Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Review Paper
Laureate Institute of Pharmacy, Kathog, Tehsil Dehra, District Kangra, (H.P.) - India
th
Accepted 25 April, 2015
Pesticide poisoning kills hundreds of thousands of people in India each year. The majority are from deliberate self-
poisoning with Organophosphorus pesticides (OP), Aluminium phosphide and Paraquat. The current response from a
public health, medical and research perspective is inadequate. There are few proven or effective treatments; in addition,
very little clinical research has been done to transfer antidotes shown to work in animal studies into clinical practice. The
human toxicity of pesticides is poorly studied and better information might inform a more sustained and appropriate
regulatory response. Further understanding may also lead to improvement in diagnosis and treatment. The few effective
treatments are not being recommended or delivered in an optimal and timely fashion to poisoned patients. A regional
approach to facilitate appropriate pricing, packaging and delivery of antidotes is required.
INTRODUCTION
Self-poisoning with pesticides is a major problem. It is and supported, could provide this information from across the
estimated that hundreds of thousands of people die each year, world. At any rate, it is known that the pesticides that cause
the majority from deliberate self-poisoning with most deaths in rural Asia, and in the world, are WHO Class I
1
organophosphorus pesticides (OP) . Aluminium phosphide and II organophosphorus pesticides - causing an estimated
3
and paraquat are also responsible for many deaths in some 200,000 deaths .
areas. Although, the number of deaths indicates that this is a At any rate, in rural Asia, the variety of pesticides
major public health problem, of the same order of magnitude available in communities for intentional or unintentional
as diabetes or HIV in many countries in the region, there is poisoning are large, reflecting the pesticides used in local
little coordinated effort being applied to improve the medical agriculture. Studies from Sri Lanka suggest that less than 20%
response to this problem. Only one antidote, atropine for OP of pesticides used for self-harm 10 are bought for the purpose;
poisoning, could be regarded as being of proven effectiveness. the majorities are freely available in the home or nearby
In this article we will describe further the requirements garden. The vast majority of these deaths are intentional;
antidotes need to meet in order to be useful in practice and our unintentional oral or dermal exposure to WHO Class I OP
experience with running clinical trials on pesticide antidotes in pesticides can cause severe poisoning, but the doses are
India. We will then argue the case for more translational usually smaller than with intentional poisoning, resulting in
research to progress antidotes that have been shown to be fewer deaths. WHO Class II OPs are generally less toxic in
effective in animals into human trials and the need for research unintentional poisoning. Where Class II OPs are the most
and planning for how best to provide and use these antidotes commonly used insecticides, unintentional poisoning is
in the resource poor rural areas of Asia where pesticide generally less likely to cause severe poisoning. Class II OPs
2
poisoning is most important . are highly toxic in intentional overdose. Other classes of
Pesticides, most frequently used in accidental/deliberate pesticide that are common causes of significant and/or fatal
intoxication globally; there is a scarcity of information on the poisoning include carbamate and organochlorine insecticides,
magnitude of both intentional and unintentional poisoning, as the fumigant aluminium phosphide (a significant problem in
well as on the relative importance of different pesticides. This north India), and the herbicide paraquat. Less common causes
information is particularly lacking from most of Africa, and of significant poisoning include the herbicides chlorphenoxy
detailed and accurate community-based data on the pesticides acetic acid derivatives and propanil, some pyrethroid
4
responsible for fatal self-harm are not available for most of insecticides, avermectins, and amitraz . The locally available
rural Asia. Sentinel centers, that would need to be identified pesticides will also determine how many poisoned people
www.pyrexjournals.org
Sharma et al PYRX. J. Pha.Pha | 003
need to apply the basic treatment correctly, to tailor treatment
to the patient, to evaluate the need for gastric decontamination, Ingredients in LBAM butylated hydroxytoluene (World
and to give antidotes early. In emergency medical treatment Health Org)
the initial management is pivotal, yet, in spite of a great
variation in initial management, with no standardization, the Butylated hydroxyanisole (E 320) & Butylated hydroxytoulene
basic principles of initial resuscitation and assessment are (E 321) are two antioxidants listed as possible cancerogenic
often applied only after gastric decontamination for which there substances, according to WHO's cancer research tricaprylyl
is currently no evidence of benefit (American Academy of methyl ammonium chloride, Potential Acute Health Effects:
Clinical Toxicology and European Association of Poison (from MSDS data) Extremely hazardous in case of skin contact
12
Centre’s and Clinical Toxicologists, 2004 a, b . (irritant), of eye contact (irritant), of ingestion, of inhalation
Information on safe airway management and intubation (lung irritant). Hazardous in case of skin contact (corrosive,
should be part of the basic training of any health worker and permeator). Inflammation of the eye is characterized by
included in any document on management of emergencies redness, watering, and itching. Skin inflammation is
published by health agencies and authorities. Gastric lavage characterized by itching, scaling, reddening, or, occasionally,
the importance of iatrogenic deaths as shown by the number of blistering. polyvinyl alcohol: (MSDS data) Potential Acute
deaths occurring after ingestion of low toxicity pesticides needs Health Effects: Slightly hazardous in case of skin contact
to be emphasized13. The role of inappropriate gastric (irritant), of eye contact (irritant), of ingestion, of inhalation.
