Republic of the Philippines

PEOPLES LAW ENFORCEMENT BOARD

City of Makat
CASE MONITORING AND EVALUATION FORM (MONTHLY)

PERIOD COVERED: MONTH/ YEAR

Date Case No. Complain Rank and Place of Date Nature of Status of If If
Filed ant/s Name of Assignme formal offense the case Decided, Penalized
Respond nt Hearing (On- Date , Indicate
ent Started going/Pe decided the
nding) Penalty
Imposed

Prepared
by: Noted by:

PLEB Secretariat PLEB

Chairman

Reviewed
by:

City
Director
Date
submitted
:
Remarks
 Republic of the Philippines
PEOPLES LAW ENFORCEMENT BOARD
City of Makat
CASE MONITORING AND EVALUATION FORM (MONTHLY)

PERIOD COVERED: January/ 2018

Date Filed Case No. Complainant/s Rank and Name of Place of Date formal Nature of Status of the case If Decided, If Penalized, Indicate the Remarks
Respondent Assignment Hearing offense (On- Date Penalty Imposed
Started going/Pending) decided
3/29/1999 280-99 June M Garcia SInsp. Jerry V Camp Crame 5/5/1999 Robbery Decided 1/16/2018 Exonerated.
Protacio
2/18/2003 03-22 Ernesto B Cabrera PO3 John Ruel Mandaluyong Abuse of Decided 1/30/2018 Case against PO2 Alvin Perlas
Rellente / Authority was DISMISSED
PO1 Alvin Perlas PO3 Rellente was Exonerated
8/14/2003 03-32 PO1 Randy SPO4 Ernesto Taguig 9/17/2003 Gun toting, Decided 1/23/2018 Exonerated.
Santos / Capungcol Oral
Giovanni defamation,
Anlap / Grave threat
Aaron Martin
/
Darlito Benitez /
Calixto
Garcia /
Carlito
Vargas /
Robert
Punzalan /
Edgardo
Lumawag /
5/24/2007 07-02 Glenn A. Muñoz PO2 Bobby Baja PCP # 5 Makati 6/7/2007 Grave Decided 1/16/2018 Exonerated.
Misconduct
1/16/2008 08-02 F/INSP Rolando SPO2 William B. Makati 2/4/2008 Grave Decided 1/16/2018 Exonerated.
Reodique Madiam Misconduct

Prepared by: Noted by:

Raychelle S. Pacheco Dr. Morena Canizares Nemesio S. Yabut, Jr.
PLEB Secretariat PLEB Chairman I PLEB Chairman II
Date
Reviewed by: submitted: May 15, 2018
Cherry Canda-Melodias, CESO V
City Director
 Republic of the Philippines
PEOPLES LAW ENFORCEMENT BOARD
City of Makat
CASE MONITORING AND EVALUATION FORM (MONTHLY)

PERIOD COVERED: February/ 2018

Date Filed Case No. Complainant/s Rank and Name of Place of Date formal Nature of Status of the case If Decided, If Penalized, Indicate the Penalty
Respondent Assignment Hearing offense (On- Date Imposed
Started going/Pending) decided
10/9/2001 01-30 Norma G Estrella PO3 Bruce Tolosa Camp Crame 12/5/2001 Abuse of Decided 2/6/2018 Exonerated.
Authority
4/16/2002 02-03 Leyben B Rosario SPO4 Tony Tenorio Caloocan 5/20/2002 Physical injury Decided 2/13/2018 Exonerated.

