Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Cap on cop overtime uncorked P. 6 | Superluxe condo’s curious math P. 7 | PLUS: More trouble at the Times P. 13
YES, BABY Leading-edge employers NEW NO. 1 What makes this startup THE LIST Meet the companies that
prioritize new parents P. 16 special? Just about everything P. 18 make work feel like play P. 20
This holiday
give your
business
the
best
T:14.5”
S:14”
network.
Save up to $400 when you
trade in your phone and buy
a new 4G LTE smartphone.*
New 2-yr activation on $34.99+ plan required. $400 = $150 instant credit
+ $150 bill credit + $100 smartphone trade-in credit.
vzw.com/myrep
Offer expires 12/31/15. Account credits applied within 2-3 billing cycles. Trade-in must be in good working condition. Bill Credit will be removed from account if line is suspended or changed to non-qualifying price plan after activation. Bill credit not available on upgrades.
*Devices eligible for instant discount: Kyocera Brigadier, BlackBerry Classic, LG G3, Samsung Galaxy S5 16GB, DROID Turbo 32GB, DROID Turbo 64GB, Samsung Galaxy Note 4, LG G Pad 10.1, Novatel 6620, Samsung Galaxy Tab® 4 10.1, LG G4, Samsung Galaxy S6
32GB, Samsung Galaxy Note 5, Samsung Galaxy Tab E 9.6. Activation/upgrade fee/line: $40. IMPORTANT CONSUMER INFORMATION: Corporate Subscribers Only. Subject to Major Acct Agmt, Calling Plan, & credit approval. Up to $350 early termination fee/line. Offers &
coverage, varying by svc, not available everywhere; see vzw.com. While supplies last. Restocking fee may apply. © 2015 Verizon. 80359
20151207-NEWS--0003-NAT-CCI-CN_-- 12/4/2015 7:39 PM Page 1
CRAINS
DECEMBER 7-13, 2015
FROM THE NEWSROOM | JEREMY SMERD
IN THIS ISSUE
The scandal is what’s legal 4 AGENDA
THE TRIALS OF SHELDON SILVER and Dean Skelos remind me of a 6 IN CASE YOU MISSED IT
truism in journalism: Sometimes the real scandal is what’s 7 REAL ESTATE
legal. In fact, Silver’s lawyers made that argument the 8 ASKED & ANSWERED We give fantasy
bedrock of their defense, arguing that you may not like that 9 HEALTH CARE
sports’ existential
troubles a
the former Assembly speaker made millions on referrals reality check
10 INSTANT EXPERT
from a doctor he also funded with research grants, but it
wasn’t illegal. It’s just what New York legislators do. 11 FINANCE
A jury last week disagreed, finding Silver guilty of 12 WHO OWNS THE BLOCK
honest-services fraud. But the 13 MEDIA
argument exemplifies what’s wrong with New York’s 14 VIEWPOINTS
politics. There are so many ways politicians use the perks of
A newspaper that is
their office to help themselves that doing so is simply really a campaign FEATURES
accepted practice. Not until U.S. Attorney Preet Bharara commercial, with the 16 BEST PLACES TO WORK
started indicting politicians did they begin to question the 36 GOTHAM GIGS
way they conducted themselves. Here are a smattering of
borough president’s
37 SNAPS
examples that may be legal but seem ethically problematic: pic on every page
38 FOR THE RECORD
the per diem allowances that legislators use to bump their
measly pay; the “fact-finding missions” that are really 39 PHOTO FINISH
junkets; and the personal expenses they charge to their campaign accounts, which
they also use to pay lawyers’ fees when they get into hot water. Nic Faitos
Another common practice is using taxpayer funds to underwrite campaign
pamphlets disguised as official newsletters, like one from Brooklyn Borough
President Eric Adams that recently arrived at my home. It initially appeared to be a
28-page newspaper called One Brooklyn, with articles and advertisements. A closer
look revealed at least one photo of Adams—and sometimes six—on every page.
There he was—smiling, dancing, BBQing, standing in front of an American flag. The
advertisements were not much better. One, from Broadway Stages, actually
congratulated Adams (for what, it did not say).
36
P.
Adams justified the mailer as a way to show constituents that he’s not just sitting
at his desk. “The most important part of this paper is to show that your borough
president is not ignoring any part of this community,” he said. “The pictures speak a
thousand words.”
These mailers are hardly the worst offense politicians commit. And I would
oppose any effort to regulate their speech. But taken together, they add up to a
permissive political culture. They are essentially campaign literature, which is why
city campaign-finance law prohibits them in the period before elections. At least
then we’ll get campaign literature funded by donor dollars. I expect to see many
ON THE COVER
more pictures of Eric Adams when he runs again in 2017. After all, he already
knows where I live. PHOTO: BUCK ENNIS
DIGITAL DISPATCHES
ECONOMIC
Prokhorov has taken sole own-
GIVE THEIR PREDICTIONS
FOR 2016
ership of the Brooklyn Nets and
Barclays Center, buying the
>
2016
Bruce Ratner’s Forest City Enterprises.
across the city’s industries
about what will shape ■ Peloton Interactive, a Chelsea-based
New York indoor-cycling fitness startup, has raised
in the year ahead. $75 million by selling a piece of the firm to
private-equity shop Callerton.
LISTEN Get the behind-the-scenes story on
COMING DEC. 21: what makes a great place to work. Music by
OUR ANNUAL BOOK OF LISTS the Wali Sanga CrainsNewYork.com/podcast
Vol. XXXI, No. 49, December 7, 2015—Crain’s New York Business (ISSN 8756-789X) is published weekly, except for double issues
the weeks of June 29, July 13, July 27, Aug. 10, Aug. 24 and Dec. 21, by Crain Communications Inc., 685 Third Ave., New York,
NY 10017. Periodicals postage paid at New York, NY, and additional mailing offices. Postmaster: Send address changes to:
BUCK ENNIS
Crain’s New York Business, Circulation Department, 1155 Gratiot Avenue, Detroit, MI 48207-2912.
For subscriber service: Call (877) 824-9379. Fax (313) 446-6777. $3.00 a copy, $99.95 one year, $179.95 two years.
(GST No. 13676-0444-RT)
©Entire contents copyright 2015 by Crain Communications Inc. All rights reserved.
GLOBAL WARMING
will increase storms’
intensity, leading to
more scenes like this
T
one in Sea Gate,
his is scary: The 170 national plans at the Paris climate- Brooklyn, after
change summit would still let the Earth’s average temper- Superstorm Sandy.
ature increase by 6 degrees Fahrenheit. To say a 6-degree
jump would drastically affect the planet would be an under-
statement. The last time temperatures were 2 to 5 degrees higher than
now, between 130,000 and 115,000 years ago, sea levels rose by 20 feet.
Much of New York would be submerged. Those few degrees would
change our world and life as we know it. And it would be irreversible.
Some of the warming that humans have caused is already baked in for
the next few millennia. But scientists say we still have a chance to avert
disaster by limiting the temperature gain to 3.6 degrees. The window,
though, is small and closing fast. It will shut when the feedback loops
become unbreakable. To name one: As the massive ice sheets melt, they
reflect less sunlight back into space, temperatures rise faster, melting
accelerates, and so on. apartments. Seal every drafty window. Give every household a smart
The way things are going, we are not going to make it. We have to do meter—and an electric bill. Phase out oil heat and old boilers. Put solar
something different. As one placard in panels, plants and reflective paint on every
Paris put it, there’s no Planet B. Opposition to government roof. Forbid overcooling offices—employers
Cities and states, obviously, cannot mandates is beside the point when will let men take off their jackets and ties.
solve this problem on their own. But Make all for-hire vehicles electric and
neither will nations. So New York must
the city could end up under water tourist buses low-emission. Limit genera-
lead and hope others follow. Ideologues tors to emergency use; connect all vendor
will defend individuals’ rights to waste energy or pay less than its true carts to the grid. Ambulances, too.
cost, but opposition to government mandates doesn’t apply when our Pass congestion pricing. Reduce alternate-side parking to monthly.
city could end up under water. Fortunately, measures such as making End free parking; slash parking mandates for developments. Discount
buildings energy-efficient and optimizing traffic save money and help off-peak subway fares. Use smaller buses and ferries at night. Charge for
the economy. But because of inertia, politics and the red tape and up- residential trash disposal. Build a rail-freight tunnel to get trucks
front costs of incentive programs, people don’t participate in them. off the roads. Keep nuclear plants open; construct more. Tax carbon.