decontamination in these deaths is important. There is a need Sodium phosphate, immediate effects: Inhalation of this
to tailor treatment to the poison and the patient; for example, if product may be irritating to the nose and throat, causing
a person has ingested a low toxicity pesticide 12 and does not coughing and choking. Ingestion of large amounts may cause
show clinical features of poisoning, it may be best to only diarrhea, nausea, vomiting and cramps. It may cause eye and
observe and support the patient rather than carrying out gastric skin irritations. Potential health effects: Primary Routes of
13
decontamination and giving antidotes . entry: Inhalation, ingestion or skin absorption. Signs and
There is much discussion about the use of gastric lavage Symptoms of Overexposure: Dermatitis may develop from
or forced emesis compared to activated charcoal in pesticide repeated or prolonged skin contact. Eyes: Irritating. Skin:
poisoned patients. Recent studies indicate that single or Irritating. Ingestion: Nausea and vomiting. Inhalation: Irritates
multiple doses of activated charcoal are safe in pesticide the nose and throat and may cause coughing and chest
poisoned patients, including patients receiving appropriate discomfort. Chronic Exposure: Dust may aggravate existing
amounts of atropine. By contrast, both forced emesis and pulmonary conditions and/or asthma. A Chemical Listed As
16
gastric lavage have potential serious complications if Carcinogen Or Potential Carcinogen .
performed in nonconsenting patients or unconscious patients
without airway protection However, in light of the absence of Allopathic recommendations for pesticide poisoning
direct data showing the benefits of charcoal over other forms of
gastric decontamination, it is difficult to make a strong Skin decontamination is accomplished with a shower using
recommendation. Overall, if a patient presented within one soap, large amounts of water, and shampoo. Skin folds, areas
hour to a health care facility, the administration of activated underneath fingernails, ear canals, and other portions of the
charcoal should be considered if the patient is conscious and body that may trap chemicals should be inspected and cleaned
gives consent. The patient should not be forced to accept the carefully. Contact lenses should be removed, so the eyes can
charcoal. Forced emesis is not recommended. Oral fluids be inspected and irrigated thoroughly if exposure is suspected.
14
should not be given . Contaminated clothing should be removed, bagged, and
laundered carefully. Leather items usually cannot be
Pesticide poisoning and suggested therapies decontaminated and should be bagged and treated as
hazardous waste. – Gastric lavage Consider if the patient
Some common brand name chemicals containing presents within 60 minutes of ingestion. Insert orogastric tube.
organophosphate compounds include Bidrin, Thimet, Orthene, Attempt aspiration first, followed by 100 to 200 ml normal
Dursban, and Guthion. Common chemical names for saline, then aspiration. Relatively contraindicated in
organophosphate active ingredients include methyl parathion, hydrocarbon ingestion it is indicated only when the potentially
ethyl parathion, malathion, and chlorpyrifos. Organophosphate life-threatening amount of poison is ingested and the
insecticides affect people in much the same way they affect procedure can be done within 60 minutes of ingestion.
