fied because the the listing date are where else is there a you see on your business, product in the marketplace. for margin improvement fiscal year 2019. Our India business remained soft on account of a
matter is private. It’s consider- still under discussion, and slowdown? with India witnessing an Today, we are happy with and growth. general slowdown in staples consumption and the adverse
ing seeking an equity valuation final details could change In terms of distribution extremely severe cyclonic where the price-led growth In fact, the operating impact of the delayed summer on our portfolio.” During the
of about $5 billion, they said. depending on investor channels, general trade and storm in the east? is, and will work on pricing as margin of 23 per cent (in Q4) is quarter, GCPL’s India sales were marginally down 0.9 per cent to
The IPO could be one of demand and market senti- wholesale have slowed down There will be an impact, but and when the situation the highest-ever for us. We ~1,356.09 crore, while its international business sales grew 10
the biggest in London this ment, the people said. A rep- in the March quarter. it is difficult to make an demands. also delivered margin per cent on a constant currency basis, said GCPL in a statement.
year. The exchange’s lacklus- resentative for Bharti Airtel However, this is linked to the assessment right now. expansion in 30 out of 31 Its revenue from the Indonesian business was up 19.34 per cent
ter domestic volumes are declined to comment. moderation in rural Odisha is a huge market but What explains the 90 bps quarters, which is significant. while Africa business grew of 13.15 per cent. BS REPORTER & PTI
.
MUMBAI | 4 MAY 2019 COMPANIES 3 <
legal services
in India would need to turn to
5G deployments to reduce
cost and improve perform-
ance, said Swedish telecom
equipment provider Ericsson
on Friday. Ericsson has
SUDIPTO DEY announced 18 commercial 5G
New Delhi, 3 May dealsgloballyandispartofthe
first wave of live 5G networks
I
n a double-whammy of acrosstheUS,EuropeandAsia.
sorts for the Big Four “The important aspect is
audit-cum-consultancy that its is critical for our cus-
firms — Deloitte, EY, KPMG tomers (operators) to move to
and PwC — the Bar Council 5G than for the end sub-
of Delhi has directed the com- scribers. 5G will drive down
panies to refrain from provid- the cost per gigabit and by
ing legal services to clients till deploying it they can deploy
further notice. The Bar Council order asked ed practices. The recent melt- much higher capacity at a
This follows a complaint the four firms to provide a list of down at the Infrastructure much lower cost to cater to
filed by the Society of Indian advocates on their rolls. The Leasing & Financial Services the rapidly growing demand
Law Firms (SILF), representing order copy said while Deloitte (IL&FS) group has put the spot- and smoother user experi-
around 100 Indian law firms. and KPMG filed their response light on statutory auditors. ence,” said Ludvig Landgren,
SILF said in its complaint that to the complaint, PwC and EY Many in the chartered head of network applications
the Big Four were actually asked for more time to submit accountantfraternitywereofthe and cloud infrastructure,
accounting firms, but are response. The Council has view that there were grey areas Ericsson South East Asia,
engaged in “doing law practice”. deferred the matter for further over jurisdiction of non-litiga- Oceania & India.
It had filed a similar complaint hearing to July 12. It asked the tion related legal services. In Ericsson also announced
to the Bar Council in 2015, alleg- four firms to refrain from the theirearlierresponsein2015,one that it has been selected by
ing that the Big Four were practice until further orders. of the Big Four said that it was Vodafone Idea to deploy its
resorting to “unauthorised This has come at a time not “engaged in the practice of Cloud Packet Core to enhance
practice of law” in violation of when the Big Four firms are law”. A source in one of the four its existing core network.
the Advocates Act. under scanner for audit-relat- firms reiterated the same stand. ROMITA MAJUMDAR
E
Warren Buffett said he had
autonomous-driving ple said. been buying Amazon shares been “an idiot for not buying” Berkshire’s annual sharehold-
technology as “trans- Tesla later increased the and the purchases will show Amazon’s shares in the past ers meeting, set for Saturday
formative” to Tesla in a call size of the stock offering, pric- up in a regulatory filing later in Omaha. Thousands are
Peter Mayhew, who Joblessness rate in aimed at ginning up interest ing 3.1 million shares at $243 this month, Buffett told CNBC in recent years. Buffett credit- expected to flock to the city.
played Chewbacca in US hits 49-year-low in the electric-car maker’s each, according to a person in an interview on Thursday. ed some of his conglomerate’s Buffett has mostly avoid-
Star Wars, dies at 74 in April debt and stock offering of familiar with the matter, who Buffett, Berkshire’s chairman purchases of airline stocks ed technology-related stocks
about $2 billion, according to asked not to be identified and CEO, said “one of the fel- and Apple to the deputies and over the years, saying he did-
Actor Peter The United States had another two people who dialed in. because they weren’t author- lows in the office that man- noted their involvement in n’t understand the products
Mayhew, giant month of job creation The chief executive officer ized to speak about it. That’s a age money” made the pur- helping Berkshire beyond and markets well enough. One
who won in April, with strong hiring in said autonomy is a funda- Tesla CEO Elon Musk 0.5 per cent discount to chases, a reference to their stock-picking duties. exception was IBM -- his $10
over fans the vast services sector and mental driver for Tesla and Thursday’s close. The offer- investment managers Todd The Amazon stake further billion investmentin 2011 did-
worldwide as unemployment fell to a level key to how it could become a that will be fully capable of ing was increased from 2.7 Combs and Ted Weschler. cements the relationship n’t end well. After taking loss-
the Wookiee not seen since 1969, the “half-trillion dollar market driving themselves. The bil- million shares. Tesla shares Combs and Weschler have between Berkshire and es, he had sold nearly all the
warrior government reported on cap company,” said the peo- lionaire plans to put those cars rose 1.3 per cent to $247.38 at gained influence at Berkshire Bezos’s company. Berkshire is IBM stock by 2018.
Chewbacca in the blockbuster Friday. The blockbuster report ple, who asked not to be iden- into a shared robotaxi service 4.36 am in New York in pre-
StarWarsmovies, has died at will help allay fears of a slowing tified because the call wasn’t that the CEO described as market trading.
the age of 74, his family economy and cheer President open to the public. A Tesla being lucrative for both the Tesla delivered just
announced on Thursday. Donald Trump as he seeks spokesman didn’t immedi- company and its customers. 63,000 cars in the first quar- US lawmakers urge authorities not to end GSP benefits to India
Mayhew died on Tuesday at his reelection next year. Employers ately respond to a request for Ahead of the call, Tesla ter but said in a letter to
home in Texas, the family said scooped up workers in comment. filed to raise at least $2 billion shareholders last week that The US should not terminate the Generalised The GSP is the largest and oldest US trade
in a statement released on the construction, health care, The comments build on through debt and stock offer- it expects to deliver between System of Preference (GSP) programme with preference programme that allow duty-free entry
actor's Twitter account. "He put computer systems design, the case that Musk made dur- ings, after a dismal first quar- 90,000 and 100,000 vehicles India after the expiry of the 60-day notice period for thousands of products from designated ben-
his heart and soul into the role administrative support and ing an investor day focused ter depleted its cash balance in the second quarter. on Friday, a group of 25 influential American eficiary countries. On March 4, President Trump
of Chewbacca and it showed in other industries, adding a total on autonomy last week that to the lowest level in three Kirkhorn re-affirmed that lawmakers has urged the US Trade Repr- announced that the US intends to terminate
every frame of the films...,” the of 263,000 net new positions for Tesla is on the cusp of having years. Goldman Sachs and forecast during the Thursday esentative, warning that companies seeking to India’s designations as a beneficiary developing
statement said. REUTERS< the month. FP/PTI< 1 million vehicles on the road Citigroup hosted the call for call, the people said. expand their exports to India could be hit. country under the GSP programme. PTI
.
MUMBAI | 4 MAY 2019 ECONOMY 5 <
T
he India Railways’ catering arm The concept of RailYatri came to
— Indian Railway Catering and the minds of promoters when they
Tourism Corporation (IRCTC) — worked with Indian Railways and
is now at loggerheads with private sec- Centre for Railway Information
tor service providers and applications Systems (CRIS) to develop
— including Nandan Nilekani-backed TrainEnquiry.com in 2012, where they
RailYatri and TravelKhana — that were realised that passengers had other
supplying food on trains. needs, which can be well communi-
According to people in the know, cated in a visual and graphic manner.
IRCTC has approached two lower Its application is currently available
courts in Karkarduma and Rohini (New in eight languages – Hindi, Marathi,
Delhi), saying that the online food Gujarati, Bengali, Tamil, Telugu,
ordering services provided by these Malayalam and Kannada.
companies are illegal. This comes after The average number of meals booked by e-catering on trains daily has now Delhi-based Duronto Technologies
the Delhi High Court recently ruled increased to about 10,000, from 5,188 in FY18 runs TravelKhana that had also raised
that railway ticketing services by the funds from seed funds such as Astarc
website and mobile application already approached the two local At present, the Railways’ arm has a Ventures and some high net-worth
RailYatri was unauthorised. courts against the on-track food tie-up with players like Dominos, individuals.
The court rejected a plea filed by providers, and expects a favourable RelFood, RailRestro, Comesum, At present, IRCTC’s e-catering serv-
Stelling Technologies, which owns and judgement, following the ruling by the Rajdhani Online Food and Zoop. ices are available at 409 A and A-1 class
operates RailYatri. The firm is backed Delhi High Court. Any impact on the “We are now working with the con- stations, for which 136 vendors and 12
by Nilekani and investors like Helion food business may affect RailYatri’s cerned authorities to complete the aggregators are empanelled.