Programs must be simplified if their use is to be required. Extreme measures? Consider the alternative. There really isn’t
Some ideas: Install radiator valves that prevent overheating of one. – THE EDITORS
FINE PRINT When the Rockefeller Center Christmas tree was lit last week, the city declared a “gridlock alert day.” It did so again the next day, as it had twice in late November. There will be five more such days through Dec. 23.
“Issuing a special advisory for traffic congestion in New York City—where the term ‘gridlock’ was invented—is like issuing a cold-weather advisory for the North Pole,” the Tri-State Transportation Campaign wrote on its blog.
BY GERALD SCHIFMAN
STATS AND THE CITY
25 WORDS OR LESS
MINORITY SHARE
“ I bought Billy Joel’s
house about 15
MINORITY- and women-owned business enterprises (MWBEs)
are winning more city contracts than ever, but it’s still a pittance.
ADDICTED TO NUMBERS? GET A DAILY DOSE AT @STATSANDTHECITY SOURCE Mayor’s Management Report,
Office of the NYC Comptroller
Neonatology
Nephrology Learn more at childrens.com/excellence.
Neurology &
Neurosurgery
Orthopedics
Urology
20151207-NEWS--0006-NAT-CCI-CN_-- 12/4/2015 6:42 PM Page 1
AGENDA ICYMI
EDITOR IN CHIEF Rance Crain
publisher, vp Jill R. Kaplan
CRAIN
assistant to the publisher
Alexis Sinclair, 212.210.0701
A
S PART OF A DEAL to hire 1,300 new police art director Carolyn McClain
photographer Buck Ennis
officers, Mayor Bill de Blasio and the City senior reporters Joe Anuta, Aaron Elstein,
Matthew Flamm, Daniel Geiger
Council promised in June to cap over- reporters Rosa Goldensohn,
Jonathan LaMantia, Caroline Lewis
time for uniformed police officers at $513 mil- data reporter Gerald Schifman
lion for this fiscal year. web producer Peter D’Amato
columnist Greg David
But in the first five months, the New York contributing editors Tom Acitelli,
Theresa Agovino, Paul Bennett,
Police Department spent $313 million on over- Erik Ipsen, Judith Messina, Cara S. Trager
time. At that rate, and excluding civilian over- ADVERTISING
www.crainsnewyork.com/advertise
time costs—usually 15% of the total—it would advertising director Irene Bar-Am
ibaram@crainsnewyork.com or
blow through the cap in nine months. 212.210.0133
senior account managers
The administration, however, says it is on Zita Doktor, Jill Bottomley Kunkes, Rob Pierce
track, citing Pope Francis’ visit as an outsize expense that won’t be repeated and the new officers as like- account managers Jake Musiker,
Stuart Smilowitz
ly to alleviate the need for overtime. Federal and other outside funding will offset some of the $313 mil- marketing coordinator LeAnn Richardson
sales/events coordinator Ashlee Schuppius
lion, a City Hall spokeswoman said. As of Dec. 4, the department had spent “below 50%” of the cap on 212.210.0282
aschuppius@crainsnewyork.com
city-funded overtime for uniformed officers, she said.
ONLINE
Budget experts said the NYPD could yet make its numbers. general manager Rosemary Maggiore
212.210.0237
“Five months in, they still have room to manage it if they’re on top of this,” said Maria Doulis, vice rmaggiore@crainsnewyork.com
CUSTOM CONTENT
president of the Citizens Budget Commission. director of custom content
While the administration insists the rookies arriving early next year will drive down overtime, offi- Patty Oppenheimer 212.210.0711
poppenheimer@crainsnewyork.com
cers have ways of creating it for themselves. Overtime spending sometimes grows along with the size EVENTS
www.crainsnewyork.com/events
of the NYPD, the city’s Independent Budget Office has found. — ROSA GOLDENSOHN director of conferences & events
Courtney Williams, 212.210.0257
cwilliams@crainsnewyork.com
Silver prepares to appeal DATA POINT closer to a makeover, but it’s unclear
manager of conferences & events
Adrienne Yee
Lawyers for Sheldon Silver, the for- MORE THAN 1,800 NEW YORK CITY who will do the heavy lifting. Cerberus AUDIENCE DEVELOPMENT
mer state Assembly speaker con- Capital Management is near a deal to director of audience & content
victed of pocketing more than $6 APARTMENTS WERE RETURNED TO buy Avon’s North American business, partnership development
Michael O’Connor, 212.210.0738
million for trading favors, are hop- RENT STABILIZATION WHEN 128 while an activist investor group, moconnor@crainsnewyork.com
ing to convince the trial judge that which has a 3% stake in the firm, has CRAIN’S 5BOROS
LANDLORDS WHO ACCEPTED TAX www.5boros.com
the jury got it wrong. Attorney launched a public campaign to turn
Irene Bar-Am, 212.210.0133
Steven F. Molo says his team will INCENTIVES FINALLY REGISTERED around the 130-year-old company. As ibaram@crainsnewyork.com
ask Judge Valerie Caproni to set THE UNITS of September, Avon had more than $2 SPECIAL PROJECTS
aside the verdict, arguing the pros- billion in debt and only about $600 manager Alexis Sinclair 212.210.0701
asinclair@crainsnewyork.com
ecution never proved that the million in cash. – AMANDA FUNG
REPRINTS
favors Silver granted depended on reprint account executive Krista Bora
the payments he received. 212.210.0750
PRODUCTION
Meanwhile, Silver has filed to col- Uber launched an aggressive politi-
production and pre-press director
lect his $90,000-plus state pension, cal offensive. Simone Pryce
after being automatically stripped media services manager Nicole Spell
of his seat upon conviction. City Opera may sing again SUBSCRIPTION CUSTOMER SERVICE
www.crainsnewyork.com/subscribe
The New York City Opera, which customerservice@crainsnewyork.com
Yahoo weighs future shut down two years ago, is work- 877-824-9379 (in the U.S. and Canada).
Verizon Communications and Barry ing its way out of bankruptcy. An $3.00 a copy for the print edition; or $99.95
one year, $179.95 two years, for print
Diller’s IAC/InterActive Corp. are organization led by hedge-fund subscriptions with digital access.
among the companies interested in manager Roy Niederhoffer, a former to contact the newsroom:
www.crainsnewyork.com/staff
buying Yahoo’s Internet business. opera board member, will take over
685 Third Ave., New York, NY 10017-4024
Last week, Yahoo’s board met to the company and pay its creditors. phone: 212-210-0100 fax: 212-210-0799
explore strategic options that A competing bidder for the 80- Salt wars Entire contents ©copyright 2015
include selling its core business and year-old opera withdrew his plan in A restaurant trade group
Crain Communications Inc. All rights
reserved. ®CityBusiness is a registered
spinning off Chinese e-commerce exchange for $300,000 once the representing 500,000 businesses is trademark of MCP Inc., used under license
company Alibaba Group. Yahoo has bankruptcy case is completed. suing the city for requiring eateries
agreement.
month, will not include a cap pro- continues the city’s efforts to secretary Merrilee Crain [1942-2012]
posal. When the city suggested a Avon awaits a caller promote healthy living.
one-year limit this past summer, Ailing cosmetics giant Avon is getting
M
anhattan-based Zeckendorf Devel- A strategy of pricing 50% above competitors
opment set the scene for sky-high and adjusting downward may turn out to be a
apartment prices in 2007 with 15 savvy business plan, said Jonathan Miller, presi-
Central Park West, the Robert A.M. dent of appraisal firm Miller Samuel. “I don’t see
Stern-designed condominium where they sold a [these metrics] as a sign of weakness at all,” Miller
penthouse for $42.4 million. At the firm’s latest said. “This illustrates that it doesn’t take a fire sale
offering, 50 United Nations Plaza, only 40 of the 87 to move a development.”
available units have closed since sales began two That doesn’t guarantee the Zeckendorfs’ gambit
years ago, according to data submitted to the state will pay off, as sales now average $2,700 a square
attorney general, city property records and inter- foot, $300 off their target. Their two penthouses hit
views with the developer. Nearly two-thirds of nearly $3,300 a square foot, so second-half sales,
the apartments that sold were closed at discounts mostly in the top of the tower, will be crucial to
that averaged nearly 9% and topped out at 16%. meeting the target.