insects -- the nervous system is damaged and breathing Cathartics used only in combination with activated charcoal
becomes difficult. Symptoms of acute organophosphate Sorbitol (1 to 2 ml/kg or 70 percent solution in adults, 1.5 to 2.5
poisoning usually appear within 4 hours of the exposure. ml/kg of 35 percent solution in children) Single dose only Not
Common, early symptoms may include headache, nausea, and recommended in poisonings that produce diarrhea
dizziness. The victim may also appear anxious and restless. (organophosphates, carbamates, heavy metals in particular) or
The later symptoms of a worsening condition are muscle those that produce ileus (paraquat and diquat) If it is used, it
twitching, weakness, abdominal cramps, and vomiting. should be as a single dose. Numerous contraindications:
Sweating, salivation, and tearing are often seen. Dark or absent bowel sounds, abdominal trauma or surgery, intestinal
blurred vision and constricted pupils are other symptoms that perforation or obstruction, volume depletion, hypotension, or
17
may occur. Tightness of the chest and coughing may lead to ingestion of a corrosive substance .
respiratory depression, or the lungs may fill with fluid. Either
way, without immediate medical attention, the victim may die. First Aid Treatments
Two antidotes doctors use for treating organophosphate
poisonings are atropine and 2-PAM. Large doses of the If the poison has been inhaled, as in the case of toxic
antidote may be needed for a severe poisoning, and follow-up fumigants, the patient should be removed to the open air and
doses may need to be given for several hours to several given artificial respiration. If the poison has been spilled on the
15
days . skin, it should be washed off immediately with large amounts of
www.pyrexjournals.org
Sharma et al PYRX. J. Pha.Pha | 004
warm soapy water, scrubbing the skin thoroughly. Drop or Thermal Decomposition
particles in the eyes should be removed by flushing with large
18
quantities of plain water . This method requires exposure of the pesticide to a high
If the poison has been swallowed, the stomach of the temperature (900-1000 °C) for varying periods of time. This
affected person should be emptied as soon and as completely method is satisfactory enough as it degrades about 98% or
14
as possible. After this has been done, a demulcent such as even more of most of the commercial pesticide formulations .
raw eggs, milk or a thin flour paste can be given. These serve The exposure time should be sufficient so as to ensure
to absorb the poison, and to soothe the irritated membranes. If complete decompositions, and care must be taken to remove
the specific poison is known, the following emergency air pollutants before the gases are discharged into the
treatments could be given. atmosphere.
A wet scrubber and filtration through a porous clay bed
Acids and carbon filter, with lagoon treatment of the waste water, are
suggested. Mercury, arsenic, lead and similar toxic compounds
Limewater or milk of lime, milk of magnesia should be given, should not be incinerated unless special residue handling and
arsenic Compounds. After emptying the stomach, raw eggs, disposal facilities are available.
milk, lime water, flour, and water, or sweet oil should be given.
Chemical Neutralization
Benzene Hexachloride
This is feasible for most of the organophosphates and
Tea or coffee and gypsum salts may be given after the carbonate insecticides, but not for the chlorinated
stomach has been emptied. Chloroans, same treatment as hydrocarbons. Various chemicals used to destroy the
benzene hexachloride. The same treatment as for benzene pesticides are nitric acid, sulfuric acid, ammonium hydroxide,
hexachloride sodium hydroxide, chlorine compounds, peroxides or other
types of active chemicals. Calcium hydrochloride seems to
Mercury Compounds have the broadest application. A strong acid or alkaline
19
hydrolysis does not provide complete treatment .
Raw egg and milk should be given immediately.
Burial
Nicotines
Burial is susceptible to contamination of waters and ground
After emptying the stomach, stimulants such as hot tea or waters from leaching and run off on pesticides. Careful shallow
coffee should be given. Parathion after emptying the stomach burial with 18 inches of earth for small quantities of pesticides
has a physician administer 1/30 to 1/60 grain of atropine in clay soil is generally acceptable until a better method is
sulfate at hourly intervals, until pupils dilate. developed.
The location should be well above ground water level,
Tetraethyl Pyrophosphate downgrade, and several hundred feet from any source of water
supply and they should also be beyond the reach of children
The same treatment as recommended in the case of parathion and animals. The burial of pesticides in sandy soils is not
may be given. The following information will also be useful in recommended as it has greater possibility of leaching into
20
this connection. surface water or ground water .
Provides information with regard to the first aid measures that This method is satisfactory for short lived materials while for
are necessary to be taken in cases of pesticide poisoning other more persistent materials, the rate of degradation is too
before a physician attends the case. slow. The persistence of some pesticides in soils is given in
proper facilities are available, surplus pesticides and
IS: 4015 (Part II) 1967: containers should be disposed of as described above.