Ventures and Omidyar Network. The business, given about 20 per cent of its required compliances according to the The average number of meals
firm had approached the Delhi High revenue stream comes from this. operating framework of IRCTC, and booked daily has now increased to
Court after IRCTC reportedly filed a This comes at a time when IRCTC is expect this to be completed at the ear- about 10,000. This average daily
petition with the Delhi Police, stating in talks with food-delivery service liest,” said Manish Rathi, chief execu- bookings under e-catering for FY18
that the ticket booking services pro- providers and restaurant aggregators tive officer and co-founder of RailYatri, stood at 5,188 meals. IRCTC provides
vided by RailYatri was illegal. such as UberEats, Zomato, Foodpanda, regarding the Delhi High Court ruling. a total of around 1.2 million meals per
An Indian Railways official told Biryani Blues, Faasos, PizzaHut and TravelKhana, however, did not respond day, out of which around 1 million are
Business Standard that IRCTC has Swiggy, to deliver food to trains. to queries by Business Standard. travelers on train.
No gold shifted
around 90.5% of the post- will automatically do it. There financial companies governance standards in insur- essentially means large-sized just for testing waters before increased and the market is
merger enhanced equity capi- is a method of treating NPAs, ance companies and requested contiguous spectrum,” raising more money from oth- discriminating between
but I am confident
outside India in 2014 tal of the entity. BS REPORTER< which is the same as the one
the insurance
them to ensure transparency. COAI Director General er sources. companies and NBFCs, too.
used by banks under RBI “We have seen the kind of Rajan Mathews told “Currently, the market is If an AAA-rated manufac-
or thereafter: RBI guidelines,” said Khuntia. industry will not turmoil in non-banking finan- Business Standard. anyway sensitive to NBFCs. turing company is raising
The Reserve Bank of India on Foreign exchange The RBI last week asked
have that kind of a cial companies but I am confi- Mathews said the rollout So, we are just playing around. money at 100 basis points
Friday said no gold was reserves rise by banks and financial institu-
problem”
dent the insurance industry of the 5G spectrum in the This is one-time issuance and above equivalent maturity
shifted outside India in 2014 tions to declare the details of will not have that kind of a absence of contiguous spec- does not set any precedent. government securities (G-
or thereafter. The statement $4.4 bn to $418.5 bn their exposure and provisions S C KHUNTIA, problem. The insurance indus- trum would not be possible. Once we have concluded rais- Secs), an AAA-rated private
comes against the backdrop India’s foreign exchange related to the IL&FS group. Chairman, Irdai try should provide stability in He said fibre was a major ing funds through external NBFC will be raising the
of reports in certain reserves soared by $4.368 The National Company times of turmoil,” Khuntia said. requirement for the penetra- commercial borrowing (ECB), same money at 150-160 basis
sections of the print and billion to $418.515 billion in Law Tribunal (NCLAT) on recovery process because there He outlined initiatives the tion of 5G spectrum and there- our rates will stabilise,” said points above G-Secs.
social media regarding the the week to April 26, helped Thursday allowed banks to was a moratorium period. regulator was planning to fore the government should the official, requesting If REC’s move is seen as a
central bank shifting abroad by the second dollar-rupee declare the defaults of the The recent rating down- undertake. ensure a dedicated RoW for anonymity. rate signal by the market, then
a part of its gold swap auction, RBI data IL&FS NPAs but restricted grade of a few Reliance enti- seamless laying of the fibre But bond market partici- cost for private NBFCs will go
holding in 2014. PTI< showed on Friday. PTI< them from initiating any ties has caused consternation More on business-standard.com network. pants do not agree that REC up further.
IBC’s 43% recovery is fair: CRISIL NBFC crisis averted: Aditya Puri
A BETTER SYSTEM CANDICE ZACHARIAHS & RAHUL SATIJA filings show.
Gross NPA trajectory Recovery rates Trend in slippages Mumbai, 3 May DECADE OF GROWTH The exposure of the wider Indian
Gross NPA~ trn (11.5) (10.0) across recovery Slippages ~ trn Private banks and NBFCs tookmarketshare away banking industry was about $92 billion
(Gross NPA% in mechanisms (slippages % in brackets) Trouble among India’s non-bank from stressed state-run lenders in March, according to an estimate
brackets) (9.5) 10.5 10.0 Average recoveryrate* (7.4) financiers will persist for at least a year
| State-run banks | Private banks | NBFCs from the ratings firm ICRA. Puri said
60 even if the danger of a full-blown HDFC Bank has no exposure to IL&FS.
(7.5) 8.0 50 UNDER IBC (6.0) (5.3) 6.0 financial crisis has passed, according
| Others % Under Puri, HDFC Bank has also
‘09-18 41 40 (3.7)
6.0 to the head of the nation’s most skirted India’s bad-loan crisis, which
(4.4)
‘09-19 43
(3.1)
4.4 4.2 valuable bank. 2008 60 18 12 10 hurt many of the country’s other
20 3.3
3.2 Tighter regulatory oversight and lenders. That has helped its shares
2.1 asset sales have staved off the worst of 47 24 18 11 outperform the broader banking index
2018
12 0 the problems afflicting India’s non- each year since 2014, boosting its
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 E ‘07-08 ‘09-18 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 E bank financial firms following last market capitalisation to more than
*Under DRT+SARFAESI+Lok Adalat; E: Estimates Source: CRISIL-ASSOCHAM Report
0 20 40 60 80 100
year’s defaults by Infrastructure Aditya Puri double that of State Bank of India, the
ANUP ROY ASSOCHAM and rating in the NCLT under the IBC,
Leasing & Financial Services,
according to HDFC Bank’s Managing
OUTPERFORMER nation’s largest lender by assets.
The stock has gained 21 per cent in
HDFCBank's lowbad loan ratio stands out % of total loans
Mumbai, 3 May agency CRISIL. 1,143 cases were outstanding Director Aditya Puri. Even so, it will be the past 12 months, beating the 16.6 per
“Also, post-implementa- as on March 31, 2019. Of these another 12 to 18 months before the 14.8 cent increase of the 10-member S&P
The advent of Insolvency and tion of the IBC, CRISIL esti- outstanding ones, 32 per cent liquidity issues in the wider sector are 10.8 BSE Bankex Index.
Bankruptcy Code (IBC) has mates the banking sector’s had surpassed the stipulated resolved, Puri told Bloomberg in Though India still has among the
resulted in a recovery rate of gross NPA (aggregate) 270-day resolution timeline, Mumbai on Thursday. 6.5 world’s worst stressed asset ratios,
43 per cent, which, according dropped to 10% in March 2019 the paper noted. “Also, there “It’s not a Lehman-like thing that soured credit as a share of total loans is
to rating agency CRISIL, is from 11.5% at the end of fiscal are a few big-ticket accounts comes and then there is contagion
3.6 3.8 estimated to have shrunk to 10.3 per
“respectable”. 2018,” it said, adding that for which resolution has not across the system,” Puri said, referring 1.4 cent by March from 10.8 per cent in
As on March 31 of this year, India’s resolving insolvency been finalised for over 400 to the US firm that collapsed a decade September, according to the central
the resolution plan for 94 score improved to 40.8 in 2019 days,” it said. ago and plunged the global economy HDFC Foreign Private NBFC Bank sector State-run bank.
stressed assets was approved from 32.6 in 2016 after the IBC. “Then, there are other chal- into a downturn. “The crisis is over, the Bank banks banks banks The banking industry has made
by the National Company Law The IBC regime also lenges such as burden on problem remains.” “substantial progress” in dealing with
Tribunal (NCLT). improved India’s ease of doing NCLT to resolve the large Last year’s defaults by IL&FS its non-performing loan problem, Puri
“For this set of 94 business’ ranking to 77 in 2019 number of cases, clarity on pri- exposed fault lines among India’s concerns about Indian mutual funds paying about 30 basis points more said. He pointed to better recognition
accounts, resolution has been from 130 in 2017. ority of claims, limited num- shadow lenders, which had grown that hold debt issued by non-bank than other top-rated corporates, of soured debt, closer central bank
reached for ~75,000 crore out However, the IBC is a work- ber of information utilities, liq- rapidly to account for a third of all new finance companies. according to data compiled by inspections and more disciplined
of ~1.75 trillion total claim of in-progress and despite two uidation at a ‘going concern’ loans over the previous three years. Shadow banks are still struggling to Bloomberg. behaviour by borrowers after the
financial creditors admitted. amendments brought for- level, and creation of a sec- Though the government’s decision to raise funds, including from the mutual HDFC Bank had an exposure of $7 implementation of the nation’s new
That makes for a respectable ward, challenges remain, with ondary asset market, which seize the company helped contain the funds which already hold about $46 billion to non-bank finance companies bankruptcy law. This gives the
recovery rate of 43 per cent,” the major one being adher- need to be addressed,” said crisis, a lingering credit crunch has led billion of the sector’s debt, according to and related firms as of December, government a window to add fresh
said a knowledge paper pre- ence to the IBC timeline. CRISIL’s President-Ratings, to reduced demand for goods like an estimate by Credit Suisse Group. compared with $11 billion for its capital into struggling state-run banks,
pared by industry body Of the 1,858 cases admitted Gurpreet Chhatwal. automobiles and triggered investor Those that can tap the markets are nearest private-sector rival ICICI Bank, Puri said. BLOOMBERG
The misallocated Why the HYV matters in UP politics Adityanath did as chief minister was a harsh
crackdown on the sand mining mafia (which
was run as a side-business by many HYV
activists); action against overloading of trucks
Once a source of Chief Minister Adityanath's clout, the Hindu Yuva Vahini is (which were allowed to go only if they paid a
T
his is the silly “tax” to HYV); and shutting down illegal hooch
season for eco- like a thorn in his side now outlets. “Unka do number ka business thupp ho
nomic policy, gaya (their illegal business crashed),” said a BJP
though some would Unthinkable in the past. But he has to. His as the unchallenged BJP leader in east UP and worker with ill-concealed satisfaction.