By traditional measures, 50 United Nations The rising dollar and a growing inventory of
Plaza would be a dud. But brothers Arthur and ultraluxury apartments (including a Zeckendorf
William Lie Zeckendorf, the third generation of project at 520 Park Ave.), has brokers across the city
Zeckendorfs to build in New York City, may actu- wary of weakening
ally have another winner on their hands, despite high-end sales.
the headwinds buffeting New York City’s top-tier “The market is a little
PRICEY CUTS: SELECTED SALES AT 50 U.N. PLAZA
condo market. more challenging than it Ranked by discount
Around the time of a Champagne-filled launch was before,” said Donna
party in a model unit of the 43-story tower on Oct. Olshan, who runs her Unit Sq. ft. Asking price Sale price % off ask $/sq. ft.
22, 2013, the Zeckendorfs signed seven contracts, own brokerage and PH36 5,893 $23,250,000 $19,500,000 -16.1% $3,309
most in the lower half of the Foster + Partners- issues a weekly report 26A 2,609 $7,635,000 $6,445,522 -15.6% $2,470
designed building. All were above the asking price on luxury-apartment 33B 3,004 $10,200,000 $9,455,043 -7.3% $3,147
except for the last, a $9.4 million unit on the 29th sales. “But I think if 19B 3,004 $8,125,000 $7,533,627 -7.3% $2,508
floor that sold on Nov. 21 of that year for $8.9 mil- developing was easy, 27B 3,004 $9,130,000 $8,466,003 -7.3% $2,818
lion, a nearly 5% discount. Sales doubled in 2014, everybody would be in Source: New York City Department of Finance, Zeckendorf Development Co.
as buyers looked at higher floors, still under con- the business.” 䡲
struction, with discounts averaging 7%. So far in
2015, with construction nearly complete, 19
apartments have been sold and the average dis-
count has jumped to 9%, based on available
records.
To explain why, William Zeckendorf said that
in 2007, the brothers bought a half-acre vacant lot
on First Avenue, between East 46th and 47th
streets, for $150 million to build the first ultralux-
ury condo in Turtle Bay. Recent sales at Trump
World Tower and 100 United Nations Plaza, some
of the highest-end buildings in the neighborhood,
averaged below $2,000 per square foot. The
Zeckendorfs hope to achieve an average of $3,000
a square foot—$500 more than their underwriting
cost—even if it takes years.
“We purposely wanted to achieve higher
prices, and so we are perfectly comfortable with a
slightly slower sellout,” William Zeckendorf said,
noting the firm had banked on taking four years to
unload the entire building.
Because the Zeckendorfs and their partner,
Global Holdings, plan to pay off their construction
loan in early 2016, he said, they can afford to wait.
William Zeckendorf conceded they may have
priced some of the upper units too high, but noted
that 10 sales were in discounted bulk purchases,
including four units to Qatar’s U.N. mission for
$45 million this year. Foreign buyers, the build-
ing’s target, typically demand a price cut during
negotiations anyway, he said.
CORRECTIONS
The renewal terms for STEVE DEFRANK’s lease are $925 a month in
the first year, $1,100 in the following year and $1,200 the year after.
The monthly rents were misstated in the Nov. 30 “Keeping the artists
who made Bushwick cool.”
“ [Transgender]
W
endy Stark is on her second run as
executive director of the Callen-Lorde people fall into
Community Health Center in Chelsea. She poverty. They turn
wants the center to continue to set the to sex work
standard for lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender health
care—even if that can put her in controversial territory. Faced
with gaps in scientific research, Callen-Lorde in recent years
has used a mix of “clinical experience and philosophy,” she
said, to develop internationally used protocols for prescribing
hormones to people who are transgender, or don’t identify with
their birth gender. “That’s a scary road to take,” said Stark, who
started as a front-desk clerk in 1994 at the organization,
which has an annual budget exceeding $50 million.
You took a hiatus from being executive director between 2012 and 2015.
What changed in the intervening years?
When I left, we were having pretty significant capacity issues. In
2010, we opened an on-site pharmacy that ended up being a
DOSSIER
profit center. The organization I returned to was much more WHO SHE IS Executive
fiscally stable. We opened a second clinic in Chelsea in 2014 director, Callen-Lorde
and were invited by a Bronx organization to be its health care Community Health Center
par tner. AGE 44
BORN Las Vegas
Will you continue to co-locate with other health groups?
RESIDES South Slope,
That’s one of our growth strategies. We believe it will meet the Brooklyn
mission of ser ving the most underser ved members of the
EDUCATION Pomona
LGBTQ community: People who are uninsured or on Medicaid,
College, B.A. in psychology and
people who are homeless, people of transgender experience. women’s studies; Baruch College,
But it’s also a financial and real estate strategy. M.B.A. in health administration
JUGGLING Stark left Callen-Lorde
New York insurers had to cover many services for transgender patients for in 2012 when she had a baby,
the first time this year. What impact do you think that had? explaining that “it sounds like a
cliché but it’s true: It’s hard to parent
Because these ser vices historically have been left out of any
a young infant and have a job that’s
coverage, people have paid for them out-of-pocket, sometimes
full-time-plus.” Instead of staying
using desperate measures. People fall into pover ty. They turn to home, Stark became senior vice
sex work. So not having to turn in that direction, and being president of special populations and
suppor ted institutionally with their health care needs, people administration at Lutheran Family
potentially will be able to join the workforce in a different way. Health Centers. She rejoined Callen-
Lorde in February after the previous
You’ve said that there’s a shortage of trans-friendly doctors in New York. executive director retired.
What does trans-friendly health care look like? REAL ESTATE DREAM The real
When somebody first steps through the door, they see estate market has made it difficult for
Callen-Lorde to consolidate its Chelsea
themselves reflected in images on the walls or in brochures. The
locations, which soon will include two
forms people are asked to fill out have appropriate questions.
clinics and two administrative sites,
Clinicians are clinically competent and understand the health
BUC K ENN IS
H
ealth insur- earlier figure. While rev- “We recognize this the market, this change broker commissions for 3.25% of monthly pre-
ers have enue doubled to $83.8 will add to your chal- is necessary to ensure Oxford plans sold to miums, from 3%.
long relied million—and New York lenges at an already dif- we are able to grow our individuals, to $10 a Brokers, meanwhile,
on brokers membership also dou- ficult time,” Oscar business in a controlled contract per month, will focus on the small-
to steer clients their bled, to 34,000—med- wrote in its letter. manner.” from $15. For small- group market, as busi-
way. The commissions ical expenses nearly “Given the unprece- UnitedHealthcare group plans, Oxford nesses still rely on them
that agents earned on tripled, to $117.2 million. dented circumstances in also recently cut its raised commissions to to buy insurance. 䡲
each policy were
enough to make a
living—at least before
Obamacare.
The Affordable Care
Act has made it easy for
individuals to buy
insurance directly
Give employees
online. And as premium
prices fall, insurers are
looking to cut costs.
Brokers are feeling the
the duck.
pinch.
Oscar has now joined
other insurers in slash-
ing what it pays agents.
Anything else
The Manhattan startup
last month notified bro-
kers that commissions
would be more than
is just chicken.
halved in February.
Oscar had planned to 70 percent of employees say
pay them $14 per con- they’d likely purchase voluntary
tract each month for
individual subscribers
insurance if it were offered by
and up to $26 for their employers.1
enrolled families.
Instead, it will pay only The question is, who will you choose?
$6 a contract per month
regardless of the number
Why not offer coverage from Aflac, the No. 1 provider
of people in the plan,
of worksite/voluntary insurance sales for 14 consecutive
according to a letter it
sent to brokers. years?2 And only Aflac offers One Day PaySM, which allows
They have little your employees’ claims to get paid in just a day when they
choice but to take what- submit online.*
ever Oscar is willing to
pay, given the insurer’s There’s no direct cost to you for offering Aflac, and getting
growing presence in the
started is as simple as adding a payroll deduction. That’s
market: It’s been gain-
ing many former cus- why small business owners like you have chosen Aflac for
tomers of failed Health 60 years. It’s also why we’re so confident Aflac is the right
Republic of New York. solution for your business.
Jason Samel, owner
of JayMar Insurance You can bet the farm on it.
Agency in Glen Cove,
L.I., said that out of sev-
eral hundred people he
helped sign up for health Call your local agent and visit
coverage, about 80% aflac.com/smallbiz
chose Oscar. Many had
been insured by Health
Republic.