Lead, Copper, Arsenic Dieldrin, BHC, DDT insecticides
Outlines the basic information intended for the use of Triazine herbicides Urea herbicides Benzoic acid herbicides 2,
physicians with regard to the symptoms, differential diagnosis 4-D: 2, 4, 5-T Herbicides Organophosphorous insecticides
21-22
and treatment in relation to poisoning due to different types of Carbamate (Carbaryl) insecticides .
pesticides and their formulations during their use in a
laboratory, field or a factory. Conclusion
www.pyrexjournals.org
Sharma et al PYRX. J. Pha.Pha | 005
and an equal quantity is imported, mainly for malaria control. 5. Dawson A, Buckley NA (2007). Integrating approaches to paraquat
poisoning.Ceylon Medical Journal, 52: 45-47.
Apparently the malaria carrying mosquito, Anopheles 6. Eddleston M (2000). Patterns and problems of deliberate self-poisoning in
culcifacious, has become resistant to many kinds of the developing world. Quarterly Journal of Medicine, 93: 715-731.
18, 23
insecticides . 7. Eddleston M, Buckley NA, Checketts H, Senarathna L, Mohamed F,
The universe of cultivated crops often overlaps the SheriffMHR, Dawson AH (2004). Speed of initial atropinisation in significant
organophosphorus pesticide poisoning - a systematic comparison of
habitats of insects responsible for transmission of human recommended regimens. Journal of Toxicology. Clinical Toxicology, 42: 865-875.
diseases. This is particularly true in the case of the mosquito 8. Eddleston M, Eyer P, Worek F, Mohamed F, Senarathna L, von Meyer
popu-lation, which breeds in diverse water bodies in all types L,Juszczak E, Hittarage A, Azhar S, Dissanayake W, Sheriff MHR, Szinicz
L,Dawson AH, Buckley NA (2005). Differences between organophosphorus
of situations. Repeated application of different pesticides insecticides in human self-poisoning: a prospective cohort study. Lancet,
ensures exposure of genera of these insects of speedy 366:1452-1459.
selection for resistance to the pesticides used. Increase in 9. Eddleston M, Karunaratne A, Weerakoon M, Kumarasinghe S,
malaria during the last few years has obviously made it Rajapakshe M,Sheriff MHR, Buckley NA, Gunnell D (2006a). Choice of poison
for intentional self-poisoning in rural Sri Lanka. Clinical Toxicology, 44: 283-286.
necessary to plan for a much greater use of DDT. Attempts are 10. Eddleston M, Mohamed F, Davies JOJ, Eyer P, Worek F, Sheriff
being made to find alternatives to DDT like Methaxsichlor, MHR,Buckley NA (2006b). Respiratory failure in acute organophosphorus
which, unlike DDT, is quickly degradable. An ideal pesticide is pesticide self-poisoning. Quarterly Journal of Medicine, 99: 513-522.
11. Eddleston M, Haggalla S, Reginald K, Sudarshan K, Senthilkumaran
Pyrethrum which is extracted from the flowers of a plant grown M,Karalliedde L, Ariaratnam A, Sheriff MHR, Warrell DA, Buckley NA (2007).The
widely in India. Pyrethrum is most effective, and being a hazards of gastric lavage for intentional self-poisoning in a resource poor
natural insecticide, is completely harmless to the environment. location. Clinical Toxicology, 45: 136-143.
Attempts are being made to grow Pyrethrum in Kashmir and 12. Eddleston M, Buckley NA, Eyer P, Dawson AH (2008a). Medical
24, 25 management of acute organophosphorus pesticide poisoning. Lancet, 371: 597-
Tamil Nadu, but, as yet, the output is very limited . 607.Eddleston M, Juszczak E, Buckley NA, Senarathna L, Mohamed
Biological control is, of course, the best way of dealing F,Dissanayake W, Hittarage A, Azher S, Jeganathan K, Jayamanne S,
with pests. This involves the use of bacteria, virus and other SheriffMHR, Warrell DA, for the Ox-Col Poisoning Study collaborators
(2008b).Multiple-dose activated charcoal in acute self-poisoning: a randomized
pathogens which attack or by the use of predators or parasites controlled trial. Lancet, 371: 579-586.
or both. A lot of work is yet to be done in this field, and 13. Green, M.A. 1987. An Outbreak of Watermelon-Borne Pesticide Toxicity.
according to the Indian Council of Agricultural Research, there American Journal of Public Health. Vol. 77 #4 November.