say it’s been that for supporters can see that a crucial rule has been to buttress his rise, he announced the formation Slowly, HYV began losing people. State pres-
five years now. It is broken. He explained gruffly to one of them of the Hindu Yuva Vahini (HYV). ident Sunil Singh quit, followed by Ram
therefore a good time that he was no longer just a mahant of the Why HYV when Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Laxman, a crucial activist who is also a Dalit.
to take stock of the sort Gorakhnath mandir but chief minister of the Parishad (ABVP) and Bharatiya Janata Yuva Singh told local journalists that the BJP lost the
of economic advice entire state and all people. Morcha (BJYM), both front organisations of the Gorakhpur by-election (2018) because HYV
that is tendered in our When he was made chief minister, Prime BJP, already exist? A BJP supporter explained workers stayed away from the campaign. A BJP
country. Minister Narendra Modi was asked by a cheeky that the HYV is slightly different. While ABVP worker said it was none other than Amit Shah,
This necessarily supporter: “Why him?” The PM replied: “iss lot and BJYM are more “prabuddh”(intellectual) who requested Adityanath to tighten the reins
MARGINAL UTILITY involves taking stock of
the sort of economists
mein sabse achha wahi hai” (he’s the best of the
lot). There was Keshav Prasad Maurya, now
and “vaicharik” (ideological) the HYV is con-
sidered “lampat” (lumpen), more interested in
of the HYV’s activities, now that he was CM
(“adhyaksh-ji ne nakel kasne ke liye kaha”).
TCA SRINIVASA RAGHAVAN we have. The result is deputy chief minister and reportedly not on creating “danga” (rioting) than ideology. In oth- But Adityanath is not prepared to let go so
dismaying.
The overall prob-
PLAIN POLITICS talking terms with the CM; Manoj Sinha, min-
ister of state for railways with independent
er words, a militia.
Anecdotal data suggests membership grew
easily. On the day the 2019 elections were
announced, the state government issued a noti-
lem is that India has far too many macroeconomists and too ADITI PHADNIS charge of the ministry of communications; and from 300 in 2002 to 1.5 million in 2014. In a fication appointing scores of HYV activists to
few microeconomists. Thus, I had pointed out a few weeks somewhere on the remote horizon, Adityanath. region where large-scale unemployment and positions on boards and other lower-level
ago specifically in the context of the closure of Jet Airways The Gorakhpur Lok Sabha seat is considered migration in search of jobs is endemic, young offices of profit. Although the model code of
T
and the aviation business generally, India has around three he first compromise people noticed “mandir ki seat”. But previous incumbents — people now had a position. In the Gorakhpur conduct came into force immediately, delaying
transport economists. This is surely very odd for such a cap- was the food. Digvijaynath and Avaidyanath — never tried division alone, 500,000 people joined the HYV the perks of office (authority, salary and official
ital and labour intensive industry. to assert themselves as “true” Hindus although as it expanded to the villages. The volunteers car and accommodation), once the election is
That’s not the only problem. Ever since the data bug bit Yogi Adityanath is a mahant, a holy man. they claimed to represent the Hindu had a range of tasks: From spreading awareness over, they will take over. “In the BJP we have a
the profession about 40 years ago, very few Indian econo- He is prohibited, for pollution-purity reasons, Mahasabha and considered BJP somewhat about encephalitis or brain fever that kills peo- system. We send the name from below and it is
mists know much of economic theory or economic history. from eating just anywhere. As MP, he would be tame on issues of Hinduism. Adityanath ple like flies in the region to issues of sanitation. vetted at every stage reaching the leadership
Both are scoffed at with a sneering, “show me the data”. invited by voters and constituents for meals realised that to be taken seriously, he needed “Earlier, when you asked a young man what he via proper channel,” said a BJP worker. “In this
What this has meant is no data, no economist to think and his supporters would warn them in to make an impression within the BJP. In the did, he would say “nothing”. Now he began say- case, none of the names we sent featured on
beyond the immediate. Our economists are mere data advance: “Maharajji khana nahin khayenge… 2002 assembly elections, the BJP fielded Shiv ing proudly: “I am a padadhikari (officebearer) the list that was finally announced.”
crunchers which means robots will replace them soon. ”. He might have a piece of fruit or a nut or two, Pratap Shukla from Gorakhpur overruling of the HYV,” explained a BJP worker. How will this creative tension play out?
What is truly worrisome is that the sort of analysis we but nothing more. claims from the mandir. Adityanath was The BJP observed the growth and develop- BJP supporters say that whatever Adityanath
saw in economics till about the mid-1970s is now virtually Now, along with party President Amit incensed and he challenged the BJP by fielding ment of HYV silently but watchfully. When and HYV might say, there’s a price to be paid
extinct. This despite the fact that an overwhelming propor- Shah, the mahant of the Gorakhnath temple Radha Mohan Das Agarwal on a Hindu Adityanath was sworn in as CM, many cele- for power. Their prediction? HYV, the source
tion of ‘Nobel’ prizes in economics have gone to theorists. is eating everywhere: You can see him squat- Mahasabha ticket against Shukla. Agarwal brated, expecting a surge in their fortunes. They of Adityanath’s clout, will eventually have to
Go deeper and you will find that among the macroecon- ting and eating with Yadavs, Dalits… defeated Shukla. This established Adityanath were disappointed. The first three things shut shop.
omists, barely a handful have been trained in formal econo-
metrics. The rest just wing it on software. Indeed, now even
budding lawyers have started doing it. It will be doctors next,
I suppose. Chartered accountants have already got in there. DINNER WITH BS > ZIA MODY | FOUNDER | AZB & PARTNERS
This sad story doesn’t end here. We don’t have economists
who have specialised in the high-impact field of law and eco-
nomics. That area, too, has been left to chartered accountants
who only study the finance bill and make pronouncements.
As to economics’ younger sister, sociology, perish the
thought. India’s economists don’t allow themselves to be
tainted by something as "flaky" as sociology.
More orphans
From the school of hard knocks
The mother of all shows, of course, is monetary economics. Over pizza and ravioli, Mody talks to gating regulations, law plus image sand, how close they are, and on
Ever since the FIIs flooded into India, monetary economists management, law plus global which side.”
have blossomed like bananas in Kerala. The only thing they Pavan Lall about her reputation, firm impact, law plus business sense”. In the next four or five years,
need to know is the term "yield" which makes it easy. The I stop and take a sip of my green Mody says, we will see the emer-
rest, yes, you guessed it, is data. It's extraordinary how much
succession and how different clients tea. She works round the clock at gence of class-action law suits in a
time is devoted to discussing the financial markets, as if we
are major players on Wall Street.
require different doses of fear a pace which would deter most
youngsters half her age and then
big way. “Promoters are listening
much harder, the noises being made
Amazingly, given that fiscal matters loom so large on our there’s the matter of her reputa- by proxy advisors and minority
S
economy’s horizon dominating everything, we have very o, who have you signed on unusual Alexandrite one tion. She’s notorious for being a shareholders are getting louder and
few specialists in public finance. I doubt if it is even taught recently?” I ask of Zia Mody, that matches her tunic. merciless task master and AZB is one or two hard class-action cases
any longer in our universities. Everyone is content just founding partner of law firm Almost always, it’s known for being one of the tough- will set the tone. It’s coming.” She
tediously analysing the Budget. AZB & Partners. After all, at this easy to tell the kind of est law firms to cut one’s teeth at. also means that fear is today a
Then there is industrial economics. Three decades ago, stage of her career, Mody, who needs mood Mody is in by her Mody smiles, then says slowly stronger factor in decision-making
some Indian economists like Ashok Desai and TCA Anant no introduction, has represented hairdo. If pulled back, with jarring honesty, “I’m an and there is genuine regulatory con-
tried to develop the field. most captains of industry that like rockstars or gang- unbalanced human and it’s obvious cern, about not making a habit of
Nothing came of it because this time even though the include Ratan Tata, Mukesh Ambani sters do with pony-tails I don’t need a balanced life as much certain business processes.
data was there the effort was too much. Result: India’s indus- and Anand Mahindra. There are sev- tied up with a band, the as anyone else because I’ve gotten How does she deal with loss?
trial policy has always been made in an intellectual vacuum eral others that we don’t know about message is: Stay out of used to a certain schedule”. Mody, a follower of the Bahá’í faith
by politicians and bureaucrats who have degrees in biology, — and Mody makes it emphatically the way. If she’s got it “You here at this time of the night who visits Israel every couple years
zoology and geology. clear it’s going to stay that way. down, you can get away and working isn’t balanced either,” on pilgrimage, says she’s okay with
Oddly enough, we do have a lot of agricultural econo- We’re catching up for dinner and with pushing the envelope. she quips. it. “Some big deals will go to com-
mists. But if you ask my colleague Surinder Sud, who is an instead of meeting at a restaurant, Today, it appears, is a regular The thing is that clients expect a petitors, a few talented partners will
absolute master of the game, they don’t know the difference we have decided to order in at AZB’s hair day. response quickly, which means that leave. The element of churn is there
between the various types of Indian soils, let alone anything corporate office at Peninsula My ravioli is bang on target, the instead of taking five days to get but the objective is to keep moving
else. But since the data is there they hold forth incessantly, Corporate Park in Lower Parel, Italian dumplings stuffed with back, it needs to be done in two ahead.” Hang on a second — did
mostly about MSP! Mumbai. We sit down in the Oak spinach and ricotta cheese are driz- days. That means you push faster Mody just say she’s okay with occa-
Ditto for international trade. The world collects the data, room. India’s best known lady zled with a tangy orange sauce gar- and run harder than others, sional losses? Has time mellowed
and our lads joyously piggy-back on it without the faintest lawyer opts for a margherita pizza nished with slices of green olive Mody says, adding it’s also the the iron lady of law? It almost
clue of industrial economics which, I would think, is the with an extra dollop of sun-dried and translucent flakes of garlic. reason she’s managed to settle sounds like she’s okay to hang up
minimum you need to know to be a good trade economist. I tomatoes from Quattro on Senapati The slightly charred zucchini and fights, and do the big deals. her boots sooner than later.