“For [Oscar] to turn
around just after open
enrollment began, it has
killed me,” Samel said. 1
2015 Aflac WorkForces Report, a study conducted by Research Now on behalf of Aflac, January 20 - February 10, 2015. Includes somewhat, very and extremely likely; of those employees who
But Oscar saw no are not currently offered voluntary insurance benefits by their employers. 2Eastbridge Consulting Group, U.S. Worksite/Voluntary Sales Report. Carrier Results for 2002-2015, Avon, CT. *One
reason to spend more on Day PaySM available for most properly documented, individual claims submitted online through Aflac SmartClaim® by 3 PM ET. Aflac SmartClaim® not available on the following: Short-Term
brokers, especially after Disability (excluding Accident and Sickness Riders), Life, Vision, Dental, Medicare Supplement, Long-Term Care/Home Health Care, Aflac Plus Rider and Group policies. Processing time is based
on business days after all required documentation needed to render a decision is received and no further validation and/or research is required. Individual Company Statistic, 2015. Individual
losing $41.5 million coverage is underwritten by American Family Life Assurance Company of Columbus. In New York, individual coverage is underwritten by American Family Life Assurance
through the first three Company of New York. Worldwide Headquarters | 1932 Wynnton Road | Columbus, GA 31999
quarters of 2015—more Z150004R 7/15
than double its year-
Why NY’s AG is throwing the book at FanDuel and DraftKings [in 5 steps]
1 2
Schneiderman’s move—if upheld—could enhance his standing as
daily fantasy sports a consumer-protection advocate and have serious repercussions
industry hit a major in states that are considering regulating rather than banning the
snag last month when New industry. Both FanDuel and DraftKings—which have each spent more
York state Attorney General than $100 million in advertising this year—are backed by powerful
Eric Schneiderman (right) investors, including NBC, Comcast, Fox Sports and Google. Nearly every
issued a cease-and-desist National Football League team has some form of sponsorship deal with one of the
order against FanDuel and DraftKings, the country’s largest DFS companies, and Dallas Cowboys owner Jerry Jones and New England
outfits. Labeling the games illegal in New York, Schneiderman Patriots owner Robert Kraft have equity stakes. Adding fuel to the fire,
accused the companies of being “the leaders of a massive, an unrelated lawsuit
multibillion-dollar scheme intended to evade the law and fleece sports fans filed in Florida last
across the country.” The companies say fantasy games—which pit month accused the
users in daily or weekly online contests based on athletes’ nation’s major
performances in real-world sporting events—are not gambling basketball, hockey,
because winning hinges more on users’ skill in assembling baseball and soccer
teams than on pure luck. State law defines gambling as “any leagues of negligence
contest in which the outcome depends in a material degree for partnering with the
upon an element of chance.” A New York Supreme Court judge companies and helping
was weighing the companies’ request to continue operating them “lure” bettors
while the legal battle with Schneiderman plays out. through “deceptive”
advertising.
SOME BACKSTORY
FanDuel and DraftKings
3
Traditional fantasy
aggressive marketing to promote majority of sports—which play out
their products. The two
companies now control roughly winnings over an entire season—are
legal thanks to an exemption in
95% of the U.S. daily fantasy- go to a mere 1% the federal 2006 Unlawful
sports market and are worth at
least $1 billion apiece. Much of
of the Internet Gambling Enforcement
that success has been credited participants Act, which excludes traditional
fantasy leagues, such as those
to the fact that daily games are
offered by ESPN and Yahoo,
more convenient and require
from government oversight.
much less time—and less skill,
Advocates for daily fantasy
some would argue—than their
sports insist that the only
season-long counterparts. New
difference between the two
Yorkers this year have wagered
forms of fantasy is duration, and
approximately $100 million on
because the winners in both cases are not determined by the
the two sites, each of which has
scores of actual games, the same rules should apply. “I’m quite
paid out more than $1 billion in
convinced it’s a game of skill, as defined by the federal statute,” said Major
prize money nationwide. But
League Baseball Commissioner Rob Manfred (above) in defense of
Schneiderman says the vast
his organization’s partnership with DraftKings. “And I’m
majority of winnings go to a mere
comfortable with the idea that it’s not gambling.”
1% of the participants, proof that
these “sharks” are using
algorithms or inside information
to game the system and cheat
everyday users. What’s more,
unlike season-long fantasy sites
WHAT’S NEXT
that primarily earn revenue from
5
Several states, including Arizona, Iowa, Louisiana, Montana and Washington, already bar DFS
entry fees and advertising, sites from accepting cash bets. Nevada recently deemed daily fantasy a form of gambling,
AP IMAGES, BLOOMBERG
FanDuel and DraftKings take a cut requiring providers to apply for state gaming licenses. FanDuel and DraftKings have countersued
of 5.5% to 13% from every wager. Schneiderman, calling his action “irresponsible” and “irrational,” and are requesting an expedited
“That’s what bookies do,” said court order declaring their activities legal under state law. In turn, Schneiderman vowed to bring
the attorney general, “and it’s both companies to court, setting the stage for a protracted legal battle that could determine the
illegal in New York state.” ultimate fate of daily fantasy sports.
AGENDA FINANCE
N
ew York’s financial tech- preferred term for startups that use we’re having productive conversa- in cash. In August, Standard
nology startups may finally innovative software to provide tions,” he said. Treasury, whose software helps small
have a chance to join the financial services. Another alum, Prem Melville, is a businesses bank online, was acquired
Wall Street big-money The city’s financial startups got a former IBM data scientist who by Silicon Valley Bank for an undis-
league, with JPMorgan Chase’s big boost five years ago when the founded Social Alpha, a firm that closed amount. No lab alumni have
announcement last week that it will Partnership for New York helped sifts through Twitter and other tried to go public, which may be wise
partner with a tiny nine-year-old launch an “innovation lab” that social media to find information of considering OnDeck’s share price
Manhattan-based firm, OnDeck offers entrepreneurs developing interest to investors. He claims has fallen more than 40% since its
Capital. promising technologies the oppor- many of the city’s largest banks and IPO late last year.
The arrangement gives JPMorgan tunity to work directly with finan- hedge funds as clients, and hopes to Gotsch said Tennessee-based
(assets: $2.4 trillion) a chance to cial institutions. turn his focus to new forms of data, defense company Digital Reasoning
serve OnDeck’s customers—typical- Lab alumni include Gary including email. “We see social opened a 20-person New York office
ly small-business owners who can’t Zimmerman, who last year debuted a media as just the tip of the iceberg,” to woo banks to its technology that
get bank loans. OnDeck (assets: $708 company called MaxMyInterest, Melville said. can read transcripts or text mes-
million) uses different criteria from which helps savers boost the amount Fintech investment is reaching sages. Pymetrics, a career-search
banks to gauge the creditworthiness of interest they earn from their frenzied levels. Last year, investors firm, received an undisclosed
of borrowers. (Its CEO, Noah accounts by automatically depositing pumped $768 million into New York- investment last week from Marsh &
Breslow, was a Crain’s 40 Under 40 their cash in online banks that offer based financial startups, up 32% over McLennan-owned Mercer Consult-
this year, and the company ranks the highest insured yields. the prior year. ing. And Kasisto, which develops
87th on Crain’s 2015 Best Places to Zimmerman, a former Citigroup A few Partnership lab alumni have speech-recognition technology for
Work list. See Page 32.) investment banker, said his startup been snapped up by larger rivals in banks, was created by some of the
“It’s a great example of the power has grabbed the attention of several recent months. In September, same people who built the iPhone’s
the city’s fintech sector can have,” of New York’s largest banks and BillGuard, a personal financial plan- virtual servant, Siri.
said Maria Gotsch, chief executive of asset-management firms, though he ning and security site, was acquired “Those people are from Stanford,”
the Partnership for New York City’s wouldn’t name names. “Our tech- by Prosper Marketplace, a publicly Gotsch crowed. “They chose to come
investment arm. “Fintech” is the nology interests a lot of them, and traded online lender, for $30 million from Silicon Valley to New York.” 䡲
63,500 SF
AVAILABLE
1200 WATERS PLACE, BRONX
WILL SUBDIVIDE TO 10,000 SF
Simone Development is now offering for
OHDVH&ODVV$RIĆFHKHDOWKFDUHVSDFHRQ
WKUHHćRRUVDW:DWHUV3ODFHLQWKH
+XWFKLQVRQ0HWUR&HQWHURIĆFHFRPSOH[
■ 'LUHFWO\RII+XWFKLQVRQ5LYHU3DUNZD\
LQ3HOKDP%D\VHFWLRQRIWKH%URQ[
■ PLQXWHVWR0DQKDWWDQ
■ /HVVWKDQDPLOHIURPPDMRUKRVSLWDOV
■ )LUVWFODVVDPHQLWLHV
■ $EXQGDQWSDUNLQJ
■ &RPSOLPHQWDU\6KXWWOH6HUYLFHDQG
07$EXVVHUYLFHWRQHDUE\VXEZD\
■ $GMDFHQWWRQHZ0HWUR&HQWHU$WULXP
■ 1RZ2SHQ0DUULRWW/X[XU\+RWHO
BY TOM ACITELLI
T
he business most prominently featured
in the recently ended federal corrup-
REBIRTH
tion trial of former state Assembly 10 LIBERT Y ST.