has been considerable success in some fields. The most 14. Freeman G, Epstein MA (1955). Therapeutic factors in survival after
lethalcholinesterase inhibition by phosphorus pesticides. New England Journal
suc-cessful of these was the almost total eradication of the ofMedicine, 253: 266-271.
prickly pear, opuntia spp which had, like many toxic plants, 15. Gunnell D, Fernando R, Hewagama M, Priyangika WDD, Konradsen F,
proliferated widely over the countryside in India, and was a andEddleston M (2007a). The impact of pesticide regulations on suicide in
SriLanka. International Journal of Epidemiology, 36(6): 1235-1242.Gunnell D,
great menace for many years. Eddleston M, Phillips MR, Konradsen F (2007b). The global distribution of fatal
The Indian station of the Commonwealth Institute of pesticide self-poisoning: systematic review. BMC Public Health, 7: 357.
Biological Control situated in Bangalore is attempting to find 16. Johnson MK, Jacobsen D, Meredith TJ, Eyer P, Heath AJW, Ligtenstein
natural enemies of a number of pests, but this work is at a very DA,Marrs TC, Szinicz L, Vale JA, Haines JA (2000). Evaluation of antidotes
forpoisoning by organophosphorus pesticides. Emergency Medicine, 12: 22-37.
early stage. The extensive use of pesticides could have an 17. Konradsen F, van der Hoek W, Gunnell D, Eddleston M (2005).
adverse effect on soil fertility and on crops. Missingdeaths from pesticide self-poisoning at the IFCS forum IV. Bulletin of
The growing requirement for the use of pesticides is theWorld Health Organization, 83: 157-8.
18. Somasundaram k.v., Epidemiological profile of op poisoning cases
obvious. But the harmful effects of pesticides with higher treatedat pravara hospital, loni, India, Indian J. Prev. Soc. Med. Vol. 40 No.3&
persistence suggest the necessity for development of 4,2009
25
pesticides which are biodegradable . 19. Roberts DM, Seneviratne R, Mohamed F, Patel R, Abeysinghe M,
HittarageA, Buckley NA, Dawson AH, Eddleston M (2005). Deliberate self-
poisoningwith the chlorphenoxy herbicide 4-chloro-2-methylphenoxyacetic
acid(MCPA). Annals of Emergency Medicine, 46: 275-284. T
References 20. Tugwell P, Robinson V, Grimshaw J, and Santesso N (2006). Systematic
reviews and knowledge translation. Bulletin of the World Health
Organization,84(8): 643-651.
1. American Academy of Clinical Toxicology and European Association of
Poisons Centres and Clinical Toxicologists. Position paper: ipecac syrup(2004a). 21. Handbook of Pesticide Toxicology, Volume 1, General Principles, W. J.
Hayes and E. R. Laws, Jr., eds. 1991. Academic Press. New York.
Journal of Toxicology. Clinical Toxicology, 42: 133-143.
2. American Academy of Clinical Toxicology and European Association of 22. American Academy of Clinical Toxicology, European Association of
Poison Centres and Clinical Toxicologists. Position paper: gastric lavage(2004b). Poisons Centres and Clinical Toxicologists. Position statements. J Toxicol Clin
Journal of Toxicology. Clinical Toxicology, 42: 933-943. Toxicol. 1997; 35:699–709,711–19,721–41,743–52,753–62.
3. Buckley NA, Karalliedde L, Dawson A, Senanayake N, Eddleston M 23. Reigart JR, Roberts JR. Recognition and management of pesticide
poisonings. 5th ed. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, D.C.,
(2004).Where is the evidence for the management of pesticide poisoning - is
1999:11–6,34–8,40–5,48–53,55–62,64,68–9,76, 80–2,87–92.
clinical toxicology fiddling while the developing world burns? Journal of
24. Gallo MA, Lawryk NJ. Organic phosphorus pesticides. In: Hayes WJ,
Toxicology.Clinical Toxicology, 42: 113-116.
Laws ER (eds). Handbook of pesticide toxicology. San Diego: Academic Press,
4. Davies JOJ, Eddleston M, Buckley NA (2008). Predicting outcome
1991:938–41,951–2.
inorganophosphorus poisoning with a poison severity score or Glasgow
ComaScale. Quarterly Journal of Medicine, 101: 371-379. 25. Members of various family practice departments develop articles for
“Practical Therapeutics.” This article is one in a series coordinated by the
Department of Family Medicine at the JSS University of Mysore.
www.pyrexjournals.org