1/8/2003 03-15 Norma H Alunan PO1 Cicero C Gaoaen / Camp Crame 3/12/2003 Extortion, Decided 2/27/2018 Exonerated.
PO1 Noel C Camp Crame Grave threat
1/8/2003 03-16 Renato T Liya / Castroverde
PO1 Cicero C Gaoaen / Camp Crame 3/12/2003 Grave threat, Decided 2/27/2018 Exonerated.
Sonny M Pure / PO1 Noel C Camp Crame Gun toting,
Castroverde Extortion,
Gerardo S Galladan / Illegal arrest &
Adonis Physical
H Alunan injuries

11/18/2003 03-39 Ariel Capunay PO2 Edison San Pedro / Makati Makati Abuse of Decided 2/20/2018 GUILTY of Simple Irregularity in the
PO1 Laurente Makati Makati Authority Performance of Duty.
Teaño / FORFEITURE OF SALARY due them
PO1 Silvestre Carpeso / for thirty (20) days.
PO1 Eduardo
11/18/2003 03-40 Joselito Telan PO2 Edison San Pedro / Makati Makati Abuse of Decided 2/20/2018 GUILTY of Simple Irregularity in the
PO1 Makati Makati Authority Performance of Duty.
Laurente Teaño / FORFEITURE OF SALARY due them
PO1 Silvestre for thirty (20) days.
Carpeso /
11/18/2004 03-41 Fernando B Castillo PO1 Silvestre Carpeso Makati Makati Abuse of Decided 2/20/2018 GUILTY of Simple Irregularity in the
Makati Makati Authority Performance of Duty.
REPRIMANDED
12/23/2005 05-11 Madonna Happy PO3 Jun Rivera-Alvarez Quezon City 1/11/2006 Physical Decided 2/27/2018 Exonerated.
Ongpauco-Rivera injuries
8/3/2006 06-06 Ronald C. Serrano PO3 Jun Rivera-Alvarez Quezon City 8/24/2006 Serious Decided 2/27/2018 Exonerated.
Physical Injury,
Grave Threats
Prepared
by: Noted by:
Raychelle S. Pacheco Dr. Morena Canizares Nemesio S. Yabut, Jr.
PLEB Secretariat PLEB Chairman I PLEB Chairman II

Reviewed Date
by: submitted: May 15, 2018
Cherry Canda-Melodias, CESO V
City Director
Remarks
 Republic of the Philippines
PEOPLES LAW ENFORCEMENT BOARD
City of Makat
CASE MONITORING AND EVALUATION FORM (MONTHLY)

PERIOD COVERED: March/ 2018

Date Filed Case No. Complainant/s Rank and Name of Place of Date formal Nature of Status of the case If Decided, If Penalized, Indicate the Remarks
Respondent Assignment Hearing offense (On- Date Penalty Imposed
Started going/Pending) decided
2/5/1998 247-98 Edwin Quiambao/ SPO2 Rolando Reyes / Makati Makati Oppression Decided 3/20/2018 Exonerated
Zenaida Quaimbao SPO1 Virgilio Makati
Sacol /
SPO1 Elizabeth Mendoza
1/24/2001 01-03 Julio Fuentes SPO1 Benjamin Umali Makati 2/28/2001 Abuse of Decided 3/20/2018 Exonerated
Authority
1/24/2001 01-04 Henry Dy/ Dina Dy SPO1 Benjamin Umali Makati Gun toting Decided 3/20/2018 Exonerated
7/5/2002 02-06 Mariel R Trinidad
SPO4 Dalmacio Fucanan / SPD SPD SPD Abuse of Decided 3/20/2018 Exonerated
SPO2 SPD Authority
Edgardo Lontok /
SPO2 Elmer
Pepano /
SPO2 Nestor Tercero
7/5/2002 02-07 Benjamin Reyes, Jr. SPO4 Dalmacio Fucanan / SPD SPD SPD Abuse of Decided 3/20/2018 Exonerated
SPO2 SPD Authority
Edgardo Lontok /
SPO2 Elmer Pepano /
SPO2
Nestor Tercero
2/9/2005 05-03 Flaviana Batislaon / PSInsp. Charlie Umayam / Camp Bagong Abuse of Decided 3/20/2018 Exonerated
Diwa, Taguig Authority
Cristino Batislaon SPO1 Baltazar Pinongan /