Speaker Sheldon Silver was Glenwood
Glenwood’s 45-story,
Management, the owner of 30 luxury apartment
287-unit luxury apart- OFFICE MATES
towers in Manhattan and in the Riverdale neigh- ment building, named 80 MAIDEN LANE
borhood of the Bronx. Liberty Plaza, debuted a
Normandy Real Estate Partners bought
year after 9/11.
Silver illegally received fees from a law firm to a 50% stake in the 25-story, nearly
which he steered Glenwood for tax-related work. 560,000-square-foot office building
from developer Joseph Chetrit in 2014.
The five-week trial saw the ex-speaker convicted Developer Jared Kushner, publisher of
on all seven counts of honest services fraud, extor- The New York Observer, was a minority
tion and money laundering. No one from partner with Normandy on the deal. The
family-owned AM Property Holding
Glenwood has been charged with any crime. Group controls the other 50%.
Glenwood founder Leonard Litwin began
buying and developing higher-end apart-
90 MAIDEN LANE
ment buildings in the 1950s. One of the best-
Normandy and Kushner also acquired
known addresses is 10 Liberty St., the first
this neighboring four-story, 30,000-
new development in the financial district to square-foot building in the 2014 deal, ART DECO CONVERSION
go up after 9/11. The tower is also within the which valued 80 and 90 Maiden at 100 MAIDEN LANE
district that Silver represented for 38 years, about $210 million in total. Developer Frank Lalezarian bought
until his felony conviction forced him to give this 24-story Art Deco office tower in
2004 and converted it into a 380-
up his Assembly seat. The block includes another unit luxury apartment building. It is
high-profile apartment development, this one a owned and managed by an LLC con-
conversion of an office building. 䡲 trolled by Lalezarian.
AGENDA MEDIA
T
he news never double the Times’ digital increase ad dollars, and a dif- past year. “That’s not what lasted a year).
stays good for revenue, to $800 million, in ferent approach to content. the Times is known for, and it Baquet noted that
long in the world five years. He’s been focused She will shift the focus to would be a huge loss not to MacCallum’s role will be like
of digital media. on the video division, long news from the expensive see [enterprise video] as that of a publisher, responsi-
Especially for The New seen as a potential source of mini-documentaries the valuable to its brand.” ble for journalistic quality
York Times. growth but which insiders division is known for. Baquet insists the Times and profits, and that she will
In October, the paper say has been neglected and Insiders have been told will still do enterprise video, hire a senior editor with
reached 1 million digital sub- mismanaged for years. that the number of staffers but wants more attention on deep video experience.
scribers. In November, The A July shake-up led to a dedicated to pulling clips breaking news. “Video can’t That’s an outdated model for
Washington Post stole the reassessment that culminat- from newswires and social be off on an island doing a new medium, say insiders.
Times’ thunder, pulling ed with buyout offers in media ultimately may rise enterprise,” he said. “No “The bottom line is you
ahead for the first time in early November and the to a dozen or more. desk does that; they do a mix have these talents who make
average monthly unique vis- appointment two weeks ago Department veterans say of enterprise and news, and video who need somebody
itors: 67 million to the Times’ of the unit’s fourth chief in Times management never video has got to accomplish who speaks their language,”
66 million, according to three years. valued video enough to build the same thing.” a staffer said. “There is
comScore. Alex MacCallum, formerly audiences for their work, Good video takes time, expertise needed in every
The Times notes that it has an assistant managing editor and is moving away from the and it needs to be “relevant phase of this.”
more people paying to be on in charge of audience devel- distinctive storytelling that after the breaking news Insiders estimate 13 of
its site. “I’m thrilled for the opment, was named assis- brought awards to the unit. event,” said one staffer. about 45 video staffers had
Post,” said Executive Editor tant editor and senior vice “The news was always MacCallum, highly regard- taken buyouts as of last
Dean Baquet. “But I’d rather president of video. When she [just] a thing we did,” said ed as a digital strategist, has week. Roughly half were
have our audience.” returns in January from one of the half-dozen star no experience in video senior producers. The Times
Baquet’s goal is to get maternity leave, she will talents who exited the unit as journalism (nor did her two has said there also could be
more paying subscribers and bring a new digital plan to morale plummeted in the predecessors, who each layoffs. 䡲
PREPARED
this evolving industry, must be able to anticipate
and react to developing trends including
demographic shifts, increased urbanization,
new technologies for information sharing and
financial processing, and green building. The NYU
School of Professional Studies Schack Institute
of Real Estate offers the MS in Real Estate, which
integrates theory with real-world practice. Learn
directly from seasoned industry veterans in
the heart of NYC—the real estate capital of the
world. Extraordinary networking opportunities,
internships at some of the top international real
estate firms, and study away opportunities around
the globe, provide a stellar education that ensures
your success now and throughout your career.
MS in Real Estate
CONCENTRATIONS:
Finance and Investment • Real Estate Management
New York University is an affirmative action/equal opportunity institution. ©2015 NYU School of Professional Studies.
AGENDA VIEWPOINTS
THUMBS DOWN
De Blasio housing proposals Community boards on de Blasio’s plan
have many zoning out 100
80
86
60
Mayor needs a better message, or a better plan 40
20
0 17
MAYOR BILL DE test of the popularity of the entire higher limits to keep out poor people. Yes No
Notes: Combined votes on mandatory inclusionary
BLASIO is having a housing plan. Finally, the administration can’t zoning and changes to building requirements. Includes
terrible time con- The administration has run into seem to counter the fear that no mat- votes with conditions. Results are as of Dec. 3.
Source: Department of City Planning
vincing New Yorkers trouble on three specifics—parking, ter what the plan, all the city will
that their city needs height restrictions and income lim- produce is luxury housing, as hap-
hundreds of thou- its—and one hangover from the pened under Michael Bloomberg, a But Bronx Borough President
sands of new hous- Bloomberg era. (not exactly true) belief that de Blasio Ruben Diaz Jr. got it exactly right
ing units—even with In what planners say is a no- continues to fuel. when he said last week that the de
GREG DAVID the enticement that brainer, the proposal eliminates To counter the drumbeat from the Blasio housing proposals are “com-
200,000 of the parking requirements for affordable critics, the mayor has changed the plicated.” The two zoning changes
apartments will be affordable. At risk units under the theory that the peo- way he is selling his plan. are only the first step, to be followed
is the mayor’s much-ballyhooed ple moving into those units will be Gentrification is a double-edged by individual rezoning of 15 neigh-
housing plan, which emphasizes too poor to own cars. Community- sword, he now says, crucial to borhoods—all different proposals
increased density and mandatory board members aren’t buying it. improving neighborhoods. He points and all containing a bewildering
affordability. Not surprisingly, increasing out that it will happen no matter number of options for the commu-
Community boards across the height limits to produce more what the city does, and it is only his nity and developers. It is hardly a
city are rejecting two proposed apartments has angered preserva- plan that will keep communities shock that people can’t figure it out.
changes to the zoning code that tionists, whose only priority is diverse with affordable housing. The administration needs to find
would set a general policy requiring keeping the city exactly as it is. To be fair, community boards a much more compelling story to
affordable housing and would alter The administration is being reflexively oppose almost all new sell its current scheme or come up
some of the requirements for double-teamed on income guidelines. zoning efforts. Council members with something much simpler to
amenities such as parking. Borough Poor communities want lower limits have generally abstained from vot- win over the public. 䡲
presidents are also either opposed to help more poor people get the ing on the de Blasio plan so far, as
or very critical. The public review of units; rich communities (insiders cite they will cast the vote that counts GREG DAVID blogs regularly at
these two changes has become a Riverdale as an example) want much at the end of the process. CrainsNewYork.com.