asked one of them the other day about the cost structure of Bapat Marg. It’s spinach and ricotta mixed greens offer as perfect a foil “At the end of the day Mody says, “I’ve been perceived
India’s textile industry. He waved me away. ravioli with a side of grilled vegeta- as they can. I offer Mody some it’s about the let- as a larger than life presence, inter-
bles for me from Cafe Zoe. but she sticks to her com- terhead of this nally for a long time now, but as my
More of the same Mody, a vegetarian and strict pact pizza, that’s neatly firm.” other founding partners will agree,
And what about sustainability issues and environmental teetotaler, has no pretensions when pre-sliced. She isn’t fib- we have the best second line of sen-
economics? These are taught only in a handful of places and it comes to dining, and is as much AZB’s league tables bing about the ior partners in the market, and
there are too few economists who know anything much at home with street food that rankings are impeccable. big deals. In institution building stands tall for
about the subject that can be of use at the local and regional includes idlis and other spicy Mergermarket’s latest report puts recent times, all of us.” So is it going to be five,
levels. Go to any seminar and you will see the same faces snacks from lesser known eateries AZB at number one with 22 deals AZB has advised seven or eight years before she and
ILLUSTRATION BY BINAY SINHA
talking about carbon emissions. as she is to five-star favorites like valued at around $9.5 billion. Tata Steel on its her founders retire? “I hope sooner,
And how many universities teach urban economics? How the Thai Pavilion at the Taj Hotel Shardul Amarchand Mangaldas & ~35,000 crore acquisition of I mean look at my hair, it’s getting
many economists do you know of who specialise in it? This in Cuffe Parade. Inside AZB’s office Co is at number two with 19 deals years of getting it right. Sounds sim- Bhushan Steel, one of the largest white now.” I disagree and tell
in a country that is haphazardly but rapidly urbanising and in Lower Parel there’s a stillness valued at $8.5 billion. It’s the same ple but few do it well. deals under the new Insolvency and Mody it’s dark in patches and she
needs such economists like a pig needs a pool of mud. that’s periodically broken by foot- with Bloomberg’s legal rankings, and So, what is the first question she Bankruptcy Code; the $14.6 billion pushes the last slice of pizza
These gaps are clearly reflected in the amount of pub- steps and the sound of young part- that of Thomson Reuters, where typically asks while taking on a case? merger of Indus Towers with Bharti towards me and it’s clear I am not
lished research in most of these areas. Why, we have only ners and associates checking on again, Mody sits pretty at number It depends on the client but if it’s a Infratel; and the $1.2 billion ATC- being asked but told to polish it off.
two or three Indian journals in which it is considered all case updates and calls as they move one by value and count. negotiation she will ask “what’s the Vodafone-Idea Cellular merger. I oblige and once done realise it’s
right to publish. As a result, the Economic and Political in and out of rooms named after That isn’t the only reason that bottom line that you want from this Is there a secret formula to catch- almost 11 pm.
Weekly has become the acceptable substitute for our uni- trees such as Juniper, Sequoia and she is the first port of call for most deal?,” she says. If it’s litigation, then ing the most high-flying of clients? How long will Mody stay in
versities. so on. promoters, conglomerate heads and the questions are judgment calls on “Different clients require different office? “Another four-five hours or
The worst consequence of this debility is that we import Dinner is laid out for us on AZB CEOs. In her favour, she’s a unique where the matter is likely to go, how doses of fear, some get it quickly, so,” she says, as she turns to face the
NRI economists who, with one or two exceptions, are not monogrammed china ware and we blend of tough-as-nails counsel who much reputational damage is likely some need to be told categorically light flashing on her phone, an assis-
quite the sharpest pencils in the box. start the minute it’s served. Mody, can switch at light-speed to offer a to happen and so on, she says, what will happen if they cross the tant with a sky-high pile of papers
It is like buying Chinese products. Okay, but not really as always, is dressed simply in a silk, sympathetic ear when the client is adding that “every meeting is a law line, and I don't think we advise and three junior lawyers who need
German engineering. purple tunic, one very large record- losing a deal, is at war with a sibling, plus. Law plus strategy, law plus EQ being virginal but what we do is direction. And vanishes into a dif-
size diamond ring and another or has made pivotal mistakes after (emotional quotient), law plus navi- counsel clients as to the line in the ferent world.
T I
he other day, yet another street them as separating puppies less than 40 them from the elements and the dangers t has been a few weeks since my being laid at my door. It was the reason na one, if not both.
dog was run over by a car near our days old from their mother amounted to on the road.” The animal activists, so mother and I talked to each other my son and his wife had a tiff in the first Since I chose to defer my holiday
house. I stopped to ask the two animal cruelty. The watchmen were vociferous when it came to ‘rescuing’ the over the phone, having had an place, and even though they kissed and plans till after the elections, I now find
watchmen nearby, the only people out- flummoxed by the turn of events. puppies, were oddly silent. “They would altercation that was, shall we say, made up, the rumblings have caused myself in danger of being done out of
side in the afternoon heat, if anything “The puppies were not ours to look have sent us to jail for animal cruelty,” unpleasant? My son and his wife too unrest at home. one entirely. Which must be why I
could be done for the unfortunate ani- after,” they said. “Neither were they ours muttered one of the watchmen, “but had their first tiff as newlyweds, caus- Oblivious to their discomfort, my wife agreed on a whim to sign up for the
mal. “A change of law would be good,” to give away.” They were unaware of ani- have done nothing against the drivers ing them both to sulk — though they keeps butting in with suggestions about extended family package to the hills this
said one of them. I asked why? The story mal cruelty laws in India. Moreover, both who have run them over.” were equally quick to make up. My accompanying them. “Can I come to St weekend. It spans three generations and
they told me gave me food for thought. were convinced that their adoption gave We silently watched the mother with daughter, whose daily commute takes Petersburg with you?” she asks, when I doubt it will amount to more than a few
It all started when a street dog gave the puppies a better chance of survival. As her one remaining offspring, now almost her from Noida to Gurugram and back, she catches them checking for reserva- clan skirmishes over harboured child-
birth to three puppies in winter this year. the animal lovers became more and more as large as her, wondering what fate had at least has reason to be in a rage on tions on the Sapsan high-speed train. hood resentments, which is all one can
The watchmen finally had something to aggressive, the men decided the unpleas- in store for them. There are no easy working days. My wife tells me off so “Can we go to Moscow with them?” she anticipate over a couple of days of being
do to pass time during their long working antness wasn’t worth it. “We’re poor answers when it comes to the manage- often that I can safely say we are in a checks with me. Quietly, when she isn’t thrown together. Cooler weather should
hours. “We looked after them, brought migrants,” they told me. “People like us ment of stray canines in cities. For perpetual state of war. Our driver of looking, the children change their choice at least ensure there won’t be too many
them milk and found gunny bags for can’t afford to mess with the police.” So humans might have spent millennia many years suddenly upped and of destination. “They’re honeymooners,” frayed feathers — or tempers. Who
them to be warm at night,” they said. the next evening, when the same children domesticating animals, they still haven’t absconded, complete with loan and I remind my wife, “we should let them knows, maybe my mother and I will even
The puppies soon became popular with passed by on their way to the park, they learnt to peacefully coexist with them. motorcycle, causing the domestic staff be.” “But they’ve already been on a hon- start being civil again.
>
OPINION 9
STAY INFORMED THROUGH THE DAY @ WWW.BUSINESS-STANDARD.COM
Volume Vl Number 40
T
he tax revenue numbers published in this newspaper yesterday are Crowd: Yes
a shock. They show a shortfall of ~1.6 trillion, when compared to the through Hindu-Muslim polarisation. But Mamata is But there’s only one thing that doesn’t happen
revised revenue numbers for 2018-19 presented to Parliament three
months ago. That represents over 0.8 per cent of gross domestic
fighting their poison with her own here — Modi. Modi hoi na (Modi doesn’t happen here)
… BJP hoi na, mithya (falsehood) hoi na, kutsha (char-
Y
product (GDP). Some of the shortfall would have been compensated by a last- ou can pick your metaphor: It takes iron to It worked in Assam, so it must work in West acter assassination) hoi na.
minute squeeze on expenditure, reported at the year-end to have been about break iron. Diamond cuts diamond. If you so Bengal. That is the reason BJP leaders have been
~60,000 crore. Taking that as accurate, the fiscal deficit numbers for the year
would have gone up from the reported 3.4 per cent of GDP to about 3.9 per cent
wish, you can even say, poison is the only
antidote to poison. It means the same thing. But the
last may be more appropriate, given that the election
claiming a near-sweep, upwards of 22 seats out of its
42. After Uttar Pradesh (80) and Maharashtra (48), M amata turns the knife and not slowly. Do your
homework, and set it on your teleprompter so
West Bengal sends the highest contingent of MPs to you don’t make a fool of yourself here, “Modi babu,”
— clear slippage from the levels of the last two years.