PO1 Jerry Balbin

Prepared
by: Noted by:
Raychelle S. Pacheco Dr. Morena Canizares Nemesio S. Yabut, Jr.
PLEB Secretariat PLEB Chairman I PLEB Chairman II

Reviewed Date
by: submitted: May 15, 2018
Cherry Canda-Melodias, CESO V
City Director
 Republic of the Philippines
PEOPLES LAW ENFORCEMENT BOARD
City of Makat
CASE MONITORING AND EVALUATION FORM (MONTHLY)

PERIOD COVERED: April/ 2018

Date Filed Case No. Complainant/s Rank and Name of Place of Date formal Nature of Status of If Decided, If Penalized, Remarks
Respondent Assignment Hearing offense the case Date Indicate the
Started (On- decided Penalty
going/Pend Imposed
ing)

No Pending Case; No New Case Filed.

Prepared by: Noted by:

Raychelle S. Pacheco Dr.
PLEBMorena Canizares Nemesio
PLEB S. Yabut, Jr.
PLEB Secretariat Chairman I Chairman II

Date
Reviewed by: submitted: May 15, 2018
Cherry Canda-Melodias, CESO V
City Director
 Republic of the Philippines
PEOPLES LAW ENFORCEMENT BOARD
City of Makat
CASE MONITORING AND EVALUATION FORM (MONTHLY)

PERIOD COVERED: May/ 2018

Date Filed Case No. Complainant/s Rank and Name of Place of Date formal Nature of Status of If Decided, If Penalized, Remarks
Respondent Assignment Hearing offense the case Date Indicate the
Started (On- decided Penalty
going/Pend Imposed
ing)

No Pending Case; No New Case Filed.

Prepared by: Noted by:

Raychelle S. Pacheco Dr. Morena Canizares Nemesio S. Yabut, Jr.

PLEB Secretariat PLEB PLEB

Chairman I Chairman II

Date
Reviewed by: submitted: May 25, 2018
Cherry Canda-Melodias, CESO V
City Director
 Republic of the Philippines
PEOPLES LAW ENFORCEMENT BOARD
City of Makat
CASE MONITORING AND EVALUATION FORM (MONTHLY)

PERIOD COVERED: June/ 2018

Date Filed Case No. Complainant/s Rank and Name of Place of Date formal Nature of Status of If Decided, If Penalized, Remarks
Respondent Assignment Hearing offense the case Date Indicate the
Started (On- decided Penalty
going/Pend Imposed
ing)

No Pending Case; No New Case Filed.

Prepared by: Noted by:

Raychelle S. Pacheco Dr. Morena Canizares Nemesio S. Yabut, Jr.

PLEB Secretariat PLEB PLEB

Chairman I Chairman II

Date
Reviewed by: submitted: July 2, 2018
Cherry Canda-Melodias, CESO V
City Director
 Republic of the Philippines
PEOPLES LAW ENFORCEMENT BOARD
City of Makat
CASE MONITORING AND EVALUATION FORM (MONTHLY)

PERIOD COVERED: July/ 2018

Date Filed Case No. Complainant/s Rank and Name of Place of Date formal Nature of Status of If Decided, If Penalized, Remarks
Respondent Assignment Hearing offense the case Date Indicate the
Started (On- decided Penalty
going/Pend Imposed
ing)

No probable
05-Jul-18 Taguig City Police cause to
PM 18-01 Benjie P. Cariaga SPO3 Gerardo Dacoco n/a Misconduct Dismissed 24-Jul-18 n/a
Station formally charge
the respondent

Prepared by: Noted by:

Raychelle S. Pacheco Dr. Morena Canizares Nemesio S. Yabut, Jr.