CRAIN’S WELCOMES SUBMISSIONS to its opinion pages. Send letters to letters@crainsnewyork.com. Send columns of 475 words or fewer to opinion@crainsnewyork.com.
Please include the writer’s name, company, address and telephone number.
AGENDA VIEWPOINTS
F
ashion is a $1.2 trillion supreme in New York, Americans’ engaged selling system, and a deeper world where fabric technology and
global industry, but com- shift away from spending on clothes understanding of consumers’ needs new fabrication can deliver incredi-
panies are having a harder does not bode well for this sizable and insecurities. ble consumer experiences: warmth,
and harder time resonating chunk of the local economy. They should: comfort, soft touches. Explain your
with American consumers. Apparel The problem is that fashion com- 䢇 Get to know their customers deeply. giant leaps; it will help you find
spending in the U.S. declined by panies have forgotten how to win the Don’t ask them what they want early users (and they will tell their
1.5% in June 2015, year-over-year, love of Americans. superficially. Understand their friends). Giant leaps create revolu-
and department-store sales were As a result, many shoppers buy hopes, dreams and wishes; study tions.
down 1.7%. clothes only when they end up on the their active and inactive wardrobes. In today’s world, new jeans, new
Indeed, for most American fami- markdown rack. In a country where Create breakthroughs that deliver for sweaters and new coats need to earn
lies, clothes are moving toward the 40% of the adult population is over- peer influencers. their way into wardrobe closets.
bottom of the budget list. While weight, new clothing has not been a 䢇 Remember that looks do count. If Engaged and highly trained in-store
households in Italy spend as much celebration. you show the goods on standard counselors can help.
as 17% of their gross income on Consumers have voted with their racks and without imagery, they Everyone still wants to go to work
fashion, American families spend feet. They wear fading T-shirts and will work their way to the final on Monday and hear, “You look
less than 4%. five-year-old jeans. Instead of markdown aisle without yielding marvelous.” Now is the New York
The trend is especially threatening clothes, many Americans buy any profit. fashion industry’s chance to tap into
to New York City, the global fashion iPhones, big cars, pets and pet sup- 䢇 Transform employees into disciples. that desire and win back its share of
capital. The industry here employs plies, and go on vacation. Deliver training and incentives that spending. 䡲
almost 200,000 people, pays more The solution: The New York- help them build relationships. Help
than $10 billion in wages and gener- based fashion industry can reconnect the “feet on the floor” see how they Michael J. Silverstein is a senior partner
ates almost $2 billion annually in tax with consumers using a mix of edu- can have “callings” as counselors and at the Boston Consulting Group and co-
revenue. cation, awareness, stunning mer- advisers, not cash clerks. author of Rocket: Eight Lessons to
While fashion may still reign chandise, a compassionate and 䢇 Take giant leaps. We live in a Secure Infinite Growth.
BABY BENEFITS
BOOM
Aging millennials and growing concerns about employee
engagement are driving improvements in parental leave
BY CARA S. TRAGER
O
n her 14-week maternity leave, Sarah Galena isn’t thinking twice
about her office job or the impact that her extended time off from
work has on her family’s finances.
And that’s precisely what her employer, Foothold Technology,
wanted to accomplish when it revised its maternity policy earlier
this year. The health technology firm, No. 69 on Crain’s 100 Best
Places to Work in NYC, bumped paid leave to 12 weeks for a birth
or adoption, from six weeks for a natural delivery and eight weeks for a C-section.
Galena, who lives on the Upper West Side, also plans to take off an additional two
weeks as part of her personal time. She said Foothold’s paid leave allows her to fully
with
Companies also want to remain competitive
their rivals on the parental-leave front.
Abacus Group LLC (No. 40) boosted its mater-
imagine myself here for many, of an all-staff meeting. nity leave last spring to eight paid weeks from
Source: Society for Human Resource
many more years.” Management Much of the improvement in one. The midtown tech firm formulated its new
Paid parental leave is having parental perks, locally and across policy—which includes a short-term disability
its moment, and the most obvious signs—aside the U.S., is being driven by “aging” millennials program that allows moms to exceed paid leave
from vocal advocacy by the nation’s parent in who are starting families of their own. “We had with a doctor’s note—after conducting research
chief and Facebook co-founder and CEO Mark never had a pregnant team member,” said into the leave policies of similar-size and larger
Zuckerberg’s taking a well-publicized two- Debra Klemm, operations manager for House of tech companies.
month paternity leave—are improvements in Kaizen (No. 94). “That changed earlier this In April, Stack Overflow (No. 4), which pro-
benefits like those offered by Foothold. That’s year, so we decided a policy was needed.” vides 12 and six weeks’ paid leave for primary
especially so in New York City. Along with In April, the 14-year-old digital-marketing and secondary caregivers, respectively,
headline-grabbing companies around the firm, located in midtown west, introduced an amended its benefit for sales employees. These
country such as Los Gatos, Calif.-based eight-week paid leave after childbirth and a workers receive at least 175% of their base
Netflix (one year paid leave) and Redmond, four-week paid leave for fathers and adoptive salary for the time they are on paid leave. The
Wash.-based Microsoft (20 weeks for mom, 12 parents. Moms and dads also can work from policy takes into account that a sizable portion
weeks for dad), many of our Best Places to home full time for four more weeks. of a salesperson’s compensation is based on
Work winners amped up their parental policies commissions, said People Team Director Joe
in 2015. ‘Work-life balance’ Humphries. The technology company, which
More than 95% of the firms on our list now Path Interactive (No. 39) for years had relied serves financial firms, also sweetens parental
provide paid time off for primary caregivers, on its policy of unlimited vacation to do double leave with as much as $5,000 in assistance for
and more than 75% grant compensated leave to duty as a parental-leave mechanism. But earlier adoption, and $500 for takeout meals during
secondary caregivers. Compare those rates this year, the search-engine optimization and the first four weeks of a leave.
with the results of the 2015 employer survey by marketing agency instituted a formal six-week Notable, too, if not surprising, is the care
the Society of Human Resource Management: paid leave for primary caregivers. (Path encour- that many Best Places companies take to ensure
Just 21% of U.S. companies offer paid materni- ages fathers of newborns to take two weeks off as that improved parental perks don’t engender
ty leave (up from 12% last year), while 17% part of their unlimited paid vacation time.) resentment in some employees even as it cre-
provide paid time off for dads with newborns, “We saw a need to think about how we ates goodwill in others. Squarespace officials,
compared with 12% in 2014. should be viewing our responsibility to helping for example, recognize that the work of parents
Moreover, the Family and Medical Leave Act employees achieve work-life balance,” said on leave still needs to get done, and simply
of 1993 requires firms with 50 employees or Michael Coppola, co-founder of the Flatiron dumping their responsibilities on employees
more to provide up to 12 weeks of unpaid leave. district-based firm. who haven’t welcomed a new baby is neither
Among Best Places companies, time-off Squarespace (No. 7) recently lengthened its fair nor, in many cases, practical. That’s why
policies for a new addition run the gamut from paid leave for primary caregivers to 18 weeks, Squarespace also hires temporary and contract
one to 18 weeks, and they are funded by the from 12, and to six weeks for nonprimary care- workers to help pick up the slack.
company, a disability program or some combi- givers, up from four. Why? The firm did the “You don’t want to burn out the rest of the
nation of both. While most Best Places offer math and realized that the average age of its team,” Passet said. 䡲
formal parental leave, others provide time off
to new moms and dads as part of a vacation,
sick-day or PTO policy.
The vast majority of Best Places also offer
HOW WE FOUND THE BEST EMPLOYERS
employees the option to take more time with-
TO ARRIVE AT OUR ANNUAL RANKING of the Best Places to Work in New York City, Crain’s partnered with
out pay. In addition, some maternity leaves
Best Companies Group, an independent research firm that dispatched surveys to more than 26,800
include such extras as a cash gift for the baby,
employees in New York City.
money for family meals and the chance to work
part time or at home for at least a couple of To be eligible, businesses had to employ 25 or more workers within the five boroughs. Scores from
employees, who answered a confidential 87-question poll, were combined with scores from a 92-
weeks after the leave ends.
question survey for employers. Questions focused on everything from telecommuting policies to opportu-
The trend toward more generous parental-
nities for advancement. Results from the employee surveys made up 75% of the total score, and from
leave policies is far from altruistic, however.
the employer questionnaire, 25%.