campaign we are talking about is our most ven- the Lok Sabha. she says, a hundred times more mockingly than
The numbers are a shock for a further reason: The Centre’s revenue growth
omously bitter yet. If this is where the BJP expected to partly make Modi calls Rahul shahzada or how Rahul may call
clocks in at only about 6.2 per cent. It is understandable if this falls short of the
The tone has been set by Prime Minister Narendra up for the losses it might suffer in Uttar Pradesh and Modi chor. She lists, in one breath, all the various
ambitiously budgeted revenue growth of 19.5 per cent. What is more worrying is Modi. Nobody can deny him that other states they had swept in pujas that take place in West Bengal, taunts Mr Modi
that growth in gross collection (including the states’ share), at 8.4 per cent, falls proud distinction. From calling 2014, they should rethink. It is true if he even knows the Saraswati Mantra, then recites
short of GDP growth (in nominal terms, ie including inflation) of 11.5 per cent. In opponents anti-national, in that the prime minister’s rallies it in Sanskrit, her crowds, including hundreds of
other words, the trend of an increasing tax-GDP ratio has been reversed. Some of cahoots with Pakistan, families on have been enthusiastic and big. Muslims, cheering. What does Mr Modi know about
the shortfall may have been on account of the progressive cutting of rates for the bail/halfway to jail, and so on. His But given the low base, the BJP has each religion?
goods and services tax. But there is the possibility that real economic growth (ie party chief Amit Shah and Uttar an electoral Kanchenjunga to She quickly moves to food. “Modi babu, if we go
adjusted for inflation) may be less than the officially reported 7 per cent. Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi climb here. to Gujarat, we eat dhokla, idly in Tamil Nadu, upma
The implications for the current year are grim. The Budget numbers for Adityanath have taken this for- Mamata isn’t also impressed by in Kerala, litti-chokha in Bihar, halwa in Gurudwara,
2019-20 project revenue growth of 14.9 per cent on the numbers that had been ward, one calling Muslim immi- the BJP’s shock-and-awe tactic. lassi in Punjab. You order people, don’t eat fish, meat,
expected for 2018-19. On the real revenue base that has emerged, tax collection grants termites or other kinds of She is probably the toughest politi- eggs. Pregnant women should not eat eggs. “Hey
vermin and the other pitching cian in India now, tougher than brother, who are you to order what women can eat
would have to grow 29.1 per cent in order to meet the new year’s Budget numbers.
Bajrangbali versus Ali. Mayawati. She is also a street-fight- or not?” The country, she says, is being told to eat
Since that is impossible, the Budget will have to be substantially re-cast as soon
as a new government takes charge after the elections. Both revenue and expen-
In large parts of the country, NATIONAL INTEREST er, which Rahul and Priyanka, what Mr Modi eats, buy the waist-coats he wears,
especially the Hindi heartland, Kamal Nath and Akhilesh Yadav watch him on TV all day. “I used to think he was a
diture numbers will have to be trimmed — and then may better reflect the decel- this is working. But there is a dis-
SHEKHAR GUPTA aren’t. But, for further clarity. selfless RSS pracharak,” she says, “but now these
eration of economic activity caused by slowing consumption trends. Since much tinction. It is working where the Arvind Kejriwal is. RSS men who paraded in khaki knickers (short-
of government expenditure is on pre-committed items like interest payments, BJP’s main rival is the Congress. Steeled through survival in a state that was no bet- pants), roam shopping malls in trousers carrying
subsidies, salaries and pensions, the axe will fall (as it did late last year) on invest- In Maharashtra, Gujarat, Madhya Pradesh, Bihar, ter than a Left Front concentration camp for her, she briefcases and make crores”.
ment in the physical infrastructure, an important driver of growth so far. Delhi, Haryana, Uttarakhand and Himachal Pradesh, also knows the art of turning adversity into opportu- She attacks him on demonetisation, never wastes
In terms of the growth outlook, some factors have improved — like the the BJP sees this line working. Because it is mostly nity. Or, grab the opportunity when Mr Modi a second on Rafale, and delivers the final
global economic situation, and receding prospects of a US-China trade war. up against the Congress. It responds by asking as to says it’s become difficult for Bengalis to even blow: “A party that was starving not long
Oil prices have climbed, but various oil exporters may up output to neutralise how its patriotism can be questioned if Indira Gandhi hold Durga Puja. The Congress ago and used to smoke the same beedi
the stoppage of supplies from Iran. Domestically, the monsoon prospects are broke up Pakistan, or how you call us soft on terror I track her through rallies on a day when is yet to thrice a day, now owns billions.”
when our father and grandmother were assassinated the menacing advance vanguard of the com- understand “And then they call themselves chowki-
less than optimal, while two lead sectors (aviation and automobiles) have taken
by terrorists. But it sounds defensive, and its tone ing Cyclone Fani stalks her helicopter. That the Modi-Shah dar,” she says as the crowd sets up a
a toss and a third (telecom) has seen value destruction, even as construction isn’t right. Or not wrong enough. Because, as we know, Durga Puja is the theme running through method “chowkidar chor hai” chant that is louder
remains dependent on government spending. The financial and corporate sec- it can’t cut poison with coconut water. these, in Bhatapara (Barrackpore, where for- and more spontaneous than any you hear
tors have come through the worst of the twin crises of bad loans and excessive To understand how this works, come to West mer railways minister Dinesh Trivedi is con- from the front-rows in Rahul’s rallies. In
debt, and credit has picked up. But much cleaning up remains to be done, and Bengal with me, going through the most verbally and testing) and Rajarhat, on Kolkata’s outskirts, where West Bengal, Rahul’s party is her rival too. But she
further systemic shocks cannot be ruled out. Monetary policy has tried to sup- physically violent election in the entire country. This Kakoli Ghosh Dastidar seeks her third term. has neatly appropriated his slogan.
port growth, but the Reserve Bank’s rate cuts find no echo in a liquidity-con- is also where Mr Modi and Mr Shah have found their “Modi babu, you must do your homework before The question then: Why does this slogan look so
strained market for a variety of reasons, including the level of government bor- match in “didi” Mamata Banerjee — her loyalists pre- you shout expletives at us Bengalis,” she speaks at a effective in the hands of a one-state leader when the
rowing. Real interest rates remain high. fer the old-style “Bandopadhyaya”, though. Not a pace that even that other fast-talker Gautam Gambhir Congress invented it, and spread it across the coun-
This is a sobering context in which to consider the promises of expansive word she says in response to the BJP is defensive, can’t keep pace with, striding left to right and back try? The short answer is, the Congress is yet to under-
hand-outs as part of the election campaign: Loan write-offs, cash payouts, and nothing is said to play the victim, and because you on her stage with the wireless microphone, without stand the Modi-Shah method. Unlike Atal Bihari
mocked her, she mocks you back like none else can looking anybody in the eye. Vajpayee and L K Advani, these two are street-fighters
possibly a higher food subsidy. As should be obvious, there simply isn’t the fiscal
with the possible exception, lately, of Raj Thackeray. “Even kids get scolded by Didimonis (teachers) and they have accordingly changed their party’s DNA.
space for all of this, or indeed any of it. When the limits of monetary policy are
when they go to school without doing their home- To fight street-fighters, you need street-fighters.
being tested, the fisc has to be in contractionary mode — especially since the
official deficit numbers conceal off-balance sheet borrowing. As it is, the ratio of
government debt to GDP remains above the limits reckoned to be desirable.
T he Modi-Shah BJP has been targeting West
Bengal for five years. If Hindu-Muslim polari-
sation is their ticket to power, West Bengal should
work. What will people do when you lie? You come Remember, just as we said in the very beginning, iron
to Bengal and tell people that there’s no Durga puja? breaks iron, diamond cuts diamond and, only poison
“Now, tell me mothers & sisters here — do we have counters poison. If Mr Modi and Mr Shah have made
The danger is a post-poll government being tempted to go the other way, be even more amenable to it than Uttar Pradesh. Durga Puja or not? a poisonous, polarising campaign their brahmastra
taking comfort from moderate inflation and opting for expansionist policies in That’s because West Bengal, like Assam, has a nearly Crowd: We do for 2019, Mamata Banerjee is showing them its limi-
order to deliver on unaffordable election promises or in pursuit of unrealisable 30 per cent Muslim population. As with the Mamata: Does anyone stop you from celebrating tations. Or why it will “hoi na” (won’t happen) in her
growth objectives — precisely the kind of policy heresy being heard currently Congress in Assam, there is a feeling that the rulers, Durga Puja? state of 42 MPs.
in some other countries. first the Left and now Mamata, have been appeasing Crowd: No
them for votes. Mamata: Louder, does Durga Puja take place here? By Special Arrangement with ThePrint
A
building climate risk into their models. Taylor from Columbia University looked major investors. Traders who specialise in couple of years ago when I do not make a science. Ten anec-
There is zero chance that any of these groups at the US market in exchange-traded these instruments have to be more attuned tagged along with a friend to dotes are no better than one, and a
are going to divest from oil or gas companies weather derivatives for 2002 through 2018, than other finance professionals to what’s watch a poorly critiqued hundred anecdotes are no better
any time soon. You still get investors in the comparing the way investors priced tem- really going on with the planet’s climate. Bengali movie, Yeti Obhijaan, little than ten.”