PLEB Secretariat PLEB PLEB

Chairman I Chairman II

Date
Reviewed by: submitted: July 25, 2018
Cherry Canda-Melodias, CESO V
City Director
 Republic of the Philippines
PEOPLES LAW ENFORCEMENT BOARD
City of Makat
CASE MONITORING AND EVALUATION FORM (MONTHLY)

PERIOD COVERED: August/ 2018

Date Filed Case No. Complainant/s Rank and Name of Place of Date formal Nature of Status of If Decided, If Penalized, Remarks
Respondent Assignment Hearing offense the case Date Indicate the
Started (On- decided Penalty
going/Pend Imposed
ing)

No Pending Case; No New Case Filed.

Prepared by: Noted by:

Raychelle S. Pacheco Dr. Morena Canizares Nemesio S. Yabut, Jr.

PLEB Secretariat PLEB PLEB

Chairman I Chairman II

Date September 4,
Reviewed by: submitted: 2018
Cherry Canda-Melodias, CESO V
City Director
 Republic of the Philippines
PEOPLES LAW ENFORCEMENT BOARD
City of Makat
CASE MONITORING AND EVALUATION FORM (MONTHLY)

PERIOD COVERED: October/ 2018

Date Filed Case No. Complainant/s Rank and Name of Place of Date formal Nature of Status of If Decided, If Penalized, Remarks
Respondent Assignment Hearing offense the case Date Indicate the
Started (On- decided Penalty
going/Pend Imposed
ing)

No Pending Case; No New Case Filed.

Prepared by: Noted by:

Raychelle S. Pacheco Dr. Morena Canizares Nemesio S. Yabut, Jr.

PLEB Secretariat PLEB PLEB

Chairman I Chairman II

Date October 26,

Reviewed by: submitted: 2018
Cherry Canda-Melodias, CESO V
City Director
 Republic of the Philippines
PEOPLES LAW ENFORCEMENT BOARD
City of Makat
CASE MONITORING AND EVALUATION FORM (MONTHLY)

PERIOD COVERED: November/ 2018

Date Filed Case No. Complainant/s Rank and Name of Place of Date formal Nature of Status of If Decided, If Penalized, Remarks
Respondent Assignment Hearing offense the case Date Indicate the
Started (On- decided Penalty
going/Pend Imposed
ing)

No Pending Case; No New Case Filed.

Prepared by: Noted by:

Raychelle S. Pacheco Dr. Morena Canizares Nemesio S. Yabut, Jr.

PLEB Secretariat PLEB PLEB

Chairman I Chairman II

Date November 27,

Reviewed by: submitted: 2018
Cherry Canda-Melodias, CESO V
City Director
 Republic of the Philippines
PEOPLES LAW ENFORCEMENT BOARD
City of Makat
CASE MONITORING AND EVALUATION FORM (MONTHLY)

PERIOD COVERED: December/ 2018

Date Filed Case No. Complainant/s Rank and Name of Place of Date formal Nature of Status of If Decided, If Penalized, Remarks
Respondent Assignment Hearing offense the case Date Indicate the
Started (On- decided Penalty
going/Pend Imposed
ing)

No Pending Case; No New Case Filed.

Prepared by: Noted by:

Raychelle S. Pacheco Dr. Morena Canizares Nemesio S. Yabut, Jr.

PLEB Secretariat PLEB PLEB

Chairman I Chairman II

Date January 4
Reviewed by: submitted: 2019
Cherry Canda-Melodias, CESO V
City Director
 Republic of the Philippines
PEOPLES LAW ENFORCEMENT BOARD
City of Makat
CASE MONITORING AND EVALUATION FORM (MONTHLY)

PERIOD COVERED: February/ 2019

Date Filed Case No. Complainant/s Rank and Name of Place of Date formal Nature of Status of If Decided, If Penalized, Remarks
Respondent Assignment Hearing offense the case Date Indicate the
Started (On- decided Penalty
going/Pend Imposed
ing)

No Pending Case; No New Case Filed.

Prepared by: Noted by:

Raychelle S. Pacheco Dr. Morena Canizares Nemesio S. Yabut, Jr.