According to the Center for American Progress,
a Washington, D.C., policy institute, the aver- Although they hail from diverse fields—including technology, law, construction and real estate—the
100 winners have at least one thing in common: a profound commitment to their workers’ happiness.
age cost to replace employees, including inter-
viewing and training, is equal to about 20% of And many are sparing no expense to achieve that goal, treating their employees to a cornucopia of
annual salaries—and sometimes as much as benefits and perks, including generous health care coverage, telecommuting options, tuition assistance
200% for executives. and a daily menu of healthy snacks. They’re also providing lots of opportunities to de-stress at the office—
In the long run, maternity and paternity fitness classes, massages and arcade games—and off-site, with such perks as unlimited vacation.
leave saves money because it helps to retain Beyond those niceties, these companies have gone the distance in creating an atmosphere of collegiali-
(and recruit) talented workers. As the unem- ty, collaboration and caring, whether assigning a mentor to ease each new hire’s transition into the fold,
ployment rate continues to drop, providing offering paid time off for volunteer work, empowering employees to turn their ideas into projects or hosting
workers with increased leverage, parental ben- company getaways in scenic destinations.
efits are “low-hanging fruit that you can offer Unless otherwise noted, all figures are as of July 2015. Health care premiums represent the portion of
across the talent pool without breaking the the individual employee’s premiums paid by the company. Average salaries are those of exempt workers.
bank,” said Bruce Elliott, manager of compen- The abbreviation n/d indicates information that the company did not disclose. — CARA S.TRAGER
sation and benefits at the Society of Human
#1
You’re B
utton is a company that strives to encourage workers to actually take time
embody the Japanese value of off. The firm provides a $500 annual
omotenashi—wholehearted hospitality. stipend for each employee to use for a getaway,
This ethos informs not only the firm’s with an additional $500 for those with a spouse
most
business model, but also its thoughtfulness in and/or children.
regard to the needs and wants of its employees, From their first day on the job, employees
within and beyond the workplace. “When you know they have landed in an unusual workplace.
join Button, you join a family,” said Stephen Button eases first-day jitters with an extraordi-
Tuition assistance/
reimbursement
On-site meals/
CIPHERHEALTH
58%
provide lactation
for community service snacks or subsidies facilities for
breast-feeding moms
Telecommuting option Retirement plan(s)
#1 #2 #3 #4 #5
BUTTON DROPBOX BOUNCE STACK OVERFLOW CIPHERHEALTH
Industry Technology Industry Technology EXCHANGE Industry Technology Industry Health care/insurance
Website usebutton.com Website dropbox.com Industry Technology Website stackoverflow.com services
NYC/U.S. employees 25/25 NYC/U.S. employees 33/1,002 Website bounceexchange.com NYC/U.S. employees 94/176 Website cipherhealth.com
2014 revenue n/d 2014 revenue n/d NYC/U.S. employees 84/85 2014 revenue n/d NYC/U.S. employees 84/84
Average salary $99,700 Average salary n/d 2014 revenue n/d Average salary $81,349 2014 revenue n/d
Days off Unlimited Days off Unlimited Average salary n/d Days off 20 Average salary $70,000
Health care premiums 100% Health care premiums 100% Days off 20 Health care premiums 100% Days off Unlimited
Year founded 2014 Year founded 2007 Health care premiums 100% Year founded 2010 Health care premiums 100%
Year founded 2010 Year founded 2009
This year’s No. 1 Best Place to Doing good feels great at this This company scores high
Work in NYC is a VC-backed company, which makes it easy Employees here don’t need to marks with its employees for A three-week rental at the
startup that embraces the for employees to pursue their explain to their moms and dads creating a culture of Jersey Shore serves as the setting
Japanese value of omotenashi, or desires to make a difference. what they do or why they achievement, healthy for a sales team retreat, and
extending hospitality Through its Dropbox for Good spend so much time at work. competition among teams enables employees to get away
wholeheartedly. Proactively initiative, workers have Instead, they just bring them to and an atmosphere that with team members. In
addressing employees’ needs hosted company tours and Parents’ Day, a companywide resonates with workers’ addition, the firm has hosted a
and wants, the firm provides a shared their educational event that shows what the firm passion for technology. volleyball game at Pier 25 in
plethora of amenities, choices and career experiences is about, mixes family time TriBeCa.The company also
including group exercise, with such organizations as All with team bonding, and provides tuition assistance on a
happy hours, free daily lunch Star Code, which prepares features special activities, case-by-case basis.
and retreats in such places as young men of color for full- including, of course, a game of
Sag Harbor, L.I., and Park City, time employment in the tech Family Feud.
Utah, as well as such family- sector. In addition, employees
friendly benefits as $1,000 in get a day off per quarter to
“baby cash” to help offset the volunteer at a charity of their
costs of a new addition. This own choosing.
firm epitomizes a supportive,
respectful and kind workplace.
#6 #7 #8 #9 #10
WISDOMTREE SQUARESPACE CLUNE FLUENT INC. ELITE SEM
Industry Financial services Industry Technology CONSTRUCTION Industry Advertising/public Industry Advertising/public
Website wisdomtree.com Website squarespace.com CO. relations/marketing relations/marketing
NYC/U.S. employees 115/115 NYC/U.S. employees 259/377 Industry Construction Website fluentco.com Website elitesem.com
2014 revenue (in millions) n/d 2014 revenue (in millions) n/d Website clunegc.com NYC/U.S. employees 62/ 62 NYC/U.S. employees 39/118
Average salary n/d Average salary $106,263 NYC/U.S. employees 34/218 2014 revenue $68 million 2014 revenue $13.8 million
Days off 43 Days off Unlimited 2014 revenue $559 million Average salary n/d Average salary n/d
Health care premiums 75%- Health care premiums 100% Average salary n/d Days off 16 Days off Unlimited
99% Year founded 2004 Days off 17 Health care premiums 50%-74% Health care premiums 75%-
Year founded 1985 Year founded 2010 99%
Health care premiums 100%
Supported by the corporate Year founded 2004
Year founded 1979
After every 10 years of philosophy “Good work takes This is a place where niceties
employment, workers at this time,” staffers thrive, and get include $25 birthday gift cards, Twice a year, $1,000 in airline
publicly traded investment their work done, in a company A lengthy career at this $50 to decorate one’s credit, 50,000 Starwood
company are eligible for a that respects the creative company has its sweet workspace, an on-site points and $500 for trip
two-month paid sabbatical to process and doesn’t impose rewards, including trips, a “saloon,” Razor scooters for spending money go to an
pursue activities for personal arbitrary deadlines or react to $1,000 gift card, a Tiffany zipping around the office, employee who lives the firm’s
growth and development, market pressures. clock, extra time off and a arcade games and TVs in every four core values: “Circle of
including traveling, Rolex watch, depending on area. Education,” “Love What You
volunteering and research. the number of years of service. Do,” “Attitude of Gratitude”
and “Strive for Greatness.”
Four additional workers each
get the airline credit and
30,000 Starwood points for
embracing one core value.