US who don’t believe in climate change. perature expectations for a particular There’s no reason for climate skeptics to did I know that awful experience one Science cannot completely dis-
These guys honestly couldn’t give a stuff. month with climate scientists’ tempera- go out of their way and make contrarian day would come handy to write prove that “yeti is real” because it is
LEONID BERSHIDSKY Christophers’s study, based on inter- ture forecasts based on the impact of bets on barely liquid contracts. about the legendary beast. Though not a question for science. Non-sci-
views with executives at investment firms human activity. They found something Nevertheless, investors should pay more the movie, like most researchers, dis- entific theories could not be falsified
with more than $1 billion under manage- approaching full agreement between the attention to what’s going on with weather missed the claim of a giant primate as they aren’t testable in a legitimate
A
tipping point for governments in ment, showed that these financiers weren’t traders and the white coats. Schlenker and derivative pricing. The market has existed species wandering in the Himalayas, way. There was no possible objection
aligning their policies with the sci- interested in selling their fossil fuel assets, Taylor wrote: for 20 years, long enough to make it clear it ended with a mysterious unseen that could be raised which would
ence of climate change won’t be didn’t see productive ways of incorporat- The observed annual trend in futures that betting against the consensus climate creäture lurking and watching show the theory to be wrong.
brought about by schoolkids demonstrat- ing climate change into their models, and, prices shows that the supposedly efficient models doesn’t pay. This should have humans leave the mountains, and Noted astrophysicist Carl Sagan
ing. It will come from a shift in investor if they did see it as a risk, then saw it as financial markets agree that the climate is broader implications. If the derivatives mar- thus helped keep the belief in folk- in his book The Demon-Haunted
sentiment. merely one of many. warming. At least so far, climate models ket is bearing out these projections, divest- lore alive. World: Science as a Candle in the
Data show that even if investors don’t That led Christophers to conclude that have been very accurate in predicting the ing from fossil fuel stocks and looking for Stories about yeti, popular among Dark, to encourage sceptical think-
flag environmental cataclysm as a major environmental lobbyists and progressive average warming trend that’s been observed more sustainable opportunities should be sherpas and among millions world- ing, offers a story concerning a
concern or even express skepticism about politicians wouldn’t sway the investment across the US. When money is on the line, it viewed as reasonable strategies. Stocks wide, are back in the spotlight after fire-breathing dragon that lives in
it, there are some who bet consistently and crowd until it saw a clear financial return is hard to find parties willing to bet against exposed to climate risks might be more mis- the Indian Army recently tweeted his garage.
successfully on the scientists being right. in adjusting for climate change. As things the scientific consensus. priced than commonly perceived. photographs of giant footsteps, When Sagan persuades a rational,
Conservatives are on the whole still stand, sustainability plays a minor role in That’s probably an overoptimistic con- claimed of a yeti. open-minded visitor to meet the
skeptical about climate change, particu- investment decisions, as was made clear clusion. The market for weather ETFs and ©Bloomberg It’s important to note that crea- dragon, the visitor remarks that he
tures like komodo dragon, giant pan- couldn’t see the creäture. Sagan
da and gorillas were all discovered replies that he “neglected to mention
partly because of folklore. Also, that she’s an invisible dragon”. The
V
irat-Anushka (Virushka) featured married. Rajesh Khanna was India’s first her husband’s persona as one of India’s drives the Virushka brand with his per- cated that the samples belonged to According to the principle of
together in the Google Duo ad last superstar and Dimple Kapadia was the finest cricketers. Sachin and his wife formance. Anushka adds the oomph. bears and not a primate species. Ockham’s Razor, attributed to 14th-
week, their second advertising darling of the nation after the success of Anjali could have been cricket’s original Akshay is a winner-all-the-way while Similar studies in the past, too, have century scholastic philosopher and
outing together after they became man Bobby but the marriage itself was not a first couple, but Anjali preferred to keep Mrs Funnybones provides class and discouraged any belief in yeti. theologian William of Ockham,
and wife. Their first campaign together very successful or enduring one. When her head down despite her own charisma. In Deepveer both partners are But as the popular aphorism goes: more straightforward explanations
was for Manyavar, just a few weeks before Amitabh Bachchan and Jaya Bhaduri tied independent credentials as a doctor. equally strong and individually no. 1. “The absence of evidence is not evi- are, in general, better. That is, if you
they tied the knot a year ago. the knot, Jaya was actually the Mohd Azharuddin and Sangeeta Bijlani Unfortunately for Abhiash and Saifeena dence of absence!” No research, so have two possible theories that fit
Deepika-Ranveer (Deepveer) too better-known half of the couple. As did hit the upper circuits for a while as a neither couple is a top leaguer. far, has disproved the existence of a all available evidence, the best the-
debuted together in an ad for Lloyd Amitabh carved a dominant position in couple but his getting mired in the Going forward Virushka, Deepveer, yeti or a bigfoot (the western version ory is which has fewer abstract
air-conditioners last month. They have Indian cinema, Jaya however faded into match-fixing controversy killed any pos- and Akshay-Twinkle are all well poised of a yeti-like creäture). ideas, or guesses.
done movies together in the past but this domesticity. sibilities of their becoming an aspira- to break the celebrity couple jinx of the So, should we believe in Nepalese So, a better and scientific theory
was their maiden effort for brand When Indian cinema’s heart-throb tional power couple. Dhoni and his wife past many decades. If Ranbir-Alia decide folklore? No. And here comes the would be that there is no giant hairy
endorsement together. Akshay-Twinkle Sharmila Tagore married the Indian Sakshi are part of Colgate’s latest version to tie the knot, they too will join this need for encouraging people towards primate roaming the snowy peaks
have been featuring together in ads too, cricket captain Mansoor Ali Khan of Andar se Strong campaign, but Sakshi August league of made in heaven critical and sceptical thinking. of the Himalayas. Because all it
the most recent one being for Pataudi, they together had just the right is hardly known. alliances to sell brands with their sparkle The study of animals whose exis- takes to prove this idea wrong is to
Fortune basmati rice. Saif-Kareena credentials to become a power couple: he Harbhajan Singh and his actress wife and sizzle. The era of the Celebrity tence has yet to be proved is known find one!
(Saifeena) have been featured together by was a right royal Nawab, and the Geeta Basra, Yuvraj Singh-Hazel Keech, Couple, methinks, is finally here. as cryptozoology and cryptids, or
AirBnB and Abhishek-Aishwarya youngest ever captain of the Indian crick- Zaheer Khan-Sagarika Ghatge, Stuart “hidden animals,” start their lives as Every week, Eye Culture features writers
(Abhiash) have jointly endorsed TTK et team and she was the first actress to Binny-Mayanti Langer, Dinesh Karthik- The writer is an advertising and media veteran blurry photographs, grainy videos, with an entertaining critical take on art,
Prestige pressure cookers. have posed in a bikini, breaking the Dipika Pallikal, Sania Mirza-Shoaib sandeep@goyalmail.com footmarks and countless stories. The music, dance, film and sport
https://t.me/SSC4Exams https://t.me/Banking4Exams https://t.me/UPSC4Exams
https://t.me/TheHindu_Zone_official
10 THE SMART INVESTOR
>
MUMBAI | 4 MAY 2019
T
he Portfolio manage- n’t show the impact of the fees products. Currently, regula- The 36-million share
After a weak show by some ment service (PMS) sec- being levied on the investor,” tions laid down by Sebi only offering garnered bids for
of India’s important fast tor has grown at a sharp said Sanjay Parikh, who is lead- mandate PMS providers to fol- 111.5 million shares from
moving goods (FMCG) pace in India, with the growing ing the initiative to implement low the weighted average institutional investors,
firms such as Britannia and pool of high networth investors the Global Investment method to calculate returns in shows data by the stock
Dabur, expectations from (HNIs) going for this invest- Performance Standards — for- individual categories. exchanges. Most of the bids
Hindustan Unilever (HUL) ment option in search of higher mulated by the CFA Institute “While the regulator has came at ~406, higher than
were a bit muted. The HUL returns. However, experts say — in India.
GAINING SCALE regulated the MF industry the base price of ~390 set for
stock, accordingly, fell by that despite the sizeable client “Moreover, there is also no Assets of PMS firms have soared, rivaling domestic MFs heavily as it is more retail- the OFS.
over 2 per cent on Friday, base, PMS providers lag their clarity on whether returns for AUM (~cr) Discretionary Non-discretionary Advisory focused, it has not set tight Shares of HDFC Life end-
before the results that came domestic MF counterparts by a financial year take into norms for the PMS sector, giv- ed at ~413.6, down 0.82 per
post market hours. This shows price hikes quite a distance, when it comes account all investor returns for Listed equity 100,609 17,744 en its orientation towards more cent, on the BSE. Another
However, the numbers undertaken in the past to reporting and disclosure that period, or excludes returns Unlisted equity 575 78 sophisticated and wealthy 3.6 million shares for retail
weren’t as bad as antici- year, coupled with efforts standards. for exiting investors,” he added. Plain debt 1,144,568 74,075 clients,” said a PMS provider, investors — those investing
pated, except for the net to improve the share of pre- Over the last four years, the According to experts, com- requesting anonymity. up to ~200,000 — will be
profit. Revenue at ~9,809 mium products, particular- size of assets managed by PMS puting returns on the basis of Structured debt 646 460 Following the 2008 market auctioned on Monday.
crore in the March quarter ly in the beauty segment, providers has grown at an only existing investors could Equity derivatives 484 -2 crash, Sebi decided to curb Standard Life, the joint
(Q4) grew 9 per cent YoY; has yielded the desired annual rate of 16 per cent. At give a lopsided view of a strate- some of the practices in the venture partner in HDFC
MFs 13,776 13,612
half a per cent lower than result. Volume growth at 7 the end of February, assets gy’s performance. PMS industry. The minimum Life, was the seller in the
the Bloomberg consensus per cent was at a 6-quarter under management of portfo- “Typically, an investor exits Others 15,572 1,258 investment size was increased share sale.
estimate of ~9,858 crore. low but met expectations lio managers stood at ~15.6 tril- a PMS-managed portfolio Total 1,276,230 107,224 171,267 from ~5 lakh to ~25 lakh, fund The UK-based firm sold
Net profit (before excep- of 6-8 per cent, coming on lion with a client base of over when he is disappointed with managers were restricted from 1.78 per cent stake, paring its
tional items) at ~1,590 the back of last year’s high 147,300. As the industry gains the returns. So, while reporting
No. of clients 136,586 6,729 3,998 pooling investments from holding to 22.88 per cent.