PLEB Secretariat PLEB PLEB

Chairman I Chairman II

Date
Reviewed by: submitted: March 4 2019
Cherry Canda-Melodias, CESO V
City Director
 Republic of the Philippines
PEOPLES LAW ENFORCEMENT BOARD
City of Makat
CASE MONITORING AND EVALUATION FORM (MONTHLY)

PERIOD COVERED: JANUARY/ 2019

Date Filed Case No. Complainant/s Rank and Name of Place of Date formal Nature of Status of If Decided, If Penalized, Remarks
Respondent Assignment Hearing offense the case Date Indicate the
Started (On- decided Penalty
going/Pend Imposed
ing)

Vehicular and Traffic Awaiting

January 18 2019 Sps. Randulf and Rowena
2019-01 PO1 Dannie Boy Felix Accident Not started Neglect of Duty On-going On-going On-going Counter-
Provencion
Investigation Unit affidavit

Prepared by: Noted by:

Raychelle S. Pacheco Dr. Morena Canizares Nemesio S. Yabut, Jr.

PLEB Secretariat PLEB PLEB

Chairman I Chairman II

Date January 29,

Reviewed by: submitted: 2019
Cherry Canda-Melodias, CESO V
City Director
 Republic of the Philippines
PEOPLES LAW ENFORCEMENT BOARD
City of Makat
CASE MONITORING AND EVALUATION FORM (MONTHLY)

PERIOD COVERED: MARCH/ 2019

Date Filed Case No. Complainant/s Rank and Name of Place of Date formal Nature of Status of If Decided, If Penalized, Remarks
Respondent Assignment Hearing offense the case Date Indicate the
Started (On- decided Penalty
going/Pend Imposed
ing)

MR is denied.
No sufficient
05-Jul-18 Taguig City Police vote to
PM 18-01 Benjie P. Cariaga SPO3 Gerardo Dacoco n/a Misconduct Dismissed 26-Mar-19 n/a
Station overturn the
original
decision

Prepared by: Noted by:

Raychelle S. Pacheco Dr. Morena Canizares Nemesio S. Yabut, Jr.

PLEB Secretariat PLEB PLEB

Chairman I Chairman II

Date March 29,

Reviewed by: submitted: 2019
Cherry Canda-Melodias, CESO V
City Director
 Republic of the Philippines
PEOPLES LAW ENFORCEMENT BOARD
City of Makat
CASE MONITORING AND EVALUATION FORM (MONTHLY)

PERIOD COVERED: APRIL/ 2019

Date Filed Case No. Complainant/s Rank and Name of Place of Date formal Nature of Status of If Decided, If Penalized, Remarks
Respondent Assignment Hearing offense the case Date Indicate the
Started (On- decided Penalty
going/Pend Imposed
ing)

22-Apr-19 PO1 Rommel Endozo Makati City Police

PM 19-02 Anita Bacalangco n/a Misconduct Pending n/a n/a n/a
PO2 Roland Pungsayan Station - PCP 10

Prepared by: Noted by:

Raychelle S. Pacheco Dr. Morena Canizares

PLEB Secretariat PLEB PLEB

Chairman I Chairman II

Date
Reviewed by: submitted: April 26, 2019
Cherry Canda-Melodias, CESO V
City Director
 Republic of the Philippines
PEOPLES LAW ENFORCEMENT BOARD
City of Makat
CASE MONITORING AND EVALUATION FORM (MONTHLY)

PERIOD COVERED: MAY/ 2019

Date Filed Case No. Complainant/s Rank and Name of Place of Date formal Nature of Status of If Decided, If Penalized, Remarks
Respondent Assignment Hearing offense the case Date Indicate the
Started (On- decided Penalty
going/Pend Imposed
ing)

No Pending case

Prepared by: Noted by:

Raychelle S. Pacheco, CPA Dr. Morena Canizares
PLEB Secretariat PLEB
Chairman

Date
Reviewed by: submitted: May 31, 2019
Cherry Canda-Melodias, CESO V
City Director