401(k), profit-sharing 401(k), with optional 401(k), ESOP 401(k) 401(k), profit-sharing
plan Roth (post-tax) plan, defined-benefit
contributions, ESOP plan
SPIRIT
GENEROSITY
1511_002 Crain's Best Places to Work in New York Ad 2015.indd 2 2015-11-22 11:45 AM
20151207-NEWS--0022-NAT-CCI-CN_-- 12/3/2015 5:45 PM Page 1
93%
LIKEABLE MEDIA
401(k), profit-sharing 401(k), profit-sharing 401(k), ESOP, defined- 401(k), profit-sharing 401(k)
plan, ESOP benefit plan plan, defined-benefit
plan
Tuition assistance/
reimbursement
On-site meals/
41%
conduct annual
for community service snacks or subsidies
performance
Retirement plan(s)
reviews for all staff
Telecommuting option
COOLEY
91%
offer cafeteria or meal
subsidies, free daily
snacks or beverages
COOPERKATZ & CO. KIMPTON HOTELS & RESTAURANTS ALLISON+PARTNERS
STREETEASY
70%
enable employees to
work flexible hours or a
compressed workweek as a
standard year-round practice ABACUS GROUP LLC
401(k) 401(k) 401(k), annual stock 401(k), pension plan, 401(k), profit-sharing
awards defined-benefit plan plan
TEADS
Tuition assistance/
reimbursement
On-site meals/
89%
offer bonuses to
for community service snacks or subsidies
employees who
Telecommuting option Retirement plan(s)
refer new hires
tommyjohn.com
20151207-NEWS--0030-NAT-CCI-CN_-- 12/3/2015 5:55 PM Page 1
PLACEIQ
48%
enroll employees in the
15%
offer paid
organization’s health sabbaticals
care plan on their first
day of hire TRANSWESTERN
401(k), profit-sharing
401(k), profit-sharing plan 401(k), ESOP 401(k) 401(k)
plan, defined-benefit
plan
97%
offer domestic-
42%
provide tuition assistance
partner benefits or reimbursement for advance
or postgraduate degrees
ZOGSPORTS EMPIRE WEALTH STRATEGIES
Tuition assistance/
reimbursement
On-site meals/
56%
hold meetings and
for community service snacks or subsidies
staff-only events
Retirement plan(s)
solely during work
Telecommuting option
SITECOMPLI hours
401(k), profit-sharing 401(k), profit-sharing 401(k), profit-sharing 401(k), equity upon 401(k)
plan, ESOP plan plan hiring, defined-benefit
plan
66%
offer additional paid time
76%
invite immediate
off for community service family members
or volunteer activities to corporate events
ACCORDANT MEDIA SILVERLINE
GOTHAM GIGS
FLOWER POWER:
Nic Faitos’ rosy fortunes are
an exception to the thorny
wholesaler situation in the
flower district.
S
everal years ago, a Saudi sheik was flying to the welcomes walk-in customers, his bread-and-butter is
Super Bowl when his private plane stopped late corporate accounts. Clients include major financial insti- NIC FAITOS
one night at Newark Liberty International tutions such as Ernst & Young, as well as hotels, restau-
Airport with big trouble: All the flowers on board rants, trade shows and nonprofits like Gilda’s Club. (“I’m AGE 57
had died and new ones were needed—urgently—before a huge Gilda Radner fan,” Faitos said.) He estimates that BORN Santa Cruz, Calif.
the sheik and his entourage could proceed to the big his staff of 62 full-time employees makes 300 deliveries EDUCATION University of Florida,
game (a sheik needs to keep up appear- on a typical day and 1,000 on Valentine’s Day. B.A. in finance
ances). Nic Faitos swung into action, deliv- Faitos won’t say how much revenue his
ering a van stuffed full of roses and tropical
When shop generates, but last year he moved from
FLOWERS OVER FINANCE
Before selling flowers, in the 1980s
flowers to the anxious passengers—at 3 in something his longtime home in the historic flower dis- Faitos was a stockbroker at Shearson
the morning. can only be trict for a larger, two-floor space on West Lehman/American Express and
“The tricky part was getting clearance to said with 26th Street. PaineWebber. In the days before per-
drive out onto the tarmac,” recalled Faitos, Such robust health is unusual in his line of sonal computers, he sold electric
who is now looking to offer this sort of
flowers, work. The number of wholesalers in the typewriters that could handle primi-
round-the-clock service to everyone. Next it doesn’t flower district—an area on Sixth Avenue tive word-processing tasks. In col-
lege, he supported himself as a door-
year, Faitos is planning to keep open his matter what between West 26th and West 30th streets,
to-door encyclopedia salesman.
Starbright Floral Design shop, in Chelsea, 24 and along West 28th Street—has shrunk from
time it is CUPID PREVAILS He hired people
hours a day. After all, when something can 20 to five in the past two decades, owing to
via Craigslist to deliver flowers on
only be said with flowers, it doesn’t matter the rise of online flower sellers and skyrock-
Valentine’s Day weekend in 2014,
what time it is. eting rents. Faitos quipped that flower-district streets
when the city was all but shut down
“If we get a midnight flower emergency, we’ll be now look like the I-95 corridor because of all the chain
by a big snowstorm.
ready for it,” said Faitos, who, for now, closes his store hotels that have moved in. That said, his business has
BUCK ENNIS
most days at 8 p.m. grown every year, and he believes the Chelsea whole-
Faitos has been wrapping roses, tiptoeing through the salers that survived the shakeout will stick around for a
tulips and tending to his gardens for 22 years. Though he good while longer. — AARON ELSTEIN
SNAPS
Fresh Air Fund gala Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children benefit
William Lauder, executive chairman of Estée Lauder Cos., Fatima Shama,
executive director of the Fresh Air Fund, Janice Savin-Williams, co-
founder of the Williams Capital Group, and her husband, Christopher
Williams, chairman and CEO of Williams Capital, at a Nov. 19 benefit for
the Fresh Air Fund. The nonprofit sends inner-city children to summer
TOP: ERIC VITALE PHOTOGRAPHY / BOTTOM LEFT: JERRY SPEIER / BOTTOM RIGHT: OWEN HOFFMANN/PATRICKMCMULLAN.COM
Christopher O’Malley,
executive director of Mary Pulido, execu-
the Interest on tive director of the
Lawyer Account Fund society, and
of New York, and Kimberly Guilfoyle, a
Wendy Flanagan, a Fox News anchor, at
Fresh Air Fund board the gala, which
member, at the brought in
Chelsea Piers event. It $540,000.
took in $546,000.
SEE MORE OF THIS WEEK’S SNAPS ONLINE AT CRAINSNEWYORK.COM/SNAPS
PHOTO FINISH
Pedaling
a new idea
T
wo low-slung black metal tricycles
wait for loads of freshly dry-cleaned
laundry outside NextCleaners on East
12th Street. A fleet of 30 electric
bicycles—inspired by European delivery serv-
ices, and costing about $5,000 apiece—are one
way former Morgan Stanley and software-
startup exec Kam Saifi, 55, plans to keep his
dry-cleaning delivery service environmentally
friendly.
As on-demand services deliver everything
from groceries to prescription drugs, compa-
nies like Saifi’s are shunning vans in favor of
freight tricycles, which are ideal for “last
mile” delivery of goods. Apart from sparing
the air, the trikes can navigate Manhattan’s
gridlocked streets and slip into parking spaces
better than trucks and vans. But adoption in
the city has been slow. Six cargo companies
operate in New York, including Revolution
Rickshaws, which leases its trikes to local
outfits City Bakery and City Harvest.
Another is NextCleaner’s cargo-trike sup-
plier, MetroSpeedy, a startup that counts Saifi
as an investor and is gearing up to make its
delivery services widely available.
— PETER D’AMATO
PETER D’AMATO
T:14.5”
S:14”
With 3D Touch, Live Photos, 7000 Series aluminum, A9 chip, advanced cameras, 4.7-inch Retina HD
display, and so much more, you’ll see how with iPhone 6s the only thing that’s changed is everything.
$5/mo for 18-mos. Well-qualified customers. Valid lease required for promotional pricing.
Limited time offers; subject to change. Eligible paid-off device trade-in, lease, $15 SIM starter kit, and qualifying service required. $5+taxes/mo. for 18-mo. lease after monthly bill credits. Must remain on qualifying service in good standing for duration of lease term. If you cancel wireless service, promotional pricing
is unavailable and payments are up to $27/mo. Amount paid at signing, if any, may reduce monthly device charge. At end of 18-mos. you must return device in good condition or pay it off to keep it. Fee may apply for damaged/lost devices. You are responsible for insurance/repairs; insurance recommended (required
for CT customers). No device security deposit required. Late/non-payment fees may apply. Up to $350/line in credits: Limited time offer; subject to change. Taxes and fees additional. Not all features available on all devices. Participating locations only. Service port-in from eligible carrier (such as AT&T, Verizon, and
Sprint), qualifying service and data plan required for each line. Initial bill credit of $100 processed within 90 days of activation. Additional bill credits applied monthly ($5/mo. for pool data or 3GB data plans and $10/mo. for data plans over 5GB) for up to 25 mos; $0 promo plans not included. Must be active and in good
standing with T-Mobile when credit is processed. One offer per Corporate Account. Offer cannot be combined with ETF or device payoff offers. Coverage not available in some areas. See T-Mobile.com for additional information, including Terms and Conditions. iPhone is a trademark of Apple, Inc. T-Mobile and the
magenta color are registered trademarks of Deutsche Telekom AG. © 2015 T-Mobile USA, Inc.