Source: Sebi Data as on February 28, 2019
crore (up 13 per cent YoY), base of 11 per cent growth. in size, experts say disclosures returns for a financial year, the clients, and the norms around In March, Standard Life
though, missed estimates For investors, though, made by portfolio managers, provider should adjust for exit- profit-sharing or performance- had divested 4.93 per cent
of ~1,651 crore. volume growth will be a particularly with respect to per- ing investors’ returns too,” said investors to the regulator’s ble with other PMS’ returns related fees were made tighter. stake in HDFC Life to raise
However, investors larger concern, going formance, should improve. Jinal Sheth, portfolio manager website, where returns shown reported,” Sheth added. While industry sources say about ~3,600 crore.
shouldn’t be disappointed ahead. “Lot of PMS firms report the at Multi-Act Equity PMS. are combined for all portfolios, The Securities and these changes have helped in Following the OFS, the
as HUL managed to “Operating margin of 23 returns of a model portfolio, Further, such practices can across strategies. These don’t Exchange Board of India’s giving more credibility, there is promoter’s holding in HDFC
expand its operating profit per cent (in Q4) is the high- which doesn’t give a fair picture lead to mis-selling. “There are give a fair picture of the per- (Sebi) site states the perform- more scope for improvement Life will come down to
margins (Ebidta) from 23.1 est-ever for us. We also of the performance of actual instances of advisors pointing formance and aren’t compara- ance of portfolio managers has in the reporting standards. 74.36 per cent.
per cent last year to 24 per delivered margin expan-
cent in Q4, despite a tough sion in 30 out of 31 quarters,
operating climate. which is significant,” said
While the cost of goods
sold as a percentage of rev-
enue remained at 48 per
Sanjiv Mehta, HUL chair-
man and managing direc-
tor. Analysts at ICICI
Sugar sector outlook turns positive for next season
cent, advertising costs and Securities also note that VIRENDRA SINGH RAWAT for June, the sentiment in the in Maharashtra reservoirs was announce its preliminary
other expenses grew at a with volume growth mod- Lucknow, 3 May sugar space is turning positive. below normal level on estimates of crop availability
slower pace than revenue, erating for five consecutive According to ratings account of lower rainfall in and production for the 2019-
at 3.5 per cent and 8.5 per quarters, demand is peak- The beleaguered domestic agency Icra, the hike, coupled the last monsoon season, 20 season. For the current
cent YoY, respectively. The ing out in certain rural sugar sector, which has been with seasonal higher sugar with indications that cane season (Oct 2018 to Sep 2019),
Street had pegged margins regions. impacted by mounting sug- demand in the summer — acreage in the state would be however, ISMA has projected
at 23-24 per cent. With HUL committed arcane arrears and market especially for soft drinks, ice ‘significantly’ lower in the production at 33 mt, about 0.5
Margin expansion was to deliver volume growth, glut, is looking for ‘sweet’ creams etc — will help reduce coming season. Even at the mt more than last season.
comfortably aided by analysts say there is room times next season (2019-20). domestic cane arrears to an all-India level, there is expec- Recovery in the sector has
growth across segments. to cede margins. This comes on the back of extent, though the magnitude tation that sugarcane avail- been higher across India com-
HUL’s mainstay product Investors will need to projections of lower produc- of the problem is quite big. ability will be much lower pared to last season.
line — beauty and personal moderate their near-term tion, coupled with higher The increase in sales quota than the current season, Although the quantum of
care — which accounts for expectations from the diversion of the crop for will support mills in clearing thereby reducing production. cane crushing is lower, sugar
about half its revenues, country’s largest consumer ethanol manufacturing. dues, even though the supply Further, with additional production was nevertheless
maintained margins at a firm. The HUL stock has Besides, given the likely situation continues to put greenfield and brownfield projected to be higher.
comfortable 28 per cent, corrected about 9 per cent higher offtake of sugar this pressure on sugar prices, cur- ethanol production capacities away from sugar into ethanol. depress sugar prices and Till end-April, 32.2 mt of
while its food and refresh- in 2019 so far, and valua- summer, with the Centre rais- rently hovering at coming up, the sugar industry This will further reduce result in arrears. sugar had already been pro-
ments, and home care seg- tions have moderated from ing the sugar sales quota to 2.1 ~31,000/tonne. is better placed to divert larg- production in 2019-20 and ISMA will obtain satellite duced in the country.
ments retained operating 70x its FY20 earnings to 59x million tonnes (mt) for May The Indian Sugar Mills er quantities of ‘B’ heavy insulate the sector from mar- images of domestic cane cul-
margins at 18 per cent each. the earnings. and a similar quota expected Association (ISMA) says water molasses/sugarcane juice ket glut conditions that tivations next month, to More on business-standard.com
A
and gave him a clean chit in all matters. “In a matter related to a s the Hindi heartland prepares ern India. However, that is not the case talks. Not even Prime
complaint concerning alleged violations of advisories of the for the fifth phase of polling on in northern India states, where the PM Minister Narendra Modi or
Commission and Model Code of Conduct, in a speech delivered by Monday, the Congress has remains popular. any Bharatiya Janata Party
Narendra Modi at Nanded, Maharashtra on April 6, a detailed nuanced its campaign tactics to make In Bharatpur, Rahul Gandhi (BJP) leader is talking about
report of the Chief Electoral Officer, Maharashtra was obtained. it appear less of a contest between accused the PM of deceiving youths by their own manifesto,” former
The matter has been examined in detail ... no such violation of Prime Minister Narendra Modi and promising 20 million jobs and leaving Union finance minister P
the extant advisories/provisions is attracted,” the EC said. PTI party chief Rahul Gandhi. It has also them unemployed. "Forget about Rs 15 Chidambaram said at a rally
decided to sidestep the BJP’s core plank lakh in bank accounts, he (Modi) did in Maharajganj, where he was
of nationalism to focus on issues of not deposit even Rs 5. He thinks that addressing an election cam-
Biopic on PM Defamation unemployment and farm distress.
The Congress leadership is set to
people of the country do not under-
stand anything. He kept assuring that
paign for the first time.
At the campaign for
Modi to release complaint filed travel in unreserved compartments in
trains heading to and from some of the
money will come in bank accounts he
had opened," Gandhi said.
Congress candidate Supriya
Shrinate, Chidambaram said
on May 24 now against Kejriwal poll-bound states, particularly Madhya In a letter written in Hindi, the if voted to power, the current
The makers of Vivek Oberoi- Pradesh, next week to spread the mes- Congress president made an emotional form of GST will be replaced
starrer biopic on Prime sage of its key promise of ‘Nyay’ or min- Congress leader Priyanka Gandhi Vadra urged the PM to protect farmers PTI appeal to the voters of Amethi urging with a more simplified GST
Minister Narendra Modi imum income guarantee of ~72,000 a them to re-elect him and promising to 2.0, where liberal tax rates
Friday announced that the year to 20 per cent of India’s poorest fifth phase across seven states ends on dynastic leadership of the Congress. give momentum to the development will suit the business com-
film will be released families. Saturday evening. Congress leaders, In terms of seats going to the polls, works in his Lok Sabha constituency munity. There would be one
countrywide on May 24, a day Addressing a rally in Rajasthan’s including party chief Rahul Gandhi it is the smallest of the seven phases. "blocked" by the BJP government. simple return every three
after the results of the Lok A man, claiming to be a BJP Bharatpur district on Friday, Rahul and general secretary Priyanka Gandhi, Seats in Bihar, Jammu and Kashmir, Taking a dig at Rahul Gandhi, months for the businessmen
Sabha elections are declared. member, has filed a criminal Gandhi in a reference to the Jan Dhan kept focus on issues that had brought Uttar Pradesh, Jharkhand, Madhya Finance Minister Arun Jaitley on Frid- in the GST 2.0. Like the Saral
The film, titled PM Narendra complaint against Delhi Chief Yojana said the Congress would the party victories in the Pradesh, Rajasthan and West ay wondered how the Congress presi- form for Income Tax there
Modi, was earlier set to Minister Arvind Kejriwal deposit ~72,000 annually in the peo- December Assembly polls in Bengal will have polling in this dent could damage the image of would be Saral GST in the
release on April 11 but was before a city court for ple's bank accounts “opened” by Prime Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan phase. In 2014, the BJP had Prime Minister Modi who is riding on Congress regime.
banned by the Election allegedly defaming the Minister Modi. and Chhattisgarh. swept most of these seats. the peak of his popularity. The Addressing the NYAY
Commission. In its order last saffron party leaders. In Rae Bareli, Congress leader The BJP leadership spent Congress sources said the dynasts have self-illusionary opinion samwad in eastern UP,
month, the EC had banned Additional Chief Metropolitan Priyanka Gandhi Vadra advised the PM the day targeting the Gandhi party has changed its campaign about themselves and tend to become Chidambaram said the
the screening of film during Magistrate Samar Vishal put to protect the fields of farmers. “You family since Amethi and Rae POLL tactics as the elections has megalomaniacs, he said adding Congress brought Right to
the poll period, saying any up the matter for hearing on are protecting people from Pakistan’s Bareli Lok Sabha seats, consid- VAULT entered the north Indian states. "Rahul Gandhi is no exception", he Education, Right to Food,
such film that subserves May 16. The complainant has aggression. This is a big achievement. ered strongholds of the family, 2019 In southern India, where the stated in a blog. Right to Information and
purpose of any political entity alleged that his and his Everyone is happy. But you should also go to polls on Monday. The BJP election is now over, the In New Delhi, BJP leader Piyush MNREGA, and now it will
or individual should not be party's reputation was protect the fields of farmers. That is leaders kept the debate centred Congress had portrayed its party Goyal said Rahul Gandhi will lose from ensure that every poor gets
displayed in the electronic dented by a defamatory nationalism as well,” she said. on the leadership of Prime Minister chief Rahul Gandhi as a more able and Amethi as he has not done any devel- ~72,000 per annum as finan-
media. BS REPORTER tweet made by Kejriwal in The campaigning for 51 seats in the Narendra Modi and criticised the tolerant leader than Modi. This is based opment work there. cial assistance.
September last year. PTI
VVPAT case: SC to
hear Oppn leaders’
plea next week
Submit expense
details in 90 days, Till Phase 6, number of women in fray crosses 600
EC tells MNS SACHIN P MAMPATTA
Mumbai, 3 May
Democratic Reforms (ADR)
and released on Friday.
A LONG WAY TO GO report. A total of 11 candidates
have cases related to hate
has declared zero assets.
But the overall proportion
n % of women candidates n % of candidates with criminal cases
The Maharashtra Navnirman Some couldn’t be analysed speech against them. of candidates with assets of
n % of candidates with assets of at least one crore rupees
Sena (MNS) has been asked to Data on candidate details up because of incompleteness or Candidates with assets of more than ~1 crore is 32 per
submit details within 90 days to the sixth phase of Lok Sabha unavailability of properly sca- 32 27 33 28 32 more than ~1 crore outnumber cent in phase six (311 in num-
of expenses incurred on the polls has revealed that the nned documents. The figure is 25 both women and those with ber). There are 2,018 such can-
23
election rallies of its president number of women candidates based on analysed affidavits. 21 20 criminal records. didates so far in the first six
17 19
The Supreme Court on Friday Raj Thackeray.An election has risen to 617. The proportion of women can- 16 The average assets of can- phases of elections. They acco-
agreed to hear next week a official said the notice for The total number of didates has actually dipped in 12 didates for the sixth phase of unt for 29 per cent of all candi-
review plea filed by 21 submission of election women candidates for this the sixth phase. It is down to 9 10 9 elections is ~3.41 crore. The dates, across phases. They
7 8
Opposition leaders seeking expenditure was issued after phase is 83. Polling for phase nine per cent compared to 12 richest candidate is the include members from the
further increase in random consultations with the six will take place on May 12 per cent in phase five. Candi- Congress’ Jyotiraditya Scindia BJP, the Congress, Bahujan
matching of VVPAT slips with Election Commission while the earlier phase (fifth) dates with criminal cases con- with assets worth ~374 crore. Samaj Party (BSP) and Aam
EVMs in the ongoing general following a complaint from is on May 6. tinue to outnumber women. In Phase 1 Phase 2 Phase 3 Phase 4 Phase 5 Phase 6 This is followed by former Aadmi Party (AAP).
elections. The apex court had the BJP demanding that The total number of candi- fact, twice the proportion of Source: The National Election Watch and Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR) cricketer Gautam Gambhir “Among the major parties,
on April 8 directed the expenditure incurred on MNS dates for phase six is 979. Of phase six candidates have (BJP candidate) with assets of 46 of the 54 candidates from
Election Commission to rallies be shown in the this, the affidavits of 967 can- criminal cases against them. Six candidates have cases against women. This includes ~147 crore. Virender Rana from BJP, 37 of the 46 candidates
increase random matching of accounts of opposition didates have been analysed in This is consistent with ear- related to murder, 25 have cas- assault or crime to outrage the Haryana’s Gurgaon con- from Congress, 31 out of the 49
Voter Verifiable Paper Audit candidates in the nine Lok a report prepared by non-gov- lier rounds of polls. Those with es of attempt to murder and modest of a woman and cru- stituency is third with assets candidates from BSP, and 71
Trail slips with EVMs in five Sabha constituencies where ernmental organisations the criminal cases against them five related to kidnapping in elty. “Two candidates have of ~102 crore. One candidate, Independent candidates have
polling booths per assembly Raj Thackeray addressed National Election Watch as account for 19 per cent of the phase six. Twenty one candi- declared cases related to rape Rajib Mahato, from the Purulia declared assets worth more
segment from one booth. PTI rallies. PTI well as Association for candidates across phases. dates have cases of crime (IPC Section 376),” noted the constituency in West Bengal, than ~1 crore,” said the report.
.
MUMBAI | 4 MAY 2019 ECONOMY & PUBLIC AFFAIRS 17 <
A
fter killing eight people in affected as soon as normalcy end is expected to bring in was 2x surge in bookings on
Odisha, cyclone Fani will returns, the ministry said. healthy collections as well. the day advance bookings
make a landfall in West Experts believe it will opened (as compared to the
Bengal early on Saturday. Bangladesh evacuates cross ~300 crore in the com- usual traffic).
Fani rolled through Odisha 500,000 people from
packing rain and windstorm that coastal areas
gusted up to 205 kmph after mak- Bangladesh evacuated over
ing a landfall around 8 am in Puri. 500,000 people from its
The storm severely damaged prop- southwestern districts as Cyclone
erty and public infrastructure in 13 Fani is likely to hit the country late
coast districts of the state. Deaths night and cause severe damage
were reported from Puri (3), after ravaging the Indian
Bhubaneswar (3), Kendrapara (1) Fani wreacked havoc on Odisha; commuters suffered due to train and flight cancellations coastlines.
and Nayagarh (1).
The cyclone was almost remi- poles have been ravaged in Puri melled Odisha, neighbouring West Minister Nardendra Modi’s rallies Arrangements in place
niscent of super cyclone of 1999, and Khurda districts. Restoration Bengal braced itself for the fury. in Tamluk and Jhargram have been for non-stop fuel
one of the worst calamities in the of power will take longer than we Even as seven constituencies postponed by a day. supply, says IOC
state’s history, which claimed over anticipated. In Bhubaneswar and from the state runs into the fifth Yogi Adityanath’s rally in Indian Oil Corporation (IOC) on
10,000 lives. Puri, the transmission infrastruc- phase of elections on May 6, the Jamshedpur, scheduled on Friday, Friday said it has made
Casualty was much less this ture needs to be relaid. No assess- state’s Chief Minister and was cancelled. The party’s presi- arrangements to ensure
time compared to 1999 as 1.08 mil- ment of monetary damage has Trinamool Congress (TMC) dent also cancelled three rallies in uninterrupted supply of petrol,
lion people were taken to safer been made yet,” said Hemant supremo Mamata Banerjee chose nearby Jharkhand on the same day diesel, LPG and jet fuel in Odisha
places before the cyclone struck. Sharma, secretary (energy), Odisha to monitor the situation from due to worsening weather. and West Bengal. “In the wake of
Odisha Chief Minister Naveen government. Kharagpur in the West Midnapore East and West Midnapore, both the cyclone Fani making landfall
Patnaik directed authorities to After the withdrawal of the district, a strategic location for North and South 24 Parganas, in Odisha earlier on Friday, IOC is
undertake immediate relief and super cyclone, an assessment was monitoring rescue operations. She Howrah, Hooghly, Jhargram, fully geared up and ensuring
restoration work. carried out by a team of Airports was on her way to a political rally Kolkata, and the Sundarbans are uninterrupted fuel supply from its
Also, mobile towers at many Authority of India (AAI) at in that district before deciding to likely to feel the initial impact of locations in Odisha and West
places were blown away, Bhubaneshwar Airport. The pas- cancel it and stayed back at Fani. Bengal on the east coast,” the Top Hollywood movies at
disrupting telecommunication senger terminal building has been Kharagpur. Flight operations were sus- company said.
services. “All telecom services are considerably damaged. The rooftop “Have cancelled my rallies for pended as Netaji Subhash Chandra
the Indian box office
down in Puri district,” said of ATC Tower has also been blown the next 48 hours because of what International Airport closed Voda Idea initiates AVENGERS: AVENGERS : JUNGLE
Special Relief Commissioner away, affecting VHF Antennas at could be an impending disaster down from 3 pm on May 3 to 8 am contingency measures ENDGAME INFINITYWAR BOOK
Bishnupada Sethi. the rooftop. Alternate ATC arrange- #CyclonicStormFANI. We are mon- on May 4. for Odisha subscribers
Bhubaneswar plunged into ment have been made. Based on itoring the situation 24x7 and doing Railways have cancelled Vodafone Idea on Friday said it ~266 cr ~240 cr ~186 cr
darkness as evening fell. The effect the feedback, it was decided that all it takes. I appeal to all people to over 225 trains anticipating has initiated contingency net after tax net after tax net after tax
has been catastrophic on the low Bhubaneshwar will resume com- cooperate. Be alert, take care and disruptions in operations because measures, including activating (seven days) (lifetime) (lifetime)
tension lines that feed the domes- mercial flight operation from 1 pm stay safe for the next two days,” she of the cyclone and has also put in emergency helpline number and
Note: Typically, a film's lifetime is considered 8 weeks’ run in movie
tic power consumers, an official on May 4. tweeted. place a quick-response team to free SMS, for its customers in halls Source: Industry estimates
said. As Fani, which means head of a The Bharatiya Janta Party also address any exigencies arising out Odisha. AGENCIES
“More than 100,000 electric snake and pronounced foni, pum- called off its rallies. While Prime of the cyclone.